1 possible legal rights of cryogenically revived persons 1 st annual colloquium on the law of...

20
1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10, 2005 A. Christopher Sega, Esq.

Upload: arthur-russell

Post on 12-Jan-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

1

Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons

1st Annual Colloquium on the Law ofTranshuman PersonsMelbourne Beach, FloridaDecember 10, 2005

A. Christopher Sega, Esq.

Page 2: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

2

Introduction

• What is the Status of the Law?

• Rights determined by Status of Revived Person

• Possible Rights by Analogy

• Actions to “Protect” Your Rights

Page 3: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

3

What Rights Are Relevant?

• Rights of the Revived Person

• Rights of Others over the Revived Persons

Page 4: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

4

Rights Depend On Identity

• Is there psychological continuity?

• Are you the “same” person?

• Are you a “related” person, descendant or “heir”?

• Are you a “new” person?

Page 5: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

5

Categories of Rights

• Property or Financial Rights

• Personal Rights

Page 6: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

6

Property or Financial Rights

• Right to Hold and Alienate Property

• Right to Receive or Direct an Inheritance

• Social Security and other Retirement Benefits

Page 7: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

7

Property Rights – Competing Principles

• Right to Hold Property vs, Restrictions on Alienation

• Rule Against Perpetuities vs. Repeal of Rule Against Perpetuities

Page 8: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

8

Personal Rights

• Citizenship

• Marital Status and Family Relationships

• Other Political Rights and Obligations

Page 9: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

9

Guidance from Other Law

• Law of Absent Persons

• Treatment of Cryogenically Preserved Embryos and Semen

• Treatment of Trans-gendered Persons

Page 10: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

10

Law of Absent Persons

• Presumption of Death

• Probate of Estate and Property Transfers

Page 11: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

11

Absent Persons - Treatment of Property

• Disposition of Land and Merchantability of Title

• Collection of Insurance Policies and Survivor’s Pensions

• Duty to Conserve Property

Page 12: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

12

Absent Persons - Re-Emergence

• Reimbursement from “Fund”

• Right to Recover Assets -- Limited

• Measure of Recovery

Page 13: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

13

Law of Absent Persons

• Is this analogous?

• Is the person “absent”?

• When will this person “return”?

• How will pre-mortem cryonics change this?

Page 14: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

14

Cryogenically Preserved Embryos & Sperm

• Status as “Descendants” of Donor?

• Contingent Rights Vesting on Gestation

Page 15: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

15

Treatment of Trans-gendered Persons

• Continuity of Identity

• Civil Protections

• “New” Status

Page 16: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

16

What Obligations Might Arise?

• Obligations to Descendants

• Obligations to the State

• Obligations to Insurance Companies

• Impact on Marital Status

• Civil and Criminal Claims

Page 17: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

17

Protecting Your Rights

• Estate Planning and Dynasty Trusts

• Domiciliary Status at Death

• Property Maintenance Trusts

• Filing Protective Refunds for Estate Taxes

Page 18: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

18

Final Thoughts

Page 19: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

19

Possible Rights

• Revived Person as Heir

• Rights and Obligations as Heir

• Duties and Obligations while in Suspension

Page 20: 1 Possible Legal Rights of Cryogenically Revived Persons 1 st Annual Colloquium on the Law of Transhuman Persons Melbourne Beach, Florida December 10,

20

Thank You!

162258v1