11-10-26l c returnsmission “a turn-key solution that removes ... - way we green - way we build...

75
1 © carbonbusters.org 2011 Zero Carbon Retrofits: The Edmonton C Returns ROI Model

Upload: others

Post on 12-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

1© carbonbusters.org 2011

Zero CarbonRetrofits:

The EdmontonC Returns ROI Model

Page 2: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

2© carbonbusters.org 2011

Carbon Busters

Page 3: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

3© carbonbusters.org 2011

Around since 1992Founder: German Energy Engineer

Eckhart Stoyke

Self funding program for cities,public and large institutionalbuildings/ No upfront cost

Triple bottom line

Page 4: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

4© carbonbusters.org 2011

Carbon Busters Results

Page 5: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

5© carbonbusters.org 2011

$ Savings

$ 25.6 millionCarbon Busters Self-fundingProgram

Page 6: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

6© carbonbusters.org 2011

CarbonSavings

78 Millions KgCO2

Page 7: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

7© carbonbusters.org 2011

Page 8: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

8© carbonbusters.org 2011

Page 9: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

9© carbonbusters.org 2011

Page 10: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

10© carbonbusters.org 2011

Research and Education based

Page 11: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

"This book is a dream come true foranyone who wants to reduce theircarbon emissions in the most cost-effective way. Godo Stoyke playsthe numbers like Mozart played thepiano - with joy, inspiration,and accuracy. It should be adaptedfor every country in the world.”-Guy Dauncey, Author of "StormyWeather: 101 Solutions to GlobalClimate Change”

Carbon BustersResearch2007/08

Page 12: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

The book details themost innovative andsustainable bylaws,initiatives andprograms that havebeen successfullyimplemented injurisdictions aroundthe world.

Carbon BustersResearch2008/2009

Page 13: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

13© carbonbusters.org 2011

Designing zero carbon buildings andsustainable communities

Integrating clean energy technologiesin new buildings and green

developments

Page 14: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

14© carbonbusters.org 2011

The WillowsCarbon Busters®

VillageA Zero Carbon Sustainable Community

Leduc County, Alberta, Canada

Page 15: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

15© carbonbusters.org 2011

Carbon Busters Village

Page 16: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

16© carbonbusters.org 2011

High performance designEnergy efficient

“Passiv” standard - 90% reduction in spaceheating

and cooling compared to existing building stock(15 kWh/m2/yr)

No furnace, oil or natural gasSmart grid

Energy plusFuture proofed

Resilient & relatively affordableIntegrated design; food, transportation, waste,

water, education, local etc

Page 17: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

17© carbonbusters.org 2011

Phase 1Design charrettes

- best practise modelsBuilding designs

Integrated clean energy systemsDraft Area Structure Plan

Setting up financing for Phase 2School and community hall design

charretteʼs to be completed

Page 18: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

18© carbonbusters.org 2011

Finalists - 2018 Olympic Village- part of an international design

team with RMI.org, Big.dk

Bjarke Ingels on TED / YouTube

Page 19: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

© carbonbusters.org 2011

Page 20: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

20© carbonbusters.org 2011

Finalists - 2018 Olympic Village

Page 21: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

22© carbonbusters.org 2011

Research 2010/2011Zero carbon retrofits

Page 22: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

23© carbonbusters.org 2011

BackgroundIncubated by GEA, Supported by

Social Enterprise Fund -Sustainable Works Edmonton

Page 23: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

24© carbonbusters.org 2011

Another way Anna Bubel, MBA, MEVDS, MCED

Page 24: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

25© carbonbusters.org 2011

Helped create social enterprisesSustainable Works

Social Enterprise Fund

Live LocalBuilder

A Better LotBuilt PV-powered strawbale house

Affordable housing consultantInroads Housing Co-operative

First Nations Housing Dev. Corp.

Page 25: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

© carbonbusters.org 2011

Page 26: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

- Non profit- Cash, Carbon and Community return

on investment

C Returns (see re-turns)

Page 27: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

“To green every home &community in Alberta”

Mission

Page 28: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

“A turn-key solution that removesall barriers to full sustainability”

Approach

Page 29: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Business Model

Specially trained, certified energyadvisors delivering superior,comprehensive green audits - qualitycontrol

Page 30: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Customized, comprehensivesoftware/hardware combo thatdelivers savings calcs, including costs,savings, paybacks, and carbonreturns on invesment.

Page 31: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Retrofit solutions arelimited to select highquality, proven, highperformance, cost-effective measuresbased on extensivemulti-year researchand experience

Page 32: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

An integrated product and servicesupply chains based on bulk-buyingdelivers lower cost to customers

Page 33: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Solutions include high-payback smallitems to capital-intensive long-terminvestments

Page 34: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Contractors are pre-qualified andtrained by C Returns

Page 35: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Community mobilization modelextends reach, geographicconcentration creates economies ofscale

Page 36: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Headquartered in Edmonton

Page 37: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Positive Impact on People and Planet

Page 38: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

- Helping Albertans to act ontheir priorities and make adifference- Save money and reduce GHGemissions- We have the power to affectchange and contribute to thelong term health of our planet

Page 39: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Coming to a neighbourhood near you!

Page 40: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

- Community mobilization - homeowners and C Returns as partners- Community buildings- Green/Convenience/Savings- Neighbourhood based- Early Adopter’s Special - 31 spotsopen/ first come first served/discount

Page 41: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

- Way We Green- Way We BuildCity of Edmonton, a resilient, carbonneutral city

Page 42: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

www.creturns.com

Page 43: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards
Page 44: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Cost and benefits : moving towardszero carbon, net zero and Passivhausstandards

Page 45: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Net-Zero

Page 46: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Passivhaus

Typical German Home (2000)

Required by German Ordinance

Typical measured in Passive Houses

Page 47: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

CarbonBusters.org2009

UK 2016•All new homes zero carbon

• Commercial by 2019

Page 48: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

CarbonBusters.org2009

Water

Page 49: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Anna &FabianBubel

1995

Page 50: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Secondary50,000

40,000

30,000

20,000

10,000

0

47,734

8,760

Natural gas Electricity

Base

172 GJ

17%

Page 51: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

50,000

40,000

30,000

20,000

10,000

0

47,734

26,545

Natural gas Electricity

Base 1°

Bubel: Primary

172 GJ

8,760kWh 2°

Page 52: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

10

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

0

10

7

Natural gas Electricity

Carbon

Bubel: Carbon

41%

Page 53: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

50,000

40,000

30,000

20,000

10,000

0Natural gas Electricity

Base 1°2010/11

Bubel: 1° Energy

71%

Page 54: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Retrofits

Page 55: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Retrofits• York 80,000 BTU Affinity Furnace (94%

efficient) - $3,537

• Toilets 1.28 low flush (3) - $873

• Low flow Showerheads (2) - $242

• Attic Insulation $1,500, Tax - $330

• Total $6,943

• Rebates received: Furnace $1,290Toilets -$195 Audit - $200

Page 56: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Carbon “after”

3 t

1 t

69.7%

30.3%

Carbon "after"

Natural gasElectricity

Page 57: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Carbon “after”

17 t --> 4 t

76%

10

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

0

10

3

7

1

Natural gas Electricity

Base2010/2011

Page 58: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Carbon “after”

83%

10

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

0

10

3

7

0Natural gas Electricity

Base2010/2011

GreenMax

Page 59: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Bubel: Caveats

• Initial consumption based on EnerGuide model

• 2, not 4 inhabitants (“no” effect on spaceheating)

• No degree day correction

• (Behaviour!)

Page 60: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

HanaeKiyooka,

Jeff Gusdal,Siri, Emi,

Coco

1914

Page 61: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Video

Page 62: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Labour

$7,140

=

$25,516

Page 63: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Source: Jeff Gusdal

Page 64: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards
Page 65: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards
Page 66: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Kiyooka-Gusdal

• 2011:

• 98 GJ natural gas

• 3,096 kWh electricity

• ACH: 10.4 @ 50 Pa

Page 67: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

2012?

Page 68: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards
Page 69: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

38,000

Page 70: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

$38,000

• E.g. 2,000 sf

• Incremental

Page 71: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Birmingham Zero Carbon House

• 174 years old

Page 72: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

Birmingham ZeroCarbon House

Page 73: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

CarbonBusters.org2009

ContactGodo StoykeDirector of [email protected]

Page 74: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

CarbonBusters.org2009

Shanthu ManoDirector of [email protected]

Page 75: 11-10-26l C ReturnsMission “A turn-key solution that removes ... - Way We Green - Way We Build City of Edmonton, a resilient, carbon neutral city. . Cost and benefits : moving towards

CarbonBusters.org2009

Anna BubelDirector of [email protected]