食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†fa @ajaj‡ rk...

47
食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産部会速記録 平成20年5月9日

Upload: vokhanh

Post on 24-Apr-2019

228 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

食料・農業・農村政策審議会平成20年度第1回畜産部会速記録

平 成 2 0 年 5 月 9 日

Page 2: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

�� � � � � � � � ��

� ����� ���� � ������������������������� ��

� ��������� ����������������������������� ��

� ������� ������������������������������� ��

� ����������� � ������������������������� ��

� ��!"#��$%&��'� ������������������������ ��

� ����() � ������������������������������ *�

� ��+,-.� ������������������������������� /0�

� ��1�� *�23 � ������������������������� 45�

�6�0�6

Page 3: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

���� ���

789!":;<=� >?@ABCDE�FGEHIJKL�MNOMNPQRST�U

V /W XYZ�[!"#�\�]�^'�EH_C`abc&dJeCD'fghi�@

jkg�l�EH_G�Bm@nop�C`a�

� qfG!":;<=�89Fop�C`arkDsdt��EDC`a�

�������

789!":;<=� CuGvw��D'dBC`�����\�^'�EH_C`a�

� xy\�D'dBC`mG���zT{�Z|G��}z��~�|G���z!"\�

����&��'|G��*zNO&�`���-�&��'|G���zUV 0� XY�

�����v����������@��|G���zUV /W XY������v���

�����|G�����z�N ¡�¢£¤"����\¥�E���v��|G���

�}z�N ¡�¢£¤"����\¥�E���v���¦§¨©|G�����z�

�����v���ª«�&¬­E���|G����*zL�MNOMNPQRST��

®¯M°T|G�����zUV /W XY!"±�² |G�����zUV /W XY!"M

�N³´µR|a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

� �� F¸em���G�K¹Dº�C`FD»nJa���f{¼½��&d¯D�

sH��a�

� jeJKf¾¿#�=&T{\dÀ�'�EH_E�@Á�C`�FGrkDsdt�

�EDC`a�

�� �� �� ��

7¾¿#�=� ¾¿Fop�C`arkDsdt�¯D·ÂC`a�

� ÃeFfGCuÄŤ"½=��JKo����\dt��EDC`a�

�6�/�6

Page 4: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

7ÄŤ"½=� ¤"½=Fop�C`a�

� bcGgh¢Æ�@jkg�l�EH_CD'�Bm@nop�C`a�

� I[fGUV /W XY�Z�[!"#�@�nj@Fop�C`a�

� Cu¯D·ÂA­eÇ�­A�j@fGÈÉC^ÊG_»nË»¹@ÌeCD'G¯D

Íop�C^ÊFDEa�

� /W XY�!"±�²�Î>&�_CD'fGÏ�}Ð /0 w&Ñ#�&d_CD'®

¯M°T\�EH_CDEaÃ�ÄÒ\ÓCÔCD'Î>DE@jkFop�C`­eÕ

ÖG`×'�ØQ�²\Ù_·ÂCDEaÃeJKGjeK�!"±�²�Î>&Ú^C

D'G!"M�N³´µR\Î>�^'�EH_CDEa�

� q��JKI�!"\�����GÛ&Ü�Fop�C`­eÕÖGÝDs¯D·ÂA

s'ÖGÞwßàáâ FãämØåe'dBC`a��æAÜ��ç�èé@�nj@

mêåe'dBC`aÆ&fë�ìí¨îmï¹'��@�nð�æAñò\óô`�¬

_Ö��å­Fop�C`­eÕÖGrs,C`@õö÷G���føùúûü\Æý@

DEL�GÜ��þñ÷GÃeJK�� &d­���@�n�Ö��f��&r�

# mJABh��FfA�J@�n�n&Ö�Ô'��å­Fop�C`ajn�¹E

�åÇ �æA@jk&�\�D'��rnAÜ�èéFfA�J@óô`�¬_m�

&��å­Fop�C`a�

� jn�¹EÆFG��G��ÕvST�Fg°T�EH_CDEÄÒ&�DCD'!

"M�N³´µR \��D'��å­Fop�C`­eÕÖGI@Öjn�n��\

ÓCÔAmKÖje\��&G��&��D'�JA­eÇ�­A�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� CEG�����µ�Fop�C`­eÕÖGg�Ä�@dBG��G��@����

-�mØåeCDEajj&�C`v�!"#=mØ_CD'GJAB D�T!mØå

eE@�n�n&ã"\#­'dBC`­eÕÖG��+$G��&@¹',eÇrn%

sv²æAT!m&C¹E@jk@�n�nA'�Fop�C`aÑ(�j@AmKG

����væA)*@�nÖ�f+�×_Ö�fD¹JB+�@�n���,FGqÕÖ

H­FfAs'GÑ(-¼.G/".G0¼. �1.2G�å3�Q4ð«@A¹'j

����,&-�&ÑE¹'�s@�nj@Fop�C`a�

� 567�NO-�Ö�ÐÆ8&fNO-�T=�ìí9á:;�Êm�BC`<=à©

�>?@m��e�@�n�n&A�'dBC`aÃe\#­CD'G��B&A��JG

CH�>fD'�A�rnFop�C`­eÕÖGCD�TÖ�Je�@�nj@&A¹

�6�E�6

Page 5: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

'dBC`a��+$G567NO-�Ö�&FñA½G\HÔ'��å­Fop�C

`�FGqÕÖÛ&jn�¹EÜ�GI±�����\ÓCÔAmKJï�@D'�)*

\D¹JB@KL�^'�_E�@Á¹'-�&�B�ÊF��@jkFop�C`a�

� jn�n���,FGvwfGUV 0M X�Ð�L�MNOMNPQRST��°T\

ÓCÔCD'G������v��&NÂKeCDEQR���OP\ØnðQ@D'G

�v��&�Rs�R�SÀ��GÃeJK!"\�����&��'gã"�EDC`a�

� ��TU&dJeCD'fGjeK�TV&��'W�AgT!\�EH_C`@@Ö

&GI��m�!"��B�&�_CD'XY�A�g+,\ZBE�@Á¹'dBC

`arkDsdt��EDC`a�

7¾¿#�=� ÕnÖ�Bm@nop�CDEa�

��������� �

7¾¿#�=� ÃeFfGT{&ïBC`[&vw�����&�_CD'{¼½��J

Kgã"\dt��EDC`a�

789!":;<=� \]��G·^U��G_,��G`��Gab��&dJeCD

'fG%c\dA�Pe&rBvwg�l@�j@Fop�C`a�

� CEGf¿��&dJeCD'f 0g �YÌe'hKe�ÃnFop�C`a�

� AdGi>GST�jZkl&rBCD'G#�f�� ¡T{&�1���m���

�� ��¶·m�lDA­eÇ�T\�_GTÎ`�j@mF_A�@�e'dBC`

mGn«F /W ~�nËGop 04 ~m�l�e'dBC`�FGV)D'dBC`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

!"#��$%&��'�

7¾¿#�=� �&G#�$%&�_CD'{¼½JKg()t�C`a�

789!":;<=� Ñ#��$%��&�_CD'g���^'�EH_C`a�

� T{�q�M�q����Fop�C`aST��T{ir&�R_G�Tfq�@�

EDC`aEHDGq�`�j@&rBGqsJ�Æ)AST&tD�uv\ w`dÃ

em��*xGCEfÛ>�yõÖDsfz«&�ÑA{|GÖDsf�{|\ÖEK`

�6�4�6

Page 6: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

dÃem��*x&fG�=f�T\�q�@`�j@mF_�j@@�EDC`a�

� CEGT{}fð~���&�`�Ö�@DC`aEHDG�T�$%&tD�uvm

��@��Ke�*x&fG�=fGT{}&�Ô'T{ñ�\ð~���&�`�Ö�

@`�j@mF_�j@@�EDC`a�

� #��$%&�_CD'fG¶·Fop�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

��() �

7¾¿#�=� ÃeFfG��() &�BE�@Á�C`a�

� {¼½��JK������v��&�Rs�R�À���%!"\����� &�

_CD'()\#­CD'GÃ�G���bcJK�e&g+,\�×'�EHs�F

À��^'�EH_E�@Á�C`�FGrkDsdt�¯D·ÂC`a�

� AdGvw�#�f 05 �CF\�>D'dBC`�FG�KJ��g��d_t�C

`a�

� ÃeFfG��{¼½rB()\dt�DC`mG{[&��\��D'gð��EH

�'��@�nj@Fop�C`�FG{¼½��@D'f��&¦§¨©\��Ô��

F()D'�EH­eÇ@Á�C`a�

� ���&�_CD'G��&!"��<=rB()\dt�DC`a�

7�9!"��<=� !"��<=Fop�C`aId�m�BCDE@dBG��&¦

§¨©\g()DE�@Á�C`a�

� q��JKf!"\��������1�# \g()�EDC`a�

� ��;��Fop�C`aCuÜ������o�@��an«@�EDCD'fGo

p /g����F`mGje\ 0W ¦§¨©·Â' Eg����\NÂ'dBC`aÛ& Ü

�&�_CD'fGjef�ÄF¤"F_�¡¢£Fop�C`�FG0WW�\��&D

'dBCD'Gð��,��n�¤¥Ü�Fop�C`­eÕÖGjef�¦DJ���

mop�C^Ê­eÕÖG§áì¨;î�W¢ \©�' 04�CFè�E�@Gjn�

n��\NÂ'��@jkFop�C`a�

� ���;�\dt��EDC`a�m��Ü�ª��Jï��Fop�C`a«,&¬

­®ìmop�C`­eÕÖG�xÜ�G¯xÜ��ª�@�EDCD'fG°±

�6�g�6

Page 7: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

0/WW ²©¨�@nÖkjDm³åe'dBC`a´ÊÆ��&op�C`­eÕÖG@

nÖkjD��J&GjnBºÊGµ¶GÃ�·�BC`­eÕÖGj�@nÖkjD�

Jï@�n�f�@ÊÕ¸�&¹ºD'dBCD'G�E�GX&rBCD'fÖ¹@è�

�M�GÃn�¹EÖ�m�@ÊÕ»¼½¾JKJï�e'��a�

� »¼½¾�@nÖkjD�þ�Fop�C`mG¿·�À�A��Æ&ÁÂmÃÊFd

BC`a¤"Äfj�rn&µ_s÷Ô'_'dBC`mGÆÅ&�BC`mG§ÆÇ;

9¢Gj�ÁÂmJ�'fAJ¹Eþñmoe'_'dBCD'GjemDJÖÕÊÕÊ

÷Ô'��aWMÈWÉ X��ÊFf MÉWW ²©¨@�nj@FGÃ�Ë»¹@,&J�Äm

�BC`­eÕÖGj�J�Ä\µ_sD��þñ@A¹'��@�n�måJBC`a

jn�¹E�1F,���pËÄABGpË�mµ_sÌ,D'��ajemop�@n

ÖkjD�²���æAèé@ÍÊF��j@&ABC`a�

� ����;��Fop�C`­eÕÖG�xÜ��²&ÎÏ`�ñòFop�C`a�

xÜ��²f«�·��&op�C`rn&GðÐX�ÑJK´é�ED'dBCD'G

Ñ����&Ò×C`@G°}²¬è�ÁÂ&A¹'dBC`aÃ�,&@nÖkjD�

Ó¾ÔÕ*mop�CD'G��Õ¯D·ÂCDErn&GjeÖ�xÜ��²@Ö�r

nA׬Fop�CD'GopÓ¾ÔÕ*f�ØÙÓÚ9ÑEB°�î9��@�n@j

kCF_'dBC`a�å^'áà©�nËFµ_�Ö�@�EDCD'fÛ·$Ümo

p�C`­eÕÖGÛ·$ÜÖJ�'��Ý�K�G©¨ÑEB�î9 /W Þ¨©@�n

��CFèsA¹'dBC`a�

� ���;�\dt��EDC`ajn�¹E�xÜ��²�ß×&µDCD'G�xÜ

��²^>àY\$¢D'dBC`ajefG«á&¥mop�C`­eÕÖG�â'

Ê�ãG©â'Ê�ã@�n}Åä�å�É\æ¹'dBCD'Gje&r¹'�²·

ç��&Nè��ÎÏ\éê`�E��â'ÊmØåe�aj�â'Êf¿á�¥&�B

C`rn&G0É X 0W жëG3ìÞíD'�×�e'dBCD'G©â'ÊG�â

'Ê&r¹'Nè�îï\éêD'dBC`aj��ã&�_CD'fGj�rn&�×

mí�'dBC`�1FGopÛ&©�ã�ðèmñòD'dBCD'GjefçÆó

ØJKôBïe��Fj�â'Ê\õí`�j@@D'dBC`aÃ�E��µR@�E

DCD'GôBïe���{ö÷V\Øn �øù\�EDE@jkFop�C`a�

� ����;��&ABC`a�"Ü��¤"M{¢�úµaje&�_CD'fGjj

&�BC`rn&GT~�µR\û�'G��ÕÖ¯D·ÂCDE�Ä�Ü����GÛ

�6�5�6

Page 8: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

& Ü������¬·\�óD'��@jkFop�C`aÃeüe�µR&�_CD

'G���;�JK()\�­'dBC`a�

� ��;��G�ý���Fop�C`mGCuþ�� Ü�Gjef�9F�KeC`

þ\�@ð�&���EDCD'G�§�;��G���^CD'Gè!GÛ&£�Ô�

Fop�C`­eÕÖG�Xj���m÷Ô'dBCD'G«,��&�BC`­eÕÖG

0� X���F 5EWW �Õ���mØåe'dBC`aj����úµ\u�`�E�&G

�hJK ¢�;9�;®; �����ïG���f�UG�ÑEB�÷V@�¹Ej

@\�!Þ�µR@�n�Fu�D'dBC`DGxå^'"�RsB-�ã�W¢ÖA

�e'��@jkFop�C`aCEGj�5û�\³n!"Nè�§î&Ö����@

�¹ErnAu�mA�e'dBC`a�

� Ã��&GþåK�{¢SÀFop�C`ajeÖrs�Ke'dBC`mGj�¬­

®ì&�BC`rn&G�Ä�þåK¤"Ä�nË�°�¦H­mopè!�Ü�@D'

¢�Ke'dBC`aJ�'Æ�\Æý&JAB�Ä�Jïmop�CDE­eÕÖG�

Ä�þåK�{¢�À&��'dBCD'G��Ff��� �M���@�nÁÂm 0É XY

op�C`rn&G�w�"�þåKm³åe'��@�nj@Fop�C`mGCHð

#Jï�à©�;£m³åe'��@jkÖop�C`�FG�K&�ÄF��`��

��"�þåK{¢\�À`�E��µR\û�'��@jkFop�C`a�

� ��k�;��Fop�C`a���&�ýmèsA¹'dBC`mGÜ�¢¸�{

W¢Fop�C`aÜ�¢¸fG�X���@�EDCD'fGCH{!æA"æA��

&@ÕC¹'dBCD'G��G�fjj&�BC`rn&G0� XY���F /É5 @

�nÁÂ&A¹'dBC`aÜ�¸�¼½Ù©@DCD'fG�9Nèm©�þ�«#

@Ö�rn&��j@mF_�@�nj@F`DG!"Nè@D'f@nÖkjD��$

Ü�@D'ì%F_�å­Fop�C`mG&@��CD'Ö�µ�<Vf�²GFop

�CD'G!"�§î@�EDCD'fGJï@nÖkjD�²@Ö G���fÃe¶

,��²FA�@AJAJ³�RK�aÃeJKG'(æAGF��C`@G%fB@n

ÖkjD&�$`��&f!"±��Ô�ÎÏG���fè!�¤PABG)*æAGF

��+m,ñ&A¹'s�@�nj@mop�C`aje&�_CD'Ö«��&�BC

`rn&G-�J�µRG���fIXYJKøù�EDCDE.EAµR&rBCD'

j�Ü�¸�{W¢\�À`�rn&�B�ÊF��@jkFop�C`a�

� ��/�;��Fop�C`mG0¡�SÀFop�C`aÛ&�¢£�12£AÕ&

�6�M�6

Page 9: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

�_CD'fG0¡&r¹'�&.3æAOPFÜ*OPmF_�a�K&��04�

�rnA{¢�e'�A�5��W¢&�AÂ�j@mF_�@�nj@F6��e'd

BC`aÆ���\Æý&��Ö÷7D'dBCD'GÛ&8ö90¡@�¹ErnA{

!Öop�CD'GÃn�¹Ej@&Ö:¨©\�EH_CD'GjeCF�;º�µR

&7ÔCD'G/W XYJKf0¡/<£�=D�DG�¨Æ¾>@�nàY&µD'÷

V\`�å�ÉÖ¢+DE@jkFop�C`a�

� �� 0W �;��Fop�C`aÜ�¤"�-#�a!"/%mi?úµD'dBCD

'G/%ÄFÜ�¤"\Øn@�n�mC`C`@A&A¹'_'dBC`aÃ�ÆFÜ

����\·Â'�sE�&fÜ�¤"#B\-#�`�j@m�&FñF��@�n

j@FGÃ��C@�EDCD'Gjj&�BC`mGᨩ®DÆ;G���f6Eù

Þ¨Æ;@�nÖ�mn�F�B�CeGF D'_'dBC`aᨩ®DÆ;��G

�ÁÖ 4EM@�n�n&÷Ô'_'dBC`DGᨩ®DÆ;m#HDEÜ����G

�/² ÉWWW @�nj@FGjefnÜ��±���G���¦\I��CF&A¹'

��@�n�&FñAUùR­&A¹'dBC`a�

� CEG6EùÞ¨Æ;�n�fGè!&Ã�CC��F_�rn&G Ü�G¤¥Ü�G

���fâJ®9GKÆ⨣Öxå^'Ln�xÜ���FNè&M­�G�åÇè!

��LÞ¨Æ;Fop�CD'GjeÖNè�.3�&�Am¹'Gi?úµ�ÆFGÜ

�\N�æ&��F_�«à�B&µßOPD'��@�nj@Fop�C`a�

� ÃeJKG00 �;��&ABC`­eÕÖGQRB@nÖkjD���úµa��Ü

��ÆFj�QRB@nÖkjDf¡¢&Ò×CD'µßè)*Gè�Ä@�nj@Fo

p�CD'Gje\·S&W¢`�j@&rBCD'�xÜ��³¢Ä\���YTK`

j@mF_�@�nj@Fì%�e'dBC`aj���G�ÖJ�' 0/² 5WWW�Õ

�¹E�F`mGUDT¹'DC¹'dBC`­eÕÖGje\CEVY÷%D'�EH

_E�@�nj@FG¢�W.��QRB@nÖkjD���X.G���f.EAµR

@D'��04���@nÖkjD���&µ`�÷VGÃn�¹Ej@\.E&øùD

'��@jkFop�C`a�

� �& 0/ �;�Fop�C`­eÕÖG¤¥Ü�����¬·µR@D'§áì¨;î

m�&FñAUù�­&A¹'dBC`ajefLYð��Ü��@ÍÇe'��Ö�

Fop�C`mG�Ä�LYð���¤ÄfG«���Æ&�BC`mGxå^' 0/WW

²©¨Z��@�nj@Fop�C`aopÃ�Ü�@D'�{¢�f //��Õ&@Õ

�6��6

Page 10: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

C¹'dBC`­eÕÖGÐX>sLY½�§D9C�ÆFGV¤{¢&ÑE¹'Ü��

\[�`�@�n�Ô�\)��D'�EH_CD'GCEÃ���\�À`�E��à

YæA,\DÖØ�CD'Gj�V¤{¢�\è�'C�BE�aª«æ&O]o@&�

�\>�'dBCD'GLY^�O&d_CD'fGV¤{¢� Ég�G_`MÀ`OG

���f-L&d_CD'fGÃe\ 4W�JK MW�@�¹ErnA��CFè�'�E

Hsj@&r¹'G§áì¨;î�{¢\�K&À�'C�BE�@�n�n&�Ô'd

BC`a�

� �� 0E �;��aab�ajefÛ&¸�Fc§d§ÆÇ;9\¤"`���efg

Fop�CD'Gh f§ÆÇ;9FAsA¹'DC�C`­eÕÖGð¹EijGEÊ

kslmÜ�@D'mNF��@�nj@FGÃ�hsf¸�ÄF³åe'dBC`­e

ÕÖGð#mÛ-�J��e'no»�»AÕFÖ³åe'dBC`DGwvFÖÜ�¼

;¾;mð#p<æA{¢\�&D'dBC`aEHG{¢&ÑEBCD'fGIj�

aab���¤Äf÷Ô'C�BC`�FGmN&W¢D'�sj@mFñH@Á¹'d

BC`mG{¢&ÑEBCD'fGV ·�qVG���f�Br�mAD�@J-�J

�<Vmop�C`�FGÃn�¹E<V\sPDG{¢&ÑE¹'�ßtu»9 \s

v`��F{¢�À\¥¹'�_E�@�Ô'dBC`a�

� ¶·mÜ�µRFop�C`mGí_CD' 04 �;�Gè!�¤"w¬·��B�Éa

�xÜ��²�èé&µ��EDCD'G!"NèFf¤"w¬·&���j@&r¹'

UDFÖ¤"áà©�xT&�K�3`�@�n�B�É\�EH�'��@jkFop

�C`aÃ��B�É��¬f�CpCAÖ�G'(æA<Vmop�C`­eÕÖGÃ

�{!@�EDCD'�NG�¢£G*yG*zGÃeüe��CF&NÂ�^'�EH

_CDEaje¶-&Ö�CpCA/%�3F¤"w¬·&�B�ÊF�EH�'dBC

`aqÕÖÖÃn�¹E{!\åJB%`��F�BC@�'g{|`�j@&r¹'G

� F��B�É\�K&�ÀD'�_E�@�n�n&�Ô'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKG�x�GÜ��²�èé&µ�DE}~�P���À@�nj@Fop�C

D'G��æ&fI[�Ü��²�èé&�_CD'f�s&À`�²&KL�^'�s

j@mFñH@�n�n&�Ô'dBCD'GÃ�E�&�1�%}~�G���f�©

�1�&s�A�ã\��DGP�D'�EHsE���T�\�ùD'W×D'dBC

`aÃ�W×�ÄÒABGÃ�ÆF�sKe'���¨ì�Ù© mjj&{|�e'd

BC`a�

�6���6

Page 11: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� �&G���;�&��@�EDCD'G�Ä-�!"±��²�×_m{!æ&{

|�e'dBCD'G�ÄFÖG���fÛ-FÖjn�¹EI±�²�èé\#­CD

'!"±��²m·çD'_'��@�nj@m{|�e'��@jkFop�C`a�

� q��nJKf¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� Ù_í_CD'G£��^Y<=JK()\dt�DC`a�

7U�£��^Y<=� £��^Y<=Fop�C`a�

� �� 0M �;�JK£��^Y�1&��'g()�EDC`a�Ð��T��&Ö¢

�CDE��\½tu;»9`�rnA�F�����\g()�EDC`a�

� Cu 0É XY��m�&d­�¤��þ� �Fop�C`a���Ä@�EDCD'

f¤�.�F 0/WW ²©¨�BGÃ�� �}&ÑEBC` ÉWW ²©¨m�"GðB��

��m 4WW²©¨�YFop�C`­eÕÖGJï&r¹'�åe'��@�n �F

op�C`a�

� �"�nËGQ�# Fop�C`­eÕÖG4MW ²©¨m�¢£� ¬­GÃ�k¦

f�4�F�¤"a�

� Ã�¿á���# m�i��GcÆ;��7�¬­G/WE ²©¨aj�# f�&°

k¦m�ÛäF�¤"@�n�&A¹'dBC`aj�7�ª���# &�_CD'fG

��@�YÁÄ&�_CD'!"#�FgST\�EH�E·F�mâ�ã\-��ED

CD'GV¤"\��D'dBC`a�

� �K&Ã�¿á&Ã�·@�nj@FG¤D½;�G�;� ¬­Fop�C`mG

0E5²©¨@A¹'�C`a�

� CEGJï�^Y E�5²©¨�nËG3¦Zf�;�Fop�C`a�&d;à©®½

»JKJï�e'�C`að�F�;���Ä}~@�nj@F,C`@G�Ä}~�k

¦mJïY&r¹'�åe'��@�n ¥mop�C`a�

� ÃeJKGj���fJï�1�ÁÂmCH�'�A��FGn«@D' 0É XY@�

n�FC@��^'�EH�'dBC`mG�Ä# H­f 0� XY�ÁÂm�'dBC

`aö�F��F`­eÕÖG¯D·ÂC`@G�Ä�¤�¤"Ä ÉW�²©¨�# fG

0� XYf ÉW/ ²©¨FG%%TFop�C`ajef�*� �¡mDÇKsí�E

@�nrnAj@mÎÏD'dBCDEa�

� ÃeJKGQ�# ��¢£� ¬­fG4MW ²©¨&µD' 0� XYf 4g� ²©¨F

�6�0W�6

Page 12: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

op�C`ajef%fB�¢£�\Æý&}~m¢£DE@�n# mop�C`a�

� ÃeJKG�y¤ÇDCD'G¤D½;�G�;�¬­ 0E5 ²©¨&µD' 0� XYf

04M ²©¨Fop�C`ajef%fBþñG}~m¥¦@�nñ§mop�C`a�

� Ã�ðB@��C`JGÃ�¨©@D'��# Fop�C`­eÕÖG�i��Gc

Æ;��7�¬­m 0�5²©¨@�n�F%%TUDE@�nª&A¹E@jkFop�

C`a�

� í_CD'G0É �;�\dt��EDC`a7�ª���¤"�â�ãàY�«ñF

op�C`aj�àYfg���@dBG7�ª��� F���Ûä�¤��V¤"\

��`�j@\�æ@�EDCD'â�ã\-�`�Ö�Fop�C`a��&��'fG

¤"~�ß× &�R_CD'ð>�9;9F�>�^'�EH�'dBC`a/W XY

F¯DC`@G0� XY���&¤"áà©�÷T�\¬­'���EDCDEa÷T�

�­�&fG,��&«®¥\¯�'op�C`mG¤"áà©��XU°\¢�'�C

`aÃ��G\���²×¬\KL`�@�nj@FGT~�±±Ô��@J²³~@J

�k�kop�C`­eÕÖGT~�@Ö��fªr@D'\���¾Ð&ù_JÔ'­

�D'dBC`aEHG/W XY���&�DCD'fGgST�EH_CDEmG�x

Ü��²&��'Ã�èé���\ÓCÔCD'GÛ& /W XY´��X �Nè�îï

µ\GB¶ÊF�>�^'�EH�E@�n# mop�CDEa�

� ÃeJKGÃ�,��YÁÄ&�_CD'fG¤��þ�{� \�+D'�>D'd

BC`a/W XYfÛ·æH¹E�fGcÆ;G�i��&µ`�þñ,¶É@�nÖ�

\��ç��èé&r¹'¤��Û¸Aþñ�# @�hJK�©�þñ�# @&¹

�& ­' º�EDCD'G©�# @�n�fÙ_í_%%TU»¬&��@�n

j@F�YÁÄ@D'�²©¨T� 0�g ²©¨@�n�F�>�^'�EH_G��ç�

&�RsrnAð�æAþñ&µD'����µ��¼½wÖ�Bd�@�nj@FG-

¾F 0/²©¨�¿Àøù\Áµ��^'�EH�E@jkFop�C`a�

� ¿á�àY�å�É Fop�C`­eÕÖGop�â�ãàYfG7�ª�����

�«fó>¤"�z«@�O�@�Ã�ÄÃ-�G�å3���-�FÎ�Ke'dBC

`aQ4fÁÂð>µ�â�ã\-�D'��@�nå�É&A¹'dBC`a�

� Ã�,f�X���@�YÁÄ�S�Fop�C`a�

� 0� �;�\dt��EDC`a¤�þ��S�Fop�C`­eÕÖGÅ­®ìF�

D'dBC`�i��@cÆ;�pËÄ�÷7JK�·æ&åJBC`rn&G�X¤�

�6�00�6

Page 13: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

�þ�méê�¦&�¹E@�nj@FG¤"�z«&dJe'fG�O¼;¾;@Ö�

3�e'GÆÇpË�ÈPµRF`@JGT"9�­;¤"&�B�CeE@jkFop

�C`aÃ�¨©G������^Y��²èé&r��"��þñ�ð#�Óì© Ö

op�CD'G0� XYÉ�pËm�i��GcÆ;@ÖÕÑ�YTU�EDCDEaE

HG�ueÖpË�Ä@D'f�s��¶·�ÁÂ@�n�n&A¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKG/W �;�\dt��EDC`a���¤�þ�@¤"�z«��B�É@

�nj@Fop�C`a0� XYf¤��¤"���m��ÊF�BC`µ[XYÒ W�/�

�T"@�nÖ�\,[¹'S��EDCDE­eÕÖG�;�G¤D½;� ¬­m�

�Õ¯DErn&�&¥¦Fk�¶·[X\·[¹'��@�nj@��JG�ÛäF

�;��*m.÷�@�nj@FË�ÌÍD'��@�nj@AÕÖÓCÔ'G¤"�z

«���&rBXY±JK¤"m[Î�¦FS�DE@jkFop�C`aÛ&�Ûä

Ff 0W жëGµ[XÒF}�¶·�÷"@�n��Fu¹@S�D'��@jkFo

p�C`aCEG/W XY�­;¤"&�_CD'ÖG��Õ���æAþ��ÏÐ\#

­CD'G[XY���@�µÒF�ÛäF E�g�÷G�4�F 0�E�÷Gn�U°FÖ

/�4�÷@�n����\�>�e'G÷"9�­;¤"&�B�ÊFdKe�@jkF

op�C`a�

� �&G/0 �;�Fop�C`­eÕÖGqÕÖ@D'�¢£��}~TÑ�ñò&�

�' ºDEÖ�FG�hJKdÒDD'��Ö�Fop�C`mGð>��KeE�¢

ç*�ÆFGdÓF`@JG]Ô�u;àGâJ®9>Õ;Æ; &d�'f.ÖYÖ

��&���e'G�&×ØmÙDsA¹'��ajem�¢}~ÌÚ�ñò@D'µ

_sÎÏD'��@�Ô'dBC`a�

� Ã�rnAÆFG���;�Fop�C`­eÕÖG�¢£�\Æý&£�M�^Y�

}~úµµR&GrBðÛ�B�ÊF�JA­eÇ�­A�@�Ô'dBCD'G}~�

&»Ü;9`�¦§¨©@D'Gð�fm¢wG�½w��Ý�"GÖnð�fd�D�

AÕ�ÖY�Þ3@�n"Gß��f£�&µ`�§¼;�@�¹EàwæA# GÃn

�¹E�"\áÔ�rnA�F�k�kAµR\û�'��@jkFop�C`a!Òæ

&¯D·ÂC`@Gm¢wG�½w@�n"FfG!ÔÇ¿á��n&op�C`­eÕ

ÖGzâ9D¹'G�â½JÖa|@�nrnAá¨Þâ©FGãw¬­�äåAÕFèæ

\dæË��ç��Gdèc�\�AÆ;éÙ©&D'£��m¢wG�½w@�nÖ�

\»Ü;9�^'�EH�EBD'dBC`aCEGKÆ⨠\��DE¤� 0WW��

�6�0/�6

Page 14: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

ÖY�£�@D'��Ò\À��@�nj@\�hJK¯D·Â'dBC`­eÕÖGÕ

n�¹EKÆ⨠\ê7F_��JG���f}~����m£�@�Ò`�j@&�

�'ÕÊA#­�B\�e'���J@�nrnA¦ë\�wìDE@jkFop�C`a

I¥¤íÍ.@JàY\îOD'��rnA@jk&gïð�EHsE�&G'(æA

ñ;Æ\ò°`� ��B�É\Ù_í_À�'�_E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKG�Nóôìí;�@�nj@ÖP��õV@�n·Ff�&Fñ@�nj

@Fop�CD'G�Nóôìí;�n«�l�¬·\¥�@�nj@FGöñ9¡*\

W¢DE÷øG���f��àY�ù�@�nj@FG¡*@�n*H­FfAs'GÃ

e\À����õ���@�nj@ÖF"\ù�'SÀD'�s��\ع'��@jk

Fop�C`a�

� �� /E �;�fg��CFF`mG£��^Y�^���\«®æ&�BC@�E

Ö�Fop�C`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ÃeFfGí_CD'GL��1&�_CD'L�zú<=JK()\dt�DC`a�

7ûüL�zú<=� L�zú<=Fop�C`aq��JKfÙ_í_CD'L��1

&��'g()�EDC`a��f�ý�s¹'�EH_CD' /4 �;�JKFop�

C`a�

� Cu��&�¢£¤"�«�@�nj@Fop�C`mGb�Êg�Ä�@dBG�¢

£&�_CD'fµ_s¹��¾<Ô½;mop�CD'G�å3�ê£@êåe'dB

C`� ¢]�# @�N/%JK�'C�BC`�¢]�ôV@�n}©B&µ_s

Je'op�C`a�

� � ¢]fCu12/%�# mjj&op�C`­eÕÖGjef 0� X}Ð�wo

p�ÁÂFop�C`mG3² 0WWWþF 5E ²��Õܹ'dBC`aÃem�ô/%&

C�BC`@G�² /4WW þF M4 ²��ôDCD'G@!&Gjef 0É XY�ÁÂF`

­eÕÖG4g ²��Õç*&�D'��a��ÑEBU° �É ²¬F�D'��@�nj

@Fop�C`a�

� ·�G�¢]��nFop�C`­eÕÖG�¢£�Ü*þÁfjj&op�C`rn

&}² g4WW þFG0g� ²�\Ü*D'��@�nj@Fop�C`a�¢]@�9àÆ

§¨&ê£\J­xå^CDE-ä]@�nÖ�m�Ce'op�C`a�ô�Åä&�

�6�0E�6

Page 15: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

_C`@GMggW þF 0W5 ²��ôDG@!F�¢]F /g ²�G-ä]Ff /5 ²�mÃ

eüeç*&��@�nj@Fop�C`aÊÅ&�_CD'fG�¢]m��ÑEB°

E� ²¬G-ä]&��'f° 50 ²¬@�nj@FGÖ�£FÖ]£&r¹'jeH­�

�²��m��@�nÖ�Fop�C`a�

� �G/g �;�Fop�C`mG�¢£�÷�µR@�nj@Fop�C`a«á�,

�¥\,'�EH_C`@GoKÊ�@dBG�¢£�12/%@�n�fX�þÁmT

¹'dBCD'G�ÁÖT¹'op�C`aj�12��m�&Z«�DGð�F�

�Mö£�²mè��FS�D'��@�nj@FG12�£�÷�\¥�@�n�m�

&FñA<V@A¹'op�CD'G12�£&��'f÷���@�nj@FG,�

¿áFop�C`­eÕÖGUV /MXY&f 0MX&Ò×' 00²��%DCD' ME ²�

\��&÷�\¥¹'��@�n��Fop�CD'GI[��'Ü*�ÁmUV�X¶

h,m¹'op�CDEmG��Õ�­®ì\,'�EHs@dåJB�@dBG�²�

¶·GUV 0� Xf÷�&X�'op�C`a�

� �ýd�sB�EH_C`@G�²^>àYFop�C`a�

� Cu��&�¢ö£¤"�â�ãàY�«ñFop�C`a�

� j�àYf£���e�&�å^CD'GUV}XJKCàY@D'sv�eEÖ�

Fop�C`­eÕÖG�¢ö£��²m,DE*x&G¤"�â�ã\-�`�j@

&r¹'�¢ö£�¤"�^>\¥�@�nÖ�Fop�C`a�¢ö£��²&�_C

D'fG��ÕU�¯D·ÂCDE­eÕÖG�� ¢]&��'fÙ_í_�¦A×_

FS�D'op�C`a�¢]&�_CD'fG\�Ff���²�Ì,&��CD'Ì

,»¬FS�D'op�CD'G0� XYZ}MZ�MZ* ±ì&¤"�â�ãmu�

åe�{�&A¹'op�C`aâ�ã�-���f«á�,\oKÊ�EH_C`@G

0� XZ� ±ìCFFop�C`­eÕÖG// �¬�u��µ&A¹'��@�nÖ�

Fop�C`a�

� �G/M �;�Fop�C`aó>L���²^>àYFop�C`a�

� jef!"±��²^>&�`�CG�å3�!^C&�R�'�>�e'��Ö�

Fop�CD'GN!"O��� �þ���\©�CD'^>�²��Æ&_`�²\

^>�^�j@&r¹'G}~���L��^>��@¤"��/%^>&�`�@�n

Ö�Fop�C`a£���_`�²f 0� XY&ïBCD'�¢]G-ä]\Æý&Ì

,»¬FS�D'op�C`ay��²&�_CD'fG��æAß×m��å­Fop

�6�04�6

Page 16: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

�C`­eÕÖGÆ�"��;��{�AÕop�CD'Gè��FS�D'��@�n

��Fop�C`a�

� �ýd�sB�EH_C`@G/É �;�&ABC`a�¢£�ô ¡*y�/%^>

µRFop�C`a�

� �¢£�ô&�_CD'fG«á�,�¥&op�C`rn&G�¢£�ô/%^>µ

R{OG�å3�ß9=¨àY@�n�mop�CD'Gè�íÍ~\¦¹E*x&k¦

\â'Ê`�@�nàYm��å­Fop�C`mGÃe&â®àD'IXYJK �|

m±0~\,[¹E*x&Ã��¦\�mâ'Ê`�a�ô£¤"��|wÌ,³´µR

{OG�D'³´µR{O@ê¹'dBC`­eÕÖGjn�n{O\��DE@jkF

op�C`a�

� CEG*y/%&�_CD'fG�h�� �y¤"^>�ã�0�\W¢DCD'G

³´u�\Øn.EA�y�²�â'ʳ´u�ÛÁµR{O@�nÖ�\IXYJKø

ùDE@jkFop�C`a�

� /� �;�Fop�C`aL��þ��S�Fop�C`mGL�n«���ÄfG£

&��'f¸�ø���¤Gz�&��'f�Ä-F�è�ªw�§¨ì9§¨��¤&

�¹'ð�æ&��ÄmË'dBCDE­eÕÖG£�Gz�JKy����$þñ@

�n�mddc�ð �EDCD'G£�@z����Äf[λ¬FS�D'op�C

`aL�n«���Äf�w!Ç�FS�@�nj@Fop�C`a�

� �ýd�sB�EH_CD'GEW �;�Fop�C`a�"L��}~úµµR@�

nj@Fop�CD'G£�f��Äf[ÎD'C�BCDEmG}~&��'fopF

Öø���¤¶[���&"D'�A���@�nj@Fop�CD'G£��@jkF

Ög()mop�CDE­eÕÖG�"L��}~úµ\¥¹'�s,ñm��@�nj

@FG�"GL���½wMm¢w��Ý�F G}~��P�õVG�"L��þñú

µSÀ@�n�"\Æý&�B�É\D'op�C`a�

� ª«æ&f,&ÒD'dBC`rn&G�½wMm¢w�@jkFfG!ÔÇ£�&f

ij�#$&�¼�A¾9t�¨%%�\&Ô�'(�±lmhs�Ce'��@�nr

nAj@\}~����&»Ü;9`�@�nrnAj@\%¹'dBC`a�

� CEGL�&µ`�}~��P�õV@�nj@FG¤��}~�@JG�ç#�Ö)

*@¤"�@�-����]@�nÖ�Öع'dBC`a�

� CEG�"L��þñúµ@�nj@FG�¢]G-ä]&��'f�"+£�,`�

�6�0g�6

Page 17: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

À@�nj@FG¿á�,&¯�'��ß;D\³¹'%¹'dBC`DGê£&�_C

D'fÃ�,&op�C`z5�b-.|@�nê£/ðß;D\�BCD'GjeF0

1\D'��@jkFop�C`a�

� �&G!"±�J��À&��'Fop�C`aN`�"±�J��À&�_CD'

fUV /gXCF&�2¬&3Ç`@�n��m��å­Fop�C`mGUV 0� X&d

_CD'f 4EWW �¬�Y&A¹'dBC`aÃ�nËG!"±fµ« g�/��Õ\I�

'��@�nj@Fop�C`mG£�&�_CD'fGUV 0� X�J�Äm /M0 ©¨

@�nj@FG0É Xm M4 ©¨@�nj@F`�FGE�M Ý&÷7D'op�C`a£�

&��'fop 0� XY���F�©:�Gß�;Ó»G¸�AÕ 0W¾�&J�D'dB

C`mG��J��4&ABCDEÖ�@D'�"5Â'op�C`a»¼½¾&�_C

D'fG0M X 0/ Ð�J��4¶ëG0� X&f 0/M�g ©¨@�nj@FG0W�É �¬�J

����mop�C`aCEG67&�_CD'fGÐX*Ð�J��4¶ë É4�4 ©¨a

¾:8&�_CD'Ö 0�É©¨J�D'��@�nj@Fop�C`a�

� IG9:GÓ¨;¦;9AÕ /É ¾�&�_CD'J��4&¬­EÍ_J­\ع

'��@�nj@Fop�C`a�

� CEGê£/ðß;D&�_CD'fGÛ-�§�¨©AÕFje\³¹'%¹'��

å­Fop�C`mGvX�Ð&67&d�'wv"£�,`�À§�¨©@�nÖ�\

�_CD'G�<=µ>&Ög�l�EH�'¥�\?DEÖ�Fop�C`a�

� £��^Y&�_CD'fGjj&¯�'��©BFop�C`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ÃeFfGí_CD'!"Q@M/%^>µRA=JKg()\dt�DC`a�

7vB!"Q@M/%^>µRA=� !"Q@M/%^>µRA=Fop�C`a�

� E/�;����&�R_CD'!"Q@µR&��'g()�EDC`a�

� UV 05 XJK�è!C^�±C�v²�Ø&rBCD'Gð>i?¶·�!"Nèf

OP��&�¹Eè!C^�±�OPm,ñ@A¹'dBC`a�

� è!C^�±C��µ���Fop�C`mG�@ÊÕ�!"NèfOP��&�xD

'����Fop�C`aUV 0� X 0/ Ð�w�"��xNè�f �����G��xNè

f[X� g0þJK 4/þ�@��&TUD'dBC`a�

� !"Q@µR@�EDCD'Gè!C^�±�{¢��À&¬­G�!Þ����%t

�6�05�6

Page 18: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

;�&�DEE��RsBGè!C^�±�§J9�;{¢ �SÀ&,ñA��sv\

ع'dBC`aª«æ&fDÖ{¢���svGCEG.EA} ��â÷�_½;à

{O\øù�EDCD'Gà©ÙD¦§¨©�svAÕ\SÀ`�j@@D'dBC`a

CEGEà&r�u�øùÖ}XÃF=`�j@@�EDCDEa�

� �&Gè!C^�±�{¢��À\¥�E���v��\UV 0� X�Ð&R>Gq�

DE@jkFop�C`mGopGv�v��&�R_CD'�ä4�­;�R>\SÀ

D'��@jkFop�C`aUV /W X�Ðop /� ��ä4�&d_CD'R>ÈÉG

���f{¼æ&�TÆ@�n��&A¹'dBC`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� Ù_í_CD'G×±G¤<=JK()\dt�DC`a�

7H9×±G¤<=� ×±G¤<=�H9Fop�C`a�

� E4 �;�Gè!G¤\�����Fop�C`a[[g()D'��Ö�mhnop

�C`�FG���@jkH­()�^'�EH_C`a�

� Cuyá�®&�_CD'G0� X*Ð&IJ�&A¹'dBCDEmGj@D�*Ð

&'«KwymLMGNOGP¿ F���eCDEa��\�)DC`@G]-àQf

R>�e'dBCD'GSD�¨�TU¼�V]F�kn@�nj@mop���eE@

jkFop�C`a`×'�N*&µD''«ïë \Ø�CDE­eÕÖG]-àQf

R>�e'��@jkFop�C`aIT�@@Ö&{��1��)\À�'C�BE

�@�nj@\�Ô'���ZFop�C`a�

� ÃeJKG,��&N*Åä&d­�W�ûû��X\W¢DEG¤OP�SÀ@�n

j@FG^nA!"±\¤"D'�sj@m�vH@�nj@Fop�CD'GÛ&W�

ûû��X\W¢DEG¤OPmØåe'��N*&��'&��\D'�jn@�nj

@FGUV /W XYJK��\�d`�E��N*ó��\*VD'�s@�nj@FG

ÐXYGvXY&��'G`×'� ��!]&��'�;§î®§¨\R>`�j@@

D'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKGø��Fop�C`a�� Eg �;�Fop�C`mGopG�¤��&d

_CD'f¿,�@dBFop�C`an«@D' /WWM XG�wYZF�ò­\�å¹

'dBC`mG040 ��YF�kn@�nj@a/WWÉ XfopCF�ò­F /W ��Y@

�nj@Fop�C`aX�±T@�nrnA��&A¹'��J@Á¹'dBC`a�

�6�0M�6

Page 19: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� ÃeJKG¸�"�£�JïqVFop�C`mG0� X�Ð@kÐ&w¸Ã�'(æ

A�x\�]�EDCD'GÃ�ã"¯\�`@�nÅä&A¹E���CCFop�C

`aop&d�'Öw¸ÃF��T\í­'��@jkFop�C`a�

� ���;�Fop�C`aè�ªw�§¨ì9§¨�Fop�C`aÐX�Ð&[\G

]8Fè�ªw�§¨ì9§¨�m�¤�EDCDEavX&d_CD'fGè_ÊF�

�¤fop�@jk^j¹'dBC^ÊmGÑ9�G�ÛäFdd_D��>&d_CD

'è�ªw�§¨ì9§¨�>§9àm���e'dBC`aopÑ9��`ê9abF

�cG�Ûä�]�±dF�cF`a�@G��ßabFop�e=Ù©FKw&A¹'

��Ö�m�cop�C`aÃeüeT�\©�CD'�f� EWgh iÄ�*zNè&µ

D')ïïë \Ø�CD'G`×'�*zNèF�¤D'�A�j@m���e'dB

C`aCEGµR&��'Ö�j&���e'��@�nj@m���e'dBC`a�

� �ue&D'Ön�&d_CD'GÃ��� ¡�Ûä&d_CD'klF�zmno

�}p\ع'��@jkFop�C`aCEGn�&d�',ñ@�Ô��&d_CD

'fzmno�kl}p\��D'��@jkFop�C`a�

� ÃeJKGq�&d_CD'Ö�§¨ì9§¨�m�¤D'dBC`aop�@jk

4W��Bmã"�e'dBC`a�

� �ue&�EDCD'Ö»:9\Æý&^j¹'dBC`�FGJABrs&µD'�

¯tm^_'��@�nrnA��Fop�C`a�m�@�EDCD'fG��rs�

uv\VY��D'��@jkFop�C`abc�&dJeCD'ÖGÛ-&ØJe�

@_Gw7 F}pßÙ©mop�C`�FGÃ�ßÙ©�·\©ÆD'�EHs@�n

rnA�F�}p\��D'��@jkFop�C`a�

� ÃeJKG*yN*�G¤µRFop�C`mGj@D��Ð 0É w&y�;áSD�

¨���m�eCD'Gopo*F�{¢m�e'dBC`a�;áSD�¨&�_CD

'fopJABN©m��@êåe'��@jkÖop�C`mG�ùù��ï¹'��

rnA@jkFf` N©mÒ�e'�A�@�nrnA@jkÖop�C`aË»nÕ

opj��ìf{x��Ì,`��ìFop�C`�FGjeJK�GÃD'ÑGy&J

­'{x��·ç`��ÖÓCÔ'I��� \,'C�BE�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� �ue&D'Ö�K&Ü*OP�uv\À�'C��j@Fzw{��r|&})''

�_E�@�Ô'dBC`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

�6�0�6

Page 20: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ÃeFfG�&��*&�BCD'G!":;<=JK()\dt�DC`a�

789!":;<=� ��*���;��\d�_sH��a«,Fop�C`mG56

7NO-�&�_CD'fG�m�fhcANO�Dº\�vP®@�EDCD'GJ�

�@Jï��c®¨à�@eE~e9;9��)\�óD'-�&�B�ÊF��@jk

Fop�C`a�

� /WW4 X3ÐÉ&f-��µ¾@A�¾�Éx+mG/WWgX 0/ Ð�67CD�T\/C

D'GÃ�GÐX3ÐG���fvX}Ð&NO ¡�N"Yç*»DÞà�T=�@

Ã�>?�m�Ò�eGÃe\EE_9@D'T!mA�e'��@jkFop�C`a

T!m˦&À�ÇG��Õ½=�����&Ö�BCDErn&G�ÐÆ8&V>?�

T=<=à©m�Ò�eGCD�Tm�Ð,8¶ë&�]�e�,©D@A¹'��@j

kFop�C`a�m�@�EDCD'fG·��E����¢GFñY��` AÁ@

��w����Br�AÕ\�s��D'dBCD'GIÖL�Jï�@D'���m

F_��BKL�e�rn�µ���3\D'C�BE�@�Ô'dBC`a�

� u¹@¤Ç�^'�EH_CD'GT=���ÄÒ m¯Je'dBC`mG��;�

�&�¹'�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

� �6�G�e~e�>@fG±%�;Kà�~e�e�\Øn�>Fop�CD'G�

��@fG�6��ñ§&7ÔCD'G�� ]\�c�>Fop�C`a�m�@�E

DCD'fG��Õ�567�h�æ~e«à\âL`�Ö�@D'SÀD'��@jk

Fop�C`a�

� �� &��'f3Gk�;�&¯�'dBC`mG�&/�;�&�K^'�EH_

E�@Á�C`a��Õ½=�����&Ö�BCDErn&Gw����&�_CD'

fG*Ð /É wJK�Ð�wCF�w�F��=�¨�®F�]�eG½D§à©Mdì

í;&�R_CD'�^YG£�&��'òÆæAT!mØåeE@jkFop�C`a

wváJKfv�!"#=m�lDCD'G�m�&d­�!"O�Fñw%!"O\�

Bbs�����\()DG�E¦ÑàYAÕ���&f��KeA��\��`�AÕG

�m��)*\)�&1ÔE@jkFop�C`aÙ_í_���)*&fµ_A�EB

mop�CD'G3Ð,8&n�F�]�e��>��[�x&d_CD'ÖGyÁY�

o@�T!\�K&À�Ke�j@@A¹'dBC`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

�6�0��6

Page 21: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ÃeFfG�&���@�G��������1&�_CD'!":;<=JKg()

\dt�DC`a�

789!":;<=� CuÐXYÖ()DCDEmG�������*&�BC`rn&G

UV 0M XY�!"±�²\Î>`��&ST��°T&�R_CD'G������r

n&GUV 0MXJK /0 XY����\�VDE@jkFop�C`aj����\OP

D'�så�É@D'jeJK()DC`���%��rn&[XY�����@Ã��

�GÃD'Ñ�XY����\�VDG!"#��g+,\�¹'��@jkFop�C

`a�

� ÃeFfG���&�R_CD'Gos��&¦§¨©�É\()�^'�EH_E�

@Á�C`a�

� ������;��Fop�C`mGUV 0� XY�����@��Fop�C`a�

� Cu����"O ���)Fop�C`mG���������@V©�@jk\,

'�EH_E�@Á�C`mG�x��´Fop�C`a0� XY��>NO���>�

&�_CD'fG`×'�!]&d�'[XYJK��&¬·D'��@jkFop�C

`a�

� �x��´Fop�C`mG�xÜ���²èé\ÓCÔCD'G/W XYJK�¢£

�ô/%&µ`�³´µR\øù`�j@@DE@jkFop�C`a�

� ��}���Ü���Fop�C`mGÜ��±��G� É�² MWWW@�nj@FG

µ[XÒ �WW TFop�C`mGTU»¬&�|�mJJ¹'��@jkFop�C`a

CEGþ��;9D�Ùâ�§�;�G5û�&�_CD'f�� gWWW &µD'��

5WWW �,¶ÉGCEQRB@nÖkjD&�_CD'f�� ÉgWWW &µDG��

É5WWW@�nj@FG�ueÖ���úµm¥KeE@jkFop�C`a�

� ���G!"±&JJ�^nFop�C`mGW�ûû��SC\W¢DCD'GG¤

OP\ØnN*�����\�VDE@jkFop�C`a�

� *x�GLô�SÀFop�C`mG¹���´Fop�C`mG�Nóôìí;��

��¡*f[XrB E/¡*÷7DG/4� @A¹'dBC`a�

� �&G�x�f¤ÇDCD'G�x�Gè!>�Fop�C`mG¹���´Fop�

C`mGê£��æ0"��dMW¢\SÀ`�E���T�\�)DE@jkFop�

C`a�

�6�/W�6

Page 22: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� 3x�G�©Ü�Fop�C`mGß���´Fop�C`mGÓ¨¦�>� &r�

§áì¨;î�F M�ãGÜ�����.�&µ`�u�\��DE@jkFop�C

`a�

� kx�Gò�� ¡�OFop�C`mG¤�ïë«à�� �\}ó>z«Ø¹E@

jkFop�C`a�

� CEGß���´Fop�C`mG�½wGm¢w \»Ü;9DCD'G£��}~

úµ\u�D'dBC`a�

� /x�G£���©��1Fop�C`mGè!ç*3¾îGL�ÈP�� 0É ¾îF

V�sv\��D'dBC`aCEG�¢]£�&�_CD'f}~úµ&��E@jk

Fop�C`a�

� �&G���&�K^'�EH_E�@Á�C`aUV /W XY�������v��

������@�nj@F�^'�EH�'dBC`mG��;��Fop�C`a�

� Ü�èé\#­CD'G�"Ü�&)�DE!"�SÀm&rBÖ,ñH@�nj@F

op�CD'G/W XY�Ø×­;&�_CD'fG¦§¨©@�EDCD'}"5Â�

^'�EH�'dBC`a�

� ð��mGÜ��±��G��úµ����SÀFop�C`a�xÜ�²�èéÖÓ

CÔCD'GN��uvæAW¢&rBG��Ü�¤"%{¢\SÀ`�j@@D'dB

C`a�

� CEGè)*�±Gþ5û��¤"úµGÜ�¢¸�{W¢�SÀ\Û&À�E�@�

Ô'dBC`a�

� ¹��@�EDCD'fG§áì¨;î�^>æ{¢«à��)mFñH@�Ô'dB

C`a�

� ���ÄÒFop�C`mG¿&¯�'dBC`a�

� Ü��±���G�@DCD'fG}² �÷7\�óD'��@�nj@Fop�

C`a�

� QRB@nÖkjD&�_CD'fGÐXYÖ÷Ô'dBC`mGIX�K&÷%DC

D'G/² /WWWGþ5û����úµ&��'ÖÐXrB�K&÷%DCD'G

ÉWWW@�nj@FG÷7DE�@�Ô'dBC`a�

� CEGÜ�¸ &��'Ööñ9��&r�{W¢�«à �@�nj@FGöñ9�

� \µ�&÷%DCD'Gn���\DE�@�Ô'dBC`a�

�6�/0�6

Page 23: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� CEG§áì¨;î&�_CD'fG§áì¨;î�{¢Ä\�²6a�©¨�÷7\

�óD'dBCD'G�xÜ�@D'�{¢%G���f� ��{¢���{W¢��

À@�nj@F /W��\�B�cj@@D'dBC`a�

� CEG§áì¨;î���àY@�nj@FGvXYÑJK�&DE�@�Ô'dBC

`a�

� ¶·G��Ffop�C`mGg()&JÔ�^'�EH_C`a�

7¾¿#�=� ÕnÖ�Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ¶·F()f�ì�EDC`mGjjFË»¹@�Ãf�D'���F`mG0W Z

��\@K^'�EH_E�@Á�C`aj�#���­F 4g JKV��^'�EH

s@�nj@FrkD�FD»nJa�

� FfG����@�nj@&�EDC`a�

}��k ���

}�*� V��

+� ,� -� .�

7¾¿#�=� ÃeFfG#�\V�DE�@Á�C`a�

� ���Ã[�{¼½JK�()ÖÓCÔCD'GlqGg+, \GÛ& ]f�Ku

�e&g�ê�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

� g�xF��&Ñl�e��f[�æ&g+,\� DE�@Á�C`�FG��&g

�ê�EH­eÇ@Á�C`a�

� ÃeFfGÕAEJKFÖ¨ F`�FGÕnüG¤9��a�

7¤9��� qf�Ûä�¤"��z«�¡¢��)*Fop�C`­eÕÖGI()�

EH_CDErn&G@nÖkjD�²G�å3��xÜ��²m}ÐÎ>�EH�E�

"G�eFË�s�JA@�n£ÊÖ�¹Eå­F`mGÃn�nj@&fAKAJ¹

E@�nj@FGÕßåKu·çD'��a*ÐJK�Ð�"FÖ 4MWW ¬�K��·ç

m�¹E@�nj@F`JKGjefo*&d�'fÛ&�!G�NGn!]Gjefµ

�6�//�6

Page 24: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

_AÎÏm��å­F`­eÕÖG��*xf��²mÃe&�n·çm�B�e'�A

�@�nj@FGáà©m·m¹'��@�nj@F`JKG�&/%m¤�D'��

@�nj@mo*Ff{�Fop�CD'GÛ&n����ÓÚ»� /g��s\I�'

dBC`�9àƧ¨�¥�ôGjemI�²m�&˶ÊF_'��@�nj@m

op�CD'G}Ð&Î>D'�EH�'Gß9=¨{O�âLµRÖ��å­Fop�

C`mGÑ��±0~�¾c;Gje\D¹JB@�B�ÊF��å­F`mGÃe¶·

&CE·çD'��@�nj@fI¯D·ÂE@dBFop�C`a�

� ð�G�xÜ��^>àYGjem*ÐJK�Ð�j�CC���FCES�DC`@G

qVf0��qVaj���F·m¹'�_C`@G©â'Ê�ã�ôBïem�Ks

0gWW�¬�s&A�Hkn@aN`�".&Ög�3�EH�'G�WW�¬fôBïe\

^j`@�nj@\gÎ>�EH�Eå­F`­eÕÖG�w gWW�¬¶·&��'f�

Èm)¹'�A�@�nj@F`JKG*ÐJK�Ð�â'Ê&��'fâ'Êmì%F

_�# m��å­F`­eÕÖGÃe¶ë&��'fj�â'ÊmAsA¹'DCn@

�n�e\qÕÖf�&¦§D'��å­Fop�CD'GÖDÃnAeÇG­�DC

`@ð& �WWW ¬îïm�Ô�@�nj@FG�X[��væA�²��¨JKê�C

`@G�©¨ÑEB�² �WWW ¬�·Â&A�@�n��Fop�CD'GqÕÖ}Ð&

Î>D'�EH_CDE±±�Ûäf��Õ()D'�EH_CDErn&k¦7���

�Fop�C`�FG7�ª���â�ãÖÃ�j@ÖÓCÔ'Î>D'�EH_CDE

­eÕÖGI¯D·ÂCDErn&GAJAJÃeFfI�/%m�& D�@�n

j@Öop�C`a�&��'fF_�AKÇß9=¨�âLG���f�N&��'f

â�ã�ìÆF�>>m�&µ{Aj@F�kn@�Ô'dBC`�FGÃ�j@Ö+

,@D'¯D·Â'd_E�@Á�C`a�

� Önð�G�=GÈÉC^ÊaqÕÖ�3DA­eÇABC^Ê­eÕÖGÜ����

�\Õn·Â'�sJ@�nj@FG��Õ()�EH_CDErn&GÜ�����f

o�Ff /g�G/M X& Eg�@�n��\)''�EH�'dBC`­eÕÖGje&¬

­'qÕÖ¤"o*ÖD¹JB�3�^'�EH_E�@Á�C`mG�Ûä&d�'Ö

)�l�mJAB©n@�n# mop�C`DGQRB@nÖkjDm��F_��

&d�'fD¹JB÷%DAmKG)*��è� Ü�\¤"`�@�nj@fD¹JB

%BE�@Á�C`mGQRB@nÖkjDmF_A�� m��å­F`ajef�

F�ÔÇ�Ûä�����ª«H@JG¿á�¬A��@JGjefð®AmKá;¨m

�6�/E�6

Page 25: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

F_A�ajj\Õn%¹' Ü�÷"&¬­�JaDJÖ)*��è�Ü�\Õn¤"

D'G¤¥Ü�\UDFÖTKDAmK/%\­æ`�J@�nj@\�ÔC`@Gá;

¨�F_A�� f¡¢\�s¹'ÖKnDJA��FGÃj�W.�ì\�J&��'

�sJa�å3�ß¼®¡¢m}ÔA���\±±ß¼®¡¢@�n�f=sEËC`@

¯v®��m[U&ABCD'Gß¼®m}Ô'�s@�nj@mo�F`JKGÃe\

D¹JB°ÔEÆFÜ�÷"\qÕÖ�3�^'�EH_C`�FG±�µ�\D¹JB

¥¹'�EH_E�a�

� }"G+,@D'¯D·Â�^'�EH_C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� â�ã �ìÆ>>�¼½wGÃeJKÜ�÷"�qV&�_CD'g+,\�EH_

CDEa�

� �J&GÕnüdt�DC`a�

7�Å��� §áì¨;î&�D'¹��ÕdAJ^�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

� ð�fG§áì¨;î&LYð�\W¢`�@�n�f�&[eE�Ô�H@ÁnÊ

F`mGð�GLY"O��Ô�JK`�@GF_�H­ð�m�A�rn&D'�s@

�n/%�3\,²&A¹'D'��å­F`�aF`JKGjem^>æ&µÄ&��

�e�@�nj@\[�&`�@Gj�­�fË»¹@xåAsA¹'s��FfA�J

@�nm�EDC`aF_�H­T³�A�G� �A�G´4`�# mUA�@�

nj@\LY:OfÉÊA�óD'��@jkF`�FGje\Ñ'&DEðÛ�SÀ@

�n�fÕnA�JA@�nj@\�µ&Á�C`a�

� Önð�fG^nw��A�F`mG�væ&-L �JK��Ö�fË»¹@d�@

�E@DCD'ÖG§áì¨;î@�n�fLn&vÑ&^nAÜ�@D'mNA�JÕ

nJ@�n�ãF`�a!ÔǶ-�FÕn�n�n&W¢�e'���JGjeCFL

Yð�&r�ߧ:à��ãm���JÕnJaÃ�o&��'ÖDdAJ^�EH­�

@jkm�eÇ@Á�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� §áì¨;î&��'�qV\góô�EH_CDEa�

� Ù_í_ÕAEJa�

7·¸��� qG*y¤"�@D'¹�Gß�d�DDE�@Á�C`a�

� }Ð�Q4��e&µDCD'fG¹7u� \�EH_CD'º&�Bm@nop�

CDEa�

�6�/4�6

Page 26: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� EHGId�D�eCDErn&GÔ��qVG*yf�@ÊÕI±Ü�F�BCD'G

��Ü�\�s�@�¹'ÖAJAJAD�"OFop�C`aÃn�nÆF^>�ã�

qVm�BC`mGjeÖ%fBñò`�@�nj@&ABC`@G�&qEË�/%

m»DsA�@�n�f�&,Ô'��å­Fop�CD'GôBïe@�n�Öop�

C`mGÃeÖôBïe`�JK&f�XG�X�Ã&f¼D'�JA­eÇAKA�@

�nqVÖop�C`aIjn�nÜ�èGÃD'CE���²mj��Y��²Ff@

'Öj�3ÐJK�â'ÊãmAsA¹E*x&f/%fVB)¹'�JA�@Ánå­

Fop�C`a�

� Ãn�nj@FGId�D�eCDErn&G§áì¨;î&�_CD'ÖqÖ�X�

K��B�ÊF_'��å­Fop�C`mGCHCHLY"OZJKf�'s�@Á�

C`aFÖGjefGEHId�m�BCDErn&GEDJª�@D'�'s�Ö�f

T¹'_'�C`a½ÐqÕÖmr¹'dBCDEª�mI±TD'dBC`a^�o*

F�ª�F`�aEHG}~�e'�'s�Ö�&��'fIfCHT¹'dBC^Êa

§áì¨;î&[`Ö�&��'f���Y�>�eC`�FGÃn�n"F{¢F_�

Ö�fÖ¹@{¢D'�­�rnA�RÖ,ñFfA�J@Á¹'�C`GEHGj�"

O&��'&�½�§D9DA­eÇH�F`r@�n�H­FfAJAJj�ÁÂ&f

¹���'�JA��FfA�J@Á¹'dBC`a�

� �k�k@^np< &�_CD'f�Ö5Â'p<\%¹'ÖK¹'��@jkFo

p�C`­eÕÖG&@��CD'ÖGj�ª�m�xÜ��*F�xÜ��ª�@D'

³¹'ÖKåA�@GIG*y¤"�mj�ª�\æ¹'�¹'� �N*F�xD'`

�Ô�&³n@�n�fõSÖA�DGI[�k�k�R�ÆFÖop�C`­eÕÖG

Ãn�n�v\�s�@�n�f¾µAdãmJJBC`aÃe\yõ@J�xF%�@

�n�ÖÃeÖjeJKî¿@D'ð¹'�¹'DCnå­Fop�C`�FG&@D'

Ö�xÜ�¼;¾;�Ê���3\�EH_AmKGÜ�ª�@D'³¹'�EH­eÇG

ÃD'Ü��²�hUAB@ÖÊ,Â&�Am�@�nrnA�\@¹'�EH­��m

ðxqEˤ"�@D'f�à©FfA�J@Á¹'dBC`a±�Ãn�nj@Fdt

�\DE�@Á�C`a�

� Ãe@�y��²â'Ê�qVFop�C`­eÕÖG��&r¹'À�Fop�C`

­eÕÖGI[ 4MW ¬@�n�>\�^'�EH�Eå­Fop�C`a0� XYJK�

ÁÉÖop�CD'G§\&jem MW ¬�Ê·Â&�Am�JÕnJGIGqÕÖNO

�6�/g�6

Page 27: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

��*x­��EDCDEKG0� XYCFf gW ¬@�n�m�¹EÊF`­eÕG�Â

�>FC�BCDEKG}G�w[&q�@jkF�DCDEKGgW ¬f�^A�G4g

¬Hr@�n�m�'_'�C`�FG%fB MW ¬·Â'ÖK¹E@�nÆFÖìÆ>

>F�BCDE�FGÖD���²mj��²&,m¹E*x&�&AD�@�nqV

mop�C`aAD�@�n�f/%mAD�@�n�Fop�C`a�

� �@f�©�qVFop�C`­eÕÖGIG@*áÖ@*/~�xT@JGÃn�n

GF�©áà©\,Â�rnA�¬F×�'dBC`mG¤"���@�EDCD'fG

ïë�GjefqÕÖNO�fu¹@%¹'_Eå­Fop�C`­eÕÖGïë�@�

nqV&�_CD'f�ä4��{�ÃÄFÎC�å­Fop�C`­eÕÖGn�ð

Ö�rnAÊÅFop�C`­eÕÖGj�"&�_CD'Öïë\D'^ýM^nAÖ

�\�Ä&��`�@�nGj�ïë�\¤"�mn#îï`�@�n�fÕnA�JA

@aÃe&IqEËf^ýM^n�E�&Gj�[Öd�DDCDErn&G©�;�K

½<¨Óà<�� �\D'dBC`aÃeH­FÖ�� 4W¬JK gW¬JJ¹'DC�

C`aÃeFCEjeJKN*�W�ûû�µR@�EDCD'ÖG�k�kAGF}p

ÄùG���fI��N*F`�fF_C^Ê�FGÃe&µD'À�AG\�+DC`

@GJAB�^ýM^n�# H­FJJ¹'DCn@�n�mo�Fop�C`�FG

ÃjKoÖjeJK�,`�©�À`�²&XÅF_A�# fÃn�n@jk��©á

à©�xT&Ö�AÂ'�EH­eÇ@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� *y�1�c�AqV\góô�EH_CDEa�

� Æ9��GÕnüa�

7Æ9��� -�J�BC`­eÕÖG��&Ü��@jkH­dA_DE�@Á�C`a

Û&@nÖkjDm�&èsA¹'s�@�nd�mop�CDE­eÕÖGÃn�¹

EÆFÜ�¢¸�{W¢�SÀ@�nj@\ÇÈÀ�'�D�@Á¹'dBC`mGµ

ÀÊF_'��rnAÁÂm�'dBC`­eÕÖGþ�NèG���f!"Nè&@¹

'¼½Ù©Ö��@aÃn�¹EÆFGDJDµ_A<Vm�¹'GJï@nÖkjD@

��²���Àm��@�n�n&êåe'�C`mG�²��À�E��µR@�n�

fÕn�nj@m�ÔKe��J@�noB\dA_DE��@GÃ�E�&±��kÊ

A÷V@J-�ã@JG���fu�G¿À@JÀ�A�Fdãm³åe'��å­F`

­eÕÖGÃ�XGÃ��ì�,ñw&��'Á�j¹'jj&fëï`�@�nrnA

�6�/5�6

Page 28: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

¼½_½\�­EmNw���³��\D'ÉD�A@�n�n&Á�C`�FdA_D

'���F`mG±�jn�¹E@jk&³¹'�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

� Ãn�¹Ej@@��ÞFG!ÔÇ÷V�³��F`mG��Õ�g()�ÆF!ÔÇ

0¡��¨Æ¾>àY&÷V\`�@�nrnAd�m�BCDEaÕn�¹Eµß�m

���Jq&fåJKA��FG�GæAj@JÖDeC^ÊmGjn�¹Ej@f÷V

m,ñA�Ja%¹'��õEË�@jkF�Ê\ËBx¹'�3Dx¹'F_�j@F

fA�JA@Á¹'DCn�F`mGÃn�¹Ej@a�

� ÃeJKGÖnð�fG����k�;��{¢úµ�u��@jkFG!ÔÇjn�

¹Ej@f,ñA�FD»nJ@�nj@FdA_DE��F`mG/W X"�Ü�¢¸

�{W¢\öñ9��`��&,ñA/~GÃj&�`@�¹'�C`�aj�Ü�¢¸

�{W¢&��'fÖn;&�kÊA��f�e'���FfA�J@Ánå­F`mG

�Ô'CHjj�@jkFÃn�¹Ej@&��'â÷\`�@�n+$@�nJÆÌ@

�n�mG,ñH@D'Ö,ñ�Ì�&D'G,ñA@jk&Ãe\[`@�nrnA³

��\±�D'�EH­eÇGJï@nÖkjD@��1�FñAµ_A<;ß�@jk

mUD,©Dm�'s��FfA�J@Á¹'dBCDEa�

� ÃeJKGÖnð�G0E �;��@jkFz.EAÜ����W¢|@�nj@Fd

�m�BCD'G§ÆÇ;9�g\³¹EÖ�&��'Gj�ÍÎF`@G` &W¢`

�j@m,ñH@�n�n&d¹Dº¹'dBC`mG�"Ü�&)�DE!"�SÀ@

�nj@mµ_AÏH@ÁnÆFGjn�¹EÖ�mI�'s�@�n,©Dm���

Fjnd¹Dº¹'���J@Á�C`­eÕÖG�ñA<V@�n@jk\,C`@G

�&µßA<VmCHCHEs�Ê�¹'GCHï�ÖF_'�AJ¹EBG��)�

@jkÖ��@�nrnA@jkm���FGjn�¹E@jk\IW¢D'�s�m

vÑ&,ñA�J@�noB\ÖnðêóÔ'�EH_E�@Á�CDEa�

� IfÜ��j@H­&D'd_C`a�

7¾¿#�=� ,ñ&��E¼½_½\�­E�ãëï@�nrnA£"JKÀ�góô

\�EH_CDEa�

� ÃeFfGjjFðY�jK^'�EH_CD'G{¼½��JK[®\dt�F_e

Ç@Á�C`a�

7�9!"��<=� ÃeFfGÜ��1Es�Êg+,Gglq\�EH_CDE�FG

d®ÔF_�ÐÑFð�u�d�\DE�@Á�C`a�

�6�/M�6

Page 29: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� Cu¤9��JKQRB@nÖkjD��G�Ûä�� &r¹'fAJAJQRB@

nÖkjD\��F_A�� Ö��@�nd�FDEajefIX����}ÐG�Ð

�T!FÖÖ�rnAg+,\Es�Ê�EH�'dBCD'GqÕÖ��FÖCufo

����G{�\rsÒ�Drn@�nj@FGïÑÓ\ÔÕ�EDCD'Gª«� �

��@�+,-.Ö�^'�EH�'dBC`a�J&� æ&QRB@nÖkjDG.

D�Y]mF_'�'Gµ Ö×�9ÖF_'G�ÛäÖ��m÷Ô'��@�nj@F

f�BC`mGÃeFÖAdAD�� Ö��@�n�f�ÝD'dBC`aÃn�¹E

� FG!ÔÇd�m�BCDEß¼®�»9ìí9ìí \�ïD'G)*��è�¡

¢\�s¹'�saÃ�E�&W.�ì\���rnA��m,ñF��@�nj@F�

eÇGqÕÖ�{O�ÆFÕn�¹Eµ�mF_�JGÙ_í_o�����g+,AÕ

Ö� DAmKo�G�µ�\�Ô'�_E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKG§áì¨;î�j@&�_CD'�Å��JK�EH_CDEmGCuLY

ð�&��'f�`Ä\TK`�mµªrFfA�J@aº&oÖ¹@ÖAg+,Fop

�CD'GÃ�j@fqÕÖÖ` �ÝD'���ÖBFop�C`aqÕÖ@DCD'

fGð��Ä\÷%D'se@�n�ÖBfnsop�C^ÊaÃjfTK`�3Ö�å

^'D'�EHs�H@Á�C`mGo�&f�����;���¿,&V¤{¢���

m���F`­eÕÖGXÃ�¤Äf 00WW ²©¨¶·op�CD'Gj��XÃFfÁ

Âf!Ç�A�F`­eÕÖGj�ÆFqVf���@Ü��mÃÊFdBC`­eÕÖG

CH��&A¹'��ÄmEs�Êop�C`a�Ksj�Æ&fè!�Ô�@D'³Ô

�Ö�mJAB���H@Á�C`awv��ÄFf!"JK�'s���@�n�Ö�

&r¹'f` �BCD'G,uDÖLYð�&��\¹ºDA­eÇAKA�@�n

��&fA�@Á�C`DGcDkè!&�ÔC`@Gè!�C^�±@D'CE��&

ØÙF_GC�&½�§D9&A�å­F`�FGjn�¹E# \Û&mN&W¢D'

Ü��D'�s@�n�3fCHCHF_��FfA�J@Á¹'dBC`a�

� F`JKGÃn�¹E��mÈ�'fÜ�����¬·&�AmBC`�FGÃn�¹

E£"FCHCH�3���m��@�n�n&�Ô'dBC`a�

� AdJ�GLYð�@��C`@G&@��C`JGL×ðD@�n§¼;�m�no

p�C`­eÕÖGÖËkÊÃn�¹EÖ�ÖW¢D'�s,ñm��@Á�C`mG�

�&f^�Æ�F�¼Úæ&�'s�LY="±æAÖ�G�kÊAg£GÛÜg�rn

AG���f�¨suGÃn�¹EÖ�ÖCHCHEs�Ê�4�e'���mo�Fo

�6�/�6

Page 30: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

p�C`�FGÃn�¹EÖ��{¢\è�'�_E�@�n�mqÕÖ����v+F

op�C`a�

� ^nw�qV&�_CD'fGjefÜ�^nC�YZFGÜ�@D'³n*x&ÝE

�A­eÇAKA���Gl�@�n�fÑ(>�Ke'��å­Fop�C`mG§á

ì¨;î&��'f�K&Ãe\{¢�G���&@¹'åJB%`�rn&@�nj@

FG§áì¨;î�;§î®§¨@�nÖ�\ðÐX>�CD'G��&�B�c��f

+{� \ÞJsåJB%`sd�K^D'��@jkFop�C`aÃn�¹E��\

_ËÊ@%¹'�EH­eÇ^nwf` ��F_�Ö�H@�n�n&Á¹'dBC`

DG�f§áì¨;î���àY@�n�\qÕÖIïðD'dBCD'GÃ�ÆFÃn

�¹E;§î®§¨\_ËÊ@+¹')*æ&Ö` mNAÖ�\��D'��O�ABG

§áì¨;î&��'f_ËÊ@��\�Ô'�jn@�nj@\�Ô'��@jkFo

p�C`a�

� ÃeJKG·¸��JKfI�K&§áì¨;î�{¢\À�'�sE�&f�xÜ

�ª�@D'³¹'�s×_@�nd�mop�CDEaIXY�qÕÖ�.D�µR�

ÆF� �LY="±�C�O�@�xÜ�¼;¾;mÞ�D'C�&góô��xÜ�

ª�@D'Ü�@D'�{¢\À�'�s��\u�`�µR\û�'dBC`aª«æ

&fÃn�¹ELYð�GLY="±\�xÜ�ª�@D'³¹E*x&G{¢úµ &

��'úµÄ&��E÷V\Øn@�nå�ÉÖ¢+D'op�C`�FGÃn�¹E�

�\©�'�xÜ�ª�@D'�§áì¨;î�W¢@�n�\µ�&À�'�_E�@

�Ô'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKGÆ9��JKfEs�Ê�EH_CDE­eÕÖGÔ�¸\&�@`��k

ÊAµRG¼½_½\�­'%¹'�s×_@�n�fC�&d¹Dº�@dBH@Á�

C`aqÕÖÖ>�'Ã�j@f®�&ù�'%¹'�_E�@Á�C`mGË»¹@Ë

xm�eJÖDeC^ÊmG�¨Æ¾>���&�_CD'fGjef8ö90¡@�nG

8ö���ÀæA��\��&D'%¹'��@jkFop�C`mG0¡@�n�f¢

m¤Ô'��5��Ô�eÇ��&F_�rn&A¹'���F`­eÕÖG��&fN

èá�GÛ&£\ܹ'��NèÖÃn�n/<mA�a���fno�NèABGßÄ

mG£\0`j@&µD'àe'�A�a!ÔÇá�@JGâQ�e��FfA�J@JG

Ãn�nã®m��@�¹Ej@FAJAJÀCA�@�n��mop�C`aÃn�n

ÆF��&fw�'��5�m�¹'G£\0¡F_�&ÖJJåKuGÃn�n0¡&

�6�/��6

Page 31: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

�DE£m�A�@��C`JG0¡/<£@ÍÊFdBC`­eÕÖG&XÖ!m�Æ

Fܹ'_E£\�_AB0¡�&�DC`@G£��nÖ¡¹sB�EDCD'Gä\

��D'� ßÄ&Úå\J­EB@�nj@Ö^jBdC`�FGæç@�n�m,ñ

&ABC`aF`JKG0¡&àeE£\���Y��F_�rnA«à\�s¹'GÃ

n�n£@�/<�£\xå^'0¡`�j@&r¹'0¡\À��ð��Í¡�æA�

�H@Á¹'dBC`ajem`×'Ff�BC^Ê­eÕÖGjn�¹E��m�&

nCs�¹'��{!mop�C`Ö�F`JKGÃn�¹E{!\{|D��Gjn�

n�¨Æ¾>���\ð��_¹J­&D'0¡\�K&SÀDE�@�nÁ�Fjn�

nå�É\¢+DEÖ�Fop�C`a�

� ÃeJKGÜ�¸�öñ9��{Oaje&�_CD'ÖÜ�¸�Ô�@D'�{¢�

�@�n�f` &���FfA�J@�ngóôFop�C`mG�J&J�'f�"

¸�ÆǸGè�¸G���f��Ffâtß�»DÞภ\è!�Ü�@D'{¢D

'_'dBC`­eÕÖGEHGI�"¸\�K&Ü�@D'{¢D'�s&ÑE¹'

fCHCH` A�,m��@fqÕÖ�Ô'dBC^Êa!ÔÇè!�)*GF@nÖ

kjD&�$F_�@�nj@ff¹_BD'dBC`­eÕÖGð�FG@nÖkjD

@d¸FfÛwm©�C`�FG!"±��ÎÏG���fè!�¤PG)*�GF³�

�&��'fÀ�6+m,ñF��@�n�n&Öêåe'dBC`DG�K&Ô�@D

'³n&ÑE¹'fG��G¦^G�©G�OGÃn�¹EÃ�[ÅäF�'(æA«à

Ö,ñFop�C`DG�K&fd¸\³¹E!"±��7�Ê�@�n�Öµ{H@Á

¹'dBC`�FGÃn�¹Eno# Ö��'öñ9æA��\CHCH%¹'�s,

ñm��@�n�n&Á¹'dBC`a�

� �GÖn�"Gaab�Fop�C`­eÕÖGje&��'Ö��Õ»¼½¾�@

nÖkjD���\ÁÂF,'�EH_CDE­eÕÖGCHCH�¤Äf÷Ô'�_C

`�FG@nÖkjD��$Ü�@D'{¢D'�sj@f,ñAj@H@�n�n&�

ÝD'dBC`a�

� =sA¹'ÈÉC^Êa�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� FfGÕnüa�

789!":;<=� ��Õ¤9��JK���Ü�èé&µD'�gñé m�BCD

E­eÕÖGqÕÖ@D'Ö�X�Ü�èé&µD'¤"áà©m·çD'��@�nj

�6�EW�6

Page 32: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

@&��'f�ÝD'dBCD'G/W XY��²µR&d�'Ö³´æAøù\û�E

@jkFop�C`mGÃ�ÖÜ�èémí�'dBGÐwÖ@nÖkjD�Ó¾ÔÕ

*m�î9 0W Þ¨©\êÔ�rnA��&A¹E@�nj@Fop�C`aj�rnA

,FCu&rBf¤"áà©�·ç&��'f¤"±�²&�s&KL�^Ke�rnA

Q@RsBm,ñF��@�nj@Fop�C`mGÃ��þñ&r¹'ß�D'dB

C`�xÜ��²^>àY�$¢��@JG���f!]o@�/%׬&Ö` f+D

',ñAïð&��'fÀ�E�@�Ô'dBC`a�

� CEG·¸��JK� �y��m�CDEmG� �y@�n�fÖ@Ö@� o@

&G�4�o@&À�$%m�e'dBCD'GÃ�ÆFI[��dãÖW¢D'�å�

É&ßÔE@jkFop�C`mGT�Ãeüe�{�&r¹'$%�eE@�nj@Ö

�BCD'GÃ�ÆF¤"��îïãÖ�B�%�A�rnA�¬Fµ�\�Ô'��@

�nj@Fop�C`aqÕÖ@D'ÖIT�JK:»½¨­ \Ønj@@D'dB

C`mGÃeüeT��ÆF` �Dxåe'G�jAµ�mA�e�j@m,ñFfA

�J@�Ô'dBC`a�

7¾¿#�=� ÃeFfG£�<=Gdt�DC`a�

7U�£��^Y<=� ¤9��JKìÆ>>�j@Fg+,@�nj@Fop�CDE

�FGUDd®Ô�^'�EH_C`@G���nÖµ«Ö�rnA�Ô�H@Á�C`

�F��D'¯D·ÂC`­eÕÖG7�ª���¤"�â�ã �>øùC�i>FÖ

/È{��tD�ß× &rBÛ&,ñm�eÇìÆ>>\`�j@mF_�@�nj@

&A¹'��å­Fop�C`a7�ª���â�ã��fG/W XYf��Õ¯DCD

Ern&�xÜ�&��'´��X �îï\GB¶ÊF�>DE@�n{�mop�C

`�FGo�"F\Ë&Ã�ë>¶·&Nè�îïm÷µD'��@�n��&fA�j

@JKG\Ë&ìÆ>>m,ñ@�nj@fA�J@fÁ�C`aEHGC�ì�JK

D'G7�ª��� &d­�¤��V¤"\��`�,ñm�BC`�FGIG!":

;<=JK�mop�CDEc�AµR�����G�Nè\��E!"Nè�/%��

\` &I@Ö6íD��GI@ÖV¤"m���e'��J` &,'�_E�@

Á¹'dBC`a�

7@!�"^nOP<=� �Å��JK§áì¨;î�^nw�qVmop�CDE­e

ÕÖGÜ�^nC�i>\ÓCÔCDE§áì¨;î�^n���E�&;§î®§¨\

�D'dBCD'GÃ�ÆF¦îñò@DCD'fG�±¯ïH@JG櫓âQH@JG

�6�E0�6

Page 33: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

âQ±lG���fø��µRGÃn�¹EÖ�&��'�f+{�m¯Je'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKG�fÜ�^nCFop§áì¨;î&³Ô�Ö�fõ�L¢&A¹EÖ��

ð�JG���fL¢@D'{¢�eAJ¹EÖ�GL¢&A¹E�H­eÕG{¢�e

AJ¹EÖ�&�¹'dBC`aÃ�ªð�@D'fG��Õ�9<=JKd�m�¹E

rn&G¤"��F�'s�Ö�GÃj\{¢F_A�J@�¹Ej@\IïðDE�

@Á¹'dBC`�FGÇÈg�3@gP�\�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

7�9!"��<=� ��Õ�"¸eCDEmGÔ�¸�{¢&ÑE¹'G�²���À

m�µ�<VH@�nj@A�F`mGo�FfCH�JK�Ý��²�mC�&op�

C`aÃ��²�\�À`�E��ðx�mNASÅ@�n�f%fB���¬·Hkn

@Á�C`aIG0WñÑEB gWW JK 5WWgò�K�mU°A�F`­eÕÖGje\!Ô

ÇÝ��©¨�K�@e�d¸&`eÇG�µ&�¹'áà©m± &A�@�nj@F

op�C`JKGÃn�¹Eêh�Y]\��`�@�nj@mì%�e�@jkFop

�C`mGjef÷ó�§îFIð¤ãô�B�ÊF�EH�'��@A�'�C`mG

%fBð>�XÁfJJ��Hkn@Á�C`aõhæ&fÃn�¹EÖ�m�'s�j

@\ì%DE�@Á�C`aCEGö÷'(FÖÌëï�'(G���f\øG\C_�

'(GÃn�¹EÖ�&r¹'áà©\xT`�@�¹ErnA��mA�e'dBC`

�FGÃn�¹E'(��¢�&r¹'�K&áà©\,Â'�s�3\D'�_E�@

Á�C`aÃn�¹Ej@\��&%¹'�sE�&ÖqÕÖ��kÊA{O�ÆFöñ

9��æAj@&�B�ÊF�_E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7ûüL�zú<=� ·¸����JKL���©�áà©xT�d�mop�CDE�

FGd®Ô�^'�EH_C`a�

� L���©�áà©�Ù_,Â&��'ÖN`�".@D'�&FñA<VH@�Ô

'op�CD'GL�ÈP���^nw¬·�E�&ÈPM7�'(�èY�GA�Df

�×�G.3�ÉE�Aj@\%�*x&��sv~&��'â÷`�@�nrnAj@

Fu�\D'dBCD'GÃn�nj@\©�'�©�xP�A�Dfáà©�ÌT&�

�'C�BE�@�Ô'op�C`a�

� CEG@*�ïë��d�mop�CDEmG@!*&��'fZðùæ&f¥¤íÍ

.�Ê�gïÑFop�C`�FGÑ�@D'Õn�jn�@�nj@Ffop�C^Ê

mGEHGLY^n�vCFfEDJ{O�mLY�^nw&��'fZðùæA¡¢\

�6�E/�6

Page 34: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

în@�nj@mop�C`�FG¤"����mïë�\îïD'�EHs@�n�f

�Eå�A�j@J@Á�C`mGƵAïë�îï@�nrnAj@m���Fop�

CDEKG¥¤íÍ.@�ÃFf@*AÕ&��'f�T�mop�CD'G+,-.\

`�*m�BC`�FGÃn�n*FÖ¥¤íÍ.&o*���\¯D�×'�_E�@

�Ô'op�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ÃeFfGúû��Gdt�DC`a�

7úû��� FA� Ö��J@Á�C`­eÕGq��JKµ_s�"&��'+,\

�×�^'�EH­eÇ@Á�C`a�

� �"�fÜ�¢¸&��'Fop�C`aÜ�¢¸&��'f¤"�@D'Ö^>æ&

õíæ&�B���rn&D'�s,ñm�knJ@Á�C`aÃ�E�&fÜ�¢¸\

wv��èü�@�n�n&UùR­'G�@D'X�Á&­;æ&Õn�n�n&��

D'�s�J@�nÖ�\ª«æ&ÒDE·FGIXfjn�n�n&`�@�nrnA

��yÁ<V&µ`�u�øù\û�'�s@�nrnAj@m,ñFfA�J@�væ

&fÁ¹'�C`a�

� Ãn�nÆFUV 0M X�Ð&R>�eE�N ¡�¢£¤"�����v��Gj�

Æ���Ü�¤"�úµ�@jk&��'fGÜ�¢¸@�n�ýfAJ¹Eå­FGÑ

�f�;9D�Ùâ�§�;�@þåK@�nj@\F"&�B�ÊF�jn@DEå­

F`a0� XJ /W X�����@_&��'�'_E@�nrnA�1&A¹'��J@

Á�C`mG�~þ9�Pmv#=\%¹'dBC`zL��h\�sü��T|Gjj

FÖÜ�¢¸�¤"M{¢��À@�nrnAj@mnEåe'dBC`�FGÃn�n

+$Ff�èü��UùR­m�e�����JA@fÁ�C`aÃn�n+$F���

���v���,\D@�nj@Öïð`�,ñm���FfA�J@Á�C`aCEf

XYo@����&d­����UùR­@�nj@ÖÖnË»¹@ // X¶ë�j@Ö

��E��@�nÖ�\��E·FGj@Df��\%��H@JGÃn�n�n&ª«

æ&ÒD'�B�ÊF�s,ñm���FfA�J@Á�C`aÃn�n+$F����

��v��@��1ÉE�AÖ�\Õn�Ô'�s�J@�n�m��@Á�C`a�

� }"�fG�xÜ��²^>àY&��'F�BC`ajef¤9��JKÖ�BCD

E­eÕÖGUV 0ÉX� 0W ÐJK�X±F�xÜ��²m°}²¬·çDEå­F�B

�6�EE�6

Page 35: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

C`­eÕÖGj�àYm�¹EdJÂF¤"���lîïf�²¬Z@�n�n&&Ô

KeEå­FGjjCF�C¹E0�@½XY¤"�@Ô�¼;¾;m�ÊF�� E5W�

¬�0�FuÔ'_Eå­F�BC`a�

� DJDGj�*ÐJK�CEµ�A 4MWW ¬@�nÊ·Â�ÆFGã���JK �WW �

¬�ôã\D'ÖÃeFÖ�BA�a3жë��KA��xÜ��²�Ê·Â@�nÆ

FG0�\Õn�n�n&SÑ'`��J@�n¦�æAàY���&��å­F�BC

`aÃn�nÆFGqfj��xÜ��²àY�¬�f­æ`×_H@Á�C`aI��

��ÆFfj�àYfmN&�½D'��DG0��qVf�BC`­eÕG�xÜ��

²^>àY�¬�f±�@Ö­æD'�EH_E�@Á�C`aÃ�E�&f0����

�B�\Õn`��JGÃeJK�â'Ê�ã@��1��B�\Õn�Ô��J@�

nj@\sPD'µR\�¹'�s@�nj@m,ñFfA�J@Á�C`a�

� �"�mG�²XÅ@!]o@�/%^>µR&��'F�BC`­eÕG¤"�îï

m÷µD'Gáà©m·meÇGÃ� G��`�ABG£��^Y�`�&XÅF_e

ÇÃeF{fÈcå­F`­eÕÖGÃn��&fXÅmÀCA�@�nqVm��å­

FGÃj&!]o@�/%^>µR\ù���`�@�n+$m��å­H@Á�C`a�

� Ãn�n+$F!]o@&,�@G£��^Y&��'f�O¼;¾;@���-�F

Ã� ��\·ÂeÇ��å­F`mG�O¼;¾;mÀ`&XÅF_A­eÇ��&�

�f·ÂKeA�@�nj@m�BC`aÃn�n+$FƧ�®­m�BC`aƧ�

®­\âs`�E��7�ª���â�ãàY��B�ABG�¢�&µ`�ÛÁµR@

�nÖ�\�Ô�,ñm�knJ@Á�C`a�

� L���nfGç*&r�×BGCEf!]o@�þ��1F�²m�V�eC`�FG

Ãn�n+$FG�²mr­eÇGáà©·ç Ö�vF_�îdm��F_�å­F`

mG�²m¤­eǨ©æ&XÅF_'�A�@�nj@F�BC`�FGjeÖ!]o

@�/%^>µR\áà©�÷µ@`�@��1Fîdm�vF_�rnA/%^>µR

\IÖ�Ô'ds,ñm��@Á�C`a�

� Ãn�n+$FGXÅ���GƧ�®­���GÃn�no�ABG��\ÓCÔE

·F/%^>µR��KA�ù���@�nj@\�´&�Ô�×_H@Á�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� ÕnÖ�Bm@nop�CDEa�

� ÃeFfGþ9��G]���ËFdt��EDC`a�

�6�E4�6

Page 36: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

7þ9��� -�J�Ãn@Á¹'�Ej@m�CDE�FGqf /W XY�Ø×­;�

F"¦§¨©@�n@jk&˹'¹��×�^'�EH_C`a�

� �"Ü�&)�DE!"�SÀ@�nj@mµ_AÏ&A¹'��rnFop�CD'G

ð��fGÜ��±���G�}² �÷7G�&+ÉæAØ×­;m��e'��

å­F`­eÕÖGje\�J&À�'�sJa��f��@D'��å­F`mGÃ�

â�Þàf�& D��FfA�J@Á¹'�C`a��m�B�¹'��@�n�f

wv���@D'f)Aå­F`­eÕÖGÃe\Õn{¢`��«&¨¡�­'�s

J@�nGÃ�å�É�@jkm�&AD�qVHkn@Á�C`a!ÔÇ!"�§î

Fjn�n�nAÜ��þñm��@�nj@G�]�§îG���fN��§î@��

CD»nJGÃn�¹E@jk&�J&�ã@D'_ËÊ@��D'�sJajefÛ&

É��G!ÔÇ�9NO�T�F��@JGN��mxP�CõF��@JGÃn�¹E

@jk&�@ÊÕ1å¹'�A�@�nà�mqfD'dBC`a�

� ����Öþ]���9NO�T�F�9�Ü�¤"&JJå�j@@�nj@\�T

�ð��µ_A}¦@Drn@�nj@\ÎT�eEå­F`mGÃ��YH@�n�n

&Á¹E�nm���H@Á�C`GÖ¹@Ö¹@jn�nj@\%kn@D'��@�

nj@mG�å3�N��§îG·��]�§î&1å¹'�JA�@�­A��Hkn

@Á�C`a�

� ÃeJKG§áì¨;î&��'F`mGCu§áì¨;î���àY&��'ÖnË

»¹@«�g()F_eÇ@à�'dBCDEa§áì¨;î����QR�æ@�å^

'G��\%�j@&r�N©GÕn�nj@\ÖskÊF��J@�nj@Fop�C

`aÖ�&§áì¨;î�ÆÌ&��'��ÕJKUDlqABG[®m�¹Eå­F`

mG{¢ÄF6a��²©¨�÷7@�nj@m��e'��å­F`­eÕÖGje�

ÄÍ@��CD»nJGÃ�o�@jk\Õn,Ke'��J@�nj@\dóÔt�E

�@Á�C`a�

� q�à�Ff�KsLY�^��Æ�F��ð�@�n�f%c\dA�="±G!Ô

Ço���EB�D»nË n¼;¾;�D»nË ngGjef,uµÄ&��Ö�A

ÊF`­eÕÖGjef���«@��F{¢DE�@�nNè�+¬m��å­F`mG

��&Ãe\Ü�@D'³n@�nâ�ÞàmCHCH ��e'�A�aIf&@Jy

õF!ÔÇ6EùF%¹'��r@JGÃn�n�F³åe'��å­F`­eÕGÕn

³nJ@�nÓà<�mF_'�A��BAJAJn«@D'v·ÂF_A��FfA�

�6�Eg�6

Page 37: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

J@�nmD'dBC`�FGÃj�,©DÖ��'UDd�Ôm�eÇdAJ^t�

E�@Á�C`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�C`a�

� ÃeFfG]��Gdt�DC`a�

7]��� }"�Õlq�^'�EH_C`a�

� T��JK�xÜ��²^>àY�d�m�CDE­eÕÖGj�àYfo��Ü�I

±ª��áà©»Ùâ�Ó�ÙD\JABÀ�sD'se'��@�nj@Ff`os�

½D'��@Á�C`DGÃem¤"Åä&@¹'f`osâ®à&A¹'��@ÁnÊ

F`mG��ÕhT��JKd�m�BC`rn&GIXY¶ëôïãFÈPD'�s@

�n�nAj@FG¤"o*FfICFfvÑ&÷J¹E­eÕÖGñ`�&ôïãFÈ

P�EHs@�nj@fõh¼È@�nØ�m�'s�@�nj@F�Ø_�^mJAB

µ_sA¹'_'�C`�FGÃ�oõhæ&�ã�õíw\Õn�n�n&d�ÔJ@

�nj@\dA_DE�@Á�C`a�

� }"�fG§áì¨;î��A�F`mGIþ9��JKÖd�m�BCDE­eÕÖG

§áì¨;î�{¢Y\·Ârn@�nj@fGICF�Ü��^�GÜ���©G±�

\¬væ&ß�`�@�n�nAj@H@Á¹'dBC`aÃe\¤"ÅäFG�væ&

§áì¨;î@�n�fè� �ª�mh�@Á�C`�FGÃn�¹EÖ�\×J`±

�áà©�qV@J�Br�@JGÃn�¹E�kÊAqV"\�Ô'GDJDGÃn�

nrnAß�\�À`�E�&IXY�kÊA�vë��â÷{O\��D'�EH�'

���F`mGo�æ&¬væASC\ßÔ�@�n»§ñ»mAJAJ¤"Åä&A�

@�n�mo�H@Á�C`aAJAJjn�¹E�F±�ÖjADGCEà©ÙDÖDG

CEÜ�&�J&³¹'�sJ@�n�nAGÃn�¹ESC�»§ñ»\&KJ��F

��D'G�ÀD'�JA�@GAJAJ{¢Ym·mKA�@Á�C`�FGÃ�o�

d�ÔÖ�EH­EK@Á�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�C`a�

� Õnüa�

7¬���� q��JK�"dA_DE��F`­eÕG+ÉæAj@\���eE+,

\�¹E�F`mGq��JKfð�f12�£�÷���@�nj@F 0W XF 00²�G

�6�E5�6

Page 38: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

jef�&+ÉæA��Aå­F`­eÕÖGjeCFfè��@�n��m�¹Eå

­F`a�K&G��ÕJK�'��rnAÜ��èé@�nj@FGjefjeJK÷

�D'�jn@�n¤"Nè&@eÇ�K&µ_A��Aå­F`­eÕÖGI÷�@

�nð�GÜ���@�nÖ�m©ED'��&ï��e��Ja���f��ÕJK�

'��rnAÜ�����\ Eg�&·Â�@�nj@fG00 ²�ABG÷�\ÓCÔE

·F�­;&A¹'���JaÖDÃem�&ÁfÁGÜ���fÜ���@�n�A�

jeCF��A��XF�ÁÊF��@�nj@F�eÇGAJAJIê¹ErnAÜ�

�����@�n+$FµßA�FfAJknJ@�n�n&Ë»¹@�^mop�C`a

F`JKGÃjKo�j@\ÓCÔEª«æA÷�µR@�n�fÕ�rn&d�Ô&A

¹'���Jð�glqDE�@Á�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� FfG�v��GÕnüa�

7�v��� ç*����vF`a�

� lq@�nrBÖð�dt�æAj@A�F`­eÕÖGIwf¤"��ª"F��Ü

��èé��&µ«�&D'dBC`­eÕÖG��æ&f��L�ç*&Ã�£m[¹

'_'Gym[¹'_'G�¬FÖès`KA­eÇò�F_A�@�n��&A¹'d

BC`a�

� ��ð®AmKn�L�ç*Gµ�L�ç*@DCD'fGn��°Êç*@D'�U

ù\�EH�'dBC`­eÕÖGÐIò��Ám·mKA�@�nj@FvÑ&»+D

'dBC`aµ�Gn��*xfµ«mn�\×B,`�EDC`aF`JKG�²��

fF_A�@�nj@FGvÑ&��&Ò×CD'¤"��ñé\�A�@��@�nj

@fAJAJF_A��FG�J&D'��\D'�EHsJ@�nj@F��@DCD

'Öø���¤¶hGÄ�O����fµßg»í�e'��ÆFG£&d_CD'fÐ

X��ÑEB 5WWW ¬�ÕÊ·Â�^'�EH_CD'Gy&d_CD'fÐX��ÑE

B MW ¬Ê·ÂDE�F`­eÕÖGCEIX�Ð�wJK 0gW ¬@�nÊ·Â\dt�

�EDCD'G�Ð�wJK�×D'��@jkA�F`mGÃeFÖAJAJ��â;

©Þ¨Æ;&f�'A�@�nÊF`JG�¬FÖès`��n&�`@�n¤"���

�ñém�BC`�FG��fvÑ&°Êç*@D'fjeF���J@�n�Ô\æ¹

'dBC`a�

�6�EM�6

Page 39: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� F`JKG��@DCD'ÖGIðx���JKh��mh��F`­eÕÖG$Üâ

÷GÃeAB�[�A¤"�&µDCD'�â÷ã@�nqæ�ã\CE�Ô'�EH_

E�@�n�mvÑ&°Êç*�I�o�Fop�C`aEH�&À`�²\·Â'se

@�¹'Ö���bc�ֵ߻í�e'dBC`ajeFCEÊÅ\·Â'DCn@G

}~��emAdðÛ��mJJBC`�FGjjfAJAJÊ·ÂfF_A�@�n�

���d�ÖÐI¸e�¹'dBC`a�

� Ãn�n��F �¹'dBC`�FGIw�Ü��èé\&@J�R\Ö¹'vÑ&

D;98>¨\D'�EH_E�@j&Án@jkFop�C`alq@�nrBÖdt

�Fop�C`arkDsdt�¯D·ÂC`a�

7¾¿#�=� FfGµ!��a�

7µ!��� ��ÕJK�xÜ��²^>àY&�DCD'À�d�m�'dBC`�FG

qÖj��&�DCD'ðêdt�DE��F`­eÕÖG%¹@õ�mF_CD'G

"v��Þ&d_CD'Ö+�õEËmô¹'��@jkAÊF`aEHGj��xÜ�

�èé&rBGÆ���Nèm# |�'�¹'dBC`a½Ð½Ð�NèmT¹'��

�mo�AÊF`­eÕÖGje&rBCD'£����@�n�Ö�'�CD'G"v

�F �g�DJ�'�A�@�n�n&A�'dBC`a%fBjeJK£�\b�Ê&

��`�·&d�'õ�mnCsô�rnAGÃn�nrnA�R@¯DCD»nJG

�²XÅmF_eÇðxneD��F`­eÕÖGAJAJÃefF_A��mo�F`

�FGÃe&µDCD'À��Ô'�K¹Dº�@jk\jeJKÖ±�SDÀ�'�E

H_E�@Á�C`a�

� ÃeJKÖnð�Gjef'(æAj@A�F`­eÕÖGop§£m# UAsA¹

'dBCD'G�ÛäJK�ïDrn@DCD'ÖGãµmI`os»ÙâD'��ÊF

`�aÃeFF_�H­�mè�£&�m¤Ce�rnA�CF$%�^'�_E��F

`­eÕÖGIG'(GF¥G��"É ­CmF_�@�n�m�BC`�FGÃe�

'(��)\IÀ�'�EH_E�@�n�m¹��F`a�

� ÃeJKGI[£���¬Ê·Â&�DCD'`osà�CDE�fG}~�&µD'

�P�õVW×m�J&AD�J@�nj@FDEaÃe\À�'�s·F�mèf�N

óôìí;�\ 0W X�Õ%¹'dBC`­eÕÖG%fBÃn�n@_&d,Ô&A¹

E�&���GÃeJKö�EË&�N�µj�G£��,ñwGÃeJK�£�µj�

@�nÖ�\UDu�d�DD'�sj@DJGvÑ&�äAW×A�F`­eÕÖGÃ

�6�E�6

Page 40: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

n�n�CFDJIF_'�C^ÊaHJKGP�õVW×�,ñw\�sà�C`�FG

�KA��Nóôìí;� �ù�\dt�DE�@Á�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

7f¿��� �"H­��F`JaÈÉC^Êa�

� ns©n�AÊF`­eÕÖG)�FcÆ;mAsA¹'dBCD'GpËÄf` &

�s&��@�ng()m�BCDE­eÕGÃ�o���mÕnA¹'���JóÔ'

�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�CDEa�

� FfGjjFCEð'jBCD'{¼½��JK()�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

789!":;<=� ]����JK��Õ�xÜ��²^>àY�õíw@�nj@

�glqm�¹Eå­Fop�C`mGop��²èé���@�n�fjeCF&A�

rnA��Fop�CD'GÃ�ÆF�xÜ��²^>àY@�nÖ�f 0ÉX 0W жë

IìCFFâ'Êã /5/W �¬�K��`,¶É&A¹'dBCD'GÖn;&ôïãm

,¶É@D'f 5MW��K�&·�@�nrnA�&A¹'dBC`aje¶ëÖI�

�×&��'fôã&A�@�nrnAj@Fop�CD'G�²^>àY@D'fqÕ

Ö@D'ÖmN&jeCFf�½D'�EaCEGjef�&FñF��@�Ô'dB

C`mG%fBhµ��ãm,ñF��@�nj@Fop�CD'GCE�²XÅmÒ(

æÀÊF��!]&��'Öð&�'�s@�n<VÖ��@�nj@Fop�C`a

��Õê�CDErn&Gj�Ü��²�èé&µDCD'fG¤"áà©��sA�²

�XÅ@JG���f/%^>µR@JG©�;îdì&��rnAÃn�nÖ�\À�

®�&ù�'µ�D'�s,ñm���FfA�J@a�xÜ��²^>àYH­FAs

'GÃn�nÖ�Fn«\�Ô'µ�D'�s,ñm���FfA�J@�Ô'dBC`a�

7�9!"��<=� -�Jop�C`mGCuúû��JK�����1@Ô�¸��

èü�@D'�UùR­@�¹ErnAd�mop�CDEaÔ�¸�j@&��'fj

e\I�!"QR�ÆFÕnUùR­�J@�n�fI�T!H@Á�C`DGCE

�����[�,\D��&fÑ(ÃeÖT!�)·&·�Ö�H@Á¹'dBC`aI

�<VH@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKG�xÜ��²^>àYG¬�f­æ`×_H@�nd�m�BCDEaqÕ

ÖÖnsÖ��ÝFdBC`aEHGâ'Ê@�n�f0��¹'��'F_�Ö�Fo

�6�E��6

Page 41: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

p�C`�FGÃ�0��SÑ'\Õn`�J@�nµ_A<Vm��@�nj@@GI

��²èé&µ`�µ�@DCD'fG��Õ��Ö�BCDEmGâ'ÊàYH­Ff

As'G/%^>µRABG��æ&fÀ`�²��XÅGÃn�¹E�Éxå^Fµ�

^p�\dA�@�nj@Fop�C`�FGÃn�¹E�J�GF�µ���@�n�

Ö,AmKj�â'ÊàY\Õn%¹'$¢D'�sJ@�nj@\�Ô'�JA­eÇ

AKA�Hkn@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKGþ9��JK}² ���G��÷7��fµß+ÉæH­eÕÖGÃe

\SÀ`�&ÑE¹'fGÛ&�]�§îG����§î@�Þ�mFñA�FfA�J

@GÃemnCs1å¹'�A��FfA�J@�ngóômop�CDEaqÕÖÖj

ef�&µ_A<VH@Á¹'dBC`a!"�§îFfÛ&���Ô�è�ÆFG�

�Ü�mÉD�@�n�fé�mA�@jkA�F`­eÕÖG5�ÖA�GíÍ3Ö

A�@�nÆFop�C`�FG�]�§î@�Þ���@�n�fFñAí"Hkn@

Á¹'dBC`aÃe\À��&ÑEBCD'fG$×!@�nj@&ÖA¹'DC�C

`­eÕÖGÜ����¬·ü��T@�n�\n���9FÖG���fNOz«G�

K&f�ä4���9FÖ�¹'�EH�'dBC`DGÃ�,&Ü�÷"Ø×�T@�

nj@Fª«æ&�1��ÃF�ã-.`�rnA��Öع'dBC`a�kÊA��

\ع'dBCD'Gj�}² \Õn%¹'"VD'�sJ@�nj@\� G�

Fª«æ&Ø�;D8>¨D'ïðD'�EH�'���F`­eÕÖGÛ&�]�§î

@�Þ�@�n+$FfÜ�÷"F"��@�n�\T� FGÃeÖöñ9��ÉE�

Að��$×!Ffop�C`­eÕÖG�ùD'dBCD'Gop /5W� �Õ�BC

`­eÕÖGjn�¹E� \÷%DAmKGÃ�� �ÆF�]�§î&ÖÜ�÷"&

�3D'�EH­�rnA��\�K&À�'�_E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� §áì¨;î���àYFop�C`­eÕÖG§áì¨;î@IqÕÖfÍÊFdB

C`­eÕÖG*JKjef���F`mGgº��@dBð+@�¹ErnA§¼;�

mop�CD'Gð#�}~�G���f¤"��Æ&ÖJ;<¨ØA§¼;�\æ¹'

dKe��Ö�K¹Dº��f{�H@Á�C`aIÀ��&ÑEBCD'fG��Õ

�^nw�qVG)*�Ê�qVGÃn�¹EÖ�&��'_ËÊ��\D'G,�­\

@¹'GÃe\��D'�Â�å�É@�n�fje\À��&ÑE¹'�&mNA�

Hkn@Á¹'dBCD'G{¢�G���f��æA}~�&^ýà\�Ô�å�É@

D'IïðÆFop�C`a�

�6�4W�6

Page 42: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

� ª«æAå�É�ÄÒfCH-C¹'dBC^ÊFGIC�&ïð\À�'��@jk

Fop�C`a�­eÇIX�Ñ�K�JK&@J$¢DE�@Á¹'dBC`­eÕÖG

CEÃ�ÅäFg()�^'�EHs��m�knJ@Á�C`a�

� §áì¨;î�{¢ÄG6a��²©¨�÷7��Fop�C`­eÕÖGjef��

�©�¨îFµ«XÃ�²©¨�K�6a��;àF÷7D'dBCD'GÃe& /W X

YµR@D'��ÕÖg()�EDCDEmGC�O�@�xÜ�¼;¾;m�3D'÷

7\¥¹'�saj���F}²©¨�K�&@J÷%D'�_E�@�Ô'dBCD'G

xå^'j��²©¨@�n��\�>D'��@jkFop�C`a�

� µ!��JK¥G��"É ­�'(��)�qVmop�CDEaqÕÖj�qVf

I�N�æA!"\%¹'�s·F�&mNA.;9H@Á¹'dBCD'GÃ��

�\u�D'dBC`aª«æ&fè!>�{OzG���f�Ûäè!>�{OzG�

ÚJ<¨Dà�ÛäF`mGÃn�¹E@jkFGjef-�J�'(m�BC`mGÃ

�ÆF�ÖméA�f%/��¥0Á'(Fop�CD'Gjef»¼½¾��1m�<

¨©\æ¹'dBC`�FGÃ��<¨©\wv�õ�$%{O«m�d�EDCD'G

�ÄFÖ�¥0Á�eE%/���mØåe�rn&A¹'_'dBC`ajef�<¨

©�Ö�BC`DG2�Öè�AÖ�Fop�C`�FGj���\u�`×sqÕÖ�

�FÖâ÷{O \¢+D'dBC`�FGI´�&j�F Ö¥Ke'�s�FfA

�J@ì%D'��@jkFop�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7U�£��^Y<=� ð�f£��1Fop�C`­eÕÖGúû����JKXÅ�

�1Fd�m�¹E@jkFop�C`a¤"áà©�·ç\Õn�n�F�¹'�sJ

@�nj@&��'fG�²�XÅ@�nj@Öop�C`DGÖËkÊ/%^>µRG

Ü���ãÖop�C`­eÕÖG34Ê·Â@JGÃn�nj@fÁ@D'ÖG�væ

&f%fB^Y�²�Ù_·Â@�n# F}~���&�jAÐÑÄFîï\D'�E

Hsj@m�vJ@Á¹'dBC`a�

� Ã�ÆFG£��1FfGEW X5BF�¬���Ù_·ÂG���fÀ`6é�²�

0W ¬Ù_·Â@�nj@FÃeüe¼;¾;ABG¤"�z«��F�B�ÊF�EH

_CDEaÀ`�²�Ù_·Â��o���G���f¼;¾;JKÄ,)��7ï��

�&��'GqÕÖF�¨â9¦ëæ&%¹'dBC`­eÕÖG*Ð�w¶ëGICF

�P�õVW×GjefQ4Ö%¹'dBC`­eÕÖGz«G���f¼;¾;��F

�6�40�6

Page 43: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

Ö�e'�E@�nj@Ö�BCD'GÑ��e'�ErBfÒ(æà�;�&#­ïe

'�EH_AmKÙ_·Âm¥Ke'��# f�knJ@Á�C`a�

� EHGµS@GÆÀ%GN�#A�D�N#@FfGUDƧ�®­ABG�Ê�UD

F`­eÕÖG�²&�m��rnFop�C`­eÕÖGJABÀÊF��# f�k

nJ@Á¹'dBC`a�

� EHGÔ��²Ö�K&èéD'_'��@�nj@Öop�C`�FGqÕÖF¤"

�z«���@Öd�\D'dBC`­eÕÖG�¬AB�Ê·Â@�n�fGÆÃæA

@�nJG�>æAx+@�n�nA°Ô�Fop�CD'GTó>z«Gv�Fk¾î

@�D�¨GCEn�z«@D'nNÖ��å­Fop�C`­eÕÖGð�&%¹'D

Cn@84C�qVÖop�C`�FGÃeüeÙ_·Â\9�'�s@�nj@F�B

�ÊF�s@�n�¬FGI�K&-�D'�s@�n�n&A�'dBC`a�

� ¼;¾;�§î@D'ÖÃnDE�N�{�\rsP�D'�EH�'dBC`�FG

I´:&-�&f4¹'�EH­�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÑGÃnDEµ�mØåe'�s@Á¹'dBC`­eÕÖGCE�K& �æ&Ö�

²XÅ@�nÖ�\�j&À��·FfGó>z«Æý&¤"�z«�«àGje\Õn

��\D'Gîì��½\` &�;D'�­�rn&D'�sJ@�nj@a���f

¼;¾;&��'Ö�¢£�&��'ê�C`@GµS��1F*¦�ÓÚ»\æ¹'�

CD'GðB� g501F�¦�ÓÚ»\æ¹'��añ`�&ÆÀGN�#�À��@j

km%%ÆÑ×Ø�É&A¹'�'GÄ,)@��²-�&d�'Ö-�3m%%Z�@

�n �m�knJ@Á�C`aÃn�¹EÖ�\Õn�n�n&D'�s�JaÃn�

¹ErnAj@\Ñ{�����g+,G���fIÕnD'�jn@�Ô'dKe�

J@�n��\rs�¹E·FG�´&«à\@�rnAj@\�Ô'�_E�@Á¹'

dBC`a�

� ÃeJKGµ!��JKXÅ��mop�CDEaXÅÃ�Ö�fI¯DErnAj@

A�F`­eÕÖG%fBXÅ\À��·FG}~����P�\<�'�s@�nj@

fFñFop�C`�FG�@D'ÖÏXÖ%¹'dBCDE­eÕÖGK.`×_@j

kfK.DAmKGrBN©æ&À�'C�BC`DG¤"�G���f¼;¾;AÕÖ

%¹'�EH�'dBC`­eÕÖGÞ�\DAmK%¹'�_E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKGo*���@D'�Nóôìí;�&fµ!���@jk\&�@D'�

&³ý&�B�ÊF�EH�'dBC`aµßà=D'��@jkFop�C`­eÕÖG

�6�4/�6

Page 44: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

��ÕÖg()�EDCDErn&G�Nóôìí;����\�K&��D'�s@�

nj@FG��¡*\��D'GÃjF÷ø\#­'�EHsrnA��\ù�D'�s

@JG���f¡*��vmF_'��JK@�¹'GóôæA£"FN©æAW×mF

_�J@�n@GÃnFÖA�@�nj@FG()D'�EH�EB`���õ���à

YG÷øGÃn�¹Ej@Ö3\ïe'�_E�@�n�n&Á¹'dBC`a�ue&

D'Öö��B&�N�«<\D'�EHs@�nj@f}~úµ�ÉAKuG�m��

�NG���fNO�FñwABG,ñw@�nj@&��'P�\<�'�EHs��

��H@Á�C`�FG�Nóôìí;�&��'jnDE�¬F��\ù��^'�_

E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ÃeJKGcÆ;��1Fop�C`­eÕÖGµßgý�\dJ­D'dBCD'�

�Fop�C`acÆ;���GÛ&èæ¢Æý&G×>�Ö�m��D'����F�

knJ@Á�C`aÃ�ñò@D'fG��ÕÖË»¹@¤"�׬AÕF¯D·ÂCD

E­eÕÖG0� XYf¤��¤"m­;¤"���\,[¹'S�DEajef�� 

��qVF`@JG[�XJKT"\À�'�s�D©9F 0� XY&ï¹E@�nrn

Aj@Öop�CD'GXY©;Æ9F,C`@G­;¤"���\,[¹'��@�n

��mop�CDEa�

� �K&f�;�%¤D½;�fG}~m�&3¡'��@�nj@FGÃËK��&

¤�m嬭KeE@�nrnA{�Ö�ÄFfop�CDEa�

� ÃeJKG��æ&fGjeÖ��Õ¯D·ÂCDE­eÕÖGÆ�G§¨îG�Ó»

@�¹ErnA.��Fîd��G/È��m>?\D'G�^Y&µ`�þñm÷7D

'_E@�nj@Ö�¹E·&Gd;à©®½»��F 0WW X&�Y�Y@�n�Õ�µ

@Ç�m±±0WW X&�Y�¦&f}Xí­'�¹E�F`­eÕÖGAB��ÎÏFD

»nJGÃÊAj@Öop�CD'G��æA�^Y�þ�ÏÐG�²èém�¹'GI

CFJïY\³¹'dKeE�m�"&jBJÔE�@�nj@F�"&µ`�þñmè

C¹E@�nrnAj@mFABCD'G�Ê�{�m¤�E@�n�n&Á¹'dBC

`a�

� �ÛäFfÐXY±¶ë÷"«à&ï¹'dBCD'G/W XYÖn�æ&÷"9�

­;¤"&jB$Ô'�B�ÊF�EH�'dBC`DG8)ØQCõ�N!"O���

��FGjef½X��°C&�R�'G��fcÆ;Fð>ÄJïD'���F`­

eÕÖGje\ /W XY &�_CD'G!X&Ò×C`@±X�YFop�CD»nJG

�6�4E�6

Page 45: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

JAB[DD\D'Jï\`�@�nj@\;&Sí@D'%¹'GË�ï�Ö�JK`

ED'�C`ajeCFÖÃnDE�FcÆ;���\^>�^�rnA��\DEå­

Fop�C`­eÕÖG�Ð�K�JKFop�CDEJGßàáâ��FÖcÆ;&�

�'�B·ÂKe���ÖhsA¹E@�nj@FG%fBjef�K&&J�jAøù

\@KA­eÇ�­A�@�ÔE@jkF`aqÕÖfwBJK�O¼;¾;AB@f

�^Y�þ���&��'f+,-.AB\D'���FG,uDÖÃeCFnsRJ

A�F0ùD'�E@�nå­FAsG¼;¾;��@*жëGÀ�µR\Õn`�J

�Ô'�Eå­Fop�C`a*Ð 0É w&fË»nÕT1�1=�ÊmòC���Ö�

¹EÖ�F`JKGq��nJKdt�\DEj@&fGÔ;9ñ¨>§;D&ï¹'�

s@�nj@FGcÆ;�èæF�{¢mèC¹'�s�ìFÖ���FGð�f¼;¾

;Fæ¹'dKe�SæË�pËGjefÖYm��å­Fop�C`�FGF_�H­

`�&Ãe\�BFD'��D'ÉD�@�nj@aÃeJKGÖnð�fGjeJKc

Æ;\[�æ&÷"D'ÉD�@�nj@\dt��EDCD'GT1FÁÂ\G�'�

EHsajef­;æ&¤"D'��Ö�F`JKGIwdt�D')w%�@�nå­

&fAJAJ�JA��F`mGF_�H­�sG�'�EH_E�@�nj@Fdt�

�EDCD'GSæË��BFD��fF_�H­%BC`@GÃeJKG÷"��Öµ

S*1Fx­F /EW ©¨GjefÐÃ�}~Ä�}¦Z&ÑE��F`mG©à;�;

F`¹'�� /WWH�ÙDF`@ 00g ²y�ÁÂ&ÑEBC`a³´& /EW ©¨\�Ð

@D'÷"`�@�nj@FGj�G�Ð�Æ8¶ë&)�&�'s�@�nj@Fo

p�C`aj�rn&¤��÷"GN!"O��� �Jï�[DDGÃeJK�K&f

¼;¾;&r�SæËpË��BFDF`@J÷"@�n�&rBGcÆ;m^>æ&�

��e'Gþ���m>?�e�rn&øù\@K^'�EH�'��@jkF`a�

7�9!"��<=� ¬���JK�¢£�12�£�÷�@���Ü���1&��'

glqmop�CDEa�

� /M XY��&d­�12�£�÷���@j�Ü�÷"��G����¬·��@�

n�f­;�ÆFsxw�@eE­;&A¹'dBCD'Gª«æ&ê�C`@G��Õ

�z�����|���;��& Ü�������Gop MM�\ 0WW�CFè�'�s

@�n�m�BC`mGj�Å­®ì\,'�EH_CD'ÖGj�Å�è�m3¡'d

BC`a�CBG�Ám÷ÔC`DG��ÑEB���ÄÖ÷%D'�sÆFGAdJ�G

Ã�nÄ\�"&jB$Ô'�s@�nj@FG��ÄÖ÷%�A­eÇ�­C^ÊDG

�6�44�6

Page 46: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

���@�nÊF`JG��ÑEB����Öè�'�¹'G¨©@D'jn�n��\

"VDrn@�nj@F`a/M XY&¬­'fÃn�n+$Ff+ÉæA��\�¹'

dBC`aÃ�ÆF /W XY&d_CD'fG��ÕÖ¯D·ÂCDEmG�¨Æ¾>à

Y@�¹ErnAj@Ö��'�90¡��ÀG���f��04�AÕ\W¢DE0¡

��ÀGÃn�¹Ej@Ö��'j�12�£�÷�µR\À�'�_E�@Á¹'dB

C`a�

7ûüL�zú<=� ��Õ�v����JK_`ç*�/%�d�mop�CD'Gl

q@�nrBdt�@�nd�Fop�CDE­eÕÖGL�_`ç*�/%�>?&�

DCD'fGg�Ä�@dB�hJK_`ç*@�n�mqsA�²�V�½\�;D'

dBCD'GÃe\­æG^>\¥�@�n£"JKGu�{O\N!"O��� \©

D'ع'��@jkFop�C`­eÕÖGÃn�n�²�V�½\­æG���^�

@�n£"JKÕjCF&mF_��J@�n�fIÀ���\,AmKïðD'�_

E�@Á¹'dBC`a�

� ¶·Fop�C`a�

7¾¿#�=� �Bm@nop�C`a�

� �JfrkD�FD»nJa�

� FfG�ÃÖй'�C`�FG��&dt��EDC`a�

7I#��� ��&DC`mGIwd�m�¹E�å3�Ü��hc�@�nj@fG�

�&ên@Ü���à©âÙDà�F��aJﹺ�@nÖkjD@JïJ¢JK�ZG

�Z&�\�Â'�s@�nj@AÊF`mGÃef�R@D'_¹ËB@KØ�e�Ç

AKA�aDJDAmKÃem�e�@A�@GÜ� ��ß�&µ�DEÜ* �@�

n�mâÙ©»9c§©@D'��'�JA­eÇ�­A�aIw�¤"N��Æ&Ã�

�m�BCDE­eÕÖGÃe\%¹'�sE�&GqGI�Ûä&���F`mGà�

�j@fG�å3�!"/%@£���Ä�¤"Ä@�nÖ�\­æ`�E�&G�Nè

&µD'�'(u�@�n�fL�CFÞJsn«&sCAsG�U AD&�_�s,

ñmMµ&��aÃemA­eÇjef�NèÃ�²�mÕÊÕÊ�m�DGÃD'ÌU

�õEË@�n�fG��Õµ!�Ê�d�&�¹Ern&Gjef�Ñ\�NAs�e

�@�n��m7��e�@�nGÃn�n��&��@�nj@\Mµ&�ÝDAs'

f�­A�a�

� Ãn`�@GÃ�E�&Õn`�J@�n@GS¨MdØMO�F`mGð�f'(u

�6�4g�6

Page 47: 食料・農業・農村政策審議会 平成20年度第1回畜産 …˙Ž†FA @AJAJ‡ RK aˆeJKG’(æAGF C‘@G%fB@n ÖkjD&”$‘‡⁄&f!"–ˇˇÔ‡˛ˇG ‡ fŁ!˙⁄PABG)*æAGF

�G'(F &JJå�'(3\� �õEËm»Ùâ`�j@m,ñF��aÃe@Ö

�&ÃØD'%KAs'f�­A�j@fGICFfTNè&µ`�'(u�@�n�f

N�GÜ�¼;¾;G�O¼;¾;GF îGDÈGÃD'Ã�·ÖkÖk@�n�m�

�+$Ff'ÊFÊÇKÇK&ï¹'�E@�nj@&ABC`aÃn�¹EjeJK�

'(u���¬@�n�fGr¹'h��G�¾\êÔEð���;�S;DæAÖ�\

�¹'%¹'�JA�@GjefH�Hkn@aÃn�nj@mnCs�s@jk@�n

�fI�Ùß@�n�\4BPÔ'�­�Hkn­eÕGÃem,SsÃA@jkfî�

Ùâ»>©`�õmhsA¹'DCnaÃjKo�j@\Ü� �@Ü*'(@GÃeJ

K'(F @�nj@F�ÞR­'GÃ�ÆF���R@D'%e�j@f?QD'%¹

'�EH­eÇ�BmE�A@Á�C`a�

� ¶·F`a�

7¾¿#�=� RFAg+,@D'�BE�@Á�C`a�

� �J&jeH­f@�n�GUD�ÃfêÆD'�C`mGop�CDEK��a�

� rkD�FD»nJa�

� vwfG���bcGc�A)*JKµßRFAGÃD'j�Ag+,\�EH_CD

Ea�

� }Ð /0 w&Î>�EDE�R��"&ë>D'�E¶·&{�m¤�D'��@�n

ÆFG�J&�KeE0�\N©æ&ëï`�J@�nj@\S�DAmKQRæ&�K

&&mF_��JGvw�+,ÖÓCÔ'gïð�EH_E�@Á�C`a�

� !"#�@DCD'ÖG��&��CD',ñAµ�\D'�Jp�\dA�@�Ô'

dBC`a�

� CEG���bcÖÃeüe�d)*F�K&�CpCA�FgT3�EH_C`rn

dt�DCD'GvwfjeF1�&�EDE�@Á�C`a�

� ÕnÖ=�Ã�Bm@nop�CDEa�

*�23 1��

�6�45�6