10,000 septic tanks later - sustainable sanitation alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · michael mcwhirter...

14
Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results of Starting Large Scale FSM

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jan-2021

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Michael McWhirter

Acknowledgement:

American Red Cross

10,000 Septic

Tanks LaterImpacts and Results of

Starting Large Scale FSM

Page 2: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Large Scale FSM Activities Occurred After The

Indian Ocean Tsunami in Aceh, Indonesia

Page 3: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Challenging Conditions Existed for Onsite Sanitation

• High Water Table

• Often clay soils

• Cramped plots

• Limited contractor and

community capacity

Page 4: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

A Common Solution was used for Sanitation

in New Houses

Advantages

• Household ownership

• Better quality than septic tank

alone

Page 5: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Household Constructed Wetlands were a Major

Feature of the Solution

Page 6: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

The Wetlands Improved Effluent Quality Significantly

• Median BOD reduced

• 33% by Septic Tank

Alone

• 61% by Septic Tank

& Wetland

Data from all 70 villages ARC worked in, first test.

Page 7: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Training and Sustainability: A Point of Pride for Us

Page 8: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Solutions Were Found to the Challenges

E.g.s

• Preventing blockage with

kitchen waste (technology

and understanding)

• Disposal with high

groundwater (raised units)

• Desludging (FSTP built,

now government improved)

Page 9: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

With Monitoring, Training and Repair We Achieved

90% of BOD <100ppm from Wetlands

Page 10: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

The Facilities Were Well Used

Total

Defecate before the Tsunami?

Private toilet

Public toilet

River / sea / Bush / Garden

54

18

28

Is the toilet now in house used?

Yes 96

Data professional final randomized survey of 642 households

% of households

Page 11: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Calang WatSan

2005 2010

Well Designed and Delivered Onsite

Sanitation Formed a Backbone for Recovery

Page 12: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

And

continue

to do so

today.

Page 13: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Session Themes

● Advantages of Wetlands:

Improvement in Effluent Quality

● O&M Challenges: Poor Design,

Construction or Operation

Leads to Blockages

● Secrets to Scale: Careful

oversight, heavy community

engagement

Page 14: 10,000 Septic Tanks Later - Sustainable Sanitation Alliance · 2019. 3. 7. · Michael McWhirter Acknowledgement: American Red Cross 10,000 Septic Tanks Later Impacts and Results

Points to Remember

● Wetlands Improve Septic Tank

Effluent Quality

● But only to ~65%

● Carefully plan design and

construction

● Capacity building and support

for longterm value