0**#)+.%0)+-#*$%casbo.web.unc.edu/files/2017/09/november-13-2013... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
!"#$%&%'()*+(*$%!((,-+#)+.%'*"/)(*$%0**#)+.%0)+-#*$%
!"#$%&$'()*+(,-)*(./$01$'2( 12-"2%3-"(,%
!""#"$%&$'()%&*'+#&%&,)'%
4,55*##*%6)5$7)"*%
!""#"$%&$'()%&*'-."#&)""'/)&$)0'%
12(7,+82%6)55)29$%
!""1,#%$)'(#0),$10*'2.3%&'4)"1.0,)"'(
34.( :,55,;%#7*%2##2(7*<%72+<,-#%=,"%2%"*/)*;%,=%#7*%>",(*$$?%#,%$-992")@*A%
B$*%C0'%)+%DE!6*F%#,%=).-"*%,-#%$252"8%$2/)+.$%,+%8,-"%92)+%$#2#*%
2((,-+#%#,%F*%#"2+$=*""*<%#,%8,-"%)+$#"-(#),+25%F-<.*#%
45)(G%H$7,;%>",I*(#*<%)+=,J%#,%92G*%$-"*%8,-%<,+K#%9,/*%9,+*8%
*+(-9F*"*<%=,"%2(#),+$%)+%>",."*$$%
67*+%#7*%LCM%#"2+$=*"%>,$#$%#7*%9,+*8%;)55%F*%>-55*<%=",9%#7*%
-+255,(2#*<%5)+*%$,%9,/)+.%#7*%$2/)+.$%<,;+%#,%#7*%-+255,(2#*<%5)+*%
;)55%*+$-"*%2%(5*2+*"%C0'%2+<%7*5>%8,-%2/,)<%(,+=-$),+%52#*"%
!=#*"%#7*%9,+#7%(5,$*$%)$%2%.,,<%#)9*%#,%<,%$252"8%$2/)+.$%F*(2-$*%
#7*%F*.)++)+.N*+<%,=%#7*%9,+#7%)$+K#%2%.,,<%#)9*%#,%5,,G%)+%C0'%
F*(2-$*%/25-*$%(,-5<%F*%,==%$)+(*%>28",55%72$+K#%$8+(*<O%
5$"/6$."78(9/:08$2(
P(#,F*"%QRST%)$%#7*%72"<%.,U5)/*%<2#*%
6*%;)55%F*.)+%=)+2+(*%#"2)+)+.%V-58U'*>#*9F*"%QRST%
W7*"*%;)55%F*%(72"#=)*5<%(72+.*$%F-#%;*%;)55%.)/*%8,-%9,"*%-><2#*$%
,+(*%#7*8%2"*%=)+25)@*<%
;<=0=>$(9/:08$2( '#2"#UB>%(72+.*$A%X-*%V2+-2"8%SR
#7
%
o 3,-%(2+%92G*%2<I-$#9*+#$%+,;%F-#%;*%;)55%$*+<%,-#%2%
"*9)+<*"%
o '*+<%8,-"%"*/)$*<%$>"*2<$7**#$%#,%12-"2%,"%'2F")+2%
47",+%Y+F,Z%Y+$#"-(#),+$A%'**%2##2(7*<%<)"*(#),+$%
o 02+2.*"$%;)55%,+58%F*%2F5*%#,%2<<%#7*%47",+%=,"%02+2.*"$%%
o 3,-%9-$#%=,55,;%#7*%)+$#"-(#),+$%=,"%*2(7%<*/)(*%8,-%-$*%
[)E2<?%52>#,>?%<*$G#,>?%*#(O\%
o W7)$%;)55%2<<%2%(25*+<2"%,=%<*2<5)+*$%2+<%->(,9)+.%
9**#)+.$N*/*+#$O%
Y=%8,-%;2+#%#,%2<<%*/*+#$%=",9%#7*%02+2.*"$K%(25*+<2"%#,%
8,-"%>*"$,+25%(25*+<2"?%>-55%#7*%*/*+#%#,%8,-"$%2+<%(7,,$*%
(,>8%#7)$%,((-""*+(*%
o W7*%)+F,Z%;)55%,+58%(,+#2)+%9*$$2.*$%$*+#%,-#%2=#*"%#7*%)+F,Z%;2$%
("*2#*<%
o %
?@(9/:08$2( C*+*=)#$%,>*+%*+",559*+#%>*"),<%*Z#*+<*<%#,%L,/*9F*"%S]
#7
O%
Y+#*")9%$->>,"#%=,"%#7*%!$$)$#2+#%X*2+%,=%^_%%U%12(7,+82%6)55)29$%
E72$*<%_*#)"*9*+#%%
o !>>5)(2#),+$%<-*%#,%#7*%X*2+K$%P==)(*%F8%X*(*9F*"%S`?%QRS`%
'*+<%2>>5)(2#),+$%#,%^_%4,+$-5#2+#$%%
E",/,$#%P==)(*%<*2<5)+*%V2+-2"8%a?%QRST%
o '>*()=)(%<-#)*$%$7,-5<%F*%,-#5)+*<%
W*2(7)+.?%"*$*2"(7%2+<%$*"/)(*%
DZ29>5*%,+%>>O%bR%c%bS%472)"K$%02+-25%[52#*$#%/*"$),+%
bNSaNS`\%
B><2#*%#,%;*F$)#*%,+%$252"8%)+("*2$*$%=,"%'E!%2+<%DE!%L:%
o L,;%)+(5-<*$%#)>$%2+<%*Z29>5*$%
o ^).75).7#$%G*8%(72+.*$%
o 7##>$ANN7"O-+(O*<-N>,5)()*$U>",(*<-"*$U$8$#*9$N$>2U*9>5,8**U
>,5)()*$N(,9>*+$2#),+N+,+U=2(-5#8U$252"8U)+("*2$*U)+#*")9U
.-)<*5)+*$N%%
%
o !55%'E!%)+("*2$*$%,/*"%SR%>*"(*+#%9-$#%F*%$-F9)##*<%F8%#7*%)28%2+<%)A8B%,=%*2(7%9,+#7O%
o DE!%+,+U=2(-5#8%)+("*2$*$%,/*"%SR%>*"(*+#%#72#%2"*%#7*%"*$-5#%,=%2%
(,9>*#)#)/*%*/*+#?%9-$#%F*%$-F9)##*<%F8%#7*%)28%2+<%)A8B%,=%*2(7%9,+#7O%["*("-)#9*+#%,"%"*#*+#),+\%
o !55%DE!%+,+U=2(-5#8%)+("*2$*$%,/*"%SR%>*"(*+#%#72#%2"*%="8%#7*%"*$-5#%,=%2%(,9>*#)#)/*%*/*+#%9-$#%F*%$-F9)##*<%F8%#7*%)28%,=%*2(7%9,+#7O%
o :,"%=2(-5#8?%=,55,;%#7*%>-F5)$7*<%(25*+<2"%,+%#7*%!EP%;*F$)#*O%
P+.,)+.%<2#2%(5*2+->%2(#)/)#)*$%=,"%E*,>5*',=#%(,+/*"$),+O%%W72+G%8,-%=,"%
(,9>5)2+(*%2+<%2$$)$#2+(*O%
E5*2$*%$**%*92)5%=",9%12-")*%<2#*<%SSNSNS`%(,+#2)+)+.%)+=,"92#),+%,+%
E*,>5*!<9)+%(72+.*$N9,<)=)(2#),+$O%
E"),")#8%2>>5)(2+#$%+**<%#,%F*%)+#*"/)*;*<%
o 128,==%2+<%/*#*"2+K$%>"*=*"*+(*%
DE!%6*F%2+<%^_Y'%W"2)+)+.$%=,"%4!'%,+58%F*)+.%>52++*<O%%4,+#2(#%12(7,+82%
)=%)+#*"*$#*<O%
C8B$'(9/:08$2( 02+2.*"$K%0**#)+.%:,"92#A%W25G%#,%8,-"%$#2==%2+<%;*%;)55%<)$(-$$%)#%
2#%#7*%+*Z#%92+2.*"$K%9**#)+.%
o 6,-5<%8,-%5)G*%#,%(72+.*%#7*%9**#)+.$%#,%F*%*/*"8%9,+#7d%
6)#7%2>>,)+#*<%#)9*$%=,"%^_N:)+2+(*d%
o '7,-5<%'#-<*+#%'*"/)(*$%9**#%9,"*%#72+%e-2"#*"58d%
4,$#%4,<*$%c%_*>,"#$%)+%Y+=,E,"#*%9-$#%F*%"-+%$*>2"2#*58%)=%-$)+.%
9,"*%#72+%,+*%(,$#%(,<*%F*(2-$*%#7*%"*>,"#$%;)55%<,-F5*%#7*%
29,-+#$%-$*<O%[W7)$%;)55%F*%=)Z*<%)+%E*,>5*',=#\%
!##2(7*<%)$%2%C-$)+*$$%4*+#*"NX*2+K$%P==)(*%(,+#2(#%5)$#%#72#%72$%
*2(7%*9>5,8**K$%<-#)*$%5)$#*<%
o W7,$*%;7,%-$*%/,)(*,/*"%YE%72/*%#7*%2"*2%(,<*%f%>7,+*%
+-9F*"%5)$#*<%$,%8,-%G+,;%#,%<)25%#7*%;7,5*%+-9F*"%
!""
!"#$%"$&'($)*+$%"$,-".(''$/&0"&%$123$4(15($6)7$-(58'8"2'$
!# $%&'(")%"*+,"-./0"1))23044')35223#6(7#.86419:./4";# <%")%0"*+,-./"='(>"%("=.?)"15(8"7%=6@("A# <%")%"B68&.)"C&@)DB68&.)"E(F6'9G"
"H# *().9"I.259)@.()"JK")1.("7='7>")1."3.5971"/6))%(K".().9"577%6()"(6@/.9"'("?%9@5)";DLLLL!D
!A!M"%9"7='7>"%("@5&('?G'(&"&=533")%"3.."='3)"%?"577%6()"(6@/.93K")1.("7='7>"<N"O# P%"3.."?6(83"5Q5'=5/=."?9%@"=.5Q.3"5(8"/6G%6)3"=%%>"5)")1."&95G"7%=6@("75==.8"R*+,"S699.()"
BB,#T"U)%"3.."1%:"5(G"57)'%(3"'("29%&9.33"5??.7)"G%69"(6@/.93"7='7>"R31%:"29%V.7).8"'(?%TW"
"X# N(7."G%6"?'&69."%6)"1%:"@671"@%(.G"'3"5Q5'=5/=."'("G%69"!"577%6()"U;DLLLL!D!A!MW"5(8"(..83"
)%"/."@%Q.8"/53.8"%("/6G%6)"95).4=.5Q."5@%6()"&%")%"B68&.)"C&@)DB68&.)"I'3)9'/6)'%("Y# *().9"I.259)@.()"JK")1.("7='7>"%("@5&('?G'(&"&=533")%"'8.()'?G":1'71"577%6()"(6@/.9"G%6":5()"
)%"Q'.:K"%9".().9"'("?%9@5)"LDLLLLLDLLLLK")1.("7='7>"<N"Z# [%6":'=="@5>."G%69"715(&.3"'(")1."R*+,"S699.()"B68&.)T"7%=6@("%(=G"\# *().9")1."5@%6()"G%6":5()")%"@%Q.")%"G%69"'(3)967)'%(5="577%6()"/G"36/)957)'(&")1."5@%6()"'("
)1."2.93%(]3"(5@."5(8"588'(&")1."5@%6()")%")1."6(5==%75).8"='(.#"P1.3."):%"5@%6()3"31%6=8")%)5="^.9%#"S='7>"_5Q.#""
"!M# `%:"36/@')"G%69"`BL"9.Q'3'%(#"B."369.")%"'(7=68."(%).3"%(":1%")1."/6G%6)34=.5Q.3"59."?%9"5(8"
)1."5@%6()3"U3.."32.7'?'7"8'9.7)'%(3"%("25&.";W#"
;""
!"#$%"$&'()%($)*+$,-./0%$123$4(50,0"*,$6"'$7)8)'9$7)50*:,$;2-9"-%,<=()5(,>$!# P%"577.33")1."379..(K")G2."!"#$'(")1."379..("?'.=8"5(8"29.33".().9#"";# a9%@")1."`BL"379..(K"1')")1."%&$>.G"U)%"588W"?%9"?'93)"379..(")%"522.59#""A# +=57."5"R[T"'("7699.()"G.59K"U)1'3"'3"5").@2"/68&.)")95(3?.9"?%9"7699.()"G.59"%(=GW"H# P,B")%".().9"5"/9'.?"8.379'2)'%("U='@').8")%";M"715957).93W#"P1'3"8.379'2)'%("'3":15)":'=="/."3..("
%(")1."`BL"379..("U'(/%bW#"c%:.Q.9K")1'3"8.379'2)'%(":'=="(%)"522.59"'("ad_#""O# ,88"CE"J"X# +9.33"P,B">.G")%"@%Q.")1."7693%9")%")1.",77%6()"`6@/.9"?'.=8"5(8".().9")1."577%6()"(6@/.9"
5(8"%/V.7)"7%8."U?9%@"G%69"@5'("!"577%6()")%"G%69"'(3)967)'%(5="\"577%6()W#"Y# P,B")%")1."5229%29'5)."7%=6@("UE(79.53."%9"I.79.53.W"5(8".().9")1.":1%=."8%==59"5@%6()"?%9"
)15)"%/V.7)"7%8."U(%"7%@@53"(.7.3359GW#"Z# P,B")%"I.379'2)'%("?'.=8#"P1'3"?'.=8"'3"%2)'%(5=K"/6)"@5G"/."1.=2?6=":1.("G%6"9.Q'.:"a'(5(e..9K"
E(?%+%9).K"ad_K"5(8"G%69"3)5).@.()3#"E("a'(5(e..9K")1."7%().()3"%?")1'3"?'.=8"522.59"'(")1."7%=6@(")')=.8"EI#"*().9"62")%".=.Q.("715957).93")%"'8.()'?G")95(357)'%("U3671"53"([email protected]"2%3')'%("(6@/.9K"%9"2692%3.W#"
\# [%6"@5G"7%()'(6.")%".().9")95(3?.93#"P1."36@"%?")1."E(79.53."5@%6()"7%=6@("@63)")%)5=")1."36@"%?")1."I.79.53."5@%6()"7%=6@(#"
!M# N(7."5=="'(?%9@5)'%("'3".().9.8K"1')".().9")%"Q5='85).#","?%9@"(6@/.9":'==")1.("/."533'&(.8"5?).9")1."85)5"'3"Q.9'?'.8"'("577%985(7.":')1")1."/68&.)"96=.3#"E)":'=="75=76=5).")1."/5=5(7."%?"'(79.53.3K"(.)"%?"8.79.53.3"5(8"8'32=5G")1'3"/5=5(7."5)")1."/%))%@"%?")1."25&.#"
!!# +9.33"aX")%".().9")1."V63)'?'75)'%(#"+=.53."(%).")1."V63)'?'75)'%("%(")1."(%).258"'3"9.F6'9.8"/.?%9.")1."?%9@":'=="/."36/@')).8#"<'Q."5"/9'.?"8.379'2)'%("%?")1'3"/68&.)")95(3?.9#"-15)":'==")1.")95(3?.9"577%@2='31f"
.")95(3?.93"'(7=68.":1G"G%6"59.")95(3?.99'(&")1."?6(83K":1%")1.")95(3?.9"'3"?%9K":15)"7563.8")1."35=59G"35Q'(&3"U'."=.5Q."%9"/6G%6)W"5(8")1."8%==59"5@%6()#""gg-."3)9%(&=G"9.7%@@.(8")15)"G%6".().9")1."/6G%6)3"5(8"=.5Q.3"3.2595).=G"?%9".571"2.93%("/.7563.")1'3":'=="@5>."3)5??'(&":%9>=%58"@671".53'.9")%"@5(5&."'(")1."?6)69.":')1%6)"15Q'(&")%"=%%>"62")1."9.Q'3'%(3"'(")1."3G3).@#""
"