06 февраля 2017 года решением Диссертационного совета Д 212.239.02 при Федеральном

государственном бюджетном образовательном учреждении высшего образования «Саратовская

государственная юридическая академия» Суменкову Сергею Юрьевичу присуждена ученая

степень доктора юридических наук по результатам защиты диссертации на тему: «Исключения в

праве: общетеоретический анализ» по специальности 12.00.01 – теория и история права и

государства; история учений о праве и государстве.

На защите диссертации Суменкова С.Ю. присутствовали следующие члены Совета:

Ф.И.О. Ученая степень Шифр специальности

Сенякин И.Н. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Хижняк В.С. Д.ю.н. 12.00.02 (юридические науки)

Нырков В.В. К.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Аникин С.Б. Д.ю.н. 12.00.14 (юридические науки)

Бакаева О.Ю. Д.ю.н. 12.00.14 (юридические науки)

Белоусов С.А. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Воротников А.А. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Ворошилова С.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Заметина Т.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.02 (юридические науки)

Колесников Е.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.02 (юридические науки)

Комкова Г.Н. Д.ю.н. 12.00.02 (юридические науки)

Конин Н.М. Д.ю.н. 12.00.14 (юридические науки)

Ковалева Н.Н. Д.ю.н. 12.00.14 (юридические науки)

Липчанская М.А. Д.ю.н. 12.00.02 (юридические науки)

Матузов Н.И. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Мордовец А.С. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Петров Д. Е. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Попов В.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.14 (юридические науки)

Радченко В.И. Д.ю.н. 12.00.02 (юридические науки)

Соколов А.Ю. Д.ю.н. 12.00.14 (юридические науки)

Цыбулевская О.И. Д.ю.н. 12.00.01 (юридические науки)

Председатель Диссертационного совета Д 212.239.02 И.Н. Сенякин

3AI{J'IIOqEHI4E ALICCEPTAIIIIOHHHa 6a3e (DeAeparr,Horo rocyAapcrBeHHoro

yqperl(aeHnfl Bbrcluero

<lCapaToBcKaq rocyAapcTBeHHas K)

Mrnucrepcraa o6pa3oBaHr.lfl u nayrcu Pocclrft

Ha concKaEIle yq€Hoii cTen

arrecrallrj oHE oe AeJro J'{9

pelugHrre AriccepTa{rloHHof o

O rpr,rcyxgeruru CyueHr<ony Ceprero K)pletuuTopa ppr;ra[qecKrix HayK.

,{uccepraqua <tr4crcrroqeHrls B rrpaBe:

cleq[aJrbHocra 12.00.01 Teopxr x [cropr{r flpaBa lr

rocyAapcrBe trprlHrra K :aqlrre 17 oxrr6px 2016

coBeroM I 212.239.02 sa 6a:e @e.qepa:r

o6pa:orarelruoro yqpexAeH[r Bbrcrneto

ropvAr-.Hec(2r aKa'qeMr,ut) MtraucrepcBa(410056, r. Caparoo, y,r. BonbcKa.s, A.

Munucrepcrea o6pa3oBaHr-rt r-r aayxu P@ ,Nl!

ceHHbrMr.r [pt.rKa3oM Mr.ruo6puayxrz P<D or 16 4exa6pl

Coacrarelr Cylrenroa Ceprefi lopreelrv 1977

or,'rnqlreM Caparoncryro rocy.qapcrBeHuyro araAeM[ro

cKar rocyAapcrBeHHar roprrA[qecKar aKa4evul>) no c

AIrCC9pTaqXlO Ha COrCKaH],le y.reHoi cTeIIeHl,I

(llpltB[ne lI-I ti xMMyHIiTeTbt xar o6qenparoar,te raTeopln x ucTopru npaBa u rocyaapcTBa; [cTopr{r [paB

trou cooere [212.239.02, co:gannou Ha 6a,:e Capar

a 2002 roay. Hayvuuu pyxooogt.rreneM A[ccepraq[rr

- Aoroop rcpnA[qecKr.rx HayK, npo@eccop, npo$eccop

Caparoocxoii rocyaapcrBeHHoii aKa,4eM[n lpaaa. B c

oxonuu,r o6yveute B ac[xpanrype ovaoi $oplruaKaaeMr-r! flpaBa.

B 2015 roAy CyneHroo Cepreii lOpr,eenv npo

AoKTopaHTypy @e,lepa,rluoro focy.qapcrBeHfi oro 610

errcuero o6pasoaanua <Caparorcrar rocyaap

Teopxu rocyAapcrBa x rrpaBa ([pr.rra3 o :aqnc,renun Nq - 3/525 or 09.12.2015 roaa.1.

ro coBETA A 212.239.02

rogxernoro o6pasoBarerr,Horo

pa3oBaHrrs

riallqecKat aKaaeMriq>)

ii @e4epaqun rro Ancc€praq[{

aoKropa HayK

nera or 06 Qeopa^r.r 2017 r. Ns 3

, rya(AaHLIHy P@, yveuofi crenenrz 4or-

o6rqereoperz.recxrlir ala-at3r, [ocyaapcTBa; ncropr4r yrreH[t o npaBe u

., nporoKojr J\! 26 glrccepraqnouuurnl

ro rocyAapcrBeHHoro 6toAxetnoro

o6pa:r <<Caparoacrax focyaapcrBeHHarr

o6pa:oa HayKh PoccaicKoii Oelepa(urr

l, http //www.ssla.ru), co3aaHHbrM np[Ka3oM

714/sx 2 uoa6pt 2012 r. c rr3MeHeH[{Mlrj BHe-

016 r. Nel576/H(.

aa poxAenlrr, e 2000 ro4y oronqr.rJr c

flpaBa (HhrHe - (DrEOY BO <Caparoe-

a,rruocrr rIOpucnpyAeHqltrr.

aaTa ropr.lariqecKax HayK Ha TeMy

rM)) no cneq[alrlHocrz 12.00,01 -Hx yqeHr.lt 3arq[Tun B A[cceprarluoH-

croii rocy4apcrueunoii aKaAeMr[ [paBa

Maarro Arercan,ao Baclur,ean.r

ra$eapu reopwt focygapcrBa lr rrpaBa

c aaqnroii n[ccepra\uLl B 2002 ro[yeuur Caparoocxofi rocyAapcrBeHHofi

KoH(ypcHbrii or6op I 6rlr :avac,ren e

Horo oopa3oBare,lbHofo yqpexAeHr-rt

FoplutlqecKar aKa.qeM[r) lo raQegpe

2

Cyuenxoa Ceprefi IOplenuu pa6oraer e ao,rxriocru ,to{eura xa$egpn reopxt,t rocy.qap-

eMI,MayK.

ro o6pa:oranlrr PoccliicKoii @eAepaqua, rroMotrlHr{K

TnIo Hayr]Hoii AerreirbHocrrr OeAepanhHoro rocyAap oro Ka3eHHoro obpasoaareDnoro

yqpexaeHm Bbrauero o6pa3oBaHr.u ((Huxeropoac araaeNrllq MuH[crepcrBa BuyrpeHHr-rx

,{e,'I PocclzicKof OeAepaqnD);

,{aolr4oaa Mapaua JleoHr.rgonna - 4oxrop aqecKllx Hay(] IlpoQeccop, 3aBeAyroquii

KaQeApoii KoHcTr.rTyrI[oHHoro x MyHrruunarrbHoro IIp <Deaepa,r suor o rocynapcrBeHHoro aB-

ToHoMHoro o6pa3oBarenbnoro yqpexAeHrrl Blrcrxero

cTBeHH6llr yHUBepcATeT);

o6pa3oBaHufl "Bo,rrorpaacxufi roclaap-

Mr4HH[Kec I4,1br AHrcxMoBurt - AoKTop rop x HayK, AoueHT! npo$eccop raSe,{-p6r reopr{rl r.r r.rcropnri rocyAapcrBa u npaea I,lp 14Hc r nD la (Qurxara) Oeaepa.lusoro

rocyaapcrBeHnoro 6loAxeruoto o6pasoeare,ruroro y eHlrt Bbrcuefo o6pa3oBaHrir (Bce-

poccuiicKxt rocyAapc TBeHHH I yHlrBepcx I er rocr]luM PIIA Mmrocra Poccrzu)>

auurr rroJroxr4TeJlbHHe oBhrBbr o altccepTarlurl.

Beayrqaq opraHq:lauar - @e4epa.nluoe rocyAapcrBeHHoe 6ro4xernoe o6pasonare,rsnoeyqpex4eHnc oncurero o6pa:oeanua <<Ilepvcxaii rocyAapcrBeHubrii Har{r,rouarbHbrf [ccJreAoBa-

Terlcruzfi yH Bepcr.tr€r> (IOprl4lvecr<r.ri Saryalrer) { ceoev no,roxurelr,HoM or3hrBe, rronrlr:r-

caHHoM AoKTopoM ropnA[qecKr.rM aayx, npoQeccopofr,r, 3acJryxeHHbrM ]opr4croM poccxiicKof

@eaepaqlru, 3aBeAyrcul[M Ka0eApofi reopl,tI,r Il racropi[ rocyAapcrBa n npaea Banepueu flaa-,rroBrfteM feyToBLIM! yTBepXIeHHOM AOI(TOpOM -MareMarriqecKtrx Hay& [poQeccopoM,pe&TopoM @e4epanluoro rocyaapcrBeunoro 6rc oro o6pa3oBareJrbHoro yqpexAeHrueucuero o6pa:oaan[r (nepMcKriii rocygapcreeuuui [aqrioHa,lbHr,rii riccreAoBarejrbcK].rii yHrr_

crBa u rrpaBa u nonurororur @e4eparr,noro rocyaapcTBeHnofo 6loar(erHoro o6pa3oBareJlbnoro

yrrpex,qeHll-f, Bhrcrrrero o6pa:oranru <<lleu3eHcK[fi ,qapcTBeHHbrt yHriBepc[TeT).

Aucceprarlrr B6r[orHeHa Ha KalbeApe reopru Aapc r Ba x npaBa (DeAepa,l6Horo r ocy-

AAPCTBCHHOIO OIOAXETHOIO OOPA3OBATEJIbHOIO Bbrcuero o6pa3oBanlra <Caparoa-

c(arr rccyaapcTBeHHarr rcpriarlqecKar a(a.4eMrrr).

Hay.ruufi KoHcyJrbraHT - Ma,rbKo A,'IeKcaH.4p Eac[JrbeBuq, aoKTop ropnarr.{ecKlix HayK,

npooeccop, 3acryxeHHbifi Aerrerr, HayK[ Poc OeAepaq[u, [pooeccop Ka$eApbr reo-

p[lr rocyaapcrBa u npaea @egepa,rruoro rocy.qa oro 6roANernoro o6pa3oBarerr,Hofo

yqpexAeHli{ Bbrcuero o6pa3oBaHr,rr (CapaToBcKat ,[apcTBeHHa,{ rcpu]tfqecKar aKa.levfi s)\:

4nperrop Caparorcroro Qnruana OeAepa"'r6Hofo roc

nayru I4ncrnryra rocyAapcrBa u lpaBa Pocc{ilcroii a

aapcTBeHHofo oroaxeTHofo yqpexaeHlrt

Ot[r,tqua,rrune onnoHeHTbr:

EapaHoB BraA[M[p Mrxainoaav - .qoxrop qecKux HayK. rpoQeccop. racnyxeH-

Hbri Aerrerb HayKu Poccuiicrofi @egepaqlr!, n pa6orHriK BbrctIIero rpoQecclrouaJIbuo-

aqiljrbHrrKa no [HHoBarIlroHHoMy pa3Br.I-

nepcureu I4ropev lOpreruven Marcapuxr.rnurnl, yr<a:ajra, qro BbrBoILt Axccepraura, ux o6ocao_aanae n rercre paoorH Aaror ocHoBaHIe cuuraG, uro pa6ora C.IO. CyMsHKoBa rrpeAcraB.Jrrer

Trt recKoro npmoxeHlzt HaIIpaBiIeHa[. ,{ucceprauua C

o6uereoperurecxtfi aHlLrt43' coor Ber c rB) er Hay'tHo,

co6oii :arepu:ennoe uccJleAoBaHLIe, Koropoe co.qepx reopefl'lecK e nofloxeHht. B coBoKyII-

HOCTrd rBJrffOlllllecr KpyIH6IM EayrrHbIM .qOCTlrXeHUeM . flasuar :aoryra aBTopa, Ha Hatrl

B3nrra, cocTorrr B Tornr, vro ero pa6ora oxBaTbIBaeT e aJrr reoperuKo-npaBoBol-.I HayM oo-

JracT[ rrccJreaoBaHrirr r.r cyqecTBeHHo pa3BIiBaeT rop K) ro tor MaTLIXy B BaxHo\{ .qnt npaK-

. Cyuenrooa (l4cK'rro.reH[r B npaBe:

Topur rrpaBa ti rocyaapcrBa; ncroput yqeHlit o

creunzl'rr,Hocrr. 12.00.01 - reopru u I-Ic-

tl rocy.{apcrBe. flo,ry,reuHue C.IO. Cy-

MeHKOBbTM HayqHEle pe3yJIbTaTEI t{ BbIBOAH, CA ect B ArioaepTaqrM! B IIeJ'IoM cneAyeT

OIICHIITb KAK HOBOE 3HAHTJC! IOIYIIEHHOE ABTOPOM! e EayqHoe aocrrr(eHle! BHoc{rlee

BKJTaA B pa3BIrTI'Ie HayKri TeOpUrr ra ncTopl4ll flpaBa rI tapcr Ba. Ar4cceprauur C.lO. Cyvex-

KoBa (d,lcxrrorreurzf, B npaBe: o6rlereoperl,Iqecr[i aH )) aorxHa 6rrrr, npu:nana cooraet-

creyror{ef rpe6oaaxualr, c$opr'ryrr.rpoeaHHblla a6i]. I

yqeHbrx creneHeti, yTBepr{c{eHHofo rIQQTaHoBJreHueM

or 24 ceura6pa 2013 roaa Ns 842. C.IO. Cyveuroa

9 u n. l0 flo,roxenuJr o npxcyxAeHrilr

paBr[eJrbarBa Poocr,Ifi a(oii Oeaepaquu

aciryx[BagT rrp[cy)KAeH[r eMy y.reHor4

cTe[eEu aoroopa I{)paa[rrecKlrx HayK rro crrellnaJ[,H

rocy.qapcTBa; ricTopru yqeHr.rr.r o lpaBe u focy/xapcTBe.

Corcrare,rr rveer 6o,ree 80 ony6,ruxoaarnsrr TeMe arrcceprarlx[ pa6or, r,I3 HI-IX 32 B

pelleH3ripyeMblx HayqHllx ISAaHI'I'IX, peKoMeHAoB BAK M[Ho6pHayKu Pocculr ruur

ony6rr,rooanrza ocHoBHEIX HayqHEIX pByrlTaroB B,{lrccepraqua orcyrcrByror

He,qoc r oBepHUe cBe4ernr o n1 6rrxaulfl x col{cKa reJrr.

UeHHocr6 HayqH6rx pa6or co[cKarerr 3aKrrorr B TOM. qTO BOIIDOCbI. CB'3AHHHC C

rIoHtTaeM r.I cyltlHocrbro r-jcrolnqeHua, Ilx B3aLIM c npaBr{JraMr-i, @opualrr onpaxeuar,

t4 HcrpyMeHTanbHoii [pupoAofi oKa3anr.rcb B pray ee a(ryaJrbHbrx! HyxAaroq{xcr B

nepBooqepelHor c[eqnajrbHor lI KoMnreKcHof Ha ypoBHe o6uteil reopr.m npaaa.

IOprl,4urecraa Hayra ocrpo Hyl(aaercr B npeacraB,rr oii o6ulereoperr.r.recxoi MoAeru a.'rb-

TepHaruBHoro peryn[poBaHur! .{ocrlmeMofo nocp

caEKuxoEllpoBaTb oTJrtrqarolqt{ect or o6ulltx alr

12.00.01 reopaa z rrcroplu npaBa tr

crBoM rlcKrloqeHrlfi r,t no3Borrroueto

npaBr.ur Bapxaqxu perynrqn{, qTo AaeT

BO3MOXHOCT6 yqeCTr, OOI,eKTr]BHO CyrqecTByroqee MH

no.alaaarcuax noI peryJ.lr |lrBHoe Bo3neIc fBre npaBa.

o6pa:ze o6uecreeuHbrx orHoueH [.

Ha[6oree :ua.nv6re nayunrre pa6orrr no reue,riuccepraqnu, ony6,rlroeanure e peuea-

3rrpyeMbrx HayqHbrx lB,qaHr.rrx, peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx BA4 Mr.rHo6pHayKx Poccm.

l. Cyueuroe , C. IO. Hopura flpaBa KaK aupaNelue roptlalrqecKxx ucx,rlo,{erurfi / C. IO.

CyueHroa // Poccnicrod ropa4nvecxnfi xypHa,.r. EKar+przu6ypr, 2009. Nl 2 (65). C. 17-21. (0,5

r.,r.).

2. Cyaeuxoe, C. K). flpuuuur::u npaaa r.r ncxruopeuar B npaBe: ac[eKTr,] coorHoffeHru /C. IO. Cyueaxoa // focy.4apcrBo u rpaBo. M., 2009. Ite 5. C. 23-30. (0,8 n.,r).

4

3. Cyuenxoe, C lO. I4crctoqlre,rbHblii cny'rai:

Hr4s / C. IO. CyMeHKoB // Xypnar pocc[icKoro flpaBa.

4. Cyueuxoe. C trO. flpaBonp "teHltreJlbHoe

arqecKr,rx uaxlrrcqenuii // V.reH6Ie :alucxrz Kagancro

pr.rr: fyuanlrrapuue uayrn. Ka:aur, 2009. T. 151, xtt.

C. IO. CyMeHKoB // Becrunr Caparoocxoii rocya

Nr 5 (69), C.30-33. (0,5 r.r.).6, Cyueuxoe, C. K). llpavuta L lcnllro'leu[t: O

cru / C. IO. CyueHroa // @tuocoOtlr npaBa. PocroB-Ha

7. Cyueuxoe, C. IO. llpar.ozoit IrMMyHxrer

lpaBoBofi acrrex:T I C, Io. Cyuenxor l/M.,2010. Ne 12. C.41-43. (0,5 n.a.).

8. Cyueuxoe, C. l{). tloasrue ([cKnoqeHlle B

croro eupaNeuua / C. lO. Cyueuroe // I43Becr[t BbIc

Cf16.,2011. Ne L C.71-83. (0,6 tt,r.)

9. Cyueuxoe, C. IO. [e$uwuqut ((B rloptaxe

rrcrroJrb3oBaHrri // C. IO. Cyueuroe // Becrunx Bopon

ra. Cepur: flpaao. BopoHex,2011. Ns 1.C. 101-l10. (0,

5. Cyaeuxoe, C. rc. IleneBoe

10. Cyueuxoe. C. IO. [4cK,1oqeHxq B opane

Qanopu nporareux.s [cKrro.]eHui u: npaeu,r / C. IO.

2011. Ne 7. C.9l-95. (0,6 n.,r.).

)Kra3tu / C.IO. CyMeHKoB // Klplar.IqecKa{ HayKa Ii IIp

nrr MBI Poccuz. Huxnui Hoaropog, 2011. Ns 1(14).

17. Cyueuroe, C iO. Ilpo6reuu OuttcaqfiI4 ltc

TrrBHo-rrpaBoBErx aKroe / C. IO. Cylreuroo // AKryul.

201t . Nr 4 (2r). C . 22-32 (0,5 t.r.).12. Cyuenxoe, C 10. tr4cxrroqtlre,]bHbre o6cro

13. Cyueuroe, C. IO. l4crs:lo\eHloe rl: rrpaBlrn

C. IO. Cynenrcoe ll Ilpaso u focyaapcrBo: 'reop[q lt(0,5 r.r.).

14. Cyuenxoe. C,!O. Hopvaruunurr,i npaeoeoii

rc,rrovenlrfi r rpaae / C. IO. Cyuemoe // Lex Russica

59-69 (0,5 n.r.)75. Cyueurcoa, C. K). L4cx:aw\eHwq B flpaBe KaK

l,t fipamriKa / C. IO. Cylrerroa // Becruux Caparoac

aeMnlr. CaparoB, 2016. Nr 5 (112). C. 23-28. (0,5 n.r.).

.,2009. Ns 7. C. 58-67. (0,7 u.r.).

I4cropur focy.4apcrBa I4 rpaBa.

oTpeH[e (aK ycJroB[e peanlr3alllll ]op!I-

focyaapcrBeHHoro yHl4BepclrrEra. ce-

C.26-33. (0,5 n.r.).

aqeHl4e t,Icl(,'rioqeH[i B rrpaBe /

Caparoe,2009.j,I aKaAeMr.r[ lpaBa.

ocoQcKo-[paBoBLre ocHoBaHLl, flapHo-

flory.20l0. N! 6. C. b0-64. (0.6 n.n.).

ucK,.lmgeHre tl3 nDaBrr: llctopl,Ilto-

eMbr 3aKoHonaTeJlbHoro onDeaejle-

e)' x npo6JteMbr ero I epv u Ho,.lotuqe-

1 ve6uux :ase,neHrii. flpaeoaenenre

9eHrt.: oco6eHHoc I r.1 HopvaTllBHofo

cltofo rocyaapaTBeHHoro yH[Bepq4Te-

pe3yrbrar oro6paNenlrr ltroroo6pa:u-a

ra: Becrnnx HuNeropo4cxoii ara.qe-

n.n.).

C.96-100. (0,5 r.,r.).

Iz3 npaBnn B TeKcTax HopMa-

e npo6,reuur pocchlcKor o npaBa. M.-

hcTBa rI yBax[TeJrbHbre np[qr.rEbr I(aK

Cyuenron // focyaapcrao u rpaao. M.,

K HOpMarr.rBHO-npaBoBoe npeaflucaHue /

rrrxa. M..2015. Ne l2 (ll2). C. 6-9.

KaK 6a3oBar OopMa Bo[IrouleHrit

lccxri raxou). M..2016. J\! 7 (ll6). C.

ecu{e cpeacTBa: Bofipocb] Teop rI

fi rocyaapcrBeHHoi,i ropnarrqecKoii aKa-

)

TeopeTltqecKl4e ocHoBbI! IopI,IAIzqecKa{

pea. A. B. Ma,rrro ; Caparoa: I4:4-ro

OfBOy BIIO (CaparoBcKar rocyAapcrBeHHa' ecxar aKaAeMrr), 2012. 384 c. (20,2

n,,r,). Tapax 500:xs.

2. Cynenxoe, C lO. Zcr,rroqesnr B npaBe: pe, [Ko-xHcTp) veHrantns aaaiuj /

C, IO. Cyr,remoe ; uog pea. A.B. Malrno ; M.: IOpr3000 ers. (1-i :aeo.q - 1000 er:.).

$opu, 2016. 3'76 c. (23,5 r.r.). Trpax

Ha qlrccepraquru u anropeQepar u IIJIII IIOJIO?KIITEJII'HbIE OT3I'IBI'I:

1) or AoKropa rcpxaurrecKlrx Nayr, rpoQeccopa 3acr\ xeHHolo lerte,rr gavxt Poccli-croi cDe4epaqua, 3aBeayrouefo oraeroM Teoptru II lrc u npaBa fi cy,4e6Hoii Bracrx @fEOY

BO <Poccuficruf rocyaapcrBeHnbrfi yHr,rBeporrer 4a-r>> B.raguunpa M[xafi,rosuqaCurpurx c laveqaHheM o loM. ,.n o ratBreHfie o Bceo6 ocTl.t ll oobeKTUBHocr xcKnoqeHrfi.

ooycnaBnuBaprqee r{x flp[cyrcrBue 6yKBa]'rbHo Bo c$epax 6urur. B ToM qncre r, flpaBe! {eAonxHo BbrcTyrraTb B KaqecTBe aKclloMbr, a! HarrpoTrrB, AaHHhrii BbrBoA, 3aKpenneHH6]ii B rloro-

xeHrar.r, BbrHoflrMoM Ha 3arrlrrry, ao,rNen 6srrl 6o,ree ieM ooocuoeafi. noAKpenreH He roJrr,Ko

coorBercrByrollrMu [puMepaM[, Ho n Heo6xoAauoii lrtiroAorofnrecKofi 6a3oii;

2) or goxropa rcpr.rAuqecKux nayr, npoQeccopal 3acJryxeHuofo .qerrenr HayKn Pocc[fi-

cxofi @e,qepaqnu, rorrgrHofo pa6orn[Ka aucuero up$SeccnoHzrJrbHoro o6pasoranur Poccui-

croii @egepaqnn, :aaeqyrorqero xa$e4pot reopr.j[ u r.rciropuu rocyAapcrBa l,I flpaBa @fEOV BO

<<,fpocnaacxrzii rocyAapcrBeHHbrii yHnBepcr,rrer uru. fl.f. ,{ernrrgoaa> B,raqumupa HI|rco,raes[-

ra Kaprauoaa c 3aMeqaHruMrr o roM, rrro aBTop H

eMy Be3Ae ((MepeluaTcr) lrcxJrroqeH[r B npaBe; rroHr,r

(HOpMaTrrBHO-[paBOBOrO [peAnLICaHIIt! np ee co6oii r ocy4apcr BeHHo-Bract Hoe Be-

,reHxe, refrrrrlMupoBaHHoe HaAllexauuNa o6parolr". e;jeue'r uruopr.rpoeaHlie rofo, rITo acKltto-

rreHru B npaBe xapaKTepHr,r Il anr rpaBoBbrx aKToBJ ble }{3.IlatoTct oDraHa\{I,I \'tecTHofo ca

\4OyIIpaBIeHhr r np. Hefocyrapcr BeHHbr\11-r rrpaBoTBopqecTBal o HeaonycTr.rMocT[

oToxaecTBJreHr.rrr cpeacTB rn [pr-reMoB B couuanbHo-[paFoBofi cQepe, TaK xax cpe4cBa e ceoei

coBoKynlrocTu aocTaBntloT coAepxaHl-Ie ropr.rar4.recKof a npueMLr BMecre co cuoco6a-

Mt1, MeTOAaMrj !1 [paBIInaMIt - rcpXAIIqeCKyrO Ta(Tr.rKy; Kpr.rTn(a IlHTefpaTIiBHofo onpeAeJIeHIIt

npaBa xax cuHre3a npaBln l-l rlcKrlrcqeHutl. KaK aocl

n6o co:.uanlre coorBercrByrolqeii I{oHrleIIqI,In lpaBa

HO ynpoqeHHoro x o,qHocTopoHHero,

I,ICCIeAOBartIl' X He MOXeT BbICTynaTb B (aqeCTBe CO yroqeii, <ron1nuofi) 3aAaq[ fto6oro

I{o yBneKcr reMoi,i {ccjre.qoBaH[r, qro

e aBTopoM I-IcK'IrcgeHrl' B rrpaBe KaK

veT oTnejlbHofo. cavocrotTeJ.lbHofo

HayqHoro rlccreAoBaHr,rr! B ToM qrzcjle Ii ypoBHr AoKTopgxoii A[cceprarlliu;3) or aoKropa rcpuauvecpu nayn, rpo$eccopa, +po$eccopa raQegpu reopuu l,r ncroptlrl

npaBa tr rocyAapcrBa CeBepo-3ana,qHoro rncruryra ynflae,reHxr OfEOy BO (PoccrilcKar aKa-

IeMI,It HapoAHoro xo3riAcrBa n rocyAapcraeunoii clyxpu tpr.t flpe:u4enre PoccaiicKoii Oe.qe-

paquu> Ba,reuuna AnApeeslqa Canyna I raugngar{ ropa4.uecnlrx Hayq AoqeHTa, AorIeHTa

Cyuexxoe, C lO. I4cr,rnqesur B npaBe1.

orlerrKa, cr{creMHbrii anurtlp / C. IO. CyMgHKoB ; rloa

CTBa, Ho Ilp[ 3ToM LICKJIIOqcHLI' OAHOBpeMeHHo B (aqecTBe aBT0HoMHOLI rpynnLl

ropuAr.rqecKlx cpe,{crB; 3aMeqaHll no rloBoay Tofo, aBTOp, BepEo noa.IepKLIBat yHI',IBep-

caJIbHhIi Xapa(Tep [paBoBhIX ucKJlIoqeHxfi, He pa3BI-jBaPT MbtcJlb o IIpIrMeHeHuri r4cKjltoLleEulI He

Tonr,Ko rlpr $opullpoeaHul-l HopMaruBnbtx arroe n cy4e6usrx [peqeaeHToB' Ho t4 Irpu ltcnoJlb-

3OBaHE[ TZHLIX IICTOqHIKOB IIO3I{TTIBHO|O [paBa: oBbrx up[HII[noB! npaeoerrx o6rlraen,

rrpaBoBoi AoKrp{HbI, HopMaraBHr,Ix AoroBopoB; 3aMerr+Hl,tt o roM, rrro B pa6ore 6rrao 6H nure-

pecHo yBr.raerr' o6cTo{TerbHbli KpLIT['recKr'Ifi aHaJIX3 I'irCrIOnBOBaHr'It [paBOBbIX l'lcKJr]or{eHutl B

cKyro ueHHocrl pa6our n tBr-serct Ilpr-rq[Hoii

[peAJ.roxeHHblx aBTopoM peKoMeHAaurii, Ha[paB,'I

KqroqeHr,rii B lpaBe;

4) or ao&-ropa ropaAlr.Iecxlx HayK, flpoQeccopa, Seccopa raQe4pu reoplu x xcropxn

rocyAapcrBa L npaaa @fBOV BO <To,rurruuclttlii ro ylapcrBeHHblii yHr-IBepcx rer,, Avlr I plrq

aBTOpy cre,{oBaro 6u yae,rurr 6o,ree

uauqecroii oTBeTarBerlHocTl,I, 1160 uc-

&rroqeHrir uMeHHo a :roii cdepe Bbl3blBaror tr TIoBLI brf rrHTepec o6qecrBeHHocru, u Aaxe

orplfllaTeJlbHog oTHorx€H{e I{ acMrcqeHurlM! a Mex.{y TeM aBTop, pacKphlBa.q KopperrtUnro Lrc-

Mro-reH[i c rcp[.q[qecKoii orBercTBeHHocrbto, ],IqlIJICf JII{IIIb AHZUII'3OM BO3AC'ICTBI,I'

r.ie ncK,'rro.reH[i e c@epe rcpu4nvecrofi

5) or aoKropa rcpuaaqecitrix HayK, npooeccop [pooeccopa Kaoeapbr rocyaapcrBoBe-

xo3riicrBa ra rocyaapcrBeHHoii cJIyx6bIaer z.s @f6OV BO <Poccaiicxa.q aKaAeMut Hapo,4no

npra flpe3r.raeHre Pocct,tfi cxoil OeAepaqltu) Hara,'Ibli ltrr opoBHbr Mangroeoi c BonpocoM o

He o6qero, a6crpaKrHofo xapaKTepa

Ha OIITIIM[3aqr]tO UCIIOJIL3OBaHTU UC-

AEaro,rlesuqa Jllrnnucroro c 3aMg.IaHlreNr o roM,

Itprcra,,tbHoe BHI{MaHLie B3a MocBt3ll lrcKn|oqeHri I,l

nprIHuLInoB ryMaH[3Ma U CrIpaBe,4JlHBOCTn Ha IIO.SBJTe

OTBgTCTBCHHOCTT';

TOM. KaKOt CMLICJI aBTOp BI!'Ia,qbIBagT B CiIOBOC

Itpr.rrllKoi Toro, .rro, ecrr{ rloc,'IeAHrjii no,4pa3yMeBaer rleJreBoe rlpeaHa3HaqeHle I]cKrloqeHll'l,

ocraercr HerrorurrHbrM, noqeMy [pII KqaccuQEKarlrll gHuii Ha Ao3Bo,reHm u otpaH[qe-

Htt aaHEoe ocHoBzlHlre He obo3Haqaerct ra(ttM Bfl ycrorBrruMcr L.i flpri3HaHHr,rM B o6uei

Teoplu npaBa TepMrrHoM, KaK ((c[oco6 [paBoBofo

J.loxHeHrle noHrrr.riHoro an Iapa I a topur]xLrecKox Ha

JrrrpoBaHlar), {60 ucryccrBenHoe oc-

-f,BJrrgrct oTpuqaTgJrr,Hoii TeHAeH{[en,

o6opor 4eficrattre,rlno neo6xoanur,rx

e (TeleoJron qecxllfi ro.[xoa>, r c

aeJto u

Arex-

ue uuerouluf Hrqefo o6qero c BBe,4eH[eM B Hayr'I

ABepnHa c aaMeqaHrflMll o roMi qro col{cKarerb llpu

Haii x cy,qe6Ho[ BJIacr[ He paccraB[r [pfoplrrgrbl,

aKtep cIuKe coolHoueH tl cruIrcrle-

BrreqaTJrer[le, qro cyae6Hat BJracrb Heo6xoaxMa

IIpAMeHtTE r1 (OHTpOJII'IpOBaT6 llCKJIrOqeHlrf, TeM

r.r3 TeKcTa aBTopeoepaTa cKJIaahIBaeTat

Art Iolo, 'lro6bl coiAaBalb. toJrKoBal b.

qTo r.lcMIoqeHLUl - 3TO OCO6bIe rlpaBoBhle cpeacTBa'

3OBaTb B rlpaBonpuMeHltTeJlr,Hot .qetTeJlbHocTa; yKa3

aBTopy c.'reaoBaro 6u uerxo orpa:urr,

opue cyre6uar BJIacrL Mo)I(er IrcnoJI;-

, IITO AI-TCCCPTAHT AONYCKAET ONPE-

.IEJ'ICHHbIC TCPMIIHOIIOII,III9CK'IC HCTOqHOCTIj' B qACTH Tr-.r yrBepx,[at! qro cyAe6nal flparTu(a

a, ToJrKoBaHLIt, npaBorlpl'IMeHeHtIt,

HoBl{aHocrtM cyAeoHof aetrerbllocrn

KoppecnoHAlrpyroT oooTBeTcrByIouII{e aKTbI, qro r1 Boflpoc 06 o6ocnoaanuocta oro-

x/IecrBJreHrn cyqe6uoii npa(TuKll lI cyAe6uoi:i ,4efle.l HOCTIT! KOTOpbIe AeCrUa 6,ru:ru1, no or-

HroAh He cr.rHoHIrMutIHH, a Al-iccepraHT o6r3aH 3Ty pa3 yrIriTr,r B aTb;

7) or aorcopa toprArlqecKlrx HayK, aoqeHTa, o$eccopa xa@eapu rocyaapcrBeuHoro

yrrpaBneHrrl a npaea @fAOY BO <<Mocroacrulf rocy BeHHr,rir rjHcrr{ryT MexAyHapoIHLIx

orHoureu[i (ynlraepcmer) Mnuucrepcrea I'IHocrpaHH x aen Pocc'licKoi Oe,aepau'lu,' B1|ra-

,ura Bnrcropoanva Cy6ouena, a xoropoll o6 BHr,IMaHUe Ha I-BJIri HtOtO KaTeropl4tl-

npeAcraBusr co6oi cl rre: cyAeoHofo npaBorBop

KOHTpOJI', OAHOBpeMeHHO OTMelIagr, qro yKa3aHHLIM

Hoarl ll 6e3anneJltu[ouuocrh yrBepxAeHlrt aBTopa

HOpMaTABHO-npaBOBOe UpeAn[CaH[g! [peacTaBn{ro

ocnreJlbHo rofo, qTo r;IcKlroqgHl;Ie 3TO

co6ofi ruurr, focyaapcrBeHHo BJlacruoe

aqlMocrb pzl3rltlrqubtx unux cy6:rexroe

MAX;

8) or Aoxropa ropnA[r]ecKux HayK, AoueHra, lr. o. [popeKropa no Hay'IHoi'i pa6ore, npo-

@eccopa rcaQe,rplr reopriu r,I ncropuu rocyrapcrBa ll r,IpaBa @fBOy BO (KocrpoMcKoii rocy-

aapcrBeHnbrii yH[Bepclzrrer) B,raanc,rara B.ragnunposuva lpyraera c 3aMerIaFI]ieM o roM,

-rro a aeropeSepare He orpaxeHa 3Bo,'Iroqru rzcxlrouiinuii, a ant ytcHel{us cyrlt l4cKr}o'{eHfi[

Ba)KHbIM 'BJI'{ETC{

TIOHIMAH]'IC TOIO, IOqCMY II KO|AA PO3HI'IKJIO AAHHOE IICUIIOqCHI'IE, qTO CNO-

co6creonano erouy I,1 B*Ae JII.I AaHHoe l,1cKq]oqeHl,Ie BgcIIpr.IHl'IMaerct t'IMeHHo KaK LlcxJlloqeHne,

a He KaK rrpaBlrJro, erqe 6o,ree ItHTepecHhrM, Ho He orp3aBu[Mct B none 3peHl-lt aBTopa, rrpea-

craBlrrercr ocBeuleHr.re rpaucQopuauuu uctotroueHlr-a { lpannLto nln uao6opor;

BE]TEHI'C; TCM CAMbIM ABTOP YMAJI'CT IIOTETIqUAq II 3

npaBoTBopqecKoro npouecca, B qacTHocrll creAoBal,lo 6rr noapo6uee ocraHoeltrr-

C' HA JIOKIIJIbHOM NPABOTBOPI{CCTBC U O6'bEKTUBI'IPO rir.l ncKJrroqeHllii B KoplopaTuBHblx Hop-

9) or AoKTopa rcplAliqccKlix HayK, AoueHTai eccopa xa$eapu fpaxaaHc(oro [paBa

OfEOy BO <Tau6oecx[fi rccyaapcrBeHHhrii yuneelcurer ltu. f .P. ,nepNaer.rHa)) BacIlJ'IIis

B.laancraaoafiqa Tpo{uuoaa, B KoropoM craBLITct Forrpoc o roM, He craHoBtlrct JIll }Icl<,lr}o-

qeHr.re, KaK rlpeanucaH[e, 3aQlrKcxpoBaHHoe B HopMe npaBa Il BotljlorleHHoe B HopMaTuBtloM

aroe, npaBrinoMl o6ocnoBanHocrb,qaHHoro Bonpoca civeargua. u6o n ucuroqesue u npaB[IIo

flo,{pa3yMeBaror o6r3arenhHr,re rpe6oeanajr, coore yrou[M o6pa3oM ooopMneHbl, ti3AarcT-

cs x pearrx3yrorc, ol llMeHll IocynapcTBa. rlo rrM, yqr.rTbrBan I( ToMy xe, rrTo He-

KOTOpbre ricKrqroqeHrir rrMreparuBHbr, MoxHo llpeal]ojlpxltTb, qTo oHlI Ha o[peae"teHHoM 3Tarle

rl-j6o Aaxe [3Haqa[6Ho BbrcTyrraroT He KaK ].rcxrroqeHn4, a KaK IIpaBI-Ina;

10) noaurcassnii ao(TopoM ropna[qecKllx Hay4, npoSeccopon, 3aBeayFrqlzM KaQeapoii

reoprn u ncropllr rocy.4apcrBa r npaBa OfAOy BO <pn6apcxuii oeaepanbHbrii yHuBepcl'Irer)

Cepreeu A.rerccanaporlr.reu .{po6uureBcKIrM, IIo B,reHHbrii KaHrxaaral\,Iu ropnar-rqecK[x

HayK, aorlenTaMr.r raQegpu reopua l,t r,tcropr.ru rocyaa u rpaoa @fAOV BO (Cu6{pcKfifi

Qegeparlnlrii yuuBepolrreD> B,raguc.ranou IOpr,eo qeM flafltreHKo, AneKcaHApoM A"'re(-

canApoBxqev Tlerpoourv r 3aBeil) rotul,t\'t yKa3aHHoi KaQe,{poii, aoKTopoM ropllA[qecruIx Ha-

yx, lpooeccopoM Cepreen A"rerccanqpoenveu rxeBcKllM. c 3aMe.IaHaeM o ToM. ltTo

paooTy Morjro obr ycr.rJ'r[Tb aeTajrbHoe pa3fpaHr-i.reHrde cKlrrcqeH[t He rrpocro c rrpaBvJraM[, a c

rrpaB[JraMrr, qro rro3BoJrrrJ]o 6u aaropyoco6oi pa:noetanocrbro flocJr e,q H r.t \ cneu anhHbrvrl

oaH03HaqHo onpe.{e,'luTb MecTo rncK[loqeHul,I B rroH oM anlapare ropu,qlrvecxoii nayru;

I 1) lo.4lrjcaHHbrfi KaH,qr-.rAaroM ropaAaqecKrrx aoueHToM, uavamnnxolr raQerpn

reopll[ I-,I r.rcroprr[ focyAapcrBa lr rpaBa @fBOy BO < aHKr-flerep6yprcKraii yH{Bepcxrer I o-

cyIapcrBeHHofi [porxBo[oxapHoii cryN6r,r Mrnir crBa PoccniicKoi @eAeparluu no Aelalr

JII.IKBIIAAITI,II NOCIEACTBIII CTI4XI{iH6IXrpaxlaHcKoil o6opoHbr. qpe3BbrqaiHbl\4 cxr)atlltrv6eAcrauf) Cranuc,rarou Eoplrcoouvelr Heu.reuxo, oAroroBreHHbrii upo$eccopolt yra:aH-

Hoi Kaoeapbr, aoxropoM roprjr[eecMx nayr<, npoQ oM. Jac,l\xeHHblM rooucr.orlr Poccui-

croii @e.{eDauuu Huno,raev I{saHornqelr Yrrusr,r c3aMeqaHlzeM oTHoc[TerLHo [pI,IqlIc-

IOpITA[rrecKot TexH[KIr, qTo He AaeTreHU, ticKrto'leH}l, K opaBo I Bop'lec Kox coctaBJltlot!

BO3\IOXHOC tb OtpelenXt b pOJrb ticKJ O'reHXta np

MeHrreJrbHbrx aKToB; B ToM qucJre lr aKToB cy.qe6uoii

npaBa, npxMeHeHrzf, lpaea, cy,qe6uoro xoxrpo,rr;

riHTepnpgTarlrroHHhrx r-r [paBorlp[-

acTr.I, [3AaBaeMbIx B xoae ToiIKoBaH[t

12) no,qnucauald .{oKTopoM roplr4t,rqecKlrx HayK, aoueHToM, 3aBeaylr:IrluM xa@elpoii

Teopl,III r ucroprjri rocyAapcrBa u npaea l4ncrlrryra (epeuca, rypu:lra u Ar.r3aiiHa (Surna,ra)

OfAOy BO <<Cerepo-Kaera:cruii OeAepa'rbnbrf yur]reepcrrer> e r. flaruropcxe AHrpeeM

Ilerporuueu Ma3ypeHKo, [o.{roroBJreHHLrii 4oqenlou yra:auuoft raSe,qpu, rangugarov

ropr;rArirr€cK[x HayK A"'reKcaHApoM fenna4reauveu pe.luncnnu, coAepxarqlii prA 3aMerra-

Huii: o roM, .rro aBTop cyxaer 3HarreHne [aK,'rro.{eHufi B lpaBe! orHocr rrx K oAHoMy lI3 nprreMoB

roplrAu.recKofi TexHuKrl, Me)KAy reM KaK y(BaHHbre B pBTopeQepare ue,'ru AeiicrBrd [cKfuoqe-

Hrf flo3Bo,rrtor cyAutr o Hnx raK o6 oco6hrx IIpaBOBO[ IOJIIITIKI-I! (OTOparr rBiUeTCq

OOJIEE IIJIIPOKI-,IM EEHOMEHOM!'IEM IPABOTBOPTIECTBO, onpliMeHeH[,Ie! ropr.ralrrecKar TexHr-r.

Ka, Bx.Jrroqarorlr4M rzx e ce6rr; o HeKoropofi u.qe aBTolloM lrot!.IloqeH[t. qTo BJIeqer Boc-

rrprrlrrr.re [ocJreAHxx B KaqecrBe 6a:uca g,ra Soplltpo [paBoBoii cticreMbr! B To BpeM{ KaK

rIpaBI-.IJIaM oTBoArrrc{ rxrrh por'Ib nol]lepxaHllr cyqecTByr.oqefo lroJroxeHtr [paBoBoii Aejicr-B]4',rcJlbHoct ll;

13) noAnr.rcaHHlli,i r,l ror]-oroB,reHHbri aoKTopoli{ rop[Arz.recKr.tx HayK, AoqeHToM! 3aBe-

ayrorqllM Kaoeapofr reopr.flr x [croprjr{ rocy,{apcrBa rr flpaBa <DfEOV BO <AmaicKnfi rocyAap-

9

crBeHHbrii yH[BepcrITeD AHToHoM A.ilercanlpoelvei BacurlesH['t c yKa3aHlleM o ueo6xo-

Anuocrrz o6.g:arenr,Hof pacul-IopoBrur raKlix noHtrl'Iii, KaK ncK'IloqeH[t-3aflperbl, IlcKrloqeHuq-

o6qsnsaHr.rs tr s oco6eHHocu llcKrtorreHa{-ofpaHl-Iqelllt (B y3KoM, HerlocpeacrBeHHoM cMbrc-

ne).

Bu6op oSauua"'Irublx orrIoHeHToB LI Beaylqei aql-lrl o6ocuogl,tsaerc{ TeM, qro

f KoMneTeHr H bl\.lr-.i I cooTBeTcTByIo-

rrpaBa rl focy.4apcTBa, xcTopnri yqeHr'I[

o flpaBe lI rocyAapcrBg, uMeror tIy6JrI-.IKaq[u B AaHHoi Qepe xccreaoBaHllt.

Beayqar opraH[3au[r ruxpoKo L3BecrHa cBo]I Ill AOCTtlittCHI'I'MI{ B OOJIACTU ACCJIEAOBA-

H[r flpaBa) npaBoTBopqecTBa, npaBonp[MeHeHxt: n BbIX AKTOB. CTEUT'I-I6HOIO TIOABOBOIO

perynlrpoBaHrur, c[ocooHa onpeAeJl[Tb Hay.IHyro u

IIOJIAXAET AOOTBCTSIBYIOIqVMI HAYTIHI,IMI KAAPAMI,I.

TIeHHOCT6 AllCCepTarIAr{, pac-

,(uccepraqnonnsri coBer orMerlaer, tITo Ha

I|cc"'renoBaHuii:

pa:pa6orana HayqHa{ KoHIIeqat ucKrtoq B npaBe, pacKpbrBarorqaq Hau6o,Tee o6-

lI coBepueHcTBoBaHur, orpaxamqa.,I

oii AeficrB[TenbHocrl-r, rx IrHcrpyMeH-

urle 3aKoHolrepHocrr ux Qopvupoaaut-lt. pea"rtu,t

cneqlroury Qopulr rupaNenu.r tlcKnloqeHzii B

TarrbHyro cy[tHocTb;

rrpeAJ'roxeHbr: HoBr'ra paKypc paccMoTpeltrit npo6"reuu AuQQepeHrr[aqn[ cucreMbl

HOpMaTABITO-npaBOBOf O pef yJrIrpOBaHIrt; aBTOpCKat Hfi[ r acKrrrcqeHri,i B npaBe; opl{ra-

HaJrlnbre cyxaeHlrt o6 ucxruo.IeHll KaK o HopMarIrBH rrpaBoBoM flpeA[xcaHurr; HoBaTopcKr.re

noAxoAhr K nayuuofi x.nacc[QlrKaqr.r[ l.rcx,rroqenr]ft s xiicKoM 3AKOHOAATCJII,CTBE| IIEJIEBbIE

ycraHoBKr-r [cK,'rnqeHtdl B [paBe; xapaKreprrcr[Ka

npueMoB ropr.rAurrecKoii TexHuKI,I;

qeHl4t KaK ropr{arrqecKr{x cpeacTB It

AOKA3AHA HCOOXOAI:IMOCTb BKJIIOqEHII' B TEOP rocy,4apcTBa a upaBa 3HaHrra o cJre-

ayrctqux 3aKoHoMepHocTtx: cooTBeTcTBl.It llcKr'IloqeH' flpaBy x HeBo3MoxHoarE rrx oroxaecT-

KuoqeHl1fi rar o6oco6,reHuoii rpyrnuBJIeHrrr c [paBoHapyureHrleM; cyqecTBoBaH],It HopM-

Iop[axrIecru4x nopu; neo6xogrruocrb rl oco6eHnocrl-I om'u{{eHI,IJI I'rcllTloqeHlli B l,lcroqHllKa,x

norrrTr4BHofo rpaBa: uHcTp) i\4eH iarbHat HalrpaBneHH llcKffo-reHxt;

BBeAeHbr: EOBHe KOHrleflTyaflbHlle IIOH{Tllt (ll KJItoqEHUE B TPABC'). (I,ICKIIIOIIEHAC KAK

IIpe,4lOXeHHbre B KaqecTBe olroHeHToB yqeHLIe {BJI'

IIlefi orpacrur ropl.rarrqecKoii HayKu - Teoparl n ucropll

TeoperIl.recKai 3HaqHMocrb IIcc.lleAoBaHIlq

aoKalaHo. .Ito: l-lcKnrcqeH'lr nptl Bceil cBoei

HOpMaTr,rBHO-npaBOBOe rrpean}JcaH!le)), ((lrc(JrtoqcH[I

(tIcKJItOLIeHne-AO3BOJTeHtte)! ([CKJ'ttOr]eHr,Ie-[pet,tMy

(HopMa-rrcKrrrorreHue)), (rIcr(J oq[TelbHat HopMD, (cp

[pueM ropr4arirrecKo[ rexnrzrr.r>>.

OBaHUn Bbl nOJIHeHHI'rX CO[CKaTeJreM

cTBO-UCKrrrOqeHr4e), ((LICKJII{)TIeHI-re (aK

ocHoBaHa TeM, qTo;

CIIIHCII IIDOTABODEqIBQCTU NO OTHOIIIC-

I431'tTfi e), (<l'lCKlIlOqeHIl9-AOllO,rlHeHUen,

9ATBO>, (tICK.JrtOlIeHtre-OfpaH[qeHI4e),

Hltto K IIpaBIrrTaM He rIpoTIzBocTotT IocJIeaHlM, Ee rlo bIBatoT IIX IOiIOXeHrIt, a BMeCTe C [pa-

COqI,IAJIEHEIX CBfiEIl; IOCPCACTBOM IIC-BraJraMl{ HarrpaBJreHbr Ha rroJrHoqeHHoe yperyJrr.rpo

KffOqeHXi npaBo rrpxodperaer Bo3MoxHocrb peaf

HOCT6 r.I pa3nOCTOpOHHOCTb TeX IIJ]rI IHbIX ClrTyaIIUU,

yqacTBylotqltxl [rHoprzpyf rroTpeoHocTb B [IcKJIro

CTBO rrojrHorleHHoro x 3EQeKTr-.rBHoro HopMaTtrBHoro p

l0

HOpMaTrBHbrM rrpaBoBbrM rrpearrrrcaHr.reM, coaepxr.rT Ll3

BXIO. npe.lcTarouee B Btne ,no3BoJIeHrt. rtl60

lopriaxqecKof o rlplieMa lIcKJIIoqeHt{e Ilo3BoJItgT

aepxaHrrr{) r.r B HopMaTrrBHoM npaBoBoM aKTe (KaK

ypoBeHh)j coAepxaqee oTJT[qarouyrocr oT o6ulef Bap

3TOM LIX KOJrJ'rr,13ITOHHOCTT4; OrafoAapr AaHHOMy npl{e

Horo npearrrzcaHru (Mal(poypoBeHbJ, l.rHrerpnpyrcIIIerc

rrplrMeHrlTeJrbHo K rrpo6JreMaT[Ke anccepTarulr

lo,rTyrleHrieM o6raAarcqr-rx HoBlr3Hoii p*ynhraroB) rt

6asosrrx MeroAos trccJreaoBaH[r: ana,rerru.recrui:i[o3HaHIlt. no3Bortlour[f gaz6olee loluo nolutl ntIX BCeOOIIIHOCT6 Iz OO:be(T[BHOCTb III]I.IC]TCTBLI-'I B

6urua, yncrrmr Hepa3pbrBH''ro cBt3b ficK,'trc.reH[ii c

eArrHcrBa r{ 6opl6lr uporuronoro)(Hocreii, B3ar.iM

MoIr KoHKpeTHocT[; cr{creMHo-crpyKTypHbril MeToA,

rcrt'toqeHue u npaBnno Kal( Hepa3pbrBHyto ctrcTeMy;

HocrHoro aHalr{3a (Teopr.rr BeporrHocrx), NreroA Mo

MCTOA;

[3JloxeHbr BecoMbre u r,ry6oxrze no coAepxaHu

noaTBepxaeHHLIe aHaIll3oM COUIIaJILHO-tIOJlltTl.i.JeCKOii

o cooTBeTcTBItt I4cI!'IIoqeHArl IIp[HIIXnaM CnpaBgAjI

HtTAt (IlCrulroqeHne> lI <IpaBo)! B KoTopoNl tIcKJIIo

MeHT npaBa, He lporuBopeqarq[n efo cylllHocTrr, Aorry

HrrMaHrrr; o Hepa3pbrBHoM eauHcTBe ucxrrorreHutr u [pJreHHocThro, AeTepM[Hr-.rpoBaHHot TeM, qTo acK,trro

Br"ro [oreHutI€lJlr,Ho He cyulecrByer 6e3 licK,rto.]etlrjii;

MaTXBHO-npaBOBOIO npe,{nllcaHrl' Kar( focyaapcTBeH

Hanr'texauu\4 o6pa:ov: o 3aKpenneHl1u l.jcKlto']eH il B

eKTXBXpOBaHUe B HOpMaT{BHhrX IpaBOBbrX aKTaX; O

o6ycroe,renuou OaKropaMn peatbHoii xa3Hu; o cfle

cpeacrB, rBlr*orqr.Ixcr nepBr4qHblM) 6a:ogu,v rounon()prrauqgcKue cpgacTBa, ri oaHoBpeMeHHo BbIcTynaE

roprIar.rqecxrx 9peacTB;

H l1fl Ha HeOAHOpOAHOCIb. i\4HOtOfpaH-

npoqeccoB, a taxNe cy6lerroo, o unx

xr npaB}rJr. rrpaBo yTpaTr.rT cBoe Kaqe-

rynrropa; LrcrrloqeHr.re, 6yayqu oco6brM

e [rtz ([) aorrontreHue s o6rqee npa-

rr3lroxurb a uoplle npaaa (rar co-

Me) IlpeaIIr.rcaHxe-ncKftoqeEl,Ie (MrlRpo-

peryJrrrpoBaH[r, He aorrycKar [ptIo6ecreqr.rBaercr cyqecrBoBaHr.re e.qr-r-

ce6e npaau,ro n ucurcueuae;

)J.lhraruBHo (rQ$erruaro. ro ecrb c

noJI630BaH KOMUJIeKC CyUIeCTByrOrqnX

ualrr'3M KaK oa3oBLI[ MeTO.II HaVqHOfO

[c&r]ro.reHnt t13 rIpaBtIII, oco3Harh

KaK oAEoii at Qopv ve,roae.recxoro

, [porBJlsro[rync{ B 3aKoHe

rpe6) eMoii a6crparuluu r.r ueo6xonr-

IIlIltI BO3MOXHOCT6 OXapaKTepI-t3OBaTh

6epser[qec(ufi Meror lr MeroA Beporr-

upoBaHrrr, @opna,rlno-ropralrvecrui

OTDAH}IqEHU': B I{AIIECTBE TCXHIZKO.

TeopeT[rlecKz e IloJloxeHut lI BhIBoabI!

ropt4l[.recKoii IIpaKTuKn, B ToM q[cre:

II IyMaHrfMa; O COOTHOIIIeHI,IIi nO-

H[e Bbrcryrasr xar neo6xoAr,ruuii :le-r r p?l3JlItlIHbIMII TtiIIaM{ IIpaBOnO-

o6rscHqenroft lrx maalloo6yc;roa-

uoryr 6r,rrr rorr,ro rr:l npaBr.rlra, a npa-

o6 onaqeraopenr.ru r;IcKrIIolIeHIreM aop-

o-arac rHor o ae,teurr. oSopv,retHor o

p[AxrrecN,lx HopMax, Haxonru[x o6b-

eBolr'l [petHa3HaqeHxfi xcKnrcqeHxll,

QIIKe [curoqeHrzii KaK ropr-tA[rrecKr.rx

Mj tr3 KOTOpbIX CKJIaAbIBaTTC' BCe

u B KaqecrBe aBToHoMHot fpyflru,I

pacKpbrrbr: cneq[ol4Ka Ilclt,ll]oqeHlt KaK rlptrgMa HlpI4a[rrec(otl TexHxKa! o6ecfleq!-

Barorqero coqeraHrle BblcoKoro ypoBHt a6crpaKuxl{ l't Q6f,:are,llHoii KoHKperHocrai neo6xoan-

Mbrx rpa LI3JIoxeHlrtt B Iopxalzqec(oii HopMe npaBoBolo lrpe,{nrlcaHut, nperycMarp[Baroruero

r.i3b.arue rr3 o6uero rpaerzra u,'ttt (u) aoro,ruenuq K HeYy; ocHoBH6le KpI.ITepIlll uaccllSnraqml

ucr<.nrcvenufi, Ir3 Koropbrx Mafucrpal,'r6HbIM Bblcryllaer llleneBa{ HanpaBneHuocrb; napHocrf, npa-

Br.u r rcorrcqeH[ii, o[pe,{e.]lrForqat HeBo3MoxHocrb IpaKToBKn ucKJIIoqeHI'It KaK HapyIneHIzJI

npaBara rl cloco6crByroqat flpaBy MaKanMaJrbHo eQ$ercrlrouo peryJrapoBarb o6uectgenur're

oTHOIUeHA{; OCO6enUOCrn repuuHocrrcTeMll! B Koropofi o6T er<rnelrpyercr lroHtr[e (IlcKrtoqe-

Hrle B rrpaBe)r; Bo[poaLr 3aKpen"rleHllt licK,lloqeH[t B HgpMarItBHLle [paBoBble aKTbr pa3rl'IqHoro

ypoBHr; ynlmajlbHat B3ariMocBt3r, IlcxJlro.IeHui:i l,l cyAeqHoi:i flpal(Tr1Klz; opraHr4q€cKoe eA[EcrBo

qereii, ctoqqrax [epea [cK[IoqeHIuMxi t'I cpeAcrB-riclsloqeH ii, Ha[paBreHHbIX Ha [x pa3pe-

IEH[C;

rr3yqeHr,r: o6uue :aronouepnocr],I aerepMtaHa[[ix l4cKrrceeHl4ii xar oco6r'rx HopMarriB-

Ebrx npaBoBlIX ltpeafiI'icautrii, napHbix c npaBunaMa; 4naccu$rrcauaouuble ocHoBasltt crparlt-

Qmaquu ucuroverufi B npaBe; cneuaQuxa Bocnputl4t acKrrlo'IeHuii B KoHTeKcre pa3rlrrlHr,lx

TunoB rrpaBorroHlrMaHrI'; oco6eHHocrr{ HopM-ticKlroqerluii I{ HopMaruBHoro npaBoBoro aKTa KaK

6a:oeoi @opulr BofliloureHlrl [cx,rro.{eHI,Iii; BaMocB43b cyae6Hoil npaKTl]Kll }'l IrcK,'l}otleHuii B

rrpaBe; rleJreBr,re ycraHoBKri ucKrlo.reHllt; topl4AtlqecKaF TepMxHoJlorut, nocpencrBoM Koropoft

ocyulecrBlrrercr reKcryalbHoe BblpaxeHne [cK,'IIoqeF tii B poccrlicxoM 3aKoHoAare"llbcrBe;

Syurcqnoua"'rlua-r tlafpy3Ka rjcKr.rroqeHr.rii, 3a(,lro.Ialonrqtct B Bbr[oJIHeHu[ uaKrloqeHlulMtr crtl-

Mynrpyrcqeii I ofpaHu-rure.]rbHoii, rapaHr[pyroqeii u I{oMneHcar]uoHHoii Qyrxuuit;npoBeaeHa MoaepHl-|3aqnfl Teoper[Ko-Meroao+orl4qecK.Ix rloaxoaoB K I{ccJIeaoBaHI-Irc

HecTaHAapTHbrx! oTJ[rqHbrx or yuu@r.tqaporaurslx. Q$uoueuoa HopMaT[BHo-npaBoBofo pery-

Jr[poBaHr-rr; [Merorrl[xcr Hay.rHbrx 3Harir,Iii, Ha(orrJIeHIIbIX B lopaatlqecl{oii HayKe no BorlpocaM

cyrqecrBoBaHur cfiequa[bHblx ropll.[urlecKnx opM; HopMarlBHo-[paBoBt]x npe{nl,lcaHtrt; ao3-

BoreHuii ri orpaHu.reHli; qenei n cpe.qcrB B rrpaBe.

3naqenue norytreHHbrx co[cKareJ'reM pe3yr+TaroB LrccJ'IeaoBaH[s Arq npaKTlrKtl

IIoaTBepr(aaeTcq TeM, qTo:

pa:pa6orausr rr BEeapen],r guasur o5 rcK,'rro,rgHhrx. caHKur-joHnpyrorqnx B HeKorophlx

o.rryarlurx unx (n) a,'u oraelrnux,nurl orrrqarou([ec4 or npaB[Jr, Ho He Hapyuarcque r-rx, Ba-

prraqun pery"'rnpoBauna; o6 nmneMeerau h ,rc K,'roqel x ii B HopMy npaBa; o repM[HocrlcreMe

r,rcr<,'Ilouenui, nrrtovarorqefi e ce6r raxr.re repulrHhlj KaF: (3a ItcKJrIoqeHueM cryqaeBD! (ticK.rrro-

qaTeJIbHbIfi cryqaii), €a l{cKqoqeH[eM)); (B [optaKe itlcK.ffoqeH]4r)), (B B[ae ],IcMro.reHr,rr)); o

Mecre n po.nlr ricxjrro,reH[fi KaK ropxAx,recl(]rx cpe,{crB F MexaHt3Me rrpaBoBoro perynnpoBaHr.rr;

onpeaeneHbr rIepcIIeKTr{BtI IIpaKTrFIecKoIo [cI9J]b3oBaHrIq IloJ'roxeHrt: o ponn l4cKJr]o-

LreH[ii B aocr[xeHarr oleparr{BHocrra r, ,qI,IoOepeHrl[ppBaHHocru npaBoBoro pefyirxpoBaH[q; o

pgxl{Me [cKJrroqeHrriij o 3aKoHo,qarenbHofi oroBopKe Ka( BaxHeiilreM cloco6e BHeApeHnr uc-

KJrroqeH[r B TeKcT HopMaT[BHOfO [paBOBOfO aKTa; O HgpMaTIBHO-[paBOB6IX TepMUHaX, B (OTO-

12

p6rx o6beKTnBrrpyroTcr lrcKrroqeHljt, a TaKr(e o TepMFiHax! tBJ'Itlolqfixct rcplravqecKllMll ae-

TepMuHaHTaM[ r.rcKjllorreHl-rii r1 o HeaoIIycTI-IMOCTtT O6q3Ha.reHI'It TICKJIIOqeHT'Ii ljHoil! He OTHO-

ctrqeiicr K HxM TepMlrHoJlofrieii; o HopMarI-.IBHbIX paMKPX, npeAenax, ycJroBlrtx ycMorpeH[s Irc-

KrroqeHr-.rii B [paBe; 06 ofpaH['reH[I-.I x 3arIpe!]eHLILl KolllcTaTarJtlvl r'r pearn3arJTLr xcJcl|ogeHt,Ii; o

anAaKTaqecKoii qeHHocTu TeopeT[qec(ofo 3HaHut B o6facTu r.IcKlloqeHllt B rlpaBe;

co3aaB r(oMrrreKc [paKT[qecK],Ix peKoMeHAaux4 no oIITI-IML3aIIu[ npuMeHeHllt ]ICKJIIO-

rteHLIi, K (OTOpbIM OTHOC'TC': H?LTt,ItIUe rjCKII]OlIeHrit B COOTBerCTBytOqei HOpMe rlpaBa, o6fia-

TerlbHat MoTrBaquq npeanoqreHur [cKrlo.IeHqt rlpaBllny, Haa'Ile)Kaqee ooopMneH e Bbl6opa

ITcUIOTIeHllt U pe3y]Il'TaTai AocTIirHyTOlO B XO/:le ero pFanIBaUllIl B IIpaBOnpEMeH]iTeilbHOM al{_

rej ycxJreHHoM KoHTpoJre peaJrr,i3arul, r.icKrrctreHUii B xciae jopJ4atl'iecKof [paKTnxa:

npeacraBr'reHbr HayqHo-[paKTuqecK[e rrpeaJ]o)rfeH]It rlo aaJlhHealneMy coBep[IeHcrBo-

BaHXTO r{CK'IrOqeHLIfi, HarIpaBJreHHbrX Ha CHXXeHne pI4C+OB nplj QOpMylrl'IpoBaHu{, 3a(penJleHr -'I

Ll pearlBaur[I tIclg-IloqeHllii, MuHnMrr3aII[rI Bo3MoxHocTu 3JloynoTpe6JreH[t IIMU.

OqeHKa AocroBepHocru pe3y,'rr'TaroB licc.'IeaoFaHrrfl Br'IqBll.tra:

TeopeTrlKo-MeToaoJrofI|YecKaq ocHoBa nccJ'IeapBaHnfl rlocrpoeHa Ha [3BecTHbIX, [po-

eepeuuux Qarrax, yq[TbrBaer ocnoBHhre aocruxeH]rf qayK[ Teoplrrl rocyaapcrBa u npaBa x or-

pacreBbrx ropr,I.qrlrlecKr.rx HayK, cor,racyerc{ c paHee ony6nrKoBaHIrbIMr HayqHbrMl{ TpyaaMfi no

AAHHO' TEMATIKC;

qeuTpar.rbuaq uqer 6arr-rpyercn Ha ro\{, rrro rlqxitoqeHxe n npane npeqcrae,uer co6ofi

3aKpenneHHoe e o$uqralrsuo llpr-i3HaHH[,rx sopuax, o$r,exruaupoBaHHoe B crreqr,L'rhHbrx rep-

uuuax oco6oe HopMarr.rBHoe rrpearrxcaHue! B6rcryflaloI ee B (aqecrBe rop[a[r]ec(ofo cpeacrBa

pernaMeHTaq![ oouecrBeHHlrx orHoureHrli. [oApa3yN4eBa]oruee AororHeHre [rui (x) r.r3'b-[Tne

,t3 [apHoro c ucKlroqeHlt€M o6rqero npaon"ra u co:aai:rqee a,'1r,T€pHaT[BH5]i nocneaHeMy Ba-

pr,raHT peryr'rqqn[, neo6xoAnrH[ AJrr .qocr[xeHr,r coq[aJrbHo 3Haq[Mbrx ue,Tei; Ilpr, ?ToM r4c-

&lroqena,t aorxHtl coorBgTcrBoBarb rpe6orannlu cuppoeglllBocrlr It ryManu3Ma, o6eo[eqrlBa-lr

TeM caMbrM Haa"'rexarq[ii ypoaenr aa@$epeuuaaun[ c4creMlr npaaa e qerax nar6oree nonHo-

ro yvera uuoroo6pa:lu, a[HaM[3Ma t,r Heoa{opo,qHocr{ o6qecrBenHErx orHoltrenni;

ucrroJ'rb3oBaHbr AocroBepubre o6ueHa),rH6te llapep anu no BonpocaM HaJrr{qllr ficn'uo-qeHnl B pa3nuqHr,rx, IIpexae Bcefo coq[tlJlhHbIx, ctcle]Nrax, aaHHbre oTpacjreBErx rcp[ArdqecKux

HayK r,t pa6orhr [o reopru rocyaapcrBa x npaBa, r{acarqul[ec.q o6T erra rr [peAMera r]ccreaoBa-

Hur, B pe3yJrhrare qefo [pe,4craBireHa eguuar o6qerepperrjqecKair KoHr]erun! ucK,llo9eH[i B

lpaBe;

ycraHoBJ'IeHo KallecrBeHHoe coorBercrBae aBTopcKlrx pe3yJt6TaroB o6rqenay,ulru gan-

HrJM 06 ucr{.JlorreHrr{x B coqr.raJrr,HoM pa3Blrrulr! npe.qr+ecrByrorutiM uapa6orrau ro lcnorlb3o-

BaHr,rro Kareroprd:i (rlcxJrroqeHl{e), (HopMarriBHo-lpaBqBoe npeAIIucaHlte)), (cneq[aJrbHarr Hop-

MD), (QopMa IIpaBa)! ((opnAuqeoKoe cpeAcrBo);

llcnoflb3oBanrl coBpeMeHHr,re MeroAuKt,t c6opa a o6pa6ol<u un@opltaqnounoro uare-puarra, [paBxnbHo onpele,reuH o6aexr u I]pe/]Mer l[cceprallrzoHHoro trccJ'reAoBaHbr.

JlnqHlrfi sKJraa coucKarerq cocrori'r B ToM, qro B ,quccepra[xu aeropov co:Eana o6-

xlereoperlFtecKat KoHuenulTt ucKi}oqeHlli, r{anpaBJreHHarI Ha pa3pe[eHHe Kp)nHoE Hayql1oii

npo6,reuu HayKr.r reop[x rocy,{apcrBa ri flpaBa, 3aMloqa]oqei'ict B npol l.rBope'IIi[ N1ex,{y o6b-

eKTraBrro cyulecrByroqei:i 3Ta,rorrHoii npupoAoii rpaBa, c oAHoii cropoHbr, lI neo6xo.4lruocruo

o6ecrteqeuur Ea rrpaKTrrKe aonxnoro ypoena .qu$SepeHqrlpoBaHHocra, o[eparuBHocru r,t [on-

Hor br npaBoBoro per) i HpoBaH Lir. c lp) | oii.

[uccepraunr Bbrrro]rnena ua naQeape reoplttr rocyaapcrBa tl npaBa @fEOy BO (Capa-

TOBCKaT fOCylapCTBeHHarr OpuAr4qeC(air aKa.qeMrrr), f,4e rrpoBo.4r.rrocb ee peqeH3upoBaHlre tr

o6cyx4euue. Ocuoenue eueorrr r.i noior{eHrd pa6otr,r AoBo.{ruucb .ql{ccepraHToM ao cBeae[at

HayqHbrx r, [pa(Trrrrecxax pa6oruuroa Ha Nre)KA] HaporHbrx ft Bcepoccuiicxr-lx KoHOepeuullxx.

Ha saceaarlan 06 OeBpanr 2017 r. ArrcceprauaogHbrii coaer npuru,r peuerrrre trptlcyrxrr,

Cyueurory C. IO. yuenyn creneu6 iloxropa roprlauqecKux Hay(.

flpu npoeegenau raiiHofo rolocoBaHlrr .{uccepraquouulrii coBer B KonltlreclBe 21 qeno-

BeKa, u3 Hrx 8.uorropoe uayx ro rpo$rruo paccMarpxBaeMoii ,(xcceprarlnx, yqacrBoRaBurrx B

3aceAarrrjr.r. r,3 28 qeroBeK, Bxo.qgulrx B coclaB coBela! Io[oJIHI{Te"1],Ho HaKTo He BBoALtJlc{,

rporoJrocoBaJrr.r: 3a - 21, lporuB - Her, He.4ei:icrBrrrerr,Hbrx 6ror-r,'rereHeii - fler.

Ilpeaceaare,ru,(lrccepraqaoHHoro coBera

AoKTop rupHAuqecKnx HayK, Ilpo0eccop

Vvenr,rii cerperaps.{lrccepraquonnoro coo

KaHArraaT roprrAxqecKlrx HayK, aouerrT B,B, Hupnon

f /,, tl 2oti t.ffi