10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ p ® xª£x pª x¥i£x n...

28

Upload: buihanh

Post on 23-Mar-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


7 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

������������ ������ ����������������� � �"!$#%�&�'���)(* +(,���)�$-

.,/10325476�0%03859:/;=<�>�?�@"ACBEDGFHBJILKNMPORQTSUDGVXWC<YIHBZF�[\MEK]BZ^YMZBR_a`%bc@edgf+O1MhACBZ^

fiAYDGFH^CjkILFHORlGBnmGm\_amRoRprq1s)fiORMhACBZ^3_3t�BZFuVvO1^xwBJyzVvO1K]Q|{'}�OGOR~YBZFh�+KN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]�a��Fk�"ILA\y�OGORMhACBE^%��~CB

���3�h�J�Z�x�����]���h�������r�����e���x�����R��� �"���5���r�¡����¢R£x�¤����¥¡���¦���"���:�P���)§G�r�J¨����©rª��¡���h«r¬

�k�������¦���P�����­�®�����xª­£x�Pª��X¥i£x���n�k�P�������]��¯�¨���� �¦�����G©x£x°L��±U����°L�u�¤«x���¤�­��²³��ª­��°h�h¯´ �G©x����²a��ª­��°h��¯:���x©)µ¶�­�x¥��­�r�����­�x� °"²a��ª­��°h�*���*�N���k¥���������¥¡���]���,���h«x���������¦�z¬� �rªr¯:������«Y��°L����·����¤��¯\���h�u¥¡���r�­�¤��ª­� °h���a§G�r�J¨����©rª���¯\��� ¥��L¬¸©r�h«C���x©r���1�¶���x©v��£r¹x¬º ��°L���¤·��»§G�r�J¨¶�¤��©rª���¯¶���:©¼� �x°L�­¥�«:�¤�h���v§G�r�J¨����©rª���½¾�5�¿���r�����x©7��������°k�����°L���¤�­��¯¦¨��,¹x�k���LÀ:��°L�­¥¡¥¡���¦�Á�­�����r�*°L�­�x�r��°L�����­�¡����²³��ª­��°,ÂÁ����ª��u��¥¡¥¡���rªr½

ÃxÄUÅYÆ�ÇeÈ¡É+Ê3Å�Ë�ÇUÄ

;=BJIe<CjejuIhO1FuIe�eKNIHA�ORjH�xK]^Y?X<Y^C~CBZF"�eACKNMhAÌMEDG^C~CK ILKNDG^Cj"DG^CB�V�OPw�FuK]?GArIH��<YQ]QNwXMEQÍORKNVÎIHDACO�ÏRB¡ÐhÑ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ�ÑH֡צÔ3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:ÑeO1}ÜDG<\I*OR^XORWCWCQNK]MZO1ILKNDG^�~CDRVvORKN^%_rOR^Y~X^YDRI3Ýu<CjuI&ÓJÕ�ئÐLÑHÖÖrÞRÕ|ÞßD:MZMZ<YFHFHKN^C?àK]^$ILACKNj¡~CDGV�ORK]^%�¤áãâ+^CB�ORjuWÜBEMEInDR�¶IHACBXFHBZäx<CKNFHBEV�BE^xIHjnDR^®�x^CD��eQ yBE~C?GB)FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^���DGFHV�ORQNK]jHVXjeILA�O1I+MPOR^�}³B)~CBZFuKNÏGBE~å��FuDGVæILACKNj�MZDG^CjuK]~CBEFLO1IHK]DG^KNj¶ÏRBZFuw��UBEQ]QÜjLO1IHK]juçCBZ~»}rw�QNDG?GK]MZORQC��DGFuVvORQNK]juV�jE�Tb®B+jHACORQ]QÜjHBZB1_CACD��¶BEÏGBEFZ_CIHA�O1I"juDGV�BD1ILACBEF�ORjuWÜBEMEILj�O1FHBè^CD1IvILFuBPO1IHBZ~éjHO1ILKNju�¸ORMJILDGFuK]QNwR_&O1IvQ]BZORjuIv^CDRI»}rwêMZQÍO1jHjHKNMPORQeç�FujuIuyDRFH~CBEFnWCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHB�QNDG?GKNMR��;ÁDR?GK]M�ë,FHDR?GFLORVXVXK]^C?»Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZjE_�ORj�K]^Y~CK]MZO1ILBE~®}rw$ILAYBZK]F^CORV�B1_ÁORFHB¿Ò³ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛßQÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEjZ_ÁOR^Y~åIHA:<Yj�^YDRI�^CBZMEBZjHjHORFHKNQNw�O1WCWCFHDRWCFHK]O1ILB�ORjÐLÑ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔèQ]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjE�ð�^�O&^x<YIky�jHAYBZQ]Q�ñïOR^C~¡juDGV�BJ�eA�O1IÁB�òCO1?G?GBZFHO1ILBE~aóJ_­ILAYB,~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^CMEB,}ÜBJI��UBEBZ^��x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB�y}CORjHBE~»WCFHDG?RFLORVXV�KN^C?�ñ��eACKNMhA»WCFHD:MZBEjHjuBZj"�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�ó¶OR^C~�MEQÍORjujHK]MZORQ³WCFHDG?RFLORVXV�KN^C?õ�ö%÷¦øúù5øûù5üeý|þ|üJÿ¦ù��ûühý|ø��Eÿ����3ü�ÿnüJþ¸ý|ø����ýï÷¦ü�ý,÷¦üJù�ü���� uüJþ����� ø�ÿ���kþ��"ü�ÿ��Tø�ÿ�ýï÷�������­þïÿ1ü����! #"

$&%('�)�* +(,.-/) " -/'�'0)213 ö%÷24��ø�5Pøûù¸ø��Jÿ76 �ý�89uÿ;:Pÿ��(8<��/�>=�=ü�ÿ2�7�­ü�ý|ü�øúù/"0�0� ��0�­þzù��"�ÿ��Jý³ù�ý|þïø?��ý�"Eü�ÿ��@894�>�5ÿ���ýA��úüJø��ý��&÷¦üB50,ü7�>C¦ÿ­ø�ýïø�50*ü�ÿ1ù�89kþ3ý��Uý|÷�D�­þ��06����E�0���­øúù¸ýïøúÿ�=0�¦øúùï÷­øúÿ�=76�ký�8F/kÿG6��Jýï÷ 1

H

Page 2: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

ñî�eACK]MhA®WCFHD:MZBEjHjuBZj�~CO1IhOró+MZOR^¼}³B)��DGFHV¿<YQÍO1IHBZ~åORj¡��DGQ]QND­�ejE��ð�^¼MZQ]ORjHjuK]MZORQ,WCFHDR?GFLORV)yVXK]^Y?C_¶DR^CBß~CBEjHKN?G^CjXjHW³BZMZK]ORQ]K � BE~êWCFuDG?GFHORV�j�ILACO1I�O1FHB�IhORKNQ]DGFuBZ~ ILD¼O®jHW³BZMEKNç�MÌORW\yWYQ]K]MZO1ILKNDG^¼WYFHDG}CQNBZVà�$@"ACB��x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GB�OR}³DG<YI¿IHACB»WCFHDR}CQ]BEV�~CBEjHMEFHK]W\ILK]DR^�OR^C~7ILAYBO1WCWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^�~CDRVvORKN^�KNj¶KNV�WYQ]K]MEKNIHQNwnFHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rILBE~�K]^�IHACBijkILFu<CMEIH<CFHB+D1�%ILACB�WCFHDR?GFLORVà_O1^C~�V¿<YjuITILAx<CjT}ÜB¶ORMZäx<CKNFHBE~�}rw¡ILACBWCFHDR?GFLORVXVXBZFZ�=ð�^n�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GBJyz}�ORjHBE~)WCFHDR?GFLORV)yVXK]^Y?C_�ILACB¿�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB�OR}³DG<YIiIHACB)ORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^�~CDGV�ORKN^ÌKNjiFHBEWCFHBEjHBE^xIHBZ~åBJò\WCQNK]MZK ILQ wñ�K]^ßOR^$ORWCWYFHDGWCFuKÍO1IHBnFuBZWCFuBZjuBZ^rIhO1IHK]DG^Ì��DGFHV�ORQ]KNjHVvó���KN~CBPORQNQNwR_CILACBnWCFHD:MZBEjHjHKN^C?�MZOR^$}ÜB~YDG^CBe�eKNILA�ILAYB�ACBEQ]WXDR�%?RBZ^CBEFLORQ'ñ¸Kï��B1�N_:ORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^\yzK]^C~YBZW³BZ^C~CBE^rI�ó�WCFuDG}CQ]BEV jHDRQNÏ:K]^C?VXBEIHACD:~CjZ�5@"Ax<CjE_YILAYB��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�MPOR^�}³B�ORMZäx<CKNFHBZ~�OR^C~vFuBZWCFuBZjuBZ^rILBE~à}rw�OR^vORWCWCQNK yMZO1ILKNDG^¿B�òYW³BZFkIP_G�eACD¡^CBEBZ~�^CDRI�}ÜB&�¶BZQNQ y�ORMZäx<�ORKN^rILBZ~n�eKNILA)~YBEIhO1K]Q]jTDR�aILAYB&K]VXWCQ]BEV�BE^\yILO1ILKNDG^%�5f�j�O�juK]VXWCQ]BiBJòYORVXWCQ]B1_�Q]BEIe<Yj�MEDG^CjuK]~CBEFeIHACB�IhORju��DR�Tç�^C~CKN^C?�DG<YI"�eACBJILACBEFI��¶Dè^CD:~CBEj�K]^¼Oß~CKNFHBZMJILBE~7?GFLO1WCAéñî�eACK]MhA7V�OPw�FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rI)IHACBvACKNBZFHORFHMhACKNMPORQ*DGFu?rO¦y^YK � O¦ILK]DR^ßDR�OvMEDGVXW�OR^rwYó�ORFuB¿MZDG^Y^CBZMJILBZ~êñî�eACBEIHACBZF+DR^CB¿BZVXWCQND­wRBZB¿KNj�IHACB¿}³DGjHjiDR�O1^CDRILAYBZFUDR^CB�ó��,f¾ç�FujuI"juDGQ]<YIHK]DG^3_x�eAYK]MhA»K]jÏGBEFuwv�¸O1FUOP�UO�w���FHDGV }³BZKN^C?��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�y}CORjHBE~%_%VXK]?GArI�}ÜB)O�WCFHDG?RFLORV ILACO1I+BE^CMZD:~CBZj+IHACB¿jkILFH<YMEIL<YFHB)DR�,IHACB¿jHW³BZMEKNç�M�?GFLORWYAKN^�K ILjMZDG^rIHFHDGQ³juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBR�,f jHBZMEDG^C~%_YV�DGFuBeFHBPO1jHDG^�O1}CQ]B1_\juDGQ]<YIHK]DG^XVXK]?GArIBJò\WCQNK]MZK ILQ wFuBZWCFuBZjuBZ^rI¿ILAYB�?GFHORWCAåK]^®OR^7O1WCWCFHDRWCFHK]O1ILB�~�O1ILOàjkILFu<CMEIH<CFHBèñ��eACKNMhA7Q]KNjuI�ILAYB�^CD:~CBEjIHA�O1I�ORFuB)~CK]FuBZMJILQNwÌMZDR^C^CBZMJILBE~aóJ_TOR^C~$IHACBZ^åMZD:~CB¿ILAYB)V�BZOR^CK]^Y?»DR���uMZDG^Y^CBZMJILBZ~��ÌKN^OåWCFHDR?GFLORV�ILA�O1I�K]jXK]^Y~CBZW³BZ^C~YBZ^rI�DR�iILACBàjHW³BZMEKNç�MÌ?GFLORWYA%�é@"ACK]jXWCFuDG?GFLO1V V¿<CjuI}³BXOR}CQNB¿ILDàMZDGVXWC<YIHB�IHACB�MZDG^Y^CBZMJILBZ~¼^CD\~YBZj���FHDGV ILACB�?GK ÏGBZ^åK]^\��DGFHV�O1ILKNDG^$OR}³DG<YIIHACB)~CKNFHBZMJILQ wèMZDR^C^CBZMJILBE~¼^CD:~CBZjE�)>�KN^�ORQ]Q wG_3OR^�BEÏGBE^¼VXDGFHB��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBJy�}CORjHBE~¼jHDRQ]<\yIHK]DG^XMZDR<CQ]~�}³B�DG^CBiKN^��eACKNMhAvILAYBi�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�OR}³DG<YIILAYBiVXBPOR^CKN^C?�DR���uMZDR^C^CBZMJILBE~��KNj�ORQ]juD�FHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rILBE~éK]^ãOR^�BJò\WCQNK]MEKNI)�UO�wR_¶��DGF�B�òCO1V�WCQNBR_}rw7ILACB���DGQNQ]D��eK]^C?èd�DGFu^MEQÍOR<YjHBZjE{

~CKNFHBEMEILQ wry�MZDR^C^CBZMJILBE~Tñ��� Yó�� MEDG^C^CBEMEILBE~'ñ��� Yó��~CK]FuBZMEIHQNwry�MEDG^C^CBEMEIHBZ~Áñ�����ró��ÌMZDR^C^CBZMJILBE~�ñ����� Yó�� MEDG^C^CBEMEILBE~'ñ��� Yó��

f ?GBZ^YBZFLO1Q�WCFuDG}CQ]BEV juDGQNÏ:KN^C?vMEDGV�W³DG^CBE^rIP_Ü�eAYK]MhA$K]jiOR}CQNBnILDvA�OR^C~CQNB�ju<CMhA�MZQÍO1<CjHBEjñ�BR��?C� _xIHACB�K]^rILBEFHWCFuBEILBEF*DR�=O�;=DG?GK]Meë,FuDG?GFLO1V�VXK]^C?iQÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBPóJ_rMZDR<CQ]~X^CD�� <CjuB�IHACBZjuB��DRFHV¿<CQ]ORB»ILDG?RBEILAYBZF��eK ILAãILACBÌBJò\WCQ]KNMZK I�KN^Y��DGFuVvO1IHK]DG^�DG^ãILACBÌ~CK]FuBZMJILQNw�MEDG^C^CBEMEIHBZ~^YD\~CBEj"ILD�K]^Y��BEF&ILACB¡MEDG^C^CBEMEILBE~è^CD:~CBZjE�f �x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GBvFuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^ ñ���`�ó+��DGFHV�ORQ]KNjHV jHACDG<YQ]~ ORQNQ]D�� ��DRF�IHACBvjkw\V�}ÜDGQNK]MFuBZWCFuBZjuBZ^rIhO1IHK]DG^åDR�UORQ]Q'ILACB��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBXFHBZQNBEÏ1OR^rI¡K]^åO�?GKNÏRBZ^åORWCWYQ]K]MZO1ILKNDG^è~CDRVvORKN^%�>�FuDGV �eA�O1IÁ�¶B¶ACO�ÏRBUjHORK]~¡jHDe�¸ORFTOR}³DG<YIÁILAYB<YjHBDR�C�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBK]^¡�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBJyz}�ORjuBZ~WYFHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?C_3�¶B�MZOR^¼~YBZFHK ÏGB�I��UDÌFHBEä:<YK]FHBEV�BE^rILj¡ILA�O1InjH<YMhA O���DRFHV�ORQ]KNjHV V¿<CjuIjHO1ILKNju�îwR�â�^�ILAYB�DG^CB¡A�OR^C~3_�KNI"V¿<YjuIe}³B�BEäx<CK]WCW³BZ~��eKNIHAàOÌÖ:Ñ��JÚ ÞRÐuÞRÕ¸í��RÑ+Ó�ÑJìXÞRÔ�Õ¸í��hÓr_IHA�O1IK]jE_GILACB�VXBPOR^CKN^C?�DR�ÜILACBeBZ^rIHFHK]BEj¶KN^XO��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�}�ORjuB�ñ����"ó5V¿<CjuI}³Be~CBEç�^YBZ~KN^C~CBEWÜBE^C~CBZ^rIiDR�'IHACB�WCFHDG?RFLORVXj"ILA�O1I�DGW³BZFHO1ILB¡DG^�ILAYB���� ñ¸^CD�WC<CFHBEQNw»WYFHD:MZBZ~Y<CFLORQjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZjhó�����jH<CORQ]Q wG_�ju<CMhA�OÌ~YBZMZQ]ORFLO¦ILKNÏRB�juBZV�OR^rILKNMZj�KNjn?RKNÏGBE^7}rwåVvORWYWCK]^C?�ILAYBjkw:V¿}ÜDRQ]K]MàBJò\WCFuBZjujHK]DR^Cj»K]^rILDéñïOR^éO1}CjuIHFLORMJILK]DR^ DR�Ló)IHACBèFHBEQ]BJÏRO1^xIvjHBE?GV�BE^rI»DR��ILAYB

o

Page 3: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

���UDGFuQ]~%� ��ð�^�OR~C~CK ILKNDG^%_xDG^CB�^CBZBE~CjeO�^CDRIHK]DG^vDR���kILFu<YILA3_ ���eAYK]MhA»V�OR�RBEj&KNI¶WÜDRjHjHKN}CQ]BIHD�~CBEIHBZFHVXK]^YB+�eACK]MhAàDR��IHACB¡juw:V¿}³DGQ]KNM+juILO1ILBEV�BE^rILjeACDGQN~àKN^»ILACB¡MZ<YFHFHBE^rI �k�¶DGFuQ]~%� �â+^¼IHACB�DRIHACBZFnA�OR^C~3_5DG^CB�^YBZBZ~Yj)OR^ � íîÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ�Õ��XÐLÑJÕ¸ÐJí|Ñ��¦ÞRÚ*ìvÑ����YÞRÔ�í]ÓJìà_'�eACKNMhAKNj�OR}CQ]B)IHDßFHBZORQ]K � B¿IHACB�OR}³D�ÏGB�y�VXBZ^rILKNDG^CBZ~å?GBE^CBZFHORQ*WCFHDG}YQ]BZV juDGQNÏ:KN^C?ÌMEDGVXWÜDG^YBZ^rIP�@"AYK]j¿VXBZMhA�O1^CK]juV�juACDG<CQN~ ORQ]QND�� ILDèFuBEILFuK]BJÏGB��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�IHA�O1I)KNj�DG^CQ wåK]VXWCQ]KNMZKNIHQNwWYFHBZjuBZ^rI"KN^�ILAYB ���i_rILA�O1IUK]jE_\K I¶juACDG<CQN~�}³B+OR}CQNB�IHD�~CBE~C<CMEB�K]VXWCQ]KNMZKNIHQNw�FHBEWCFHBEjHBE^xIHBZ~�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB*��FHDRV ILACB*BJò\WCQNK]MEKNIT�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GBR�'@"ACB¶}³BZACO�Ï:KNDG<CFTDR�YIHACK]jÁ~CBE~C<CMEIHKNÏRBUMZDRV�yW³DG^CBE^rIejHACDG<YQ]~»~CBEWÜBE^C~�DG^CQNw�DG^�IHACB�jHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZjUDR�ÁILACB�FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^�QÍO1^C?G<�OR?RBR_O1^C~ê^YDRIXDG^ãIHACBàjuw:^rIhORMJILK]M���DGFuV DR�iIHACB�BZ^rILFuK]BEj�KN^�IHACB � ��_,K|��BR� _UjHBEVvO1^xIHK]MZORQ]Q wBEäx<CKNÏ1ORQNBZ^rI"BZ^rIHFHK]BEj&jHAYDG<CQ]~»QNBPOR~�ILD�IHACB+jLO1V�B+FuBZju<CQNIHjZ�,ðz�Á�UB�<YjHB+ç�FujuIuyzDGFH~YBZF&WCFuBZ~\yKNMPO1IHBßQNDG?GK]MÌORj�juBZV�OR^rILKNMZjv��DGFXILACB�d�DGFH^ MZQÍO1<CjHBEj»K]^ DG<YF»OR}³D­ÏRBèBJòYORVXWCQNBR_"ILACBE^IHACB�<Cju<�ORQ"ë,FuDGQ]DG?ÌK]^rILBEFHWCFuBEIHBZFHj)~YD$^CDRI¿��<CQ ç�Q]Q,IHACK]j¿FuBZäx<CKNFHBZVXBZ^rIZ�$fiMZMEDGFH~YK]^C?èIHDIHACB�jHBZV�OR^rILKNMZjE_aIHACB¡DGFH~YBZF�DR��IHACBnMEQÍOR<YjHBZj�OR^C~àDR�'ILACB�MZDG^­Ýu<C^CMEIHK]DG^Yj�KNj�KNFHFuBZQ]BJÏ1OR^rIP�f�^rwãë*FuDGQ]DR?åWYFHDG?GFHORVXV�BEF��eK]QNQU�x^CD��¡_&ACD��¶BEÏGBEFZ_&IHA�O1IXjH<CMhA OåFuBJyzDGFH~CBEFHKN^C?�VvOPw~YFLORjkILK]MZORQ]Q wvMhACOR^C?GB�ILAYB�}³BZACO�Ï:KNDG<CFeDR�TILACB¡WCFuDG?GFLO1VÌ�f�^CDRIHACBZFFHBEä:<YK]FHBEV�BE^rI¶IHA�O1IK]j*<Cju<�ORQ]Q w)K]VXW³DGjHBE~�DG^ �¡` ��DGFHV�ORQNK]jHVXj5KNj*IHA�O1IDR�%ORQ yQND��eK]^C?¡��DGF¶OXÓJÕïÐ�� �JÕ��:ÐLÑHÖXÐLÑ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�ÕzÞRÕ¸í|ئÔ�DR�%IHACBi�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB1�@"AYK]jV�BZOR^Cj¶IHA�O1I¶jHB�yV�OR^rILKNMPORQNQNw�FHBZQ]O1ILBE~vKN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^Ìñ���DRF¶B�òCO1V�WCQNBR_\ORQ]Q�IHACBi�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�O1}ÜDG<\IU�x^CD��eQ yBE~C?GB»FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^ã}�ORjuBZ~ãDG^�+BZjHMEFHKNWYILKNDG^ ;=DG?GKNMZjhó�juACDG<CQN~�ORQ]juD$juw:^rIhORMJILKNMPORQNQNw}³B+?GFuDG<CW³BZ~�IHDG?GBEIHACBZFE�,@"ACK]jUFHBZäx<CKNFHBEV�BE^xIeKNjZ_:DG^�ILAYB�DG^CB+A�O1^C~%_­Ýu<YjuILK ç�BZ~�}rw�MZDG?1y^YKNILK ÏGBvOR~CBZäx<�O1MEwG��Îâ+^7ILACBvDRILACBEF¿A�OR^Y~%_,ILACBEFHB�ORFuBvWC<CFuBZQ w7WCFHOR?GV�O1ILKNM�FuBPORjuDG^CjZ_juK]^CMEB�O�jkILFu<CMEIH<CFHBE~ßFHBEWCFHBEjHBE^xILO1ILKNDG^èO1Q]Q]D��ejU��DRF&�¸ORjuIHBZFeFHBJILFHKNBEÏ1ORQï�SUFuKNIHK]MZj�DR�*O�Q]DG?GKNMJyz}�ORjHBE~ßO1WCWCFHDGORMhAßILD ��`gDR�îIHBZ^�ñ�K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx<�O1IHB¿Q]DG?RK]M��eKNIHAçCFHjuIky�DGFu~CBZF*WCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHBeQ]DG?GKNMR�Tðz�Ü�¶B�MZDG^CjuK]~CBEF*K]^�ACD�� �¸ORF �*ÐLÓJÕ��HئÐHÖ:ÑJÐ5Ò³ÐLÑHÖRí��HÞRÕ�ÑeÚ]ØHÛRí��jHO1ILKNjuç�BEj�ILACB$FuBZäx<CKNFHBZVXBZ^rIHjàKN^rILFHD:~C<CMEBZ~ OR}³D�ÏGBR_�KNI»juACD��ej�K]^ �¸ORMJI»jHDGVXB$juIHFHDG^Y?~YBEç�MEKNILjE� @"ACB�@�O1FHjH�xK]OR^cjHBZV�OR^rILKNMZj»DR�nWCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHB$Q]DG?GKNMßKNj�ILACB�WCFuDRILDRI�w:W³B$DR��O~YBZMZQ]ORFLO¦ILKNÏRB¼juBZV�OR^rILK]MEj �XACD��UBJÏGBEFZ_¿K Iè~CD:BZjè^YDRI$ORQNQ]D�����DGFßOR^ OR~CBEäx<�O1ILB®ILFHBZO1IuyVXBZ^rIeDR�'K]^YMZDGVXWCQ]BJILB�O1^C~�MZDG^rILFHOR~CKNMEILDRFuw��x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB1_aDGF&DR�'jH<C}xÝuBZMEIHKNÏRB�OR^Y~àIHK]VXBJy~YBZW³BZ^C~CBE^rI,�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GBR��;TO¦ILBZFTDG^%_¦�UB¶jHA�O1Q]QxjHBEB¶ILACO1I'IHACK]jÁ~CBJç�MZK I�MZOR^¿}³B¶D�ÏRBZFHMEDGVXB}rwåMZDR^CjHKN~CBZFuK]^C?���DG^CVXDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM�;=DG?GK]MEj�O1^C~��ÌD:~�ORQ;=DG?GKNMZjE�»@"ACBv<Cju<�ORQjuw:^rIhO¦òD1�'ç�FujuIky�DGFu~CBZF"WCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHB¡Q]DG?GKNMi~CD:BZje^CD1IejH<CWCW³DGFkI�O�jkILFu<CMEIH<CFHBE~ßFHBEWCFHBEjHBE^xILO1ILKNDG^àDR��x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB1�è[:K]^CMEB�ORQNQ5ILACB�FHBZQNBEÏ1OR^rI¿KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEBvWCFuDG}CQNBZVXj�ORFuB�<Y^C~CBZMEK]~�O1}CQ]B1_5KNI�K]jO1Q]jHD�^CDRI�WÜDRjHjHKN}CQ]B¡ILD�WCFHD�Ï:K]~YBn��DGF�jHBEVvOR^rIHK]MPO1Q]QNw»OR~CBZäx<�O¦ILB¿KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�WCFuD\MEBZ~C<CFuBZjE�ð�^éIHACBè��DGQ]QND��eK]^C?åjHBEMEILKNDG^%_��UB$juA�ORQ]Q�K]^rILFuD\~Y<CMZBèjuD1y�MZORQ]QNBZ~��+BEjHMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^ ;ÁDR?GK]MEjZ_���eAYK]MhA®ORFHB�OR^®O1IuILBZVXWYI+IHD�D­ÏRBZFuMZDGVXB�}³DRIHAåD1�¶IHACB)QÍORjkIuyzV�BE^xIHK]DG^YBZ~$WCFuDG}CQ]BEV�j�}rw<YjHK]^Y?�O)^CDR^CjuILOR^C~�ORFu~ßjkw\^rILO¦òÌOR^C~�}rw�FHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]^Y?�IHACB¡BJò\WCFuBZjHjuKNÏRB�W³D­�¶BZFE�� îÿiý|÷�,÷ ���"ü�ÿG6­þzü�øúÿ "�� �Eþïþ��ûühý�/�eøúÿ>� �Eþ��"ühý|ø��Eÿ�øûùÁü��ûù��¶ÿ��JýTù�ý��Jþ�/��ø�ÿG�­ÿ¦þ�/�úü�ý�/� �¦üJþ¸ýzù 1��� ý|÷�kþ�ÿ¦ü0� Hù �1ù����ø�ÿ�ýï÷�;��ø�ý�uþ|ü�ý��­þ�¶üJþ����ý�uþ��&øúÿ��0���0=Eø��uü�� ���0=Eø��uù" ����� �Eÿ2� /��ý �ûü�ÿ�=��¦ü�=�uù/" �ü�ÿ2����� � , �"!$# , ��ø�:0�� % �ûü�ÿ2=0�¦ü0=0uù 1 �

&

Page 4: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

f�MZMEDGFH~CKN^C?èILD$�eA�O¦I)�UB»A�OPÏRBÌjHORK]~ <C^rIHK]QU^YD­�¡_¶;=DG?GKNM»ë,FHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?ÌQ]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjäx<�O1Q]KN�îwXO1j&FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^»QÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEjUDG^YQNwXKN�%IHACBEwvORFuB+BZäx<CKNWCWÜBE~��eKNIHA»OR^»ORWYWCFHD1yWYFHKÍO¦ILB,~CBEMZQÍO1FLO1IHKNÏGB*juBZV�OR^rILK]MEjZ_¦�eACK]MhAnK]j=^CDRIÁIHACB¶MZORjHB*��DGFTë,FHDGQNDG?C_¦ORjTK]QNQ]<CjkILFLO¦ILBZ~�}rwIHACB�BJòYORVXWCQNBR�,ðzIejHAYDG<CQ]~�}³B�^CDRIHBZ~�ILA�O1I"�¶B¡~CD�^CDRIeMEQÍORKNV IHA�O1IeK I"K]j"^CD1I"WÜDRjHjHKN}CQ]BIHDnjuDGQNÏRBiO�jHW³BZMEKNç�M�FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^�WCFuDG}CQ]BEV �eKNIHAXIHACBiAYBZQ]WXDR�%O�ë,FHDGQNDG?¡WCFHDR?GFLORVà{juK]^CMEB)ë,FHDGQNDG?vKNj+MZDRV�WC<\IhO1IHK]DG^�O1Q]QNwvMZDGVXWCQNBEILB1_ÜIHACK]j+KNj+ORQ �&OPw:j+W³DGjHjuK]}CQNBR��d�D��UBJÏGBZFE_IHACK]j*KNjUO¡WCFHDR?GFLORVXVXK]^C?¡ORWYWCFHDrO1MhAvK]^��eACKNMhAvILACB��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBiKNj*^CDRI¶BZ^CMED\~CBE~vKN^C~CBJyW³BZ^Y~CBZ^rI&D1�3ILAYB��UOPw�KN^X�eAYK]MhAvK IK]j*WCFHD:MZBEjHjuBZ~%����òYORMEIHQNw�}³BZMPO1<CjHB�DR�=ë,FHDRQ]DG?¡}³BZK]^Y?MEDGVXWC<YIhO¦ILK]DR^�ORQ]Q wXMZDGVXWCQ]BJILB1_�ORQ]Q³ILACB�FHBEjHW³DG^CjuK]}CKNQ]KNI�wèñ¸B1��?Y�N_C��DGF&IHBZFuV�KN^�O1ILKNDG^�DR�TILAYBKN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�WCFHD:MZBEjHjhó¿QNK]BZj)KN^7ILACB�A�O1^C~Cj�DR��WCFHDG?RFLORVXV�BEFZ_*OR^Y~êMZOR^C^CDRIXO1<YILDGV�O1IHK yMZORQ]Q w$}³Bv?G<�O1FLOR^rILBEBZ~%�Ìð�^ O �¡` juw:juIHBZVà_5ILACB�K]^rILBEQ]QNK]?GBE^xI�FuBEILFuK]BJÏRO1QVXBZMhACOR^CK]juV�jjuACDG<CQN~éñ�K]~CBZORQ]Q wCó+}³B�OR}YQ]B�ILDßACOR^C~CQNB�ORQNQ5ILACB��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBvILA�O¦I�KNjnFuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rILBZ~�KN^Oèjkw:^xILORMEIHK]MZORQ]Q w®MEDGFHFuBZMJI)�&OPwG_*�eACKNMhAãVXBPO1^Cj�ILACO1I)DG^CBvV¿<CjuI�FuBZjkILFHKNMEI)DR^CBZjuBZQN�eIHDO�jH<Y}CQÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBàñ�jH<CMhA¼ORj���O1IhO1Q]DG?xó�KN�¶DG^CB)�&O1^xIHj�IHD�<CjHB�OÌ;=DG?RK]M�ë,FHDG?RFLORVXV�KN^C?O1WCWCFHDGORMhA»��DGF �¡`��\fi^�D�ÏGBEFuÏ:K]BJ� DR�TBJò:IHBZ^C~CBE~è;=DG?GKNM+ë,FHDR?GFLORVXjU�eK ILA»~CBEMZQÍO1FLO1IHKNÏGBjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZjnOR^C~�ILACBEK]FnORWCWCQNK]MPO¦ILK]DR^èILDàFHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rILKN^C?è�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBXMPOR^®}ÜB���DG<C^Y~¼K]^� & o\_��ro\_ H & _³o��ï�

���YÊ=ÆaË ��Å�Ë�ÇUÄ���Ç��UË�Ê�

@"AYB�O1IuILBZVXWYI¡ILDÌWCFHD�Ï:K]~YBX��DGF�OàjuILFu<CMEIH<CFHBE~7FHBEWCFHBEjHBE^xILO1ILKNDG^7DR�UK]^Y��DRFHV�O1ILKNDG^è�&O1jDR^CB�D1�3ILAYBiV�ORK]^�VXDRILK ÏRO¦ILK]DR^Cj���DGF*K]^rIHFHD:~C<CMZKN^C?�BPORFuQNw �¡` ��DGFHV�ORQNK]jHVXj�ju<CMhA�ORjU[\BJyV�OR^rILKNM ��BJI��UDRFH�xj+OR^Y~Ì>�FHORV�BEjZ���3ÐuÞRìvÑhÓ¡A�OPÏGB�}ÜBEBZ^àK]^rILFuD\~Y<CMZBE~Ì}rw �ÌKN^CjH�rw � � & �O1j,FHBZMEDGFH~:y�Q]KN�RB¶~�O1IhO+jkILFu<CMEIH<CFHBEj��DGF�FHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rILKN^C?¡WCFHD1ILDRI�w:WCKNMPORQ\jHKNIH<�O1IHK]DG^Cj5OR^C~)DG}\yÝuBEMEIHjZ�i@"AYB¿�RBJwèK]~YBPOX�UORjiIHDvMEDGQ]QNBZMEIiORQNQÁIHACB�KN^Y��DGFuVvO1IHK]DG^�^CBEMZBEjHjLO1Fuwß��DRF�ILFuBPO1IHK]^C?OXjHK IL<�O1IHK]DG^�KN^ÌDG^YB�WCQ]ORMZB�ñ�IHACBn��FHORVXB¡��DRFeIHACK]j�jHK IL<�O¦ILK]DR^aóJ�¶ð�^ � � & �ï_ �ÌKN^CjH�rwàMZDRV�y}YK]^CBE~vACKNjUK]^rIHFHD:~C<CMEIHK]DG^XDR�%IHACB���FHORVXB�KN~CBPO¡�eKNILAvOn?GBE^CBZFHORQ³FHB�ÝuBEMEIHK]DG^�D1�=Q]DG?RK]MeORjUO�¡`ê��DRFHV�ORQ]KNjHVà�'d�OPwGBZj � m1sC_:mGm��aMZFHK ILKNMZK � BZ~)ILACO1I>�FLORVXBZj*QÍO1Mh�¿O���DGFHV�ORQYjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZjZ_O1^C~�jHACD��¶BZ~�IHA�O1I*�eKNIHA�OR^�ORWCWCFuDGWCFHK]O1ILB¶��DGFHV�ORQ]K � O1IHK]DG^vñ¸D1�ÜIHACBZKNF5V�DR^CDRILDR^CK]M1_G^CDG^\yWYFHD:MZBZ~Y<CFLORQTORjuWÜBEMEIHjhóJ_³>�FLO1V�BEj�MZOR^ß}³B¡jHBEBZ^$ORj�O�juw:^rIhORMJILKNM�Ï1ORFuKÍOR^rI�DR��çCFHjuIky�DGFu~CBZFWYFHBZ~YK]MPO¦ILB¡Q]DG?RK]MR�� ÑJìXÞRÔ�Õ¸í����nÑJÕ¸ÙUئÐL×�Ór_a�eACK]MhAÌ�UBnjHA�ORQNQÁMZDG^CjuK]~CBEFiKN^ßjHDRV�BJ�eA�O1I�V�DGFuBn~YBEIhO1K]Q|_�ACO�ÏRB}³BZBE^é~CBEÏRBZQNDGWÜBE~c}xw��+<CK]QNQ]KÍO1^ ����� �i��DGF�FHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rILKN^C? ILACBßjHBZV�OR^rILKNMZj�D1�¡^�O1IL<YFLORQQ]OR^C?G<COR?GB�ñîILACKNj�B�ò\WCQÍORKN^Cj+ILAYBZK]F�^CORV�BPóJ�)@"ACBJwåORQ]QND�� IHD�FHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rInMZDG^CMEBZWYIHj¿OR^Y~DR}:ÝuBZMJILj�ORj¡^CD:~CBZj¡K]^�O»?GFHORWCAêñ¸juBZBX>�KN?G<CFHB H óJ��[\<YMhA¼O»?GFHORWCA�A�ORj�I��¶DÌ~CK ô3BEFHBE^xII�w:W³BZjÁDR�\BZ~C?RBZjZ{ÁWCFuDGW³BZFuI�w+BZ~C?GBEj�O1jHjHKN?G^�WCFuDGWÜBEFuIHK]BZjñ�Q]KN�RB,MZDRQ]DG<CFLó³ILDeMEDG^CMZBEWYILj¶ñ�BR��?C�N_��FuDG?xó�OR^C~®DG}:ÝuBEMEILj�ñ¸B1��?C� _ �¡BEFHVXKNIhóJ_=�eACBZFuBPORjnðk[xy�fey�BE~C?GBZjnK]^rILFuD\~Y<CMZB�ACKNBZFLO1FHMhACKNMPORQFuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^CjHAYK]WCj�ORV�DR^C?+MZDR^CMZBEWYILjOR^C~)KN^CjuILOR^CMEB"FHBZQ]O1ILKNDG^CjuACK]WCj'}ÜBJI��UBEBZ^XDG}:ÝuBEMEILjOR^Y~MEDG^CMEBZWYIHjZ�ë,FuDGWÜBEFuIHK]BZjeO1FHB+KN^CACBZFuKNIHBZ~�ORQNDG^C?)ðk[xyzf�y�BE~C?GBEjZ�>�DGFUB�òCO1V�WCQNBR_YIHFHBEB+��FHDG?GjE_�OR^C~»IHA:<Yj

s

Page 5: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

�� �������­þ

���� �

� ÿ­ø��"ü0�

�¦þ���=

�!uþ��&ø�ý �� , �

�� , �

�� , �

�� , �

� �0���0�¦þ � þ��(8=ÿ

��þ�uÿ

ö:þ���þ���= ��þzüJù|ù���þ��0=

>�K]?R<CFHB H {,f juBZV�OR^rILKNM�^CBEI��¶DGFH�a�

O1Q]jHD �¡BEFHVXKNIZ_5K]^CAYBZFHK InIHACB»MZDRQ]DG<CFn?GFHBEBZ^7��FuDGV ��FuDG?GjE�åð�^ V�OR^rw®juw:juIHBZVXjZ_*K]^CAYBZFkyK IhOR^YMZBßKNjvDG^YQNwã}rw ~CBJ�¸OR<CQ IP_&ILACO1I�KNjZ_e?GFLO1jHj���FuDG?Gj�~CD ^CDRIvK]^CACBEFHK I�IHACBèWCFuDGWÜBEFuI�w?RFHBZBE^%_�juK]^CMEB�IHACK]j¡�UDR<CQ]~®}ÜBXK]^®MZDG^rILFHOR~CKNMEILKNDG^��eKNILAåILACBXBJò\WCQNK]MEKNI�WCFHDRWÜBEFuI�wåBZ~C?RBjHOPw\KN^C?�ILA�O¦I,?GFLO1jHj5��FHDR?Gj,ORFuB"}CFHD��e^%�5@"AYB�VXK]jujHKN^C?i��DGFuVvORQ�Ó�ÑJìXÞRÔ�Õ¸í��hÓ+Ø � ÑJìXÞRÔ�Õ¸í����ÑJÕ¸ÙUئÐh×�Ó��UORj�MEFHKNIHK]MEK � BE~�}xw�b®D\D:~Cj � H H p �¶OR^C~ �UFLO1MhACVvO1^ � H q �ï��@"ACBvVXBPO1^CK]^C?D1�"OÌ?RKNÏGBE^ [\BEVvO1^xIHK]M ��BJI��UDRFH�$�&O1j�Q]BJ�îI¡ILDÌIHACBXK]^rIL<CK ILKNDG^�DR�UIHACB�<YjHBZFuj¿OR^Y~®ILAYBWYFHDG?GFHORVXV�BEFHj,�eACD�KNV�WYQ]BZVXBZ^rIHBZ~�ILACB�WCFHDG?RFLORVXj*WCFHD:MZBEjHjHKN^C?�IHACB�^YBEI��¶DGFH�xjZ�USUDG^\yjuBZäx<CBE^xIHQNwR_=K]~CBE^xIHK]MZORQ'^YBEI��¶DGFH�xj�MZDR<CQ]~èQNBPOR~ÌILDvÏRBZFuwß~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI�FuBZjH<YQNILjE_%~CBEWÜBE^C~CK]^Y?DR^7�eACK]MhA DR�"IHACB�jkw\jkILBEV�j¿�UORj)<CjuBZ~ ILDèWYFHD:MZBZjuj)KNIZ�èfij)O1^ K]Q]QN<CjuIHFLO1IHK]DG^�DR�"IHACK]jWYFHDG}CQNBZVà_r�UB�WÜDGKN^rIUDG<\I¶IHACBiW³DGjHjuK]}CQNBiO1V¿}CK]?R<CKNIHK]BZj�K]^�IHACBiKN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^XDR�=WYFHDGW\yBEFuI�w»BE~C?GBEjZ�ð�^ß>�KN?G<CFuB H _YIHACB¡WCFHDGW³BZFkI�w»BZ~Y?GB �kMZDGQNDG<CF �¿��FuDGV �u>aFuDG? �¿IHD �Ht¡FuBZBZ^��V�OPwG_³DG^ÌIHACB�DR^CB�A�O1^C~%_3VXBPO1^ÌILACO1I+?GFuBZBE^èK]jeILACBnDG^CQ w�WÜDGjujHKN}CQ]B�MZDGQNDG<CFe��DGFe��FHDG?GjñîÏ1ORQ]<CB)FuBZjkILFHKNMEIHK]DG^aó��Xâ+^�IHACB�DRILAYBZF¡A�OR^C~3_TK I¡MZDG<YQ]~�V�BZOR^$ILA�O¦I�O1^xwß��FHDG?�A�ORj�O1IQNBPORjkI'IHACB&MEDGQ]DG<YFT?RFHBZBE^%_r}C<YI�VvOPw¡A�OPÏRB&DRILAYBZF�MEDGQ]DR<CFHjTILD:D)ñ¸K ITV�KN?GArI�}³BU?GFuBZBE^��eKNIHAFuBZ~�jkILFuK]W³BZjhó��,f¾WCORFuIHKÍORQaFHBEMZDG^YjuILFu<CMEIHK]DG^vDR�%ILAYBijHBEVvO1^xIHK]MEjUDR�T[:BZV�OR^rILK]M ��BJI��UDRFH�xj�eK ILACKN^�ç�FHjkIuyzDGFH~CBEFeWCFHBE~CK]MZO1ILB¡Q]DR?GK]Mi�UORjeWCFuBZjHBE^rILBZ~ßK]^ � H prm��ï���ÑhÓ �JÐJíúÒ³Õ¸í|Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí��hÓ ñ���;Tó�V�OR�RBßIHACB$äx<�OR^rILK ç�BZF�IHA�O1I�KNj�K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNw¼WCFHBEjHBE^xIàKN^WYFHDGW³BZFkI�w¼BE~C?GBZj»ñ¸<C^CK ÏGBEFHjLO1QUK]^åILACBvFHBPO1~CK]^C?ßORj�Ï1ORQN<CB�FuBZjkILFHKNMEIHK]DG^CjE_,OR^C~¼BJò\K]jkILBZ^:yIHKÍORQÁ��DGFiIHACB)DRIHACBZF+DRWYILKNDG^aó�B�òYWYQ]K]MEKNI)ñ¸jHBEB)}ÜBEQ]D���óJ��@"ACBJw$~CBZjuMZBE^C~å��FuDGV jHD1yzMPORQNQ]BZ~�kjuILFu<CMEIH<CFHBE~ K]^CAYBZFHK IhOR^YMZBX^CBEI��¶DGFH�xj � � H q\_ H � �|_��eAYK]MhA¼�¶BZFuBvç�FHjkI¿FuBPORQNK � BE~¼KN^®ILAYBjkw:juILBEV������������ � o1p �|��@"ACBZKNF,VvORKN^)K]~CBZO�K]j5ILD¡jkIhORFkI�eK ILAXO1IHDGV�KNM �hØ¦Ô �hÑ�Ò³ÕîÓ�ñ¸<C^CORFuwWYFHBZ~YK]MPO¦ILBZjLóvOR^C~gÐLئÚ]ÑhÓêñ�}CK]^CORFuwãWCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHBZjhó�_iO1^C~ <CjuB�Ocñ¸FLO¦ILACBEFvjHV�ORQNQîó)jHBEI�DR�BEWCK]jkILBEV�DGQNDG?GKNMPORQNQNw¡OR~YBZäx<�O1IHB"MZDG^CjkILFu<CMEIHDGFHj*ILD�}C<YK]Q]~)MEDGVXWCQ]B�ò¿MEDG^CMZBEWYILjOR^Y~XFuDGQ]BEjZ�

m

Page 6: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

@"AYK]j*K]~CBZO+A�ORj*}³BZBZ^X��<CFuIHACBZF,~YBEÏGBEQ]DGW³BZ~�}ÜD1ILA)��FHDGV ILACB"IHACBZDGFuBEIHK]MPO1Q�OR^C~�ILACBeWCFHORMJyIHK]MZORQrWÜDRK]^rITDR�CÏ:K]BJ�¡��ð�^�WCORFuIHK]MZ<YQÍORFE_­IHACBZFuB¶KNj�O�?GFHBZO1IÁÏ1ORFHKNBEI�w¡DR��ju<CMZMEBZjujHDGFuj5juw:juIHBZVXjñ�BR��?C� _ ����� � � � pY_ � ox_am � �ï_ � � �������� � H � _ H � �ï_ ������ � � oGo �ï_ � ��� � � � qGq\_�q � �|_ � ���� q �ï_ � ����� � q1sC_¦q & �|_ ��� � ����� ��� o��ÍóJ_­�eACKNMhA�A�OPÏGB¶}ÜBEBZ^�<CjHBE~¿K]^¡~CK ô3BEFHBE^xI'ORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^~YDGVvO1K]^Cj"ju<CMhAèORj�^�O1IH<CFLO1Q=QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GB�WCFuD\MEBZjujHK]^Y? ��� m �ï_�MZDG^\ç�?G<CFHO1ILKNDG^�DR��IHBZMhAC^CKNMPORQjkw:juILBEV�j � H H H �ï_aORjejHDR�îI��UORFuBnKN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^�jkw:juILBEV � o � �|_C��DRF�DRWYILKNV�K � K]^Y?�äx<CBZFuK]BEj�IHD~CO1IhOR}CORjHBEj � o � �ï_�DGF&��DGF"ju<CWCW³DGFuI�KN^àWYQÍOR^C^YK]^C? ��� & �ï�>'K]?G<CFuB&o�K]^rILFuD\~C<YMZBZj�juw:^rIhO¦ò¿OR^C~)juBZV�OR^rILK]MEj�DR�ajuDGVXBUDR��IHACBUMEDG^CMZBEWYI,MEDG^CjuIHFH<CMJILDGFujBEV�WYQ]D�wGBE~®KN^åjkw:juILBEV�j�DGF¡K]^rÏRBZjuIHK]?rO¦ILBZ~åK]^$IHACB�Q]KNIHBZFHO1IL<CFuBR� �ÌDRjuInDR�¶IHACB�juw:juIHBZVXj~YD ^CDRI�WYFHD�Ï:K]~CBß��DRF»ORQ]QeDR�¡IHACBZjuB$MZDG^CjkILFu<CMEIHDGFHjE_iOR^ Ï:KNMZBßÏRBZFHjHOY_eILACBJw V�O�wê<CjuBO1~C~CKNIHK]DG^CORQ'MEDG^CjkILFH<YMEILDRFHj�^CDRI¡K]^rIHFHD:~C<CMZBE~®AYBZFHB1��fi^�BJò:ILBE^CjHK ÏGB�Q]K]jkI�DR�+ñ¸VXDGjuI+DR�hóIHACB�MEDG^CjkILFH<YMEILDRFHjiMEDG^CjuK]~CBEFHBZ~ß<C^rILK]QÁ^CD�� MZOR^ß}³B���DR<C^C~èKN^ � s �ï�"@"ACBnç�FujuIiMZDGQN<CV�^

��������� 3������ ����� � 3� !�"���� ��� ��#3%$ ���"� $ ��#��'&)(*� 3����"� ����� � 3�+!�"����+ ��� ��#3%, ���"� , ��#��-�.&0/��D� 12� 34#650�87�'9:&<;�=?>@�D� A�> � � B�CED!3 #GF A�H * �'CJIKH(��DL> #NM H?DO� #QP����RSR�>T�D� U6> � � B�CED!3?# F U6H * �'CJIKH(��DL>�#LVWH?DO��# P���./XR ="��9:/�YZ>!� [�Y?> B�CED!3?# F �uü�þ.� �B�H4D!3?# F ��C<I\H(��D]>�# P ��[^Y P���./X;�&09:/�Y_>!� `�Y?> B�CED!3?# F �uü�þ.� �B�H4D!3?# F ��C<I\H(��D]>�# P ��`^Y P�������a> 3 �"��� > � � > 3 b���"�. > � > # 3 $ ����� $ > # �

>�K]?R<CFHB�o\{[xw\^rILO¦òÌOR^C~àjHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZj"D1��MEDG^CMZBEWYIiOR^C~àFHDGQNBiILBEFHVXjZ�D1�3ILAYB�ç�?R<CFHB�jHACD��ejILACB�ñï;=K]juW\y�QNK]�1B�ó�MZDR^CMZFuBEILB�juw:^rIhO­òvIHA�O1IK]j*<CjuBZ~�KN^XVXDGjkI¶D1�3ILAYBjkw:juILBEV�jE_T�eAYBZFHBZORj�ILACB�juBZMZDR^C~®MEDGQ]<YV�^$KN^xIHFHD:~C<CMEBZj�ILACB�O1}CjuIHFLORMJInjkw:^xILO¦ò$IHA�O1I¡K]j<YjH<�ORQNQNw�BEV�WCQND�wGBZ~¼K]^�ILACBEDGFHBJILK]MZORQ*�UDGFu��DG^��+BZjuMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^®;=DG?GK]MEjZ�Ì[:ILORFuIHK]^C?��eKNIHAO¦ILDGVXK]M¡MZDR^CMZBEWYILj¡OR^Y~èFHDGQNBZjE_3DG^CBnMPOR^$<YjHB�IHACBZjuB¿MZDG^YjuILFu<CMEIHDGFHj+IHDv}C<YK]Q]~ÌMZDGVXWCQNBJò�hØ¦Ô �hÑ�Ò³Õ"Õ�ÑJÐ�ì�Ó�OR^C~êñ¸KN^èILACB)Q]ORjuI+FHD���ó�ÐLئÚ]Ñ)Õ�ÑJÐJì�ÓG� ��jHK]^Y?�IHACB�OR}CjkILFHORMEI¡jkw\^rILO¦òÜ_IHACB�MEDG^CMEBZWYI��u>aFuDG?C_ �X�eAYK]MhAèA�O1ji}³BZBZ^$KN^rILFHD:~C<CMEBZ~ÌK]^ÌIHACB)[:BZV�OR^rILK]M ��BJI��UDRFH�àDR�>'K]?G<CFuB H _*MZOR^ }ÜB»~YBZjHMEFHKN}ÜBE~ã}rw®ILACB»MEDG^CMZBEWYI)ILBEFHVdc6e�f�g2h*i^jlk�monoion�p*q �sroq*totJe=_�eAYBZFHBbcue�f)g2h*i�OR^C~lr6q*tQtJeÌORFuB�O1ILDGVXK]MiMZDG^CMEBZWYIHj¿ñ�MZDG^YMZBZW\Ii^�O1V�BEjhóJ_aO1^C~@m6noion�pvqKNjiO1^$O1ILDRV�KNM�FuDGQ]Bvñ¸FuDGQ]B¡^�O1V�BPóJ��@"ACB¿<C^CK ÏGBEFHjLO1Q'äx<�OR^rIHKNç�BEF+VvO1�RBZj�MZQNBPORFeILA�O¦Ii�¶BACO�ÏRBnKN^rILBZFuWCFHBJILBE~àIHACB¡WCFHDGW³BZFkI�w»BZ~Y?GB�O1jeO�Ï1ORQN<CB�FHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^%�ð�^$DRFH~CBEF�ILDv~CBEç�^YB¿ILACB¿juBZV�OR^rILKNMZj+DR�*MEDG^CMEBZWYI+IHBZFuV�jE_3DG^CB�MZDG^CjuK]~CBEFHj+KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO¦yIHK]DG^Yj8w�_C�eAYK]MhAàMZDG^CjuK]jkI�D1�5O)^CDG^:y�BZVXWYI�w»juBEI�xOyåñ�ILAYB�~CDGV�ORK]^»DR�TILAYB�KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO¦yIHK]DG^�ó'OR^C~XOR^)KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^n��<C^CMEIHK]DG^¿IHA�O1I*O1jHjHKN?G^Cj5IHD�BEÏGBEFuw�O¦ILDGVXK]MMZDG^YMZBZW\INz OjuBEI�z%y|{}xOynO1^C~nIHDiBEÏRBZFkw¿O1IHDGVXK]M,FHDRQ]B�~ O�}YK]^�ORFkw¡FHBEQÍO1IHK]DG^b~Ey|{}xOy��axOyÜ��@"AYBIHACK]Fu~»MZDGQN<CVX^»K]^�>�KN?G<CFHB�o)juACD��ej�AYD­� ILAYK]j"K]^rIHBZFHWYFHBEILO1ILKNDG^���<C^CMJILKNDG^»K]j"B�ò\IHBZ^C~YBZ~IHD»MZDG^YMZBZW\I�O1^C~�FHDGQNB�ILBEFHVXjZ��f�^åORQNIHBZFH^CO1ILK ÏGBn�UOPw$DR�¶~CBEçC^CK]^C?�IHACB)jHBEVvO1^xIHK]MEj�DR�MEDG^CMEBZWYIXOR^Y~ãFuDGQ]BXILBEFHVXj¿K]j�IHDè?GK ÏGB�OÌIHFLOR^CjuQÍO1IHK]DG^¼K]^rILDß��DRFHV¿<CQ]ORBvD1��çCFHjuIky�DGFu~CBZFWYFHBZ~YK]MPO¦ILBèQNDG?GK]M1{èMZDR^CMZBEWYI»ILBEFHVXj�ORFuBßILFHOR^CjHQ]O1ILBE~ K]^rIHD®��DGFuV¿<CQÍO1Bà�eK ILAéDG^CBà��FHBEB

Page 7: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

Ï1ORFuKÍOR}YQ]BàOR^C~ FuDGQ]B�ILBEFHVXjvKN^xIHD®��DGFuV¿<CQ]ORBà�eK ILAãI��UD7��FuBZBßÏ1ORFuKÍOR}CQNBZjE� @"AYBèBJòYORMJI~YBEç�^CK ILKNDG^�DR�UIHACK]j�ILFHOR^CjuQÍO1IHK]DG^$KNjnO1^®BZORjuw�MEDG^CjHBEäx<CBZ^CMEB�DR�¶ILACB�ILACKNFH~�MZDRQ]<CVX^�DR�>'K]?G<CFuB�o\�,>�DGF*BJòYORVXWCQNBR_rILACB�OR}³D�ÏGB�MZDG^CMEBZWYI¶ILBEFHV ��DGF,ILAYB�MEDG^CMEBZWYI �H>�FHDG? ��w:K]BEQ]~CjIHACB���DGQ]QND��eK]^C?���DRFHV¿<CQ]On�eKNIHAà��FuBZB�Ï1ORFHK]OR}CQNB�Á{

c6e�f�g2h*iañ � ó�� k��³{Íñ m6noion<p*q3ñ � ���\ó � r6q*tot e=ñ��\óuó��

� Ø¦Ô �hÑ�Ò³ÕTÖ:Ñ �*Ô�íîÕ¸í|ئÔYÓ"MZOR^�^CD�� }³B&<CjuBZ~�ILD�O1jHjHKN?G^)^�ORVXBZj�ñ¸OR}C}CFuBEÏ:KÍO¦ILK]DR^Cjhó=ILD�QÍO1FH?GBIHBZFuV�jE�">�DGFeBJòYORVXWCQ]B1_CILACBn~CBEç�^YKNILKNDG^��oq2n� �

c6e�f�g2h*i!j k�m6nQion�p*q �sr6qvtotJeèORjHjuK]?G^CjIHACBe^�ORVXB��oq2n��IHD�IHACB"ILBEFHV cue�f�g2hvi?jak�m6nQion�p*q �sr6qvtotJe3_x�eAYK]MhAXMPOR^�ILACBE^�}³Be<CjHBE~O1j�O1}C}CFHBJÏ:KÍO1IHK]DG^���DGF&IHACK]j&IHBZFuV �eACBZ^ÌMZDG^YjuILFu<CMEIHK]^C?X^CBJ� MZDR^CMZBEWYI�IHBZFuV�jE�f Õ�ÑJÐ�ì)íîÔ3ئÚ]ØHÛ ��ñ¸@ �UDPòCó"MZDG^CjuK]jkILj�DR�,O)ç�^CK ILB�jHBEI�DR��MZDG^CMEBZWYIiOR^C~ÌFHDGQNB�~CBEçC^CKNIHK]DG^CjD1��IHACB»��DGFHV z �

�� OR^C~�� � ~¿_*�eACBEFHB z KNj�O$MZDG^CMEBZWYI�^�ORVXBR_�� KNj�OåFuDGQ]B

^CORV�B1_ � K]j�O�MZDG^CMEBZWYI�IHBZFuVÌ_ÜOR^C~ ~ K]jiOvFHDRQ]BnIHBZFuVÌ� ��jH<�O1Q]QNwR_3DG^YB�K]VXW³DGjHBEj�ILAYBO1~C~CKNIHK]DG^CORQ�FuBZäx<CK]FuBZVXBZ^rI�ILA�O1I¡IHACB�~YBEç�^CK ILKNDG^Cj�ORFHB�<C^YK]äx<CBßñ¸K|��BR� _TOR^rw�^�ORVXB�VvOPwD:MZME<CF¡O1I�VXDGjkI�DG^CMEB�ORj�O�Q]BJ�îIuyzA�OR^C~$juK]~CB¿D1�UO�~YBEç�^CK ILKNDG^aóiOR^Y~�ORMEw:MZQNK]M�ñ�K|��BR� _3ILAYB~YBEç�^CK ILKNDG^ DR��O¼^�ORVXBÌV�<CjuIv^CDRIP_"~YK]FHBEMEIHQNw�DGFXK]^C~YK]FHBEMEIHQNwG_UFHBE��BEF�IHD¼ILACKNj�^CORV�BPóJ�f�j¿OßMEDG^CjuBZäx<CBZ^YMZBR_~CBJç�^CKNIHK]DG^YjnMZOR^7}³BvjHBEBZ^�ORjnVvO1MZFHDRjZ_��eACKNMhA7MPO1^7jHKNV�WCQ w�}ÜBB�ò\W�OR^C~CBE~%�ßf�^7K]^rIHBZFHWYFHBEILO1ILKNDG^lw KNj�OßVXD:~CBZQ*DR�eOà@ �UDPò7K ôãKNI�jLO1IHK]jkç�BZj)O1Q]Q5ILAYB~YBEç�^CK ILKNDG^Cj]z �

�� OR^C~�� � ~ MZDG^rIhO1K]^CBE~åKN^èILACB)@ �¶D�òÜ_=Kï��B1�N_=K �4z y �� y OR^Y~

� y ~ y AYDGQ]~Cj"��DGF&IHACBZjuB¡~CBEç�^YKNILKNDG^CjE�ð�^�IHACB�Þ¦ÓhÓ�ÑJÐ�Õ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ �hئìiÒ�ئÔ3ÑJÔ�Õ*DR�=ILAYB��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB+}�ORjuBR_�DG^CBiMPOR^»KN^xIHFHD:~C<CMEB+K]^C~YK yÏ:KN~C<�ORQNjeñ¸}rw)?GK Ï:K]^C?iIHACBZV ^�ORVXBZjLóJ_xOR^C~XORjujHBEFuIWCFHDRWÜBEFuILKNBZj,DR�aIHACBZjuB�KN^C~CK Ï\KN~C<�ORQNjZ�Tðz�� ����O1FHB¡^�ORVXBZj"��DGFeK]^Y~CKNÏ:K]~Y<�ORQ]jE_ � KNj�O�MZDR^CMZBEWYI�IHBZFuVÌ_aOR^Y~ ~ O�FHDRQ]B+ILBEFHVà_CILACBE^� ñ � ó+OR^Y~ ~�ñ � ���Jó+ORFHBàÞ¦ÓhÓ�ÑJÐ�Õ¸í|ئÔYÓr��f ç�^YKNILB�jHBEI�DR�¶jH<YMhA¼ORjujHBEFuILKNDG^Cj�KNj�MPORQNQ]BZ~�O1^��� Ø��Á�5fi^»KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^bwgñî�eACK]MhA�ORQ]juD)ORjHjuK]?G^YjUBZQNBZVXBZ^rILj � y�� xby�ILD¿KN^C~CK Ï\KN~\y<CORQC^�ORVXBZj � ó�KNj,O�V�D:~CBZQ\DR�³ILACBEjHB�ORjHjuBZFkILK]DR^Cj,KNô � y � � y¿OR^Y~ßñ � y ��� yCó!� ~EyÜ�,>�DGFB�òYORV�WYQ]BR_"�oq�n�%ñ$#&%('*)�+-,�ó3KNjÁOeMEDG^CMEBZWYI'ORjujHBZFkILKNDG^�OR^C~ m6nQion�p*q%ñ$#(%&'*)�+-, ��.vnoion�pvq0/*1CóKNjeO)FHDGQNB¡ORjHjuBZFuIHK]DG^3�f¾�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GBi}�O1jHB�ñ�� �&ó*MEDG^CjHKNjuIUDR�ÁO�@ �UDPò�2 OR^C~�OR^vf �UDPò�3»�5f�jUVXBZ^rILKNDG^CBE~KN^nIHACBUKN^xIHFHD:~C<CMJILK]DR^%_1DR^CBUKNj'^CD1IaÝu<CjkI5KN^xIHBZFuBZjuIHBZ~)KN^�FHBJILFuK]BEÏ:KN^C?�IHACBU�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB¶ILA�O1IKNj+BJò\WCQNK]MEKNILQ w�juIHDGFHBE~åKN^èjH<YMhA¼O ���i{ÜDG^CB¿juACDG<CQN~�ORQ]juD»Q]K]�1BnIHD»A�OPÏGBXORMZMEBZjuj+ILD�ILAYBKNV�WYQ]K]MEKNIHQNw»FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rILBZ~ �x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB1��@TDàVvOR�1B)ILACKNj�W³DGjujHK]}YQ]BR_=DR^CB�V¿<CjuI�}³BXOR}CQ]BIHD�~CFLOP� K]^Y��BEFHBZ^YMZBZj���FuDGV IHACB�BJò\WCQ]KNMZK ILQNwàFuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rILBZ~®�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GBR�)f�j�B�òYORV�WYQ]BZjD1�=I��UD¿I�w:WCKNMPORQ³K]^Y��BEFHBE^CMZB+WYFHDG}CQNBZVXjUKN^ �+BZjuMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^»;=DG?RK]MZj*�¶B�jHA�ORQNQÜMEDG^CjuK]~CBEF¶ILAYBju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^èOR^C~àILACBnK]^CjkIhOR^YMZB�WCFHDG}YQ]BZVà� � �54JÓ��\ìiÒ³Õ¸í|ئÔ$K]j�MZDR^CMZBEFH^CBE~è�eKNILA�ILAYBäx<CBEjuIHK]DG^ß�eAYBEILAYBZF+DG^YB�MZDR^CMZBEWYI+KNj+O�ju<C}³MZDG^CMEBZWYI+DR�*OR^CD1ILACBEFiDG^CB1�i>�DGFuVvO1Q]QNwR_Y�¶B~YBEç�^CB¿��DRF+?GKNÏRBZ^$MEDG^CMZBEWYI�ILBEFHVXj � O1^C~76 OR^C~�O�@ �UDPò82�{ � K]jiju<C}Cju<CV�BE~®}rw6 �¡��FE��IZ�92 ñ �;:=< 6»ó�K ô � y {>6Zy�ACDGQ]~YjiK]^èORQ]QÁVXD\~CBEQ]j4w D1�?2�� ��;7juw:juIHBZVXj<YjH<�ORQNQNw�DRôÜBZF�ILACB�MZDGVXWC<YILO1ILKNDG^ÌD1�,ILACBnjH<C}Cju<CVXWYILKNDG^èACKNBZFLO1FHMhArwßD1�,ILACBnMZDG^CMEBZWYIHj

q

Page 8: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

~YBEç�^CBE~®KN^�O�@ �UDPòåORj+jkw:juILBEV jHBEFuÏ:K]MEBàñ¸MZQ]ORjHjuKNç�MZO1ILKNDG^aó��¡bcAYBZ^å~CBEç�^YK]^C?�IHACB»íîÔ �ÓJÕ|ÞRÔ �hÑeÒ³ÐLØ 4ZÚ]ÑJìÌ_aDG^CBnMZDG^YjHK]~YBZFHjiO�@ �UDPò 2 OR^Y~$OR^ßf �UDPò 3»��@"AYB�K]^Y~CKNÏ:K]~Y<�ORQ �KNjeOR^àK]^CjkIhOR^CMEB¡DR��IHACB¡MZDG^CMEBZWYI�ILBEFHV � �¡��FZ� IP� 2 OR^C~�3 K ô � y�� � y�AYDGQ]~CjeKN^ÌO1Q]QVXD:~CBZQNj"DR� 2 OR^C~ 3»�U>�DGF"B�òYORV�WYQ]BR_�K �'IHACB¡@ �UDPòàMZDG^rILORK]^Cj"IHACB�O1}ÜD�ÏGB�~CBJç�^CKNIHK]DG^D1�3ILAYB�MEDG^CMZBEWYI��Qq�n�³_\O1^C~�IHACBef �UDPòXMZDR^xILORK]^YjIHACB�OR}ÜD�ÏRB+ORjujHBZFkILKNDG^Cj,��DGF #(%&'*)�+-,%_IHACBZ^�. ������� '5/*1�KNjUO1^�K]^CjkIhOR^YMZB+DR��r6q*totJev�eK ILA�FuBZjHW³BZMJI&ILDnILACKNjU@ �UDPò�OR^C~�f �UDPò3��àDGjuI���;¾jkw:juILBEV�jßñ¸B1��?Y�N_ ����� �_ � � � ������ _�� ��� � �%_ � ��� �+ó�BEV�WYQ]D�w7KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEBWYFHD:MZBZ~Y<CFHBEjeIHA�O1I"DR^CQNwXW�ORFkILK]ORQ]Q w�jLO1IHK]ju�îwXILAYB�FHBZäx<CKNFHBEV�BE^xIUILA�O1IUILACB�FuBZjH<YQNI"juACDG<CQN~~YBZW³BZ^C~�DR^CQNw)DR^�ILAYB�juBZV�OR^rILK]MEj¶D1�3ILAYB�FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^�Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBR_xO1^C~v^CD1IUDG^�ILAYBjkw:^xILORMEIHK]M���DGFHV DR�UIHACB�BZ^rILFuK]BEj�KN^$ILACB ���i�%@"ACBEjHBvjkw:juILBEV�j�<CjuB�juD1y�MZORQ]QNBZ~¼ÓJÕ¸Ð�� ���Õ��:ÐHÞRÚ'ÞRÚ�Û:ئÐ�íîÕ �:ì�Ó»ñ�jHBEBR_3B1��?Y�N_ � ��� �ï_3SUACORWYILBEF�sróJ_��eACK]MhAèORFHB¡juIHK]QNQ=}�ORjHBE~ßDG^ßO�W³DGK]^rID1�"Ï\KNBE� ~CBZFuKNÏRBZ~7��FHDRV [\BEVvO1^xIHK]M ��BEI��¶DGFu�:jE{�ILACBv�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB»}�ORjHBvK]j¿juBZBZ^ãORj¿O~YK]FHBEMEIHBZ~�?GFLO1WCA%�[:IHFH<CMJIL<CFHORQ%jH<Y}CjH<CVXWYIHK]DG^�ORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�j*ILFkw�IHDX~YBEILBEMEIejuK]VXK]QÍO1FHKNIHK]BEjKN^åIHACBv?RFLORWCAYjnMEDGFHFuBZjHW³DG^C~YK]^C?àILDÌIHACBvMEDG^CMEBZWYIHj�ILDà}ÜBXILBEjuILBE~¼��DGF�jH<C}YjH<CVXWYILKNDG^%�@"AYBEwåA�OPÏGB�ILACB�OR~YÏ1OR^rILOR?GB)ILA�O¦I�IHACBEwåO1FHB�<CjH<CORQ]Q wèÏGBEFuw�B��XMEK]BZ^rI�ñ¸W³DGQNw:^CDRV�K]ORQîó��f�^�KNV�W³DGFkIhOR^rI*~CKNjLOR~YÏ1OR^rILOR?GBeK]j5IHA�O1I*ILACBJwXORFHB�DG^CQ w¿juDG<C^C~%_:}C<YI�Ô3Ø¦Õ �hئìiÒ³Ú]ÑJÕ�Ñ"��DGFFuBPORjuDG^�OR}YQNwèB�ò\WCFHBEjHjHK ÏGBXFHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^®Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjE��ðz�UOR^�K]^CMEDGVXWCQ]BJILB�ju<C}Cju<CV�W:yIHK]DG^�O1Q]?GDGFuKNIHACV OR^Cjk�UBEFHj�O�ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^àäx<CBEFuw��eK ILA �kwRBZjZ_ ��ILACBE^�IHACK]jeO1^Cju�¶BZFeK]jMEDGFHFuBZMJI�ñ¸jHDR<C^C~C^CBEjHjLóJ�¿ðz�KNI+OR^Cjk�UBEFHj��eKNIHA �u^CDC_ �»ILACBE^�IHACK]ji~CD\BEj�^CDRI�VXBPO1^�OR^rwxyIHACK]^Y?C{�}³BZMPO1<CjHB�DR��ILACB�KN^CMZDGVXWCQNBEILBE^CBZjujZ_,ILAYBàju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^ãFuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^CjHAYK]W7VXK]?GArI^YBEÏGBEFuIHACBZQNBZjHj)AYDGQ]~%�»@"Ax<CjE_5ILACB�}ÜBEA�OPÏ:K]DG<CF�DR�&IHACB�O1Q]?GDGFuKNIHACV ~CD:BZjn^CDRIn~CBZW³BZ^Y~CjDR^CQNw»DR^àIHACBnjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZjZ_a}C<\IiO1Q]jHDXDG^àDRILAYBZFe�¸ORMEIHDGFHj"ILACO1I�ORFHB�^CDRIeILFHOR^CjuW�ORFHBE^rI�IHDIHACB¡<CjHBEFZ�[:K]^CMEB H � ���Y_YOX^CBJ� I�w:W³BnDR��ORQN?GDGFHK ILACVXjZ_:jHD¦y�MPO1Q]Q]BE~$ÕzÞ*4ZÚ]ÑHÞ � � 4hÞ¦Ó�ÑHÖ�ÞRÚ�Û:ئÐ�íîÕ �:ì�Ór_Y��DGFFuBPORjuDG^CKN^C?ÌKN^¼~CBEjHMEFHK]W\ILK]DR^®QNDG?GK]MEj¡A�ORj�}ÜBEBZ^7~CBJÏGBEQ]DGW³BZ~%�àd�BZFHB1_'IHACBvQNDG?GK]MZORQ5W³DGK]^rID1��Ï:KNBE� K]j�^CD1I»DG^CQ w <CjuBZ~éILD ~YBEç�^CB$IHACB$jHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZjE_�}Y<YIàORQ]juD¼��DGFvIHACB$~CBEjHK]?R^D1�+ORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�jE_5ILA�O1IXKNjZ_*ILACB�K]^\��BZFHBE^CMZBàWCFuDG}CQ]BEV�j�O1FHB�MZDG^YjHK]~YBZFHBE~ O1jX~YBZ~C<CMJILKNDG^WYFHDG}CQNBZVXj*K]^vQNDG?GKNMZjZ�'ð�^�WCFuK]^CMEK]WCQNBR_GILAYBZjHB+ORQ]?GDRFHKNIHACVXj,ORFHB�VXBEILAYD\~Cj��DGF*?GBZ^YBZFLO¦ILK]^Y?çC^CKNIHBiVXD\~CBEQ]jE��@"ACBJw�MPO1^�}ÜBijHBZBE^�ORjUjuWÜBEMZK]ORQ]K � O1IHK]DG^Cj*DR�=IHACB�ILOR}CQNBPOR<�MZORQ]ME<CQ]<Yj��DGFçCFHjuIky�DGFu~CBZF,WYFHBZ~YK]MPO¦ILB"Q]DR?GK]M1�'@"ACB"^YDG^\y�jkIhOR^Y~�ORFH~�jkw\^rILO¦òXDR� ��;ÌO1^C~)ILACB"FuBZjuIHFHKNMEILBE~B�ò\WCFHBEjHjHK ÏGBE^CBZjujD1�CILACBEjHB¶Q]DG?GKNMZjTORQNQ]D��ej=ILDi~YBZjHKN?G^nIHBZFuV�KN^�O1ILKN^C?"WCFuD\MEBZ~C<CFuBZjE_rK|��BR� _¦��DGFV�OR^rw�~YBZjHMEFHKNWYILKNDG^»QÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEj"DG^CB�DG}\IhORKN^Cj&~CBEMZK]juK]DG^�WCFuD\MEBZ~C<YFHBZj"��DGF¶ILACB¡FHBEQ]BJÏRO1^xIKN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEBvWCFuDG}CQNBZVXj�ñ�jHBZB � � ���DGFnOR^7KN^xIHFHD:~C<CMJILDGFkw®B�ò\WÜDGjuKNIHK]DG^®DR�&IhO1}CQ]BZOR<\y�}CORjHBE~KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�V�BJILACD:~Cj�K]^��;TóJ�5@"AYBàç�FujuI�IhO1}CQ]BZOR<\y�}CORjHBE~ãju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^ ORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�UORj+~YBEÏGBEQ]DGW³BZ~ßK]^ � H pRs �'��DRF�IHACB�Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GB 3��5_a�eACK]MhA�O1Q]Q]D��ej"��DGFeILACB�ç�FHjkIiçCÏRBMEDG^CjkILFH<YMEILDRFHj¡DR�¶>�K]?R<CFHB¿o\�¿[:K]^CMEB�ILACBE^%_%ILAYK]j�ORWYWCFHDrO1MhA���DRF+~CBZjuK]?G^YK]^C?�ju<C}Cju<CV�W:yIHK]DG^àORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�j�&ORj�BJò:IHBZ^C~CBE~ÌIHDXIHACB¡K]^CjkIhOR^CMEB¡WCFHDG}YQ]BZV � m � _ � �TOR^C~�ILD)Ï1ORFuK]DG<Cj~YBZjHMEFHKNWYILKNDG^�Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjBJò:IHBZ^C~CKN^C? 3���ñ�jHBZB1_YB1��?C� _ � m �:_\mGq\_ H H _ H o��³��DRFQ]OR^C?G<COR?GBZj�eK ILAà^x<CV¿}³BZF�FHBZjkILFuK]MEIHK]DG^Yj � � & �Á��DGF&ILFHOR^CjHK ILK ÏGB¡MZQNDGjH<CFuBnD1�5FHDRQ]BZj�OR^Y~ ��� � �Á��DGF&IHFLOR^\yjuKNIHKNÏGB�FHDGQNBZj � ��� �Ü��DRFUMZDR^CjuIHFH<CMJILj&ILACO1I"ORQNQ]D�� IHD�FHBJ��BZFUIHD¿MZDR^CMZFuBEILB�~YDGVvO1K]^CjjH<CMhAàORj^x<CV�}ÜBEFHj �'OR^C~ � oGm �5��DRFiILACB)IHFHBPO¦ILVXBZ^rI¡DR�?GBZ^YBZFLO1Q,O¦ò\K]DGVXj+DR�ILAYB¿��DGFHV � �

6ß_�

Page 9: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

�eAYBZFHB � ��6 VvOPw»}³DRIHAà}³B¡MZDGVXWCQNBJò»MEDG^CMEBZWYIeILBEFHVXjhó��âiIHACBZFnK]VXWÜDGFkIhOR^rI¡FuBZjHBZORFHMhA MEDG^rILFuK]}C<YIHK]DG^Yj���DGF ��;éORFuBvMZDR^CMZBEFH^CBE~7�eKNILAåILACB�~CBJyMEK]~�O1}CK]QNKNI�wåOR^C~7IHACB»MZDRV�WCQNBJò\KNI�w®DR�eILAYB»jH<C}Cju<CVXWYILKNDG^ WCFHDR}CQ]BEV�KN^ ~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI���;Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjE��ðzInA�ORj¡IL<CFu^CBZ~7DR<YI¡ILA�O1I�ILAYB�Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZj¡<CjuBZ~7KN^¼BPO1FHQNw ��; juw:juIHBZVXj�¶BZFuB�IHD\D�BJò\WCFuBZjHjuKNÏRBR_C�eACKNMhAvQ]BE~�IHDn<C^Y~CBZMEK]~�OR}YK]Q]K I�w)DR�%IHACB�jH<C}Cju<CVXWYILKNDG^vWCFuDG}CQNBZV� H p & _ � H �|��@"ACBnç�FHjkI�MZDGVXWCQNBJò\KNI�wàFHBEjH<CQ ILj ����� _ �rq���jHACD��¶BZ~�ILA�O¦IiILAYBZFHB)MZOR^C^CD1I�}ÜBW³DGQ w\^YDGV�K]ORQ�ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^¼ORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�jE_=BEÏGBE^¼��DGF�ÏGBEFuwåjHV�ORQNQ,QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ�Xð�^®ILAYBVXBPO1^xIHK]VXBR_aILACBn�UDGFujuIky�MPO1jHB)MZDRV�WCQNBJò\KNI�wàDR�*ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^$K]^$OvQ]ORFH?RBnMEQÍORjuj+DR� ��;Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZj¡A�O1j�ñ¸ORQ]VXDGjuI¡MEDGVXWCQ]BJILBZQ wYó�}³BZBE^¼~CBJILBEFHVXK]^CBE~ � & m:_ & sC_ & q��|��bcKNILA�ILAYBB�ò\MZBZW\ILK]DR^ßDR�5O���BJ� WÜDGQ w:^CDGVXKÍORQNQNw�~CBEMZK]~COR}CQ]B¡Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZjE_CILACB�MZDGVXWCQNBJò\KNI�w»FuBZju<CQNIHjFHOR^C?GB�}³BEI��¶BZBE^��ië DGF¡MED �ië O1^C~7ë[Yë³f�S �e�ÁbcACBEFHBPO1j�IHACBZjuBvFHBEjH<CQ ILj�ORFuB�?GK ÏGBE^�eK ILAÌFHBZjuWÜBEMEI�IHD�OR^èBEV�W\I�wÌ@ �¶D�ò ñ¸Kï��B1�N_aILAYBEwÌMZDG^CjuK]~CBEFiju<C}CjH<YV�WYIHK]DG^ßDR�*MZDG^YMZBZW\IIHBZFuV�j&�eK ILA�FHBEjHW³BZMEIeIHD�O1Q]Q3KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^YjhóJ_ ��BE}ÜBEQ � � � �=A�ORjejHAYD­�e^�ILACO1I"ILACB�B�òxyWCOR^CjHKNDG^�DR�Á@ �¶D�òv~CBJç�^CKNIHK]DG^YjUV�O�wXQNBPOR~vIHD)OR^�B�ò\WÜDG^YBZ^rILK]ORQ3}CQND��&y�<CW%_x�eACKNMhA»VvOPwFuBZju<CQNIHj+K]^$O�QÍORFu?GBZF�MZDGVXWCQNBJò\KNI�w¼ñ¸MED �iëcK]^YjuILBZOR~èDR�*W³DGQ w\^YDGV�K]ORQîó¶��DRFiMZBEFuILORK]^èQ]OR^\y?R<�OR?GBEjZ��@"ACB�<CjHBXDR�"?RBZ^CBEFLORQO¦ò\K]DRV�jXñ�K]^�3� Tó+BEÏRBZ^7MZOR<CjuBZj�IHACB�ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^WYFHDG}CQNBZV IHD¡}ÜBEMZDGVXB �5ò\WC@"KNV�B�y�MEDGV�WYQ]BEIHB � H pro��ï�5ðzIA�ORjORQNjHD¡}ÜBEBZ^�jHACD��e^�IHA�O1I,��DGFMEBZFkIhORKN^�QÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEj¶IHACB+K]^YjuIhO1^CMZB+WYFHDG}CQNBZVÎMPOR^»}³B+A�O1FH~CBEFUILA�O1^�ILACB+ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^WYFHDG}CQNBZV ����� _ & � �ï�*SUDG^CjuK]~CBEFHK]^Y?¡IHACBZjuB�MEDGVXWCQ]B�òYK I�w¿FuBZjH<YQNILjE_xDG^CBeVvOPw�O1jH���eACBJILACBEFKN^CMZDRV�WCQNBEIHBR_�}Y<YI)W³DGQNw:^CDGVXKÍO1Q,ORQ]?RDGFHK ILACVXj¡jHACDG<YQ]~7^CD1I¿WCFuBE��BZFuFHBE~ãD�ÏRBZF�IHACB�MZDRV�yWYQ]BEIHBÌDR^CBZjE_U�eACK]MhA ORFHBà^CBZMEBZjujLORFuK]QNw�D1��ACK]?RAã�¶DGFHjkIuyzMPORjuBßMZDRV�WCQNBJò\KNI�wR� >�KNFHjkI�B�òxyW³BZFuK]BE^CMZBEj � m:_CoGo��Ü�eK ILA�KNV�WYQ]BZVXBZ^rIHBZ~vjkw:juILBEV�jU<CjHKN^C?¿MZDRV�WCQNBEIHBiORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�j*jHAYD­�¡_AYD­�¶BEÏRBZFE_\ILACO1I,DG^XFHBZORQ]KNjuILKNM ���Uj5IHACBeFH<C^)ILKNV�BUK]j5MEDGV�WCORFLOR}YQ]BUIHD¡IHA�O1I*DR� � � ��������O1^C~ � �����Îñ¸K|��BR� _CV�O1IL<YFHB�juw:jkILBZVXji<YjHK]^Y?XKN^CMZDRV�WCQNBEIHB�ORQ]?RDGFHK ILACVXjhó���¶BE��DGFuB¿�UB)IL<YFH^$ILD»ILAYBXMEDG^C^CBEMEIHK]DG^�}³BEI��¶BZBZ^ ��;êO1^C~å;ÁDR?GK]M)ë,FuDG?GFLO1V�VXK]^C?Y_Ü�¶BjuACDG<CQN~ QNK]�RB�ILD®V�BE^rILK]DR^ãI��¶D7K]^rIHBZFHBEjuIHK]^C?®MZDG^C^YBZMEIHK]DG^Yjv}³BEI��¶BZBZ^���;gO1^C~ VXDGFHBIHFLOR~YKNILKNDG^�ORQ�ORFuBPORj»D1��QNDG?GK]MEjZ� [\MhACKNQ]~ � H pGp��+�&O1j�IHACBèç�FujuI»ILD DR}CjHBEFuÏGB�ILACO1I�ILAYBQ]OR^C?G<COR?GB 3� ãKNjnO�juw:^rIhO1MEILKNM)ÏRO1FHKÍO1^xI¡D1�UILAYBXWYFHDGW³DGjHK ILKNDG^�ORQ'V¿<CQNIHK yzV�D:~�ORQTQ]DG?RK]M����ñ¸juBZBe^CBJò:I¶jHBEMEILKNDG^aó�_\O1^C~XIHA�O1I*ILAYB�B�ò:ILBZ^YjHK]DR^vDR� 3� à}rw)ILFLO1^CjHK ILKNÏRB"MZQNDGjH<CFuBeDR�FuDGQ]BEj � & �CMEDGFHFuBZjHW³DG^C~Yj*IHD�WCFHDRWÜDGjuKNIHK]DG^�O1Q:~\w\^CORV�KNM&Q]DR?GK]Miñïë ��;TóJ�Gð�^)WCORFuIHK]MZ<YQÍORFE_1ILAYBO1Q]?GDGFuKNIHACV�j<CjuBZ~àK]^»VXD\~�O1QÜQNDG?GK]MEjU��DGF&~YBZMZKN~CK]^Y?)jLO1IHK]juç�OR}CK]QNKNI�w�ORFuBiÏGBEFuw�jHKNV�KNQÍORF,IHDIHACB�ILOR}CQ]BZOR<\yz}�ORjHBE~�ORQ]?RDGFHK ILACVXje^CBE�eQ wß~CBJÏGBEQ]DGW³BZ~$��DGF ��;�Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjE��@"ACK]jiMZDG^\y^YBZMEIHK]DG^�}³BEI��¶BZBE^ ��;¼OR^Y~ÌVXD\~CORQ3QNDG?GK]MEj&A�ORje}³BZBE^ß<CjuBZ~�ILD�ILFLO1^Cju��BEF�~YBZMZKN~�OR}CKNQ]K I�wFuBZju<CQNIHje��FuDGV VXD:~�ORQ%QNDG?GK]MEjUILD ��; � H p H _ H prox_�s �\_�s � �|��+BEMZKN~�OR}CKNQ]KNI�wåDR��ILAYBàKN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�WCFHDG}YQ]BZVXj¿��DGF 3� ¾MZOR^ O1Q]jHD$}³B�DG}YILORK]^CBE~ãORjXOMEDG^CjuBZäx<CBZ^YMZBiD1�3ILAYB��x^CD��e^X~CBZMEK]~�O1}CK]QNKNI�wnFHBZju<CQNI,��DRF5ILACB"I��¶DnÏ1ORFHK]OR}CQNB¶��FLO1?GV�BE^rI*DR�çCFHjuIky�DGFu~CBZF�WCFHBE~CK]MZO1ILBnQ]DG?RK]MR�"@"AYB¿QÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GB�� MZDR^CjHKNjuILjiDR�*ORQNQÁ��DRFHV¿<CQ]ORB¡DR�,ç�FujuIuyDRFH~CBEF¿WCFHBE~CK]MZO1ILBvQ]DG?GKNMXIHA�O1I)MZOR^�}ÜBv}C<CK]Q In�eK ILA7IHACB�ACBEQ]W DR��WCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHB�juw:V¿}³DGQ]jñ�K]^CMEQ]<C~YK]^C?èBEäx<�ORQ]K I�wYó�OR^C~�MZDR^CjuILOR^rI�juw:V¿}³DGQ]jàñ�}C<YI)�eKNIHACDG<YI���<C^CMEIHK]DG^ jkw:V¿}ÜDRQ]jhó<YjHK]^Y?»DG^CQNwÌILACB¿Ï1ORFuKÍOR}YQ]BZj ��� ³� �+BEMZK]~COR}CK]QNKNI�wàDR��� A�ORj�}³BZBZ^åjHAYD­�e^åK]^ � �rm �ï��ðzI

Page 10: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

KNj¿BPO1juw¼IHD$jHBEB�ILA�O1IZ_*}xw7ORWCWCFuDGWCFuKÍO1IHBZQNwåFuBJy�<YjHK]^Y?èÏRO1FHKÍO1}CQ]BX^�ORVXBZjE_¶O1^xw¼MZDG^YMZBZW\IIHBZFuV DR�eILAYB»QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GB�3��cMPOR^�}³B�ILFHOR^CjHQ]O1ILBE~ K]^rILD�O1^ � y|��DGFHV¿<YQÍOà�eK ILA DG^YB��FuBZB¿Ï1ORFuKÍOR}CQNB»ñ�jHBZB � H m�����DGF+~CBJIhORKNQ]jhó��nf ~YK]FHBEMEI+IHFLOR^YjHQÍO¦ILK]DR^èDR�*ILACB)MEDG^CMEBZWYI¡ILBEFHVk�~ �]ñ � ~ � z�ó¡w\KNBZQN~Cj�ILAYBv��DGFHV�<CQÍO k Ü{]ñK~�ñ���� Yó�� ñ � �Y{ÍñK~�ñ ���Gó �@z)ñ �GóHóHóuóJ�å[\KN^CMZBIHACB¿ju<C}Y��DGFuV¿<CQÍO � �Y{îñ:~�ñ� ���ró � z)ñ��róHó�~YD\BEj+^CDRIiMZDG^rIhO1K]^ Á_³ILACKNj�Ï1ORFHK]OR}CQNBnMZOR^$}ÜBFuBJyz<CjHBE~%{¶FuBZ^�O1V�KN^C?¿ILACB¡}³DG<C^C~�Ï1ORFHK]OR}CQNB ��KN^xIHD èw:K]BEQ]~Cj&IHACB¡BZäx<CKNÏ1ORQNBZ^rIe��DGFHV�<CQÍOk ³{]ñK~�ñ�� Có�� ñ � Á{îñK~�ñ � Üó �@z¿ñÜóHóuóHó�_��eACK]MhA¼<CjHBEj¿DG^CQ w$I��UDßÏ1ORFuKÍOR}YQ]BZjE�»@"ACK]jMEDG^C^CBEMEIHK]DG^$}³BEI��¶BZBE^�3���OR^C~ � juACD��ej+ILA�O1I+OR^rwßB�ò:ILBZ^YjHK]DR^åD1� 3� }rwÌMZDG^\yjkILFu<CMEIHDGFHjiIHA�O1IiMPOR^è}³B�B�ò\WCFHBEjHjHBE~å�eK ILAßIHACB�AYBZQ]WßDR�,DG^CQ w�I��UD�Ï1ORFuKÍOR}CQNBZj"w:K]BEQ]~CjiO~YBZMZKN~�OR}CQNB ��;,� ��<CV�}ÜBEF"FHBZjkILFuK]MEIHK]DG^YjeOR^C~�MZDGVXW³DGjHK ILK]DR^�DR�'FHDGQNBZjeORFuB�BJòYORVXWCQ]BEj"DR�MEDG^CjkILFH<YMEILDRFHj�ILA�O¦I¡MPOR^C^YDRI¡}ÜB)B�ò\WCFHBEjHjHBE~¼�eKNIHACK]^ � � ��<CV¿}³BZF�FuBZjkILFHKNMEIHK]DG^CjiMPOR^%_AYD­�¶BEÏRBZFE_�}³BàBJò\WCFHBEjHjuBZ~cK]^ � _UIHACBÌB�ò:ILBZ^YjHK]DR^ DR� � }xwãMEDG<C^rILKN^C?¼äx<�OR^rIHKNç�BEFHjZ_�eAYK]MhAàA�ORjeFHBEMZBZ^rIHQNw�}³BZBZ^àjHAYD­�e^àILD�}³B�~YBZMZKN~�OR}CQNB � m H �|�[:K]^CMEB�;=DG?RK]M)ë,FHDR?GFLORVXVXK]^C?�Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZj¡O1FHB)MZDRV�WC<\IhO1IHK]DG^�O1Q]QNwàMEDGV�WYQ]BEIHB�OR^C~ ��;Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZj�ORFHB�<CjH<CORQ]Q w�~CBZMEK]~�OR}YQ]BR_�DG^CBvV�OPwåjLOPw¼IHA�O1I ��; Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjnA�OPÏGB�QNBZjujB�ò\WCFHBEjHjHK ÏGB¿W³D��UBEFZ�&ðz���UB�MZDG^YjHK]~YBZF�;ÁDR?GK]M¡ë,FHDR?GFLORVXVXK]^C?)Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZj�ORjeFHBEWCFHBEjHBE^\yILO1ILKNDG^èQ]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZj+FHO1ILAYBZF+ILACOR^åORj�WCFHDR?GFLORVXVXK]^C?XQÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEjZ_3IHACBZ^åDG^CB�DG}CjHBEFuÏRBZjIHA�O1I¶jHBJÏGBZFHORQ3D1�%ILACB ��;ßMZDR^CjuIHFH<CMJILDGFuj&MPOR^Y^CDRI¶}ÜB�BJò\WCFHBEjHjuBZ~%�ð�^v�¸ORMJIP_x~CK]jîÝu<C^CMJILK]DR^O1^C~®B�ò\K]juIHBZ^rILK]ORQ*FHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^Cj�ORQ]QND­� ��DGF¡K]^YMZDGVXWCQ]BJILBEQNwÌjHW³BZMZK ç�BZ~¼�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBR�»>�DGFB�òYORV�WYQ]BR_\ILACB�ILBEFHV

ñ ��� t�� �]ñ��2n����.Qh��CóHóZñ� + � � ó

QNBPOPÏGBEj"KNI"DRWÜBE^��eACK]MhA�f �¶D�ò�K]^C~YKNÏ:K]~C<CORQÜKNj �UKNQ]Q��j¶WÜBJIP_CO1^C~»�eACBEIHACBZFeKNIUK]j"O¿MZO1I"DGFO¡~CDG?Y�*[\<CMhA»O1^ �u<Y^C~CBZF�y�juWÜBEMZKNçCMPO1IHK]DG^���K]j*^CD1I¶W³DGjujHK]}YQ]B"�eKNIHAXIHACBid�DGFH^XMZQ]OR<CjuBZjDR�IHFLOR~YKNILKNDG^�ORQ�;=DG?GK]M�ë,FuDG?GFLO1V�VXK]^C?vQÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ��@'DàD�ÏGBEFHMZDRV�B�ILACKNj�~CBEçCMZKNIZ_'B�ò:ILBZ^:yjuK]DG^Yj�D1�5;=DG?GKNM¡ë,FHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?¿QÍO1^C?G<�OR?RBZj"}rw»~CKNj�Ýu<C^CMJILKNDG^ßO1^C~�MZQÍO1jHjHKNMPORQ=^YBZ?rO1IHK]DG^ñ�K]^�MZDG^rIHFLORjkI�ILD �u^CBE?rO1IHK]DG^nORjÁ�¸ORK]QN<CFHB �xó3A�OPÏGB¶}ÜBEBZ^¿KN^xIHFHD:~C<CMEBZ~ � sxq\_ � s\_1qGo\_ H & _1o H �|�d�D��UBJÏGBZFE_�ILACBEjHB¡BJò:ILBE^CjHKNDG^Cj"ILFuBPO1IeDR^CQNw�jHDGVXB¡ORjuWÜBEMEILjeDR�ÁIHACBZjuB�MEDG^CjkILFH<YMEILDRFHjZ{,��DGFB�òYORV�WYQ]BR_rIHACB �uMEQÍORjujHKNMPORQ�^CBE?rO1IHK]DG^���K]^XILACBEjHBiORWCWCFuDrORMhACBEjUDG^CQ w�FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rIHjUILACBiORjkyW³BZMJIeILA�O1I�O�jHBJI�OR^C~àKNILj"MEDGVXWCQ]BEV�BE^xI�O1FHB�~CKNj�ÝuDGKN^xI �YILAYB¡�¸O1MEI"ILACO1IeILACB¡<C^CKNDG^�DR��OjuBEI¶�eKNILA�KNIHjMEDGVXWCQ]BEV�BE^xI¶K]j*ILAYB��eACDRQ]B�<C^CKNÏRBZFujHB+KNj¶^CD1I¶ILOR�RBE^�K]^rILD�ORMZMEDG<C^rIP�,@"AYBKN^rILBZ?RFLO1IHK]DG^»DR�"�+BZjuMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^à;=DG?GKNMZj&�eKNIHAàOXFu<CQ]B�MZORQ]ME<CQ]<Cj&IHA�O1I�K]jeO1}CQ]B+IHD�B�òYWYFHBZjujd�DGFH^åFH<YQ]BZj¡A�O1j�}³BZBE^®KN^rÏGBZjkILKN?rO1ILBE~®KN^ � m & �|��âiILACBEF��UDGFu�$K]^$ILAYK]j¡~CK]FuBZMJILK]DR^$MPOR^%_��DRF"BJòYORVXWCQ]B1_C}ÜB���DG<Y^C~ÌKN^ � q1p �|�

� ÇeÈ� �� ��Ç��UË�Ê�

@"AYK]j&KNj&OR^�ORFuBPO�D1�ÁQ]DG?GKNMZjILA�O1IUA�ORj&}³BZBE^�K]^rÏGBEjuILKN?rO1IHBZ~���DGF¶ä:<YKNILB+On�eACK]QNBR_\OR^C~���DGF�eAYK]MhAÌOX?GFuBPO1I"Ï1ORFuK]BJI�w»DR�'V�BJILACD:~Cj�OR^C~àFHBEjH<CQ ILj�ORFHB�OPÏ1ORK]Q]OR}CQNBR�5ð�^�ILACB���DGQNQ]D��eK]^Y?C_

H p

Page 11: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

�¶B+?GK ÏGB�O�ÏGBZFkw�juACDGFuI&K]^rILFuD\~C<YMEILKNDG^%_r�eACKNMhA»BZVXWCA�ORjuK � BEjUILAYB+MZDG^Y^CBZMJILK]DR^»}ÜBJI��UBEBZ^�+BEjHMEFHK]W\ILK]DR^�;ÁDR?GK]MEj�OR^C~ �ÌD:~�ORQ�;ÁDR?GK]MEjZ�¿>�DGFiV�DGFuB¿~CBJIhORKNQ]BZ~$KN^rILFHD:~C<CMJILKNDG^Cj�OR^Y~D�ÏRBZFuÏ:KNBE�ej�DR��IHACB�ORFHBZO)�¶B�FHBE��BEF&ILACB¡FuBPOR~CBEF�IHD � oGqx_ � pY_amRo\_ & � �ï�@"AYB®WCFuDGW³DGjHK ILK]DR^�ORQ�V¿<CQNIHK yzV�D:~�ORQeQ]DR?GK]M ��� BJò:IHBZ^C~CjÌWCFHDRWÜDGjuKNIHK]DG^�O1Q�QNDG?GK]Mß}xw �WCORK]Fuj�D1�,<C^�ORFkw�DGW³BZFLO¦ILDGFujZ_��eACK]MhAßORFHB�MPO1Q]Q]BE~Ì}³DPòÌOR^C~Ì~CKÍORVXDG^C~àDGW³BZFHO1ILDGFujZ�&@"AYB� juILOR^C~é��DGF�IHACBè}�O1jHK]MßV�D:~�ORQ�Q]DG?RK]MàDG^ �eACKNMhA VXDGjkI�VXD\~�O1Q�QNDG?GK]MEjvO1FHBè}C<YK]Q]~ñ�jHBEB$}ÜBEQ]D���óJ_�OR^C~ �kV¿<CQNIHK yzV�D:~�ORQ �èV�BZOR^CjvIHA�O1I»DR^CBèMZDR^CjHKN~CBZFuj�V�DRFHBßIHA�OR^ DG^YBWCORK]F¶DR�T}ÜDPò�O1^C~�~CKÍORVXDG^C~vDGWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHjE� �+BZW³BZ^C~YK]^C?)DG^�IHACB�K]^rIHBZ^C~CBE~àORWCWCQNK]MPO¦ILK]DR^%_IHACBZjuB»DGW³BZFLO¦ILDGFuj�V�O�wåA�OPÏRB»~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI)K]^rIH<CKNIHKNÏGBXVXBPOR^CKN^C?GjE�$>�DGFnB�òYORV�WYQ]BR_�KN�"�¶B�UOR^rIiIHDvFuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rI+ILKNV�B�y�~CBEWÜBE^C~CBZ^rIi�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBR_aILACBE^ß�UB�MPOR^Ì<CjHB�IHACB�~CKÍORVXDG^C~DRWÜBEFLO1IHDGF���������� � �¡OR^C~åILACBX}³D�ò$DGWÜBEFLO1IHDGF � ��������� �|_Á�eACBEFHB�IHACB�K]^rILBE^C~CBE~7V�BZOR^\yKN^C?åDR�¡Oå��DRFHV¿<CQ]O���������� ����� KNj �L[:DGV�BJILKNV�B�K]^�ILAYBÌ��<YIH<CFHB1_��cAYDGQ]~CjE_ � �eACBEFHBZORj� �������� � ���êKNj�VXBPOR^rInILDèB�òYWYFHBZjuj �ufiQ �&OPw:j¿K]^åILACB���<YIL<CFuBR_���ACDGQ]~YjZ� � ðz�"�¶B��UOR^rIIHDßFuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rI)�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GB�OR}³DG<YI�ILAYB�}³BZQNK]BE��j¡DR�&K]^rILBEQ]Q]KN?GBZ^rI�OR?RBZ^rILjE_�ILACBE^®�¶BvMZOR^<YjHB�IHACBvDRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj��� ����� �!�nOR^C~ � ��"���#� �ï_'�eACBEFHB � ����� � ��� jHACDR<CQ]~7}³BXK]^rILBEFHWCFuBEILBE~O1j �H`eDG}ÜD1I H }³BZQNK]BJÏGBZj�ILA�O1I$�åACDRQ]~CjE_ �»O1^C~��� ����� �����®O1j �H`eDG}ÜD1I H }³BZQNK]BJÏGBZj�ILA�O1I�ãK]j¿W³DGjHjuK]}CQNBR� � @"AYB»~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI�V�BZOR^CKN^C?Gj�D1��IHACB�DGW³BZFHO1ILDRFHj)ORFuB�IhOR�1BZ^�K]^rIHD$ORMJyMEDG<C^rI�}rw�<CjHKN^C?àOR~C~CK ILK]DR^�ORQ5O­òYKNDGVXj�DGF�}rw�K]VXWÜDGjuK]^C?�OR~C~CK ILK]DR^�ORQ�FuBZjkILFHKNMEIHK]DG^Cj�DR^IHACB¡jHBEVvOR^rIHK]M�juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBZj¿ñ¸jHBEB¡}ÜBEQ]D���óJ�>'K]FHjkIP_³�UB�MZDR^CjHKN~CBZF+IHACB)}�ORjuB)Q]DG?GKNM ����KN^�O�}CKNI�VXDGFuB�~CBJIhORKNQ|� �'ئÐ�ì �:Ú Þ:Ñ¿D1�IHACK]jQNDG?GKNM+ORFuB�}Y<CK]Q I&��FHDGV O1ILDRV�KNM+WCFHDRWÜDGjuKNIHK]DG^Cj&%ßO1^C~ � ~CK ô3BEFHBE^xIeVXD:~�ORQ%W�O1FLORVXBEIHBZFHj' <CjuK]^C?�ILACB �¶D\DGQNBPOR^ÌMZDG^Y^CBZMJILKNÏRBZj � ��( ��)+*nOR^C~èIHACB¿VXD\~�O1QTDRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj �-, ��<Y^C~� , �J�*>aDRF"BJòYORVXWCQ]B1_

� ��"��� � �.�/��������� �Pñ0%��1����"����2���)3%³ó

KNj�Ov��DGFuV¿<CQÍOXDR��� �:_%�eACKNMhA$MZDG<CQN~$}ÜB)KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJILBE~®O1j+jLOPw:K]^C? �u`�DG}³DRI H }ÜBEQ]K]BJÏGBEjIHA�O1I)juDGVXBEILKNV�B�K]^7IHACB���<YIL<YFHBR_4%��eK]QNQ¶AYDGQ]~%_5�eAYK]Q]B�O1I¿ILAYB»jLORVXBvILKNV�Bv`�DR}ÜDRI�o�eKNQ]Q"}³BZQNK]BEÏRBÌIHA�O1I5)3%éKNj�W³DGjujHK]}YQ]BR� � d�BZFHB6 �"�7� �R_" �"���82®OR^Y~9������� ��O1FHBßVXD:~�ORQWCORFLORVXBEIHBZFujZ_aOR^C~:%ÌK]jeOR^àO1IHDGVXK]M+WCFuDGW³DGjHK ILK]DR^%�ð�^åDGFu~CBZF+IHDà~YBEç�^CB�ILAYBXjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZj�DR� � �\_=�UB�MZDR^CjHKN~CBZF¡jHD¦y�MPO1Q]Q]BE~1;�Ð�íúÒ�×rÑ�ÓJÕ¸Ð�� ���Õ��:ÐhÑhÓ=< ñ/> �?àó�_Ü�eACKNMhAèMZDG^YjHK]jkI+DR�,O�jHBJI�DR�,W³DGjujHK]}YQ]B¡�UDGFuQ]~Cj@> OR^C~$OXjHBEI@?D1�,ILFLO1^CjHK ILK]DR^ÌFuBZQÍO¦ILK]DR^CjZ� �*ORMhA$WÜDRjHjHKN}CQ]B¡�¶DGFHQN~BA �1> MEDGFHFuBZjuWÜDG^Y~Cj+ILDvOR^èK]^rIHBZFkyWYFHBEILO1ILKNDG^åDR�&WCFuDGW³DGjHK ILK]DR^�ORQ5QNDG?GK]M1_ÁK|��BR� _'K I�O1jHjHKN?G^CjnO�IHFH<YIHA®Ï1ORQN<CB$%DC��FE¦p�� H�G IHDBJÏGBEFuw$O¦ILDGVXK]M�WCFHDRWÜDGjuKNIHK]DG^H%=��@"ACB)jHBJII? MZDR^xILORK]^Yji��DGFiBJÏGBEFuw$VXD\~CORQÁW�ORFLO1V�BJILBZF' OàILFLO1^CjHK ILK]DR^®FuBZQÍO¦ILK]DR^T~@J {K> �L>Î�NMORQ]KN~CKNI�wèDR�eO ���¦y|��DGFHV¿<YQÍON�ãKN^®ILAYB�¶DGFuQ]~BAàDR�O ��FHKNWC�RB�juILFu<CMEIH<CFHB:< K]j�~CBEç�^YBZ~�}rwèK]^Y~C<CMEIHK]DG^ßDG^ßILAYB¿juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuB)DR����¦y|��DGFHV�<CQÍORB1{

O � ����ø�ýïø��Jÿ¦ü0� � � �0��uü�ÿ � �Eÿ­ÿ����ýïø�50Hù ��ø�:0�ø��7����ø?�kü�ýïø��Jÿ �küJÿ "eüJù �1ù��¦ü0� " 6�»øúÿZýïþ�� ���2� ��¼üEùü�6�6­þ�5Pøûühý|ø��Eÿ¦ù 1H H

Page 12: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� < ��A�� %àKNô % C H ñ���DRFeO1ILDGVXK]MiWCFHDGW³DGjuKNILKNDG^Cj+%aóJ�� < ��A�� � ��� KNô1< ��A�� �7OR^C~ < �A�� ���)@"AYBXjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZj�DR�ILACB�DRIHACBZF�UD\DRQ]BPO1^»DGWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj"KNje~CBEç�^YBZ~ßKN^�ILACB¡<Cju<�ORQ=�UO�wR�

� < ��A�� �-, �8�èKNôB< ���� �ßACDGQN~Cj&��DGF�ÞRÚîÚ��jH<CMhAàILA�O1I�ñ A ���Áó!� ~@J��� < ��A�� � , ���ßKNôB< ����� �ßAYDGQ]~Cj"��DGFiÓ�ئìvÑ��$�eKNILA¼ñ/A ���=ó!� ~@J��

@"AYB � ��yz��DGFuV¿<CQ]O=�ÌKNj �¦ÞRÚ¤í¸ÖvKNô6< ��A � �ÌAYDGQ]~Cj¶��DGF&ORQNQ ��FuK]WC�1B+juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBZj < OR^Y~O1Q]QÜ�¶DGFuQ]~Cj�A�KN^ <��@"AYK]j¡~CBEçC^CKNIHK]DG^�DR�ILACB�juBZV�OR^rILK]MEj���DGF � �»QND\DR�:j+ÏRBZFkw®juK]VXK]Q]ORF�IHD»ILACBXjHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZj��DRF ��;7Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZjE�iSUDR^CMZBEWYI+ILBEFHVXj � DR� 3��7MZOR^è~CKNFHBZMJILQ w�}ÜB�ILFLO1^CjHQ]O1ILBE~ßK]^rIHD��DRFHV¿<CQ]ORB ���¾D1� � �®}xwêK]^rIHBZFHWYFHBEIHK]^C?®MZDG^YMZBZW\I»^�ORVXBZj»O1j�O1IHDGV�KNM�WCFHDGW³DGjuKNILKNDG^CjO1^C~èFHDRQ]B�^�ORVXBZj+O1jiVXD\~�O1QTWCORFLORVXBEIHBZFujZ�i@"AYB �UD:DGQ]BZOR^ßMEDG^C^CBEMEIHKNÏGBEj�DR� 3� ORFHBjuK]VXWCQNwvFHBEWCQÍORMEBZ~à}rw»ILACB¡MZDRFHFHBEjHW³DG^C~CKN^C? �UD\DRQ]BPO1^àMEDG^C^CBEMEIHKNÏGBEjiDR� � �\� ��^CK ÏGBZFujLORQFuDGQ]B�FHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^Cj�ñ�Ï1ORQN<CB�FuBZjuIHFHKNMEILKNDG^CjLónORFuB»FHBZWYQÍORMEBZ~ }rw¼IHACB»MZDGFuFHBEjHW³DG^C~CKN^C?$}ÜDPòDRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFZ_ÜOR^C~èB�ò\K]juIHBZ^rILK]ORQTFHDGQNBnFuBZjuIHFHKNMEILKNDG^Cj�ORFHBnFHBEWCQÍORMEBZ~$}rw�ILACB�MZDGFuFHBZjuWÜDR^C~CK]^Y?~YKÍORVXDG^C~»DGW³BZFHO1ILDRFZ�*>�DGF&B�òCO1V�WCQNBR_YIHACB¡MZDG^YMZBZW\I�IHBZFuV k�~ �sz j ��� � )8zgw:K]BZQN~Cj&ILAYB���¦y|��DGFHV�<CQÍO ��� � z �L������)8z��@"AYBZFHB�KNj)OR^ DG}rÏ:K]DG<Yj H��AH MZDRFHFHBEjHW³DG^C~CBE^CMZBà}³BEI��¶BZBZ^ ��FHK]WY�RB�jkILFH<YMEIL<YFHBZjH< OR^Y~KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^Yj wãDR�93� 5{'ILACB�~CDGV�ORK]^ x y D1�vwãMZDGFuFHBEjHW³DG^C~CjILDnIHACBijuBEI¶DR�=W³DGjkyjuK]}CQNBi�¶DGFHQN~Cj > _CILACB�KN^xIHBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^ � yvDR�ÁIHACB¡FHDGQNB+^�ORVXB � MEDGFHFuBZjuWÜDG^Y~Cj"ILD¿ILAYBIHFLOR^YjHKNIHK]DG^�FuBZQÍO¦ILK]DR^ ~��a_:OR^Y~�ILAYB�KN^xIHBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^^z%y)DR�ÜILACB�MZDG^YMZBZW\I&^�ORVXB z¾MEDGFkyFuBZjuWÜDG^Y~Cj¶IHD¡IHACB�jHBEI¶DR�Ü�UDGFuQ]~CjK]^)�eACKNMhA zcA�ORj*ILFu<YILAXÏ1ORQ]<CB H �5ðzIK]j*BPORjkw�ILD�jHACD��ñ�}rw$K]^C~Y<CMEIHK]DG^$DG^èIHACB�juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBXD1�¶MEDG^CMEBZWYI¡ILBEFHVXjhó�IHA�O1I�ILAYK]j+MEDGFHFuBZjHW³DG^C~YBZ^CMEBZjO1Q]jHD¡ACDRQ]~Cj5��DGF,MEDGVXWCQ]B�ò)MZDR^CMZBEWYI¶IHBZFuV�j � {�KN�ow�KNj*OR^�KN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^)D1� 3� ßOR^Y~< KNj&ILACB¡MEDGFHFuBZjHW³DG^C~YK]^C? ��FHKNWC�RB¡juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBR_�ILAYBZ^ � y E A��7< ��A�� ��� G �ð�^XW�ORFkILKNMZ<CQ]ORFZ_RIHACK]j,KNV�WYQ]K]BEj'IHA�O1I � :�� 6 KNôN����� ���$KNj5ÏRO1Q]K]~3�'@"ACKNj*jHACD��ej*ILA�O1I~YBZMZKNjHKNDG^�WCFHD:MZBE~C<CFHBEj,��DGF5Ï1ORQ]KN~CKNI�w�K]^ ���+MPO1^�}³B"<CjHBE~�IHD�~CBZMEK]~CB"ILAYB�ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^WYFHDG}CQNBZV KN^ 3��,� â+^CBåjHAYDG<CQ]~¾^CDRIHBR_+ACD��¶BEÏRBZFZ_�ILA�O¦IàIHACK]j�DG}YjHBZFkÏ1O1ILKNDG^¾~YD\BEj^YDRI�w:KNBZQ]~ê~CBZMEK]juK]DG^êWCFHD:MZBE~C<CFHBEjv��DGFXf �UDPòêFHBZORjHDR^CK]^C?Y_&DGF���DRF�FuBPORjuDG^CK]^Y?¼K]^ ��;Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZj&�eK ILAà^x<CV¿}³BZFeFHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^CjZ� �ÌDGFuB�FuBZMEBZ^rIi�¶DGFH�»DR^ÌVXD\~CORQ%Q]DR?GK]MEjU�eKNIHA�k?GFLOR~YBZ~ VXD:~�ORQ]K ILKNBZj � � H p � ��ñ��eACKNMhA MZDRFHFHBEjHW³DG^C~ IHDê^x<CV�}ÜBEFÌFuBZjuIHFHKNMEILKNDG^CjLóàOR^Y~�k^CDGVXK]^�ORQNj � � s & �nñî�eACK]MhAêMZDGFuFHBZjuWÜDR^C~ ILDåf �¶D�òãKN^C~CK Ï\KN~C<�ORQNjhó�~CKN~ê^YDRI���D\ME<Cj�DR^~YBZMZKN~�OR}CKNQ]K I�wvKNjHjH<YBZjZ�ðz��DG^YBè�&OR^rIHj�ILD�ORjujHK]?R^cIHACBèVXD\~CORQ�DRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj��eK ILAcO7jHW³BZMEKNç�M$VXBPO1^CK]^C?éñ¸Q]KN�RB�k�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB�D1��O1^àKN^rILBZQNQ]KN?GBZ^rI"O1?GBZ^rI���DGF �uK]^�IHACB���<YIL<CFuB �xó�_YILAYBZ^à<CjHKN^C?¿ILACB¡}�O1jHK]MVXD:~�ORQ=Q]DR?GK]M � ��K]j�^CDRI�jH<���MEK]BE^xI+jHK]^YMZB�K Ii~YD\BEji^CDRIiV�D:~CBEQÁIHACB�juWÜBEMZK ç�M�WCFuDGW³BZFkyIHK]BEj¶ILACO1I"VXD\~�O1Q³DRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHjU�eK ILAvIHACK]j¶K]^rILBEFHWCFuBEILO1ILKNDG^�jHAYDG<CQ]~»jHO1ILKNju�îwR�5ð�^»DGFH~YBZFUIHD~YBZjHMEFHKN}ÜB¿IHACBZjuBXWYFHDGW³BZFkILK]BEjZ_=DG^YB)MPOR^�<CjuB�O1^®O­òYKNDGV�O1ILKNM�ORWYWCFHDrO1MhA%�)>�KN?G<CFHB & K]^\y

H o

Page 13: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� ��� �¦þ������Zù¸ø�ýïø��Jÿ¦ü0�Rý|ü��­ý��0���0=Eø�Hù �������� � ���� �� �� � � � �� � � � ���� � �� �� �� � �� � ���� �� � �1 � �� �� � �� 1 � �� � �

� ����������������ü �Pø��0�êù��z÷�/�"ühý|ü

�� ��»ü�ÿ2�!�#"Zø��?��� $&%(' �*),+ %.-*/0- )�#"Zø��?�­ù � �� � -*/012/ )3)345�6���64 %.- 7 øúÿ>� kþ�kÿ�� ,þ�����Hù>�K]?G<YFHB & {O¦ò\KNDGV juMhACBZV�O1ILO�OR^Y~ÌKN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�Fu<CQ]BEj"��DGF"V�D:~�ORQÜQ]DG?RK]MZjE�

IHFHD:~C<CMEBZj&juDGV�BiO¦ò\K]DGV juMhACBZV�O1ILO)OR^C~vIHACBiMEDGFHFuBZjHW³DG^C~YK]^C?¿KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB+FH<YQ]BZj¶V�D:~C<CjW³DG^CBE^Cj�O1^C~ ^CBEMZBZjujHK IhO1IHK]DG^%�é@"AYBZjHBèORFHBßO¦ò\K]DGV juMhACBZV�O1ILO¼FLO1IHACBZFXILA�O1^ O¦ò\K]DRV�jjuK]^CMEB �èOR^C~�� VvOPw»}³B¡jH<C}YjuILK IL<YIHBZ~à}rwàORFH}CK ILFHORFuw�V�D:~�ORQ³��DGFHV�<CQÍORB1�@"AYBå}CORjHKNM$V�D:~�ORQ+QNDG?GKNM � �7K]j»MhA�ORFHORMEIHBZFuK � BE~¾}rwéIHACB�O¦ò\K]DGV jHMhACBEVvO¦IhO98:<;>=O1^C~ � K]^�ILACB���DGQNQ]D��eK]^C?�juBZ^CjuBR{�O»��DGFHV¿<YQÍON��D1� � ��KNj�Ï1ORQNK]~êñ¸Kï��B1�N_TACDGQN~CjnKN^¼O1Q]Q�¶DGFuQ]~Cj�DR�,O1Q]Q���FHKNWC�RB¡juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBZjLó�KNô�K IeMPOR^Ì}ÜB�~CBZFuKNÏRBZ~ß��FuDGV K]^YjuIhO1^CMZBEjiDR�?8:<;>=O1^C~ � <CjuK]^C?åV�D:~C<Cj�W³DG^CBE^CjvO1^C~ ^CBEMZBEjHjHK IhO1IHK]DG^3� @"ACBÌDRILACBEF)ILACFuBZBàjHMhACBEVvO1ILO~YBZjHMEFHKN}ÜB�W³DGjHjuK]}CQNBXWYFHDGW³BZFkILK]BEj�DR�&VXD:~�ORQ�DRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj�ILACO1I�BJò\WCFHBEjHj �u�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GB�DR�KN^rILBZQNQ]KN?GBZ^rIeOR?RBZ^rILjE_ ��Kï��B1�N_aKN^àIHACK]jeK]^rIHBZFHWYFHBEILO1ILKNDG^ �-, �8�$juACDG<CQN~ß}³BnFuBPOR~ßORj �HOR?GBE^xI' �x^CD��ej �Á� � @"Ax<CjE_>8 MZOR^èKN^xIH<CKNIHKNÏRBZQNw�}³B�FuBPOR~èORj �uf�^èK]^rIHBZQ]QNK]?GBE^rIiO1?GBZ^rI+~YD\BEj^YDRI�ACO�ÏRB�K]^YMZDGFuFHBZMJI¿�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB1_ ��DGFnV�DGFuB�WYFHBZMEK]juBZQNw³{ �uðz�"OR?GBZ^rI ' �:^YD­�ej:��KN^O�jHK IL<�O¦ILK]DR^%_�IHACBZ^ �gAYDGQ]~Cj»KN^ IHACK]j�juKNIL<CO1ILKNDG^%� � @"ACKNjàWYFHDGW³BZFkI�wc~CK]jkILK]^Y?G<CK]juACBZj�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB���FHDGV }³BZQNK]BE��{�OR^»OR?RBZ^rI&V�OPwXÏRBZFkw��¶BZQNQÜ}³BZQNK]BEÏRBiKN^vK]^YMZDGFuFHBZMJIU�¸ORMJILjE_\}C<\IK IeMPOR^Y^CDRI��x^CD�� ILACBEVÌ�*@"ACBnO¦ò\K]DRV jHMhAYBZV�OA@è~YBZjHMEFHKN}ÜBEj�W³DGjHK ILK ÏGB�K]^rIHFHDGjuWÜBEMEILKNDG^%_Kï��B1�N_ �ufi^ K]^rIHBZQ]QNK]?GBE^rI»OR?GBE^rIÌ�x^CD��ej��eA�O1IàKNI��:^YD­�ejE_ �c�eACBEFHBPO1jßO¦ò\KNDGV juMhACBZV�OB ~CBEjHMEFHK]}³BZj»^YBZ?rO1IHKNÏRBßK]^rIHFHDGjuWÜBEMEILKNDG^%_"Kï��B1�N_ �uf�^ K]^rIHBZQ]QNK]?GBE^rIvO1?GBZ^rI»�x^CD��ejv�eA�O¦IK I�~CD:BZj»^YDRI»�x^CD��¡� � bcACK]QNBC8 O1^C~D@ ORFuBè?GBE^CBZFHORQ]Q w O1MZMZBEWYILBE~ O1j�FHBZORjHDG^COR}CQ]BO­òYKNDGVXjn��DGFn�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBR_ B KNj�~CKNjHWC<\IhOR}CQNBR{�^CBE?rO1ILK ÏGB�KN^rILFHDRjHW³BZMEIHK]DG^ KNV�WYQ]K]BEj�ILA�O1IIHACB¿O1?GBZ^rI+MZOR^$ORjujHBEj+KNIHj�D��e^èMEDGV�W³BEIHBZ^CMEB�KN^ÌILAYB�jHBE^CjHBnILA�O1IiKNI��x^CD��ej+�eACBZ^ßKNILjD��e^è�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB�K]j�^CDRI+ju< �XMZKNBZ^rI+ILD�jHDGQ ÏGB)OXMZBEFuIhO1K]^ßILORjH�a�iSUDG^CjHBEäx<CBZ^rILQ wG_%IHACBZFuBO1FHB,I��UD�~CK ô3BEFHBZ^rITVXD\~�O1QGQ]DG?RK]MZjÜILA�O1IÁVXD:~CBZQG�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GBDR�\K]^rILBEQ]QNK]?GBE^xI=OR?GBZ^rIHjZ��@"AYBQNDG?GKNMFEG@v~CK]juWÜBE^CjHBEj�eK ILA�^CBZ?GO1ILK ÏGBeK]^rILFuDGjHW³BZMJILKNDG^%_rK|��BR� _rKNI*<YjHBZjDG^CQ w�IHACBejHMhACBEVvO1ILO8�:<;H=G_ �®_I8X_J@Á_C�eACBZFuBPORj!E B OR~C~CK ILK]DR^�ORQ]Q wXORQ]QND��ej&��DGF B �f�jOR^XORQNIHBZFH^CO1ILK ÏGB&ILD�IHACK]j,O­òYKNDGV�O1ILKNM&ORWCWYFHDrORMhA���DGF,~CBJç�^CKN^C?KEG@»O1^C~LE B _xDG^CB"MZOR^O1Q]jHD�MhA�ORFLO1MEILBEFHK � BiIHACBZjuB�Q]DG?GKNMZjK]^»O¿juBZV�OR^rILKNM��UO�wv}rw�FHBEjuIHFHK]MJILKN^C?�ILAYB�OR~CVXK]jujHK]}YQ]BIHFLOR^YjHKNIHK]DG^®FHBEQÍO1IHK]DG^CjnK]^ ��FuK]WC�1B�juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBZjZ�å@"ACB»QNDG?GK]MME�@êMEDGFHFuBZjHW³DG^C~Yj�IHDßILAYBFuBZjkILFHKNMEIHK]DG^ ILDãÐLÑON�Ñ �Gí��RÑàÞRÔ³Ö¼ÕïÐuÞRÔYÓJíîÕ¸í��RÑ�ILFLO1^CjHK ILK]DR^ãFuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^CjZ_*Kï��B1�N_ILACB���DGFHV�<CQÍO

H &

Page 14: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� AYDGQ]~Cj)KN^ãORQ]Q�UDGFuQ]~Cj�DR�iORQNQ ��FHKNWC�RB�juIHFH<CMJIL<CFuBZj��eKNIHAãFuB � B�ò\KNÏGBÌOR^C~ IHFLOR^CjuKNIHKNÏGBIHFLOR^YjHKNIHK]DG^$FuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^Cj+K ô KNI�MZOR^å}ÜB�~CBEFHKNÏRBZ~���FHDGV K]^CjkIhOR^YMZBZj�DR�8:<;>=r_ �®_>8æOR^Y~@ê<CjHKN^C?�V�D:~C<Cj�WÜDG^YBZ^CjXOR^C~�^CBEMZBEjHjHK IhO1IHK]DG^3�7fi^�O1Q]DG?GDR<CjHQ wG_E B MZDRFHFHBEjHW³DG^C~Cj)IHDIHACBvFuBZjkILFHKNMEIHK]DG^�ILDàILFLO1^CjHK ILK]DR^åFuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^Cj�ILA�O¦I¿ORFuB�Ñ�� �:í��¦ÞRÚ]ÑJÔ �hÑXÐLÑJÚ ÞRÕïí|ئÔYÓG�»@"ACBZjuBMEDGFHFuBZjuWÜDG^Y~CBZ^CMEBZj�MPOR^�}³B�<CjHBE~àIHDX~YBZjHKN?G^»IhOR}YQ]BPO1<�ORQ]?GDRFHKNIHACVXj¶��DGFFE�@èO1^C~ E B }rwKN^rILBZ?RFLO1IHK]^C?¿IHACB¡jHW³BZMZK]ORQ%WCFuDGW³BZFuIHK]BEj�D1�'IHACB�ILFLO1^CjHK ILK]DR^»FHBZQ]O1ILKNDG^Cj&KN^rILD)ILACB¡Fu<CQ]BEj"DR�IHACB�IhOR}YQ]BPO1<àMZORQ]ME<CQ]<YjZ�@"AYB$WCFHDGW³BZFkILKNBZj�DR�¡VXD:~�ORQ�DGWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj�ILA�O1IvV�D:~CBEQ�ILKNV�B�y�~CBEWÜBE^C~CBE^xI��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBACO�ÏRBåORQ]juD7}ÜBEBZ^ K]^rÏGBEjuIHK]?rO1IHBZ~éKN^é~CBEILORK]Q¿ñ¸jHBEBR_�BR��?C�N_ � & �\_ H pGq��+��DGFvD­ÏRBZFkÏ\KNBE��ORFkyIHK]MEQ]BZj)DR^�IHACK]j¿IHDGWCKNM�óJ�¼ð�^ãDRFH~CBEF�IHD�FHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rIXILK]VXBJyz~CBZW³BZ^Y~CBZ^rIXOR^C~ãjH<Y}:ÝuBZMJILKNÏRB�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GBiK]^ �+BEjHMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^v;=DG?GK]MEjZ_\DG^CBiMZOR^»K]^rIHBZ?GFHO1ILB�V�D:~�ORQaDGW³BZFHO1ILDGFuj&K]^rIHD ��;Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjE� �¶BZMPO1<CjHBÌDR�iIHACBßO1}ÜD�ÏGBàVXBZ^rILKNDG^CBZ~ãMZQNDGjHB�MEDG^C^CBEMEILKNDG^ }³BEI��¶BZBE^ ��;O1^C~ßVXD\~CORQ%Q]DR?GK]MEjZ_�jH<YMhA$OR^ßKN^rILBZ?RFLO1IHK]DG^CjeO1WCWÜBZORFHBE~ÌIHDv}³B�FHO1ILAYBZF�jHK]VXWCQNBR�UðzI�A�O1jIH<CFH^YBZ~7DG<\IP_�AYD­�¶BEÏRBZFE_*IHA�O1I�ILACKNjnKN^rILBZ?RFLO1IHK]DG^åK]j�V�DRFHB�MZDGVXWCQNBJò�ILACOR^7BJò\W³BZMJILBZ~3_}³DRIHA���FuDGV IHACB¡jHBZV�OR^rILKNM¡OR^C~�ILACB�ORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�KNM�W³DGKN^xIeD1�'Ï:K]BJ� ��� q\_ H pY_ � _ H p H �ï�b®BXMZQ]DRjHB�ILACKNj�juBZMJILK]DR^¼}rw�V�BE^rILK]DR^CK]^C?�juDGV�B��¶DGFH�èIHA�O1InK]j¡MZDG^YMZBZFu^CBZ~®�eKNILA�ILAYBMEDG^C^CBEMEIHK]DG^7}³BEI��¶BZBE^ V�D:~�ORQ*QNDG?GK]MEj�OR^C~7QNDG?GK]M)WYFHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?C��t�BZQ ��DG^C~ � sGs �¶B�òxyIHBZ^C~Yj �+K]jîÝu<C^CMJILKNÏRB�;ÁDR?GK]M�ë,FHDG?RFLORVXj,ILD �*WYK]juIHBZVXK]M�;=DG?GKNMeë*FuDG?GFHORV�j*}rwXK]^rILFuD\~Y<CMJyKN^C?èVXD\~CORQ¶DRWÜBEFLO1IHDGFHj � OR^C~�� {���DGF¿OèQ]KNIHBZFHORQ �e_,IHACB�BJò\WCFuBZjujHK]DR^ � � juACDG<CQN~}³B)FHBZOR~åORj�� � K]j��x^CD��e^��ÌOR^C~�� �¾jHAYDG<CQ]~�}³B)FHBZOR~åORj�� �¾V�OPwè}³B�ORjHju<CVXBZ~%� �t�K]DRFH~�OR^YD�OR^C~ �ßORFuIHBZQNQ]K � mRp��5<CjuB)V�D:~�ORQÁQNDG?GK]M¡ILDvDG}YIhO1K]^èO�<Y^CKN��DGFuV FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO¦yIHK]DG^�DR�'~CK ô3BEFHBZ^rI�ORWCWYFHDrORMhAYBZje��DGFejuILFu<CMEIH<CFHKN^C?�;ÁDR?GK]M�ë,FuDG?GFLO1V�j"�eKNIHA»ILACB�ACBZQNW�DR�}YQ]D:Mh�:j'OR^C~nV�D:~C<CQNBZjE�'ð�^ � o �\_ � � _ H _­s H �ï_1VXD:~�ORQrDGFÁILBEV�W³DGFLO1Qx;ÁDR?GK]Më,FHDG?RFLORVXV�KN^C?Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjeO1FHB�K]^rIHFHD:~C<CMZBE~%�

�gǶÄ�� ÇUÄ+Ç,ÅCǶÄ�Ë�Ê ��Ç��UË�Ê�

@"AYK]j*FHBEjHBPO1FHMhA�O1FHBPO¡A�ORjORQNjHD¡MZFuBPO1IHBZ~�O�Ax<C?RB�^x<CV�}ÜBEFD1�%ORWYWCFHDrO1MhACBZj¶OR^C~XFHBEjH<CQ ILjZ_�eAYK]MhA��UBeMPO1^C^CDRI~CBEjHMZFuK]}³BeK]^�~CBEILORK]QYACBZFuBR�5@"ACB"��DGQNQ]D��eK]^Y?+K]j*O�}CFuK]BE�ÜK]^rIHFHD:~C<CMEIHK]DG^KN^rILD�ILACBnBJò\K]jkILK]^Y?vORWYWCFHDrO1MhACBZj�O1^C~ÌIHACB�WCFuDG}CQNBZVXjeIHFHBZO1ILBE~è}rwàIHACBZjuB¿ORWYWCFHDrO1MhACBZjE�âiÏRBZFuÏ:KNBE�ej�DR�'IHACB�ORFHBZOXMZOR^%_C��DGF"B�òYORV�WYQ]BR_Y}ÜB���DG<C^Y~àKN^ � sxo:_ao & _³o1s �|���^CD��eQNBZ~C?GBUFHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rIhO¦ILK]DR^)QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEj�}�ORjuBZ~)DG^�MZQÍO1jHjHKNMPORQ:Q]DR?GK]MEj&ñ�BR��?C�N_GçCFHjuIky�DGFu~CBZFWYFHBZ~YK]MPO¦ILB"Q]DR?GK]MPó�ORFHB"VXDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM&K]^¿IHACB"��DGQ]QND��eK]^C?+juBZ^CjuBR{,K �3O�jkIhO1IHBZVXBZ^rI �vMPOR^X}ÜB~YBZFHK ÏGBE~���FuDGV O��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB)}�ORjHB1_%ILACBE^ �®MPOR^åORQNjHD�}³B)~CBEFHKNÏRBZ~$��FHDRV OR^rwßQÍORFu?GBZF�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GBÌ}�ORjuBR� @"ACKNj�WYFHDGW³BZFkI�wêACORjXIHACBÌOR~YÏ1OR^rIhOR?RBàIHA�O1IXDG^CMEBÌ~CFHOP�e^ K]^Y��BEFkyBE^CMZBEj¡^CBZBE~®^CD1I¡}ÜB)FuBEÏ:K]juBZ~$�eACBZ^®OR~C~YKNILKNDG^�ORQTK]^\��DGFHV�O1ILKNDG^àMZDGVXBZj�KN^%��d�D��UBJÏGBZFE_IHACK]j�Q]BZOR~Cj�IHD�IHACB¿~CKNjLOR~YÏ1OR^rILOR?GBnIHA�O1I+OR~C~CKN^C?vKN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^�MZDR^xIHFLOR~YK]MEIHK]^C?�DG^CBnDR�IHACBX~CFLOP�e^¼KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEBZjnQ]BPO1~Cj�ILDÌOR^¼KN^CMZDG^YjHK]jkILBE^CMEwR_5OR^C~�ILAx<CjnVvO1�RBZj¡ILAYB��x^CD��eQ yBE~C?GB�}�ORjuB�<CjuBZQNBZjHjE�*ð�^vV�OR^rw�ORWCWCQNK]MZO1ILKNDG^CjZ_GIHACB��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBiOR}³DG<YI*IHACB��¶DGFuQ]~ßñ�ILAYB

H s

Page 15: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

O1WCWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^�~CDRVvORKN^aó"K]j�FHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rILBE~®KN^èOR^ßK]^CMEDGV�WYQ]BEIHB��&OPwG� ��BEÏRBZFkILACBEQ]BZjujZ_=DG^YB�UOR^rILj¿IHD$~CFLOP� Ò³Ú Þ �rÓJí�4ZÚ]Ñ»MZDR^CMZQN<CjHKNDG^Cj���FuDGV ILACB�OPÏ1ORK]Q]OR}CQNBX�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB1�®ð�^7IHACK]jjuKNIH<�O1ILKNDG^%_r^CBJ�eQNwXORMEäx<CK]FuBZ~XK]^Y��DGFuVvO¦ILK]DR^)VvOPw)juACD�� ILA�O¦I¶juDGVXB�DR�ÜILACBEjHB�WCQÍO1<CjHKN}CQ]BMEDG^CMEQ]<CjuK]DG^Cj¶�UBEFHB��eFHDG^Y?C�,@"ACK]jUjHACDG<YQ]~»^CDRI&Q]BPO1~�ILD)K]^YMZDG^CjuK]jkILBZ^YMEw�D1�=ILACB��x^CD��eQ yBE~C?GB¡}�ORjuBR_a}C<YIeFHO1ILAYBZF"ILDXO)�eKNILAY~CFLOP�UORQ=DR�'jHDGVXB�DR�TILACB¡WCQ]OR<CjHKN}CQ]BiMZDG^CMEQ]<CjuK]DG^YjZ�;=BJI5<Cj5jkIhORFkI��eK ILA�IHACFHBEB&jHKNV�WCQNB*BJòYORVXWCQ]BEj'ILACO1I5KNQ]Q]<YjuILFHO1ILB,IHACB&jHK IL<�O¦ILK]DR^Cj'KN^n�eACKNMhA^YDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CK]M�KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�VXBEIHACD\~Yj�O1FHB�~CBZjuK]FLO1}CQ]B1� �¿Ñ EÞ �:Ú¤Õ¶Ð��:Ú]ÑhÓ)ORWYWCQNw»IHD�VXDGjuIKN^C~CK Ï\KN~C<�ORQNjeñ¸FuBZjuW%�:I�w:WCKNMPORQaDGF*^CDRFHV�ORQ�K]^C~YKNÏ:K]~C<CORQ]jLóJ_G}C<\IU^CD1I¶IHD�ORQNQ|�TfijUOR^�B�òYORV�yWYQ]BR_a�¶B¿VvOPwàMZDR^CjHKN~CBZF�WCFHDGW³BZFkI�wßBE~C?GBEj+K]^è[\BZV�OR^rILKNM ��BEI��¶DGFH�xjZ��ð�^ÌILACBn^CBEI��¶DGFH�D1�e>�K]?R<CFHB H �¶BvACOR~®IHACB�~YBE�¸OR<CQ I�Fu<CQ]B �H>�FHDR?Gj�ORFHBàÔ3ئÐ�ìXÞRÚîÚ �)?GFHBEBZ^%� � @"ACKNjnFu<CQ]BjuACDG<CQN~v}³BiO1WCWCQ]KNBZ~��eACBZ^YBEÏGBEFUILAYBZFHB�K]j^CD�K]^Y��DGFuVvO¦ILK]DR^)MZDG^rILFHOR~CKNMEILKN^C?�KNIP�'fij¶Q]DG^C?O1jU�UB�DR^CQNwX�x^CD��¾IHA�O1I �¡BEFHVXKNI¶K]j"O���FHDG?C_x�¶B�~CBZ~C<YMZB+ILACO1I ��BZFuV�K IUKNjU?GFuBZBZ^3�@"AYBFu<CQ]B"KNj5^CDRIO1WCWCQ]KNBZ~¿IHD�?RFLORjuj5��FHDG?GjE_rDR�³�eACK]MhA�KNI5K]j,�x^CD��e^XIHA�O1I,IHACBEw�O1FHB"^CDRI*?RFHBZBE^ñ�jHKN^CMZB�ILAYBEw�ORFuB¡}CFHD��e^aó��@"AYB � Ú]Ø�Ó�ÑHÖ��ßئÐ�Ú Ö � ÓhÓ��\ìiÒ³Õ¸í|ئÔ�� � � ��� ORjujH<CVXBZj¶}rw�~CBE�¸OR<YQNI*ILA�O¦IIHACB�O�Ï1ORKNQÍOR}YQ]BKN^Y��DGFuVvO1IHK]DG^�KNj�MZDRV�WCQNBEIHBR�àðz��OR^�ORjHjuBZFkILK]DR^7MPOR^Y^CDRI¿}³Bv~YBZFHK ÏGBE~ ñ¸<CjuK]^C?èMEQÍORjujHKNMPORQKN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB*V�BJILACD:~Cjhó3��FuDGV ILAYB�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB}�ORjuBR_¦ILACBE^¿S¶b$fã~CBE~C<CMZBEj�K ILjÁ^CBZ?GO1ILKNDG^%�@"AYK]j�ORjHju<CV�W\ILK]DR^ K]jE_¶��DGFXBJòYORVXWCQNBR_UBEV�WYQ]D�wGBE~ K]^ãFHBEQÍO1IHK]DG^�O1Q&~�O1ILOR}�ORjuBZj�O1^C~ K]^;=DG?RK]M¿ë,FuDG?GFLO1V�VXK]^C?�QÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEji�eKNIHA ����BE?rO1IHK]DG^$O1j¡>³O1K]Q]<YFHBR� � fij¡OR^$B�òCO1V�WCQNBR_�¶B$V�O�wêMZDR^CjHKN~CBZFvIHFLORKN^ MZDR^C^CBZMJILKNDG^Cj»K]^ O®ILKNV�BJIhOR}CQNBR{�KN��O®MZDG^C^YBZMEIHK]DG^éKNj�^CDRIMEDG^rIhORKN^CBZ~åK]^�ILAYB�IHK]VXBEILOR}CQ]B1_%�UBXMZDR^CMZQN<C~CB�ILA�O1I�K I¡~CD\BEj¡^CDRI�BJò\K]jkIP��ðz�U�¶B�QNBPORFu^Q]O1ILBEF�DR^êILACO1IvIHACBZFuBßK]j�jH<CMhAcOåMZDG^Y^CBZMJILK]DR^ ñ��eACKNMhA �UORj�^CDRIvMZDG^rILORK]^CBE~ KN^êILAYBIHK]VXBEILOR}CQ]BPóJ_:ILACBE^à�¶B¡V¿<CjuIe�eK ILAC~CFHOP� ILAYK]j"MZDR^CMZQN<CjHKNDG^%�@"AYB �3ÐuÞRìvÑ�Ò³ÐLØ 4ZÚ]ÑJì MEDGVXBZj)��FHDGV ILACB�~CDRVvORKN^7DR��V�D:~CBEQ]Q]KN^C?èO1MEILKNDG^CjE�7ð�^ãIHACK]jMEDG^rILB�ò\IZ_aKNI"KNj"K]VXWÜDGFkIhOR^rI&IHD�~CBZjuMZFHKN}ÜB��eACKNMhAÌWYFHDGW³BZFkILK]BEjeORFHB�MhACOR^C?GBE~èOR^C~»�eACKNMhAFuBZV�ORK]^Ì<C^CMhA�O1^C?GBZ~$}rwßOR^$ORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^àDR�,ILAYB¿ORMJILK]DR^%� ��jH<�ORQNQNwR_³IHACB¿ORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^D1��O1^�ORMEIHK]DG^�MhACOR^C?GBEj&ÏGBZFkw���BE� ORjuWÜBEMEILj"D1�TIHACBi�¶DGFHQN~%�*>�DGFUB�òYORV�WYQ]BR_\}rw»jHBE^C~CK]^Y?O�V�OR^x<CjuMZFHKNWYI�DR�,IHACK]j+ORFuIHK]MZQNBnIHD�O�WC<C}CQNK]jHAYBZFZ_3ð�ACO�ÏRB�MhA�OR^C?GBE~�KNILjiQ]D:MPO1IHK]DG^%_a}C<\Iñ�ACDGW³BE��<CQNQNwYó�^YDRI)KNIHj�MEDG^rILBZ^rIZ�®@"ACB»juD1y�MZORQ]QNBZ~ ����FLORVXB�O¦ò\KNDGV�j �ß~CBEjHMEFHK]}³BR_,�eACKNMhAWYFHDGW³BZFkILK]BEj)FHBEVvORKN^7<C^CMhACOR^C?GBE~ }rw7ILAYB�ORWCWCQNK]MPO¦ILK]DR^7DR��OR^ãORMEIHK]DG^3� [\KN^CMZB�IHACBZFuB<YjH<�ORQNQNw¡KNj5O�ÏRBZFkw¿QÍO1FH?GB*^x<CV¿}³BZF5D1�CILACBEjHB"O­òYKNDGVXjZ_RDR^CBUjuACDG<CQN~nILFkwnIHD+OPÏGDRK]~¿A�OPÏ:K]^Y?IHD$juILO1ILBvIHACB�B�òYWYQ]K]MEKNIHQNwG�ßf WÜDRjHjHKN}CQ]BvjHDGQN<YILKNDG^®IHDèILACKNj¿WCFHDR}CQ]BEV KNj�ILD$BEV�WYQ]D�w®O^YDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CK]M�KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB�Fu<CQ]B1_'�eACKNMhA7jLOPw:jnIHA�O1I�ñ¸^CDGFuVvO1Q]QNwYó+ORQNQ*ORjHW³BZMJILj¿D1�UILAYB�¶DGFuQ]~$ILA�O¦I¡ORFHB)^YDRI¡BJò\WCQNK]MZK ILQ wÌMhACOR^C?GBE~®}rwèIHACBXORMEIHK]DG^$FuBZV�ORK]^èKN^rÏRO1FHKÍO1^xI+<C^C~CBEFK ILjeORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^%�ð�^êILACBàQ]K ILBZFHO1IL<YFHBR_UO¼?GFuBPO1IXÏ1ORFHKNBEI�w�DR��~YKNôÜBZFHBE^rI»ORWCWYFHDrORMhAYBZj�IHD¼^CDR^CV�DR^CDRILDR^CK]MFuBPORjuDG^CKN^C?ÌACO�ÏRB�}³BZBE^7K]^rIHFHD:~C<CMZBE~%_TDR�U�eACKNMhA®^YDG^CBXjHBZBEV�j¡ILDà}³B �kIHACBX}ÜBEjuI��ÌORW\yWYFHDrORMhA3�fgÏRBZFuw�W³DGjuKNILK ÏGB+~YBEÏGBEQ]DGWYV�BE^xI�K]j&IHACB��¸ORMEI"IHA�O1I�FHBEMZBE^xIHQNw»juBEÏRBZFLO1QTFuBZju<CQNIHjMEQÍORFuKN�îw:K]^Y?àIHACB»MZDG^Y^CBZMJILK]DR^ }ÜBJI��UBEBZ^ã~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI�ORWCWYFHDrORMhAYBZj)A�OPÏGB�}³BZBE^ DG}YIhO1K]^CBE~ñ�jHBEBR_CB1��?C� _ ��� H _ � sY_ � m:_Cq H _ ��� �ÍóJ�,ð�^�IHACBi��DGQNQ]D��eK]^C?Y_G�UB�}CFuK]B � wXK]^rILFuD\~C<YMZBiIHACBi��DG<CF

H m

Page 16: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

VXDGjkIeK]VXWÜDGFkIhOR^rI&I�w:W³BZj�DR��ORWCWCFuDrORMhACBEjZ�� ئÔYÓJí]ÓJÕ�ÑJÔ � � � 4hÞ¦Ó�ÑHÖ+ÞJÒrÒ³ÐLØZÞ ����ÑhÓr_�DR�:�eACK]MhAn`eBZKNIHBZF �j �+BE�¸O1<CQNIÁ;=DG?RK]M ��� q��xKNjÁOeI�w:WCKNMPORQB�òYORV�WYQ]BR_³MZDR^CjHKN~CBZF�^CDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CKNM�Fu<CQ]BEjiDR��ILACB���DGFHV �"z ^CDGFuVvORQNQNw»KNV�WYQ]K]BEj��v� �[:<CMhA¼O»Fu<CQ]B)MZOR^®}³B�ORWCWYQ]K]BE~êñ¸K|��BR� _�� K]j�KN^CjHBEFuILBE~®KN^èILACB��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�}�ORjuB�ó�_'K �NzAYDGQ]~CjE_=OR^C~$KN^CjHBEFuIHK]^C?�� ~CD:BZj�^YDRI�~CBEjuILFuD�wèMZDR^CjHKNjuILBE^CMEwèDR�*ILACB)�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB)}�O1jHBR�f�j�O1^�BJòYORVXWCQNBR_­�UB¶VvOPw�OR?rO1K]^¡<CjHBILACB~CBJ�¸OR<CQNI'FH<YQ]B �H>�FHDG?Rj'O1FHB^CDGFHV�ORQNQNw�?GFHBEBZ^%� �;=BJI,<Cj�ç�FujuI*O1jHjH<YV�BUIHA�O1I'ILACB&�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GBU}�ORjHB"MEDG^rIhORKN^Cj'IHACB&KN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^%{ �Lt¡FHORjHj��FuDG?Gj�ORFHBÌ}CFHD��e^%�¾fi^ KN^C~CK Ï\KN~C<�ORQ"MZOR^C^CD1I�}³BÌ}³DRILA }CFHD��e^éOR^Y~ ?GFHBEBZ^%� t¡FHORjHj��FuDG?Gj�ORFHBà��FHDG?RjZ� �¡BEFHVXKNIXK]j�Oå��FuDG?C�¾[\MED\DRIHBZF�K]j�O¼?GFLO1jHj���FuDG?C� � ð�^êILACKNjvMPO1jHBR_IHACBX~CBE�¸OR<YQNInFH<CQNB�MZOR^¼}³BvO1WCWCQ]KNBZ~�ILD �¡BEFHVXKNIZ_T}Y<YI¿^CD1InIHD$[\MED\DRIHBZFE�»@"ACBvV�O­ÝuDGFWYFHDG}CQNBZV ILA�O1IàO MEDG^CjHKNjuIHBZ^CMJwxyz}�ORjuBZ~gORWYWCFHDrO1MhA¾V¿<YjuI�jHDRQNÏGB�KNj�ILACB$äx<CBEjuILKNDG^ DR�AYD­�æIHD7FHBEjHDGQ ÏGBèMEDG^ � KNMEILjv}ÜBJI��UBEBZ^c~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI»Fu<CQ]BEjZ{åORWCWCQ w:K]^C?®~CBE�¸OR<YQNI�Fu<CQ]BEj�K]^~YKNôÜBZFHBE^rInDRFH~CBEF�V�OPwèQNBPOR~$ILDà~CK ô3BEFHBZ^rI�FHBEjH<CQ ILjE�X@TDàK]Q]QN<CjuIHFLO1IHBnIHACK]j¡WCFuDG}CQ]BEVÌ_3Q]BEI<Yj+ORjujH<CVXBnIHA�O1I�ILACBnjuILFuK]MJIiKN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^ �Lt�FLO1jHje��FHDG?Gj�ORFuBn��FHDR?Gj �XK]j�FHBEWCQÍORMEBZ~è}rwIHACB�~YBE��BPO1jHK]}YQ]B�K]^Y��DGFuVvO¦ILK]DR^ �Lt¡FHORjHje��FHDR?GjiO1FHB�^CDGFHV�ORQNQNwv��FuDG?GjE_ �X�eACBZFuBPORj�O1Q]Q%ILAYBD1ILACBEF�KN^Y��DGFuVvO1IHK]DG^»FuBZV�ORK]^Yj&ILACB�jLORVXBR� ��D��¡_a}³DRILAà~CBE�¸O1<CQNI�FH<YQ]BZj�ORFuB�O1WCWCQ]KNMPOR}YQ]BIHD�[\MED\DRIHBZFE�$fij)jHD:DG^ O1j¿DG^CB�D1�"ILACBEV K]j�ORWCWCQNK]BE~%_�ILAYB�DRILAYBZF¿DG^YB�K]jn^CD$Q]DG^Y?GBZFO1WCWCQ]KNMPOR}YQ]BR�à@"Ax<CjZ_,DR^CB�V¿<CjkI¿~CBEMZKN~CBv�eACKNMhA DR�"ILACB�WÜDRjHjHKN}CQ]B�FHBEjH<CQ ILj�juACDG<CQN~ }ÜBWYFHBE��BEFHFuBZ~%_\DGFZ_:KN�%IHACBiMEDG^ � KNMEI¶MPOR^Y^CDRI&}³BiFuBZjuDGQNÏRBZ~�~C<YBiILDnWCFHKNDGFHK ILK]BEj*ORVXDG^C?�Fu<CQ]BEjZ_AYD­�7V¿<CMhA�K]^Y��DGFuVvO¦ILK]DR^+MPOR^�juIHK]QNQG}ÜB*~CBE~C<CMEBZ~���FuDGV jH<YMhA¿OR^�<C^CFuBZjHDRQNÏGBE~�juKNIL<CO1ILKNDG^%�>�DGFBJòYORVXWCQNBR_xILACB�MZDG^CMEQ]<CjuK]DG^YjUMZDR^CMZBEFH^CKN^C? ��BZFuV�K I¶juACDG<CQN~v^CD1I&}³BiK]^ � <CBZ^YMZBZ~»}rwIHACB¡MZDG^ � K]MJI"��DGF�[\MZD:DRIHBZFZ�f ìvØZÖrÞRÚaÔ3ئÔ�ìvئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í���Ú]ØHÛRí��"�UORjZ_\��DGF¶B�òYORV�WYQ]BR_:WCFuDGWÜDRjHBZ~v}xw �ÌM �+BZFuV�DRIuI"OR^Y~�+D�w:Q]B � � H _ �Gp��|�*@"ACKNj&Q]DG?RK]M�ORQ]QND­�ej¶��DGF"O¿~CK]ORV�DR^C~vDGW³BZFHO1ILDRFZ_Y�eACKNMhA»K]jU�eFuKNIuILBZ^àORj� _%�eACBEFHB � � juACDG<CQN~®KN^rIL<CK ILKNÏRBZQ wè}³BXFuBPOR~®ORj ���7K]j�MEDG^CjuK]juIHBZ^rIP� � @"ACB�~CBJ�¸OR<CQNIFu<CQ]B��H>�FHDR?GjTORFHB¶^CDGFHV�ORQNQNw+?RFHBZBE^��+MZOR^nIHACBZ^¿}³B¶�eFuKNIuILBZ^�ORj'IHACBUKNV�WYQ]K]MZO1ILKNDG^ �oq�n� �� r6q*tot e � r6qvtotJe3�'ð�^�DGFH~YBZF%ILD"IHFHBPO¦ITIHACK]j=KNV�WYQ]K]MZO1ILKNDG^�MZDGFuFHBZMJILQ wG_­ILACB*Q]DR?GK]M'^CBZBE~CjO1^vOR~Y~CKNIHK]DG^�O1QCK]^Y��BEFHBE^CMZB�FH<CQNBR_G�eACKNMhAvKNj¶O1}CQ]B"ILD�~CBEFHKNÏRB���DRFHV¿<CQ]ORB"DR�ÜILACBe��DGFHV � �O1MZMZDRFH~CKN^C?�IHD�IHACBZKNF¶KN^rILBZ^Y~CBZ~�jHBZV�OR^rILKNMZjE�,ð�^vWCFuK]^CMEK]WCQNBR_GILAYK]j*K]^Y��BEFHBE^CMZB�FH<CQNB�O1Q]Q]D��ej<YjvILD ~CBE~C<CMEB � �Á_eKN� ) �¾MZOR^C^CDRI�}ÜBè~YBZ~C<CMEBZ~%� @"ACKNj�K]j�^CDRI�O1j�jHKNV�WCQNBßO1j�KNIV�OPwèjuDG<C^C~®jHK]^YMZB)�UB�ORFuB¿�¸ORMZBE~å�eK ILA�ILACB)��DGQNQ]D��eK]^C?vMEw:MZQNK]M)~CBEWÜBE^C~CBZ^YMEw³{n�eACKNMhA��DRFHV¿<CQ]ORB�DR�=ILACB+��DRFHV ) �ßORFHBi~CBZ~C<YMZK]}YQ]B+O1Q]FHBZOR~Yw�~CBZW³BZ^Y~Cj"DG^�ILAYB+K]^Y��BEFHBE^CMZB+Fu<CQ]BIHD»}ÜB)~YBEç�^CBE~%� �+D�w:Q]B)O1^C~ �ÌM �+BEFHVXDRIHI�juDGQNÏRB¿ILACKNj+WCFuDG}CQ]BEV }rwèKN^rILFHD:~C<CMEK]^C?�O1^O1WCWCFHDRWCFHK]O1ILBE~7çYò\BZ~\yzWÜDGKN^rI�jHBZV�OR^rILKNMZjE�¼fi^YDRILACBEF)FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO1ILK ÏGBàDR�eILACB»MEQÍORjuj)DR�VXD:~�ORQ3^YDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CK]MiQ]DG?GKNMZj&KNj"ILACB��¶BZQ]Q�y��x^CD��e^àOR<YIHD\BEWCK]jkILBZVXK]MiQ]DG?GKNM � �Rs �ï�ð�^àMZQ]ORjHjuK]MZORQ%WCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHB�QNDG?GKNMR_\IHACB�^CDRILKNDG^»DR��Q]DG?GKNMPORQÜMZDG^YjHBZäx<CBE^CMZBnK]je~CBJç�^CBZ~à�eKNIHAFuBZjuWÜBEMEIeILDàÞRÚîÚ%ìvØZÖ:ÑJÚúÓ+DR��O¿jHBEIeD1�T��DRFHV¿<CQ]ORBR���UÐLÑ PÑJÐLÑJÔ�Õ¸í¸ÞRÚÜÓ�ÑJìXÞRÔ�Õïí��hÓ � H p � �3ILOR�RBEjO1jXQNDG?GKNMPORQ¶MZDG^CjuBZäx<CBE^CMZBEj�ORQ]QILACB���DGFHV�<CQÍORB�ILA�O1IXACDRQ]~�K]^ ÞRÚîÚ'Ò³ÐLÑ PÑJÐ�ÐhÑHÖåìvØZÖ:ÑJÚúÓr�@"AYB�WYFHBE��BEFHFuBZ~vVXD:~CBZQNj,ORFHB"<YjH<�ORQNQNw�~CBEç�^YBZ~�O1j5ILACBeVXK]^CKNVvORQxVXD\~YBZQ]j'�eKNILA�FuBZjHW³BZMJIIHDãOã?GK ÏGBE^cÒ³ÐLÑ PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑèÐLÑJÚ ÞRÕ¸í|ئÔgDG^cK]^rILBEFHWCFuBEILO1ILKNDG^CjZ� @TD�K]Q]QN<CjuIHFLO1IHBßILAYK]j»K]~YBPOY_

H �

Page 17: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

�¶B»MZDR^CjHKN~CBZF)OÌjHK]VXWCQNB�B�òCO1V�WCQNB���FuDGV�WYFHDGW³DGjHK ILKNDG^�ORQ*Q]DR?GK]M1�Ìðz�e�¶B�ORjHju<CV�B�ILA�O1IIHACBZFuB»ORFuB�DG^CQ wåI��¶D$WCFuDGWÜDRjHKNIHK]DG^CORQ5Ï1ORFHK]OR}CQ]BEj@% � � _�IHACBZ^7�¶B�A�OPÏRB���DG<CF¿~CK ô3BEFHBE^xIKN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^YjZ{=A������ ���E_'K]^®�eAYK]MhA %7OR^C~ � ORFuB��¸ORQNjHBR_&A��� ���E_'K]^®�eAYK]MhA %¼K]j¡ILFH<YBO1^C~ � KNj¶�¸ORQNjHBR_"A����� �E_CKN^v�eACKNMhA=%�K]jU�¸ORQNjHBiOR^C~ � KNjUILFu<CBR_YOR^C~ A���� �E_YKN^v�eACK]MhA:%àOR^Y~� ORFHB¿IHFH<CB1�nf�jHju<CV�B)IHA�O1I+IHACB)WCFHBJ��BZFuBZ^CMEBXFuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^� K]j+?GK ÏGBE^å}rw A������ ���� A���� �E_A������ ���� A������ �=A���� �� A���� ���)OR^Y~ A������ �� A��� ���Z�7@"ACB�BEV�WYI�w7jHBEIXDR����DGFuV¿<CQÍO1B��ACORjUO1Q]Q�K]^rIHBZFHWYFHBEILO1ILKNDG^CjORj*VXD\~CBEQ|_G�eACKNMhA�VXBPOR^Cj,IHA�O1I A����� ���*K]j,ILAYB�DG^YQNw)VXK]^CKNVvO1QVXD:~CBZQï�Tð�^nW�ORFkILK]ME<CQÍO1FZ_�)3%¿K]jTOeMZDG^YjHBZäx<CBE^CMZB"D1�����eK ILA�FHBZjuWÜBEMEI'ILDeILACKNjTWYFHBE��BEFHBE^xIHKÍORQjuBZV�OR^rILKNMZjZ�,@"AYB�juBEI$E � G BJò\MZQN<C~CB�ILACB+I��¶D�K]^rILBEFHWCFuBEILO1ILKNDG^Cj A���� ���"OR^Y~ A����� ���Z�,@"AYBFuBZV�ORK]^YK]^C?èVXD:~CBZQNjZ_�A��� � �A����� �¿ORFHB�K]^YMZDGVXW�ORFHOR}CQ]B��¡��FE��IZ�� �_UOR^C~ãORFuB�IHAx<Cj�}³DRIHAVXK]^YK]V�ORQRVXD\~YBZQ]jE�5[:K]^CMEB )3%)~CD:BZj'^CDRI5AYDGQ]~nK]^�}³DRIHA%_RK I�MZOR^¿^CD�Q]DG^C?RBZFT}ÜB¶~CBZ~C<YMZBZ~3�@"AYK]j*jHACD��ej*ILA�O¦I*WCFHBJ��BZFHBE^rILKÍO1Q�jHBZV�OR^rILKNMZj,w:K]BEQ]~Cj*O�^CDG^YV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]MU��DGFuVvO1Q]K]juVÌ�=f�^KNV�W³DGFkIhOR^rI�BJòYORVXWCQ]B���DRF+WCFHBJ��BZFuBZ^rILK]ORQ�juBZV�OR^rILK]MEji��DGFiIHACB)MPO1jHB)DR�*WCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHB)Q]DG?RK]MKNj �JíîÐ����\ì�Ó �JÐ�íúÒ³Õ¸í|Ø¦Ô � q � �ï�,d�BEFHBR_xILAYB"?GDrORQCKNj5ILD¡VXK]^CKNV�K � B*ILACBeBJò:IHBZ^CjuK]DG^XDR�3O�?GK ÏGBE^WYFHBZ~YK]MPO¦ILB ��_xK|��BR� _YO1^vK]^rIHBZFHWYFHBEILO1ILKNDG^GwãKNj¶WCFuBE��BEFHFHBE~�D�ÏGBEF"OR^vKN^rILBZFuWCFHBJIhO1IHK]DG^��è_\K ��ay�� ���éACDRQ]~CjE� �+BJ�¸OR<CQNIiFH<CQNBZj+QNK]�1B �H>�FHDG?Rj+ORFuB¿^CDGFuVvORQNQNw�?GFuBZBE^���MPOR^$ILAYBZ^�}ÜBB�ò\WCFHBEjHjHBE~ß�eKNIHA»ILACB¡ACBEQ]WàDR�5O1^ �uOR}C^CDGFuVvO1Q]KNI�w�WCFuBZ~CKNMPO1IHBR_ ���eAYK]MhAàK]j"VXK]^CKNV�K � BZ~3{

�Qq�n�3ñ � ó �B)8c��Áñ � ó � r6qvtotJe=ñ � ó����ò\MZBEWYILKNDG^Cj�IHD¼ILACKNjvFu<CQ]BÌMPOR^ ^YD­� juK]VXWCQNwã}³BßBJò\WCFuBZjujHBZ~ }rw KNV�WCQNK]MZO1ILKNDG^Cj¿QNK]�RBoq�n��6eÁñ � ó � c��Áñ � óJ� @"AYBå�¸ORMJI�ILA�O1Ilc�� K]j»VXK]^CKNV�K � BE~éVvOR�1BZjàjH<CFuBåIHA�O1I�ILAYB~YBE�¸OR<CQ IeFH<CQNB�K]jeORWYWCQ]KNBZ~�ILD�OR^�K]^Y~CKNÏ:K]~Y<�ORQ3<Y^CQ]BEjHjeKNIeKNjeO��x^CD��e^ÌBJò\MZBEWYILKNDG^%�@"AYB)K]^rILFuD\~C<YMEILKNDG^ßD1�*Ò³ÐLØhÒ�ÑJÐ�Õ¸í|ÑhÓ¿ILACO1I¡O �uFuBPORjuDG^�OR}YQ]B �$Ô3ئÔ�ìvئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í��níîÔ PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑÐLÑJÚ ÞRÕ¸í|Ø¦Ô � jHACDR<CQ]~àjLO1IHK]jk�îw��&O1jZ_aDG^�ILACB¡DG^CB�A�OR^Y~%_�V�D1ILKNÏ1O1IHBZ~�}rw»ILACB��¸ORMJIeILA�O1Iju<CMhAãWCFHDGW³BZFkILKNBZj¿MZOR^�}ÜB»<CjuBZ~�ILD$MEDGV�WCORFHB»O1^C~�BEÏ1ORQ]<CO1ILB�~YKNôÜBZFHBE^rI�ORWCWCFuDrORMhACBEjIHD¼^CDR^CV�DR^CDRILDR^CK]M»FuBPORjuDG^CK]^Y? � srpY_¶qGm �ï�câ+^êIHACBàDRILACBEF�ACOR^C~%_&IHACBZjuBßWCFuDGWÜBEFuIHK]BZjMZOR^àORQ]juD¿}³B�K]^rILBEFHWCFuBEILBE~àORj&K]^\��BZFHBE^CMZB�Fu<CQ]BEj�ñ¸QNK]�RB�V�D:~C<CjUWÜDG^YBZ^CjLóJ_C�eACKNMhAàMZOR^�}ÜB<YjHBZ~)IHD+?GBZ^YBZFLO¦ILB"^CBJ�ê^YDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CK]MMZDR^CjHBEä:<YBZ^CMEBZj ��� ���|�5ðzI�A�ORj*ORQNjHD�IL<CFu^CBZ~�DG<YIIHA�O1I5IHACBZFuB"K]j,O+MEQ]DGjuB&MZDR^C^CBZMJILKNDG^�}ÜBJI��UBEBZ^XWCFHBJ��BZFHBE^rILKÍO1QCjHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZj5OR^C~�K]^Y��BEFHBE^CMZBEjFuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^Cj�jLO¦ILK]jk�îw:K]^C?àMZBEFuIhO1K]^åWCFHDGW³BZFkILKNBZj � � � �|�v>�K]?R<CFHB)sÌ?GKNÏRBZj�jHBEÏRBZFHORQ¶B�òYORV�WYQ]BZjD1��ju<CMhAßFuBPORjuDG^�OR}CQNB¡WCFHDGW³BZFkILKNBZjZ�f jHKNV�KNQÍORF�O1WCWCFHDGORMhAê��DGFXBEÏ1ORQN<�O1IHK]^C?®OR^C~ MEDGVXW�ORFHKN^C?$ILACBÌjHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZjX��DGF�;ÁDR?GK]Më,FuDG?GFLO1V�j&�UORj�<CjHBE~ßK]^ � & p\_ & H �|�*f�j�VXBZ^rIHK]DG^CBE~ßO1}ÜD�ÏGB1_�ILACB �LSUQNDGjHBE~àb®DGFHQN~�fijkyju<CVXWYILKNDG^���K]^Ì;=DG?GK]M¡ë,FuDG?GFLO1V�jE_aOR^C~�ILACB�MZDGFuFHBEjHW³DG^C~CKN^C?XIHFHBZO1ILVXBZ^rI�DR�5^YBZ?rO1IHK]DG^O1j ����BZ?rO¦ILK]DR^¼ORjn>aORK]QN<CFHB ��Q]BPO1~Cj�ILDèOà^CDG^CVXDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM)}ÜBEA�OPÏ:K]DG<CF�DR�&;ÁDR?GK]MXë,FHD1y?RFLORVXjZ�Ì@"A:<YjZ_*KNI�K]j�^YDRI¿ju<CFHWCFuK]juK]^C?ßIHA�O1InILACBEFHB�KNj¿OèMZQNDGjHB�MZDG^Y^CBZMJILK]DR^ }ÜBJI��UBEBZ^O1WCWCFHDGORMhACBZj���DGFi~CBJç�^CKN^C?�~CBEMZQÍO1FLO1IHKNÏGB�jHBEVvO1^xIHK]MEj���DGF¿ñ¸BJò:IHBZ^C~CBE~aóiQ]DR?GK]M¡WCFuDG?GFLO1V�jñ�BR��?C� _ � srm:_Cs � _ H s\_ H p � �îóUO1^C~»��DGFHV�ORQ]KNjHVXj,��DGF&^CDG^YV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]MiFuBPORjuDG^CKN^C?C�5ð�^�WCFuK]^\yMEK]WCQNBR_¦ILACBEjHB"jHBEVvO1^xIHK]MEj5~CBZW³BZ^Y~XDR^�OiWCFHBJ��BZFuBZ^CMEB�FuBZQ]O1ILKNDG^�}³BEI��¶BZBE^�VXD\~YBZQ]jE�'@"AYBZK]F~YBEÏGBEQ]DGWYV�BE^xI��&ORj�juILFuDG^C?GQ w�K]^ � <YBZ^CMEBZ~�}rwnIHACB&jHBEVvO1^xIHK]MEj'��DGF�OR<YILD:BZWYK]juIHBZVXK]MQ]DG?RK]M

H q

Page 18: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� F � � � /��J/�� 4��(45�� ��� F � ��ü�ÿ2�!� �&�­ø�5hü0��uÿEý%ý�� � �gýï÷�uÿ!��� F � � ��/�� � /�� � 4������ /0-*12/ ��� F � ��ü�ÿ2����ø��7���úø�uù>��� ýï÷�uÿ!� F � ��� � 4�� � ��� / ��� /0- 4 - � ��� M ��� F � ��ü�ÿ2�!� F � ��� ýï÷�uÿ!� F � � � ��� ��� F � � �\ü�ÿ2��� F � � ýï÷�uÿ!� M ��� F � � � �����34 % �*) $&%.- % � % - �>�K]?R<CFHB+sY{*ë*FuDGW³BZFuIHK]BEj�D1��^CDR^CV�DR^CDRILDR^CK]M+KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEB¡FHBZQ]O1ILKNDG^CjE�

O1^C~$��DGF+~CBJ�¸OR<CQNI¡QNDG?GKNMR�¡f ç�FHjkI�D­ÏRBZFkÏ\KNBE� DR�*ILACBEjHBXMZDG^C^YBZMEIHK]DG^Yj�K]j�?GK ÏGBZ^�KN^ � � & �|��àDGFHB¶FHBZMEBZ^rI,�¶DGFH�¡K]^nILACKNj'~CKNFHBEMEILKNDG^�MZOR^¿}³B¶��DG<Y^C~¿K]^�ILACBUWCFHD:MZBEBZ~CKN^C?Gj�D1��ILACB¶MZDG^\y��BEFHBE^CMZBEj�� ��DG^\y �ÌDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM ��ò:ILBE^CjHKNDG^Cj*DR�³;=DG?GKNM"ë,FHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C? � � & & �aOR^C~ �u;ÁDR?GK]Më,FuDG?GFLO1V�VXK]^C?¿OR^C~ ��DG^YV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]M�`eBPORjuDG^CKN^C? � � q � �|�

"!$#%!'&(!')+*,!'-

� H � �®�,fi}�O1~CKeOR^C~/.�� �ßOR^C^COY��@'BEV�W³DGFLO1Q&Q]DG?RK]MvWYFHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?C�10�Ø �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø� �1ì 4Jئڤí�� � ئìiÒ �:Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�_ �\{ûoGqRq � o � m:_ H � � � �

� o � ���\`¡�\f�WYI"OR^Y~�`�� �n���UDGQï�Á;ÁDR?GK]M�WCFHDR?GFLORVXVXK]^C?�OR^C~v^CBZ?rO¦ILK]DR^%{�f ju<CFuÏRBEwR�0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐhØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_ H �32 oRpY{ � � q H _ H ��� sC�

� & �n>U� �&OGOR~YBZFZ�rf�<C?GVXBZ^rILKN^C?eMZDG^YMZBZW\I�Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZjÁ}rw�ILFHOR^CjHK ILK ÏGB,MZQNDGjH<YFHB*DR�CFuDGQ]BEjZ{fi^ O1QNILBEFH^�O¦ILKNÏRBèILD�ILBEFHVXK]^CDGQNDG?GKNMPORQ�MEw:MZQNBZjE� ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó7Ø$Õ ��Ñ54�6rÕ �7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐJÔ³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ80�ئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ$Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ97�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_¶W�OR?GBEj�sGs � �sxm H _a[xw\~Y^CBEwR_Üf�<CjuIHFLORQNKÍOY_ H ��� H �

� s �n>U� �&OGO1~CBZFE_�dn� y;:Y� �=<<CFuMh�RBEFuIP_>:Y�)d�BZKN^CjHDGAY^%_>:Y���1<<CQ]QNBZFE_ �i�)d�DGQ]QN<C^C~CBEFZ_�i� ��BZ}³BZQ|_"b � ��<YIHIZ_�OR^C~cdn� y;:Y�Uë,FHDRçCIHQ]KNMhA%� @TBZFHVXK]^YDGQ]DG?RK]MPO1Q"�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBFHBZWYFHBZjuBZ^rIhO¦ILK]DR^%{¶f WCFuDGW³DGjLORQÜ��DGFeO�IHBZFuV�KN^CDGQ]DR?GK]MZORQaQ]DG?GKNMR� ��> �¡ð@TBZMhAC^CKNMPORQ�ÌBZVXD¿@ ��y � p¦y�p1sC_ �+BZ<YIHjHMhACBEje>aDRFHjHMhAx<C^Y?Gj � BZ^rILFu<CV �?<<CF �@<<Y^CjuIHQ]K]MhAYB�ð�^rILBEQ]QNK y?GBZ^ � _ ��O1K]jHBEFHjuQÍOR<YIHBZFu^%_ H ��� pY�

� m �n>U� �&OGO1~CBZFE_ �"�Á>�FLO1^CMZDG^YK|_��i�=d�DGQ]QN<C^C~CBEFZ_��i� ��BZ}³BZQï_ÁOR^C~®dn� y;:Y�=ë,FHD1çCILQNK]MhA%�fi^¿BEV�WCKNFHKNMPORQxOR^CORQNw:jHKNj'D1�aDGWYILKNV�K � O1IHK]DG^+IHBZMhAC^YK]äx<CBZj'��DGF'IHBZFHVXK]^YDGQ]DG?RK]MPO1QRjuw:j�yILBZVXjZ�A0�Ø �:ÐJÔ³ÞRÚTØ � ÒrÒ³Ú¤í|ÑHÖB7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_\sC{ H p � �AH & o\_ H ��� sC�

��� �n>U� �&OROR~CBZF5OR^C~�ë'�RdiOR^YjHMhAC�1BR�³f jHMhACBEV�B&��DRF5K]^rILBE?GFLO¦ILK]^Y?iMZDR^CMZFuBEILB"~YDGVvO1K]^CjK]^rILD�MZDR^CMZBEWYI+Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZjE�ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó¿Ø¡Õ ��ÑB4�6rÕ �C7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ�0�ئíîÔ�Õ� Ø¦Ô PÑJÐhÑJÔ �hÑ"Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ�7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_¦WCOR?GBZjÁsxmRo � sxmGq:_R[xw\~Y^CBEwR_Rfi<YjuILFHORQ]K]OY_H ��� H �

H �

Page 19: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� q �n>U� �UOGOR~CBEFiOR^Y~ �i�Üd�DGQNQ]<C^C~YBZFZ� < ?Zw � { <�^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB ?�BZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^�OR^Y~w¶^\��BZFHBE^CMZB � w:jkILBZVà� � 7�� ����� � �:ÚîÚ]ÑJÕïíîÔ�_�oCñ & ó�{ � �AH sC_ H ��� H �

� � �n>U� �&OGO1~CBZF�O1^C~ �i�=d�DRQ]Q]<Y^C~CBZFE�nf IHBZFuV�KN^CDGQ]DR?GK]MZORQ=�x^CD��eQ]BZ~Y?GB)FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO¦yILK]DR^ juw:jkILBZV �eKNIHA MEDGV�WYQ]BEIHBÌKN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEBèORQN?GDGFuKNILAYV�jE� ð�^ �å�U`eK]MhArILBEF�OR^Y~dn���UDGQNBEwR_)BZ~CK ILDGFujZ_ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓêØ¼Õ ��Ñ �,íîÐhÓJÕ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ �ßئÐL×�Ó���ØhÒØ¦Ô �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÓhÓJíîÔ:Û �¿Ñ��JÚ ÞRÐuÞRÕïí��RÑ ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:ÑJ_�ÏGDGQN<CVXB�m � qêD1� �ÁÑ��JÕ��\ÐLÑ �nئÕ�ÑhÓíîÔ � ئìiÒ �\Õ�ÑJÐ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑJ_*W�OR?GBEj � q � �rm:_ �¡ORKNjHBEFHjHQ]OR<YIHBZFH^ ñ|t�BZFuVvO1^xwYó�_ H � � H �[\WCFHKN^C?GBEF � M*BEFHQÍO1?C�

��� �n>U� �&OROR~CBZF�OR^C~)fn�G;ÁOR<\òÜ�C@TBZFuV�KN^CDGQ]DR?GK]MZORQrQ]DG?RK]MZjÁ�eKNIHA¿VXD\~�O1Q\DGW³BZFHO1ILDRFHjZ�\ð�^Si� �ÌBZQNQ]K]juA%_CBE~CKNIHDGFZ_ �UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó¿Ø¡Õ ��Ñ 4���Õ � 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ�0�ئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐ��ÑJÔ �hÑ+Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_RW�O1?GBZj �Gp � � � H sY_ �ÌDG^rIHFBPO1Q|_xS&OR^COR~�OY_ H � � m\��ÌDGFH?GOR^ �¡OR<\��VvOR^Y^%�

� H p ��>U� �&OGO1~CBZF$O1^C~ dn� y;:Y�¡â+ACQN}�ORMhA%� f V¿<CQ ILK yz~CK]VXBZ^YjHK]DR^�ORQiIHBZFHVXK]^YDGQ]DG?RK]MPO1Q�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBXFuBZWCFuBZjuBZ^rIhO1IHK]DG^�Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBR� 0�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ*Ø � ÒrÒ³Ú¤í|ÑHÖ ��Ø¦Ô � � Ú Þ¦ÓhÓJí��HÞRÚ�TØHÛRí��hÓJ_�mCñ|oGó�{ H m & �AH � q\_ H � � m\�

� H H ��>U���UOGOR~CBEFUOR^Y~ �n�Y[YO1IuILQ]BEFZ� �+BEjHMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^�Q]DG?RK]MZj,�eK ILAvjkw:V¿}ÜDRQ]K]M�^x<CV¿}³BZF¶FHBJyjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^CjZ�³ð�^)b �Gb7ORAYQ]juIHBZFE_:BE~CKNIHDGFZ_ �UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó+ØeÕ ��Ñ � ÙUÑJÚ �Õ ��� �:ÐLØhÒ�ÑHÞRÔ� Ø¦Ô PÑJÐhÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ�7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ � � � � 7����� � _ÜW�OR?GBEj¡o � & � o �rq\��:RDGAY^bcK]Q]BJw 2 [\DG^Cj�;%IL~%_ H ����� �

� H o���>U� �&OGOR~CBEF�OR^Y~ �n�U[YO1IuILQNBZFZ����<CV¿}³BZFXFHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^Cj�DR^ MZDGVXWCQNBJò�FuDGQ]BEjvK]^~CBZjuMZFHKNWYILKNDG^XQ]DG?GKNMZjE�Üð�^��UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó+Ø�Õ ��Ñ �*í �Õ �B7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑئÔéÕ ��Ñ��¶Ð�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓèØ ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�ÕzÞRÕ¸í|ئÔcÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û ��; � ��� � � �ÌDGFu?rOR^ ��O1<Y��VvO1^C^%_C;=DGjef�QNILDRjZ_ H � ��� �

� H & �nSi� �&O1FLORQ¶OR^C~ �®�,t�BZQ ��DG^C~%��;=DG?GKNM�WYFHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?�OR^C~7�x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB�FHBEWCFHB�yjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^%�A0�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ'Ø �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_ H �32 oRp\{ûq & �AH s �Y_ H ��� sY�

� H s ���n� �UK]~CDRKNI'OR^C~�Si�R>�FHDGKN~CBEÏ1OR<\òÜ� ��BE?rO1ILKNDG^�}rw�~CBJ�¸OR<CQNI5OR^C~¿<Y^CjuIHFLO1IHKNç�BE~¿Q]DG?RK]MWCFHDG?RFLORVXjZ� � ��ÑhئÐLÑJÕ¸í��HÞRÚ � ئìiÒ �\Õ�ÑJÐ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑJ_aq �\{ �rm �AH H o\_ H ��� H �

� H m��¡f�� �UDRFH?GKN~�OY��â�^$IHACB)FHBEQÍO1IHK]DG^CjuACK]Wß}ÜBJI��UBEBZ^å~CBZjuMZFHKNWYILKNDG^�Q]DG?RK]M¿O1^C~$WCFHBE~CK yMPO1IHB�QNDG?GK]M�ä:<YBZFHKNBZjE��`eBZjHBZORFHMhA7`�BEWÜDGFkI�;TS"[Y`"yz@e`"y�o � m­yzf�_ �+BEW�ORFkILVXBZ^rI�DR�SUDGV�WY<YILBEFi[:MZK]BE^CMZB1_a`�<\IL?GBEFHj ��^CK ÏGBEFHjHK I�wG_³ë,K]juMPO1ILO��UOPwG_ �$:Y_ �+[\fn_ H ��� & �

� H � �¡f�� �¶DGFH?GKN~�OY_�`�� :Y� �UFHORMhACV�OR^%_ �¿��;*�"�ÌMPt¡<CKN^C^CBEjHjZ_OR^Y~�;*�'f���`�BEjH^CKNMh�³�S&;Áf+[C[\ðkSi{�f jkILFu<CMEIH<CFLORQn~�O1ILO V�D:~CBZQ¡��DGFÌDG}:ÝuBZMJILjE� ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó ØÕ ��Ñ 4������ � ��� � 7�� ��� � 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � ÞRÔ³Þ�Û:ÑJìvÑJÔ�Õ&Ø�nÞRÕzÞR_YW�OR?GBEj+m � � � q\_Yë'DGFkILQÍO1^C~%_aâ+FHBE?C� _ H � � � �

H �

Page 20: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� H q���`�� :Y���UFLORMhAYVvOR^3� bcA�O1I �jßKN^ OãMZDG^CMEBZWYIZ{ [:ILFu<CMEIH<CFLO1Q���DG<Y^C~�O1IHK]DG^Cj»��DGFjHBZV�OR^rILKNM�^CBEI��¶DGFH�xjE� 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ 0�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚnØ � ÞRÔ � � Þ ���:íîÔ3Ñ � Õ��CÖRí|ÑhÓJ_� { H oGq �AH mRo\_ H � qGq\�

� H � ��`���:Y� �¶FLORMhACV�OR^%�Y[:IHFH<CMJIL<CFuBZ~)K]^YACBZFuKNIhO1^CMZB^CBEI��¶DGFu�:jE��ð�^�b �­f��­b¼D:D:~Cj5OR^Y~`��%:Y� �UFHORMhACV�OR^%_GBE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ � ÑhÓ�ÑHÞRÐ����)íîÔ ��ÞRÕ��\ÐuÞRÚ �%ÞRÔ:Û �YÞ�Û:Ñ��ÁÔ³Ö:ÑJÐhÓJÕ|ÞRÔ³ÖRíîÔ:ÛR_��<CORFuIHBZFHQ w�ë,FuDG?GFHBEjHj"`eBZW³DGFkI ��DC� H _�� � � `eBZW³DGFuI ��DC� & q1sxo\_:W�OR?RBZj & � � q �Y��UDGQNIZ_ �UBEFLOR^CBE�»OR^C~ ��BJ�eVvO1^Ìð�^CM1�N_³S&O1V¿}CFHKN~C?GB1_ �ßORjujZ� _ H � q �Y�

� H � ��`�� :Y� �UFLORMhAYVvOR^3_ �¿��;,� �ÌM�t�<CK]^Y^CBZjujZ_»ëT�n>¶��ë'O1ILBEQ yk[:MhAC^CBZKN~CBZFE_v;,��f��`�BEjH^CKNMh�³_¶OR^C~ fn� �UDGFu?GK]~COY��;=KNÏ:K]^C?Ì�eKNILAãS&;=f+[C[\ðkSi{5bcACBE^ OR^Y~ ACD�� IHD<CjHB�O �¡;3ykâ � ��y�QNK]�1B�Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBR�'ð�^ :Y�a[\D��&O\_CBZ~CK ILDGFE_ �¶Ð�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓ�Ø � ÑJìXÞRÔ �Õïí�� ��ÑJÕïÙUئÐL×�ÓJ_W�OR?GBEj�srp H�� srm � � �àDGFH?rO1^ �¡OR<Y��V�OR^C^3_U[\OR^ �ÌO1ILBEDC_&S&O1Q]KN��� _H ��� H �

� oRp ��`���:Y� �UFLORMhAYVvOR^ OR^C~ :Y�¶t)�&[\MhAYV�DGQ � B1� f�^ D�ÏGBEFuÏ:K]BJ� D1�+ILACB �¡;%y�â � ��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBêFuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^ juw:juIHBZVà� � ØHÛRÔ�íîÕ¸í��RÑ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ � ñ|oGó�{ H q H�� o H � _H � �rm\�

� o H �n[Ü� �¶FLORjuj�OR^C~ :Y� �+K�òÜ���+K]j�Ýu<Y^CMEIHKNÏGBÌjHBEVvOR^rIHK]MZjX}�ORjuBZ~é<CW³DG^êW�ORFuIHKÍORQ�OR^Y~}ÜDRIuILDGV)y�<YW®BJÏRO1Q]<�O1IHK]DG^3��ð�^ ;,�'[:ILBEFHQ]KN^C?C_TBZ~CK ILDGFE_ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó»ØXÕ ��Ñ 4�6rÕ �7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐJÔ³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ)Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_�W�OR?GBEj H ��� � o H & � �Ìð�@ë*FuBZjujZ_ H ��� m:�

� oGo���ë'� �UFHBEjHMEKÍOR^CKï_��"�'>�FHOR^CMZDR^CK|_ÁOR^Y~7[Ü�=@TBZjujLORFuK]jE�vð�VXWCQ]BEV�BE^xIHK]^C?�O1^C~åIHBZjkILK]^Y?BJò\WCFHBEjHjuKNÏGBX~CBEjHMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^$QNDG?GKNMZjZ{�f WCFuBZQNK]VXK]^�ORFkw�FHBEWÜDGFkIP��ð�^ �UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓXØÕ ��Ñ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐJÔ³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � �1ìiÒ�Ø�ÓJí �:ì Ø¦Ô ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � ÑJÕ¸Ð�í|Ñ��¦ÞRÚ����%Ó�Ñ���ÞRÔ³Ö � Õ�ئÐ��Þ�Û:Ñ PئР��� �Jí|ÑJÔ � ���:; � � � � ����� � ÞRÔ�Õ|Þ � Ð�� ����� � � _";=BZMJIL<CFuB ��DRIHBZj�KN^fiFuIHKNç�MEKÍORQÜð�^rILBZQNQ]KN?GBZ^CMEBR�a[:WCFHKN^C?GBZF � M*BZFuQÍOR?Y_ H ��� � �,@'DXORWYWÜBZORFZ�

� o & �nt�� �UFHBJ�e�¦OY� �nئÔ�ìvئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í�� � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û� �ÁØHÛRí��HÞRÚ �TØ �:Ô³ÖrÞRÕïí|ئÔYÓ�Ø � ئì �ìvئÔYÓ�ÑJÔYÓ�ÑJ�*S&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?RB���^CK ÏGBZFujHK I�w�ë,FHBZjujZ_ÜS&ORV¿}YFHK]~Y?GBR_ ���)_ H ��� H �

� o1s �nt�� �UFHBJ�e�¦OY_ :Y� �+K òÜ_�OR^C~ �)� ��DG^YDGQ]KN?GBR� �nئÔ�ìvئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í�� � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û� � Ô� �RÑJÐ���í|ÑJÙ,�XS"[\;Áð+ë*<Y}CQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^CjE_TSUBZ^rILBEFn��DGF+IHACB�[:IL<Y~Yw�DR�";ÁOR^Y?G<�OR?GBXOR^Y~ð�^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^%_C[:IhO1^Y��DGFH~3_aS&ORQ|� _ H � � q\�

� oGm�� �®� �U<CMhACAYBZKNIZ_>U� �®� �+DR^CK]^CKï_,OR^C~�fn�*[\MhA�ORBEFu�����+BEMZKN~�OR}CQNB�FHBZORjHDG^YK]^C?$KN^ILBZFuV�KN^CDGQNDG?GK]MZORQ��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB®FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^¾juw:juIHBZVXjZ� ð�^ �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó®ØÕ ��ÑC4��GÕ �>7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ 0�ئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑXØ¦Ô � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ��97?0 �� � 7�� ���G_CW�OR?GBEj�qRpRs � q1p � _�SUACORV¿}³BZFuwR_a>�FLOR^CMEBR_ H � � & �

� o � � �®���U<CMhACAYBZKNIZ_$�®� :RBZ<Cjk��BZQN~%_=b � ��<YIuIP_TOR^C~ �®�T[:ILOR<C~YIZ�X[\<C}Cju<CVXWYILKNDG^�DR�ä:<YBZFHKNBZj¡ILDàDG}:ÝuBEMEIuyzDGFHKNBZ^rILBE~¼~�O¦IhOR}�O1jHBZjE� 7JÔ PئÐ�ìXÞRÕ¸í|Ø¦Ô � ��ÓJÕ�ÑJì�ÓJ_ H � ñ H óJ{ & & �m1sC_ H � � sC�

o1p

Page 21: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� oGq�� �i��>¶��SUAYBZQ]Q]ORjZ� � ØZÖrÞRÚ��ÁØHÛRí�� � � Ô57JÔ�Õ¸ÐLØZÖ � �JÕ¸í|ئÔ��àS&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?RB ��^CKNÏRBZFHjuKNI�wë*FuBZjujZ_ÜS&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?RBR_ ����_ H � �GpY�

� o � ��;*�G>³O1FHK]^ �ORj�~CBEQ³SUBZFuFHDC� �ÌDGQNDG?C{Áféjuw:jkILBZV ILA�O1I*B�ò:ILBZ^Y~Cjë*FuDGQ]DR?+�eKNILA)VXD:~�ORQQ]DG?GKNMR� ��ÑJÙ ��ÑJÔ3ÑJÐuÞRÕïí|Ø¦Ô � ئìiÒ �\Õ¸íîÔ:ÛR_CsC{ & m � m1pY_ H � � � �

� o � ��ë'� �+BJÏ1OR^x}C<%_n`�� :Y� �¶FLORMhACV�OR^%_�ëT�+t)�+[:BZQN��FuK]~C?RBR_¡OR^C~ �i��b � �&ORQNQÍORFu~%�;TOG[C[\ð �"{ef �x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB�y�}�O1jHBZ~¾jHDR�îI��UORFuB®KN^Y��DGFHV�O1IHK]DG^ jkw:juILBEVÌ� � ئì)ì � �Ô�í��HÞRÕïí|ئÔYÓ¿Ø¡Õ ��Ñ � ��� _ & sañïmGóJ{ & s � s � _ H � � H �

� & p �=:Y���+K òÜ� f MZQÍO1jHjHK ç�MPO¦ILK]DR^\yzIHACBZDGFkw D1�ßjuBZV�OR^rILK]MEj�DR�è^CDRFHV�ORQ�Q]DR?GK]MêWCFHD1y?GFLORVXjZ{�ðh�Á[:IHFHDG^Y?�WCFHDRWÜBEFuILKNBZjE� � �\Ô³ÖrÞRìvÑJÔ�Õ|Þ37JÔ PئÐ�ìXÞRÕ¸í��HÞ:ÑJ_����iðHðJñ & óJ{úoGoGq �oGmGm\_ H ��� m\�

� & H �=:Y���+K òÜ� f MZQÍO1jHjHK ç�MPO¦ILK]DR^\yzIHACBZDGFkw D1�ßjuBZV�OR^rILK]MEj�DR�è^CDRFHV�ORQ�Q]DR?GK]MêWCFHD1y?GFLORVXjZ{�ð�ðh�3bcBPO1�ßWCFuDGWÜBEFuIHK]BZjE� � �:Ô³ÖrÞRìvÑJÔ�ÕzÞ 7JÔ PئÐ�ìXÞRÕ¸í��HÞ:ÑJ_����iðHðJñ & óJ{úoGmGq �o ���Y_ H ��� m\�

� & o��=:Y� �+K�ò3�%[\BZV�OR^rILKNMZj¶DR�%QNDG?GK]MeWCFuDG?GFHORV�jE{'@"AYBZK]F¶K]^rIL<YKNILKNDG^Cj*OR^Y~���DGFuVvORQ�WYFHDGW\yBZFuIHK]BEjZ�efi^¾D­ÏRBZFkÏ\KNBE�¡� ð�^¾f��e>�<CACFuVvO1^C^ O1^C~ d��e`�DRIuIP_+BE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ �ÁØHÛRí����� �JÕ¸í|ئÔèÞRÔ³Ö 7�Ô PئÐJìXÞRÕ¸í|ئÔ����*ÓhÓZÞ �­Ó¡Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí��iíîÔ � �:íîÚ]Ø�Ó�ØhÒ �&��ÞRÔ³Ö � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_YW�OR?RBZj�o1s H�� & oGq\� �+B�t�FH<YwxILBEFZ_ H � � m\�

� & & �=:Y� �+K òÜ_Ü;,�3ëTBZFHBEK]FHOY_%OR^Y~$@��3ë,F � w:V¿<CjHKN^CjH�xKï_%BZ~CK ILDGFujZ���nØ¦Ô � � ئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í�� � � �Õ�ÑJÔYÓJí|ئÔYÓ7Ø �TØHÛRí�� �UÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:Û�� �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓJ_�ÏGDGQN<CVXB � oGq�D1� �ÁÑ��JÕ��\ÐLÑ�nئÕ�ÑhÓ�íîÔ � 7��³[\WCFuK]^C?GBEF � M*BEFHQ]OR?C_ H ��� m\�

� & s ��>U� �+DG^CK]^YK|_ �®�';=BZ^ � BZFHKN^CK|_$�¿� �iO1FH~CKï_�OR^Y~®b � ��<YIuIP��@"AYBvMZDRV�WCQNBJò\KNI�wèDR�MZDG^CMEBZWYI&QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ�Áð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�ØiÕ ��Ñ$6rÔ³Ö 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐJÔ³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑئÔ��¶Ð�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓnØ�;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐhÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕ¸í|ئÔßÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR_xW�OR?GBEj H m H��H � o\_aS&O1V¿}CFHKN~C?GB1_ �ßORjujZ� _ H ��� H �

� & m���>U�"�+DR^CK]^CKï_ �®��;=BZ^ � BZFHKN^CK|_ �¿�"��ORFH~CKï_5OR^Y~7b �"��<YIHIZ�è@'FHORMEILOR}CQNB�MZDG^YMZBZW\IQÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ�vð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�Ø�Õ ��Ñ 4�6rÕ � 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ 0�ئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑØ¦Ô � ÐJÕ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_\W�OR?GBEj�srm � � s � & _�[:w:~C^YBEwG_³fi<YjuILFHORQ]K]OY_ H ��� H �

� & � ��>U� �+DG^CK]^YK|_ �®�Ü;=BZ^ � BZFuK]^CKï_ �¿� ��ORFH~YK|_³OR^C~Ìf��Ü[\MhA�ORBEFu��� �+BZ~Y<CMEIHK]DG^ÌK]^àMZDG^\yMZBZW\I�QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ{�>�FuDGV jH<C}Cju<CVXWYILKNDG^7ILDèKN^CjuILOR^CMEB�MhACBZMh�xKN^C?C� 0�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ"Ø�TØHÛRí���ÞRÔ³Ö � ئìiÒ �\Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�_Ysañ¸sxó�{�sro & � sxmRo\_ H � � sC�

� & q���>U� �å� �+DG^CKN^CK|_ �i��d�DGQ]QN<C^C~CBEFZ_ �®�C;=BZ^ � BZFuK]^CKï_Cf�� �®�a[:W�ORMZMZORVXBZQÍO\_ �¿� ��ORFH~YK|_OR^C~èb � ��<YIHIZ��@"ACB)MZDRV�WCQNBJò\KNI�wàDR�*B�ò\K]juIHBZ^rILK]ORQ�äx<�O1^xIHKNç�MZO1ILKNDG^èKN^èMZDG^YMZBZW\IQÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ�80�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_�m & { & p � � & oGq:_ H � � o\�

o H

Page 22: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� & � ��b �:fn� �*VXBZFujHDG^3�%@'BEV�W³DGFHORQaOR^C~�V�D:~�ORQCQNDG?GKNMR�³ð�^@:Y�rÏ1OR^�;=BZBE<r�UBE^%_YBE~CKNIHDGFZ_�¡ÞRÔ³Ö*4JØ�Ø�×àØ � ��ÑhئÐLÑJÕ¸í��HÞRÚ � ئìiÒ �:Õ�ÑJÐ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑ����³Ø¦Ú�� � � �*QNjHBJÏ\KNBZFE_%fiVXjuIHBZFky~�ORVà_C@"ACB ��BEIHACBZFuQÍOR^Y~CjZ_ H � � pY�

� & � � �®��>'KNIHIHK]^C?Y� �&O1jHK]MXVXD\~�O1Q,Q]DG?GKNMR��ð�^ �¿�$�®�'t�O1}C}�OPwG_5Si� :Y�Td�DR?G?GBZFE_5OR^Y~:Y�Uf��¶`eDG}CK]^YjHDG^%_"BE~CKNIHDGFHjE_��¡ÞRÔ³Ö*4JØ�Ø�×�Ø �ÁØHÛRí��ÌíîÔ � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑÞRÔ³Ö �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:Û����³Ø¦Ú�� 4R�Câiò:��DGFu~ ��^YKNÏGBEFHjuKNI�wvë*FuBZjujZ_aâ�ò:��DGFH~3_�� �)_H ��� & �

� srp ���¿� �®�'t�OR}Y}�OPwG�X@"ACBZDGFuBEIHK]MPO1Q*��DR<C^C~�O1IHK]DG^Yj+��DGF¡^CDG^\yzV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]M¿FuBPORjuDG^CK]^Y?K]^ B�òYW³BZFkI»juw:jkILBZVXjZ�gð�^ �)�¶`��¶fiWYIZ_eBZ~CK ILDGFE_ �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�ØàÕ ��Ñ � � � �� Ö �¦ÞRÔ �hÑ � Õ��YÖ �B7�ÔYÓJÕïíîÕ��:Õ�Ñ¿Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí��hÓnÞRÔ³Ö � ØZÖ:ÑJÚúÓ�Ø � Ø¦Ô ���:Ð�ÐLÑJÔ�Õ � �­ÓJÕ�ÑJì�Ó���=Þ � ئÚîÚ]Ñ��|Ó��:Ð�� �ÁØ �­Ò � �3ÐuÞRÔ �hÑJ_��UBEFHQNK]^%_ H � �rm\�C[\WCFHKN^C?GBEF � M*BEFHQÍO1?C�

� s H ���¿�"�å�5t¡OR}C}�OPwR� �ÌD:~�ORQOR^Y~¼ILBEV�W³DGFLO1Q,Q]DG?GKNM�WCFHDG?RFLORVXV�KN^C?C��ð�^7f���t�O1Q yILDG^%_³BZ~YKNILDRFZ_ � ÑJìiÒ�ئÐuÞRÚ �ÁØHÛRí��hÓ¿ÞRÔ³Ö � ��ÑJíîÐ � ÒrÒ³Ú¤í��HÞRÕïí|ئÔYÓJ�afiMZOR~CBEV�KNM�ë,FHBEjHjE_;ÁDR^C~CDG^%_ ���)_ H � �rq\�

� sxo����¿� �®��t�O1}C}�OPwG_�Si� :Y��d�DR?G?GBZFE_+OR^Y~ :Y�"f��e`eDG}CKN^CjHDR^%_+BZ~YKNILDRFHjZ����ÞRÔ³Ö �4JØ�Ø�×�Ø �ÁØHÛRí��¡íîÔ � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ�ÞRÔ³Ö �TØHÛRí�� �¶ÐhØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:Û����³Ø¦Ú�� � ��nئÔ�ìvئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í�� � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û�ÞRÔ³Ö �ÁÔ �hÑJÐ�ÕzÞRíîÔ � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR�Câ�ò\��DRFH~ ��^CKNÏRBZFHjuKNI�wë*FuBZjujZ_Üâ�ò\��DRFH~%_ ����_ H ��� sC�

� s & �nt��at¡ORFu?GD�Ï�OR^Y~NM��at¡DRFLOR^C�1DC� �ÌD:~�ORQ3Q]DG?GKNM��eK ILA�^�ORVXBZjE��0� � �:íîÚ]Ø�Ó�ØhÒ �:í��HÞRÚ�TØHÛRí��J_�oGo\{ � prq � � & � _ H ��� & �

� sGs � �®�Üt¡BEQN��DG^C~3�*;ÁDR?GK]M+WYFHDG?GFHORVXV�KN^C?)OR^C~àFHBZORjHDR^CK]^C?��eKNIHA�K]^CMEDGV�WYQ]BEIHB+K]^\��DGFkyVvO1IHK]DG^3� � Ô�Ô³ÞRÚúÓ¿Ø � ÞRÕ ��ÑJìXÞRÕ¸í��hÓ�ÞRÔ³Ö � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ H o:_ H ��� sC�

� sxm�� �®�³t¡BEQN��DG^Y~�OR^C~ M¿��;=K ��jHMhACK I � ��@"ACBnjkIhOR}YQ]B+juBZV�OR^rILK]MEj"��DGF&Q]DR?GK]M+WYFHDG?GFHORVXjZ�ð�^ê`¡� ��D��UORQ]ju�:K&OR^C~ �)� �UD��¶BZ^%_BZ~CK ILDGFujZ_ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓÌØ�Õ ��Ñ RÕ � 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ��Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ � �¦ìiÒ�Ø�ÓJí �:ì Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐHÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_*W�O1?GBZj H prqRp �AH p��Gp\_US&O1V�y}CFHKN~C?GBR_ �Ìf�� _ H � ���Y� �Ìð�@gë,FHBEjHjE�

� s � � �®�Gt�BZQ ��DG^C~�OR^C~ M��1;=K ��jHMhACK I � �\;=DG?GKNM¶WCFuDG?GFHORV�jÁ�eKNIHA�MEQÍORjujHK]MZORQx^CBZ?GO1ILKNDG^%�xð�^�¿�xb¼ORFuFHBZ^vOR^C~»ëT�\[ � BEFHBZ~YK|_YBE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ �UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó¡Ø�Õ ��Ñ�PÕ �37�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ� Ø¦Ô PÑJÐhÑJÔ �hÑßØ¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí�� �UÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_W�OR?GBEj�mGq � � m � q:_&S&ORV�}CFHKN~C?GBR_ �Ìf�_H ��� pY� �Ìð�@ ë,FHBEjHjE�

� sxq�� �®�³t¡BEQN��DG^Y~�OR^C~ M¿�a;=KN��juMhACKNI � �*SUQ]ORjHjuK]MZORQ%^CBE?rO1ILKNDG^»K]^»QNDG?GKNMiWCFuDG?GFLO1V�jeOR^Y~~CK]jîÝu<C^CMEIHKNÏRB�~CO1IhOR}CORjHBEjZ� �nÑJÙ ��ÑJÔ3ÑJÐuÞRÕ¸í|Ø¦Ô � ئìiÒ �\Õ¸íîÔ:ÛR_ � { & � m � & �rm\_ H ��� H �� s � �nt�� �+Bàt�KÍO1MZDGVXDèOR^Y~ �®�5;ÁBE^ � BEFHKN^CK|� �UD\DRjuILKN^C?èILAYBàMEDGFHFuBZjuWÜDG^Y~CBZ^CMEBÌ}³BJyI��UBEBZ^g~CBEjHMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^ Q]DR?GK]MEjÌO1^C~ WCFuDGW³DGjHK ILK]DR^�ORQ+~Yw:^�O1V�KNMåQNDG?GKNMZjZ� ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �

�hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓXØnÕ ��Ñ � ÙUÑJÚ �Õ � ��ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ���=� � 7�������_�W�OR?GBEj�oRprm � o H o\�Yf�fif�ð|y�ë,FHBEjHj �¦@"ACB �Ìð�@Uy�ë,FHBZjujZ_ H ��� sY�

oRo

Page 23: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� s � �nt�� �+Bßt¡K]ORMZDRV�D�OR^Y~ �®�;=BZ^ � BZFuK]^CKï�éSUDG^YMZBZW\IvQ]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZj)�eKNIHAê^x<CV�}ÜBEFFHBZjkILFuK]MEIHK]DG^Yj�OR^C~êçYò\WÜDGKN^rILjZ_eO1^C~ KNIHjvFuBZQÍO¦ILK]DR^CjHACKNWã�eK ILAêV¿<\y�MZORQ]ME<CQ]<YjZ�cð�^�UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�Ø¿Õ ��Ñ �UÚ]Ñ��RÑJÔ�Õ � � �:ÐLØhÒ�ÑHÞRÔ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � ÐJÕ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ�7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í �Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ�� � � � 7�������_CW�OR?GBEjes H H�� s H m\� :RDRAC^àbcKNQ]BJw»OR^C~Ì[\DR^CjZ_ H ��� sC�

� mRp ��;*�t�K]DRFH~�OR^YD�OR^C~ fn� �ßORFkILBZQNQ]Kï��[:ILFu<CMEIH<CFHKN^C?�Q]DG?RK]M�WCFuDG?GFHORV�jE{�f VXD:~�ORQORWCWCFuDrORMhA%�A0�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_�o H ñïoGóJ{úm � � � sC_ H ��� sC�

� m H � �e�Ct¡F�<OR~CBEQ|_ �®��âiIuILDC_\OR^C~ �"�Y`�DGjuBZ^%�Á@&�¶D1y M+ORFHK]OR}CQNBi;=DG?GKNM��eK ILA�SUDR<C^rILK]^Y?K]j �+BZMEK]~�O1}CQ]B1�,@'DXORWCW³BPO1F�KN^�ë,FHD:MR�a;=ðkS"[ � q\_ H ��� q\�

� mGo��=:Y���)��d�ORQ]W³BZFu^ÌO1^C~��)� �ÌDGjuBZjE�fg?R<CK]~CB+IHD�MZDGVXWCQ]BJILBE^CBZjuj�O1^C~�MZDGVXWCQ]B�ò\KNI�w��DGF¡V�D:~�ORQ,QNDG?GK]M)D1�&�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�OR^C~¼}³BZQNK]BJ��� 0�Ø �:ÐJÔ³ÞRÚ&Ø � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í �Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_am1sC{ & H � � & q � _ H ��� o\�

� m & ��ë'�adiO1^CjHMhAC�1BR� � �¿Ñ��JÚ ÞRÐuÞRÕïí��RÑ 7JÔ�Õ�Ñ|ÛRÐHÞRÕ¸í|Ø¦Ô¼Ø � ÑJÐ�ì)íîÔ3ئÚ]ØHÛRí��HÞRÚ�� � ئÔYÓJÕïÐuÞRíîÔ�Õ��4hÞ¦Ó�ÑHÖ�� �nÞRÕ|Þ �kÖRÐJí��RÑJÔ �àÞRÔ³Ö ��ØZÞRÚ �kÖRíîÐhÑ��JÕ�ÑHÖ � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR� ð�^\çYòÜ_¿[YO1^C�rI$fi<\y?G<CjuIHK]^%_ H ����� �

� m1s ��ë'� :Y�\d�OPwGBZjE�Áð�^�~CBE��BE^CMZBiDR�%QNDG?GK]M1�3ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�Ø�Õ ��Ñ RÕ �37�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ0aئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ�� 7?0 � � 7 � P_ÁW�OR?GBEjnmGm � � m � m\_S&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?GB1_ �ßORjujZ� _ H � qGq\�

� mGm���ë'��:Y�³diOPwGBEjZ�e@"ACB�QNDG?GKNM�DR����FHORV�BEjZ�&ð�^��¿� �ÌBZ^rI � K]^C?Y_³BE~CKNIHDGFZ_ �3ÐuÞRìvÑ � Ø¦Ô ��hÑ�Ò³Õïí|ئÔYÓ)ÞRÔ³Ö � Ñ �GÕ �ÁÔ³Ö:ÑJÐLÓJÕzÞRÔ³ÖRíîÔ:ÛR��b¼ORQNIHBZF�~CB)t�FH<YwxIHBZF�OR^Y~�SUDC� _ �UBEFHQ]KN^%_t¡BEFHV�OR^rwG_ H � q � �

� m � � �i�5d�DGQ]QN<C^C~CBEFZ�àd�w:}CFuK]~ K]^\��BZFHBE^CMZBEj¿K]^ �¡;%y�â � ��y�}�O1jHBZ~¼�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB�FHBEWCFHB�yjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^�jkw\jkILBEV�jE�Yð�^@4���Õ � ��ÑJÐJìXÞRÔ �ßئÐh×�Ó���ØhÒ�Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ÏGDGQN<CV�B+oGm H DR� 7JÔ PئÐ�ìXÞRÕ¸í]× � �ÁÞ ���54JÑJÐ�í����:Õ�ÑJ_GW�OR?GBEj & � � sxq\_ �,}CK]^C?RBZFu��BEQ]~%_Yt�BZFkyVvOR^rwR_ H ��� pY�C[\WCFuK]^C?GBEF � M*BEFHQ]OR?C�

� mGq�� �i�5d�DGQ]QN<C^C~CBEF¿OR^C~�>¶� �&OGO1~CBZFE� �+<�O1Q]KN�îw:KN^C?Ì^x<CV�}ÜBEF¿FHBEjuILFuK]MJILK]DR^Cj¿K]^¼MZDG^\yMZBZW\IeQÍOR^C?R<�OR?GBEjZ�Tð�^ �UÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓnØ+Õ ��Ñ'6rÔ³Ö 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�ئÔ�UÐ�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓeØ ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�ÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR_¦W�OR?RBZj & & m � & s � _S&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?GB1_ �ßORjujZ� _ H ��� H �

� m � � �i�Td�DGQNQ]<C^C~YBZFZ_Áb �$��<YIuIP_5O1^C~��®�'[\MhAYV�KN~YIuy�[\MhA�OR<ClY�à[\<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^7ORQN?GD1yFHKNIHACVXj���DGF�MZDG^CMEBZWYI�~CBZjuMZFHKNWYILKNDG^ Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBZjE� ð�^ �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó$ØÌÕ ��Ñ �RÕ �� �:ÐLØhÒ�ÑHÞRÔ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑXØ¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_³W�OR?GBEj & s � � & m & _=[xILD:Mh�ryACDGQ]Và_�[x�UBE~CBZ^%_ H ��� pY�

� m � �¡@��%d�DRWCWÜB1_ÁSi� ��KN^C~CBZFuVvO1^C^%_�:Y���+<�OR^rI � _%f��3[\MhACVXK]BE~CBZQï_%OR^Y~ �®�%>'K]jHMhAYBZFZ��Uf�S � M�m\{ÁIL<YIHDGFHK]ORQ:OR^C~¿V�OR^x<�ORQï����ð�@ã`�BEWÜDRFuI H pGpY_R@TBZMhAY^CK]MZORQ���^CKNÏRBZFHjuKNI�wDR� �¶BZFHQNK]^%_��UBZFuQ]K]^3_�t�BZFHV�OR^rwG_ H ��� & �

o &

Page 24: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� � p �nt�� �"�ed�<C?GACBEjÌO1^C~ �å� :Y�eSUFHBEjHju�¶BZQNQ|� � � ئìiÒYÞRÔ�í|ئÔcÕ�Ø � ØZÖrÞRÚ �ÁØHÛRí��J��ÌBEIHA:<YBZ^ 2 SUDC�N_a;=DG^Y~CDG^%_ H � �RsC�

� � H �¡@��:ð�VXK]BEQ]KN^CjH�xK|�³`eBZju<CQNIHj¶DG^�ILFHOR^CjuQÍO1IHK]^C?¡~CBJ�¸OR<CQNIHj,ILD�MZK]FuMZ<CVXjHMEFHKNWYILKNDG^%� 0aØ �:Ð��Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ & oCñ H óJ{ H & H��AH s � _ H � �rq\�

� � o��¡f�� ��DG}YjLOY�¡>�KNFHjkI+BJò\W³BZFuK]BZ^YMZBZj+�eK ILAèIHACB�[��y�â � �c�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB¿FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO¦yILK]DR^7�UDGFu�x}ÜBE^CMhA K]^ ^CO1IL<CFHORQ&Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GB»ORWCWYQ]K]MZO1ILKNDG^CjE� � 7 � � ��� � �:ÚîÚ]ÑJÕïíîÔ�_oCñ & ó�{ûq1p � q � _ H ��� H �

� � & �=:Y� ��D\BEACQ]BEFZ��fi^åORWYWCQ]KNMPO1IHK]DG^àDR�*ILBEFHVXK]^CDGQNDG?GKNMPORQ=QNDG?GK]MEj�IHD»MPORjuBJy�}CORjHBE~åFuBPO¦yjHDG^CKN^C?C�að�^ �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓiØ"Õ ��Ñ �TØ �:ÐJÕ �=7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑiØ¦Ô �¶Ð�íîÔ ��JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓ�Ø ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔÌÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û�� ; � � ����_xW�O1?GBZj & m H��& � o\_ �¶DG^C^%_³t�BZFuVvOR^rwR_ H ��� sY� �ÌDGFu?rOR^��¡OR<Y��V�OR^C^%�

� � s � ������DG^CDGQNK]?GB1�Tâ�^�IHACB+FuBZQÍO¦ILK]DR^v}³BEI��¶BZBZ^à~CBJ�¸OR<CQNI&OR^C~�OR<\ILD:BZWCKNjuILBEV�KNMiQNDG?GK]M1�0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ & mCñ & óJ{ & s & � & �ro\_ H � ���\�

� � m�� ��� ��DG^CDGQNK]?GB1�èâ+^¼IHACB�FuBZQÍO¦ILK]DR^®}³BEI��¶BZBE^êMEK]FHME<CVXjHMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^®OR^C~�O1<YILD:BZWCKNjkyILBZVXK]M¡QNDG?GK]M1�,ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó¿Ø¡Õ ��Ñ 4 4RÕ �C7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ 0�ئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑØ¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ���7?0 � � 7�� ���R_xW�OR?GBEj H o H & �AH o H �Y_:[YOR^ �ßO1IHBZDC_YSUf�_H � � � � �ÌDGFH?GOR^���O1<Y��VvO1^C^%�

� ��� �n[Ü� ��FHOR<CjZ_ �¿�¶;=BEACVvO1^C^%_eOR^C~ �®� �ßOR?GKN~CDGFZ� ��DG^CVXDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM�FHBPO1jHDG^CKN^C?C_WCFHBJ��BZFHBE^rILKÍO1Q3VXD\~CBEQ]j¶OR^C~�ME<CV¿<CQ]O1ILK ÏGB�Q]DG?GKNMZjE� 0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚTØ � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í �Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_CsGsañ H�� oGó�{ H � q � oRprq:_ H � � pY�

� � q��¡f��¶;TO1<\òÜ� �UBZQNK]BE��j�KN^ V¿<CQ ILK�y�OR?GBE^rI)�UDGFuQ]~CjE{èfæILBZFuV�KN^CDGQNDG?GK]MZORQUQNDG?GKNMZj�ORW\yWCFHDrO1MhA%��ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓnØ�Õ ��Ñ��¶Ú]Ñ��RÑJÔ�Õ � � �\ÐLØhÒ�ÑHÞRÔ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ¡Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � ��Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ�� � � � 7�������� :RDGAC^»bcKNQ]BEw�OR^C~ß[\DG^CjE_ H ��� sY�

� � � ���¿�¶;=BEACVvO1^C^%� bcA�O1I�O®MEDG^C~CK ILK]DR^�ORQ"�x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBß}CORjHBÌBZ^rIhORKNQ]jE�éð�^ `¡�8:Y��UFLORMhAYVvOR^3_%BZ~CK ILDGFE_ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�Ø�Õ ��Ñ 4¦ÓJÕ97�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑXئÔ�UÐ�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓeØ ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�ÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR_¦W�OR?RBZj�o H o � oRoGo\_@'DGFuDG^rILDC_³â+^rIP� _ H � � � �

� ��� ��dn� :Y�:;ÁBJÏGBEjHäx<CB�OR^Y~�`¡� :Y� �UFLORMhAYVvOR^3����òYWYFHBZjujHK ÏGBZ^YBZjHj�OR^Y~XIHFLORMJIhOR}CKNQ]K I�w�KN^�:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RB�FHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^ OR^C~®FHBZORjHDG^YK]^C?C� � ئìiÒ �:ÕzÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_& {ûq � � � & _ H � �rq\�

� qRp �¡f��%;=BJÏ:w$OR^C~ �®�úSi�=`eDG<CjHjuBEIZ��SUfi`�ð ��{%f FuBZWCFuBZjHBE^rIhO1IHK]DG^�QÍO1^C?G<�OR?RB�MZDRV�y}CK]^CKN^C?XACDGFH^ÌFH<CQNBZj�OR^C~Ì~CBZjuMZFHKNWYILKNDG^ßQNDG?GKNMZjZ�Uð�^Ìb �ab7ORAYQ]juIHBZFE_³BE~CKNIHDGFZ_ �¶ÐLØ ��hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓXØnÕ ��Ñ � ÙUÑJÚ �Õ � � �:ÐLØhÒ�ÑHÞRÔ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ�7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ� � � � 7����� � _YW�OR?GBEj & o & � & oRq\� :RDGAY^àbcKNQ]BEw 2 [\DR^Cj�;=IH~%_ H ��� � �

o¦s

Page 25: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� q H �$M¿�r;=KN��juMhACKNI � � �UBJI��UBEBZ^vMEK]FuMZ<CVXjHMEFHK]W\ILK]DR^)OR^C~XOR<YIHD\BEWCK]jkILBEV�KNM&Q]DG?RK]MR�Yð�^�`¡� :Y��UFLORMhAYVvOR^3_%BZ~CK ILDGFE_ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�Ø�Õ ��Ñ 4¦ÓJÕ97�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑXئÔ�UÐ�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓeØ ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�ÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR_¦W�OR?RBZj�o & m � o¦sGsC_@'DGFuDG^rILDC_³â+^rIP� _ H � � � �

� qGo��=:Y�R;=DG}³DC_ :Y� �ÌKN^C�RBEFZ_rO1^C~¿f��1`�O­ÝHORjHBE�¦ORFZ� �'Ø �:Ô³ÖrÞRÕ¸í|ئÔYÓ�Ø �¡í]Ó � �:Ô �JÕïí��RÑ �ÁØHÛRí���UÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR� �Ìð�@Uy�ë,FHBZjujZ_ H ��� o:�

� q & ��`�� �ßORM�t�FHBE?GDGFE��ð�^CjHKN~CB&ILACB&;'â¡â � MZQ]ORjHjuKNç�BEFZ� � 7 � � ��� � �\ÚîÚ]ÑJÕ¸íîÔ�_xoCñ & óJ{ ��� �� o\_ H � � H �

� q1s ��`�� �ßORMPt¡FuBZ?GDRF�O1^C~ `¡� �&O1IHBZjZ� @"ACBß;Tâ¡â � �x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GBàFHBEWCFHBEjHBZ^rILO1ILKNDG^QÍOR^C?R<�OR?GB1�:@TBZMhAY^CK]MZORQY`eBZW³DGFkI�ðk[\ð �1`i[xy �rq­y H ���Y_ ��^YKNÏGBEFHjuKNI�w¡DR�³[:DG<YILAYBZFH^)S&ORQ yKN��DGFu^CKÍOY_ H � �rq:�

� qGm����¿� �ßO1�:KN^CjHDR^%�+t�BZ^YBZFLO1Q'W�O¦IHILBEFH^CjiK]^ß^YDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CK]M�FHBZORjHDR^CK]^C?Y��ð�^ �¿� �®�t�OR}Y}�OPwG_aSi� :Y��d�DG?G?GBEFZ_�O1^C~>:Y�Cf���`eDG}CKN^CjHDR^%_YBE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ �¡ÞRÔ³Ö*4JØ�Ø�×�Ø �ÁØHÛRí��íîÔ � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ�ÞRÔ³Ö �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:Û�� �³Ø¦Ú�� � � ��ئÔ�ìvئÔ3Ø �Õ�ئÔ�í��"ÞRÔ³Ö �ÁÔ �hÑJÐ�ÕzÞRíîÔ � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR_1WCOR?GBZj & m �AH H pY�¦â�ò:��DGFH~ ��^CKNÏRBZFujHKNI�wnë,FHBEjHjE_âiò:��DGFu~%_ � �)_ H ��� sC�

� q � �$M¿� �ßO1FHBZ�a_¦f�� ��BZFHD:~CB1_1O1^C~ �®��@'Fu<Cj � M � w\^YjH�xK|_GBE~CKNIHDGFHjE� �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛÞRÔ³Ö ��ئÔ�ìvئÔ3ئÕ�ئÔ�í�� � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û�� � �:íîÐuÖ,7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐJÔ³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑJ_�ÏGDGQN<CV�B� o �)DR� �TÑ��JÕ��:ÐhÑ ��ئÕ�ÑhÓ�íîÔ � 7��³[\WCFHKN^C?GBEF M*BZFHQ]OR?C_ H ��� m\�

� qGq�� �e� �ÌO�w:jE_rSi�­fiWYI BR_�:Y�¦t¡FuK]BEjHVXBZFZ_­O1^C~B:Y� �¡ORjkIL^CBEFZ� ��ò\WÜBEFHKNBZ^CMEB�eK ILA �iy�`eBZW%{fi^»DG}:ÝuBEMEIky�MZBE^rILBZFuBZ~��x^CD��eQ]BE~C?GB�FHBEWCFHBEjHBE^xILO1ILKNDG^»QÍO1^C?G<�OR?RBR�=ð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓØ 7 � � � � � 7 � � ���G_�W�O1?GBZj � o � � q\_ H � ���Y�

� q � � �e� �ßOPw:jZ_a`¡� �+K]DR^C^CBR_\OR^C~�`¡�\b®BZKN~�OY� �iy�`eBZW�jkw\jkILBEV D�ÏGBZFkÏ:K]BE�¡� � 7�� ������ �\ÚîÚ]ÑJÕ¸íîÔ�_aoCñ & óJ{ � & � � q\_ H ��� H �

� q � �=:Y� �ÌM�S&ORFkILArwG�XSUKNFHME<CV�juMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^ � f ��DGFuV DR�¶^CDG^\yzV�DR^CDRILDR^CK]MnFHBPO1jHDG^CKN^C?C�0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ H & ñ H 2 oGóJ{úoGq � & � _ H � �GpY�

� �Gp ���¿� �ÌM �+BEFHVXDRIHIZ� ��DG^YV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]M"Q]DR?GK]M&ðuðh{ ��DG^CVXDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM"V�D:~�ORQCIHACBZDRFHK]BEjZ�0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø¡Õ ��Ñ � ��� _³o � ñ H ó�{ & & � mGq\_ H � �ro\�

� � H ���¿� �ÌM �+BEFHVXDRIHIiOR^C~ :Y� �+D­w:QNBR� ��DG^\yzV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]M�Q]DR?GK]M�ðh� 0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ5Ø � Ð�Õ¸í �� �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ H & ñ H�� oRóJ{�s H�� qGo:_ H � �RpY�

� �ro��=:Y� �àK]^C�1BZFZ�3fi^vD�ÏRBZFuÏ:KNBE�cDR�3^CDG^CVXDG^CDRIHDG^CKNM"FHBPO1jHDG^CKN^C?nOR^C~XQ]DG?GKNM"WCFHDR?GFLORV)yV�KN^C?C��0�Ø �:ÐJÔ³ÞRÚ�Ø �TØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì)ì)íîÔ:ÛR_ H q:{ � m �AH o � _ H ��� & �

oRm

Page 26: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� � & � �®� �ÌKN^CjH�rwG�¡f ��FHORVXBE�¶DGFH����DGFiFuBZWCFuBZjuBZ^rILKN^C?��:^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBR�¡ð�^åë'�ÜbcKN^CjuIHDG^%_BZ~CK ILDGFE_ � ��Ñ �*Ó � ����ئÚ]ØHÛ �ÌØ � ئìiÒ �:Õ�ÑJÐ �Áí]ÓJí|ئÔ�� �ÌMPt¡FHO��&y�d�KNQ]Q|_ ��BE� �DGFu�³_H � qGm\�

� �Rs ��`��aSi� �ÌD\DRFHBR�5[\BZV�OR^rILKNMPORQÜMZDG^YjHK]~YBZFLO¦ILK]DR^Cj&DG^�^CDG^YV�DG^YDRILDG^YK]MiQNDG?GKNMR� 0aØ �:Ð��Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � Ð�Õïí � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_CoGmCñ H óJ{úqGm � � sY_ H � �rm\�

� �rm�� �®� �àDGFuIHK]VXBZFZ�\â+^�Q]OR^C?G<COR?GBZjÁ�eKNIHAnI��¶DiÏ1ORFHK]OR}CQNBZjZ���5ÑJíîÕîÓ ���:Ð � ��ìXÞRÕ �� �ÁØHÛRí]×�\Ô³Ö �&Ð��:Ô³ÖYÚ Þ�Û:ÑJÔ�Ö � � ÞRÕ ��]_³o H { H & m �AH srpY_ H � qGm:�

� � � � �i�*Si� �ÌDRj � �1D��ejH�xK|� � �\Ñ����\Õ¸íîÔ:Û � ÑJìiÒ�ئÐuÞRÚ �ÁØHÛRí�� �UÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì�ÓJ�¼S&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?GB��^CK ÏGBZFujHK I�wàë*FuBZjujZ_ÜS&ORV¿}CFuK]~C?RBR_ ����_ H � � � �

� �rq�� �i� ��BZ}³BZQ|�gSUDGV�WY<YIhO1IHK]DG^CORQeMZDGVXWCQ]B�ò\KNI�wãDR��ILBEFHVXK]^CDRQ]DG?GKNMPORQUFHBPO1jHDG^CKN^C?7KN^�Uf�S �)�,0�Ø �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � ÐJÕ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ & sañ & óJ{ & q H�� & � & _ H � ���Y�

� ��� � �i� ��BZ}³BZQ|� � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛàÞRÔ³Ö � Ñ���í]ÓJí|ئÔ�íîÔ ��� 4ZÐ�í¸Ö � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|Ø¦Ô � ��ÓJÕ�ÑJì�ÓJ_ÏGDGQN<CV�BvsxoGoßDR� �ÁÑ��JÕ��\ÐLÑ ��ئÕ�ÑhÓ�íîÔ � ئìiÒ �:Õ�ÑJÐ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑJ�å[\WCFuK]^C?GBEF � M*BEFHQ]OR?C_H ��� pY�

� � � � �i� ��BE}ÜBEQ|�¡@TBZFHVXK]^YDGQ]DG?RK]MPO1QTFuBPORjuDG^CKN^C?»K]j+KN^CACBEFHBZ^rIHQNwÌK]^rILFHORMEILOR}CQ]B1� 0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚØ � ÐJÕ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_\s & ñ|oRóJ{úo & m � o¦s � _ H ��� pY�

� � p � �i� ��BE}ÜBEQ'O1^C~����CÏRDG^Ì;Á<YMh�³�¶d�w:}CFuK]~àFHBZORjHDG^YK]^C?�K]^��Uf�S �)�*ð�^ .��Cb �a`�ORjOR^C~�;*�:[\ORKNIuIhOY_rBE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ � ÑJÕ ��ØZÖ:ئÚ]ØHÛRí|ÑhÓ�PئР7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ�Õ � ��ÓJÕ�ÑJì�ÓJ_rÏRDGQ]<CVXB & _W�OR?GBEjio � p � o � � � ��DGFuIHA\y�d�DGQ]Q]OR^C~%_ H � ���Y�

� � H ��ë'�1>U�­ë�O1IHBZQ�yk[\MhAC^YBZK]~YBZFZ����^C~YBZMZKN~�OR}CKNQ]K I�w+DR��ju<C}Cju<CV�W\ILK]DR^�K]^ ��ð �¡;,� 0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚØ � ÐJÕ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ & � ñ|oRóJ{úo � & � oRqGo\_ H � � � �

� � o��nSi�UëTBZQNILORjHDR^%�¾@"AYB �Uf�S � juw:juIHBZV � OR^êD­ÏRBZFkÏ\KNBE�¡� � 7�� ����� � �:ÚîÚ]ÑJÕïíîÔ�_oCñ & ó�{ H H s �AH H � _ H � � H �

� � & �¡@��=ë,F � w:V¿<YjHK]^YjH�xK|� ��DG^:y�VXDG^CDRIHDG^CK]M¡��DGFuVvORQNK]juV�j�OR^C~$QNDG?GKNM�WCFuDG?GFLO1V�VXK]^C?Y�ð�^ �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�ØnÕ ��Ñ �¦Õ � 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ)Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí�� �¶ÐLØHÛRÐuÞRì �ì)íîÔ:ÛR_CW�OR?GBEj � mGm � � q1sC_�S&O1V¿}CFHKN~C?GB1_ �Ìf�_ H � � � � �àð�@gë,FHBZjujZ�

� � s �¡@��rë,F � w:V¿<YjHK]^YjH�xK|�3[:IhO1}CQ]B&juBZV�OR^rILKNMZj5��DGF5~YK]j�Ýu<Y^CMEIHKNÏGB"WYFHDG?GFHORVXjZ� ��ÑJÙ ��ÑJÔ �ÑJÐHÞRÕ¸í|Ø¦Ô � ئìiÒ �:ÕïíîÔ:ÛR_ � {�srp H�� sxo1sY_ H ��� H �

� � m��=:Y� ��<COR^rI � OR^C~ �i�T[\MhAYV�K I � � �¡^YD­�eQNBZ~C?RBJy�}CORjHBE~®~CKNjLORV�}CK]?G<CO1ILKNDG^Ì��DGF�V�O¦yMhACK]^CB�IHFLOR^CjuQÍO1IHK]DG^3� � íîÔ³Ö¦Ó�ÞRÔ³Ö � Þ ���:íîÔ3ÑhÓJ_\sC{ & � � mGq\_ H ��� sC�� ��� � �®� �+<CKNQ]Q]K]OR^%�à[\BEVvO1^xIHK]M�V�BEV�DGFkwG�Ìð�^�®� �àK]^Cju�xwR_*BZ~CK ILDGFE_ � ÑJìXÞRÔ�Õ¸í��37�Ô �

PئÐJìXÞRÕ¸í|Ø¦Ô �UÐLØ �hÑhÓhÓJíîÔ:ÛR_5WCOR?GBZjXo H � � oGq1pY�$�Ìð�@ ë,FuBZjHjE_&S&O1V¿}CFHKN~C?GB1_ �ßORjujZ� _H ��� �Y�

o �

Page 27: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� � q���`�OPw:V�DR^C~7`eBZK ILBZFE��fÎQ]DG?GKNM)��DGF¡~CBE�¸OR<YQNInFHBPO1jHDG^CKN^C?C� 0�Ø �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ"Ø � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ H & { � H�� H & o\_ H � �GpY�

� � � � �n�\[YO1IuILQ]BEFZ�%f MZDR^CMZBEWYI&Q]OR^C?G<�O1?GBeBJò:ILBE^C~CBZ~��eK ILAX~CKNôÜBZFuBZ^rI¶�:KN^C~CjDR�%IHFLOR^CjuK yILKNÏRBUFuDGQ]BEjZ�:ð�^�t��Rt <DGF � OR^C~�[³�Rd <DGQ]QN~CDG}CQNBZFZ_­BE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ 6 � � �¿Ñ��\ÕîÓ ����Ñ 0CÞ �:ÐLÑhÓJÕ|Þ �Û �\Ô:Û ���\Ð ;���\ÔYÓJÕ¸Ú¤í�����Ñ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ ��� ;$7 � � P_a^x<CV¿}³BZF H H & qXKN^ß;=BEMEIL<YFHB ��DRILBEjK]^�fiFkILKNçCMZKÍO1Q3ð�^rILBEQ]Q]KN?GBZ^YMZBR��[\WCFHKN^C?GBEF M*BZFHQ]OR?C_ H ����� �

� ��� �¡f��¶[\MhA�ORBEFu���¾â+^êIHACBÌMEDGVXWCQ]B�òYK I�w�DR�iIHACBßKN^CjuILOR^CMEBÌMhACBEMh�xK]^C? WCFuDG}CQNBZV K]^MZDG^CMEBZWYI�QÍOR^Y?G<�OR?GBEjT�eK ILAnBJò\K]jkILBZ^rIHKÍORQxäx<�OR^rILK ç�MPO¦ILK]DR^%� 0aØ �:Ð�Ô³ÞRÚaØ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ�Õ7JÔ PئÐ�ìXÞRÕïí|Ø¦Ô � �­ÓJÕ�ÑJì�ÓJ_ao\{úo � m � oGq �Y_ H ��� & �

� H pGp � ���³[:MhACK]QN~%�*fgMZDGFuFHBZjuWÜDR^C~CBZ^YMZBnIHACBZDRFuw»��DGF&IHBZFHVXK]^YDGQ]DG?RK]MPO1Q³QNDG?GKNMZjZ{*ë,FuBZQ]KNV�K�y^�ORFuw�FHBEWÜDRFuIP�Tð�^ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�ØiÕ ��Ñ 4�6rÕ �37JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ 0�ئíîÔ�Õ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑØ¦Ô � ÐJÕ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_\W�OR?GBEj�s ��� � sxq H _�[:w:~C^YBEwG_³fi<YjuILFHORQ]K]OY_ H ��� H �

� H p H � ���'[\MhAYK]Q]~3��SUDGV¿}CKN^CK]^Y?�IHBZFuV�KN^CDGQ]DR?GK]MZORQ�QNDG?GK]MEj+�eKNIHA®ILBE^CjHB�Q]DG?RK]MR��ð�^ �¶ÐLØ ��hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦ÓåØÌÕ ��Ñ �¦Õ � �eئÐ�Õ��RÛ ��ÑhÓ�Ñ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ�Ø¦Ô � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ87�Ô�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑ����� 7 � �����G_CWCOR?GBZj H prm �AH oRpY_ H ��� & �

� H pro�� ����[:MhACK]QN~%� @TBZFuV�KN^CDGQNDG?GK]MZORQ�MEw:MZQNBZj7O1^C~ IHACBãWCFHDGW³DGjuKNILKNDG^�ORQ��Üy�MZORQ]ME<CQ]<YjZ�ð�^ �¶ÐhØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó$ØàÕ ��Ñ �TØ �:ÐJÕ � 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕïí|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑ$Ø¦Ô �¶Ð�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓØ�;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|Ø¦Ô ÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:Û��$; � � ����_*W�OR?GBEjXmRp � � mRoRpY_�UDG^C^%_³t�BZFuVvO1^xwR_ H ��� sC� �ÌDGFu?rOR^ �¡OR<Y��V�OR^C^%�

� H p & � �®�\[\MhACVXK]~YIkyk[\MhA�O1<ClC�Á[\<Y}CjH<CVXWYIHK]DG^�K]^ ��;3y�â � �¼K]j<C^C~YBZMZKN~�OR}CQNBR�%ð�^v`�� :Y��UFLORMhAYVvOR^3_%BZ~CK ILDGFE_ �¶ÐLØ �hÑhÑHÖRíîÔ:Û¦Ó�Ø�Õ ��Ñ 4¦ÓJÕ97�Ô�Õ�ÑJÐ�Ô³ÞRÕ¸í|ئԳÞRÚ � Ø¦Ô PÑJÐLÑJÔ �hÑXئÔ�UÐ�íîÔ �JíúÒ³Ú]ÑhÓeØ ;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�ÞRÔ³Ö � ÑHÞ¦Ó�ئÔ�íîÔ:ÛR_¦W�OR?RBZjTsxo H�� s & H _@'DGFuDG^rILDC_³â+^rIP� _ H � � � �

� H pRs � �®�'[\MhACVXK]~YIkyk[\MhA�O1<ClßO1^C~7t)�T[\VXDGQ]�¦OY�)f&IuILFuK]}C<YIHKNÏRB)MZDG^CMEBZWYI�~CBZjuMZFuK]WYIHK]DG^Cj�eKNILA�MEDGV�WYQ]BZVXBZ^rIHjZ�80�Ø �\Ð�Ô³ÞRÚ�Ø � Ð�Õ¸í � �Jí¸ÞRÚ 7JÔ�Õ�ÑJÚîÚ¤í Û:ÑJÔ �hÑJ_Ysxq:{ H�� o � _ H ��� H �

� H prm���;*� �)�=[\MhAx<C}³BZFkIP_T`��%t��%t¡D:BZ}³BZQï_3O1^C~ �n� :Y�%SUBZFuMZDG^CB1�n@"AYB)juILFu<CMEIH<CFHBXOR^Y~DGFH?rO1^CK � O1ILKNDG^�DR�¡O®juBZV�OR^rILKNMÌ^CBJIv��DGFXMZDRV�WCFuBZACBE^CjHKNDG^ O1^C~ KN^Y��BZFuBZ^CMEBR�cð�^�n� M¿�T>�K]^Y~CQ]BEFZ_TBZ~CK ILDGFE_ � ÓhÓ�Ø �Jí¸ÞRÕïí��RÑ ��ÑJÕïÙUئÐL×�Ó � � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔãÞRÔ³Ö �%Ó�ÑØI;�Ô3ئÙ"Ú]ÑHÖ�Û:Ñ 4 � � ئìiÒ �\Õ�ÑJÐLÓJ_CW�OR?GBEj H o H��AH qGm\�Yf�MPOR~YBZVXK]M�ë,FHBZjujZ_ H � q � �

� H p � � �)�3[\ACDGA�O1VÌ�"f jHBEVvOR^rIHK]MPO1Q'O1WCWCFHDGORMhAßILD�^CDG^CVXDG^CD1ILDG^CKNM¡Q]DG?GKNMZjE�&ð�^ 7 � � �� �1ìiÒ�Ø�ÓJí �:ì Ø¦Ô �ÁØHÛRí�� íîÔ � ئìiÒ �\Õ�ÑJÐ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑJ_)W�OR?GBEj7oRqGm � oGq � _¿ðzILACORMPOY_�n� �)� _ H � �rq\�

� H prq��nSi�Y[xILK]FuQ]KN^C?C� �ÌD:~�ORQ�O1^C~XIHBZVXWÜDRFLORQCQNDG?GKNMR�að�^�[³�rfi}CFHORV�ju�rwG_ �¿� �®�\t�O1}C}�OPwG_OR^C~¡@��­[Ü���"� �ÌORK]}�O1<CVÌ_�BE~CKNIHDGFHjE_ �¡ÞRÔ³Ö*4JØ�Ø�×+Ø��TØHÛRí��íîÔ � ئìiÒ �\Õ�ÑJÐ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑ���³Ø¦Ú�� 6r�aâ�ò\��DRFH~ ��^CK ÏGBZFujHK I�w�ë,FHBZjujZ_Üâ�ò:��DGFH~%_ ���)_ H ��� & �

oRq

Page 28: 10325476 0%03859:/perso.univ-mlv.fr/ocure/baader97logicbased.pdf · k ¦ P  ® xª£x Pª X¥i£x n k P ] ... `gDR îIHBZ^ñ K]VXWCQ]KNMZK ILQNwYó*BZäx< O1IHB¿Q]

� H p�� ��b ��Ï1OR^�~CBZF�d�D\BE�7OR^C~ �®��~CB�`�K Ýu�RB1� SUDG<C^rIHK]^C?$DG}xÝuBZMEIHjZ�/0� �ÁØHÛRí��»ÞRÔ³Ö� ئìiÒ �\Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ�_�mCñ & ó�{ & oGm � & srm\_ H � � m\�

� H p � �¡f��5Ï1OR^ét�BZQN~CBZFE_ �)�,fn�*`�DGjujZ_UOR^C~/:Y�U[³�[\MhACQ]KNWY����@"ACB��UBEQ]Q y|��DG<C^C~YBZ~�jHB�yVvOR^rIHK]MZj���DGFi?RBZ^CBEFLORQ5QNDG?GKNM�WYFHDG?GFHORVXjZ� 0�Ø �:ÐJÔ³ÞRÚ*Ø�Õ ��Ñ � ��� _ & �Y{ � oRp � � m1pY_H ��� H �

� H H p ��b �:fn�rb¼D:D\~YjZ�3bcA�O¦I �j¶KN^vO¡Q]KN^C�a{'��DG<C^Y~�O1ILKNDG^Cj,��DGF*jHBEVvO1^xIHK]Me^CBJI��UDGFu�xjZ�Áð�^�¿�=t)� �UDR}CFHD�� OR^C~$f�� �®�ÁSUDGQNQ]KN^CjZ_³BZ~CK ILDGFujZ_ � Ñ�Ò³ÐLÑhÓ�ÑJÔ�Õ|ÞRÕïí|ئÔ7ÞRÔ³Ö �ÁÔ³Ö:ÑJÐ��ÓJÕzÞRÔ³ÖRíîÔ:Û� � Õ��CÖRí|ÑhÓ�íîÔ � ØHÛRÔ�íîÕïí��RÑ � �Jí|ÑJÔ �hÑJ_ÜWCOR?GBZj & m � �ro:�Üf�MPOR~CBEV�KNM¿ë,FHBEjHjE_;ÁDR^C~CDG^%_ H � qGm\�

� H H H �=:Y�&`¡�¶b®FHK]?RAxIZ_ �e�&[Ü�¶b®BZK�ò\BZQ]}COR<CVà_ ��� �UFHD��e^%_it)�U@�� M*BEjHDG^Y~CBZFE_�[Ü�U`��ë�ORQNV�BEFZ_ :Y�'ðh� �UBEFHV�OR^%_,OR^Y~�dn�5d�� �ÌD:DGFuBR�èf �x^CD��eQNBZ~C?GB�y�}�O1jHBZ~�MEDG^Yç�?1y<CFLO1IHDGF+ILACO1I¡jH<CWYWÜDGFkILj�jLORQNBZjE_=BZ^C?GKN^CBZBEFHKN^C?C_ÁOR^C~åV�OR^x<Y�¸ORMEIH<CFHKN^C?�O1I¡f,@ 2 @^CBEI��¶DGFH�»jkw:juILBEV�jE� � 7 � Þ�ÛrÞ��ZíîÔ3ÑJ_ H s�ñ & ó�{ ��� � �GpY_ H ��� & �

o �