© 2002 ibm corporation terena 2006 do not distribute 1 what’s really happening on the net:...
TRANSCRIPT
1
© 2002 IBM CorporationTERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute
What’s Really Happening on the Net:Lessons from the Real World
Michael R. NelsonDirector, Internet Technology and StrategyIBM [email protected]
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
My Background
B.S., geology, CaltechPh.D., geophysics, MIT1988 -- Congressional Science Fellow4 years as Senator Gore's science advisor4 years as IT policy wonk at White House1998-1999 -- Technologist at FCC8 years at IBM Industry Strategy Council, Internet2Former Chairman, TPRCVP, Public Policy, Internet Society
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
50 Things I learned in Washington
LESSON #1
ALWAYS have a good bumper sticker
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
50 Things I learned in Washington
LESSON #3
To make a point, you need two good, memorable “factoids”
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
50 Things I learned in Washington
LESSON #3
To make a point, you need two good, memorable “factoids”
(preferably true)
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
50 Things I learned in Washington
LESSON #8
Always look beyond the headlines
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #1 - Bandwidth
The Headline
World Land Speed Record > 500 Mb/s
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #1 - Bandwidth
THE HEADLINE
World Land Speed Record > 500 Mb/s
THE OTHER NEWS
Last mile technologies15-20 Mb/s at $50/month from Verizon100 Mb/s for <$40/month in Hong Kong
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #2 – Internet Video
THE HEADLINE
Warner Brothers, Fox offer TV shows (including “Desperate Housewives” on the Internet
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #2 – Internet Video
THE HEADLINE
Warner Brothers, Fox offer TV shows (including “Desperate Housewives” on the Internet
THE OTHER NEWS
Amateur and illegal video everywhere!
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
VIDEO EVERYWHERE
Bit torrent 30% of ALL traffic in 2004
50% of all traffic in 2005
70% of all traffic in some countriesAmateur video
Star Trek fan videos
Gaming videos
Webcams everywhere
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #3 - Grid
THE HEADLINE
TeraGrid, EGEE demonstrate <10 TeraOp/sec grids
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #3 - Grid
THE HEADLINE
TeraGrid and EGEE demonstrate <10 TeraOp/sec grids
THE OTHER NEWS
Akamai PC-based grids even more powerful
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
PC-based Grids
SETI @Home Berkeley Open Infrastructure for Network Computing
>684,000 users
>1,080,000 machines IBM’s World Community Grid
>100,000 donors
>170,000 machines Fight AIDS @ Home Dozens of other projects
http://www.distributedcomputing.info/projects.html
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Hacker attacks and mega spammers
Thousands of hackers making a living using zombies to send spam or run DDoS attacks
Take over 2000 PCs before breakfast
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #4 - Collaboration
THE HEADLINE
Scientists using Access Grid, VRVS
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #4 - Collaboration
THE HEADLINE
Scientists using Access Grid, VRVS
THE OTHER NEWSThe Gaming Revolution
Producing GDP equivalent to Belgium'sMegaconferenceMay 1 Business Week cover story
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #5 - Entertainment
THE HEADLINE
News Corp. buys MySpace for $560 Million
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #5 - Entertainment
THE HEADLINE
News Corp. buys MySpace for $560 Million
THE OTHER NEWS
Internet isn’t just a medium, it’s a place80 million MySpace users20 million log on every day, <20 minutes
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #6 - Spam
THE HEADLINE
Spam is out of control
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #6 - Spam
THE HEADLINE
Spam is out of control
THE OTHER NEWS
The vast majority of spam is blocked and we’re making progress
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #7 - Authentication
THE HEADLINE
Microsoft Passport, Liberty Alliance
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #7 - Authentication
THE HEADLINE
Microsoft Passport, Liberty Alliance
THE OTHER NEWS
Open source, open standards, federated identity management gets real
MIT’s Technology Review Top 10 technologies
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #8 – Governments and the Net
THE HEADLINE
Internet GovernanceUnited Nations wants to control the Net
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Who “manages” the Internet?
World Summit on the Information Society Governments realizing the power of Net
Media
E-business
Threat to monopoly phone company (VoIP)
Political speech So they want to regulate or control it “Internet governance”
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
HEADLINE #8 – Governments and the Net
THE HEADLINE
Internet GovernanceUnited Nations wants to control the Net
THE OTHER NEWS
Attempts to regulate the Internet popping up everywhere
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Policy-Legal-Regulatory Ecosystem
ITU ConventionInt’l Telecom Regs
APEC-TEL
Commission of the European Community
USAFCCFCC
[WCIT][WCIT]PP2006PP2006
eSecTG
eSecTG
NSTACNSTACCanada
Australia
InfsoInfso
ParliamentParliament
Germany
NANCNANC
IndustryCanadaIndustryCanada
Many Others
CybercrimeConvention
Signatories &Justice Ministers
CITEL
DOSDOS
BNETZA-TBNETZA-T
Other multilateral and bilateral agreements
DOJDOJ DOCDOC
DHSDHS PSECPPSECP
WGSCWGSC WGANTSWGANTS
PCC.IPCC.I
NGN WGNGN WG NGN regNGN reg
ParliamentParliament
France
NetherlandsUKHomeOfficeHomeOfficeParliamentParliament
CIOTCIOTEZEZ
OFCOMOFCOM
JusticeJusticeARCEPARCEP
JusticeJustice
BfVBfV
JHAJHA
CouncilCouncil
ASIOASIO
ACAACA
DTIDTI
Tony Rutkowski, Verisign, ITU NGN workshop, March 2006
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Common infrastructure requirements worldwide
Availability, Security and Legal High availability
• analysis of network metrics and outages
Network attack mitigation Priority access during emergencies Alerts and notices during emergencies Restoration after emergencies Personal emergency services Preventing unwanted intrusions
• Filters (DoNotCAll)• Aids (CallerID)
Law enforcement/judicial/national security assistance
Cybercrime mitigation• Forensics capability• Fraud detection and management• Digital rights management
Universal access
Competition Requirements Unbundling Service interoperability User/subscriber access by service
providers Default service and routing options Nomadicity
• Number portability• Roaming• Payment method flexibility
Operations Requirements Directory access among providers Intercarrier compensation Transaction accounting
Other Consumer Requirements Disability assistance Universal Service CPNI protection
Tony Rutkowski, Verisign, ITU NGN workshop, March 2006
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
50 Things I learned in Washington
LESSON #17
There is nothing more dangerous than an old model applied to a new medium
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
“Mail governance” (1950): Who made choices about postal service?
Hundreds of governments and the post offices they ran
Universal Postal Union
(customers)
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
“Phone governance” (1970): Who made choices about phone service?
Hundreds of governments
Hundreds of government-run telephone companies
International Telecommunication Union
(“subscribers”)
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
The flow of power
Governments
ITU
Phone companies
Individuals
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Who makes choices about the Net?
Dozens of intergovernmental organizations, standards bodies, and international NGOs
Hun
dred
s of
gov
ernm
ents
and
natio
nal c
onso
rtia
Thou
sand
s of
IT v
endo
rs,
netw
ork
prov
ider
s, IS
Ps…
Milli
ons
of In
tern
et u
sers
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
The flow of power
Governments
International Organizations
Vendors, ISP, software vendors
Individuals
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
WHO’S PAYING ATTENTION?
European Commission’s Television without Frontiers directive
WIPO Webcasting treatyFCC’s regulation of VoIPWiretapping and data retention requirements ITU’s Next Generation Networks initiativeTelco’s growing monopoly/duopoly powerNet Neutrality debate
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Critical technology choices
Authentication and directories Privacy-enhancing technologies (P3P) Digital Rights Management Filtering technologies to block spam, porn Voice over IP Wireless Internet standards Web services and Grid computing Instant messaging IPv6 deployment Linking the phone network and the Internet Rich media standards (SIP, multicast, etc.) End-to-end vs. walled gardens
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Tech answers to policy problems
Privacy P3P, etc.Piracy DRMPornography Filtering tech.Protection AuthenticationPricing Grid standardsPolicing Wireless Internet Psychology Phone-Net
mergerProcurement Voice over IPPayments Protectionism
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Role of the NREN community
Educate policy makersUnbiased source of technical advice“Canary in the coal mine”
Tackle issues early
Privacy, IPR, securityTest out new technologies & standardsPromote open standards, open source
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
We must deliver a clear message
We are entering the third phase of the Internet
Megabit/sec > gigabit/sec
Communication > computing > collab.
Web services, mash-ups
Wireless, sensors, pervasiveTechnology choices, not regulation
© 2002 IBM CorporationTERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute
BACKGROUND SLIDES
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Locus of Decision-making
No government All government Degree of government involvement
International
Regional
National
Company/Local
Individual
Internet standards
Online taxesCensorship
Telecom regulation
Spectrum policy
DNSIP addresses
Trade policy
Cyber-crime
Development aid
Spam
On-line privacy
Cyber-security
E-government
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Locus of Decision-making
No government All government Degree of government involvement
International
Regional
National
Company/Local
Individual
Spam
(Many different decisions in many different places)
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Locus of Decision-making
No government All government Degree of government involvement
International
Regional
National
Company/Local
Individual
Internet standards
Online taxesCensorship
Telecom regulation
Spectrum policy
DNSIP addresses
Trade policy
Cyber-crime
Development aid
Spam
On-line privacy
Cyber-security
E-government
Where “Internet governance” is needed
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Where are we headed?
No government All government Degree of government involvement
International
Regional
National
Company/Local
Individual
Global “Internet governance”
Scenario #1
Scenario #2
Scenario #3
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
The Third Phase of the Internet
1969 1980 1990 2000 2010
Cap
abili
ty
Phase 1 - Communicating
Phase 2 - Content
Phase 3Collaboration
?
The Third Phase of the Internet
1969 1980 1990 2000 2010
Cap
abili
ty
Phase 1 - Communicating
Phase 2 - Content
Phase 3Collaboration
?
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporationuser
Phase 1 -- Remote Log-on
Computer
Computer
user
Phase 1 -- Remote Log-on
Computer
Computer
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporationuser1
Phase 1 -- E-mail - one-to-one
user2
Computer
Computer
user1
Phase 1 -- E-mail - one-to-one
user2
Computer
Computer
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporationuser
Phase 2 -- The Web -- one-to-many
Web server
user
Phase 2 -- The Web -- one-to-many
Web server
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporationuser
Phase 3 -- Distributed storage -- many-to-many
Napster files
Napster files
Napster files
user
Phase 3 -- Distributed storage -- many-to-many
Napster files
Napster files
Napster files
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporationuser
Phase 3 -- Distributed Computing -- many-to-many
Grid Server
Grid Server
Grid Server
user
Phase 3 -- Distributed Computing -- many-to-many
Grid Server
Grid Server
Grid Server
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Many Flavors of Distributed Computing
Power per node1 100
Num
ber
of n
odes
10
1 MPeer-to-peer (PC-based) Napster KaZaa SETI@home
Many Flavors of Distributed Computing
Power per node1 100
Num
ber
of n
odes
10
1 MPeer-to-peer (PC-based) Napster KaZaa SETI@home
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Many Flavors of Distributed Computing
Power per node1 100
Num
ber
of n
odes
10
1 MPeer-to-peer (PC-based) Napster KaZaa SETI@home
Grid Computing (Server-based)National Grids TeraGrid
Many Flavors of Distributed Computing
Power per node1 100
Num
ber
of n
odes
10
1 MPeer-to-peer (PC-based) Napster KaZaa SETI@home
Grid Computing (Server-based)National Grids TeraGrid
IBM Research
TERENA 2006 Do Not Distribute © 2006 IBM Corporation
Many Flavors of Distributed Computing
Power per node1 100
Num
ber
of n
odes
10
1 MPeer-to-peer (PC-based) Napster KaZaa SETI@home
Grid Computing (Server-based)National Grids TeraGrid
The Holy GridEverything integrated with everything
Many Flavors of Distributed Computing
Power per node1 100
Num
ber
of n
odes
10
1 MPeer-to-peer (PC-based) Napster KaZaa SETI@home
Grid Computing (Server-based)National Grids TeraGrid
The Holy GridEverything integrated with everything