1649007/2017/f & p (os) -...

20
r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3. (M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn ce00(8 m1cou3/0c8çjonrscn&uB msGITm(ID S3SO,6)S 2j0ea-i6mlth, r j(OjGMOWMU j& nioa 1nJwoCfl6J5 6IOCW]Q flGJTTh2J&U8 'D maupmmlaya a,inynlau8 3.1 cu1w1smmo Q3NOU)3(03nIILS 0U)WaQSGIS nJbflcw3cccms tmiou n13nno nDGIfl'n)6)s nsJoaeGI6 3.1.1 momioocThmmlGi 6 )an&c)€,js19uTmooa5 (0)1ø(UTth (fl)o(TUflQCfl C)2J aocno (Mj(b2r AJMaMnj ~(DMM)lMg cnjaIln.Jo 630 cmbOmoøor&JLS 1j9&6)S(S Ø)O aiGUo mi mt6QD(D)1q JatMm1&dS ø6n auo&nincutmoo uc&easrii &oeiS5 u cn3a icuxfl aø 08 (1.3.e(ffi.) GM(0152 mSn 0jO&QOWOGrT) ()1øQCfl1ae6kjiøaoD(a). cmbcmlcn3cn)1 2003-2004(8 ca,co r0&6)3(8 oQrJSCJlJ (tITG6)CTG) fl31QWO@ (3(J3(TU flJl)o flhl&1GTUIU)o CZBb(T)3ø3n9JLS (WOØ6LJ acnxnl (n n).ng)013,n4o3) OQ6)J C6ka206mo mSrq0a@Dm2§ 3sP a0lu dqol 0001 2004(8 coj1&,c5oa1. 3cim &,cnKnl cnomaoom BQ 0 &6 1 -I(86M somliD(m)1J36m (02nJlcthøl65. 2007, 2011 n4)(Ml .116313iCC8 @nJOW)Cfl)J &om ,Jao mc(5rmo6)s (rJl.n.J1.nJl.) nJQU()1 mSn. JOcOQ3CT) ((MM6M3@j 0 nJø3 fl)6)nJ. m16(nIt1Ths(8(n) COflJoSnJ(3 2013-flY3 U(thlcD)6)S (fl)OQ,(Th1cO, r.JO(3 rS3&6)KQ) r4)..Q&Oo. a&u 6>einjniç 2ib512a13 (n..o&oo.) dc8aym lnicOOøo (moCfllOOCfl fl)(8&6)3C G3C0 nJøifl) 33(1% (UTboWl&ølJ. @QT Q3(0)& ln.icthOøo C 0 EZJ 6 U (1)16) tj m1(3M23oSm(uo & (8(ThmnJo, CU)16)6)(fl)C13, &m1&u3, n1m008n3, 630qJaoç, tsocthn.S (au1.6M1.nn6ss1.) nDcm nJl.nJl.nJl. (010)1fl)1 eio&ni msm&. ()1øQ6 S6)6)rtJ esoc 0210c8&6 øoauo ao©co, tn.J&'Oøo 0006u uth1ee eafl n s&cx8, miono s1mioom nina, øunu8, o16nJa6nJo(6 ' m1nJco)6)s cnlaaQ]OGm JaxTh2J 011.6k4).nØO.nQ)(. aa6tJn) croomlnOCID CflM3cO6)0øO 006)JT)1(fl €1a &,s(D&&6)GI8/ m1aur5x8(53 o&s(8), 3(Mma,u, coocu5, nq1ma,u3, 6)&4is8no, u06m6m3u8, n njlojss ml8anosmo/0i36m308, 06 )J(mfll6 )co &ucu(Bcao)mo n)ffl)lOJ cmiaoms nja010o m101th6Q6fl)O6m. ø)(3Cfl(m(D6rflo, flJ1.6ng).ng)Cfl5.n2. CU)1(fl)o6flJ(3 2013(OS (?6fl (WJOWO@ aicunxO a8nejom&,u3 ea16m1Q2th016flOflfl; 3 , C(ThCth nJl.nJl.nJl. rY8citnj6rflOfl m1ø6)611mS&QOCfl0 ØGnO(T5X6 6mOnflJ1S1(mflOm ø6Jl3O a16Jce6cu3Oo a)]5212fl&Q lmj@Q n)61*1J1CO1cQ)O1oU 6&U3cft, 60 1 &,6rr8m3t.saaicr8 (.ni1.cm1.) a,ozo&,00xn 6x0ømsO1CflOQ)1(0(m. nJ1CTD1S, .nJ1Sfl)1. &191 nJl.nJl.nJl. a,(OOd1(a8 U sø1m6nJgøflmOGI3 .nJ1.m5I €o,øücö moCfllOO(T) cn)cB&Qocô MgG cmo o6M;(an j 3Col %j . aO03W1(8GY fl3ThCnjcø,&1 (nil .n)n4ic%1.) (To6VDJ flfl3çJffl9jflQ 2 Bç jl&. (T5ka(j1c-s no 1a/cmomioimla acwolBoa1OnX36fl%ftO6m3U3 tnJ,Oøo co8i1 ocnowan ccns1 =gm ; a n j(oj(a8 aizcrn mmoJa6m3u8 61 ' aseotaaoomlwbâ rnlotlo mcul$flQfla sSO&GJm1bQD3O@ nooaaajt00005 m1&m1aom asc*,tl.zzl. 21 cnn6m & nija .fM'' 5 eitDlpmi. ca3oao3 - nOQ1fld aJ,4gU eflzlp (U,. cnnm3 OLaOSJ4 cscrô fligns). nj)ntoz~a.enJ - o.niji4n5. a 4cno3niiso ym1nJ. 91 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) 2/23

Upload: dinhtram

Post on 10-May-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

r__a3nau\ocn)c

III

I 3. (M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I

m)ocnloocn ce00(8 m1cou3/0c8çjonrscn&uB msGITm(ID S3SO,6)S

2j0ea-i6mlth, rj(OjGMOWMUj& nioa 1nJwoCfl6J5 6IOCW]Q flGJTTh2J&U8

'D maupmmlaya

a,inynlau8

3.1 cu1w1smmo Q3NOU)3(03nIILS 0U)WaQSGIS nJbflcw3cccms tmiou n13nno

nDGIfl'n)6)s nsJoaeGI6

3.1.1 momioocThmmlGi 6)an&c)€,js19uTmooa5 (0)1ø(UTth (fl)o(TUflQCfl C)2J

aocno (Mj(b2rAJMaMnj~(DMM)lMg cnjaIln.Jo 630 cmbOmoøor&JLS 1j9&6)S(S Ø)O

aiGUo mi mt6QD(D)1q JatMm1&dS ø6n auo&nincutmoo uc&easrii

&oeiS5 u cn3a icuxfl aø 08 (1.3.e(ffi.) GM(0152 mSn0jO&QOWOGrT)

()1øQCfl1ae6kjiøaoD(a). cmbcmlcn3cn)1 2003-2004(8 ca,co r0&6)3(8 oQrJSCJlJ

(tITG6)CTG) fl31QWO@ (3(J3(TU flJl)o flhl&1GTUIU)o CZBb(T)3ø3n9JLS (WOØ6LJ

acnxnl (n n).ng)013,n4o3) OQ6)J C6ka206mo mSrq0a@Dm2§3sP a0ludqol

0001 2004(8 coj1&,c5oa1. 3cim &,cnKnl cnomaoom BQ0&61 -I(86M

somliD(m)1J36m (02nJlcthøl65. 2007, 2011 n4)(Ml .116313iCC8 @nJOW)Cfl)J

&om ,Jao mc(5rmo6)s (rJl.n.J1.nJl.) nJQU()1 mSn.JOcOQ3CT) ((MM6M3@j0 nJø3

fl)6)nJ. m16(nIt1Ths(8(n) COflJoSnJ(3 2013-flY3 U(thlcD)6)S (fl)OQ,(Th1cO, r.JO(3

rS3&6)KQ) r4)..Q&Oo. a&u 6>einjniç 2ib512a13 (n..o&oo.) dc8aym

lnicOOøo (moCfllOOCfl fl)(8&6)3C G3C0 nJøifl) 33(1% (UTboWl&ølJ. @QT Q3(0)&

ln.icthOøo C 0EZJ 6U(1)16)tj m1(3M23oSm(uo & (8(ThmnJo, CU)16)6)(fl)C13, &m1&u3,

n1m008n3, 630qJaoç, tsocthn.S (au1.6M1.nn6ss1.) nDcm nJl.nJl.nJl. (010)1fl)1

eio&ni msm&. ()1øQ6 S6)6)rtJ esoc 0210c8&6 øoauo ao©co, tn.J&'Oøo

0006u uth1ee eafl n s&cx8, miono s1mioom nina,

øunu8, o16nJa6nJo(6' m1nJco)6)s cnlaaQ]OGm JaxTh2J 011.6k4).nØO.nQ)(.

aa6tJn) croomlnOCID CflM3cO6)0øO 006)JT)1(fl €1a &,s(D&&6)GI8/

m1aur5x8(53 o&s(8), 3(Mma,u, coocu5, nq1ma,u3, 6)&4is8no,

u06m6m3u8, n njlojss ml8anosmo/0i36m308, 06)J(mfll6)co &ucu(Bcao)mo n)ffl)lOJ cmiaoms nja010o m101th6Q6fl)O6m.

ø)(3Cfl(m(D6rflo, flJ1.6ng).ng)Cfl5.n2. CU)1(fl)o6flJ(3 2013(OS (?6fl (WJOWO@ aicunxO

a8nejom&,u3 ea16m1Q2th016flOflfl; 3, C(ThCth nJl.nJl.nJl. rY8citnj6rflOfl

m1ø6)611mS&QOCfl0 ØGnO(T5X6 6mOnflJ1S1(mflOm ø6Jl3O

a16Jce6cu3Oo a)]5212fl&Q lmj@Q n)61*1J1CO1cQ)O1oU 6&U3cft, 60 1 &,6rr8m3t.saaicr8 (.ni1.cm1.) a,ozo&,00xn 6x0ømsO1CflOQ)1(0(m.

nJ1CTD1S, .nJ1Sfl)1. &191 nJl.nJl.nJl. a,(OOd1(a8 U sø1m6nJgøflmOGI3 .nJ1.m5I

€o,øücö moCfllOO(T) cn)cB&Qocô MgGcmo o6M;(anj3Col%j. aO03W1(8GY

fl3ThCnjcø,&1 (nil .n)n4ic%1.) (To6VDJ flfl3çJffl9jflQ 2 Bç jl&.

(T5ka(j1c-s no 1a/cmomioimla acwolBoa1OnX36fl%ftO6m3U3 tnJ,Oøo

co8i1 ocnowan ccns1 =gm;anj(oj(a8 aizcrn mmoJa6m3u8 61

'aseotaaoomlwbâ rnlotlo mcul$flQfla sSO&GJm1bQD3O@ nooaaajt00005 m1&m1aom asc*,tl.zzl.

21 cnn6m & nija .fM'' 5 eitDlpmi. ca3oao3 - nOQ1fld aJ,4gU eflzlp (U,. cnnm3 OLaOSJ4 cscrô fligns). nj)ntoz~a.enJ - o.niji4n5. a 4cno3niiso ym1nJ.

91

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)2/23

Page 2: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2076 00' 37 nY rftanJavOU,1& c]JtSntDcV3W eaU)V070WO Sff (Do. 4 (nJingyflXC2)J.th08)

&ld onS 6)LnJOOnJ30'O(8 QØ6)J (mej&nQ)n15.nil.) noBamoDfl. CrOo(TUJXXfl

m&aeo8 wmowl&,& cmJ8.n9)niiS. oøwOSOçjo a,ø &bffl&TUr&108

a)(0002o (cuJ1.otl.ng)) n Talci Cfl)O6cThtth nJ&06m3u8 m1&901aecro

øomuoZ soa6 1nfl1GQn91Cl6 air4 oac8a6q- o (ngo.ng)0i5.ng)m1) 'z

a32crD ffuOOnJ(fl613UB&6)O oxot&. nC6fl4CU) flJcö0616)C GThJ2 agoxm JaDcfl

06s 6a001Tho wa (strul.mJl.) Z4,089 aa,os1301 &,6TD&QOc606J)(D1

cm, (G'IM.CIØCIO.nJl. lnJcOOøO &,øOOc6,3øGKI) ml UThS()l0) ff100)

(36fl50.Do 1.63.&aQ cnø8o,m ng3q03o €esb lbJl.6.$1(Zfl)lCfl

Mf o6)njSm0t &,O6IUT) wmcruno3o n)crnw)ofløo'na. Q6flJl2sci1 wonJ

nl (nft.4 a1i)' cmnil m6k, jS0fliCT1) Joø0niwl wm0'\Mfl0Do

@W0()o nJ(2DC01 6ThJ2JflJl6i W0(j(fl) cm(wajomaloco) Z1,635 oaoslol &1aB

Smbfl&66)m).

curosocil anjo8m cm4 cnxu3 6)&1niflJ Gilanwu'5 (n).n1.n)d.n.ft

r4.) r4)CTT) &,cnjn)l ø01C06TO (m6m3rn6)s 630nfl(3 89GY). (7JTDOJ(8 Z1,635

a&osl Tuc8&Qoøl6X WmO1MOO(D)o UbG)çj. n .nØYTU.nil.nflfl) 26)6)2J

2015-(8 6)eJc8 630nfl (uTbOJO(SCW &,Qo 2015 630W 17ff) Cfl)oCTlitiOO)

ro8a6ocbo culb300i wl&lGlulmo OnJ0(8 6)6XaJflJ eilaqn.0 (auna1ErrxOxo)

cmathW8 no3 a,øxBn.Js&o ud5cm. &,Gfl tn910 &øoth (,ni&0bo

Cfl)ocTh000) aâaø0&(T) n0 (8mwl&,ocb6m3@10 cuTonJo,0u09J130 CuJl.0n4).ng)

(fl3.ng)Qj10) 6)63&,Q30Off1) c9,Cb06 croommoom (fl)(8&Q0(o fll.6)ng).n)0).4)JO

QOJ&T1) 2016 mnJcd1-16C15 6nj OJ.

ucm16)s GCUlflJ06W3&8

3.1.2 nilSmmo mm0moø0rac.s cmo curflci lnJthOCfl clOOfla t(a)cthU nJl&

3.1(tZ mZ&lsnt

3.1: 1iD)G)S cnlc8am36m 6),JPJflJo wmcTua33anøfl)lo

• - n3jenl - - . - . - - cnm(TtmOnO(aaT) olcmI

(1)0. CITh)JWQIDO -

SC .01&6)eJo 4,089 2,454 caosl a4TTSCn)rfllGmt%)10 3,635 OWbogl fli1.ng)nS. 0%(0,1

m1aam30Jo ca,cn3-cn20mmo(n cn.xsa,on2au5 a3O(Wo s)aJeJnflsao njauwll moej npj o61x&3Iao5, 9!fl1ej13U,fl' mspaQo. *vI:4 ncuZ 0J0mn)11 onbs1m)mcnoI3ftt

cnocwe,uS, Laxu&<wmo mlmo&0aD w11afl (w.a.oa)mnma w,5 0Joto omjnnaoZ. cs&n nj,.itn1cna,c qs'mj eJtqlo SILD.01. (p UIZØTZ)Cflo (IJ%OoSl

0050. açomiooS 18,500 SALD.W2. 0M01.0000Z 0C©fl 2J.8bO ofl

)0LO3)3tJA0fffl EI1BCIO% (7J6('J0St46)3<13 a,%Dcmo. n3a1caIn3 ao ejonjuft GThG4J3O31CCU3 a, 93830$, nfl° acu) ocux 40 oj($thlconflcl&02o. a.€nBcn)qedsmcw(S m1jcu1ni&smnflma.o OI($QO€rflQJO c)nu(m)161 0UbrMl 30 0Jfl10 St.00'o CU%COO gc4$(513Thw0c0$.

_________ nhl6mjo opucm nJ4SQ m1 m.e0nJfl)W)OGfl5.

2 nJ2i1, (U(U6flJ 1,463 3.1 &0Pi3O1Q( ,ilUi50 %JtUfli10) O8t€OJOW(O O)2OO flJ60fl13 wl a,cnZcm.t6m03x$ oTh8am1000. LDiPl=Mn nfl6fl38 CTUXT)

nJYfl110i9316)S - (fl)oct'UnDfl) CreS&Ooth ØflOJfl$ QaJeJflJOO2 Zl,463 o oIoo nJnr51ao0. m'k$2rlaGmo

a Q)JOnO 0i1OtflOCfl 1,973 _________

nJl&&1)ti010 cruocnimcn.um)1sl C%JOmD .flgJni1 cn1zzi1.eço.

(fl)'DA0S93I30S _________ 7,525 •. - -

camot&ao34 cimon1-tqto (a a.aajat) O)O.35/20141fl(,fl&&a n/C3fl011 32 O00 2014.

on(mzImlA.3ol Mn )ow3WMx3Rw3lma n.A.nJl.nS cca,nsaa&tS wmntnn3oo cnmSa1niao3 cnmnl smm1o,th1aeaoC6. QaJfl3flJ.S05 Ctl)t31530 cmmt CU01m3(ih1fl MOM.t1noaoa nJ1 001a39s co.Qjo3.O nncnjoo,1affi3tUl cmaa.am3 Cno cnll&thafli nJtfltadJndlO% aws.

nwiItMnol3IOl t.mjofl000iI fla01a0flJ5 amjn,t

cao(fll I.13,st.ci'. caoo1 ((.1.5 noSks1. canat 1112.2 nco.6tf9.O1. cnnr3 IV-3 a430.6t032.

n1a a m2nJ3T3 8

- min1athja 30.034 LnJa3 I1e mn528 cuyummatA nqjçpo mbcflQ0JSac0Y,. fge

0aa.cr2O 4èm3aSniQoS c$3(fl nOoo01aQ2aCWo oa13rn tmlwu,1 (]Nl3Cl GT33CWW14nO eml.

92

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)3/23

Page 3: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

=rtI I

e

(7&WJ 3Wo III- (&D(DJW(&D1WO7 630(W7Q

&6n&nni1a3 soo8 tn.JcO,Oøo njauoi1os nio&m1 [n-lni(801ThC90 a,o08 (2015 nwc) aoei cm8r&lcmmlmce,o n m1on1a6)61to)om, mmcu)OCD)co

201908.

ni1w1iuimo nJQDaD1c06)0(D)1 930(0) (TU(8CB6)3(3 J(0TTh1(08 (ffTbQ)2flJ(311j Z817.50 oaosl (ni11n.-u5.) njocoflcaü acwØI08 (s cu5kmo6nn8 2015) cnlcro2o ro61u1 nJ8n9J

1m108 mnoc8a m08aa,mcmosri%.

6)000tmo 0106)eJcru6njkl8 o16s 63o uomoomo 1.63.0e,Adka6 2J1O

cø,o. mfl .au1.s (16 630ww1 2019) .j(o)1o6iuoo cuo&qj1a,o o(8 (fl)o(fliUOCI) 8&eo(6I(n2 m08a 10)3Q) v ni000m Wlnfll0)i1U161 aanoa nJ003nJwl s(o)oocno nio lmlawna]oInfl

633a03 OJ(5n9JflJ10 6301 uoca)wmo nilazo B,6fl(0)O6th.

CiJ1.E1.na)nJ5. m1 so(bcu)m)(LoQoc cnoaco)lcm Z817.50 a&,osl fl)Q3o

cmlaflGke, m08a1(maB1oJe)cD (fl)o(ThIJOO) n8a€xxokn eJ€1a6)1(n) Cumamom fllnUl0XOTOfl6X (f00flthO(flo @OXflX3c6Q3(0) (fl(08&,6Tflo.

ca)ooucmm1n)o1n)1 atx8aQo8 n &6)(fl @acknes ajo uoowjomo nnsi6nXi86 OnJ3(8 nççç nil cr0)1moa51 nxnowlaoo.

nJ3jls/ nioml o1s6mo Jmo aY)1o8 86s1o. QnJ3(

)c108 mlcml a6r1&n).-s16rncnx8ae1 ei1ceQm nico1a33m(mmlQc cuorml cmcc)alomo flhlafllt0)o cru1.63.cu)l.o6)s nO3WOo OJ(8eto (0)08 momliiom nxôaeoolm mco3ca,immosn5.

S niaMlaolani6ral flJOfl1) 001 n36)ps1&6)08. (m1nJ6rTl-onoas3 oanQ8

OO66)1& r.)(mlflJ OtoCrUflOCD CrU666)3016X 0)2Jifl)061fl.

cozar nJuocoTu)acmml08 niauan1w&s m2alceinjm, cthO0(8 (flOBcthOS, th6n3mjralaZ €aooth rnlni eocu5 nilu0001 eu&aobowlaj. 63oao1ç 2i&&1\

611308 0)36)WnJfl(D)(TflflJ cmcn)lcocrn2.

o8neiom iruicelcni 065otoowlno1mni10 fllwflnJflJlo a jqmpm)20

(ni10)3OflJ10 (a1c0100ffn3 n4)Cfl ©1 S(0)Th1cth.

fl)tfl)DM3ce6)° toff 0(1) MZcOQOO1(fllthlS(D)l08 ulcn&s 6TIJOWS(Ma@~o QM§08@20 lcmoo't olcuflofl08 niati$a6m

oflct5 ma,cm o1oflii1eJoa6mo a,n8ntc9ja8 a,00nbei ninimi0008 J16)r1jsmlco)1&ao1cm6x0)m nj&auowlco.

niFsflGluTmo O216)J0)ml6i cnoenjS ni(8r&16)01m cth0a(1i16)2J QJ0

oomo/aonaai5oo&u8 -,n1aul6nileil1 jomcon,lxi (ngiinil(d 2015-08) sowa)ox]$1 nil. ).)(1) mlcwowl wm<e,00 n36flZ( & CWo(

(.&&nj.) ml lacwnonfl. sw1nio1cm j6nwla,1o8 nJQDUBl 6,S %10ngj 1560c6,6) (TUomJCflDtoj o s1mro)lfnfl&&Qlcm a6m&&,eJ

€thc18 .&6'6)OJ.6)S nJDl(flil6flileil2l ol 0(1(d nJfl(1fl OJOW0O) (ul(n1a33m 6W36) cmim3njnaio&el 6)lo,o6n5.

3.1.3 6)o(u$ a,ø m)eie,08 oop t(mlniol&&ecn.

3.1.4 rjaumla2os 1J2 nileiaonA ajaml omcm~o nuco)106)s MIGRO

(fl)0QD(0)Go 61m6umu8 coowl. jolccmowcno rioeim3U8 oo€c tnJ(0)lnfl&

fljlWiGTUlTho (0)06)J nJflD©l crunojlac,oci3 Qaqcml&cm mnaummmlmo nQ3&C(3UDo 50 cthl.EZjl. (GTO6)2J *flD16)2i &2QJl08 nJ1&m1nj1&QOnS

1.6 30b2j&&1 ql..01. (n)o.2l..)1.) aubna11o)1 21

93

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)4/23

Page 4: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

-. -

2016 0064 31 (if ca?aw(rvoml& QJ&n&(WW 80nn19 076nJ0(3S (00. 4 (&7.nO)0t 02Qô(/ö)

(mn)16)1 &6TflcB6)Oc66)&))-J (6)9Uni(a)o6fl1(3 2015 (08) 6)00(Ofl)O nJ(ID(U)l 6)aJGJOJ

3,693.48 aaos1 (flOCffl. (u10)00)X0) 63ø n )o.91..Q))0J1(D Z2308.43

cBaosl. o3)1xnos 000 nj1&izn5o o6LIaJTm16X

e,3øcuTufla38 630 n4)o.p1..aYnJ1G5 &Q0&6)6kj5 S1.nJl.Cfl01. &s(meion)l

(b(D. (3,271 ca,os110) DMIM L"JWOM&,006m0 ,JflJ6)S LnJ(b)lnJ03100

t2nJ06)2J L00)a 0LWl&U 6ThJQiQJ £,6fl)&6)36)1M0)lC0S cB<0flO

&,iurnio m\o )i20D) m1uneoa,u8 ntj1iloo&th.

V 0)000ae10 GflflDl(tl& )61U2J10)1cIDOloU OlCj0(fi

(60..an8-)11 0n33a1o&Q1061 U(m1YQS 51.nJITUI. Z4,089

os1to1 m112jth. 2013 (d M900OLGOO CW16)6)gWZCu

OLniO&g 010n10(85 631.87 oos1fl0D1 fl6)0&6)6)5l

(DCT1) ø611)6l3I3QS CO6,U8 (U)1(fl)OGfli& 2014(08 6ni1..onw8.

00000Q(nJ0Q8. 934.61 (2&,QslCfl)001 nl)..(BcOOo. flJ(8(U1nJ1sJ.

nJG&, 'o nJ(8Qsxn &,OøGm6fl3U8 63CTDo 0(06)1

sfla510cml. (lan926PiUWo o c08 nj1un1&m(U)nJ36)QJ

6rZD61J1308 n4)g L(TC)0(0D6TM36)S a(o)lcronna1o) Q(U)lrj

6)J2idi avii1.anoy8. (2013)-6)ai m1oeoeu8 ums1auoocoo06Q1 )s

2013 21(0)(08 2014 OJ6)(0 flJ(8no1nJ(0)l 5 cmcnaiomo cmawl€e,wl

6cx08 mo8ao 61% aY4)cT.cu)1& 64 ou gym mloael08

ni1m1a mlcoaô (2014 (U)1(1006Th(8 ai-es n16) mo,1eeQ06r

825.65 ca,os'b)ocxyl sw1..(m 1(8.(uxonocec)

BmJOU8 6m6m36)S 0112J C&,0o cfl)cO(0)1ønOl(5)03OD)l

U1j1JQB3D)1 6(0)6131308 m11&.ai1. <m1otaO03xY QMUflJ nJlGJ

njlamaeocs8 qffygoa nj8aixn Z130.85 c&o,os112

tnm16)6)mâ66 Z52.34 othos1a6)S crmwie, W(fl(fl)nOOfllo (130.85

&,QS16)S 40 ub(mo(Do) e1Qm1no1so&Q1.

O,6fl8SIIY10)( Ison rt3n9i1n162i 000?3608c90 COJGIE )CL(fl)0nlcB(0

6m61313&8 6Th10000J o&eaMofl S0006(0). (13TOeO6X0)

na3 oi1ooxi8 i1o1 ml l&ecncJ nqyn5

(rOotmoom n8a008 a)oJsl m(O8&,l (630w 2016). (01LDOJ0 (o)2QObl

CMMO(Dl nl(8Ml&e6)scmnJ)oø@Dal(08 QnJOeJo JTbflflDl(08 ni1ouo

ii1cSiq m(ae6)eU8 m3a1 jio€o. mflmom8

6)O(0Tho iilQJflJ ni&nce6)th166)Cm(51l(I) ng).BcthOo. nilancmnfknlalco)

fll(0&6)&6)6 (0,l1n)omo aol6GsaQmo)l.

ois1 (mJte,oma, aomGmo &Thl0nOQ0 621o01Tho aJ1QJCII

e6rDa6)o&6)lQ2)cBcj0U8 61s6m3o njlcncmnilmla ml el62J aiyul

)O(flo & m06)l6 Søt0)l(0(1fl. &S06)(0), 10ThOnfl613136)S

6)210(010)0 lnai1@idi rwlnla000S otJ1&lo5I6i QMMAMIO

(mOslmiOO(flo ne). .C&,Oo. eJs oQll(ocmlç. 0)6ZJf36)6 61)J0nfl

Ja(39S0&6)U8 000aolllw ml.nilxaiM./sml..(8. u86çjS

(010)11111 21(0)lcsJ10iOJ&,08OMOMMMOup nil.eng.ny1.nyo8./

(fllo(fl)flOO) (fl)(8&Q0(8 (m0oW1&øl&Q00101(m.

V 630cwl cuos)Jth1 alIMMMUB nJ&0(00 6)001(08 MD6MCkJ5 1%106

6)La108 ( 8.n)o.&.cnl)13 n)(m 6)sn11))o)(8 csoa&]6c1

mo LnJU)0fl nJ&,ø1fl(0Iu)l6i QflOi ( ø6W(OlmlCD) 2013(08 920J

ccsnJaGI m34, 6m3nn(ams1ntnm (01 36m(TOffEWaØIm 'eI1&o a)(T1iIflJ10

a1SO0).

OWOMO nJaU(ml O,JeJ(1) 74,089 0a3s10,,)l5 colifola ml ,000lyDie<mb, aWllTh !sis caosl a40 J1.

11 4).&ca3o E1m,m 2o1a1clfl3a6)l mfl.a%nb5 aoiai non u00101k1c4 nilnilw 'e.saioas ,'am

1a n011w1(0X)1o05 w1uoo1ato1.oean. 12

7934.9 ca,31-824.04 caosl+ m,iw1aa,o) cu1unii1oO)cIl thLtmnGIi, oro1o, .,Jeffin2o WASSQG.

13 is ni1cuo,im,o 65 61(Z ntj (TO& C13i 3110&nt1.

94 ______________________________

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)5/23

Page 5: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

cma(2vAowo 111 (GDU)2OJ(8(W)U) 63ocw7p

ic82ioø8 6)fflM60 -.Jo(8 S(A øo6)6)6fl1 (mbflJ(6)S 1Q3)1

0106aT31txZfl LnJcth000 T32.26 a&osl (1)1(Offfl. O1Q

OJ12i6Qt)go 1wEflu1O08cn10GJo 201402 O% Z37.34 GaDS1=000

oau1ao1m. nfl&-S1. n11w161u10)o 1(n6)s lçjnilQJ

nila08 Lamo aosmorfith a€oa11o1ocm omslaunom

nilei Z75.44 aaos1)o6m. (6136)W flJ1Si61D1U)o 1)o)1co)oQooJ)1 IDflJGIEl

QJ0(T1) n (UTjdn)o.&.(fl)1cthU3&6)M(0)IgDJIPJ()1 Z304.80 2&s1 cuøw1a,oio1 &smac,oa@rgofl.

630(U)1* e6GflQ5ITh0J108 CmD0(0)øo QniY()l0l&O01)

&)c18 (øooøGni 6).n fi.1.cD516)GJ) 18,000

a,u66 cumc0flm002 maoi nil nuonxoo

Gm n$TD. Cfl)oCTU030) Cfl)(3&6)O(2 mo2misl cno8ce,l

n4).'D.C&Do. .nQ)ac CfllD)6)S cunslm)nom cifl@i

GnJaMls)QJ ml&2q0t6m30 0DD(fl D(Mlc0l6)GJ 02OPJ (M(D@

fli0io a6Tnao16)Js mo6)6m(mo (fl)offUflOCY) Cn)C86Q0(3 flJ3&.

Q&n)03.nfl.2liD)l08 (fl1DOnJlQ6)j5 n)aa.(fl)l&U2 "0txJ(8

a~joa njcnao&m3" mln)l 65 1nc5 01 ni

KWQo6n. nilwlgizamo ooai)nmlmol mlmlemj my&no.

&.m)l.&o gom cn)ocacmla lOU),O2 flJfl)3flX?Dl

moo8 (n)ocfll030) &6)3&6)C 0nJSl (moWl&0leQOCfl3flhl.

(UTb(MnJO6)2J, nJlclgr?sm)o ma 01U)16i 6)0301O)o nJ(U0fl 6)JeJ0Jl08

usmlD)l 01D&6R2 n)CF1) 0rfl3lml6X 2J0)ljni1QJ

Z3.31 ce,osloEn ((slcninomniThi). nfl& nDo(yunom n)6e6)o0lcn

C01611l 0)026)J D)0&SC0* 60) @nJcthOGTflo 2014

(aoZ 201508 nilm&mo QaJ) nio6T3ltxm n)PO 6ThJ0J0J0

UQS 0J12JW)O) Z2.35 2OOS1)&Q06fl).

nJl)61t)o 0na16)jm1mlmo)l C1O6136flQ1) 01 366)0c8,0 tOø

amola Lsoa3cr&ajl,~6)oq(y5 njcowlQoci3 45nicaO6T1

)aDo6m m)ocnlnom cnx8aoo8 nes onsl nm8a,lcotth

(oiux 2016). 006)i cwnas2a* aj06u31 01 ooQa&,o

Q8cn6tm ncowuiufla5 acmnioemm5 cmoni niomo

m -6sa&uZ nil mo 1m8 u &oll5 cnoaa

ctnlo lc.1(U)&U LnJ30o a oocmo)lmom8 2nnJs1

(UTboW1&,(0l&6)O(DOQJl.

a GD CU fl O6)cth)S flhlcO3Cfl)CUO

3.1.5 as08 mlcsao (imioô nio6) axurusmnwm cnmlsito cnlc2no6Tno 0)S&6)(ThTh108 (0)c6,®3Q)l n)61iJlDlfl)0loCf 6JO jd6)t2O (UTCT8(t

&n2m3scea2 amoS (.n.il.cml.) ni 51 cns4Thio&eocn3m5 uolløm,m%. .ni1.

cnfi. (Anejom5108 nio alO@m 01cn16i 15 a ouimlcn108 O,6n8Cfl)

sismc3 Boni8 m n4lm6xmal08 (3t€J3Cfl.) QJC\C)JCTUD LnJ&OCb0 Ii3Otri3J6m

(Q)C8B6 6)6)0w G3On6 afl(p 6)0afl\Cfl)(6 (0 .63.r4)n1i(Ui,&.) mo1m(m. Jl(m1

0006)J Ca6)iSJD)16)2J nJl.r,il.nJl. nJflD(0)lcthU8&Q flhl@DflKflo 6)sFfl)0)

£6fl2Cfl)n9d08 £,00& (c-4)o.mil.n4).)'4 a1)J1 (ltJ(Th &DOOGmo, .J.COl.cft0O01CD

B(2J3(P3 flqO&6)c 6TgQfl (6)0W 2015). oLGnneô nio016)ccDo axtn)6mawcn

mlc3aEoGmo &,6T12Cfl)nSi6Tn1C3 ml nloe6)6n nil.n.ftail.

umll08 "aOGffiOJ3 ni2e" njym cn.ith1c58 Z1,463 aosl 6ThJ2J0i108

14 nj1.aj1 nu,1aiaej noa 1c.oMt&o ol 1cS mlo,atl c14 o1q,umDa jac,sad

MJo.tTol.,4). ccnuomq www.planningcommission.gov.inlreports/genrep/overviewMCA.pdf

95

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)6/23

Page 6: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2016 000 37 (IY J01)0077& 04n16)(D7W 670(11179 07og (i7o 4 (c,i7Xwjaot)

(DTøl. nCGIT(U n &6)1CO m1nJ(r1m) 6)Q(77177)O Qai2J0iO (fl)(8&QO(3 flJnfl1CcOQ61T

(0)0Gm.

.nJl.(fl)l. 6)SC o(30&6)1T)© th0(o6Th0 (flOoCfl)fl0(T) 6)0(0106 Ln1130)

mlc3Q2oGm (z0ej1a,6)s 0J1J6m1 mlo&€3 156)%jsr0)ocno1çj. m8lm08 cmoni

(fl1(0c676)1(O8 (0)6XID 19J6fl11flX$c66) fl(08QcGaGfl3l OJ(TD.

61Th61JT308 Lu1 01)0:

.u1.cru1. &,øo& ax6aomol a(5nJa63 Qiogoo n6mn-uo0

Oi(lio m1c3z(01aeocn (0(0)lnJ 6)aieJflJ 7767 O0S1)0)1 n4).WD.@cO)0O.

0)1sm0)11ø16)(m(0) Q03 2013-2014 2o(a1(03 ni13ot nil flhJfli) 0)10

aeløei niUfi)0m6U13U8 a006rflo 1,210 0&,os1oot1 Qx8(ThTh6)5.

afl6flU OJ(866) 4)(fl) (U0)O (u(0ow1&,(1016)0) s&n 6)aJ2JdI

ni16flo 1,463 aaoSlcO)OcD)l &o1m&,07)6fl30)l (n41nJl3 2015). aw

ut10)l ni06006fl3(fl) aIOO&,Uà, ga,o6nkce,1 (mjS c6J0cQQU3

njbc3utnflml mloth 6nJ0w0&6Th1Y(0)l0 630

m3b06mnio 61E0510(m1çJ.

2014 021 (fflcflcn)0106m øGôni nJJGIECU3 6061 1,210 6CthOSlt)0(D1 (ml sT0)la))6X0)Cm (fl)(8o6)0Cô ijonisl mco3al.

(o(nx 2016). L ml0i0)10) 6mowa,a)o) snJ0Wy0)&o

i&O &,61me0leQisaB6 &,(o0O&,0(3 20156)81 fll0c06)

au8ac mcrum20(al 1,500 aa,osl(n)ocn)l noullao6m6)o)nDoni

cmocnicstmla (n)oe,(mla (3nS0&6)6)S (JbnJ0(8(ThLflJcth000

croomlnoa) 600(DI6)81 6)otL&nlQ0(b0S m)(m0U)l&,00 kml' 5

a06flCU3 n3ococ6S lnJ0aJ8ifli 20156)81 ml&€$koZ T1,463 aaosl

onl ni Dl c jl&6)00 m10t3(Tfl3U. -1nsrwu3 ni&&Gfl6X ai©l6ThJ2Jn

&,1nxth nJl.nJl.nJl c3ci000t1(a ce,00nlZ m C&6)0C)1(fl) nil.l.

n4)1t. nJOaOQ]Wl flOQc0 nQ)(m QUC0T77)0S2 cD,sl (thQ)l00D

4Cmo (n)o(ThflOO) (fl)&&00(8 nJO6T010).

OnGmCLJ ni &,6)S 23(ølt 6)sjQJO 11D)10 nJ02Ofl1U)l wm(m

n000o

uo6)cuscm 63C0 63(01 630a0(3 (001(W6)Q nJl.nJl.nJl. e,00nlm

r,@(TDO)IMO(O8 QOOJS1 alocEbOOSMW. 03Th6U136X1) 0000&QQJ0CI

nn6IEnJ3 nj(8ae16)n 0(mlj OaJGlfli 10X0) LW0C (ThnU0O £,OQ)ffT)

(0)10 a00GmW0)l. u1wol GooS(Djj9@gCrD niDOcG,US 2l(0)QJ0')

i'S& nil(2r3u nilmla ai&Q niyth1caomo 6niow001(0()16Xfl&6)

ol 03nisl 63fffl0 6fl01fl)l.

n)..C&Oo cO,6Tfl600&Ql07X0) LnJB00O CL6M&65 CU0 (DloT0)l0)2nJ

owl6&6)6fl ni0fl&,6)5 Q(m1njC1J'IQi (312.85 t,osl) nioo a,smeio

ofl0oD. C ocmui6)ei MIPJQJIPJgOO nJl0JGmlmlQi unjm3nincio&o1 (C)

26)i )6flhl(fl1)OloO) nicen (n)4.aDl.) 0(U)1cth0i aii8inJ000

(mslcn1con)0o6)C0)i0US ,jleidi (250.48 Caosl) nixo &,ncii (mfl0

cm. om cn1o&oa,o (mQIl2i )J\0)\00Uo 62.37 Cmosl (UI)l0an1.

nJ0flcB6)S "eimo)o, @OOo (t3ThC)J &,S8Th08 S01) 01(0)1, nJo00nJ01cOQ00)O

pimcno j00. o mooio1aQ0(no fl)ou,l&G)(m ai086m3Q, &,scmml

6)&e06nCoJ0&)(08 ecnqlnS, ngymlni ni (n3(m2ooycmlcno8io (3rs&,0

0?) ce,32JOC)JCfl)fl ce,o06mnJo nhIWlGlUT0)o niaumlao0aimsmom niOC

,ffiU8e6 (-010c065 ng)4sU)l. ml0a6)& 0)l (0)00(0)Q)< O GmJ(p,)omonJl

nfl5 Cfl)oCfllCOO) (flX5&00(8 (0flnJSl (flOScB,l (630cnC 2016). nffI4tJ)l

(U)0Q0C6fli(fl)l8iO n.C.th0L2il6X lCWl2iO usmlcx)1&e6)cm

is cmflatOQOJM(U) mflnoa&& ole 1nm,o1)cmlm31 no,cmcam nt4aa3 bSla&aJ.

96

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)7/23

Page 7: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

rwaiwJO@o I/I- a J(v(xn

G3QØ ()ø(ulTh1QJ @QøflJo 1n 3O6)S (fl1(D&Q2o

§OGTT 6IUi6MU8 cmonaio malmoa8 a3ohn.Jsl

U()1cE0S W d(bQ13UDo o m1anJcawa'n) (fl&bO(fl)\(Th

3.1.6 trumi nioei (n)(18.nJ1.oil.) uo nja kn&s wmnJøoc cm

6I3o JS,o )W2fl2J niyDato 0OW6)W1D) OJ1GJCfl1Ø&Q1058 cm4aJl

1&ecm. na&nj1oi1.cj2sIymmlffl laY3 niøm Jwmilaw aioumaa msjo

cO6)0QJ1. cO,0(0611)o, nC1$.nJtflJl. nilgalOMIMI ay)36,9D36)6m&03 omwflcnthmno nJflU

cm1fl0$ m1cmo 1€eQonim nJ01J16c06Q008 asp0$ omc1mo'n1 GmJGjnjO&,o

ymo6n5. c86m0$ aoç7 coru5 olagm$ (n.08-m!4) n)cmth 630 mlCc&aJ

nJOIU)10$ aikmo WMnJMMOQX om6Mu8 eji1eecm 0001xn a,n1aQ(n.

&ea6moai1 6) ).c tawjB. (.Qnq.cørc&cmm}) &enoail nCT8.n.J1.flJ1.

(.n)a$.n.i1.(ul.) @(MjCjIcDW WfflnJOØQU 0M56MCf8&@j nJOC

m1cmo a nsmd6noaaD a39 am 8-c 3wi2Jc1Ja1Mb6m36)S

(fl)r&S1, cnbslcnaoom muTdmos njte,cn)cno mQJOCnOJ ce1s1 J01wffm1&6Crfl.

aa,im n$&Q0016i wmaoco aamOeiD)o nJ06ysoJ1 nJl.nJl.nJl. nJQD(l

QOC8U(n1(32QUb6U3U8 ln.Jcth000 63(o nJ(DGDl mS,JO&QGmC0O

anJcreao)o nyn5 c)1coajocn1a6oa$ .,gyr&cJ1.aJl., g)mj&anj&, nym1ni

cucr.Jaai0e06mo. 6)nJO(M6)CiJ Mmm1cn 0)06)P r4)C6.nJl.0il. Q

mSJD&QO(T3 -Josl.

(fl)o(TUO3CT) 0Q0&aCaYo flIQScD)o a)1a&9dnJnJ10 ng)Ct8.nJl.flJl./ 6JQ $I7 nCm1C)Jo nJglcth 3.2oJ1(3 (ThO0(D)20

6)aJct(?B101&QCrfl

j1a 3.2 (Tt)o(TUOO(fl a (8aQ3cb1C(taY10 a T1)Q)fl2CSD)0

fl)lCadinJflJ2O C(fl6W3o (mTh1eJ 0)Dt(u)a110

. . . .. cu,lcn3a,'ogtt 6M (ZIØJ

0)1Cfl21G . Q53 . 0L1.Qft '- ai1nJcDmo

(?caas1coflo) .th3a(thn1C3 (T ca3s1iil<S) ( 3(1)0)

aao 5,071 13947 (-)3 86633

3.72

cn)c8eeoc8 (67 ov(vøa(0o)

2,454 1,30,706 607.19 15.00

(33 cowøo(no) _________ 7525 1 44,653

(wOra€Jo6uio n4jotwç4) & WJOW (0)UJfl)JOWI(W (fl1JWJWJJ

nJl.QJl, nØUfllQi 630a)

a,1o8 m1tmo a)1m1&ai1aQoni1amo Jau0fl(010$ 67 ubo)aomo QW)08 aiS

(fl)o(TUIDO(T) (ThC&O6)00161 m1aesfr,Jcmm1c)1 n)(T&nJ1.OJ1. (-) 3,866.33

aa,os10 (UTb60) CflQtDo 33 uo(momo 3(0)0 MIM08 asae i6mai

fl6)S 40 r&iGXtlU) 01Q& (UTU)'lGi r4)CT$.nil.flJl. 607.19 a&os1Qøo6m. &,SO6)0)

€Jau(m1ca6)s 2cmorzila nØa3.nJl.nil °. (834.60 6th3S10 .6)n).((t(Il(8.

8.9 uoc)aJomnJ1oo6rI. ,oflmoo8 uomoommin eje1aecm a omioimla amo

Cfl)omiOO(flo ms(uImlcn) fl16&1JCa0)1(15 cmo(m1&we4.

16 nj&ma,o,eJo as3n1 o,j mdea3ulas "I°S

3aQ2(Tfl17

Cfl1OSQ3O1N j.&Q&

mnmaóla cmwn!uoscuo nJ(sm33cn1eJo eJ3cm1QflaQ1O)) o,10a0,4n%

g'°2 o,lcnhiAaS nj00wm30$, Qm tnO0 flI3OJ nJNafla2flfl &01Cr,3a.'DO4 t)10aQ3fl GDO%.

Is O Th4"QJSm3nIO1,D CCT)WIQS aon1 CCa1 JS2OIO)t)ThO10Th5S xtocepw.fl mto.,j.naJotnaJa8

O) GflUU1 (U)JO3aO1tOI .OnJJ.OI3{&GRflS n1cp5b cnlan3mS.

97

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)8/23

Page 8: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2076 o84 31 o' a2iovom7& W ,aoww eoaLM ma 4 (ai7ngj(T.JJo5)

(2i1 n4 S&6)OO 6YD) 6)nJQJC)J .e6mae16)eJs.eeoecu) COiGmo fllanJlCTS30i ej nini amaoanioo nm5 n&eoo onjsl mmBcel (ow 2016). tomflOOITh1mn3&,CT1) 00o6m3u8 eQo&6xniou3 cnxnxcjs mhxiS.e6 oocty6moa,(m cZ(fl56313o nlW1l&6)61fl6)2Xmo GDoOUflQCfl cnxa&eo(a

2X)oJ5l (n)j1aO(D,zE. a0D6mo (fl)o(O JO) n3 Cm56m3o nic1wmtj &6TT) &coaG)b) .nn3.nJ.ni1. imm1cn (t)O6)WD)o n).(mfit(m. c6,Sfl3m)cth 6MQMdd)@ [email protected])crn (MajO 15 uaocncru)16xnac)ou3 nioo .thOOJo (1t)1ø(flD. 6)3(616)C n)0Z.nJ1.fli1./.6)nl).(m(&C31(3. &,6m&e0&c0 m301 1@s ulisi nJc61cn6m1a000 aoøGmo Dm)1QnJGC2O(nIB@j(M65

@ 001 1&eo0jm1 txöan aileinitisS L&D0O671

ngsoim 01afl0915 .4)nmm06ni. oouooçJ &m8 ©oai um1ss n)fl.nJ1.flJ1./.6n4).fl1j(&(Uiby2. $6ID6)0aQ1)CO0 @21 n9SQ3CD 6ThJ2JflJo (mom)noa) mic8aøoaøo Qil.6 ).nQ)Cfl3.nQ)3GO nJODW)1

(TOoCfliflDCflo mscmmcm mlcBe iasmi16xI 630 O øm'rmo flh1CTh,eJ0)o 1orn1. nJ(01(fl)fl1(U)1 OlII°PJOW) nJO

o16)QJ (.6n).n).) Qm50-6mjGJdI nb cnmimbcn a1c1& (mu)1)1øm) .G &(I3j(8 Q -uoeJo Cfl)J&0(OAnJE%31T)6)S (fllcB.&adnio øD(W)o JøbW6mio6TT &,6maoo.e6)1nx65.

G)s8mIc(n,.,u(d c6)aa*

3.1.7 an8cnjnn3 cBOOd16i ce3Cfl3 38.3.5 cnJa000 amacnnaion &oenn.iwl O0fl]JO0, 1)C10n9i08 &,3GJQflJW1cfl6S 031flJCTUOC1) 030(fl)o eir13j n16)e)aI(M 6flJ103 nnl6)s njW)t2S6m3 £,6fl3(fl)n9d6m)C8a (TOoffOflOO) CTO(8&Q3& cnc68smo. nfflLnJbWB 2015 n c86nñm3(5c5&to(ii (.&6)6)ni.) onoe1n auowymo nioD nl&.qAg LnJO(o a6n&mcra .aoioniw1ues mom8umoo nunqio )6)2iCfl)

6nJl&3 nfl (mflDb J&(Bc86)Oo n rnQCDb&QCfl)(th Z7,822 c&,os1cnom. aci8cn1 000 &&n3cnnaici3 &0aoniw1 (40 ni(3o)

oaniiou3 ml imioao n1jym ombo8 (20 QJ(8r&16)(O1O) ml1 cncts&,wa LDqjomlojanoa8) a&fl8 nJnGitTS) ninimin unam&

mScs,&n @s3mti3 aridool 19,55519 e)osbro6n. o16x n4)OtnJl.CB1.

567.10 cZ&,os1D)39Y5.

61Th6fl3&3 GD36)W aJflD)(TI) a3n6m3&8 mblaai1j

> .&6cuD6s (m&nomLiJao(0o 40 0&,QP6)00) O,Gfl3(TUnSd(T8 &o2ioniwl

01(08 (fl)o(flIfO(fl 0\X866)3ø1(15 QJ1aQaD C8p6)&. nJøW3(flo 713,947

GcO,OSICDD6T75. Z19,555 C,%OSI 6s&ai1cMnaia8 a9cmou8 (fl)oCfl)flQ(fl m)(&eG)onbn$ C1fl&16T)o D(3)1D)1CC8 (D1(Tflo 40 n96M3Q866)

6&bnalo eJstec)cm flTh3O(flo (-)5,608 os1a)3Q)1m1.B6)0.

> &,6n&nti3 &o2ioniw1, 1ocue (ni1a1.nnii) crtocnlnom nj8&eo&o5 n08ce,6m nJøøomo flJlafll©o, (M2JO) nJ(D()l JScth6l313O8 n)e3o

W)6)Cfl) a8a 1n51a3 ms cnla&ai nJ(UtmlC(EU53 15 UDmQQmo 630..0(6] @ng).Q 8.(8. 2JgleQ6m° ng)CTT) }UD

aJt2 6)nQ).((8.(Ui(8/ng)0.nJ1.nJ1. a6maQoanm5fla 6s&mradcl8 znJd6)0i sThb1cbcm1çJ ng)CT1i

67t56m3u3 n1øle2ai1. (umauep1m10003 am@s m1o&ijaow

fl,454 c.e,os1)1acr2xoS .thm3nt,&l6mDx8.04 eJ&aQ0T) 6)n).aTT4(&031bj3. 16.08

UOMMOM(blo CfllcE&tnJWYO)161 ny1tnil.flJ1. 842.57 OOSlaOctho. (UW803)

rua)o (fl)o(flIJOCfl Cfl)(&6QO0161 MIGcOMnMOM Z5,071 O&3S1cfl)1Q02R3

19 !7822/1230.

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)9/23

Page 9: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

(warwJatwo III- jaiøTWm 63ofl1)7

OomUOm(m)1Cfl2 eE1&ecm .6) 8.ajt nj2coTmlcn owno

a6.nJ1.aJ1. (-)4,441.40 Q&os1cn)20 cm,cn)1co1ce6)0.

> &,S36W3) (fl)o(TUIJOQ) cro(8c)eo(DI6)Cn (omQDl3lSO(0)Th3O nucm1cn)6)s

7.59 (Th()øDCflo ø3(j)flJO, .ng)CTa.nJl.flJl. (-)1409.70

6cD,OS1I233T1.

> Thø1umo ao zym)16)c £,crn)tY &,c0001(8 6)çjS

cO11c0M0anJO6)2J 6,s(821omr&1a i6)21 m8&,oco (nimiri&u3

6)6)nfl(3006fl106 6)Q121SO nJflD(ml 6)8e4)C6.nJ1.S1. (flO2JOo 6)SC301iX3 cziw,

aocn ,j1.,j1.u1. mskrwDom my&,m njls,cmm ,.jau(thie,6)s agn&Tu

r&i08 o0a108 p1nfl(3mi 114)(M0 6Th6m3u8 n1(O1coai1aj.

n)o.(TUl.nO). lnJ&,DøcZiO6Tl) &JOt©ø) QJOJ(1\1O a,øonlcl58 u s2cutu)1pocmcm oil.

6)c4.nyn5.r4)ttZ 2onJSl cnø8cefl (ao& 2017). Os(ÔaBC(DthKTÔ C6)01 &,O(DGTflo

mx8&e 2Ji1&6)fffl c1bwla oJcba1O(flo GmQ3&6)&,)3 nQ)Oô.nil.flJl/

almlaaznø3 suma,ccnn ulomøloo3

D OnJSl Toowto&seomoculJ.

jamats cn8a8 .

3.1.8 o&,1a3 oill2io&n3 ce,am1n&Ja nJo6jsoil1 OJDthUQø6thO,(J8 lnJ&000 (pJl

aionlacraioS (jl.a2.) ooasthcw6m3u8 Jl5sCø1m6fl3( roca2jø

mo lm11o'n uoi8wtuxi o ø ocn cnioonjm

6G136) (jathr&1lc6QcO n)cTfl a ocm)o6)sa,octh6mo. an(5)lmo(8 ©6Xm nJl.cO

a33mB6flXWT3U8 a au&joio umaaxmao cu&oio cnb00auoOa2fiøl&6)

6mo.

njoGm1Th Q3(oJcflJl(O a1crno O)D6PnJoa1)(rfl lID)OO)611T3C13 61fl6U136)S

aul'eiscna,%3 wcbcmml'n) WOc?63UU3

3.1.8.1 mci1 O&6)6 cnuyoonfl r1 UrUlcQRml(02G0&&lo oil.6)n).ng)Cfl.

Dan1cn)6)s noSM01W 02JQD a096zu3u3 niømml. i m MOg

€unu3 oiø mlxo5 momin3m oum3uLeoni6rEl anu1 (UTCTU2L()6fl) &,W231

nS1C1Z nJ2OWTD)locOG)lcfl) ajoca,3 &,m&mraia aø08 (r4)o.cni1.n)) (fl)O(flUOCfl

(TU(8a00(8 CUTboWl,& a i&3o®colaoqJnJa,(8ceô nJQUCl

a,S)W& (t3 aJ6m1cn)ajoe6)a, r4)CIl) @OQU u33QS)3Gfl) QT 023 QJØ

(mmlQyc?D. n4)o.m)l.ng) lescnwl nmm6ctJ UUOWOT3U8-(.n0.2.00 c)oøcmao 1Jdk0' nJ1cO, 3.3 niB acti8ce,l

cn)lcblce6)1cm1.

ni5lth 3.3 rUQVni)1 "eJs(ncx?)lcu OJni imlini W36lfl36)S W1(0G3o&01n3&S

(%&fl4)êd5.flJ1/atha8CTuflIa3ani3<

_____

1 nJQD(OTil OJltth(flXfl J3( iGJ3(&U3 piong QaJO(B(U), (1tJ,3ø fl)(BOJ1GD 23ni)6,&,

________________ momla OS ai1iubmo

2 a,6ltTwsc a,oejoniwl oiaoaQl monjniCUörSo. nico)nic8naio âis1 (1)151 coi1ç4 mw8aoo

3 (1fl6).O fUQDIThl 6wocil Z3,900 aaosl Z4,089 aaosl

4 IJIGflJ96 01356, aKafl)S6Th QaCrUT 1,463 aaosl 6WOOJIM8 a6T1CU5 0JC8th6) (U%(0)1

atom cmoaQi al1a6um ai&mmB nixm ml&qjnnla@ao mlBazoGmo

5 ©aJ3(8 n)a9 Ohlcth aJO(6QlJl51G4 cUflD(0)1 9101026)S 30 (m(a)ZiOa)O 010x )A'a m)mo St) nJ36mls (11â,(n)m(OThla)001

aGllBatnflQ)(ô& eece,aI3oo

6 nJltUni)l aJ1O1MU)ltthU8 @3(dOblJl5leJ @2 11 Q6)SQ n.JQD(1Dl (T©la,U3

&,6TT3(fl)n16mQJ(Bth ruaocoi mSn.3thQCfl)©l(fl

ok

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)10/23

Page 10: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2016 236j 31 oY raw(rvom7 U(3,116)ØIW eO(LO O?Ca/Ofd 02o. 4 (ii1.ncn)aj&ot)

nj1njmm, OHM. OHn)rsñ.ni1/a(b a&iSotnii9 .0s03(6 (cuitm.i.n.)

.30i6m1 oio s&oomo11 niGm6swT3o.

7 ooioi&x (fl)1.63.(U)1. £63 10 m)1.63.(u)1a63 6 eJ&o ne&oçcrl 0jo(SnaJlcthCUo.t11 OJa.9Jo s1.sx Cfl&,O 10 GJ&Mo

c8rjnGrm WqM03 ii$1Lub i&mo&u8th nnñ.&, mcola,m at n3 gdoc1 lnxnfiø8 sm1t51

m©1moc86xrn Qow001 øo se€mmj cn1conJm6Gr3u&e9 (UDOO)030) (mmaeJo eJ11. &,DDd1manJGn1 G3OnC(8 m(&eoc13 CIXY3CJ)OO (DlCa@ffTg moo.Jm6n36) cml msmccmrq10 nialflY)1 nejscn1ca8 lnJwOCfl03oR 615130 nøøia aiscl n)0.Cfl0.n)Cfl)l(3 Din O(3n9Ji "(n)ocB,()ia, niciicno&,u3, (Th3(6lr mio6)auô, &611ñ0Dn(,r &,oioniwi 0)2J3) ne0 nJOIXO)i "PiS&, 6m3o Cm3, o (mS)m) (0)03&6)61Do" nQ(m (D1q(Th(1515)i6 (fl)o(fl1C3m(fl)&&6)3&/nn)n)(fl3c4)ø3 e'oneiij°.

cO,mm8alcommmo DctTfl6)s ioyit3 w6mSmou 000o oicoTo)ocno)&)cm 630 u(m1neJsa(15TmiQi10 'QisC0fleJo (IY)6131303 0090 )J0aY115)i aiç1j n)0ii moaunom atx3&3 srnmeo zonJsi no (ow 2016). CnJ3(3 n)6(AP* i&im ninicnn u86)js001x65, am3aur&1o3 aoeioniwi croowoo

GrmwougBo 0(& l)i(?J8 cnicmo (00 (ifl0li)i &QRTh, afl6T13Ct a6e,u8 smixth m2mejoco ooqau3 umis smi8 m(b2J

OOKD) ClISM&MOMMU8 nJopmi 4)cmaBicnoc3, La1)) conJsi z6nJoaD 6 nJscm niQU(15)i 00smi(3 io0pm3o8 Mc)i)i ms(3m &,00(8

LoJLAlQD nQo&6)i nJmit ftcDoa(bo(8 & mica 3)iO(M. cm60136)mecn) ai(3 Ja/xmiaY6)s (3,&a16m1axo) asano &,00(3 (021a,cdZ Cfl30000J ano oo(0flom.

3.1.9 rzJi.nJl.nii uaBia,Ø8 ' n3otna3' n (b)6)&06TT (15Th(5fl00a6)CTm6, a6rr3mmo3 %oejoojwloW mi&aifla0000 nsmi6a6o6nmJoaDocno (Di2J MI&MMOM2M2MLnJC(0)&03) (Tb(J$,0(J0Jo, )icD)o (1flWiO3000J006m.

(fl)i&D0øC nJe,01cB63 TÔ36s Cflic&1q1nJ0J0 ciei JQJiU)o (ZBi(016)a, imD(ia noiuoot cacnx3 nOl ioLe€0o3 ©a,cm c49flJo a06mm)

a,oGJonJwi)oGn r&ronaJ(y3 aomojwluocml ni ica€jsnd5. a6n3cn)na16i 0J0MnIIISU8 am3auraicr3 a,000ixn

2014 6)Md 12 OS moffnonxflM866xx8, nii!161Z1O)o -.Jaucmi(n)16)s amg &tfl)nJ03

a,o0/3 000a6)m)(15)imolD)i cc3o1) o)o10)6m 0,wln3Jc18 Qc)01m106@10 000D,&,0 th6fl5(fl)nWlS a,00& (nio.mftn) aimoulathlsj. ojiikiro rjj

mjoau000 n(3a00(016)0 øwiaoomiaiw& niom 66nzgn(8 oodQJalocao) o00821 t4o.0ti.n) mi ma 1121015D1 naia6)sn 6ni3fluc0) atorunoa a6eo&mo?)i0cr02. aoo3 cnsoc6 (m~)L(n~olN cn)nonJcn6930 mo&e,i (0i&a0Zi61J13U3, caLc &o6)oc 6i a ocnitimia oon Ji6x (asi..ng) alTI

nii.nJi.nJiGflT003 moSa,icn coi(ScQotoimuS, csuo1 aua,axtlnaicIS, (0i060nJ6(3nS0ce6)CJS n)cmi0n3 mi&wjuoi 003u3 n4$mini nJ(OIU)6MI4 (Wi. (mi.yD5k03 aJiJ 039615(303, (fl)om)flQ(flmi&eQOOiGi OOicaY06s flJi.0r4).c4) m6.r4)oS 0i0Otm1. g2lD 21396l13U3 LnJcth1(36co,o I aimoS 9 flJ6)0 nJfl(U1U)106@1 c(3. n)r.nJi nJ06m3iaD) U fl3nJ(T)61i136) (umnia)i.

n40.flttaJ) cJ&.C)10 nMa1an 6ru&nJ32 (cnJ xxi). 21 1908 OEJ Q1O& COJ3(SO1 fl3lt!a30o ca(o3ntcSaoa4 omoioim1( nflaa0)3,Jm, mnojono cmmd 0 ionoi J)"°2 °'2°fl. °' ,W(16 000nlo)oJ52o))2. mmulas @mm1oknm6mo ncma(oi Oton namnvaoana(áeaQY nflwlaoimo mZflOI2Wo 0m2 ,OUICM (0)OaQJ, 1m3o8 (TUO(fl1flCT) OO.SaG,O()Th(1 co&nc11IkcTh6flIm1eJ3m5.

2

100

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)11/23

Page 11: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

UDeWJOGl'o ill- m2oir5rm 630(w17

QUomflOfl()3øC06flULO6) 111 D3D) (BflJffU1ith&3

3.1.9.1 &,6n3au.-aoa1ocnfl 63g "(MajoB a,øo8 ni&000wtjm1o8 (n1(mo ca)o6)c u1na6imm2nJo62J Cfl)oCrUlDOCflCfl)C8&6)3t3 ooiou8e nj1øaDøo) nJnJcTu0thu8 (Ol(t8øçj:

nJl.nil.njl nJQD(U)l&,6)S &,GflZCfl)n9ICT3 cth32K0)fl (TDOWO(06T1) 30 flJ(8rt®OGIñ.

200508 cmocmoocn 66)0C (UThoWlcth®l (0)O6)J cOnJ(?$8 CIJQJnflOøflJ1,

macn xmm1io (fl)J&3ø o1aynno©ass flSçJO&6)CflD nJQJ)()1cth16)2J cmbsltmIDOCn 113CPjC0 ce,oeJonjwl 30 adaofl

n asoø', cu1w1siuuo nuw1aot momc8 nnlmoa8cn3 o&,oan&io 0xOOo6Q10 oon1oc31ø3 &,GTTaCTUr&JCT& &,3eJc0)C 3022

flJ&raiQiOaQOCl3 OnJO&( 1@(T1). 2013 6)2J 13°00(fl51(nQoZni

Uli1!G1UT)o (0)0061J nJflU(U)1&6)CflJ6T131 nJO GC1J1 CTO2 (3(8'J3(ThO,

i9J10 a,snômMqJn3 ce,oejodI 30 0icth9ia1oa1

ngyrno8 QanjOTOMM &,coo0108 o,m&n.oñ a,oeianiwl 40 jnotnfl

m1]1ø1thQ2Cm. 10 flJ-&1° mw1a aGnöcn)thlnZ &,oejoniwl m3a1cn

uniw1 *&e6 2,921723 cos1s UiWlcü, nmom21a613&ao.

(fl)offUflO(r) Cfl)C8&6)3(8 2016 08 D(&,b) a3onJs1 lnJcthOøo nJQD((B1 a6xxn)1 croi1a,& a,6nZcnM31c6 &0on1623 onmo,j&,ocbøoen

&,6rthcror&1c6 a,00016)eJ ca,oeJoniwl 40 nJcsdajocn)1 Cfl1CS6flfl)1©. 30

cSrai6nmm cn.)owocoGm n8croraic3 &,oejoniwl m1aaaininio 6flJOW,ø)&,o

&øro '16ni6rT r01c68Rs5' 24 njQucufl&,uceQorñ mjowce,wo&,co,.

ln.Jwom 'iw1cr3no1ø&E 25 U1& 6U13U3&6) 6flJ3U)(D)&3rno si12JOJo flJ@6)ø dm;s;(o)pjocml(al,o@;o. &,S3ø(o), 6)S)G(8eJo alsico &,sn&mraloñ aoan

niaucolaoloniGm wcnmMnoca)o &O&6)16)a1(fl2o Cfl)oCfl)flO(r) (flMB&Q3(8 cwn11

. nj1gi61mmo oucm1cn omoø1m1n1co8 twin aio&u cn

26Uo oil€onicno 6micjcm &SJB D(U)1i1(3 &6fl3Cfl)th1C13 cthOeJDOJWl 30

&oçpocn1 m1thi11&& iiøflmo8 (n)omiooa) cm3amolol ainflJsl (WoWi&OQ3CflOc&J. a,so6)an, a,6fl3Cfl)fl9J(T3 e2oa3nJw1 40 CU(5n*løQcBQ16)1D?

ala2o &,øOnO,D(DnZ nJøa3flJW1 wcnm)nnocwo OJ6)rJ.

a,m&n)r&in8 a,®on1ei njcucnine,uñ tni&,3øo 3nnn16 MM80a@lg (1,635 ao,os1) (06Mg €DwaiDnO6n5 mc8ca,6ntm -

jauw$1n6s mlo'nicui 63Onfl& (mnocn)ajo©o nJl6)(11) (fl)1.63.UJ.)1 &ecoto sonjaorajaB anojo 1ixi8n3 (a&nØo.) (Ton 3u1)2]Oo.

630nt)øl (fl)nflOcfl)o &,Gfl3Otngd6IflQY(a 6)&,36flQJøCfl) Q22Jwm(mO)16)C 150 (Jb(0)

aio(naocn,1ø1aQo. nia&&1 (U1Ô6 w~pdh JflU()l 6ThJeJQJ1G1 30 u0mmommool n)1ensm6rE(o)o6n.

LnJ&3øO 630nfl& Cfl)nOOcWo a G)O6QOCfliOQS, cmøa, nJnD()1 6mJQinilaY3 630n0ø1 (ltnf101D)o u86)ceeolce6)on nos19d. CUIb6UI36XI)

ocajouS niWkimmo njaum1cwss &n o&e 63omoolaum000mool

cncc8(Sa,6rr6 Z943.62 aa,osloo&n526. 6MOaeIQW2@9 QJ1.1.n)nI CUThW)3DRTh

22 niia 5.2 (iii) "M3 ,,Qn(03 noIMWSMJ cajacm,ia1 Mg303ao1 "L602MI4e3ni-.wg nlc~dodff

(ao1nomjc5 2010). 23

madQda & ow1oo ,jb3 2015 Cfl c1mj1&nj1ej11 olcaad5W cTkm1fi mø1m2n ma3ml] wo(UOJo

m1 24

m10iw1w1 wTfføo1ao*J %slm0 mia O1.j1aQ3(n1a niu1ao t nb84u ..nzxm1aa*m nJncnicm. m1en1 u1ma,cuq a1saQrm m1celcu q4m1 c12cncG,1au3 am11aQ1m) nv(5aau3 -uAi5 n1raaj ,jao

,1aoS aiJnm1o6JS1oo2. 2S 0a3(O10)o aJOOthi oSJmw3 !i,ogs ca,1oiS 30 wma3mo (nano1 aunaoo e.oaJoIm2cuonsio)

ICTfl IftJa3C0O a9flaQ3aQ1m2th.

enno1 cmnnoo X'; St&J1(flJ1=4,089 .jn,baoo.,X(4,089-X) 0.30, x (4,089 * 0.30)-(030 .Q 1.3 X I,226.70 . mowiano&, X = 1,226.70/I.3 943.62.

101

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)12/23

Page 12: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2076 0064 37 ( 1aoJcn)6m7& QJ&i216)(0IV) 673(W7 070ff (7)0. 4 (&7.iXjc6)

691.38 c2aosl. 63.&n)o O00)1 6)6)L(U)Q10(fl)1& ()nj6rn&,1Gio)127

o1.acw1.ae3unJo m(08c ,6ncmo6n5. ni6)691, 6nj6)ni34 36)ffUn*1Q 00

cIko8 63Dni)ølm)a00)0 &DcO6)0a6)(Tj0U 6)Z0(0mo 1GThJ2iQJ1(08

m1(Tno 630n0& (fl)aO0fl)o ocaQTccfl c4)G15 C)JC\C)JC11XC Jd5(U). (0)6a0

2J03011Y1 £6flZ(fl)rt6Th)&ce6) (fl)offOfl3CDffUC3&6)0& c1)(080cth6n G30nUø101)

nfl0)o Z1,226.70 OthDS1 (4,089 ce,0s1cfl6)s 30 (Jb(U)QlOCflo) m 7 cnfl nx&rn.

7) Mogo an(0)ow1a2oø (Tu2flco)1)06m (U)1(TUo6flJth 201408 naum1x6 n

oio1n &,oømo)1 nJO67UITh( n&<x a,00ñ ng)ommoGrñ. ni6)&-i9J

&,o 1&600 auow ni8 øou6xm 6im6xn 6301 a3ono

U 1ø(fl)1Q. LU(0)) C((3W(fl &,0(D6mo (fl)oUU000) (To(3a6)0ø1o)

283.08 '26,0s1. (W1&,20iY1 (1(3\o (ms)cm m(a8c&,6TE1 nicm. (m&,0O6mo

6fl00 1cmcn9iso Z123.7U7c6,0S1Cfl)0615 28

moan0n06Q0 nJnGIurmth ((th(n 2016) i n5mm osswml m1xaioni

(2 r3 sonJ16i (0)Lni0o rncnx moQa<OM0) a)000m001 0Tm1)

(0)06Th 0Th06. 1OJ(nM0)(0) 0BW()1 &,OøGmo W(DnJ(OQIO(0) CDn9SG)(2)0Cfl)0

9133a1ç nØ(TDo (fl)o(fllUO(T) 0fl0(36)0(3 nJOG1tTö). cthSQ6)(0) 9nuxm1 6ThJ0

(7y)1(06)cm&co3 nfl)©l6)S taCrU0W.Sa5)ao (M

cB(Thnlo 0)1(O0t n)(TDo (fl)(866)0C3 nJfl610T0).

630aO&(fl)afl0)o a6m603&eam0)16)mao;01 thø0C)16)PJ 6flD6)nj G(q)(551

a1i8 tacxo) LDWoa1cm nqyrnflmo8 aonis1 cmj1aoøaçj. MOUM

MU a6n8cn)n16m06) Z123.71 6ce,osl6)s Qo)ø15cmçJo(o1m w(nelo@o

@3W(0)1 &0(06mo 6110&,o.

S c4)o.Cfl)1.n) u016)eJ (1t1&Q1U3 41 lni&,00 nj(0Ixofl 3mia,c (micej(tlml

nii (mni&,ocmo u&mps) u&o onJøs

es)ocno151 nj6fl'o nidaeonian (mcr m1e,1w m1cmo ctnc)Jsou0631(08

ai1(mo 0aQ11(0(m. njc&m i3nnqjo3e,too1co8 (ur 1&e1u 41.5)

3a€ .c6na flJ6&6)&U8 nço m3cm1ce,

nJGTThD)o ojd&@OM (MOjc%OUOo m(08,1a)16T1. m1cno2oO6m

o1 njo61r6 th niodSn.j mcmniLecS (mu)1a(m(7)&aJ n8&

6)2(1flo thS06)(7)) 0nJc3(3nS0aQU3 m(08&,10)3 GUm(Th&

(fl)oCrUIJofl) 6)0(16)( cn)ocnlcrte 61)J0 D(0)&6) CGo ,(0ao0))1 6flJ00)1

c66Wm1 n)0ta10m.

2015 08 &,ø0(3 &0oc9J116)2J0(D0U3 (B2W81jfl61Uf0) 01(751(0)1(758 630 003

w1 ann ajou8 rx3aeo8 6)0fl)t& n1230(8 (?3175S63(Th cm(o)ow1a,o0

nafl1 c3m mniuço (0100ce01-2j n)ffT 6IU)61313U8 nlolce-aJ1-2k.

(n)oce,(0)1& (3nqS0&6)6)S C(3&756)(75775) (mS&m06n5 mma o1oo&2t

th. mo1m30)&mmxm or&nmjci8 &oo0103 niopm1 csnu1 (Moa

(U)16 flnS0&6)6)S 0cTh(0)O)1(fl flJ1(0aJXU0 Z548 cBe,os1 6maini1co8

m)omcoo86eo(8 S2il n S(01Th0(fl (?J175QJ&,00Do

x8&c mo8 o1ocm.

cn)om)nocn mxB&c)oâ ©uues aio s11o8 ((upwc 2016) nin6vstux6

nJQU(0)1 m75jo&olcou8 (@i1 u8jes) Dc75Th1

fli0Qj$nJ (fl08&ffOOJ(06)S (WbThJ&1LnJth2000 2i0L(0)o Wsnj0O6)001(m 63(0

0(IJcmo)06)6mcmo 6)6)nJ(3(751 6)Joii1eoi 6)6)OJ(3\(0)1 flJ06I3(758 000&,

io8 (aRai1.n).) 0(fl2707fl) QJ\flJ(fl1flthU8 6)6nCrflI2706fl5.

annjs1 tm1aoie, omcmo& a ceo8/ai1.øn).nn3.nyo8 oaw

6?313U6e6 o1co n)o.0tftng). cruJl& 1flo1oe(mc icoisl (75)6)CITh0)O

eagno 6863c,)a3(Tt1a MMMUJO 633a001 Q3nO(3øO)1øCI 7.50 o,mgio&th. 28

aO1O),01J(5 2015 MIMZa fl,OJoQOJ(ô 2019 W OMWIM M3MJ no,jcmmad, 10 J53m3no nj,< -&1acn1mao13, am,a,3

102

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)13/23

Page 13: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

(&WQMJOfl'o III- (romJai(&wD)m O(W7

6TI1 (OTt)øo 63Ø CIIflJOtD n)o.Otln 1(08 cmoonejoa,mo h1aflj. no8e nl8ne1030 0,mZ010.-s08 &,oni anJoQi2 a, s1

ax08 acn6m3u8 6)&,OScOQ003 aai6TTglo2@p mloolam6mm0006n5cro&&coB ng)o.(TUl.ng) innow1&ecim6 uia auauyo oxm aaim8nin6r 6eUD6)2J

8ri6rnx8&6 anbwla, C(flo m(08&,cm(m1(ñ nQ)o.(fl)l.nQ)ID)l(02 cnlm5 ©1oJ2J1ce6)cthc0)o 6ThJflD. GITb6UI3G)(T) (T1)(L66)06 ojnjcmn1e,u8 cnyna,o

(bD(8(0)00 cO,1 6)&,0 0a6)cthcWo øcO,cD)o 6)(0)P0 Do

D($cQ thS(0)(03 C(flo (fl(08&,oD(u)1a 3(oDcO,&,cfl)o Say. S,s06x0) .jaixm1cx s cni uncxn

6XD)0Ø C@i3W(Th1 Qi& 2fl5)lJ(fl6

iZcrur9ja8 a,(0odlG)aJ acD(T13 3.1.1 Ln.ith,Døo cthGfl8Otn9lO3 1o,oeiooia)1 40

QDcfl)1&66)o. nJø n)r&1(T8 o,02JonJw1cw6)s 30-00 r&1(a15)l

ma,o Jaucu)1(0)6)s (S(mraJ1 3 ng)o.Sl..00 cgrmi1 OW&MMIWOM8 &,rthcro aioñ a,3aoniu)1 20 CkJ(Sn9do a,s1 m11m(o8a,cm(G)06n1 QmIM001 a,6n&n r9iC18 a,oeJo(IJw1u6)s 36-37-00 flJ(3ngdo 18cn)j6m e

mm8a,1nxx08 molmoap.

aos cD,6fl8(fl)n9iCI8 &,00016)GJ flJflJ(flliD&,U8 (nJ&,Døo cB,6flZ(TUr&1C13 cODG)O

niwl 40 ni(&&sa)ocw1cocn). 10 ()i(BrstO as1 m11 0n1cmaN0 (GT,6P5.

cO,DGJDflJWl G3QKC5 (TUoCfl)000) 0 6)30161 oJiac 6Xfl)14O1 ms(mmlQ) gGflU(flQ6)S moeimool 030r08&Q30161 (Wl..ng) cfl(0&o,lcQ) (mb(fl

noaaanm06scD)o6th. amoolma Mjaaapowl cnsco5flcw 1s1&Q3cO108 6,03(8 nø9S&6)30Z (m3(nJ0o p6roodloymaA 1au1n6s

iwlnl8ni3 (fl)I@DOJo, n1&emo'xy niauml &oeicwdi, m1(86niow000 6).QJ6)6T13 6Ubn9Jl QJ(81W(D6 nØO1)l @6a@150aua 26n31aQo1o6n5

cmbCQano (U1b@(3(0UD0) CnS(u1m1Q)X). nJ1OTIW (U)1..ng). cOff&fl) O&16X1 1c8'el1j1&6)onicm &32FD)flJ 20 C)i(8r&iQ300Y1 misi.

6)Th6m36)S n101&6mW?m108, (fl)om 030) fl3thc66)D( cmBo nnmO6)iW)1 0)0nJO6)QJ m11 ole,onjcm co,oioniwl r&123fllWTh6X1P

1oomlloTD1c08 crooaunommm1rn 761,095 w3os1cn)26)s (nJowQmm

ajeio Z353 (Raosl) cuiow1o,ni(Oai3mo'° e9ioeai31oot, &,S36X0) nJ(D(Ufl

06)S 03tth n6JDCt8 lnJ&,300 D(11)6)S CUDrs9il 3 (u1,01)1

omm,a1o5 coicrel ni(Ocm c)JeJdi fl,390 oth63s13Gn5, 'D GmJGicü 30-Do nJBthlaio6n5 cniitlno o,W mbam mloaQlwä m1cmo cumth

14,6510 Q&3Slfl)3'flfl cQ(8a0ThOQ30. (W)DD(0) Z14,651 0&,Dsl S&6)l(03(03

&n3ncnx8€e6 Z61,095 aaDs1cn)es mw1anj000mo GJG1c66)o.

63oJJ1* mswImlco) auomianmla, nib mmm18 m11 m08&,(M &,DeJ

nilG)ei 21 MMMOMOMW (0)S9fl3l 40 o ooxomlo8 wTh0J0t3n)lthQ(m

(momliD30xlt(8&Q3016X ()iO0Dmni1fll0)o a £)16)aS 11 n(T1)

noon nonxnx&e@o8 ns n0js1S1co8 (o(n 2016) cmzbin0n0j.

(b03(Jb(ól 30 Ub(0)Q33fflOøfl)30 ni0TD (9lmaloaD nio00mnil010)0 6,6rfl&6)l

6)eJs1a6)ocnJou8 3uw, ninimin otocruoocnm1n5 CG3n9j&(DIZ n)(mo

Q0tJ ©106)J(Tmb61 & (ci)b( S(&)o (fl)oCfll030)(010)bc15 6)Q2

6)nJ nJ0a0omni1nn1co)nio QJ&&6)16)a1ffl OtomlOD(DmMôa6)3(8 oJO6mTtD1.

(fl)o(fltJDCfl m)6a6)001ec aIo1nJsl nø©Dni0aiDE1 (/DOl £3O6mo

Otoml030)W1m16l nJ(Da3m flibnOl(0)o 61m63T3U8 a6m€o6)16)QisThbO2Cm. 14,651 aaosl aj1ginioa6)ccnJou8 c8o5 la(a58 400 (/0(0)

29 n1)4}} & IU'GU W),03oQ1 nOh(TOliThlQllQl 01caJ3 LJJQMJ@n CTh03(OO 77I,222 C4 3S1G1fl45 0)101)20 50-Do

nidn.io MIMx & 603o ni4tnioo dMfl&TO&4flGD4 ThntoDmot4aoDolCnl (no5caoli 0J0233(fl CU%fl1L0Th3O} !II.III

0a31 anjow5.

osua .aiom,1 oojeinI (awcr-I) !.,oas caasl ObM3 mao,a4 oJ1.ønjJ.naJT6.ngc 1(fl231TIlaj tJaO0o L..J(6)lflJ4nhlG e lnmaooJo nuo a.gnaobZ nj1e,njt3ovo,o rwoa1 aanaQo1a%.

103

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)14/23

Page 14: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2016 00 31 (if wmJ0m7& exww 00wr 07co&5 02o. 4

ZDCDo 0JøQiD(flo QJ(fflQG)ZffY) QKT1)(U)(0) Cfl)oCfliOD(fl (flX8&6)D(3 mIGxuW1,~J151

aSlcd.

aCn&rUajd SØD016)2J icae1u 26 1nJ&Dø0 mIDX8 (fl)ocfl)flDG)

cn)c8003ø1n6 m)163.(u)16)s 15-00 flJD(8n911&o p)(8 aGn60mncT8 nfl (U(D)1

UlQJ(3ri9lo 71 03 6mcs)o amu)lce, &6T1301)nJC18 nfl (U1(D$1 fli(9J6)(MTh 6)O2D021Tho n102Qflc6ni1US nn1caos omnJo mzkaGm (mom5. aimoia5 wono njocm nias1o3 o1iqni1u8 adlo&s 63%

(JDC0)DCflo flJl()o flJ(3aDlj1 nJoalDnJwl 40 UbO)IZO(flo 0J6)0 0)(08(ScO6fl0)D6Tt.

61O)6I36)S m1o1&ad6mcm)1o8 &IE(65 0)6flThCmD08 nJC3nSDQJ3' (0))D0D

66)10 WrnD(naxfl cn1c8waio &,m 6)nJ,DOo cn)1.63.(u)1ca6)s 11-Do flJ(3010

&,6fl8(fl)n&J6m0)(3ce6 )6t3T36)S fl1@&9dnJ910) 72,454 13&D51 (ThløiG)th

1&6)o &6n8m 6m(8th 0)6?3T36)S ml jJrd2DlXY Z2,454 c&osl nJSJl(JD Cfl)nOl()o ©l&ea3 ei&coso (2030-08). 0JaDcml inJl6x 67 ub)a)DmnJo mr.dla@~(m& (fl)o0tflD(fl Cn)c8,iaQD(8 (UT,Q)(th 6)&,DGfl nSS663

0)636)S mlcaa*uo J6Do 0flO16)& eJ1&60T) QJ(8no Q0)08

(fl)oCttfDO) mi8&eo&o5 nimaom nilrThmo mo8&,l stmsnanom (2031

0tl.3.(u)l026)S 15-00 QJD(8n11,o aaxo3 c0-5 ml1 m08lcnoleis

auomUnDm CM&MOO101 !2,15332 0&,DSlQY6PS 0J02D0)

(Tti&700 nJS3D1&65 (UY(3afll&OD0fl) (fl)DCflJ0Tlc6, GMJO (MnJnl&e6)Js ceo 6)jJcflXtD. OJ03D0) flJlnDlGY)Omlth 630 (/t0)D(flo n/J)(T1) mlo&e mica U1oikno 630 (mSimliJD(flflJo GDctDi0Cm.

(TUomflDO)00)105 Q3DmnJia010)0 M08&MM aD IPJCII niiniGmi micalo) D6)6mcmo 15 QM8cfrjo cB,DPJ0Yd1 nu(micn)6)s nJodnJD cs)i&snJimDxDi

6flJDa&,U3 nffDo (fl)o(IUflDCD(fl)(3&G)Dd (M~Cna 2016 (o8 M(UWU 230nJSic2108 njO61tT0). CC) O (51tfl161 nil&,cnxno 6(1)010 6XS)o 6)0)DW108 (UThOfl)060)303 gsi&c)ffno)icn nJOC23 (fl)o(fl1fD(T) (Ti0 0JQJCrODcD) cruDcnJ(uTmia )JeJcO41OS nieflQ) amom1eqM M@(8-2j

0ith106)D08 w6m00021 (TDaflD)i&6)6)C17)o (fl)(806)0th 03(fb6)j.

atoauoomm)(8&6)D0lGi Q3OnJSi (moW1a0i 6)0CflD&3icJ, &DOGIflo 0J021D(T) flJi110100 m i0s06mnth 63(Mei08 (fl)i.63.(U)i. Q20)C2JD 0Th6 cJa108 (flil.6I.CWi. 21IM6 01)i.63.(uJl6)S 15-00 flJD(8rsJl&o MWOOM n36)0)S,1OJo Goa flJ(8n9Jo W)08066)D fl1&.Do nfl5 onq)ni5.niiai08 -uoGm3mi

n3ai0; 8.ngru5.nJi0a06sDjo c008th11D) cth0 a&n&roioñ cthODfllOS (cwi.crul.n.) ojnicrwj 6mJ(m10cm(th flJ0Q2D) nJinnimo MM&ffiIMM2SG6UB 61E6 (Wl.63.(fl06)S 15-Do flJD(3nic9,o ø(86) nmD6T15. &)25D6)0) nJOUOfl

l(08 mlcmo cmo(mnDcooImlo) ejsla@gomm awmunom (flM86Q0(8 nJOcDm aDcnJ(mmlan56u8u 61JGflW1CO, 3.1.6 oB OJi&3lcO,0i0)(SnJD6)2J (ro(866)0(3

C)iO&iSlnJOnY)iGi .n4)08.nJi.flJi ,01mim 0)Døccn,Dln)oy,imo08 (fl)oObtfl)D (fl3nJO2)D6fl5.

&36T1ñCfl)n3d08 co,(00016)eJ (U1(8100iU8 12.6.6 LnJaD00 ammnx8a6 nf6Mai3 8&e1au8 ms(m016)6006ncmJD€o,Do)0 aJ(OlnJDeJic66)DCflo nilTail a,u8 (1â96)Dcfl2o g2@0 £39171 ml r)1&6) icnu&,oa)D(ai nID6IWU3 fl&0øS D&0)D66)i(o3 mi(TDo 0Cfl)(3nfl J2)01ThD010 nJiOl&QD

31 ntootnon) nt4a0001m enlcaemt nmi33cnwt,n1coo a Il-la UZnl4o cma maSa1as6mflyw

alcfl 40 nJA04O 6'a0"j 0J1 JIIId5 T.,981 oaasl. J(m1o)6nu30 nicat MIMM8 MMJMIMnJJnflAala aj1ao2ocni,u3 1u16Ia1 1O13% ?6,828 c,91 LOM o)l1eJ nJ)3m !2,133 0.th35t 32 (To(n1fl3(n nuaQ3ø1(n) e,g1o.00m nJal3n)ni1nn1(mc n4i.e.mikoos 11-30 flJ4nlJo alam aIa1(mm2su31s,

abS 40 niSo oaorq e1aenma1 !a.oai ca,gl. J(a)1(nut*li3o nhtt QImOS flEa ll3rnculnnlcno eiElaGiacmil&$ ea a1nma !a.als ca3st f2m c3wn1eJ22 nJym3(ma T2,163 cant

104

- --.-- -.----- p

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)15/23

Page 15: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

~Wjocwo 111 (warnJ (2J3WO)n 00QDIØ'

qai (GTflJa,OCfbo 6flDin5l0l&6o. cuToa(u)m)al)o, cmg1&6)1u8 12.6. 10 lnJ&,000 annJ nn8&Tu16x eowooaifl m1&am1aecn ronawm o; 61Jmm161 cumcT)cmm1Jccn,o 01wmcom1orno aJIZ3(ThJ (fl)o(fl)flOCfl flX8&Q301CC(mOGr15.

o3njo&tmm COGn Z1&6flcO,U3 nJ(o cbnJ1cbauqlo6n% ng)(Tn36T1 61U)W13 6)S fl10l&aJGmaTU)1Ø3 &,ommc. no6retu3 oiddi6nal mocrunomau(&eQo

0161 nJ 6W 6weiculco8 (71,463 (Reos1) m1afleccn MMMS6Wawm ©o 06)Jo rUQ)3CJ5hOQ2(m Pko1co3 ffllcmo mx8 aOl u&&oo (D (MC1JcO,OOo m)z2eJo 8CP)r&16r1Dcn)(86 2isi. co rrxn&eô mbd mwlçpmm cn)omJcmml&,cnMl,om,o ax3omm1q (0)J0O

611).

cruocnIoom CTU(8 QO(61ØC (t3Thël[nJ3)1nJ&,300 (63000 2016) 00TU6flJ(PJ)(D

m 0 )nm16)0§ 1n.inJc3o'roxonJo nj(01njoejcnajo 3(rorai6)6)m0161 i1c53 6)J(mJ. (mb(m1(n0c03 (U)6)Cfl) 2aD6m02fl(mflaJ6)Jo 1nJa3sm6)rJ

s9ffm9cmai(01( &,6n&lmal6')6)6mc8 Qffuc8 aOl uIm16)çJcmo cnocnmom otx8aeoc3 njO6TUm).

n10dcm32Jo n.06113(tJS aic3&e ceaa1o3 w2cnx3 aol Jloiae2cnxm16)m 6)01 &ecjo m12Kn1c3aecm. 660xb1m1o8 cO0OO1 OC)J611

c@owcml nom1 aacu1m6mc)o6n5.

8(fl)n(T8&,0O(8 lnJcO,000 C]JlWlGTmTho (0)061Jo &unic8otmmo ©s&m omioo (n l&&11&6)cn CIJO(n11, isoaolcd 6 Jc6tho cmn5. m)1.b3.(w1 03Cm(68 20 &.16xT0) (/bODCtbOl ni36th1B tSOa01c L.J()l&&11i 1S3aOlcO6'l nlmo 5 oDanQomcmm1o8 ajmwla,o a,s&,00 &,OcD)&,OW)O

J5czJ)oco8 cmm2cru(614 &,6nm)n31cy8 &,oaiocuwlnflc& njcm1omo aio cnolcm1 tn&ioñ co)0od16l ø(8166)1u3 29(08 QJ1&b3lcth01c66)Cm. e000 mmguomalomo th1ooJlcn2o ,m&n)a3 a,ojoww1,1c8 n.jcoajocuwl

UWc)j(8r&Jo n4ym ui61w1acwos 63o ni&&I6xmm CJC3QDCD oi0rmo. mbo OnJoG)eJ 63300o 0Ub(omo flMBaDmd&GMo a,Gnam)thlaa oejocuw1, nJ(b ooaiwl anai acmnjc8n8jo ncrn oJ&w1o'n0s. uio2a]omo n11c5)o a,cxwo nJQ&Oi, 1soao1 &,scm 633600 icm5kno fl3TO©3© QR8r&16XmTh o1q) 6)61m)Gm108 aolas njucmoomo mow1&,nioaiocn nilnrfluo Cfl)oOU030) (1U(8c66)00l(fl mc081o,a nw1 a mcacSaG3 am8m.ra1a a,oejocijwtn1c8 lsoaola ascmca,006mo Qj(o2GmTm6m agodi, G3Y10J0&6)0 aJfffl(U)06fl5.

c,6fl&fl)n9Jfl3 &,(O3616)2J a0ø8nJflGlThm nJnJ(noa,u3 X8&6 wxiy8 i oa,amzo&n5 ngmi 61m6zm6)s n1oloai6imm1o8 a6YI32. LDBorO 061T)o nJlcO, 3.4 08 gaos u,1&a&(m. ('D a,6ma@a,u8 gpor OCOGM =MIMI oou)oo6n).

33 to U3m3mO.

105

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)16/23

Page 16: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

20:6 0064 3: ol wlawauoml& wisomrw eoa4Y o7apdf mo. 4(aitngyniovjsad)

IJSLO 3.4: cs1 CUDDC0)1(OZ cwom ansJ1w1aos (nJ(0)3'QI3(0)o

1

l0;;:dboei3cmwl ejaajo flmlc m1cmo 20 Ob(0) (UØ(a)OcD)(th 2066 oio a6n8crurai Qomo m(0x8a6 ejg1aecm cumw1anjothomo'

- - - !24,620 0&451

(Th3nflaJ0o )LnO(8c0)o uocbo(Tho1 iSoo1e &sciajct a,oajonjwl 3 OJnto LffiaoLool nWThBmceQ3uS 20 uoco) cma. au&nmocn cm<&eèothlth ejtee2cm

alomo.a2s(m1 cunw1aAo@o !7,386' oaosl CTUOnflaJOaó )LflO(&mfl (/b(b3Ob0i (SDn014 20 er30Dr&0 a,oejocuwl crol U)03m° T&fl)CJ asnZm&i&m 3ac cmbuSlie,aoeo 6,381

6)emc (W,O s6xa10) o1)6,e2J cn)mlkJ6 nO1W2eS 10 (Jb(0)03(flo -

cTtxüeQoc6la5 meao.

6T0)6UT36)S mlcbloa16mwmTh08 S,GIE (DOPOW1 C1Jm5(0)(0) nQ)6)(15X1D0(08 C&,L03 crtxB 96)o016i torn oocn(nx8.e00i8 Oi1.inad (UTOOnJ&it nJ(1CO6flD1&Q6XIJ 1LnJOçJgc 1SOO1Q1m8 nian1 u]omo ojcmom8 a,&rrörn)raicr3 a,oeiocuw1t1c8 0090 oJ01xw1mo(0i1 m1uj(05).nj Lsorolcg n1(n)omJbcm0om0o), 2 uOmOomo (0)16)0 cth200JO 6)6m(TDo 6)nJ0(0)0QJ 10 (/D(Th)00(Do a1cDiomED06T1 nJc61U)Gm1a6)2TD(th n)(mo CUIGIi5.

(Wl..nØ., (13Th(0)6)&,0&T, Gfl&(0)Qi0D) is1cnc 10 (IO(0)00(flo ng)rn) J1C m1ucn1eqam0)1(6 1.63.6)a0)0g (UI D16)OJ12J2o CUlb(Th10&2Q1W3MI. 63.6)a,. 6301 ms&s10 6)&Qoml.

atom nonxnxthe@o(ö (0fl6) 00nJs1nflw8 (cowc 2016) nJoGluImo% LSOr Dl a6Th!s8 ajcocm cO2S0)efl(flo &Oni10)2o a (0)(TUQLnJ(0)0eJ0(0)o OJOJGtD c)aidkmcth & mm,an a1nJo(0mono1c1&Qomo6ry5 ng)cmOGTt.

lsonnl& &,O6WTTh02Jo as1ioeo am 6ma(&6 aooacm nd)O1X0)lW0W3 QiO2nJsl cmildboosmw.

a6TT8(MrAJ(Y3&,00016)QJ (tJIi&)&6)1U8 30.1.1 tn.J000 n0)106)0002 11wni6n36)aC O&fl3LS16W110eJlp1". aflfl&tutmo oiicm1a too al. olqcö DJ~q@CIJIO& cnDg16)1 1500 ojo 1acIm1cn1(03 aJ116tuimo 0)100~61JGMM09 aiwn)aiia6wm o&qoo 0)o06Uo moo 1& 1l6(0)(0) 05)10016t10 Ln.Jcu&1mmo (m,cbo&oocm (ThlD)(0)ltXDo (6ThQaJ0$lC8OJ ORDRIOGA 15-00 C1JO(Br91lcO, (ThlcflRWlo (0)ara1eJ1 &,0eJQJ(mOa)Wl16X o$m0s6m aoQJcw(ii aGn&nkalctS %opjocijwlGwo9 Oao. &SOQ(U), acooc8 Ln.J&,000 n186maw000 6)6)anJolaae6ng wa0ai61Jocmrs1 ajcôaum ailco8 ctl(m10 &,5fl3(fl)-&6m)6)O egIcuomp. nmemableilo 630 u000uocó) LSOnDlog o0161JQ(Mr&11 6)s 90 U0©Oomo &0J16)OW)0W3 aia1oS nioGDlTh 851€o1u$ acoonini &niowo&cocnoalçj.

61m6w3c13 oTh01*1-,2jo am8nmaia3 a008 lnJcth000 "Wa 6fl86)0C go5cn3Lsj 009106s" MltftmJMCMW S6hJs1rn) a mnx3&oo8 6)6)eJ 2016

-co8 moej aoilw3, njlTlgmo GDfl tic0ym mlm10 Si al.ail (BTbcO,6)GJ 724,969 aao1 mioinilc8, ocog a6)snSktx8 son kn3r&ilcoc(MgO

2056 oS a40OrdSQTflUlItOd 0X114)Q200 (3ng300)o t2.462 caasl no 014n,to.

2056 05 aalSMMlSQfln*5a4 0131402(T1) U0Q3{3o t2462 C&.aSl X 3 njSnijo.

00 O'u'a3

77.386 0a301'DbS (0101)20 6 flJdr.Sj000) fl0203 ooiloo 0 &3(03CflI3t0) ?I,005 ca,s1 db2osJcpu3.

106

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)17/23

Page 17: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

aDJaa1'o II!- anaajoidøiwa 60w7i'

736)JO m1cBwzi1theom njrunuih00% ummaim1 mas3a,1nkmoo&n5. wT6m36xo niøacnjou8, VMMMAOOCUM MR2oQQJOnU mcon1&Qm m)oGnJ aw1 n3cncct3 ce,côon1sej aisniminaua msoa@6m6aicth cmoiuoenj soo$ ñ mnx8os m1cnjaInJø®o1y1 cmnoubaM6nE

SW6)çtJ flJ\QJCIUfl&U3 ng)o.(TU1.nO)EWløS (Dl(1Do Cfl)J(0)36)6mffflo 'w(3mc a s ooJ1ci1'co)6)s n1c8omjcno n)o.m)l.ng). tnJ&,OØZOGTT nffl(mDGTT) (fl)oCfll030) c1uc80Q08 n@s am s1w18 (ww(A 2016) n.JC) 6n1. cnlc&jlnas mlB(2.nicno a &w 6)GiThito (UTb(D)100A }&©(U) 630Q®O nxn8e6M3100 icoamothi nia 10 gamcmo nJo61Bm.

€e,g3jw8 C)am61Jo (DleiC)ilOB CUCEDQOS aam03 nJO61UO) ainicnioa,u3 ms&Jleio - 1tW)&306TDo cO,6fl8TDr&J08 1e,oejon.iwl ai16Mo m1a6M1acm

flt3W0) ei&Qfl).

em&nmai06 10,(00016)eJ 27.1.1 w061mo'tm16i go&w,o.eøu8th ocno1m3 1m1cnocmrso c1ii,01o8m1cTn2 m@®,1qo eotimcn10 &613 cD$n)&o1 jamcmmoa3 mcnx8co6 mw1a,000 mc$am2.

'a ninxnn a,sn8cro.-aj&mmc3ao5 n@s rsomcru(o6mo QnjagOaMD 096)1( cn1cmo agoam nnlm3 niMli000qo a0lcn5 nj101&Q06MD) (tfl6)Cfl) (01 &6)3Cflo LD@p cUlbwl&,30o mc&,m). g2mi (fl)omiOOmffUC&ceQOOiGi (Uoamom oJ1o1co6)con) cn3thJ&,0031 6njoW1&Q00. cft,6fl3CEOn916flXQX8cB4 (mCO1&6)11s ama cnmom6m3u8th (u)aamaJ (0\6W36)S nJOtflOWo omamo1 ax8aon& ajoxnin Uflbwl&,30o mc8a,crn.

&cnñmraicrô &,000l&>ei Cc3Cfl3 3.1.3 lnJcB4O(00 01008 no)WAq nJlioau1nj1 £G)DCflo i m1j1aeomo nJ01nJo2J1&6)omo tnJ U0)0) nil&cnxno QJOGml coaQo6m3u3a6) Q.Jc2n)ow sommocno th6n8mTh916flXW8&6 cmbwla,ocbo mam (onjo8 n4j(Rp4 nil&,mxno). cOjSO6XC) 0nJD( (9aq16 133W 6m308 3(UlmamOCIII)3 t43W1&,Q3cfl)3 amQnJ(&Ddc Jcwas)l &,030€th(J3 0a6um j-eiatoñm jcxJktn cn(U3th3mo c6,6TT3m)nJGmU)6cO6) (UOWlcth3 m06rg3&,o. anjoc nØC9kaSi flhlcth(flXflfl3T)l0) o3wteQcrnth niaucml a@ocwl nQSO) 6)1733C010o 0ai16S 30 u3m(1m1eJw1&,rZmoce6)ca3 nJ3Sl

n)Cfl)o, 'D amo 3 n00)16i amj(m16)a3crfl 901 2m0&IBOam ni3&JlS auampjn6ul3u3 ml8ath1aQ3o3 3w1a6)3ni naymo a,GnôcItthJCI8 o,ccocâ ninimia

&1m6m3u3 m1o11jo

" cn3crtx8aeool6i croo m1aoonicanj (no1..n)) nj191tuimo (5)C)GU njflU()1cø6XXfl)l (fl)ocfl)fl3CflCfl)(3c6Q3(& CJlJ flJl.l.c9)n6 cmQoJo6 jctm1ø8 mwnxm1 cno8ce,lcoxth anJO(39 nç nil&, cn.)cncIm16i e0wam3cn)1 cns(uT)oa8 aqcmie6)cm n)JD 1nJflJ0T)l cB,o oam6jmniamocw1 snJowG ocw101aQQaxTnao (O216J nJflJ.) co16)s Cu u0m3u3aenn 3cD)1m1affnIzm cmoau03m cnx&ee3&6iOtJl6)Cn (0G(8cTfl3611. nJQ&-&I In 13(t) Cfl16DJCTWO) &,Gn8m)raloñ a,(0001cu8 s1flocm1.

V &,6fl3Cfln9Kr a,(o3016)eJ 6nicwu Q), crmmmjciwo-1V o3 1mIn.ice30o anjo3 cç niithn mcmuflmo'nS) mcncuo

m1mbou e!m1co)6)s aJlcr nJQU(o)1 saflcwQs amuoamom CUTU)1(uB o,nj1cnmocr8 3&J3Cmmcu)o umolo&mm6xm nJo%jls 6uncs8&e31 QnjWBOWU02CM65 amm16)ionn1o8 &nfl008 nios1ejo

xuo&n5. nJCôJ nJauoflm)neio (&&nØ nymm16 cdk3nJDJmo cthsn&ltralC78 a000lo8 nqc111cso 1 1anj11e. 1mo o,saflo8 m1mo Oil U3SO&6W113 53 6)nfl&SOo 003fl./6)0lfl)1Cu3 nlnlmocIl sBm/ng)see6m 91010 I86kJ6)S n.JQD

107

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)18/23

Page 18: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

2076 2064 31 cñ wafli(Tt)0(fl7& ak&,9øW eo(w7g 07Q0J 0o. 4 (nXt4)

(0)100S 6)Q0(TOpo (9010)6)S 30 Ub(0fflo @0WaBmo &,6fl3(ltr91 6mcox8e6 Gnjo(ag nopqq oitthmxno ms(uT)onJcnxmoGn5.

Vt' nJQU(0)ltiY6)S )0c(8 n6 j001$ Tqat& 296.40 46)6 19221 nflDl OQ0IYl a qSo&Q6ma506T1. (g0u1 n36)S$6)0fl8 LDmIcuGn 6)aJeJ OJ0) ci000cSl (5)&,u2)0cfl) Z2.62 a,os1/n@e6x8 nieA &,sm1000&el

oca8, &,m3nunmS&o QnJ0($ n)aç 1acruomm1mo1 66)&006n @1s (88.92 &(8) ljeJSO ?232. Ca0S1735T1.

aJo6m1ni1e,cnxn mnie,ocmo &,6nñcn),a1n8 atani1aci c0 0øflJ10 OUMOMaOeJO@OJIM mna om1a€m ocni1th1&mo c901 ani.

(U ØCn'. (m6r36xn6)Qwa1as3 &,m3crur1gio$ a,oeioo.iwl cBmoJ(room1a6)cJcnjou3 L'J(fl3(o)(U) (m,crt3(u)1&,u8 ntocmnom croc&eeo&q (ml(6l6)&, e1fflce6)o.

nJBc&a1 6m6m36)5 m1(bte1a16m(znm1c8 &,Gnñcn)ngJoS 0,(oOo16)eJ (Tj(8lcBQlU 31.5 LnJcthOøo cth6fl&IUnalGTThDX3&55 CnJ0 n) Oil ncmml6X @00) acnl ol3mlçl&ocm (nio&jls a cnnoB u8ps)

J-m)Qicruo&m mø81o,o(T8 c3mW10,oøo cwo8agcma n)cth n 6)6icnx1&n3 cthsn&mraioB &o2onJu)ln6)s moc n)Cm0(8 cth6flñm)rtC18 O()0&6)lcIY0Jo søo oi1&ao. n oi,,nicmn ocBm)Q10&Qcmc6 olsnnpu3o3 @sa anoth n)cka*

imml&,u8, mlolmcmjoei rI3Tothla3 &oaocuwloo 6)SOn0jo m omtaQm7y)ol 00910% g)crno6n. n3aio t)l..) @06MU@06MI tcuu5coamo8, cthlj &.GnBffu09Ja3 e,oeiooiwl awi acnioo8 cmjo3 ngy4 olamauiulcnol o,aool sjail løl@a cnomo0cncnx8caQo&a) ila fô@çJøs, atoff coma n)ff.nQ)8 CO6TflllJ.

a3Tuljcñ aaon1aej ciçoicrunaci8 flJoeJlas)oanl&a6)(

3.1.10 a,6n&n)raici3 &,øoolpi oioicmc 3 3-nB LnJ&,000 cB3C08 6nj1 90 dlflJm)ctUmlma,o ø&,(8(fl O1Th)6)Cfl) 0 fl)16)C Cfl)ø&-&J0 630cwl* nl ria naDlcnofl 630 aooa-ado unn9soail6xn m)ocmrom mx8a@oc8 nllc&e6)6rr,ori5. uo6)s mlø1€o316mcml(o3 ce,rgtth mnm&u niaomlapp)s ml(8io6fl)LnJflJcmUfl&,q3 2015 CU)l(fl)o6flJ( scö (S6Th3acWo, 2016 n031nJla53 OJ6MD

cao) n110J06ur303 cuTbmm)ci 16 ca,oslas LrCUCUThl&,U3 G go6)cxyalel0 cn)øce,a10nJa(3.-,qjsooil6)m mlDaJl&lj n)Ot06fl.

nL(Xt1)o 6) -u6)5cn5 cncoa-aio sooil,m ml ncsomm cnomicom cruc8e006 aojsl maj8a,l (mcn( 2016).

nJ(fl)onfl0(bo -

6WnflaJCBa1SDaQ(I3 003a6)%1) (Tu3mJcn)la/cn)Dccm1a n4fl(p1C1Içfla&3 CflJ6fl) L(0(DCY06)S nJfllG&b3W1aØ3(lm(a3cbfl)o 6)aIo(mD), JPJdi Cbm0I3 cn6m3c4

aGUSCfl)aiGmcS tth(?13C& 3O3IO6)C(T1J3U8 cn)ocmnam 3(i5nJ(6m&3 0()1d,(bh0cXS1

(TUoCfl)L3(fl Cn)Ô€O6)DC C6fl:

1. nJl.nJl.nil Ucifli oncn5I 6flJ3n0riJC(3n3iS3a6)&3 )c3ooas)(m aananmo &,,iejni C)DW(Do Th)3d aoa nM3ae35

108

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)19/23

Page 19: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

t

(W3r2QJQfl)o III- mamdmd01VXn 630tW1

cnpwa3/cmenja&3 ni&c&ow1ajm1mcVbn&io (BoWtthø1aQ

2. nJ1,nJl.nJl 1a6)s acbooa(s3 3O3aQCCnJ3&8 mxsaeowl6xl* (0)3 6U3(M cwo(baailaeG SO1)26I1 nO)(T1) 2Oflø 1W3fl tnJC(0\o nav eJmma.

3.2 6)nJ3(CcD&XJeJ3 n)C3DT36S nJa,(03(3 (1)1&Jnfl6mo

Icn!$aaJQ

3.2.1 a,aiim16)ei oojejocnioorum6mu3 (nj1.nn5a.uS) oa,

au38Q3(8 (ftae.) jau&eeo naknfla,u3ce6o anJ6Ttl iomxmo91iw1& 6)S flJlWXb6fl) ijan19ooicn L 1 ' nQnJS(m. cro0906ma11qo

a02Jio,u3 m1cnaogfl 'D nj1.nyn5.. &,&8 j1cm1 oo&,o

nffl(8nj3S CTfl.

i1.n9)m3Ae6)s gaiamA m1c&mnGmo sJWT3o ml 60)3o (Gm(0201x61 _Ij

3O6Tfl3 n)Oto 0)3ø(03C6m3 n4)(Tflo nJølC&OWl&QTh0)lO)OcQfl ngcf

63c0)oa16IJeJocruo3Jm6m3u3 2010-11 M~M& 2015-16 €th3eKfl)CUl(o6 6)sifl0) 50

njlcoxom Lnialroonn 8 107 mlöaao&m B(8(mm6m3o nJ&

0u3wl&Q&,E)6fl33cflfl. (b66W36)S nJl(0)ø6m )lno3Jaxmmlth goicalma

178.79 OcO,3Sl 29 icuiou8 aaco@mY&e6)o(8 cnoømlBoQub nJnMmfl

dicoB nJl.n0 .&UcO6 0fl1(08 Z51.47 aa,osl ojlejCW2m 20

irmla' fl.nm3..au3ce6' m laco5 nil@JQx0)1ç a6m&6)oaQoocn,l(o

m. LDT iuMumlas axol nflej g)cnn).au8 3no&6&Qo

mclsx ajmslcmoomcmmlw& o&co mx3aeoc8 nios 633&w0&,u 6flJ3th6 s

6flJO&6 nc)mon)lc0839 m(0&,Q)o 6ThJQ)C0). 727.77 aa,oslco)6)s 10 ooejla

LB~6)S aicmln4 CIJ1eI flJ3J3O 31th,6)S (fl)nfl3fl)0(0)ThO6)5 a36n5 000aelcnnoI; soco t LnJcljyolmldboa n.jlcmlg v ni3nJ3co nJe3l

ce,uôth ni&,ø301(08 6)&,OS&Qc6,(fl)O 6)oJ(fl(0).

633(US1* ml(a1oa16m6m3u8 (0)36)9 oJ(L 6)aJ()6)njS2fffl.

alnlaB6mar3c

F pngffll6u)cu o (a0)1a4O3aJCDfl4o

.

3.2.2 aao o7 ei4aisoml&n3 einThaw oa0thja0rs(r8 eillgafi

(acoSais06n3)o oa(O@ roocnn3m 6)uoa,ls MSQJCrUOU n.ila,mxn oceo&jan

n90ñ i1uJlc?cu3 (crolcu3oao) po (m&o6)3cB OJcthcth&8âQ2o EZX nJl.nTh.tOU8th6)o

,Jcthco6ma3u8 QJlwMbGmo mscoT0)&,cD)o Lo.U5)ln1o3nimo mscon)ca,cwo 6)SPCTfl2.

g?nJa(b6M6M3@~6)S nilan(osn) &.icolnoorum m1&,1(a 1U0(Dl(0S6)çJ tnJV5W 617303 os2wwl ejn5aul&,1co3 jcL 6)0)1lce6m1.

C"09 mjomm,cn ccsmt&rrO nñantm caad,.qcoaiia on1gn1 cant oso2as nJnJnU33 caa4kjcn o5 c,thlqoIl cn,nsm3 o,o3ad t"Wmerd no ninan caoaco,a3o5 03n6 cant CJ1a1QOJY, cane c,4

aui3okSaaiiS cao&qcnnssoZ eib1qcu, cant cp ca333p3 n1 mwnoj,jon ca,t,cn,sicI eilzlgni5, cane o1cu,n3 äk..fl3n'3tS.J1 ooJnJeMinna css3ccorta5 eM.1RCUY. c.wanç oI&oos1n (s,nxda2r eflzi1g 1m1cu. 1.

cant 9,4 ct6m1, in3 o uesJono caojcnn,g8 ejb,1ns (nanScsai3) .to.oaos ia ao3a02a nJ3mo5aula 023,zxw1 011r34ThnbJ 41 ns8aoatua tO.OaGIOS QMJ 0Ja2112n alolS .aeIokllauSaol mama cane 0.J01a1S0JSnJaV3 ojianomca4a.Jcnraso8 enalR(ul (cn1(wca3) ml8nMfll eotjo% ooan.

nj1nat3oja&8 e4icnnwlao4nfl OCnI d033Q15 0113.04 sl nnad u3njcn,n. aJ1.ijDaOi.04 o1o.0aa,a1 0,1cm,, Qmasnvlagw mlcm,o nil.0flm 034aoo1aua$ ncnjcnx81J )1aO ms2a2a nonlni c1nnn c.oja=j nina.Jon,nu3.0d noamago nnam, 831.o.oa/41088%milaelo8 thku5 oa mulaaaolm oo&8% t naa a,.jininu5ad tw,o fl)0Sa3nm0l10 nJ3nJCTiO 8l,JOO 00113016 01J3.0d 2 auaad.

109

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)20/23

Page 20: 1649007/2017/F & P (OS) - vizhinjamcommission.comvizhinjamcommission.com/.../11/CAG-Report-vizhinjam... · r __a3nau\ocn)c III I 3.(M &cwGxn 613w1ç cnlcblo.%16m0n3u8 I m)ocnloocn

1649007/2017/F & P (OS)21/23