· web viewcomparison groups measures caregiver-child relationship caregiver-child relationship...

4
Table E-106. Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy, healthy caregiver child relationship outcomes First Author, Year Comparison Groups Measures Caregiver-Child Relationship Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 2) Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 3) Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 4) Cohen, 2004 50 Cohen, 2004 50 G1: Trauma- Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (TF- CBT) G2: Child Centered Therapy for Treating PTSD Parenting Practices Questionnaire (PPQ): self report [Parenting Practices Questionnaire (PPQ)] Baseline score mean (SD) G1: 135.60 (15.20) G2: 136.44 (15.80) Endpoint score mean (SD) G1: 144.38 (15.55) G2: 139.19 (13.61) Change score mean (SD) Between group, p<0.001 NA NA NA E-139

Upload: buikhuong

Post on 23-Jun-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1:  · Web viewComparison Groups Measures Caregiver-Child Relationship Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 2) Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 3) Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part

Table E-106. Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy, healthy caregiver child relationship outcomesFirst Author, Year

Comparison Groups Measures

Caregiver-Child Relationship

Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 2)

Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 3)

Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 4)

Cohen, 200450Cohen, 200450

G1: Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (TF-CBT)G2: Child Centered Therapy for Treating PTSD

Parenting Practices Questionnaire (PPQ): self report

[Parenting Practices Questionnaire (PPQ)]Baseline score mean (SD) G1: 135.60 (15.20)G2: 136.44 (15.80)Endpoint score mean (SD) G1: 144.38 (15.55)G2: 139.19 (13.61)Change score mean (SD)

Between group, p<0.001

NA NA NA

E-139

Page 2:  · Web viewComparison Groups Measures Caregiver-Child Relationship Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 2) Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 3) Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part

Table E-106. Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy, healthy caregiver child relationship outcomes (continued)First Author, Year

Comparison Groups Measures

Caregiver-Child Relationship

Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 2)

Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 3)

Caregiver-Child Relationship (Part 4)

Deblinger, 200151

G1: Supportive Therapy G2: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

SCL-90-R Post-Traumatic Stress Subscale [SCL-90-R] (mother)

Impact of Events-Intrusive Thoughts (mother)

Impact of Events-Avoidance of Thoughts (mother)

Parenting Practices Questionnaire (PPQ): self report

[SCL-90-R PTS Subscale]Baseline score mean (SD)G1: 18.17 (18.04)G2: 25.33 (16.07)Posttest score mean (SD)G1: 12.35 (11.67)G2: 14.67 (20.28)Within group change score meanG1: -5.82 (d = .34)G2:10.66 (d = .62)Follow up score mean (SD)G1: 12.91 (12.19)G2: 11.48 (14.59)Within group pretest-follow up change score meanG1: -5.26G2: -11.48Between group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)TimexGroup: F = 2.92, p = NS (NR)Within group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)Time: F = 9.97, p<.0.001

[PPQ]Baseline score mean (SD)G1: 147.00 (13.15)G2: 144.95 (12.41)Posttest score mean (SD)G1: 146.74 (12.93)G2: 149.48 (15.81)Within group change score mean G1: -1.26 (d = .02)G2: +4.48 (d = -.36)Follow up score mean (SD)G1: 148.39 (13.35)G2: 151.05 (15.16)Within group pretest-follow up change score meanG1: +1.39 G2: +6.10 Between group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)TimexGroup: 1.38, p = NS (NR)Within group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)Time: F = 3.54, p<0.05

Impact of Events-Intrusive ThoughtsBaseline score mean (SD)G1: 12.26 (9.63)G2: 18.19 9.92)Posttest score mean (SD)G1: 9.26 (9.88)G2: 10.00 (10.49)Within group change score meanG1: -3.00 (d = .30)G2: -8.19 (d = .81)Follow up score mean (SD)G1: 8.65 (10.09)G2: 8.95 (9.49)Within group pretest-follow up change score meanG1: -3.61 G2: -9.14Between group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)TimexGroup: F 3.23, p<.05Within group Time: F = 16.17, p<0.001Within group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)Time: F = 16.17, p<0.001

Impact of Events-Avoidance of ThoughtsBaseline score mean (SD)G1: 13.91 (10.48)G2: 15.95 (8.13)Posttest score mean (SD)G1: 11.91 (9.85)G2: 10.90 (9.55)Within group change score meanG1: -2.00 (d = .21)G2: -5.05 (d = .54)Follow up score mean (SD)G1: 10.65 (10.02)G2: 8.90 (8.52)Within group pretest-follow up change score meanG1: -3.26G2: -7.05Between group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)TimexGroup: F = 1.22, p = NS (NR)Within group MANOVA (pooled SD across groups)Time: F = 8.17, p < 0.001

E-140