1 demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) population dynamics 2)...

102
1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments Steinar Engen, Centre for Biodiversity Dynamics, Dept. of Mathematical Science, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway

Upload: julie-peters

Post on 03-Jan-2016

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

1

Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes

1) Population dynamics2) Community dynamics3) Selection in fluctuating environments

Steinar Engen, Centre for Biodiversity Dynamics, Dept. of Mathematical Science, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway

Page 2: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

2

For more detailed lectures on diffusion, extinction, dynamics ,age-structure and abundance models see

www.math.ntnu.no/~steinaen/lovund_2012

and more on age-structure

www.math.ntnu.no/~steinaen/ISEC_2012

and/or Lande, Engen and Sæther 2003, Stochastic Population Dynamics in Ecology and Conservation, Oxford University Press.

These lectures are based on co-authored papers with Russell Lande and Bernt-Erik Sæther during the last 20 years. For a list see my home page

www.math.ntnu.no/~steinaen

Page 3: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

3

Single species population dynamics

Environmental and demographic stochasticityDiffusion theory

Extinction Some harvesting statistics

Age structure

Steinar Engen, Centre for Biodiversity Dynamics, Department of Mathematical Sciences

Page 4: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

4

Population fluctuations for some species

Page 5: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

5

Page 6: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

6

Page 7: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

7

Page 8: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

8

Page 9: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

9

Page 10: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

10

Distribution of individualfitness wfor two bird species

Page 11: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

11

Page 12: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

12

Page 13: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

13

Page 14: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

14

Page 15: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

15

Page 16: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

16

Page 17: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

17

Page 18: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

18

The Green function

Page 19: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

19

Expected time to extinction

Page 20: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

20

Page 21: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

21

Page 22: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

22

Page 23: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

23

Page 24: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

24

Page 25: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

25

The expected time to extinction is often very large

Page 26: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

26

Page 27: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

27

Page 28: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

28

Page 29: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

29

Page 30: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

30

Page 31: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

31

Page 32: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

32

The rate of increase in fitness of any organism at any time is equal to its genetic variance in fitness at that time

Page 33: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

33

The rate of increase in fitness of any organism at any time is equal to its genetic variance in fitness at that time

The rigour of its demonstration requires that the terms employed should be used stricktly as defined; the ease of its interpretation may be increased by appropriate conventions of measurement. For example, the ratio p:q should stricktly be evaluated at any instant by enumeration, not necessarily of the census population, but of all individuals having reproductive value, weighted according to the reproductive value of each.

Page 34: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

34

Page 35: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

35

Page 36: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

36

Page 37: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

37

The total reproductive value V of the population growth exactly exponential, and lnV has exactly linear growth.

The age distribution approaches the stable age distribution

R. A. Fisher

Page 38: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

38

Population size

Total reproductive value

Age-structured population, no density regulation.

(The total reproductive value serves as a filter)

Page 39: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

39

Page 40: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

40

Page 41: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

41

Page 42: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

42

Community dynamics History The infinite allele model – neutral models Independent species dynamics Comparison of two dynamic models giving Fisher’s log series model

Page 43: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

43

The discovery of abundance patterns by Corbet and Williams in 1942:

Page 44: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

44

Page 45: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

45

Poisson Gamma negative binomial

Page 46: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

46

Page 47: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

47

Page 48: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

48

Page 49: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

49

Page 50: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

50

Page 51: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

51

10 minutes’ break

Page 52: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

52

Page 53: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

53

Page 54: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

54

Page 55: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

55

Page 56: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

56

Page 57: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

57

Page 58: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

58

Homogeneous models with speciations and extinctions

Page 59: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

59

Page 60: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

60

Homogeneous models with speciations and extinctions

Inhomogeneous Poisson process

Homogeneous Poisson process

Page 61: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

61

Page 62: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

62

Page 63: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

63

Page 64: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

64

Page 65: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

65

Page 66: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

66

Page 67: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

67

So what is the difference between the two types of model?

Answer:

Temporal fluctuations of abundant (observable) species are very different.

Neutral model with demographic noise only: extremely small fluctuations and species turnover rates

Gamma model with environmental noise: More realistic fluctuations and turnover rates

Page 68: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

68

Page 69: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

69

Neutral model, demographic noise only

Model with environmental noise

Typical lifetime of species

Page 70: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

70

Stochastic components of selection

Decomposition of the Robertson-Price equation,covariance formula for selection in an age-structured population

Density-dependent selection, r- and K-selection in a stochastic environment

Evolutionary effects of different non-selective harvesting strategies in a fluctuating population

Page 71: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

71

Page 72: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

72

Page 73: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

73

Page 74: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

74

Page 75: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

75

Page 76: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

76

Page 77: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

77

Page 78: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

78

For more details see Engen and Sæther (2013 Evolution, in press)

Page 79: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

79

Page 80: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

80

Figure 1. Observed decline in mean carapace length of rock lobsters captured in the fishery at two locations off the coast of Western Australia from 1972 to 2005 [10]. Only animals with a carapace length of greater than 76 mm (dotted line) can be legally harvested. This decline apparently is partially an evolutionary response to extremely high annual exploitation rates of adults ( 75%), ∼combined with a required minimum carapace length of 76 mm in harvested individuals.

(Allendorf et al. 2008)

Page 81: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

81

What about non-selective harvesting?

What are the effects?

With a given mean annual yield, are there differences between harvesting strategies?

Page 82: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

82

This result can be generalized to a sexual population with multinormally distributed z and constant G-matrix(Engen et al. 2012)

Page 83: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

83

Page 84: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

84

Page 85: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

85

Page 86: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

86

Page 87: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

87

Page 88: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

88

Page 89: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

89

Page 90: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

90

Page 91: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

91

Page 92: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

92

Page 93: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

93

Page 94: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

94

Page 95: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

95

Page 96: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

96

We can now investigate the evolutionary component due to harvesting for different harvesting strategies:

Constant harvesting

Proportional harvesting

Threshold harvesting

Page 97: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

97

Page 98: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

98

Page 99: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

99

Page 100: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

100

Page 101: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

101

Page 102: 1 Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes 1) Population dynamics 2) Community dynamics 3) Selection in fluctuating environments

102

Demographic and environmental stochasticity in population processes

1) Population dynamics2) Community dynamics3) Selection in fluctuating environments

Steinar Engen, Centre for Biodiversity Dynamics, Dept. of Mathematical Science, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway