1/21 smsu march 16, 2004h increasing user acceptance of technical information in cross-cultural...
TRANSCRIPT
1/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Increasing User Acceptance of Technical
information in Cross-Cultural Communication
Thomas L. Warren, ProfessorTechnical Writing ProgramOklahoma State University
Stillwater, OK 74078
2/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Overview of Talk
• Communication Theory• Applying a theory• Conclusions/
Recommendations• Questions
3/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Communication Theory
• Provides insight into how best to communicateProcessPreparation
4/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Compliance-Gaining (C-G) Theory
• What the theory suggestsUse conscious strategy to
have receiver comply with sender’s request
Behavioral change only needed; not cognitive—you want the receiver to act a certain way (or avoid acting a certain way)
5/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
C-G Strategies
General strategies summarized (4)1. Rewarding—Promising a
reward for compliance2. Punishing—Threatening
punishment for noncompliance
6/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
C-G Strategies. Cont.
General strategies summarized, cont.3. Expertise—“I” know subject
as well as good/bad outcomes
4. Impersonal/Personal Commitments—moral appeals/call in debts
7/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Rhetorical Strategies
• Description• Narration• Illustration• Division-
Classification• Process
analysis
• Comparison-Contrast
• Cause-Effect• Definition• Argumentati
on-Persuasion
Traditional methods of development
8/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Cultural Elements
ITEM CULTURE A/B IMPLICATIONS A/B
Individuality and Goals
A: Personal, individual achievements; free willB: Interpersonal, group reactions; fate
A: Help advance; focus on self; “I need to do . . .”B: Improve group; self unimportant; “We need to do . . .”
9/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Applying the Theory to Instructions
Compliance-Gaining RHETORIC CULTURE
Rewarding Cause-effect A: You will be rewardedB: The group will benefit
Punishing Description A: You will be failB: The group will fail
Expertise Comparison-contrast
A: I’ve been there; done thatB: I’ve seen impact on group productivity
10/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Applying the Theory, cont.
Compliance-Gaining
RHETORIC CULTURE
Impersonal Commitments
Process A: You will accomplish tasksB: The group will meet goals
Personal Commitments
Process A: Owe it to yourself.B: Owe it to the group
11/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Sample Text
Microsoft® Office 2000 office suite opens an exciting new door to business computing for the millennium. Now you can work faster and more efficiently than ever before by using the wealth of new features that Office 2000 provides. That much you might expect. But Office 2000 also offers new ways to collaborate with other people who are using the Web, or with your company’s intranet. Whether you work with people in the same room, down the hall, or around the world, Office 2000 can help you in ways that you might not imagine.
SOURCE: Discovering Microsoft Office 2000 Premium and Professional. Microsoft Corporation, 1999, p. 2.
Assumed Reader: American.
12/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Analysis
Microsoft® Office 2000 office suite opens an exciting new door to business computing for the millennium.
C-G Strategy: Expertise (“I” know. . . .) to support Promise.
Rhetorical Strategy: Description.
Cultural Strategy: Looks outward to business.
13/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Analysis, cont.
Now you can work faster and more efficiently than ever before by using the wealth of new features that Office 2000 provides.
C-G Strategy: Reward. Promise of results from complying.
Rhetorical Strategy: Description of what will happen.
Cultural Strategy: Individual benefits.
14/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Analysis, cont.
That much you might expect.
C-G Strategy: Expertise. “I” understand you.
Rhetorical Strategy: Cause-effect.
Cultural Strategy: Uses 2nd person you; individual goals and expectations.
15/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Analysis, cont.
But Office 2000 also offers new ways to collaborate with other people who are using the Web, or with your company’s intranet.
C-G Strategy: Reward. Comply and get additional cooperation.
Rhetorical Strategy: Comparison-contrast between old and new ways of working.
Cultural Strategy: Working with others. But still uses 2nd person your.
16/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Analysis, cont.
Whether you work with people in the same room, down the hall, or around the world, Office 2000 can help you in ways that you might not imagine.
C-G Strategy: Expertise. “I” know what will happen.
Rhetorical Strategy: Narration. Presents “story.”
Cultural Strategy: Encourage improved work within the group. But still uses 2nd person you.
17/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Summary of Analysis
• Compliance-Gaining StrategiesRelies on rewards Promises from sure knowledge of
product and outcomes (Expertise)
• Rhetorical StrategiesDescription is the main strategy
used
• Cultural StrategiesFocuses on 2nd person pronoun you Individual goals
18/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Applied to Culture B
• To make it more accessible to Culture BPerspective should be more
“Expertise”—speaking with the voice of authority
Increase narration to show increase in group goals and productivity
Change pronouns to 3rd person to emphasize group
19/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Conclusions/Recommendations
• Turning to communication theory can help improve reader acceptance
• Especially important when developing cross-cultural communications
20/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Questions
21/21
SMSU March 16,
2004h
Contact
Thomas L. Warren, [email protected]
Technical Writing Program/M205
Oklahoma State University
Stillwater, OK 74078
+1 405 744 9473 (V), +1 405 744 6326 (F)
www.okstate.edu/artsci/techwr