11. tanada vs angara

8/13/2019 11. Tanada vs Angara

1/33

!"#$%&'( *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0!"#$%&% ()"$*

12/'&2

34 5647

+,$, -., //0123 &45 16 /227

89+:%$*) %, *;? ;--; =)&9-9@"% ()!%*%-+6 4A BCBDCEA .F GHC#HIJIKKI>C !C>4GC 4>? 4A G4LK45CEAM +$%+)$9) ;-=)N;-; 4>? O)P%$ ;$$)Q) 4ABCBDCEA .F GHC R.SAC .F $CKECAC>G4GITCA 4>? 4A G4LK45CEAM -9(;-)$ #, #%$N;! 4>?R)$;(9) $, &)$;N%!6 D.GH 4A G4LK45CEAM (9U9N N9:%$*9%! "-9)-6 -;*9)-;N%()-)&9( #$)*%(*9)-9!& ;!!)(9;*9)-6 (%-*%$ V)$ ;N*%$-;*9U% =%U%N)#&%-*9-9*9;*9U%!6 N9P;!WP;Q;-+ P;"-N;$;- V)"-=;*9)-6 9-(,6 #R9N9##9-% $"$;N

$%()-!*$"(*9)- &)U%&%-*6 =%&)P$;*9P)-+ P9N"!;- -+ &;+:":"P9= -+#9N9#9-;!6 9-(,6 4>? #R9N9##9-% #%;!;-* 9-!*9*"*%6 I> ECKECAC>G4GI.> .F T4EI.SAG4LK45CEA 4>? 4A >.>WX.TCE>BC>G4J .EX4>IY4GI.>A6#",','*/"809:0;%=+;$=) ;-+;$;6 ;N:%$*) $)&"N)6 N%*9(9; $;&)!W!R;R;-96 R%R%$!)-;NU;$%Z6 ;+;#9*) ;@"9-)6 $)=)NV) :9;Z)-6 -%#*;N9 +)-Z;N%!6 %$-%!*)R%$$%$;6 O)!% N9-;6 +N)$9;, &;(;#;+;NW;$$)Q)6 )$N;-=) &%$(;=)6 :N;!)#N%6 O)R- )!&%? V$%==9% 8%::6 I> GHCIE ECAKC[GITC [4K4[IGICA 4A BCBDCEA .F GHC #HIJIKK!C>4GC \H. [.>[SEEC? I> GHC E4GIFI[4GI.> D5 GHC #ECAI?C>G .F GHC #HIJIKKI>CA .F GH;XECCBC>G %AG4DJIAHI>X GHC 8.EJ? *E4?C )EX4>IY4GI.>M !;NU;=)$ %-$9@"%Z6 I> HIA[4K4[IG5 4A !C[ECG4E5 .F :S?XCG 4>? &4>4XCBC>GM (;$9=;= U;N=%R"%!;6 I> HCE[4K4[IG5 4A -4GI.>4J *EC4ASECEM $9Z;N9-) -;U;$$)6 I> HIA [4K4[IG5 4A !C[ECG4E5 .F*E4?C 4>? 9>?SAGE5M $):%$*) !%:;!*9;-6 I> HIA [4K4[IG5 4A !C[ECG4E5 .F ;XEI[SJGSECM$):%$*) =% )(;)6 I> HIA [4K4[IG5 4A !C[ECG4E5 .F VI>4>[CM $):%$*) $)&"N)6 I>HIA [4K4[IG5 4A !C[ECG4E5 .F V.ECIX> ;FF4IEAM 4>? *%)V9!*) *, +"9-+)-;6 I> HIA[4K4[IG5 4A %LC[SGITC !C[ECG4E568"0#*/"8?"/(" */ @2/$28A B9 BCCD *+ ,-" E*8&< =82">%"80-'# ,-"8",* *+ ,-" :20, >2H*8',A *+ (*$/,8'"0 -20 8":*&$,'*/'G"< '/,"8/2,'*/2&%$0'/"00 2/< "(*/*>'( 8"&2,'*/0 2>*/?0, 0,2,"0; I, -20 '88":"80'%&A #8*#"&&"< ,-" J*8*:'/? Q.-'&'##'/" 2(("00 ,* +*8"'?/ >28M",09 "0#"('2&&A ',0 >2H*8,82


3/33

43$ 5$)#)#*1 #1 !"#$%

68?$'/? >2'/&A VBW ,-2, ,-" E=F 8"O$'8"0 ,-" .-'&'##'/"0 Q,* #&2(" /2,'*/2&0 2/"/, ,-8*$?- ,-" 8"&"20" 2/< $,'&'G2,'*/ *+ #$%&'( +$/"/, +*8 ,-" (*/0'"/, '/ 2((*8%"80 *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/" S"/2," 8"("':"< 2 &",,"8


4/33

F/ 6$?$0, Be9 BCCc9 ,-" >">%"80 *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/" S"/2," 8"("':"< 2/*,-"8 &",,"8 +8*>,-" .8"0'"/,0 '/ P'/2/('2& S"8:'("0 28" -"8"%A 0$%>',,"< ,* ,-" S"/2," +*8 ',0

(*/($88"/(" #$80$2/, ,* S"(,'*/ ]B9 68,'(&" \II *+ ,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/;QF/ R"(">%"8 C9 BCCc9 ,-" .8"0'%"8 Bc9 BCCc9 ,-" .-'&'##'/" S"/2," 2"/,0 V'"/, 20 6//"N"0 B9 ] 2/< e ,-"8",* 2/< (*&&"(,':"&A 8"+"88"< ,* 20 1$&,'&2,"82&=82"/, */ 6?8'($&,$8"6?8"">"/, */ ,-" 6##&'(2,'*/ *+ S2/',28A 2/"/, */ =28'++0 2/< =82#&">"/,2,'*/ *+ 68,'(&" \II *+ ,-"Z"/"82& */ =28'++0 2/< =82#*8,0 K'("/0'/? .8*(""/, */ =82


5/33

6443g ]

U/"/, *+ R'0#$,"0

6443g e

=82

F/ R"(">%"8 Bb9 BCCc9 ,-" .8"0'"/, *+!2,'+'(2,'*/9 "/,0 '/(&$"/, J-'(- 28"

'/,"?82& #28,0 ,-"8"*+9 0'?/"< 2, 12882M"0-9 1*8*((* */ BD 6#8'& BCCc9 ,-" 02>" 2/< ":"8A 68,'(&" 2/< 7&2$0" ,-"8"*+;

=* ">#-20'G"9 ,-" E=F 6?8"">"/, 82,'+'"< %A ,-" .8"0'#*0"< *+ ,-" 6?8"">"/, .8*#"8 2/< Q,-" 200*('2,"< &"?2& '/0,8$>"/,0 '/(&$"/, J-'(- 28" '/,"?82& #28,0,-"8"*+;Q

F/ ,-" *,-"8 -2/"/,'*/"*82/ "20$8"0 '/ +2:*8 *+&"20, "/,0 '/ P'/2/('2& S"8:'("0 >',>"/,0 ,* "N'0,'/? /*/L(*/+*8>'/? >"20$8"09 >28M", 2(("009/2,'*/2& ,8"2,>"/,9 2/< %"8 ]C9 BCCc9 ,-" #8"0"/, #",','*/ J20 +'&"*82/


6/33

.-'&'##'/" 6>%2002"/,0;

R$8'/? ,-" F82& 68?$>"/, -"&< */ 6$?$0, ]`9 BCCb9 ,-" 7*$8, $&,'L:*&$>" E=F 6?8"">"/, 2/< *,-"8 "/,0 >"/,'*/"< '/,-" P'/2& 6(,9 20 0**/ 20 #*00'%&";

6+,"8 8"("'#, *+ ,-" +*8"?*'/? "/,09 ,-" 7*$8, 02'< ', J*$&< (*/0'"/,0 '/:*&:'/?((0$(

I/ ,-"'8 1">*82/ '>#$?/'/? ,-" :2&'"/, 30,2%&'0-'/? ,-" E*8&< =82#2'8 .-'&'##'/" 0*:"8"'?/,A0#"('+'(2&&A ,-" &"?'0&2,':" #*J"8 J-'(-9 $/


7/33

3; E-",-"8 #8*:'0'*/0 *+ ,-" 6?8"">"/, 30,2%&'0-'/? ,-" E*8&< =82%"80 *+ ,-" S"/2," 2(,"< '/ ?82:" 2%$0"*+ *$/,'/? ,* &2(M *8 "N("00 *+ H$8'0'00'*/J-'(- '/(&$"/,0 '/ P'/2/('2& S"8:'("0;

F/ ,-" *,-"8 -2/#&'"< 8"H"(,'*/ *+ ,-" ,8"2,A ">%*"&Ad VBW J-",-"8 ,-" #",','*/#8"0"/,0 2 #*&','(2& O$"0,'*/ *8 '0 *,-"8J'0" /*, H$0,'('2%&"X V]W J-",-"8 #",','*/"8L>">%"80 *+ ,-" S"/2," VE'?%"8,* 3; =2i2'/'O$" 7*0","/?W 28""0,*##"< +8*> H*'/'/? ,-'0 0$',X 2/< VeW J-",-"8 ,-" 8"0#*/%"80 *+ ,-" S"/2,"2(,"< '/ ?82:" 2%$0" *+


8/33

VBW =-" Q#*&','(2& O$"0,'*/Q '00$" T %"'/? :"8A +$/"/,2& 2/< :',2&9 2/< %"'/? 2>2,,"8 ,-2, #8*%"0 '/,* ,-" :"8A H$8'0", -"2< */ 2/<


9/33

$%& ()*+, -++.&a/0&+ ,%& 10.*,234& !.*)+5)6,)07 84&* ,%& 107,*04&*+9:

I/ 0""M'/? ,* /$&&'+A 2/ 2(, *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/" S"/2," */ ,-" ?8*$/< ,-2, ', (*/,82:"/"0,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/9 ,-" #",','*/ /* "/,;

=-" +*8"?*'/? ,"N, ">#-20'G"0 ,-" H$


10/33

(*$/,8A '/,* ,-" E=F9 *8 #200 $#*/ ,-" 6$"#)( *+ ,82'( #*&'(A *+ 8"'( /2,'*/2&'0>Q 28" :'*&2,"< %A ,-" 0*L(2&&"< Q#28',A #8*:'0'*/0Q 2/*," ,-" #8"+"8"/,'2& $0" *+ P'&'#'/* &2%*89"0,'( >2,"8'2&0 2/< &*(2&&A #8*2M" ,-"> (*>#",',':";

.",','*/"80 2:"8 ,-2, ,-"0" 02(8"< (*/0,',$,'*/2& #8'/('#&"0 28" *82/d /2

2W I/ ,-" 28"2 *+ '/:"0,>"/, >"20$8"0 8"&2,"< ,* ,82"/, */ =82"/, 1"20$8"09 \*&;]`9 U8$?$2A !*$/ 2/A "0,'( 0*$8("9 J-",-"80#"('+'"< '/ ,"8>0 *+ #28,'($&28 #8*


12/33

V%W ,-2, 2/ "/,"8#8'0"h0 #$8(-20"0 *8 $0" *+ '>#*8,"" *8 :2&$" *+#8*" *8 :2&$"*+ ',0 &*(2& #8*#*8,"< '/,* ,-" ,"88',*8A *+ 2/A *,-"8 (*/,82(,'/?#28,A(3,-- A$ ,++*"2$2 )"$,)6$1) 1* -$(( %,B*",A-$ )3,1)3,) ,++*"2$2 )* -#.$ @"*20+)( *% 1,)#*1,- *"#/#1 '/ 8"0#"(,*+ &2J09 8"?$&2,'*/0 2/< 8"O$'8">"/,0 2++"(,'/? ,-"'8'/,"8/2& 02&"9 *++"8'/? +*8 02&"9 #$8(-20"9 ,82/0#*8,2,'*/9'( *#"82,'*/ *+ ,-" >"2/0 *+ ,82/0#*8, 2/< /*, */,-" /2,'*/2&',A *+ ,-" #8*


13/33

G,+3 "/, */=82"/,09 #; ]Dce] V">#-20'00$##&'"1 )3$ ,"$, *% )3$ H$1$",- I/"$$6$1) *1 4",2$ #1 D$"B#+$(d

=,)#*1,- 4"$,)6$1)

B; I/ ,-" 0"(,*80 '/0(8'%"< '/ ',0 0(-"%"89 '/ 8"0#"(, *+ 2&& >"20$8"0 2++"(,'/? ,-"

0$##&A *+ 0"8:'("09)"$,)6$1) 1* -$(( %,B*0",A-$ )3,1 #),++*"2( )* #)( *?1 -#.$ ($"B#+$( ,12 ($"B#+$ (0@@-#$"(;

]; 6 1">%"8 >2A >"", ,-" 8"O$'8">"/, *+ #282?82#- I %A2((*82&&A 0$##&'"80 *+ 2/A *,-"8 1">%"89"',-"8 +*8>2&&A '"/, *8 +*8>2&&A 2&&A %"8; V68,'(&" g\II9Z"/"82& 6?8"">"/, */ =82%"8 ,* "/0$8" ,-"(*/+*8>',A *+ ',0 &2J09 8"?$&2,'*/0 2/< 2'/'0,82,':" #8*("',2,'*/0 */ ,-" 8*&" "N#*8,0 #&2A '/ /2,'*/2& "/,2/< /"?2," ,-" #8"+"8"/,'2& ,8"2,>"/, 2((*8


14/33

F/ ,-" *,-"8 -2/%*#&">"/, ,-"9 ,-$0d

F/ #",','*/"80h 2&&"?2,'*/ ,-2, .;R; B_bC :'*&2,"0 S"(,'*/0 BB V."80*/2&R'?/',AW B] VP2>'&AW 2/< Be V!*&" *+ j*$,-W *+ 68,'(&" IIX S"(,'*/ Be VS*('2&@$0,'("W *+ 68,'(&" gIII 2/< S"(,'*/ ] V3"8"&A0,2,">"/,0 *+ #8'/('#&"0 2/< #*&'('"0; 60 0$(-9 ,-"A 28" %20'(2&&A /*, 0"&+L"N"($,'/?9 >"2/'/? 2 &2J 0-*$&< %" #200"< %A 7*/?8"00 ,* (&"28&A


15/33


16/33

&2(M *8 "N("00 *+ H$8'0"/,2& #8*,"(,'*/ 2/< >2/2?">"/,9 *$8 (*$8,0 -2:" /* (&2'> ,*0#"('2& ,"(-/'(2& (*>#","/(" 2/< "N#"8'"/(" 2/< #8*+"00'*/2&

O$2&'+'(2,'*/; E-"8" /* 0#"('+'(9 *#"82%&" /*8>0 2/< 0,2/"/,0 T >$0, %" ?':"/ 2 8"2& 2/< "++"(,':" *##*8,$/',A,* +20-'*/ 2/< #8*>$&?2," ,-*0" /*8>0 2/< 0,2/A 2/< #2,8'>*/A9 0-*$&< %" 8"2< 2/#",','*/ 2/< ,82A 2/< 2&& 8"?'*/0 *+,-" (*$/,8A 0-2&& %" ?':"/ *#,'>$> *##*8,$/',A ,* "/,0 *+ "N(-2/?" */ ,-" %20'0*+ "O$2&',A 2/< 8"('#8*(',A;

60 #*'/,"< *$, %A ,-" S*&'(',*8 Z"/"82&9 S"(; B &2A0 '( "/,9 20 +*&&*J0d

B; 6 >*8" "O$',2%&" " 2/< J"2&,-X


17/33

]; 6 0$0,2'/"< '/(8"20" '/ ,-" 2>*$/, *+ ?**2M" ,-"> (*>#",',':"X 10 2/< VeW %A8"O$'8'/? ,-" S,2," ,* Q0 2/< 2882/?">"/,0 *+ "N(-2/?" */,-" %20'0 *+ "O$2&',A 2< 8"('#8*(',AQX]` 2/< 0#"2M0 *+ '/ ',0:"8A J*8"/,; 6/< J" -*&< ,-2, ,-"8" 28";

6&& ,*&',0#8*,"(,'*/ *+ P'&'#'/* "/,"8#8'0"0 */&A 2?2'/0, +*8"'?/ (*>#",','*/ 2/< ,82A; E-'&" ,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/ #",','*/ ,-2, '0 01%,#" ;

Q4N ;$+*/1#R$( =$$2 )*5"*)$+) Q$,. G+*1*6#$(


18/33

U#*/ ,-" *,-"8 -2/2'/,2'/ ,-2, ,-" E=F ',0"&+ -20 0*>" %$'&,L'/2'"09 J-'(- (*>#8'0" ,-" :20,>2H*8',A *+ ',0 >">%"80; U/&'M" '/ ,-" U4 J-"8" >2H*8 0,2,"0 -2:" #"8>2/"/, 0"2,0 2/%"8h0 :*," "O$2& '/ J"'?-, ,* ,-2, *+ 2/A *,-"8; =-"8"

'0 /* E=F "O$':2&"/, *+ ,-" U4 S"($8',A 7*$/('&;E=F "/"/,0 #8*:'0'*/J'&& 8"O$'8" 200"/, *+ 2&& >">%"80; 6/A >">%"8 >2A J',- ,-"6?8"">"/, $#*/ ,-" "N#'82,'*/ *+ 0'N >*/,-0 +8*> ,-" 2& $0" *+ ,-"J*8&"/, 2/"/, '0?':"/ ,* 0 *+ ,-" ,6*01) *% ),"#%% "$20+)#*1 2/< ,-" @$"#*2?#)3#1 ?3#+3 )3$ "$20+)#*1 #( )* A$ (@"$,2 *0) ; S#"('+'(2&&A9 Z6== 8"O$'8"0 2/ 2:"82?",28'++"$20+)#*1 ",)$ *% STU %*" 2$B$-*@$2 +*01)"#$( ,* %" "++"(,"< J',-'/ 2 @$"#*2 *% (#LCTF :$,"( J-'&"


20/33

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


21/33


22/33

'/0,2/, U,*#'2; >) 60() /"*? ?#)3 )3$ (*+#$): #) ($$.( )* "$K()"0+)0"$ ,126,"+3 ,@,+$ ?#)3 )3$ @"*/"$(( *% )3$ ",+$E 2",?#1/ %"*6 )3$ B#+#((#)02$(*% 3#()*": )3$ 2:1,6#(6 ,12 B#),-#): )3,) ?#-- .$$@ #)E %," %"*6 A$+*6#1/ , @$)"#%#$2 "0-$E , @0-(#1/E -#B#1/ -,? ,))01$2 )* )3$ 3$,")A$,) *% )3$ 1,)#*1;

$%)*5 -++.&a$%& *&&?&7, 375 C&>)+B3,)4& D0E&* =-" E=F 6?8"">"/, #8*:'#2'80 .-'&'##'/" 0*:"8"'?/,A9 0#"('+'(2&&A ,-" &"?'0&2,':" #*J"8 J-'(-$/ ,-2, 02'< E=F #8*:'0* ,-" #*J"8 ,*,2N9 J-'(- '0 &*


23/33


24/33

0-2&& #8":2'&9Q ,-$0 $/O$"0,'*/2%&A $&,'&2,"82& T ,-2, '/:*&:" &'>',2,'*/0 */ .-'&'##'/"

0*:"8"'?/,A; =-"0" 28" "/$>"82,"< %A ,-" S*&'(',*8 Z"/"82& '/ -'0 7*>#&'2/(" #, +8*>,2N9 '/(*>" 8"("':"< '/ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0 %A9 2>*/? *,-"809 ,-" P"#*8, 52/M *+ ,-" U/',"" #8':'&"?"0 20 ,-*0" ?82/,"< ,*@2#2/"0" 2/< [*8"2/ 2'8 (288'"80 $/"/, *+*%,2'/'/? ,82/0', *8 :'0',*8 :'020 +*8 2 0*H*$8/ '/ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0 /*,"N(""


25/33


26/33

Q22,,"8 *+ 2 #2,"/, '0 2 #8*("00 +*8 *%,2'/'/? 2 #8*%"80 0-2&& #8*:'0,2/("09 ,-2, 2/A ' ,-" 2%*:"9 2 E=F 1">%"8 '0 8"O$'8"< ,* #8*:'


27/33

#8*#&">"/,'/? ,-" #8*:'0'*/0 *+ =!I.SJ',-'/ ,-"'8 *J/ '/,"8/2& 0A0,">0 2/< #8*("00"0;

5A 2/< &28?"9 ,-" 28?$>"/,0 2


28/33

S* ,**9 0'/(" ,-" .-'&'##'/" '0 2 0'?/2,*8A ,* >*0, '/,"8/2,'*/2& (*/:"/,'*/0 */ #2,"/,09,82"&A ,-" 1'/'0,"8'2&R"(&282,'*/ 2/< R"('0'*/0 2/< ,-" U/"/, ,-*1$ '0 +&2J"< %"(2$0" ', '0 '/ "++"(, 28"H"(,'*/ *+ ,-" P'/2& 6(,9 J-'(- '/ ,$8/ J20 ,-" "/, 0'?/"< %A S"(8",28A 42:288*9'/ 8"#8"0"/,2,'*/ *+ ,-" !"#$%&'( $#*/ 2$,-*8',A *+ ,-" .8"0'"82,"< J-2, (*/0,',$,"0 ,-"P'/2& 6(, 0-*$&< -2:" %""/ ,-" 0$%H"(, *+ (*/($88"/(" *+ ,-" S"/2,";

Q6 %#1,- ,+) 9 0*>",'>"0 (2&&"< @"*)*+*- 2$ +-*)0"$9 '0 2/ '/0,8$>"/, J-'(- 8"(*8>28A *+ ,-" #8*(""2A -2:" ,2M"/ #&2(" *:"8 0":"82& A"280; =-" ,"N, *+ ,-" QP'/2& 6(, 3>%*"&A9 (*/($88"/(" *+ ,-" S"/2," '/ ,-" E=F6?8"">"/,;

=-" 1'/'0,"8'2& R"(&282,'*/0 2/< R"('0'*/0 J"8" "< 2'/'0,"80 %A :'8,$" *+ 68,'(&" gg\d B *+ Z6==J-'(- #8*:'"/,;Q 3_

=-" U/%"80 J-'(- Q-2:"


29/33

'/>',>"/,0 */ 0,2/'/2,'*/ *+>*/*#*&A9 "N#2/0'*/ *+ *#"82,'*/ *+ "N'0,'/? +'/2/('2& 0"8:'(" 0$##&'"809 ,">#*828A"/,8A *+ #"80*//"&9 +8"" ,82/0+"8 2/< #8*("00'/? *+ '/+*8>2,'*/9 2/< /2,'*/2& ,8"2,>"/,J',- 8"0#"(, ,* 2(("00 ,* #2A>"/,9 (&"28'/? 0A0,">0 2/< 8"+'/2/('/? 2:2'&2%&" '/ ,-"/*8>2& (*$80" *+ %$0'/"00;Q 37

F/ ,-" *,-"8 -2/"LJ*8M +*8 ,-"(*/"/,9 %'/"/,0 "/, */ =28'++0 2/< =82#&*A>"/,9 20 0$%0"O$"/,&A 8"(,'+'""/%"80h '/$,"&A '00'*/(2>" $# '/ ,-" +'80, "/, */ "0,2%&'0-'/? ,-" E*8&< =82


30/33

20 ,-" 2?8"">"/, "0,2%&'0-'/? ,-" E*8&< =822/9 ,* >2M" 0$8" ,-2, ', '0 (&"28 ($, 2/< ,-"8"0-*$&< %" /* >'0$/2,,"80%A ?':'/? ,-'0 &",,"8;

=Y3 7Y6I!164d =-2/M A*$;72/ ,-'0 7*>>',,"" -"28 +8*> S"/2,*8 =2i22/;

=Y3 7Y6I!164; =-2/M A*$9 S"/2,*8 =2i2 S"/2,*8=*&"/,'/*a 6/< 2+,"8 -'> S"/2,*8 4"#,2&' Z*/G2&"0 2/< S"/2,*8 K'/2;

DG=; 4N\G=4>=NE 3,B$ 1*) ($$1 )3$ 1$? (0A6#((#*1,+)0,--: )",1(6#))$2 )* 0( A0) > (,? )3$ 2",%) *% 3#( $,"-#$"E ,12 > )3#1. #)1*? +*6@-#$( ?#)3 )3$ @"*B#(#*1( *% )3$ P*1()#)0)#*1E ,12 ?#)3 )3$ 7#1,- I+) #)($-%; 43$ P*1()#)0)#*1 2*$( 1*) "$80#"$ 0( )* ",)#%: )3$ 7#1,- I+)[ >)"$80#"$( 0( )* ",)#%: )3$ I/"$$6$1) ?3#+3 #( 1*? A$#1/ (0A6#))$2[ 43$7#1,- I+) #)($-% (@$+#%#$( ?3,) #( /*#1/ )* A$ (0A6#))$2 )* ?#)3 )3$/*B$"16$1)( *% )3$ @,")#+#@,1)(;

>1 @,",/",@3 V *% )3$ 7#1,- I+)E ?$ "$,2 ,12 > 80*)$d


31/33

!: (#/1#1/ )3$ @"$($1) 7#1,- I+)E )3$ "$@"$($1),)#B$( ,/"$$d C,F )* (0A6#),( ,@@"*@"#,)$ )3$ Q4N I/"$$6$1) %*" )3$ +*1(#2$",)#*1 *% )3$"$(@$+)#B$ +*6@$)$1) ,0)3*"#)#$( ?#)3 , B#$? )* ($$.#1/ ,@@"*B,- *% )3$ I/"$$6$1) #1 ,++*"2,1+$ ?#)3 )3$#" @"*+$20"$(;

>1 *)3$" ?*"2(E #) #( 1*) )3$ 7#1,- I+) )3,) ?,( ,/"$$2 )* A$ (0A6#))$2 )*)3$ /*B$"16$1)( %*" ",)#%#+,)#*1 *" ,++$@),1+$ ,( ?3,)$B$" )3$#"+*1()#)0)#*1,- @"*+$20"$( 6,: @"*B#2$ A0) #) #( )3$ Q*"-2 4",2$N"/,1#R,)#*1 I/"$$6$1) ; I12 #% )3,) #( )3$ *1$ )3,) #( A$#1/ (0A6#))$21*?E > )3#1. #) (,)#(%#$( A*)3 )3$ P*1()#)0)#*1 ,12 )3$ 7#1,- I+) #)($-%;

=-2/M A*$9 18; 7-2'8>2/;

=Y3 7Y6I!164; =-2/M A*$9 S"/2,*8 =*&"/,'/*9 12A I (2&& */ S"/2,*8Z*/G2&"0;

DG=; HN=^I\GD; >"/, */ ,-'0a

DG=; \>=I ; ,/"$$ ?#)3 )3$ *A($"B,)#*1 Z0() 6,2$ A:D$1,)*" H*1R,-$( *0) *% )3$ ,A012,1+$ *% 80$()#*1; 43$1 )3$ 1$?(0A6#((#*1 #(E > A$-#$B$E (),)#1/ )3$ *AB#*0( ,12 )3$"$%*"$ > 3,B$ 1*

%0")3$" +*66$1) )* 6,.$ ;G@#-*/0$

I/ #82A'/? +*8 ,-" /$&&'+'(2,'*/ *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/" 82,'+'(2,'*/ *+ ,-" E=F 6?8"">"/,9#",','*/"80 28" '/:*M'/? ,-'0 7*$8,h0 (*/0,',$,'*/2&&A '>#*0"< #&A 0-*J/ ,-2, #",','*/"80 -2:" /* *,-"8 #&2'/9 0#"""2/, 0$(- (2#8'('*$0 2/< J-'>0'(2& "N"8('0" *+ H$"/, 20 '0 "O$':2&"/, ,* &2(M *+ H$8'0*$/, ,* 2/ ":20'*/ *+ 2 #*0',':" #&2,'*/ *+ &2J; _1 P2'&$8" */ ,-"


32/33

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


33/33

=-" ">'/"/, +$,$8'0, @*-/ 42'0%',,9 2$,-*8 *+ ,-" %"0, 0"&&"8'(2&&A9 #*&','(2&&A 2/< ($&,$82&&A '/ ,-" /"N, ("/,$8A;Q Y" 8"+"80 ,* ,-" Q+8"">28M",Q "0#*$0"< %A E=F 20 ,-" Q(2,2&A0,Q '/ ,-'0 (*>'/? 60'2/ 20("/%"80-'# '/ ,-" E=F; 4*,J',-0,2/ +*8 ,-" "/, *+ '/,"8/2,'*/2& ,82%"80-'#9 M""/&A 2J28" *+ ,-" 2 IA =9!&9!!%= F.E J4[b .F BCEIG,

!) )$=%$%=,

11. tanada vs angara

Documents