1 oxygen for category ii intrauterine fetal resuscitation: a … · 74 background/significance 75...

15
Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a randomized, noninferiority trial 1 “O 2 C 2 Trial” 2 Protocol (November 2, 2016) 3 4 5 6 Principle Investigator: Nandini Raghuraman, MD MS 7 Washington University School of Medicine in St Louis 8 660 S Euclid Ave 9 Maternity Building-5 th Floor 10 St Louis, MO 63110 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a randomized, noninferiority trial 1

“O2C2 Trial” 2

Protocol (November 2, 2016) 3

4

5

6

Principle Investigator: Nandini Raghuraman, MD MS 7

Washington University School of Medicine in St Louis 8

660 S Euclid Ave 9

Maternity Building-5th

Floor 10

St Louis, MO 63110 11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 2: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Specific Aims 29

30 Maternal oxygen administration for concerning fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) patterns is common practice 31 on Labor and Delivery units in the United States. Despite the broad use of oxygen, it is unclear if this 32 practice is beneficial for the fetus. Category II FHT, as defined by the National Institute of Child Health 33 and Human Development (NICHD), is a broad class of FHT patterns that may suggest cord compression 34 and/or placental insufficiency for which oxygen is most commonly administered. Although some animal 35 and human studies have demonstrated that maternal hyperoxygenation can alleviate such fetal heart rate 36 decelerations, this purported benefit has not been shown to translate into improved fetal outcomes, 37 particularly in relation to acid-base status. In fact, some studies suggest harm with oxygen use due to 38 lower umbilical artery pH and increased delivery room resuscitation or increased free radical activity. 39 Given the indeterminate evidence for this ubiquitously employed resuscitation technique, there is an 40 urgent need to further study the utility of maternal oxygen administration in labor for fetal benefit. 41

We propose a randomized controlled non-inferiority trial comparing oxygen to room air in patients with 42 Category II FHT. Our central hypothesis is that room air alone is not inferior to oxygen administration 43 with regard to neonatal acid-base status and FHT and may in fact, be a safer option for resuscitation due 44 to less production of reactive oxygen species. 45

Primary Aim: Determine the effect of maternal oxygen administration for Category II FHT on 46 arterial umbilical cord lactate. 47

Hypothesis: Room air, as a substitute for oxygen supplementation, is no different than oxygen in 48 altering the acid-base status of the neonate as reflected in umbilical arterial (UA) lactate. 49

Fetal hypo-oxygenation, as reflected by decelerations in the FHT, results in metabolic acidosis due to a 50 shift from aerobic to anaerobic metabolism in which lactate and hydrogen ion production significantly 51 increase causing a decrease in pH. Elevated umbilical cord lactate has been shown to be a surrogate for 52 fetal metabolic acidosis and resultant neonatal morbidity. The primary outcome will be umbilical arterial 53 (UA) lactate, and secondary outcomes will be other components of a UA gas. 54 55 Secondary Aim #1: Characterize the effect of oxygen administration on fetal heart tracing patterns 56

Hypothesis: Oxygen administration will be associated with a rate of persistent Category II FHT 57 that is not different from those exposed to room air. 58

Oxygen is typically administered in response to FHT interpretation. Hence, evaluating the effect of 59 oxygen on subsequent FHT is pivotal to labor management. The primary outcome will be resolution of 60 Category II FHT. We will also investigate the effect of oxygen administration on mode of delivery, 61 particularly cesarean delivery for non-reassuring fetal status. 62 63 Secondary Aim #2: Evaluate the safety of oxygen administration by measuring reactive oxygen 64 species (ROS) in maternal and neonatal blood. 65

Hypothesis: Oxygen administration will be associated with increased oxidative stress in maternal 66 and neonatal cord blood as represented by malondialdehyde (MDA). 67

Over-oxygenation can result in free radical or ROS formation that have detrimental downstream effects. 68 The presence of reactive oxygen species results in degradation of lipids in the cell membrane and 69 resultant formation of malondialdehyde (MDA), which has been studied as a surrogate for oxidative 70 stress. 71

72

73

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 3: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Background/Significance 74

Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common practice 75

on Labor and Delivery units in the Unites States. Despite the broad use of oxygen for intrauterine 76

resuscitation of fetal heart rate decelerations, it is unclear if this practice is beneficial for the 77

fetus. In a recent review of maternal oxygen administration in labor, Hamel et al1 concluded that 78

there is insufficient evidence for routine oxygen administration for intrauterine resuscitation and 79

that such administration may even be harmful via production of free radicals. The 2012 80

Cochrane review evaluating maternal oxygen administration for fetal distress also found limited 81

evidence to evaluate the effectiveness of oxygen for fetal distress.2 82

Category II FHT, as defined by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development 83

(NICHD)3, is a broad class of FHT patterns which can include both variable and/or late 84

decelerations, representing cord compression and placental insufficiency, respectively. These 85

decelerations are often thought to be a reflection of fetal hypooxygenation. The underlying 86

hypothesis for oxygen benefit and the primary motivation for generalized use in labor is to 87

transfer oxygen to the fetus and therefore improve or reverse the perceived fetal 88

hypooxygenation determined by the FHT. 89

Although some animal and human studies have demonstrated that maternal hyperoxygenation 90

can alleviate fetal heart rate decelerations4, 5

and increase fetal oxygen saturation6-9

, this 91

purported benefit has not been shown to translate into improved fetal outcomes, particularly in 92

relation to acid-base status. For example, a study in primates by Morishima et al demonstrated 93

that maternal oxygen administration to those with acidotic hypoxic fetuses elevated fetal oxygen 94

levels and eliminated late decelerations but did not correct acidosis.10

95

There are a limited number of clinical trials addressing maternal oxygen administration for fetal 96

distress in labor. In 1995, Thorp et al conducted a randomized trial of oxygen versus room air in 97

the second stage of labor, and found no benefit to oxygen exposure and in fact discovered that 98

the oxygen group had a lower umbilical artery pH. This difference was theorized to be a result of 99

fetoplacental vasoconstriction as a result of prolonged oxygen exposure.11

Similarly, Nesterenko 100

et al performed a trial of laboring women randomized to oxygen or room air and found that more 101

infants in the oxygen group required delivery room resuscitation.12

Excess oxygen exposure in 102

this setting has also been linked with increased free radical activity. In a 2002 trial by Khaw et al, 103

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 4: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Placenta

Umbilical vein

Fetal heart

Sytemic fetal

circulation

Umbilical arteries

women were randomized to oxygen or room air during cesarean delivery. There was no 104

difference in umbilical artery pH between groups, however the oxygen exposed group had 105

increased free radical activity in cord blood samples8. Studies such as these have prompted 106

questioning of both the safety and the efficacy of oxygen for Category II FHT and highlight the 107

urgent need for further investigation, particularly given its wide-spread use. 108

The primary objective of this study is to evaluate whether oxygen for intrauterine fetal 109

resuscitation of Category II FHT affects fetal metabolic acid-base status as determined by 110

umbilical cord lactate values. Secondary objectives include analysis of additional cord gas 111

parameters used to predict neonatal wellbeing, changes to FHT patterns, and cord blood and 112

maternal MDA as a marker of free radical activity. We hypothesize that room air exposure for 113

Category II FHT in labor is no different from maternal oxygen administration with regard to fetal 114

acid-base status. 115

Specific Aim 1: Determine the effect of maternal oxygen administration for Category II 116

FHT on arterial umbilical cord lactate. Fetal hypooxygenation, as reflected by decelerations 117

in the FHT, results in a metabolic acidosis due to a shift from aerobic to anaerobic metabolism in 118

which lactate and hydrogen ion production significantly increases as a result of glucose 119

breakdown and pyruvate conversion.14

This rise in lactate results in decreased pH or an acidotic 120

state. Elevated umbilical cord lactate has been shown to be a surrogate for metabolic acidosis in 121

the fetus and is associated with neonatal morbidity.15

It has also been shown to precede pH 122

changes in the setting of hypooxygenation.14, 16

123

The theorized benefit of maternal oxygen administration is increase oxygen 124

delivery to the fetus via the umbilical cord vein (Figure 1) resulting in 125

prevention or reversal of anaerobic metabolism and a subsequent 126

reflection in umbilical cord artery findings. This, however, has not been 127

substantiated by evidence thus far. We hypothesize that room air, as a 128

substitute for oxygen supplementation, is no different than oxygen in 129

altering the acid-base status of the neonate as reflected in umbilical 130

cord gas parameters. Secondary outcomes will be additional 131

components of an umbilical artery gas. 132

Figure 1: Fetoplacental circulation

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 5: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Oxygen exposure

Reactive oxygen species

Lipid peroxidation

MDA

Specific Aim 2: Characterize the effect of oxygen administration on fetal heart tracing 133

patterns 134

In clinical practice, oxygen is administered to patients with Category II FHT in order to 135

resuscitate potential fetal hypooxygenation that manifests as heart rate decelerations. Evidence 136

thus far shows that Category II FHT are associated with a wide spectrum of neonatal outcomes 137

and therefore do not uniformly reflect fetal acid-base status19, 20

. Hence, evaluating the effect of 138

oxygen on subsequent FHT categorization is pivotal to labor management. The outcome that will 139

be investigated is rate of persistent Category II FHT after intervention. We will also evaluate the 140

types and frequency of deceleration patterns present both pre and post intervention. We 141

hypothesize that oxygen administration for Category II FHT will be associated with a rate of 142

persistent Category II FHT that is not different from those exposed to room air. 143

144

Specific Aim 3: Evaluate the safety of oxygen administration by measuring reactive oxygen 145

species in maternal and cord blood 146

In order to safely apply maternal oxygen administration for intrauterine fetal resuscitation, the 147

risks of oxygen exposure must be further explored. Over-oxygenation can result in free radical 148

formation, downstream effects of which include cell membrane and DNA damage and resultant 149

carcinogenesis.21

Although oxygen supplementation is often critical to resuscitation in most 150

settings, studies evaluating hyperoxygenation in adults and animals have shown detrimental 151

cardiac22

,pulmonary23

,and cerebral effects24

. Over-oxygenation in neonates has been shown to be 152

associated with bronchopulmonary dysplasia and retinopathy1, 25

. Furthermore, reintroduction of 153

oxygen after a period of hypooxygenation can result in adverse effects as the fetus and newborn 154

lack robust antioxidant systems1, 26

. 155

One of the primary markers of oxidative stress studied in the 156

literature is malondialdehyde (MDA). The presence of 157

reactive oxygen species results in degradation of lipids and 158

resultant formation of MDA27

which then modifies endogenous 159

proteins. MDA levels, therefore, have been studied as a 160

surrogate for oxidative stress.28-32

(Figure 2) 161

Figure 2: Pathway of oxidative stress

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 6: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Increased MDA levels in the neonate may be consequential and have been associated with 162

morbidity including hyperbilirubinemia33

and hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy34

.There is also 163

evidence that MDA can be transplacentally transported and thus, both mother and fetus are at 164

risk for downstream effects.35

165

Prior studies have evaluated the relationship between maternal oxygen administration in labor 166

and markers of free radical formation8, 12

with mixed results. We hypothesize that maternal 167

hyperoxygenation for Category II FHT is associated with increased oxidative stress in the mother 168

and fetus. We will measure MDA in maternal and neonatal cord blood samples as a gage for 169

oxidative stress and to assess the relationship between oxygen administration and subsequent 170

free radical formation. 171

Significant and Potential Impact 172

Current practice on our Labor and Delivery is maternal oxygen administration in the presence of 173

Category II FHT for the duration of labor. This practice is unproven in benefit thus far and in 174

fact, some studies suggest harm11, 12

. Although it may improve fetal oxygenation, evidence thus 175

far does not show an improvement in fetal acid-base status which ultimately correlates with 176

neonatal outcomes. Our study has the potential to create a paradigm shift in intrauterine fetal 177

resuscitation and has significant clinical implications for the fetus and mother. No prior clinical 178

trials in this setting have used cord lactate as a primary outcome. Umbilical cord lactate is an 179

established marker of asphyxia and predictor of neonatal morbidity14

and serves as a useful 180

assessment of the benefit, or lack thereof, of oxygen for fetal resuscitation. Prior studies have 181

mainly evaluated cord pH as the primary outcome which not only falls behind lactate as a 182

predictor of neonatal outcomes, but also does not serve as an accurate reflection of the degree of 183

metabolic acidosis that may be present due to hypooxygenation17

. Furthermore, previous trials 184

addressing oxygen administration for similar indications have not employed a similar three-185

pronged approach to evaluating outcomes via neonatal acid-base status, FHT patterns, and free 186

radical activity. If our stated hypothesis is proven, room air may be an equally efficacious, safer, 187

and cost saving alternative to oxygen. Additionally, it would pave the way for further 188

investigation into the most effective strategies for intrauterine fetal resuscitation. 189

190

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 7: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

Strategy 191

The aim of this study is to compare maternal oxygen administration to room air for intrauterine 192

resuscitation of Category II FHT in relation to cord gas parameters, FHT patterns, and oxidative 193

stress in the fetus and mother. The study will be a prospective, randomized non inferiority trial to 194

be conducted at Barnes Jewish Hospital. Current practice at our institution for intrauterine fetal 195

resuscitation of Category II FHT include any of the combination of (1) oxygen administration via 196

nonrebreather face mask at 10L/min (FiO2 approximately 0.80)36

continued for the duration of 197

labor (2) intravenous fluid bolus (3) maternal repositioning (4) discontinuation of oxytocin. We 198

hypothesize that room air for Category II FHT will be no different than oxygen administration in 199

reducing the degree of fetal metabolic acidosis. This study will include term, singleton patients 200

admitted to Labor& Delivery for spontaneous labor or labor induction. Multiples, fetal 201

anomalies, Category III FHT, umbilical artery doppler abnormalities and preterm pregnancies 202

will be excluded. Additionally, women will be excluded if oxygen is required for maternal 203

indications such as hypooxygenation or cardiopulmonary disease. Our primary objective will be 204

umbilical cord lactate. Secondary objectives include additional cord gas parameters including 205

umbilical artery pH, umbilical artery base deficit, and umbilical vein oxygen saturation; FHT 206

categorization and deceleration patterns; maternal and umbilical cord blood measurement of 207

malondialdehyde. 208

Consent will be obtained at time of admission to Labor & Delivery. Randomization to either the 209

oxygen group or room air group will be performed when the patient is in active labor (defined as 210

regular contractions and ≥ 6cmcervical dilation) and develops Category II FHT necessitating 211

intrauterine resuscitation as determined by the care provider team (Figure 3). This will be 212

performed via a computer-generated randomization sequence in a 1:1 ratio. Patients randomized 213

to the oxygen group will receive the above stated current management of oxygen via 214

nonrebreather face mask at 10L/min and “per-protocol” defined as receiving the mask for at least 215

90% of the remaining duration of labor including during cesarean delivery. Patients randomized 216

to the room air group will not receive oxygen for Category II FHT unless otherwise required for 217

maternal indications. Alternative and/or additional intrauterine resuscitation techniques for both 218

groups (i.e. fluid bolus, maternal repositioning, and discontinuation of oxytocin) will be left to 219

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 8: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

the discretion of the medical team. The initial 6 patients consented and randomized will be part 220

of a compliance run-in with the same protocol as above. 221

. 222

223

224

225

Specific Aim 1: Determine the effect of maternal oxygen administration for Category II FHT on 226

neonatal cord gas parameters 227

After delivery of the infant, a segment of the umbilical cord will be removed with immediate 228

collection of umbilical artery and vein samples by trained providers. These samples will be sent 229

to the hospital laboratory for routine cord gas measurements as is universally practiced on our 230

Labor and Delivery unit. 231

Specific Aim 2: Characterize the effect of oxygen administration on fetal heart tracing patterns 232

The patient’s primary nurse will document the time at which intervention is initiated. A blinded 233

investigator will then retrospectively assess FHT categorization and deceleration patterns both 234

pre and post intervention. 235

Specific Aim 3: Evaluate the safety of oxygen administration by measuring ROS in maternal 236

and neonatal blood 237

We will be measuring serum MDA in both cord and maternal blood as a marker of oxidative 238

stress. MDA is a byproduct of lipid peroxidation, which occurs as a result of oxidative stress. 239

Measurement of Thiobarbituric Acid Reactive Substances (TBARS) is a commonly used assay 240

Admission to L&D for delivery

Category II FHT in active labor:

Oxygen for duration of labor

until delivery

Room air for duration of labor

until delivery

Enrollment

Figure 3: Flow diagram for randomization and treatment groups

L&D: Labor and Delivery FHT: fetal heart tracing

Randomization

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 9: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

for quantifying MDA30

37

This assay is performed by fluorometrically measuring the MDA-TBA 241

complex formed in plasma or serum by the reaction of MDA and TBA. 242

Upon delivery of the infant, an additional sample of umbilical artery blood will be collected for 243

this analysis. An optional sample of maternal blood will also be drawn within 60 minutes of 244

delivery. Both blood samples will be centrifuged to collect plasma which will then be stored at -245

80◦C until the TBARS assay is performed. 246

Data Collection 247

The patient’s primary nurse will perform real-time documentation of oxygen initiation, any 248

disruption in intervention, administration of amnioinfusion and additional resuscitation 249

techniques performed (number of times patient is repositioned, total intravenous fluids, 250

discontinuation of oxytocin). Study staff will collect data from medical records on: 251

1) Antepartum history: 252

a. Demographic data: Maternal age, race 253

b. Obstetric history: parity, prior cesarean, gestational age at delivery 254

c. Medical history: BMI at initial prenatal visit, diabetes, chronic hypertension, 255

severe anemia (Hemoglobin <7), tobacco use, illicit drug use 256

d. Prenatal course: diagnosis of hypertensive disorders, gestational diabetes, 257

abruption, intrauterine growth restriction, oligohydramnios 258

2) Intrapartum data: 259

a. Indication for admission/induction 260

b. Oxytocin (duration, total received dose) 261

c. Analgesia 262

d. Duration of labor (first and second stage) 263

e. Diagnosis of chorioamnionitis 264

f. Mode of delivery 265

g. Indication for cesarean 266

h. Electronic fetal monitoring 267

3) Neonatal course: 268

a. APGARs 269

b. Neonatal weight 270

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 10: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

c. Admission to special care nursery (SCN) or neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) 271

d. Duration of admission to SCN or NICU 272

e. Diagnosis of any of the following: hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy, respiratory 273

distress syndrome, oxygen requirement, requirement of hypothermia therapy, 274

seizures, sepsis or suspected sepsis, neonatal death 275

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan 276

In addition to principle investigator review of adverse events, a data and safety monitoring board 277

(DSMB) will be established. This board will have three individuals (Dr. Collen McNicholas, Dr. 278

Omar Young, Dr. Emily Fishman) not directly involved in the study. The DSMB will meet once 279

50% of participants have been recruited to review any adverse neonatal or maternal events 280

among the study cohort and determining safety of continuing the study to completion. The 281

DSMB will receive a report of any severe and/or non-severe adverse neonatal outcomes within 282

72 hours of occurrence. Reportable severe adverse neonatal outcomes include intrapartum 283

stillbirth and neonatal death. Reportable non-severe adverse neonatal outcomes include need for 284

hypothermia protocol, seizures, and prolonged NICU stay >72 hours. 285

Statistical Analysis 286

Intention-to-treat (primary analysis) and per protocol analyses will be performed. Chi-squared 287

and Fisher’s exact tests will be used to compare categorical variables as appropriate. Continuous 288

variables will initially be assessed for distribution pattern via the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. 289

Normally distributed variables will be compared using Student’s t-tests and non-normally 290

distributed variables will be analyzed with the Mann-Whitney U test. These analyses will be 291

supplemented by multivariable logistic regressions to adjust for confounders. 292

Tests with p <0.05 will be considered statistically significant. Analyses will be performed using 293

Stata (Stata Corp., College Station, TX). 294

For the primary outcome of lactate, 95% confidence intervals (CI) will be calculated for the 295

mean cord lactate levels in each group. Comparison of the 95% CI in each group will then 296

determine non-inferiority or inferiority. 297

Additional interaction analyses for the primary outcome will be performed for the following 298

subgroups: 299

1) Presence of chronic medical conditions (hypertensive disorder, diabetes) 300

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 11: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

a. Patients with hypertensive disorders (chronic hypertension, gestational 301

hypertension, preeclampsia) 302

b. Patients with diabetes mellitus (gestational diabetes, T1DM, T2DM) 303

2) Recurrent late decelerations pre intervention 304

3) Recurrent variable decelerations pre intervention 305

4) Prolonged deceleration pre intervention 306

5) Fetal tachycardia pre intervention 307

6) Fetuses with intrauterine growth restriction 308

7) Chorioamnionitis 309

8) Within oxygen group: Duration of oxygen exposure 310

a. <50% of total duration of active labor (onset of active labor to delivery) 311

b. >50% of total duration of active labor (onset of active labor to delivery) 312

313

Odds ratios and 95% CI will be calculated for the secondary outcome of persistent Category II 314

FHT. Kaplan-Meir analyses will be performed for fetal monitoring analyses. 315

For the outcome of maternal and cord blood MDA, a fetal MDA will be calculated by 316

subtracting umbilical artery MDA from maternal MDA for each sample. The calculated mean 317

fetal MDA and maternal MDA values will then be compared between groups using either 318

Student t test or Mann Whitney U test. 319

320 Sample size analysis 321

A review of previously collected data from our institution of 5182 term singleton pregnancies 322

revealed a mean cord lactate of 3.5±1.6 mmol/L in women with Category II FHT within 30 323

minutes of delivery. All of these deliveries were managed using our current protocol of routine 324

oxygen administration for Category II FHT. Given the normal mean lactate seen in our 325

population of patients with Category II FHT, a noninferiority approach was selected to test our 326

hypothesis that room air is not inferior to oxygen administration in treating Category II FHT. A 327

total sample size of 98 patients will be needed to detect a non-inferiority margin of 30% with 328

90% power, using a one-sided two-sample t-test (alpha 0.025). To accommodate a 15% drop 329

out/cross over rate, a total of 114 patients will be needed. We plan on performing an initial 330

compliance run-in of 6 patients making the total enrollment 120 patients. Data analysis will only 331

be performed on the 114 patients enrolled after the initial 6 patients enrolled/randomized in the 332

compliance run-in/pilot. Previous studies have shown an increased risk for neonatal morbidity 333

with cord lactate cut-offs ranging from 3.2-6.014, 15, 38-41

. The margin of noninferiority was 334

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 12: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

therefore set at a lactate cut-off of 4.5, above which there is a clear association with neonatal 335

morbidity. 336

337

338

339

340

341

342

343

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 13: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

344

References 345

346

1. HAMEL MS, ANDERSON BL, ROUSE DJ. Oxygen for intrauterine resuscitation: of unproved benefit 347 and potentially harmful. American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 2014;211:124-7. 348

2. FAWOLE B, HOFMEYR GJ. Maternal oxygen administration for fetal distress. The Cochrane database 349 of systematic reviews 2012;12:Cd000136. 350

3. ROBINSON B, NELSON L. A Review of the Proceedings from the 2008 NICHD Workshop on 351 Standardized Nomenclature for Cardiotocography: Update on Definitions, Interpretative 352 Systems With Management Strategies, and Research Priorities in Relation to Intrapartum 353 Electronic Fetal Monitoring. Reviews in obstetrics & gynecology 2008;1:186-92. 354

4. KHAZIN AF, HON EH, HEHRE FW. Effects of maternal hyperoxia on the fetus. I. Oxygen tension. 355 American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 1971;109:628-37. 356

5. ALTHABE O, JR., SCHWARCZ RL, POSE SV, ESCARCENA L, CALDEYRO-BARCIA R. Effects on fetal heart rate 357 and fetal pO2 of oxygen administration to the mother. American journal of obstetrics and 358 gynecology 1967;98:858-70. 359

6. BULLENS LM, VAN DER HOUT-VAN DER JAGT MB, VAN RUNNARD HEIMEL PJ, OEI G. A simulation model to 360 study maternal hyperoxygenation during labor. Acta obstetricia et gynecologica Scandinavica 361 2014;93:1268-75. 362

7. HAYDON ML, GORENBERG DM, NAGEOTTE MP, et al. The effect of maternal oxygen administration on 363 fetal pulse oximetry during labor in fetuses with nonreassuring fetal heart rate patterns. 364 American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 2006;195:735-8. 365

8. KHAW KS, WANG CC, NGAN KEE WD, PANG CP, ROGERS MS. Effects of high inspired oxygen fraction 366 during elective Caesarean section under spinal anaesthesia on maternal and fetal oxygenation 367 and lipid peroxidation†. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2002;88:18-23. 368

9. GARE DJ, SHIME J, PAUL WM, HOSKINS M. Oxygen administration during labor. American journal of 369 obstetrics and gynecology 1969;105:954-61. 370

10. MORISHIMA HO, DANIEL SS, RICHARDS RT, JAMES LS. The effect of increased maternal PaO2 upon the 371 fetus during labor. American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 1975;123:257-64. 372

11. THORP JA, TROBOUGH T, EVANS R, HEDRICK J, YEAST JD. The effect of maternal oxygen administration 373 during the second stage of labor on umbilical cord blood gas values: a randomized controlled 374 prospective trial. American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 1995;172:465-74. 375

12. NESTERENKO TH, ACUN C, MOHAMED MA, et al. Is it a safe practice to administer oxygen during 376 uncomplicated delivery: a randomized controlled trial? Early human development 2012;88:677-377 81. 378

13. Practice bulletin no. 116: Management of intrapartum fetal heart rate tracings. Obstet Gynecol 379 2010;116:1232-40. 380

14. TUULI MG, STOUT MJ, SHANKS A, ODIBO AO, MACONES GA, CAHILL AG. Umbilical cord arterial lactate 381 compared with pH for predicting neonatal morbidity at term. Obstet Gynecol 2014;124:756-61. 382

15. WESTGREN M, DIVON M, HORAL M, et al. Routine measurements of umbilical artery lactate levels in 383 the prediction of perinatal outcome. American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 384 1995;173:1416-22. 385

16. GJERRIS AC, STAER-JENSEN J, JORGENSEN JS, BERGHOLT T, NICKELSEN C. Umbilical cord blood lactate: a 386 valuable tool in the assessment of fetal metabolic acidosis. European journal of obstetrics, 387 gynecology, and reproductive biology 2008;139:16-20. 388

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 14: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

17. Executive summary: Neonatal encephalopathy and neurologic outcome, second edition. Report 389 of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists' Task Force on Neonatal 390 Encephalopathy. Obstet Gynecol 2014;123:896-901. 391

18. MALIN GL, MORRIS RK, KHAN KS. Strength of association between umbilical cord pH and perinatal 392 and long term outcomes: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ (Clinical research ed) 393 2010;340:c1471. 394

19. CAHILL AG, ROEHL KA, ODIBO AO, MACONES GA. Association and prediction of neonatal acidemia. 395 American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 2012;207:206.e1-8. 396

20. FREY HA, TUULI MG, SHANKS AL, MACONES GA, CAHILL AG. Interpreting category II fetal heart rate 397 tracings: does meconium matter? American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 398 2014;211:644.e1-8. 399

21. YONEI S, FURUI H. Lethal and mutagenic effects of malondialdehyde, a decomposition product of 400 peroxidized lipids, on Escherichia coli with different DNA-repair capacities. Mutation research 401 1981;88:23-32. 402

22. WIJESINGHE M, PERRIN K, RANCHORD A, SIMMONDS M, WEATHERALL M, BEASLEY R. Routine use of 403 oxygen in the treatment of myocardial infarction: systematic review. Heart (British Cardiac 404 Society) 2009;95:198-202. 405

23. NEW A. Oxygen: kill or cure? Prehospital hyperoxia in the COPD patient. Emergency medicine 406 journal : EMJ 2006;23:144-6. 407

24. HELMERHORST HJ, SCHULTZ MJ, VAN DER VOORT PH, DE JONGE E, VAN WESTERLOO DJ. Bench-to-bedside 408 review: the effects of hyperoxia during critical illness. Critical care (London, England) 409 2015;19:284. 410

25. SOLA A, SALDENO YP, FAVARETO V. Clinical practices in neonatal oxygenation: where have we failed? 411 What can we do? Journal of perinatology : official journal of the California Perinatal Association 412 2008;28 Suppl 1:S28-34. 413

26. SIMPSON KR. Intrauterine resuscitation during labor: should maternal oxygen administration be a 414 first-line measure? Seminars in fetal & neonatal medicine 2008;13:362-7. 415

27. DALLE-DONNE I, ROSSI R, COLOMBO R, GIUSTARINI D, MILZANI A. Biomarkers of oxidative damage in 416 human disease. Clinical chemistry 2006;52:601-23. 417

28. PRYOR WA, STANLEY JP. Letter: A suggested mechanism for the production of malonaldehyde 418 during the autoxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids. Nonenzymatic production of 419 prostaglandin endoperoxides during autoxidation. The Journal of organic chemistry 420 1975;40:3615-7. 421

29. ILHAN N, ILHAN N, SIMSEK M. The changes of trace elements, malondialdehyde levels and 422 superoxide dismutase activities in pregnancy with or without preeclampsia. Clinical biochemistry 423 2002;35:393-7. 424

30. SUHAIL M, SUHAIL S, GUPTA BK, BHARAT V. Malondialdehyde and Antioxidant Enzymes in Maternal 425 and Cord Blood, and their Correlation in Normotensive and Preeclamptic Women. Journal of 426 clinical medicine research 2009;1:150-7. 427

31. LORENTE L, MARTIN MM, ABREU-GONZALEZ P, et al. Sustained high serum malondialdehyde levels 428 are associated with severity and mortality in septic patients. Critical care (London, England) 429 2013;17:R290. 430

32. LORENTE L, MARTIN MM, ABREU-GONZALEZ P, et al. Association between serum malondialdehyde 431 levels and mortality in patients with severe brain trauma injury. Journal of neurotrauma 432 2015;32:1-6. 433

33. BASU S, DE D, DEV KHANNA H, KUMAR A. Lipid peroxidation, DNA damage and total antioxidant 434 status in neonatal hyperbilirubinemia. Journal of perinatology : official journal of the California 435 Perinatal Association 2014;34:519-23. 436

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020

Page 15: 1 Oxygen for Category II Intrauterine Fetal Resuscitation: a … · 74 Background/Significance 75 Maternal oxygen administration for fetal heart rate tracing (FHT) changes is a common

34. KIRIMI E, PEKER E, TUNCER O, YAPICIOGLU H, NARLI N, SATAR M. Increased serum malondialdehyde 437 level in neonates with hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy: prediction of disease severity. The 438 Journal of international medical research 2010;38:220-6. 439

35. ROGERS MS, MONGELLI M, TSANG KH, WANG CC. Fetal and maternal levels of lipid peroxides in term 440 pregnancies. Acta obstetricia et gynecologica Scandinavica 1999;78:120-4. 441

36. PARILLO JE. Critical Care Medicine: Principles of Diagnosis and Management in the Adult, Fourth 442 Editin. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier Inc, 2014. 443

37. YAGI K. Simple assay for the level of total lipid peroxides in serum or plasma. Methods in 444 molecular biology (Clifton, NJ) 1998;108:101-6. 445

38. RIDENOUR RV, GADA RP, BROST BC, KARON BS. Comparison and validation of point of care lactate 446 meters as a replacement for fetal pH measurement. Clinical biochemistry 2008;41:1461-5. 447

39. WIBERG-ITZEL E, LIPPONER C, NORMAN M, et al. Determination of pH or lactate in fetal scalp blood in 448 management of intrapartum fetal distress: randomised controlled multicentre trial. BMJ (Clinical 449 research ed) 2008;336:1284-7. 450

40. ALLEN RM, BOWLING FG, OATS JJ. Determining the fetal scalp lactate level that indicates the need 451 for intervention in labour. The Australian & New Zealand journal of obstetrics & gynaecology 452 2004;44:549-52. 453

41. LINET T, LAPORTE J, GUEYE H, BOOG G. [Microvolume dosage of lactate in cord blood for the 454 evaluation of the neonatal well-being]. Journal de gynecologie, obstetrique et biologie de la 455 reproduction 2002;31:352-7. 456

457

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by a Non-Human Traffic (NHT) User on 09/27/2020