#1 sunday sagi hip dislocations & pelvic injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false?...

21
11/19/2018 1 Pelvic Mythology HC Sagi, MD FACS Professor and Chief of Trauma University of Cincinnati MYTH CLASSIFYING A PELVIC FRACTURE BASED ON PLAIN RADIOGRAPHS AND COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY WILL TELL US IF A PELVIC FRACTURE IS STABLE OR UNSTABLE 58 year old lady falls off of horse. Pa

Upload: others

Post on 10-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

1

Pelvic Mythology

HC Sagi, MD FACSProfessor and Chief of Trauma

University of Cincinnati

MYTH

CLASSIFYING A PELVIC FRACTURE BASED

ON PLAIN RADIOGRAPHS AND COMPUTED

TOMOGRAPHY WILL TELL US IF A PELVIC

FRACTURE IS STABLE OR UNSTABLE

58 year old lady falls off of horse. Pa

Page 2: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

2

8 month F/U Non-operative RxDyspareunia and Recurrent UTI

How do we prevent this?

Page 3: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

3

True or False?

CLASSIFYING A PELVIC FRACTURE BASED

ON PLAIN RADIOGRAPHS AND COMPUTED

TOMOGRAPHY WILL TELL US IF A PELVIC

FRACTURE IS STABLE OR UNSTABLE

ARE THESE THE SAME INJURY?

ARE THEY CLASSIFED APC-1, APC-2 (or something else…)?

ARE THESE THE SAME INJURY?

ARE THEY REALLY BOTH CLASSIFED LC-1 (or something e

Page 4: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

4

The Impetus…

Page 5: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

5

Page 6: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

6

Page 7: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

7

METHOD OF EUA

• 15 distinct fluoroscopic images:

– Static, ER, IR, Push-Pull– AP, Inlet, Outlet projections

AP COMPRESSION - ER

LATERAL COMPRESSION - IR

Page 8: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

8

BILATERAL PUSH AND PULL

50% = No fixation (True APC-1)

50% = Anterior fixation (Occult APC-2)

APC INJURY

APC-1?

50% = No fixation (True APC-1)

50% = Anterior fixation (Occult APC-2)

APC INJURY

APC-1?

Page 9: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

9

60% = APC-2a (Ant ORIF ) 40% = APC-2b (Ant + Post

ORIF)

APC INJURY

APC-2?

60% = APC-2a (Ant ORIF ) 40% = APC-2b (Ant + Post

ORIF)

APC INJURY

APC-2?

EXAMPLE #1

NO BINDER

Page 10: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

10

Management?

EUA (Push/Pull)

Page 11: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

11

EUA (IR/ER)

32Is Anterior Only Fixation Adequate?

EXAMPLE #2

Page 12: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

12

Maximum ER

pull

push

Page 13: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

13

pull

push

LC INJURY

INCOMPLETE LC-1?

?

Page 14: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

14

LC INJURY

INCOMPLETE LC-1?

?

LC INJURY

INCOMPLETE LC-1?

?

?

Page 15: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

15

LC INJURY

– 63% -- No fixation (LC-1a)

– 37% --Anterior / Posterior fixation (LC-1b)

INCOMPLETE LC-1?

Page 16: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

16

Example #1

Incomplete Sacral Fracture

Page 17: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

17

Page 18: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

18

EX

BUT…

Example #2

Injury CT

Incomplete Sacral Fracture?

Static Inlet View

Page 19: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

19

Inlet – Lateral Compression

Post Fixation

• Static radiographs inadequately define pelvic ring instability:Some APC-1 ---> APC 2 (and need fixation)Some APC-2 ---> Fl/Ex too muc (need post

ORIF)Some LC-1 ---> IR too much (?)

Poor functional outcomes may be due (in part) to undiagnosed instability.

Conclusion

Page 20: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

20

Conclusion

• Pelvic EUA helps to confirm stability and avoid unnecessary transfers for surgery… for me.

• Pelvic EUA is an important diagnostic tool to guide treatment and fixation…for me.

Conclusion

Existing Classification Systems are OBSOLETE and cannot help to decide

treatment with modern strategies.

Conclusion

Page 21: #1 Sunday Sagi Hip Dislocations & Pelvic Injuries · 2018-11-20 · 11/19/2018 3 true or false? classifying a pelvic fracture based on plain radiographs and computed tomography will

11/19/2018

21

Existing Classification Systems are OBSOLETE and cannot help to decide

treatment with modern strategies.

Conclusion

X

ασπρο πατο!!

ευχαριστώ