2 legal and criminalisation, prosecution and social ...€¦ · people, showing important...

2
Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide [TvT] provides an overview of the human rights situation of trans persons in different parts of the world and develops useful data and advocacy tools for international institutions, human rights organisations, the trans movement and the general public. It is a comparative, ongoing qualitative-quantitative research project conducted by TGEU's TvT team in close cooperation with 20 partner organizations and more than 50 trans activists and researchers in all six world regions. The data collected are compiled and updated periodically and can be viewed in detail in English and Spanish on the TvT website: www.transrespect-transphobia.org. The TvT 'Legal and Social Mapping' tables provide information on the legal and social situation of trans people in 116 countries in Africa, Asia, Central and South America, Europe, and Oceania. These TvT 'Legal and Social Mapping – World #2 – Criminalisation, Prosecution, State-Sponsored Discrimination and Hormones, Hormone Therapy and Gender Reassignment Treatment / Surgery' tables provide information on legal measures that criminalise trans people, showing important differences between criminalisation and actual prosecution. The tables also show different forms of state-sponsored discrimination ranging from legal exclusion of non-binary identities to e.g. exclusion from certain professions [teachers, police, military]. They also give insight into trans people's health- care situation, showing several aspects of medically supervised hormone therapy and gender reassignment treatments, including requirements like 'psychiatric diagnosis', as well as the availability of funding. They also list the existence of 'alternative practices', such as acquiring hormones on the black market or applying industrial silicone without medical supervision. Legal and Social Mapping – World #2 Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide The 'Legal and Social Mapping' was produced by Transgender Europe's Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide [TvT] project [current as of Aug. 2014]. Continuous updates and more detailed information can be found at www.transrespect-transphobia.org. The TvT research report from 2012 discusses and contextualises these Mappings: www.transrespect-transphobia.org/uploads/downloads/Publications/TvT_ research-report.pdf. www.transrespect-transphobia.org A research project funded by A research project initiated by Criminalisation, Prosecution and State-Sponsored Discrimination Hormones and Hormone Therapy Gender Reassignment Treatment / Surgery and Body Modifications www.tgeu.org Legal and Social Mapping – World #2 Criminalisation, Prosecution and State-Sponsored Discrimination Hormones and Hormone Therapy Gender Reassignment Treatment / Surgery and Body Modifications Criminali- sation Prosecution State- Sponsored Discrimination Medical Supervision Without Medical Supervision Funding Available Forms Requirements Funding 'Alternatives' 1 when no or limited GRT / GRS Europe [Part 1] Albania O CD O Andorra Armenia O P Austria I TP O PHS AC BA CR H HR Ma V PHS Azerbaijan O BA H Ma RPT Belarus Belgium B O NHI PHI AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V NHI Bosnia-Herzegownia B P Bulgaria GRS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V Croatia B O BA CR HR L Ma NHI Cyprus P BA CR H HR L Ma Czech Republic Denmark B O PHS BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P V PHS Estonia NHI BHA CR H HR L Ma P RPT V Finland B I NHI PHI AC BA BHA H HR L Ma Me P RPT V NHI PHI PHS France CD B I NHI PHI PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma P V NHI PHI Georgia P BA BHA H L Ma P Germany B I TP NHI PHI BA CR H HR L Ma Me P V NHI PHI Greece O B P NHI PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V Hungary B NHI AC BA BHA H HR L Ma P RPT V NHI Iceland B NHI HR L Ma Me P V NHI Ireland B I TP PHS BA H HR Ma P V PHS Italy CD G CD B P PHS AC BA BHA H HR Ma Me P V PHI PHS Kosovo P AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma P V Latvia Liechtenstein Lithuania B P Luxembourg Europe [Part 2] Macedonia P Malta B AC BA H HR L Ma Moldova P BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Monaco Montenegro B NHI Netherlands B P TP O NHI AC BA BHA CR H HR Ma Me P RPT V NHI Norway B O PHS BA CR H HR L Ma Me V PHS Poland G TE B P O PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V Portugal PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P V PHS Romania CD B P PHS BA H Ma P V PHS Russia TE O B P AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V NHI PHS San Marino Serbia B AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P V Slovakia CD I NHI PHI BA CR H HR L Ma NHI PHS Slovenia B O PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P V PHS Spain NHI O AC BA CR H HR L Ma Me P V NHI O Sweden G G B I O PHS AC BA CR H HR Ma Me P V PHS Switzerland B PHI PHS AC BA CR H HR L Ma P V NHI PHS Turkey CD O TO P AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V NHI PHS UK CD O B PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L Ma Me P RPT V PHS Ukraine B P BA H HR L Ma RPT V No / none Existing practice without medical supervision Provided under medical supervision Only with psychiatric diagnosis No appropriate data Only in parts of the country Legal exclusion of non-binary identities Existing legal measures / documented practice Criminalisation / prosecution / discrimination under certain circumstances No existing legal measure No documented cases Only in parts of the country No appropriate data Criminalisation, Prosecution and State-Sponsored Discrimination CD So-Called Cross-Dressing G GRT / GRS E Employment TE Trans Events TO Trans Organisations O Other 2 Without medical supervision B Blackmarket I Internet P Pharmacies TP Trans People O Other Funding NHI National Health Insurance PHI Private Health Insurance PHS Public Health System O Other Available forms AC Adam's Apple Contouring BA Breast Augmentation BHA Buttock / Hip Augmentation CR Chest Reconstruction HR Hair Removal H Hysterectomy L Liposuction Ma Mastectomy Me Metoidioplasty P Phalloplasty RPT Removal of Penis / Testicles V Vaginoplasty Key und Footnotes www.transrespect-transphobia.org 1 Include GRS done abroad or illegally, application of industrial silicone etc. 2 Legal measures used to target trans people being visible as trans people in public, e.g. anti-homosexuality bills, anti-prostitution laws, nuisance laws State is listed under both Asia and Europe

Upload: others

Post on 30-Apr-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2 Legal and Criminalisation, Prosecution and Social ...€¦ · people, showing important differences between criminalisation and actual prosecution. The tables also show different

Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide [TvT] provides an overview of the human rights situation of trans persons in different parts of the world and develops useful data and advocacy tools for international institutions, human rights organisations, the trans movement and the general public. It is a comparative, ongoing qualitative-quantitative research project conducted by TGEU's TvT team in close cooperation with 20 partner organizations and more than 50 trans activists and researchers in all six world regions.

The data collected are compiled and updated periodically and can be viewed in detail in English and Spanish on the TvT website: www.transrespect-transphobia.org.

The TvT 'Legal and Social Mapping' tables provide information on the legal and social situation of trans people in 116 countries in Africa, Asia, Central and South America, Europe, and Oceania.

These TvT 'Legal and Social Mapping – World #2 – Criminalisation, Prosecution, State-Sponsored Discrimination and Hormones, Hormone Therapy and Gender Reassignment Treatment / Surgery' tables provide information on legal measures that criminalise trans people, showing important differences between criminalisation and actual prosecution. The tables also show different forms of state-sponsored discrimination ranging from legal exclusion of non-binary identities to e.g. exclusion from certain professions [teachers, police, military]. They also give insight into trans people's health-care situation, showing several aspects of medically supervised hormone therapy and gender reassignment treatments, including requirements like 'psychiatric diagnosis', as well as the availability of funding. They also list the existence of 'alternative practices', such as acquiring hormones on the black market or applying industrial silicone without medical supervision.

Legal and Social Mapping – World #2Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide

The 'Legal and Social Mapping' was produced by Transgender Europe's Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide [TvT] project [current as of Aug. 2014]. Continuous updates and more detailed information can be found at www.transrespect-transphobia.org. The TvT research report from 2012 discusses and contextualises these Mappings: www.transrespect-transphobia.org/uploads/downloads/Publications/TvT_research-report.pdf. www.transrespect-transphobia.org

A research project funded by A research project initiated by

Criminalisation, Prosecution and State-Sponsored DiscriminationHormones and Hormone TherapyGender Reassignment Treatment /Surgery and Body Modifications

www.tgeu.org

Legal and Social M

apping– W

orld #2

Criminalisation, Prosecution and

State-Sponsored Discrimination

Hormones and Horm

one TherapyGender Reassignm

ent Treatment /

Surgery and Body Modifications

Criminali-

sationProsecution

State-Sponsored

Discrimination

Medical

SupervisionW

ithout Medical

SupervisionFunding

Available Forms

Requirements

Funding'Alternatives' 1 w

hen no or lim

ited GRT / GRS

Europe [Part 1]

Albania O

CDO

Andorra

Armenia

OP

AustriaI TP O

PHSAC BA CR H HR M

a VPHS

AzerbaijanO

BA H Ma RPT

Belarus

BelgiumB O

NHI PHI AC BA BHA CR H HR L

Ma M

e P RPT VNHI

Bosnia-Herzegownia

B P

BulgariaGRS

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P RPT V

CroatiaB O

BA CR HR L Ma

NHI

CyprusP

BA CR H HR L Ma

Czech Republic

Denmark

B OPHS

BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P V

PHS

EstoniaNHI

BHA CR H HR L M

a P RPT V

FinlandB I

NHI PHI AC BA BHA H HR L

Ma M

e P RPT VNHI PHI PHS

FranceCD

B INHI PHI PHS

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a P VNHI PHI

GeorgiaP

BA BHA H L Ma P

Germany

B I TPNHI PHI

BA CR H HR L M

a Me P V

NHI PHI

Greece O

B PNHI PHS

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P RPT V

HungaryB

NHI AC BA BHA H HR L

Ma P RPT V

NHI

IcelandB

NHIHR L M

a Me P V

NHI

IrelandB I TP

PHSBA H HR M

a P VPHS

ItalyCD G

CDB P

PHS AC BA BHA H HR

Ma M

e P VPHI PHS

KosovoP

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a P V

Latvia

Liechtenstein

LithuaniaB P

Luxembourg

Europe [Part 2]

Macedonia

P

Malta

BAC BA H HR L M

a

Moldova

PBA BHA CR H HR L M

a

Monaco

Montenegro

BNHI

NetherlandsB P TP O

NHI AC BA BHA CR H HR

Ma M

e P RPT VNHI

Norway

B OPHS

BA CR H HR L M

a Me V

PHS

PolandG

TEB P O

PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L

Ma M

e P RPT V

PortugalPHS

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P V

PHS

Romania

CDB P

PHSBA H M

a P VPHS

Russia TE O

B P AC BA BHA CR H HR L

Ma M

e P RPT VNHI PHS

San Marino

SerbiaB

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P V

SlovakiaCD

INHI PHI

BA CR H HR L M

aNHI PHS

SloveniaB O

PHS AC BA BHA CR H HR L

Ma M

e P VPHS

SpainNHI O

AC BA CR H HR L M

a Me P V

NHI O

Sweden

GG

B I OPHS

AC BA CR H HR M

a Me P V

PHS

Switzerland

BPHI PHS

AC BA CR H HR L M

a P VNHI PHS

Turkey CD O

TOP

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P RPT V

NHI PHS

UK CD O

BPHS

AC BA BHA CR H HR L M

a Me P RPT V

PHS

UkraineB P

BA H HR L Ma RPT V

No /

none

Existing practice w

ithout medical

supervision

Provided under

medical supervision

Only w

ith psychiatric diagnosis

No appropriate

data

Only in parts of the country

Legal exclusion of

non-binary identities

Existing legal measures /

documented practice

Crim

inalisation / prosecution / discrim

ination under certain circum

stances

No existing

legal measure

No docum

ented cases

Only in parts

of the country

No appropriate

data

Criminalisation, Prosecution and

State-Sponsored Discrimination

CD So-Called Cross-DressingG

GRT / GRSE

Employm

entTE

Trans EventsTO Trans OrganisationsO

Other 2

Without m

edical supervision

B Blackm

arketI

InternetP

Pharmacies

TP Trans PeopleO

Other

Funding

NHI National Health Insurance

PHI Private Health Insurance

PHS Public Health System

O Other

Available forms

AC Adam

's Apple ContouringBA

Breast Augmentation

BHA Buttock / Hip Augm

entationCR

Chest ReconstructionHR

Hair Removal

H Hysterectom

y

L Liposuction

Ma

Mastectom

yM

e M

etoidioplastyP

PhalloplastyRPT

Removal of Penis / Testicles

V Vaginoplasty

Key und Footnotes w

ww

.transrespect-transphobia.org

1 Include

GRS done

abroad or

illegally, application of industrial silicone etc.

2 Legal m

easures used to target trans people being visible as trans people in public, e.g. anti-hom

osexuality bills, anti-prostitution laws, nuisance law

s

State is listed under both Asia and Europe

Page 2: 2 Legal and Criminalisation, Prosecution and Social ...€¦ · people, showing important differences between criminalisation and actual prosecution. The tables also show different

Lega

l and

So

cial

Map

ping

– W

orld

#2

Crim

inal

isat

ion,

Pro

secu

tion

and

Sta

te-S

pons

ored

Dis

crim

inat

ion

Horm

ones

and

Hor

mon

e Th

erap

yGe

nder

Rea

ssig

nmen

t Tr

eatm

ent /

Su

rger

y an

d Bo

dy M

odifi

catio

ns

Crim

inal

i-sa

tion

Pros

ecut

ion

Stat

e-Sp

onso

red

Disc

rimin

atio

n

Med

ical

Su

perv

isio

nW

ithou

t M

edic

al

Supe

rvis

ion

Fund

ing

Avai

labl

e Fo

rms

Requ

irem

ents

Fund

ing

'Alte

rnat

ives

'1 w

hen

no o

r lim

ited

GRT /

GRS

Afrik

a

Ango

la

Bots

wan

aO

Egyp

tCD

Keny

a

Nam

ibia

O

Nige

riaCD

OCD

TO

Sout

h Af

rica

B P

BA C

R H

Ma

Me

P V

Ugan

daO

Zam

bia

OP

Amer

ica,

Cent

ral a

nd S

outh

Antig

ua a

nd B

arbu

daO

Arge

ntin

aO

B P

B

A BH

A CR

H H

R L

Ma

P RP

T V

Baha

mas

Barb

ados

OO

P

Beliz

eO

OB

P O

Braz

ilO

B P

OPH

SAC

BA

BHA

CR H

R L

Ma

VPH

S

Carib

bean

Net

herla

nds

O

Chile

OO

B P

PHS

AC B

A BH

A CR

H H

R L

Ma

VPH

S

Colo

mbi

aP

PHS

B

A BH

A CR

H H

R L

Ma

Me

P V

NHI

PH

I PHS

Cuba

B P

PHS

AC B

A CR

H L

Ma

Me

P V

PHS

Ecua

dor

TEP

PHS

BA B

HA C

R HR

L M

aPH

I PHS

El S

alva

dor

OB

PPH

S

Haiti

O

Jam

aica

OB

P O

Mex

ico

CD O

CDO

P O

PHS

BA B

HA H

R L

RPT

VPH

I PHS

Nica

ragu

aO

B I P

PHS

Peru

TEP

AC B

A BH

A CR

H H

R L

Ma

Puer

to R

ico

TE O

B I P

BA B

HA C

R HR

Ma

Sain

t Ki

tts

and

Nevi

s

Sain

t Vi

ncen

t an

d th

e Gr

enad

ines

Sint

Maa

rten

Surin

ame

OB

P

Trin

idad

and

Tob

ago

OO

OB

P

US V

irgin

Isla

nds

OB

P

Vene

zuel

aTE

OP

BA B

HA C

R L

Ma

Asia

East

Tim

or

Hong

Kon

gP

PHS

AC B

A CR

H H

R M

a RP

T V

PHS

Indi

a CD

OP

TPPH

S O

AC

BA B

HA C

R H

HRL

Ma

Me

P RP

T V

PHS

Indo

nesi

aO

TEB

P TP

Isra

elB

PPH

SAC

BA

CR H

Ma

Me

P V

NHI P

HS

Japa

n O

A

C BA

BHA

CR

H HR

L M

a M

e P

RPT

V

Kaza

khst

an

OP

BA C

R H

HR L

Ma

RPT

NHS

Kyrg

yzst

an

PBA

CR

H HR

L M

a RP

T V

Mal

aysi

a CD

G T

E O

CD T

E O

TOB

P TP

O

Mon

golia

O

O

The

Phili

ppin

es

O O

B P

A

C BA

BHA

CR

H HR

L M

a RP

T V

Russ

ia

TE O

B P

A

C BA

BHA

CR

H HR

L M

a M

e P

RPT

VNH

I PHS

Sing

apor

e O

OB

P

AC

BA B

HA C

R H

HRL

Ma

RPT

V

Sout

h Ko

rea

OB

TP

AC

BA B

HA C

R H

HRL

Ma

Me

P RP

T V

Tajik

ista

n O

TO O

TPRP

V

Thai

land

E

I P T

P

AC

BA B

HA C

R H

HRL

Ma

P RP

T V

Turk

ey

CD O

TO

P

AC

BA B

HA C

R H

HRL

Ma

Me

P RP

T V

NHI P

HS

Uzbe

kist

an

TOB

PBA

H M

a RP

T

Ocea

nia

Amer

ican

Sam

oaP

TP

Aust

ralia

I

BA

BHA

CR H

HR

L M

a P

RPT

VPH

S

Cook

Isla

nds

TP

Fiji

P

Guam

Kirib

ati

Naur

uO

New

Cal

edon

iaP

New

Zea

land

B P

IPH

SBA

CR

H HR

L M

a RP

T V

PHS

Niue

P O

Papu

a Ne

w G

uine

aO

Sam

oaO

P TP

Solo

mon

Isla

nds

O

Tahi

tiP

TPBA

HR

RPT

Toke

lau

Tong

aCD

OP

O

Tuva

lu

ww

w.tra

nsre

spec

t-tr

ansp

hobi

a.or

g

No

/ n

one

Ex

istin

g pr

actic

e w

ithou

t m

edic

al

su

perv

isio

n

Prov

ided

und

er m

edic

al s

uper

visi

on

Only

with

psy

chia

tric

dia

gnos

is

No

appr

opriat

e d

ata

On

ly in

par

ts

of th

e co

untr

y

Le

gal e

xclu

sion

of

non

-bin

ary

iden

titie

s

Exis

ting

lega

l mea

sure

s / d

ocum

ente

d pr

actic

e

Crim

inal

isat

ion

/ pro

secu

tion

/ d

iscr

imin

atio

n un

der

ce

rtai

n ci

rcum

stan

ces

No

exis

ting

leg

al m

easu

re

No

docu

men

ted

cas

es

Only

in p

arts

of th

e co

untr

y

No

appr

opriat

e d

ata

Crim

inal

isat

ion,

Pro

secu

tion

and

Stat

e-Sp

onso

red

Disc

rimin

atio

n

CD S

o-Ca

lled

Cros

s-Dr

essi

ngG

GRT /

GRS

E Em

ploy

men

tTE

Tr

ans

Even

tsTO

Tra

ns O

rgan

isat

ions

O Ot

her 2

With

out m

edic

al

supe

rvis

ion

B Bl

ackm

arke

tI

Inte

rnet

P Ph

arm

acie

sTP

Tra

ns P

eopl

eO

Othe

r

Fund

ing

NHI

Natio

nal H

ealth

Insu

ranc

ePH

I Pr

ivat

e He

alth

Insu

ranc

ePH

S Pu

blic

Hea

lth S

yste

mO

Othe

r

Avai

labl

e fo

rms

AC

Adam

's A

pple

Con

tour

ing

BA

Brea

st A

ugm

enta

tion

BHA

Buttoc

k / H

ip A

ugm

enta

tion

CR

Ches

t Re

cons

truc

tion

HR

Hair R

emov

alH

Hyst

erec

tom

y

L Li

posu

ctio

nM

a M

aste

ctom

yM

e M

etoi

diop

last

yP

Phal

lopl

asty

RPT

Rem

oval

of Pe

nis /

Test

icle

sV

Vagi

nopl

asty

Key

und

Foot

note

s w

ww

.tra

nsre

spec

t-tr

ansp

hobi

a.or

g

1 In

clud

e GR

S do

ne

abro

ad

or

illeg

ally

, ap

plic

atio

n of

indu

strial

sili

cone

etc

.2

Lega

l m

easu

res

used

to

targ

et t

rans

peo

ple

bein

g vi

sibl

e as

tra

ns p

eopl

e in

pub

lic,

e.g.

ant

i-hom

osex

ualit

y bi

lls, an

ti-pr

ostit

utio

n la

ws,

nui

sanc

e la

ws

St

ate

is li

sted

und

er b

oth

Asia

and

Eur

ope