สัมมนาวิชาการครุศาสตร์ 2552

343

Upload: piya-sakcharoen

Post on 28-Mar-2016

240 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

research,chula

TRANSCRIPT

  • !

    "#$%&$'%(%$) **) ,&-. ,) ) ( /

    )! 10 2% .. 2552 ( %(%$) 6()-

    # %(%$) 6()-

  • n'lu1

    nruv n ?fi 'r d n i l vtr n t n rnSil u rQ il fl r ds tfl u n n r riu zu fi nr n gfi ri ta rir d ; r u vr o or o r ri rr r r :r f6dvunvu3nrrixlnl?vrl{nrafinurllrifrrnil a']ilvT{i4'u r;nrfin udrqu'l rrn:f,fl{olnintrrufvn'l

    4 J 3" 4 | vn1?Ant*1lfrofruruurn1{n1?s-nnlrdnu'lfirurrynruuriffsrr:.rd',rrrriofinqufir:In1riu lnmfiidsr{rrrirderflu*urkGsufffini'rterninn'uflr,rrJ"lrlrfluur,rnirfrrs6*ynrnradn:c'rro.ruriuFu unyd r rq nr.r't ru rfl u{ri'r vr T r rlry r-u r rd o n'r :v(ru ur n mfi n ur d gio g

    "frrsQdsfiarinr'.rnoi'r? nilvn?fi1dnft6'drrfiunrafls'lunrad'prnr:fin:g'rrfionffr.rnQ1li

    l, G v 14 ro I atfltJttll.tyt't.tFt1un?fi'tfiFt?finu']6't6Fl? [Flfltqvvtvofl'r.1fl{ n1?tJnnttnvv\DNu'rFlSrrnv!nn1n?4iad!+'nxnrrfrnsrfifrqrunril $ny?:run1?r3fliln1enoufrfr:la;fivr6nrvr c{onnfro{ffuuurrJfrg:J

    nrrfinumorila;ryra"lurIn1r5u nTapirrfiun'rrfrineirr ffo{orfftinrrfin:crfrun{runvi{uodr.:-

    di q v\ lrv v t e a 4 i.{s3s{s rfro"tri'16{oduvruunvo.ininrelilfnnHuuoFnso{nrefrn:g'rfrfrnraid'etrflugru(Research-based Education) drluriQ{dti'rur:'r n{u'rsrrEi$nvflfinnruvn?fi''rnni tfrrq?rrnaerirun{rui4'rJunvxnrruit''rn1?d1u?ur1nfisvfir{curi,rfl"lfinrad'mrur4run1T\n1?finrs1flo{il?;rvr11ilr;fiunr,r'rild'rr5c nruvnqfildnilv{rn.rnrniruurivrsrd'u 6'rtd{nrl#fin'rarJayqila{1n'r?itny

    ',,"tzustmrzuntrui4'sr:d'utrfi lurX.Jffo "u{an?aililr{nrefinurrfiontavl'rxurfirT.:flu" rfiolflunr:tzuluil?2n{rui6'tttto-trrrulsraf rini{u fninrnra ng ornrrri un:fiRnrirrfin:gr unrrdoar:l

    iaruutr-{rJqnosrilorlonrnnrdrfl{'unnrilu'rnrilyn?fi16nfilfr ar" unv cc6cfl viru{vrfr quvrf,irf unrqd'ru 0qnfl'r

    ,

    ronc{rflJevno:rnrnJr:lrDtrnmunvrzuEruil?2n{'rui{flr:Fr'utrfrqriufi tffar:-Laqrzun.rruStrnmrrnvruntruid'tLvn{nrefin:grfirirrnus"lunl?il?vqilnlod 4.uru

    -- duo nrrurnrqnrnnf

    -caGtr!'-Xdrrqlvhntneniuurinurdu ui'rrfluor.i'xEr.i'r rsnnreqf:lfrq:frrieuliQfl"lun'larzuEr*vreorr{'nrrrHff6'run md nur { d'.: n il d { q yd r fl firuur il ry rr rtt r fi rrn ; ff{ nr illpr fl eq Lr

    Aq_b{*4J-r1ld Fr?1s'r?d nrr. ffid'u nrrgnumfi

    nru:Jdnru:n qnT nnr i 1d'r nrn enf:lurivrfl 1 ffl' G)o fi?flfl'lf]3J ls3&&ls

  • / 10 .. 2552 # 13.30-15.30 . & 401: ( 1/1 *+,-./- &*+

    #0012

    : !" ($ %)

    1 - 6

    "' $ ()*+ : ,-%)(**.(*/0"1 (.3., 4 )-55-)

    7 12

    ",44'6 /'"3* /0.(* 7* ! 89/'+5%6/: 1/2 >-)?5 )%) %( $?'%6 (.%.488 ,3)

    13 - 18

    /@5-' (/?? '3'9A?5).5B-C/'3A ?''3" 55+7? ,5'(*8?'">>! 89/'+5%6/: 2 (. 8)

    19 - 27

    6-4' 3(?? 3*5!89/'+5%6/: 1 >-)?5 )%) %( $?'%6 (. 5 5%>A ?'"4')

    28 - 31

    " 5(* 9)* 895-5%6/: 1 (5- 81)

    32 - 38

    3%/'$335*? (/9A 895-5%6/: 3 (4E $ %)

    39 45

    .!?3?",4-5$-5?'$3/'4(*? 557 88?'">>5).5B-C?'",4-5$-5!89/'+5%6/: 1 >-)$,F45 G/'+5 (.%.$% $3))

    46 50

  • (-(&)

    & 403: ( 1/2 *+,-./- &*+ #0012

    78*/H1/0A(*78,3 '58*?' /',)%65 8@ 4 7'58(/+5 (.%., !'5)

    51 57

    5+'"4)%)!$ 7 "! ,35%6 $ 3"85 )5" 5"3!%6 (.8,)5 55)

    58 - 63

    .!78*5"4)%)7)5? "3")") ).5B-C" 5(*68$ ?'%")) 8"4)%) : "'!*5(8/54?'8",4 (.,,4 ' 48)

    64 70

    "'>53$3(* 5' "38' 8"4)%)!7'3895-5%6/: 6 >-)5 5"5 (.,19 ,5)

    71 76

    %6" 55- ' "'?" 5*5 "'? 3 9A" 5(* ?'.5B-C!89/'+5%6/: 1 >-)$,F45 G/'+5 (.% )*, ., >$ ), .% 4 >3)

    77 - 83

    .!K55>378*LL!?'"" 5!*7$"4)%)5)" 55+"4)%)?'$)")) 8"4)%)!895-5%6/: 3 (. ) ? 8)

    84 - 90

    & 405: ( 2/1 *+,-.0 . *+ #56/12

    ) 89$3%6!+%6!99A)5/81%A$ (.5. -5-C)

    91 - 97

    $?'>5/H117+%6 (%.3.8) 5 ?'"4')

    98 - 110

  • (-(&)

    -!'9.) ?/A!5",4?'

    " 53)" : %65",4$35,7>8 (.3.5/' 5$1>1)

    111 - 119

    (/? $75 8 (.3.%,3 8, 4) 120 - 125 %6 "'/(H$)6" 5/06/'"? 8

    7"5/H$$, (.3.) ) 126 M 133

    %6? >*5 $?'%6") (.%.3.-%3C 5)

    134 - 139

    & 407: ( 2/2 *+,-.0 . *+ #56/12

    "" 5(*3 8 ?'"" (%.3.811 ),, ., -3 $,),)

    140 143

    ?'/H1)55F!>-)35 !A !* 5?!!F-)5"" "9 33 (.4A ,33, .3 5))

    144 150

    ? 3"((5/H117$3(*%6%A$?' "57*+" $ (%.3.811 ),, .4@A4 %58)

    151 158

    "' -'354E) !*%%6 (.3.$,) ,3,)

    159 165

    & 406: ( 3 *+,-.*+-12 "*" 585>' ? (* $789!)?'

    $5/'4 88 (.%.3. 3, 4) 166 170

    /',)78* -/'5/@)/'55+'! .(*/'5 '3%6!99A ), (..%$ $'>)

    171 177

    4E/)?3 Advanced Progressive Matrices (APM) !89/'+5%6/: 4 >-)$,F45 G/'+5 (.3. ?/H11, %.3.5 )

    178 - 184

  • (-(&)

    $?'?.$3(*(4'*+>378*

    ' $/0A'8 )/'+5%6 () , ()

    185 192

    /H$$.)$)6-4')+ ? 3*5 ?' 88"( )'3/114E) "4'",%) $,F45 (.3. 4 $)$,8)

    193 200

    & 408: ( 4 *+,-.5+ .- *+95:12 " 55+85+'3*/0.(* (*!"(-?37

    ' '"--%6 ())) /95$)) 201 207

    ",4!$5!*/'!>8'35-5%67!),5"$5,55!.(*?'.(* (.3. %,-C '))

    208 215

    /.5B-C 8@%/P?'3)!'389/'+5%6/: 2 >-)$,F45 G/'+5' ,5 8@%/P?'3)95>378*$ 'K9?'$ ')6" (.,11 /'A, .@' 5()

    216 221

    /813)75-5%6 : ?' )$3(* (.3.,- R4))

    222 233

    & 409: ( 5/1 *+,-.,;;/ ? -4E-4 /0? %6(*

    ( 5)8 %1 ?'"4') 234 239

    )5%"(/?/ $?' 8,3(* %/?/ ( *89))

    240 243

    " 5"3!)()",%)4E) $,F45 )" 5(*)55)A 88"( (.%.3.4@A4 )

    244 253

    (/?5 57/'8,5' "(.(*/" !)>-)?5 )%) %( $?'%6 (./' 3 /354, %./',5 )8()

    254 - 258

  • (-(&)

    ,-?'!"",446/'"!

    $ 3" "?',->378*"! $%6 (%.3. ) ?* , ?'"4')

    259 -264

    "'(/? "" - ' )5$3(*"3!.(*'3%6!99A97/'%?')/'% (%.3.-, , 45" ?'"4')

    265 274

    A!*5( $3* )5$3(*5"3!.(*?' K)>" $ (.3./' 4$)

    275 280

    $/@)?5 5'$3(*"(.(*7+%6!99A>378* $/0A (.%.3.$,E ,5, .%.3. 3C >- )

    281 287

    & 404: ( 5/2 *+,-.,;;/ $?'')3)5/'5."(7$3(*

    ?"(4 (.%.3.% 5(1.) 288 290

    /'5>"" 55+ $!"(> 3? (1*55',() (% ' 4)

    291 293

    /" 55+7"3!'3895-5%6/: 6 3*>378* )5 ""(5"(" $3(*? 12 !9)'*" 5"3" ?' ( 4% ./'5()

    294 300

    4E/)5+,!! '389/'+5%6 /: 1-6 >-)$,F45 G/'+5 (.%.R)8 !-)

    301 305

    %6/H$$5" 55-3(,!5-5%6))* >8L, 5 $ 38, /:%6 2550 (,,5 4 ")

    306 309

    >/?5/U)$3(,*78*(* 5 -'8 )895-5%6/: 1 (,,5 4 ")

    310 313

  • (-(&)

    .!?+4$ >378*'*

    (*.).5B-C?'$)")))3!895-5%6/: 2 (,1) ?.%)

    314 319

  • : !"# A Development of Electronic Media for Thai Language Pronunciation : Parts of Syllable

    @AB!C D"@AB!C EF!CC 2550 EG"!C

    #H !"#$%&'()()*'+,-./ : .1&'

    %234 One-Group Pretest-Posttest Design $.!".)D3D&( 3 %#!E%F) 2 /&) 1 %FE 2550 22 & )D3D " ". 1 !&! 2550 #E 6 I&! 2550

    JD+4()*'+,-./ : .1&' )%! Microsoft Excel ! +!4 38 J. !4J!1&D++.1&'4+4()1"&!#S" D+ 1 & ##S D+ 0 & #J4 J%!1JS3)3T.()*')1E !#D3+,-./4 J4D3(). JS$&4&"*!D$J../4 J./ %() U4*3"V . +4D3()!JS).&4%2 100 WE).4D3()!JS).&4%2 32

    Abstract The objective of this study was to develop the electronic media for Thai language pronunciation :

    Part of Syllable. The type of this study was One-Group Pretest-Posttest Design. The experiment group was 22 students in the second grade of Tessaban Bansakngoy School in the first semester, academic year 2006 since March 1st to July 6th , 2006. The result of this study was got the electronic media for Thai language pronunciation: Parts of syllable, to develop in Microsoft Excel program amount 38 worksheets. This was showing the score immediately after filled out the parts of syllable. By assigned the condition of correction and give one point if true, zero point if fail. The assessment of professional found that the electronic media was built to use for Thai language pronunciation practice. The result of experiment found that every students got a full points in every worksheets and could pronounce Thai language. And the result of Thai languages Pronunciation in Aesopjs Feble UDekchai Kab TumyaeV found that after the testing, the learner can read 100 percentages, before the testing the learner can read only 32 percentages.

    1

  • #!IEJI"!C .%2)3()!&!!m'+./1 S+."

    %" S%"*.%!#E))4.#E!E%&!))4S n 4*%"+(&%2.)."$D+4/&!+!1E D"D 4 4*))!+4.E.. "!&!!.*"D+4*&).. ()D+4*1D&!+!& .)%J4 J,$o&1Dp. (p !%S. 2537. + 124)

    &m (Kenneth. 1968 #ED p !%S. 2537. + 125) 4$%1.4J/ 1

    1 ) 1 1 ) 2 1 ) 3

    J/ 1 JJ.

    JS.D)!+(.!..STp'/1+("+(%!%p'4!)&S4)&4!. *%+/1!%2/S4 JS.E%+/S4!%2&!+! E4&!1DD. . D3 3 1 &( 1 ) 1 %1 ) 2 3

    JS$.!.!%vT+() %+/1!%2/S4 +(+E)*&( .!. +"$+E))D+.!.&( !.S&+(&' !.Sm%! D+JS!.S+)1.".n )%%2&+(&' !()&".n !"!&1/)+4%2Ipw'+(%2"!p'1/+(). %& )D+)".%+/1!%2S4 !.!#!.".&)! $4"+ 4S( ()+(%& n D+!+*"+(+!(."4%+!4 &.&+. #S1+ (Encoder) D+JS !.!##4+ (Decoder) !4.D%&+(( () %4& $4&(D+JS.!. )!D/D+!J".SD$$.!S

    "+( (1&!)".())

    &)&$& 4!.

    /S4

    &!+!

    2

  • 4 JSE&4)()*'+,-./ : .1&' ()D+JS4S.1&+(.1&' S+)1.".n )%%2&+(&' WE)%2( x+4&D+!.)!.&+*!. .JD+JS!#.+( .+(%4!.S !KDLEG#"!C

    ()()*'+,-./ : .1&' !MH!C

    & %2E)4D$.! Pre-Experiment One-Group Pretest-Posttest Design 4 (J.p "!&S $/ y"/p'. 2545. + 53)

    O1 X O2

    X &( "%")#S4 (treatment) O1 &( 4. (Pretest) O2 &( 4+ (Posttest)

    LIK! 4. 3 %#!E%F) 2 /&) 1

    %FE 2550 22 & GG!NBN!C " ".) 1 !&! 2550 #E 6 I&! 2550 K!OEKB 4D3()*'+,-./ : .1&' K!OEKI 4. 1) & 2) J./ #INBN!!I"BIA !4".% 1. E& !3...J. &( 36 J. 2. EJ./ !3...&'D".J. 3. %!+JS3)3T #INBN!C !m4".% 1. ()*'+,-./ : .1&' 44

    1.1 ET3&( x)D3D/4%#!E .. 2529 - 2531 D43 4**#E43 %#!E%F) 3

    1.2 ()*'+,-./ : .1&' D+!p4/ 2

    / 2 3()&!'#)"E

    3

  • / 3 p1()*'1&)!&'4

    / 4 p1()*'1&)!!.+E)&'

    / 4 & UV U!!V %2&)!!.+E)&' %2"D++*&'1".& ()D+.1&' .)!.$T"D+1&! ".1&'.

    1.3 4&!#S"1() 44.1&'&' p()1".#S"+(!. m&( 4.1&'D+#S" &)!1E 1 & 4.1&'D+J4 &".4! W &$&'$J.

    1.4 () * ' +,-./ : . 1&' !.%4

    J. U{ - {|V %2T3&( x3 4** J. U{{ - }~V %2T3&( x3 %#!E%F) 1 J. U4 {V %2T3&( x3 %#!E%F) 2 J. U4 V %2T3&( x3 %#!E%F) 3

    J. U{ - }~V ".J.+4D+!&"*!. 30 & &E4&'%2+ +!&!. 1 &' !&.. 1 & ".J.! 30 &' WE)!.& 30 & &!!.+E)&' J. U{ - }~V %2J.)D3+D& .J. U4 {V U4 V !&"*!4%!p &( 2,000 2,600 & "!4 ()D+JS)!DJ. U{ - }~V * "&!"".+.$&&+(()JS$.!. !()4()*'+,-./ : .1&' * JS4!'T3&)S.D()*'D+S.DS%())!' (S%.!) 72 + %2%D3()*'+,-./ : .1&' ()D+JS4%E4".!() JS%& .!S$#)$ 4())++JS%&!..!D4SD+.$"+

    2. %!()*'+,-./ : .1&' 44 ()*'+,-./ : .1&' ".JS3)3T

    4/()1&

    4

  • %%$1()"!&1JS3)3T JS3)3T%!&!+!!1()*'+,-./ :

    .1&' 3. 4D3()*'+,-./ : .1&'

    D+JS.%() U4*3"V 4/ 6 ()4./.D3()*'+,-./ : .1&'

    ()*'+,-./ : .1&' %4D33 %#!E%F) 2 D/&) 1 %FE 2550 !m4

    1) JS.&)&!+! D+JS. 2) JS.1&'D+!&"*! *JSD+()D+JS.

    EJ./ 3) DJ.!#!. .1&'!.%D4 D".&'&(

    .J.".%D+./.4 4) JS&D4)!%vT+().!n *D+4W DJ. U{V ()(&!

    #S"&!1D1JS 3.3 D+JS.%() U4*3"V & ()4./

    +D3()*'+,-./: .1&' !#G"BIA 4D3&.y) @!C

    1. & D+4()*'+,-./ : .1&' %! Microsoft Excel +4()1"&!#S"D+& 1 & ##S D+ 0 & #J4 !!&D++.1

    2. J%!1JS3)3T . ()*'+,-./ : .1&' )1E !#D3+,-.4

    3. J4D3 . JS$&4&"*!D$J..4$&' !JS 9 & )./ 36 J. *.)+4 J./ %() U4*3"V . .4D3).&4%2 32 +4D3).&4%2 100 LEOGE@!C

    1. JD+4()*'+,-./ : .1&' )%! Microsoft Excel 4&( xT3&)D3D/4%#!E .. 2529 - 2531 (!3. 2531) %2JS%""!11!3).. 4( +1+S" +( ,-+4 +(!%p' $%p'".n D$.!/ +S"() &p&T3&T3&

    5

  • )D3D/4%#!E .. 2529 - 2531 %D3()D++S"() ".n D+!&!+!!3.D+/!%m/!1E

    2. J%!1JS3)3T . ()*')1E !#D3+,-.4 %2D1 "JS&E#E+"S D3*14"D+D+T.+! .1&*4D++*34 D+JS%"D+!)$4 ()&!S4" WE)+*.() !&D++.1&' D+JS$SD)&+&"S."4

    3. +4D3 . JS$&4&"*!D$J..4$&' %2JS%"4&. 4.D+JSvD+JS"! !m&!+!1& 4&!3 (2531) WE).. +.&&$" !.%2"D+.S4&+(J D+.%2&1D&!+!1& n 4 4*))!+4.E".. "!&!!.*"D+4*&).. "..*"!+JS$.!.)&!.4 .!. %2"D+4&4p.1&' %2" Ipw'. JS"D+4&"*!.E!#./4 WE)&)+4D+%2&&$"%2&4). %2&)JS&$&4!. +!!&))!.ED+JS.4$&' !#S4* %2!S+ WE)JS4!'T3&)S.D()*'D+S.DS%())!' (S%.!) ()D+JS4%E4".!()JS%& WE)%2"!&!!D+JS! %2S()++. .!S$#) $ JS4!S4&%3T%"! (Experimentalism) 4) John Dewey .. Learning by Doing WE)#(.%2+D1E 4&+4S"!3TT"E+.3" .. 2542 !" 22 WE)+4D4E. 4E"E4+. JS$&!&!!#S"4#(.JS!&!&T)$4 4E"!+S"E1 ( x+S"#E)!$..!D+JSS4" S.".()"43" JS!#S4$#) $ S4()S+.S$%/

    4. J./ %() U4*3"V . +4D3!JS).&4%2 100 WE).4D3!JS).&4%2 32 %2 !()4S.1&'+(& D+JS1D.!#)#4+&4 S.$4)!"$4 $41&S."+ D1p)./*D+!S4%!4ED+JS!D.S4&%!S.1&'D+4S.)(&"4%

    6

  • #G!C AKBD : LMPKABB@ABEJ#Q SYNTHESIS RESEARCH OF LOCAL CURRICULUM DEVELOPMENT : STRATEGIC LEARNING OF CHILD ] CENTERED

    @AB!C ' 4. $p "m!!m D"@AB!C &p&$"' !+3/$' EF!CC 2551 EG"!C &+'

    #H &+' !"#$%&'()&+'1&!S4+S"#)m+S"#)S.4S $.!".&()+S"#) 172 .! &()!(%2%! $% !&+'1!S3%!p3&$pp #")D3 &( &!#)J . D3%!p)!&+' %2)J"J. .. 2525 2548 %F)J"J.!)$4 &( .. 2542 %21m1#E %2.$&&%2m'4%TT 3 )!)$4 &( $.!( x3 13 %#!E%F) 6 4&p!%#!E+.3" "%)E&( +S" $.!".4!$.! &()!()D3%2J4S4 !"&$p/&()!(4JS3)3T +&.&!4& !4D3+&.#"&.&!3()!) &.&.&!. !J34 !4!S%2&3)! !4+.S 6 +. J4S 7 J #")D3D&+'1!S%2&. &.y).)!"x !4!!"x4#"&. D3&$pp +S"#).D+T.!( +)/S!%vTT4!+ %3 +S"#)!&41E%%$"' 4!%( + )!D3 )!D4( + 431E D+!. JS!..!!/&x 3 &'#) 3$!3 $m"')D34S &(!4J4S4SSpD31!3)D+JS43$!3 4 ,-%"/S!%vTT#) .+4 JS+4"!$& 4%3$! ! E4S %JS%& 3$!34%3$! .%4" %vT+D4"$&&)!&!S&!1DD+S"#)!. !.!D#.4&!S !.!.!! ! 4%!p *!!. 14. 4!4+!JSSD#).+ D+&!S)!"!4x1!S#)D+%2%2%v$

    7

  • #!IEJI/#!I#Q"E_Q 3TT"E+.3" +S"%#!E+S"E1 ( x 4$4&. +S"!.)%2 .)%4#)41!!..!D.))/%vT+D3$!3 &! /S!%vTT#) &$ppE%&' JE%!D3+S" . .D+T.4 4D3+S"1.!.+S"#)!.4"&!%2S.1#) %+S"#))1E *! )++ .D+4&! S./&%"4!.!%m/.)& (&p!E+.3". 2539 : 10 ,&p!E1 ( x. 2547: 49)) ! E&!"%21&SD+S"#) 4%#!E+4$!' ($p "m!!m. 2546 : &4. ) . &S!&!"4+S"#) S.D4! JSE4&4 )!4+S"#) )!S.%2!++%" !&+'%2&'&!S()&SJS))1E%D3+S"#)D+!%m/".% !KDLEG#"!C ()&+'1&!S4+S"#)m+S"#)S.4S !MH!C ! m'4+S"#))J"J. D .. 2525-2548 +4&+'%23%!p3&$pp +&$p/1&()!(%!&$p/ *!1!S D$% &+'1!S $%J1 #INBN!C %!4&()!(&+'1 $$! !! (2527 : 10-15) )44%!%!1W& !& !p%2!".%!p&. 5 4 !J%!&$p/!."). 70 &1E % 4 +!4 172 .!$%4%%$!$% 1E (2542 : 3) J.D+JS3)3T"&!)"3( +D+1 %%$1 %4D3 2 & 10 () J!% JSE$%4#S"" 98.03 E#(4.JS!&!)"DE$% !!I"BIA

    D*!1!SJS4.".()"4 .! E$% D$%4$.! "!&41 ()!&+'".% #G"BIAOGDKNB

    &+'1!S3%!p 41!S%2&!#)&. $%3( +&+'3&$pp 4$%J"!p1( +4+S"#)

    8

  • @!COGE &+'+S"#) : $m"'S)JS%2&T !J)%2%4*.D!/% 4 1. )J"J.!)$4&(D ..2542 %2.D3. !I+!E)34D+4+S"#E !,-! %3!m'3$ E%2"$D+4%2.! 2. D4+S"#) !/S!%vTT#))!+%3!)$4 %2. +S"%4D+!4+S"D.)4&&!"1#) WE)%2%"!"!p'1+S"%#!E +S"!m!E +S"E1 ( x $m3 2544 3. ++S"#) )!%""!&41E%%$"' !()p+*.%2.%2 4) 4))+4D+!&( E1!S( x %2.DE1!S( x)4&&$!#E1!S/13$!3 ()!+4%2&!"%21#) 4& m (2542 : 31) !3 (2536 : 48) ).#E1!S( xD+S"#) 4. 1!S4%3 3 4 1m!!%p /1!1 4. p1+S"#) !%SD3 )!41( + 431E D+!. +S" %2. &S!&!S&!1D!(!1E )4E !&+'+S"3()!#) 4)!3 (2536 : 72) . 4&&p!%#!E+.3" (2541 : 81-90) . +S"#)!#444%!+(4!! %4( + 4&m+(3)!"! %%$ / +((D3()4()1E D+!. 5. JS)!..!D+S"#) !/&x /&3 /S!%vTT#) JS%&3 WE)$&&).!%2$&&)S.D#) %2. +S"#))1E !/%vT+&!"1#) $&&D#)!&!SE%2.+E)1.! 4& D' 3( "' (2539 : 205-206) %! (2541 : 29-34) ).#EJS)!..!D+S"#). !$&/D/ 6. p1/S!%vTT#)1!!..! JS+4/S!%vTT#)!.!+4' 3T%2 %3!m' D3$!3 &S3D#)!%D3%2( +4! &p!#E!..!4m!ST/4! 3$!3!..!%2JSD+1!S .!&+'%vT+&!" D+#)%DE4S,- +*4. $&&+. ".!..!!"".% ()! ".$&&!+)/"". ".!$4.!D4 E%"+)"!1" 4& D' 3( "' (2539 : 207-212) !3 (2541 :191 198) )4.#E 1$&&". n D+S"#) 4JS+%2"&T DJ $

    9

  • "$ D+4 &S&!1DD+S" &+' J +S"#)%D3 JS%&3$!3$() 4$ $%p' +.S 7. +4( +3 .D+T.4S.D$.!( x3 WE)%2%"%D3D3"%4 %2. ( +D+S"#)%2( +)4)D" 4& &. !3 (2540 : 96) .( +D+S"%2)&T) +S")4( +"!m'4&$4+!1+S" !&!.+!! !%3'".3"% ( +)+44%2pSp %2.SD3+E) n !#3()!%4D+ n 3 #&S!J &+'( +%2.4 &&$!"#$%&')"D+41E 4& D' 3( "' (2539 : 122) ).#E +4( +."!&!&T!&!+!".S1 !&!#S" ! !&!.D %2))!%3'. WE)!#+4D+ 4S&&$!$3D&4 8. $m"')D3D4S 4!+4$4%&'1+S" )J"D+44&!S "&" %2. JS"D+4JS%2&T 4&!3 (2540 : 71) ).#E+4$4%&'13.!&+'%vT+ &!"1#) "!)"D+4 ++4!m4S 444m)++ !%2$.! %2$&& 4,-%" D3+.SD#) 4.!!( & Sp D+/S!%vTT#)!.! m" +(D3%2#)S,-%p' %2. !()+S"#)!D3 &S!&!1DD%D34! S D+&!&T%2+ +*4D+4!(%" 4E&&&'&!S 4& !" 23 +.3TT"E+.3" ).4$%. 4E "E4+.JS$&!&!!#S"4 (&p!E+.3". 2545 : 5) $4!$.+!14S)JS%2&T4) ! %m (2542 :1) !!TE (2542 : 23-24) 4.#E D+JS!..!D 4&!!#"!/ S !( %vT+ +(E&&4" 4S"!&!D 3()!S/3"% %%$"'D34 9. 4J4S .D+T.1J4S%2$.!%p' / $.! S !pSpD31!3 J4S4434 !%S.S 4 !$"!&S 34 4&S!&"$ 3.+( 4!(%" 4S()D#) 4D3+.S#)%2() !/S!%vTT#).!4E%!J "!/ !&'%+1J4S %2. .)!(1J 4S 4!&+'+S" 4+.S &&$!#E))"D+JS4S 4& !3 (2534 :19-20) / ' (2534 : 48) D' 3( "' (2539 : 210) ).#E p1J4S)4. $4%&'S"

    10

  • 34 !%S.JS"!$4%&'4 4&&"+(*4" .!D+D34$$%p')4+4D#) &S"! ( +mWE)"&!1D. 10. DD3() !/S!%vTT#) 4$$%p' +.SD#) !D3%4!S.++ %2. ))!D#)!D3D+4%3' %2%+4$' 4&"!p'13TT"E+.3" !" 57 ).#E D++.E4!$&&D3$!3D+!..!D4E 4%p' &!S &!3T/S!%vTT#)!D3 ".3 4S)JS%2&T).#E JS!%p'" !m'm!3")4! &SD3()(),-&4 %vT+&&!S D3+.S)++3()!%p'3"1 (&p!E+.3". 2542 : 42) 11. +4D+S"#) JS+4"!$& 4$&SD+1! E4S !%3!m' %3$!JS%&D3 ! %JS%&) !4&S1"!&!S&!!#&!!&D ! "4"!JD3+S".!D3())%21 D3+.S.&$!&. ! %!J"!/4 %2. JS+!&!"+ 1DD+) 4& +'m (2536 : 211 213) ).#E +)1JS+D+S"#). JS+"%2JS3 D+& .! $ 3.+(&SD4!"!)+S"+4 D+$J %3$! 3 .%,-! !! ! !%3!m'D3+S"D+.JS%& 3$!3 12. %vT+D+S"#) .D+T.4 &S!/! /S!%vTT#)!!. !.!&!!#D#.4&!S %2. &S /S!%vTT#) "%"/+(%3+. WE)14. D+!%.+/S!%vTT#) !D+&!S &!!)DD#.4&!SD+./S!%vTT#) "BOG "BOGENB

    1. D+S"#)"4&!.!!($JS)1 +.4S 4#) )"4.%2".()E4!mJ".&$p/1 2. +.&4D+!%"&$p.)4.! $+S"#) 44 !%m/ 4 ()%2"..3$!3() n "BOG!C#`KE

    &!E#E%v)!J".+S"#)D+%J*

    11

  • B

    !3. (2536). #AIAK#!IKB"BD. $ : !'&$$/ 4. !!TE. (2542). 4S)%2S'. LHO!EbAE PcNdHIIQE. $ : !'&$$/4. D' 3( "'. (2539). AK : OGO!EbK. $ :. m . (2542). efAK : OOG. $ : E. p' 33. (2542). !#GI. $ : $p'!+. &p!E+.3". (2545). GQQKPcOK .P. 2542 OGOB"IKI (k 2) .P. 2545. $ : +&. $$! !!. (2527). #G!C : EIm. $ : $p'!+. Glass , G.V. and other. (1981). Meta Analysis in Social Research. California : Sage Publication.

    12

  • #LmmGcEG#HBEJ@ABNB"`EGDIPcEF 1/2 dMKOI!KPK PA!COGPc The Development of a Desired Character in Giving for Students in Grade 1 Class 2

    @AB!C p33 $4/

    3()D !(' D"@AB!C m"+.!+""' S'E EF!CC 2552 EG"!C D3

    #H & !"#$%&'(),-D+%2JSD+#p')&S%2JS4 E&!SE1)!".D+13 %#!E%F) 1 / 2 $.!".%23 %#!E%F) 1 / 2 m"+.!+""' S'E %FE 2551 37 & !1!S4&!"+D+SED+#p'D+%2JSD+ E&!&4+*)!".D+1 4#")D3D&+'1!S4. +&.&!#) &. &+'( + &S114&!&4+*1!&+'( + J. !&!SED+))+! (16.32) 1p)!)1 !.)!.4)1+(!& ( 18.91) !()#!#E+"$J". U1)!.41!& S".%V !&!SE".&)1&( 4D)4& (35.21) !&!&4+*D() oICcC#"OGNBdBOICp ` q INBr $1.1 (1.) (28.42) !()#!. #!&+(!. 35 & 37 & &4%2 94.59 ."*!D)& 2 & 37 & &4%2 05.40 .!.&&% 4&!&4+*D() oI!!BIHNBdBOICpI ICc#H`r &().!%3' (D+.4S1*, &.&.., 4!,-!( &! 4!) ( 35.29) !()&S.D+v#E/1!..))!.!!4*. !.!&(). 37 & +!44&!&4.!.3. &4%2 100.00 4&!&4+*)!.3.!4*. D+.4 $ !.!$"+"$ ( 27.22) 4&!&4+*D() U&4.%2.))"!D!4*.V 4() (29.52) 4&!&4+*D() o CGI!!NBIHdBOICpCHBr 3.& ( 48.85)

    13

  • #!IEJI/#!I#Q"E_Q %v$&!"*!%41.14"#$.S E44% &.D+T.!&!3(). JSD+&(JS)% JS&(JS)4% 4)(!&4%. JS)!3().D+T.!..%2JS4 "' ' ".%2JSD+))D+T.1 !&.D+T.E%2JS!.JSD+ ("p, 2533: 15) "4.. U)&.D+T.D&!%v$!&.1%+*." +(3)%2JS!.JSD+ +"$.1#S!)!" ".*D)$4*&3"4%2V 3"!4S.41". ".S.4D+JS()4 "!)4S4 ( 4.4".!.S& &(S..!!.4S.4 ( , 2552:17) DE!$.&. D41.1D+.&. E%v$14!"4&$pm!S.! ( 3$! p $m , 2550: 1) +&14&$pm! m! 1*%2&)+*." &4#E"!..! &SDx./!.&)!&TD&$ppE%&'1 %2JSD+1D+%2&4)!&!$1 +"$J4. &pJSED),-D+!&$pm! m!4D+ ()D+43"S.D&!4.!&!$1 !MH!C 1. %3$.!". %3 3 %#!E%F) 1 %FE 2551 256 & $.!". 3 %#!E%F) 1/2 37 & 2 . m*!1!S ()) 5 m&! 1$%F%2y!3!1!4*S.+ +(.+.3" 4!+!D+$43 4!*T%3'()#%23$%2%$%F D%FE 2551 43 %#!E%F) 1 44& U3()SV 43T3D+43 %#!E%F) 1 $&&)1 ()!. 4!1 "44 1. 1 &!"+ 1.1 D3)!!S! &S.#E1!. WE)" S.4S +*"4%F !.!oD3 4 D+""!. #"S.D/3. %2. 4 %44!!.4 SE. 1.2 &S4'() U$1'13V WE)4D++*&!DT%!14* n !.3!yD+4S () UJS%)%V WE).()&!!1 J.* m' JS!. )/)%2S' 4&!.!!(.!D1 &S 3

    14

  • 1.3 &S)&$pm!D%2JSD+#!&!&4+*14"D!..!D3.+(!. 4D+".&14&!&4+*. 111!&+'( + 2. 1 %" 2.1 &S+(3T3#EJS%& 2.2 &S!)1)!&D+!. 2.3 ++43 %#!E%F) 1 4m!)1D+ JS!.D%3$!!143 2.4 JS!.!)1.4&!SE". %4D+ W#!11D". n 3. 1 $% 3.1 &SD+14&!SE)!".)4&)1 3.2 &SD+1"().DD+!. 3.3 &S114&!&4+*1!&+'( + !CmOGLE@

    1. &!"+D+!+*&!$1'1JS() D+4&!SED++*.1"$1'4 &( +".!.!( +!D. WE)$m&'44&+"#$ 4 %2,-&!!!""D+41E D"D1$& 4D+" D&+'JS)14& &(D+ (&!//, 2548)

    2. #p'4&3.+(JS) 14& D+SE4D!&!$1 WE)$TD$m)!"4 UV !()D+*%2,4D4 +E)D))4&(&!$1 (, 2552)

    3. &1D+ n)!.D3.) +*."!&!$1 !!).%vD+JS).4 D+1!&!$11E 4&$ppE%&' &( &!+*+*DJS()D+&!3.+(JS)..+(JS)S.Dx)"$1'4 (p 10 %)E4, 2551)

    4. !.3.!4*.D+!. +*. &().!%3' (D+.4S1*, &.&., 4!,-!( &! 4!) D+()n!.4.1. D+$ D+!&!$1 +*4.%4D+4*S" &(#p' UD+V D+4*!S)3.+(&! &! &!!"" !&!+*+*DJS() WE)"&.!)&E)%" (&p!m!, 2550)

    5. !.3.D!4*.D+!.!4*.D+.4 $ !.!$"+"$ &D++*#E&!!""&!+.DJS()WE)%2"E)4

    15

  • 6. &4.))%2"!D!4*. &( 4() 33 '+ D+$ !&!$1 4 4D++*.SD+ &(.%v&!$1D+JS()

    7. &4.!.3.D+!4*.!.*4& 3. 3.D+D )4.SD+.D+ !.%2)"D++()1. ".D+D+4D+D "BOG & . p4D+4p'4#p'D+SD+ D+.!&!$1 &,-).%v %2JSD+)!")&4D+ D+D+1!&!$1 E&4&$pp .".() &&$ppD4()".% 3. " B Em. 2542. GQQKPcOK LMP 2542. $!+& : !'

    &$$/4. "p !"$. 2533. !KHN. $!+& : !'/!'. &p!m!. 2550. !MEA_#IcEG&' (Online). Socialscience. igetweb.com, 12 /&! 2552. &!// (!,). 2548. MIEGC!- #!KDL (Online). www.kalyanamitra.org, 11 /&! 254 . S'()4*. EA_EQ!K AEJ#H (Online). Swu.ac.th, "!. 4* %F) 24 y) 347 !&! 2544. y yy. 2550. #LmmGcEG#"dL#B !#IdHNBG!EG (Online). Kroo.ipst.ac.th. 3$! '. 2550. EA_#LmMICMI#LmMId L B IB ! d H N B ! K I L I K EF Pc 2550 `EGDIPcEF 4 - IMIPcEF 3 (Online) . www.takbuddhis.com. # 4 &p. 2551. #LmmGcEG#"d GH@HI! (Online). www.kroobannok.com, 21 . ' $!. 2551. #LmmGcEG#"@AB (Online). 3.&! , 19 /&! 2551. p! +."S . EA _ CMIHq NB HHB (Online) . bbznet.pukpik.com, 5 2548 . 2552. KdKCK!QmHB!ABCNB. S'.!J.43 &$pm ! + &' & ! S ( &' !+3 ) , $ !+& : % ' &4' 4.

    16

  • 4 / &p. 2546. #I EA_#I OG#!I@H LIGAB !CPc`EGDIPcEF 6 (Online). www.learners.in./th/fil. #m!#.2548. CK#HCGNB @AB NBIEJ@AB HB I (Online) . www.sathir- dhammasathn.org, 29 +&! 2548. 3$! p $m. 2550. #LmMI#!IAB. $!+&:..W. &!!&3). ______________ . #!IL"CEJ@ABNB (Online). OK NATION.net, 2551 ______________ .mG 10 EGcHB (Online). www.showded.com, 20 ! 2551.

    17

  • #@! #!IABcIKdBOICpCHA!HP oL""!Br OG o@ABEOEr

    #!IABc"`EGDIPcEF 1/2 IKC#"OGCMI!# 15 M!#I 2552

    18

  • EbIMG!AEOO GHG`wOIK@IeMxEGHw OGGH#!IIDNO LIGABOG#dd"`EGDIPcEF 2 INTERACTION BETWEEN DESIGNING TEACHING STYLE AND BASIC DESIGNING SKILL LEVEL ON HANDICRAFT LEARNING ACHIEVEMENT AND DESIGNING ABILITY LEVEL IN THE AREA OF WORK-ORIENTED EXPERIENCES OF PRATHOM SUKSA TWO STUDENTS

    @AB!C '/ +'3 D"@AB!C m"$p'!+ ,%#! EF!CC 2551 EG"!C 34

    #H & !"#$%&' 1)()%J!m%4x'4&!!#D+.&4.4+4 +.$.!3 %#!E%F) 2 )! 1) 4( x". 2) S%)"". 3) !%!m'+.S%4( x m %2344.4+434!$.!D* 4!S% 4 S%&( 1) S%!&-4S/". 2) S%!.!&-4S/". 3)S%!&-4S".1 4)S%!.!&-4S".1 !4( x%2"%D4*!J!m%4x'!&!!#D%2"%"! $.!".%43 %#!E%F) 2 80 & (!4$.!41$.!4$.!&&$!4$.! &()!(D%4S% 4J!m44&!!#D &+'1!SD3 &+'&!%% 2 J. &y)J!m( x+4S..4.!&T !.!m%!m'+.S% ( x".J!m.!&T ".!m+4( x".J!m4&!!#D1.!&T

    19

  • Abstract The purposes of this research were to compare the handicraft learning achievement and designing ability level between pretest and posttest scores and between groups of prathom suksa two students with 1) different designing teaching style, 2) different basic designing skill level, and 3) interaction between designing teaching style and basic designing skill level. The research method was an experiment using randomized block, pretest and posttest design, with 4 designing teaching style: 1)structured-sample pictures, 2) unstructured-sample pictures, 3) structured-real objects and 4) unstructured-real objects, with basic designing skill level as blocking variable, and 2 dependent variables: handicraft learning achievement and designing ability level. The sample consisted of 80 prathom suksa two students, randomly selected and assigned to the experimental and the control groups. The research instruments were designing teaching style, designing learning achievement test, and designing ability level measurement. Two way analysis of variance was employed for data analysis. The research results indicated that the posttest of handicraft learning achievement and designing ability level were significantly higher than pretest; and there was no significant interaction effect between designing teaching style and basic designing skill level on handicraft learning achievement and designing ability level, but there were significant main effects of basic designing skill level on handicraft learning achievement and designing ability level of the students. #!IEJI"!C 4E)!&$p/ 4!JSD+"*!/D+!" &!&4)!&'%2!"+E))!&!&T%2 WE)!#!D+41E D"JS4 J. &!&4&'!#44!.!m'S #JS4"$.#Sm!%!p)+!!%2)!&!".() ()!W1%2.)!/4&!&4&' 4 #S4"$D+#SmD!. ! !4%p')+!!&!&4&' *T"""!/ (3 'D+T. , 2532) &!&4&'!&$p&.".%3"".&!.!4. !&$p&.".$&&)!&!&4&'4 JD41E *.!D+JS&'4&!ED &!&4&'D+.$&&D%3" &.!" ".' Torrance (1962) 4$%p&!&4&'E1 Ligon 4 4*$ 6-8 %F "&'14*%)%S.&!%2!1E 4 4%p')$D+4* .!3.&!S+*D+.4* 4*$ 6-8 %F !&!&4&'43. WE)%2J1S. WE)D+4*""!Ipw')&!+4 144&!&4+* J. )!1&4D".n !+.4 2 +.)&T +.

    20

  • &(m!3" +.)&(%p')!!%21&$.".n +(%""') ( $T',2539) 4 .%3 (2530) 4.#E&$pp1. )4!&!S4&$p&. (Value) &!&4&' (creativity) #%3' (function) % (arts, sciences and technology) 4( x +!4!1 (design methodology) D3+. .1!1 .!J")!( x)4+!!)%2JS%3 (professional) D&" 4 #JS34" D()1JS #.4&'D"1JSD+JS1D %"1JS"!)4#.4 J&'*%2%"!"1JS Dp 3.D+E41D1 "1&' 4)!4&'4"1" ".Dm+E)#JS!D+JS%""!)JS+4+1 +(D+JS+4+1" ()&')4.34. 4JS+)&3 .D34 4"!1 " J)1E !%2J"1JS WE)"!%%$1D+4)$4 ( "pwp',2526) 3+E))()&!&4&' 4D+&!&T&(3D$.!S3& %2$.!%p'+E)D+S"%#!E$m3 2521 (y%%$ .. 2533) %43 3 &( " %4x' )"!%S.3 3 !$4!$.+!)!$.D+!&$p!")&T&( %2 !D3 !%%$S.! )!&$p!"D%%$ "+% ! +&!SD+!.!&!&4)!&'4 (Em , 2533)

    E4.1" %JS%2JS$.!S3&4" D+JSD!$.E ()&'%4x'1 43 %#!E%F) 2 JSp+*. )D3S.!S%)%% ".!.!#$%4. S%D4+!+ D$.!S3&43 %#!E%F) 2 +*.%/!&!.!&D44S"./4S".1 JSED)%J!m1)!S%"". ! EJ!m1)!( x".4 JD() %2JD+JS !#%%2D%%$D+4&&!%2D/%v$4 %2%3'".JS+E +(&SJSD4$.!S3&%4x' ! %vT+4#Sm".%D&"4

    21

  • !KDLEG#N!C 1.()%J!m%4x' 4&!!#D+.&

    4.4+4 +.$.!13 %#!E%F)2 )!4( x". .4+4

    2.()%J!m%4x' 4&!!#D+.$.!3 %#!E%F)2 )!S%)"". (S%%/!/!.!& S%4S/"./4S".1)

    3. ()E%!m'+.S%4( x4&!!#D)!".J!m%4x' 4&!!#D !MH!C () %234 (experimental research) 4.+4 434!$.!D* ()+%!m'+.S% 4( x)!".J!m%4x' 4&!!#D $.!S3&13 %#!E%F) 2 4!S% 4 S%&( S%)!/!.!+4& S%)4S/"./4S".1 !4( x%2"% D4*!J!m %4x' !&!!#D%2"%"! WE)!1 "m44".% %3)E$.!". %3DE& %2)ES.D43 %#!E%F) 2 /&) 2 %FE2549 m"$p'!+ ,%#! ! 80 & (!4$.!41$.!4$.!&&$!4$.! $.!".D3m$.!.3 ().$.!%3%2 2 4 &( 4S 40 & 4") 40 & !$.!".& 80 & H!C "`KIH 1. 4$.!4 4$.!".3 %#!E%F)2 80 &)(4$.!.3 41$.!4 4$.!)!4( xS4( x") !$.!.%2$.!. 4 $.! ".$.!!)!4( xS 10 & 4( x") 10 & $.!($.!".1$.!4 $.!4) 1 D+JSJDD+4S/". 3 S% 4+4&D $.!".) 2 D+JSJDD +4S/". 3 S% 4!.+4&D $.!4) 3 D+JSJDD +4S".1 3 S% 4+4&D $.!4) 4 D+JSJDD +4S".1 3 S% 4!.+4&D 2. JSJ4SDD 4"!( +"#$%&'3"!!&+' 1( +D+JS&$p$"!%%$

    22

  • 3.DD 4"!( +"#$%&'!&+'DD+JS&$p$"!%%$ 4.44&!!#D 4+4J"#$%&'%! "&$p/%!( xD 4JS&$p$ 3 &p D+JS&$p$%!J4D3%!&!!#D %%$1)!"! HH JS%2JS4$.!". 4 $.! 4D3J4S+4& / !.+4& 4D3J4SD+4S/".4S".1)JS41E 5 JSD3 14 &n 50 WE)!1 "4 1. "S.! JS3 S+4&!.+4&"+(1".! !()JS1D4D+)!"!%""!1 " 2. 4."!JS 5 () 3. JSJ!%! 4. .$.!4%2 4 $.! ".$.!!4&!!#DS 10 & 4&!!#D") 10 & 5. 4$.!". 6. 3 1" m ! mD )!"!%""!1 " 7. $.!4".$.! 4 $.! )!"!JS""."!)+4D""1$.!4S 8. )!4 4D3J4SD+4S/".4S".1)JS1E 5 JD3 14 &n 50 9. !() $44 JS!J"D+&"!%!4&!!#D%!J!m &)4!&+'1!S !#G"BIA 1. &+'1!S( x #")D3&( &.y) ( x ) .)!"x (S.D.) 4D3%!SPSS for Windows 2. &+'1!S ()""#$%&'1) 1 &( %J!m 4&!!#13 %#!E%F) 2 )!4( x".+4 #")D3&( &+'&!"".44&. $.!!m' (dependent group t-test) 4D3%! SPSS for Windows 3. &+'()""#$%&'1) 2 &( %S%()&!!#D%4x' #")D3&( &+'&!"". 44&.$.! (independent group t-test) 4D3%! SPSS for Windows 4. ()""#$%&'1) 3 &( &+'%!m'+.S% 4&!!#D13 %#!E%F) 2 #")D3 &( &+'&!%% 2 (Two-way ANOVA) 4D3%! SPSS for Windows

    23

  • @!C 1. J!m.+ 1S%4+4&D+4S/".D. +JS!&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 .05 2. )!4&!!#D") !()p%&!"".1&.y)&&!!#D&J!m. + . +JS!&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 0.5 3. )4S%4+4&D+4S/". +JS!&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 0.5 4. !.!m%!m'+.S%4( x ".&.y)1&4&!!#D.!&T#")4 0.5 ".!m+4( x".".J!m 4&!!#D1.!&T LEOGE@!C J& !%4*).D 4)JS.%2 1. J!m.+1S%4+4&D+4S/". J. J!m.+1S%4+4&D+4S/". +JS!&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 .05 WE)4&!!"x)" . &J!m1)!S%)"".+4+.$.!4!&!"". ()4+4&%2+4S%D WE)D+JS!&&!&4 ".)!"!4D D+3..!".44&!&4&'4!1E 4)1E JS4" 1". S%/)D3%2()D& %2/)D3%2/)!.!4!% JS)%24**!.11D4S/ ()S%/*!#4#E( +)%21/4. 4D4!!/D+4S+S% 4&1 4S. ( Bandura ,1977: 22) .. S%)D+J4". &(4E"./ !#%p1/".4()&!+!S%m!)1D4.. 4S".1 WE)!#444%"."!&!&4&'S%&)&S+4D+ 4S".1%2)WW1E ED+%&!+!D+""#$%&')"%211E !4+E) y !/".E%241 ")!.$.WW .JD+JS!&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#"

    24

  • 2. )!4&!!#D") J. )!4&!!#D") !()p%&!

    "".1&.&y)&&!!#D &J!m.+ +JS!&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 .05 WE)!.4&!!"x)JS" . ( xD13 %#!E%F) 2 )!4( x"".+4 ()!JS)!4&!!#DS !&!&4&'")4 !#&44++&43()! %2&!&4)%"". &4)%%$".&!&44!J!JD+4)D+!. !#!+*&!!m'1)".n 4!)!"$ D+4&!&4D+!.".()% !#1D( +)WW4 &4 "4DD"!1 "".n E.JD+&&!!#D!&J!m%4x'4 +"$J4.1" E!.+*)4.34D&&!!#DJ!m1JS .JS)!4&!!#D") #!"!" D!&!D1+!) !,-," %S%)!1 "!.$.WW% +"$%v4. .JD+JS!4&!!#D")!&&!!#D!&J!mS1E 4 !()p&!"".1&.y)&&!!#&J!m. +JS!&&!!#&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 .05 41 T / ( 2540 ) E&!!m'3+"$ 1$.!"%"J!m3"4" oD&1E4%"33 1"E 10 . "%)!J!".J!m &(SDD,!m 3. JS)4S%4+4&D+4S/".

    J. +JS!&4&&!!#D&J!m)!1E .!&T#")4 .05 WE)4&!!"x)JS" . S%)"".( x)"". .J".&4&!!#D%4x'13 %#!E%F) 2 4+"$J). JS)4S%4+4&D+4S/". ()S%4+4&D %2m)&D D+JS!&D)4 !()!&)4 %2"+4*.JD+JS4"."!".!D4&!&4&' D+JS!#&44++&43()! D+!&!&4)++!.#S%4 !%v.!D3())%2/". JS4+*/".4D4S%p' D3 &'D+!.4..4S".14) French ( 1952 ) 4E. 4**3/)!p.n!.!4WW3. / !./+!(/#. WE)4& Travers ( 1964 ) . D&!&44D+.3 %#!E /..)!4 D+JS44./+!()!!"".n1/%S.. 4+"$J

    25

  • 4. E.JD+JS)4S%4!.+4&D+4S/".+ JS!4&&!!#D)!1E D ".!..J#EJ!mD+)!1E ()14&!!m'4&+.&'J JS4++!&!&4&')%D+!. ".!.4&&$!&!&4DD+!m'4&1 " &'E.JD+J"J!.!Sp'!.%2%"!"#$%&' E!.%J*.)& E.JD+&J!m%4x'!.)!1E 4. %!m'+.S% 4( x J. !.!%!m'+.S% 4( x".&.y)1&4&!!#D .!&T#")4 .05 WE)!.4&!!"x)" . S%4!%!m'". J%. S% 4D".&.y)1&4&!!#D .!&T#")4 .05 !()p"!4D. $.!)!( xDS!&.y)4&!!#DS)$4 J JS)4S%)"".!&.y)1&4&!!#D !."". ()S%)JS !D3D4%2S%)!p1D3()&( /".".1 WE)D3() 2 %/ D1 "J"() JSD3S%1())!4!.!% %2S%).!.WW D+JS!.111D4.34 ED+!.!$%&%vT+D JSD3%p'4!,-,() )D3+pw'.D+J)!.+!(1&SJS 4JS"&4&'J1E ! ED+!.!%vT+$%&D.)& )!4( xD)4 E.JD+!&.y)1&4&!!#D)!1E "!%4 "BOG 1. &)!D4%2ED!. 5 %4+' 2. &4D & 15 .n$$.!4%2)+!!!. +(% &&$!D+.$$.!4 &,-,.".() 3. &DD+!&!WW!)1E ()4&!!#1JS4. B T /. 2540. Pc#!IIMKL"LIK!OEK!@IeMx !KHK`}}~NOG#"PcGHEGPK!"K Pc 10. m'%TT&$"'!+pw" &p&$"'$"+! !+ &!m$. $T'. 2539. O. !'& ) 1. $!+& : !'$p'!+. "pwp'. 2526. O. !+& :!'', 3 'D+T.. 2532. CIB#H!. $ : !+&% !".

    26

  • 4 .%3. J"/pw'%. !!DE_KI kP I.D. Open House. /&3$"+!&p#%v"!"' $p'!+. Em, . 2533. #AIEGI@KIAKEGDIPcLMP 2521. ( y%%$ .. 2533 ) .$!+& : !' &$$/. Bandura , Albert. 1969. Principle of Behavior Modification. New York : Holt Rienhart & Winston. French,J.E. 1952. Children preferences for picture of pic tonrealnpattern. The Elementary School Jornal 53 (October 1952) : 90-95. Torrance,E.P. 1962. Constructive behavior:stress, personalily,and mental,health. New York : Englewood (liffs,N).: Prentice-Hall. Travers,R.M.W. 1964. Tranmission of information to human receivers. Jornal of information to human receivers. Jornal of Educational Psychology.(2) : 1-5.

    27

  • cMmG!HAOO!HBI" `EGDIPcEF 1 dMKOI!KPK PA!COGPc

    @AB!C '! )!x &p D"@AB!C m"+.!+""' S'E EF!CC 2551 EG"!C 3%"

    #H & !"#$%&' 1) ()D+"+D&!&T14S&!4p 2) ()Emp)4S)4!1$.!".)D3D%2m"+.!+""' S'E 43 %#!E%F) 1 %FE 2550 4$.! 5 + !%2 178& JS*!1!S4D314 E! +E)+E)&!4 #!&!&4+*1)EmpD4S)4!#!&!%DD!+E)+E)&!4 &+'1!S3&$p/4&+'( + (Content Analysis) &+'1!S3%!p4&.&!#) &. J. 1) !&!"+D&!&T14S&!4p D+&!.!!(D!14+*.++(%2!"mp)$&%21E&3.4S 2) !Emp)4S)4! SE3 $ +*414D+ !. 90 )"1.!!+E)+E)&!4 !&!"(()3.*1Dp !!. 70 !.& 1D++(p WE)4D++*. Emp)4S)4!14+*%2S%m! #!IEJI/#!I#Q"E_Q

    !"xE13" (2548 : 3,4) !"x) 1 4.#E&$pp1&)E%&' Dx!( WE)!%o+!14ES.)&$&D+%2 U&. &4 !&!$1V 4!)+!!3. &"!m!3""*!"!/ ""!&!" D4$1/ ."D "%vTT &!S &$pm!"E)E%&' WE)!".3 11.5 .#E &$pm! "mp "ED&!%2!( 1x D4E*4+4..4%S%E 4E4&$pm!&!S &4D3&$pm!%2( x1SWE)1m/E Em(2550) 4.#E&$pm!)&.%S,vD+3+% 4. W()"' 1+!) ! D( J()J. $/ !!!& "TS %S"E)4

    28

  • !&& !+"$J +*.%3'.!!.." JS)!m +(!D.!D+3%2&4 *&( .!. JS%& &S ' ()".n D)&!" &$pm!&!S +(&!%2&4D+41E D"JS WE)4&&$ppE%&'1m"+.!+""' (2546) )""E)4"..!)4! &pJS+*. &%S"ED+4*" ".)!3 %#!E%F) 1 ()44%2&$pp)4+(&$pp)E%&'"4"%" %v$ %vT+4)4! 4y%vT+()1 .%2%vT+&T1&! !J".#3"1JS& WE)%vT++. %2%vT+)!!"&!.!!(D%vT+&D&!$& .D&! %vT+)!+**&( 4*+(3114"mp +( Emp D4S&!4 +*%vT+ 1"!p".n D +(!".D+ ! y !J. 4J.!()+*1"+."!)".n 4+"$ &pJSE!&!")E 4 UEmp )4S)4!13 %#!E%F) 1 m"+.!+""' S'EV ()D+41!S!D3%2D&$ppE%&' ()D++*&!&T4&!"+4"E +(!Emp 43.)4! D &!".% !KDLEG#"!C 1. ()D+"+D&!&T14S&!4p 2. ()Emp)4S)4!1 !MH!C & %2"!D4%#!E &pJSD33%" %2S%!+E)+E)&!4 WE)!1 "4! 5 1 4. 1. 1 SD / "$D+4&!D 2. &!"+ 3. !(%" 4. 1!S 5. %!J%" EGN!C &( 3 %#!E%F) 1 m"+.!+""' S'E %FE 2550 $.!".)D3D ! 5 + !178 & *1!SD3D/&" %FE2550 & !$.EEmp)4S)4! !+E)+E)&!4 %"+)!%1D/)%2 #INBN!C & ! 4 3$4 &( 1. 1!4S%' $' )J141 2. E!+E) +E)&!4 %2"E!+E)+E)&!4 1".+D+E)%4+'

    29

  • 3. #!&!&4+*1)EmpD4S)4! %2#!&!&4+* 2 " ") 1 #!)&!&4+* &!SE1 41 n ") 2 #!"!1)4S)4! 4&()+!$"!)"&!%2 4. #!&!%DD!+E)+E)&!4 !#G"BIA JS&+'1!S3&$p/4&+'( + (Content Analysis) &+'1!S3%!p4&.&!#) &. @!C DEEmp)4S)4!13 %#!E%F) 1 !J 4 1. !&!"+D&!&T14S&!4p D+&!.!!(D!14+*. ++(%2!"mp)$&%21 E"3.4S 2. !Emp)4S)4! SE3 $ +*414D+ !. 90 )"1.!!+E) +E)&!4 !&!"(()3.*1Dp!!. 70 !.& 1D++(p WE)4D++*.Emp)4S)4!14+*%2S%m! "B!Cm 1. &!"+D&!&T14S&!4 %4*&T 2 %4* &( 1.1 D+&!.!!(1 "+#E&!&T14S&!4 4pD+&!.!!(D14 WE)+!#14444#E 96.00 1.2 &!SE / "!)4 .!#E 36.51 SE!.3 !.D!()+*++( !1 )!!TTp.3 .3.*1 E$%4D( ". !13..!D+"+#E&!&T14S&!4 +*.++(%2!"mp)$&%21 E&3.4S 2. Emp)4S)4! %4*).3 .4Emp)4S)4! 4 2.1 3 $ +*414D+#E 41.01 &!SE)43%2D+4.!.!DD 2.2 "1.!!+E)+E)&!4 #E 92.70

    30

  • 2.3 !. 60 3.*1!!.!)! !!. 70 !.& 1D++(p WE)%2%4*)&pJS!&!D4%2.) %4*)1"4D++*.Emp)4S)4!14+*%2S%m! .()43 !!)3..!Emp '%3 4%S,v !D+!EmpD3)!!3 3.()n !()! '%3 %""%2.)4D4S&!41+4.!&!4$ 4. !+)&!4+%4+' 1 ".'%3 3.&!4+$ "!%2.)41'%3 #(%2%v&T)3.Emp14%2.4 "BOG J &pJS!1 4 1. &!4!Emp)4S)4! D43 %#!E%F) 1 D%FE". n % 2. &!"$.!)!D()!+E)+E)&!4 ()%23 %#!E%F) 1 WE)%243 *$41

    3. &!4!Emp)4S)4!D$43 4. &!!).!4*&41.!%m/ ()%S,vD+

    "+#E&!&T14S)4! B &! 34 E. 2550. $!+& : 21 !&! 2550 . + 5. m"+.!+""' S'E. 2546 . O@LM

    dMKOI!KPK PA!COGPc 2546 ] 2550. 1m/E Em . 2548. IKwPc"K. $!+& :

    +*!'.

    31

  • #!IAB!`KB`IMIPcEF 1

    @AB!C !m' 3()T D"@AB!C !m!4. EF!CC 2551 EG"!C

    #H D& D& !"#$%&'() 1) +(*'()&!S)+

    ( "+3 !m!E%F) 1 )!&$p/ 2) +%m/1+(*' 3) %J.+4+(*' 4) E&!ED1)!".+(*'

    $.!".)D3D& %23 !m!E%F) 1 !m!4. +4!$% 31 & 4$.!".4m( (Purposive Sampling) &()!()D3%4 +(*'()&!S)+( "+3 !m!E%F) 1 %!&$p/+(*' 44J!m #!&!ED1)!".+(*' &+'1!S4D3#"( x4. &.y) .)!"x &+'%m/1+(*'pw'%m/ (E1 / E2 ) !."). 80/80 4&!"".1J!m.+4+(*'4#" (t-test for Dependent Sample) J.&$p/1+(*'4( +!&$p/S.D44!$ 4&&J"!&$p/S.D44#E4! %m/1+(*'!&.. 85.20 / 85.16 %2%"!!!"x)+4 J1+S..4+(*'.!&T#")4 .01 !&!ED".+(*'S.D4!#E!)$4

    ABSTRACT The purposes of this study were to develop an electronic book (E-Book) on introduction to hide for mattayomsuksa 1 students based on quality of electronic book, to test for the efficiency of the electronic book, to compare pretest and posttest academic achievement by using electronic book, and to study level of studentsj satisfaction of electronic book. The samples of this study were 31 students from Mattayomdansamrong School, Samutprakan province. The samples were chosen by purposive sampling method. The instrument constructed in this study were electronic book, evaluation form for E-Book quality, academic achievement test and the questionnaire for studentsj satisfaction. The data were analyzed for arithmetic mean, standard deviation, to examine the efficiency of the E-Book. Standard criteria E1/E2 not less than 80/80 was used with t-test for dependent samples for pre and post academic achievement test.

    32

  • The Analysis of data revealed that the quality of E-Book in content was excellence with all of items and the production technique was rated at excellent and very excellent level. The Efficiency of E-Book was 85.20 / 85.16, which reached the standard criteria. The achievement of students who studied by using E-Book was posttest higher than pretest significantly at .01 level.The studentsj satisfaction on E-Book was at more to most satisfied level. #!IEJI/#!I#Q"E_Q

    3TT"E+.3" $m3 2542 1)!"! (y) 2) ..2545 !" 22 .. 4E"E4+.JS$&!&!!#S"4 #(.JS!&!&T)$4 4E".!D+JS!#"!m!3""*!/ (%IS%E, 2545 : 12) !" 24 $. 4S D+#E +.))14D%4*)&TWE)%"!3TT"y4.3. (1) 4( +!D+4&&!D &!#41JS 4&E#E&!"".+.$&& (3) 4!D+JS4S%p' ,-%" D+4 &4%2 %2 .4D,S.".() (5) .!$D+JS!#4 /4! () &!4()D+JS4S !&!S !#D3%2.+E)1S %( +)J"()4 !" 64 x".!$D+!J" " +(3 ())!' 4$$%p' &()E() 4.414&!!#DJ" 4D+!$J"D+SD.JSJ" &()E 4%4D+!1.14.%2m! !" 65 D+!$& 4JSJ"JSD3&()E ()D+!&!S &!!# DJ" ! D3&)+!! !&$p/ %m/ !" 66 JS!m414&!!#DD3&()ED)4 ()D+!&!S )D3&()ED+&!S4"4.".()"43" !" 67 x".!D+!J" &()E ! "4"! " %!JD3&()E ()D+4D3)&$!&. +!!S1& (%IS%E, 2545 : 38) Em 44D+4&3TT"Ey4.E4 +4+S"E1 ( x $m3 2544 1E 4!+&T))"&( .!D+JS4 S4".".()"43" 4#(.JS!&!&T)$4 !#"!m!3" "*!/ (Em, 2544 : 4) 4+4$4+!1+S"E1 ( x4. WE)#(.%2!"xS D+JS4&$ppE%&'3. D+JS!&!&4&' D,S D, . 1 && D+JS!&!S%2 S.%)%&!T+ !/D4 () D3& %m&4 mD++!!#p' 4+4&+S"E1 ( xD4D+ 4.S%2 8 $.!

    33

  • 4. / &p""' "' &!Em! $1EE % 3& S/".% (Em, 2544 : 4 - 5) +$.!3& Em4+4.%2S)!$.JSD+!&!S &!1D) 3 & ! 4 !#& &". n !D3D.#S" +!! &$!&. !&$pm!J"/pw'+(mD+!. !#%2+!S.&p !+*&$p&.!"&")4"."4!&$pm! m! &.!)%2( x 4. &!1 W()"' %+44 %S.D+JS!#3.+(" E)"4"!34x !#43"S.D&!4.!&!$1 .!!(1.1D4 D1&! (Em, 2544 : 1 ) /%v$&1!!.!".&$p/3" E1!$' D+&4D4%)%% !.E4"4S%4!)"!&S%2%v&T JS!#(S4$ $#) !.4S.".D++(. ".%2()*')%2 '4'W'!D3())!%m/S (%/p !"$ &p, 2550:1) +D#E !3&!"'D3.!! WE) JSJS!#D3%3'&!"'D4.!%m/ WE)4D3&!"'%2() %2.+E)1D3&)%2)!.) !#( +D+4 DS%/) /&()+ S%+!$44" D(&()+1!S ('4 3m4, 2546 : 35) +(*' (E-Book) %2&D+!.WE)41E DE1% ()&!"1!$')() +(1%$DS%4" ()414.+(%")% (' &3! &p, 2549 : 2) $44.1+(*'&(!m4*1!S)%2 1&! "1 /) /&()+ ". n 1!S43()!( + +())!m'14 JS. !#1#E1!SDS%1!"!4))1 3()!4.4 4* !#1!S*'!()!JS"D344 (TT&$p # &p, 2550 : 2) +(*' E%2() "!)4&!!..+D%v$ ()!#D3.!&!"'4.4&!%m/ +(*'E%2()S)JS!#(4"! #))4 ($%J3" +p', 2540 #ED .!" $! &p, 2550 : 2 ) !m!4. 4$.!S3& 44"!1Em4. 444D 2 p &(43( x"!!"xS ()D+%2%"!+S"E1 ( x $m3 2544 D$43 444D3)!"!D+WE)!#(4"!&!#4 &!D1 (!m!4., 2550:4) 4!33.% 43 !m!E%F) 1 WE)%23)!"!1$.!S

    34

  • 3& D.))4D( +&!S)+( "WE)&!&!SD1 ( x .)"!(,-%"DJ"/pw')+ .!&!S)+( "!. 14&!S)p1+)D3D%" 14&!S( ")&()!()D3DJ"/pw'+ !J!m/&I)+( "&.1") n )JS44()%2&S.!(%D+$& %2( +D!.3D+"4"! !.D. %/%". n !.D+D)JS1E 4+"$ D+JS4&4D&!D+!. 4.+(*' (E-Book) 1!3.D433.% ().!D+S&& E( +44" $) $)! !&!!DE !#( +!()*4"!" 4!.%2"!JS&m)". n )%D( +4.++(*'D& 4&3TT"E+.3" $m3 2542 !" 1, 3, 5 !" 61 65 +.3TT"y4. %2%"! + $4+!1+S"E1 ( x $m3 2545 ()"D+!#E( +4" %2%"!+&T1+S"E1 ( x ).. ".!D+JS4 S4" 4#(.JS!&!&T)$4 !#"!m!3" "*!/ O!#Hef

    +(*' () &!S)+( "+3 !m!E %F) 1 D& JS&4S%4 4! (Generic Model) +()4)%. ADDIE Model (y , 2550: 11) !%2D+(*'WE)%4&'%+ 5 1 "&( &+' (Analysis) (Design) (Development) %D3 (Implementation) %! (Evaluation) !KDLEG#"!C 1.()+(*'()&!S)+( "+3 !m!E%F) 1 2.()+%m/1+(*'()&!S)+( "+3 !m!E%F) 1

    3.()%J!m.+4+(*' 4.()E&!ED1)!".+(*'

    !MH EG D& 4. 3 !m!E%F) 1 /&) 1 %FE 2551 !m!4. /!( +4!$% 524 &

    35

  • LIK! 4.3 !m!E%F) 1 /&) 1 %FE 2551!m! 4. +4!$% 31 & 4$.!".4( (Purposive Sampling) 4%2)(3)!"! 30266 3.% +S"#E !m!4. K!OEPc %4 "%" 4. 4+(*' ()&!S)+( "+3 !m!E%F) 1 "%"! 4. 1. &$p/1+(*'4( + 4&&J"() 2. %m/1+(*' 3. J!m1. +4+(*' 4. &!ED1".+(*' #INBN!C EGHB!

    1. +(*' %4( + 3 "&( ") 1 &!S)+ ") 2 J.++,F!( ") 3 &()!($%p'++

    2. %!&$p/+(*'4( + 4&&J"() 3. 44J!m 4. #!&!ED1)!".+(*' !!I"BIA JS4!1!S4"4 1. .)! JS 4m ()14" D3&()&!"' D3+(*'()&!S)+( "+3 !m!E%F) 1 D+$& 2. 4D+1%2$&& 1 & ".&()&!"' 1 &() 3. D+44J!m. 30 1 + D+44"+(*' & 1 .!. 3$4+(*')! +!4 3 .! 4+4D+E "..! ! ,-/+E( +"..! .! 2 3)! ! 6 3)! 4. !()4E( + ,-&$.! JS 444J!m+ D+#!&!&4+*)&!ED1)4+(*' ()&!S)+( "+3 !m!E%F) 1 )41E

    5. 4&+'1!S ()$% J+(*'"!"#$%&'1".% !#G"BIA #")D3D&+'1!S%4

    1. &.#"( x 4. &.y) (Arithmetic Mean) .)!"x (Standard Deviation) &+'1!S4D3%!*S%#" SPSS for Windows ()%!&$p/+(*'4( + 4&&J"() 4E4pw'%J ($T3! 4, 2543 : 100) 4 &.y) 4.51 -

    36

  • 5.00 +!#E!&!+!!D44! / ED!)$4 &.y) 3.51 - 4.50 +!#E!&!+!!D44 / ED! &.y) 2.51 - 3.50 +!#E!&!+!!D4% / ED% &.y) 1.51 - 2.50 +!#E!&!+!!D4 / ED &.y) 1.00 1.50 +!#E !&!+!!D4)$4 / ED)$4 2. &+'%m/1+(*' D3S" E1 / E2 &p4D3%! Excel 3. 4&!"".1J!m.+4+(*' 4D3#" (t test for dependent samples) &+'1!S4D3%!*S%#" ( SPSS for Windows) LE@ J&+'1!S$%44 1. &$p/1+(*' : 4( + !&$p/S.D44!$ 4&&J"() :!&$p/S.D44 #E4! (44 9 44! 5 ) %2%"!!!"x)" &(!&$p/!.").44 2. +(*'!%m/1 / %m/1Jm' (E1 / E2 ) . 85.20 / 85.16 %2%"!!!"x)+4&(!%m/!."). 80/80 3. J!m+S...!&T#")4 .01 %2%"!!!"x)+4 4. !&!ED".+(*')1E D4! #E!)$4 (4!)$4 1 4! 11 ) "BOG +(*'D& JS !14 1. +(*' %2&!D3%2&()!(D#.43&!SD+ %2"$&)!&!3TD+ n 4%2)%ED JS)+(*'"&E#E&!! &!!#1" &!.!!(1$&D+ n , ()4+(*'D+!%m/S$4 +!!)%D34 2. &!"/1&()&!"' ! $%p'%() n )D+E&&4" .!/D3!+(!. &"4" D&()&!"'D+ !.)D+4EJ. CD ()&!44*DE1 3. +(+. &$D+$&!()% DS%()*'() n WE)!#3.D+!#( +34"4 $#))!&!!D WE)!.%2"+D.4

    37

  • B Em. 2544. GOGIKwAB OG#ddNAK Pc"``w LMP 2544. $ : !'&'.&4$/pw'. ' &3!, / &3!, x 4.J, 4D +!1 p & $' (. 2549. BL LIGAB!PK `IMIPcEF 3. E&&4" +S"%TT E!+pw" 13&()E !+. .!" $!, /!' 3, $!" m. 2550. #!I EHNd}}~ PcGHEGPK! dHNBDm C. E&&4" +S"%TTE !+pw" 13 &()E !+. y . 2550. #AIO (Instructional Design). 3$ : /&3 &E &pE"' !+S. (4) $T3! 4. 2543. !C`KB (I#` 6). $ : $' TT&$p #, !Sp' ! 1' y!!. 2550. dH!M"`KEfK (Step ] by - Step) !#EEOG Id#IK . E&&4" +S"%TTE!+pw" 13&()E !+. %/p !"$ , '4 !m $3" 4 4. 2550. efd LIGAB#mKPK ` IMIPcEF 2. E&&4" +S"%TTE!+pw" 13 &()E !+. '4 3m4 . 2546. UE() *' () D+ (3+4V !I#H OGk !CHB#I!KPc &%x! : # !+%. !m!4.. 2550. #LmPc EGCEFPc 2549 . !$% : 4 %IS%E (&'!+3). 2545. GQQKPcOK .P.2545 OB" IKI (k 2) .P.2545. $ : +.

    38

  • !HPEGCHHIBO AE`w `IMIPcEF 3

    @AB!C /pw ' D"@AB!C !m!4. +4!$% EF!CC 2550 EG"!C

    #H ()4'%D& !"#$%&'() 1) 4'% ()44!S%( x+3 !m!E%F) 3 2) +%m/14'% ()44!S%( x)1E 3) %J!m.+44'% ()44!S%( x $.!".)D3D& %23 !m!E%F) 3!m!4. +4!$% 30 & 4$.!".4( (Purposive Sampling) 4%23 !m!E%F) 3 /&) 1 %FE 2550 )(3)!"! 30227 44! &()!()D34. 4'% ()44!S%( x)1E %!&$p/ 4'4( + 4&E 44J!m %!J/&%"44!/+)44D34'% #"

    )D3D&+'1!S4. &.y) ( X ) .)!"x (S.D.) &+'%m/14'%4D3S" E1 / E2 4&!"".1J!m.+4D34'%4#" (t test for dependent samples) J. 4'%!&$p/4( + S.D44! &$p/4&E S.D44! %m/14'% (E1/E2) !&.. 84.97 / 90.78 J!m1+S..44'% ()44!S%( x )1E .!&T#")4 .01 #!IEJI/#!I#Q"E_Q E %2S()&!T!1$&&&! 4#.4&!S ,- ! (m! &'&!+3 S%v( +$D+$&&S.".()"43" (!3, 2546 : 2) &!T+4". n 1$&/"' !J".%)%&!x1$% ! %4 E!&!%2 )"!%%$+S"E13" WE)#(%2&TD&$p/E

    39

  • 1% ()&D+%2&4 !%vTT !&!$1 !/! )1.1.!!(.&'D (Em, 2544 : 1) 3TT"E+.3" $m3 2542 +4D!" 6 .4E"%2%()&D+%2!$')!Sp' . "D "%vTT &!S &$pm! !m!m!D43" !#S..!JS()4.!&!$1 (%S%E, 2545 : 5) +4E 4+4D!" 22 . 4E"E4+.JS$&!&!!#S"4 #(.JS!&!&T)$4 4E".!D+JS!#"!m!3""*!"!/ !" 24 +4. 4D+#E+.))14 1 (1) 4( +!D+4&&!D &!#41JS 4&E#E&!"".+.$&& 1 (2) ,- &4 4 J3T#p' %$"'&!S!D3()%o%vT+ 1 (3) .!D+JS4S%p' ,-%" D+4 &4%2 %2 .4D,S.".() 1 (5) .!$D+JS!#4 /4! () &!4()D+JS4S!&!S ! !#D3%2.+E)1S JSJSS%!() +.%/". n (Em, 2544 : 3) Em E+4D+D3+S"E1 ( x $m3 2544 1E ()D+4E1 ( x 4&/&!%)%x &! &!T+ %2$m'D+!.D&$p/ED+!#"&!"1$&& &! JS!/D1.1.!!(.&'D&! ( Em, 2544 : 3) +S"E1 ( x $m3 2544 4+4S"!+S" %4&'&!S +(S &$pp +(&.! &$pm! m!1JS.%2 8 $.! +4D+#E !4+S"#E %4 S !%p'() n )#E".+.J()JS 4"4S 3)%2( x 3)")!"! (Em, 2544 : 5, 27-28) !m!4. WE)%2#ED4&p!E1 ( x 4!+!/D+$.!S3& +S"#E )%23( x 3)!"! "D+%2%"!!"xS $.!3& WE)%S.D+S"E1 ( x $m3 2544 4. 3 30227 44! %23+E) D+S"#E!m!4. WE)44!%23)!"! ()4ED+43 !m!E%F) 3 4!#(4"!&!D +(&!#41!" ".%FE 2547 %2"! ( +13 4%" 4D+4!(%" SJ.%2 %21 " S%vT+%vT+D#p' D4!)%" .D+T.D3mm"%& ".()D3.)J.! D4!

    40

  • %%vT+&( D41"!1JS JS"D3D"!4$$%p'()m"! "m"D+JS3!+& #JS!.1D 1 "%")#S" D.1JS%%vT+&( +!14D+T.D+JS3!m"1JS!.)#E .JS!.D3!m"1JS.)&D+1 "%"!. E%"!.#S""!41 " %2+"$D+J!m/&%"&.1") JS"D34$$%p'!D,-%" E!.!#"!$%p'4+ n & WE)D+&.D3.SD4"!4$$%p' Dp)JS14D)!4!"!" D+14( +D.)JSD % %vT+D4!3 30227 44! JSE!&4&"!E()%vT+D4!4. . 4'()%!#%vT+4.4 ()JS!#3!m"%"4+ n & 4'%2())!#%4D+JS3!4+ n & .)" !%m/!.4%.()34() !$44.)D+&$p&.". !#D+JS43! /4%! n "%&. &&"4".)3.4E4S4&!D44 3.D+JS4S". n 4. 4* 3.D+JS!#"4"!4.!%m/.! !!"x4 %+4D"! "43.D+$$4!$.+!4.!%m/ !#%%$4'4&& m)D+!. n D+.D43. 4'3.%vT+JS!.!)4 14&!S&!S)+!! JS!!% ! JS!&!!#"".4 ($3 1pw", 2528 #ED 3' m!$p', 2550 : 2) 4'%2())D+J4S)S! 4+"$J). S1&4+* 75 % 4 13% !J 6% ) 3% ( Dale, 1956 #ED px!"' 4m, 2547 : 2) 4'!#D3%4 $.!$&& (3 ($p, 2533 #ED 3' m!$p', 2550 : 2) &!+4&D%v$ +*.%v$())S.J. Video CD (VCD) +()"4%. W4 4&!!.! WE)!)&().!4 ()&$p!")4.!4+%4.J.W4!14* +D+4D !#*J.44&$p/!.()! !S &(). J.W4 !#%4.4D3&!"'4 !#1!S().4. D34!."% !#1!%.J.+("+*44!."% !1 "DJ"!.$. !&!"'$%p'**!#4 (" $, 2546 : 220) D+JS WE)%2JS3 30227 44! !&!D)4'%() 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 1E E VCD +D3%2()()%vT+)D4!4.

    41

  • O!#Hef 4'% ()44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 D& JS+41 "D"!11 ' "pm$ &() n, 2528; 3 &%, 2528 (#ED / 4x, 2538 : 32 34) %41 "4 1) +4$4%&'%o+!)34 2) !1!S 3) &4(1!S 4) 1' 5) "!E%' 6)% 7) &()!($%p')D3Dm" 8) E%' 9)"4". 10) E 11)"1.%D3 12) %D3 13)%! !KDLEG#"!C 4'%D& !"#$%&'() 1. ()E&$p/4( + &$p/4&1 4'%() 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 2. ()+%m/14'%() 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 )1E 3. ()%J!m1.+44'%() 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 !MH EG +D& %23 !m!E%F) 3 !m!4. +4!$% )E )ED/&) 1 %FE 2550 480 & LIK! $.!".D& 4.3 !m!E%F) 3 !m!4. +4!$% /&) 1 %FE 2550 30 & 4$.!".4( (Purposive Sampling) WE)%23 !m!E%F) 3 )3)!"! 3 30227 44! +S"#E !m!4. K!OEPc %4 "%" 4. 44'%()44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 )1E "%"!4. %m/14'%() 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 J!m1 .+44'% () 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 #INBN!C %4 1. 4'% () 44!S%( x %44'()( +)%2I 2 () m" 7 () 4 1) &!S)%)44!S%( x 2) 4$-$%p' 4!-D! D44! 3) 44!S%4) (S) 4) 44!S%!+)!4. 5) 44!S%!+)!4!.. 6) 44!S%! 7) 44!S% 8) 44!S%' 9) 44!S%"

    42

  • 2. %!&$p/4'% () 44!S%( x4( + 4&E 3. 4()4J!m 4D34'% ()44!S%( x%4 1) 44J!m .+44' 44J!m/+E( +".()D1 2) %!J/&%"44!%4D34'% ()44!S%( xD1 1 (3) #E (9) !!I"BIA 4'%()44!S%( x+3 !m!E%F) 3 D& JS4()!1!SD/&) 1 %FE 2550 D34 8 & & 2 3)! ! 16 3)! !#G"BIA &+'1!S()%J"!"#$%&'14'% ()44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 D& D3#"()&+'1!S4 1. &.#"( x 4. &.y).)!"x ()%!&$p/4'%()44!S%( x JSE4pw'%J"!&41 $T3! 4 (2543 : 100) 4 &.y) 4.51 5.00 +!#E !&$p/D44! &.y) 3.51 - 4.50 +!#E !&$p/D44 &.y) 2.51 - 3.50 +!#E !&$p/D4% &.y) 1.51 - 2.50 +!#E !&$p/D4D3 &.y) 1.00 1.50 +!#E !&$p/D4&%%$ 2 #")D3&+'&$p/144J!m %4 &.#")D3 &p43&!4&+.1!$4%&'S (IOC) ()"&!"3( + (Content Validity) #")D3&p&.&!141 (p) #")D3&p&.1 (r) #")D3&p&!3()!)14 y (KR-20) #")D3D&p&.&!3()!)1%!J%" 1 (rtt) 3 #")D3&+'%m/14'% ()44!S%( x D3m+%m/3%' (E1/E2) 4 #")D34()%J!m.+ 4D3#" (t-test for dependent samples) LE@!C J&+'1!S$%44 1. 4'% () 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 !&$p/4( +4!D44! &$p/4&E4!S.D44! 2. 4'% () 44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 )1E !%m/1 / %m/1Jm' (E1 / E2) . 84.97 / 90.78 %2%"!!!"x)+4

    43

  • 3. J!m1+4 4'% ()44!S%( x +3 !m!E%F) 3 )1E S...!&T#")4 .01 "BOG D4'% D& JS!1&( "BOGHB@!CENB 1. &S!#D34'% ()44!S%( xD& D+E4" Dp)14D)!4! +(D+E 4'D)$&()1! 2. !#4'%D& E4" ()&!S.4 "BOGHB!C#`KE 1. $& +(JS$&&)% !#m4'%D& %4'()() n 4".% 2. +(+.E &.!D+$&D+.4'% +(()() n ()D3%+.E 3. &!4'%D( +3() n 4()%2%+4%!pDJ" +(4W( 3 %2%"!&!"1JS4 4. &!E%J4S+.D3()4'% ()() n ()%m/D B !3 Em. (2546). GQQKPcOK .P. 2542OG OB"IKI (k 2) .P. 2544 OG GQQKPc## .P. 2545. $ : !'. Em. (2544). AKPc"``w LMP 2544. $ : !' &'.&4$/pw'. " $. (2546). IB!A#I!KGHIdE. $ : 4' W $&'. px!"' 4m . (2547). !HPLIGAB OG#dd EGHwNK !` 2. m' %TTE!+pw", 13&E, pw", !+ &. 13&E, pw", !+1.. $T3! 4. (2543). !C`KB (I#` 6). $ : $'. 3' m!$p'. (2550). !HPGEfK LIGAB OG#dd EGHwCP!HL !` 2 .

    44

  • m'%TTE!+pw", 13&E, pw", !+&. / 4x . (2538) . B!HPEGCIfPE `EGDIPcEF 5 `KBOGEG. m'%TTE!+w" , 13%#!E, pw" , !+S. %IS%E. (2545). GQQKPcOK .P. 2542 OB"IKI (k 2) .P. 2545. $ : +& 4.

    45

  • !"#$ %$ &'' (#)* +,-./0 1 ' (23$ 45,

    !"$ , 6!"$ ! 0$ 67 2552 8$ $%

    # & ! ' ()%*+ ,-./0 '%$%$0 ' 0,, (1) %0' (2) ,450,,6(% 0 (3) 6 6) (1) 0 (2) 8%$& !9)1 ! :'5 9*+ 2551 ;05%)-' 0%,(&'456%% (Pre-test) %%B6 '(% (1) 5%)' 0C000,,0 '6D) E606 F*) ; 4 5% 6%6 1 5%6%0,,% (2) 5%)' 0C00)E6H$60,, 0 '6I06 F*) 3 5% 0 (3) 5%& , 7 5% H$5% 14 -'0 + K, %,'45'85H()%&) 7 0 14 %,(&'45C%(Post-test) -*+,6 (1)%& 3 0,, H5-./5+ K,

    ' 0 '45'85H 06 ) ,;'M () 6, 0.05 ;,6%) 1 2 0 3 ;, (2) -' 0%,%8%& , '6D) I '6'%E) 3 0 ) 1 48*& 8 )'6,),I 0 '6 /'0'6 ()%,,-%,6%% 0 (3) %0,, ,450,,6(% H5-./4) $9/$6;

  • *+%8%45%0' 0 ,450,,6(% )6%-./0 '8%;,$& !*+9) 1 $ 6$ %"%-./

    1. $*+'(% ,$& !9)1 ! ;9*+ 2551 :') 1 ; 7 5% 5% 36-38 ' 262 '

    2. '()%(%)H$5H% & 1) 0,,%,'45'85H(&I$%$0 ' 2) 0-45 3 0,, E506 %0,,%0' 0,,

    ,450,,6(% 0 0,,%0'H$5 ,450,,6(% %06 0,, 14 0- & 42 0-

    3) '()%(%)H$5R,,85%4 3 $ %,5 (1) 0,,%,'45'85H(&%,5 +I 0 + 20 ' 0 (2) 0,, + K,8&% '!45%06; 0 - 50 ' 0 (3) 0,, '8%-45 H 5 5 E506 ',-$%, ,, '&;H%(&%VWX% 0 ' 30 ' 0 Z -45 E506 E6K, K,5% K, 0 K,E5 ,-B' 0 0 1 2 0 3 ;, -45'Q; 3 6 E5%,'()%(%)H$5H%

    3. '()%(%)H$5H' 85%4! '(%0'%%;R4 MiniTab +(-./

    1. %%0,, ; 0 %, '()%(%)H$5H% 2. %,(&I$%$0 ' 6%% (Pre-test) 0 ' -' 0 3. 0,6:H5%06 5%%%B66%; 6 6a 6-7 ' 4. %0-45)E5& 5% 14 a 2 ', ((%100 ) 5. -5'0 5+ 8% H8 ;%0

    &%06 '& 0 -'45(&%) ()%&%) 7 0 14 ;, 6. %,'45(&I$%$0 '8%'%'& (Post-test) 7. ' -' 08%06 5% !

    $ ' 0 %:-% & 1. -%, Pre-test ,6 (1) ; 4 5% )-' 0000,, '6'

    00 '6D)E606 (2) ; 3 5% ' 000E6H$60,, 0 '6I

    06 )$;'M () 0.05 ;, ;H5 (1) 5%)'6D)4 '6 /'0 (% Coefficient of Variance; %CV) ); E5%0,,) 1 (2) 5%)'6D)4 %CV 4 %0,,) 2 0 (3) 5%)'6D)); %CV 4 %0,,) 3 -E50H) 3.1 -%,00'!)8%' 0-./& 3 5 8%6%6H$5

    47

  • %,8% Anderson-Darling )$;'M () 6, 0.05 E6,6B0,, & *H$5%,I!;,'6I06 5E606%&

    2. 3 0,, ;,06 6% ) 3.1 -6%6;,%0,,6a

    % 6%6

    ) 1 ) 2 ) 3 0,,) 1 %0' 5% 1/1 5% 1/2 5% 1/1 0 1/2 0,,) 2 ,C0,,6(% 5% 1/7 5% 1/3 5% 1/3 1/4 0 1/7 0,,) 3 '0 0,,6(% 5% 1/5 5% 1/6 5% 1/5 0 1/6

    33( (1) ) 1 '(%6%6)-' 0 P-Test E606 ) , 6, 0.05

    (2) ) 2 '(%6%6)-' 0 P-Test 06 ) , 6, 0.05 ) 3.2 -%,I %0,,) 1 2 0 3 6%-./ ;,

    6%6) 1 2 0 3 ;,

    85%%,I H0: MdT1= Md T2= Md T3 0 H1: Md T1 Md T2 Md T3 :6%6

    :' 0 '

    + K,

    '45'85H

    & 3 5

    ) 1 *P-value 0.550 0.028 0.096 0.026

    - %, H0

    ) = 0.05

    K H0

    ) = 0.05

    %, H0

    ) = 0.05

    K H0

    ) = 0.05

    MdTi (E5%)

    MdT1=27.00 MdT2=27.00 MdT3=26.50

    MdT2=44.80 MdT3=43.90 MdT1=43.21

    MdT2=16.50 MdT1=15.50 MdT3=15.50

    MdT2=88.85 MdT1=86.40 MdT3=85.50

    ) 2 *P-value 0.028 0.096 0.076 0.016 - K H0

    ) = 0.05

    %, H0

    ) = 0.05

    %, H0

    ) = 0.05

    K H0

    ) = 0.05 MdTi

    (E5%) MdT2=28.00 MdT3=27.00 MdT1=25.75

    MdT3=44.35 MdT2=43.50 MdT1=42.65

    MdT2=16.00 MdT1=15.50 MdT3=15.50

    MdT2=87.00 MdT3=86.15 MdT1=83.95

    ) 3

    *P-value 0.305 0.077 0.041 0.027

    - %, H0

    ) = 0.05

    %, H0

    ) = 0.05

    K H0

    ) = 0.05

    K H0

    ) = 0.05

    MdTi (E5%)

    MdT2=27.00 MdT1=26.75 MdT3=26.50

    MdT2=44.10 MdT3=44.00 MdT1=43.05

    MdT2=16.00 MdT1=15.50 MdT3=15.50

    MdT2=86.60 MdT3=86.00 MdT1=85.30

    48

  • (1)* H$5'6 P-value ,'6F&; (Adjusted for ties) (2) Md !*'6I8%' 0 ;, :6a (3) T1, T2, 0 T3 '(%%0,,) 1 2 0 3 ;,

    1

    27.0

    43.2

    86.4

    27.0

    44.8

    26.5

    43.9

    85.5

    15.516.5

    88.9

    15.5

    0 20 40 60 80 100

    !"

    # 3

    $%&

    '

    ()

    3 2 1

    2

    25.8

    42.7

    84.0

    28.0

    43.5

    27.0

    44.4

    86.2

    15.5

    87.0

    16.015.5

    0 20 40 60 80 100

    !"

    # 3

    $%&

    '

    ()

    3 2 1

    4) 3.1 -./& 3 5 ) 1 4) 3.2 -./& 3 5 ) 2

    3

    26.8

    43.1

    85.3

    27.0

    44.1

    26.5

    44.0

    86.0

    15.516.0

    86.6

    15.5

    0 20 40 60 80 100

    !"

    # 3

    $%&

    '

    ()

    3 2 1

    )* Pre-Test ( Post-Test

    14

    12

    14

    16 16 16

    13

    15

    13 1313 13

    15 1515 15

    10.0

    11.0

    12.0

    13.0

    14.0

    15.0

    16.0

    17.0

    1/1 1/2 1/3 1/4 1/5 1/6 1/7 *

    )

    Pre-Test Post-Test

    4) 3.3 -./& 3 5 ) 3 4) 3.4 ,,'6I6%0 % ;05%

    +* Pre-Test ( Post-Test

    14.3

    14.9

    12.812.9

    11.8

    12.713.5

    12.912.4

    13.7

    14.7

    14.1

    14.714.815.214.7

    10.0

    11.0

    12.0

    13.0

    14.0

    15.0

    16.0

    1/1 1/2 1/3 1/4 1/5 1/6 1/7 *

    +

    Pre-Test Post-Test

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    (

    Pre-testPost-test

    Pre-test 11.00 13.00 12.84 15.00 3.22 25.10Post-test 13.00 15.00 14.67 17.00 2.97 20.23

    Q1

    Q3 SD %CV

    4) 3.5 ,,'6D)6%0 % 4) 3.6 ,,'6!6a 6%0 ;05% % 8%& ,

    49

  • H$5%,8% Kruskal-Wallis ) 3.2 & (1) 6) 1 ,6 %& 3 0,,H5-./5' 0 5'45'85H E606 8 )5+ C 0 -& 3 5 06 ;, (2) 6) 2 ,6%& 3 0,,H5-./5+ 0 '45'85H E606 8 )5' 0 -& 3 5 06 ;, 0 (3) & , ,6 %& 3 0,,H5-./5' 0 5+ E606

    8 )5'45'85H 0 -& 3 5 06 )$;'M () 0.05 ;, 3. -%,'6I8%-./& 3 5 %& 3 0,, 66

    % ) 1 0 ) 2 H$5%,8% Friedman ,6 E6'06 ) , 6, 0.05 4. 4) 3.1 3.2 0 3.3 0,,%06 0,,,'6I8%-./

    06 5 ) 1 2 0 3 ;, ,6 %0,,) 2 H5'6I06 5 0 -& 3 54) 5 ) 2 0,,) 3 H5'6I5+ 4 && %0,, ,450,,6(%& BH$56%6*) $6H5E545;0,,6(% 450,6P)8%(%'45+ 6a '4'%$6H5,%46%,85

    5. 4) 3.4 0 3.5 ,,'6D)0 '6I' 08%-' 0%,6%0 % ;05% ;, ,65%'6D)0 '6I48*& 0 4) 3.6 ,,'6!6a & , ,6 '6'%E) 3 (Q3) '6D) '6I 0 '%E) 1 (Q1) %'648*& 8 ) '66,),I (SD) 5% 8% /'0 (%CV) '6 -./

    *+ -E5& 1. %& 3 0,, E506 H5-./5+ K, ' 0 '45

    '85H 06 );'M () 0.05 ()%D 6%) 1 2 0 & , ;, 2. % ,450,,6(% H5-./4 &5

    '!$ + 0 ' 3. -' 0%,%8%& ,'6D) I '6'%E) 3 0 ) 1 48*&

    8 ) '66,),I 0 '6 /'0'6 ()%,,-%,6%% " ;' *+06$. 2542. &;;(-./3#( &.-. 2542. !.2550.3!( &'' &.-. 2550. ((-

    -458%,8%, ' (1) ' ' )%' H5,& (2) ! )H5,&!) 0 )%;' 6a 0 (3) %D $ % $$ % . $ $ 0 % . Q '5' )H5'%' H5';*+&B%6)

    50

  • 51

    Problem-Based Learning Approach in the Instructional Package on Linear Equation System and Applications for 2nd year students at Valaya Alongkorn Rajabhat University Under Royal Patronage

    Abstract

    The purposes of this research were to 1) create the instructional package on Linear Equation System and Applications, 2) determine the effectiveness of the problem-based learning approach in this instructional package on Linear Equation System and Applications, and 3) study students achievement and compare self- directed learning readiness before and after the use of this package. The samples of this study were 20 second-year students in the 2008 academic year, in the faculty of Science and Technology, at Valaya Alongkorn Rajabhat University. The research instruments consisted of a problem-based learning instructional package, 4 learning unit test, an achievement test, and a performance test on learning process and self-directed learning readiness. The collected data was from unit tests 30%, an achievement test 30%, and a performance test on learning process 40 %, and these total scores were then analyzed by Binominal test. The collected data from the self-directed learning readiness test was compared by T-test. The research results showed that more than half of the sampling group scored more than 60% of the criterion test at the statistically significance of .05. However, the packages efficiency was at 78.12/65.78, and the results from students pre-test and post test were not different at the statistically significance of .05. /

  • #jcc%j#CTOCCC"^%d%^!dXXh!d#$Y^dhb!dXgXc]^"^%dZd!dh#$j_k#l%CTOCm4I5"^"!dXi Z^[\c!"g"[\cXi "#!dY[n^Z"dZd!d!d^XXd"!Z"Xi ^YdX^d[\cYdgY[ZjdZj"!dYZ"^opX^X X^l [[#jXXiCTT4mC4FCG5^`X!!dXi "g[ad[[]#q!dXbd^!d"[a!d[a!d!d`Z^d"^"^[d#$X^bop[rXdXd"X d!^de"!d][r# !d#b]dXgX!d]bXdY^dgY[!d[\cb

    dX X!dZZjd"[a%]!d#b]#$!dZd"c`i X[\cclgs%CTOVmG5!d^^XdXX^

    qt!d%]]Y^dXZ[\""XbqtdX lu,6-/+*2/0D0-?5v%]jb]!d"^%`b]!dZjdX!d#b`s]!^bX!d]Y^dZd[aX!d[aliCTOTmOCJ5!d^Zjd[\c[as!d[a!["^!d%]]^"XX^` !dZjd[\c[as]gXcXb[a]!dd"!dbbd^hi [\c]]dZj["g[add"!dg[a#b]d[\c#b][^d`ej`]4`jb][\c`]C`dXX^][aXg]G`XdXd`]O`!d^dg`]T`X X!d#b][\c`]S`d!d`]V`[lw(70-7(B4xxVmCSFGG5!d^Zjd[\c[asX^^!!i!d!dop"^d!!d^db]l&,6CIIGd"j "BCTOxmCxFGI5!d^Zjd[\c[asjZd!d[Y^d^%`[][^_Zb]d!Z[\""dXhZZjd#!dY^d^%`!dXd!ZYdY^d^%`b]gZjdZd[\cZd^XbjZd^^Z"X Z[\c]^%`lR,*@16@y(7(//0B4xxVmT4FSS5^Xds%j]^i gXcZ"^%Xb"^Zd%^jdXYZd[aX!dl%CTOJm4I5^d^!d""%XZ"]"g!d^Zjd[\c[as!d[dj^][k#b`jd[ ^Zjd%jkrYi v%]""[\c"%jkrYi ]^Zjd[\c[as!djd[ X`dSI %`Y["gdTI!d`^i!d^dg!dbY

    52

  • &WS&R" 4[jXb%]j#jXijd4v%]b`b]jd[ [z%#CTT4"gG! CY^d"4![a%!X# ! CXi X GXb]b]ZjdZ" G4j^]Zjd[\c[as!d [^dO[^dhi [\cd!db`op^]4b]v ]Cg^]Gfjd]O[ jd GCXb]b[!d[^d ^["g[a^j^Td^^q{Jd[^g"!d^Zjd[\c[as["g[i!d^dg GGX!bX![^dX!bZjdj^Xg[\cXgZ["g OdXik#Xb]bO4%qtX^"]]d]Zjd[\c[asZ!d#b]g^"^[X X^Xdb`OCgXb]b]dZd!dj]jc"X]Xdlu,6-/+*2/D170@0/>5X]b`l2,6/(6/D170@0/>5k]Zjd^jX^Xdl|}u5OGgXb]b][[d^Zjdl&+>,*/5%]j#jXijd4OO[[Xb]bX`Zjd[{~XX#b]XXjb]]^Y^dXISOIJSXX!ZjICIIJIXg""gICIT_d!!d"ZjdZ"CJXX4IIXX^"dGIXq{dGIX^dOI"X[^g"!d^Zjd[\c[as!d"Y^dX X^^Yvlw(70-7(5%g^[a"Zjd[\c[asZJ`^``]4`"^

    `]C`jb][\c[\c`]G`X^^Xg[\c`]O`XdXd`]T`!d^dg`]S`X d!#b][\c`]V`d!d`]J

    `[

    Sh]ZjdZX d!Y^dXdXf]Xil x 5]sl=w5^lR06,?017&(-/5/F/(-/

    53

  • Q&R" 'X^Xf]dXf]]sl=w5X^

    ^q{["!d^Zjd[\c[as

    ('TU U Y

    UZ

    UZ

    [& \H]^]_

    ^q{["

    JI TSGI VIGJ 4OITGC 4JSI TJ4C Jx4xS VOJT VVxV CGT

    "]4^Xf]X^OX`TSGIXf]q{4JTGXf]["!d^Zjd[\c[asVOJTb][]Xf][adX_Xq{]gdSI 'K^!d]X`dSI%`Y[X_[adTI!d

    `^

    RS&[

    "&[

    RS&Q'*U "` [ab

    U["[&TQ'*U "` [ab

    T$`*

    ?5P72D3

    CI 4O IVI IIO4

    "]C^"g!d]Y^dX`dSI%`Y[X_"gd

    TI!d`^]^gXcITl)FD17*(IIT5^X[i!d^dgYX

    /T4Cl)FD17*(IT5"^Zjd[\c[as!dZj^b]jd[ !d"Y^ddX^_"^"]]dgk[^` 4j^]^"Zjd[\c[as!db]jd[ [k#VJ4CWSTxJv%][aX# # ^f]l;4W;C5]gi ]X^VIWVI^]Xv%][a# f]#STxJ``"[a#

    44[Zjd[\c[as!d"ZdXgXcZ[Xdd!dZ[r"Zjd[\c[ase]X"^%`"^g"Xd^`"%[^d]!dgd![!dY^d#b]

    54

  • #$Y[]"[f## #^``!d^Zjd[\c[as"^[X Xb!dZd!d"X^ZdX!d][aXb]bZ]"X!d

    h#$k#!d]"!dY^d^d[k#

    4CZjd[\c[as!dXd[aZgjXi %YXXdX"i`!d"XdX]"X^[\cg#^`Zdd#b]^^XX^_X]^"!d^Xbd"Zg 4G!d"ZjdX"^^q{^[a# ^f]l;C5v%]Xd]gb]"d]Zjd[adTFJdv%]X!d`Ov%]Xd]"gXY^d^%X"^X#db]"!d"Y^d^]"%_Zjd[\c[asYY^d[k#gb]]d^Zjd[\csYY^dX#d%glg#YkBCTOGm4C45 4OZ"XddY##]"#$k#eZdh%i ]g^v%]Zjd[\c[as[aXdXdv`gdv`gY"g^"%"[a!d]!ddX!db]gZd!d[a^jli B CTOTm J5Z^dY[gZd#$X^Yj^"

    C"ZX``Y^d" "%jkrYi ]^Zjd[\c[as!dZj^b]jd[ ]!d"d%`X`dSI%`Y[X_"gdTI!d`^ C4 ]Y^d"^""j^]!d"d%`[^db]jd[ [ab`]Z" %_dhgjXi ]Y[ZjdZhi j`]djb]e]%d!d`Z^g""]"hi [\c] ]dhj]Zd^Xdj["g[\c"[a"!Z"Zd!dbbd]"X^X X Xgv%]"gY[!!d^!d[a!d!d"`Y^dX X!dd^Xd""k!^lCTOOm4445]#![]d!d[a!ddX X!d`bd[\c"j#$Xik#Xi #$X^jXdZ"gX!dY[Zjd!d"Y^dZjd[a%]"Xd]ZX]Y^d"[""[aXXZgZdjX^jZgjb"#b]#b]Zd^!dv%]!dbgZd!d!dY^d%`"[r# !db]^lR,*6@w16@y(7(//04xVVmC45 CCZ[!d"[!dk#"ZdXi ^Xh l+*E02 -2,+(5 #b]opZd!d[a!dgZ!d!d"[g

    #b][[dY[a!d^jv%][!dk#"^

    55

  • !d`Z^dX!dXh]!d^gY[!d[[gZdX!dY

    d#!dY^dlX CTOVmJS5 CG !dZchY^dg^gY^d^"!d]Zjd[\c[asdop!dZd!d^dgjZd #$[\cc

    h[[ ZjdX!d!hi ZgZd[g_"Zgl# cc 1M*?@1CTOmSSFSx5

    G ^X[i!d^dg!dZjd"^Zjd[\c[asYX]^gXcIIT"XY^d!d"op!d^dgZd!dY#b]""gh%TeOX]ZjdZ"Xd"g^CJX`!d^b!dXX!d!dX[i !d]"%Xopj`gZ!dXXj"fXd!dXdXdj^!d[b][[adlR(7716@R(774xJGmCOFFGId"# cc 1M*?@1CTOOmSJFSx5"

    #q!d%^^!!d^e]dZd!dX!dgop]"XdXdd!#b]gdX^^bs( ^sgXch]IT!dX`dSI"gdTI!d`^^!d^Zjd[\c[as!dZj^b]

    jd[ ]!d"d%`XhgZjd!dZ^`Y^dgi!d^dg!dXopZd%`T&R"

    4!d^Zjd[\c[as]Zjd!Z[\""`X^%XX"Zjd[\c[asX[^d]`"%"

    CXdhi [\c] [adgZjd[\c[asjXi e"[[[\c_Yd[aXhi [\c#b][a!d]"gY[[ #Y[

    G[Zjd[\c[as^^[e][ai][a"^^Zjd[\c[asjXhX^X [ad

    56

  • %CTOS,"" #$%[ KcdK*T, \Z"'K_,]#]Kcdc ,e'&'&T,"" #$%(U"U",]#]Kcdch"k!^CTOO,"fU+ # !'QQU&][cc# lXi 5iX$#XhiCTOT# !gU!U&,&''W(,## X`] Cg## "i #XT4C# cc 1M?*@1+BR1-16/0CTOOh#^ ~nX"g ^#X4O4X CTOV''i%eRS&` ""` "W#$%

    j'd[cc# lXi 5iX $ #Xh

    [[#jXXiCTT4QS&R "*'[U+ # !&'*T Xi TGlTxxFSI45CGFCJX jCTOx'#g'[,"f'",!%!jY i 4l45mGOFOOg#YkU[U&U!&R+!]## CTOGBCGGw1D0@R,*@16@+1'1?(|y(7(//04xxVkA3lA7223;=30J./01234567839:37/;

  • !"! #

    $%&! '"'($%&!

    )' ! "##$

    #% $&' !(# "#$)'&$($( !(# "#$#% *)')" $""$!+,&-$.$($!/0"!#',1"2&&-344. (# "#$*5)"2#+)"67$

    88$$ 88$$ '($ $ ) 9*:54 8#$(/$));?@A>BCDEF=GBCH.I5JK$!+!2#+)")((($"JLI4M$!+

    !"+"N$; K"($(1;OLPLK)#("QRQ>SQT'(" ! "##

    $#% 8#6'0"!#(; U:LIVK'&W#+

    '("#+$"N$0"!#(8##+$$"N$0##+; UVLJMK

    #+0+; U:LI5K)#+$"N$+$#; U:LX.K'$#)"#+'("T&$($( :#+'("

    .L $$'"$#%" 8#6')#+2")""$*Y$#(JLJ4

    3L $""$#%" 8#6')#+)""$*Y$#(JLJ4

    :L $$0"!" $"$#%" 8#6')#+2")""$*Y$#(JLJ4

    58

  • !*+,!(-*.- &W$"+#$$(!+TZ[#!#"$

    ((($($6&&T#)+&\Y"]!$&*2#+"$&^6'!;$H34:J_54K$,#& !&\(%!+0+&()"T0+$"+ '!+$!+0+2#+!"]"

    '+(Z[Z$'((&\Y!"]!;$^H34:4_VJJK$)"2#+&\$*!+T0+$$T`^a$* '("&\#"2#+)"0T0+#$0)$ T0+$)T0+&%"0T0+&W&($*Y)$((!$*!+T0+$#'b(#)*2&&!+2#+! 8#N'T0++$!$#$^'$;34VM_XK2#+""!*"6! 2#+)" 0+ +! cc !+!&d()+&\Y2&'&W',1!*"]!+2#++!" T0++$0+,#+ !+88$#"]$$^^!$''!+$#*2&"$&^6')(& #$/$2#+"

    &W $*!+T0+$#$0+2#+"$&^6' !T0+$(T*%!$2#+#$'$!#% ,0"( T0+#+8#N'!#(#2"" !#&W$(&W',1 )"0$T0+^($!+(&e$*#2+2#+,*&W"$+'&^6' '##0#!+T0+$$!)$T`^a$$#$&W$&W',1 **0+$2#+2&&(!+(]2"" !#%#*0+2&&!+!$&*2#+

    ^ &W$"#+)T)&W$*Y$*!+T0+$0+#"&W((($(T0+!$ !( "##$'!+&W)!'b $)'&W&8!$!( "##$!+$&^6'"T!+T0+$$T`^a$#$ ,"2&

    (!

    .L !( "##$#% 0"!#(!#

    3L !( "##$#% *)')" $)"2"

    59

  • !*!.L ' !(# "#

    $#% 3L'&$($( !(# "#

    $#% *)')" $

    )!)/ ,$,)#fghBQQijFkBCH.II4$""

    ;SlAhhSK0+;lCFmh>DG>K );BQQ=AnoQ>K$*&W"&d("$&^6']N',]!0"(!

    *'"&!&!,$,2#+)",&-$. $($!/0"!

    #',1"2&&-344. (# "#$*5)"2#+)"67$

    88$$88$$'($$)9*.3HXJ5

    1!'"&!,&-$.$($!/0"!#',1"2&&-344. (# "#$*5)"2#+)"67$88$$88$$'($$)9*:54*#""/$));?@A>BCDEF=GBCH.I5JK

    !2*'"!2*&3&2.L'3L:L" $!2* 3&2 .L #+0+;DG>K3L #+ ;OlAhhSK :L #+

    ;pQQ=AnoQ>SK)2!!

    ,$,T0+2#+)$$ +8#N')# fghBQQi jFkBCH .II4 $"" 0+ )$*&W"&d("$&^6']N',]/T0+*(0#*&W(!2#+#$,

    60

  • !2*'"

    4!

    .L !( "##$#% 0"!#(

    3L !( "##$#% *)')" $)"$1!

    T0+()((("!Y"&WY*3XV #&W+54L5J "2"3J &-*::3#&W+XXL4J)")*344#&W+MXLJJ

    ! "##$

    #% 8#6'0"!#(; U:LIVK '&W#+'("#+$

    "N$0"!#(8##+$$"N$0##+; UVLJMK#+0+

    ; U:LI5K)#+$"N$+$#; U:LX.K'$#)"#+'("&'"5 &!%&'(" !(#

    "#$#% 8#6') +0"!#( 8#

    ,(+)T$"N$0#; UVLJ3K& 2#+*#2+

    "+#; UVLJ.K)$0+!,"+ 0+! ,];

    UVLJ.K +$$"N$*#$0+! $$'^(; U:LX.K&'"6 &''(" !(#

    "#$#% 8#6') +0"!#(8#

    )#"$$$"N$0#; UVL..K&q#8!+/&\Y,

    !)+$; U VL.JK) +$$"N$*#$!+)"T0+$,$)"

    &&W(; U:LM4K$*88$!+ $)T0+$; U

    :LM4K#$ T0+$88$$0")+; U:LM4K

    !2*&.L '3L :L " $

    !2*

    .L#+0+;DG>K3L#+;OlAhhSK:L#+;pQQ=AnoQ>SK

    61

  • &'"7 1'(" !(#

    "#$#% 8#6') +0"!#(8#$#

    ,!%# #)+$"N$0#; U VL33K$!; U

    VL.XK) +$N$*#'0##) +!"; U:LXVK T&$($( :#+'("

    .L $$'"$#%" 8#6')#+2")""$*Y$#(JLJ4

    3L $""$#%" 8#6')#+)""$*Y$#(JLJ4

    :L $$0"!" $"$#%" 8#6')#+2")""$*Y$#(JLJ4&2 T !(# "#$#% T0+$ +)#"2&$, 58&2( )($1!3*& .L.*,:#+&W)!&(&)'b#(

    $!!+((($$+T0+$&W*Y .L3T'b#+!+ ,'!+&d(+$2#+"$6',$#$0+) .L: T*!+T0+(#% $$" )!+$)!'b"2& 68&2( )!/3*3L. ,$,2#+)&$($( !(# "#$)&')" $!,"2&)&! ( $+ , 3L3 *(,"2& T0+!]"$)"N'"2 3L:$#% T0+()'b!#(]"2&

    62

  • # ) H ;34:MKL! !*)*'09:% *21";"0 - !!H(r #TL$^H;34:4KL!0")0H'',$3H'cL^' $L ;34VMKL 9:'';;1"") 9
  • !" #$%&'() *+),%-)./

    %'$ 0 # (%'$ !-1'$ # (2' "##"-)/ '$ $%&'(%&)$*

    +,-

    3 $* +,-./0(*+0$*'**%12%&.34*)(,5$+**+6*/() $*7%89::9;:?=@AB CDA=

  • -45(6-76, +,-0* b) +,-((0(.)(c*' Wd %12.)(0(*%(0e'(*5 W( V%12%(V1V22 2$ 'a$'Q0(X'(2**!$+7%%%Q/,Q)V+,-%+,-!1X'( W*1210%&*0()(*'f,2/Q +XX'(122V b) +,- W b) +,-5 W(%&QVV'*(V**+,-( bV(2/0('2'%12 W$/V*120( b) +,- V*5a0(X'(c*)d WV**+,-25*`12 W.)(2**0('.)(!a g`'($('Q*).)(0$5 W(*'*(10e%1250(X'('%&a+7%*!/.)($*'h%0*+f,2 W,22 W*121i*'/.)(X'(%'/*+ W$*' W2i0(*' W/Q WVVXV 12*+*5*`'/((.)(5 W(*)(*/(02V**'V'$-V1Q(*+!)(*V!($+*2'V*+'Qc*)d,((2'21Q0(.)(X'()(/'a/(0**'V'*+,f,Q$.)((X'(%&a+7%/$V** / j8"#"#6"kP%V*!05*+X 0(0 5)0'V2550(a/'-0*5)2*1*5X'((XV*(/'-0*'00(%,2%'-$'1*120*512e$25*`*1/'*1'0*'X() $VV*'2f,2 W//,Q0%120*5X'(/,Q,50(X!*'00X'('a$!)('*(V! g`2.`/'X%V$ b7'(51*!,22*)(,58lmno]p^]l^]P *)(,5 W*/(0'``2V5*V$5X 0(*/(02V5*`/5*./*5V2X'(*5*)(,52'*1)(255Q%01) $VVe'X5 W(,'2*0Q 8

  • aX'(*)(,5*5*`*+/ W$(!(')./-*Q*)(,5..340*+ W'V2S a$.)(a*12+,-*)(,5%/Q*)(,

    5 +0(*5*`$0 +XaX'(20(*5*`/,QQ.)(+,-(2V1V20(.)(X'('%&*)(,5Q 0%&*)(,5V+( WV+Vf,2

  • $*'** W$*'255*`3-%& g``/Jsqv][2!,'a V V0(/(V*( g``2)8q^^snsuq[stlP $ V*(1$*'2)0(/(V V8qzztnntrq[stlP%120(/(0 V2 V*'/*'f,2 W$*'5*`/3-**% WQ0(a'a W.)((

    *)($*/(0'(X'('*) W*'!21Q(*)(/'a $*'**!1*5*`% W W2'aV0(*%'%$/'a W220('a')(2eX'($+*'(V0(VX'('3-/Jsqv][X'(0( W*1215V%& g``$%&*5V'aQqnssqlrG]Ips]^8YkxYPX'(0('a')(5/)( VVV%12$50(*%22'0*QX 50('a!'00*5a/X'(12Q' *5*`/*)(,5$+*2.)(/.)(0*+'/((Q*)(,5/.)($+*%&X'(1(/,Q)V'/*) W5*`2a*1*V+2X**'X g`0(*')'X'($'**'aVV**12eX'(*'$'0'($2.)(X'(+,-$*'**2!2 W g`$ b%

    *0('*/'$( g``*/'$( g`` W$)00('X%12/'*/'$(QX'/,QVy/ V$*( g``2)' .25*` ,2Qa*1)+,-/Q%1Qy%+"#UUX'(5'(0(.)(X'(%&*)(,58lmno]p^]l^]Pf,2 W g`5V.)(0`%

    X)('X,!%&*)(,5QX'(,50(.)(02+,-5*+0(0'$*'**Q!%&*)(,5$+*/.)(*V*)X V(*)($*/(001Q*+125$/X'(1X0.-)'$ Y_ %12 VV.34*+/2'0(*+0$*'**V2'0( ' "_ %12 VV*)(,5/2'0(*+0$*'**V2'0( ' S_ %12 VV+**+/2'0(*+0$*'**V2'0( ' U_ %12 VV*)(,5V/2'0(*+0$*'** #_ %12 VV+**+V/2'0(*+0$*'**

    67

  • T_ %12+,-.34*)(,5$+**+/2'0(*+0$*'*0*7%!#('$ Y_+,-/()V1Q(

    +,-/()'*+'VQ !+,- R2S)+,-/Q%1Qy%+"#UU$+,-$*'3-22/(V3-**22/(V*)(,52V+,-$*+$22/(V+*2*+ "_($.

    ($."$VV*1($.$VV0(*+0$*'**$($. Q,5$.Q$VVX .)(*&S%12V*$*'*(' *1Q12$ . S_(*+

    *+5SZf,2*+$('*(V)(012

    5$/XYZZLZZZ$12*).)(0( W120(.)(')(1(*)(Qe$25*`$%&*)(,5$+**+/

    .)('(0/Qe*+Y0(**'V'%Y12Q U_(*121aVV/() U_Y($V$VVV.34*+125$/XYZZLZZZ0'VQ !+,- R2SX'($VVV.34*+f,2**/(/$VVVZ_SUZ_T#*55$/(/$VVVZ_USZ_Tk$**2/$VVVZ_kZ U_"($V$VVV*)(,5X'($VVV*)(,5f,2**/(Z_UUZ_T*55$/(Z_SZZ_TZ$**2/$VVVZ_kY

    U_S ($VV'+*2*+2V'VQ !+,- R2S #_'5' #_Y *1Q !+,- R2S ! #_" *1Q _SY$ _S"'VhX'(( _SY W'$( _S" W*V* #_S .)(5*$*+7* *Q2"/Q'VQ _"'5'V*2*$X (%12V*)'$*V* #_U .)(5$VVV*)(,5$VVV.34$$VV'+*2*+X 'VV Q" '8|p]\[]^[P $(5*$2X'(**h2/*$8P $'V*$/*h2'0(*8[\[]^[P $**V2Vy8=_GP

    68

  • #_# .)('5' WYZ ' 'S2#_T .)(5$VVV*)(,5$VVV.34$$VV'+*

    2*+X 'VV Q"'8|t^[\[]^[P T_*/() 5*$2X'($VV'*)(,5.34$+*2*+Q'$'Q'$*V***h2/

    *$8P$**V2Vy=_G_$ VV*$/*$''V*!$VV[[]^[$VVr]|]lr]l[$$VVslr]|]lr]l[5.34*)(,5$+**+/0*7%'')%32X V, V,7%Q0$'$ Y_ 2'0(*+0$*'**.34*+)2'0( 2'V*5*`!_ZY "_ 2'0(*+0$*'***)(,5)2'0( 2'V*5*`!_ZY S_ 2'0(*+0$*'**+**+)2'0( 2'V*5*`!_ZY U_ 2'0(*+0$*'***)(,5)2'V*5*`!_ZY #_ 2'0(*+0$*'**+**+)2'V*5*`!_ZY T_ 2'0(*+0$*'**.34*)(,5$+**+ 2$ X 0VaX'(') Y_*+,-!,5*+$*'**X 0(V'VQ12e..34*)(,5$+**+1X "_*+,-!,./5*+$*'**X 0(V0Q !+,- R2S!%&**'V'01212eX'(1X122' W(

    S_*+,-!,5*+$*'**X 0(V0'VQ !+,- R2S10'VQ12e!%&*'0*+*'*'1'*'*X'(1X

    69

  • $74_"#UY_ ($ !" #$$-(3

    #$3%0 *)'%'89 !"#$:!$&;-1 #

  • ),V'#$% #*)3)33#$)3:!$&;-1 #>V#$!, $$,

    %'$ V`Q0 # (%'$ *

    3 $* 0*QQ W*%12*'')(2V*'VV*+/0'VQ+,- R2T $%12+,-.')(2V*'

    VV*+/0'VQ+,- R2T *'2*/,Q 0*QQ*1'VQ+,- R2T20*+%25U(QQ"ZZ*0() $VV$%&'0( Wy%12%&'$*'/p]m[]p 8"ZZYP */()'*h2$V2Vy$* *8Jpt[tztu Dlqu s^^ P $V* 8Dlqu[sz r]^zps|[stlP V*$ //()2X'(7-.%V Y_ *'')(2V*'VV*+/0'VQ+,- R2T * $*! '')(%12%&V*'VV*+/QQx/Q*1YP/Q(0(' g`0(!8/'$( g``P"P/Q5*/(0 g`$$/()1'VV g`8$/()PSP/Q%&**'8%2%)PUP/Q12$ V *'8`**'P#P/Q$.5.*'/8**'0`PTP/Q5.*'8 j'0PP/Q7 .*'8(*+P$xP/Q V*'8(VVP "_ VV/*).)(05(2*).)(2''')(%12%&V*'

    VV*+*).)((VVS *1YPVV W.)(5*'8:qzsus[q[stl t@lrs}srmqu r]}]ut|n]l[P "PVV W.)('8Cqlqv]p t [w] u]qplslv ]l}sptln]l[P $SP VV W.)( 8C]rsq[tp t Emnql H]uq[stlP Q%VVV.)(05(20y.)(2'($'VV25*`# *1YPVV)($VVhVh8Dz[s}]K]qplslvP"PVV/08=]u\rs^ zs|usl]P SP VV)( W8

  • 0'(*'* WVVX!*'$1V&2'$*VV'+,-X2.%V',225 W($(X/ V f,20(' g`0%&+,-'V'+,-0* ,2*1)$V0'V+,-/Q%1Qy,2X%(20('V'+,-%&*0(*V/(V*012)$!'(('(12*5*$$.$0-$0(%0* WVV8VL"#UZPVX'(0*X/(2 WQ g`'+,-0'2. ,2*1 'X01'2($5X'(0(*'' +8"#UZ(!,0L"#SkP%V.2 ,2*150(+,-/'-0*'.0(/'*!0'$( g`50(V5('VV**'/Q0 bVX'(X' W g`2.VX !, 7% bV0*f,2. 7!+,-'V+,-/Q%1Qy5SZLZYZ$/5V

    y$ .+,-8"##ZP 2%V'(2.)(,20. 2XX'(y25'*1*!0*' WVV/'(*0'0(

    '/)+,-/Q%1Qy%+"#UU'02%&V*' WVVX'(X/Q0%&X'(X,5 W2+,-%12*V*'VV/,QQQ'2%125.0(.)(!5X 0(0'V'+,-X'(X 0.-)'$ Y_ %12*'')(2V*'VV/0'VQ+,- R2T* "_%12+,-.')(2V*'VV/0'VQ+,- R2T*'2*/,Q!#('$ S@.*-W,$0*QQ*1'VQ+,- R2T$.+\*+ 2 0*+ %2 *'+,-5U(QQ"ZZ* X@ #'$ *1210aVV/()X'($$VV $$VV7-2VV*'

    VV/$VV7- 7X W*(

  • Y@233% aVV/().)(X'('5'Q YP%&'')(2V*'VV/0'VQ+,- R2T'0($(5X 0( V $* W'')( "P+,-V*'VV/%&'')(2(V*'VV'5.7-!' *8Jpt[tztuP$*'+%1Qy(*)(0-/*)(Jptz]rmpqu{ltu]rv]2 WV'52 W5'V/Q/51 bV0',2QV0$( g`0)(8C]pps]lot]pLYkkP Z@),% */()2VV*'VV/'**h28C]qlPV2Vy8=[qlrqprG]}sq[stlP *8Jpt[tzquDlqu^s^P$V*8Dlqu[szr]^zps|[stlPV*$ //()2X'(7-2VV*'VV/

    2*/,Q'$ $*! /Q/'')(%12%&V*'VV/.)(QQx/Q'Q : #S(0(' g`0(!8/'$( g``P : #X5*/(0 g`$$/()1'VV g`8$/()P : #

  • 5*/(0V g`0(7 V.)(2*.V g`Qe2*/(0V g`$(.)((+,-*(*(/() W/() -1/()%12 Wy0'50/QX : #

  • : #>/Q5.*'8 j'0P/QQ Wi5 8Jp]^]l[q[stlP /( .*'/.)(5$0(512**'0(0Q'X'('*/(0!)(05**''.)(5(%10(122VVV/1225$! : #[/Q7 .*'8(*+P/QQ W j'0(.)(*)($$ 2+8=wqp]Is^stlP')(*'$+/$0*'X*V'0(*(**'/08Dzztnntrq[stlP VV.*'/$/V1211$/QQ*).)($.)(7 %12/( / 'a g`.*'/$$ j'0(.)(X'($'**'aV*).)(*).)( W.)(5*'$Q$0(7 $ 'a2*%1 g`%2 : #\/Q V*'8(VVP W/Q2*).)( V*'$*7%*''%)(/.)(%12%*'/.)($*V*' WX '25'X(1XQ0(/()(V$.)(%12 V *'f,2.1*V*$V*'.V*'/.)( W) YP/($'(' Y_YP20(0('')(2V0(*)(2V*'VV/*)*5V12*'V*50(/(0 Y_"P*)*')$VVi'25$*((0(V0$0X Y_SP1/'*).)((0(*2/'X'(5%2%122X'(X'(5X X'(X'(12 "P5V5.X 0( "_YP0*'')(%12%&V*'VV/.)(.)(**+,-/'a*0$*5%)'2/ V*'-0'2$'0()(!,V*'/ "_"P5'')(%12%&V*'VV/.)(5X 0(*0(.)(2`1.)(2 V0')e'h%.)(2`2V .*'%122X'(5. V 5X 0( SP/($05*QX S_YP*+,-2V$ 12e2(0(aV*'/Q)1- g``*'`*'(*'(*/()*7% S_"P*+,-2V%&'')(2V0(*)(2V*'VV/0'VQ12e

    75

  • $*%&+-y$*$L5_;]'),* ^33 #SU@@XZZU_XZZY@%6 L"#Uk__8"#SkP_:-3)3303.&;#&;+'.`, $$_%6 5%%_V_8"#UZP_$.%&+,-'V'+,-hVV2x8%_+_"#UZ\"#UUP_0 V'$)_YZ8SP6Y\Yx_5Vy$ .+,-_8"##ZP_.-),-)/$ 0&;)3&;::]a3@@XZYY_XZY\b_%65V y$ .+,-_C]pps]lot]pL_B_8YkkP_ORBGNGNPcMFdQEecMPNGCGfEghGQQI+ijMLRkcMFdMNENCI+ lNICRLHCGMNBQ mEIGPNAMKEQIjMROEHDNGHBQORBGNGNP_A]]p^]69rmzq[stlqu_

    76

  • &;!),*))3:]%) !" #$#$:-)0&;-1 #SV#$!'.`, $$89$-)0nEQBCGMNIDGdiFMNPnEBKGNEIIgHMREoOEICgHMREAEBILRGNPpNMqQEKPErBIEQGNEBNKiHBKEFGHiHDGEfEFENCMjsRBCDMFIBhIBMNEgCLKENCIBCcDLQBQMNPhMRNtNGfERIGCumEFMNICRBCGMNJQEFENCBRugHDMMQ@

    %'$ _+(L_7*$_+'0 # (%'$ ! 3 ( *QQ! *%12Y_+,-*%*$*%(*$V'%1Qy*)(V.347*($7* "_%12 VV*$$%.34'0(*$*%($*$V'%1Qy*)(07%$5$ WSX'($' 7V* 7V**7$*'+,-*/Q !+,- R2Y !*1Q !+,- R2Y R+,-"##Z5"UZ**12120(0*1$VVV,/()2.)(0(*'/()/$ V/Q.)(5/()*'*(*!2V2Vy*!'V* 4%$*!'!%*)'0( $=J==

    . X'('Q

    Y_ *$*%( *$V'%1Qy*)(7-X$*+$.34*%0V'2*$V*%($*$V'%1Qy*)().34)

    "_ *$V'%1Qy*)(*+!%.34X'((++ $%'5X'( W'VY'V"*1*$V'%1Qy*)(7-X!%.34X'((%+,-++ $%'VS*1*$*%(!%.34X'(0*+%+,-++ 'b+ $%

    S_ 7V**7*$V*%(*$V'%1Qy*)($.34) 712e*1 7*'+,-*$*'VV*5'V

    77

  • ivICRBHC

  • !+,- R2Y'V%12'%1Qy*)(f,2X'($'*)()(7-X$)(*+ W5*)(/$*%125X 'Q$0( W/() V5V*)0(V%1Qy/$'0(VX 12%*(/Q !+,- R2Y R+,-"##Z%V$V WS 7f,2QS 7QX'(.V'*%(V'%1Qy*)($VV''Q0*QQ*.)(,+,-*%*$*%(*$V'%1Qy*)($*$.34Q07%$$* 7/QS'(

    0.-)'$

    Y_%12+,-*%*$*%(*$V'%1Qy*)($*$.34

    "_%12 VV*$/.34/Q !+,- R2Y'0(*$*%($*$V'%1Qy*)(07%$5$ WSX'($' 7VV* 7V**7$*'+,-* S_%12%.34/Q !+,- R2Y'0(*$*%($*$V'%1Qy*)(07%$5$ WSX'($' 7VV* 7V**7$*'+,-*!#('$ -) #'$

    *1Q !+,- R2Y R+,-"##Z5"UZ*'$V W 7'VV*k#* 7V**7xx*$ 7*'+,-*#*

    0 #),%

    *(8J]pz]l[qv]P*h28C]qlP*!28:p]m]lzPV2Vy8=[qlrqprG]}sq[stlP*!'V8[ []^[P* 4%*!'!%*)$**$ $VV'8>l]MqDA>IDP'0( $=J==

    '$

    #SQ !+,- R2YQ'"Sk*0` W' 7VV* W 7V**7$ W 7'+,-*5'V'7%$(Q !+,- R2Y*$*%(h2"S_YT*$*$25'VT*$$*$)'VS*$

    79

  • *$*)(%1Qy7-XQ%V'7%$(Q !+,- R2Y*$*)(%1Qy7-Xh2Sk_YU*$*$25'V#*$$*$)'V#Z*$*$*)(%1Qy*+%V'7%$(Q !+,- R2Y*$*)(%1Qy*+h2S_US*$*$25'VT*$$*$)'V#Z*$

    #X 7/*%V*$*%(*$V'%1Qy*)(Q7-X$*+'h2$347-X$*+

    *$*%(*%V$ *1 *$V'%1Qy*)( .34

    )3:]%#!3 .-

    .34$'h2Q7*($7* *%V*$*%(*$V'%1Qy*)(

    #

  • X'('f,2 W.0`*%(0)(%2/,Q*%(/$(25*`*1*).)(X'('2(.)( W5*`)(*.)('

    V/.)('0(.)()(*'**'**'(**'$( g`$'05122 0(0'5$ V $.)()' ..)(2$12'5. X 0(0%&.)($X'('5)!+,-%120(V.)($*1):ml:slr:tzm^ W)2(0(.)(X'(+7%$*0/

    "_ *$*%(*%V*$V'%1Qy*)(.34 7/$'0(a2*%(50(.34'%2X'(V*%('(-*1-7-X*+$*'50( V0)(*$V'%1Qy*)(7-X$*+*%V$ '2X !($*%1Qy*)(2'50(!)(5*/(0V0eX'('2X%1Qy'h%*)(-7-X!1 W%1Qy5V)(Q-~g%)'')/$7- W-25 W12'Q2%1Qy*)(7-X)0'0(/(0VeX'('2/,Q120e5 W(0(-7-X012*)$)5V*+ W2!,.f,2*+X'($( g` W0/*+f,2-$( g`0()(*'.VV/Q0*')(*''02!)($ W$( g`2''V0$( g`*+'V !+,-Q W2V' W12/'0('a V12e0('a5%120('a'*)(*/(0%120('+*+i' 75$')/2e22V 5%120( W.)(.'**'(*$0('a%(2 W2**0*/()/2X(%$'f,2aX'(*+V0'a$*Ve'/((X'( W' Q'*%(02*%V' g``22/(V*!2X W2 W*'$( g`$'*!%1Qy2'aQ*QQ*!7-*!%1Qy

    *+*!'(V)('0( .$*!'(.$!(%V/0V/(Q !+,- R2Y(V2*%(012aa2*%(+*2'/'a)(1i'0('a)(1520'Q.'2X*%(5VV'%1Qy*)(7-X$*+'%12'V*)(%1Qy/$V**%120(*)V%1Qy*$

    / WV**$5'Q' W*0$('Q, W(V*'1''V*%(V/

    5+,-$f,2V*%(Q50(2*%(0)($/.)(0/(!(V*%(VV'%1Qy*)(!,$( '

    81

  • $!(*5,!,/'aQXV5$VV'V20(X 15/(*5!1QX .34*%V*$V*%($*$V'%1Qy*)(7-X$*+2 V*5a0/,Q)V ge.)(*)7)V''*!'**%(*)(%1Qy!2 W(122(520'(*%(25'V(*%(2)(f,2*%( W$)00('*11(02)(5*/(0Ve12*%(50(.)( V12%1Qy*)(2/(0$!)(2Q W/QVX'(X )*20012eX

    S_ *$V'%1Qy*)(*+ W$ 'VY2!5.34(++ $% .$'0(a*+ W* V25*`5V%&'( g`` %*+!,)(*'.VV/Q0*')(*''02!)($ W$( g`2''V0$( g`25*`*1-V*'f,2!15 W)(0)(12e50(!5.34eX'((++ $%12"Q* W+$*+2(.++ $% W2('(+ *)(,$*$V'%1Qy*)(7-X W$ 'V"2!5.34X'((%+,-87*(P%+,-++ $%87* P *%(-7-X/Q%&7- WX $/Q-~g%)'X'(V%&$/'a2XX'(V*%(7-12/(, g`$/'Q2*%(

    7-X,.0(%1Qy*)(7-X'/,Q W2V(+-7-X W12!*)(f,2$'h%'(*0'*)(

    7-X)0'!5.3412eX'('Q0(7-0V)($((0(7-0V'$ .$VV'V27-X$550(V*5!X!)(X/(0*5!1/'+,-*(*(%21112e2*$V'%1Qy*)(7-XX!%.340%+,-$%a-Q(-i bVV5 .') bV./ W5*`*$V*%( W$ 'VS2!5.34X'(0*+%+,-++ $%87*(P'b+ $%87* P.$'0(a*$*%(!5.34X'((*$V'%1Qy*)($5X WX 0+'QQ(

    (%')) $VV/$VV'V*%((*%(0'(0'f,2*%(Q

    '(*0$ g``0($VVV'QU'(X'0V

    'a!(! V%2 W7- bV'2/,Q$0($VV'V'*%(2'* W$VVV2*!'X'(*V*$' 5X 0($12X'(/(

    82

  • Q !+,- R2Y W21Q)'Q*)(%1Qy, W$ 5*`*%(%'.%V*$*%(!%.342 W1Q'(- W1Q2V(-X'('2 W1Q'(*)(QQ%*%(%(V&72/(Q !+,- R2Y !(#/VT'1!,T/VT'15'/(/ !*1# RT'1!,T RT'1Q'X*5,!,'VQ/'VVQ R2"1S50(. V)(/2.VS0`*%($%1Qy*)(2'2%V"'Q0`**(*V-/0'(-,50(*$*%(!%.34%+,-++ 'b+ $%X 0+'$*$*%(!%.34*+X'(122*%(.V*'1*%($((-'(12$*'$( g`2Q( W-V*'*+

    Q 7/a!%.34$.34X'('h% 7V**7.34' 7'*$ 7'QQ% 7V**7*$*%($*$%1Qy*)(7-X*+*/()'a2*%($%1Qy*)('.0( V*5a0X'('/,Q

    83

  • #$?*V$ ;w#=#)=' ##*0 )'*#$:!$&;-1 #

  • "_*$**+'(*)('(*)(,$'(5f'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+*$h2)/,Q'($*h2/*$**+$$5*`!2'V_ZY'*$h2'V)$*/'%/f%12 V*)(%1Qy'0(3-/X%$X***+/'%0'V

    -45(6-76, %& +0(`((Q+5*` ,2*1%&5*0(*7%+,-12+,- W g%1Qy25*`0%&*7%*0(*!a+7%Q'( g``*)(**'$*)($( g` W.)(0)($)V.)(12X'('0*$*)($*+*+ W+2i-0*' WVV$ W%1Qy0 0(V$/12'VV5*`0*0( W.)(*V)Q g``0*$$( gV!V+$*8_PX'( V )1Q$*+%1250(*7%+,-*+/)0'V'$07%* WQ%V'*+/ +XQ$'!,

    gVX V*5a2* 'a20 'a,2X'($2/(V%0f,2Q1V122*!02$2*+ W25'V/Q)((+-$*12 W5'V/Q0-VX'*11Q0`%(+*)(2( W%1Qy V2 W/Q%1250('*)(0%2/,Q01Q/Q)X W5'V f,2'*(V3-b)(*8C]qlslvmu I]poqu K]qplslvP/Dm^mo]u 8YkTSP2c)('/,QX'('!(*)(0!12/(V*)('2),50()(0*dQ'*(V%V``+,-$%_+_"#U"$hVV$(X/%28hVV2"P%_+_"#U#'U$'+,-"""S$"Uf,2% X'('+,-(,'.)(**!)($%&X'($!1.)(*5*`2'V'+,-(0(.)(%&$a+7%*)('1Q$0('*(V*0$*!'/.)('*5,!,*$V**i-V*''.`!$ *)(0(%12 $$(X/ g`$V)*/$'V+,-Q( )g**2'$*-%, *85*+,-$L"#U#P'Q,20V/VV2*).)(XX'(a*1V$%1Qy%1210(*%(20/QX 'X g`0'e'(1Q12512 W122*5*`2 W%1Qy/121200Q2)/,Q 'f'0*+Q*('%12%&*/(03-%&*/(0*+/X%$X*8Jsps]qlrs]p]l[w]tp

    85

  • tpvpt[wtnq[w]nq[szqumlr]p^[qlrslvP!1 W$,22!,V2$'!,'*/(001Q*+ W'V2 V'(x'VX'($*)('8Jpsns[s}]ltslvP(7%8@nqv]Cq{slvP'7%008@nqv]Eq}slvPV 8Jpt|]p[At[szslvP 'VV8:tpnqusslvP8>o^]p}slvP(*(8=[pmz[mpslvP$(8@l}]l[s^slvP8%(*L "#UT 6 "YP(0(*/(001Q$(X2%&0(*!*+/,QQ**+ W* V,22VV5*`02)(2*X'*+ W2.34*+258%%%L"#Sk6""kP2/((.)(,0+,-./f V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+2*!*+$**+/Q+,- R2S0.-)'$

    Y_%12+,-$ VV*!*+$f%12 V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+/

    "_%12+,-$ VV**+$f%12 V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+/

    3 '$

    3-%&*/(0*+/X%$X*8Jsps]qlrs]p]l[w]tptpvpt[wtnq[w]nq[szqumlr]p^[qlrslvP

    ') $VV%&*/(0*+3-%&*/(0*+

    /X%$X* V'(x'V%& W) $VV2 V'(U/Q'Q%-33\)3 %-33 #-4Y:

    Y_*)('8Jpsns[s}]ltslvP Y_/QV*)(%1Qy"_(7%8@nqv]Cq{slvPS_'7%008@nqv]Eq}slvP

    "_/Q)( bV

    U_V8Jpt|]p[At[szslvP#_'VV8:tpnqusslvP

    T_8>o^]p}slvP

    S_/Q%*12

    _ (*(8=[pmz[mpslvPx_(8@l}]l[s^slvP

    U_/Q(*)('(

    86

  • ''$') $VV%&*/(0*+2%& WU/Q V'(

    S@ : 3 %:] W/Q*%(0($'0(V*)(%1Qy'1211Q2%V22)(1$ 2 V22/(V1Q*+2*%V'(Q*5!121!

    X@ :#$%'-3'0(X'()(1Q0'X'(V V1 bV *(*('Q*5!7 $ 2*)($**'2X'()(V%12$*)'0(5*)(1 V'0(V*)(0%12/*)(*/(00((/,Q

    l]vptm||p][]^[\|t^[[]^[r]^svl

    87

  • 3'$ Y_$ 2+,-

    $ (*1f%12 V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+

    $ V'(YP *!*+ $"P**+

    "_1Q20( W1Q2 W*)(%1Qy25 W*+0Q2U12

    5!#('$

    Q W'f,20($VV$.'$VV>l] vptm| |p][]^[ \ |t^[[]^[ r]^svl'$VV$.''Q

    >Y >">Y !,*!*+$**+*f

    %12 V*)(%1Qy125>"!,*!*+$**+,f

    %12 V*)(%1Qy125!,f%12 V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$

    X*%12%&*/(0*+ 20(0

    20(0*QQ*1Q+,- R2S2.*+)025 $* *Q2U8Q+,- R2UP00 R+,-"##Y5#"*

    *12120(0 *12120(0*QQ$V W" 7'Q YP *12120(0*1$.')(*V20(0f%12 V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+ "P*12120(0'. V'($VV'*!*+125$$VV'**+ '$aVV/() *QQ.)('5'$aVV/()'('.)(/Q'5'Q Y_' V.)()(*+%12/122V+,-Q2S8Q+,- R2SP'.*+)025 W 20(0

    88

  • "_ 'V.)( */2 W 20(0''Q$! */$ 2*'X'(V%12/*105 S_''V8Jp][]^[PV 20(0'0($VVV'*!*+125f,2.)((/,QYhVV'0(VQQkZ U_'0( 5$VV'**+ #_'5'($.')(*V5YT*V*V#Z0(*V*1Q*+2 W*)(%1Qy25 W*+1250Q2Uf,20$*V'5f%12 V*)(%1Qy125'0(3-/X%$X*%12%&*/(0*+

    T_12.)('51Q*V$.')(*V5YT*V25'$(''V8Jt^[[]^[PV 20(0'0($VVV'*!*+1252 W$VVV*)/V$VVV20('Vf,2.)((/,QYhVV'0(VQQkZ

    _'0( 5$VV'**+*Q */()

    *QQ.)(X'('5*/()'0( $5a) =J== tp Mslrt^ }]p^stlYY_#''X Q

    Y_**!%1Qy/*$*!*+125$*$**+X'($*h28n