0' 122&-.&'3#&,$4&-$',-.' /%5...
TRANSCRIPT
!"!#"$%
$
!"#$%&'($)"*+',-.'/&0'122&-.&#'3#&,$4&-$',-.'
/%5"+"7-!"##$%&'()'*%++"+",'-$).)''/"+01'-)'-2%+3%,'-$).)'
2/26/19
2
The Greek Triumvirate
Socrates Plato Aristotle470-399 BC 428-347 BC 384-322 BC
Sanskrit written in 3500 BC Socrates was writing circa 470 BC
2/26/19
3
Greek foundation for modern ethics
“Ethics” a Greek word meaning, “relating to one’s character”
Virtue Ethics: Use of virtue to do the right thing
Deontology: Duty to rules
Consequentialism: Consequences of actions
!"!#"$%
&
!"#$%&'$('&)*'+,,)(-).'".)/"0)("'/(-'&12).3$&$+('-+)&'(+"'+%%1.'$('/'3/%110
! !"#$%&'()*+$&+,*'(! -+.(! /()*+$&+,*'(&01+*2+&! /0#32+! 4*,$#5&6.#7#67&
!"#$%&'()*&%$+%,)($&-$./)(01&$&2)0/$)&201+3$4)2+50-/$
!""#$%&'()#*+,-.-,/!"#$%"&'()&*"+,)"*$-".$"/'01"%$2)034"4#$)4"4)5-+&&*"+,$-4'067"#$%"&'()&*"+,)"*$-".$"#+8)"4)5"%'.#"4$2)$0)"%#$"%+4")5.,)2)&*"/+.7"#$%"&'()&*"+,)"*$-".$")09$*"4)5"%'.#"4$2)$0)"*$-"#+.)1"
01123()#$%&!"#$%"&'()&*"+,)"*$-".$".)&&"4$2)$0)"*$-"&$8)1"#'2"$,"#),:".$"#+8)"4)5"%'.#".#)";),4$07"#$%"&'()&*"+,)"*$-".$")0<$-,+6)"+"1+.)".$"1,'0("2$,)"+&<$#$&:"4$"#)"$,"4#)"%'&&"#+8)"4)5"%'.#"*$-
456(7%#$%&!"#$%"&'()&*"+,)"*$-".$"#+8)"4)5"%'.#"+"4.,+06),"%'.#$-."+"<$01$2
=,')&*:">+0"?@ABAC"!"#$%&'()*+,-""('%./(*0,1#2%3#$,(/$,456(/$#$,4$%'%./7,89#,:%$$#/,;.",89(',<9(6#,=>",?#&%3%./3,?;;D"B@EFB@GCD"H+,;),"I$&&'04:"J0<D
2/26/19
5
When the context changes, judgment changes
Percent Increase From Context One to
Context Two
Odd sexual activity 72% increase
Immoral sexual activity 136% increase
Unsafe sex 25% increase
Moral decisions are under assault by context
Ethics does not occur in a vacuum.
!"!#"$%
#
!"#$%&'(#)($&*$+(",-.
!"#$%&'!()*)!&$*#+&#!+
,-.*'!()*)!&$*#+&#!+'
+$&&#%/'-0'+$1'-00$%2$*'&*$)&3$%&')%2'+.4$*5#+#-%'
!"#$"%&"'()%&!*+$,%&!-"."/%$.+0%+/0&
! !"#$%&&"'(")*$+)"$+$,"-")%."'%/*$.)%/0
! 1%-$+22$*"#$%&&"'(")*$3%/$*/0")45*"$%)$-)"+-$+)"$-%#5678/-$*%9"$+)"
!"!#"$%
&
!"#$%#&$'((#)*#+$
,'-./+#*$0'$)')'((#)*#+%$
!"#$%&'(")*+,-
./*0,1"%$2$13'405"6$+,-
71*0,1"%$2$13'405"6$+,-
8+)$"%'90($)$*-
80/:"%';,+4%0#-' <**$*:90-'
!"#$%&'()'$)%*)+,'-)./"'01,)!
! !""#$%&'()#*&+%,-.,/.()#.&.(""#/#-$#&0#%1##-&%12&3#,-'-/#''#.&(-&'%,-.,/.&.#6(,%(2-&7-(%'! 8&.&2"&9:;&3#,-'&%<#/#&('&,&<,="&2"&,&'%,-.,/.&.#6(,%(2-&.(""#/#-$#&0#%1##-&%12&3#,-'&! +3,==&>&,55/24(3,%#=?&9@;&! A#.(73&>&,55/24(3,%#=?&9:;! B,/C#&>&,55/24(3,%#=?&9D;
!"!#"$%
&
!"#$#%&'$()&(%)*+,*&"'*-+.(%*!/('0&*
! !"#$%&'$()*+,-%&"()$#.*/0123! 4)5%#,-*!*6,-%&"()$#.*7$%&-8,-*/09:3! !"#$%&'()*+,-.)+/)0+&#%+()12345! 6'%'&+7'897.#%-.#)12:45
! *+;).$(/<$.#$$9)12:45
! =$>%$..7+&)12:?5! @AA%$..7+&8B7+($&,$)12:?5! ;#<,-*4)5%#,-*=*+,-%&"()$#.*8$%&-8,-*/0>>3! C-D.#'&,$)'D-.$)12:E5! F$&$%'()$9>'#GH)I$/7,7#.)12JE5
! @&"7$#H)12K45! C+,7'().L7((.)I$/7,7#.)12KM5NG7#'L$%O)=2P2O)*$O)Q2O)R'&.+&O)S2T2O)Q'L$%O)02T2O)U,U'G+&O)62U2O)SH'&O)F2O)T($7&O)@2O)'&I)S7,$O)=2=2)KEEM)S7.L)/',#+%.)/+%)#G$)>%$>'%'#7+&)+/),G7(I).$"-'()'D-.$V)@)%$W7$;)'&I)9$#'<'&'(H.7.2)0G7(I)@D-.$)'&I)X$A($,#O)JKO 3K4<3:M
!"#$%&'()%*(+%,'(-(&.'(#,*.,+*'/%*0%"1#,.2('3*+(1#"+%"%+*&2(%,'*
! !"#$%&'()*'*&+,%-.'/+#0#$'2$$"#%-*
! !"#$%&'*&#+*'3,0/"#0$%&)+4.'*&+,%-.'/+#0#$'2$$"#%-*'#%'4,5
! 6,5'7,%8&'+$3,-%#9$'&()&'&($'3"#$%&'3)5*$7':/+,;$3&$7<'&($'2$$"#%-*',%'4,5
! 6,5',=%':#7$%'=#&(<'&($'2$$"#%-*
!"!#"$%
%
!"#$%&''"($)*%&+)$
!"#$%&'($)"$*($+,$&$-(.&)+",/%+0$1+)%$&..$)%"/($1%"2$3"#$/#0(-'+/($"-$
)-(&))-(&)
4%"('(-$3"#$&-($+,$&$
-(.&)+",/%+0$1+)%5$3"#$6()$/"2($"7$)%(2$
",$3"#
!"#$%&'($)"$*($4%"('(-$3"#$
!"#$%"$&"'$()*+",%$-"$-.)$*-(",/$)0"-1",*$*-1(()%$2&$-"314$451),-*6
!"#$%$"&%'()*(+,%"-- .$*/0"(
!"!#"$%
$&
!"#$%&'()'**+$&,$-).(*#$
!"#$%$"&%' ($)*+" ,-%"../
!"#$%&'()* +$%&'() ,-./""-
!"%)"%'0'1'&- ,)23)./"() 4)156!"7$18)"&
9:;/.7'() 9:$./8) </%=
!8":./"() >.$7)"() 91)?).")%%
!"#$%"$&"'$()"#$*'(+,-./$#).0$&"'1$-2,.0+$(3&(4
!"#$%&'(#)$&*+,-)$."#$"+,/#$%0."+,.$&$/"0*.1$!+2#.02#/3$/"#$%+,')$4,/.$4,25$,5$&-)$/0.$+-$26$'&51$!"#$/##2#)$.+$(-+%$%"&.$/"#$%&/$)+0-71$!"#$(-#%$&$'+.$&8+,.$/#91
!"!#"$%
$$
!"#$%"&'$()&$("*&$"+$,"-.$.&'/"*'&$')"#$(&0/&.1*2&3$#)&*$,"-.$245&*($'1,'6
!"#$%"&'("()*"+,-%("'&*"('".*"#,()")*-/"0)*"#$&(*1"2*/"0)*")$1"$"3-4%)"'&"2*/""566"!"1,1"#$%"7,%%")*-"$&1"('43)")*-/"0)*"%$8%"()*-*"#$%"%*9".4("!"1'&:("-*2*2.*-"$&8"%*9/"
!"#$%"$&"'$()*+$,'-+$&"'$',+$./-0'+1$! !"#$%&'()"*"++,-!"#$%./*01/)0*2-3-
!"#$%4/*1)/#! 5)"6"*10*2-7##-8$$"91+-/$-:/;09-4#0"*1+-
! !"#$%"%&'()*$+",-.)%-/%0+'1,%! 2$3+-$4%5-44-&16)%&6-$/).! 7/0"0$%-/%.1,$+#-.-'/%
! <"9/6")=-$)/>-?@:-A+0*2-60)1A"--! 8"69%)'%"%&'66$"01$! :,'6'0-;$%)'%)*$%&6-$/)%! <'+0-#$%='1+.$64>%?-#$%"/5%6$"+/
!"!#"$%
$!
!"#$%&'()#*$+,'-$./
!"#$%&'%(')%*+',%#-')$%(').%/0.$)123
!"#$"%&'$()*$%&+,#*-./$,+*'%#-$
!"#$"%%&'()*(+),"-#-"%%("%% .'%&/&0")
.%123'-'41
!"!#"$%
$&
!""#$%#&'()*#&+,-$./0#!1.$,,#-+(2#)*3#+*#()*/#1'"-'.2,!1.$,,#-+(2#)*3#+*#()*/#1'"-'.2,
!"#$%&'()*+#&,-%+()-%.*#"*/0',*%$%&1*2-),-&%
+()-%.*30&*#,'%)3*4 "0,*(*/%("'*,0*("*%".
5("*6%*,(-78,9*)%(&"%.9*(".*%)(60&(,%.
!"#$%&'%(#%')$)'*+%',#-.'%(.'/$&%
!"#$%%!&$"'$ $((!'!$"')*
!"!#"$%
$&
!"#$%&"'()*+,$-")./(*$
!"#$%&'(')*%+,-$.- /%012.- 3%4-'('
50&2*"67
80#6"9- :-&;-12*9- <;"1"602,"67'
!"#$%&'()$'*)%+,-$.-'! !"#$%&$'()*+,)$+'-#-&')$+)'.-)/%#0,! 0%1-)%2)0-*#+$+3! 4",35-+'6!#$'$!*0)'.$+7$+36%8-+95$+,-,+-&&! $+3-+"$'(6%#$3$+*0$'(68#*!'$!*0)$+'-00$3-+!-6&'#--')&5*#'&! &%!$*0)$+'-00$3-+!-:)8-#&%+*0)$+'-00$3-+!-:)-5%'$%+*0)$+'-00$3-+!-! 8-#&8-!'$1-)
!"!#"$%
$&
!"#$%&'
! !"#$%"&'#()'$#*+"
! ,%"-%$%"#(.%/'0()1-2"&/')0*03%(.%
! 4+(%-2&50(2%3"02&53%(10(%(%--'
!"#$%&'(%)*+&',-.
! !"#$#%&&'(#$')%#%*+&",-'
! ,.%'/(0(/",-',+'1+2%3,.%'/(0(/",-',+'4%'1+2%$
2/26/19
16
Justice
• Loyalty, citizenship, duty, and teamwork
• fairness and equity
• leadership
Temperance
• Self-control• Caution, prudence & discretion• Humility and modesty
(but not false humility and modesty)
2/26/19
17
Spirituality and Transcendence
• appreciation of beauty and excellence• gratitude• hope/optimism/future
mindedness• sense of
purpose/spirituality/faith/religiousness
• playfulness and humor• forgiveness and mercy• zest/passion/enthusiasm
Do you want to measure your virtues
!"!#"$%
$&
!"#$%&'()*+($#(,-&(./'$,&()%&"(0&*1/"2()/$%(+#,'(31/&"$-(
!"#$%&'(%)"*&+(%"#%,-+*%./"(#&%
2/26/19
19
Two Way Bridge
Ask your client to send virtue
across the bridge
2/26/19
20
Friendly but not Friends Inner Circle:
Your loved one
Friends & Family
Acquaintances& Clients
!"!#"$%
!$
!"#$%&'()*+$,&!"-&.-**#/0&+1&.-2&311-/%-$&!$-(*4-/*&(/%&
.56-$7#8#+/&
!"#$%&'("%&$(')*+,"--.+#%&-'
/+*0.#1'.#'2(.&3'435+6%67'2"#$"*-&+-"'
+89"6$.5.$7
!"!#"$%
!!
!"#$%&'()*+,&-./.0%&'/)!++.&%'1%.()'(2)3.$14$#)
!"#$%&'()*%+,*%-&$.(*(#/%&(.$*0,*$1(2$343$-55%6%,7)8$9#%&6%9,772$*0($343$:*0%6)$;%#(6*-#$<-%&(.$,&.$)"99-#*(.$,*$*%/()$=2$-*0(#$343$-55%6%,7)8$6-77".(.$>%*0$%/9-#*,&*$;-;$?,&.$;-;$%&*(##-+,*%-&$+"%.(7%&()@$A($6-&67".(.$*0,*$343B)$9#%&6%9,7$/-*%'($%&$.-%&+$)-$>,)$*-$,7%+&$343$,&.$6"##2$5,'-#$>%*0$;-;@$C0(#($>(#($*>-$-*0(#$%/9-#*,&*$/-*%'()D$*-$6#(,*($,$+--.$9"=7%6E#(7,*%-&)$#()9-&)(8$,&.$*-$1((9$*0($+#->*0$-5$9)260-7-+2$"&#()*#,%&(.$%&$*0%)$,#(,@$
!"!#!$$%&$'()#*(+,-(.($+#/$)#*(0,1$/+,%$#%2#3($,%-#4(/)(-0#
!"#$%&"'()$*)+,"-&).$/01,2$34,56718,$92215,"$:;<<=>;<?@A
!"#$B150(,C$D&)(E,".$!,F67G$/01,2$34,56718,$92215,"$
!"#$H0,($I#$J("K,"'().$34,56718,$!1",57&"$2&"$L6KC15$()+$B,'K,"$/&''6)15(71&)$
!"!#"$%
!&
!"#$%#"%
&'()*+,-&./0.1-2.13'(0+4-.5-&6/4+/7+/3+8-9:-;+*/8<-0)+1=.1-
$9#$>#$$
!"#$%&'%(&)(#%*+,(&-.+/0**%#&1&2&-03+&.(&!0.4
!"!#"$%
!&
!""#$%&"$'()*+,'#-
*+$.)/'&01)(,2,#)+344,()"')5,6785)1$99,#,("
!"#$%&'($)*+,-)"*$./*0'1&%$1&'.*
!"#$%&'()*&+",-,+$"(."/%$".$01$2,$")3"$'$2/."/%&/"+$&4"/)"&2"$24"5*)41,/")*",)2,+1.()26"
7)/('&/()2"(."/%$"/%(28"/%&/"31$+.")*"4*('$."/%$"#$%&'()*",-,+$6""
2/26/19
25
The behavior cycle for losing virtue
Deficiency or Excess of Virtue
Replace Virtue with Group Goals
Adopt Group Goals
Close Involvement with a Group
Professional standing in a field
Judge Ken Anderson’s Behavioral Cycle
The Ends Justify the Means
Win at Any Cost
Adversarial Process – One Winner & One Loser
Associates with ADAs and Other Districts Attorney
District Attorney of Williamson County
!"!#"$%
!#
!"#"$%!$"&
'()*$+,-()"./%0#1-*,%0*$-2,0%3-.#+0%0#1-*,
!"#$%%!"#$%!"#$
!"#%&'%(''&%)*')+*%
&'%,-&%."/0(1$
!"##$"%$&'()*+
,"-.('/.)'"0
1("*2$34'05
6"0%"(7')8
!"!#"$%
!&
!"#$%&'$(&")
!"#$%&'()*+,"-)*.&/0*)1234567
8(9*&9-9":#*9&;()*+1&01&
#*9<&*#&#*9&)1&;()*+)*.&
!"!#"$%
!&
!"#"$"%&'()&*+,-+.
/"%0"1$234&
!"#$%&'()$*"+*$
,-./(#-0#1$2'($0+--'*$)&'*#0*$2'(
!"!#"$%
!%
!"#$%&'($)"$*+",$-"#.$/"+)(0)
!"#$%"&'$()*"$*+'$,"-./$0.")'1$!"#$.'02'$0.")'1$3)$*+'$&'0)*(&'4$5"#$0-'$6#/7'/$
0.")'1$
!"!#"$%
&'
!"#$%&'%($%#)*%$('%#%+,-%,)%&'
!"#$%&'($)*(+'#
!"#$%&'($')*+#(,
-"$.($(+%)/&01$#2($3"#*$')*+#(,
45$3"#$6&7($&$6)2+&7($&89$.(%&'($#8(+%)/&01$)+$6(&82$3"#$0"2+$3"#*$')*+#(,
-"$*(:&)*$3"#*2(05$5*"6$&8$#8(+%)/&0$&/+1$*(+#*8$+"$')*+#(,
-%($)6:"*+&8+$+%)8;$)2$+"$(89$<(00,
!"!#"$%
&$
!"#$%&'$