013-whataboutnivirnadipani

230
½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 1 ed AÁ me'D yeD b,f vJ ¿ ½SifÓP a½Tjrifwifq&mawmf rif;uGef; a½Tjrifwifawmif 1334ckESpf yXr0gqdkvqkwf 1 &uf

Upload: thwin-myint

Post on 14-Oct-2014

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Uploaded from Google Docs

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 1

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

½SifÓPa½Tjrifwifq&mawmf

rif;uGef;

a½Tjrifwifawmif1334ckESpf yXr0gqdkvqkwf 1 &uf

Page 2: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

2 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 3: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 3

rmwdum

trSwfpOf

taMumif;t&m pmrsufESm

1/

2/3/

4/5/6/7/

8/9/10/11/

12/13/14/

rmwdumtcsD;pum;

tcef;(1)ed'gef;

edAÁme'DyeDtm; okH;oyf&jcif;taMumif;edAÁme'DyeDtm; ½IMunfhykH

tcef;(2)aumuEk'fAdrmeftm; avYvmjcif;

edAÁme'DyeDtm; okH;oyfenf;edAÁmeft&aumufuGJí tusifYuGJonfvkyfief;rSefçrrSef yef;wdkifjzifYppf&rnfedAÁmefudk twdtusodzdkYvdkonf

tcef;(3)aumuEk'fAdrmef\ 'kwd,urÁnf;udkavYvmjcif;

edAÁmef[lonf b0wdkY\rjzpfjcif;avmvlonf a½SUb0çaemufb0udkodEdkifovm;pdwfwefcdk;qdkonfrSmwefcdk;onf vl\ rarG;rDESifYaoNyD;aemuf tjzpfudk odEdkifovm;ynmpGrf;jzifY vl\ a½SUb0aemufb0odEdkifovm;Ak'¨tbd"r®0g'\ tESpfom&udk,fYuHudk b,folupDrHzefwD;oenf;

311

1519

23253234

41444548

525356

Page 4: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

4 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

rmwdum

trSwfpOf

taMumif;t&m pmrsufESm

15/16/17/18/19/20/21/22/23/24/25/26/27/28/29/30/31/32/33/34/35/36/

BudKufjcif;onfvnf; qif;&JyifAk'tbd"r®0g'\ b0tjrif('óe)ynwfESifYy&rwfonf emewåjzpfovdk {uwåvnf;jzpfonfuHqdkwmbmvJb0[lonfb0\ taMumif;&if;b0\ tusdK;&if;uHESifY0dygufpdwfrsm; wom;wnf;jzpfo[Zmwur®ESifY ememu©Pduur®b0tusdK; 0dygufemrf½kyfb0[lonf pdwåu©PrQomb0tponf trd0rf;wGif;uavmy#doaE¨ç b0ifç pkwdpdwfrsm;trd0rf;wGif;ü tMunf½kyfrjzpfvl[lonf uHaMumifYjzpfaomowå0gokH;q,fYwpfbkHb0 jyóemokH;q,fYwpfbkHb0(=Oyywådb0)&ykHAk'tbd"r®m[m bmvJvlYb0 b,fu&oenf;a,musfm;çrdef;r b,fvdkaMumifYuGJjym;&oenf;vlwdkY\ rwlaomtjzpfrsm; bmaMumifYuGJjym;jcm;em;&ovJtoufwdkjcif;ç½Snfjcif; taMumif;&if;

57636669717274788285878890929394949899103107109

Page 5: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 5

rmwdum

trSwfpOf

taMumif;t&m pmrsufESm

37/38/39/40/41/42/43/44/45/46/47/48/49/50/51/52/53/54/55/56/57/58/

a&m*genf;jcif;çrsm;jcif; taMumif;&if;½kyfqdk;jcif;çvSjcif; taMumif;&if;rdwfaqGenf;jcif;çrsm;jcif;ESifY MoZmtmPm taMumif;&if;Opömypönf;jynfhpkHjcif;ESifY rGJjcif; taMumif;&if;,Ofaus;jrifYjrwfaomZmwd ½Sdçr½Sd taMumif;&if;ÓPfxufjcif;çEkHUjcif; taMumif;&if;uHowådqdkwm bmvJedAÁmef'DyeDq&m\ b0tjrifbmvJy&rw¬t½Sd0g'onf Ak'0g'r[kwft½Sdqdkwm bmvJtedpöonf y&rwft½Sdjytcsdefudk jiif;qdkonfhpum;y&rwfESifYynwforkwdopömESifY y&rw¬opöm orbm*jzpftxufopöma&mufaomfvnf; atmufopömrysuftjzpfESifYt½Sdonf twlavmt½Sdw&m;tppfonf Nidrf;a;jcif;oabm,aeYbk&mYomoemonf vd*Fomoemtjzpf a&muf½Sdr½SdESifYt½Sdonf twljzpfí tcsdefjzifYwdkif;r&'ku©onf y&rwft½SdjytoGiftjyifudk jiif;qdkonfhpum;tewåonf y&rwft½Sdjyae&mXmeudk jiif;qdkonfhpum;y&rw¬t½Sd0g'onf Ak'¨0g'ESifY vm;vm;rQrywfoufy&rw¬t½Sd0g'onf pdwåZ0g'

112113116118124125130131137139140146150152157159161163167171172173

Page 6: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

6 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

rmwdum

trSwfpOf

taMumif;t&m pmrsufESm

59/60/61/62/

63/64/65/

66/67/68/69/

tcef;(4)edAÁmefonf wefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;onf tqdktay:

okH;oyfcsufedAÁmefonf wefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;ovm;edAÁmefa&mufaomaMumifY &m*ukefjcif;avmopömav;csufonf tcsdefrjcm; wNydKifeufvnfonfysufaomopömrsm;

tcef;(5)tEkyg'daooedAÁmefonf 0dygufemru©Em t<uif;rJY

csKyfqkH;jcif;vm;oOyg'daooESifYtEkyg'daooedAÁmeftekyg'daooedAÁmefonf &[EÅmwdkY\edAÁmefoOyg'daooedAÁmefonf atmuft&d,mwdkY\edAÁmef

tcef;(6)oknwçtedrdwåçtyÜPd[dwedAÁmef pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

oknwedAÁmefponfoknwedAÁmef t&aumuftrSefcE¨mESifYedAÁmefonf tNydKifjyKí rpyfEdkiftedrdwåESifY tyÜPd[dwedAÁmef t&aumuftrSef

179183185187

191194203

207209210213

Page 7: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 7

rmwdum

trSwfpOf

taMumif;t&m pmrsufESm

tcef;(7)edAÁmefonf t½Sd-ponftay: pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

edAÁmeftrSef½SdaMumif; azmfjyykHtay: pdppfcsufedAÁmef\ tjrifYqkH;Nidrf;csrf;rIjzpfykH okH;oyfcsuf

tcef;(8)edAÁme'DyeD okH;oyfcsuf tcsKyfpum;

edAÁme'DyeDtay: NcKHikHokH;oyfcsufedAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ ed*kH;

70/71/

72/73/

219223

227228

Page 8: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

8 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 9: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 9

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

½SifÓPa½Tjrifwifq&mawmf

rif;uGef;

a½Tjrifwifawmif1334ckESpf yXr0gqdkvqkwf 1 &uf

Page 10: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

10 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 11: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 11

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

1/ tcsD;pum;av;pm;tyfaom q&mawmfBuD;wpfyg;xHrS v,fwDq&mawmf\

]edAÁme'DyeD} trnf½Sdaom pmtkyfudk zwf½IcGifY &cJYonf/ þpmtkyfudk zwf&aomtcg þpmünTefjyaom edAÁmefonf ,aeY Ak'bmom0ifvlxk em;vnfaeaom edAÁmef jzpfEdkif&monf[k av;pm;,kHMunfrdayonf/ odkYaomfvnf; þedAÁmefESifYpyfvsOf;í wkHUjyefaompdwfxm;rsm; pma&;olü wzGm;zGm;cHpm;vm&onf/

þedAÁmefonf tu,fyif Ak'vrf;nTefjycJYaom edAÁmefavm-[líjzpfonf/ þedAÁmefonf Ak'toQifnTefjycJYaom edAÁmefrS aoGznfvsuf½Sdonf-[k pma&;olü aumufcsufcs xGufay:aecJYavonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]edAÁme'DyeD}-udk okH;oyfa0zefNyD; ]edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ}[lí wifjyvdkpdwfrsm; pma&;olxHrS ½kef;uef xGufvmMuygonf/

xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; þtqdkudk qdk&efoifYçroifYudk tqifYqifYcsifY& csdef&ayonf/ tb,fhaMumifYqdkaomf edAÁme'DyeDudk jyKpkarG;zGm;ay;cJYaom v,fwDq&mawmfBuD;um; omoemü jrifYrdk&fwrQ cdkifcefYawmfrlcJYaom q&mawmfBuD; jzpfaomaMumifY jzpfonf/ tusifYodu©m t&vnf;aumif;? yd#uwftwwfynm t&vnf;aumif;? vlay;olay; bGJUaygif;rsm;pGmESifY obm0tavsmuf&aom bGJUaygif;rsm;pGmudk ydkifqdkifawmfrlaom?jrefrmESifY jrefrmhtjyif urÇmwdkifatmif xif½Sm;ausmfMum;cJYaom q&mawmfBuD; jzpfayonf/ wynfhwyef;t&vnf; avmuD? avmukwå&mpG,fpkH&aom wynfhwyef; txift½Sm;rsm;udk rsm;pGmarG;xkwf jyKpkawmfrlEdkifaom q&mawmfBuD; jzpfayonf/

Page 12: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

12 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYjyifvnf; q&mpOfquftm;jzifY ax&0g' tpOfrjywfbJ ax&0g' t,ltqrS wpfz0g; rwdrf;aomaMumifY tvGefcdkifcefYaomt,ltqaemufcH½Sdonf[k qdk&rnf/

þodkYaomtaMumif;rsm;aMumifY þrnfaom? jrifYrdk&fwrQ BuD;rm;aom q&mawmfBuD;tm; xdyg;aomtqdkudkqdkvsif jrifYrdk&fawmifudk vufoD;jzifYxdk;ol jzpfaervm;-[k csifYcsdef&jcif; jzpfygonf/

jrifYrdk&fawmifudk vufoD;jzifYxdk;jcif;onf BuD;rm;aomtEÅ&m,fudk&Edkifygonf/ vlonf pdwfvIyf½Sm;rI taMumif;uav; wpfckrSsjzifY BuD;rm;aomtEÅ&m,fudk tvG,fwul 0ifcGifYray;oifYaMumif; owdjyK&ygrnf/

odkYaomfvnf; pma&;olonf -]tv,fvrf; tawG;tac:orm;} jzpfygonf/Ak'xkwfazmfnTefjycJYaom tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:udk teuf½Idif;

qkH; OD;nTwfvsuf½Sdol jzpfygonf/xdktawG;tac:onf avmuü tazG;tvuf tawmufajymif

qkH;aom opöm/ xdkopömonf tu,fí tm;rmef0ifvsuf toufxif½Sm;½Sdonf[kqdkvsif tEÅ&m,frSeforSs uif;pifvGifYaysmuf ra&mufrvmbJ½Sd&rnf[k ,kHMunfol jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY toG,foG,faom tEÅ&m,ftMum;rS pm½Iolrsm; awGUjrifEdkif&ef þusrf;udk BudK;pm;í arG;zGm;azmfxkwfvdkuf&ygonf/

þtcsdefrSpí pm½IolwdkY ESvkH;twGif;ü oefY½Sif;aom opömrsm;twGuf ae&may;Edkifaom tcGifYtvrf;rsm; jzpfxGef;ygap/

þpmonfvnf; axmufulEdkifygap/½SifÓP

rif;uGef; 1334ckESpf? yXr0gqdkvqkwf 1 &uf

Page 13: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 13

tcef;(1)

ed'gef;

Page 14: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

14 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 15: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 15

tcef;(1)ed'gef;

2/ edAÁme'DyeDtm; okH;oyf&jcif;taMumif;]edAÁme'DyeD}onf edAÁmefESifYpyfí wnfaqmufxm;aom taumif;

qkH;aom taqmuftODav; jzpfonf/ ]edAÁme'DyeD}onf edAÁmefESifYpyfíwnfaqmufcJYMuaom a½S;taqmuftODrsm;\ trSm;rsm;udk z,f½Sm;vsufoyfoyf,yf,yf wnfaqmufxm;aom taqmuftOD jzpfonf/

xdka½S;u taqmuftOD [lonfrsm;rSm ]*rÇD&m*rÇD& r[medAÁLw'DyeD}ESifY ]edAÁmeo½ly'DyeD} ponfwdkY jzpfMuayonf/ þtrSm;rsm;udk½IMunfhodjrifNyD;olwdkYtaeESifY þ]edAÁme'DyeD}udk ½IMunfhvsif þedAÁme'DyeD\tvSonf vufzspfwD;í tHYcsD;rukef jzpf&zG,f ½Sdayonf/

edAÁme'DyeDonf taMumif;t&m tm;jzifYvnf;aumif;? toGifoP²meftm;jzifYvnf;aumif; yDjyifjcif;? cefYxnfjcif;? oefY½Sif;jcif;? vTrf;rdk;jcif;?ysHUESHYjcif;paom t&nftcsif;aumif;rsm;jzifY a0qmvsuf½SdonfudkawGU&ayrnf/

xdkodkYjzpfaomaMumifY edAÁme'DyeDudk Munfh½IolwdkYonf tm;pdkufítxl;Munfhae&ef rvdktyfawmhbJ rsufapYyom'udk tvdktavsmuf 'a&maomyg; qGJac:oGm;cH&ouJYodkY jzpf&ayonf/ NyD;vsif xdkol\ESvkH;pdwf0rf;ü jynfhvSsrf;auseyfrIrsm; jzpfyGm;NyD; atmufyg tmar#dwfoHrsm; ay:xGufvm&ayonf/

]tif;-½Sif;oGm;wmyJ/ [kwfayom;yJ/ wpfcgwnf; em;vnfoGm;wmyJ/ edAÁmefeJYpyfNyD;awmh b0ifusayaygh}}ponfjzifY jzpfavonf/ ]edAÁme'DyeD}onf omoemrS4if;? avmurS4if;? usrf;taxGaxGrS oabmw&m;rsm;jzifY wnfaqmufvsuf aMumif;usdK;,kwådrsm;udk tcsufususoGif;NyD;

Page 16: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

16 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

½Sif;vif;wnfaqmufxm;aomt&m jzpfavonf/xdkYaMumifY ]edAÁme'DyeD}-[laom taqmuftODonf avmuü

tvSqkH;aom aumuEk'fAdrmef taqmuftODuav; jzpfíaeavonf/avmuü aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;wpfck ½SdonfqdktHY/xdkAdrmefuav;onf rxd&ufaom ajymuftrTrf;wdkYjzifY apYapYpyf

pyf wnfaqmufxm;aomaMumifY ½IMunfYolwdkY rsufESmrvTJcsifatmifb0ifusNyD; at;jrrI&oudk cHpm;&rI jzpfaponfqkdtHY/ xdkaumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onf ]edAÁme'DyeD} jzpfavonf/

[kwfyg\/ þ ]edAÁme'DyeD}wnf;[laom aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onfvnf; Munfh½Iol b,folwkYdudkrqdkwdkYtm; qGJ,lnIdUiif rcGgcsifatmif½Sdapavonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]edAÁme'DyeD}[laom xdktaqmuftODuav;onf vSrsdK;<u,faom aumuEk'fAdrmefuav; jzpfygawmhonf/

,if;aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;um; Mobmvufckyf tjynfh&aomAdrmefuav; jzpfayonf/ ,if;Adrmefuav;udk ½IMunfholrsm;onf yk*¾dKvftrsdK;rsdK; ½Sdavonf/ xdkyk*¾Kdvfrsm;onf-

wnfaqmufrIudk a½SUwef;wifxm;Muaom yk*¾Kdvfrsm;?tokH;csrIudk a½SYwef;wifxm;Muaom yk*¾Kdvfrsm;ESifYomrefvlrsm; jzpfMuavonf/aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onfum; xdkokH;rsdK;okH;pm;aom Munfh½Iol

y&dowfwdkYtm; qGJ,lnIdYiif rcGgcsifatmif ½SdapEdkifayonf/þyk*¾KdvfokH;pm;wGif y&d,wf(pmay)ynm½Sifrsm;onf wnfaqmufrI

udk a½SUwef;wifxm;Muaom yk*¾Kdvfrsm; jzpfMuayonf/ þy&d,wfpmayynm½SifwdkYonf aumuEk'fAdrmefudk ½IMunfh&mü Adrmefuav;\ ydokumynm (y&d,wfpmayynm)jzifY wnfaqmufxm;[efudk tav;xm; ½Ipm;Muayonf/

Page 17: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 17

aumuEk'fAdrmefudk zefqif;wnfaqmufolum; txufrSqdkcJYNyD;onfhtwdkif; y&d,wf(pmay)wnf;[laom ydokumynmü aqu(vdr®mjcif;)? aum0d'(wwfodjcif;)? 0d'l(uRrf;usifjcif;)? yg&*l(wpfzufurf;a&mufwwfajrmufjcif;)ponfjzifY obm0ay; bGJU*kPfwdkY txyfxyfxkHNyD; rTrf;NyD;ol jzpfonfhtm;avsmfpGm tjypfrsdK;rxif uif;pifatmif wnfaqmufcJYayonf/

xdkYaMumifY xdkolwdkYrsufapYü aumuEk'fAdrmefonf xnfjcif;?0gjcif;? cefYnm;jcif;rsm;vnf; ½Sdonfhtjyif tdjcif;? EGJYjcif;? oGJUaysmif;jcif;rsm;vnf; ½Sdaeonffudk awGUjrifMu&avonf/

xdkYtjyifvnf; aumuEk'fAdrmefonf ordkif;vufusef tajymuftrTrf;rSeforQ ukefvdkYrSonfvnf; axG;jcif;? vdrf;jcif;? ½Iyf½Sufcwfjcif;tvsOf;r½SdbJaeonfudk awGU½SdMu&avonf/

olwdkYonf aumuEk'fAdrmef\ &yf[efwnf[ef tedrfhtjrifY tuGufyEéufrsm; tpp nDnGwfajyjypf[efudk awGYjrifMu&í xdkAdrmefuav;\tnIdUtiif vGifYpifvGwfxGufatmifyif r½kef;EkdifbJ ½SdMuayonf/

xdkYtjyif tokH;csrIudk a½SYwef;wifMunfhMuaom yk*¾dKvfrsm;um;y#dywform;rsm; jzpfMuayonf/ olwdkYonf aumuEk'fAdrmefudk ½IMunfh&mü tokH;usrIudk a½SUwef;wifí MunfhMuavonf/

olwdkY\rsufapYü aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onf tvsm;teH b,favmufus,fovJ/ tcef;ao; tcef;BuD;rsm; b,fykHzGJUxm;ovJ/ wuf&qif;&rnfhvrf;u b,fvdkvJ/tvif;tarSmifu b,fvdkaeovJ/ av0ifavxGuf ½Sdovm;çr½Sdovm;-tpp tokH;ESifY ajyjypfjcif;½Sdr½Sdudk ½IMunfhMuavonf/ aumuEk'fAdrmefonf olwdkY\ tokH;csrsufapYü tpp tokH;usonf[k xifjrifí rcGgcsifatmif ½SdMuavonf/

Page 18: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

18 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

<uif;aom usefMunfholrsm;um; aumuEk'fAdrmefudk ½IMunfholrsm; y&dowfü ta&;ygolrsm; r[kwfMuawmhay/

xdkolrsm;um; cHpm;rIudk a½SYwef;wifMuaomyk*¾dKvfrsm; jzpfMuayonf/ olwdkYonf bmomw&m;udk o'g"gwftm;jzifY qnf;uyfaeMuaomAk'bmom0ifrsm; jzpfMuavonf/ olwdkYü aumuEk'fAdrmef\ taumif;tqdk;ESifY taMumif;tusdK;udk tu,fodjrifEdkifaom rsufapYrsm;½SdMuonfr[kwfay/

olwdkYonfvnf; aumuEk'fAdrmefudk awGU&aomtcg tHYMocsD;usL;MunfEl;rqkH; ½SdMuavonf/ [kwfygonf/ aumuEk'fAdrmefonf olwdkYrsufapYudk tHYMocsD;usL; rMunfEl;EdkifbJ raeEdkifatmif owådrsm; ½SdMuayonf/ olwdkYonf taumif;ESifYtqdk;? taMumif;ESifYtusdK;udk odwwfaomynmt&nftcsif;rsm; r½SdMu[líyif qdk&aomfvnf; awmufajymifjcif;?xnf0gjcif;? ausmfMum;jcif;rsm;udkrl olwdkY cHpm;wwfMuayonf/

xdkYaMumifY olwdkYonfvnf; aumuEk'fAdrmefudk awGU&aomtcgtwkrJYAdrmef? wpfckwnf;aomAdrmefponfjzifY tHhMocsD;usL;? tMunfEl;BuD;MunfEl;NyD; xdkAdrmefuav;rS rsufESmrvTJcsif ½SdaeMuavonf

þodkYyif aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onf Munfh½Iolwdkif;\ Mobmvufckyfudk tjynfht0&aom Adrmefuav; jzpfayonf/ þAdrmefuav;udk ½IMunfholwdkif;onf olwdkY\rsufapYrsm;udk þAdrmefuav;rS rcGgcsifatmif qGJ,lnIdUiifrIudk cHMu&onfcsnf; jzpfavonf/ xdkYaMumifY olwdkYonf þAdrmefuav;udk olwdkY\ MobmvufckyfoHrsm;jzifY oGef;avmif;Mu&avonf/

Page 19: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 19

3/ edAÁme'DyeDtm; ½IMunfhykHpma&;olonf þAdrmefuav;udk ½IMunfh&mü-]tv,fvrf;tawG;tac: ynmrsufapY}-jzifY ½IMunfhygonf/y&d,wf(pmay)orm;rsm;uJYodkY wnfaqmufrIrsufapYjzifYvnf;

rMunfhyg/y#dywform;rsm;uJYodkY tokH;csrIrsufapYjzifYvnf; r½IMunfhyg/omrefvlrsm;vkd cHpm;rIrsufapYjzifYvnf; r½IMunfhyg/xdkYaMumifY olwdkYçolwdkYjrifouJYodkY þaumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onf

vufckyfMobm oGef;xdkufaom Adrmefuav;[k rjrifjcif; jzpfygonf/þpma&;ol\ tv,fvrf;rsufapYü-þaumuEk'fAdrmefuav;onf tay:,H a½TrIefYusJxm;aom

txJrS EGm;acs;ç½THUap;ESifY aumuf½dk;EG,fç0g;jcrf;rsm;jzifYcHí wnfaqmufxm;aom Adrmefom jzpfaeayonf/

qdkvdkonfrSm pma&;ol\ tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:rsufapYü-]þAdrmefonf wu,f tokH;cscHEdkifaomAdrmef r[kwf/ rSefbD½dk?

zefaygif;acsmifrsm;wGif; oGif;xm;&rnfh [efjyAdrmefuav;om[k jzpfonf/þAdrmefonf tu,ftokH;jyKEdkifaom oH? opfom;?a½T? aiGtppfwdkYjzifYwnfaqmufxm;aom a½TAdrmefr[kwf/ EGm;acs;? ½THYap;wdkYjzifY wnfaqmufxm;aom a½TrIefusJ ½THUap;Adrmefomjzpfonf}-[k wifjyvdkygonf/

þpum;onf trSefudkqdkaompum; jzpfygonf/þpum; rSefESifYrrSefudk pm½Iolrsm;ukd,fwdkif w&m;olBuD;vkyfí

qkH;jzwfEdkif&ef þpma&;olu avSsmufvJvdkygonf/pm½Iolonf trSefudkjrwfEdk;í trSefudktm;udk;ygvsif þavQmuf

vJcsufudk NidfrfoufpGm ½IMunfhapvdkygonf/ rme? tmCmwpaom qdk;npfaomw&m;rsm; pdk;pOf;rQ todktxm;r½SdbJ t½Sdudk t½Sdtwdkif; awGUjrifod½Sd

Page 20: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

20 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Edkif&ef pma&;olu BudK;pm;í avQmufxm;wifqufrnf jzpfygonf/trSefudkjrwfEdk;aomtm;jzifY BudK;pm;í ½IMunfh em;qifEdkifMu yg

apownf;/

Page 21: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 21

tcef;(2)

aumuEk'fAdrmeftm;avYvmjcif;

Page 22: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

22 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 23: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 23

tcef;(2)aumuEk'fAdrmeftm;avYvmjcif;

4/ edAÁme'DyeDtm; okH;oyfenf;aumuEk'fAdrmefudk ]a½TAdrmefr[kwf? a½TrIefusJAdrmef}-[k pma&;ol

tqdkjyKcJYygonf/ þtjrifudk tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:rsufapYjzifYjrifonf[kvnf; qdkcJYygonf/

xdktjrifonf tjcm;olrsm;udkyg awGUjrifatmif rwifjyEdkifvsifpdwåZtjrifvnf; jzpfEdkifygonf/ þodkYr[kwfaMumif; tcdkiftrm wifjyEdkif&ygrnf/

xdkodkYwifjy&mü þAdrmefuav;udk ESpfrsdK;ESpfpm;tm;jzifY avYvmwifjy&ygrnf/ ]yXrtrsdK;}-rSmè

þaumuEk'fAdrmefuav;\ ywf0ef;usif0Jç,mrS tpteuav;rsm;udk avYvmtuJcwfjcif; jzpfygonf/

]usefwpfrsdK;}-rSmèxdkAdrmefuav;\ tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;udk qdwfzJYcsdK;Nzwfí

avYvmMunfh½Ijcif;rsdK; jzpfygonf/þavYvmrI ESpfrsdK;vkH;rSm tay:,H a½TrIefusJ? ½THUap;Adrmef jzpfonf

udk od½Sd&rnf jzpfygonf/ pm½IolwdkYtm; a½TAdrmefr[kwfaMumif; avQmufvJwifjy&mü yXravYvmrIjzifY a½S;OD;pGm wifjyygrnf/

tdk - av;pm;tyfol-uREkfyfESifYtwl aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;udk tajy;tvTm;avQmufNyD;

wpfywfavmuf vSnfhMunfhMuygpdkY/]awGUygNyD}/ aumuEk'fAdrmef\ wpfae&mrSm trSwftom; urÁnf;

ESpfck/ ,if;rSm þaumuEk'fAdrmefudk wnfaqmufol\b0udk azmfjyxm;

Page 24: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

24 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

aom urÁnf;rsm; jzpfygonf/,if;urÁnf;ESpfckudk awGUaomae&mrSm aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;\

152? 166wdkYwGif jzpfygonf/,if;urÁnf;rSm atmufygtwdkif; jzpfygonfè(1) ]edAÁmefpum;onf rSm;rnf?wdrf;rnf tvGefBuD; aMumifYMuzG,f

r½Sd}-[kvnf;aumif;?(2) ]omoemtwGif;ü vljzpfíae&aom ,ckb0onf edAÁmefESifY

teD;qdkufaeaom b0aywnf;/ aovGefí omoemr½Sd&müvnf;aumif;? tyg,füvnf;aumif;jzpfcJYaomf ,ckqdkufvkeD;yg;aeaomedAÁmefESifY MumavçMumav uGmvSrf;íoGm;jyefav\}-[kvnf;aumif;? jzpfygonf/

aumuEk'fAdrmefudk avYvm&mrS þawGU½Sdcsufonf a½TAdrmefr[kwfaMumif; yXravYvmcsufjzifY wifjyEdkifaom awGU½Sdcsuf jzpfygonf/[kwfygonf/ þawGU½Sdcsuf urÁnf;rsm;onf aumuEk'fAdrmefudk zefqif;ol\b0udk azmfjyaeaomurÁnf;rsm; jzpfygonf/þawGU½SdcsufurÁnf;rsm;t&aumuEk'fAdrmefudk zefqif;wnfaqmufol\ b0onf tb,f jzpfowJYenf;/

olYb0onf zefqif;wnfaqmufolawmY zefqif;wnfaqmufoltrSefyifjzpfonf/ þtaMumif;udkrl þurÁnf;udk rawGUrDuyif od½SdEdkifNyD;jzpfonf/ tb,fhaMumifYqdkaomf þAdrmefudk olaqmufxm;onfudk odNyD;jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

xdkYaMumifY þawGU½SdcsufurÁnf;rsm;jzifY olYb0udkavYvm&efvdkonfrSm ol\ zefqif;wnfaqmufrI ydokumb0onf a½Tç aiGç oHçopfom;-ponfudk zefqif;wnfaqmufaom ydokumavm? jrufç 0g;jcrf;ç½THUap;çEGm;acs;wdkYjzifY zefqif;wnfaqmufaom ydokumb0avm/ þodkY

Page 25: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 25

om avYvmzdkY½Sdonf[lí jzpfygonf/þAdrmefrS awGU½Sdcsuf urÁnf;rsm;onf þAdrmefaqmufol\ b0

udk a½TAdrmefydokumb0ESifY a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumb0? tb,fjzpfonf[k nTefjyEdkifygoavm- nTefjyEdkifonf[k ajym&ygrnf/

þurÁnf;rsm;onf þAdrmef wnfaqmufzefqif;ol\b0udka½TAdrmefydokum r[kwf? a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumb0[k txift½Sm;azmfjyaeygonf/ awGU½Sdaom urÁnf;ESpfckteuf ESpfckpvkH;uyif olYb0\a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumb0jzpfaMumif; odomxif½Sm;apygonf/

þtaMumif;rsm; jywfom;vmap&ef atmufwGif tus,fw0ifY½Sif;vif;ygrnf/

yXrurÁnf;rSmè]edAÁmefpum;onf rSm;rnf?wdrf;rnf tvGefBuD; aMumifYMupdk;&drfzG,f

r½Sd}-[lí jzpfonf/ þonfudk yXr ½Sif;ygrnf/]edAÁmefrSm;rnf pdk;&drfzG,fr½Sd}-qdkvsif tb,fonf rSm;rnf pdk;&drf

owJYenf;/]aAm"dyu©d,rsm; rrSm;bdkYom pdk;&drf&onf}-[lownf;/þü ]aAm"dyu©d,}t& ]edAÁmef}rygaom aAm"dyu©d,udk ,l&ay

rnf/ ]edAÁmef}udk oD;jcm;qdkNyD; jzpfaomaMumifYyif/ xdkYaMumifY ]aAm"dyu©d,}t& ]edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;tusifYw&m;}-[líom t&aumufMuygpdkY/

xdkYaMumifY ]edAÁmef}pum;onf rSm;rnf? wdrf;rnf-tvGefBuD;aMumifYMupdk;&drfzG,fr½Sd}-[laom pum;\ teuft"dyÜg,fonf -

]edAÁmefodzdkY ta&;rBuD;? edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;tusifYudk usifYzdkYomta&;BuD;onf}-[lí aumufcsufcsEdkifygonf/

pm½Iol tb,fodkY oabm&ygovJ¿

Page 26: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

26 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]edAÁmefukdodzdkY ta&;rBuD;? edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;usifYzdkY ta&;BuD;onf}-qdkaomþtqdkudk b,fodkY oabm&ygovJ/

]edAÁmef}onf ]edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;tusifY\ tusdK;}-yif jzpfonf/]tusdK;}qdkí tjiif;yGm;zdkYvnf; vuf½kH; rqefYwef;vdkufapcsifyg/ ZeuusdK;rsdK;udk rqdkvdkaMumif; odapcsifygonf/ edAÁmefonf edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;tusifY\ ]orÜmyutusdK;}-yif jzpfygonf/

]tusdK;}jzpfaom edAÁmefudkrodbJ (trSefudkrodbJ)? taMumif;jzpfaom edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;tusifYudk b,folonf b,fodkYaomapwemjzifY usifYrnfenf;/

avmuü tusdK;aus;Zl;udk rodrjrifbJ tusifYtvkyfudk jyKEdkifaomolrsm; ½Sdygoavm/ ½Sdvsif xdkolwdkYonf tb,folwdkYenf;/ tao;qkH;vufvkyfulvDutp tBuD;qkH; voGm;N*dK[foGm;jcif;ESifY urÇmppfwdkufjcif;rsm;txd tm;vkH;onf tusdK;udkwnfaqmufzdkY odkYr[kwf tusdK;udkumuG,fzdkY vkyfaeMuonfcsnf; jzpfonf/ tusdK;udkrodbJESifY taMumif;udkzefwD;aeol-[líum; aMumif;usdK;nDnGwfaomavmuü vkH;0r½SdEdkif/

usdK;aMumif; usdK;jywfaeaom odkYr[kwf aMumif;usdK; oaErwnfao;aom t½l;çuav;i,fESifY tdyfaeolwdkYüom aMumif;usdK;rodbJtaMumif;udk vkyfaumif;vkyfaeayvdrfYrnf/

odkYaomfvnf; xdkolwpfpkum; avmuü pum;t&mr0ifaom]taAÁm[m&du}wpfpkom jzpfayonf/ ajymavmufçqdkavmufç ta&;,lavmufaom avmuüum; aMumif;usdK;udk rodjrifbJ taMumif;udkjyKvkyfwnfaqmufaeNyD-[lí vkH;0r½Sday/ pm½Ionf þt&mudk ÓPfzGifYrnfqdkvsif ÓmPfzGifYolwdkif;yif yGifYvif;pGm trSeftwdkif; us,fus,fjyefYjyefYodEdkifcGifY½Sdygonf/ xdkYaMumifY tusdK;udkrodbJ taMumif;udkvkyfzdkY-qdkonfudkvufajr§mufvdkufMuygpdkY/

Page 27: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 27

qufvufí tusdK;udk jywfjywfom;om;rodbJ taMumif;rSefudkvkyfEdkifçrvkyfEdkifudk aqG;aEG;Edkifygao;onf/ ]edAÁmefonf rSm;rnfçwdrf;rnf?tvGefBuD; aMumifYMupdk;&drfzG,fr½Sd}-[laompum;ü ]enf;enf;yg;yg;odvsifNyD;wmyJ}-[laom t"dyÜg,fvnf; xGufoifYoavmuf xGufaeygonf/

qdkvdkonfrSmè]edAÁmefudk odyfodaezdkY rvdkygbl;/ tusifYudk usifYzdkYyJodw,f/ edAÁmefudkawmY enf;enf;yg;yg; odvsifNyD;wmyJ}-

[kvnf; wpfcsuftm;jzifY qdkvdk&m a&mufayonf/þtqdkudkawmY pm½Iol b,fodkYoabm&ygoenf;/edAÁmefudk rSefuefonfhtqifYtxd rod½SdbJ edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;

tusifYudk rSefuefatmif usifYEdkifygrnfavm/ ]edAÁmefudk odyfodaezdkYrvdk}-[laom t"dyÜg,fonf edAÁmefESifYpyfí wdusjywfom;atmif odzdkYrvdk-[kqdkvdkonf/

avmuü b,fvkyfief;rqdkonf xdkvkyfief;\ yef;wdkifudk ]tEkaAm"-od}-[kac:aom tavsmfod(tEkrme-od)}tm;jzifY4if;? ]t0aAm"-od}ac:aom udk,fwdkifod? ypöu©-odtm;jzifY4if;/ ,if;todESpfyg; wpfyg;yg;jzifYodNyD;rS aocsmaomvkyfief;-[k qdkcGifY½Sdygonf/ odkYr[kwfvsif xdkvkyfief;onf ra&&maomvkyfief;-[k qdkcGifY ½Sdygonf/ (0g) qdk&ma&mufayonf/ ]t0aAm"-od}-[lonfrSm trSeftwdkif; NyD;jynfhpkHatmifod? tukefod/ xrif;qmí 00pm;\/ tJ'gvdkod&ef ]00BuD;odwm}udk qdkvdkygonf/

þpum;t& aumufcsufxGufvmonfrSmè]vkyfief;wpfckü trSm;trSef rSwfausmufonf ]yef;wdkif}-jzpfonf/

xdkYtwl yef;wdkif\ trSm;trSef rSwfausmufonfvnf; ]vkyfief;}yifjzpfrnf}-rSmvnf; ajymzG,fr½Sdyg/ þaumufcsufrsm; xGufvmygonf/

Page 28: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

28 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]vkyfief;rSef? vkyfief;rSm;}-udk yef;wdkifrSwfausmufjzifY pHwifqkH;jzwf&rnfqdkaom pum;onf orkwde,fy,fwGif opömusaom pum; jzpfygonf/ Oyrmè vrf;oGm;jcif;onf vkyfief;jzpfygonf/ oGm;jcif;\ tqkH;yef;wdkifudk a&mufjcif;onf xdkvrf;oGm;jcif;\ vkyfief;trSefjzpfaMumif;oufaoom"uyif jzpfygonf/ yef;wkdifudk ra&mufjcif;onfvnf; oGm;jcif;vkyfief;\ rSm;,Gif;jcif;jy oufaoom"uyif jzpfygonf/

xdkYtwl pm;0wfaea&;qdkif&m vkyfief;rsm;\ trSm;ESifYtrSefudkpm;0wfaea&;jynfpkHjcif; rjynfhpkHjcif;[laom vkyfief;\ qdkufjcif;?rjynfhpkHjcif;[laomvkyfief;\ tqdkufa&mufcHyef;wdkifudkMunfhNyD; qkH;jzwf&avonf/

xdkYaMumifY vkyfief;\ trSm;ESifYtrSefudk pHxdk;p&mum; ]yef;wdkif}-om jzpfonf[laom pum;onf orkwde,fy,fü opömusaompum;trSefyif jzpfonf/

5/ edAÁmefteufaumufuGJí tusifYuGJonfxdkpum;rsm;rSefcJYvsif yef;wdkifjzpfaom edAÁmefudk aocsma&&matmif

rodbJ vkyfief;jzpfaom edAÁmefa&mufaMumif;tusifY aAm"dyu©d,w&m;udktrSefusatmif b,fodkYusifYrnfenf;/ edAÁmefudk aocsma&&matmif rodbJedAÁmefa&mufaMumif; aAm"dyu©d,tusifYudk rSefuefatmif rusifYEdkifbJ½dS&rnfrSm trSefyif jzpfonf/

]edAÁmef}udk trSeftuefrS tenf;i,frQ wdrf;apmif;aom teuft"dyÜg,ftm;jzifY todjzpfaponf qdktHh/ edAÁmefa&mufaMumif; tusifYjzpfaom aAm"dyu©d,tusifYonfvnf; edAÁmefodkYra&mufaom vGJrSm;aomtusifY jzpf&mygrnf/ xdkpum;udk oabmusEdkifatmif avmuudk us,fus,fjyefYjyefY rsufvTmyifYí MunfhoifYygonf/

Page 29: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 29

urÇmYEdkifiHa&;avmuü vIyfvIyf½Suf½SufjzifY rNidrfrouf jzpfaeygonf/ xdkodkYjzpf&jcif;taMumif;onf ]EdkifiHawmftmPm}qdkaom pum;vkH;uav; wpfvkH;wnf;\ teuft"dyÜg,fudk tenf;i,frQpDuGJvGJaomt"dyÜg,fzGifYqdkcsufjzifY odaerIrsm; uGJvGJMuaomaMumifY jzpfonf/

xdkYtwlyif þwdkif;jynfü olykefolueftrsm;ESifY tkyfcsKyfolwdkY\y#dyu©rsm;onfvnf; pum;vkH;wpfvkH;wnf;\ t"dyÜg,fzGifYqdkcsufuav;uJGvGJjcif;rS pcJYavonf/

xdkYtwl bk&m;oQifvufxufuvnf; ]r*Fvm}-[laom pum;vkH;\ teuft"dyÜg,fzGifYqdkcsufrsm; uGJvGJrIaMumifY avmuBuD;wpfckvkH; 'ku©Nidrf;at;aom r*Fvm½dSaomvrf;aMumif;udk ½SmrawGUjzpfNyD;? 'ku©&MuonfrSm q,fYESpfESpfwdkifMumcJYonf-[k od&ygonfè

tcsdKUonf tqif;udk r*Fvm?tcsdKUonf toHudk r*Fvm?tcsdKUonf tawGUtxdudk r*Fvm?þodkY r*Fvm\ t"dyÜg,fzGifY uGJvGJjcif;tay:rSm rSDvsuf olwdkY\

r*FvmusifYpOfonf trSefrS uGJvGJMu&avonf/qdkcJYNyD;aom taMumif;t&mrsm;onf ]yef;wdkif}udk trSefrS tenf;

i,frQuav;jzpfap? aoGznfNyD; odaevsif ]tvkyf} rrSefEdkifaMumif; avmuxJrS jyqdkp&mtcsdKUudk xkwfjyjcif; jzpfygonf/ ÓPfusufpm;í xdkxufapYpyfaocsmatmif xkwfMunfhEdkifMuapvdkygonf/

rsm;pGm us,f0ef;raeap&ef ]edAÁmef}udk t"dyÜg,fzGifYykH tenf;i,frQuGJvGJjcif;tay:rSDí vkyfief;rsm;uGJjym;oGm;ykHukdk wifjyaqG;aEG;&ygrnf/

]edAÁmef}\ ygVdyk'fonf ]&m*u©a,m? a'gou©a,m}-[lí ½Sdygonf/,if;udk tzGifYq&mtoD;oD;onf rdrdwdkYpdwfoefovdk zGifYMuygonfè

Page 30: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

30 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]&m*wdkY\ ukef&mukefaMumif;}- [lívnf;aumif;?]&m*wdkY\ ukefjcif;}-[lívnf;aumif;?o'´gpnf;urf; trsdK;rsdK;jzifYvnf;aumif;?tbd"r®mpnf;urf; trsdK;rsdK;jzifYvnf;aumif; zGifYMuygonf/]edAÁmef}\ teuft"dyÜg,fonf þrQavmuf tenf;i,fuav;

uGJvGJcsufjzifY bmta&;jZpfEdkifoenf;-[k qdkzG,f½Sdygonf/[kwfygonf/ &m*-ukef&mukefaMumif;ESifY &m*-ukefjcif;? þESpfrsdK;

onf "gwfoHtm;vkH; wlMuonf/ ypönf;oHuav;rQyif rwluGJNym; jcm;em;rI½Sdayonf/

]aMumif;}ESifY]jcif;}-þrQom xl;onfr[kwfygavm/ &m*ukef&m-[laom? &m*-ESifY &m*-wdkY\ "gwfteufcsif;ü 0g'½SifESpfOD;vkH;yif wlrQpGmvufcHMuonf/ þodkY wpdk;wpduav;rQ jcm;em;csufonf vkyfief;ü]ausmcsif;uyfvsuf} qefYusifzufqDodkYavQmufoGm;onftxd uGJvGJoGm;onfudk awGUcGifY½Sdayonf/

[kwfygonf/]ausmufoabFm0g'}onf ]tomae}-[lí jzpfygonf/]pGef;vGef;}-paom wjcm;aom0g'rsm;um; ]tomraeMuESifY ?

touf½Iwm½Idufwmudk rD;yGwform;uJYtvm;odkY BudK;pm;½IrSwf? owduyfMu}-[lí teufypönf;uav; wpdk;wpdrQuGm,kHrQjzifY vkyfief;csif; qefYusifMuukefonf jzpf\/

ausmufoabFmq&mrsm;u Mo0g' ay;Muonf-]tomraevdkY BudK;pm;rIwpfrsdK;rsdK;udkvkyfvsif vkyfwJYtwGuf rSm;

NyD}/ edAÁmefonf ]etm,l[e} w&m;tm;pdkufrIuif;&aom w&m;jzpfonf/tm;pdkufvsif edAÁmefESifY vGJNyD/ xdkYaMumifY rD;yGwfa,musfm; uJYtvm;odkYBudK;pm;½IrSwfwmudk rvkyfMuESifY}- [lí jzpfygonf/

Page 31: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 31

pGef;vGef;q&mawmfrsm;uvnf; Mo0g' ay;Muonfè]ysif;&daygYq raeMuESifY/ BudK;pm;½IrSwf owduyfMu/ oHo&mtp

b,fu[k rodEdkifonfrS vTwfxm;cJYonfhpdwfudk xdef;Muodrf;Mu/ odkYrS&m*? a'go-ponfwdkY ukefEdkifMuvdrfYrnf}- [lí jzpfonf/

olwdkYESpf0g'onf bk&m;omoem\atmufrS edAÁmefokdY OD;wnfcsDwufaeMuaom w&m;&Jazmf&Jzuf odkYr[kwf oDwif;okH;azmfokH;zufcsif;jzpfMuayonf/ odkYaomfvnf; wpfOD;ESifYwpfOD; ajzmifYajzmifYBuD; qefYusifvsuf ½SdMuayonf/ olwdkY\ vkyfief;qefYusifrIonf aygif;pnf;í r&EdkifawmYonfh tajctaeodkYyif aumif;aumif;BuD; qdkufaecJYayNyD/

tu,fíom ]ausmufoabFm}-vkyfief;onf xdkvkyfief;\ yef;wdkifjzpfaom &m*ukefzdkY a'goukefzdkYudk jzpfapcJYonfqdkvsif pGef;vGef;\vkyfief;onf xdkvkyfief;\yef;wdkifjzpfaom &m*ukefzdkY? a'goukefzdkYudkrjzpfbJ ½Sday&monf/ tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf olwdkY\vkyfief;onf ESpfaxGjym;vsuf ajzmifYajzmifYqefYusifaomfvnf; olwdkYESpf0g'vkH;\ yef;wdkifum;]&m*ça'goukefzdkY}-[laom wpfckwnf; jzpfaeaomaMumifYwnf;/ xdkYaMumifY&m*ça'goponfukefaom yef;wdkifa&mufzdkYqdkvsif olwdkYvkyfief; ESpfrsdK;teuf wpfrsdK;rsdK;onf {uefrSm;&ayrnf/ tu,fí rSefonfqdkvsifwpfrsdK;om rSef&rnf jzpfayonf/

þtqdkudk awmifxdyf½Sdbk&m;xH vrf;trsdK;rsdK;wufvsif a&mufEdkifonfyif -[laom BuHvkH;jzifY apm'u rwufoifYaMumif; apYapYpyfpyfa0zefMuapvdkonf/ awmifxdyfwufvrf;onf taxGaxGjym;aomfvnf;txufodkYwufrI OD;wnfcsufcsif; xyfwljzpfMuonf/ tcsif;csif; ajzmifYajzmifYqefYusifjcif; tvsOf;r½Sday/

Page 32: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

32 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

6/ vkyfief;rSefrrSef yef;wdkifjzifYppf&rnfxdkESpfrsdK;teuf b,fvkyfief;rSm;í b,fvkyfief;rSefonfudk qef;

ppfzdkY vdkayonf/ wpfrsdK;rsdK;rSm;jcif;onfvnf; enf;aomepfemrI r[kwfay/xdk0g'wpfrsdK;twGuf aemufvdkufom0ursm;um; NrdKU½GmtESHYcsDvsuf ½SdMuonf-r[kwfavm/

trSm;trSefudk rnfodkY qef;ppfrnfenf;/vkyfief; trSm;trSefudk yef;wdkifjzifY ppf&rnf/ opömusaom pum;

w&m;udk atmufydkif;u tav;teuf aqG;aEG;wifjycJYNyD; jzpfonf/xdkYaMumifY vkyfief; trSm;trSefudkod&ef ]yef;wdkif}-udk pHxdk;&ygrnf/

ausmufoabFmq&mwdkY yef;wdkifum; tb,fenf;/pGef;vGef;q&mwdkY\ yef;wdkifum; tb,fenf;/xdktar;twGuf ausmufoabFmq&mrsm;u-]edAÁmef} -yif[k ajzayrnf/pGef;vGef;q&mrsm;uvnf; xdkYtwl-]edAÁmef}-[kyif ajzayrnf/[kwfNyD/ ]edAÁmef}u b,fvdkaeí ]bmrSrvkyfbJ tomae}-qdkwJY

tvkyfudk ay;&wmvJè ausmufoabFmq&mrsm;udk ar;vsif olwdkYonfatmufygtwdkif; ajzqdkMuayvdrfYrnfè

]edAÁmef}um; &m*-wdkY\ ukef&mukefaMumif;wnf;/ xdkYaMumifY &m*ukef&m edAÁmefa&muf&ef &m*-ukefaMumif;jzpfaom &m*-ponfwdkY\ ukefNyD;í jzpfap? rjzpfay:ao;í jzpfap? ukefaeaomae&m odkYr[kwf ]&m*wdkY\r½SdbJjzpfaeaomae&m}-udk ½IMunfhae&onf/} þodkY ausmufoabFmq&mrsm;onf qdkMuayrnf/

olwdkYtqdkü edAÁmefonf &m*wdkY\ukefjcif; r[kwf/ ]&m*wdkY\ukef&mukefaMumif;onfom edAÁmefjzpfonf}-[lvdk\/ olwdkY\vkyfief;onf

Page 33: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 33

olwdkYyef;wdkifESifY nDnGwfygayonf-[líyif csD;usL;p&m ½Sdonf/ rSm;onfqdkvsifvnf; tjcm;wpfae&m&mrSom jzpfzdkY ½Sdayonf/ olYoabmw&m;ESifYolYvkyfief;um; pyfrd[yfrdvsuf tqifajyaeayonf/

wzef pGef;vGef;q&mwdkYuvnf; olwdkYyef;wdkifudk atmufygtwkdif;xkwfjyzdkY ½Sdayonfè

]edAÁmef}[lonf &m*wdkY\ ukefaMumif;r[kwf/ ukef&mvnf; r[kwf/xdkoabmudk oar®mt|uxmrSm q&mawmf ½SifAk'aCmou ukef&mukefaMumif;[k tmaygiftm&if;oefoefESifY qdkcJYonfrSm yrm'avc (arYNyD;a&;om;jcif;)om jzpfonf/ edAÁmefonf &m*ponfwdkY\ ukefjcif;rQ jzpfonf/ y&rwfw&m;onf rkcstm;jzifY bm0owådrSwyg; tjcm;bmowådrQtu,fpifppfr½Sd/ ½Sdovdkvdkqdkjcif;onf wifpm;íqdkjcif;rQ jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifYausmufoabFmodaeaom edAÁmefonf rrSef/ edAÁmefonf&m*-ponfwdkY\ ukefjcif;rQomwnf;/ xdkYaMumifY edAÁmefudk rsufarSmufjyKEdkifqdkufa&mufEdkif&ef &m*wdkY\ jzpfNyD;jzpfap?rjzpfao;íjzpfap r½Sdaejcif;udkorkwfxm;aomedAÁmefudk tm½kHjyKaeí rjzpf/ jzpfçysufocFg&jzpfaomum,ocFg& ponfudkom vkHYvBudK;ukwf tm;xkwf&rnf/ odkYrSom xdkum,ocFg&ponfwdkY\ vkH;0Zmwfodrf; csKyfNidrf;jcif;edAÁmefodkY a&mufrnf}-[lvdkonf/

olwdkYonfvnf; olwdkYvkyfief;ESifY olwdkYyef;wdkif nDnGwfMuvSacswum;/ xdkYaMumifY olwdkYvkyfief;udk tjypfwifp&mr½Sd/ csD;usL;p&mom½Sdonf/ tdk-pm½Iol-

]edAÁmef}onf trsm;tjym;½Sdoavm/olwdkY ESpf0g'onf edAÁmefESpfrsdK;udk wifjycJYNyD/xdkYaMumifY tvkyfESpfrsdK;udkvnf; vkyfudkifaeMuNyD/b,folrSefoenf;/

Page 34: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

34 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

edAÁmefonf olwdkYwifjyovdk ESpfrsdK;½Sdvsif ESpf0g'vkH;\ vkyfief;rsm;rSefayrnf/ xdk ESpfrsdK;ESpfpm;edAÁmefrsm; ½Sd&moavm/ r½SdEdkifaomaMumifYwpfOD;OD;onf {uefyif rSm;cJYNyD/ olwdkYtrSm;twGuf epfemcsufum; b,favmuf euf½Idif;rI ½Sdoenf;/

]edAÁmef}\ "gwfeuftxd rrSm;EdkifMuao;? ypönf;eufuav;rQyifjzpfonf/ ao;rTm;aom þtrSm;uav;onf BuD;rm;aomtrSm;udkarG;zGm;apcJYonfrSm ykHjyifxJur[kwf? [dktwdwfESifY [dkta0;wpfae&mrSr[kwf- jzpfaeavonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]edAÁmef}onf rSm;rnf-wdrf;rnf? tvGefBuD; aMumifYMupdk;&drfzG,fr½Sd}-[laom tqdkonf tb,fodkY rSwfcsufcsoifYaomtqdkjzpfoenf;/ pm½Iol BudKufovdk w&m;olBuD; vkyfapcsifygonf/

þae&mwGif pm½Iolü jyefar;csifaom jyóemuav;wcsdKUjzpfay:aernf xifygonfè

7/ edAÁmefudk twdtusodzdkY vdkonf]edAÁmef}udk trSeftwdkif; odonf}-[lonf qdkufa&mufrS r[kwfavm/

rqdkufa&muforQ trSeftwdkif; rodEdkif-½Sdrnf r[kwfygavm/ trSeftwdkif;odaevsifvnf; qdkufa&mufaeí jzpfrnf r[kwfygavm/ qdkufa&mufaevsifvnf; bmvkyfief;udk vkyfae&OD;rnfenf;-ponf ponf jzpfygonf/

]edAÁmef}udk wpfr*fwpfzdkvf a&mufNyD;ol jzpfap? vkH;0 ra&mufao;ol jzpfap? edAÁmefudk yGm;rsm;jcif;? tm;xkwfjcif;vkyfolonf-

]edAÁmef}udk trSeftwdkif; twdtus odaezdkYvdkygonf/odvnf;odEdkifpGrf; ½Sdygonf/rsufarSmufjyKNyD;olESifY rjyK&ao;ola&m edAÁmefa&mufa&; vkyfol

wdkif;-

Page 35: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 35

]edAÁmefudktrSeftwdkif; twdtus od&rnf/ odvnf; odEdkifonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

okdYaomfvnf; xdkESpfOD;wdkY\ edAÁmefudk odMuykHjcif;um; jcm;em;ygonf/ rsufarSmufjyKNyD;olodaom edAÁmefvnf; þedAÁmef? rjyK&ao;ol odaom edAÁmefonfvnf; þedAÁmef/ þodkY ESpfOD;ESpf0wdkY todcH&aomedAÁmefonf wpfckwnf;aomedAÁmef jzpfygonf/

odkYaomfvnf; xdkESpfOD;wdkY\ edAÁmefodykHjcif;um; tjcm;em;BuD;jcm;em;ygonf/ rsufarSmufjyKNyD;ol\ todonf udk,fwdkifodjzpfaom]t0aAm"dtod} jzpfygonf/ ]ypöu©od}-[lívnf; ajymvsif oifYygonf/

rsufarSmufrjyK&ao;olwdkY\ todum; ]uGif;qufod} jzpfygonf/]tEkaAm"od}vnf; jzpfygonf/ ]tEkrmeod}-[lívnf; ajymvsif oifYygonf/

OyrmjzifYajymvsif ]avqma&mifjcnf}udk xkwfvkyfokH;pGJolwdkYtod?avqma&mifjcnfudk wGufcsuftqdkjyKcJYaom oD0&D½SifwdkYtod/ xdk todESpfrsdK; jcm;em;ouJYodkYjzpfygonf/ oD0&D½SifESifY xkwfvkyfokH;pGJolwdkY odMuaom avqma&mifjcnfrSm wpfckwnf;omjzpfonf/

odykHjcif;um; oD0&D½Sifonf ]tEkaAm"od} jzpfonf/xkwfvkyfokH;pGJolonf ]t0aAm"od} jzpfonf/xdkxufxda&mufaom OyrmjzifY EIdif;cdkif;vsif atmufygtwdkif;

EIdif;cdkif;&rnf/ ]ocsFmykpämwpfck\tajzudk q&mESifYwynfhwdkYaygif;í½SmMuonf-qdkygtHh/

q&monf xdkocsFmtajzudk wGufjyvdkuf\/ xdktcg wGufjyaomq&monfvnf;aumif;? wGufjyrIudk avYvmaeaom wynfhonfvnf;aumif;? tck-wpfckwnf;udk twlwuG odMu\/

Page 36: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

36 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdk todcH&aomtajzonf ESpfrsdK;rjym;? wpfrsdK;wnf;om trSefjzpfonf/ odkYaomfvnf; odMuaom q&mESifYwynfhwkdkY\todum; ESpfrsdK;jym;onf/ q&mYtodum; ]t0aAm"od} jzpfonf/ wynfhtodum; ]tEkaAm"od} jzpfygonf/

]edAÁmef}udk rsufarSmufjyKNyD;olESifY rjyK&ao;olwdkY\ todcHae&aomedAÁmefonf vnf; þtwl wlnDae&ygrnf/ odMuaomtodonfomjcm;em;&ygrnf/ xdk todjcm;jcif;aMumifY todcHedAÁmefcsif; xl;jcm;rae&-[k qdkvdkygonf/

xdkYaMumifY edAÁmefudka&mufatmif vkyfvdkolonf edAÁmefudk rsufarSmufrjyK&ao;aomfvnf; rsufarSmufjyKNyD;olodaom edAÁmefESifY wom;wnf;jzpfaom edAÁmefudk odae&ygrnf/ odEdkifpGrf;vnf; ½Sdygonf/ odaumif;vnf;odaumif;ygonf/

]odjcif;}ESifY ]qdkufa&mufjcif;}onf wjcm;pDjzpfygonf/ ausmufaygufí NyD;oGm;jcif;? ausmufaygufí NyD;oGm;onfudk odjcif;/ þESpfrsdK;jcm;em;ouJYodkY jcm;em; ygonf/ ausmufaygufNyD;olonf aemufwpfcgausmufraygufawmYyg/ ausmufaygufNyD;onfudk odolonfum; aemufwpfcsdefü ausmufaygufvdku aygufygOD;rnf/

]edAÁmef}onf vlwdkif; rqdkufa&mufEdkifvsifom ½Sd&rnf/ vlwdkif;odEdkifaomt&m jzpfonfum; trSefyif-[k qdkvdkygonf/

þpum;tpOfjzifY edAÁmefonf-rqdkufa&mufolwdkY rodEdkifaomt&m r[kwfjcif;/edAÁmefqdkufa&muf&ef ]edAÁmef}pum;rSefzdkY ta&;BuD;jcif/vkH;0rodbJ jzpfap? ra&r&mtodjzifY jzpfap? edAÁmeftodudk y"ge

rxm;bJ aAm"dyu©d,tvkyfudk y"gejyKojzifY edAÁmefodkY rqdkufa&mufEdkifjcif;-rsm;udkpm½IolwdkYtm; wifjycJYygonf/

Page 37: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 37

wifjycsufrsm; aMumif;usdK;,kwåd qDavsmfoifYjrwfvsif ]edAÁmef-onf wdrf;rnf? rSm;rnf? tvGefBuD; aMumifYMupdk;&drfzG,fr½Sd}-[laomtqdkpum;\ a½TrIefusJydokumb0 jzpfaMumif; a½TAdrmef\ydokumb0r[kwfaMumif; tuJtav; cwfEdkifMuygrnf/

[kwfygonf/ þ yXrtqdkonf ]a½TrIefusJAdrmef}\ ]ydokumb0}azmfjyaom urÁnf;tqdk jzpfygonf/

Page 38: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

38 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 39: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 39

tcef;(3)

aumuEk'fAdrmef\ 'kwd,urÁnf;udkavYvmjcif;

Page 40: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

40 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 41: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 41

tcef;(3)aumuEk'fAdrmef\ 'kwd,urÁnf;udk avYvmjcif;

8/ edAÁmef[lonf b0wdkU\ rjzpfjcif;avmuREkfyfwdkYonf tvGefvSaom aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;udk avYvm

cJY&mü Adrmefwnfaqmufol\b0udk bmjzpfonf-[k wD;rdacgufrdonftxd avYvmcJYNyD;NyD jzpfygonf/

aemufxyfí 'kwd,urÁnf;jzpfatmif txufygavYvmcsufudkjznfhqD;&ygrnf/ qdkvdkonfrSm aumuEk'fAdrmefü awGU½Sd&aom 'kwd,urÁnf;onf þ-txufyg b0owfrSwfcsufudk taxmuftul jyKygrnfavm/þokdYjyKygrS olYb0udk a½TrIefusJ Adrmef ydokumb0-[k twnfjyKoifYayonf/

xdkYaMumifY ,ckqufí 'kwd,urÁnf;udk avYvm&efvdkayonf/ol\ aumuEk'fAdrmefrS awGU½Sdcsufjzpfaom 'kwd,urÁnf;onf þ aumuEk'fAdrmefudk zefqif;ol\ b0udk a½TAdrmefydokumb0 r[kwf/ a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumb0jzpfonf-[k jyygrnfavm/ ,if;udk qufí qef;ppfMuygpdkY/

,if;um; tb,fenf;/ olYpum;ydk'fum;è]omoemtwGif;ü vltjzpfae&aom ,ckb0onf edAÁmef\teD;

qdkufaeaom b0aywnf;/ aoí omoemr½Sdaom vlrsdK;ü jzpfcJYaomfvnf;aumif;? tyg,fü jzpfcJYaomfvnf;aumif;? ,ck qdkufa&mufvkeD;yg;aeaom edAÁmefESifY MumavçMumav uGmvGef;íoGm;jyefav\}-[lí jzpfonf/

ol\ xdkpum;onf ol\ b0tjrif? b0oabmw&m;rsm;udkjyoMuaom pum;rsm; jzpfMuayonf/ xdkpum;rsm;t& olonf ]b0}udkb,fodkYjrifowJYenf;/

Page 42: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

42 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]omoemtwGif; vltjzpf&aeaom ,ckvlb0}-qdkaom pum;jzifY t½Sdeft[kefjzifY pD;qif;NyD;? twdwfrS vmcJYonf/ ,ck tvsifwkef;uvnf; wpfae&m&mrSm jzpfcJYonf/ ,ckum; omoemwGif; vlYb0udk&aeonf/ þodkY t"dyÜg,f a&mufayonf/

þpum;jzifY qdkvdkcsuf&onfrSm ,ck ypöKyÜefb0ESifY twdwfb0udkvufcHjcif;yifwnf;/ wzef- ]aoí omoemr½Sdaom vlrsdK;üvnf;aumif;?tyg,füvnf;aumif; jzpfcJYaomf}-[laom þpum;rsm;jzifY ],ckrS aemiftem*wfb0 ½Sdonfudk vufcHazmfjyjcif;} jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifY þpum;pkudk aumufcsufcs&vsif ol\ b0tjrifonfè]vlonf twdwfrS ypöKyÜef? wzef ypöKyÜefrS tem*wf þodkY wzswf

zswf ajymif;a½TUpD;qif;avQmufonf}- [lí jzpfonf/wzefvnf; ]edAÁmefESifYeD;\? edAÁmefESifY MumavçMumav a0;av\}-

[laompum;rsm;t& ol\b0tjrifü ]edAÁmef}qdkonfvnf; yg0ifvm\/,if;-olqdkvdkaom ]edAÁmef}um;-]b0wdkY\ rjzpfjcif;}-wnf;/xdkYaMumifY ol\b0tjrifudk olYpum;rsm;t& aumufcsufcsvsifè]vlonf twdwfrS pD;0ifvmí? ypöKyÜefxJ a&mufvmonf/ ,ck

ypöKyÜefrS wzef xGufcGgoGm;aomf tem*wfxJa&mufonf/ þodkY wajymif;jyefjyef vnfaeonf/ xdkodkYrvnf&ef ypöKyÜefü aAm"dyu©d,[kqdktyfaomedAÁmefa&mufaMumif; tusifYudk odkYr[kwf aemufb0wzefrjzpfaMumif;tusifYudk usifYvsif b0ed*kH;csKyfonf}-[líjzpfonf/

]ol\ b0tjrifonf ol\ y#dpöorkyÜg'fvnfykHESifY jywfykH jzpfonf/þodkYvsif olü b0tjrif ½Sdonf/ xdk b0tjrifonfvnf; cdkifrmwdusonf/ xdkYaMumifY olonf yXrpum; t&uJYodkY acgif;rJYol? ESvkH;rJYolr[kwf½SdaeNyDavm/} þodkY tar;xGufygonf/

Page 43: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 43

xdktar;twGuf pm½Iol pOf;pm;oifYygonf/ol\b0tjrif {ueftrSef [kwfyg\avm/ odkYr[kwf-olYb0tjrifrsm;onf aMumif;usdK;qefaom trSefjrifjcif;rsm;aum

[kwf\vm;/ þodkY ESpfcsufESpfvD pdppfMunfhzdkY vdkygonf/yXrar;cGef;tajzudk pm½IolwdkYtm; wifjytoday;vdkygonf/olwifjyaom b0tjrifonf oludk,fwdkifodjrifaom b0tjrif

r[kwf/ Mum;zl;em;0 rSwfrdorQawGudk pkqkHNcKHNyD; wifjyxm;aom b0tjrifom jzpfonf-[lí today;vdkygonf/

þodkY &ifY&ifYoD;oD;Mum;&ojzifY pm½IolwdkYonf zdzdESdyfESdyfBuD; wifjyzdkY BudK;pm;aejcif;vm;-[kyif txifvGJaumif; vGJaeEdkifygonf/ pm½IolwdkYtm; þodkY zdESdyfwifjy&jcif;twGuf t&om r,lvdkyg/ t&omvnf;tu,f½Sdrnfr[kwfyg/ xdkYjyif zdESdyfrIonf tmCmww&m;½SdrSom vkyfíjzpfygonf/ tmCmww&m;[lonfvnf; yk*¾v"d|mef wdkuf½dkuf½SdaerSjzpfygonf/

Oyrmqdkvsifè AdkvfcsKyfatmifqef;udk *VKefOD;apmqdkolu owfcJY\/ *VKefOD;apm touf½SifaepOfvnf; jzpfNyD;? AdkvfcsKyfatmifqef;udkcspfjrwfEdk;jcif;½Sdaom yk*¾dKvfrsm;onf *VKefOD;apmudk tmCmw xm;Muayrnf/

,ckuJYodkY tcsdefrsm; a½GUvsm;vmNyDjzpfaomMumifY *VKefOD;apmvnf;r½SdawmYaomtcg uREkfyfwdkYwawGonf AdkvfcsKyfatmifqef;udk cspfaomfvnf; *VKefOD;apmudkum; rrkef;awmYay/ tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf yk*¾v"d|meftm;jzifY wdkufp&mr½SdawmYaomaMumifYygwnf;/

"r®"d|meftm;jzifY ]*VKefOD;apm\vrf;pOf vlowf0g'onf rrSef}-[k qufvufwdkufrnfawmY jzpfygonf/ odkYaomf "r®"d|mefe,fy,fütmCmww&m;\ae&m r½Sdyg/

Page 44: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

44 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þtwlyif þpmonfvnf; tmCmww&m; r½Sdyg/ xdkYaMumifYtaMumif;rJY zdESdyfjcif;vnf; tvsOf;r½SdygaMumif; rSwf,lMuapvdkygonftzdESdyfcHyk*¾v r½SdawmYonfjzpfí zdESdyf&efvnf; tvsOf;r½SdawmYNyDjzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY olwifjyaom b0tjrifonf ol\b0tjrifr[kwfbJolrSwfom;zl;orQ olrsm;tjrifrsm;udk wifjyjcif;omjzpfonf-qdkaompum;rSm opömpum;om jzpf ygonf/ opömpum;jzpfí opömrD;½SL;udktjynfht0 vif;apvdkaomaMumifY tm;jznfhoGef;avmif;qdkjcif;om jzpfygonf/

[kwfygonf/ þpum;onf opömpum; tppftrSef jzpfygonf/olwifjyaom b0tjrifonf olodjrifaom b0tjrif r[kwfyg/ olwifjyaom y#dpöorkyÜg'fvnfjcif;çjywfjcif; oabmw&m;tjrifvnf; oludk,fwdkifodaomçjrifaom oabmw&m;tjrifvnf; tvsOf;r[kwfyg/

þpum; trSefjzpfaMumif; tenf;i,f ½Sif;jyvdkygonf/ ol\b0tjrifü twdwfb0ç tem*wfb0rsm; ygygonff/ þü twdwfb0-qdkonfrSmvnf; rarG;rDtcsdefwpfcsdefutjzpf-[k qdkjcif;jzpfygonf/tem*wfb0 qdkonfrSmvnf; aoNyD;aemuf wpfcsdefcsdefü jzpftHYaomtjzpf-[k qdkjcif;jzpfygonf/

9/ vlonf a½SUb0 aemufb0udk odEdkifovm;þodkYaom ]b0}rsm;ukd jrifEdkif&eftwGuf olü tu,fyif tod

ÓPfrsm; ½Sdaeoavm/ odkYr[kwf olwifjyonfhtwdkif; tu,fyifa½SUb0? aemufb0rsm;udk od½Sdaeygoavm/

vlonf ]a½S;b0ESifY aemufb0}rsm;udk od½SdEdkifygoavm? odMuoavm¿

Page 45: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 45

þjyóem\ tajzonf tjiif;yGm;zG,ftajzrsdK; jzpfEdkifayonf/vlawmfawmftrsm;pkonf ]rodEdkif}-[lí ajzrnfrSm trSefyif jzpfayonf/wpf&m-wpfa,muf? wpfaxmif-wpfa,muf yk*¾dKvftcsdKUonf ]odEdkifonf}-[k ajzvdku ajzzdkY½Sdayonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]odEdkifonf}-[lom vlwcsdKU\tajzudk ausausajrUajrU aqG;aEG;rS usefjyóem at;zdkY½Sdayonf/ xdkYaMumifYodEdkifykHrsm;udk qef;ppfzdkYvdkayonf/

vlonf twdwfESifYtem*wfb0rsm;udk odEdkifonf-[lonftb,fykH tb,fenf;rsm;jzifY odEdkifoenf;/ ]odEdkifonf}-[k ajzaomvlxl;vlqef;rsm;onf þodkYajzMuzdkY ½Sdayonfè

- pdwfwefcdk;tm;jzifY odEdkifonf/- xdkYjyif odEdkifpGrf;(ynmpGrf;)jzifYvnf; odEkdifonf/

þodkY ESpfrsdK;ajzMuzdkY ½Sdygonf/

10/ pdwfwefcdk;qdkonfrSm]pdwfwefcdk;}-qdkonfrSm tb,fenf;/]pdwfwefcdk;}-[lonf ykwD;pdyfjcif;? uodkPf;½Ijcif;? 0ifavxGufav

rSwfjcif; paom ½kyftm½kHur®|mef;rsm;udk ½IrSwfí? pdwfudk tBudKuftrkef;ESifYcsKwfcs,frItawG;tac:rsm; r0ifapbJ xdkxdktm½kHrsm;tay:rS xGufusvGifYarsmroGm;bJ? xdkxdktm½kHrsm;udk pl;pdkuf ½IrSwfaeatmif vkyfjcif;rStpjyK&rnf/ xdkrS wqifYqifY jrifYjrifYNyD;? xdkxdktm½kHudk ½IrSwfaomfvnf;t½IrSwfcHtm½kHyif aysmufqkH;onftxd jynfh0NidrfoufrIa&mufatmifjr§ifYwifjcif; jyK&rnf/

xdktqifYtxd jr§ifYwifNyD;olonf ÓPftxl;rsm; uGefYjrL;0ifqefYvmatmif enf;emcHí avYvmrIudk jyKvkyf&ayonf/xdktqifYodkY a&mufaomtcg udk,fwpfa,mufwnf;yif jzpfvsuf ]wpf&myJ? wpfaxmifyJ-

Page 46: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

46 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[k jrifolwdkYudk xifapownf;}-[k [efyef zefvdkufvsifvnf; jrifolwdkYonf olzefonfhtwdkif; jrifvmMuayonf/ þonfvnf; wefcdk;wpfrsdK;jzpfavonf/

]olrsm;awG bmpdwful;aeygovJ}-[k odatmif tavYtusifYvkyfvsif odEdkifonf/ ta0;uvlawG\ tjzpftysufESifY toHyvHrsm;udkvnf;od&çjrif&çMum;&atmif vkyfEdkifayonf}/ ]rarG;cifb0ESifY aoNyD;aemufb0awGudkvnf; odatmif}-vkyfEdkifonf/

þonfwdkYonfum; pdwfwefcdk;rsm; jzpfonf/} þodkY ajzaumif;ajzayrnf/

þü pm½IolESifY ausausvnfvnf aqG;aEG;zdkY txl;vdktyfvmygonf/ þaqG;aEG;p&m taMumif;t&monf tvGefrausajrUvG,faomtaMumif;t&m jzpfygonf/ xdktaMumif;t&monf þjyóemudk at;at;aq;aq; aqG;aEG;csifpdwfrsm; arG;zGm;apcsifygonf/ atmufwGifqufvufaqG;aEG;ygrnf/

tdk-pm½Iol-wefcdk;udk oifvufcHvdkonf r[kwfygavm/odkYr[kwf vufcHaeonf r[kwfygavm/xdkodkYqdkvsif wefcdk;taMumif;udk ,kwådaA'ynmjzifY qef;ppfodjrif

qifjcifjcif;vkyfief;udk oifudk,fwdkif vkyfzl;ygNyDavm/],kwådaA'ynm}-qdkonfrSm jyKvkyfjcif;ESifY jzpfay:jcif;\uGif;qufjzpf&yfrsm;udk azmfxkwfrIynm jzpfygonf/odkYr[kwf ],kwådaA'ynm}-qdkonfrSm ]tbd"r®mynm} jzpfygonf/þynmrsm;jzifY wefcdk;udk oifudk,fwdkif avYvmzl;aeNyDvm;/]þae&mü þpsmefudk þodkYyGm;vsif þtbdnmOfrsm;&onf/

Page 47: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 47

þtbdnmOfrsm;onf þrnfaomb0udk jrif&jcif;paom tjzpfrsm;jzpfMuonf/}

þodkYaomavYvmcsufrsm;udk ,kwådaA'ynmjzifY avYvmod½SdcsufawGyJ-[lí rowfrSwfbdkY pm½IolwdkYtm; owday;vdkygonf/ þavYvmod½Sdcsufonf psmefyGm;jcif;? tbdnmOf&jcif;ESifY xdkxdkþþ b0rsm;udkjrifjcif;wdkY\ uGif;quftodrsm; tvsOf;yif r½Sdyg/ xdkYjyif þrQ todynmonfvnf; tbd"r®mynm r[kwfao;yg/

wefcdk;udk vufcHvdkvsif odkYr[kwf vufcHNyD;jzpfvsif wefcdk;udk þodkYaom ,kwådaA'enf;jzifY csOf;uyfNyD;zdkY vdkygonf/

xdkYjyif-aemufwpfcsufjzifYvnf; csOf;uyfzdkY vdkygonf/ þtcsufrSm wefcdk;

½Sifudk odkYr[kwf wefcdk;½Sif\wefcdk;pGrf;udk udk,fwdkifavYvmapYikMunfhjcif;jzpfygonf/

wefcdk;taMumif;udk tjynfht0em;vnf&efrSm þtcsufESpfcsufESifYjynfhpkHNyD;jzpfzdk Y vdktyfygonf/ pm½Iolonf þ'kwd,tcsufudkvnf;avYvmapYikNyD;aeNyDavm/

wefcdk;taMumif;aqG;aEG;vsif þtajccHtaMumif;ESpf&yftay:ütajccHrS oifYavsmfygrnf/ odkYrSom oyf,yfaomaqG;aEG;wifjycsuf jzpfEdkifygrnf/ xdkodkYr[kwfvsif udk,fxif&mudk udk,fajymMuaom pum;tzsif;rsm;om jzpfaezdkY taMumif;½Sdygonf/

wefcdk;\ ,kwådaA'ynmonf eufeJygonf/ wefcdk;&aeolrsm;yifwefcdk;\ ,kwådaA'ynmudk em;vnfaeol r½Sdoavmuf ½Sm;Edkifygonf/pm½Ioludk,fwdkifyif wcgw&Hü wefcdk; jzpfzl;Edkifygonf/

wefcdk;onf obm0owåd-qdkNyD; wcgw&H txl; rqnf;yl;aomfvnf; jznfhqD;csuf tvdktavsmufaeNyD; &½Sdjcif;rsm; jzpfwwfygonf/

Page 48: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

48 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Oyrmè udk,fYtwGuf ra0;awmYaom tem*wfü tjzpfqdk;BuD; jzpfvdkaomtcg jzpfap? tjzpfaumif;BuD;jzpfvdkaomtcg jzpfap? xdk-xl;jcm;aomtjzpfudk tem*wfrwdkifrDuyif od½SdNyD;ovdk jzpfaejcif;rsm; jzpfonf/

þodkYaom tjzpfrsdK;rsm;onf vlwdkif;vdkvdkrSmyif wpfBudrfr[kwfwpfBudrf qdkovdkü jzpfzl;Muayonf/ xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; xdk-rjzpfao;aom]tjzpf}ESifY BudKwifNyD;odjcif;ESifY tb,fodkYqufpyfonf-[laom,kwådaA'ynmum; r½SdMuçrodMuay/ b,fvdkvnf;rodygbl;-[komrSwfcsufcsMu&onf/

þü ]'g-pdwfwefcdk;aygY}? þodkYaom rSwfcsufrsdK;um; ,kwådaA'ynmr[kwfay/ ]pdwfwefcdk;onf pdwfwefcdk;jzpfonf}-[k odjcif;um; emrnfrSnfhwwfaomynmomjzpfayonf/

wefcdk;\ ,kwådaA'ynmonf wefcdk;&jcif;xuf av;eufjcif; ½Sdayonf/ xdkYaMumifY pm½Iolrsm;onf wefcdk;\ ,kwådaA'ynmESifY pyfvsOf;íoabmayguf em;vnfxm;NyD;jzpf&ef taMumif; enf;ayonf/ tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf wefcdk;udkyif tvdktavsmuf&½Sdjcif;rSty vkyfEdkifolyif½Sdaumif;rS½Sdrnf jzpfaomaMumifY jzpfygonf/

11/ wefcdk;onf vl\ rarG;rDESifYaoNyD;aemuftjzpfudk odEdkifovm;xdkYaMumifY wefcdk;taMumif;aqG;aEG;&mü wefcdk;udk ,kwådaA'ynm

jzifY avYvmcsufudk csefvSyf&rnf jzpfygonf/ odkYaomfvnf; þae&mütcsufwpfcsufudkawmY tqdkjyKxm;cJYvdkygonf/ ,if;um;-

]wefcdk;onf rarG;rDuESifY aoNyD;aemuf tjzpfwpfckckudkrjrifEdkif? rodEdkif}-[laomtcsufyif jzpfygonf/þtqdkudk pm½Iol tav;teuf em;vnfcJYapcsifygonf/ wefcdk;

\ ,kwådaA'ynmabmiftwGif;rS þtqdkudk acszsufEdkifaom pGrf;&nfudk

Page 49: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 49

pm½Iol awGU½Sdvsif tcsdefra½G;yif þtqdktwGuf xkacsvTm oufaoom"uay;&ef toifY½SdaeaMumif;yg pm½Iolonf rSwfom;xm;cJY apcsifygonf/

wefcdk;taMumif;udk usefaomaemufteufwpfcsufjzifY qufvufaqG;aEG;vdkygonf/ pm½Iolonf wefcdk;½SifESifY wefcdk;½Sif\ wefcdk;pGrf;udkwpfBudrfodkYr[kwf wpfBudrfü udk,fawGUBuKHzl;zdkY ½Sdygonf/ þü wefcdk;[lonfudk us,fus,fvGifYvGifY teufzGifYyg&ap/

&aoY&[ef;ESifY a,m*Drsm;\ uodkPf;tp½Sdonfudk yGm;rS&aomwefcdk;/ *dkPf;q&mç "gwfq&mç tif;q&m-polwdkY\ vkyfief;taxGaxGrS&aom wefcdk;/ arSmfq&mçpdwfynm½Sif-tp½SdonfwdkY/ wefcdk;- tp½Sdaomwefcdk;rSeforQonf ]wefcdk;}yif jzpfygonf/

pm½Iolonf þwefcdk;½SifwdkY\ wefcdk;pGrf;udk wpfBudrf odkYr[kwfwpfBudrfü udk,fawGU-awGUzl;rnf[k xifygonf/ pOf;pm;Munfhay;apcsifygonf/ pm½Iolü awGUBuKHzl;aomwefcdk;½SifwdkY\ wefcdk;taxGaxGonfrsm;ygvdrfYrnf/

ta0;ae&m vSrf;jrifEdkifaom wefckd;? ta0;tcsdefudk a½SUaemufr[l vSrf;jrifEdkifaom wefcdk;? olrsm;pdwfudkodaom wefcdk;? ta0;rStoHudkvSrf;Mum;Edkifaom wefcdk;-wdkYjzpfygonf/

þwefcdk;taxGaxGrsm;twGif;ü rarG;rDb0rStjzpf odkYr[kwfaoNyD;aemufü jzpftHYaom b0tjzpf/ þtjzpfrsm;udk vSrf;jrifjyaomwefcdk;½SifESifY ,if;\wefcdk;pGrf;udkudk,fwdkifawGUzl;ygNyDavm/

xdkYjyif awGUzl;vsifvnf; xdkwefcdk;½Sifajymjyaom aemufb0?aemifb0rS tjzpfrsm;onf olajymonfESifYrjcm; tu,fyifjzpfaecJYonf?odkYr[kwf tu,fyif jzpfvmcJYonf-[k wefcdk;½Sif\ tajymESifY wu,fYtjzpfudk oifudk,fwdkif qufpyf avYvmcJYzl;NyDavm/

Page 50: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

50 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

pm½IolrajzrDrSmyif þjyóem\tajzudk BudKwifNyD;tqdkwpfckjyKxm;csifygonf/ þtqdkum; pm½IolwdkY\ þjyóemtajzonf ]tif;}-[lí b,fenf;ESifYrQ rjzpf&}-[lí jzpfygonf/

wefcdk;½Sifrsm;onf ta0;rSt&mudk vSrf;í jrifMuçMum;Muonfudk ajymqdkMu\/ xdkajymqdkcsufonf ajymwdkif;[kwfçr[kwf avYvmolwdkYtwGuf [kwfonfvnf; awGUEdkif\/ [kwfovdkvdkavmufvnf; awGUEdkif\/

odkYaomfvnf; wefcdk;½Siftrsm;pkonf ta0;ae&mESifY ta0;tcsdefrsm;rS taMumif;rsm;udk ajymqdkMuaomfvnf;? arG;NyD;ESifY raociftwGif;rSta0;rsm;udkom tajymrsm;Muayonf/ arG;ESifYaowdkY\ [dkrSmzufta0;rStjzpfrsm;udk tajymrrsm;Mu/ odkYaomfvnf; wcsdKUwavaom wefcdk;½Sifrsm;url ajymMuvsuf ½Sdayonf/

xdkolwdkY xdkodkYyif ajymaomfvnf; xdkolwdkY\pum;onf tESpftom;aumufí &onf[lí tvsOf;yif r½SdEdkifay/ Oyrmè pGef;vGef;q&mawmfBuD;-paom jrefrmjynfrS orxwefcdk;½Sifrsm;onf i&Jom;rsm; taMumif;? ewfa'0wmrsm; taMumif;udk rsm;pGmajymqdkcJYMuayonf/

q&mawmfBuD;trsm;onf ]igonf EGm;b0udk b,fESpfBudrfjzpfcJYNyD?vlb0udk b,fESpfBudrf jzpfcJYNyD}-[lí vlykHtv,fü a[mnTefvsuf ½Sdayonf/ xdkpum;rsm;rSefaMumif; uREkfyfwdkY b,fodkYem;vnfMu&oenf;/

qdkvdkonfrSm ola[majymcsuf rSefuefaMumif;udk ola[mcsufudkemoltrsm;rSm-

b,fodkY odEdkifcGifY½Sdoenf;/b,fodkY oufaoxlEdkifoenf;/oufaoxlí a[mygoavm/Oyrmè ]igonf vGefcJYaomESpfaygif;b,fESpf&mu b,fae&mü

b,foljzpfcJYonf/ þpum;udk avYvm&ef igaoíjrKyfESHcJYaom ,ckb,f

Page 51: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 51

ae&mü ajrwGif rnfrQwl;azmfvsif awGUjrifEdkifrnf}/ þodkY oufaoxlvsufa[majymjcif;½Sdrnf r[kwfay/ xdkodkYjzpfvsif xdkolwdkY\ta[monf tESpfom&rJYaom ]wkpäpum;}rsm;rQom jzpfav&monf/

[kwfygonf/ pum;ü ]pum;rSm;av;rsdK;} ½Sdygonf/ xdktxJüwpfrsdK;onf ]pum;zsif;} jzpfygonf/ ]pum;zsif;}-[lonf tESpfom&rygxif&majymaompum;rsm; jzpfygonf/ xifíajymjcif;jzpfaomaMumifYxdkpum;onf rkom;pum;awmY r[kwfyg/ xdkpum;onf ]rdk;ay: Mu,f½Sdonf? jrpfxJ a&½Sdonf}-[laom pum;rsm;ESifY? ajymolom odNyD;emolrodaompum;rsm; jzpfygonf/ ½dk;om;aomolrsm;onf þtzsif;pum;rsm;udk ajymqdkjcif;rS a½SmifMuOfMuayonf/

,ckacwftokH;tm;jzifY vlUpnf;? vlUabmif? vlU,Ofaus;rIü ajymolomodí emolrodaompum;udk ajymqdkjcif;onf ]<um;0gjcif;jzpfonf}-[k ½IwfcscH&avonf/ xdkYaMumifY ajymolomodí emolrodaom jyóemwpf&yfudk wifjyvdkvsif wifjyajymvdkolonf ajymqdkaompum;twGufoufaoom"u tvkHtavmufjzifY emMum;pl;prf;Edkifonftxd BudK;pm;a[majymMu&ayonf/

aemufb0çaemifb0? þtaMumif;t&mrsm;udk a[majymMuaomyk*¾dKvfrsm;onf þodkYoufaoxlí a[majymjcif; tvsOf;r½SdMuay/xdkYaMumifY pm½Iolonfvnf; xdkolwdkY\ wefcdk;t& a[majymcsufudkawGUzl;aumif; awGUzl;Murnf jzpfaomfvnf; xdka[majymcsuf\ cdkifrmaMumif; taxmuftxm;udkum; tvsOf;yif awGUzl;rnfr[kwfaMumif;BudKwifajymqdkvdkygonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]aemufb0? aemifb0ESifYpyfí wefcdk;jzifY tvsOf;yifra[majymEdkif}- [líyif aumufcsuf csay;vdkygonf/

Page 52: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

52 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þrQaom wefcdk;taMumif; aqG;aEG;csufonf þaumufcsufudkcsEdkif&ef vkHavmufcJYNyD-[k pma&;ol ,kHMunfygonf/

12/ ynmpGrf;jzifY vl\ a½SUb0aemufb0 odEdkifovm;þrQjzifY wefcdk;taMumif; aqG;aEG;csufudk &yfem;NyD;? qdkvdkjcif;

taMumif;bufqDodkY jyefqufay;vdkygonf/ þwefcdk;taMumif; aqG;aEG;bufqDodkY xGufvmonfum; ]vlonf aemufb0? aemifb0taMumif;odEdkifoavm}-[laom jyóemtwGuf tcsdKUolwdkY\ ]wefcdk;jzifY odEdkifonf}-[laom pum;rSjzpfonf/

þrQjzifY þtqdkudk aqG;aEG;cJYNyD;NyD-[k ,kHMunfygonf/ qufvufí ]ynmpGrf;jzifY vl\ a½SUb0? aemufb0udk odEdkdifonf}-[laom tqdkudk aqG;aEG;zdkY vdkygao;onf/

þ ]ynmtpGrf;[lonf tb,fenf;}/ þjyóemjzifY xdktqdkudkaqG;aEG;rI tpjyK&ygrnf/ tb,fonf ynmtpGrf; jzpfoenf;/

]ynmpGrf;}-[lonf tusdK;udkodojzifY taMumif;udkodjcif;? tpdwfudkodojzifY taygif;udkodddjcif;- tp½SdonfwdkY jzpfownf;/

avmuü ]taoG;udkjrifí toGifukdkodjcif;? tayG;udkjrifí tyifudkodjcif;}-rsm;onfvnf; ynmpGrff;jzifY azmfjyaom pum;rsm;yif jzpfygonf/ ykHpHtm;jzifY vlwpfOD;\ ajymqdkpum; wpfvkH;wavudk Mum;umrQjzifY xdkol\t&nftcsif; b,frQjzpfonf-qdkonfukd odjrifjcif;? tvsm;ESifYteHudkodojzifY tus,ft0ef;udkodjcif; ponfwdkYjzpfonf/

xdkodkYqdkvsif-a½SUçaemufb0rsm;udk odaom ynmpGrf;um; tb,fenf;/tb,fudk jrifojzifY a½SUESifYaemufb0rsm;udk tb,fykH odoenf;/a½SUçaemufb0rsm;udk odaom ynmum; ]Ak'¨tbd"r®mynm}-

Page 53: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 53

jzpfonf[k pm½IolwdkY ajzaumif; ajzMurnf-[kxifygonf/tb,fudkjrifojzifY a½SUçaemufb0udk odoenf;-qdkvsifum; ,ck

b0\ aumif;çqdk;ESpfwefaom tjzpfrsm;udkjrifí odonf-[kvnf;ajzaumif;ajzrnf-[k xifygonf/

þtajzrsm;t& jyóemESpf&yf xGufvmygonf/jyóemwpf&yfum;-]Ak'tbd"r®monf a½SUb0çaemufb0wdkYudk today;aom tbd

"r®m [kwfygoavm}- jyóemESifY? aemufwpf&yfrSm-]b0\ qdk;çaumif;ESpfwef tjzpfrsm;onf rarG;rDb0u jyKvkyf

csufrsm;\ t&dyfrsm;jzpfonf qdkonfrSm trSef[kwfygavm}-[laomjyóemrsm; jzpfMuayonf/

þjyóemESpf&yfum; avmuü tav;teufqkH; jyóemESpf&yfjzpfonf/ þjyóemrsm;udk aqG;aEG;&efrSm odkif;rIç0dkif;rItenf;i,frQjzifYvkH;0 rvkHavmufEdkif/ þjyóemudk odkif;odkif;0dkif;0dkif; jyefYjyefYus,fus,faqG;aEG;&zdkY vdkayonf/

13/ Ak'tbd"r®0g'\ tESpfom&Ak'¨tbd"r®monf rarG;rDub0ESif Y aoNyD;aemufb0wdk Y\

jzpfjcif;ESifY rjzpfjcif;udk zGifYazmfnTef;qkdaom tbd"r®m [kwfygoavm/þjyóem em;vnf&ef ]Ak'tbd"r®m}udk atmufyg ar;cGef;uav;

rsm;udk acgif;pOfjyKí tajy;tvTm;uav; avYvmzdkY vdkygonf/ ,if;wdkYrSm-Ak'tbd"r®m0g' tESpfom&onf tb,fenf;/ta&twGuf rsm;oavm/Ak'tbd"r®m\ b0tjrif('óe)onf tb,fenf;-

[lí jzpfMuonf/

Page 54: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

54 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]Ak'¨tbd"r®m\ tESpfom&}um;-]0drkwåd}-[kac:aom ]vGwfajrmufrI}-jzpfonf/0drkwådtjyif ydkvGefaom tESpfom&[lí Ak'¨tbd"r®mü r½SdNyD/

xdkYaMumifY Ak'tbd"r®0g'\ tESpfom&onf tjym;r½Sd? wpfyg;wnf;om/,if;wpfyg;um; qdkcJYNyD;aom ]0drkwåd}-[kac:aom ]vGwfajrmufjcif;}omwnf;/

þü ]vGwfajrmufjcif;}-[kac:aom ]0drkwåd}udk qufvufaqG;aEG;vdkygonf/ tb,frS vGwfajrmufjcif;onf ]vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)}jzpfoenf;/ tdrfaxmifrSvGwfajrmufjcif;onf 0drkwådavm/ odkYr[kwftdrfaxmifrJYb0rS vGwfajrmufjcif;onf vGwfajrmufjcif;avm/ xdkYtwlpD;yGm;rS vGwfajrmufjcif;onf vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)avm/ pD;yGm;rJYtjzpfrSvGwfajrmufjcif;onf vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)avm/

tb,frS vGwfajrmufjcif;onf vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd) jzpfoenf;/vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)teuf tw¬t"dyÜg,fum; tb,fenf;/tb,fonf vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)\ o½kyfouef jzpfavo

enf;/ ]0drkwåd}\ teuftw¬um; ]edó&P}[laom ]trSDtcdkuif;jcif;}[laomt&m jzpfonf/ wzefvnf; ]edó&P}[kac:aom trSDtcdkuif;jcif;onf tb,fenf;[ltHY/

]trSDtcdkuif;jcif;}-[lonf-]udk,fYMur®mudk udk,fzefwD;Edkifjcif;?udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEdkifjcif;} jzpfygonf/csKyfíqdkvsif -]vGwfajrmufrI}\ teuft"dyÜg,fonf ]udk,fYuHudk ukd,fpDrHEdkifjcif;}

jzpfygonf/

Page 55: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 55

xdkYaMumifY ]tb,frS vGwfajrmufjcif;onf vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)jzpfoenf;}-[laom tar;twGuf tdrfaxmif½SdçtdrfaxmifrJY? pD;yGm;½SdçpD;yGm;rJY? ponfjzifY taxGaxG tvDvDwdkYrS vGwfajrmufjcif;onf ]vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)} rjzpfEdkif/

]uHrSm;udk pD&ifae? BudK;ukdifaeaom BudKufjcif;çrdkufjcif;çrkef;jcif;wdkYrS vGwfajrmufjcif;onfom ]vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)} jzpfonf/ odkYr[kwfè]uHrSm;jzpfaom tjyKtrlç tajymtqdkESifY pdwfaepdwfxm;trSm;wdkYrS vGwfajrmufjcif;onfom ]vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)}jzpfonf/jrifjcif;çMum;jcif;ponfESifY jrifp&mçMum;p&mponfrsm; jrifwwfç

Mum;wwfaom rsufapYçem;ponfwdkYrS vGwfjcif;wdkYum; ]vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)}\ teuftw¬t"dyÜg,fESifY vm;vm;rQrqdkifaom vGwfajrmufjcif;rsm; jzpfMuownf;/

þae&mü pm½Iol\ &ifwGif;ü ]vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd)}\ teuft"dyÜg,fESifYpyfí r½Sif;vif;ovdk cyfqdkYqdkYrsm; <uif;aernfvm;- atmufarYrdygonf/

xdkYaMumifY pk'fapm'emuav;jyKvsuf qdkcJYNyD;aompum;udk jznfhpGufaqG;aEG; jyvdkkygao;onfè

]udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHekdifjcif;onf vGwfajrmufjcif;(0drkwåd) jzpfcJYvsifþ]vGwfajrmufjcif;}udk vlwdkif;yif &aeonfr[kwfygavm/ xdkYaMumifY Ak'tbd"r®monf þvGwfajrmufrI tESpfom&udk nTefjyaeonfqdkvsif þvGwfajrmufrIudk vlwdkif;tvdktavsmuf &aeNyD;jzpfí Ak'tbd"r®m rvdkNyDr[kwfygavm}/ þjyóemudk ajzqdkygrnf/

Page 56: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

56 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

vlwdkif;onf udk,fYuHudk udk,frpDrHEdkifbJ ½Sdaeygonf/Ak'tbd"r®monf udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEdkif&ef nTefjyaom wpfck

wnf;aom tbd"r®m jzpfygonf/xdkYaMumifY vlwdkif;yif udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEdkifcsifvsif Ak'tbd"r®mudk

csOf;uyf&efvdktyfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY Ak'tbd"r®monf tydkr[kwfyg/

14/ udk,fYuHudk b,folu pDrHzefwD;oenf;þae&mü ]vlonf udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEdkifvsif udk,fYuHudk b,f

olvmí pDrHonfudk cHae&oenf;/} þodkY bkawmí ar;csifzG,f jzpfygonf/ þtar;udkajz&ef atmufygjyóemtcsdKUudk wifjy&ygrnf/

vlonf BudKufp&mawGUvsif BudKufonfqdkthH/ rkef;p&mawGUvsifrkef;onfqdktHh/ xdk tBudKufESifYtrkef;pdwfwdkYonf BudKufp&mESifYrkef;p&mudkawGUíyifjzpfMuoavm? rawGUbJyif xdkBudKufpdwfçrkef;pdwfrsm; jzpfMuoavm/

xdktar;udk ,xmblwusus ajzvsif tBudKufçtrkef;pdwfwdkYonfBudKufp&mESifY rkef;p&mrsm; ½SdMuíom jzpfMuonf-[k ajz&rnfjzpfygonf/tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf pdwfonf tm½kHESifYuif;í rjzpfaumif;aomaMumifYyif/

þae&mü BudKufp&mESifY rkef;p&m[lonf olUpdwfü xifaeonfht&myif jzpfonf/ olrsm;pdwfü BudKufp&m[kwfçr[kwfonf y"ger[kwf-[k owdcsyfapvdkygonf/

qufvufí aqG;aEG;&efrSm-]BudKufzG,fçrkef;zG,fawGudkawGUí BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;pdwfrsm; jzpf

onfqdkvsif BudKufzG,fçrkef;zG,frsm;udk awGUxdodjrifolwdkif;onf BudKufpdwfçrkef;pdwfrsm; jzpfMuoavm}-[k tar;jyK&ef jzpfygonf/

xdktar;udkvnf; ,xmblwususajzvsif-

Page 57: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 57

]BudKufzG,fç rkef;zG,fESifYawGUolwdkif;onf BudKufpdwfçrkef;pdwf jzpfMuonf r[kwf-[k ajz&ef½Sdonf/ tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf BudKufpdwfçrkef;pdwfrsm;onf BudKufzG,fçrkef;zG,ftm½kHudk &aomfvnf; ]BudKufzG,fçrkef;zG,frsm;r½Sd}-[k ESvkH;oGif;rSefvsif? ESvkH;oGif;Edkifvsif rjzpfay:EdkifaomaMumifYyif/

wzef qufvufí aqG;aEG;&efrSm-]BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;rsm;onf csrf;omrIudkjzpfapoavm}-[lí

jzpfygonf/xdktar;udkvnf; ,xmblwusus ajzqdkvsif-]BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;rsm;onf csrf;omudkrjzpfapbJ qif;&Judkjzpfap

onf}-[k qdk&ygrnf/

15/ BudKufjcif;onfvnf; qif;&Jyifþae&mü tenf;i,f quf½Sif;&ef½Sdygonf/]rkef;jcif;onf qif;&Jqdkvsif [kwfyg\/ BudKuf&jcif;onf tb,f

odkYvsif qif;&Jqdkbdoenf;/ ,if;onf csrf;omonf r[kwfygavm/vltrsm;onf csrf;omvdkMuaomaMumifYyif BudKuf&rIudk r&-t& wnfaqmufaeMu&onf r[kwfygavm}-[ltHh/

atmufygwdkYudkjyí BudKuf&jcif;\ qif;&JjzpfykHudk xif½Sm;apcsifonf/

vlonf pdk;&drfjcif;? idka<u;jcif;? ylaqG;jcif;? ESvkH;romr,m pdwfrMunfvef;jcif;? aMumifYMujcif;-þt&mrsm;jzpfonfudk ]csrf;omonf}-[k qdkMurnfavm? ]qif;&Jonf}-[k qdkMuoavm/ ,if;udk tvG,fwulESifYyif ]qif;&Jonf}-[k qkdMuaMumif; ajzzdkY½Sdygonf/

xdkodkYqdkvsif þqif;&Jrsm; tb,fYaMumifY jzpfoenf;? tenf;i,fqef;ppfMuygpdkY/

Page 58: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

58 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]vlonf cspfp&mçBudKufp&mwpfckckudk csrf;omcHpm;&ef cspfjcif;çBudKufjcif;jyKonf qdktHh/ xdkolonf cspf&çBudKuf&í csrf;omudkcHpm;&onf-[k qdk&ygrnf/ xdkcsrf;om\ tESpfom&onf tb,fenf;/}

þtar;\tajzudk tomyif xm;cJYvdkonf/ xdkcsrf;om\ tem*wfudkom qufvuf avYvmMunfhapvdkonf/

]xdkcspfp&mESifY BudKufp&monf tcsdefumvç ae&mXmeç jyKjyifrIya,m*wdkYESifY uif;Edkifaomt&m r[kwf/ xdkYaMumifY cspfvdkYrSr0rD xdkcspfp&monf tvSnfhtajymif; wpfckckqDodkY ajy;0ifaeawmYNyD/ xdkYaMumifY cspfwwfolonf cspfp&m taysmufqkH;cH&rIESifY &ifqdkif&avNyD/ xdktcsdefü olonfcspfp&mudk rcspf&rDutwdkif; wnfNidrf;at;csrf;pGmyif ½Sdrnfavm? pdk;&drfçylaqG;idka<u;çpdwfysufjcif;yif jzpfrnfavm/}

]tpu rawGUcJY&vsif taumif;om;vm; cspfol&,f? ckawmY udk,fYtoJawGESvkH;awG[m wpfppD wpfppD auRjyKef;ukefMuNyDaum cspfol&,f/} þtoHrsm;onf txufutar;\ tajzudk ,xmblwususxkwf&efrSwfwdkifrsm; jzpfygonf/ xdkYjyif vnf; ]odyfcspfvsif odyfidk&w,f}-[laompum;onf tcspf\ tbd"r®mvrf;rsm;rS opömpum;yif jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]cspf&jcif;onf aumif;onf}-[kqdkvsif xdk-]aumif;onf}\aemufü qufvufNyD;jzpfyGm;aom ]qdk;onf}- qdkonfrsm;udkvnf;vufcHoifYavonf/ tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf xdk-]qdk;onf}qdkonfrsm;onftvdktavsmuf jzpfay:vmMuonf r[kwfbJ ]cspfjcif;aMumifY jzpfay:vmjcif;} jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

þae&mü aumufcsufwpfck xGufvmygonf/,if;um;è]cspfjcif;onf aumif;vnf;aumif;onf? qdk;vnf;qdk;onf}-[lí

jzpfygonf/

Page 59: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 59

þodkYqdkvsif cspf&olü t½IH; &oavmç tjrwf &oavm/ cspf&olonf ukefonfESifY wlaeayNyD/ ukefonfonf t&if;tESD;jrIyfESHjcif;aMumifYay;vnf; ay;&oljzpfonf/ ukefypönf;&jcif;aMumifY ,lvnf; ,l&oljzpfayonf/ ,if;ukefonfonf t½IH;çtjrwf[lí ed*kH;ü ½Sd&onf/ xdkYtwltcspfüvnf; ed*kH;ü t½IH;çtjrwf(Balance sheet)ü wGufjy&ayNyD/

cspf&olü cspf&í csrf;omjcif;onf ]&,ljcif;} jzpfygonf/ cspf&í]pdk;&drfçylaqG;çidka<u;}&jcif;onf ]ay;qyf&jcif;} jzpfygonf/ xdkESpfXmeudkcsdefxdk;í ed*kH;csKyfvsif tb,fonf vufusef usefygrnfenf;/

]csrf;omokc}[kac:aom t&monf tHhMozdkYaumif;\/ ol\&efbuf-[k ,lqtyfaom qif;&J'ku©ESifY wqufwnf; jzpfaeonfrSmvnf; tHhMop&m jzpfonf/ owå0gwdkYwGif xdkokcESifY'ku©wdkYonf wpfcsdefwnf;ü wNydKifeuf r½Sdwwf? rjzpfwwfaomfvnf; wpfckaemufodkY wpfckuaumufaumufygatmif vdkufaeonfum; trSefyif/ xdkYaMumifY wpfckudkcHpm;&,ljcif;½Sdvsif tjcm;wpfckudkyg BudKufonfjzpfapç rBudKufonfjzpfap vufcH&onfom jzpf\/ ,ck uREfkyfwdkY\tjzpfudk Munfhyg/ wkwf'PfaMumifY emusifjcif;'ku©udk cHpm;&NyD;aemuf? oufom&m&½Sdjcif; okconfa&mufvmayonf/

pm½Iolonf cspfjcif;\ t½IH;çtjrwfudk þrQjzifY aumif;pGmoabmaygufvsuf½Sdrnf-[k xifygonf/ tu,fí ]cspfjcif;}onf aumif;uifodkYcJwpfvkH;udk ajr§mufwifjcif;uJYodkYom jzpfonf/ cJvkH;\ wufaeaomoufwrf;onf cspf&íaumif;jcif;- jzpfcJYvsif cJvkH;jyefusaeaom oufwrf;onf cspf&íqif;&Jaejcif; jzpfayrnf/ cJvkH;onf txufodkY q,faywufvsif atmufodkYtjyefc&D;vnf; q,fayyif jzpfp&m½Sdrnf trSefyif/

þrQjzifY taumif;ESifYtqdk;onf csdefcGifn§m nDayawmYonf/

Page 60: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

60 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

odkYaomfvnf; cJvkH;\ ajrBuD;ESifY½dkufcwfNyD; vdrfYvnfoGm;jcif;onfum; tydkxGuf usefOD;rnfum; trSefyifjzpfonf/ xdkYtwl cspf&olüvnf;taumif;ESifYtqdk; ausonfxm;OD;? b0'Pf&m'Pfcsufum; tydktwGufvufusefcH&zdkY aocsmayonf/

xdkYaMumifY cspf&jcif;onf taumif;çtjrwfrxGufbJ tqdk;çt½IH;omxGufaMumif; xif½Sm;vSayonf/ xdkYaMumifY umvD'goq&mBuD; uvnf; ]tcspfudk tESpf½Smolonf MuufoGefOudk tESpf½SmoluJYodkY wpfzwfcGgNyD;vsif tESpfawGUEdk;jzifY txyfxyfcGgaomfvnf; tESpfudkrawGUbJ MuufoGefcdk;t½dkufcH&NyD; tESpf½Sm&ef MuufoGefcGgolom rsuf&nfus&jcif; tzwfwifonf}-[k qdkcJYjcif; jzpfonf/

þrQjzifY cspfjcif;\ qif;&Jjcif;udk jzpfapykHudkvnf; ½Sif;vif;vufcHEdkifavmufayrnf-[k ,kHMunfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY jyóem&if;udk jyefvnfí azmfvdkygonf/

jyóem&if;rSm ]BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;onf csrf;omudk jzpfapoavm?qif;&Judk jzpfapoavm}-[lí jzpfygonf/

xdktar;\ tajzonf ]qif;&JrIudk jzpfaponf}-[lí jzpfygonf/xdkokd Yqdkvsif xdk-]tBudKufESifYtrkef;onf jzpfapoifYoavm?

rjzpfapoifYoavm}-[lrl ]rjzpfapoifY}-[k ajzqdk&rnf jzpfonf/]xdkodkYrjzpfapoifYaMumif;odvsuf tb,faMumifY tBudKufçtrkef;

rsm; jzpfaeoenf;/} xdktar;\ tajzudkajzvsif ]rjzpfatmif rwwfEdkifMuaomaMumifY}-[kyif rvTJra½SmifomyJ ajz&zdkY ½Sdayonf/

]xdkodkYqdkvsif tb,fodkY rvTJra½Smifom jzpf&oenf;}-[lí xyfar;&ygrnf/ xdktar;udk ½dk;½dk;uav;ajzolonf atmufygtwdkif;ajzzdkY½Sdayonf-

Page 61: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 61

]t½G,fa&mufvmí aoG;om;uvnf; qefYusifzuf"gwfudk qmavmifiwfrGwfaeonf/ wzef xdkqefYusifzuftm½kHuvnf; ndIUiifjr§LqG,faeonf/ xdkYaMumifY "r®wmobm0twdkif; tcspfpdwf"gwfrsm; jzpfay:vmjcif;jzpfonf/ rxGufay:vmatmif wm;íqD;í r&jcif; jzpfonf}/ þodkYajzayrnf/

þtajzt& aumufcsufqGJvsif ]vlonf rcspfrBudKufoifY-[koabmxm;onf/ odkYaomfvnf; ywf0ef;usiftajctaet& rcspfrBudKufbJ raeEdkifatmifjzpfNyD; cspfBudKufrIvkyfief;udk vkyf&onf}-[lí jzpfonf/

]BudKufrIçrkef;rIvkyfief;rsm;}onf ]uHrsm;}jzpfonf/ xdk]uH}rsm;udkb,folpDrHoenf;/ b,folYtvdkus pDrHzefwD;oenf;/ udk,fYtvdkustwdkif;yif zefwD;ygoavm/ ]ywf0ef;usif tajctaetm½kHrsm;t& BudKufrIçrkef;rIrsm; jzpf&ygonf}-[laom txufyg½dk;om;aomtajzt&qdkvsif xdkcspfuHçrkef;uHudk udk,fYtvdkustwdkif; udk,fzefwD;jcif; r[kwf/ ]tjyifty ya,m*rsm;aMumifYom cspfuHçrkef;uHrsm; jzpfMu&onf}/ xdkuHrsm;udk udk,fwdkifpDrHxm;jcif; r[kwfay/

xdkodkYqdkvsifè ]xdkuHrsm;udk b,folpDrHzefwD;vdkufygoenf;/}½dk;om;aomtajzü xdktar;\tajzonf yg0ifcJYNyD/ ,if;um;è]tcsdeftcg? ae&mXme? jyKjyifrIya,m* ywf0ef;usif} jzpfownf;/[kwfyg\/ txufrS ½dk;om;olwkdYtajztwGif;ü ]uHudk pDrHolwdkY

um; udk,fwdkifr[kwfbJ ywf0ef;usiftm½kHESifY rdrdaoG;om;wnf;[laomt&mrsm;jzpfaMumif;}xGufqdkcJYygonf/ xdktaMumif;udk bk&m;oQifonf]"r®eDwd}wpfae&mü ]umavm,ówd blwmed}-ponfjzifY azmfxkwfcJYzl;avNyD/

]vlawGrSm tcsdeftcg&JU trsdKt0g; tpm;taomufrcH&oludkb,folvdkYodMu&JUvm;}-qdkwJY pum;ya[Vduav;udk azmfjycJYygonf/

Page 62: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

62 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

vlrsm;onf udk,fYuHudk uddk,frzefwD;EdkifMu/udk,fYuHudk tcsdeftcg\vufrSm jzpfap? toGifoP²mef ya,m*

wpfckck\ vufrSmjzpfap 0uGufí tyfESHxm;Muonf/ xdkolwdkYtm; xdktcsdefumv? xdkae&mXme? xdk toGifoP²mefya,m*rsm;onf cs,fvS,faeMuonf/ xdkolwdkY\uHuddk xdkt&mrsm;onf pDrHay;ae zefwD;ay;aeMuownf;/

þrQjzifY udk,fYuHudk udk,frpDrHEdkifvsif b,foluvmí pDrHay;oenf;-[laom jyóem\tajzonf auseyfoifYayNyD/

xdkYaMumifY ]udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEkdidjcif;}-[laom xl;uJaom teuftw¬½Sdaom ]vGwfajrmufrI(0drkwåd)}udk vlwdkif; r&Ekdif/ &olonf tvGefxl;cRefaomolom jzpfzdkY½Sdygonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]vGwfajrmufrI(0drkwåd)}\teuftw¬ESifYpyfí &ifü½Sif;vif;apcsifygonf/

[kwfygonf/]vGwfajrmufrI(0drkwåd)}\ teuftw¬t"dyÜg,fonfè]trSDtcdkuif;jcif;} jzpfygonf/]trDStcdkuif;jcif;}\ teuft"dyÜg,fonfè]udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEdkifjcif;} jzpfygonf/]udk,fYuHudk udk,fpDrHEdkifcGifY½Sdol} qdkonfrSmè]udk,fwpfa,mufwnf;ESifY NyD;jynfhpkHaeol} jzpf&ygrnf/]udk,fwpfa,mufwnf;ESifY NyD;jynfhpkHaeol} qdkonfrSm-]qmavmifrIcyfodrf;Nidrf;NyD; at;csrf;rIudk xm0&pdk;ykdifaeol}

jzpfygonf/]Ak'tbd"r®m\ tESpfom&um; þt&mom} jzpfownf;/Ak'¨tbd"r®mudk aqG;aEG;vmcJY&m þrQjzifY xdkAk'¨tbd"r®m\

tacgiftnGefYjzpfaom ]&o}udk aqG;aEG;cJYNyD;NyD-[k qdkcsifygonf/

Page 63: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 63

Ak'tbd"r®m\ b0vGwfajrmufrIonf-]aoNyD;aemuf rjzpfjcif;jzifY} vGwfajrmufaom vGwfajrmufrI r[kwf

ay/ xdkYaMumifY Ak'tbd"r®m\ þtydkif;onf a½SUçaemufb0rsm; jzpfçrjzpfnTef;qdkjcif; tvsOf;r½Sday/

16/ Ak'tbd"r®m0g'\ b0tjrif('óe)<uif;usefaom Ak'tbd"r®m\jyóemudk qufvufaqG;aEG;&ef

oifYygNyD/ Ak'tbd"r®mudk ukefpifatmifaqG;aEG;rSom xdkAk'tbd"r®m\teuftw¬tzGifYrsm;wGif rarG;rDESifY aoNyD;aemufb0rsm;taMumif; yg0ifEdkifjcif;½Sdçr½Sd odEdkifrnf jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY Ak'tbd"r®m\ <uif;usefaomjyóemudk qufvufaqG;aEG;vdkygonf/

Ak'tbd"r®m\ b0tjrifonf tb,fenf;/b0udk Ak'¨tbd"r®monf tb,fodkY teufzGifYazmfcJYavoenf;/þjyóem\tajzonfvnf; us,f0ef;½IyfaxG;ygrnf/ xdkYaMumifY

pdwf½Snf½SnfjzifY a0a0zefzef csdefcsdefqq avYvmaqG;aEG;zdkY vdkygonf/aqG;aEG;csufwdkif;ü pm½IolESifY oabmuGJvGJp&mrsm; trsm;tjym;awGU&zdkY½Sdygonf/ pm½Iolonf ]rdrdtusdK;pD;yG;m;} tvdkYiSm "r®"d|mefjzifYom okH;oyfqkH;jzwfNyD; ½IMunfhzdkYvnf; BudKwifowday;vdkygonf/

Ak'tbd"r®monf ]b0}udk tb,fodkY teufzGifYoenf;/Ak'tbd"r®mü ]b0}onf-ur®b0? Oyywådb0 -[lí ESpfrsdK;vmygonf/]b0}udk þodkYESpfrsdK;jyaomfvnf; tu,füum; ]wpfrsdK;wnf;yif}/]tajccH}ESifY ]toGifoP²mef}udkcGJí qdkaomaMumifY ESpfrsdK;jym;ae

ygonf/

Page 64: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

64 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[kwfyg\/ ]b0}[lonf ]tajccHoabmw&m;}tm;jzifY ]avmuDuH} jzpf\/ xdkavmuDuH\ ]toGifoP²mef}-onfvnf; ]b0}yif jzpfygonf/ xdktoGifoP²mefum; ]vlçewfçjA[®m}-ponfh ]Oyywådb0} jzpfonf/

þae&mü ½IyfaxG;roGm;&ef þ]Oyywådb0}udk ½Sif;vif;xm;cJYvdkonf/ avmuü v,f,mtvkyform;? pufrItvkyform;? pma&;pmcsDtvkyform; ponfjzifY ½Sd\/ þü tvkyfvkyfjcif;ESifY tvkyform;rsm;udkcGJjcm;í Munfhvdkufapvdkygonf/

]tvkyform;}-[laom t&mrsm;onf ]tvkyfvkyfolrsm;\toGifoP²mef}rsm; jzpfygonf/ xdkYtwl ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}onf ]tvkyform;}[laom ]toGifoP²mefrsm;\ tajccHt&m}rsm; jzpfMuygonf/ xdk]tajccH}jzpfaom ]tvkyfrsm;}udk rjywfvkyfaeolonf ]tvkyform;}jzpfygonf/ þwGif ]rjywf}[l&mü rem;bJ-[k rqdkvdkyg/ aemufuvnf;vkyfcJYonf? ,ckvnf; vkyfaeonf? aemifvnf; vkyfvwUåHH/ þonfudk]rjywf}[k qdkvdkygonf/

]tvkyform;}onf ]Oyywådb0} jzpfygonf/]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}onf ]ur®b0} jzpfygonf/þum; OyrmESifY Oyar,sEIdif;,SOfcsuf jzpfygonf/]uHtrsdK;rsdK;}onf ]ur®b0} jzpfygonf/ ,if;uHtrsdK;rsdK;udk

rjywfqnf;yl;aeaomolwdkY\ tpOftwef;onf ]Oyywådb0} jzpfygonf/]Oyywådb0}ü {ua0gum&b0? pwka0gum&b0-ponfjzifY axGjym;jcif;onf xdkOyywådb0\ tajccHjzpfaom ur®b0\ axGjym;aomaMumifYjzpfonf/

þü ]tajccH}[laom pum;onf ]y&rwf}[laompum;\ 'kwd,emrnf jzpfonf/ ]toGifoP²mef}[laom pum;onf ]ynwf}[laompum;\ 'kwd,emrnfjzpfonf/

Page 65: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 65

[kwfygonf/ ]½kyfçemrf}jzpfaom ]y&rwf}wdkY\ zGJUpnf;aeaom]toGifoP²mef}rSeforQvnf; ]ynwf}rsm;csnf; jzpfygonf/ xdkYtwl]toGifoP²mef} txl;xl;jzpfaom ]ynwfwdkY\ tajccH}onfvnf;]½kyfçemrfy&rwf}csnf; jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]y&rwf}\'kwd,emrnfonf]tajccHw&m;}jzpfNyD;? ]ynwf}\ 'kwd,emrnfonf ]toGifoP²mefw&m;}jzpfygonf/

]tajccH}\ trsdK;trnf axGjym;aomaMumifY ]toGifoP²mef}jzpfaom ]Oyywådb0}rsm;vnf; trsdK;trnfaxGjym;jcif; jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifYOyywådb0onf b0\ teuftw¬ü yg0ifae&m,laeaomfvnf; ]ur®b0}udk a0zefvsif tusKH;0ifNyD; jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]b0t&}udk ta&;wBuD; ajymqdkaqG;aEG;zG,f½SdvsifOyywådb0udk csefvSyfNyD; ]ur®b0}udk aqG;aEG;vsif vkHavmufapNyD;jzpfayonf/

Ak'tbd"r®mü ]b0}\ teuftw¬onf ]uH}om jzpfownf;/]avmuDuHw&m;-um; ]b0\ teuftw¬t"dyÜg,ftppf} jzpfonf

[lownf;/]b0}\ teuftw¬t"dyÜg,fudk acG;aumif? EGm;aumif? vlaumif?

ewfaumif? jA[®maumifponfjzpfonf[lí ,lMujcif;um; t&yfpum;?Zmwfpum;? &yfokH;½GmokH; vlnHhwdkYtokH;rQom jzpfownf;/ usrf;0ifç*ef0if?w&m;0ifaom ]b0}\ teuftw¬t"dyÜg,fum; ]vlaumifç ewfaumif}ponfwdkY vkH;0çvkH;0 r[kwfukef/

tb,faom yd#uwfynm½SifaomfrSvnf; ]b0}\ teuftw¬t"dyÜg,fudk ]uH}rSwyg; vlçewf--ponfwdkYjzpfonf-[k today;owfrSwfynwf&paumif;onf r[kwfay/ tu,fí ig-xif&mpdkif;í today;owfrSwf ynwfvsifvnf; w&m;abmifudkausmfí ]"r®ESifYtbd"r®}wdkY\

Page 66: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

66 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

tjyifzufrS t&yfokH;? &yfokH;½GmokH; todÓPfjzifY ynwfowfrSwfjcif;omjzpf&mownf;/

]uH}rSwyg; tjcm;wpfckckudk ]b0}t&aumuf,l&ef tb,fynm½SifrQ w&m;0ifatmif rwwfEdkifMu-[kqdkvdkygonf/ ]uH}w&m;om ]b0jzpfonf-[ktaotcsm rSwfom; odjrif&mownf;/

þae&mü pm½Iolonf tenf;i,f apm'emp&m ½Sdaumif; ½Sdygrnf/ ]b0}qdkwm ]uH}yJ? ]uH}qdkwmvnf; ]y&rwf}tm;jzifY rSefrSmygyJ/,if;t&mrSefouJYodkY ]ynwf}tm;jzifY vlçewfpaom Oyywådb0rsm;onfvnf; ]b0}t&,lvsif rSefrnfyif r[kwfygavm}- [k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/

þtar;twGuf ajzp&monf ukefcJYNyDjzpfonf/ xdk YaMumifYþtar;udk ajzrnfhtpm; ar;oltm;om jyefí atmufarYzG,fpum;udkjyefqdkp&m ½Sdayonf/ ,if;um; ]ynwfç y&rwfonf odkYr[kwf toGifoP²mefESifY tajccHonf wjcm;pDavm? twlwlavm-qdkonfudk rSwfcsufay;yg}-[lí jzpfonf/

17/ ynwfESifYy&rwfonf emewåjzpfovdk {uwåvnf;jzpfonf]ynwf}[laom ]toGifoP²mef}onf ]y&rwf}[laom ]tajccH}

r[kwf/ ]y&rwf}[laom ]tajccH}onfvnf; ]ynwf}[laom ]toGifoP²mef}r[kwf/ þodkYtm;jzifY ]ynwf}ESifY ]y&rwf}onf wjcm;pDjzpfonf/]emewåjzpfonf}-[k qdkvdkonf/

]ynwf[laom ]toGifoP²mef}onf ]y&rwf}[laom ]tajccH}wdkY\ tpktaygif; jzpfonf/ wzef ]y&rwf}[laom ]tajccH}onfvnf;]ynwf}[laom ]toGifoP²mef}\ tpdwftydkif;yif jzpfonf/ þodkYtm;jzifY ]ynwf}ESifY]y&rwf}wdkYonf twljzpfonf/ ]{uwåjzpfonf}-[kqdkvdkonf/

Page 67: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 67

]ynwf}ESifY ]y&rwf}wdkYonf ESpfaxGyifjym;aomfvnf; wom;wnf;jzpfaom w&m;rsm;yif r[kwfygavm/ ]ynwf}ESifY]y&rwf}onf xdkodkYESpfaxGjym;aomfvnf; wom;wnf;jzpfaomt&m jzpf½kHomru ]y&rwf}onf]ynwf}xuf t&mus,fvsuf½Sdonfudk atmufarYEdkifavonf/

]ynwf}onf ]tpdwfrsm;} pka0;aeaom ]taygif;}jzpfonf/]y&rwf}um; xdk]taygif;}udk wnfaqmufEdkifaom ]tpdwfrsm;}

jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]tpdwf}onf ]taygif;}xuf t&mus,fayonf/xdkYaMumifY ]ynwf}\opömjzpfaom ]orkwdopöm}ESifY ]y&rwf}\

opömjzpfaom ]y&rw¬opöm}wdkYonf NydKifí wnfEdkifaomt&mrsm; r[kwfMuay/ tb,faMumifY NydKifí rwnfEdkif&oenf;-ar;vsif txufuwifjycJYonfhtwdkif;-

]ynwf}ESifY]y&rwf} ESpfaxGjym;aomfvnf; wom;wnf;jzpfonfvnf; wpfcsuf/

]ynwf}xuf ]y&rwf}onf t&mus,fonfvnf; wpfcsuf/þESpfcsufaMumifY-[k ajz&ayrnf/[kwfygonf/ vESifYaewdkY\ ta&mifrsm;ESifY ]ynwfçy&rwfwdkY\

opöm}rsm;ESifY wlygonf/ va&mifonf aea&mif r[kwfyg/ xdkYtwl aea&mifonfvnf; va&mifr[kwfyg/ odkYaomfvnf; va&mifonf aea&mif\a&mifjyef jzpfygonf/ aea&mifonf va&mifjyefudkjzpfapaom tvif;a&mif jzpfygonf/

ta&mifESpfckwdkYonf þodkYyif ESpfaxGjym;aomfvnf; wom;wnf;jzpfygonf/ xdkYjyifvnf; aea&mifonf va&mifxufvnf; t&mus,fygonf/ xdkYaMumifY va&mifESifYaea&mifwdkYonf wcsdefwnf; wpfae&mwnf;ü ta&mifcsif;NydKifí wnfaeEdkifjcif; r½Sd&yg/ tb,faMumifYqkdaomfaea&mifçva&mif[k ESpfaxGjym;aomfvnf; wom;wnf;ta&mif jzpfonf

Page 68: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

68 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

vnf;wpfcsuf/ va&mifxuf aea&mifonf t&mus,fonfvnf; wpfcsuf/ þtcsufrsm;aMumifY jzpfygonf/

þOyrmjzifYvnf; ]y&rw¬opöm}ESifY ]orkwdopöm}wdkY rNydKifEdkifaMumif;udk odkYr[kwf NydKifír&aMumif;udk oabmayguf&rnf jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifYwcsdKUvlrsm;ajymwwfaom ]'gu y&rw¬opöm ajymwmyJ? orkwdopömudkvnf; ajymOD;rSaygY}/ þodkYaom pum;rsm;onf opömESpf&yf NydKifjyaomtajymrsm; jzpfygonf/

þodkYNydKifír&aMumif;? NydKifp&monf tvsOf;r½SdaMumif;udktxufu ½Sif;cJYonfhtwdkif; oabmaygufvsif t&mus,faom ]y&rw¬opöm}udk jrifojzifY t&musOf;aom ]orkwdopöm}\ ]opö}tjzpfrsm;onf]y&rw¬opöm}atmufodkY pkef;pkef;jrKyf aysmufuG,f&aMumif; vufcHoifYayonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]b0} t&ajymqdk&mü ]y&rw¬opöm} t&jzpfaom]ur®b0}udk ajymqdkvsif xdkur®b0\ toGifoP²mefjzpfaom ]Oyywådb0}jzifY jrif;aumif;pdkif;&m acG;usdK;uefYvefYoabmrsdK; 0ifcsifpdwf rjzpfay:bJ ½Sdapcsifygonf/

qdkvdkonfrSm ]y&rwf[laom ]tajccH}jzifY ]b0}udk t&aumufaqG;aEG;aeonfhtcg ]y&rwf}\ t&dyfay:rSm&yfí wdkufcdkufacszsufzdkYBudK;pm;csifpdwfudk tcsdefrD ZufowfEdkifapcsifonf][lí jzpfonf/ þae&mü þpum;tpOfjzifY ]b0qdkwm uHyJqdkwm rSefrSmyJ/ Oyywådb0tm;jzifYb,fvdkvJ}-[laom tar;twGuf ar;oltm; atmufarYapcsifaomtcsufrsm;udk wifjycJYjcif; jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]b0} t&aumufudk qufvufaumuf,l aqG;aEG;ygrnf/]b0}\ t&onf ]uH}rSwyg; tjcm; aumuf,lp&mr½Sd/]uH]om ]b0}t&aumuf,l&rnf jzpfownf;/

Page 69: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 69

Ak'tbd"r®mü ]b0}udk þodkYyif teufzGifYcJYonf/tdkèpm½Iol? uREfkyfwdkYonf þae&mtxd Ak'tbd"r®m\ 'kwd,ydkif;

jzpfaom ]b0}tydkif;udk avYvmcJYMu&m ,cktcgü ]b0}[lonf tb,ft&mjzpfonf-[lonf txd t& aumuf,lEdkifcJYMuayNyD/ ydkí euf½Idif;xda&mufpGm avYvmEdkif&ef ]b0}t&jzpfaom ]uH}udk a½SUodk Ywdk;íavYvm&ayrnf/

18/ uHqdkwmbmvJxdk]uH}onf tb,fodkYaomt&menf;/]uH}[lonf ]apwem} apwodufwnf;[laom ]emrfy&rwf}

w&m;wnf;/ ,if; ]apwem}apwoduf emrfw&m;wnf;[laom ]uH}\teuft"dyÜg,fum; ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}-[lí jzpfonf/

]uH}onf ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}/]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}onf ]uH}/xdkYaMumifY ]uH}udk odcsifolonf ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}udk odcsifoluJYodkY

avYvm&rnf/ ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}udk odcsifolonf tvkyfvkyfjcif;\ ]wnf&mXme}jzpfaom ]vkyfief;}udk avYvm&ayonf/

xdkYtwl ]uH}udk odvdkçem;vnfvdkaomolonf ,if;uH\wnf&m]ur®yx}udk avYvm&ayrnf/

]uH}onf ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}jzpfí-tvkyfvkyfjcif;rSeforQonf ]uH}rsm; jzpfygoavm/tb,f tvkyfvkyfjcif;rsm;onf uHrsm; jzpfoenf;/tvkyfvkyfjcif;\wnf&m vkyfief;(ur®yx)um; tb,ft&mrsm;

enf;/

Page 70: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

70 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]ur®yx}rsm;um;-cdk;jcif;? owfjcif;? tm½kHusL;jcif;-[laom tjyKtrlrsm;ESifYvdrfjcif;? qJjcif;? tzsif;ajymjcif;? ukef;wdkufjcif;-[laom tajym

tqkdrsm;tjyif?tvdkpdwf? trsufpdwf? b0tjrifrSm;[laom tawG;tac:rsm;/þq,fyg;ESifY þq,fyg;\qefYusifzuf q,fyg;/ aygif;-ESpfq,f

jzpfonf/ þESpfq,fonf ]uH}\ ]ur®yx}rsm; odkYr[kwf uH-[laomtvkyfvkyfjcif;\ ]vkyfief;rsm;} jzpfygonf/

]uH}onf ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;jzpfonf} qdkaomaMumifY ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}wdkif;onf ]uHjzpfonf}-[k ,lír&Edkif/ þ]ur®yx0ifvkyfief;}rsm;rSay:xGufvmaom tvkyfvkyfjcif;rsm;onfomvsif ]uH}jzpfonf/

þae&mü ]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}ESifY ]vkyfief;}udk oabm uGJaezdkY vdkayonf/ avmuü puf½kHçaps;½kHESifY v,fawmponfwdkYonf tvkyfvkyfjcif;rsm; r[kwfMu/ ]vkyfief;}rsm;om jzpfMuonf/ xdk puf½kHçaps;½kHESifY v,fawmponfwdkYü vkyfudkifMuolwdkY\ vIyf½Sm;aeaom trlt&mrsm;onfom tvkyfvkyfjcif;rsm; jzpfonf/

]tvkyfvkyfjcif;}-[laom pum;onf ]trlt&mjyp um;vkH;} jzpfonf/ j'yf0w¬K ponfudkjyaom ]trnfpum;vkH;} r[kwf/ xdkYtwl]uH}[laom pum;vkH;onfvnf; ]Bud,memrf pum;vkH;} jzpfonf/]'AÁ0w¬K}paom emrfpum; vkH;0r[kwf/ xdkYaMumifY-

]ur®yx}rsm; jzpfMuaom cdk;jcif;? owfjcif; tp½Sdaom t&mrsm;onf ]uHrsm; r[kwfMu}/ xdk cdk;jcif;çowfjcif;ponfudk ]apYaqmfaomapwemw&m;}onfomvsif ]uH} jzpfonf/

þae&mü-

Page 71: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 71

]apYaqmfaom apwemw&m;}wdkif;vnf; ]uH-r[kwf}/þur®yxrsm;ü ]apYaqmfaom apwemw&m;}-onfomvsif ]uH} jzpfonf/]uH}udk þuJYodkY wduspGm t&aumuf,lEdkifzdkY vdkayonf/ okdYrSom

]b0}udk avYvm&mü wdusa&&mayrnf/ ,cktcsdefü ]b0}\ teuftw¬onf tawmfyif euf½Idif;odrfarGUí vmayNyD/

19/ b0[lonf[kwfygonf/ ]b0}[lonf tb,ft&mrsm;wJYenf;/]b0}[lonf cdk;jcif;çowfjcif;paom vkyfief;ESpfq,fwdkYü jzpfajrmuf

&efapYaqmfaom pdwf\trlt&muav;rQ} jzpfownf;/þrQjzifY Ak'tbd"r®m\ b0tjrif nTefjyaom ]b0}\ teuf

tw¬o½kyfonf NyD;ajrmufjynfhpkH ukHvkHavNyD/ odkYaomfvnf; Ak'tbd"r®m\]b0jzpfykHtjrif}-onfum; NyD;ajrmufukHvkH jynfhpkHjcif; r½Sdao;ay/ NyD;ajrmufukHvkH jynfhpkHonfhtjzpfodkY a&muf&efum; ]b0\ taMumif;ESifYtusdK;quf}rsm;udkvnf; qufvufavYvmzdkY vdkayao;onf/

xdkYjyifvnf;-]b0jzpfaMumif;}rS ]b0}-jzpf\/ wzef-]b0}rS ]b0tusdK;}-jzpf?]b0tusdK;}rSwzef ]b0jzpfaMumif;}-jzpf/þodkYvsif ]b0tvsOf} woGifoGifpD;qif; vIyf½Sm;ç&[wfcsm;vdk

ajy;vTm;oGm;vmaeaom ]oHo&m}udk jrifjy&zdkY ½Sdayonf/ xdkYjyif xdkoHo&mrS xGufjy&zdkYvnf; ½Sdayonf/ odkYrSom ]Ak'\b0tjrif}onf jynfhpkHukHvkHjcif;odkY a&mufayrnf/

Page 72: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

72 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[kwfygonf/ Ak'tbd"r®m\ b0tjrifü-]b0}onf vnfywfaeaom (0¥)w&m;jzpfonf[k qdkygrnf/b,fodkYvnfaejcif;onf ](0¥)} jzpfoenf;/txufü t>rufrQwifjycJYonfhtwdkif;-]b0aMumifY qif;&Jjzpfonf/ qif;&Jí rcHEkdif? yifyef;onf/rcHEdkif yifyef;í 4if;rcHEdkif yifyef;wdkYaysmufatmif b0vkyfjyef

onf/ wzef b0aMumifY yifyef;qif;&J jzpfjyefonf}/þodkY (0¥)vnfaeonf/þodkYqdkvsif ]b0tjrif}udk jynfhpkHap&ef ]b0\taMumif;}udkvnf;

avYvm&ayrnf/

20/ b0\ taMumif;&if;b0\taMumif;um; tb,fenf;/b0\ taMumif;&if;um; ]yifyef;acG,dkif rcHEdkif} jzpfjcif;wnf;/]yifyef;acG,dkif rcHEdkif}-[laomtrnfonf ]udavom}[laom

pum;vkH;\ 'kwd,trnftjzpf okH;EIef;jyvdkufjcif; jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY]yifyef;acG,dkif rcHEdkif}jcif;\ teuftw¬o½kyfum; ]udavomq,fyg;}jzpfaom BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;çponfwdkY jzpfavonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]tb,faMumifY b0jzpfoenf;}-[laom tar;\tajzonf ]BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;}ponf jzpfaomaMumifY}-[lí ajz&ayrnf/[kwfygonf/ BudKufjcif;ç rdkufjcif;ponfwdkYonf vlYoEÅmeftwGif;ü yl;0ifNyDqdkvsifxdkvlonf vkH;0wnfNidrfatmif &yfwnfEdkifjcif;r½Sd jzpf&avonf/

xdkolonf wyifyef;yef;jzifY acGEGrf;,drf;,dkifvsuf ½Sd&ayonf/xdkYaMumifY xdkolonf ,if;wyifyef;yef;jzifY acGEGrf;,drf;,dkif rcHEdkifrIukdajz&efç azsmuf&efvkyfief;jzpfaom ur®yxw&m;rsm;udk 0ifa&mufvkyfudkif

Page 73: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 73

&avonf/ xdkYaMumifY xdkolonf ]ur®b0} jzpfvmcH&ayonf/þodkYyif ]ur®b0} jzpfay:vm&jcif;\taMumif;onf ]udavom}

jzpfaom BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif; ponfrsm;aMumifYjzpfaMumif; xif½Sm;ownf;/]b0}onf ]udavom\tusdK;} jzpfownf;/xdk]udavom}[laom BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif; tp½SdonfwdkYonfvnf;

tb,faMumifYjzpfoenf;- ar;zG,f ½Sdayonf/ xdk]udavom}[laomtBudKufçtrkef;ponfwdkYonf ]b0\ tusdK;t&if;? tusdK;zsm; w&m;taxGaxGudk tjrifr½Sd? rokH;oyfrdjcif;aMumifY} jzpfonf/ tb,fodkYenf;/

vlonf b0rsm;pGmjzpfaeaom t&m0w¬Kjzpfonf/ wpfaeYç wpfem&DtwGif;üyif b0aygif; ta&twGuftm;jzifY rsm;jym;vSpGm jzpfaeaomt&m0w¬K jzpfonf/ xdkvlonf xdkuJYodkY b0rsm; tvsOfrjywf? tMum;rvyf wif;vsOf;pyfí jzpfaeouJYodkY? b0\tusdK;&if;ç tusdK;zsm;w&m;taxGaxGonfvnf; jzpfay:íaeonf/

xdkodkYyif ]b0ESifY b0\tusdK;rsm; cPrvyf wif;vsOf;pyfíjzpfysuf ajymif;vJaeaomfvnf; xdkvlonf ]b0}udk rodbJ½Sdaeonf/]b0\tusdK;}udkvnf; rodbJ ½Sdaeonf/ ai;vsufçarmvsuf ]b0ESifYb0tusdK;}wnf;[laom tvsift[kefü arsmvsuf ½Sdaeayonf/ xdkodkYarsmíae&jcif;onf tenf;i,fav;rQ oufomvSonf r[kwfay/ xdkokdYjzpfaomfvnf; xdk-roufomoufouf tjzpfrsm;udkyif xdkolonf ESpfpkESpfpkHcGJí Munfhaeavonf/

yXrwpfpkwpfykHum; roufom'D*&Denf;aom tykHjzpfNyD;? 'kwd,tykHum; roufom'D*&Drsm;aom vGefuJaomtykH jzpfavonf/ þokdYcGJNyD;vsif xdkvlonf vkH;0toufomr½Sdaom uH\tusdK;rsm;xJrS yXrtykHESifY'kwd,tykHudk csdefxdk;í avYvmaeayonf/

Page 74: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

74 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

csdefxdk;&mü yXrtykHonf 'kwd,tykHxuf oufomaeonfudkxdkolonf udk,fwdkif od&çawGU&avonf/ xdktcg xdkolonf vkH;0roufomjcif;rsm;xJrS oufomonf[kxif&aom t&mudk awGU½SdcGifYESifY BuKHavawmYonf/ xdkYaMumifYyif xdkolonf roufomrItjynfh½Sdaom t&myifjzpfaom xdkroufromt&mESifY a½SUqufvsif oufomovdkjzpfaeaomxdkyXrtykHudk axmufNyD;? oufom&m½Sdonf-[k ]b0\ tusdK;qufwpf0ufudk} -qufzufwG,favonf/ usefwpf0ufudk aMumuf½GHUpufqkwfavonf/ ,if;odkY aMumuf½GHUpufqkwfjcif;onfyif yXrtykHudk ydkrdkeuf½Idif;pGmoufomonf-[k xifapavawmYonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]b0\tusdK;quf}rsm;onf xdkvloEÅmefü jrwfEdk;p&mrsm;-[k txifrSm;rIrsm; jzpfavonf/ xdkYaMumifY xdkolonf b0tay:ürSm;,Gif;aomtjrif½SdNyD; oufomrIodkY &rnfxifvsuf r&avwdkif; wyifyef;yef; wEGrf;acGacGjzifY BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;paom udavomw&m;rsm;qifYyGm;qifYuJ xlxJpGm jzpf&avonf/

þrQjzifY ]b0taMumif;}udk azmfcJYjcif;rsm; vkHavmufNyD-[k xifygonf/ b0\ taMumif;ud kazmf&mü taMumif;&if;jzpfaom udavomrsm;udkomru taMumif;&if;\ taMumif;&if;jzpfaom ]b0tajctae}ESifY taMumif;zsm;pm&if;0ifNyD;jzpffaom t&mudkyif t>rufrQyg0ifatmifwifjycJYNyD; jzpfygonf/

21/ b0\ tusdK;&if;,cktcgü ]b0\tusdK;&if;}udk qufvufwifjy&ef ½Sdygonf/b0\ tusdK;&if;um; tb,fenf;/]b0\ tusdK;&if;}um;è

Page 75: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 75

]xdk-]b0}[laom ]ur®}\ &ifYusufjcif;-[laom t&mrsm;jzpfyGm;jcif;}-wdkYjzpfygonf/ qdkvdkonfum; ]b0\tusdK;}onf-

xdk-]b0}[laom ]uH}\tusdK;jzpfaom 0dyguf½kyfçemrfrsm;?jzpfyGm;jcif;-Zmwd?usqkH;jcif;-Z&m? ysufjyKef;jcif;-r&PwdkYjzpfonf [lownf;/þae&mü ]b0}[laom ]uH}ESifY uH\tusdK;jzpfaom ]0dyguf}wdkY

qufoG,fykHukdk tenf;i,f½Sif;xm;zdkY vdkygonf/ odkYrSom ]Ak'tbd"r®m\b0tjrif}onf oefYpifpGm jrifcGifY&ygrnf/

uH\tusdK;(0dyguf)[lonf tb,fenf;/xdk0dygufESifYtwljzpfaom ½kyfçemrf odkYr[kwf apwodufw&m;rsm;

um; tb,fenf;/ þjyóemudk ausrSyif ]uH}ESifY uH\tusdK;jzpfaom]0dyguf}wdkY qufoG,fykHrsm; ½Sif;ygrnf/ xdkYaMumifY jyóemrsm;udk avYvmtyfygonf/

uH\tusdK; ]0dygufpdwf}[lonf tb,fenf;/0dygufonf uHESifYoD;jcm;avm? twlwlavm({uwåavmç emewå

avm)/]0dyguf}onf ]uH\tusdK;} jzpfonf/]uH}onf ]0dyguf\taMumif;} jzpfonf/avmuü taMumif;ESifYtusdK;wdkYonf {uwåvnf;jzpfonf?

emewåvnf;[kwfMuonf/ qdkvdkonfrSm ]taMumif;ESifYtusdK;} rSeforQonf ]wpfckwnf;jzpfonf}[kvnf; qdkí&onf/ ]wjcm;pDjzpfonf}-[kvnf; qdkí&onf/ þum; taMumif;ESifYtusdK; [laom w&m;ESpfyg;wdkY\qufoG,fykH avmued,mr-wnf;/

þtqdkudk ykHpHjy,k*fjzifY tenf;i,frQ ½Sif;vif;wifjyygOD;rnf/ykHpHrSm rQpfESifY0g;? qefESifYxrif;wdkY jzpfonf/

Page 76: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

76 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

rQpfonf 0g;\ taMumif;ed'gef;? 0g;onf rQpf\ tusdK;ed*kH;wnf;/qefonf xrif;\ taMumif;ed'gef;? xrif;onf qef\ tusdK;ed*kH;

wnf;/ þykHpHrsm;ü 0g;ESifYrQpfonf twlwlvnf; tusKH;0ifvsuf ½Sdonf?oD;jcm;pDtjzpfvnf; tusKH;0ifvsuf ½Sdonf/ qefESifYxrif;vnf; xdkYtwlyif/ tb,fodkYygenf;/

rQpfonf 0g;r[kwfaomfvnf; 0g;ESifYtaMumif;uif;aom t&mvnf; r[kwf/ xdkodkY taMumif;uif;aom t&mr[kwfaomfvnf; rQpfudk0g;[krqdk&/ xdkYtwl 0g;udk rQpf[k qdkcGifYr&/ þodkYvsif rQpfESifY0g;onfoD;jcm;pD(emewå)tjzpf jzpfonf/

xdkodk Y oD;jcm;pD(emewå)jzpfvsif rQpfESifY0g;wdk Yonf b,fodk YtaMumif;ruif;-[k ajymp&m½Sdao;oenf;/

rQpfonf 0g;r[kwf? 0g;onf rQpfr[kwfaomfvnf; xdkrQpfESifY xdk0g;wdkYonf tESpftom;tm;jzifY wjcm;pDr[kwf/

rQpf\ &ifYa&mfoGm;jcif; tajctaeonf 0g;[kac:&jcif; jzpfNyD;?0g;\ Eke,fao;aom tajctaeonf rQpf[kac:&jcif; jzpfonf/xdkYaMumifY rQpfESifY0g;wdkYonf ]Ekjcif;ç&ifYjcif;} toGifomjcm;em;onf?

tESpftom;um; oD;jcm;pDr[kwfMu/ xdkodkYjzpfaomaMumifY rQpfESifY0g;wdkYonf twlwl({uwå)[k qdkcGifY&avonf/

qefESifYxrif;vnf; þtwlyif/ {uwåçemewåtjzpf aMumif;usdK;qufoG,fygonf/ 0dygufESifYuHwdkY aMumif;usdK;qufET,fykHonfvnf; þokdYaom qufEYT,fykHrsdK; qufoG,fygonf/

]uH}onf ]0dyguf}r[kwfyg/ ]0dyguf}onfvnf; ]uH}r[kwfyg/ þodkYjcm;em;jcif;(emewå)tjzpfrsm; jzpfMuygonf/ wzefvnf; ]uH}onf ]0dyguf\ Eke,fao;aomtajctae} jzpfygonf/

Page 77: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 77

]0dyguf}onf ]uH\ &ifYusufNyDjzpfaom tajctae} jzpfygonf/þodkYvsif 0dygufESifYuHwdkYonf ]0dyguf}ESifY]uH}[lí ESpfaxGjym;aomf

vnf; wom;wnf;aomt&m({uwå) jzpfygonf/ (uHESif Y0dyguftESpftom;wlykH)

Oyrm olYtoufudkowfvsif tjypf½SdonfudkodNyD; owfrIrSa½SmifMuOfzdkY qkH;jzwfonf/ ,if;onf umrukodkvfapwemjzpfonf/ olonfaemufudk owfp&mawGUvsif rowfawmY/ ,if;onf xdkuH\ tusdK;0dygufwnf;/

]rowfawmYbl;}-[k qkH;jzwfcsuf usoGm;jcif;onf ]uH}wnf;/xdkqkH;jzwfcsuftwdkif; rowfbJwnfaejcif;onf ]0dyguf}wnf;/]rowf}apwemuHESifY ]rowf}0dygufwdkYonf ]rowf}[laom

tESpftom;tm;jzifY wlnDaeMuygonf/]uHEkykHESifY 0dyguf&ifYusufykH}rSmè]rowfawmYygbl;}-[lí qkH;jzwfcsufcsí owfjcif;rS a½SmifMuOf

aom ]apwemu}H-wnf;[laom emrfw&m;uav;onf jzpfay:NyD;? XDçbifcsufcsif; csKyfaysmufoGm;onf/ pdwåu©P wpfcPom tcsdefumv ½Sdygonf/ xdkYaMumifY xdkuHuav;onf jzpfcGifY tcsdefwmwdkojzifY tvGefEke,fygonf/

a½SmifMuOfonfh apwemuHw&m;twdkif; vaygufçESpfaygufa½SmifMuOfaejcif;onf ]0dyguf}-jzpfygonf/ ,if;0dygufonf tcsdefMumjrifYpGm a½SmifMuOfaeojzifY tvGef&ifYusufygonf/

þü 0dygufESifYuHwdkY\ wom;wnf;jzpfykHudk ,kwådaA'enf;tm;jzifYwifjycJYygonf/ pm½IolwdkYonf þodkY {uwåjzpfykHudk tav;teufoabmaygufzdkY vdkygonf/

Page 78: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

78 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þodkY {uwå(wom;wnf;) jzpfykHudk oabmraygufvsif uH\tusdK;jzpffaom 0dygufudk odjrifzdkY taMumif;rvkHavmufyg/ xdkYaMumifYwom;wnf;({uwå)jzpfykHudk þrQjzifY&yfí wu,fjzpfysufykHudk vufawGUavYvmzdkY wdkufwGef;vdkygonf/

22/ uHESifY0dygufpdwfrsm; wom;wnf;jzpfpm½IolwdkYonf ]uH}udkum; odMuonf/ ]0dyguf}udkum; odaumif;rS

odayrnf/ 0dygufESifYuHwdkY\ wom;wnf; jzpfykHonf odrfarGUvGef;vSayonf/ pdwfjzpfykH\ jrefqefvGef;jcif;uvnf; uHESifY0dygufwdkY\ ESpfaxGjym;NyD;wom;wnf;jzpfykHudk rodapEdkifaMumif; jzpfaeygawmYonf/

uHESifY0dygufwdkYonf b,fokdYESpfaxGjym;í tb,fokdY wom;wnf;jzpfMuoenf;/

]uH}onf ]jyKvkyfjcif;½Sdaompdwf} jzpfí?]0dyguf}onf ]jyKvkyfjcif;r½Sdaompdwf} jzpfygonf/þodkYvsif uHESifY0dygufwdkY ESpfaxGjym;ygonf/xdkodkYjym;aomfvnf; uHESifY0dygufwdkYonf ]pdwf}[laom w&m;ukd,f

rsm;yif jzpfMuonf/ þodkYvsif uHESifY0dyguf wom;wnf; jzpfMuonf/ESpfaxGjym;jcif;udk jyqdk&mü ]uH}onf jyKvkyfjcif;½Sdonf/ ]0dyguf}

onf jyKvkyfjcif;r½Sd[k qdkcJYygonf/ wpfenf; ]uH}onf ]tjyK}? ]0dyguf}onf ]tusdK;tjypf} jzpfygonf/uH\ jyKvkyfjcif;½SdykHESifY 0dyguf\ jyKvkyfjcif;r½SdykHudk qufvufaqG;

aEG; wifjyygOD;rnf/]uH}onf owfjcif;apwemudk wdkufcdkufaom ]rowfjcif;apwem}

jzpftH/ ]rowfpdwf}onf jzpfay:vmygonf/ þ-]rowfpdwf(oDvpdwf)}

Page 79: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 79

onf owfjcif;apwemudk wdkufcdkufí wnfaxmif&aompdwf jzpfygonf/owfjcif;apwemudk rowfjcif;apwemjzifY wdkufcdkufí wnfaxmif&ygonf/ þ]rowfpdwf}udk wnfaxmifae&aom tcdkufü ]rowfpdwf}onf]oDvukodkvfpdwf} jzpfygonf/

rowfjcif;apwemudk wnfaxmifNyD;aemufü ,if;-]rowfjcif;apwem}udk qufvufNyD; wnfaxmifraeawmYaomfvnf; ]rowfpdwf}onf qufvufwnf½Sdjzpfay:aeygonf/

tb,faMumifY þodkY wnf½Sd&oenf;/rowfjcif;apwemudk wnfaqmuf&mü ]owfpdwfonf vJusoGm;

NyD;} jyefvnfí r½SifoefEdkifao;aomaMumifY jzpfonf/þodkYvsif ]uHESifY0dygufpdwf}wdkYonf ]wnfaqmuf&jcif;ç rwnf

aqmuf&jcif;}tm;jzifY ]emewå}ESpfaxGjym;Muygonf/xdkodkYvsif uHESifY0dygufwdkYonf wnfaqmuf&jcif;ç rwnfaqmuf&

jcif;tm;jzifY ESpfaxG jym;aomfvnf; ]rowfpdwf}tjzpfjzifY wom;wnf;({uwå)jzpfvsuf ½SdMuygonf/

]uH}ESifY]0dyguf}wdkY\ ESpfaxGjym;aomfvnf; wom;wnf;jzpfykHonfeuf½Idif;vSygonf/ xdkYaMumifY tjcm;ykHpHwpfckjzifY qufvuf ½Sif;vdkygao;onf/

£w¬d"kwå[laom rdef;rusL;aom olonf yXrqkH; usL;tHHhaomrdef;rü tm½kHusL;pdwf jzpfay:vm&ef ]tm½kHrusL;bJaeoifYonf}-[laompdwfudk tjyif;txefwdkufcdkufí wnfaqmuf&ayonf/ 'kwd,çwwd,paom rdef;rwdkYüum; vGefusL;vdkaompdwfudk xdkodkY wnfaqmufzdkYrvdkbJ ½Sdaeonfudk awGU&ayrnf/ xdkYxufvnf; rdef;rudkjrifwdkif; vGefusL;vdkaompdwfrsm; rwnfaqmuf&bJ tvdktavsmuf ay:aygufvsuf½Sdaom pdwfrsm;yif jzpf&mayonf/

Page 80: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

80 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

yXrpdwfonf ]uHpdwf} jzpfonf/ aemufpdwfrsm;onf ]0dygufpdwf}jzpfonf/ 0dygufpdwfESifY uHpdwfwdkYonf ]vGefusL;vdkpdwf}csif; wlnDMuonf/wom;wnf; jzpfonf/ odkYaomfvnf;-

]uHpdwf}onf wnfaqmufrIygaompdwf jzpfonf/0dygufpdwf onf wnfaqmufrIrygaompdwf jzpfonf/þodkYvnf; rwlcGJjcm; ESpfaxGjym;vsuf ½Sdonf/0dygufpdwfonf tb,faMumifY wnfaqmufrIrygbJ ½Sd&oenf;/

uHpdwf\ wnfaqmufxm;aom t½Sdeft0grsm; rukefao;aomaMumifYodkYr[kwf usL;vGefaom uHpdwf\apwemonf ]rusL;vGefoifY}[k jzpfay:vwåHUaom aumif;aomapwemudk tvJxdk;xm;NyD; jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

xdkYxufxif½Sm;aom uHESifY0dygufwdkY\ ESpfaxGjym;aomfvnf;wom;wnf;jzpfykHudk oabmusEdkif&ef ykHpHwpfckudk aemufqkH; xkwfjyvdkygao;onf/ ,if;um; xGufavç0ifav-paom ½kyfur®|mef; wpfckckudk½IoloEÅmefüjzpfaom ]uHpdwfESifY0dygufpdwf}rsm; jzpfygonf/

xdkolonf wpfaeYvsif wpfem&DcefY w&m;xdkif&ef xGufavç0ifavudk pdwfrSwffrS raysmufqkH;atmif avYvm\/ xdkolonf w&m;xdkifaomtcg xGufavç0ifavudk pdwfrSrxGufatmif BudK;pm;í wifae&aomaMumifYumr- ponfrSvGwfaom 0dwufç0dpm&[laom BuHpnfjcif;çokH;oyfjcif;w&m;rsm; jzpfvsuf½Sd\/

xdkodkYyifjzpfaomfvnf; xdk0dwufESifY0dpm& w&m;rsm;onf olwdkYjzpf&aom xGufavç0ifavtm½kH\ BudKufzG,fç rkef;zG,fç csKwfcs,fzG,frsm;rS vGwfaeaomaMumifY umrçAsmyg'ç0d[ðomrsm;rSvGwfaom 0dwufç0dpm&jzpfíaeavonf/ xdkYaMumifY xdkw&m;xdkifaomolonf ESpfodrfYrIç csrf;ajrhrIçat;NidrfrI-[laom yDwdçokcESifY {u*¾wmw&m;rsm;vnf; jzpfyGm;vsuf½Sdayonf/

Page 81: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 81

xdkolü xdkw&m;ig;yg;pkH yg0ifaom ½lyyXrpsmefpdwfonf jzpfay:ae\/ xdkYaMumifY xdkolonf w&m;xdkifaepOfwpfem&DtwGif;ü umrpäEpaom umrESifYpyfaom eD0&P[laom tkHUykef;a&m*grsm;onf uif;uGmNidrf;at;vsuf ½Sdavonf/ xdkolonf wpfem&DapYaomtcg w&m;xddkifjcif;0wfedAwf apYiukHvkHNyDjzpfí ,aeYtzdkY w&m;rSxívm\/

aemuftcsdefü xdkolonf w&m;udk rxdkifawmYNyD/ tdrfrIvkyfief;rsm;udk csOf;uyfvkyfudkifvsuf ½Sd\/ xdkvkyfudkif&aom tdrfrIvkyfief;rsm;uvnf;ol\ w&m;xdkifaepOfu jzpfay:cJY&aom Nidrf;at;rIrsm;udk ysufjym;oGm;avmufatmif aESmuf,Sufwm;qD;jcif;? vSJcsNzdKzsufEdkifjcif; tiftm;rsm;r½SdMuay/ xdkYaMumifY xdkolonf w&m;xdkifpOfuuJYodkYyif ,ck rxdkifawmYaomtcsdefvnf; umrçAsmyg'ç0d[ðomwdkYrSvGwfaom 0dwufç0dpm&wdkYomjzpfaeonf/

xdkw&m;rsm;om jzpfaeaomaMumifY xdkol\pdwfoEÅmefonf ESpfodrfYçcsrf;ajrhç at;Nidrf;jcif;wnf;[laom yDwdçokcç{u*¾wmrsm;vnf;raysmufrqkH; jzpfay:aeonf/ xdkYaMumifY xdkolonfvnf; psmeft*Fgig;yg;yg0ifpkHnDaom ½lyyXrpsmefpdwfonf jzpfay:íyif aeonf/

tdk-pm½Iol-þjyqdkcJYaom tpOfjzifY jzpfaompdwfonf ½lyyXrpsmefpdwf [kwfçr[kwf apm'emvdkpdwf jzpfay:ygovm;/ apm'emvdkvsifapm'emrjyKrD atmufygar;cGef;rsm;udk ajzapcsifygao;onf/

þpdwfonf tb,frnfaom pdwfygenf;? umrpdwfavm/ umrpdwfjzpfvsif tb,f umrpdwfygenf;/ umraombepdwfrsm;[k qdkrnfavm/ ,if; umraombepdwfjzpf&ef tb,ftm½kHudk ,lrnfenf;/

qufvufívnf; xGufavç0ifavtm½kHonf umrtrnfcHxdkufaomtm½kH [kwfyg\avm/ umrtm½kH trnfcHxdkuf&ef xGufavç0ifavonf ESpfouftyfçom,mtyfaom oabm ½Sdyg\avm/

Page 82: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

82 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

txufygar;cGef;rsm;udk rajzvdkvsifjzpfap? ajzNyD;vsifjzpfap? þjyqdkcJYaom pdwfonf ½kyyXrpsmefpdwfrsm;jzpfaMumif; vufcH&ayrnf/þpdwfrsm;onf w&m;tm;xkwfcsdeçf tm;rxkwfcsdefom uGJjym;onf? ½lyyXrpsmefpdwfjcif;um; twlyif/

þodkY w&m;tm;rxkwfcsdefüvnf; ½lyyXrpsmefpdwfonf tb,fYaMumifY &ae&oenf;/ w&m;tm;xkwfcsdefü jzpfay:aomuHonf eD0&Pw&m;rsm;udk tvJxdk;cJYonf/ tm;rxkwfcsdefüvnf; xdkodkY tvJxdk;cJYaomt½SdefjzifY eD0&Prsm; jyefvnfírxEdkifçr<u Edkifao;aomaMumifY qufvufí ½lyyXrpsmefpdwf jzpfay:aejcif; jzpfygonf/

tm;xkwfpOfujzpfaom ½lyyXrpsmefpdwfonf ukodkvfjzpfonf/tm;xkwfNyD;aemufü qufvufíjzpfay:aeaom ½lyyXrpsmef

pdwfonf 0dyguf jzpfonf/ þü ukodkvfpsmefonfvnf; 0dygufpsmef r[kwf?xdkYtwl 0dygufpsmefonfvnf; ukodkvfpsmefr[kwf/ þodkY ukodkvfESifY0dygufwdkY xl;jcm;uGJjym;jcif;(emewå)tjzpfodkY a&mufonf/

23/ o[Zmwur®ESifY ememu©Pduur®þodkYyif jzpfaomfvnf; ukodkvfpsmefonf 0dygufpsmefrS oD;jcm;

r[kwf/ 0dygufpsmefonfvnf; ukodkvfpsmefrS oD;jcm;r[kwf/ tb,fodkYoD;jcm; r[kwfoenf;/

ukodkvfpsmef\ &ifYusufjcif;onf 0dygufpsmefjzpfonf/ 0dygufpsmef\ Eke,fao;aomtjzpfonf ukodkvfpsmefjzpfonf/

uHESifY0dygufwdkYonf umv tjcm;tqD;½SdMuonf r[kwf/ uH\umv tqkH;rSaemufü tpjyKaomumvonf 0dyguf\umv jzpfonf/xdkodkY a½SUumvESifY aemufumvonf oD;jcm;umv jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY,if;udkyif ]emeu©Pdu}[k qdk&onf/

Page 83: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 83

þodkY uHESifY0dygufwdkY ememu©Pduumv a½SUaemuf½Sdjcif;onfESpfaxGjym;aomtjzpf (emewå) jzpfygonf/

xdkodkY umva½SUaemuf jzpfaomfvnf; aemufumvüjzpfaom0dygufpdwfonf a½SUumvüjzpfaom uHpdwf\jyKvkyfrIjzifY NyD;aompdwfjzpfonf/ oD;jcm;tm½kHESifY oD;jcm;0w¬KwdkY\ ½kdufcwfrIaMumifYjzpfonfr[kwf/

xdkYaMumifY uHESifY0dygufpdwfwdkYonf wom;wnf;tjzpf ({uwå)[kqdk&avonf/ uHESifY0dygufwdkY\ ]{uwå}ESifY ]emewå}jzpfykHonf ½Sif;av½Iyfavjzpf&rvdk ½Sdayonf/ xdkYaMumifY ay:vGifap&ef OyrmjzifY nTefjyvdkygonf/

vufcwfjzifYacgif;vmif;udk xdk;ESufwD;cwfaomtcg acgif;avmif;oHonf ay:xGufívmavonf/ ,if;acgif;avmif;oHonf xdk;cwfNyD;aemuf tcsdef tenf;i,fMumonftxd xGufay:NrJ xGufay:vsufyif½Sdonf/

acgif;avmif;udkxdk;jcif;ESifY acgif;avmif;jrnfjcif;? acgif;avmif;oHqufvufxGufay:jcif;wdkYonf ]taMumif;ESifYtusdK;} wpfpkH jzpfonf/]xdk;jcif;}-onf ]uH}jzpfonf/ ]acgif;avmif;oHxGufjcif;}onf ]0dyguf}-jzpfonf/ xdk;qJüvnf; acgif;avmif;oH xGufay:onf/ xdk;NyD;rSvnf; acgif;avmif;oH xGufay:onf-[k acgif;avmif;oHxGufay:jcif;[k qdktyfaom0dygufonf ESpfrsdK;jym;onf/

xdkESpfrsdK;udk ]xdk;qJtoH}ESifY ]xdk;NyD;toH}[lí emrnf rSnfhMuygpdkY/,if;toHESpfrsdK;onf ]xdk;qJ}ESifY]xdk;NyD;}[lí umvwpfckpDjzpfaomaMumifY]wpfckwnf;}-[k ajymír&Edkif/ xdkodkY wpfckwnf;r[kwfvsif xdk;NyD; acgif;avmif;oHonf tb,faMumifY jrnf[D;ae&oenf;-[k ar;zG,f½Sdonf/

Page 84: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

84 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdk;NyD;acgif;avmif;oHonf xdk;qJaomtoH\t½SdefaMumifY jrnf[D;aejcif;jzpfonf/ tb,ftrIudpö wpfckck oD;jcm;taMumif;aMumifY jrnf[D;onfr[kwf-[k trSefajymvdkvsif þodkYajz&ayrnf/ xdkodkYqdkvsif xdk;NyD;toHESifY xdk;qJtoHonf tb,frSm oD;jcm;pD [kwfoenf;/

þokdYyif uHESifY0dygufonf umvwpfckpDjzpfaomaMumifY ESpfaxGjym;onf/ umvjym;aomfvnf; tjzpftm;jzifY wpfckwnf;jzpfaomaMumifYwom;wnf;-[kyif qdk&onf/ þae&mü wom;wnf;jzpfykHudk oabmus&ef rsm;pGm eufeuf½Idif;½Idif; ½IMunfhzdkY vdkygonf/

]uH}onf ESpfrsdK;½Sdygonf/ jyKqJrSmvnf; tusdK;udk jzpfapygonf/jyKNyD;rSmvnf; tusdK;udk jzpfapygonf/ ]o[ZmwuH}ESifY ]ememu©PduuH}[lí tbd"r®a0g[m&tm;jzifY ac:ygonf/ qdkvdkonfrSm-

]uH}[lonf ]apwem}jzpfonf/,if;apwemonf olYcsnf; jzpfír&/ tazmftaygif;rsm;ESifYom

wGJícsnf; jzpf&onf/ ,if;odkY wGJíjzpfonfudkyif ]uHpdwfjzpfonf}-[kqdk&onf/ ,if;]uHpdwf}tm;vkH;onf ]uH}r[kwf/ ,if;]uHpdwf}tm;vkH;xJrS]apwemoabmwpfckwnf;}omvsif ]uH}jzpfonf/ ,if;]uH}onf olESifYjzpfazmfjzpfzufrsm;udk olYtwdkif; jzpfaponf (o[Zmwur®)/

xdkYjyifvnf; ,if;]uH}onf oljzpfjyD;aemuf qufíjzpfaompdwfrsm;udkvnf; olrygawmhaomfvnf; olyg0ifpOfupdwftwdkif; qufíjzpfapayonf(ememu©Pduur®)/

þodkYyif uHonf o[ZmwESifh ememu©Pdu-[lí ESpfrsdK;jym;onf/ xdkYaMumifY ukodkvfpdwfESifY 0dygufpdwf? umvwpfckpDjcm;aomfvnf;wom;wnf;jzpfaMumif; qdktyfygonf/ umvjym;vsuf wom;wnf;jzpfykHudk oabmaygufEdkif&ef xufoefaomapwemjzifY Oyrmwpfck qufíjyKvdkygonf/

Page 85: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 85

a&m*gonfwpfa,mufonf aq;0g;jzifY ol\a&m*gudk ukoonfqdktHh/ temESifYaq; wnfhvsif aq;0g;aMumifY a&m*gaysmufayrnf/ þüukojcif;onf ]uH}jzpfonf/ ukopOfü a&m*gaysmufjcif;onf ]0dyguf}jzpfonf/ xdka&m*gaysmufjcif;onf ukoNyD;onfrS aemufwzef þa&m*grsdK;jyefrjzpfao;rD tcsdeftxd aysmufaeayrnf/

þü ukojcif;]uH}onf wpfckwnf; jzpfonf/ a&m*gaysmufjcif;]0dyguf}um; ESpfrsdK; jzpfaeayonf/ ukopOf aysmufjcif;ESifY ukoNyD;aemufvnf; qufí a&m*gaemufxyfrjzpfonftxd a&m*gaysmufaejcif;-[líjzpfonf/

xdkESpfrsdK;onf wpfckESifYwpfck xl;jcm;ygoavm? twlwlygavm/aq;0g;ukopOfaysmufaom a&m*gaysmufjcif;ESifY aq;0g;ukoNyD;

onfrS aemuftxd aysmufaeaom a&m*gaysmufjcif;onf wloavmçxl;oavm/ þodkYyif ]uHESifY0dyguf}wdkY\ ]{uwå}ESifY]emewå}jzpfykHonfoabmrSm ½Sif;onf txd ½SdaeoifYayonf/

þodkY ]uHESifY0dyguf}wdkY\ ]taMumif;çtusdK;qufoG,fykH}udk ½Sif;ojzifY ]uH\tusdK;jzpfaom0dyguf}-[lonf tb,fenf;-[laom jyóemonf NyD;jynfhpkHNyD[k xifjrifygonf/

24/ b0tusdK; 0dygufemrf½kyfþü ]b0\tusdK;w&m;}rsm;udk wifjycJY&m ]b0}ESifY]tusdK;}udk

qufpyfjycJYygNyD/ ,cktusdK;rsm;ESifYtwljzpfaom ½kyfçemrfwdkYtaMumif;udktenff;i,frQ qufíqdk&ygrnf/

]0dyguf}[laom ]b0tusdK;}rsm;onf jrifjcif;çMum;jcif;paom pdwfrsm;ESifY cHpm;jcif;çrSwfom;jcif;-paom pdwfESifYtwljzpfaom ]apwodufw&m;rsm;} jzpfygonf(emrf)/

Page 86: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

86 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYjyifvnf; udk,ftrlt&m? EIwftrlt&mESifY toHjyKjcif;? eknHhçaygYyg;çcHH Yxnfjcif;? yljcif;çat;jcif;çjzLjcif;çeDjcif;paom ½kyfrsm;vnf;jzpfygonf(½kyf)/

,if;wdkYonfyif ]b0\tusdK;rsm;} jzpfMuygonf/,if;wdkYonf-tajctaetm;avsmfpGm jzpfyGm;jcif;(Zmwd)?us½IH;jcif;(Z&m)?ysufjyKef;jcif;(r&P)rsm; jzpfMuygonf/xdkYaMumifY ]0dyguf}[laom ]b0\usdK;w&m;}onf ]toGifoP²mef}

tm;jzifY ,if;wdkYudk jrifcGifYr&Edkif/tb,fYaMumifY 0dyguf½kyfçemrfwdkYudk jrifcGifYr&Edkifygoenf;- qdkcJYacs

aomf ]0dygufemrfç½kyfwdkYonf yifudk,f½kyfçemrfrsm;ESifY a&maxG;wnfaeaomaMumifY jzpfygonf/}

qdkvdkonfrSm ]uH}wnf;[laom ]apwem}aMumifY yifudk,f½kyfçemrf(e*dk½kyfçemrf)rsm; wrsdK;wrnf ajymif;vJjzpfaeonfudk rodEdkifçrjrifEdkif}-[k jzpfygonf/

,if;]0dygufemrf½kyf}wdkY\ taiGUtouf tusdK;qufjzpfaom pdk;&drfjcif;? ylaqG;jcif;? idka<u;jcif;ponfom toGifoP²meftm;jzifY xif½Sm;ownf;/

þrQaompum;pOfjzifY Ak'tbd"r®m\ b0tjrifudk awGUjrifEdkif&efBudK;pm;vmcJYonfrSm b0½kyfvkH;onf ykHMurf;avmif;NyD;NyD-[k ,lqygonf/[kwfygonf/ ]b0}udkvnf;aumif;? ]b0\taMumif;ESifYtusdK;}udkvnf;aumif;? xdk ]tusdK;ESifYtaMumif;wdkY jyefvnfqufykH}udkvnf;aumif;wifjycJYNyD;ygNyD/

qufvufí tEkpdwftacsmudkif½kHrQom vdkawmYrnf-[k xifyg

Page 87: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 87

onf/ apm'emçaom"em (tar;çtajz)wnf;[laom aumfywfç pl;ao;çaqmufi,frsm;jzifY tacsmudkifMunfhMuygpdkY/

b0\ ½kyfvkH;ykHMurf;onfum; tb,fenf;-]b0}[lonf ]uH}jzpfonf/tb,faMumifY ]b0}udk &oenf;/]t0dZÆm}paom udavomaMumifY &onf/b0tusdK;um; tb,fenf;/odjrifjcif;ç cHpm;jcif;ç rSwfom;jcif;ç yljcif;ç at;jcif;ponf ponfh

]0dyguf emrfç½kyf}wdkY\ jzpfjcif;(Zmwd)? us½IH;jcif;(Z&m)? ysufjyKef;jcif;(r&P)rsm;wnf;/

tb,faMumifY b0jzpfaMumif;jzpfaom t0dZÆmpaom udavomrsm; jzpf&oenf;/

]b0\tusdK;}rsm;jzpfaom 0dygufemrfç½kyfwdkY\tay:ü ESvkH;oGif;t½IjrifrSm;aomaMumifY ]b0taMumif;}rsm; jzpf&ygonf/ ]'ku©udk 'ku©rSef;rodbJ? 'ku©udk okc-[k txifjrifrSm;jcif;}-onf ]t0dZÆm}-jzpfygonf/xdkodkY txifjrifrSm;rIaMumifY BudKufjcif;ç rkef;jcif;paom udavomrsm;qifYyGm;vmonfudk ]udavomrsm;jzpfjcif;}-[k qdkvdkonf/

þum; ]b0\½kyfvkH;ykHMurf;} wnf;/

25/ b0[lonf pdwåu©PrQomþodkYqdkvsif ]b0[lonf pdwåu©PrQjzpfí wdkawmif;vSacs w

um;? tb,fodkYenf;}-[k ar;csifzG,f jzpfygonf/ [kwfyg\? ]b0[lonfwdkawmif;\}/ ,if;odkY wdkawmif;onfudk rauseyfvsif ]b0\teuft"dyÜg,f}udk oD;jcm;zGifYEdkifygonf/ odkYaomfvnf; Ak'\tbd"r®mtwGif;u zGifY&ygrnf/

Page 88: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

88 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]Ak'\tbd"r®m} twGif;u ]b0}udkzGifYqdkxm;onfrSm ]uH}[k twdtus zGifYqdkxm;ygonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]b0}udk ]uH}rSwyg; tjcm;zGifYp&mr½SdNyDr[kwfygavm/

wpfxdkiftwGif;rSmyif ]b0(ur®b0)}onf rsm;pGmajymif;Edkifonf/Oyywådb0-omvsif vrsm;ç&ufrsm; MumEdkifonf/Oyrm- pdwfaumif;½Sdaeolonf ,if;pdwfaumif;udk tzsuftqD;

rcH&ao;oítxd pdwfaumif;twdkif; ½Sdaeayrnf/ ,if;onf ]Oyywådb0}jzpfonf r[kwfygavm/

26/ b0tp trd0rf;wGif;uavmþodkY ]b0\teuft"dyÜg,f} jzpfaeygvsif rdcif0rf;wGif;ü pjzpfp-

om;aumifonf ]b0-&onf}[k qdkEdkifygrnfavm/þjyóemonf tav;teuf pOf;pm;oifYonf/ omrefvlrsm;

onf ]rdcif0rf;ü tpjyKvsifjyKjcif;}-yif ]b0&NyD}-[k txif½SdMuonf/þtwlyif xdktcsdefu&cJYaom b0onf ]aoNyD;rSqkH;onf}-[k xifjrifMujyefonf/

]b0}[lonf þajctp acgif;tqkH;jzpfaom taoG;çtom;çtaMumçt½dk;ponfwdkYjzifY zGJUxm;aom ½kyfvkH;½kyfcJBuD;-[k

rSwfxifMuonf/ xdkYaMumifY ½kyfvkH;½kyfcJjzpf&ef tpjyKaomtcsdefonf ]b0jzpfrIpcsdef}-[k xifjrifMuonf/ ½kyfvkH;½kyfcJBuD; ysufcsdefudk ]b0aocsdefçb0qkH;csdef}-[k xifjrifMuonf/

xdktxifçtjrifrsm;onf Ak'\tbd"r®mü w&m;r0ifaomtxifrsm; odkYr[kwfpdwåZtxifrsm;om jzpfonf/ ]b0tpjyKaomtcsdef}onfrdcif0rf;wGif;üjzpf&ef rsm;pGm taMumif;uif;vSayonf/

tb,faMumifYenf;¿

Page 89: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 89

]b0}[lonf ukodkvfçtukodkvfapwodufrsm;ESifY twljzpfaom ]apwem}wnf;[laom ]uH}wnf;/,if; ]ukodkvfESifYtukodkvfpdwfrsm;onf rdcif\0rf;wGif;ü aZm

apmEdkifMu jzpfEdkifMuygrnfavm/ rdcif0rf;wGif;ü om;aumifonf touf&ªNyDavmç r&ªao;avm/

]uHpdwf}rsm;onf toufr&ao;aom om;aumifudkxm;ítouf&vsufESifY tdyfaysmfaeaom vGwfvyfaomvlrsm;üyif jzpfjcif;r½SdMuacs/}

xdk rdcif0rf;wGif;om;aumifü &ufçvçem&DESifY rdepfçpuúefYwdkYtvdkufom;aumif[k ac:Edkifaom txnfj'yfoP²mef ½Sdonfvnf;rSef\/ xdkom;aumifESifYxdpyfae&aom tawGUtm½kHtrsdK;rsdK;- rsm;onfvnf; rSef\/xdkodkYjzpfaomaMumifY xdkom;aumifonf cHpm;rIçrSwfom;rIrsm;jzpfrnf-[k r,lqxdkufoavm-[k ar;zG,f½Sdyg\/

xdkuav;i,fudk uREkfyfwdkYü prf;oyfud&d,m r½Sdí rodEdkifaomfvnf; um,yom'-paom ½kyfMunfrsm; MunfNyDvm;çrMunfNyDvm;-pojzifY qifjcifpOf;pm;EdkifcGifYum; ½Sdayonf/

arYaq;tay;cH&olonf cHpm;rIçrSwfom;rIrsm; ½Sdygoavm/ ½Sdvsifxdkolonf cGJpdwfjzwfawmufrIrsm;twGuf (arYaq;ay;ícGJpdwfcsdefwGif)emusifjcif;ponf jzpf&m\/ xdkolonf cGJpdwfjcif;ponfaMumifY emusifygoavm/

cHpm;jcif;ç rSwfom;jcif;ponfwdkYonf ]0dygufemrfw&m;}wnf;/xdk]0dygufemrfw&m;}rsm;ESifYtwljzpfaom udk,ftrlt&mç EIwftrl

t&mç toHponfh ½kyfrsm;vnf; jzpfygonf/ þarYaq;tay;cH&aomþolü pdwåZ½kyfrsm;aum jzpfygoavm/

Page 90: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

90 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

arYaq;tay;cH&í arYaeolonf 0dygufemrf½kyfrsm; odkYr[kwfpdwfESifY pdwåZ½kyfrsm; csKyfaeMuygonf/ ]uH}onfè]0dygufemrf½kyf}rsm;jzpfaeNyD;? xdk0dygufemrf½kyfrsm;tay:ü ESvkH;oGif;rsm;ygrS jzpfEdkifonf/

xdkYaMumifY trd0rf;wGif;ü½Sdaom uav;i,fonf arYaq;tay;cH&olxuf ]0dygufemrfç½kyf}rsm; ]rjzpfrnf}rSm aocsmygonf/ xdkodkYrS 0dygufemrf½kyfrsm; rjzpfvsif ,if;wdkYudk ESvkH;oGif;rSm;jcif;aMumifY ]udavomjzpf}?,if;odkY udavomjzpfNyD;rS ]uHpdwf}jzpf&aomMumifY xdkuav;ü ]uHpdwf}onf ]vkH;0rjzpfrnf}rSm taotcsmygwnf;/

xdkYaMumifY trd0rf;wGif;ü ]b0eduEÅdu avmbaZm}apmonf-tp½Sdaom ]uHpdwfrsm;} jzpfaMumif;jypum;rsm;onf tajctjrpfr½SdaomodkYr[kwf wu,f tjzpfrSefESifYuif;uGmaom pum;rsm;om jzpfMuayonf/trd0rf;wGif;ü uav;i,fü ]uHpdwfrsm;} tvsOf;rjzpfaomaMumifY ]0dygufpdwf}rsm;vnf; tvsOf;rjzpf/

xdkYtwl trd0rf;wGif;uav;i,fü ur®Z½kyfrsm;vnf; tvsOf;rjzpf/pdwåZ½kyfrsm;vnf; tvsOf;rjzpf/ OwkZ½kyfESifY tm[m&Z½kyfrsm;jzifYNyD;onfht&mrQ jzpfayonf/

27/ y#doaEçb0ifçpkwdpdwfrsm;þpum;aMumifY pm½Iolonf vuf½kH;vufarmif; wef;vmrvm;

yif/ atmufygar;cGef;udkyif ar;csifrvm;yif/]y#doaEpdwf}qdkwm b,fvdkvJ/b0ifpdwfuaum b,fvdkvJ/NyD;awmYvnf; trd0rf;ü rsufapYçem;ponfwdkY\ ½kyfMunfrsm; rjzpf

NyDavm}-ponfh jyóemrsm;yif/

Page 91: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 91

]y#doaEpdwfçb0ifpdwf}rsm;onf rdcif0rf;wGif;ü vkH;0rjzpfEdkifyg}-[líyif ajz&ygrnf/ xdkodkYqdkvsif ]y#doaEpdwf}[lonf tb,ftcsdefüjzpfoenf;-[laom tar;\tajzudk xkwfay;zdkY vdkygonf/

]y#doaEpdwf}onf ]b0ifpdwf}ESifY wpfckwnf;aompdwf jzpfygonf/]y#doaE}[laom trnfESifY ]b0if}[laom trnfrsm;onf xdktrnfrsm;trSnfhac:cH&aompdwfrsm;\ tvkyfudpötvdkuf&½Sdaom trnfrsm;jzpfygonf/

xdkpdwfrsm;um; ]uH\tusdK;jzpfaom 0dygufpdwf}rsm;wnf;/ xdk-]uHESifY0dygufwdkY qufoG,fykH}onf txufu tus,fw0HY wifjycJYonfhtwdkif; wom;wnf;({uwå) jzpfonf/

qdkvdkonfrSm tu,fí ]uH}wpfckjzpfonf qdktHh/ xdk]uH}\aemufü odkYr[kwf xdk]uH}jzpfNyD;tqkH;ü ]b0ifus}ygonf/ þ]b0if}onf ]xdkuH\b0if} jzpfonf/ xdk]uH}onf ]umrukodkvfuH} jzpftHh/ ,if;aemufü usaom b0ifonf ]umr0dygufb0if} jzpfonf/ wzef qufíqdkygOD;rnf/

tu,fí ]½lyukodkvf yXrpsmefaZm} apmvsuf ]uHpdwf}jzpfonfqdktHh/ xdk]uHpdwf}\aemufüjzpfaom b0ifonf ]½ly0dyguf yXrpsmefb0if}om jzpfonf/

]½lyukodkvf yXrpsmef}onf ]jzpf&mXme}-[k qdktyfaom ]'Gg&-½Sdonf}/ ]½ly0dygufyXrpsmef}u jzpf&mXme[laom ]'Gg&-r½Sd}/

,if;odkY jzpf&mXme'Gg& r½SdygbJvsuf xdk½lyyXrpsmef0dygufonf]b0iftjzpf} tb,fodkY jzpfoenf;/ ]'Gg&½Sd}jzpfaom ½lyukodkvfyXrpsmefESifYwqufwnf; ]qufpyfaeaomaMumifY} jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY tjzpfcH&aom]½ly0dygufyXrpsmef}\ ]tpqkH;pdwf}onf ]uHESifY qufpyfrI ½SdaomaMumifY}]y#doaE¨}jzpfonf/ ]tv,fpdwf}rsm;onf ]b0ifpdwf}rsm; jzpfMuonf/]tqkH;pdwf}rsm;onf ]pkwdpdwf}rsm; jzpfMuonf/

Page 92: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

92 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þodkYyif y#doaEç b0ifpdwfrsm;onf trd0rf;wGif;om;i,fü jzpfonf r[kwfyg/ ]uHpdwf}jzpfaom olwdkYüom þodkY ]y#doaEç b0ifç pkwdpdwf}rsm; jzpfMuygonf/

y#doaEpdwf[lonf uH[laom b0wpfckESifYwpfckudk qufpyfay;aompdwfjzpfonf/

pkwdpdwf[lonf b0(0g)uH\ a½GUavsmoGm;aomtjzpf jzpfonf/

28/ trd0rf;wGif;ü tMunf½kyfrjzpfqufvufí trd0rf;wGif;ü rsufapYçem;paom tMunf½kyfrsm;

rjzpfoavm - [ltHh/ ]rjzpf}-[líyif uREkfyfwdkY ajz&ygrnf/[kwfygonf/ rsufapYESifY em;ponfrsm;onf trd0rf;wGif;ü rjzpf

r[kwfMuyg/ odkYaomfvnf; ]tMunfrsm; rjzpfao;yg}/ þae&mü ]tMunf}-qdkaomt&mum; tb,fenf;/ ,if;udk½Sif;&ef Oyrm jy&ygrnf/

OyrmrSmè vQyfppfyefumESifY rD;vkH;çrD;acsmif;ponf wpfckkck jzpfygonf/ þOyrmü qdkcJYaom wpfckckonf xkwfvkyfaompuf½kHrS xkwfNyD;onfqdkvsif yefumçrD;vkH;çrD;acsmif; wpfckcktjzpfodkY a&mufygonf/ odkYaomf,if;wdkYudk vQyfppfESifY qufoG,fay;jcif; r½SdorQ vnfjcif;çvif;jcif;paom ouf0ifvIyf½Sm;rI[k qdktyfaom ]tMunfw&m;}rsm; r½Sday/

]rsufapYçem;}ponf trd0rf;wGif;uyif jzpfcJYonfrSefaomfvnf;xdkrsufapYESifY em;wdkYonf tMunfr½SdMu/ vQyfppfESifY rqufoG,f&ao;aom vQyfppfypönf;rsm;uJYodkY yif ½Sdao;onf/

]tMunf}-[laompum;onf ]Edk;jcif;}tp½Sdonfh oifYavsmfaomtrnfjzifY rSnfhac:tyfaomt&m jzpfonf/ rsufapYvkH;BuD;\twGif;üoef;OD;acgif;oP²mef ponfwdkY vkH;0r[kwfukef/

Page 93: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 93

pufudkxkwfvkyfaom puf½kHonf puftpdwftydkif;rsm;udk xkwfvkyfwyfqifay;vdkufayvdrfYrnf/ xdkodkY wyfqifNyD;cgrQjzifY xdkpufudk]Edk;NyD}[k rac:xdkuf/ tESpfwpf&mwdkifatmif rEId;bJxm;vsif EId;&efçvnf&efb,favmufNyD;jynfhpkHNyD jzpfaomfvnf; rEdk;ay/ EId;olu EId;rSom vnfayçEdk;ayrnf/

pufonf ]rsufapYçem;}ponfjzpfNyD;? puf\ vnfjcif;çEdk;jcif;onfrsufapYtMunfç em;tMunf jzpfonf/ pufudkEId;ay;olum; ]uHpdwfrsm;}jzpfjcif;wnf;/

29/ vl[lonf uHaMumifYjzpfaom owå0gþokdYqdkvsif ]vlonf uHaMumifYjzpfaomt&m} r[kwfbJ bmom

bm0jzpfaeaomt&mavm-[k ar;csifzG,f jzpfygonf/]vlonf bmombm0jzpfaeaomt&m r[kwfyg/vkH;0yif uHaMumifYjzpfaeaomt&m jzpfygonf}/vl-trsdK;rsdK; uGJaeonfrSm ]uH}u cGJxm;í jzpfygonf/ wcsdKUqif;&J

í wcsdKUcsrf;omjcif;ponf uGJjcif;rsm; jzpfygonf/aumif;aomuHudk vkyfolonf ]aumif;aomtusdK;}udk jzpf&yg

onf/ raumif;aomuHudk jyKvkyfolonfvnf; ]raumif;usdK;rsm;}udk &ygonf/ twdwfu b,favmufvlqdk;jzpfcJYaomfvnf; tck ]aumif;atmif}vkyfí&Edkifygonf/ twdwfu vlaumif;BuD; b,favmufyif jzpfaomfvnf; tckqdk;vsif ]vlaumif;rjzpf}Edkifyg? ]vlqdk;}yif jzpf&ygrnf/ þrQa&&m aocsmvSygonf/

xdkYaMumifYyif-]b0}[lonf ]uH(ur®)}jzpfonf-[k cH,ljcif; jzpfygonf/

Page 94: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

94 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

30/ okH;q,fYwpfbkH b0jyóemxdkodkY ]uH}udk vufcHonf}-qdkvsif Mum;zl;ae&aom ]okH;q,fhwpf

bkHb0}rsm;onf tb,fodkYenf;-[k ar;csifaumif; ar;csifzdkY ½Sdygonf/]okH;q,fYwpfbkHb0jyóem}onf ao;i,faom]b0jyóem} r[kwf

ay/ odkYaomf ]Ak'\b0tjrif}udk wD;acgufrdvsif ,if;jyóemonf eufeJaomjyóem r[kwfawmYay/ [kwfygonf/ ]Ak'\b0tjrif}udk aqG;aEG;cJY&mü ]ur®(=uH)}jyKvkyfí jzpfonf}-[k ]b0vnfykH}udk wifjycJYNyD;ygNyD/

]tvkyf}üvnf; ]taumif;çtqdk;}[lí ESpfrsdK; ½Sdygonf/xdkYaMumifY vkyfrIaMumifY ]jzpfay:vmaomtjzpf}-onfvnf; ESpfrsdK;

jzpf&ygrnf/þonfyif ]Ak'\tbd"r®(opöm)} jzpfygonf/trSm; vkyfjcif;/trSm; jzpfjcif; (0g) 'ku©jzpfjcif;/trSef vkyfjcif;/trSef jzpfjcif; (0g) 'ku©csKyfjcif; (0g) Nidrf;csrf;jcif;/þ]opömav;csuf}twGif;ü okH;q,fYwpfbkHavmu yg0ifjcif;

½Sdrnfavmçr½Sdrnfavm-a0zefapvdkygonf/ avmuü opömav;yg;rSvGwfaomoabm-[k ½SdEdkifrnfavm/

31/ okH;q,fYwpfbkHb0(=Oyywådb0) &ykH]okH;q,fYwpfbkHavmu}onf ]trSefjzpfjcif;(0g) Nidrf;csrf;

jcif;-r[kwf}/ trSefjyKjcif;rsm;vnf; r[kwf/ trSm;jzpfjcif; (0g) qif;&Jjcif;omwnf;/ þuJYodkY ]opöm}twGif; 0ifavonf/ okH;q,fYwpfbkHavmuonf opömtwGif;0ifcJYvsif odkYr[kwf opömtwGif;rS jzpfcJYvsif xdkopömonf ]vltwGif;ü ½Sdoavmç vl\ tjyifbufrsm;ü ½Sdoavm}-[ltHh/

Page 95: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 95

vlwGif;ü ½SdaMumif;- ajz&ayrnf/xdkYjyifvnf; xdkopömrsm;onf wpfcsufjcif;jzpfMuoavmç wNydKif

euf jzpfMuoavm- qdkvsif ]wNydKifeufjzpfMuonf}-[k ajz&ayrnf/xdkodkYqdkvsif ]okH;q,fYwpfbkHavmu}udk ajctpacgif;tqkH; wpfvH

rQavmufaom þudk,fum,ü ½SmazG&zdkY rvGJawmYacs/okH;q,fYwpfbkH[lonf tb,fenf;/tyg,fi&JESifY vlçewfçjA[®mwdkYwnf;/tyg,fESifY vlçewfçjA[®mrsm;onf tb,fYaMumifY jzpfMuoenf;/]tyg,f(b0)}[k qdktyfaom ]tyg,fuH}udkvkyfí ]tyg,f}-

[laom ]xif½Sm;rI(=Oyywåd)} jzpfonf/ xdkYtwl ]vlçewfçjA[®m(b0)}[kqdktyfaom uHudkvkyfí ]vlçewfçjA[®m}[laom ]xif½Sm;rI(=Oyyywåd)}jzpfonf/

tyg,fb0um; tb,fwdkYenf;/tyg,fb0rsm;um; ]tukodkvfuH}wdkYwnf;/]tukodkvfuH}vkyfaomolonf vkyfpOfwif;vsOf;vnf; xdktukodkvf

uH\owådaMumifY qif;&Jonf/ vkyfNyD;aemufvnf; xdkqif;&JrIBuD; vufusefwif;vsOf; usefaecJYonf/ þodkY xif½Sm;aom qif;&JtpOfwef;BuD;jzpfay:aerIonf ]tyg,fb0} jzpfonf/ tukodkvfuH0dygufjzpfaomb0ifrsm; usaejcif;onf tyg,fb0\ ]Oyywådb0} &jcif; jzpfonf/

,if;tukodkvf0dyguf\ tukodkvfjzpfNyD;aemuf yXrqkH;aompdwfonf ]tyg,fy#doaEpdwf}-jzpfonf rnf\/ odkYr[kwf ]tyg,fZmwd}-jzpfonf rnf\/ tv,fpdwfrsm;onf ]b0if}? tqkH;pdwfonf ]pkwd}jzpfonf rnf\/

vlçewfçjA[®mrsm;\ b0jzpfykH(=OyywådjzpfykH)vnf; þenf;twdkif;udkrSD;í odEddkifcGifY ½Sdavonf/

Page 96: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

96 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkodkYqdkvsif owå0gwpfOD;onf ]tyg,fESifY vlçewfçjA[®m}[laomb0wpfckcküjzpfaevsif b,favmuf MumjrifYpGm jzpfae&rnfenf;/ b,fodkYjzpfae&oenf;- ar;zG,f½Sdayonf/

owå0gwpfOD;onf wpfckckaomb0ü b,favmufMumjrifYrnf-[lí twdtus a&wGufí r&Edkif&may/ twdkawmif;qkH; umvrQjzifYvnf; b0wpfck ed*kH;csKyfEdkifavonf/ þpum;udk xif½Sm;atmif wifjyygrnf/

tyg,fb0 &aeaom owå0gwpfOD;\ tyg,fb0 yXrqkH; pjzpfaompdwfrSm tukodkvfuH\ tusdK;jzpfaom tukodkvf0dygufxJrS ]y#doaEvkyfief;}udk vkyfEdkifaom pdwf jzpfonf/ aemufqufjzpfaom pdwfrsm;rSm y#doaEvkyfief;udk vkyfcJYaompdwfESifY tvm;wlpdwfonfyif ]b0ifvkyfief;}udk vkyfvsuf qufjzpfonf/

xdkowå0gü þ]tyg,fb0}&atmif ypfcsvdkufaom ]tukokdvfuH}aMumifYjzpfaom rsufapYtMunfç em;tMunfponfrsm;ESifY ]tyg,fb0}[laom ]tukodkvfuH\0dyguf}pdwfrsm;aMumifY jzpfaom udk,ftrlt&m?eIwftrlt&m ponfrsm; jzpfay: ydkifqdkifvsuf ½Sdonf/

xdkYaMumifY xdkowå0g(=xif½Sm;jzpfjcif;)onf jrifjcif;çMum;jcif;paompdwfrsm; jzpfygonf/ ajymjcif;qdkjcif;? tcsufay;jcif; ponfrsm;udkvnf; olvkyfvdkvsif vkyfygonf/ ol jrif&çMum;&onfrsm;onf pdwfrMunfomp&mrsm;csnf; jzpfaewwfygonf/ udk,ftrlt&mç EIwftrlt&m ½kyfrsm;onfvnf; ywf0ef;usifESpfoufrI rcH& jzpfaeygonf/

xdkYaMumifY rsm;aomtm;jzifY olYESvkH;oGif;onfvnf; vuf½Sd tyg,fb0xuf tqifYtwef; rjrifYEdkifatmif ½Sdygonf/ xdkYaMumifY olapmaomaZmrsm;vnf; tukodkvfaZmrsm;yif jzpfaeygonf/ xdkYaMumifYyif olYb0onf ]tyg,fb0}xJrSmyif jyefí jzpfaeygonf/

Page 97: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 97

þodkY w0JvSnfhvSnfh ]tyg,foHo&m}vnfaejcif;udk ]tyg,fOyywådb0}-[k ac:&ygonf/ xdkYaMumifY tyg,füae&rnfhumvudk owfrSwfí rjyEdkifay/

½SnfMumEdkifaom tcGifYtvrf; ½Sdayonf/wdkawmif;Edkifaom tcGifYtvrf;vnf; ½Sdayonf/]0dyguftrSef aZmtjyef}-[lonfhtwkdif; txufü qdkcJYonfrsm;ü

aZmapmykHonf ]tukodkvfaZm}-[k jycJYonf/ aZmonf tm½kHESifY tu,frqdkif/ tyg,fom;jzpfí olYtm½kHonf pdwfrMunfp&m½Sdrnf rSefaomfvnf;]ESvkH;xm;wwf}vsif ]raumif;pdwf}[laom tukodkvfaZmrsm; rusbJ]aumif;pdwfaumif;uH}[laom ]ukodkvfaZm}rsm; usa&mufEdkifygonf/

ESvkH;xm;wwfatmif oifMum;olESifY awGUvsifvnf; ESvkH;xm;wwfonfyif jzpfygonf/ ESvkH;xm;wwfí ukodkvfuHpdwfrsm; jzpfyGm;vdkufonfESifY wNydKifeuf? tyg,fb0onf ed*kH;csKyfayonf/ aemufrS jyefqnf;yl;vsifom jyefjzpfayrnf/ þodkYvsif tyg,fb0onf wdkvnf; wdkEdkifonf/

tjcm;aom vlçewfçjA[®mpaom b0wdkYonfvnf; xdkenf;rjcm;ay/ jzpfaMumif;çysufaMumif;ESifY jzpfMuykHçysufMuykHonf wxyfwnf; wl\/jzpf&aom uHç 0dygufwdkY wpfckESifYwpfck rwlMuonfom xl;onf/

tyg,fb0ü tNrJae&ol[lí r½Sd/ tyg,fb0usaeaom owå0gonfvnf; vlçewfçjA[®mb0rsm;odkY tBudrfBudrf usa&mufcJYvnf; usa&mufcJYNyD;NyD/ usa&mufvwåHUvnf; jzpfEdkifonf/ xdkYaMumifY þ]okH;q,fYwpfbkH}onf ]0#fbkHBuD;} odkYr[kwf vSnfhvnfae&aombkHBuD;}[lí ajymqdkaeMujcif; jzpfonf/

þrQjzifY ]okH;q,fYwpfbkHb0}rsm; taMumif; ½Sif;vif;í NyD;oifYayonf/

Page 98: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

98 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

32/ Ak'tbd"r®m[m bmvJþpum;tpOfjzifY ]Ak'tbd"r®m}\ ]b0tjrif(=b0jzpfykH)} ½kyfvkH;

onf NyDjyifxif½Sm;oifYoavmuf xif½Sm;NyDjyifcJYNyD-[k uREkfyfwdkY ,lqygonf/ xdkYaMumifY Ak'tbd"r®m]b0tjrif(=b0jzpfykH)}udk aqG;aEG; wifjycsufrsm; ed*kH;csKyfvdkufygonf/

,cktcgü Ak'tbd"r®mü ]b0tjrif}udkvnf;aumif;? ]tESpfom&}udkvnf;aumif; wifjycJYNyD;jzpfí ]Ak'\ tbd"r®}wpf&yfvkH;udk aqG;aEG;NyD;NyD[k rSwf,l&ygrnf/ tuREkfyfwdkYonf apmapmtydkif;rsm; twGif;u]a½SUb0çaemufb0 taMumif;rsm;udk vlodEdkifoavm}- [laomjyóemudk aqG;aEG;&ef ]Ak'tbd"r®m}udk aqG;aEG;Mujcif; jzpfygonf/

,ck Ak'tbd"r®mudk aqG;aEG;cJYayNyD/b,fvdkvJ? Ak'tbd"r®monf a½SUb0ESifY aemufb0rsm;½SdaMumif;

nTefjyaom odkYr[kwf b0udk a½SUçaemufwdkYjzifY teufzGifYjyaom tbd"r®m[kwfyg\avm/

]Ak'tbd"r®m}onf rarG;rDESifY aoNyD;aemufwdkYjzifY NcH&Hvsuf teufzGifYjyaomtbd"r®m vkH;vkH;r[kwfyg/

]Ak'¨tbd"r®m}onf-]b0-[lonfudk þodkYjzpfonf? aumif;çqdk;ESpfwef pkefqefa,muf

,ufcwfaeonf-[k b0tjrifydkif;jcm;jyí? xdkokdYrjzpf&ef þokdY wnfaqmuf&rnf-[k vlwdkYtm; pdwful;,Of(tmom)rsm; ukefqkH;NyD;? Nidrf;csrf;&ef odkYr[kwf b0ukefqkH;&efnTefjyaom tbd"r®momjzpfaMumif;} awGU&ownf;/

xdkYaMumifY a½SUu ]ynmjzifY a½SUb0çaemufb0rsm;jzpfaMumif;odEdkifonf}-[laom tqdktwGuf ]Ak'¨tbd"r®mjzifY odEdkifonf}[laomtqdkonf ausysufcJYygNyD/

Page 99: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 99

33/ vlUb0 tb,fu&oenf;]tjcm; ynmwpf&yfjzifYvnf; owå0grsm;b0ü rarG;rDuESifY

aoNyD;aemufrsm;wGif b0rsm;qufjzpfao;onf-[lí odEdkifao;onf}-[k qdkcJYygao;onf/ ,if; tjcm;ynm&yfum; ]b0 aumif;çqdk;ESpfweftjzpfrsm;udk awGU&jcif;} [lownf;/

,cktcgü usefjyóemrsm;udk qufvufaqG;aEG;&ef oifYavsmfygonf/

þtjrifonf vltawmftrsm;pkxHü wifusefvsuf ½Sdygonf/,ckb0 aumif;çqdk;ESpfwef tjzpfrsm;udkawGU&ojzifY? ,if;wdkYudk

axmufqNyD; ]twdwfb0rsm;vnf; ½Sdonf? tem*wfb0rsm;vnf; ½Sdrnf}? þodkY tu,fyif odjrifEdkifygrnfavm/ tu,fí odjrifEdkdifonf-[kyif qdktHh/ tb,fodkY þ,ckb0 tjzpfrsm;udkawGUí odjrifEdkifygoenf;-[k ar;&ayrnf/

þtar;udkawGUvsif pm½Iolonf atmufygtwdkif; jyefí ar;csifayvdrfYrnf/

]þvlYb0onf tb,frS&oenf;/tb,faMumifY vljzpfvmoenf;}/þar;cGef;jzifYvnf; aemufb0udk odonf/ þar;cGef;onf pm½I

olar;csifonfrsm;xJü yXrusaomar;cGef;wpfckom jzpfzG,f½Sdygonf/[kwfygonf/ þar;cGef;onf ar;xdkufaomar;cGef; jzpfygonf/

þar;cGef;rsm;udk a½S;a½S;uvnf; ar;cJYvSygNyD/ a½S;uar;cJYolwdkY\ tar;onf tvGefyif apYpyfoyf&yfvSygonf/ oabmu ,ckar;aomoabmyif jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY xdkar;cGef;rsm;udk xkwfjyvdkufygNyD/

Page 100: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

100 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]½lyH e ZD0EÅd 0'EÅd Ak'¨g?}(udk,fonf b0r[kwf][k trSefodolrsm; ajymMuonf)]uxH EG,H 0dEwdrH o&d&H/}(þa[majymolawGrSm a[majymp&mudk,fBuD;udk b,fu&oenf;)]ukwó t|d ,ue yd@arwd?}(ol\ t½dk;pkçtoJpdkifrsm;aum b,fu&owJYenf;)]uxH EG,H oZÆwd *AÇo®dEÅd /}(olYtar0rf;wGif;ü olb,fvdk a&mufowJYenf;)þodkY *gxmjzifY pum;ydk'ffav;ydk'f ar;cJYygonf/ þü ay:vGifrI

jzpf&ef ]½ly}-[laom yk'fudk ]udk,f}-[k jrefrmjyefvdkufygonf/ ]½kyf}-[kjyefvsif y&rwfoHygí ½Iyfaernfpdk;í ½kyfESifYudk,fvnf; rxl;NyDrdkY jyefvdkufjcif; jzpfygonf/

[kwfygonf/ ]½kyf}qdkvsif awmçawmifça&çajr½kyfrsm;vnf; yg0ifEdkifí us,fjyefYvGef;oGm;ygrnf/ þü ]½ly}t&onf ,if;odkY tus,ftjyefYqdkvdkonf r[kwfyg/ þvlrsm;\½kyfudk qdkvdkygonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]½ly}t&udk]udk,f}-[k jyefqdkcJYygonf/ xdkYjyif ]ZD0}teufudkvnf; ]b0}-[k jyefqdkvdkufygonf/ ]ZD0=touf}[k odaeMuygonf/ ]touf}ESifY]b0}onf wpfckwnf;[k vlrsm;odaeMuonf r[kwfygavm/ toufaoaomoludk ]b0qkH;ol}-[k qdk&onf r[kwfygavm/

]ZD0}udk ]touf}[kjyefvdkufvsif e*dkuyif toufay:ü cyfrIefrIefjzpfaernfjzpfí ZD0udk ]b0}[k jyefvdkufjcif; jzpfygonf/ xdkYjyif ]t,H}wdkY]£rH}wdkYu emrfpm;tpGJrsm; jzpfygonf/ b,fvdkpGJaomfvnf; ,ck aqG;aEG;rnfht"dyÜg,f rzsufí vSatmifpGJí xm;vdkufygonf/ þtar;onfjrefrmoufoufjzifYjyefvsif atmufygtwdkif; t"dyÜg,fxGufygrnf-

Page 101: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 101

]udk,faumifonf b0r[kwf-qdkvsif olwdkYudk,fBuD;udk b,fu&oenf;/ olwdkYt½dk;ESifYtoJpdkifrsm;uaum b,fuvmoenf;/ trd0rf;ydkufxJudkaum olwdkY b,fvdka&mufMuoenf;/}

þtar;rsm;onf ]vlYb0 b,fu&oenf;? tb,fYaMumifY vljzpfoenf;}-[laom tar;rsm;ESifY twlyif jzpfayonf/

xdkYaMumifY þtar;onf uREfkyfwdkYajz&efrvdkaomtar; jzpfonf/tb,fYaMumifYqdkaomf þtar;\tajzudk avmuü MoZmtanmif;qkH;jzpfaom trSefw&m;udk azmfxkwfwifjycJYaom yk*¾dKvfwpfOD;u ajzqdkNyD;jzpfaomaMumifY jzpfonf/

,if;yk*¾dKvfum;vGefcJYaom ESpfaygif;ESpfaxmifYig;&mausmfu jzpfxGef;cJYaom ]Ak'¨bk&m;oQif}yif jzpfonf/

,if;\tajzonf atmufygtwdkif; jzpfonf/ ,if;tajzonfvnf; ygVdvdkjzpfí ygVdvdka&m? ygVdrodolrsm;twGuf jrefrmvdkyg wifjyvdkufygonfè

]yXr uvvH a[mwd?}(tpyXr uvva&Munf jzpf\)/]uvvm a[mwd tAÁK'H/}(uvva&MunfrS tjrIyfEk jzpf\)/]tAÁK'g Z,aw ayod?}(tjr§KyfEkrS tjr§KyfMurf; jzpf\)/]ayod edAÁwåwD Caem/}(tjr§KyfMurf;rS om;wpf jzpf\)/]Cem yomcg Zm,EÅd?}(om;wpfrS cufrrsm; jzpf\)/

Page 102: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

102 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]auom avmrm ecgydp/}(qHçtarT;çajconf;vufonf; jzpf\)/],Oöó bkOÆwd rmwm tEéHygeOö abmZeH/}(rdcifu xrif;çtazsmfESifY pm;p&mwpfckck pm;\)/]aweaom ww¬ ,mayod? rmwk ukpäd*awm ea&mwd}/(,if;wdkYESifYyif rdcif0rf;aeolonf rdcif0rf;ü rQwvsuf ae\)/xdkYjyifvnf; þudk,faumifESifYpyfí jywfjywfom;om; a[mcJYjcif;

rsm; rsm;pGm ½Sdaeayao;onf/ ,if;wdkYteuf atmufyg a[majymcsufonfvnf; tawmfxda&mufyGifYvif;aom a[majymcsuf jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY ,if;jyóemESifYpyfí MunfndkEdkif&ef atmufwGif azmfjyvdkufygonf-

]t,H ar uma,m ½lyd pmwkr[mblwdaum rmwmayw¬du orÇa0g ? Mo'e ukr®m olypa,m}/qdkvdkonfrSm-]þbkwf½kyf udk,faumifBuD;onf rdbESpfOD;wdkY aoG;rsm;a&mpyf&mrS

jzpfonf/ xrif;çrkefYrsm;jzifY yGm;pD;BuD;jrifYaeonf}-[lí jzpfonf/]vlonf þodkYjzpfvmonf}-[kyif uREfkyfwdkYvnf; ajymqdk&ayrnf/]rdbwdkY\aoG;ESpfck a&mpyfaomaMumifY ]vljzpfonf}- rSwfom;oifY

onf/ xdkodkY rdbwdkYaoG;a&mpyf&mü ]wwd,ypönf;wpfck} aemufxyfa&mpyfao;onf-[k rxifapvdk/ xdkodkY a&mpyfvmaMumif; tv,ftvwftawG;tac:udk azmfxkwfodjrifMuolwdkY\ tqdktrdefYrsm;üvnf; tvsOf;rawGU&/ uREfkyfwdkYudk,fwdkifvnf; ½dk;om;pGm 0efcH&vsif ]rodaMumif;}yif0efcH&rnfrSm trSefjzpfayonf/

xdkYaMumifY trdaoG;ESifY tzaoG;[k-qdktyfaom yXrESifY 'kwd,ypönf; ESpfrsdK;tjyif okH;ckajrmufjzpfaom ]*EAÁ}[laom ]wwd,ypönf;wpf

Page 103: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 103

rsdK;} aemufxyfí aygif;vmao;onf-[k rcH,loifYukef/ cH,lvsif ]tm*rçobm0} wpfckckjzpfaom ,kwådjzifY jyqdk&efvdkonf/ rjyEdkifbJ cH,lvsif]pdwful;,OfpdwåZjzpfrI odkYr[kwf tmo0yGm;rI}om tzwfwifNyD; qif&JJwGif;euf&zdkY ½Sdonf/

34/ a,musfm;çrdef;r b,fvdkaMumifY uGJjym;&oenf;þae&mü rauseyfvsif pm½Iolü ar;p&mar;cGef;wcsdKU xGufzdkY½Sdyg

onf/ þodkY ]ypönf;ESpfckaygif;í vljzpfonf}qdkvsif vlwdkif;yif twljzpfMuygawmYavm/ vlwdkif;yiftrdESifYtzwdkY\ aoG;a&mpyfjcif;aMumifY jzpfMuonfcsif;wlvsuf tb,faMumifY vlrsm; wpfOD;ESifYwpfOD; rwluGJjym; jcm;em;Muoenf;}/ þodkY ar;zdkY½Sdygonf/

]vlrsm;onf tb,fodkY wpfOD;ESifYwpfOD; rwluGJjym; jcm;em;aeoenf;}- þodkY jyefar;vsif atmufygtwdkif; ajzayrnfè

]vlonf wpfOD;ESifYwpfOD;wlonf-[lí wpfa,mufrQ r½Sd/ wpfckr[kwf wpfckü uGJjym;jcm;em;vsuf½Sdonfudk rkcsawGUEdkifonf/ þonfwdkYudkxm;í tBuD;rm;qkH;aom uGJjym;rIudkxkwfjyvsif ]a,musfm;ESifY rdef;r}jzpfonf/

aoG;ESpfcka&mpyfí jzpfonfcsnf;qdkvsif twlwl jzpfygawmYavm/tb,faMumifY tcsdKUonf a,musfm;jzpfí tcsdKUonf rdef;rrsm; jzpfaeMuoenf;/ þodkY jyefar;csif ayvdrfYrnf/ þjyóemudkajz&eftwGufar;oltm; tenf;i,f jyefíar;cGef;xkwf&ygrnf/ ,if;um; atmufygwdkYjzpfygonfè

a,musfm;qdkwm b,fvdk[mvJ/rdef;rqdkwmuaum b,fvdk[mvJ/

Page 104: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

104 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

a,musfm;ESifYrdef;r[lonf vl\aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mü toGifoP²mefrwl uGJjym;jcm;em;Muaom tjzpf½Sdolrsm;udk qdkygoavm/

pm½Iolonf þtar;twGuf pdwf wdkaumif;wdkygrnf/ xdkYaMumifY]'gr[kwfvdkY bmvJ}-[kyif qdkcsifaumif; qdkcsifygvdrfYrnf/ þodkYrsm;tu,fíqdkcJYvsif pm½Ioludk ar;cGef;jzifYyif ajz&ygrnf/

[kwfygonf/ a,musfm;çrdef;rwdkY\ aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mü xl;jcm;aomtoGifoP²mef ESpfrsdK;onf vl-pjzpf&mü wwd,ypönf;jzpfaom *EAÁaMumifYjzpfonf/ ,if; *EAÁ\taMumif;onf ]tvkH;}jzpf&ef qnf;yl;cJYvsif ]tvkH;}jzpfonf/ ]tjym;}jzpf&ef oifYavsmfvsif ]tjym;}jzpfonf/ þodkYqdkvsifþodkY vkH;aomçjym;aomoabmonf vlürl oifYwefygap/

xef;yifrsm;ü tb,faMumifY tcsdKUxef;apYudkpdkufvsif xef;ryifaygufvsuf? tcsdKUxef;apYudkpdkufvsif xef;zdkyif aygufvmMu&oenf;/xef;yifu xef;oD;-oD;í xef;apYjzpf&mü vluJYodkY ]*EAÁ}[laom wwd,ypönf;rsm; yg0ifaejyefao;oavm/ (oabFmyifvnf; twlyif)/

þtar;jzifYyif ajz&ygrnf/ ]t0dnmPu}[laom emrfw&m;r½Sdaom þxef;apYonf tzdkçtr ESpfrsdK;aomxef;yifrsm;udk aygufyGm;apEdkifao;vsif vlrsdK;apYjzpfaom trdçtzwdkY\ aoG;taygif;aMumifY vl-toGifuGJrIrsm;jzpfonfudk vufcHEdkifoifYygonf/

,aeYvlrsm;onf tu,fí vdkvsif vljzpf&mü xdk-vljzpftHhaomvl\ aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mü tvkH;udkvdkvsif-tvkH;? tjym;udkvdkvsif-tjym;jzpfatmif jyKvkyfEdkifvsufyif ½SdaeMuayNyD/ a,musfm;\ rsdK;aoG;xJrStvkH;udk jzpfapEdkifaom rsdK;aoG;trsdK;tpm;jzifY rdef;r\rsdK;Oudkudk aygif;apvdkufvsif arG;vmaomuav;\ aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mü tvkH;uav; yg½Sdvmrnf jzpfonf/

Page 105: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 105

xdkYaMumifY vl\ aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mü tvkH;oP²mef? tjym;oP²mefESpfrsdK;jzpfjcif;onf ]*E¨AÁ}\ taMumif;tm;avsmfpGmjzpfonf r[kwf/trdaoG;ESifY tzaoG; aygif;&mü tzaoG;\ ESpfrsdK;ESpfpm;½SdonfhteufwpfrsdK;ESifYaygif;jcif;aMumifY tzdkjzpfap? trjzpfap wpfrsdK;jzpfjcif; jzpfonf/

tzdkrsdK;aoG;ESifYaygif;vsif tzdkjzpfonf/ trrsdK;aoG;ESifYaygif;vsiftrjzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY vl-aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mü oP²mefESpfrsdK;teuf wpfrsdK;rsdK;jzpf&ef taMumif;&if;rSm ]tz\rsdK;aoG;}om jzpfonf/ xdk-tzaoG;onfvnf; xdkESpfrsdK; a&maeaomaMumifY trdrsdK;OESifY xdpyf&mü wpfrsdK;aomtzaoG;ESifYom xdpyfaygif;pnf;avonf/

,if;odkY aygif;pnf;jcif;udkvnf; tb,ftrsdK;ESifYom aygif;pnf;&rnf? tb,ftrsdK;ESifY raygif;&[k bmESifYrQ? b,folurS pnf;owfaygif;qkHay;jcif;vnf; ,aeYtxd ½SdcJYzl;onf r[kwfacs/

xdkYaMumifY vlwdkY\ aygif;ESpfvkH;qkH&mü xl;jcm;aomtoGifoP²mefESpfrsdK;teufwpfrsdK;rsdK;udk &aeMujcif;onf ]tAsmyg'}(aMumifYMurJY)&ae&jcif;om jzpfayonf/ ]uH}aumif;ívnf; r[kwf? ]uH}qdk;ívnf;r[kwfukef/

xdkYjyifvnf; þtoGifoP²mefESpfrsdK;teuf tb,ftrsdK;onf-aumif;onf? tb,ftrsdK;onf-qdk;nHhonf-[lívnf; r½Sd/ ]½Sdonf}-xifolrsm;onf pdwfrrSefol? pdwåZa&m*g½SdolwdkYom jzpfMuayonf/tb,faMumifYqdkaomf þtoGifoP²mefrsm;onf ]uH}\tusdK;jzpfaomtoGifoP²mefrsm; r[kwfMuaomaMumifYwnf;/

þ-a,musfm;ESifYrdef;ronf aumif;rIçraumif;rIudk jyKvkyfjcif;[laom vl\uHaMumifY jzpfay:vmaom a,musfm;ESifYrdef;rrsm; r[kwfaomaMumifY[k qdkvdkygonf/

Page 106: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

106 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þ-aumif;rIçraumif;rIuHaMumifYjzpfaom a,musfm;çrdef;r[lí½Sdygao;\avm-[k ar;csifaumif; ar;csifygvdrfYrnf/

½Sdygonf/ aoaocsmcsmyif-½Sdygonf-[lí ajz&ygrnf/ tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:udk odjrifNyD;olrsm;\ avmuü a,musfm;çrdef;rteufj'yfonf aygifESpfvkH;qkH&müuGJjym;aom toGifoP²mefudkrSwfí qkH;jzwfjcif; tvsOf;yif r½SdMuacs/

xdkolwdkYonf a,musfm;ESifYrdef;rudk tb,fodkYowfrSwfMuoenf;-[k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/ xdkoljrwfwdkYonf atmufygtwdkif; owfrSwfMuygonfè

]vlwpfOD;OD;onf ol\ aygifESpfvkH;qkH&mae&mü tvkH;ygonf jzpfap? tjym;ygonfjzpfap? oefY½Sif;aom [efyeftjcif;t&m½Sdvsif]a,musfm;}jzpf\/ r½Sdvsif ]rdef;r} jzpfonf}/

oefY½Sif;aomtjcif;t&m[lonf tb,fenf;/tm½Hkig;yg;udk cHpm;jcif;½Sdaom avmuüom þ-oefY½Sif;ç roefY

½Sif;[laom pum;udk ajymqdkp&m ½Sdygonf/ þ-]oefY½Sif;}[lonfrSm]BudKufvdkjcif;}u vGefuJí? tBudKufcHvdkjcif;u ikyfcsdKUaejcif;-[k tMurf;zsif;tm;jzifY qdk&ygrnf/ xdkYtwl ]roefY½Sif;}-[lonfrSmvnf; BudKufvdkjcif;ua½SUwef;a&mufrvmbJ ]tBudKufcHvdkjcif;}u a½SUwef;a&mufjcif;[k qdk&ygrnf/

þodkYaom trlt&m[efyef tBuD;ti,frsm;jzifY oGm;jcif;ç vmjcif;ç vIyf½Sm;jcif;ç upm;jcif;ç jyifqifcs,fojcif;paom udk,ftrlt&m?EIwftrlt&mrsm;onf a,musfm;ESifY rdef;rudk cGJjcm;aom tjcif;t&mrsm;jzpfMuygonf/ wenf;tm;jzifY ]roefY½Sif;}[laom pum;\teufonfþodkY em;vnfoifYonf/

]ESpfoufom,mzG,faom tqif;çtoHçteHYçt&omçtawGUwdkYudktvdk&rufaemufodkY aumufaumufvdkufí vGefvGefusL;usL; rl;rl;arYarY

Page 107: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 107

cHpm;jcif;? ,if;cHpm;jcif;aMumifYjzpfaom udk,fçEIwftrlt&mrsm; jzpfonf}/]oefY½Sif;aom tjcif;t&m}-[lonf ]ESpfoufom,mzG,faumif;

aom tqif;ponfwdkYü rcHpm; r[kwfaomfvnf; vGefusL;,pfrl;jcif; r½SdbJxdef;xdef;odrf;odrf;jzifY rrSm;,Gif;atmifcHpm;jcif;? ,if;cHpm;jcif;aMumifYjzpfaom udk,fçEIwftrlt&mrsm; jzpfonf}/ wenf;vnf;-

]avmbrsm;ol\ udk,fçEIwfçESvkH; trlt&mrsm;}onf ]roefY½Sif;aom tjcif;t&m} jzpfygonf/ avmbw&m;rsm;uif;uGmaejcif; r[kwfaomfvnf; enf;yg;aom odkYr[kwf ]w'*Fy[mef y,fowfxm;aomolwdkY\ udk,fçEIwfçESvkH; trlt&m}onf ]oefY½Sif;}onf/ xdkodkY oefY½Sif;aomtjcif;t&m½Sdolonf a,musfm;tjzpf ½Sdol? roefY½Sif;aom tjcif;t&m½Sdolonf rdef;rtjzpf-[laom udk,fum,½kyfw&m;½Sdol jzpfonf/

þa,musfm;ESifY rdef;rrsm;onfom t,kwfESifYtjrwf cGJí&onf/tv,fvrf;tjrifudk oabmayguf odjrifolwdkYavmuü txuf

qdkcJYNyD;onfhtwdkif; a,musfm;çrdef;r[lonfrSm þolwdkYom jzpfonf/þodkY t,kwfçtjrwf ]uH}jzifYcGJí&aom a,musfm;ESifY rdef;rrsm;

udkjrifjcif; tawGUtBuKHjzifY rarG;rDESifYaoNyD;aemuf b0rsm;½SdaMumif;todynm rjzpfEdkif/

þt&monf Ak'tbd"r®t& jzpfonf/

35/ vlwdkY\ rwlaomtjzpfrsm; bmYaMumifYuGJjym;jcm;em;&ovJtjcm; rsufarSmuf tjrifoufaoxlp&m wpfckckjzifYom aemif

b0ç aemufb0rsm;½SdaMumif; odEdkifaumif; odEdkifayrnf/ xdkYaMumifY tjcm;rsufarSmuftjrifwpfckckudk xkwfvdku xkwf&ef pm½Ioltm; wdkufwGef;&ayrnf/ þodkYqdkvsif pm½IolxHrS wifjyp&m tajrmuftjrm; xGufvmzdkY½Sdayonf/

Page 108: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

108 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYaMumifY þodkY wifjy&ayrnfè]vlonf trdçtzwdkY\ rsdK;aoG;rsm; a&mpyfjcif;aMumifY jzpfay:vm

onfqdktHh/vlwdkYonf tcsif;csif; twltrQ jzpfMu&monf? ,ckrlum;xdkodkY rjzpf-

(1) tcsdKUvlrsm;onf toufwdkí? tcsdKUvlrsm; touf½SnfMuonf/

(2) tcsdKUvlrsm;onf a&m*guif;í? tcsdKUrl a&m*grsm;Muonf/(3) tcsdKUvlrsm;onf ½kyftqif;vSMuí? tcsdKUrl t½kyfqdk;Muonf/(4) tcsdKUvlrsm;onf rdwfaqGo*F[rsm;ESifY MoZmtmPmrsm;í?

tcsdKUenf;Muonf/(5) tcsdKUvlwdkYonf aiGaMu;OpömrGJí? tcsdKU csrf;om<u,f0Mu

onf/(6) tcsdKUvlwdkYonf Zmwd[kqdktyfaom jzpfyGm;rI odkYr[kwf vkyf

udkifrI? þt&mwdkif; tqifajyjrifYjrwfí? tcsdKU tqifrajy?,kwfnHhMuonf/

(7) tcsdKU todÓPfxufNyD;? tcsdKU todÓPf EkHUMuonf/þtjzpfrsm;onf tb,faMumifY vlü uGJjym;jcm;em;ae&oenf;-

[k ar;vdkayvdrfYrnf/þt&mrsm;udk ajzqdk&rnfum; rsm;jym;vGef;vSonf/ cufum;

rcufyg/ tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:udk awG;ac:rIvrf;p &NyD;olwdkYtwGufþtajzrSefonf oifykef;BuD;tHpmrQom jzpfygrnf/

[kwfygonf/ xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; tus,fçtus,f rsm;pGmrcsJUbJvdk&if;a&mufatmif wdkwdkusOf;usOf;jzifY aqG;aEG;vdkygonf/

Page 109: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 109

36/ toufwdkjcif;ç½Snfjcif;taMumif;&if;(1) vlrsm; tb,faMumifY touf wdkMuç½SnfMuoenf;/

uHçpdwfçOwkçtm[m&[laom taMumif;w&m;av;rsdK;aMumifYjzpfygonf/ qdkvdkonfrSm ,if;av;rsdK;aumif;vsif touf½SnfNyD;?raumif;vsif toufwdkygonf/ xif½Sm;atmif jyygrnf/

toufwdkjcif; odkYr[kwf aojcif; trsdK;rsdK; ½Sdygonf/ ,if;wdkYudktb,fodkY toufwdkjcif; odkYr[kwf tb,faojcif;onf tb,ftaMumif;aMumifY[k t>rufrQ cGJjyaqG;aEG;ygrnf/

tqdyfcwftowfcH&jcif;? wkwfçxm;rsm;jzifY towfcH&jcif;? udk,fYzmom tqdyfaomufaojcif;? BudK;qGJcsaojcif;rsm;onf ]uH}aMumifYaojcif;rsm; jzpfygonf/

tqdyfrsm;aomufrdí aojcif;? opfyifrSusí aojcif;? txifvGJNyD; towfcH&í aojcif; ponfrsm;onf pdwfaMumifYaojcif;rsm; jzpfygonf/

tyl½Syfí aojcif;? tat;ywfí aojcif; ponfrsm;onf OwkaMumifYaojcif; jzpfygonf/

roifYjrwfaom tpm;taomufudkpm;í aojcif;onf tm[m&aMumifYaojcif; jzpfygonf/

]uHaMumifYaojcif;rsm;}[l&mü tb,fokdYaom ]uH}rsm;enf;/olYtoufowfjcif;paom uHrsm;wnf;/xdkodkY udk,fçEIwftrlt&mrSm;rsm;udk jyKcJYol? jyKqJjzpfol wpfOD;OD;

onf ywf0ef;usif\ 'Pfcwfjcif;udk ½kyfrSmjzpfap? pdwfrSmjzpfap cH&NyD;þodkY aoqkH;&ygonf/ xif½Sm;&ef ykHpHjzifY MunfhoifYygonfè

]vlwpfa,mufonf tjcm;vlwpfa,muftm; oGm;íowfvsiftowfcH&ol\ ckcHcsufjzifY owfolvnf; aoEdkifavonf/ tu,fí

Page 110: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

110 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

aovsif tb,faMumifY ao&oenf; odkYr[kwf toufwdk&oenf;/ ol\olrsm;udkowfvdkaom apwemuHaMumifY ao&onf? toufwdk&onf}-[k qdk&rnf r[kwfygavm/

þae&mü pm½Iolonf tu,fí tv,fvrf;oabmw&m;udkodjrifjcif;r½Sdvsif auseyfovdk cHpm;&ayvdrfYrnf/ ]'gawmY [kwfwmaygY}-[lívnf; qdkrdaumif; qdkrdvdrfYrnf/ ]'gawmY [kwfwmaygY}-qdkvsif]bmr[kwfovJ}-[k jyefar;&zdkY ½Sdygonf/

olao&jcif;onf ol\ owfvdkaom apwemuHtjyif tjcm;taMumif;wpfckck ½Sdao;ovdkvdk olY&ifxJü udef;aeayrnf/ xdkt&mum;tb,fenf;][k ar;vdkonf/

tu,fpifppfü xdkt&monf vkH;0r½Sdaomt&m jzpfonf/ ]aozdkYuHygí olu olrsm;udk oGm;owf&onf}-[k ajymvdkaumif; ajymayrnf/þtajymonf tusdK;udk taMumif;vkyfajymaom tajym jzpfygonf/tjrifrJYolwdkif;vdkvdkyif rdrdtjrifrJYrIudk zmax;&ef taMumif;aMumifYjzpfaomtusdK;udk taMumif;wzefvkyfí ajymMuwkef; ½Sdavonf/

pifppfü ]aemufb0u uHygvmí ,ckb0rSm uHqdk;udkjyKvkyf&onf}-qdkonfrSm tv,ftvwfusaom rSefaomtawG;tac:udkausmfí qdkjcif; jzpfayonf/

]uH}onf ]uH}tjzpf rae? ]0dyguf}tjzpfodkY vSnfhajymif;oGm;ayonf/þ0dygufonf ]raem'Gg&}[laom ae&mudk,lí aemuf]uH}topfwpfckjzpf&ef taMumif;jzpfonf[k qdk&aomfvnf;? xdk]raem'Gg&}onf ]uHopf}jzpf&mtaMumif;ü taMumif;&if; r[kwf/ ]uH}jzpfapaomaZmonf ESvkH;oGif;tm;avsmfpGm vSnfhajymif;EdkifcGifY ½Sdonf/ ]y&awmaCmoç a,medaomreodum&}-ponfwdkYaMumifY ]aZm}onf vSnfhajymif;oGm;Edkifonf/

Page 111: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 111

qdkvdkonfrSm tm½kHonf tusdK;0dygufjzpfaom ]b0if}[laom]raem'Gg&}odkY xifvmonf qdktHh/ rdrd\ ]a,medaomreodum&çta,medaomreodum&}tm;avsmfpGm ukodkvfaZmçtukodkvfaZm wpfckckqufMu&ayonf/ ]uHqdk;b0if}[laom raem'Gg&rSmxifvmaom tm½kHjzpfaomaMumifY aZmüvnf; ]uHqdk;b0if raem'Gg&} tm;avsmfpGm]uHqdk;(aZmqdk;)}yJ jzpf&rnf-[k pnf;r½SdEdkifay/ (0dyguftrSef aZmtjyef)/

xdkYaMumifY ]aemufb0uHaMumifY ,ckb0ü uHopfjzpfaom owfjcif;trIudkjyK&onf}-[laom tqdkonf rawmfroifYaomtqdk jzpfonf/

,ck ]uHqdk;topf}udkjyKjcif;onf ESvkH;oGif;rSm;aomaMumifYjzpfonf/ ,ck tb,faMumifY eSvkH;oGif;rSm;&oenf;qdkvsifè

]rSefuefrIudk oifMum;csuf rem&íjzpfonf}/tb,faMumifY rem&onf qdkvsifè]rSefuefolESifY raygif;&í}-[k ajz&rnf/tb,faMumifY raygif;&oenf;-[k qdkvsifè]rSefuefolESifY aygif;Edkifavmufatmif tajccHtcsuftvuf

tcsdKUwdkY rwnfaqmufaomaMumifY}-[k qdk&rnf/,if; tajccHtcsuftvufum; tb,fenf;qdkvsifè]ay;jcif;çurf;jcif;? udk,fusifYw&m;½Sdjcif;? pdwf"gwfjr§ifYwifjcif;}?

ponfwdkY jzpfonf/ ]tajccH½Sdjcif;}[laom pum;vkH;onf ]yg&rD][laompum;vkH;\ 'kwd,pum;vkH; jzpfayonf/

þrQjzifY vlrsm; tb,faMumifY toufwdk&ç½Snf&onfudk odem;vnfcGifY tenf;tusOf; &avmufNyD[k xifygonf/ pdwfESifYOwkçtm[m&wdkYaMumifY toufwdk&ç ½Snf&ykHonf tapYtpyf taotcsm enf;aumif;enf;oGm;ygrnf/ þaqG;aEG;&aom yifrtaMumif;ESifY rsm;pGmywfoufjcif;r½Sdí cyf[[rQjzifY NyD;cJYjcif;jzpfygonf/

Page 112: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

112 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

37/ a&m*genf;jcif;çrsm;jcif;taMumif;&if;(2) qufvufí ]tb,faMumifY tcsdKUa&m*genf;í tcsdKUrsm;&onf]udk aqG;aEG;vdkygonf/

þ]a&m*gtaMumif;}onfvnf; av;rsdK;yif ½Sdygrnf/ uHçpdwfç Owkçtm[m&wdkYyif jzpfygonf/ qdkvdkonfrSm uHemç pdwfemç Owkemç tm[m&em-[lí tema&m*gonf av;rsdK;jzpfygrnf/

þü ]uHem}qdkonfrsm;um; vuftjzwfcH&jcif;? xm;tckwfcH&jcif;? wkwft½dkufcH&jcif; ponfwdkYjzpfonf/ þodkYaomtemrsm;onftb,faMumifY ]uHem}[lí qdkEdkifoenf;/ cdk;jcif;? owfjcif;tp½SdaomtrIudkjyKolonf þodkY jyKaomaMumifY t½dkuftykwf tckwftxpfrsm;?tqdyfcwfcH&jcif;rsm; ponfwdkYESifY &ifqdkif&avonf/ þodkY jyKaomtrIonf cdk;jcif;tp½Sdaom ]apwemuH} jzpf\/ xdkYaMumifY þtemrsm;onf]uHem}rsm; jzpfonf/

]pdwfem}um; tb,fenf;/ pdwfaMumifYjzpfaom taMumyef;a&m*gtrsdK;rsdK; jzpfonf/ Oyrm- pdwåZacgif;udkuf?aemausmwuf? ydkufem-ponfwdkY jzpfonf/

þü ]uH}ESifY]pdwf}udk tb,fodkY cGJjcm;rnfenf;-[k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/ar;vdkonfrSm toufwdkjcif;? a&m*g&jcif;rsm;udk jzpfapEdkifaom ]uH}ESifY]pdwf}wdkYudk b,fvdkcGJjcm;rnfenf;-ar;zG,f½Sdonf[k qdkvdkygonf/

þtar;udk ,aeY em;vnfEdkifaom pum;vkH;jzifY ajymvsif vG,ful½Sif;vif;ygonf/ ,aeYem;vnfEdkifaom pum;rSm-

pdwf-ESpfrsdK;½Sdonf/ wpfrsdK;rSm ]tjyifpdwf}? tjcm;wpfrsdK;rSm]twGif;pdwf}[lí jzpfonf/ þpum;jzifYajymvsif ½Sif;ygonf/

- tjyifpdwfonf ]uH} jzpfygonf/- twGif;pdwfonf ]0dygufpdwf} jzpfygonf/

Page 113: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 113

[kwfygonf/ uHESifY0dygufonf tjyifpdwfESifY twGif;pdwfrsm;[kac:xdkufaom tjzpf ½Sdygonf/

]uH}vnf; pdwfESifYrS twljzpf&aomaMumifY ]pdwf}yif jzpfygonf/]0dyguf}vnf; ]pdwf}yifjzpfygonf/xdkodkY ]pdwf}csif;wlaomfvnf; ]uHpdwf}onf udk,fydkif'Gg&tm½kHrsm;

jzifY xif½Sm;ay:vGifygonf/ ]0dygufpdwf}rSm udk,fydkif'Gg& r½Sdonfomruoludk,fwdkifuyif jyefí 'Gg&ae&mudk wm0efcH ,lae&jyefygonf/ xdkYaMumifYolonf ikyfygonf? twGif;usygonf/

þodkY ]uH}ESifY ]pdwf}udk em;vnf&ygrnf/ ,if;udkvufcHvsifuHaMumifYjzpfaom toufaoqkH;rI? a&m*g&rIESifY pdwfaMumifYjzpfaomtoufaoqkH;&rI? tema&m*g&rIrsm;udk cGJjcm;Edkifrnf-[k ,kHMunfygonf/

OwkESifY tm[m&wdkYaMumifYjzpfaom a&m*grsm;rSm xif½Sm;vSygonf/ tcsOfpm;í zsm;jcif;? tyl½Syfí zsm;jcif;ponfwdkY jzpfygonf/

þrQjzifY vlrsm; a&m*grsm;jcif;? enf;jcif; taMumif;udk wifjycJYNyD;jzpfNyD[k ,lqygonf/

38/ ½kyfqdk;jcif;çvSjcif; taMumif;&if;(3) qufvufí ½kyfqdk;ç½kyfvS uGJ&jcif;taMumif;udk wifjyygrnf/ ½kyfqdk;ç½kyfvS-[lonfrSm tb,fenf;/ tb,fodkYaomtqif;onf ½kyfqdk;jzpfí tb,fodkYaomtqif;onf ½kyfvSjzpfoenf;/

edrfYçjrifY? rJçjzL? qlçBuKH þajcmufyg;½Sdjcif;onf rvS? vGwfrS vSonf-qdkvsif xdk]tvSESifYrvS}onf ]uHaMumifYjzpfaom tvSESifYrvS}wdkY r[kwfukef/ Owkçtm[m&rsm;aMumifYom jzpfMuaom tvSESifYrvSrsm; jzpfMuavonf/

Page 114: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

114 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[kwfyg\/ Owkçtm[m&rsm; rQwvsif rnf;vGef;jcif;çjzLvGef;jcif;?edrfYvGef;çjrifYvGef;jcif;wdkYrS vGwfrnf/ 0vGef;çydefvGef;jcif;wdkYrS vGwfrnf/

]uH}aMumifYjzpfaomtvSum; xdkqdkcJYNyD;aomtvSrsm; r[kwfukef/vufrygjcif;? vufydkygjcif;? ESmacgif;wdkjcif;ç½Snfjcif;? ezl;us,fjcif;ç

usOf;jcif;? qHyif eufarSmif½Snfvsm;jcif;? aumYysHaejcif;ç raejcif;wdkYonfvnf; ]uH}aMumifYjzpfaom tvSESifY rvSrsm; r[kwfukef/ ]uH}aMumifYjzpfaom tvSum;-

]tvGefMunfaom a½T&nfywåjrm;tvm; ru? wjrjrat;puf?wvufvufawmufajymifaom EIdif;wkrJYtvSw&m; jzpfavonf/

,if;udk pum;vkH;rsm;jzifY wdkuf½dkufo½kyfazmfjcif;iSm vkHavmufaompum;vkH; twdtus r½Sday}/

]uH}aMumifYjzpfaomtvSudk azmfusL;vdkukefaomolwdkYonf tvSty\ tpteuav; wpfzJYwavudk azmfusL;&efyif pmrsufESmaygif;rsm;pGmjzifY zGJUxm;aom pmtkyfaygif;rsm;pGmudk tokH;jyKMu&avonf/

]uHaMumifYjzpfvwf? tvS"gwf\? xkyÜgwfedoif? þ½SdpOfu?vl½Sifayg,,f? *gxmoG,fí? zGifYus,fqef;axG? a[mwdkYayvnf;? qkH;aptHhiSm? rwwf&monf / / awZmBuD;jrifYzGHUNzdK;wnf;/}uHaMumifYjzpfaom tvStyonf þíþrQ euf½Idif;vGef;vSacs

onf/ uREfkyfwdkYvnf; þtvSudk cHpm;omcHpm;wwfí azmfjyrIudkum;rjyKvkyfEdkifacs/

xdkYaMumifY þtvSudkazmfjy&ef wm0efqdkufvmvsif þtvSudkrazmfjybJ taMumif;t>rufrQudkom uREfkyfwdkYjyEkdifayonf/ atmufygtwdkif; em;vnfEdkifatmifom BudK;pm;Muygukef-

Page 115: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 115

]uHaMumifYjzpfaom tvSydkif½Sifonf ywf0ef;usifvlom;wdkY tay:ü txdtcdkufr½Sd ulnDaz;rzdkY toifY ½dSaeavonf/ ½GH½SmpufqkwfoGm;jcif;vkH;0r½Sd/ tcsdKU udk,fYxufomolrsm;tay:ü 0rf;ajrmuf0rf;omjzifY ]omrI}udk todtrSwfjyKEdkifaompdwf ½Sdayonf/ <uif;usefaom ywf0ef;usifrsm;tay:üvnf; tb,faMumifY þodkYjzpfonf? þtjzpf\ taMumif;onftb,fjzpfonf-[k Edk;Mum;odjrifaeavonf}/

tvSykdif½Sif\pdwfonf þodkY jzpfaeavonf/þpdwfçapwemuH\ tjcif;t&m [efyefwdkYonf olYudk,fum,

\ vIyfíç½Sm;í upm;í&orQ tpdwftydkif;wdkif;ü tm;vkH;xifvsuf ay:vGifvsuf½Sdonf/

Oyrm- rsufvkH;çrsufckH;çESmacgif;çEIwfcrf;çyg;çvufçajcçcg;ponfwdkYjzpfonf/ xdkYtwl toH\ twdk;çtus,f? tedrfYçtjrifY? tzGifYçtydwfESifYpum;\ teufj'yfponfwdkYvnf; jzpfayonf/ þt&mtm;vkH;onftxufqdkcJYaom pdwfapwemuHtwdkif; wuGxyfwl jzpfaeMuonf/

þtvStyonf ]uHaMumifYjzpfaom tvSty} jzpfonf/pdwfaMumifYjzpfaom tvSESifYrvSum; Zmwfrif;orD;ç ½kyf½Sifrif;orD;

wdkY\ wpfyGJwdk; tvSESifYrvSwdkY jzpfayonf/ olwdkY\ tvScef;ütvS?tusnf;wefcef;ü rvS(tusnf;wef)/ þt&mrsm;onf [eftvSodkYr[kwf pdwfjzifY wrifvkyf,l&aom pdwåZtvSwdkY jzpfayonf/ xdkYjyifvnf; trsdK;orD;i,fwdkY\ jyifqifrIaMumifYjzpfay:aom tvSonfvnf;pdwåZtvSwdkYyif jzpfMuayonf/

Oyrm- EIwfcrf;u rNyKH;ygbJvsuf NyKH;aeonfxif&avatmifaq;ulxm;jcif;? rsufvkH;u &DaeçMunfaejcif;rsm; r½SdygbJvsuf ½Sdaeonfxif&atmif aq;ulxm;jcif;? umraoG;r<uygbJvsuf <uaeonfxif&

Page 116: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

116 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

atmif vufzrdk;? vufzsm;ESifY yg;wdkYwGif aq;ulxm;jcif;? umrpdwf r0ifygbJvsuf 0ifaeav[ef xif&avatmif &ifom;udk awmifY<uaeav[efjyKxm;jcif; ponfwdkYjzpfonf/

39/ rdwfaqGenf;çrsm;jcif;ESifY MoZmtmPmtaMumif;&if;(4) qufvufí usefaomjyóemrsm;udk aqG;aEG;ygrnf/ ,ckqdkufvmaom jyóemwdkYum; tcsdKUvlrsm; rdwfaqGtaygif;toif;ESifY MoZmtmPmaumif;NyD;? tcsdKU raumif;jcif;taMumif; jzpfygonf/

qdkvdkonfrSm tcsdKUolü cspfolcifolrsm;í MoZmBuD;rm;onf/tcsdKU þodkYr[kwf/ þonfrSm tb,faMumifYenf;-[lí jzpfonf/

þtajzvnf; ESpfcsufcefY ajz&rnf/uHESifY ynm? Opömypönf;wdkYaMumifY [lí ajz&rnf/[kwfygonf/ ynmç tmPmç Opöm½Sdolrsm;xHü vlrsm;onf 0dkif;tkH

aeMu&ayonf/ xdkYjyif xdkolajymqdkaom pum;udkvnf; vdkufemMu&ayonf/ xdkYaMumifY ynmjzpfap? Opömjzpfap? tmPmjzpfap/ ESpfckjzpfapçokH;ckjzpfap ydkifqdkifolonf rdwfaqGtaygif;toif;? cspfolcifolaygrsm;íol\pum;onf MoZmtmPm ½dSavonf/

odkYaomfvnf; þolrsm;onf cspfcifolESifY MoZm½Sdol tppftrSefrsm; r[kwfMuay/ cspfír[kwfbJ? rcspfaomfvnf; atmifYumerf;rsm;omjzpfMuayonf/ olYab;rS rdwfaqGESifY olYMoZmatmufrSolrsm;onf ]olYudk}cspfMuçMoZmcHMuonfvnf; r[kwfay/ ]ol&½Sdae&m}udkom MoZmcHMu?cspfcifaygif;oif;Mujcif; jzpfayonf/ þae&mrS olqif;oGm;&vsif þolüMoZmESifYrdwfaqGo*F[? cspfolcifolrsm; uif;uGmaeayrnf/

xdkYaMumifY xdkolonf rdwfaqGrsm;ol? MoZmBuD;rm;ol-þodkY rqdkEdkifawmYacs/

Page 117: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 117

þodkYqdkvsif rdwfaqGçcspfcifolrsm;jym;olESifY MoZmaumif;ol-[lonf tb,fenf;/ þjyóem\tajzum; ae&mudk y"gerxm;bJESifYtcspfcifcH&ç MoZm&olrsm;om jzpfMuownf;-[k ajz&ayrnf/

ae&mr½SdbJ þolonf tb,faMumifY cspfolcifol rdwfaqGo*F[aygrsm;ol? MoZm½Sdol tb,faMumifY jzpf&oenf;/

ol\]uH}aMumifY jzpfonf/]olYuH}um; tb,fenf;/xdk ]uH}um; ywf0ef;usifvlom;wdkYtay:ü vkH;0 ,kHMunfpdwfcscH&

avmufatmif? udk,fYxufom remvdk vkH;0rjzpfbJ? udk,fYxufomonfudk0rf;ajrmuf0rf;om todtrSwfjyKEdkifjcif;yif jzpfavonf/

[kwfygonf/olrsm;b0udk r½IpdrfYçremvdk r½Sdaomolonf vlwdkif;\tjrwfEdk;cH t,kHMunfcHyk*¾dKvfyif jzpfygonf/vlwdkif;onf udk,fYb0twGuf tazmfvdkcsifMuygonf/ xdkYjyif

vrf;nTefajymqdkrnfholudkvnf; tvdk½SdMuygonf/ odkYaomfvnf; xdktazmfESifY vrf;nTefMoZmay;rnfholonf udk,fYb0twGuf b,fvdkrS txdtcdkufrjzpfEdkif[kvnf; pdwfcsvdk? ,kHMunfvdkygonf/ xdkYaMumifY udk,fYb0 BuD;xGm;&yfwnfEdkifrItwGuf olrsm;b0udk avScg;xpfjyK&rnf[laom]£óm}[kqdktyfaom tazmf½SdaomuHudk jyKolonf ta>ct&Hç tazmftaygif;ESifY MoZmtmPmr½Sdjcif; jzpfygonf/

þrQjzifY rdwfaqGrsm;í MoZmtmPm½SdolESifY rdwfaqGenf;íMoZmtmPmr½SdoltaMumif;udk aqG;aEG;NyD;ygNyD/

Page 118: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

118 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

40/ Opömypönf;jynfhpkHjcif;ESifY rGJjcif;taMumif;&if;(5) qufvufí ypönf;OpömrGJolESifY jynfhpkHoljzpf&jcif;taMumif;udkaqG;aEG;ygrnf/

tcsdKUvlrsm;rGJí tcsdKUcsrf;omMuonfrSm tb,faMumifYenf;/ ypönf;OpömjynfhpkH&jcif;\ taMumif;udk vlwdkYonf rdbcsrf;omjcif;? vif odkYr[kwfr,m;csrf;omudk &jcif;? xDaygufjcif;? a½Ttdk;aiGtdk;rsm;aumuf&jcif;wdkYjzpfonf[k qdkvdkMuolrsm;vnf; ½Sdayonf/

tu,fpifppfü rdbcsrf;omrsm;rS tarG;tzGm;cH&jcif; ponfwdkYonf csrf;omjcif;\ taMumif;r[kwf-[k rqdkEdkifyg/ odkYaomfvnf; þtaMumif;rsm;onf csrf;omjcif;\ t&if;usaom taMumif;rsm;rlum;r[kwfyg/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf vlcsrf;om om;orD;rsm;jzpfjcif;? csrf;omaomr,m; odkYr[kwf vifudk&jcif;? aiGxkyf&jcif;? xDaygufjcif;ponfwdkY½Sdaeaomolyifjzpfap? ol\ ]udk,fydkifuH}rygvsif xdkt&mrsm;onf MuufaysmufiSufaysmuf rMumcif jzLcgjymcgoGm;zdkY ½dSayonf/

xdk ]udk,fykdifuH}qdkonfum; tb,fenf;/]udk,fydkifuH}um; t&if;tESD; jr§KyfESHjcif;rsm;wnf;/ ypönf;Opöm jynfh

pkHjcif;\ twGif;usqkH;aom taMumif;onf ]t&if;tESD;jr§KyfESHjcif;}yifjzpfygonf/

vlcsrf;om om;orD;jzpfol tp½SdolwdkYonf xdk csrf;omaom a½TçaiGçypönf;ç ypö, tppudk ray;&ufçrurf;&uf? r0,f&ufçra&mif;&ufbJ½Sdaom a½TçaiGçypönf;çypö,udk qkyfudkifí xdkifMunfhaeapcsifonf/ þodkYqdkvsif þolü ypönf;Opömrs; rGJrnfavmç csrf;omrnfavm/

udk,fYypönf;udk ESarsmwGefUwdkr½SdbJ ay;jcif;çurf;jcif;? a&mif;cs0,f,ljcif; ponfwdkYonf t&if;tESD;jrKyfESHjcif;yif jzpfygonf/

Page 119: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 119

[kwfygonf/ 0,f,ljcif;ç a&mif;csjcif;rsm;onf t&if;tESD;jr§KyfESHjcif;yif jzpfygonf/ þodkYjr§KyfESH&mwGif ESarsmwGefYwdkrIrsm; jzpfaevsif rjzpfay? roifYavsmfay/ vlcsrf;om om;çorD;polwdkYonf t&if;tESD;rjr§KyfESHbJcsrf;omaeMuygoavm/

xdkYaMumifY csrf;omaeolwdkY\ csrf;omaMumif;w&m;um; rdbcsrf;om\ om;orD;jzpfjcif;ponfwdkY jzpfonf[k rqdkEdkif/ ]t&if;ESD;jr§KyfESHjcif;omvsif csrf;omjcif;\taMumif;} jzpfayonf/

xdkYxuf taMumif;&if;udkajymvsif udk,fYypönf;Opömudk ESarsmwGefYwdkraebJ a&mif;jcif;ç0,fjcif;udkvkyfEdkifaom ]'geapwem}onf taMumif;&if;jzpfonf-[k ajym&ayrnf/ þü ]a&mif;jcif;ç0,fjcif; t&if;tESD;jr§KyfESHjcif;onf 'geapwemavm}-[k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/

][kwf\}-[k ajz&ygrnf/ ]'ge}-[lonf ]pZevu©Pm}-[lonfhtwdkif; ]pGefYvTwf}jcif;onf ]'ge}rnfygonf/ t&if;tESD;jr§KyfESHrItwGufa&mif;olç0,folwdkYonf rdrdbufrS wpfckaomypönf;udk pGefYvTwfMu&onf/odkYr[kwf ay;qyfMu&onf/ Oyrm- aiGjzifY qefpyg;0,fí &if;ESD;jr§KyfESHíukefoG,folonf qefpyg;&½Sd&ef rdrd\aiGudk pGefY&çvTwf& ay;qyf&avonf/ þodkY aiGudk pGefYjcif;çvTwfjcif;çay;qyfjcif;vnf; 'gerajrmuf-[kqdkrnfavm/ qdkcsifvsif taMumif;ESifYwuG qdkapcsifygonf/ taMumif;b,fodkYjyrnfenf;/

qefpyg; &csifí aiGay;jcif;jzpfonf/ xdkodkY &csifí ay;jcif;jzpfaomaMumifY 'ger[kwf[k taMumif;jyrnfavm/ 'gerSeforQ tb,f'geonf &csifíray;bJ r&csifrIESifY ay;aom'ge[lí ½Sdygoenf;-[kjyefar;&ayrnf/ 'gejyKolrSeforQonf ]jyKrnf}-[koabmESifY ]jyKvkyf}odkYr[kwf ]tm;xkwfrI tbdocFg&}jzifY jyKvsif ]&csifíjyKolcsnf;} jzpfonf/

Page 120: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

120 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

(u) tcsdKUonf udk,fu ay;urf;jcif;jyKaomaMumifY ywf0ef;usifütpp tqifajyvnfavatmif 'gejyKonf (=tqifajyrI &csifaeonf)/

(2) tcsdKUuvnf; aoNyD;aemuf ½Sdonf-xifNyD; aoNyD;aemuftyg,fi&JrusbJ vlçewfçjA[®mrsm; jzpf&eftwGuf 'gejyKjcif; jzpfonf (=vlçewfçjA[®mb0tjzpf &csifaeonf)/

(3) wzef tcsdKUuvnf; ywf0ef;usif tpptqifajyatmifvnf; r[kwf/ aoNyD;aemuf vlçewfçjA[®m[kqdktyfaomaumif;aomb0 jzpf&efvnf;r[kwf/ ]aoNyD;aemuf bmrQrjzpfawmYaom edAÁmefqdkaom} t&mudk &&eftwGuf 'gejyKayonf/ (=edAÁmef &csifaeonf)/

xdkYaMumifY 'gejyKoltm;vkH;onf tu,fí ]'geudkjyKrnf}-[k ]tbdocFg&}tm;pdkufí jyKolqdkvsif ]&csifí} okdYr[kwf ]ajrmfvifYcsuf}jzifY jyKolcsnf; jzpfavonf/

]&csifjcif;}wnf;[laom tm;tpGrf;aMumifY (0g) ajrmfvifYcsufaMumifYom tao;tzGJrS pí BuD;us,fonfwdkYudk vªEdkifçay;Edkifygonf/ þodkYajrmfvifYcsufjzifYjyKjcif;onf tjypfwif uJY&JUtyfaomt&m r[kwfay/]'ge\ tESpfom&}onf þt&myif tppftrSef r[kwfygavm/

]bmrQrajrmfvifYbJ} odkYr[kwf ]bmrQr&csifbJ} tb,folonfjyKEdkiftHhenf;/ tu,fí þodkYjyKEdkifol ½Sdonfqdkvsif xdkolrsm;um; b0ukefqkH;NyD;aom tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:jzifY tvkH;pkHNidrf;csrf;NyD;aomyk*¾dKvfrsm;ESifY pdwåZt½l;rsm;om jzpf&mygonf/

[kwfygonf/ yXryk*¾dKvfonf tm;vkH;Nidrf;csrf;rItwGuf NyD;jynfhpkHNyD;jzpfí 'geudk tcGifYoifYvsif jyKaomfvnf; ]vdkcsifjcif;}-[kqdktyfaomtm;pdkufrI(tbdocFg&) tvsOf;rygbJ jyKumrwåjzifYom jyKayonf/

Page 121: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 121

xdkYjyif pdwåZorm;rsm;uvnf; 'geudk bmrQajrmfvifYcsufr½SdbJ]bmrQrjzpfçr½Sdaom? aoNyD;aemuf a&mufvdrfYrnf}qdkaom ]edAÁmef}qdkonfudk tm½kHjyKí rsufarSmufjyKí 'geudk jyKMuayonf/ xdkodkYr[kwfvsifvnf;,lolçay;olESifY ,lp&mçay;p&mypönf;? þokH;ckwdkYonf vkH;0rNrJMu-tedpöcsnf;? vkH;0qif;&JMu-'ku©csnf;? vkH0tpdk;r&Mu-tewåcsnf;-ponfjzifYqifjcifvsuf 'geudk jyKMuayonf/

xdkYjyifvnf; 'geudk bmrQajrmfvifYjcif;r½SdbJ jyKolwpfOD;vnf;usefayao;onf/ olum; udk,frSmvnf; ypönf;ydkaeí olrSmvnf; udk,fYrSmydkaomypönf; vdkaeí? xdkYjyif olYudk csrf;omoGm;onfudk jrifvdkí ay;ol-[lí jzpfayonf/ þolonfvnf; 'ge tESpfom&udkazsmufí zmodzmom &rf;&rf;prf;prf;jyKolyif jzpfayonf/

þolwdkYwGif ]'geudkjyKrnf}-[k tm;pdkufrIESifYjyKvsuf bmrQajrmfvifYjcif; r½SdolwdkYonf 'ge\tESpfom& taysmufqkH;cHae&aom olwdkYomjzpfayonf/

þtaMumif;udk xif½Sm;atmifppfvsif rsm;pGmt½kyfqkd;aMumif;awGUEdkifayonf/ edAÁmefudk rsufarSmufjyKí (0g) edAÁmefudktm½kHjyKí ay;olqdkolvnf; &,fzG,fyif/ olonf edAÁmefuk odoavm/ ynm½Sdqdkonfrsm;yifedAÁmefudk xdkvdkjiif;Mu? þvdkjiif;Mu jyKae&onf/ 'gejyKolvlomrefonftb,fedAÁmefudk oGm;í tm½kHjyKrnfenf;/ xdkYaMumifY xdkolwdkYonf edAÁmefudktm½kHjyKcdkif;vsif awma&mufawmifa&muf a&mufcsif&ma&muf? wwforQrSwforQ ½kH;NcKHNyD; tm½kHjyKaeayrnf/ aumif;uifudk aomfvnf;aumif;?ynwfudkaomfvnf;aumif; tm½kHjyKvsuf½SdrnfrSm rvGJwnf;/

þodkYqdkvsif tb,fodkYvsif ay;jcif;apwemtwGuf ae&m ½SdawmYoenf;/ awma&mufawmifa&muf aygufaomtm½kHrsm;udk ½SmazGae&onfESifYyif ay;jcif;apwemtwGuf xm;½Sd&ef ae&mr½SdawmYay/

Page 122: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

122 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

wzef ay;ol? ,lol? tay;cHypönf;-þokH;rsdK;wdkY\ rNrJjcif;? tESpfr½Sdjcif;? qif;&Jjcif;? rvSrytokbjzpfjcif;rsm; ponfudkatmufarYí ay;olonfvnf; þtwlyif 'ge\tESpfom& taysmufqkH;cH&onf/ þt&mrsm;udk qifjcifaevsif 'get&aumuf,l&aom ay;qyfwwfjcif; apwemonf b,fodkYay:rnfenf;/

ay;ol? ,lolvnf; yk*¾vtjzpf {uef½SdonfxifrS tay;cHypönf;onf rGefjrwfoefYpif aumif;onfxifrS xdk 'geapwemonf xufjrufpGmESifY jzpfyGm;vmzdkYtaMumif; ½Sdayonf/ tenf;qkH;tm;jzifY ay;tyfrnfhypönf;\ tokH;usaumif;rGefykHudk qifjcifrSomvsif 'geapwem jzpfyGm;&zdkY ½Sdayonf/ xdkodkYr[kwfvsif raumif;aomypönf;jzpfí ]rNrJç qif;&Jç tESpfr½SdçrwifYw,f}í vTifYypfvkdufjcif;ESifY pdwfxm;jcif; wloGm;&zdkY ½Sdavonf/xdkYaMumifY þay;jcif;onfvnf; 'ge\tESpfom& taysmufqkH;cH&aomay;jcif;wpfrsdK; jzpfonf/

xdkYjyif udk,fYrSmvnf;-ydkí? olYrSmvnf;-vdkí olYudk jznfhqD;onfhtaejzifYvnf;aumif;? olYtm; oem;ívnf;aumif; ay;jcif;onf ay;jcif;ESifY,ljcif;\ qufoG,fykHudk tusdK;rodbJ ay;jcif;jzpfí 'ge\tESpfom&jynfh0zdkYtaMumif; r½Sday/ xdkYjyif xdkol\ ay;urf;jcif;onf pufqkwfzG,fvnf; aumif;vSayonf/ xdkolonf olay;onfudk ,lrnfoltm; txufpD;rS ikHYMunfhaeoljzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY olYtay;udk&olonf olYwHawG;udkaomuf&onfhyrm ½GH½SmpufqkwfzG,f cHpm;&rIrsm; cH&zdkY½Sdayonf/

'geESifYpyfí ½Snfvsm;pGm a0zefcJYonf/ qdkvdk&if;rSm 'ge-[lonf&,ljcif;r½Sdaom'ge[lí r½Sd/ &,ljcif;rygaom 'ge-[lí½Sdvsif xdk-'geqdkonfrsm;onf 'ge\tESpfom& ysufNyD;jzpfonf-[k wifjyEdkif&efa0zefcJYjcif; jzpfygonf/

Page 123: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 123

[kwfygonf/ ]'ge}-[lonf ]&,ljcif;rygaom ay;qyfjcif;oufouf t&mr[kwf/ udk,fu þt&mudkay;onf? olYqDu xdkt&mudk&onf/ þonfyif ]'ge} jzpfonf}/

xdkYaMumifY t&if;tESD;jr§KyfESHaomtjzpf-[k qdktyfaom qefpyg;0,f&ef aiGay;&jcif; ponfvnf; ]'ge}yifjzpfaMumif; todtrSwf jyKEdkifapcsifonf/ wpfckawmY½Sdonf/ ]'ge}onf-

]0¥edódw}[kac:aom &p&mwdkuf½dkuftwGufay;aom 'geESifY]0d0¥edódw}[k ac:aom &p&mwdkuf½dkuftwGuf r[kwfaom

ay;jcif;'ge[lí ESpfrsdK;½SdEdkifonf/ wenf;ajym&vsif-]vnfatmifvkyfaom'ge}ESifY ]vnfatmifvkyfjcif;r[kwfaom'ge}

[lí jzpfonf/tb,fodkYenf;/]qefay;í aq;&onf}-[l&mü qefay;jcif;onf vnfaom'ge

odkYr[kwf wpfywfvnf'ge jzpfavonf/ qefpyg;&atmif aiGay;0,f,ljcif;vnf; wpfywfvnf'geyif/

cspfcifí vufaqmifyPÖmay;jcif;? qkcsjcif;? olY*kPfudkylaZmfjcif;ponfwdkYonf wpfywfvnfr[kwfaom'gewdkY jzpfonf/ om;r,m;ESifYrdbpolwdkYudk auR;arG;ay;urf;jcif;onf wpfywfrvnfaom'gersm; jzpfEdkifayonf/

'getaMumif;onf þrQaqG;aEG;csufjzifY vkHavmufygNyD/þodkY 'gersm;rsm; jyKEdkifavmufatmif udk,fYypönf;Opömtay:ü

ESarsmwGefYwdkjcif;r½SdbJ rsm;pGm t&if;tESD;jr§KyfESHjcif;onf ypönf;Opömcsrf;omaMumif; jzpfygonf/ wpfywfvnf'gejzpfap? wpfywfrvnf'gejzpfaptaMumif;oifYovdk jyKoGm;Edkifavmufatmif udk,fYypönf;udk ESarsmwGefYwdkjcif;r½SdbJjyKvsif csrf;omrnf/

Page 124: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

124 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

avmuü wpfywfvnf'gevnf; rsm;rsm;vkyfzdkYvdkonf/ odkYrSavmupD;yGm;[laom OpömaMu;aiG wdk;yGm;rnf/ wpfywfrvnf'gevnf;rsm;rsm;vkyfzdkY vdkayonf/ odkYrSom avmukwå&mpD;yGm;[laom rdwfaqGaumif;? todtjrifaumif;? pdwf"gwfaumif; tajctaersm; wdk;yGm;rnfjzpfonf/

þuJYodkYr[kwfbJ udk,fYaiGaMu;udk olrsm;xH rtyf&ufçrESH&ufray;urf;&ufbJ? qefa&pyg;rsm;qdkvsifvnf; xdkYtwl ra&mif;&ufçrcs&uf*dka'gifrSmodkavSmifNyD; wGefYwdkESarsm rapäaygaevsif xdkol vlrGJjzpfaMumif;jzpf&onf/ abm*aA' ynm rsufapYESifYMunfhvsifvnf; aiGaorsm;jzpfaMumif;jzpfí rcsrf;omEdkifaMumif; awGY&ayrnf/

þrQjzifY tcsdKUvlrGJí tcsdKUcsrf;omaMumif; aqG;aEG;csuf NyD;jynfhpkHygNyD/

41/ ,Ofaus;jrifYjrwfaomZmwd ½Sdçr½SdtaMumif;&if;(6) qufvufí vlrsm; ,Ofaus;jrifYjrwfaomZmwd ½Sdolçr½Sdoljzpfjcif;taMumif;udk aqG;aEG;ygrnf/ [kwfygonf/ tcsdKUvlrsm; ,Ofaus;jrifYjrwfaomZmwd ½Sdí tcsdKUr½Sdjcif;onf tb,faMumifYygenf;/

þodkYjzpf&jcif;onf olwdkY\ ]rmew&m;}aMumifY jzpfayonf/]rmew&m;}[lonf udk,fYb0udk udk,ftxifxm;í xdkb0twGif;

ü epfaejcif; jzpfonf/ udk,f&aomb0onf wefzdk;½Sdonf/udk,fYxuf atmufusolrsm;xuf omonfudkvnf; ,pfrl;onf/

txifxm;onf/ armufrmonf/ udk,fESifY wef;wlolESifYvnf; NydKifqdkifonf/ udk,fYxufomvGefolESifYvnf; wdkif;wmí rausrcsrf; yifyef;onf/ckcHonf/

þonfrSm]rme}jzpfonf/

Page 125: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 125

]rme}yg0ifaom odkYr[kwf ]rme}tazmf&aom apwemuHyif jzpfonf/ þ]uH}aMumifY ½dkif;pdkif;nHhzsif;aom Zmwd(=jzpfyGm;rI)rsm; jzpf&onf/þ-]rme}tazmf½Sdaom]uH}ESifY ½dkif;pdkif;nHhzsif;aom Zmwd(=jzpfyGm;rI)}ESifYb,fodkY qufoG,foenf;/ þ- ]rmetazmf½dSaomuH}aMumifY vlonftav;*½kjyKxdkufoludkvnf; rjyK/ t½dktaoay;&rnfholudkvnf; ray;/ae&mxdkif&mESifY vrf;wdkYudk OD;pm;ay;&rnfholudkvnf; ray;/ þodkYvkyfvmonf/

]udk,fYydkufqH½SdrS udk,fYxrif;pm;&onf? ydkufqh½SdzdkYbJ vdkonf/ þt&mrsm;onf tydkjzpfonf/ b,ftwGufvkyfrnfvJ}-[k ywf0ef;usifudkxDrxifol? udk,fYb0uGufuGufudkom jrifol jzpfvmonf/ xdkYaMumifYolonf ywf0ef;usifESifY tqufjywfNyD; txD;usefb0udk &½Sdvmonf/xdkYaMumifY ,kwfnHh½dkif;pdkif;aomZmwdudk jzpfapayonf/

xdkrStjyefonf ,Ofaus;jrifYjrwfaom ZmwdjzpfaMumif; jzpfonf/

42/ ÓPfxufjcif;ESifYEkHUjcif;taMumif;&if;(7) qufvufí vltcsdKUonf todÓPfxufí tcsdKUEkHY&jcif;taMumif;udk qufaqG;aEG;ygrnf/ þtaMumif;onf aemufqkH;taMumif; jzpfygonf/ tcsdKUÓPfxufí tcsdKuÓPfEkHYjcif;\ taMumif;um; tb,fenf;/

þjyóem\tajzum; usef;rmjcif;çrusef;rmjcif;? ywf0ef;usifaumif; &jcif;çr&jcif;? qnf;yl;-pl;prf;jcif;çrqnf;yl;-rpl;prf;jcif;tm;jzifYynmtEkHYçtxufuGJjym;Muonf[k ajzzdkY½Sdygonf/

[kwfygonf/ usef;rma&;raumif;aom olwdkYonf ÓPfEkHYíoGm;wwfMuygonf/ usef;rma&;aumif;olrsm;onf xufívmwwfygonf/xdkYaMumifY usef;rma&;onf ÓPfEkHYjcif;çxufjcif;rsm;\ taMumif;-[kqdkcJYjcif; jzpfygonf/

Page 126: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

126 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYjyif ywf0ef;usifaumif; &olonf ÓPfxufwwfygonf/r&vsifum; ÓPfEkHYwwfygonf/ txl;tm;jzifY av;ESpfatmufi,f½G,fpOfu txl;yif ywf0ef;usifaumif; &zdkYvdktyfonf-[k ,aeY todynm½Sifrsm; pl;prf;awGU½SdaeMuygonf/ touf ig;q,ftxd ½SdaeNyD;orQynmrsm;\xuf0ufonf av;ESpfatmuft½G,fuyif wwfcJYaomynmrsm;jzpfonf-[k tqdkjyKMuonf/

[kwfvnf; [kwfayrnf/ tb,ft&mjzpfap ]tpaumif;zdkY}onft"du ta&;tBuD;qkH; jzpfayonf/ b,fynm&yfudkyif vdkufpm;onfjzpfap aygufa&mufatmifjrifNyD;olrsm;xH vdkufpm;&rS xdkynmudk NyD;ajrmufEdkifavonf/ Zmwdrcdkifjcif;onf NyD;ajrmufrIudk uefYuGufEdkifavonf/

vlYb0twGuf av;ESpfatmufumvonf awGUorQudk oifMum;&aomumv odkYr[kwf b0tbd"gef tjyif;txefvSef&aomumv jzpfonf/ tm;vkH;qkdrS tm;vkH;udk jzpfonf/ txufumvrsm;um; olYt½G,fqdkif&m tbd"geft<uif;tusefuav; wcsdKUudkom vSefavSm½SmazG&awmYjcif; jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY i,fpOfu rdbpaom ywf0ef;usifonfvnf;ÓPfxufjcif;çEkHYjcif;twGuf taMumif;tcsufyif jzpfzG,f½Sdayonf/

xdkt&mrsm;onf ÓPfxufjcif;çEkH Yjcif;udk jzpfaponfjzpfap?rjzpfaponfjzpfap þae&mü ÓPfxufjcif;çEkH Yjcif;\taMumif;-[krqdkvdkay/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf þtaMumif;rsm;onf tu,f ÓPfxuf&ç EkHY&oljyKvkyfaom t&mrsm; r[kwfbJ? tjyiftyrS jzpfaomaMumifYÓPfxufjcif;çEkHYjcif; taMumif;-[k rajymyavmufay/

ÓPfxufjcif;çEkHYjcif;\ taMumif;tjzpf ajym&rnfum; xdkol\pl;prf;qifjcifrI ½Sdjcif;çr½Sdjcif;omvsif jzpfayonf/ tu,fí xdkolonfpl;prf;qifjcifrIudk jyKtHh/ tpl;prf; tqifjcifcH&aom xdkt&mudk xdkolodrnftrSefyif jzpfonf/

Page 127: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 127

xdkodkY pl;prf;qifjcifrd&efvnf; odjrifwwfuRrf;olxHrS tqkdtqkH;trudk &zdkYvkdayonf/ ,if;odkY&&ef xdkolwdkYESifYaygif;rdzdkY vdkavonf/xdkodkYaygif;rd&efvnf; xdkolESifY tusifYp½dkufwlzdkY vdkayonf/ xdkodkYjzpf&efvnf; b0iftajccH&yfwnfcsuf rSefzdkYvdkayonf/

,if;tajccH&yfwnfcsufum; tb,fenf;-[ltHh/ay;urf;jcif;? apmifYxdef;jcif;? tm½kHig;yg;cHpm;rIrS iYHHqdkif;jcif;

tp½SdonfwdkY jzpfonf/ þt&mrsm;½Sdolonf ÓPfxufzdkYjzpfNyD;? r½Sdolonf ÓPfEkHYol jzpfygrnf/ þodkYyif vlrsm;ü ÓPftxufçtEkHY jcm;em;uGJjym;&ygonf/þrQjzifY vl\ÓPftEkH Yçtxuf uGJjym;&aMumif;udkaqG;aEG;NyD;cJYygNyD/

þodkYqdkvsif pm½Iolwifjytyfaom jyóemwaxG;BuD;udk ajz½Sif;cJYygNyD/ pm½Iolonf ]rsufarSmufvlrsm; tb,faMumifY qdkcJYNyD;onfhtwdkif;uGJjym;ae&oenf;}-[k awG;ac:tyfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY þt&mrsm;onfjyóemjyKtyfaomt&mrsm;vnf; jzpfygonf/

qdkcJYNyD;aom pum;tpOfrsm;jzifY xdkjyóemrsm;\tajzonfNyD;jynfhpkHoifYNyD-[k ,lqygonf/

rsufarSmufb0 tawGUtBuKH tjrifrsm;onf tqef;wMu,fjzpfaeaom t&mjzifY zGJUpnf;wnfaqmufxm;aom t&m[lí wpfckrQ ryg0ifay/ xdkodkYyifjzpfaomfvnf; rdrdb0 tjrifrsufvkH;rsm; rjzpfay:raygufyGm;bJ eD0&Pwdrfov’mrsm;(zefqif;½SifaMumifY aemuftwdwfb0rsm;ujyKvkyfcJYaom ]uH}aMumifY[laom wdrfov’mrsm;) txyfxyf &pfywfzkH;tkyfaevsif tm;vkH;vdk qef;aeEdkifayonf/

Oyrmtm;jzifY vkH;0rsufapYrygbJ vljzpfvmoltwGuf urÇmavmuBuD;ESifYtjynfh ae&mtESHY½Sdaom ta&mifçtvif;çtqif;rsm;taMumif;udk wpdk;wpduav;rQ todrjzpfEdkifouJYodkY jzpfayonf/

Page 128: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

128 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYaMumifY rsufarSmuftjzpfrsm;udk ar;jref;aqG;aEG;rnfqdkvsifaqG;aEG;ar;jref;p&mrsm; rukefEdkifatmifyif ½SdayOD;rnf/ odkYaomfvnf;,ckaqG;aEG;NyD;cJYonfrsm;onf ]aemufb0}ESifY ]aemifb0}jzpfonf[k awG;ac:Edkifp&m rsufarSmufawGUjrif&csufrsm;tjzpf tawmftwefNyD;jynfhpkHaom a½SUwef;ta&mufqkH;rsm; jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY xyfqifYaqG;aEG;aevsif tcsdefrsm;pGmudk tokH;jyK&zdkY½Sdygonf/ þrQ rsufarSmuftjrifrsm;udk aqG;aEG;&jcif;jzifY auseyfESpfodrfYzdkYyefMum;&ygrnf/

þrQjzifY rsufarSmufawGU½Sdcsufrsm; aqG;aEG;csufudk urÜwfzkH;íed*kH;tkyfvdkufygonf/

b,fvdkvJ? tdk-pm½Iol-rsufarSmufawGU½Sdcsuf b0tawGUtBuKHynmjzifY rarG;rDESifY aoNyD;

aemuf b0rsm;½Sdonf-[k odjrifEdkifygoavm/uREkfyfwdkYonf rsufarSmufb0ü awGU½Sd&csufrsm;udk rsm;pGm aqG;aEG;

NyD;cJYygNyD/ tb,f rsufarSmuftjzpfwpfckckonf a½SUb0ESifYaemufb0rsm;½Sdonfudk odEdkifatmif taxmuftudk; oufaoom"u jyKEdkifMuygoenf;/

vkH;0 rawGUcJYNyD r[kwfygavm/ xdkYaMumifY rsufarSmufawGU½Sdcsufrsm;jzifY a½SUb0ESifY aemufb0rsm;udk odEdkifonf-[laom ynm&yfonfrrSefuefaom ynm&yfom jzpfonf-[k rSwfcsufcsMuygpdkY/

þodkYqdkvsif uREkfyfwdkYonf twdwfrS aqG;aEG;csufudk jyefaumufMuygpdkY/ þaqG;aEG;csufum; tb,fenf;/

]yk*¾dKvfwpfpkonf a½SUb0ESifYaemufb0rsm;udk pdwfwefcdk;jzifY jzpfap? ynmjzifYjzpfap? rsufjrifb0tawGUtBuKHynmjzifY jzpfap odEdkifonf}-[laomtqdkudk aqG;aEG;cJYjcif; jzpfygonf/ ,cktcg uREkfyfwdkYonf-

Page 129: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 129

pdwfwefcdk;udkvnf;aumif;?Ak'¨tbd"r®mudkvnf;aumif;?b0tawGUtBuKHynmudk4if; aqG;aEG;cJYNyD;ygNyD/b,ft&mESifYrQ vlom;rsm;onf a½SUb0ESifY aemufb0rsm;udk rod

EdkifaMumif;om awGUcJY&ygonf/ awGUEdkifaMumif; oufaoom"u wpfpwavrQ r&½SdcJYyg/

xdkYaMumifY ]vlonf rarG;rDESifY aoNyD;aemufb0rsm;udk odEdkifygoavm}-[laom ar;cGef;udk vufudkifjyKí aqG;aEG;cJYcsuf\ tajzonf,cktcg xGufay:cJYygNyD/ ,if;um;-

vlonf rarG;rDESifY aoNyD;aemuf b0rsm;udk bmESifYrQrodEdkif/odovdkvdk½Sdjcif; qdkMujcif;onf pdwåZjzifYqdkMujcif; odkYr[kwf

odav[efjyKí r½dk;rom;qdkMujcif;om jzpfonf}- [lí jzpfygonf/þodkYqdkvsif a½SUqufí ajymqdkp&mrsm;udk ajymqdk&ygrnf/]vlonf a½SUçaemufb0rsm;udk rodEdkif}-[kqdkvsif vlxJrSwpfOD;

jzpfaom ]edAÁme'DyeD}q&mvnf; rodEdkif/ b,fenf;ESifYrQrodEkdif}-tajzxGufygonf/ xdkYaMumifY olwifjyaom-

]þb0onf rarG;rDb0wpfckcku jyKvkyfcJYaom ]uH}aMumifYjzpfonf/ þb0ü aemifjzpf&ef ]uH}wpfckckudk qnf;yl;ao;vsif aoNyD;aemufü qufjzpf&zdkY½Sdonf/ þ]uH}udk rjyKvkyfawmYvsif b0tvsOf½kyfodrf;ícsKyfNidrf;jcif;BuD; csKyfNidrf;onf}/

þokdYaom ol\wifjycsufonf odkYr[kwf þodkYaom ol\b0tjrify#dpöorkyÜg'fonf olYudk,fydkif y#dpöorkyÜg'f [kwfygawmYrnfavm/

vlonf vlrsm;\ a½SUESifYaemufb0rsm;udk jrifEdkifaom tcGifYtvrf;r½Sdvsif olvnf; rjrifbJ ½Sd&m\/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf olonfvnf;vlwpfa,mufyif jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

Page 130: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

130 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYaMumifY olwifjyaom y#dpöorkyÜg'f b0oHo&mtjrifonf Ak'tbd"r®mtay: tawG;acsmfxm;aom rSm;,Gif;aeaom y#dpöorkyÜg'fomjzpfavonf/ rSm;,Gif;aeaMumif; udkatmufygjyóemjzifY pm½IolwdkYtm;odjrifapcsifygonf/ ,if;udk tenf;i,f qufvufí aqG;aEG;ygOD;rnf/

43/ uHowådqdkwm bmvJa½SUb0çaemufb0ESpfcktMum; qufoG,faom ]uH\owåd}jzpfap?

tjcm;wpfckckjzpfap? xdkt&m0w¬Kuav;onf b0ESpfckqufoG,f&ef½Sdygonf/ ,if;-t&m0w¬Kuav;onf y&rwfavm odkYr[kwf ynwfavm/

þjyóem\tajzonf ol\ tbd"r®mpmtkyfpmwrf;rsm;ü azmfjyNyD; ½Sdygrnf/ tu,fí ,if;t&m0w¬Kuav;onf "gwfckepfq,fYESpfyg;y&rwfw&m; r[kwfcJYvsif e,fy,fudkausmfaom]tbm0w&m;} jzpf\/

]tbm0w&m;}um; wu,ftm;jzifY r½Sdw&m;/ odkYr[kwf pdwfjzifYwnfaqmufxm;aom pdwåZw&m;om jzpfonf/ ,if;odkYaom ]tbm0w&m;} okdYr[kwf pdwfjzifYwnfaqmufxm;&aom þw&m;jzifY tb,ftusdK;udk onfydk;aqmif½GufEkdifjcif; r½Sdvsif b0ESpfckudk b,fodkYpyfEdkifrnfenf;/

þpum;udk acsyvdkaumif; acsyvdkayrnf/]b0ESpfckonf tMum;[lí r½Sd/ xdkYaMumifY uH\owåduav;onf

vnf; ajy;vTm;aep&m rvkdyg/ Oyrm-rD;awmufaeaom rD;wdkifrS rD;r½Sdao;aomrD;wdkifodkY rD;ul;ovdkom jzpfygonf}/ þodkY rdvdEyO§§mpmtkyfa&;q&m\ avoHudkrSD;í ajymqdkvdkaumif; ajymqdkvdkygrnf/

xdktqdkonfvnf; tu,fü oifYavsmfjcif;½Sdonf r[kwfay/rD;wdkifrSrD;udk tjcm;rD;wdkifodkY rD;ul;jcif;onf rD;rJYrD;wdkifESifY rD;½Sd

rD;wdkifwdkY wpfckESifYwpfck erf;Mu&çxdpyfMu&onf/ xdpyfjcif;onf quf

Page 131: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 131

oG,fjcif;jzpfonf/ ,ck b0ESpfckum; þodkYrerf;Muç rxdpyfMu/xdkYaMumifY þOyrmvnf; jynfhpkHonfr[kwf/,ckqufoG,faom b0ESpfckonf rsm;pGm ta0;tvHBuD;vnf;

jzpfcGifY½Sdonf/ NyD;qkH;cJYonfb0ESifY aemufpawmYrnfhb0ESpfckonf Xmetm;jzifY jcm;rSjcm; jzpfonf/vkH;0yif rxdpyfay/ xdkYaMumifY ul;pufp&mt&mwpfrsdK;rsdK; vdkudkvdkayonf/ xdkt&monf uH\owåduav;jzpfcJYvsif-

,if;-uH\owåduav;onf obm0avmç tbm0avm/uH\owådqdkaom t&muav;um; tb,fodkYaom t&muav;

ygenf;/ tu,fírsm; xdkt&muav;onf rodEdkifaom owådxl;uav;-[kqdkvsif pum; odyfNyD;rSm;oGm;ygrnf/ rodEdkifaom t&muav;udk a½SUwef;wif pma&;xm;jcif;onf teuf½Idif;qkH;rdkufrSSm;rIudk arG;zGm;&ef ydkufemvmjcif; r[kwfygavm/

44/ edAÁme'DyeDq&m\ b0tjrifbmvJxdkYaMumifY ]edAÁme'DyeD}q&m\ b0tjrif odkYr[kwf y#dpöorkyÜg'fjy

pum;rsm;onf olydkiftjrifrsm; r[kwf/ olYpum;rsm;vnf; r[kwf/ Ak'tbd"r®mudk tawG;acsmfNyD; nTefjycJYMuaom ]q&mYq&myk*¾dKvf}wdkY\pum;jzpfygonf/

þ,ck pma&;ol\pum; rSefuefaMumif; tenf;i,frQ oufaoxljyvdkygonf/ ]tqkH;b0\uHESifY tpb0\0dygufwdkY wpfckESifYwpfcktaMumif;ruif;Muaomfvnf; xdkuHESifY0dygufwdkYonf wpfckwnf;r[kwfukef}-[lí qdkMuonf/ xdkYxuf½Sif;atmif qdkygOD;rnf/ Ak'tbd"r®mudktawG;acsmfcJYMuaom rdvdEyO§mpmwrf;udk a&;jyKcJYolrS tp a½S;uyk*¾dKvfrsm;onf b0udk þodkYwifjyMuonf/

Page 132: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

132 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

tb,fodkY wifjyukefoenf;-[lrl-],ckb0ESifY rarG;rDtwdwfb0wdkYonf wpfckwnf; r[kwfMuukef/

odkYaomfvnf; taMumif;um; ruif;ukef/ wzefvnf; ,ckb0ESifY tem*wfaoNyD;ü jzpfvwåHUaom b0wdkYonfvnf; xdkYtwl taMumif;ruif;aomfvnf; vkH;vkH;yif wpfckwnf; odkYr[kwf wpfaumifwnf; r[kwfMuukef}/ þodkY qdkMuçwifjyMuukef\/

þodkY ajymqdkMuukefaom olwdk Yonfyif tjcm;wpfae&müatmufygpum;rsm;udk EIwfESifYwGwfwGwf½Gwfí ajymqdkMujyefonf/

,if;pum;rsm;um;-],ck igwdkY\ aumif;çraumif;tjzpfrsm;onf rarG;rD aemufqkH;

b0wkef;u igwdkYyif aumif;çraumif;jyKcJYaomaMumifY jzpfonf/ xdkYtwligwdkYjyKaom aumif;çraumif;trIrsm;onfvnf; aoNyD;aemufü igwdkYyifcHçpHjzpfay:&OD;rnf}- [lownf;/

þae&mü jyefajymp&mrsm; ½Sdygonf/ ]ynwftjzpf þodkYrS rokH;EIef;rajymqdkvsif b,fodkYvkyfrnfvJ/ þodkY ]igwdkYç igwdkY}-[lí okH;eIef;ajymqdk&rnfyif r[kwfygavm}-[k qdkcsifayrnf/

þodkY ajymcsifonfYtwdkif; ajymyg/ þodkYrS ]igwdkYçigwdkY}-[k okH;EIef;rajymvsif rjzpfyg/ xdkYaMumifY aemufb0wkef;u jzpfoludkvnf; ]igwdkY}yif?,ckb0 jzpfqJoludkvnf; ]igwdkY}yif/ aemufjzpfvwåHUoludkvnf; ]igwdkY}yifjzpfygonf-[k ajymyg/ ajymxdkuf yg\/

odkYaomfvnf; ajym½kHyif ajymapcsifygonf/ rarG;cifu ola&m?jzpfqJola&m? aoNyD;aemuf jzpfrnfholyg ]ig}wpfa,mufwnf;tjzpfudkrlrxm;oifYyg/ þodkYrxm;vsif rarG;cifu ]ig}vkyfcJYaomtrItwGuf ,ckjzpfqJ]igY}rSm ]qdk;arGçaumif;arG} &rSmjzpfí? tarGqdk;&oljzpfvsif rarG;cifu]igY}udk aMumufcsifaMumufyg/

Page 133: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 133

odkYaomfvnf; aoNyD;rS jzpfay:tHhaom]ig}twGuf vkH;0 raMumufapcsifyg/ xdk-aoNyD;aemuf jzpftHhaom]ig}onf ,ck]ig} vkH;0r[kwfyg/,ck]ig}u raumif;vkyfNyD; aoNyD;jzpftHhaom]ig}udk raumif;arG ay;cJYaumif;ay;cJYayrnf/ odkYaomfvnf; aoNyD; ]ig}onf ,ck]ig}r[kwfí xdk-aoNyD;]ig}twGuf vkH;0ylp&m r½Sd? aMumufp&mvnf; r½Sdyg/ ]ig-aoNyD;rS jzpftHhaomig-u ,ckjzpfqJ-igudk jyefí qdk;arGçaumif;arG ray;EdkifaomaMumifYig-aoNyD;rS jzpftHhaomig-udk bmrQvSrf;NyD; aMumufp&mrvkd}-[lownf;/

xdkolwdkYonf þodkYrylbJ raMumufbJ aeMuoavm/xdkolwdkY\ t"duvkyfief;onf xdkaemufb0jzpfrSmudk aMumufí?

aemufb0rjzpfatmif vkyfaeaomvkyfief; jzpfonf/tb,faMumifY aemufb0jzpfrSm aMumufMuoenf;/b0jzpfvsif 'ku©&í þodkYaom jzpftHhaom'ku©udk aMumufMu

aomaMumifY aemufb0udkaMumufMuonf [lownf;/xdkolwdkY\ ]b0}onf apmufxdk;rdk;ajrmf jzpfonf/ tb,faMumifY

qdkaomf olwdkYtbd"r®mu wjcm;? olwdkYtusifY wjcm;- jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/ [kwfygonf/ olwdkYtbd"r®mt& ]aemifjzpftHhaomb0onf ,ckb0ESifY taMumif;ruif;aomfvnf; ,ckb0r[kwf}-[k qdkvsif xdk-aemifjzpftHhaomb0udk ]igYb0jzpfao;onf}-[k ynwfpum;vkH;jzifYyif okH;EIef;ajymqdkzdkY roifYawmYay/

olwkdYtbd"r®mt& ]aemifjzpftHhaomb0onf ,ckb0ESifY taMumif;ruif;aomfvnf; ,ckb0r[kwf}-[kqdkvsif txufygolwdkY tbd"r®mt&(0g) olwdkYtqdkt& aemifjzpftHYaomb0onf ,ckigYb0 r[kwfygaomaMumifY? aemifjzpftHhaomb0onf csKyfcsifcsKYyf-rcsKyfcsifae? jzpfcsifjzpf-rjzpfcsifae ,ck]igYb0}ESifY bmrQrqdkifygojzifY aemif jzpftHhaomb0udk,ckb0uaeNyD; bmrQ vSrf;íylp&mvnf;r½Sd? yifp&mvnf; r½Sd? aMumuf

Page 134: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

134 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

p&mvnf; r½Sd? vefYp&mvnf; r½Sd? 0rf;ajrmufp&mvnf; r½Sd? 0rf;enf;p&mvnf; r½SdawmYay/

odkYaomf olwdkYonf aMumufaewkef;yif/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf,ckb0 udk,fY0rf;ydkufxJu jzpfay: aygufzGm;oGm;aomom;onf aocsmwyftyfyif udk,fYom;jzpfonfrSm trSefjzpfonf/ xdk-udk,fYom;udkyif udk,fYudk,fESifYpmvsif ]olwyg;}[k okH;EIef;ac:a0:&onf/ tb,fenf;ESifYrQigYom;jzpfí olonfvnf; olwyg;r[kwf? ]ig}yif[k rajymqdkMu/

xdkodkY wu,fwrff; odEdkifjrifEdkifavmufatmif ododxifxif qufoG,faeaom om;udkyif ]ig}jzpfonf-[k rajymEdkifbJ ]olwyg;}-[kajym&vsif ododxifxifr[kwfbJ pdwfrSef;jzifY BudK;pm;vsufqufoG,f&aom]aemifjzpfvwåHUb0}udk ]ig}-[k okH;EIef;ajymqdkjcif;onf roifYjrwf/ okH;jcif;okH;vsif ]olwyg;}-[kyif okH;oifYawmYonf/ ynwfrSmyif tvGJ½SdcJYNyD/avmua0g[m&ESifY rnDrnGwf jzpfcJYNyD/

xdkYaMumifY olwdkY\b0onf yljcif;½Sdovdk? aemifb0twGuf yloifYovdk½Sdrnf r[kwfavm-qdktHh/ xdkodkYvnf; roifY-[kyif qdk&rnf/

]om;udkcspfonfç om;udkcspfonf}-tp½Sdaom pum;rsm;onfxdkom;udk tu,fcspfMuonf r[kwfMu/ trSefü ]udk,fYudk,fudk cspfMujcif;om} jzpfonf/ udk,fYtokH;taqmifypönf;? ta>ct&Hypönf;- þrnfaomypönf;uav;tjzpf cspfjcif;jzpfonf/ t0wftxnfç yef;rmvfponfudkcspfjcif;uJYodkYyif udk,fYb0jynfhpkHrItwGuf cspfjcif;jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifY þodkYcspfaom om;trdç om;tzç armifESrç q&mwynfhponfh tcspfrsm;onfvnf; ig&mESpfq,fY½SpftcspfjzpfzdkY rsm;pGm taMumif;enf;yg;vSygonf/ wpfaxmifYig;&mcspfrsm;om jzpfzdkY½Sdavonf/

wpfaxmifYig;&mtcspfonf udk,fYb0udk tajccHaomtcspfrsm;vnf; jzpfonf/ xdkodkYyif jzpfaomfvnf; xdkxdkrdbESifY om;orD;ç armif

Page 135: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 135

ESrwdkYonf olwdkYtcspfudk wpfaxmifYig;&mcspf odkYr[kwf udk,fYb0udktajccHaom tcspf-[k rodjrifMuawmYukef/ tb,faMumifY þodkYjzpf&oenf;/

tpyXrü udk,fYb0udk tajccHNyD; cspfcJYjcif; trSefyif/ odkYaomfvnf; MumjrifYvmaomtcg xdk-udk,fYb0udk tajccH wnfaqmufxm;aom tcspfwdkYonf BuD;xGm;jyefYus,fí vmavonf/ ]t&ufudk tpüvluaomufonf? aemuftcg t&ufu vludkaomufonf}- qdkouJYodkYyif tpü udk,fYb0udktajccHNyD; tcspfudk wnfaqmufcJYonf/ MumjrifYvmaomtcg xdktcspfrsm;u tm;aumif;vmaomaMumifY udk,fYb0udk vTrf;rdk;oGm;cH&jcif; jzpfonf/ qdkvdkonfrSm ]tcspf}onf udk,fYb0udk 0g;NrdKoGm;onf-[lí jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]udk,fYtwGuf olrsm;udkcspfonf}-[k rodawmYbJ ]olrsm;udk oufouf udk,fucspfonf}-[k odjrifvmavawmYonf/ xdkYaMumifYyifudk,fYtcspftwGuf udk,fYtoufç udk,fYb0udk tqkH;½IH;cHEdkifMujcif; jzpfayonf/

tpü ]tcspf}udk udk,fuaomufonf/ aemiftcg ]tcspf}u udk,fYudkaomufoGm;onf/ þodkYkjzpfonf/ þüvnf; udk,fYom;onf vkH;0yifudk,frSyGm;aom udk,f\ udk,fyGm;uav;udkyif udk,fYudk,favmuf rcspfEdkif-qdkvsif aemifjzpftHhaomb0 udk,fYtwGuf ,ckb0 aMumufonfç ylyefonf-qdkonfrSm aemifb0twGuf r[kwfbJ? ,ckb0 udk,fuaevsufpdwåZjzpfaejcif;om jzpf&ayrnf/

xdkYaMumifY aemufb0twGuf udk,fusifYw&m;rsm; ,ckb0uyifusifYaeMujcif;onfvnf; aemufb0aMumufrI-[laom pdwftm;vGefrI(=tbdocFg&) pdwåZa0'em jzpfrIBuD;aMumifY jyKvkyfusifYBuHaeMujcif;omjzpfayonf/ olwdkYonf olwdkYpdwåZvkyfief; twGuf jrefrmpum;ykHwpfckjyKMuavonf/ ,if;um; ]t&dyfvdkcsifvsif aeyluapmifYyg} [lownf;/

Page 136: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

136 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]t&dyfvdkcsifvsif t&dyfxJoGm;}/ 'gyif raumif;ygavm/ (0g)t&dyfxJoGm;ae&ef raumif;ygavm/ t&dyfaemuf a½TUvdkufvsif NyD;onfr[kwfygavm/ xdkYaMumifY olwdkYb0onf ]tjrifESifYtvkyf} odkYr[kwf ]tbd"r®mESifYb0} r[yfrdç rpyfrdaom tusdK;tyJYBuD; jzpfaeavonf/

þodkY tb,faMumifY jzpf&oenf;/olwdkYonf ]b0}udk ravYvmMuay/ oabmw&m;pmwrf;rsm;udk

om avYvmMuayonf/ xdkYaMumifY udk,frygaomacgif;onf b,frSra½GUEdkifay/ ra½GUEdkifaomaMumifY acgif;onf Munfhjrifp&m? Mum;emp&mponfYtm½kH topftopfwdkY iwfrGwfNyD; pdwåZ jzpfoGm;&avonf/

xdkYaMumifY olwdkY\ oabmw&m;rsm;onf pdwåZoabmw&m;rsm;jzpfaeMuayonf/ [kwfygonf/ olwdkYonf ]Ak'tbd"r®m}udk avYvmMuaomfvnf; xdk]Ak'tbd"r®m}\ wu,fYb0udkum; razmfaqmifEdkifMuay/xdk ]Ak'tbd"r®m}udk olwdkYcHwGif;ü oGm;&nf tvdrf;vdrf;jzifY ikHxm;Mu½kHikHxm;Muayonf/

]Ak'¨\oabmw&m;}um;-aemufb0½Sdjcif;ESifY r½Sdjcif;udkvnf;aumif;?a½SUb0½Sdjcif;ESifY r½Sdjcif;udkvnf;aumif; jiif;qdkcJYayonf/þodkUjiif;qdk&jcif;\ taMumif;udk oabmaygufatmif avYvm

Edkifol jzpfap? þodkYyif jiif;qdk&rnf[k oabmaygufNyD;ol jzpfap? þolrsm;uom Ak'\wnfaqmufcJYaomb0udk awGU½Sdjcif; jzpfayonf/

]pdwåZoabmw&m;}½Sdaom olwdkYonf Ak'\wnfaqmufcJYaomb0udk awGU½SdMuaom þolrsm;uJYodkY r[kwfMu/ rajzaumif;aomjyóemjzpfí rajzjcif;omjzpfonf-[k auseyfvG,foGm;cJYMuayonf/ (0g) ynm½SdvkyfoGm;cJYMuonf/

Page 137: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 137

45/ y&rw¬t½Sd0g'onf Ak'0g'r[kwfxdkYjyif olwdkYonf þodkY a½SUçaemufb0rsm; ½Sdjcif;çr½Sdjcif;ESpfrsdK;rS

vGwf&ef oabmw&m;opfwpfck wnfaqmufMuayonf/,if;um; ]y&rw¬0g'} jzpfavonf/odkYr[kwf ]y&rw¬t½Sd0g'} jzpfavonf/xdk0g'jzifY aemufb0çaemifb0rsm; ½Sdçr½Sd ESpfrsdK;vkH;udk jiif;qdk&ef

rsufvSnfhjyzdkY jzpfavonf/ olwdkYrsufvSnfhonf rsufvSnfhom jzpfavonf/ olwdkY rsufvSnfhjyolrsm;udk,fwdkifyif wu,fjiif;qdkrIudk tNrJwef;jzpfatmif rwnfaqmufEdkifMuay/ (0g) wu,fjiif;qdkrIudk oabmusatmifrwnfaqmufEdkifMuay/

þjiif;qdkrIonf omoemawmfü yXrae&mudk tenf;qkH; &apEdkifavonf/ þjiif;qdkrIrsdK;udkum; jrefrmjynfom;rSeforQ jyKwwfaervm;yif qdk&rnf/

jrefrmjynfü q&mawmfBuD;wpfyg;vnf; þodkYyif ESvkH;rl[ef wlayonf/ ]omoemawmfü yXrae&m(aomwmyef)udk vlwdkif;&aew,f-vdkYajymvdkufcsifw,f/ vlMum;raumif;rSmpdk;vdkYom}-[lí EIwfjzifY wwGwfwGwf½Gwfí rdefYqdkzl;cJYayonf/

olonf (0g) ,if;q&mawmfonf y&rw¬0g'DwdkY\ rsufvSnfhudkem;vnfjcif;tm;jzifY a½SUçaemufb0rsm; jzpfçrjzpfrSvGwfatmif odjrifEdkifaomt&m-[k ESvkH;ydkufawmfrlaomaMumifY jzpfayonf/ olxifovdk[kwfyg\avm/

þ]y&rwft½Sd0g'}udk xkH;vkdacs a&vdkaESmufaeaom olwdkYonfvnf; omoem\ yXrae&m&olwdkY toGiftjyifESifY zDvmqefYusif ½SdaeMuonfudk tvG,fwulyif awGUcGifY½Sdonf r[kwfygavm/ ]y&rw¬t½Sd0g'}onf ]Ak'0g'r[kwfay}/ olwdkY\ pdwåZ0g'om jzpfayonf/

Page 138: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

138 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Ak'onf ol\b0tjrifudk wifjy&mü-]y&rw¬udk t½Sdoabmtjzpf wifjycJYjcif; r½Sday/]tjzpfw&m;tjzpfom wifjycJYayonf/olwdkYonf olwdkY\ y&rw¬t½Sd0g't& pdwfvnf; t½Sdjzpfonf/

apwodufvnf; t½Sdjzpfonf/ ½kyfvnf; t½Sdjzpfonf-[k qdkMuonf/xdkolwdkYonf xdky&rw¬w&m;rsm;udk cEmw&m;rsm;jzpfonf- [k

vnf; qdkMujyefonf/ xdkw&m;rsm;onf cEmavm/ umvçXmeçoP²meftjym; wpfq,fYwpfyg;wdkYjzifY cGJjcm;pdwfjzmí Munfhol\tjzpfrsm;onfcE¨mavm/

xdk pdwfçapwodufç½kyfrsm;jzifY zGJUaomt&mudk]opömav;yg;}udk azmfxkwfjyoMuaom yk*¾dKvfwdkYtjrifü cEmrsm; r[kwfMuukef/

xdkYaMumifY ]cE¨m}onfvnf;aumif;? pdwfçapwodufç½kyfrsm;onfvnf;aumif; ]tv,fvrf;}udk azmfxkwfjyoawmfrlcJYMuaom yk*¾dKvfrsm;tjrifü ]t½Sdw&m;rsm;}-[k rxifMuukef/xdkodkY rxifaMumif;udk olwdkYazmfjyMuaom pdwfçapwodufç½kyfwdkY\ trSwfvu©Pmpum;rsm;ü xif½Sm;awGUjrif&ayonf/

xdktrSwfvu©Pmrsm;um; tb,fenf;/,if;wdkYum; ]tedpö? 'ku©? tewå}wdkY jzpfayonf/[kwfygonf/ tv,fvrf;udk azmfxkwfjyocJYMuaom yk*¾dKvfwdkY

onf pdwfçapwodufç½kyf[kqdktyfaom y&rw¬rsm;\ vu©Pmudk ]tedpöç'ku©çtewå}[k nTefjycJYMuygonf/

xdkvu©Pmjypum;vkH;rsm;onf pdwfçapwodufç½kyf[kqdktyfaom y&rw¬w&m;rsm;\ ]t½Sdw&m; tjzpfudkjiif;qdkjyaom pum;rsm;} jzpfygonf/

Page 139: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 139

t½Sdw&m;tjzpfrSjiif;qdkjcif;rsm;teuf þvu©Pmjy pum;vkH;okH;vkH;jzifY jiif;qdkjcif;onf tapYpyfqkH;? taocsmqkH; jiif;qdkcsufyif jzpfonf/

46/ t½Sdqdkwm bmvJþae&mü ]t½Sd}qdkaom pum;\ teufudk tenf;i,f zGifYyg&ap/]t½Sd}[lonfrSm ]twåowåd}[kqdktyfaom udk,fYudk,fudk &yfwnf

Edkifaom pGrf;&nfESifY ]twåed,owåd}[k qdktyfaom ywf0ef;usifudkygaqmifEdkifaom pGrf;&nf½Sdaomt&m jzpfygonf/

]twå}ESifY ]twåed,owådrsm;}½Sdaomt&monf]t½Sd}jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/tu,fí jzpfay:vmaom w&m;onf twåowådESifY twåed,

owådrsm; 0ifaeaom ]t½Sdw&m;rsm;} jzpfcJYygrl? xdkw&m;ü umvç XmeçoP²mersm; trSefyif ½Sday&monf/ þYü-

]umv}-qdkonfrSm ],ckçaemufçaemif} jzpfonf/]Xme}-qdkonfrSm ]eD;ça0;çwGif;çjyif} jzpfonf/]oP²me}-qdkonfrSm ],kwfçjrwfçMurf;çEk} jzpfonf/tu,fí jzpfay:qJ jzpfap? jzpfay:NyD;aemuf wnfqJjzpfap?

ysufoGm;tHhtcsdefwdkifatmif jzpfap ]jzpfay:aeaomt&m}onf udk,fYudk,fudk &yfwnfEdkifaomowådESifY tjcm;t&m0w¬Kudk jzpfay:atmif jyKEdkifpGrf;aomowådrsm; ½SdonfqdktHh/ xdkt&monfom ]t½Sdw&m;} jzpfonf/xdkt½Sdw&m;üomvsif ppfrSefaom umvçXmeçoP²mersm; ½Sdonf/

]twåESifY twåed,owådrsm;} r½Sdí t½Sdw&m;r[kwfaom ]tjzpfw&m;rsm;}ü umvçXmeçoP²me}rsm; tu,fr½Sdukef/ vlü ]oauFw}jzifYom ½Sd[efjzpfíaejcif; jzpfayonf/ tb,faMumifY þodkYjzpf&oenf;-[laomf ]t½dSw&m;r[kwfaomaMumifY}-[lvdk/

Page 140: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

140 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkpum;rsm;t& xdkpdwfçapwodufç½kyf y&rwfw&m;ü ]twåowådESifY twåed,owåd}rsm; ½Sdoavmçr½Sdoavm- qef;ppf&zdkY ½Sdavonf/

xdky&rwfrsm;udk azmfxkwfcJYaom tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:udkwifjyEdkifcJYol Ak'toQifonf xdky&rwfrsm;ü umvçXmeçoP²mersm; ½Sdonf-[k azmfxkwfcJYoavm/ Ak'toQifonf xdky&rwfrsm; t½Sdr[kwfaMumif; azmfxkwfcJY? nTefcJYonf/

,if;wdkYrSm ]tcsdefumv? ae&mXmeESifY toGifoP²me}udk jiif;qdkaom ]tedpö? 'ku©? tewå}[laom pdwfç apwodufç ½kyf y&rwfwdkY\vu©Pmjypum;vkH;rsm; jzpfMuayonf/

47/ tedpöonf y&rwft½Sdjy tcsdefudkjiif;qdkonfhpum;þpum;vkH;wdkY\ teuftw¬ t"dyÜg,fudk tenf;i,frQ qef;ppf

í aumuf,ljyvdkygonf/ xdkpum;okH;vkH;teuf ]tedpö}[laom pum;vkH;\teufudk avYvmMuygrnf/ ]tedpö}[laom pum;vkH;onf ]t}ESifY ]edpö}[laom ESpfvkH;aygif;pum;vkH; jzpfygonf/ þü-

]t}onf ]wm;jrpfjcif;jy} pum;vkH; jzpfygonf/]edpö}onf ]NrJjcif;}teufjy pum;vkH; jzpfygonf/þpum;ESpfvkH;udk aygif;vdkufaomtcg ]rNrJjcif;} odkYr[kwf

]tNrJr½Sdjcif;}[lí xGifay:vmygonf/b,folrNrJoenf; odkYr[kwf b,fol tNrJr½Sdoenf;/pdwfçapwodufç½kyf[laom y&rw¬wdkY rNrJjcif;? tNrJr½Sdjcif; jzpfyg

onf/ þü ]rNrJjcif;}[lonf tb,fodkYjzpfonfudk qdkoenf;/]NrJjcif;}\ qefYusifzufjzpfjcif;udk ]rNrJjcif;}[k qdk&ygonf/xdkodkYqdkvQif ]NrJjcif;}[lonf tb,fodkYenf;/

Page 141: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 141

]NrJjcif;}[lonf ]rNrJjcif;\ qefYusifzuf}yif jzpfonf-[lí ajz&ayrnf/ þodkYqdkvsif ]NrJ}ESifY ]rNrJ}wdkY\ teuftw¬wdkYonf w&m;aor½Sdukef/]NrJ}[k towfrSwfcH&aom twdkif;twmrS ausmfvGefaomtjzpfonf ]rNrJ}jzpfí? ]rNrJ}[k towfrSwfcH&aom twdkif;twm\ atmufusaomtjzpfonf ]NrJ} jzpfaeavonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]NrJ}ESifY ]rNrJ}onf wpfckudkwpfck axmufqíjzpfaomt&mrsm;jzpfonf/ xdkodkY axmufqrSjzpfaomt&monf axmufqolESifYuif;í r&Edkifay/ odkYr[kwf axmufqol\ owfrSwfcsufESifYuif;íjzpfEdkifaomt&m r[kwfay/ qdkvdkonfrSm ]þtcsdeftwGif; jzpfay:orQonf ]NrJ}jzpfonf? þtcsdefrStxufjzpfaom t&monf ]rNrJ}jzpfonf}-þodkY owfrSwfcsuf½SdrS ]NrJ}ESifY ]rNrJ}udk jzpfapEdkifrnf[k jzpfygonf/

þ]tedpö}[laom pum;vkH;udk okH;EIef;cJYaom Ak'toQifonf ]NrJ}ESifYrNrJ}wdkY\pnf;jcm;ay;&m owfrSwfcsufudk tb,fodkY >rufcJYavoenf;/

½kyftwGufqdkvsifvnf; ]vufzspfwpfwGwftcsdef\ uka#ig;axmifausmfydkif; wpfydkif;}tcsdefrS atmuftcsdefrsm;onf ]NrJaomtcsdef} jzpfonf/4if;tcsdefESifY txuftcsdefrsm;onf ]rNrJaomtcsdef} jzpfonf/ pdwftwGufqdkvsif vufzspfwpfwGwftcsdef\ uka#wpfodef;ausmfydkif;wpfykdif;tcsdefrSatmufjzpfaomtcsdefrsm;onf ]NrJ}aomtcsdefrsm; jzpfonf/ xdktcsdefESifYxdktcsdefrStxufjzpfaom tcsdefrsm;onf ]rNrJ} jzpfMuonf/

þodkY owfrSwfcJYygoavm/þodkY owfrSwfcJYrSom uka#ig;axmifausmfydkif;-wpfykdif; tcsdef

oufwrf;½Snfonf-qdkaom ½kyfrsm;ESifY uka#wpfodef;ausmfydkif;wpfykdif;tcsdefoufwrf;½Snfonf qdkaom emrfw&m;rsm;twGuf ]rNrJ}[k rSwf,lEdkifcGifY½Sdrnf jzpfavonf/

Page 142: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

142 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

tu,fí þodkYowfrSwfcJYjcif; r½Sdvsif xdkodkY tcsdefoufwrf;½SdMuaom ½kyfESifY emrfrsm;onf ]rNrJ}[kqdk&ef tMuyftwnf; tcJtuyf ½Sdayonf/ tb,fodkYenf;/

uka#ig;axmifausmfydkif;wpfydkif; toufwrf;½Sdaom ½kyfonfvufzspfwpfwGwf\ uka#ig;axmifausmfykdif;wpfydkif; tcsdefwdkYxufydkívufzspfwpfwGwfvkH;vkH;tcsdef? þtcsdefrsm;ESifYpmvsif rNrJonf trSefjzpfaomfvnf; vufzspfwpfwGwf\ uka#ig;axmifausmfydkif;wpfydkif; tcsdefudkxuf0ufcGJxm;aomtcsdef odkYr[kwf uka#wpfaomif;ausmfydkif;wpfydkif;tcsdef? þtcsdefrsm;ESifYpmvsif ]NrJ}[lí jzpfoGm;&zdkY ½Sdavonf/

]NrJçrNrJ}[laom pum;rsm;onf ½Snfaomtcsdefudkaxmufíwdkaomtcsdefudk ]NrJ}?wdkaomtcsdefudkaxmufí ½Snfaomtcsdefudk }rNrJ}?þodkYac:a0:&onf r[kwfygavm/

xdkYaMumifY ]NrJESifYrNrJ}udk cGJjcm;&ef owfrSwfxm;aom pHjyKtcsdefr½SdcJYqdkvsif ]NrJ-rNrJ}ajymqdk&ef rjzpfEdkifaom tajctae ½Sdayonf/

emrftwGufvnf; xdkYtwlyif emrfudk vufzspfwpfwGwf\ uka#wpfodef;ausmfydkif;wpfydkif; oufwrf;umv½Sdonf-[k ,lqajymqdkMuonf/xdkemrfonf þrQ toufwrf;umv½Sdonf-[k ,lqajymqdkMuonf/xdkemrfonf þrQ toufwrf;umv½Sdonfqdkvsif xkdemrfoufwrf;xufwdkaom oufwrf;umv [lívnf; ½SdEdkif&monf/

umvonf uka#wpfodef;ausmfydkif; wpfydkif; ponfjzifYvnf; ½SdEdkifonf r[kwfygavm/ þrQwdkawmif;aom tcsdefydkif;[lí r½SdEdkif-[krnfolrQ tcsdefay;EdkifcGifY r½Sday/ ,ckacwfvdk trfpxa&mif,lepfrsm;udkpepfwus okH;pGJwwfNyD;jzpfaomacwfü þrQwdkawmif;aomtcsdefjzifYajymyavmufonf r[kwfawmY-[kqdkvsif t&,fcH&zdkY aocsmayonf/þodkYqdkvsif uka#wpfodef;ausmfydkif; wpfydkif; oufwrf;umv½Sdaom

Page 143: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 143

emrfonf uka#wpfoef;ausmfydkif;wpfydkif;umvESifY pmvsif q,fqyifydkíNrJaeavonf/

xdkYaMumifY emrfw&m;udk rNrJ-[k tb,fqdkrnfenf;/þodkYyif ½kyfçemrfrsm;udk ]rNrJ}[kajymqdk&ef tcuftcJ½Sdayonf/

xdktcuftcJudk ausmfvTm;Edkif&ef pHjyKtcsdefwpfckckudk Ak'¨toQifonfowfrSwfaMujimí rxm;cJYay/ þodkYvnf; xm;cJYí rjzpfay/

Ak'toQifonf tvGefwefzdk;½Sdaom ]tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:}udk azmfxkwfjyocJYol jzpfayonf/ ol\ tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:onfpdwful;,OftawG;tac:\ ajymif;jyeftcsdK; jzpfonf/ tu,fí tcsdefwpfckckudk ]NrJESifYrNrJ}wdkY\ pnf;jcm;&m Mum;rSwfwdkiftjzpf pHjyKowfrSwfcJYvsif owfrSwfEdkif&ef wu,f o½kyfoaumifwpfck trSef½Sd&ayrnf/

Oyrm- pifwD*&dwfjy'g;wdkifü wpfrSatmufonf a&cJ&rnf/wpf&mrStxufonf a&ql&rnf-[k aMujimcJYonf/ xdkodkY aMujimonfhtwdkif; 'D*&Djy'g;onf tu,fí-wpfatmufa&mufaecJYvsif tjyifavmursm;onf a&rsm; cJae&rnf/

þuJYodkY tu,f jzpf&yfwpfckck r½SdbJ? tb,ftcsdefonf ]NrJESifYrNrJ}wdkY\ pnf;jcm;&m Mum;umvtcsdefjzpfonf-[k aMujimowfrSwfvsifpdwåZowfrSwfcsuf? pdwful;,OfowfrSwfcsufom jzpfayrnf/ xdkYaMumifYxdktvkyfrsdK;onf Ak'toQif tvsOf;yif rvkyfaomtvkyf jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]tedpö}[laom pum;vkH;\ teuftw¬onf ]jzpfçjzpfNyD;rS ysufoGm;jcif;}[laom teuftw¬ rjzpfEdkif&m/ ]jzpfNyD;aemuf r½Sdjcif;}[laom ][kwGm tbm0}teufrsdK; zGifYEdkif&ef txufqdkcJYonfhtwdkif;pHjyKtcsdef r½SdaomaMumifYwnf;/ xdkYaMumifY-

]tedpö}[laom pum;vkH;\ teuftw¬onf]tcsdefudk jiif;qdkaom} pum;vkH;yif jzpf&monf/

Page 144: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

144 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]NrJ}-[k ajymedkifaom tcsdef[lí vkH;0r½Sd/ tNrJudk r½Sd/ bdwfbdwfr½Sd/ b,fawmYrQ r½Sd-[k qdkvdkay&monf/

pdwfçapwodufç½kyf[laom y&rw¬w&m;wdkYonf y&rw¬t½Sd0g'DwdkY,lMuovdk tESpftom;tjzpf? tv,fvrf;udk azmfxkwfwifjycJYMuolwdkYa[majymcJYMujcif; ½Sdonf r[kwfay/ tm;vkH;aomavmuudk ]ypö,or0g,}-[k qdktyfaom ]rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif; tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;jzifY pka0;aygif;pyfxm;aomt&m}-[lí tus,fw0ef; rdefYMum;>rufqdkcJYMuayonf/

þ-]avmu}[lonf a&çajrçawmçawmif? ork'&m? vl? wd&pämef?tdk;tdrf-tp½Sdonfrsm;ESifY pdwfçapwodufç½kyfrsm; jzpfygonf/

þ-]avmu}udk ESpfydkif;awmY cGJEdkifygonf/(1) pdwfçapwodufç½kyfrS <uif;aom avmuESifY(2) pdwfçapwodufç½kyf-[laom avmu-[lí jzpfygonf/tb,faMumifY þodkYcGJ&oenf;/ESpfydkif;pvkH;yif rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;tao;tzGJuav;rsm;

pka0;aygif;pyfaeaom t&mrsm;csnf; r[kwfygavm-[k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/[kwfygonf/ a&çajrçawmçawmif? vl? wd&pämef? tdk;tdrf ponfwdkYonfvnf; rjynfhpkHaom taMumif;(ypö,)rsm; pka0;aeaomt&m ]or0g,}rsm;jzpfygonf/

Oyrm-tdrfjzpf&ef opfom;pç 0g;p-ponfjzifY tdrfwpfvkH;jzpfzdkYtwGuf rjynfhpkHaom tpdwftydkif; odkYr[kwf tdrfaqmufypönf;rsm;jzifYpkaygif; wnfaqmufcHxm;&aom t&m jzpfonf/

]vl}qdkonfrSmvnf; xdkYtwl jzpfygonf/ taoG;tom;ç t½dk;tausm-ponfjzifY tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;jzifY wnfaqmufcHxm;&aomt&m0w¬Kjzpfygonf/ <uif;aom a&çajrçawmçawmif ponfvnf; þenf;

Page 145: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 145

rsm;twl jzpfygonf/xdkYjyif pdwfçapwodufç½kyf[laom emrfw&m;rsm;vnf; a&çajrç

awmçawmif-ponfuJYodkYyif rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;rsm; aygif;pyfpkpnf;aeaom t&mrsm;yif jzpfygonf/ Oyrm- pdwfjzpf&ef tm½kHESifY'Gg&wdkYaygif;pkH&ygonf/ þü tm½kHonfvnf;aumif;? 'Gg&onfvnf;aumif;pdwfjzpf&eftwGuf rjynfhpkHao;aomtaMumif; tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;jzpfygonf/

apwodufvnf; pdwftwljzpfygonf/ ½kyfqdkvsifvnf; þtwljzpfygonf/ ]Oyg'g½kyf}[kqdktyfaom rsufapYtMunfçem;tMunfponf?onf]bkwf½kyf}[kqdktyfaom rmjcif;çMurf;jcif;? qGJjcif;çiifjcif;? yljcif;çat;jcif;? vIyfjcif;çwGef;jcif;rsm;\ tcsdK;tay:rSDí jzpfaeonf/

xdk]bkwf½kyf}wdkY\ zGJUpnf;ykHtcsdK;rsm;onf rsufapYtMunfjzpfzdkYrjynfhpkHao;aomtaMumif;rsm; jzpfonf/

xdkYtwl ]bkwf½kyf}rsm;onfvnf; wpfckjzpfzdkYtwGuf tjcm;okH;ckonf rjynfhpkHao;aomtaMumif; jzpfonf/ wpfckwdkif;onf þodkYyifokH;ckwdkY\ pka0;aeaom toGifom jzpfonf/ þodkY pdwfçapwodufç½kyfESifYa&çajrçawmçawmif ponfwdkYonf ]ypö,or0g,}w&m; odkYr[kwfrjynfhpkHao;aom tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;jzifY wnfaqmufcHxm;&aomt&mrsm;tjzpf wlnD&ygonf/

þodkYyifwlaomfvnf; pdwfçapwodufç½kyfwdkYonf a&çajrçawmçawmif? vl? wd&pämef ponfwdkY wnfaqmuf&mü ]tajccHoabmrsm;}jzpfonf/ a&çajrçawmçawmif? vl? wd&pämef ponfwdkYonf ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}[k qdktyfaom ]tajccHw&m;}wdkYjzifY twnfaqmufcHxm;&aomtoGiftjyifw&m;rsm; jzpfonf/

Page 146: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

146 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þodkYyif a&çajrçawmçawmif? vl? wd&pämef ponfESifY ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}wdkY uGJjym;jcm;em;Muonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]avmu}udk-

]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}wdkY wpfydkif;?<uif;aom a&çajrçawmçawmifpaom t&mrsm;udkwpfydkif;/þodkY ESpfydkif; cGJtyfygonf/

48/ y&rwfESifY ynwftajccHtydkif;onf ]y&rw¬} jzpfygonf/þü ]y&rw¬}\ qdkvdk&if; teuft"dyÜg,frSm ]acszsufír&aom

t&m} [lí jzpfygonf/ odkYr[kwf ]aemufqkH;tajctae}[lí t"dyÜg,f,l&ygonf/ Oa&mywdkuf\ a½SUem;acwfrS tufwrf(Atom)0g'D½SifwdkY\tufwrf(Atom)\teufESifY wlnDygonf/

tufwrf0g'DwdkYponf ]tm;vkH;aomavmu[laom wdkuftdrfBuD;\ tajccHtkwfcsyfrsm;um; tufwrfrsm;jzpfonf}-[k ,lqouJYodkY•è

]tm;vHk;aoma&çajrçawmçawmif? vl? wd&pämefponfwdkY\ tajccHw&m;um; pdwfçapwodufç½kyf[laom y&rw¬w&m;}rsm; jzpfygonf/

]y&rw¬}\ teuft"dyÜg,fonf ]acszsufír&}-[líjzpfonfqdktHh/ tb,fodkY acszsufí r&oenf;/ þodkY ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/

þtajzonf atmufygtwdkif;jzpfygonfè]a&çajrçawmçawmif? vlçwd&pämefponfudk acszsufvsif pdwfç ap

wodufç½kyf[lí <uif;usefygrnf/ pdwfçapwodufç½kyfwdkYudk acszsufvsifum; bmrQ tusefr½Sdyg/

acszsufr&-[lonf tufwrf0g'Drsm;uJYodkY ]tm;vHk;\ tajccHjzpfovdk? ,if;udk acszsufvsifvnf; rysufaomt&m jzpfonf}-[k qdkvdk&if; r[kwfay/

Page 147: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 147

]acszsufír&}-[lonf acszsufvsif ]ysuf}ygonf/ tb,ft&mrSvufusefrusef-[k qdkvdk&if; jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]y&rw¬}\ teuft"dyÜg,fonf ]tjzpfw&m;rsm;\ aemufqkH;ydwf tjzpfw&m;tjzpf wnf½Sdaeaom tajccHw&m;}[lí jzpfygonf/

þodkYvsif avmu\ tajccHydkif;onf ]y&rw¬ydkif;} jzpfygonf/xdkYjyif usefaom toGiftjyifydkif;onf ]ynwfydkif;} jzpfygonf/þodkYyif avmuudk ]y&rw¬ydkif;? ]ynwfydkif;}[lí ESpfydkif;cGJtyfyg

onf/xdkodkY ynwfydkif;? y&rwfydkif; ESpfykdif;cGJtyfaomfvnf; b,ftydkif;onf ]t½Sdykdif;}? b,ftydkif;onf ]r½Sdydkif;}[lírl rcGJtyfay/

tcsdKUaom tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:udk oabmraygufMuaomyk*¾dKvfwdkYonf ]ynwfykdif;udk r½Sdxif}í? ]y&rwfydkif;udk t½Sdxif}Muavonf/ xdkolwdkYonf ]y&rw¬t½Sd0g'D}rsm; jzpfMuayonf/

xdkolwdkYonf ]ynwfydkif;}rS t&mjzpfaom a,musfm;ç rdef;rç igçolwyg; ponfwdkYudk ]r½Sd}-[k ,lqMuonf/ ]igr½Sd? olwyg; r½Sd/ a,musfm;[lívnf; r½Sd? rdef;r[lívnf; r½Sd}-[lí ajymifajymifwif;wif; ajymqdkMuayonf/ xdkolwdkYonfyif ]½Sdonfum; ½kyfçemrfrsm;omwnf;}[lí qdkMujyefonf/ þodkYyif y&rwfydkif;rsm;udk ]t½Sd} ,lMujyefavonf/

pifppfü xdkolwdkY\pum;onf uav;qefvGef;vSayonf/ ]Armonf vljzpf\/ xdkYaMumifY vlonf Armjzpf&rnf}/ þodkY awG;ac:tyfaomuav;i,f\ tawG;tac:onf NyKH;csif&,fcsifpzG,f rjynfhpkH rESHYpyfaomtawG;tac:jzpfonfudk awGU&ouJYodkY jzpfonf/

]½kyfçemrf}onf ]t½Sd}jzpfonf/ xdk½kyfçemrfwdkjzifY twnfaqmufcHxm;&aom igçolwyg;ça,musfm;çrdef;rrsm;rl ]r½Sd}-[kqdkjyefonf/ tb,fodkYenf;/

Page 148: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

148 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

½kyfçemrfonf olwdkYqdkwdkif; tu,fyif t½SdjzpfcJYvsif xdkt½Sd ½kyfçemrfwdkYjzifY twnfaqmufcHxm;&aom igçolwyg;ça,musfm;çrdef;rrsm;onf rsm;pGmaom½kyfçemrfwdkY\ tpkta0;jzpfí ydkíyif ½SdzG,faumif;vSonf r[kwfygavm/ ]igçolwyg;ça,musfm;çrdef;rponf r½Sd? ½kyfçemrfom½Sdonf}-[laomtqdkonf opfom;ç0g;ponfom ½Sdonf? xdkopfom;ç0g;wdkYjzifY jyKvkyfxm;aom tdrf-[lírlum; r½Sd}-[kqdkaompum;ESifY vkH;0wxyfwnf;usatmif wlavonf/

]opfom;ç0g;om ½Sdonf? opfom;ç0g;jzifYjyKvkyfaom tdrfrlum;r½Sd}-[laom pum;udk uREkfyfwdkY b,fodkY oabmxm;Murnfenf;/

xdkodkY tqdkjyKaomoludk,fwdkifyif opfom;ç0g;wdkYjzifY aqmufxm;aomtdrfudk wxyfwnf;usatmif ½IjrifawG;ac:Edkifrnfavm/ tu,fíwxyfwnf;usatmif ½IjrifEdkifvsif xdkolonf tdrf-udk tdrf-[lívnf;okH;pGJ&aumif;rSef; rod jzpfav&m\/

vlwdkif;yif opfom;ç0g;ESifY xdkopfom;ç0g;wdkYjzifY wnfaqmufxm;aom tdrfudk vkH;0yif uGJjym;atmif cGJjcm;odMuolcsnf; jzpfavonf/txl;tm;jzifY xdkxdktdrfrsm;udk wnfaqmufaomtdrf½Sifrsm;ESifY vuform;rsm;onf xdktdrf\ opfom;ESifY0g;wdkYjzifY wnfaqmufxm;onfudk vkH;0odMuonf/ xdkolwdkYonf xdkodkY vkH;0odMuygvsuf tdrfudk opfom;ç0g;wdkYESifYxyfwlodNyD;? opfom;ç0g;wdkYonf vlaexkdifokH;aqmif&ef rjzpfí rokH;aqmifbJ aeMuouJYodkY rokH;aqmifbJaeMuoavm/

þodkY rokH;aqmifbJaeol[lívnf; vkH;0r½SdEdkif/ þodkYjzpfvsifþodkYaom opfom;ç0g;wdkYjzifY jyKvkyfxm;aomtdrfudk cGJjcm;íodaejcif;onf tb,ftusdK; jzpfaprnfenf;/ tu,fí rokH;aqmifbJaeol ½SdonfqdktHh/ xdkodkY rokH;aqmifbJaeol\ pdwfonf pdwfrSefavmç pdwfrSm;avm/

Page 149: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 149

]tdrfrsm;onf opfom;ç0g;wdkYjzifY wnfaqmufxm;aomt&m jzpfonf/ opfom;ç0g;wdkYonf vl aexdkifokH;aqmifp&m r[kwfouJYodkY tdrfonfvnf; vlrsm;aexdkifokH;aqmifp&m r[kwfMuukef/ xdkYaMumifY igwdkYonf v[mjyif odkYr[kwf opfyifatmufrsm;ü aeMu&rnf}/ þodkYqdkvsufv[mjyifç opfyifatmufwdkYü aeaomolonf tu,fí þodkYyif½SdonfqdktHh/ b,fodkY oabmxm;Murnfenf;/

avmuü ]igç olwyg;ç a,musfm;ç rdef;r r½Sd/ xdk ]igç olwyg;ça,musfm;ç rdef;r}jzpfatmif wnfaqmufxm;aom ½kyfçemrfrsm;om ½Sdonf}-qdkaom olwdkYonf txufyg ]tdrfr½Sd}-[kqdkaom vltwdkif; jzpfavonf/]igç olwyg;ça,musfm;çrdef;r r½Sd? ½kyfçemrfom ½Sdonf}-[k y&rwfavYvmolwdkif; tu,fyif odMuayonf/ odkYaomfvnf; ]igçolwyg;ç}wdkYudk aysmufatmif b,fol wpfOD;wpfa,mufonf azsmufEdkifcJYoenf;/

xdk ]ig ? olwyg;ESifY a,musfm;çrdef;r} ponfwdkYonf trSm;rsm;r[kwfMuukef/ ]trSefrsm;? opömrsm;om} jzpfMuukef\/ xdkYaMumifY opömudkaysmufatmif azsmufír&bJ ½Sd&mygonf/ xdkaMumifY aysmufatmifazsmufEdkifcJYaomolvnf; r½SdcJY jzpf&mygonf/

xkd ]igçolwyg;ESifY a,musfm;çrdef;r} ponfwdkYonf aysmufatmifazsmufaumif;aom oabmrsm;aum [kwfyg\avm/

þodkY qkdzG,fawmY ½Sd&mygonf/ ]igçolwyg;}ponfwdkYonf trSefrSm ]opöm}rsm;jzpfMuonfrSm rSefaomfvnf;? ,if;opömonf ]orkwdopöm}odkYr[kwf ]ynwådopöm}rsm; r[kwfavm- [lí jzpfygonf/

[kwf\/ ]igçolwyg;}onf ]ig}-r[kwfonfudk ]olwyg;}/ ]olwyg;}-r[kwfonfudk ]ig}/ þodkY opömrsm;rSefaomfvnf; xdkopömonf ]orkwdopöm}rsm; jzpfonfrSm rSefygonf/ ]orkwdopöm}rsm; jzpfaomaMumifY trSeftm;'D*&Dudk avsmYaygYwGufvdkygoavm/ þodkY jyefar;&ygrnf/

Page 150: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

150 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]avsmYaygYwGuf&rnf}-[k ajzavrnfvm;yif/ ]orkwdopöm}onf]ynwådopöm}jzpfí rSefonfqdkaomfvnf; tu,frSefonf r[kwf}-[k]qdkaomolwdkY\ EIwfcrf;ESpfvTmtMum;wGifom rSefonf}/ þodkYrsm;taMumif;jyavrnfavm/

tu,fí þodkYqdkvsif xdkoltm; jyefíowday;&ygrnf-]igçolwyg;}wdkY\ tjzpfonf tu,fyif EIwfcrf;ESpfvTm tMum;rSm

om jzpfaomt&mavm/ avmurSm vlESpfa,muf½Sdvsif yXrvlbufMunfhygu 'kwd,vlonf ]olwyg;tjzpf} tu,fr½SdNyDavm/ xdkYtwl olYudk,folvnf; 'kwd,vludkaxmufí ]igjzpfonf}[laomtjzpf tu,fr½SdNyDavm}/

þodkYar;í ½Sdaeonfhtjzpfudk odjrifapcsifonf/þodkYodjrifNyD;]orkwdopöm}onf EIwfcrf;ESpfvTmwdkY tMum;rSmomru urÇmavmutoGifoP²mefrsm;tjzpf tu,f½Sdaeonfudk odjrifapcsifygonf/

þodkY owd&ap&ygrnf/ þonfudk atmufarYrdvsif ]orkwdopöm}onf EIwfcrf;ESpfvTmwdkY\ tMum;rSmom½Sdonf}-[laomtqdkudk jyef½kyfodrf;rnfrSm aocsmygonf/

49/ orkwdopömESifYy&rw¬opöm orbm*jzpfxdkjyifvnf; wpfenf;tm;jzifY qdkaumif;qdkygOD;rnf/ ]orkwdopöm}

onf EIwfcrf;ESpfvTmwdkY\ tMum;rSmxuf ydkvGef½Sdaomfvnf;? y&rw¬opömESifY ,SOfvdkufaomtcg opömae&myif NrJatmif r,lEdkifawmYatmif tvdktavsmuf aysmufysufoGm;&avonf/ xdkYaMumifY a,musfm;çrdef;r[laomorkwdopömrsm; rSefMuaomfvnf; ½kyfçemrf[laom y&rw¬opömESifY wdkufcdkufvdkufaomtcg a,musfm;çrdef;r[laom orkwdjzpfaom xdkopömrsm;ausajrhysufjym;&rnfrSm r[kwfygavm}/ þodkY qdkaumif; qdkEdkifygonf/

þtqdktwGuf tenf;i,f ½Sif;Munfhygrnf/

Page 151: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 151

]orkwdopömESifY y&rw¬opöm? þodkY opömESpfck NydKifvdkufaomtcgorkwdopöm ausajrhysufjym;onf r[kwfygavm}-qdkvsif ]r[kwfyg}-[kyifqdk&ygrnf/

]orkwdopöm}onf ]y&rw¬opöm}ESifY NydKif&vsif rxifr½Sm; jzpfoGm;jcif;om jzpfygonf/ ausajrh ysufjym;oGm;jcif;rsm; rjzpfyg/ ]ysufjym;onf}-qdkonfrSm tvif;ESifY txdcH&aom tarSmifrsm; avsmYyg; usqkH;&ouJYodkYaomtjzpf jzpfygonf/

orkwdopömESifY y&rw¬opömonf tarSmifESifYtvif;uJYodkY vkH;0qefYusifbuf 0da&m"doabmrsm; r[kwfMuyg/ aea&miftvif;ESifYva&miftvif;uJYodkY odkYr[kwf ydk;pkef;MuL;\tvif;ESifY rD;cGuf\tvif;uJYodkY wom;wnf;jzpfaom ]orbm*}oabmrsm; jzpfygonf/

va&mif\tvif;onf aea&mifESifYawGUvsif ysufjym;oGm;oavm-[ltHh/ ]ysufroGm;}-[kyif ajz&ygrnf/ xdkodkYqdkvsif aea&mifatmufüva&mifonf xGef;vif;awmufyaeao;oavm-[lvsifvnf; ]rawmufy}[kyif ajz&ygrnf/ þodkYqdkvsif xdkpum;ESpf&yfqufpyfatmif b,fodkY,l&rnfenf;-[k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/

þodkY ,l&rnf-[k ajzygrnf -]va&mifESifYaea&mifonf ta&mifoabmtm;jzifY wpfrsdK;wnf;

yif jzpfygonf/ odkYaomf va&mifonf aea&mif\ a&mifjyefta&mifomjzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifYyif ,if;rlvta&mifjzpfaom aea&mifESifY odkYr[kwfva&mifxufus,f0ef;í tajccHusaomaea&mifESifY awGUaomtcg va&mifonf aea&mifESifYjyefvnfí aygif;pnf;oGm;ygonf/ þodkY ajz&ygrnf/

[kwfygonf/ va&mifonf aea&mifaMumifY ysufjym;oGm;onfr[kwfyg/ olY vif;NrJtwdkif; vif;vsufyif ½Sdygonf/ odkYaomfvnf;olYtvif;xuftm;aumif;aom odkYr[kwf tajccHusaom aea&mifESifY

Page 152: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

152 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

aygif;oGm;jcif;om jzpfygonf/ a&maESmoGm;jcif;-[k qdktyfaom ]orbm*}tjzpf a&mufoGm;jcif;omjzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

þtwlyif orkwdopömonf y&rw¬opömESifY awGUaomtcg orkwdopöm\ opömobm0jzpfaom rSefuefjcif;tjzpfrS aysmufysufoGm;&jcif;r½Sdyg/ y&rw¬opöm\ opömobm0jzpfaom rSefuefcsufESifY ta&mtaESmcH&NyD; rxifr½Sm;jzpfoGm;&jcif;om jzpfygonf/ xdkodkY rxifr½Sm; tjzpfcH&aomfvnf; va&mifuJYodkYyif orkwdopöm\ obm0jzpfaom rSefuefcsufonf jzpfxGef;vsufyif jzpfxGef;NrJyif jzpfygonf/

50/ txufopöma&mufaomfvnf; atmufopömrysufavmuü opömokH;rsdK; ½Sdygonf -(1) orkwdopöm?(2) y&rw¬opöm?(3) t&d,opöm-[lí jzpfygonf/þwGif aemufqkH;jzpfaom ]t&d,opöm}onf ]y&rw¬opöm}tay:

rSm wnfaqmuf&ygonf/ y&rw¬opömrrSefvsif t&d,opömwnfaqmufrI rjzpfxGef; ratmifjrifEdkifyg/

wzef y&rw¬opömonfvnf; ]orkwdopöm}ay:rSm wnfaqmufxm;ygonf/ ]orkwdopöm} rrSefvsif y&rw¬opömudk jzpfxGef;atmifjrifatmif wnfaqmufí r&Edkifyg/

þodkYqdkvsif ]orkwdopöm]onf tb,frQ tajccHusoenf;/xdkxdk txufxufopömrsm; opömobm0 qdkufçrqdkufudk atmufç

atmuf opömrsm;udk csdK;zsufypfí tvsOf;rjzpfyg/tu,fí txufuqdkcJYNyD;onfhtwdkif; txufxufopömrsm;odkY

a&mufaom tcg atmufçatmufopömrsm; ysufjym;ukefonf? opömobm0

Page 153: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 153

udk pGefYMuukefonfqdkvsif txufxufopömrsm; opömobm0 ½SdMuaMumif;bmESifYwdkif;wmrnfenf;/ odkYr[kwfvsifvnf; xdkxdk txufxufopömrsm;onf tb,ftay:ü &yfwnfaeMuao;oenf;/

txufxufopömonf atmufçatmufopömay:rSm&yfí wnfaqmuf&aomaMumifY atmufopömudk ]txufopöma&mufNyD}-[k azsmufzsufypfvdkufvsif txufxufopöm\ &yfwnf&monf r½Sd-jzpfcJYonf/xdkYaMumifY txufopömonfvnf; opömtjzpfrS avsmus azmufysufoGm;&avonf/

þodkYjzpfMuaomvlrsm;onf avmuü txift½Sm;yif ½SdaeMuonf/ xdkolwdkYrSm atmufygyk*¾dKvfwdkY jzpfMuygonf-

yXrü orkwdopömudk tav;xm;MuaomolwdkYonf oN*ØK[foifjcif;? w&m;aqG;aEG;jcif; ponfjzifY y&rw¬opömudk t&½SmMuonf/ awGUíodaomtodudk tcsdef,lí yGm;rsm;Muonf/ Mumvmaomtcg y&rw¬opömqdkonfudk olwdkYqdkufa&mufMuonf/

xdktcg olwdkYonf ]igçolwyg;ESifY a,musfm;çrdef;rrsm; ½Sdonf}-[laom orkwdopöme,fudk jzwfausmfMuavawmYonf/

]½kyfçemrfom½Sdonf? igçolwyg;ça,musfm;çrdef;rçigYom;çigYorD;tu,fr½SdNyD/ olYOpömçigYOpöm[lí tu,fr½SdNyD/ olYr,m;ESifYrSm;vsiftjypf½Sdonf qdkonfrSmvnf; ]olYr,m;}rSm tu,frS r½SdaomaMumifYrSm;onfqdkonfrSmvnf; wu,fr½SdEdkif/ atmufwef;pm;jzpfaom? y&rwfopömudk rodolwdkYtm; odyf½dkif;roGm;ap&ef ajcmufxm;cJYaom ajcmufvkH;çvSefYvkH;omjzpfonf/ tu,fí rSm;cGifYBuKHí rSm;vsifvnf; bmrQ tjypfr½Sd?tb,faMumifYqdkaomf rSm;onfqdkonfudkuyif trSefr½SdaomaMumifYjzpfonf/

Page 154: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

154 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[kwfonf/ "gwf½kyfBuD;wpfcku "gwf½kyfBuD;wpfckudk qGJjcif;çzufjcif;ponf vkyf&mrSm ]trSm;}[laom t&m0w¬K\ wnfae&monf r½SdNyD/tazmfwynfhç wlrçESrç udk,fYorD;qdkonfudk þodkYjyKaomfvnf; roifY[lír½SdNyD/ tm;vkH;onf "gwf½kyfBuD;rsm;csnfh jzpfonf/ olwdkYü vkyfrnf-[kvnf; tm;xkwfEdkifonfY ya,m* Asmyg' ½SdMuonfr[kwf/ taMumif;oifYí xaemif;yGifYjcif;rsdK; jzpfonf/ apmifYpnf;p&m[lívnf; r½Sd/vGefusL;p&m[lívnf; r½Sd/ aumif;onf[lí txl;vkyfp&mvnf; r½Sd/raumif;[lí txl;a½Smifp&mvnf; r½Sd/ xdkYaMumifY 'geçoDvonfvnf;jyKzG,ftxl; r½SdNyD/ taMumif;oifYvsif xaemif;yGifYjcif;rQom ½SdawmYonf/rvkyfrjzpfí vkyf&jcif;ü taumif;çtqdk;[lí r½SdNyD}/

þyk*¾dKvfrsm;onf ]tud&d,0g'? ta[wku0g'? ew¬du0g'}oabm½Sdoltjzpf usa&mufvsuf aeMuayownf;/ þolwdk Yonf,aeYacwfü rsm;jym;pGm xGef;um;vsuf ½SdNyD/ txl;tm;jzifY ]Ak'0g'y&rw¬t½Sd0g'D}rsm;xHü txl;tm;jzifY acwfpm;aeayonf/

þtjzpfrsm;onf olwdkYxifovdk tjypfr½SdMuonfrsm; r[kwfay/olYr,m;çom;udk tjypfr½Sdxifí taMumif;oifYaomtcg vGefusL;vsifvnf; aemufqkH;ü t½dkuftESuf txdk;tckwfESifY tcsKyfcef;/ þt&mrsm;ESifY xdkolwdkY &ifqdkif&&ef taMumif;onf olYvkyfief;rsm;\ ed*kH;ü taotcsm ½Sdaeayonf/

xdkYaMumifY þtjzpfrsm;onf rvdkvm;tyfaomtjzpfrsm; jzpfMuayonf/ tb,frS þrvdkvm;tyfaom tjzpfqdk;rsm; arG;zGm;vmygoenf;/

]ynwf odkYr[kwf orkwdopömudk t½Sdrxm;&mrS} arG;zGm;vmjcif;jzpfygonf/

tb,faMumifY orkwdopömudk t½Sd-rxm;avoenf;/y&rw¬opömudk t½Sdtjzpfxm;vdktm; rsm;vGef;oGm;&mrS jzpfonf/

Page 155: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 155

xdkYaMumifY ]y&rw¬t½Sd0g'D}wdkYonf qifqifjcifjcif jyKusifY awG;ac:oifYonf/ y&rwfonfvnf; ]ypö,or0g,}w&m;? ynwfonfvnf;]ypö,or0g,}w&m;yif/

þodkY rjynfhpkHaom taMumif;uav;rsm;\ pka0;aeMuonfcsnf;jzpfygvsuf ]tajccHESifY toGifoP²mef} þrQjcm;em;umrQjzifY y&rw¬udk-t½Sd? ynwfudk-r½Sd/ þodkY cGJjcm;íodjrifjcif;onf oifYavsmfonf r[kwfay/

wu,fpifppfü y&rw¬t½Sd0g'DwdkY odjrifMuonfhtwdkif; ynwfw&m;rsm; t½Sdr[kwfovdk? y&rwfw&m;rsm;vnf; t½Sdr[kwfMuay/þodkY trSeftwdkif; odjrifoifYayonf/ þtodonf tu,fyif rSefuefaomtodtjrif jzpfayonf/

ynwfESifY y&rwfonf tajccHESifY toGifoP²mef[laom jcm;em;csufrSwyg; tjcm;aom ]t½Sd-r½Sd}cGJ&ef jcm;em;jcif; tvsOf;r½Sday/ ESpfckpvkH;onf rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;\ pka0;aeaom ae&monfum;? rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm;\ pka0;aeaom t&mom jzpfrnf- r[kwfygavm/

þodp&monf tenf;i,f ½IyfaxG;ygonf/ pka0;aeaomt&monf ]pka0;aeaomt&mom jzpfonf}-[k qdkvdkygonf/

[kwfygonf/ r½Sdao;aomt&mudk tjcm;t&m0w¬KESpfckudk pka0;apvdkufojzifY t½Sdtjzpf-tu,f a&mufvmEdkifygoavm/

tu,fí a&mufvmapEdkifvsif pka0;aomt&myif jzpfygap?]½Sdonf}-[k qdk&ygrnf/ ra&mufvmvsifum; xdkpka0;aomt&mudk ]t½Sd}-[k rqdkEdkifyg/ pka0;aeaomt&m-[líom qdk&ygrnf/

Ak'¨toQifonfvnf; ]y&rw¬w&m;rsm; pka0;aeaomt&mrQ}-[líom a[mcJYonf? em;vnfygonf/

tb,fodkYenf;-

Page 156: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

156 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]pu©KHp y#dpö ½layp OyÜZÆwd pu©K0dnmPH}-ponfjzifY jzpfygonf/½kyftwGufvnf;-]{uH r[mblwH y#dpöwa,m r[mblwmwa,m y#dpöblawy#dpö{uH r[mblwH a'Gr[mblaw y#dpöa'G r[mblwm}-[lí

jzpfygonf/ ,if;wdkY t"dyÜg,frSmè]jrifpdwfonf rsufapYESifYtqif;wdkY ESpfckaygif;jzpfygonf/Mum;pdwfonfvnf; em;ESifYtoHwdkY\ ESpfckaygif; t&m0w¬K jzpf

onf}-[lí jzpfygonf/xdkYjyif ]rmjcif;-[laom wpfckaombkwfonf ]zGJYjcif;ç yljcif;ç

vIyfjcif;}[laombkwfokH;ckwdkY\ taygif;oP²mefjzpfonf}-ponfjzifY jzpfygonf/

þt"dyÜg,fudkqdkufatmif BudK;pm;í BudKufMunfhMuygukef/]rsufapYESifYtqif;udkpGJí jrifpdwfjzpfonf}-[lonfESifY ]jrifpdwf-

[lonf rsufapYESifYtqif;wdkY\ ESpfckaygif;jzpfonf} qdkjcif;onfum;txl;jcm;em;csuf r½Sd[k xifygonf/ [kwfygonf/ jrifpdwfjzpf&ef þESpfyg;jynfhpkHrSjzpfonf r[kwfygavm/ wpfyg;yg;avsmYvsuf jrifpdwf\ wpfpufuav;rQyif rjzpfEdkifonf r[kwfygavm/ xdkYaMumifY jrifpdwfonf þESpfckwdkY\taygif;jzpfonfrSm vufrcHEdkifp&m½Sdrnf rxifyg/ þESpfckwdkY\ taygif;jzpfí jrifpdwfudk rsufapYjzpfonf odkYr[kwf tqif;jzpfonf-[k rqdkvdkaMumif;vnf; oabmusxm;apvdkonf/

wzef þodkYqdkvsif tvif;wdkY? reodum&wdkYvnf; ygojzifY jrifpdwfonf rsufapYçtqif;çtvif;ESifY reodum&-av;rsdK;wdkYtaygif; jzpfonf-[k qdkygawmYtHhavm-[ltHY/ þodkY rqdkcsifyg/ tvif;ESifY reodum&wdkYonf jrifpdwftwGuf t"duZmwfaqmifrsm; r[kwfbJ? Zmwf&efrsm;omjzpfaomaMumifYyif/

Page 157: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 157

txufygpum;rQ qdkvsifyif jrifpdwfonf rsufapYçtqif;wdkY\ESpfckaygif;jzpfaomfvnf; jrifpdwfudk rsufapYESifYtqif;rsm;r[kwf-[kvufcHvsif jrifpdwf½Sdí r[kwfygavm/ þodkY ar;zG,f½Sdjyefygonf/

þar;cGef;udk ]r[kwf}-[k ajz&ygrnf/jrifpdwfonf rsufapYESifYtqif; ESpfckaygif;vdkufonfhtwGuf

rsufapYvnf;-r[kwf? tqif;vnf;-r[kwfaom tjzpfwpfcka&mufoGm;jcif;om jzpfygonf/ ]jrifpdwftjzpf a&mufoGm;jcif;}om jzpfygonf/ ]t½Sdjzpfvmjcif;r[kwf}-[lí qdkvdkjcif; jzpfygonf/

51/ tjzpfESifY t½Sdonf twlr[kwf]tjzpf}udk ]t½Sd}[k r,loifY xifygonf/]tjzpf}ESifY ]t½Sd}onf jcm;em;csuf tBuD;tus,f ½SdEdkifygonf/pu©K0dnmPf[laom jrifpdwfudkvnf; ]t½Sd}[k r,lqEdkifyg/ ]tjzpf

a&mufvmaomt&m}-[líom ,lqEdkifygonf/ ]tjzpfESifYt½Sd}uGJjym;&eftenf;i,fzGifYqdkygrnf/ oabmus&ef tav;teuf avYvmapcsifygonf/

avmuü ]aq;vdyf}-[laomt&m ½Sdygonf/ þ-]aq;vdyf}-[laomt&monf tb,fodkYaomt&menf;? t½Sdavmç tjzpfavm/ avmuü ]aq;vdyf}[laomt&monf ]tjzpf}-jzpfygonf/ ]t½Sd}-r[kwfyg/

]aq;vdyf}-[lonf þodkYjzpfygonf/ aq;çaq;½dk;ESifY zufçziftpDcH?þav;rsdK; pka0;aeaomt&m jzpfygonf/ xdkodkYqdkvsif aq;vdyf[laomt&monf avmuü xif½Sm;onf r[kwfavm/ xdk-]aq;çaq;½dk;ESifY zufçtpDcH} av;rsdK;wdkY\ taygif;onf ]aq;vdyftjzpf} xif½Sm;aeonf r[kwfygavm/

Page 158: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

158 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]aq;vdyf}onf ]zufçtpDcHESifY aq;çaq;½dk;} av;rsdK;taygif;tjzpfxif½Sm;ygonf/ xdkodkYxif½Sm;aomfvnf; ]t½SdawmY r[kwf}yg/ xdkav;rsdK;wdkY\ pka0;aeaom ]tjzpf}om jzpfygonf/ xdkav;rsdK;wdkY\ tpkta0;omjzpfonf-[kqdkvsif xdkaq;vdyfonf xdkav;rsdK;teufrS wpfrsdK;rsdK;avmodkYr[kwf ESpfrsdK;avm odkYr[kwf okH;rsdK;avm/ xdkuJYodkYr[kwfvsif av;rsdK;vkH;avm/

þodkY wpfckrQ r[kwfyg/ þav;rsdK;rS tvGwfjzpfygonf/ aq;vdyf-[lonf zufudkac:jcif; r[kwfyg/ zifpDcHçaq;çaq;½dk;-wpfrsdK;rsdK;udkac:jcif;vnf; r[kwfyg/ zufESifYzifpDcHESpfrsdK;udk ac:jcif;vnf;r[kwfyg/zufçzifpDcHçaq;çaq;½dk; av;rsdK;vkH;udk aq;vdyf-[k ac:jcif;vnf; r[kwfyg/ ]aq;vdyf}udk zuffçzifpDcHçaq;çaq;½dk;-av;rsdK;udk aq;vdyf[kac:vsifþav;rsdK;udkxyfí cGufwpfckwnf;ü xnfhxm;vdkufvsifyif aq;vdyfjzpf&rnf r[kwfygavm/ xdkYaMumifY xdkav;rsdK;udkac:jcif; r[kwfyg/

]aq;vdyf}onf ]aq;çaq;½dk;çzufçtpDcH}-þav;rsdK;wdkYr[kwfaomt&mwpfrsdK; jzpfygonf/ zufonf yXrypönf;? zifpDcHonf 'kwd,ypönf;?aq;onf wwd,ypönf;? aq;½dk;onf pwkw¬ypönf;rsm; jzpfMuonfqdktHh/aq;vdyfonf yOörypönf;jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

þodkYqdkvsif aq;vdyf[laomt&monf ]t½Sdjzpfaom t&m0w¬K}[k qdkoifYonf r[kwfygavm-[ltHh/

]r[kwf}-[líyif ajz&ygrnf/tb,faMumifYqdkaomf ]tjzpf}om jzpfaomaMumifY jzpfygonf/]jzpfvsif}-]½Sdrnf}r[kwfygavm-[ltYHH/ ]r[kwf}-[k ajz&ygrnf/

tb,faMumifYqdkaomf tu,f]t½Sd}jzpftHh/ xdkpka0;aeaom av;rsdK;udkcGJzsufvdkufaomtcg jzpfay:vmonfqdkaom yOört&m0w¬Konf vufusef usefcJYav&m\/ þodkY rusefcJYaomaMumifY [k ajz&ygrnf/

Page 159: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 159

[kwfygonf/ t&m0w¬K ESpfrsdK;jzpfap? xdkxufrsm;pGmudk jzpfap?pka0;aygif;pyfvdkufvsif xdk-aygif;pyfaomt&mrsm; r[kwfaom ]oD;jcm;t&m0w¬Kwpfck} jzpfay:vm(OyÜg') a&mufvmygonf/ odkYaomfvnf;xdkpka0;xm; aygif;pyfxm;aom t&m0w¬KoD;jcm;onf taysmufqkH; cH&ygonf/ xdkodkYqdkvsif xdkjzpfay:vmonfh t&m0w¬Kudk ]t½Sd}[k qdkEdkifygawmYrnfavm/

]jrifpdwf}tp½Sdaom y&rw¬w&m;rsm;onf þodkYaomt&mrsm;jzpfMuygonf/taMumif;ESpfrsdK; jzpfap? okH;rsdK; jzpfap? aygif;MuaomaMumifYjrifpdwfponfjzifY OyÜg'tjzpf qdkufa&mufvmMujcif;onf xdkaygif;qkHcJYaom taMumif;rsm; aygif;qkHrItjzpfrS uif;uGmoGm;Muaomtcg xdkjzpfay:vmaom jrifpdwfponfh t&mrsm;onf taysmufqkH; cHMu&ayonf/

xdkYaMumifY jrifpdwfpaom xdkt&mrsm;udk ]t½Sdw&m;-r[kwf}?]tjzpfw&m;}-[k qdkcJYjcif; jzpfygonf/

þodkYqdkvsif avmuü jyKjyifrIESifY ruif;orQ ynwfç y&rwfruseftm;vkH;aom t&m0w¬Krsm;onf ]t½Sdw&m;rsm; r[kwf}bJ? ]tjzpfw&m;}csnf; jzpfaeav&m\-[k qdktHh/ [kwfygonf-[k ajz&ygrnf/

avmuü pdwfçapwodufç½kyfESifY ynwfrsm;ygrusef taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm; pka0;aeaomt&m rSeforQonf t½Sdw&m;rsm;r[kwfMuyg/ tjzpfw&m;rsm;csnf; jzpfMuygonf/

52/ t½Sdw&m;tppfonf Nidrf;at;jcif;oabmþodkYqdkvsif t½Sdw&m;um; tb,fenf;/xdk-pdwfpaom tjzpfw&m;udk jzpfay:atmif pka0;ay;vdkufaom

rsufapYçtqif;paomt&mrsm;avm-[ltHh/r[kwf-[k ajz&ygrnf/

Page 160: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

160 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

rsufapYpaom jrifpdwfjzpfatmif pka0;Mu&aom jrifpdwf\ rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;uav;rsm;onfvnf; jrifpdwfuJYodkYyif tjcm;aomrsufapY-ponfjzpf&ef rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;tpdwftydkif; uav;rsm;\ pka0;aeaomt&myif jzpfygonf/ rsufapY-ponfwdkYonfvnf;t½Sdw&m;rsm; r[kwf? tjzpfw&m;rsm;yif jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

]t½Sdw&m;}rSm taMumif;tpdwftydkif;wdkYjzifY pka0;í jzpfay:&aomt&m r[kwfyg/ xdk taMumif;tpdwftydkif;wdkYjzifY rpka0;bJ wnf½Sdaeaomt&mum; ]&m*ça'goçarm[}-[kqdktyfaom ]vl\ tBudKufçtrkef;çtrdkuf}-wdkY\ rjzpfay:bJ wnf½Sdaeaom tjcif;t&m} jzpfygonf/

þü rjzpfay:bJ wnf½Sdonf-qdkaomfvnf; cPwjzKwfrQ csKyfqkH;í rjzpfay:onfudk ]rjzpfay:}-[k qdkvdkonfr[kwfbJ ]t<uif;rJY rjzpfay:awmYonfudk odkYr[kwf ]aemiftcg b,fawmYrS rjzpfay:awmY}onfudk]rjzpfay:}[k-qdkvdkygonf/

þodkY tBudKufçtrkef;çtrkdufpaom udk,fyifyef; pdwfyifyef;rIudkjzpfapwwfaom oabmwdkY vkH;0rjzpfay:bJ wnf½Sdaeaom? at;jraomoabmonf ]t½Sdw&m;} jzpfygonf/

þ]t½Sdw&m;}onf tb,ft&mrsm;pka0;NyD;rS wnfaqmufxm;aomt&m r[kwfaomaMumifY b,ft&mrsm;udkzJY,lvsif ysufpD;edkifonf[kvnf; qdkp&m r½Sd/ qdkvdkonfrSm þ]Nidrf;{;aomoabm}onf b,ft&mESifYrQ pka0;wnfaqmufxm;jcif; r[kwfygí b,ft&mrsm;udkcGJjcm;zsufqD;aomfvnf; þNidrf;{;jcif;rSmrl rysufpD;-[k qdkvdkygonf/

xdkYjyif þNidrf;at;jcif;onf b,ft&mESifYrQ wnfaqmufxm;aomt&m r[kwfvsif r½SdEdkif-[kvnf; qdkírjzpf? tb,faMumifYqdkaomf vlütBudKufçtrkef;çtrdkufponfr½Sdjcif;aMumifY Nidrf;at;jcif;oabmonftrSefyif½SdaomaMumifY jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifYÞ

Page 161: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 161

vlü ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}[k qdktyfaom þwpfckwnf;aom oabmw&m;onfomvsif ]t½Sdw&m;} jzpfygonf/

<uif;usefaom vlü½SdorQaom oabmw&m;rSeforQç t&m0w¬KrSeforQonf t½Sdw&m;rsm; r[kwfMu? ]tjzpfw&m;}rsm;csnf; jzpfMuayonf/

þt&mrsm;onf vufzspfwpfwGwf\ uka#wpfodef;ausmfykH wpfykHrQyJ toufwrf;umv wnfcsdef½Sdonf jzpfcsifjzpfygap? uka#ig;axmifausmfydkif; wpfydkif;rQyJwnfcsdef ½Sdcsif½Sdygap/ xdkYxufMumí vufzspfwpfwGwf tcsdefvkH;yif olwdkYoufwrf; ½Snfcsifvsifvnf; ½Snfvsm;ygap/xdkYxuf wpfpuúefYç wpfrdepfç wpfem&Dç wpf&ufç wpfvç wpfESpfç ESpfaygif;rsm;pGm urÇmcsDívnf; wnf½Sdcsif wnf½SdMuygap/

b,favmufyif olwdkY\ oufwrf;umv wdkjcif;ç½Snfjcif;wdkYonfolwdkY t½Sdw&m;jzpfrIudk taxmuftuljyKEdkifjcif; vkH;vkH;yif r½Sday/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf olwdkYonf rjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;tpdwftydkif;wdkY\pka0;aeaom taygif;om jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

xdkYaMumifY oufwrf; wdkwdkç½Snf½Snf? tvDvDaom ypö,or0g,w&m; rSeforQwdkYonf ]tjzpfw&m;rsm;}om vkH;vkH;{uef trSefjzpfMuownf;/

53/ ,aeY bk&mYomoemonf vd*Fomoemtjzpf a&muf½Sdþü y&rw¬t½Sd0g'DwdkYonf þwifjycJYonfESifY rwluGJjym; oD;jcm;

wdkY jzpfMuukef\/ ]olwdkYonf pdwfudkvnf; ]t½Sd}xm;Muukef\/ apwodufç½kyfwdkYudkvnf; ]t½Sd}[k rSwfxm;Muukef\/ ynwfrsm;udkvnf; ]t½Sd}[krSwfxm;Muukef\/

xdkolwdkYonf tb,fol\ wynfhom0ursm; jzpfMuoenf;}/tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:udk azmfxkwfwifjycJYaom Ak'toQif\ wynfhom0ursm;yif jzpfMuayonf/

Page 162: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

162 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkodkYqdkvsif Ak'toQifonf xdkolwdkYjrifouJYodkY ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}-[laom y&rw¬"r®rsm;udk ]t½Sdw&m;}tjzpf a&mufatmif ]oypö,"r®}rsm; r[kwfMu/ ]pdwfçapwwodufç½kyf}w&m;wdkYonf ]typö,"r®}rsm; jzpfonf-[k a[mMum;cJYygoavm/ þodkYvnf; a[mMum;cJYonf r[kwfay/

tu,fí ]pdwfçapwwodufç½kyf}rsm;onf ]oypö,"r®} odkYr[kwf]ypö,or0g,r"r®}tjzpf Ak'toQifa[mcJYvsif ]oypö,"r®}onf ]tjzpfw&m;(OyÜg')}odkY a&mufaomw&m;om jzpfygonf/ ]t½Sdw&m;}-[k Ak'toQifra[mcJYay/

xdkYaMumifY ]y&rw¬t½Sd0g'D}wdkYonf Ak'toQif\ wynfhom0utjzpf olwdkYudk,fwdkif olwdkY &yfwnfaeMuaomfvnf;? olwdkY&yfwnfcsufonf ]Ak'toQif\ oabmw&m;tay:ü &yfwnfaeMuonf r[kwf/Ak'toQif\ oabmw&m;ESifY oD;jcm;cGJvsuf &yfwnfNyD; aeMuayonf}/

odkYaomfvnf; xdkolwdkYonf Ak'toQif\ tqdktqkH;ratmufrSuif;vGwfaomolwdkY jzpfonf-[lí qdkívnf; rjzpfao;ay/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf xdkolwdkYonf Ak'toQifnTefMum;cJYaom aqmif&efESifY a½Smif&eftusifUrsm;udk xufoefaom apwempdwf"gwftjynfhjzifY Ak'toQif\tqkH;tratmufwGif &yfwnfaeMuaomaMumifY jzpfonf/

odkYaomfvnf; olwdkYxHü½Sdaom Ak'¨toQif\ tqkH;tr[laomomoemonf aqmif&efça½Smif&ef[laom rSwfom;xm;aom ]toGiftjyifw&m;rQ}om jzpfawmYaomaMumifY ]toGiftjyifomoem} odkYr[kwf ]vd*Fomoem}? þomoemom jzpfawmYonf/

]b0Nidrf;csrf;a&;} xlaxmif&mü ]vd*Fomoem}jzifY tb,f rl&tHYenf;/

xdkYaMumifY todtjrif½SdolwdkYonf udk,fYb0\ tu,fpifppf&aeaom b0ü epfepf0if0if ,pf,pfrl;rl;jzifY ]xdk&aeaomb0onf igYtwGuf

Page 163: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 163

trSefqkH;qdkonfudk&atmif igYb0udk vSnfhajymif;rnf}-[k owd& apcsifygonf/ (0g) owd&&ef oifYavsmfayonf/

xdkYaMumifY þtxd pum;uRHí oifYavsmfayonf/ xdkYaMumifYþtxd pum;uRHí a0zefvmcJYygonf/ trSefpifppf vdktyfaompum;onfum; ]pdwfapwodufç½kyf} y&rw¬w&m;onf ]t½Sdw&m; r[kwfMu}-[laom pum;om jzpfygonf/ [kwfygonf/ þy&rwfrsm; ]t½Sd}r[kwfaMumif; Ak'tbd"r®rsm;ü txift½Sm; tjywftom;jzifY tus,fw0HY>rufMum;cJYonf/

54/ r½SdESifYt½Sdonf twljzpfí tcsdefjzifYwdkif;ír&þy&rwfrsm;onf þqdkcJYonfhtwdkif; t½Sd-r[kwfvsif t½Sdr[kwf

aomt&monf wdkif;wmp&m tcsdefaum ½Sdygrnfavm/ r½Sdaomt&monf]twdwf}[lívnf;aumif;? ]ypöKyÜef}[lí vnf;aumif;? ]tem*wf}[lívnf;aumif; ½Sdygrnfavm/ odkYr[kwf r½Sdaomt&mudk raeYuç ,aeYçreufjzef-[k wdkif;wmp&m ½Sdygrnfavm/

]r½Sdaomt&m}onf tcsdeftm;jzifY ]wdkif;wmp&m r½Sd}yg/ r½Sdaomt&mudk twdwf[lívnf;aumif;? ypöKyÜef[lívnf;aumif;? tem*wf[lívnf;aumif; qdkp&m vkH;0r½Sdyg/

þodkYqdkvsif ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}[laom ]t½Sdw&m;}onf tcsdeftm;jzifYwkdif;wmí&ygoavm[k ar;zG,f½Sdygonf/

þ-]t½SdESifYr½Sd}onf tu,fpifppfü ESpfaxGuGJaomt&m r[kwfyg/ þpum;twGuf Mum;&olrsm; rsufarSmifukyfoGm;rvm; atmufarY&ygonf/ odkYaomfvnf; þpum;udk trSeftwdkif; qdk0HYonfqdkvsif þtwdkif;yif xyfíqdk&ygrnf/

Page 164: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

164 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[kwfygonf/ þ-]t½SdESifY r½Sd}w&m;onf twlwlyif jzpfygonf/þodkYqdkvsif tb,faMumifY ]r½Sd}[lívnf;aumif;? ]t½Sd}[lí

vnf;aumif; ESpfckuGJjym;aeoenf;/ þtar;udk ½Sif;ygrnf/þtar;\ twdkqkH;tajzrSm ]vlaMumifY}-[lí4if;? uGJaeonfrSm

wpfckwnf;aom oabmü owfrSwfvdkolu Mum;jzwfí &yfvdkufaomaMumifY jzpfygonf/

þtajzudkvnf; em;½Sif;atmif tawmfBuD; BudK;pm;&zdkY½Sdygonf/þodkY tb,faMumifY em;r½Sif;&oenf;-[ltHh/]vludk em;vnfNyD; r½SdaomaMumifY}-[k ajz&ygrnf/½Sdygap/ txufrS ]t½SdESifY r½Sd} wpfckwnf;jzpfvsuf ESpfckuGJykHudk

em;vnf&ef OyrmjzifY quf½Sif;MunhfygOD;rnf/ avmuwGif vlwdkif;üta½SUt&yf? taemuft&yf½Sdonf-[k owfrSwfNyD; ½SdMu\/ xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; ol\ta½SUt&yfonf tjcm;olwpfOD;\ ta½SUt&yfESifY rwlnDay/omrefvlawG\ pum;ukdvnf; trSef-[k xifaumif; xifayrnf/ vlESpfa,mufruyJ wpf&ma,mufjzpfygap? vlwddkif;\ ta½SUt&yfESifY taemuft&yfwdkYonf xyfwlrsm;om jzpfMuonf-[k ajymvdkMuayonf/

xdktxifrsm; r[kwfaMumif;udk qufí½Sif;ygrnf/vltrsm;r[kwfbJ vlESpfa,mufyif jzpfygapOD;/ xdkvlESpfa,muf

udk ta½SUçtaemuf wef;í &yfaeygap/ NyD;vsif taemufbufvludk ]ta½SUt&yf b,frSmvJ}-[k ar;yg/ xdktar;udk taemufvlonf atmufygtwdkif; xyfar;yg/ ]oifajymaom ta½SUt&yfonf b,fae&mrSpí ta½SUt&yf jzpfoenf;}-[k ar;yg/ xdkolu þodkY ajzayrnf-

]uREfkyf pkH&yfaeaomae&mrS tpjyKí ta½SUt&yf pjzpfonf}-[lajzayrnf/ [kwfvnf; [kwfayonf/ olYudk,f\ta½SUbufonf olYtwGuf]ta½SUbuf}yif jzpfonf/

Page 165: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 165

wzef ta½SUbufrSvltm; atmufygar;cGef;rsm; ar;MunfhoifYayonf/ taemufbuft&yf[lonf tb,ft&yfenf;/ xdk taemufbuft&yfonf tb,frS poenf;-[lí jzpfygonf/

xdkolonfvnf; ajzayrnfè ]taemuft&yf[lonf taemufvl½Sd&mt&yf jzpfonf/ xdktaemuft&yfonf rdrdajctpkHrS tpjyKonf}-[lí jzpfayonf/

þodkYqdkvsif þolESpfa,mufwdkY\ ]tMum;t&yf}udk taemufvl\tqdkü ]ta½SU}-[k qdkonf/ ta½SUvl\tqdkü ]taemuf}-[k qdkonf/xdkolESpfOD;wdkY\ ae&mwpfckwnf;twGuf uGJjym;aeaom tqdkESpfckonfb,ftqdk trSefjzpfoenf;/

b,ftqdkrSm;onf-[lí b,folrQ rqkH;jzwfEdkif&m/ xdkjyif tqdkESpfckvkH;rSefonf-[lívnf; rjzpfEdkif&m/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf tqdkjyKolESpfOD;\ tMum;uGufvyf jzpfaom ae&monf wpfckwnf;jzpfvsuf wpfOD;onf]ta½SU}? wpfOD;onf ]taemuf}? ESpfrsdK;qdkxm;aomaMumifY jzpfonf/

þodkYqdkvsif þjyóem\opömum; tb,fenf;/]ae&m}[laom wpfckwnf;aomt&mudk ta½SUç taemuf-[k

ESpfckjzpfatmif vlucGJaejcif;/ þodkY wpfckwnf;aomae&monf ESpfck[kvlucGJaomfvnf; tppftrSefü wpfckwnf;aomoabmrSmyif wif;vsufcHaejcif;/ þt&monf þjyóem\opöm jzpfygonf/

þqdkcJYaompum;jzifyif ]t½SdESifYr½Sd}wdkY wpfckwnf;jzpfykHudk BudK;pm;í oabmaygufMunfhMuygukef/

xdkYaMumifY ]r½Sdw&m;}ü ]tcsdefr½Sd}ovdk?]t½Sdw&m;}üvnf; ]tcsdefr½Sd}ukef/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf ]t½SdESifYr½Sd}wdkYonf qdkcJYNyD;onfhtwdkif;vlucGJí ESpfckuGJaeaomfvnf; olYyuwdoabmtm;jzifY ESpfckrjym;?wom;wnf; jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

Page 166: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

166 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

tb,fokdY wom;wnf;jzpfoenf;/tajzonf atmufygtwdkif;jzpfonf-]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}-[laom y&rw¬rsm;\ twåowådESifY twå

ed,owåd r½Sdjcif;onf odkYr[kwf xdkw&m;wdkY jzpfay:aepOfü udk,fudk,fwdkdif&yfEdkifaomtm;ESifY olrsm;udkjzpfay:atmif jyKvkyfEdkifaomtm;rsm; r½Sdjcif;onf twåowådae&mü ]r½Sdw&m;} jzpfonf/

wzef ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}[laom ]t½Sdw&m;}[lonfrSmvnf; vlwdkYü½Sdí ]t½Sdw&m;}-[lí ajym&aomfvnf; xdkt½Sdw&m;onf wpkHwpfckaomrjynfhpkHao;aom taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm; aygif;pkHpka0;aomaMumifY jzpfay:vmaomw&m; r[kwfay/ jzpfay:vmaom ]OyÜg'tjzpf}a&mufaom w&m;yif tvsOf;r[kwfaomw&m; jzpfygonf/

þü jzpfay:vmjcif;r½Sdaom w&m;ESifY jzpfay:vm&aomfvnf;twåowådESifY twåed,owådrsm;r½Sd-[laom w&m;ESpfyg;wdkYonf jcm;em;oavm? twlwlavm/ wu,ftjzpfü ]twåowådw&m;}ESpfyg;onf twlwlyif jzpfayonf/ ]r½SdrkefYudkay;jcif;ESifY rkefYray;jcif;}-[laom pum;uJYodkYjcm;em;csufr½Sdaompum;rsm; jzpfMuayonf/ þodkY wom;wnf;jzpfygonf/

þodkYjzpfvsif ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf} y&rwfrsm;udk vufzspfwpfwGwfumvü uka#wpfodef;ausmfydkif; wpfykdif; oufwrf;½Sdonf? ig;axmifausmfydkif; wpfydkif;rQ½Sdonf/ þodkY tb,faMumifY tcsdef½Sdava,mif qdkaeMuoenf;/

þtar;\tajzrSm atmufygtwdkif; jzpfygonf/txufyg ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}y&rwfwdkU\ tcsdeftwdkif;twm

rsm;onf xdk y&rwfw&m;wdkY\ taMumif;tpdwftydkif;wdkY pka0;aeaomtoGifoP²mef\ oufwrf;jypum;rsm;rQom jzpfygonf/ xdkodkY pka0;ae

Page 167: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 167

aom toGifoP²mef\ oufwrf;jyrQjzpfaom pum;rsm;t& xdk pdwfpaom y&rwfw&m;wdkY\ twåowådESifY twåed,owådrsm;½Sdaom t½Sdw&m;-[k ,kHrSm;rnfudk y,fazsmufvdkí odkYr[kwf ,kHrSm;rnfudk pdk;&drfaomaMumifY,if;-pdwfpaom y&rwfrsm;onf ]tedpö}jzpfonf/ odkYr[kwf ]tcsdefrJY}jzpfonf[lí owfowfrSwfrSwf rdefYMum;cJYjcif; jzpfayonf/

,if;-]tedpöteuf}udk twdtus&,lvsif ]tNrJr½Sdjcif;} teufomru ]tcsdefjiif;qdkjcif;}txd ,lrS jzpfrnfhtaMumif;? pdwf-paom y&rwfwdkY\ oabmobm0onf jzpfay:vmaom tjzpfw&m; jzpfaomfvnf;]r½Sd}onfhtaMumif;udk tus,fw0efY em;vnfcJYNyD;NyD-[k pm½IoltwGuf,kHMunfvdkygonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]tedpö}[laom pum;vkH;onf ]pdwf}paom y&rwfwdkY\]tcsdef½Sdonfudk jiif;qdkaompum;vkH;} jzpfygonf/ þodkY tcsdeftm;jzifYtjiif;cH&aom y&rwfrsm;onf ]t½Sdw&m; r[kwfaMumif;} xif½Sm;apygonf/

55/ 'ku©onf y&rwft½Sdjy toGiftjyifudk jiif;qdkonfhpum;xdkYjyif ]'ku©}[laom ]pdwf}paom y&rwfrsm;\ vu©Pmjy pum;

vkH;onfvnf; xdky&rwfwdkY\ ]t½SdtjzpfudknTefEdkifaom axmifYwpfckudkjiif;qdkaompum;vkH;}-yif jzpfayonf/

[kwfygonf/]'ku©}[laom pum;vkH;onf ]'k}[laom pum;vkH;ESifY]u&}-[laompum;vkH;wdkY aygif;pyfxm;aompum; jzpfygonf/ ]cr}-[laom pum;vkH;ESifY aygif;pyfxm;aom pum;vkH;[kvnf; qdkMuygonf/

þodkY ]'ku©}\ teuft"dyÜg,fonf ]qif;&Jjcif;}-[lí jyefqdkMuygonf/ ]yDVew¬}-ponfjzifYvnf; av;eufvmygonf/ ]qif;&J}-[líyifem;vnfMuygpdkY/

Page 168: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

168 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þü ]qif;&J}-[lonf tb,fenf;/þpum;onf ]cHpm;rIjypum;} jzpfygonf/ ]cHpm;rI}onf tawmf

aocsmrI? a&&mrIenf;aomt&m jzpfygonf/ þolYtaeESifY ]aumif;}-[laomcHpm;rIonf xdkolYtaeESifY ]qdk;}-[laomcHpm;rI jzpfonfvnf;rsm;pGm½Sdayonf/ xdkYjyifvnf; xdkt&mrsm;udkyif tjcm;olwpfOD;taeESifYaumif;çqdk;ESpfwef rxifjyef-[lívnf; ½Sdwwfayonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]'ku©}\ teufudk ]qif;&J}-[k qdk&aomfvnf; þae&mü]'ku©}-[laompum;vkH;onf ]cHpm;rIjypum;-r[kwf}-[k rSwf,loifYavonf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf aumif;çqdk; ESpfwef? xdkaumif;çqdk;ESpfwefrSvGwfaomoabm cHçpHrItm;vkH;yif þü ]'ku©}-t&aumuf,lrnf jzpfaomaMumifY jzpfayonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]'ku©}-[laom pum;vkH;udk ]'k}ESifY]cr}-aygif;xm;aompum; [lonfxuf ]'k}ESifY]u&}wdkY aygif;xm;aompum; jzpfonf-[kqdkjcif;u ydkíoifYzdkY ½Sdavonf/

[kwfygonf/ ]'k}-onf ]wm;jrpfjcif;jy pum;vkH;} jzpfonf/tu,fí ]cr}- jzpfvsif ]cr}onf ]cHEdkifjcif;jypum;vkH;}jzpfí þESpfvkH;aygif;í ]'ku©}-[k,lvsif ]rcHEdkifjcif;}-teuf xGufygrnf/

þodkYqdkvsif ]rcHEdkifaomt&mum;} tb,fenf;/ þt&mudknTefjyvdkvsif pHjyKowfrSwfcH&aomvl½SdzdkY vdkvmygonf/ okdYr[kwf pHjyKowfrSwfxm;aomqif;&J jzpf&ygrnf/ Oyrm- ]b,frSb,ftxdjzpfaomqif;&Jonf cHEdkifaomtajctae} jzpfonf/ <uif;aomqif;&Jonf]rcHEdkifaomtajctae} jzpfonf/ þodkY pHjyKowfrSwfcsuf½SdzdkYvdkygonf/

]'ku©}-[laom pum;udk azmfxkwfokH;EIef;cJYaom Ak'¨toQif udk,fwdkifu þpHudk owfrSwfcJYjcif; tvsOf;r½Sday/ xdkYaMumifY þtxufygtaMumif;rsm;aMumifY ]'ku&}-[laom pum;vkH;aygif;u ydkíoifYavsmfjcif;

Page 169: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 169

jzpfygonf/þü ]'ku©}\teuf ]qif;&J}[lonf tb,fodkYaom teufenf;-

[kar;vsif-]qif;&J}-[laomteufonf]jyKvkyfí r&jcif;}-[laom teuf½Sd

onf[k ajz&ygrnf/ odkYr[kwf ]cufjcif;}-teuf½Sdonf[k ajzygrnf/b,ft&mrsm;udk jyKvkyfír&jcif; jzpfygoenf;-[ltH/],kwfatmifçjrwfatmifESifY Murf;atmifçEkatmif}rsm; jyKvkyfí

r&jcif;jzpfonf [k ajz&ygrnf/[kwfygonf/ ]'ku©}o½kyfouefrsm;jzpfMuaom ]pdwfçapwodufç

½kyf}y&rwfrsm;onf Murf;atmifçEkatmif? ,kwfatmifçjrwfatmifrsm;]jyKvkyfí r&Mu}yg/ jyKvkyfí r&jcif;onf ]cufjcif;}-jzpfygonf/ wzefcufjcif;onf ]qif;&Jjcif;}-jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY þ]qif;&J}\ teufonf ]cHçpHjcif;jy a0'empum;vkH;r[kwf}/ ]cufcjJcif;jypum;vkH;}jzpfonf-[k qdkcjJYcif; jzpfygonf/

tb,faMumifY 'ku©\o½kyfjzpfaom y&rwfrsm;ü ]Murf;çEk? ,kwfçjrwf} jyKvkyfír&onf-[ltHHY/ tMurf;jzpfapç tEkjzpfap? t,kwfjzpfapçtjrwfjzpfap- 4if;wdkYwpfckckrQ ½SdNyD;rjzpfaomaMumifY[k ajz&ayrnf/

[kwfygonf/ t&mwpfckckonf tu,fí tMurf;½Sdaeonfqdkvsif tEkvkyfí jzpfay&monf/ xdkodkYr[kwfbJ tEk½Sdaeonfqdkvsifvnf;tMurf;jzpfatmif vkyfEdkifay&monf/ t,kwfçtjrwfwdkYvnf; þtwlwpfckck½Sdvsif tjcm;wpfckckjzpfatmif jyKEdkifcGifY ½Sday&monf/ þodkYjyKír&jcif;onf ]Murf;çEk? ,kwfçjrwf} wpfckrQr½Sd-[laom teufudk azmfjy&ma&mufayonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]'ku©}\ ]qif;&Jjcif; odkYr[kwf cufcJjcif; odkYr[kwfjyKvkyfír&jcif;}-[laom þteuft"dyÜg,frsm;onf 'ku©o½kyfjzpfaom

Page 170: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

170 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}wdkY\ ]t,kwfçtjrwf? tMurf;çtEk} toGiftjyifrsm;tvsOf;r½Sdjcif;udk ajymifpifoGm;atmif jiif;qdkjcif; jzpfayonf/

þodkY ]'ku©}[laom pum;vkH;jzifY ]'ku©}o½kyfaumifjzpfaomy&rwfrsm;ü ]t,kwfçtjrwf? tMurf;çtEk}[laom toGiftjyifrsm;-r½Sd}-[k jiif;qdkjcif;onf xdky&rwfrsm;\ ]t½Sdtjzpfudk jiif;qdkjcif;} jzpfayonf/

þpum;rSefonf/ þtaMumif;udk jyygrnf/ ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}y&rwfrsm;onf taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm; pka0;aygif;pkHvkdufí]pdwf}-ponftjzpf a&mufaomtcg xdk]pdwf}ponfonf tu,fyif udk,fwdkif&yfEdkifpGrf;aom owåd½Sdonfqdkvsif olü t,kwfçtjrwf? tMurf;çtEk[laom toGiftjyifw&m;rsm; ydkifqdkifvsuf ½Sdav&m\/

qdkvdkonfrSm ]pdwf}ponfwdkYonf tu,fyif ]t½Sd}jzpfonfqdkvsiftoGiftjyifw&m;rsm; ½Sd&rnf-[k jzpfygonf/ xdktoGiftjyifrsm;um;t,kwfESifYtjrwf? tMurf;ESifYtEkwdkY jzpfMuonf/ xdkodkY toGiftjyifw&m;rsm;½Sdvsifvnf; tMurf;½Sdvsif tEkjzpfatmif jyKvkyfí &&rnf? vG,f&rnf?csrf;om&rnf/ xdkYtwl tEk½Sdvsifvnf; tMurf;jzpfatmif jyKvkyfí&&rnf? vG,f&rnf? csrf;om&rnf trSefyif/

xdkodkYjzpfvsuf ]'ku©}[laompum;vkH;jzifY vkyfr&? cJcufonf?qif;&Jonf-[k qdkvdkufjcif;jzifY ]'ku©o½kyfaqmif} y&rwfrsm;onf toGiftjyifrJYw&m;omjzpfonf-[k qdkvdk&m a&mufygonf/

xdkYjyif toGiftjyifrJYw&m;onf t½Sdr[kwfaomw&m;om jzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]pdwf}paom y&rw¬w&m;rsm;onf t½Sdr[kwfaomw&m;rsm; jzpfonf-[k ]'ku©}[laom y&rw¬vu©Pmjy pum;jzifY jiif;qdkjyygonf/

Page 171: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 171

56/ tewåonf y&rwft½Sdjy ae&mXmeudk jiif;qdkonfhpum;xdkYjyifvnf; usefao;aom y&rw¬vu©Pmjypum;vkH; ]tewå}-

onfvnf; xdky&rw¬wdkY\ t½Sdtjzpfudk jiif;qdkjyaom pum;yif jzpfayonf/ [kwfygonf/ ]tewå}[laom pum;vkH;onf teuft"dyÜg,ftm;jzifY ]tESpfom&rJYjcif;(tom&ua|e)}jzpfonf-[k todtrSwfjyKcJY&aompum;vkH; jzpfygonf/

þ]tewå}-[laom pum;vkH;onfvnf; ]t}ESifY ]twå}[laomESpfvkH;wdkYaygif;xm;aom pum;jzpfygonf/]t}onf ]wm;jrpfjcif;jy} pum;yifjzpfygonf/ ]twå}rSmrl ]txnf}[laom teuft"dyÜg,fjypum; jzpfygonf/

]txnf}[lonf tb,fenf;/]txnf}[laom pum;onf ]ae&mESifYpyfaom pum;}yif jzpfyg

onf/]txnf(j'yf)}jzpfí ,if;-txnfj'yf\ wnf&mçrSD&m ½Sd&ygrnf/Oyrmtm;jzifY ]txnf}tjzpf tao;trIefqkH; t&muav;yif jzpfygap?xdktxnfonf ]twGif;}-[lívnf;aumif;?]tjyif}-[lívnf;aumif;?]teD;}-[lívnf;aumif;? ]ta0;}-[lívnf;aumif; av;rsdK;av;pm;aom]wnf&mç rSD&mjy} tajctaersm; ½Sd&ygrnf/

xdkYaMumifY ]tewå}onf ]txnfudkjiif;qdkaompum;}odkYr[kwf]ae&mudkjiif;qdkaompum;vkH;} jzpfygonf/ ]tewå}udk ]tESpfom&r½Sd}-[lí tumçtacgufvdkt&mrsm;om wnf½Sdaeovdkvdk xifcGifYjzpfay:ygonf/ þodkYr[kwfyg/ tewåvu©Pm\ o½kyfjzpfaom ]pdwf}paomy&rwfrsm;\ twåowådr½SdonfhtwGuf t½SdtjzpfajymqdkrIudk tm;ay;aom]ae&m}udk jiif;qdkonf-[k em;vnf&rnf jzpfygonf/

Page 172: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

172 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

57/ y&rw¬t½Sd0g'onf Ak'0g'ESifY vm;vm;rQrywfoufþodkYqdkvsif Ak'toQif\ ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf} y&rw¬ vu©Pmjy

pum;rsm;jzpfaom ]tedpöç'ku©çtewå}wdkYonf xdkvu©PmwdkY\ o½kyfjzpfaom y&rwfrsm; ]t½Sd}r[kwfaMumif;udk jiif;qdkaompum;rsm; jzpfayonf/odkYr[kwf xdky&rwfrsm; jzpfay:cGifYBuKHí jzpfay:aomfvnf; olwdkYudk,folwdkY aqmifvsuf &yfpGrf;Edkifaom t&nftcsif;ESifYjynfhpkHaomt&mr[kwf[k jiif;qdkMuygonf/

[kwfygonf/ ]t½Sdw&m;}[lonfum; udk,fYudk,fukdaqmifvsuf&yfwnfEdkifpGrf;aom t&nftcsif;½Sdaomw&m; jzpfygonf/ xdkw&m;onftu,fí½SdcJYvsif xdkw&m;ü ]tcsdef}onfvnf;aumif;? ]ae&m}onfvnf;aumif;? ]toGiftjyif}onf4if; ½Sd&mygrnf/

xdkYtjyifxdk]t½Sdw&m;}\ xdk]tcsdefçae&mçtoGiftjyif}rsm;onfrazmufrjyefvnf; {uef ½Sday&m\/

taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm; pka0;íaeaom tjzpfw&m;wpfckü½Sdaom tcsdefçae&mESifY toGiftjyifrsm;onf olYyuwd½Sdaomt&mr[kwf/ vlwdkY oauFw?vlwdkY owfrSwfxm;aom azmufjyefaomt&mrsm;om jzpfMuayonf/

razmufjyefaom tcsdefçae&mESifY toGiftjyifrsm;½Sdaom t&monfomvsif udk,fYudk,fudkaqmifvsuf &yfpGrf;Edkifaom odkYr[kwf twåowåd½Sdaomw&m; jzpfygonf/

]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf}y&rwfwdkY\ yuwdobm0udk pm½IolwdkYtjyefjyef qef;ppfcJYayNyD/ xdkw&m;rsm;udk taMumif;tpdwftydkif;uav;rsm; pka0;rS jzpfay:onfudk pm½Ioludk,fwdkifvnf; em;vnfcJYavmufNyD[k,lqygonf/ qdkvdkonfrSm xdky&rwfrsm;onf udk,fYudk,fudkaqmifvsuf

Page 173: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 173

&yfwnfEdkifpGrf;aomw&m; r[kwf/ taMumif;i,frsm; pkaygif;aeaomtjzpfw&m;-[k em;vnfcJYavmufNyD-[k ,kHMunfaMumif; jzpfygonf/

xdkYtjyifvnf; xdky&rwfw&m;rsm;udk wifjycJYaom Ak'toQifudk,fwkdifuvnf; xdkw&m;wdkY\ vu©Pmjypum;vkH;rsm;jzifY xdkw&m;rsm;onft½Sdw&m;rsm;r[kwfMuaMumif; apYpyfaocsmpGm jiif;qdkjycJYonfudk pm½IolwdkY oabmaygufavmufNyD-[k xifygonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]y&rwft½Sd0g'}onf ]Ak'0g'}ESifY vm;vm;rQ rywfoufaom0g'jzpfygonf/

58/ y&rw¬t½Sd0g'onf pdwåZ0g']y&rwft½Sd0g'}onf Ak'0g'udk ]b0}rygbJ ]oabmw&m;}csnfh

wnfaqmuf&mrS odkYr[kwf udk,frygbJ acgif;csnf;&yfwnfae&mrS ay:xGufvmaom ]pdwåZ0g'}-oufouf jzpfygonf/

olwdkYonf ]cEm}[laompum;udk ]t½Sd}xifMuayonf/]cEm}onf ]pdwfçapwodufç½kyf} y&rwfrsm;jzpfonf-[k olwdkY,lq

onf/ olwdkYxifonfhtwdkif; trSefr[kwfay/]cEm}onf ]umvçXmeçoP²me}wpfq,fYwpfaxGtm;jzifY xdk]pdwf}ponfudk ½IMunfhaomolüom jzpfayonf/

]y&rw¬t½Sd0g'D}wdkYonf a½SUçaemufb0rsm; r½Sd-[k olwdkY\ y&rwft½Sdrsm;jzifY rsufvSnfhjyMuayonf/ onfbufb0rS ½kyfçemrfonf [dkbufb0½kyfçemrf r[kwf/ [dkbufb0rS ½kyfçemrfonfvnf; þb0½kyfçemrfr[kwf/ odkYaomfvnf; ½kyfçemrfcsif;taMumif;rl ruif;ukef-[lownf;/

olwdkYonf ]þb0onf xdkb0r[kwf}-qdkaomfvnf; xdkb0twGufþb0rS raMumufbJ raeEdkifMuukef/ xdkYaMumifY olwdkYrsufvSnfhonfolrsm;udk jy½kHrQom tusdK;½Sdayonf/ udk,fwdkif tusdK;xl; xGufay:atmifrlum; rvSnfhEdkifMuay/

Page 174: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

174 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

olwdkYonf ]Ak'tbd"r®m}udk avYvm&mü b0ESifYn§dí tajccHoabmrsm;udk aocsmonftxd aumuf,lEdkifatmif rBudK;pm;MuaomaMumifYjzpfayonf/

xdkYaMumifY xdkolwdkY\b0onf ]b0ESifY oabmw&m;} oD;jcm;pDjzpfvsuf apmufxdk;rdk;ajrmf jzpfvsuf½SdMuayonf/ þodkY udk,fYb0ESifY udk,fYoabmw&m;yif r[yfrdaom apmufxdk;rdk;ajrmf wnfaxmifrIrsm;onfa½S;tcgcyfapmapmuyif wnf½SdcJYNyD; jzpfonf/

uREkfyfwdkY taotcsmajymEdkifonfrSm Ak'tbd"r®mudk tawG;acsmfcJYaom ]rdvdEyO§m}pmwrf;udk jyKpkcJYaom yk*¾dKvfxHüyif b0 apmufxdk;rdk;ajrmftjzpfrsm; wnf½SdcYJNyDudk od½Sd&ayonf/

xdkYaMumifY þrSm;,Gif;aom b0tjrifrsm;onf aumuEk'fAdrmefudkzefqif;ol\ udk,fykdif b0tjrifyif r[kwfay/ olY-y#dpöorkyÜg'fonfolodjrifaom y#dpöorkyÜg'f r[kwf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

þrQjzifY aumuEk'fAdrmefudk zefqif;ol\ b0tjrifonf olYtjrif-r[kwf½kHomru ol\ b0tjrifvnf; r[kwfí? ]rSefuefaomb0tjrifr[kwf}aMumif; oabmaygufoifYygNyD/ ,if;okdYoabmaygufatmif tav;teuf wifjy&ygrnf/

þodkYqdkvsif aumuEk'fAdrmefq&m\ olwifjyaom ]þb0onfrarG;rDb0wpfckrSuHaMumifY jzpfonf? þb0rSjyKaomuHaMumifYvnf;Oyg'gefrukefao;vsif aoNyD;aemufüvnf; b0jzpf&OD;rnf}-[laompum;onf olrodbJ? odav[ef pdwåZjzifYqdkjcif; jzpfavonf/

þodkYqdkvsif aumuEk'fAdrmefudk zefqif;ol\ b0trSefudk em;vnfcGifY½SdayNyD/ ol\ aumuEk'fAdrmefwpfae&mü atmufyg olYb0\oauFwESpfcsuf xm;cJYonfudk uREfkyfwdkY avYvmcJY&NyD r[kwfygavm/

Page 175: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 175

(1) edAÁmefonf rSm;rnfçwdrf;rnf tvGefBuD; aMumifYMupdk;&drfzG,fr½Sd- [laom t&mESifY?

(2) omoemtwGif;ü vltjzpf&aeaom ,ckb0onf edAÁmef\teD; qdkufaeaomb0 aywnf;/ aovGefí omoemr½SdaomvlrsdK;ü jzpfcJYaomfvnf;aumif;? tyg,fü jzpfcJYaomfvnf;aumif; ,ck qdkkufwdkufeD;yg;aeom edAÁmefESifY MumavtvSrf;uGma0;av oGm;jyefav\}/

þt&mrsm;onf aumuEk'fAdrmefwpfae&mü taotcsm usef½SdaecJYaom t&mrsm; jzpfygonf/ þt&mrsm;onf odkYr[kwf þurÁnf;pmrsm;onf olYb0\ rSefuefaomo½kyfudk azmfxkwfí jyaeayonf/

,ck uREfkyfwdkYü olYb0udk tb,fodkYodaerIrsm; jzpfaeMuNyDenf;/olYb0onf a½TAdrmefydokumavm?a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumavm/þt&monf pm½Iolukd,fwdkif qkH;jzwf&awmYrnft&mom usefyg

awmYonf/ pma&;oltaeESifY aumuEk'fAdrmefzefqif;ol\ b0udka½TAdrmefydokum r[kwf? a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumb0omjzpfaMumif;wwftm;orQ avQmufvJwifjycJYygNyD/

þt&mudk pm½Ioludk,fwdkif BudKufovkd qkH;jzwfapcsifygonf/qkH;jzwf&efvnf; wdkufwGef;ygonf/

pm½Iolonf tu,fí avQmufvJcsufrsm; rjynfhpkH-[k ,lqvsifavQmufvJol\ tawG;acsmfaerIjzpfaMumif; 0efcH&ygrnf/ xdkodkYr[kwfbJavQmufvJrIrsm; NyD;jynfhpkHonf[kqdkvsif qufí avQmufvJcsufudk zwf½ItuJjzwfapvdkygonf/

pma&;ol qufí avQmufvJ&ef ½Sdygao;onf/

Page 176: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

176 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

,if;rSm tu,fí aumuEk'fAdrmefzefqif;ol\ b0onf a½TrIefusJAdrmef\ ydokumb0jzpfonfudk awGU&onfqdkvsif þaumuEk'fAdrmefonf b,fenf;ESifYrQ a½TAdrmef r[kwfEdkifawmYay/ a½TrIefusJAdrmefomtaotcsm jzpf&ygawmYrnf/

,if;udk aocsmonfxuf aocsm&ef xdkaumuEk'fAdrmefuav;\tpdwftydkif;uav;wcsdKUudk qdwfzJYí oufaoxljyavQmufvJ&ef wm0ef½Sdygao;onf/ ,if;wm0efudk qufí ,lvdkygonf/ qufí avQmufvJ&rnfrSm þt&mom jzpfygonf/

þt&mudk ,ck qufí avQmufvJ&ygawmYrnf/w&m;olBuD;wdkY\ bufrvdkufpdwfxm;jzifY trSefw&m;udk OD;xdyf

wifvsuf qifjcifMunfh½IMuapvdkygonf/

Page 177: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 177

tcef;(4)

edAÁmefonfwefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;onf tqdkay:

pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

Page 178: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

178 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 179: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 179

tcef;(4)edAÁmefonf wefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;onf tqdkay: pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

59/ edAÁmefonf wefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;ovm;aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;ü tydkif;okH;ydkif; ½Sdygonf/(1) Adrmefuav;wpfckvkH;udk xrf;xm;aomwdkifESifY xkyfça,muf- ponfrsm; onf tydkif;wpfydkif; jzpfygonf/(2) aemufwpfydkif;rSm trdk;çtumponfrsm; jzpfygonf/(3) wwd,tydkif;wpfydkif;rSmum; yef;ajymuf yef;EG,fESifY tcuf

tvufponfrsm; jzpfygonf/pm½IolwdkY odjrifEdkif&ef tenf;i,frQomqdyfzJYí oufaoxlwifjy

rnfjzpfí þtydkifokH;ydkif;teuf okH;ydkif;vkH;udk avYvmwifjyrnf r[kwfawmYyg/ ta&;tygqkH;aom ]wdkifESifY xkyfça,mufydkif;}udkom avUvmwifjyrnf jzpfygonf/ usefaomtydkif;rsm;onf þtydkif;tay:ü tm;vkH;rSDíaeMuayonf/ þtydkif;udk avYvmrdvsif useftydkif;rsm;twGuf tvdktavsmuf NyD;rnfjzpfygonf/

yXrtydkif;onf aumuEk'fAdrmefwnfaqmufol\ a0g[m&ü]oacFyu@}[lí jzpfonf/

þtydkif;ü ]edAÁmef}onf tvGefwefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;onf}-[k jyqdkxm;ygonf/ wefcdk;BuD;ykHudkvnf; OyrmjzifY qufíazmfjyxm;ygonf/

jyykHrSm þodkYjzpfonfè]½GmolBuD;wpfa,mufonf olaeaom½Gmü½Sdaom vk,ufowfjzwf

wwfaom cdk;olBuD;udk aMumufíae&onf/ wcsdefü xdk½GmolBuD;onfjynfh½Sifrif;BuD;tm; cpm;rdaomaMumifY NrdKU0ef&mxl;tqifY tjr§ifYcH&avonf/ olonf NrdKU0efjzpfaomtcg cdk;olBuD;udk tqkH;pD&ifvdkufavonf}/

Page 180: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

180 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þOyrmü- cdk;olBuD;ESifY t0dZÆm? ½GmolBuD;ESifY avmuDynm?aMumuf&jcif;ESifY 'ku©opöm? jynfh½Sifrif;ESifY edAÁmef? NrdKU0ef&mxl;ESifY r*fynm-twljyKí xm;avonf/

þpum;rsm;\ vIyf½Sm;rIudpöudk pdppfvsif atmufygtwdkif; awGUjrif&ygrnf-

]avmuDynmjzpfaom ½GmolBuD;onf cdk;olBuD;[laom t0dZÆmaMumifY?'ku©[laom ab;&efudk aMumufíavm? tjcm;taMumif;udpö ½Sdíavmrod/ wpfckckaomtaMumif;aMumifY edAÁmefwnf;[laom jynfh½Sifrif;xHtcpm;0ifavonf/ xdkedAÁmefwnf;[laom jynfh½Sifrif;BuD;udk cpm;rdaomaMumifY avmuDynm-½GmolBuD;onf avmuDynm-½GmolBuD;tjzpfrSavmukwå&mynm-NrdKU0ef&mxl;udk &½SdoGm;avonf/ avmukwå&mr*fynm-NrdKU0efonf &mxl;jrifYí tmPmBuD;vmaomaMumifY 'ku©[laomab;&efudkjyKvkyfaeaom t0dZÆm-cdk;olBuD;udk owfjzwfuGyfrsufvdkufavonf-[lownf;/

þpum;vIyf½Sm;rIrsm;\ aumufcsufudkqGJvsif atmufygtwdkif;xGufay:vmygrnf-

]avmuDynm-½GmolBuD;onf tb,faMumifY r*fynm[laomNrdKU0efjzpfoGm;&ygoenf;/ cdk;olBuD;udk owfEdkifaomaMumifYavm? odkYr[kwfcdk;olBuD;udkowfNyD; &yf½Gmat;csrf;atmif jyKEdkifaomaMumifYavm/ odkYr[kwfedAÁmef-bk&ifudk cpm;aomaMumifYavm/ tb,faMumifY avmuDynm-½GmolBuD;tjzpfrS r*fynm-NrdKU0ef jzpfoGm;&ygoenf;/}

þtajzonf ta&;BuD;ygonf/ þtajzvGJvsif ]edAÁmef}onfwefcdk;tmEkabmftvGefBuD;aomt&m jzpfonf}-[laomtqdk ysufjym;oGm;Edkifygonf/ þtqdk rysufjym;bJ atmifjrifEdkif&ef atmufygtwdkif;ajz&ygrnf? ajzíxm;ygonf-

Page 181: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 181

]avmuDynm-½GmolBuD;onf edAÁmef-jynfh½Sifrif;BuD;ESifY awGUaomaMumifY r*fynm-NrdKU0ef jzpfoGm;&avonf}-[lí jzpfonf}/

þodkYqdkvsif ]edAÁmef}onf a½S;uqdkcJYonfhtwdkif; wefcdk;tmEkabmfBuD;onf}-qdkonfrSm qdkcJYonfhtwdkif; rSefayawmYonf/ ]edAÁmef}onf]avmuDynmrS r*fynm}tjzpf vSnfhajymif;ay;Edkifaom MoZmtmPm½Sdaom t&mwnf;/ ]r*fynmESifY avmuDynm}onf ]NrdKU0efESifY ½GmolBuD;}uJUodkY &mxl;tqifYcsif; jcm;rSjcm; jzpfavonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]edAÁmef}onfþtwdkif;yif avmuDynmudk r*fynmtjzpf vSnfhajymif;ay;Edkifjcif; rSefvsif wefcdk;tmEkabmf BuD;vSayonf/

odkYaomfvnf; avmuDynmudk r*fynmjzpfatmif edAÁmefonftu,fyif vSnfhajymif;ay;Edkifygoavm/

cdk;oludkowfEdkifaomowåd odkYr[kwf cdk;oludkowfí &yf½Gmat;csrf;atmif vkyfEdkifaomowåd? þt&muav;rsm;uom avmuDynm-½GmolBuD;udk r*fynm-NrdKU0efjzpfatmif vSnfhajymif;ay;EdkifaomtaMumif;jzpfEdkifonf r[kwfygavm/

þü edAÁmef-jynfh½Sifrif;onf vSnfhajymif;rIjyKjcif;ü tmPmtyfESif;oltjzpf yg0ifrnfjzpfaomfvnf; taMumif;r[kwfjzpfaeonf r[kwfygavm/ þodkYqdkaomf edAÁmefonf tb,frSm wefcdk;tmEkabmf ½SdawmYoenf;/wu,ftjzpfonf þodkYyifjzpf&rnf r[kwfygavm/

]r[kwf}-[k tu,fíjiif;qdkonfjzpftHHY/ jiif;vdkolonf opömav;csufudk wNydKifeufvnfap&ef vSnfhjyEdkif&ayrnf/

]edAÁmef}wefcdk;½Sdonf}-[k tqdkjyKcsufudk taMumif;jyaom txufygpum;onf opömav;csufudk wNydKifeufvnfapEdkifaom tajctaer½Sdaompum; jzpfygonf/

Page 182: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

182 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; þpum;onf tajctjrpfr½SdbJ aygufvTwfyJpm; qdkpum;awmYvnf; r[kwfay/ jrefrmwpfjynfvkH;ESifY ax&0g' omoem wpfckvkH;uyif av;pm;&aom tzGifYusrf;aygif;rsm;pGmudk jyKpkcJYaomt½Sif r[mAk'aCmo\ tqdkt>rufpum;udk tajccHtjzpf xm;aompum; jzpfayonf/

½Sifr[mAk'aCmo\ pum;[lonfrSm tb,fenf;/]edAÁmef}onf &m*wdkY uif;&muif;aMumif;? a'goçarm[wdkY uif;&m

uif;aMumif; jzpfonf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf edAÁmefudktaMumif;jyKí&m*-ponf ukefMu&aomaMumifY jzpfonf/}

þtqdkudk ol\ oar®m[t|uxmü apm'emçaom"emaygif;rsm;pGmjzifY tcdkiftrmwnfaqmufí xm;cJYayonf/ t½Sifr[mAk'aCmo\ pum;[lonfrSm þonfwdkYwnf;-

xdktajctjrpf½Sdaom pum;yifjzpfaomfvnf; xdkpum;onf opömav;csufudk wNydKifeuf vnfapEdkifrnfavm/ tu,fí vnfapEdkifonfqdkvsif xdkpum;onf atmifjrifaompum; jzpfEdkif\/

tu,fí opömav;csufudk wNydKifeuf rvnfapEdkifvsifum; þpum;onf odMum;rif;BuD;qdkaom t&mudk,fwdkifyif qif;NyD;? ]bk&m; þodkYa[mcJYonfudk uREfkyfudk,fwdkif oufaocHygonf}-[kqdkaomfvnf; atmifjrifaompum; rjzpfEdkif/

xdkYaMumifY-(1) ]edAÁmefa&mufNyD;rS &m*ukef&oavm? &m*ukefaomaMumifY

edAÁmefa&mufoavm}/(2) edAÁmefa&mufaomaMumifY r*f&oavm? r*f&aomaMumifY

edAÁmefa&mufoavm}/þjyóemrsm;udk a0zefpOf;pm;oifYygonf/

Page 183: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 183

60/ edAÁmefa&mufaomaMumifY &m*ukefjcif;avm]edAÁmef wefcdk;½Sdonf}-[k wifjyvdkol\ tqdktm;jzifY ]edAÁmefa&muf

aomaMumifY &m*ukefonf? r*fvnf;jzpfonf}-[k qdkvdkaeonf/ ol\qdkcJYaompum;rsm;ü þodkY t"dyÜg,f½Sdaeonf/

þodkYqdkvsif edAÁmefxHodkY yXroGm;pOfu ynmonf ]r*fynm}rjzpfao;ay/ avmuDynmyif jzpfao;onf/ avmuDynmonf a*gMwbl-[laom trnfjzifY edAÁmefudk cpm;NyD;rS edAÁmef\ wefcdk;½Sdefapmf tmEkabmfrsm;u cpm;vmaom a*gMwbl[laom avmuDynmudk r*fynmtjzpf&mxl;wdk;vdkufonf/ ynmonf r*fynm[laom &mxl;wdk;NyD;rS cdk;olBuD;-ork',udk owfjcif; jzpfonf/ xdkYjyif xdkodkYowfNyD;rS &yf½Gmat;csrf;onf/

þü tpOfudk umvjzifYqdkvsif atmufygtwdkif; jzpfygrnfè(1) avmuDynmjzifY edAÁmefudkawGUjcif;onf yXr/(2) edAÁmefawGUNyD;aemuf avmuDynmrS avmukwå&mtjzpfa&muf

jcif;onf 'kwd,/(3) avmukwå&mynmu cdk;olBuD;(ork',)udk owfjcif;ESifY

&yf½Gmat;csrf;jcif;onf wwd,- [lownf;/xdkodkYr[kwfbJ r*fjzpfvsifjzpfjcif;yif cdk;oludkvnf;owf? &yf½Gm

vnf; at;csrf;onfqdkvsif qkdygap/ &mxl;&vsif&jcif;vnf; owfEdkifygonf/ odkYaomfvnf; ,if;onf Oyrmjzpfí-[k xm;vsuf owfEdkifonfyif½Sdygap/

]edAÁmef}awGUonfu wpfcsdef/&mxl;&jcif;? owfjcif;u wpfcsdef/ þodkY jcm;em;í aejyefayonf/xdkYjyif cdk;olqdk;í ½Sifbk&ifxHoGm;vsif cdk;ol\qdk;onf-[k todcH

&jcif;u wpfcsdef?½Sifbk&ifxHoGm;onfu wpfcsdef/

Page 184: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

184 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þodkY tcsdef jcm;jyefavonf/þodkYvsif opömav;csufonf wNydKifeufrvnfbJ ½Sdaeavonf/opömav;csufonf ]"r®puf} jzpfavonf/avmuü pufwpfckonf Edk;onfqdkvsif ½SdorQaom puftpdwf

tydkif;wdkif; wNydKifeufyif olYqdkif&mudpöudk vkyfaqmifMu&avonf/ xdkodkYr[kwfvsif xdkpufonf rvnfaompuf? ysufaompuf jzpfygonf/pufysufaevsif tb,ftpdwftydkif;onf tvkyfrvkyfbJ ½Sdaeoenf;-[k qef;ppf&ayonf/ puf\ tpdwftydkif;wdkif;ü olYqdkif&mvkyfief;udpö½Sd&ayonf/

Oyrm-eHywfwpftpdwftydkif; wpfywfvnfqdkvsif? eHywfESpfutywf0uf? eHywfokH;u wpfywfcGJ? eHywfav;u ESpfywf-ponfjzifYjzpfonf/

þodkY olvkyf&rnfhvkyfief;udk rvkyfawmYjcif;onf ]pufysufjcif;(0g) pufrvnfjcif;} jzpfayonf/ xdkpufudk tb,fuysufonf-[kppfaq;olonf xdktpdwftydkif;rsm; olYvkyfief;udpötwdkif; vkyfçrvkyfqef;ppf&ayonf/

]edAÁmeH tm*r® &m*'a,m cdPm}-qdkaom t|uxmudk rSD;xm;aom ]edAÁmef wefcdk;½Sdonf}-[laomtqdkonf opöm"r®pufudk vnfapEdkifaomtqdk r[kwfaMumif; wifjycJYayNyD/

xdkYaMumifY xdktqkdonf opöm"r®puftysufBuD; jzpfaeavonf/þodkYjzpfvsif-]tb,f-opömtpdwftydkif;onf ysufaeavoenf;/ ½Smvsif

awGUEdkifrnfavm}/ tu,fí ysufaejcif;rSefvsif ½SmMunfhygrl rkcsyifawGUjrif&ayrnf/

Page 185: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 185

61/ opömav;csufonf tcsdefrjcm; wNydKifeufvnfonfatmufygwdkYonf "r®puftpdwftydkif;rsm;\ vkyfief;udpöudk nTefjy

aom "r®puf\ uufwavmufrsm; jzpfygonfè(u) 'ku©t&d,opömonf ]todcHudpö} ½Sdonf/( c) ork',t&d,opömonf ]ty,fcHudpö} ½Sdonf/( *) eda&m"t&d,opömonf ]tqdkufcHudpö} ½Sdonf/(C) r*¾t&d,opömonf ]yGm;&aomudpö} ½Sdonf/þyGm;tyfaom ]r*¾t&d,opöm}onf tb,fenf;è(1) rSefuefaom tjrif?(2) rSefuefaom tawG;?(3) rSefuefaom tajym?(4) rSefuefaom tvkyf?(5) rSefuefaom tae?(6) rSefuefaom BudK;pm;jcif;?(7) rSefuefaom Edk;Mum;jcif;?(8) rSefuefaom wnfMunfjcif;(pdwfxm;jcif;)wdkY jzpfygonf/þodkYqdkvsif rSefuefaom tjrifçtawG;ponfudk b,frSm vkyf&

rnfenf;/ qdkvdkonfrSm rSefuefaom tjrifçtawG;-ponfwdkY\ tjrifçtawG;cH&rnfh w&m;um; tb,fenf;/ þr*¾opömyif jzpfavoavm/ork',ç eda&m"opömrsm;yif jzpfavoavm/ 'ku©opömyif jzpfavoavm/

tb,fopömonf ]todcHudpö ½Sdonf}-[k "r®puf\ uufwavmufü tb,fnTefjyaeygoenf;/ ]edAÁmef}onf ]todcHudpö} ½SdEdkifygrnfavm/

þtar;\tajzudk yd#uwfü ]or®m'd|d}udkzGifYaomtcg-]'kau© ÓPHç 'ku©ork'a, ÓPHç 'ku©eda&ma"ÓPHç'ku©eda&m"*grdeDy#dy'g ÓPH}-[kawGU&wwfayonf/

Page 186: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

186 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

tu,fpifppf þpum;onf aqmifolwdkY tm;vGefaompum;om jzpf&monf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf r*fÓPfonf r*fÓPfudk jyefíodrI rjzpfEdkifaomaMumifYwnf;/ r*fÓPfudk jyefodonfqdkvsif ypöa0u©PmÓPfawmfom jzpfvsif-jzpfcGifY½SdaomaMumifYwnf;/

xdkYaMumifY þtar;\tajzonf opöm"r®puf uufwavmuft&ajzvsif ]'ku©opöm}om jzpf&mygonf/ [kwfygonf/ r*¾opömonfrSefaom tjrifçtawG;ponfudk cH&rnfhopömonf ork',ç eda&m"çr*¾opömwdkY vkH;vkH; rjzpfEdkif/ ]'ku©opöm}om jzpfygonf/

]'ku©opöm}[laom wpfckwnf;aom opömw&m;onfomvsif r*¾opöm[laom todrSefponfwdkY\ todcHopömoufouf jzpfygownf;/þodkY ]'ku©}udk r*¾jzifYodaomaMumifY ]'ku©-[krxifbJ okc-

[kxifNyD; ESpfoufjrwfEdk;rIrsm;}onf uif;uGmoGm;Mu&ygonf/ þodkY]ork',opöm} ty,fcH&aomaMumifY ]'ku©}jzpfrnfhtvkyfrsm;udk rvkyf/'ku©vnf; Nidrf;ygonf/ ]'ku©eda&m"}[laom ]edAÁmef}onf þodkY ]tqdkufcHoufouf} jzpfygonf/

opömav;csufonf yGm;jcif;çodjcif;çy,fjcif;çqdkufjcif;-[k av;csufjzpfaomfvnf; av;csdefav;umv jzpfMuonfr[kwfay/ wpfcsdefwpfumvwnf;wGifjzpfaomw&m;rsm;om jzpfMuayonf/

avmuOyrmtm;jzifY a½TpESifYwlaom ow¬Kwpfpudk &½Sdvmaomolonf 0rf;ompGmjzifY odrf;qnf;vsuf apmifYa½Smufxm;ygonf/ xdkYaMumifY]qif;&J&onf(tm&u©'ku©)}/ wpfaeYü xdkow¬Kpudk jzwfawmufí avYvmonf/ a½Tr[kwfaMumif;udkodí xdkow¬Kptay:ü ]wG,fwmjrwfEdk;rIçapmifYa½SmufrI ]tmv,}rsm; ysufjym;oGm;avonf/ xdkYaMumifY ow¬KpudkrapmifYa½SmufbJ aeavawmYonf/

Page 187: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 187

þykHpHü ow¬Kpudk ]avYvmqef;ppfjcif;}? a½Tr[kwfaMumif;]odjcif;}onf tcsdefumvwlnDoavmç oD;jcm;avm/ xdkYjyif a½Tr[kwfaMumif;odjcif;ESifY a½Tpr[kwfaom ow¬Kpudk a½Tpxifí pGJaeaom ]tmv,uGmjcif;}onfvnf; tcsdefumv twlavmçoD;jcm;avm/

wzefvnf; xdk-tmv,uGmjcif;ESifY qufvufapmifYa½SmufrIudk]pGefYjcif;}onfvnf; tcsdefumv twlavmç oD;jcm;avm/ xdkvkyfief;tm;vkH;onf odkYr[kwf xdktjzpftm;vkH;onf tcsdefumv ]twlwuG}wnf;/

opöm"r®pufonfvnf; þOyrmtwl wNydKifeuf jzpfMuavonf/]r*¾}jzifY ]'ku©}\qif;&JykH avYvmrdaomaMumifY ]'ku©}udk ]okcçokb}

xifNyD; pGJaeaom tmv,ork',rsm; uif;NyD;? ]'ku©Nidrf;jcif;(eda&m")}jzpfavonf-[laom pum;ü ]r*¾ç'ku©çork',çeda&m"}wdkY olYudpöESifYolwNydKifeuf tvkyfvkyfMuykHonf xif½Sm;vSayonf/

62/ ysufaomopömrsm;þodkYqdkvsif ]avmuDr*f}jzpfap? ]avmukwå&mr*f}jzpfap wpfckck

aomr*fjzifY eda&m"udk rsufarSmufjyKoGm;onf-[laom oabm½Sdaomtqdkonf tqdkrSef r[kwfEdkif/ r*¾jzifY eda&m"udk rodEdkif/ eda&m"ü todcHudpör½SdaomaMumifYwnf;/

þodkYqdkvsif r*¾jzifY ]eda&m"udkod}aomaMumifY ork',y,fonfqdkonfrSmvnf; r[kwfEdkif/ eda&m"ü ork',jzpfp&mrS r½SdygbJvsufeda&m"udkodjcif;aMumifY vnf; b,fodkYvsif ork',uGmusygrnfenf;/

xdkYaMumifY 'ku©vnf;rjzpfawmY-[kqdkvsif eda&m"½Ií eda&m"jyefa&mufonf-[kqkd&m a&mufygonf/ 'ku©opöm\ tcef;onf ryg0ifbJusdK;ysufcJYNyD/ ork',y,fí 'ku©Nidrf;onf[laom pum;onf 'ku©opömudkjyqdkaompum; r[kwf? eda&m"opömudkjyqdkaompum;om jzpfonf/

Page 188: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

188 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

tu,fí 'ku©opömudkjyqdkaompum;[kyif qdktHh/ xdktqdkvnf; rSm;ayonf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf 'ku©opömonf ty,fcHudpö jzpfoGm;aomaMumifY wnf;/

avmuDç avmukwå&m b,fr*fjzifYjzpfap ]edAÁmef}udk rodEdkif/]qdkufa&mufonf? rsufarSmufjyKonf}-qdkaompum;onf ]od}

qdkaompum;ESifY oD;jcm;jzpf&rnf/]pu©KESifY½ly} aygif;qkHjcif;aMumifY xdkaygif;qHkrIESifYtwl ]pu©K0dnmP}

jzpfonf/þüvnf; ]reESifYedAÁme} aygif;qkHrIaMumifY ]r*¾}jzpfonf/þodkYjzpfvsif ]r*¾}onf tb,fodkYvsif ,if;\tm½kH ]edAÁme}udk

odygrnfenf;/]pu©KESifY½ly} aygif;aomaMumifYjzpfaom ]pu©K0dnmP}onf ,if;\

tpdwftydkif;jzpfaom ]pu©KESifY ½ly}udk jyefíodEdkifoavm/ aemufpdwfwdkYtuljzifYom odEdkifrnf r[kwfygavm/

þodkY ]edAÁmef}udk b,fr*fjzifYrQ rodEdkifvsif-]edAÁmef}odí avmuDynmonf avmukwå&mr*fynm &mxl;&oGm;

onf? odkYr[kwf edAÁmefü avmuDynmudk r*fynmjzpfatmif &mxl;wdk;ay;Edkifonf}- þpum;rsm;onf tESpfom&rJYaompum;rsm; jzpfygonf/

xdkYjyif þodkY avmuDynmonf edAÁmef\ &mxl;wdk;ay;cH&rIaMumifYr*fynm jzpfcg cdk;olBuD;-t0dZÆmudk owfEdkifonf-qdkonfrSmvnf; tESpfom&rJYaom pum;vSomjzpfaom pum;jzpfayonf/

þpum;&yfuav;jzifYvnf; aumuEk'fedAÁmefonf a½TedAÁmefr[kwfbJ a½TrIefusJedAÁmefjzpfaMumif; txift½Sm; awGUjrif&ayonf/

Page 189: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 189

tcef;(5)

oOyg'daooedAÁmefonf0dygufemru©Emt<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;vm;

Page 190: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

190 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 191: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 191

tcef;(5)oOyg'daooedAÁmefonf 0dygufemru©Em t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;vm;

63/ oOyg'daooESifY tEkyg'daooedAÁmefaemufxyf qufí tenf;i,frQ ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}ESifY ]tEk

yg'daooedAÁmef}rsm;taMumif; wifjycsufudk avYvm&rnf jzpfygonf/]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}udk b,fodkYwifjyoenf;/]udavomrsm; av;Budrfav;vDtm;jzifY csKyfqkH;Mu&m yXrcsKyfqkH;

onfrS pwkw¬csKyfqkH;NyD;onfhwdkifatmif ]edAÁmef}onf ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}jzpfonf-[l\/

]tEkyg'daoaoedAÁmef}um; tb,fenf;/]þedAÁefum; toufaoNyD;aemufüjzpfaom Nidrf;at;rI}-[lownf;/[kwfygonf/udavomcsKyfNyD; cEmvufusef½Sdao;vsif ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}?udavoma&m cEmyg vufusefr½SdawmYatmif csKyfNyD;vsif ]tEk

yg'daooedAÁmef}/þodkYqdkygonf/ xdkYaMumifY ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}udk ]aoNyD;rS}-

[k qdkcJYonf/ cEmpJjcif;onf ]tEkyg'daoo} [kwfyg\avm/xdkYjyif udavomrsm; t<uif;rJYcsKyfNyD;oGm;NyDjzpfaom &[EÅmyk*¾dKvf

rsufarSmufjyKaeaom edAÁmefonf ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef} [kwfyg\avm/þjyóemrsm;jzifY txufyg edAÁmeftqdkrsm;udk xdk;azmufMunfhoifYygonf/

cEmpJoGm;jcif;onf odkYr[kwf tem*wfü ZmwdrjzpfawmYbJ jzpfoGm;jcif;onf ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef} [kwfyg\avm/ tu,fí ][kwfonf}-qdkvsif ,if;edAÁmefonf ]tbm0}-[laom bmrQr½Sd[laomtqifYudkausmfvTm;atmif rwwfEkdif&m/

Page 192: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

192 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

[kwfyg\/ xdkt&monf tu,f½Sdonfqdk&ef bmESifY oufaoxlrnfenf;/ xdk-]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}udk b,fola&mufrnfenf;/

]edAÁmef}[laom pum;onf ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}? ]tBudKufçtrkef;çtrdkuf-paom pdwfyifyef;rIudkjzpfapwwfaom oabmwdkY\ aemifrjzpfay:aomtm;jzifY ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}[laom teuftw¬½Sdaompum; jzpfygonf/

]Nidrf;at;jcif;}-[laom pum;onf emrfpum;? emrnfjypum;r[kwfyg/ Bud,mpum;vkH; trlt&mjypum;vkH; jzpfygonf/ Bud,monf]emrf}[laom um&uESifYuif;í jzpfaumif;aom pum;vkH;avm/

þrSmbuf raorDjzpfaom &[EÅmyk*¾dKvfonf aoNyD;aemufjzpfay:aom ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}Bud,m\ ]uwåm;}jzpfonf-[k ajzvdkaumif;ajzvdkrnfvm;yif/ xdkodkYjzpfvsif ]uwåm;}ESifY ]Bud,m}onf umvjcm;í&Edkifrnfavm- qifYar;&ayrnf/

þodkY ]Nidrf;at;ol r½SdbJ} ]Nidrf;at;jcif;trlt&m}om ½Sdonfqdkvsif xdkt&monf obm0w&m; r[kwfEdkif/ tbm0w&m;om {uefjzpf&ayrnf/

þae&mü ]tbm0w&m;}[lonfrSm ]pum;om½SdNyD; xdkpum;\teufqHr½Sdaomw&m;}-[k qdkvdkygonf/

[kwfygonf/ Nidrf;at;olr½Sdaom Nidrf;{;jcif;onf ]Nidrf;{;jcif;}-[k b,folawGUodEdkifrnfenf;/ b,folrQ rawGUodEdkifaom Nidrf;at;rIudkb,folonf azmfxkwfcJYrnfenf;/ azmfxkwfolonf awGUodol vkH;0rjzpfEdkif/ txifjzifY azmfxkwfxm;jcif;om jzpfayonf/

þtxifpum;onf tb,fodkYvsif tqHçtESpfçtom; yg0ifEdkifygrnfenf;/

þae&mü ]Nidrf;at;ol-r½Sd? Nidrf;at;jcif;om-½Sdonf}-qdkaompum;udk cdkifrmatmif jyKvkyfol]uwåm;}-r½Sd/ jyKvkyfjcif;trlt&mom ½Sdonf-

Page 193: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 193

paom pum;ESifY xyfwlr[kwfavm}-[k rauseyfoH xGufcsif xGufayvdrfYrnf/

þodkY rauseyfí r&/ xdkt&mum; ]ur®}paom "r®wdkY\ ]t½Sdr[kwfaMumif;? tjzpfrsm;om jzpfaMumif;? xdkYaMumifY uwåKowåd r½SdaMumif;}-xif½Sm;&efqdkaompum; jzpfonf/ ynwfudk jiif;qdkcsuf r[kwf/ ,ckt&mum; ]Nidrf;at;jcif;Bud,m}twGuf Nidrf;at;oluwåm;rSm ynwftm;jzifYyif ]r½Sd}-jzpfaeonf/

&[EÅmyk*¾dKvf\ ½kyfemrfcEmrsm; csKyfqkH;NyD;jcif;onf ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}-jzpfjcif;-qdkvsif-

xdk½kyfemrfcsKyfNyD;vsif &[EÅmyk*¾dKvf[lonfudk ]r&tyf}awmYay/xdkYaMumifY xdkedAÁmefçxdkNidrf;at;jcif;onf ]Nidrf;at;olr½Sdaom Nidrf;at;jcif;}jzpfonf/

]Nidrfat;olr½Sdaom Nidrf;at;jcif;}udk ]Nidrf;at;jcif;}-[k ac:avmufygrnfavm/ uwåm;rJYBud,mjzifY pum;yDatmif wnfaqmufí &Edkifygoavm/

xdkYaMumifY Nidrf;at;jcif;om½Sdí Nidrf;at;olr½Sd-[laom pum;onf]pum;usdK;ç pum;yJYç pum;t*FgcsdKUwJYaom} tcsnf;tESD;pum;om jzpfygonf/

xdkYjyifvnf; ]edAÁmef}onf ]eda&m"opöm} jzpfonf/opömav;csufudk b,frSm ½Sdonf-[k Ak'toQif a[mMum;cJYyg

oenf;-]£ro®ða,0 Asmrrawå uaV0a& oonrSd oreau}-[lí a[mMum;cJYayonf/]todpdwf"gwfESifY trSwfonm½Sdaom wpfvHrQavmufaom vlrSm

jzpfonf}-[k a[mcJYonf r[kwfygavm/

Page 194: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

194 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

edAÁmefonf Nidrf;at;rI/xdkNidrf;at;rIonf vlrJY txD;usef Nidrf;csrf;aeaom Nidrf;csrf;rIr[kwf/]vl\Nidrf;csrf;rI}-[k qdkvdkygonf/a'oemonf MunfndkzG,faumif;avmufatmif ½Sif;vGef;vSyg

onf/þodkYqdkvsif tEkyg'daooedAÁmef teufqHonf ]½kyfemrfrsm;

aemifrjzpf&awmYatmif csKyfqkH;jcif;} [kwfEdkifygawmYrnfavm/ þ½kyfemrfrsm; aemifrjzpfawmYbJ csKyfqkH;jcif;udk tEkyg'daooedAÁmef[k ,ljcif;onf]0db0wPSm}rsm; woGifoGif,dkpD;jcif;\ trSwftom; jzpfygonf/ odkYr[kwf Oapä''d|dwdkY a&tvsOfyrm woGifoGif pD;qif;aejcif;udk awGU&jcif;jzpfygonf/

tEkyg'daooedAÁmefudk þodkY today;jcif;onf tEÅ&m,frsm;vSayonf/ avmuudk tarSmifusapEdkifygonf/ vlrsm;ü ]0db0wPSm}udkjzpfyGm;&ef taumif;qkH;aom vufckyfMobmjzpfygonf/

[kwfygonf/ ,aeY Ak'0g'Drsm;yif þodkY tEkyg'daooedAÁmefudktod½SdaeMuaomaMumifY atmufygtwdkif; NiD;jiLMuygonfè

]þcEm0efBuD;onf av;vGef;vSwum;? aorSyJ at;vdrfYwum;}-ponfjzifYjzpfygonf/ olwdkY\ 'ku©Nidrf;jcif;onf þcEm ½kyfemrfcsKyfrS-[k pdwåZjzpfaeMuonf/'kku©Nidrf;jcif;onf eda&m"opöm? þopömonfvlxJrSm½Sdonf-[k tyGifYvif;qkH; a[mcJYygvsuf tqif;&JMu&onf/

olwdkYonf vludkausmfí Nidrf;csrf;rIudk arQmfaeMuolrsm; jzpfonf/avmuonf þolrsm;udk tb,faumif;usdK; jzpfxGef;apEdkifvdrfYrnfenf;/

xdkYaMumifY tEkyg'daooedAÁmefudk &[EÅmaoNyD;aemuf ,ljcif;onftEÅ&m,fBuD;vSonf/ ,ljyolwdkYudk,fwdkifvnf; tvGefrdkufrJ&m usygonf/

Page 195: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 195

[kwfygonf/ ]b0}[kqdktyfaom tb,fjzpfay:aeaom ½kyfemrftpOfudk vQyfpD;vufaomtcgjrif&aom t&m0w¬Kudkjrifoavmuf wpfcPav;jzpfjzpf em;vnfodjrif oabm0ifzl;vsif þodkY,ljyí rjzpfEdkifbJ½Sd&mayrnf/ b0udk vkH;vkH;ydwf rjrifaomaMumifY b0udkausmfNyD; [dkvSrf;onfvSrf; vSrf;NyD; prf;ae&jcif; jzpfayonf/ odkYr[kwf ½kyfemrftpOfwdkY\jzpfay:jcif;[laomb0udk trSefrjrif trSm;udkjrifNyD; trSefxifaomaMumifYom Oapä''d|dudk tEkyg'daooedAÁmefjzpfatmif ,lrdjcif; jzpfavonf/

olonf ,kwådaA'(Logic)ynm½Sifjzpfí þtEkyg'daooedAÁmef\o½kyft&aumufESifY Oapä''d|d\ o½kyft&aumufudk uGJatmifcGJEdkifvsifcGJEdkifrnf/ odkYaomfvnf; ol\uGJjym;rIudk cGJjcm;jycsuf t½Snftvsm;BuD;onf tbd"r®mrsufvkH; odkYr[kwf tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:rsufvkH; yGifYNyD;olwdkYa½SUarSmufü tcsdK;tcsdwf tNrD;tarmufrwnfhbJ awmwpfvkH;awmifwpfvkH;pum;rsm;om jzpfaeayonf/

64/ tekyg'daooedAÁmefonf &[EÅmwdkY\edAÁmefþodkYjzpfvsif tEkyg'daooedAÁmef[lonfrSm tb,fenf;/]&[EÅm\edAÁmefjzpfonf}-[k ajzayrnf/þpum;twGuf ½Sif;&ef rsm;pGm½Sdayrnf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf

&[EÅmü ½kyfemrfrsm; ½Sdaeonf/ þ½kyfemrfrsm;onf avmuDw&m;rsm;vnf;jzpfaeonf/ avmuD½kyfemrfonf ]Oyg'geu©Em} w&m;? ]oOyg'daoow&m;} jzpfaeonf/ þodkY odaeaomaMumifY jzpfonf/

&[EÅm\edAÁmefonf tEkyg'daooedAÁmefjzpfaMumif; ½Sif;vif;vdkvsif txufygtcsufrsm;udk ½Sif;Edkifzdk Y vdkvmonf/ txufygwdkYudktb,fodkY½Sif;rnfenf;/ þjyóemudk½Sif;&ef atmufygtwdkif; yXr jyefar;&rnfè

Page 196: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

196 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]&[EÅmwdkY\½kyfemrfonf Oyg'geu©Em xdkufoavmç rxdkufoavm}/]avmuD½kyfemrfwdkif; Oyg'geu©Em xdkufoavm}/þtar;udk ajzolonf vG,fvG,fajzvsif ]avmuDcEmwdkif; Oyg

'geu©Em jzpfonf/ &[EÅmwdkY\ ½kyfemrfaom bmaomçnmaom avmuDw&m;jzpfvsif Oyg'geu©Emyifjzpf&rnf}-[k ajzayrnf/

xdkodkYajzoludk atmufygtwdkif; pOf;pm;p&mwpfckudk ay;&rnf/Oyg'gef½Sdaom w&m;[lonf-(1) Oyg'gefxdkufaom w&m;rsm;?(2) xdkOyg'gefxdkufaomw&m;wdkYESifY ,SOfazmf,SOfzuf w&m;rsm;?(3) xdkw&m;rsm;\ tusdK;w&m;rsm;-jzpfMuygonf/t&aumufvsif Oyg'gef½Sdaom avmuD½kyfemrftm;vkH; &ygrnf/

odkYaomfvnf; Oyg'gefw&m;ESifY Oyg'gefESifY,SOfzufw&m;? xdkw&m;\ tusdK;w&m;? þw&m;rsm;r[kwfaom w&m;onf avmuDw&m;yif jzpfaomfvnf; Oyg'gef½Sdaomw&m;-[k rqdkxdkufr[kwfygavm/

þw&m;½SdEdkifrnfavm-[k jyefar;zG,fawmY ½Sdygonf/]½Sdonf}-[k ajzygrnf/ &[EÅmyk*¾dKvfonf &[EÅmjzpfcsdefrSpí avm

uudk apmif;írMunfhawmYbJ jrifonfudk jrifonfhtwdkif;('da| 'd|rwåH)?Mum;onfudk Mum;onfhtwdkif;(okaw okwrwåH)? odkYr[kwf t½Sdudk t½Sdtwdkif;(,xmblw)odjrifí yvDyvm azmufazmufjyefjyef cHpm;jcif; r½Sday/

xdkYaMumifY BudKufjcif;çrkef;jcif;çrdkufjcif;rsm; tvsOf;r½Sdacs/xdkYaMumifY &[EÅmyk*¾dKvfü ]pGJvef;jcif;(Oyg'gefw&m;)}rsm;vnf; rjzpf

ay/ xdkYaMumifY &[EÅmyk*¾dKvfoEÅmefü xdkOyg'gefESifYtwljzpfaom ukodkvfçtukodkvfw&m;rsm;vnf; rjzpfawmYay/

xdkYaMumifY ukodkvfçtukodkvfw&m;rsm;\ tusdK;jzpfaom ½kyfemrfw&m;rsm;vnf; rjzpfawmYay/ &[EÅmjzpfonfrSpí b,fawmYrQ rjzpf

Page 197: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 197

awmYay/ xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; xdk&[EÅmyk*¾dKvfonf Mum;jcif;ç jrifjcif;çolemjyKjcif;ç ar;jref;oludk ajzMum;jcif;paomw&m;rsm; jzpfvsufyif ½Sdayonf/ xdk&[EÅmyk*¾dKvf\ xdkMum;jcif;ç jrifjcif;ç olemjyKjcif;ç ar;jref;onfudkajzMum;jcif;-paomw&m;rsm;onf tb,fodkYvsif ]Oyg'gef½Sdaom w&m;?Oyg'gefESifYywfoufaomw&m;} jzpfrnfenf;/

qdkvdkonfrSm-]&[EÅmyk*¾dKvfüvnf; avmuD½kyfemrfrsm; jzpfvsuf½Sdonf/ xdk½kyf

emrfrsm;ü Oyg'gefw&m;ESifY b,fodkYqufpyfrnfenf;}-[lí jzpfygonf/þokdYqdkvsif atmufygtwdkif; vG,fvG,f ajzavrnfvm;yif-]olYrSm Oyg'gef½SdvdkY Oyg'gefw&m;ac:jcif; r[kwf/ ol\½kyfemrfrsm;

udk olrsm;wdkYu pGJvef;í&aomaMumifY Oyg'gefac:jcif; jzpfonf}-[lownf;/

xdktqdkonf aumif;aomtqdk r[kwfay/ þtqdkom rSefuefcJYvsif avmukwå&mw&m;udkpGJvef;ol Oyg'gefjzpfolrsm; trsm;tjym; ½Sdayonf/ þpum;udkvnf; acsyvdkrnfvm;yif/

]edAÁmefudkpGJjcif;onf Oyg'gef r[kwf? ormqEç bmnmponfjzifY]-jzpfonf/ Ak'toQifuyif þodkY tcGifYray;ay/

]edAÁmefudk igY[m-[kBuHolonf edAÁmefudk a½SU½IESpfouf\}-[k a[mayonf/ xdkYaMumifY edAÁmefudkpGJjcif;udk Oyg'gefr[kwf[k racsyoifYay/

xdkYaMumifY Oyg'gef\tm½kHjzpfaomaMumifY &[EÅm\½kyfemrfudkOyg'gef½Sdaomw&m;tjzpf aumuf,lrnfqdkvsif edAÁmefudktvGwfray;bJaumuf,l&zdkY ½Sdayonf/ þodkY raumufEdkifvsif Oyg'gef½Sdaom w&m;t&&[EÅm\½kyfemrfudk raumufoifYay/

þodkYraumufoifYvsif-

Page 198: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

198 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

avmuD½kyfemrfwdkif; ]Oyg'geu©Em rzGJUxdkuf}[k t"dyÜg,fopf xGufay:vmygonf/

þt"dyÜg,fopfonf w&m;enf;vrf; rusoavm/ tu,fíw&m;enf;vrf;usvsif &[EÅmyk*¾dKvfonf oOyg'daoo&[EÅm r[kwfaMumif; ½Sif;vif;ygonf/ &[EÅmyk*¾dKvf\edAÁmefonf ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}tppftrSef jzpfygonf/

txufyg pOf;pm;p&mwifjycsufrsm; tu,fí enf;vrf;rus-[kqdkvsif tb,fodkY rusygoenf;/

]&[EÅmyk*¾dKvf\ ur®Z½kyfESifY jrifjcif;çMum;jcif;paom 0dyguf0dnmOfrsm;onf Oyg'gefukefNyD;jzpfaom &[EÅmjzpfNyD;csdefüjyKvkyfaom ]uH\tusdK;}rsm; r[kwfMu/ &[EÅmjzpfNyD;csdefü tusdK;udkjzpfapwwfaom uH[lonfudkyif rjyKvkyfawmYaomaMumifY xdk&[EÅmyk*¾dKvf\ oP²mefü½Sdaeaomur®Z½kyfrsm;ESifY jrifjcif;çMum;jcif;paom 0dyguf0dnmOfrsm;onf &[EÅmrjzpfrD Oyg'gef½SdpOfu uHrsm;\ tusdK;rsm;jzpfonf/

xdkYaMumifY &[EÅm\ rsufapYçem;ponfESifY jrifpdwfçMum;pdwf ponfonf Oyg'gef\tusdK;w&m; odkYr[kwf Oyg'geu©Emw&m;[kyif ac:oifYonf/ xdkYaMumifY &[EÅmrsm;\ rsufapYçem;-ponfESifY jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfponfrsm;udk Oyg'geu©Emr[kwf}-[k wifjycsufonf enf;vrf;rus}-[kqdkp&m½Sdayonf/

þodkYqdkolonf y&rw¬½kyfemrfjzpfaom ]uHç0dyguf}wdkYqufpyfykHudkrodrjrifbJ Mu;zl;em;0txifjzifY ajymqdkjcif; jzpfonf/ þoltm; þtqdkjyKvdkvsif atmufygjyóemudk ajzapNyD;rS þtqdkudk qdkvdkao;vsiftav;teufqdkzdkY wdkufwGef;oifYayonf/ ,if;jyóemrSm-

]t[dwfukov0dygufjzpfaom jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfponfonf umrukodkvfuH\ y0wådtusdK; jzpfonf/ þtusdK;ESifYtaMumif;onf b,fodkY

Page 199: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 199

qufpyfaeoenf;}/ &[EÅmjzpfaeol\ jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfponfü umrukodkvfuHrsm; r½SdaomaMumifY ,if;-jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfponfjzpf&ef umrukodkvfuHonf &[EÅmrjzpfrDa½S;rS jzpf&m\/ xdkodkYjzpfvsif ]uH}wnf;[laom-taMumif;ESifY jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfpaom-tusdK;onf ]umvjcm;vsuf}½Sd\/ ]Xme}vnf; jcm;aumif;jcm;Edkif\/ þodkY umvjcm;vsuf qufoG,frIonf tb,fodkYaomt&mjzifY qufoG,fygoenf;/

þae&mü ]ur®0doa,m tpdaEÅa,sm}-[laom rEÅmefudk½GwfírajzbJ? jiif;qdkrnfqdkvsif þrEÅmeft& jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfpaom tusdK;0dygufrsm;ESifY umrukodkvfuHwnf;[laom taMumif;uHrsm; qufoG,fonf-[laomt&mvnf; t½kyfodrf;cH&oifYonf/ odkYr[kwf tjiif;ckHcH&rIonfvnf; xnfhoifYonf/

]uH}t&mjzpfí ]rBuHtyf}qdkvsif xdkt&mvnf; uHt&mjzpfí rBuHtyfaomaMumifY ]r,loifYawmY}-[k qdkvdkygonf/ þodkYqdkvsif þt&mum; BuHxm;aomt&mr[kwf? bk&m;a[mjzpfonf-[k qdkaumif; qdkrnf/

þtqdkudk atmufygtwdkif; jiif;qdk&rnf/]þt&monfvnf; bk&m;ra[m/ umrukodkvfuHonf xdkuHESifY

umvjcm;NyD;aom y0wådtcgü jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfpaom ]t[dwfukodkvf(0g) tusdK;0dyguf}rsm;udk jzpfaponf-[kvnf;aumif;/ xdk]t[dwfukodkvf0dyguf}rsm;onf ]umrukodkvf}aMumifYom jzpfonf-[kvnf;aumif;/bk&m;oQif wdkuf½dkufra[mbJ ½Sd&rnf? y&rw¬avmuudk t&aumufrSaeí a[movdkvdk ykH[efomvsif ½Sdvdku ½Sdaernf}/

þtqkH;tjzwfudk ½dk;om;olwdkY\wm0eftjzpf aqG;aEG;rIrS >cif;csefcJYvdkonf/

y&rw¬w&m;wdkY\ aMumif;usdK;qufoG,frIonf ]{uwå} jzpf&efvnf; taMumif;ESifYtusdK;wdkYtMum;ü umvjcm;írjzpfaMumif; txuf

Page 200: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

200 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

ae&mrsm;ü t½Snfta0;yif wifjy avQmufvJcJYygNyD/ tu,fíom þavQmufvJcsufrsm;taeESifY rSefuefrIS raoGrznf ½SdcJYvsif ,aeY tbd"r®m\ o½kyfrsm;onf trSefrS aoGznfvsuf½Sd&rnf/

Oyrmtm;jzifY atmufygwdkY jzpfonf-(1) Zmwdonf y#doaE rjzpfEdkif/ xdkYaMumifY okwåefygVdawmfrsm;

ü Zmwdae&mudk y#doaE[laom pum;vkH;jzifY okH;EIef;a[mxm;NyD; r½SddEdkif/

(2) avmukwå&muHonf ur®Z½kyfudk rjzpfapbJ r½SdEdkif/ tu,fí rjzpfbJ½Sdonfqdkvsif ur®Z½kyf[lonf &[EÅmwdkY\ rsufapYçem;-ponf rjzpfbJ½Sdonf/

þodkYaom tbd"r®mo½kyfrsm;jzpfonfh þt&mrsm;onf tb,faMumifY trSefrS aoGznf&rnfenf;/ uHESifY0dyguftMum;ü umvrsm;pGmtjcm;cHae&aomaMumifY uHESifY0dygufwdkY\ tusdK;qufjcif; rjzpfEdkifawmYí jzpfonf/

&[EÅm\ rsufapYçem;paom ur®Z½kyfrsm;ESifY jrifpdwfç Mum;pdwfpaom 0dyguf0dnmOfrsm; Oyg'geu©Em rjzpf-[k tqdkudk enf;vrf;rus[kxifvdkvsif y&rw¬½kyfemrfjzpfaom uHESifY0dygufwdkY\ qufoG,fykH apYpyfpGmodNyD;rS xifapoifYonf/

xdkodkYod½SdNyD;jcif;r½Sdvsif &[EÅmwdkY\ rsufapYçem;paom ur®Z½kyfrsm;ESifY jrifpdwfçMum;pdwfpaom 0dygufemru©Emrsm;onf xdk&[EÅmyk*¾dKvfrsm;ü Oyg'gefw&m; vkH;0 t½Sif;tuif;tjywf r½SdNyDjzpfaomaMumifY Oyg'geu©Emr[kwfaom avmuDyOöu©Emw&m;wdkY jzpfonf-[k vufcHEdkifoifYayonf/ þodkYqdkvsif-

]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}onf &[EÅmwdkY\edAÁmef jzpfygonf/[kwfygonf/ þedAÁmefonf b,fenf;ESifYrQ Oyg'geft<uif;½Sdaom-

Page 201: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 201

edAÁmef r[kwfyg/ aomwmyefedAÁmefonf umrwPSmpaom Oyg'gefrsm;<uif;ygao;onf/ ou'g*grf\edAÁmefonfvnf; El;nHhodrfarGUaom umrwPSmpaom Oyg'gef usefygao;onf/ tem*grf\edAÁmefonfvnf; ½kyg½lyb0wPSmrsm;jzpfaom Oyg'gefrsm; usefygao;onf/

&[EÅm\edAÁmefum; bmOyg'gefrQ t<uif;tusef r½SdawmYyg/xdkYaMumifY &[EÅmwdkY\edAÁmefonf Oyg'gef[lorQ wpfckrQ t<uif;

tusef r½SdawmYaomaMumifY ]oOyg'daoo}[kac:aom Oyg'gef<uif;aomedAÁmef rjzpfEdkifyg/ ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}om jzpfEdkifygawmYonf/

xdkYaMumifY ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}onf cEmemrf½kyfcsKyfNyD;aemufrSjzpfEdkifaom edAÁmef tvsOf;r[kwfawmYyg/ þodkYr[kwfaMumif;udk wpfenf;tm;jzifYvnf; em;vnfp&m ½Sdygao;onf/ ,if;rSm-

]0dyguftAsmuw cEmrsm;onf ]y,ftyfaomw&m;rsm; r[kwfjcif;} jzpfygonf/ ]y,faumif;aomw&m;rsm; r[kwfjcif;} jzpfygonf/y,faumif;aomw&m; r[kwf? y,f&efoifYaomw&m; r[kwf? y,fí&aomw&m; r[kwf-[k qdkvdkygonf/ rsufapYpaom ½kyfcEmrsm;ESifY jrifpdwfpaom 0dygufcEmrsm;onf w&m;jzifYy,ftyfaom udavomrsm; r[kwfMu/ y,fíjzpfEdkifaom udavomrsm; r[kwfMu-[k qdkvdkygonf/

þodkYjzpfvsif xdkcEmemrf½kyfrsm; b,fr*fjzifY y,frnfenf;/ y,fp&m r*fvnf; r½Sdyg/ xdk0dyguf½kyfemrfrsm; y,fíaum aysmufygrnfavm/aysmufonf-[kvnf; r½Sdyg/ ]½Sdonf}[k qdkolrsm; ]{upöoów} pdwåZ0g'Drsm;om jzpfygonf/

olwdkYonf ]ykxkZOfaoNyD;vsif qufjzpfonf? &[EÅmaoNyD;vsifawmY rjzpf}[k ]tcsdKUjzpf? tcsdKUrjzpf}-[k t,l½SdMuaomolwdkY jzpfygonf/olwdkYonf ]pdwåZ0g'D}rsm; jzpfMuygonf/ tu,frodbJ pdwfxiftwdkif;wGufcsuf&rf;qí ajymolrsm;om jzpfMuygonf/

Page 202: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

202 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYaMumifY olwdkYonf ]ykxkZOfaovsif raysmuf}[laom pdwåZudkpGJí ]&[EÅmaovsif emrf½kyfaysmufonf}-[k 'kwd,pdwåZwpfrsdK; jzpfjyefygonf/ aysmufonf-[k½SdaMumif; ajymqdkpum;onf þodkYyif trSef r[kwfyg/

]0dyguf½kyfemrf}onf y,fí aysmufEdkifaomw&m; r[kwfyg/ xdkYaMumifY y,fí aysmufonf-[kvnf; tvsOf;r½Sdyg/ aysmufcsifvsif olYzmomaysmufygrnf/ tjcm;taMumif;rsm;aMumifY aysmufonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

odkYaomfvnf; xdkaysmufjcif;udkvnf; ]aysmufonf}[k þ-]opömt&m}ü ajymp&mpum; t&mr0ifyg/ þ-]0dyguf½kyfemrf}wdkY\ taysmufonf odkYr[kwf t<uif;rJYjzpfap csKyftqkH;rsm;onf ]aysmufonfçqkH;onf}-[k ajymp&mpum;rsm;tjzpf t&m0ifaompum;rsm; tvsOf;yif r[kwfMuyg/

]0dyguf½kyfemrf}wdkY\ t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;rIonf ]taAÁm[m&Du} jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf vlrINidrf;csrf;a&;[laomopömESifY rqdkifaomaMumifY jzpfygonf/ xdkYaMumifY 0dygufemrf½kyfrsm;t<uif;rJY csKyfqkH;aumif; csKyfqkH;rnf/ odkYaomfvnf; þcsKyfqkH;rIonfr*fESifYy,fowf csKyfqHk;apvdkufaomaMumifY csKyfqkH;jcif;vnf; r[kwf/r*fESifYy,fowfp&m udavomwdkY\ t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;vnf; r[kwf/þodkYaom taMumif;rsm;aMumifY vkH;0 t&d,mopömr0ifaompum;odkYr[kwf edAÁmefESifY vm;vm;rQrqdkifaom pum;rQom jzpfygonf/

þtaMumif;aMumifYvnf; tEkyg'daooedAÁmefonf 0dyguf½kyfemrfwdkY\ t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;udkac:jcif; rjzpfEdkifyg/ 0dyguf½kyfemrfwdkY\t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;onf bmrQ ajymp&mr½Sdaompum; ]taAÁm[m&Dupum;}om jzpfonf/ tb,faMumifYqdkaomf xdk0dyguf½kyfemrfwdkY\ csKyfqkH;rIonf tb,folücH&aom csKyfqkH;rIjzpfonf? xdkolü xdkodkY 0dyguf½kyfemrfwdkYtcsKyfqkH;cH&aomaMumifY t<uif;tjzpf tb,fodkY½Sdonf-[k b,fodkY ajymp&m½Sdao;oenf;/

Page 203: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 203

csKyfqkH;NyD;onfhaemufü tcsKyfqkH;cH&ol[lí uwåm;qufvufíwnf½SdraeawmYaomaMumifY ajymp&mr½Sdaompum; ]taAÁm[m&Du}-jzpfonf[k qdkvdkygonf/ opömESifY rqdkifaompum;ESifY teufwlygonf/

b,fcsKyfqkH;rIrsm;ürl csKyfqkH;NyD;aemuf þcsKyfqkH;rI\ tusdK;tjrwfudk qufcHoluwåm;½Sdoenf;? ar;zG,f½Sdyg\/ BudKufrIçrdkufrIçrkef;rI t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;onf ,if;odkY tcsKyfqkH;cH&aom yk*¾dKvfvufusef ½Sdygonf/xdkolü 'ku©Nidrf;jcif;tusdK;&onf-[kvnf; ajymp&mpum; usefygonf/

xdkYaMumifY udavomwdkY\ csKyfqkH;jcif;onf opöm0ifygonf/0dyguf½kyfemrfwdkYcsKyfqkH;jcif;? t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif; rjzpfay:awmY

atmifyif tEkyÜg'csKyfjzifY csKyfqkH;jcif;/ þcsKyfqkH;jcif;onf opömr0ifyg/ajymp&mpum; t&mr0ifawmYyg/ ]taAÁm[m&Du} jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY tEkyg'daooedAÁmefonf &[EÅmwdkY\ Oyg'geft<uif;r½SdawmYaom edAÁmef jzpfygownf;/

65/ oOyg'daooedAÁmefonf atmuft&d,mwdkY\edAÁmefxdkYaMumifY ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}onf tb,fenf;-[laom ar;

cGef;\tajzudkvnf; edAÁme'DyeDü ajymMum;ouJYodkY rjzpfEdkif/ þü edAÁme'DyeDwGif pmrSm;ovdk ½Sdaeonf/ ]av;Budrfav;vD}-[kvnf; ajymonf?]udavomtusef}-[kvnf; ajymonf/

tu,fí edAÁme'DyeDü av;r*fav;zdkvfjzifY a&muftyfaomedAÁmefudk ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}-qdkcJYvsif rrSefEdkif/ atmufr*fatmufzdkvfokH;ckwdkYjzifY a&muftyfaom edAÁmefqdkvsif þtqdkonf rSefuefaomtqdk jzpfonf/]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}onf atmufr*fçatmufzdkvfokH;ckwdkY\ tm½kHjzpfaomedAÁmef jzpfonf/

Page 204: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

204 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

edAÁme'DyeDvnf; tu,fí þtwdkif; atmufr*fatmufzdkvfokH;ckwdkY\ tm½kHjzpfaom edAÁmefrsm;udk ]oOyg'daoo}-[kqdkcJYvsif edAÁme'DyeDütjypfwpfck xGufvmonf/ ,if;um;è

]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}udk 0dyguf½kyfemrfwdkY\ t<uif;rJYcsKyfqkH;jcif;}-[k ,lxm;aomaMumifY pwkw¬r*fçzdkvfwdkY\ tm½Hkjzpfaom edAÁmefonf]oOyg'daooESifY tEkyg'daoo}-xdkESpfrsdK;wdkYrS tvGwfjzpfaom edAÁmef-jzpfay&m\/ þodkYrjzpfoifYaomaMumifYvnf; tjypfrvGwf&m/

þodkY tvGwfvnf; rxm;cJYavmufay/ þae&mü trSm;yif jzpf&m\/

ol\ y&rw¬'DyeDusrf;ü ]oOyg'daooedAÁmefonf udavomedAÁmef}jzpfonf? ]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}onf ]cEedAÁmefjzpfonf}-[k ½Sif;½Sif;vif;vif; azmfjyxm;aomaMumifY jzpfonf/

þodkY av;r*fav;zdkvfvkH;wdkY\ tm½kHjzpfaom edAÁmefonf ]oOyg'daooedAÁmef}-[k ,lcJYvsif rrSefEdkifay/ txufrSqdkcJYonfhtwdkif; pwkw¬r*fçzdkvfwdkY\tm½kHjzpfaom edAÁmefonf ]tEkyg'daoo} jzpfaomaMumifYwnf;/

]tEkyg'daooedAÁmef}udk ]cEedAÁmef}[k ,lqjcif;ü tjypfrsm;onfeuf½Idif;rIBuD;rm;vSaMumif; pm½IolwdkY oabmaygufcJYavmufygNyD/

þrQ ]oOyg'daooESifY tEkyg'daoo}tcGJtwGuf wifjycsufjzifYaumuEk'fAdrmefuav;\ tpdwftydkif;uav;wpfckudk qdwfzJYjycJYygNyD/

þaumuEk'fAdrmefonf a½Tom;Adrmefavm? a½TrIefusJxm;aom½THUap;Adrmefavm-[lonfudk pm½Ioludk,fwdkif qkH;jzwf&efom wm0ef½SdygawmYonf/

Page 205: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 205

tcef;(6)

oknwçtedrdwåçtyÜPd[dwedAÁmefpdppfokH;oyfcsuf

Page 206: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

206 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 207: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 207

tcef;(6)oknwçtedrdwåçtyÜPd[dwedAÁmef pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

66/ oknwedAÁmef ponfqufvufívnf; þAdrmefuav;\wpfae&mudk ajymif;í qdwf

zJYNyD; wifjyvdkygao;onf/ a½Tom;avm? ½THUap;avm aocsmwyftyf odEdkif&ef wwd,oufaoxlcsuftjzpf qufvufwifjyygrnf/ ,if;rSm-

]oknwçtedrdwåçtyÜPd[dwedAÁmefrsm;qdkif&m pum;rsm;} jzpfygonf/ edAÁme'DyeDü ]oknw}tp½Sdaom edAÁmef\trnfwdkYudk ]edAÁmef*kPfudkazmfjyxm;aomtrnf} odkYr[kwf ]edAÁmef\ t&nftcsif;udkjyaomtrnf}-tjzpf wifjyxm;ayonf/ wifjyxm;ykHrSm-

]oknwedAÁmef}[lonf ]yvdaAm"cyfodrf;wdkYrS uif;Nidrf;qdwfNidrfaomw&m;} jzpfonf/ ]tedrdwåedAÁmef}[lonf ]oP²mefedrdwf t&dyftoGifxifrIcyif;rS uif;½Sif;aom w&m;} jzpfonf/ ]tyÜPd[dwedAÁmef}[lonf]awmifYwjcif;cyfodrf;rS uif;Nidrf;aomw&m;} jzpfonf}/ þodkY jzpfygonf/

]oknw}tp½Sdaom edAÁmef\trnfrsm;onf edAÁmef\ tmum&ab' trnfrsm; jzpfMuygonf/ ]tmum&}onf *kPfavm? ]tmum&ab'}onf ]*kPab'}avm/

tmum&udk jrefrmjyefxm;aom ]tjcif;t&m}[laompum;onf]*kPfjzpf&ef roifYavsmfay/ ]toGiftjyiftajctae}[líom jzpf&ef oifYavsmfygonf/

]edAÁmef\ t&nftcsif;jypum;} qdkonfxuf ]edAÁmef\ toGiftjyif tajctaejypum;} jzpfzdkYrSm ydkíqDavsmfygrnf/ pum;vkH;udk jiif;qdkjcif;onf rxda&mufvSyg/ o'gynmorm;rsm;onf (0g) o'gwwfaomyk*¾dKvfrsm;onf pum;vkH;ukd rdrdtokH;jyKvdk&modkYa&mufatmif qGJoGif;Edkif

Page 208: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

208 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

aom t&nftcsif; ½SdMuonfcsnf; jzpfMuygonf/xdkYaMumifY þpum;udk t½Snftvsm; rqdkawmYyg/]t&nftcsif;}qdkaompum;ESifY ]toGiftjyif}[laompum;rsm;

jcm;em;\çrjcm;em;-[k jiif;qdkvdkolrsm; jiif;qdkp&m jzpfaeygrnf/þpum;\teufrsm; wu,f jcm;çrjcm; aemufxm;í pma&;ol

tvdktm;jzifY þteufrsm;udk þodkYowfrSwfNyD; qdkygrnfè]t&nftcsif;}-[lonf ]pGrf;&nfowåd}jzpfNyD;? ]toGiftjyif}-[lonfrSm xdk-]pGrf;&nfowådrsm; jzpfay:&mt&m} jzpfygonf/odkYr[kwf ]*kPf}ESifY ]*kaP;} jzpfygonf/þ]oknw}paom emrnfrsm;onf *kPfemrnfrsm; r[kwf/

*kaP;emrnfrsm; jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/ *kPfjypum;rsm; r[kwf?]*kaP;jypum;}jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkaMumif; wifjyaejcif; jzpfygonf/ edAÁme'DyeDonf ]oknw}paomtrnfudk ]*kPfjypum;}tjzpf wifjyxm;ygonf/

edAÁme'DyeDwnfaqmufol\ tjcm;usrf;pmjzpfaom ]y&rw¬'DyeD}wGif þedAÁmefae&m\ tzGifYüvnf;-

]tmum& aba'emwd wd0d"ó oknwm'duó *kPaum|mwó aba'e}-[k wifjyNyD; ½Sdaeygonf/þy&rw¬'DyeDusrf;ü *kPfjypum;tjzpf wifjyaMumif;udk tus,f

w0ifY ½Sif;csufrsm;ü xifvif;ygonf/ oknwedAÁmeftwGuf ½Sif;csufüocFww&m;rsm; yvdaAm"BuD;rm;ykH? tjrwfqkH;t&[wåzdkvfyif yvdaAm"rsm;ykHudk wifjyNyD; xdkrSrNidrf;jcif;ESifY,SOfvsuf ocFw\ajymif;jyeftcsdK;jzpfaom tocFwjzpfaomedAÁmefudk *kPfwifjyygonf/

Page 209: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 209

67/ oknwedAÁmeft&aumuftrSef]oknwedAÁmef}[lonf yvdaAm"rsm;½Sdaom ocFww&m;rsm;\

ajymif;jyeftcsdK;jzpfonf-[k wifjyjcif;onf edAÁmef\tjcif;t&m tmum&udk jyonf rnfygrnfavm/

xdkwifjycsufudk ,ckzwfNyD;ygNyD/ edAÁmef\ oknwmum&-[laomoknjzpfjcif;tjcif;t&mudk uREkfyfwdkY b,fodkY em;vnfaeMuNyDenf;/

þodkY em;vnfaeMuNyD r[kwfygavm/]edAÁmef}[lonf ocFww&m;rsm;uJYodkY aMumifYMur½Sdowwf}-[lí

jzpfonf/ þt&monf ]tmum&}-rjzpfbJ ]*kP}om-jzpfaeonf r[kwfygavm/

]edAÁmef\*kPf}udk rjybJ edAÁmef\*kaP;udkjyrS ]tmum&}jzpfrnf/xdkYaMumifY edAÁmefudk oknwmum&jzpfykHjy þpum;rsm;onf rrSefEdkif-[kqdkvdkygonf/ yvdaAm"Nidrf;jcif;? uif;qdwfjcif;onf edAÁmef\ oknwmum&r[kwf-[k wifjyvdkjcif; jzpfygonf/

]yvdaAm"rsm; uif;Nidrf;qdwfNidrf;jcif;}udk edAÁmef\ ]oknwmum&}-jzpfonf[k qdkjcif;rSm edAÁmeftay:ü tjrif a0oDaeí jzpfygonf/ tb,fodkY tjrifa0oDaeoenf; qdkaomf edAÁmefudk udk,fwdkifod(t0aAm")tjzpfrodbl;onfudk xnfhra&wGufbJ BuHod(tEkaAm")tjzpf tavsmfodrSmyifedAÁmef\ tajctaetjcif;t&m]*kaP;jzpfaom ]tmum&}udk rodbl;ao;jcif; jzpfygonf/ þodkY a0oDaeaMumif;udk edAÁmefESifYcEm wpyfwnf;jzpfatmif pyfrjyEdkifjcif;ü oufaownfayrnf/

[kwfygonf/ yvdaAm"uif;Nidrf;jcif;udk edAÁmef\oknwmum&-[k qdkvsif cEmESifYedAÁmef\ wpyfwnf;jzpfykHukd rjyqdkEdkifbJ ½Sd&ayrnf/þae&mü ]pyfEdkifrSmyg}-[k xifvdkol ½Sdaumif;-½Sdayrnf/ tb,fodkY pyfrnfenf;-[k jyefar;vsif pyfjyayrnf/

Page 210: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

210 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

]edAÁmefonf yvdaAm"rsm; Nidrf;jcif;jzpfí ocFwonf rNidrf;jcif;jzpfonf/ þü Nidrf;jcif;ESifYrNidrf;jcif;onf tMum;tvyfr½Sd? wpyfwnf;jzpfonf/ Nidrf;jcif;e,fonf rNidrf;jcif;e,f\ wpfzufwGif½Sdonf/ ydkufqHjym;\acgif;ESifYyef;uJYodkY ESpfck jcm;em;aomfvnf; ydkufqHrSm wjym;wnf;jzpfonf/þodkYpyfonf}-[k qdkvdkaumif; qdkvdkayrnf/ þtqdk rrSefay/

68/ cEmESifYedAÁmefonf tNydKifjyKírpyfEdkifcEmESifYedAÁmef\tpyfonf acgif;ESifYyef;pyfenf;rsdK; rjzpfEdkif/ tb,f

aMumifYqdkaomf acgif;ESifYyef;onf NydKifEdkifonf/ acgif;vnf;½Sdonf? yef;vnf;½Sdonf/ þodkY NydKifEdkifonf/ xdkYaMumifY ydkufqHwpfjym;wnf;ü xdkbufçþbufjym;vsuf pyfjcif;rsdK;onf cEmESifYedAÁmef\pyfjcif; r[kwfay/

cEmESifYedAÁmef\pyfjcif;rSm rNydKif&ay/ ]cEmvnf;½Sdonf? edAÁmefvnf;½Sdonf-[k rqdk&}-[lí odapvdkygonf/ cEm½SdoltwGuf edAÁmefr½Sd&/edAÁmef½SdoltwGuf cEmr½Sd&-[lí jzpfygonf/

cE¨mESifYedAÁmefpyfjcif;onf ]opfikwfudk nOfhtcg wapäxifolüaeYtcsdefa&mufaomtcg wapär[kwf? opfikwf[kodjcif;uJYodkY jzpfonf/þü opfikwfESif Ywapäonf rNydKifay/ wapäjzpfcsdefü opfikwfr½Sd?opfikwfjzpfcsdefü wapär½Sd/ þodkYvsif ]þt&monfyif xdkt&mjzpfonf}-txd pyfjcif;onf ]cEmESifYedAÁmef}wdkY\ wpyfwnf;jzpfjcif; jzpfonf/

tu,fí edAÁmeftay:ü tjrifa0oDraevsif edAÁmef\ ]oknwmum&}onf ]edAÁmefESifYcEmwdkY\ wpyfwnf;jzpfaom tjcif;t&mudk jyqdkaompum;}-jzpfaMumif; tvG,fwulyif odjrifayrnf/

]edAÁmefESifYcEmwdkY wpyfwnf;jzpfykHonf tb,fodkYvsif oknwmum& jzpfoenf;}- þodkYar;zG,f ½Sdayonf/ tajzonf atmufygtwdkif;jzpfonfè

Page 211: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 211

]oknwedAÁmef}onf Oyg'geu©Emrsm;udk tewåtjzpf½IMunhfolwdkYqdkufa&mufaomedAÁmef jzpfonf/ þü cEm[lonf y&rwfw&m;rsm;\tcsdefokH;rsdK;? ae&mav;rsdK;? toGiftjyifav;rsdK;-aygif;wpfq,fYwpfrsdK;wdkYjzifY jym;aeaomtjcif;t&m jzpfonf/

wzef tewåonf ]ae&mav;rsdK;udkaysmufatmif ½IMunfhcsuf}jzpfonf/ þodkY½Ijrifcsuft& Oyg'geu©Emonf ae&mtm;jzifY trSefr½Sdonfudk odjrifcHoGm;&onf/ xdkYaMumifY Oyg'geu©Emonf wpfq,fYwpfaxGrjym;Edkif jzpfNyD;? Oyg'geu©EmtjzpfrS usqkH;onf/ Oyg'geu©EmtjzpfrSusqkH;jcif;onf ]edAÁmef}jzpfonf/ þedAÁmefonf ]oknwedAÁmef}-jzpfonf/

þonfyif ]oknwmum&} jzpfygonf/þt&mudk tenf;i,f qufí½Sif;ygOD;rnf/ykxkZOfyk*¾dKvfonf Oyg'geu©Emrsm;udk ½IMunfhaomtcg olwdkY\

todÓPfjzifY Oyg'geu©EmudkazmufcGJ&ef tcJtuyf ½SdaeMuayonf/avmuü Ak'toQifonf ]tv,fvrf;tawG;tac:}udk xlaxmif

NyD; wifjyvdkufaomtcg xdkykxkZOfyk*¾dKvfonf Oyg'geu©Emü ]twåESifYtwåed,owåd} r½SdykHudk toifMum;cHcGifYudk &½Sdavonf/

xdkykxkZOfonf xdkoifMum;csufjzifY rdrdçolwyg; ESpfOD;om;wdkY\Oyg'geu©Emudk udk,fwdkif avYvmuGif;qif;í ½IMunfhavonf/ xdktcgOyg'geu©E¨monf wpfcsdefuxifouJYodkY ]twGif;½Sdonfçtjyif½Sdonf?teD;½Sdonfçta0;½Sdonf}-[k tESpfom& ½Ijrif½SmazGír& jzpfvmonf/

qdkvdkonfrSm-xdktcsdefü ]ykxkZOfonf Oyg'geu©Emudk a½S;tcsdefuodcJYonfESifY

ajymif;jyeftod jzpfay:vm&ef OD;wnfvmonf}-[k jzpfonf/ xdkYaemuf]ajymif;jyefjrifvmonf/ þOyg'geu©Emonf teD;çta0;ç twGif;çtjyif½Sdaomt&mrsm; r[kwfygvm;}-[lí jrifvmjcif; jzpfonf/

Page 212: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

212 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þodkY Oyg'geu©Emudk teD;çta0;çtwGif;çtjyiftjzpf jrif&mrS]teD;çta0;çtwGif;çtjyifr½Sdaomt&mygvm;}-[lí ]om&}r[kwfaomtm;jzifY ajymif;jyefjrifqJ tcsdeftxdyk*¾dKvfonf ]ykxkZOfyk*¾dKvf} jzpfonf/

xdkodkYajymif;jyefvefoGm;rIaMumifY ,if;Oyg'geu©E¨mrsm;tay:tmv,(wG,fwmrI)xm;jcif;rsm; aysmufysufoGm;jcif;aMumifY ]Nidrf;at;jcif;} jzpfonf/ ykxkZOfyk*¾dKvfonf þNidrf;csrf;jcif;odkY qdkufa&mufcsdefüykxkZOfr[kwfawmYbJ b0ajymif; cHoGm;&onf/

b0ajymif;ykHudk tenf;i,f wifjyygrnf/ Oyg'geu©Emü eD;ça0;çwGif;çjyifrsm; ½Sdaom ]om&}r[kwf-[k ykxkZOftjzpf aemufqkH;tod jzpfonf/ ,if;tod\t½SdefjzpfaompdwfESifY ]Oyg'geu©Emonf tESpfom&½Sdaomw&m;r[kwf}-[laom tm½kHwdkY qkHpnf;wdkufqdkifonf/ ,if;wdkufqdkifjcif;ESifYtwl ]Oyg'geu©Emonf tESpfom&t½Sdr[kwf}-[laom today:vmonf/ ,if;tod\b0rSm ykxkZOfb0\ tjcm;rJYb0 jzpfonf/

þae&mü ykxkZOfr[kwfawmYaom þyk*¾dKvf\tm½HkjzpfaomedAÁmefonf tjcif;t&mtm;jzifY ]oknw}jzpfonf/ þedAÁmefonf]oknwmum&edAÁmef} jzpfonf-[k qdkvdkygonf/

[kwfygonf/ þedAÁmefonf Oyg'geu©E¨m\ ae&mav;rsdK;rSuif;qdwfjcif;aMumifY Oyg'geu©Em rrnfEdkifawmYbJ edAÁmefjzpf&ykH tjcif;t&m tmum&udk azmfjyaomaMumifY odkYr[kwf tjcif;t&mtmum&½SdaeaomaMumifY ]oknwedAÁmef} jzpfygonf/ odkYr[kwf ]oknwjzpfaomedAÁmef} jzpfygonf/

Page 213: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 213

69/ tedrdwåESifY tyÜPd[dwedAÁmef t&aumuftrSefþodkYyif edAÁmef\oknwpaom tmum&[lonfrSm edAÁmef\ yvd

aAm"rSuif;jcif;paom *kPfudkqdkaompum; r[kwfyg/ edAÁmef\ cEmESifYwjcm;pDr[kwfaom tjcif;t&mudkjyaompum; jzpfonf/

tmum&tm;jzifY edAÁmefokH;rsdK;½Sd&onfrSmvnf; cEmü ]umvçXmeçya,m*}-[laom tydkif;okH;ydkif;½SdaomaMumifY jzpfonf/ xdktydkif;okH;ydkif;udkvu©PmokH;csufjzifY zsufqD;&ygonf/

,if;okH;ckrSm edAÁmef\ tmum&okH;ckwdkY jzpfMuygonf/]tedpövu©Pm}jzifY Oyg'geu©Em\ ]tcsdefydkif;}rsm;udk zsufygonf/

xdkodkYzsufaomaMumifY Oyg'geu©Em ysufokOf;oGm;rIonf ]edAÁmef}jzpfygonf/,if;edAÁmefonf tedpöjzifY Oyg'geu©Emudk zsufí&aomedAÁmef jzpfaomaMumifY ]tedrdwåtjcif;t&m½Sdaom edAÁmef} odkYr[kwf ]tedrdwåmum&edAÁmef}jzpfygonf/

]'ku©}jzifY Oyg'geu©Em\ toGifoP²mefav;rsdK;udk zsufygonf/xdkodkY tzsufcH&aomaMumifY Oyg'geu©E¨monf tEkyg'geu©E¨mjzpfNyD;]edAÁmef}-jzpf&onf/ ,if;edAÁmefonf ]tyÜPd[dwedAÁmef} jzpfonf/ 'ku©jzifYOyg'geu©Emudk zsufí&aomedAÁmef jzpfaomaMumifYjzpfonf/

þae&mü ]edrdwå}ESifY ]yPd[dw}wdkY\ o½kyfudk uGJEdkifcJcGifY ½Sdonf/]edrdwå}[lonf cEm\ cEmtjzpfwnfaqmuf&mü tpdwftydkif;

jzpfaom ]ckçaemufçaemif(ypöKyÜefçtwdwfçtem*wf)}[laom tcsdefrsm;udkqdkjcif; jzpfonf/ edAÁme'DyeDrSmuJYodkY ]oP²mefçedrdwfç t&dyfçtoGif}[lívkH;axG;íaumuf,l&ef taMumif;r½Sd/

]edrdwf}[laom jrefrmpum;ü ]edrdwfaumufonf}qdkaom pum;\teufuJYodkY jzpfonf/ þpum;ü ]edrdwf}[laom ]tcsdef}udk a[monf/]twdwfaumufonf}-[louJYodkY jzpfonf/

Page 214: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

214 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

þpum;ü twdwfaumuf,lykHrSm ]twdwfrSykHESifY ypöKyÜeftjzpfudkwdkif;wmí tem*wftwGuf t½IH;tjrwfwGufjyjcif;} jzpfonf/ ]Oyg'geu©Emjzpfonf} qdkonfvnf; þodkY ]edrdwfcEm} jzpfjcif;yif/

xdkYjyif ]yPd[dw}-t&vnf; Oyg'geu©Em\ tpdwftydkif;wpf&yfjzpfaom ]tMurf;çtEk? t,kwfçtjrwf}[laom toGifykdif;udk aumuf,l&rnf/ y&rw¬'DyeDrSm uJYodkY4if;? edAÁme'DyeDrSmuJYodkY4if; rxdwxdjzifY 0dk;wdk;0g;wm; [dk[dk[if[if aumuf,l&rnfr[kwf/

]oknw}paom t&mrsm;onf ]tmum&jypum;}om jzpfonf/]0daoojypum;} odkYr[kwf ]*kPfjypum;} tvsOf;r[kwf/ xdkYaMumifY

]oknwçtedrdwåçtyÜPd[dw}wdkY\ teufudkvnf; *kPfqefqef aumufírjzpf/ ]tmum&}usus xdrdwduspGm aumufEdkif&rnf/

edAÁmef\ ]oknwmum&jzpfykH}udk tus,ftm;jzifY wifjycJYNyD;ygNyD/þwifjycsufrsm;t& ]oknw}\teufonf ]yvdaAm"wdkY\

uif;qdwfjcif;}-[lí edAÁme'DyeD[louJYodkY ,loifYygrnfavm/ þodkY,lvsifedAÁmefESifYcE¨mwdkY\ pyfvsufjzpfykH tjcif;t&monf tysufjym;cH&onf/odkYr[kwf tzkH;vTrf;cH&onf/

[kwfygonf/ edAÁmefESifYcEmwdkY\ oD;jcm;vGef;aom*kPfudk xkwfjyojzifY edAÁmefESifYcE¨mpyfykHudk tvGJvGJtacsmfacsmf todjzpfayawmYrnf/ydkufqHwpfjym;\ acgif;ESifYyef;uJYodkY jcm;aeaomt&m-[k todjzpfayawmYrnf/

tu,fpifppfü edAÁmefESifYcEmrSm þodkYjcm;onf r[kwfEdkif/ xdkYaMumifY edAÁmef\ oknwmum&onf yvdaAm"wdkYrS uif;Nidrf;çqdwfNidrf;jcif;jzpfonf rqdkEdkif/ tjcm; edrdwåmum&jzpffykH? tyÜPd[dwmum& jzpfykHrsm;vnf; rrSefEdkifay/ yvdaAm"wdkYrS uif;Nidrf;jcif;paom tqdkrsm;onf edAÁmef\tmum&udkjyaom pum;rsm;r[kwf/

Page 215: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 215

þrQ t>rufpum;jzifY aumuEk'f Adrmefuav;\ tzl;twufi,fwpfckudk qdwfzJYjycJYygNyD/ a½Tom;tvsOf;r[kwfbJ ½THUap;rsm;om jzpfaMumif; oufaojy avQmufvJcJYygNyD/

aumuEk'fAdrmefonf a½TAdrmefavmç ½THUap;Adrmefavmqdkonfudkpm½Ioludk,fwdkif w&m;olBuD;vkyfí tqkH;tjzwfjyK&ef ½Sdygonf/

Page 216: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

216 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 217: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 217

tcef;(7)

edAÁmefonf t½Sdponftay:pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

Page 218: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

218 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 219: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 219

tcef;(7)edAÁmefonf t½Sdponftay: pdppfokH;oyfcsuf

70/ edAÁmeftrSef½SdaMumif; azmfjyykHtay: pdppfcsufqufvufí aumuEk'fAdrmef\ ½THUap;AdrmefjzpfaMumif;udk aemuf

qkH;wpfcsuftaeESifY oufaoxlí avQmufvJvdkygonf/,if;-aemufqkH;wpfcsufqdkonfrSm-(1) edAÁmefonf t½Sd[kwfyg\avm/(2) tjrifYjrwfqkH;Nidrf;csrf;rIaum [kwfyg\avm/(3) El;nHheufeJ odEdkifcJonfqdkonfrSm rSefygoavm?

[laom t&mrsm;jzpfygonf/]edAÁmef}udk ]t½Sd}jzpfaMumif; tcsufESpfcsufjzifY ajzqdkxm;ygonf/,if;tajzrSm atmufygtwdkif;jzpfygonfè]edAÁmef t½Sdr[kwfvsif bk&m;&[EÅmrsm; t½Sdr[kwfEdkif/ bk&m;

&[EÅmrsm; trSef½SdaomaMumifY edAÁmefvnf; t½Sdjzpfonf/}þodkY wpfcsufwifjyxm;onf/]aemufwpfcsufrSm-]edAÁmefonf y&rwfjzpfaomaMumifY t½Sdjzpfonf}-[lí jzpfonf/edAÁmef\ ]t½Sd}jzpfykHwifjycsufjzpfaom þESpfcsufonf oifYavsmf

avsmufywf aumif;jrwfyg\avm/yXrwifjycsufonf edAÁmef t[kwftrSefr½Sdvsif bk&m;&[EÅm

r½SdEdkif? ,ck bk&m;&[EÅm trSef½Sdí edAÁmef½Sdonf-[lí jzpfonf/þtajz aumif;rGefygoavm/bk&m;ESifY &[EÅmqdkaom yk*¾dKvfrsm;onf edAÁmef[laom oabm

w&m;udk azmfxkwfwifjycJYaom yk*¾dKvfrsm; jzpfonf/ edAÁmefonf xdkyk*¾dKvfrsm; azmfxkwfwifjyrIaMumifY ay:vGifxif½Sm;vmaomt&mom jzpfonf/

Page 220: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

220 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYaMumifY edAÁmef½SdaMumif;ajymvdkvsif edAÁmefudk azmfxkwfcJYolrsm;½Sdjcif;ESifYoufaoxl&ef oifYavsmfygrnfavm/ þodkYvnf; wpfcsuf pOf;pm;zG,f½Sdonf/

xdkYjyifvnf; yk*¾dKvfwpfOD;onf bk&m;&[EÅm trSef½SdaMumif; b,ft&mjzifY odEdkifrnfenf;/ tu,fí odonfqdkvsif xdkyk*¾dKvfrsm; azmfxkwfwifjycJYaom edAÁmefoabmw&m;udk aygufa&mufjcif;tm;jzifYom odEdkif&ayrnf/

þodkYqdkvsif bk&m;&[EÅmudk tppftrSef½Sdonf-[k odolonfedAÁmefukd qdkufzl;ol jzpfonf/

qdkcJYNyD;aom wifjycsufrsm;udkqufí tuGufazmfvdkufaomtcgatmufygtwdkif; xGufay:vmonf-

]edAÁmefonf ig-odaomt&m jzpfonf/ edAÁmefudk ig-odí xdkedAÁmefudk azmfxkwfwifjycJYMuaom bk&m;&[EÅmrsm;udk ig-odonf/ wzef xdk-bk&m;&[EÅmrsm; {ueftrSef½Sdolrsm;jzpfMuí ig-odaeaom? ig-&aeaomedAÁmefonfvnf; {uef-t½Sdyifjzpfonf}/

þoabmonf acsmacsmBuD; usa&mufav\/ þonfvnf;wpfcsuf/ þtaMumif;rsm;aMumifY yXrjyqdkaompum;onf oifYçroifYpOf;pm;qifjcifoifYvSygonf/

qufvufí 'kwd, edAÁmeft½SdjzpfaMumif;jypum;udk avYvmMuygrnf/ ]edAÁmefonf y&rwfjzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifYt½Sdtppfjzpfonf}-[k qdk&efedAÁmefudk y&rwfjzpfaMumif; wifjyygonf/

y&rwf[lonf tb,fodkY ynwfESifY uGJjym;jcm;em;rI ½SdygowJYenf;/]y&rwfw&m;rSefvsif opömav;csuf\ udpöBuD;av;csuf ½Sdonf/

ynwfrSefvsif r½Sd}-[k ajzqdkxm;onf/

Page 221: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 221

þudpöBuD;av;csuftwGif;0ifvsif-y&rwf? r0ifvsif-ynwf}-[lowwf/

]opömav;csuf}onf ]t&d,opöm}jzpfonf/ y&rw¬opöm jzpfonf/t&d,opömonf y&rw¬opömay:ü wnfaqmufxm;aomt&m jzpfonf/t&d,opömudk y&rw¬opömu arG;zGm;ay;xm;onf}-[k qdkvdkygonf/

þodkYjzpfvsuf ]y&rwf [kwfçr[kwf} t&d,opömESifY jyefwdkif;&rnf-qdkonfrSm taMumif;tusdK;0ifqefYonf-[k xif&atmif tawmfyvDyvm BudK;pm;,lzdkY ½Sdayonf/

y&rwfESifYynwfcGJ&ef nTefjyaom þenf;edosonf rPdom&rOÆLomq&mtm; ay;cJYaom ]r[mxko*AÇ}[laombGJUudk vTJajymif;vufcHzdkYodkYr[kwf xdkbGJUudk jyefvnf vufcHodrf;ydkufEdkifzdkY oifYavsmfaom enf;edosjzpfrnf-[k xifjrifrdavonf/

,ckacwfvdk ur®ouwmÓPf yGifYvif;xGef;um;aomacwfüþaMumif;usdK;jypum;rsm;\ tESpfom&rJYykHonf nTefjyolrsm;\ tnTeftMum;yifrvdkbJ omrefrsufapYudka0Yí MunfhumrQjzifY odMurnfjzpfí,if;wdkYudk a0zefírjyvdkygNyD/ odkYaomfvnf; edAÁmef opdäääu&Pudpö½Sdíy&rwfjzpfykHudk oufqdkifvGef;aeí tenf;i,f wifjyygrnf/

]edAÁmef}onf udk,fawGUçÓPfawGU ESpfyg;tm;jzifY awGUEdkifaomt&mjzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY y&rwf jzpfonf/ tb,fodkY udk,fawGUç ÓPfawGUESpfyg;jzifY awGUEdkifoenf;/

udk,fawGUjzpfykHrSm þodkYwnf;/aomwmywådr*fodkY qdkufaomtcg tvGefylavmifMuyfwnf;aom

'd|dç0dpdudpäm oHan§mifYrsm; ESvkH;wGif;rS uRwfusonf/ þESpfyg;onf i&JrsdK;apYjzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY þESpfyg;Nidrf;jcif;onf i&Jtdk;BuD;ESpfvkH;Nidrf;jcif;jzpfonf/ (0g) uGJoGm;jcif; jzpfonf/ rarG;rDujyKcJYaom ra&rwGufEdkifaom

Page 222: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

222 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

uHqdk;rsm; vGwfNidrf;Muonf/ aoNyD;aemuf b0wdkYüvnf; pdk;&drfp&mtvsOf;r½SdawmY/ þonfvsif udk,fawGUedAÁmefwnf;/

ÓPfawGUykHrSm þodkYwnf;/ igYtm; an§mifYBuD;ESpfpif; uRwfayNyD-[k ½Ijrifaom tcg ÓPfawGUjzpfjyef\}-[lownf;/

jycJYaompum;rsm;ü ]udk,fawGUçÓPfawGU} ESpfyg;wdkYwGif ]udk,fawGU}[laom pum;udk tenf;i,frQ avYvmMunfhapcsifygonf/

]udk,fawGUjy} pum;rsm;ü wu,fudk,fawGUjzpfEdkifaom pum;onftenf;i,frQ jzpf\/ twdwfpum;rsm;ESifU tem*wfpum;rsm; vIdifvIdifygae\/ tem*wfü uHqdk;rsm;Nidrf;jcif;? twdwfrS i&Jtdk;rsm; uGJjcif;rsm;onfpdwful;om jzpfEdkif\/ udk,fawGU rjzpfEdkif/ udk,fawGUjzpfEdkifaom udavomoHan§mifYrsm;uRwfonf qdkonfrSmvnf; pdwful;,OfqefvSygonf/ ykHjyiftwGif;rS tmvm'ifrD;cGufqef;pGrf;&nfudk em;axmif&ouJYodkY jzpfygonf/

þ]udk,fawGUçÓPfawGU} tawGUESpfrsdK; odkYr[kwf rsufarSmuftjyKcH&jcif; udpöESpfrsdK;jzifY½SdaeaMumif; edAÁmefudkjyEdkifaomaMumifY edAÁmefonfy&rwfjzpfonf-[k qdkvdkaMumif; wifjyxm;ygonf/

]y&rwfonf t½Sdjzpfonf/ edAÁmefonf wu,fawGUEdkifaomaMumifYy&rwfjzpfonf/ xdkYaMumifY edAÁmefonfvnf; t½Sdjzpfonf}-[lowwf/

þwifjyaom t½SdjzpfykH aMumif;usdK;jypum;rsm;onf odkYr[kwfedAÁmef\ t½Sdtjzpf taMumif;jypum;rsm;onf tu,f cdkifvkHjcif;½SdNyD-[k ,lqoifYygoavm/þwifjycsufonf twå0g'kyg'gefudk cdkifNrJoefrmatmif zGJUaESmifaeaom tqdkrsm;omjzpfonf-[k xifjrifygonf/

]igwdkYbk&m; EIwfcywfawmfonf trSefjzpfonf}? tb,faMumifYqdkaomf ]igwdkYbk&m;onf trSefjzpfaomaMumifY}yif/ wzefvnf; ]igwdkYbk&m;onfvnf; trSefjzpfonf? tb,faMumifYqdkaomf igwdkYbk&m;\ EIwfcywfawmfrsm;onf tppf{uef rSefaeaomaMumifYjzpfonf}/

Page 223: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 223

þpum;rsm;onf ]twå0g'kyg'gef}udk oefrmxGm;BudKif;apaompum;rsm;jzpfygonf/ oabmw&m;udk b0tay:rSm raqmufbJ oabmw&m;udk oabmw&m;ay:rSm xyfqifYwnfaqmufjcif;onf ]twå0g'kyg'gef}udk cdkifrm½Sifoefaponf/ avmutwGuf ]twå0g'kyg'gef}jzifYtb,f tusdK;½SdtHhenf;/

þrQjzifY edAÁmef t½SdjzpfykHjypum;rsm;udk tenf;i,frQavYvmjcif;udk tqkH;owfoifYygonf/

71/ edAÁmef\ tjrifYqkH;Nidrf;csrf;rIjzpfykH okH;oyfcsufqufvufí edAÁmef\ ]tjrifYqkH;Nidrf;csrf;rIjzpfykHjy pum;}udk avYvm

aqG;aEG;Muygrnf/]Nidrf;csrf;rI}onf-(1) cHpm;rI½Sdaom Nidrf;csrf;rIESifY(2) cHpm;rIrJYaom Nidrf;csrf;rI? ESpfrsdK;½SdonfwGifÞedAÁmefNidrf;csrf;rIonf 'kwd,Nidrf;csrf;rI jzpfonf/ a½SUNidrf;csrf;rIonf

ay;qyfrS&aomt&m jzpfonf/ aemufrSm xdkodkYr[kwf/ xdkYaMumifY aemufNidrf;csrf;rIrSm tjrifYqkH;jzpfonf-[lí wpfcsufqdkxm;onf/

xYdkjyifvnf; cHpm;rI½Sdaom i&JBuD;½Spfxyf? i&Ji,f wpf&mESpfq,fY½SpfxyfwdkY trIwGJwef;vef; ½Sdaeonf/ cHpm;rIrJYNidrf;csrf;rIrSm xdkodkYr½Sd/xdkodkYr½SdaomaMumifYvnf; jrifYjrwfonf-[k qdkygonf/

þtqdkrsm;onf rsm;pGm ajymp&mr½Sdyg/ odkYaomfvnf; pmqdkvnf;rod? pmzwfolwdkYvnf; odrnfr[kwf? uREfkyfvnf;rodaom t&mrsm;udktav;xm;íwifjyjcif;ü aygY[mvSayonf/ i&JBuD;i,fwpf&mokH;q,fYajcmufxyfudk ol-odygrnfavm/ uREfkyfwdkYaum odEdkifygrnfavm/

Page 224: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

224 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

xdkYaMumifY tdyfrufxJrSm taMumif;t&mrsm;udk udkifprf;&ouJYodkYpmzwf&onfrSm a,mif0g;0g;½SdSvSonf/ edAÁmef\ tjrifYqkH;Nidrf;csrf;rIjzpfykHonf rsufarSmuftjzpfü þrQrxifrvif;aomt&m jzpfowJYavm/

tvdkçtrsufNidrf;jcif;? tjrifrSm;aysmufjcif;rsm;aMumifYjzpfaom Nidrf;csrf;rIonf þrQ rIef0g;owJYavm/

qufvufí edAÁmef\ cufcJeufeJ odrfarGUykHjyqdkaom pum;udkqufvufí wifjyygrnf/ edAÁmef\ cufcJeufeJrIonf 'ku©\ cufcJeufeJrIESifYtnD jzpfonfh 'ku©eufrIavmufyif 'ku©Nidrf;rI eufeJonf-[k wifjyygonf/

þwifjycsufü txl;ajymqdkp&m r½SdvSyg/

Page 225: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 225

tcef;(*)

edAÁme'DyeDokH;oyfcsuf tcsKyfpum;

Page 226: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

226 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

Page 227: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 227

tcef;(*)edAÁme'DyeDokH;oyfcsuf tcsKyfpum;

72/ edAÁme'DyeDtay: NcKHikHokH;oyfcsufþrQjzifY ]edAÁme'DyeD}wnf;[laom aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;\

ta&;BuD;aom tpdwftydkif;udk tenf;i,frQ qdwfzJYavYvmí wifjycsufrsm; tqkH;owfoifYygNyD/

þwifjycsufrsm;onf aumuEk'fAdrmefuav;\ þtpdwftydkif;rsm;onf a½Tom;tppf jzpfaeonfudk awGUjrif&oavm? odkYr[kwf ½THUap;rsm;jzpfaeonfudk awGUjrif&ygoavm/

þpm wifjyavQmufvJolonf-]aumuEk'fAdrmefonf a½Tom;Adrmefr[kwf? ½THUap;Adrmefjzpfonf}-

[k avQmufvJaecJYygonf/pm½Iolonf w&m;olBuD;vkyfí þjyóemudk udk,fydkifÓPfjzifY

ormorwfusatmif qkH;jzwfzdkYyif jzpfygonf/þrQpum;pOfjzifY wifjycsufonf ed*kH;odkY a&mufoifYygNyD/ þpmjzifY

aumuEk'fAdrme fzefqif;ol\ b0udkvnf;aumif;? aumuEk'fAdrmef\tpdwftydkif;rsm;udkvnf;aumif; wwftm;orQ xkwfjycJYygNyD/

þwifjycsufrsm;jzifY tESpfom&[kwfESifY r[kwfudk azmfxkwfodjrifvdkolwdkYtwGuf tESpfom&r[kwfonfudk tESpfom&vkyfaejcif;'ku©rSvGwfajrmufapcsifaom qEudk azmfjyygonf/

xdkYjyifvnf; þpmonf opömrD;½SL;twGuf ylaZmftyfaom tenf;i,faom avmifpmqDwpfrsdK;vnf;jzpf&ef tvdk½Sdygonf/ þrD;½SL;a&mifonf avmursm;\ rsm;ajrmifaomudpörsm;twGif;rS wpfckwavudkjzpfapNyD;ajrmufatmif aqmifEdkifaom t&nftcsif;jzpfay:rnf-[k ,kHMunfygonf/

Page 228: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

228 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

73/ edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ ed*kH;jrifYrdk&fawmifudk vufoD;jzifYxdk;ovdk jzpfcsifjzpfrnf/þpum;udk a&;om;cJYNyD/ t&mxifonfjzpfap rxifonfjzpfap

þt&monf pma&;ol\ y"getaMumif; r[kwfyg/]opömw&m;onf avmurSm trSef½Sdonfqdkvsif xdkopömpum;udk

vif;csif;vmapjcif;onfomvsif þpma&;ol\y"ge} jzpfonf/jrifYrdk&fawmifBuD;ü tmCmww&m; tenf;rQ pma&;olrxm;yg

av;pm;tyfaomt&m jzpfonfhtwdkif; jrifYrdk&fawmiftjzpf av;pm;vsuf?OD;nTwfvsuf tpOfyif ½Sdygonf/

[kwfygonf/ v,fwDq&mawmfbk&m;BuD;onf xkxnf½SdaomynmçoDvç0D&d,½SdoltrSefyif jzpfavonf/ ol\ ajc&mawmfç vuf&mawmf tcsdKUtpdwftydkif;uav;rQ awGUjrif&jcif;jzifY odEdkifcGifY ½Sdavmufatmifyif jzpfygonf/ tvm;wlyk*¾dKvfwpfOD;onf tem*wfü ay:OD;rSay:aygufjzpfyGm;vmawmYrnfvm;-[kyif awG;xifp&m jzpfygonf/

xdkYaMumifY OD;nTwfyg\? av;pm;yg\? 0yfwGm;yg\/ q&mawmfBuD;\ jzLpifaomtusifYawmf? jrifYrm;aom twwfynmawmf? BuD;jrwfaomodu©mawmf tp½Sdonfrsm;onf uREfkyfwdkYOD;acgif;ay:ü tNrJwnfygap/

xdkodkYjzpfaomfvnf; tazrSm;onfudk ]tazrSm;jzpfonf}[laomtaMumif;jzifY xdktaztrSm;udk wm0ef,l&ef rjzpfEdkifyg/ wm0ef,lvsiftazuvnf; BudKufrnfr[kwfyg/

tazonf olrSm;í ol\trSm;tarGudk om;wdkYtm; qufvufíay;vdkpdwf½SdEdkifygrnfavm/ om;wdkY\ vrf;a[mif;ay:wGif vrf;opfxGifoGm;rnfudk r½IpdrfYEdkifaomtaz [lí avmuü ½SdEdkifygoavm/

tzdk;\trsdK;udk tazxufjrifYatmif aqmif½GufEdkifjcif;aMumifYtaz rausreyf jzpfEdkifygrnfavm/

Page 229: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

½SifÓP udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK

edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿ 229

þodkYrjzpfEdkif-[k uREfkyf,kHMunfonf/xdkYaMumifY þpmonf jrifYrdk&fawmifudk vufoD;jzifYxdk;ol jzpfaumif;

jzpfrnf ½Sdaomfvnf; v,fwDq&mawmfbk&m; oufawmfxif½Sm;½SdvsiftBudrfBudrfom"kac:rnf[k uREkfyf,kHMunfygonf/

v,fwDq&mawmfbk&m;onf awmifay:wufaeí t&yfjrifYoljzpfrnfrxifyg/ wu,fwrf; t&yfjrifYol-ponf jzpfrnfxifygonf/wu,fwrf; t&yfjrifYoljzpfvsif þpmtwGuf tBudrfBudrftxyfxyfom"koHrjywfbJ ½Sd&mygonf/s

[kwfygonf/ tazY0rf;ydkuftwGif;ü tltwufaygufvsufae&mom;vkyfolonf odí taz\0rf;ykdufudk xm;xufxufjzifY xdk;azmufítaz\ xdktpdwftydkif;jzpfaom tltwufudk jzwfawmufypfvsif tazpdwfqdk;rnfavm/ csD;rGrf;oHrjywf txyfxyf jzpfay:rnfavm/ þtaz\0rf;ydkufudk xm;xufxufjzifY xdk;azmufNyD; taz\ udk,ft*Fg tpdwftydkif;wpfcktm; jzwfawmufypfovdkjzpfí jrifYrdk&fawmifudk vufoD;jzifYxdk;ovdk jzpfaumif;jzpfygrnf/

odkYaomfvnf;-opömtwGufjzpfí taz 0rf;om&rnfrSm rvGJwnf;/tazonf þt&mudk 0rf;enf;&avmufatmif ol&JabmraMumif/

£ómçrpä&d,w&m;rsm;jzifY r&pfaESmif/xdkYaMumifY tm;vkH;aompm½IolwdkYonf opömtwGuf vufceJ

tvif;a&mifudk rxdwfrvefY raMumufr½GHUbJ aysmf½Tifcsrf;ajrhí at;jrMunfomaompdwfxm;jzifY þpm\ trSefESifYtrSm;udk yk*¾dKvfa&;rzufoufoufaom "r®"d|mefjzifY arwåmyGm;NyD; tqkH;wdkif ½dk;om;EdkifMuygapownf;/

Page 230: 013-WhataboutNivirnadipani

udk,fwdkif zwf½Iwnf;jzwf&ef? wpfqifYul;,ljzefYa0jcif; cGifYrjyK ½SifÓP

230 edAÁme'DyeDb,fvJ¿

pm½IolwdkYtwGuf þpmonf tjrifYqkH;aom b0Nidrf;csrf;a&;tusdK;udk o,fydk;EdkiforQ o,fydk;aqmif½GufEdkifygap/

½SifÓPa½Tjrifwifawmif? rif;uGef;

1334 ckESpf? yXr0gqdkvqkwf 1&uff

þpma&;ul;NyD;csdef (1364ckESpf uqkefvqef; 5&uf? 16-5-2002? Mumoyaw;aeY)

E:\3tja\NnaGnl\Nivirna\Nivirna.pm6(Nsym)