11 walsh womenshealth - ucsf medical education · 1.4% endometrial adenocarcinoma ... , national...

24
5/23/17 1 Update in Women’s Health Judith Walsh MD, MPH Division of General Internal Medicine Women’s Health Center of Excellence Plan for today… Review some of the most significant published advances in the Women’s Health medical literature over the past year Top articles Key articles Guidelines Assess the strength and scope of the evidence presented in the selected literature Apply this new information to our clinical practice Take-home points SGIM Annual Meeting, April 2017 Erin Contratto MD, Bimla Schwarz, MD and Lydia Pace MD Process 16 Journals March 1 2016 -Feb 2017 4 Independent reviewers: ranked 1-4 stars Criteria How new/innovative is this information? Strength of the evidence? How will it change my practice?

Upload: phungdung

Post on 10-Jun-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

5/23/17

1

UpdateinWomen’sHealth

JudithWalshMD,MPHDivisionofGeneralInternalMedicineWomen’sHealthCenterofExcellence

Planfortoday…• Reviewsomeofthemostsignificantpublishedadvancesin

theWomen’sHealthmedicalliteratureoverthepastyear– Toparticles– Keyarticles– Guidelines

• Assessthestrengthandscopeoftheevidencepresentedintheselectedliterature

• Applythisnewinformationtoourclinicalpractice– Take-homepoints

• SGIMAnnualMeeting,April2017– ErinContratto MD,Bimla Schwarz,MDandLydiaPaceMD

Process

16JournalsMarch12016-Feb20174Independentreviewers:ranked1-4stars

Criteria

• Hownew/innovativeisthisinformation?• Strengthoftheevidence?• Howwillitchangemypractice?

5/23/17

2

• OCPsandCancer• BingeEating• CranberryandUTIs• Tomosynthesis

• Lymphedema&blooddraws

• HormonetherapyandCVD

• DXAmonitoringontherapy

• Atypicalfractures

ISSUESAFFECTINGREPRODUCTIVEAGEWOMEN

Case

• 39yearoldwomanwhohasbeenonOCPssinceshewas19,whenshestartedthemforirregularandpainfulmenses.Shedoesnotdesirechildrenandishappywithherlightandrelativelypainlessmenses.Shewouldliketocontinuebutisworriedthattheymaynotbesafeforwomenafter40.Whatdoyoutellher?

TheNews

• Lifetimecancerriskandcombinedoralcontraceptives:theRoyalCollegeofGeneralPractitioners'Oral Contraception Study– Iversen etal.AJOG2017

5/23/17

3

UKRoyalCollegeofGeneralPractitioners'Oral Contraception Study

• 46,022womenrecruited1968-1969• Followedforupto44years

– 4661everCOCuserswithatleastonecancerduring884,895woman-yearsofobservation

– 2341neverCOCuserswithatleastonecancerduring388,505woman-yearsofobservation.

Iversen etal.AJOG2017

Results

• Previousconcernsofanyincreasedriskofbreast andcervical cancerlostwithinfiveyearsofstoppingCOC– noevidenceofincreasedriskofeithercancerrecurringwithtime.

– Suggestsearlierdiagnosisratherthantrueharm• Increasedriskoflung cancerwasseenonly

amongeveruserswhosmoked

ImportantcancerreductionspersistmanyyearsafterstoppingCOCuse

• Poissonregressiontoestimateincidencerateratios(IRR)betweeneverandneverCOCusers– adjustedforage,parity,smoking,andsocialclass

EveruseofCOCassociatedwithreducedcancer:• Endometrial (IRR0·66,99%CI0·48-0·89)• Ovarian (IRR0·67,99%CI0·50-0·89)• Colorectal (IRR0·81,99%CI0·66-0·99)• Lymphatic/ (IRR0·74,99%CI0·58-0·94)Hematopoietic

Iversen etal.AJOG2017

Implicationsforpractice

• Hormonal“contraception”maybeimportantforcancerprevention– EspeciallyifBMI>30– Evenifshewerenotseekingcontraception– Evenifshewere50yearsofage

• Levonorgestrel IntrauterineDeviceasanEndometrialCancerPreventionStrategyinObeseWomen:ACost-EffectivenessAnalysis

– Dottino JA,etal.ObGyn 2016

5/23/17

4

Irregularbleedinginpremenopausalwomen?

• Bodymassindextrumpsageindecisionforendometrialbiopsy:cohortstudyofsymptomaticpremenopausalwomen– Wiseetal.AJOG2016

• AIM:Toassesstheeffectofbodymassindexonriskofendometrialhyperplasiaorcancerinyoungsymptomaticpremenopuasal women

Methods

• Retrospectivecohortof916premenopausal womenreferredforendometrialbiopsyforabnormaluterinebleeding– Noknownhistoryofendometrialcancer

• SinglesiteinNewZealand,2008-2014• Meanage=42yo• 50%obese(BMI>30)

Wiseetal.AJOG2017

4.9%had“primaryoutcome”1.4%endometrialadenocarcinoma1.1%complexhyperplasiawithatypia2.4%complexhyperplasiaNOatypia

Agedoesnotpredictendometrialrisk

Wiseetal.AJOG2017

PredictorsofPremenopausalEndometrialhyperplasia/cancer

Wiseetal.AJOG2017

5/23/17

5

Implicationsforpractice

• Thinkaboutpreventingendometrialcancerwhencaringforobesewomen

• Considerultrasoundtoassessendometriallining+/- Biopsy– Especiallyifmenorrhagiaresultsinanemia

Case:HPV• 25yearoldwomanreceived2dosesofHPVvaccineseveralyearsagoandwantstoknowifsheshouldrestarttheHPVseries?Youtellher…

A. Sincelastdose>12monthsago,sheshouldrestartthefull3doseseries.

B. Ifshereceived2dosesbeforeage15,nofurtherdosesareneeded.

C.HPVvaccineisonly2dosesnow,regardlessofage.

Background:HPVvaccination

v9vHPVvaccine– Gardasil9(Merck®)– FDAapprovedDec2014– 2016:onlyvaccinedistributedinUS– 6,11 (genitalwarts)– 16,18+31,33,45,52,58(oncogenic)

MMWRDec16,2016

TheNewsv TwovsThreeDosesofHumanPapillomavirusVaccineNewPolicyforthe

SecondDecadeoftheVaccinationProgram- Markowitzetal.JAMA.2016

v Immunogenicityof9-valentHPVvaccineUsing2-DoseRegimeninGirlsandBoysvsa3-DoseRegimeninWomen– Iversen etal.JAMA2016§ 1377boys&girlsages9-14§ 97.9%seroconversion4weeksafter2nd dose

vACIPDec2016(AdvisoryCommitteeonImmunizationPractices)• Routinevaccine11-12yo• 2doseseriesages9-14(0,6-12mo)• 15-26:3doseseries(0,1-2,6mo)

MMWRDec16,2016

5/23/17

6

Conclusion

vHowmanydosesofHPVvaccineshouldpatientsreceive?

• If2dosesinitiatedbeforeage15years,nofurtherdoses.

• Ifseriesstartedafterage15,3dosesgiven.• Ifvaccinationscheduleisinterrupted,donotrestartseries.

MMWRDec16,2016

Case:BingeEatingDisorder38yo womanpresentstodiscussweightlossoptions.Shehasdifficultywithportioncontrolanddescribesweeklyepisodesofeatinglargequantitiesoffoodinashortperiodoftime.Shefeelsthatshecannotcontrolherselfduringthesebinges.RecentlysheconsumedanentirebagofOreosin30minutes.Shedoesnotinducevomitingorexerciseexcessivelyafterbinges.BMIis29.Whattherapywillpreventbingeeating&reduceweight?

A.sibutramineB.self-directed- cognitivebehaviortherapyC.lisdexamfetamineD.sertraline

BingeEatingDisorder• MostcommoneatingdisorderintheUS

• Lifetimeprevalence– women 3.5%(vsmen2%)– obese 5-30%

• DSMVCriteria– recurrent(>1x/wk)over3mo– brief(<2hrs)– psychologicallydistressedbinge-eating:consumelargeramountsoffoodthanmostpeoplewouldundersimilarcircumstances&lackcontrolovereating

• Currenttreatmentguidelinesareconflicting(AmericanPsychiatricAssociation,NationalInstituteforHealth&CareExcellence)

News:LisdexamfetamineforBingeEatingdisorders

vBinge-EatingDisordersinAdults:AsystematicReviewandMeta-analysis

- Brownley etal.AnnalsofInternalMedicine2016.

Objective:summarizeevidenceaboutbenefits&harmsofpsychological&pharmacologictherapiesforadultswithbinge-eatingdisorder.Methods:systematicreviewFunding:AHRQ

5/23/17

7

Results

• 34trialswithlow/mediumriskofbias• Female:77%• Meanage:36-47years• MeanBMI:28.8-41• Treatments:6weeks– 6months

Brownley etal.Annals2016.

BingeEatingDisorderTherapiesTherapy Abstinencefrom

bingeeatingDepressionsymptoms

Weight

Second-generationantidepressants*

Improved(RR1.67)

Improved(MD-1.97)

Nochange

Therapist led-CBT

Improved(RR4.95)

Nochange Nochange

lisdexamfetamine Improved(RR2.61)

- Decreased(5.2-6.3%)

topiramate Moderate benefit(58-64%vs29-30%)2 trials

- Decreased(4.7kg)

*citalopram, escitalopram, duloxetine, bupropion,fluvoxamine,paroxetine,sertraline

Brownley etal.Annals2016

HarmsofTreatment

• Notreportedin– Psychologicalstudies– 20/25pharmacologicstudies

• 3Trials=lisdexamfetamine– Sympatheticnervoussystemarousal:RR4.28– Insomnia:RR2.8(CI1.74-4.51)– GIupset:RR2.71– Generalsleepdisturbances:RR2.19– Headache:RR1.63

Brownley etal.Annals2016

Conclusions

• Inadultswithbingeeatingdisorder:– Increaseabstinencefrombingeeating

• therapistled- CBT• topiramate• lisdexamfetamine• 2nd generationantidepressants(i.e.citalopram,escitalopram,fluoxetine,fluvoxamine,paroxetine,sertraline)

– Reduceweight• topiramate• lisdexamfetamine

Brownley etal.Annals2016

5/23/17

8

Case:Cranberryjuice• 36yo womanrecoveringfromrecentE.coliUTIstates,“mymothertoldmecranberryjuicetreatsUTI’s,isthistrue?”Youtellher…

A) ThereisnoevidenceoncranberryjuiceandUTIsB) Cranberryjuice/capsuleshavenotbeenproved

effectiveatpreventingUTIC) Cranberryjuice/capsulespreventUTIsfornursing

homepatientsD) Wrongjuice- tryorangejuice

Background• Cranberryproanthocyanidins

– inhibitadherenceofE.colitouroepithelial cells

• PriorstudiesUTIprophylaxis– women78.5yrs– 300mL(~10oz)=36mg– dailyx6months– decreasedbacteria&pyuria

Howelletal.NEngl JMed.1998Lavigne etal. Clin Microbiol Infect.2008Avorn etal. JAMA.1994

TheNews

• Effectof Cranberry Capsules onBacteriuriaPlus Pyuria Among Older Women in NursingHomes.– Juthani-Mehtaetal.JAMA. 2016

• Objectives– effectof2cranberry capsules/day

(72mgproanthocyanidin)• bacteriuria+ pyuria• womennursinghomeresidents

MethodsStudyDesign

– Double-blindplacebo-controlled,efficacyRCT– 21NursingHomes:Aug2012-Oct2014

Outcomes– Bacteriuria(>100KCFU)+pyuria(WBC)

• assessedq2months,followed12months

Exclusioncriteria– chronicsuppressiveantibiotics– ESRD– Unabletoprovidebaselinecleancatchurinespecimen– warfarin– hx ofnephrolithiasis– indwellingbladdercatheter– nursinghomeresidence<4weeks

Juthani-Mehtaetal.JAMA. 2016

5/23/17

9

ResultsNoDifferences

Outcome Cranberrytablets(n=92)

Placebo(n=93)

Bacteriuria +pyuria 29.1% 29.0%SymptomaticUTI 17 16

Allcausehospitalization 33 50

MDRGNBBacteriuria 9 24

AntibioticsforsuspectedUTI 692 909

Totalantimicrobials 1415 1883

Juthani-Mehtaetal.JAMA. 2016

Conclusions

• CranberrycapsulesunlikelytopreventUTIforwomen>65years,residinginnursinghomes

• SupportedbyCochraneReview2012– CranberryunlikelytopreventUTIover12months

MammographyScreening

TheOngoingSaga

5/23/17

10

Case

Ms.Smithisa50yearoldwomanwhojusthadherfirstscreeningmammogramwhichshowsheterogeneouslydensebreastsbutnootherabnormalities.• Menarcheat12,firstchildat32• Nohistoryofabreastbiopsy• Nofhx ofbreastcancer

Sheasksifsheshouldhave“oneofthose3Dmammograms”?

Yousay:

• No,Digital(2D)mammograms,every2yearsarefineforyou

• Yes,Digital3Dmammograms(tomosynthesis),every3years

• 2Dor3Dmammogramsevery1yeararefine• Let’sreviewyourriskfordevelopingbreastcancerandyourpreferences

Background

Wangetal,MayoClin Proc2014

• 50%ofbreastsaredense• Tomosynthesis (3Dmammography)

• Nowavailable~22%ofU.S.facilities• Variablycoveredbyinsurance

TheNews• Raffertyetal,BreastCancerScreeningUsingTomosynthesis

andDigitalMammographyinDenseandNondense Breasts,JAMAApril2016

• Objective:– screeningperformanceaccordingtobreastdensitylevel– digitalmammogram+tomosynthesis vsdigitalmammogramalone

• Funding– Hologic

5/23/17

11

Methods

– Retrospectivepre/postanalysisofscreeningperformancemetricsfrom13centers

– 452,320screeningmammograms• 278, 906digitalmammos (2D)• 173,414digitalmammos +tomosynthesis (3D)

– Compareddifferencesin(a)recalland(b)cancerdetectionrates,amongwomenwithdensevs.nondensebreasts

Results

AddingTomosynthesis (3D)todigital(2D)mammography1.Decreasedrecallrates2.Increasedcancerdetectionrates3.Effectslargerfordensebreasts

Resultsbybreastdensity

Raffertyetal.JAMAApril2016.

Takehome

• Forwomenwithdensebreasts,tomosynthesisMAYbepreferable(ifavailable)

• Butlong-termclinicalimplicationsstillunknown– Over-diagnosisrates– Breastcancermortality– Costeffectiveness

5/23/17

12

USPSTFGuidelinesMammography• Age 50-74: screening mammography every 2 years• Age 40-49: individualize decision to begin biennial

screening according to patient’s context and values• Age ≥75: no recommendation (insufficient evidence)

BreastExam• Clinicalbreastexaminationalone– insufficientevidence• Recommendagainstteachingwomentoperformroutine

breastself-examination– Nomortalitybenefit– Higherratesofbenignbreastbiopsies

» USPSTF2016

USPSTFGuidelines

• Evidenceisinsufficienttoassessthebalanceofbenefitsandharmsfordigitalbreasttomosynthesis(DBT)

• Theevidenceisinsufficienttoassesstherisksandbenefitsofadjunctivescreening(ultrasound,MRIorDBT)forwomenwithdensebreastsandanotherwisenegativescreeningmammogram

– January,2016

TheNews

• TailoringBreastCancerScreeningIntervalsbyBreastDensityandRiskforWomenAged50YearsorOlder:CollaborativeModelingofScreeningOutcomes– Trentham-Dietzetal,AnnInt Med2016

• Modelingstudyofwomenaged50-74at4differentrisklevelsand4breastdensitylevels

• Examinedoutcomesfromannual,biennialandtriennialscreening

IfMs.Smithwasinthemodel….• BreastCancerRiskAssessmentTool(GailModel)https://www.cancer.gov/bcrisktool/– 5-yearrisk1.3%(average);lifetimerisk12.1%(average11.3%)

Lifetimescreeningoutcomesfor1000womenataverageriskwithheterogeneouslydensebreasts….

Triennial Biennial AnnualDeathsaverted 4.8 6.3 8.4Falsepositiveresults 917 1197 2123Overdiagnosis 16 20 28

5/23/17

13

Ratiooffalsepositivestodeathsaverted(harm:benefit)byrisk,densityandscreeninginterval

Studylimitations

• Harm:benefitratiosconsiderfalsepositivesnotoverdiagnosis– Highlydependentonpatientpreferences

• Magnitudeofoverdiagnosis consideredinstudyisunclear

• Strategyforriskestimationisalsonotclear

Take-home

• “Screeningbenefitsandharmsexistonacontinuumacrossage,riskanddensity,withtheoptimalscreeningintervaldependingonwomen’svaluesandpreferencesforbenefitsandharms.”

• Triennialscreeningmaybereasonableforlow-riskwomenparticularlythosewithnondense breasts,dependingonpatientpreferences– NotcurrentlyrecommendedinU.S.guidelines

Yousay:

• No,Digital(2D)mammograms,every2yearsarefineforyou

• Yes,Digital3Dmammograms(tomosynthesis),every3years

• Ifyouwant,2Dor3Dmammograms,every1yeararefine

• Let’sgetsupplementalimagingwithMRInow• Let’sreviewyourriskfordevelopingbreastcancerandyourpreferences

5/23/17

14

Case• Ms Jonesisa75FwithahistoryofHTNandLbreastcancer12yearsago,s/pmastectomy,chemo,tamoxifen

• Today,BPis175/80ontheR.Yousuggestcheckingbotharms,butshestopsyou,sayingaboutherLarm,“that’smymastectomyarm!”

Yousay:a) Oh,you’reright,thankyousomuchforremindingmeb) Thatisaloadofbaloney,anybreastcancersurvivor

canhaveBPchecksonbotharms.c) Whatkindofmastectomydidyouhave?

TheNews• ImpactofIpsilateralBloodDraws,Injections,BloodPressure

Measurements,andAirTravelontheRiskofLymphedemaforPatientsTreatedforBreastCancer.– Fergusonetal,JournalofClinicalOncology 2016

• Objective:– Evaluateassociationbetweentrauma&armswellinginpatientstreatedforbreastcancer

Breastcancer–relatedlymphedema

• Armswelling,discomfort,andultimatelyimpairedfunctionduetocompromisedlymphaticdamage– Removedlymphnodes(sentinelbx orALND)/axillaryXRT

– Lifetimerisk;14.4mo.averagetimetoonset• Knownriskfactors:ALND,obesity,increasedageatDx

Commonrecommendationsforpreventinglymphedema

• Avoidtraumatoipsilateralarm– blooddraws,injections,BPchecks

• Onplaneflights(pressurechange),wearcompressionsleeves

• Theseguidelinesarebasedonanecdotalevidence,notrigorousstudies

• Placeburden/stressonpatients&providersACS: Lymphedema; NationalLymphedemaNetwork; www.hopkinsmedicine.org;http://ww5.komen.org/BreastCancer/Lymphedema.html

5/23/17

15

MethodsStudyDesign:singlesite,prospectivecohortstudyofwomenscreenedforlymphedemainbreastsurgicalclinicParticipants:632womennewlydiagnosedbreastcancer• allhadmastectomyorlumpectomy• 65%hadsomeradiationMethods:

• Prospectivescreeningforlymphedemawperometer(infraredvolumeassessment)pre-op,post-op,thenq3-7months

• Patientsurveyateachvisit» #intervalblooddraws/injections/BPreadings/traumaatriskarm» #flights

Fergusonetal.JournalofClinicalOncology2016

Resultsofmultivariateanalysis

Fergusonetal.JournalofClinicalOncology2016

Conclusions• Ipsilateralblooddraws,injections,BPchecks&flightsdidnotincreasearmswellingatmedian24monthsposttreatment

• Increasedarmswellingisassociatedwith:– AxillaryLNdissection– RegionalLNirradiation– BMI≥25– Cellulitis

• Thesefindingsareconsistentwithotherstudiesbutamorerigorousdesignandlargersamplesizewasused

Fergusonetal.JournalofClinicalOncology2016

Takehome

• Strictprecautionsaboutlymphedemapreventionarenotevidence-basedandwarrantskepticism

• WhatwouldyousaytoMs.Jones?a) Oh,you’reright,thankyousomuchforstoppingme

b)Thatisaloadofbaloney,anybreastcancersurvivorcanhaveBPchecksonbotharms.

c) Whatkindofmastectomydidyouhave?

5/23/17

16

Menopause

VasomotorSymptoms

• MinniePauseisa53yearoldwomanwhohadherlastmenstrualperiod18monthsago.Sheisstillhavinghotflashesandawakensatleasttwiceanightwiththem.Shefeelsexhaustedatworkeverydayandwantssomethingthatwill“reallywork.”Heronlymedicalhistoryishypertensionwellcontrolledonlisinopril.Sheisconsideringtakingestrogenbutwantstoknowifitissafe.Whatdoyoutellher?

Whatdoyoutellher?

• Whydon’tyoutryblackcohash- thatwillworkjustaswell

• Venlafaxineisaseffectiveashormonesanditisalotsafer

• Hormonetherapyisprobablyok,ifyoudon’ttakeitfortoolong

• Absolutelynot- noonetakeshormonesanymore

5/23/17

17

Whatdoyoutellher?

• Whydon’tyoutryblackcohash- thatwillworkjustaswell

• Venlafaxineisaseffectiveashormonesanditisalotsafer

• Hormonetherapyisprobablyok,ifyoudon’ttakeitfortoolong

• Absolutelynot- noonetakeshormonesanymore

ShouldIusehormones?

• Ok,sotheymayhelpmysymptoms……butaretheysafe?

Background

• ManyobservationalstudiesshowedaninverseassociationbetweenhormonetherapyandCHD

• Clinicaltrialshavesuggestedeithernooradverseeffects

• WomenintheobservationalstudiesweretypicallyyoungerwithHTinitiatedclosertomenopause– “TimingHypothesis”

TheNews

• VascularEffectsofEarlyvsLatePostmenopausalTreatmentwithEstradiol(ELITE)– Hodis etal.NEJM2016

• Objective– Tocomparetheimpactofhormonetherapyonsubclinicalatherosclerosiswhentherapyisinitiatedsoonaftermenopausevs alongtimetimeaftermenopause

5/23/17

18

Methods:ELITE• 643healthypostmenopausalwomenwithoutdiabetesorclinicalCVD– Stratifiedbytimesincemenopause

• <6yearsvs.≥10years

• Randomizedto1mgestradiolpluscyclicprogesteronevaginalgel(45mg)vs.placebopillsandgel

• Primaryoutcome:changeincarotidarteryintimalthickness– Measuredevery6months– Secondaryoutcome:coronaryatherosclerosismeasuredbycardiacCT

Results:ELITE

• Amongwomen<6yearsfrommenopause– Inplacebogroup,CIMTincreasedby0.0078mm/year– Inestradiolgroup,CIMTonly0.00044mm/year

• P=0.008

• Amongwomen10+yearspostmenopause– CIMTincreased0.0088mm/yearvs0.0100mm/year

• P=0.29

• NodifferencesincardiacCTmeasuresofatherosclerosisineitherstratum

Conclusion

• Oralestradiolwasassociatedwithlessprogressionofsubclinicalatherosclerosiswheninitiatedwithin6yearsofmenopause,butnotwheninitiated10+yearsaftermenopause

TakeHome

• Estrogentherapygivenaroundthetimeofmenopausedoesnotappeartohavedeleteriouscardiovasculareffects

• Thiscanbetakenintoaccountfordecisionmakingaboutestrogentherapyformenopausalsymptoms

5/23/17

19

Osteoporosis

BoneDensityMonitoringEmergingTherapies

Case

• Bonnie Bony is a 68 year old woman who wants to know whether she should have another bone mineral density test. You started her on alendronate last year after a t-score of -2.9. What do you tell her?

Bonnie

1) Let’s schedule it now2) We should do it next year3) There is no need to do it4) I have no idea…what do you think?

Background

• PriorstudieshavenotshownthatrepeatedBMDmeasurementsaremorepredictiveoffracturethanbaselinemeasurement

• WhetherornottomeasureBMDduringpharmacotherapyiscontroversial

• Treatmentfailureisuncommon

5/23/17

20

TheNews

• ChangeinBoneMineralDensityisanIndicatorofTreatment-RelatedAntifracture EffectinRoutineClinicalPractice– LeslieWDetal.AnnInt Med2016

• Objective– ToevaluatewhetherrepeatBMDtestingisanindicatoroftreatment-relatedfractureriskreduction

Methods• PopulationbasedregistryinManitoba,Canada• CanadianGuidelines

– Baselinetestingatage65– 3yearfollowupformostpatients– 1yearfollowupforthoseonAIorsteroids– 5yearfollowupforthoseconsideredlowrisk

• DXAdatabase99%completeandaccurateandcanbelinkedwithotherpopulationbasedhealthdatabases

• Outcomes:Incidentnontraumatic hip,clinicalvertebral,forearmandhumerus fractures

Results

• 6629womeninitiatingosteoporosistreatmentwherechangeinBMDcouldbeassessedatoneormoreskeletalsites– 85%initiallyreceivedbisphosphonates

• DetectablechangeinBMD:– Detectableincreasein30.4%ofwomen– Detectabledecreasein18.8%ofwomen– Stablein50.8%

Results• 61,088personyearsoffollowup

– Median9.2years• WomenwithadetectabledecreaseintotalhipBMDhadincreasedriskoffracture– 2.9%(95%CI:1.5%to4.4%)at5yearfollowup– 5.5%(95%CI:2.8%to8.1%)at10yearfollowup

• WomenwithadetectableincreaseintotalhipBMDhadalowerriskoffracture– 1.3%(95%CI:0.4%to2.2%)at5yearfollowup– 2.6%(95%CI:0.7%to4.5%)at10yearfollowup

• ComparableresultsforfemoralneckBMDandlumbarspineBMD

5/23/17

21

Conclusions

• TreatmentrelatedincreasesinBMDareassociatedwithadecreasedfracturerisk

• TreatmentrelateddecreasesinBMDareassociatedwithanincreasedfracturerisk

• BMDmonitoringamongwomenonosteoporosistreatmentmay behelpfulinidentifyingthosewithsuboptimalresponses

Take-home

• MonitoringBMDamongwomenonosteoporosistherapymaybeusefulinidentifyingwomenwhohave“suboptimalresponses”totherapy

• Unansweredquestions– Whatis“suboptimalresponse?”– Whatis“treatmentfailure”– IfBMDgoesdown,whatwillyoudodifferently?

AtypicalFemoralFractures

• Althoughbisphosphonatesclearlyreduceriskofhipfracture,therehasbeenincreasingconcernaboutatypicalfemoralfractures

• Atypicalfemoralfractures:– Transversefracturesoriginatingatlateralfemoralcortex

– Subtrochanteric orfemoralshaft– Non-comminutedandassociatedwithcorticalthickening

TheNews

• Riskofhip,subtrochanteric andfemoralshaftfracturesamongmidandlongtermusersofalendronate:nationwidecohortandnestedcasecontrolstudy

• Objective– Todetermineoverallsafetyandefficacyoflongtermuseofalendronateinpatientswithosteoporosis

5/23/17

22

Methods

• NationwidepopulationbasedstudyinDenmark• 61,990menandwomenaged50-94atthestartoftreatmentwhohadnotpreviouslytakenalendronate

• Outcomes– Incidentfractureofhip,subtrochanteric femurorfemoralshaft

• Non-fracturecontrolsmatchedbysex,yearofbirthandyearofalendronateinitiation

Results• Incidenceofsubtrochanteric/femoralneckfracture

– 3.4/1000personyears(95%CI:3.2-3.6)• Incidenceofhipfracture

– 16.2/1000personyears(95%CI:15.8to16.6)• Risknohigherinlongtermusersthanincurrentorpastusers

• Highermedicationadherenceandlongerdurationofusewereassociatedwithareducedriskofhipfracture– 0.73(95%CI:0.68to0.78)forMPR>80%– 0.74(95%CI:0.56to0.97)foruse≥10years

Conclusion

• Thebenefit/riskratiosupportsabenefitofalendronateevenwithuseformorethan10years

TakeHome

• Theoverallbenefittoriskratioisfavorableforalendronate,evenwithlongtermuse.

• Longtermalendronateusewillavertmanymorehipfracturesthanwillitcauseatypicalfemoralfractures

5/23/17

23

CurrentTherapies

• Bisphosphonates• SelectiveEstrogenReceptorModulators• ParathyroidHormone• Calcitonin• Denosumab

NewTherapies

• Abaloparatide– PeptidethatselectivelybindstheRGconformationoftheparathyroidhormonetypeIreceptor

• Romosozumab– Monoclonalantibodythatbindssclerostin,increasesboneformationanddecreasedresorption

QuickTake:Abaloparatide

• Abaloparatide-ComparatorTrialinVertebralEndpoints(ACTIVE)Phase3doubleblindRCTwith2463women

• Over18months,abaloparatide reducedtheriskofnewvertebralandnonvertebral fractures

• Moreinformationaboutthebenefitsandrisksneeded

• Howdoesitcomparewithotherosteoporosistreatments?

– MillerPDetalJAMA2016

QuickTake:Romosozumab• FractureStudyinPostmenopausalWomenwithOsteoporosis(FRAME)doubleblindplacebocontrolstudyrandomized7180womentoreceiveromosozumab orplacebo

• Monthlysubcutaneousinjectionfor12monthsfollowedbydenosumab (every6months)for12months

• Lowerriskofvertebralfractureat12monthsandat24monthsaftertransitiontodenosumab

• OnecasesofONJandtwoatypicalfemoralfracturesinromosozumab group

• Howdoesitcomparetootherosteoporosistherapies?

5/23/17

24

TakeHome

• Twonewosteoporosismedicationsonthehorizonandornewlyapproved

• Wheretheyfitinwithothermoreestablishedmedicationsremainstobeseen

TakeHome

• OCPsappeartobesafeforlongtermuse• NewHPVVaccinerecommendationsarefortwodosesifseriesinitiatedbeforeage15

• Newevidencefortreatmentofbingeeatingdisorder.

• Roleoftomosynthesis needsadditionalstudy• CranberrydoesnotpreventUTIs• Newevidenceforlymphedemariskdependingonmastectomycharacteristics

Summary• Estrogengivenaroundthetimeofmenopausedoesnotappeartohaveanydeleteriouscardiovasculareffects

• MonitoringBMDinwomenontherapymayidentifythosehavingasuboptimalresponse

• Overallbenefittoharmratioforalendronatefavorsbenefitforlongtermtreatment

• Romosozumab andAbaloparatide bothpromisingnewtreatments– Needadditionalinformationabouthowtheycomparewithexistingtreatments

Questions?