© 2010 airadvice, inc. using energy services to drive maintenance and retrofit sales

56
© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

Upload: april-boyd

Post on 20-Jan-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

Page 2: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Series Schedule – Using Energy Services To…

• Session 1 – April 14th

Ensure Maintenance Agreement Renewals

• Session 2 – April 21st

Win New Maintenance Agreements

• Session 3 – May 4th

Drive Retrofit Project Revenue

Page 3: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

It’s No Accident…

Page 4: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Service Business Key Performance Indicators

You Can’t Manage What You Can’t Measure

Revenue from 2007 2008 2009PM Agreements 875,654$ 989,333$ 915,264$

% Change 13.0% -7.5%

Additional Service and Repairs 1,648,332$ 1,864,636$ 1,849,393$ % Change 13.1% -0.8%

Retrofit Projects 1,248,333$ 1,754,333$ 1,453,344$ % Change 40.5% -17.2%

Total Service Revenue 3,772,319$ 4,608,302$ 4,218,001$

% Change 22.2% -8.5%

Gross Margin % 34.0% 35.0% 32.0%

Total Service Gross Profit 1,282,588$ 1,612,906$ 1,349,760$ % Change 25.8% -16.3%

Service and Retrofit Revenue Mix

Service and Retrofit Revenue

$876 $989 $915

$1,648$1,865 $1,849

$1,248

$1,754$1,453

$-

$1,000

$2,000

$3,000

$4,000

$5,000

2007 2008 2009

Revenue ($k)

PM Agreements Service & Repairs Retrofit Projects

Page 5: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

The Financial Leverage of Service

Total

PM Agreements $3.02

Service / Repairs $7.48

Retrofit Projects $5.41

Total $15.91

Each $1 of service agreements generates the equivalent of $15.91 in new revenue

PM Agreements

$1

Page 6: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

“Cancellation Proof” Your PM Agreements

1. Probe for financial pain 2. Make energy is relevant (gain permission)3. Demonstrate potential savings (benchmark)4. Identify specific “low/no cost” measures that will

immediately reduce costs and improve cash flow5. Implement and verify

Page 7: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Debunking the 2 Myths That Prevent Energy Services Programs from Moving Forward

1. “Energy costs can’t be controlled”2. “Reducing energy spend will take a lot of capital”

Page 8: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Energy Service Agreement™ Sales ProcessGet the Meeting

1st Meeting - Introduction

Building Survey / Energy Benchmark

Present the Proposal

Close the Service Sale

Not an Opportunity Today

Confirmation / Verification

Sell Energy Services

~ 3% of cold calls result in a meeting

~ 1 in 6 1st meetings result in a PM agreement

Page 9: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Case Study

• 138,000 sf• Built-up system

– Chiller– Boiler

• Pneumatic, constant volume control system

Page 10: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Energy Benchmark

Page 11: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Temperature

Low-Cost Energy Savings Identified

Fix control issues

Eliminate weekend operation

Page 12: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Carbon Dioxide

Low-Cost Energy Savings Identified

Fix economizer / ventilation control

Page 13: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Low Cost Energy Savings Identified

• Increase cooling / decrease heating setpoints• Optimize temperature control and lighting

scheduling• Fix economizer / improve ventilation control• Boiler lockout above 60 F

Over $70,000 of energy waste eliminated for $6,000 investment

Page 14: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Retrofits are the Pot of Gold

Page 15: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Agenda – Session 3

1. Current economic climate for retrofit projects2. Retrofit project sales process3. Psychology of the sale4. Proving value with monitoring and verification5. Using utility rebates to your advantage

Page 16: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Current Economic Climate

Page 17: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Retrofit Project Sales Process1st Meeting

Building Survey

Energy Analysis

Not an Opportunity TodayClose the Project Sale

Present Proposal

Implement Retrofit

Performance Verification

Page 18: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Sources of Leads

Existing Service Base Bid Spec / RFPs

Page 19: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Retrofit Project Sales Process1st Meeting

Building Survey

Energy Analysis

Not an Opportunity TodayClose the Project Sale

Present Proposal

Implement Retrofit

Performance Verification

Page 20: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Building Survey / Energy Analysis

• Define a process that is: Repeatable Scalable Credible

Page 21: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Trade Offs

Simplicity | Complexity

Automation | Manual Labor

Page 22: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Guideline Document

• ASHRAE RP-669 / SP-56

Page 23: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Types of Energy Audits – ASHRAE Definitions

• Preliminary Energy Use Analysis• Level I – Walk-Through Analysis• Level II – Energy Survey and Analysis• Level III – Detailed Analysis

Page 24: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Preliminary Energy Use Analysis

• Analyze historic utility use and cost

• Develop an EUI• Compare to similar

buildings

Energy Benchmark

Page 25: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

What’s the Difference?Level I

Walk-Through AnalysisLevel II

Energy Survey & AnalysisLevel III

Detailed Analysis

Focus of Audit • Documenting systems and operations

• Rough estimate of savings potential

• No / low cost measures

• Energy consumption by end use• More rigorous estimate of

savings potential• No / low cost and capital

measures

• Detailed analysis of subsystems

• Investment-grade estimates of savings potential

• Capital measures

Inputs • Utility bills• Site drawings• Site walk-through• Interviews

• Level I items, plus measurement of key environmental parameters

• Level II items, plus measurement of key equipment operational parameters

Outputs • Checklists• Engineering estimates • Spreadsheet calculations

• More complex spreadsheet calculations

• Simple computer energy models

• Complex computer energy models

Page 26: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Data Collection

Data Loggers

Building Automation System Trend Logs

Custom Data Acquisition Systems

Page 27: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Typical Analysis Methods 3,000 0.1085$ 7,000 0.0984$

190,000 0.0839$ 200,000 0.0646$

0.0111$ 0.0087$ 0.0063$

kWh Billing Demand 200 400 600March 363,200 728.0

Date Consumption Peak Demand Demand (kW) Load Factor PLL-C TOU-SSD-4 PLL-CJan 1/28/2008 214,880 256,000 654 470880 46% $ 23,557 $ 11,350 $ 12,207 Feb 2/25/2008 488,960 (56,864) 643 432096 113% $ 38,046 $ 15,291 $ 22,755 Mar 3/27/2008 363,200 102,544 626 465744 78% $ 31,112 $ 13,368 $ 17,744 Apr 4/28/2008 363,680 117,088 626 480768 76% $ 31,135 $ 13,375 $ 17,760 May 5/28/2008 335,040 89,760 590 424800 79% $ 29,758 $ 12,770 $ 16,988 Jun 6/26/2008 320,160 105,096 611 425256 75% $ 26,511 $ 34,275 $ (7,764)Jul 7/28/2008 356,320 99,872 594 456192 78% $ 30,845 $ 36,474 $ (5,629)Aug 8/27/2008 341,120 115,360 634 456480 75% $ 33,803 $ 35,981 $ (2,178)Sep 9/29/2008 359,200 118,376 603 477576 75% $ 29,816 $ 36,785 $ (6,969)Oct 10/28/2008 298,880 106,192 582 405072 74% $ 25,626 $ 12,201 $ 13,425 Nov 11/24/2008 284,800 70,952 549 355752 80% $ 25,921 $ 11,824 $ 14,097 Dec 12/29/2008 370,240 97,640 557 467880 79% $ 30,348 $ 13,112 $ 17,236

356,478$ 246,810$ 109,668$

31%

$-

$5,000

$10,000

$15,000

$20,000

$25,000

$30,000

$35,000

$40,000

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Monthly Electric Bill

PLL-C

TOU-SSD-4

Hand Calculations

Spreadsheets

Computer Models

Page 28: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Retrofit Project Sales Process1st Meeting

Building Survey

Energy Analysis

Not an Opportunity TodayClose the Project Sale

Present Proposal

Implement Retrofit

Performance Verification

Page 29: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

The Energy Project Proposal

Page 30: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

You Do Not Get Paid…

by the hour

for complexity

by the pound

Page 31: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

You Get Paid For…• Providing information useful

in decision making• Moving projects forward

Page 32: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Focus on the Financial Decision Maker

Page 33: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Is Energy Savings a Motivator?

“By maintaining proper tire pressure, keeping your engine in tune, and replacing dirty air filters you can improve gas mileage by up to 15%.”U.S. Department of Energy

The Psychology of the Sale

This savings is equivalent to 1 free tank of gas every other month

Page 34: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

What if someone stole a full tank of gas out of your car…every other month

The Psychology of the Sale

Would you be more likely to take action?

Page 35: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

The Psychology of the Sale

“If you move forward with this project you will save $X per year”

“If you do nothing you will continue to waste $X per year”

vs.

Psychologically, most people will do more to avoid a penalty than to earn a reward

Page 36: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

The Cost of Doing Nothing

Page 37: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

The Psychology of the Sale

Page 38: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Retrofit Project Sales Process1st Meeting

Building Survey

Energy Analysis

Not an Opportunity TodayClose the Project Sale

Present Proposal

Implement Retrofit

Performance Verification

Page 39: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Performance Verification

Baseline PeriodECMEvent

Performance Period

1. Measure impact of ECMs

? 2. Ongoing monitoring and verification

??

Reduce the risk of saying “Yes”

Page 40: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Two Perspectives

Building Owner

“Did I get what I paid for?” “Did I get credit for what I provided?”“Did my customer perceive value?”

Contractor

Page 41: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Comparisons Challenges• Variables that impact baselines

– Weather– Occupancy– Utility Rates

Page 42: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Methods for Performance Verification

1. Periodic Energy Benchmark2. Continuous Energy Monitoring System

Page 43: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Closing the Loop“Adding the continuous energy monitoring and verification application to the BuildingAdvice™ program will really help us close the loop for our customers. Now when we’re proposing a sizeable energy retrofit project we can include a system that will accurately measure and report the actual energy savings delivered. This eliminates a tremendous amount of financial risk for the building owner. We think this will help justify moving forward with more projects.”Rick CookeVice PresidentAirco Commercial Services

Page 44: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Using Utility Rebates to Your Advantage• Two types of rebates

1. Prescriptive2. Custom

Page 45: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Prescriptive Rebates

Page 46: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Prescriptive Rebates – Xcel Energy

Example:• Replacement of ten 20-

ton RTUs• Proposing high efficiency

(12 EER) w/ economizers

Efficiency upgrade:($75 + $5 x (12.0 – 10.2) / 0.1) = $165 / ton$165 / ton x 20 tons / unit x 10 units = $33,000

Economizers:$20 / ton x 20 tons / unit x 10 units = $4,000

Total rebate = $37,000

Page 47: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Custom Rebates

• Requires pre-approval and submittal of engineering analysis

• Xcel Energy provides rebates of up to:

– $400 / kW (electricity)– $5 / mcf (gas)

Page 48: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Energy Analysis Rebates

• Rebate for a portion of the cost of an energy study or audit

• AirAdvice can help you work with your utility to understand and approve your energy analysis process

Page 49: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Biggest Challenge in Working With Utilities

• Don’t get slowed down

Page 50: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Case Study

• 138,000 sf• Built-up system

– Chiller– Boiler

• Pneumatic, constant volume control system

Page 51: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

An Energy Benchmark™ Determines ActionENERGY STAR® Energy Performance Rating

• Greatest opportunity for improvement

• Invest in new equipment and enhanced O&M practices

Invest

Source: ENERGY STAR

Recommended Capital Improvements• Retrofit chiller plant with variable

speed drives on compressor, fans, pumps ($205k)

• Replace pneumatic system with DDC ($181k)

Page 52: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Energy Savings Audit

Page 53: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Why Does This REALLY Matter?• From the building owner’s

perspective…CASH IS KING!• Building value is determined by

cash flow

NOI = Gross Income – Operating Expenses• Income (lease payments)• Expenses (taxes, insurance, utilities, depreciation on

capital upgrades)

Building Value = NOI / Cap Rate

Page 54: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

• 99% of all commercial real estate has a mortgage• Commercial real estate mortgages are generally

short term (3 to 5 years)• Refinancing a loan for a property that has declined

in value requires cash• Reducing operating expenses…

– Increases NOI– Increases asset value– Decreases cash required to refinance

Why Does This REALLY, REALLY Matter?

Page 55: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Summary• Current economic climate – tight grip on cash• Your best leads will come from existing service base• Develop a method for energy analysis

– Repeatable– Scalable– Credible

• Highlight the “cost of doing nothing”• Include a system of performance monitoring• Utilities – friend or foe?

Page 56: © 2010 AirAdvice, Inc. Using Energy Services to Drive Maintenance and Retrofit Sales

© 2010 AirAdvice, Inc.

Questions

? ? ?

?

?

?? ?