20 july 2015 agenda(marked)

8/15/2019 20 July 2015 Agenda(Marked)

1/14

20 July 2015 Agenda Page 1

Republic of the PhilippinesSANGGUNIANG PANLUNGSOD

City of Baguio

REGULAR SESSION, 20 JULY 2015, 2:00 P.M.

SESSION NR. R-28

A. OPENING OF THE SESSION1. Opening Prayer

Hon. LEANDRO B. YANGOT JR. shall lead the opening prayer.2. Pambansang Awit

Baguio MarchPCL Creed

Hon. ELMER O. DATUIN shall lead in reciting the PCL Creed.

3. Roll Call

B. ORDER OF BUSINESS

1. Minutes of the Regular/Special Sessions:[a] R-26 Regular Session on July 6, 2015 ; [b] S-01 Special Session on July 8, 2015 ; [c] S-02 Special Session on July 10, 2015 ; and [d] R-27 Regular Session on July 13, 2015 .

2.

INVITATIONS:

Oral motion of Hon. Faustino A. Olowan and Hon. Joel A. Alangsab as amended during the 29 June 2015Regular Session to invite in aid of legislation Mr. Romeo D. Concio, City General Services Officer to givea report as to why the security guards of the Baguio Convention Center and the Burnham Park wereremoved and to comment on the possibility of hiring security guards thereat.(Item 2b, 29 June 2015 Agenda)

(NOTE: Mr. ROMEO D. CONCIO, City General Services Officer, was requested to be present in today'smeeting in aid of legislation regarding the discontinuance of security services at the Baguio ConventionCenter and Burnham Park.)

3. Letter dated 22 June 2015 of Mr. Ronald Ryan M. Roque and Mr. Norman R. De Leon, Senior SiteCoordinator and Managing Director respectively, Summit Publishing Co., Inc. - OOH Division, regarding

their proposal "Ad Supported Waiting Sheds for Baguio City". (Item 57, 13 July 2015 Agenda) (NOTE: Mr. RONALD RYAN M. ROQUE and Mr. NORMAN R. DE LEON, Senior Site Coordinator andManaging Director respectively, Summit Publishing Co., Inc. - OOH Division will present in today’s meetingtheir project proposal regarding "Ad Supported W aiting Sheds for Baguio City".)

4. Letter dated 16 July 2015 of Hon. Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog and Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen to Atty.Brenner L. Bengwayan, Secretary to the Sanggunian, requesting that invitations for the Regular Sessionon 20 July 2015 be sent to Engr. Alexander C. Castañeda, District Engineer of the DPWH-CAR andP/Supt. Evilio Degay, Chief, Traffic Enforcement Unit, Mr. Pio Velasco, owner of PG VelascoConstruction and Mr. Francis Cuyob, owner of 3K Rock Engineering.

(NOTE: The following personalities were requested to be present in today's meeting in relation to theongoing road rehabilitation or construction at Marcos Highway and Kennon Road and other ongoing roadconstructions in the city:

[a] Engr. ALEXANDER C. CASTAÑEDA, District Engineer, BCDEO, DPWH-CAR;[b] P/Supt. EVELIO B. DEGAY, Chief, Traffic Management Branch, BCPO;[c] Mr. PIO VELASCO, P.G. Velasco Construction; and[d] Mr. FRANCIS CUYOB, 3K Rock Engineering.)

5.UNFINISHED BUSINESS – 13 JULY 2015 REGULAR SESSION:

Committee Report Nr. EDUC-2015-004Letter dated 15 April 2015 of Dr. Ronaldo A. Paraan and Bishop Carlito J. Cenzon, Chairman andTreasurer respectively of the Baguio Heritage Foundation, Inc., reiterating among others their request tohold in abeyance the ongoing fencing and improvement of the City Hall grounds until the NationalHistorical Commission of the Philippines ( NHCP) responds to their letter dated 14 April 2015.The Committee on Education, Culture and Historical Research recommends that the matter beNOTED in the light of the "cease and desist order" issued by the National Commission on Cultureand Arts (NCAA) on June 3, 2015, the fact that works in the project had to stop notwithstanding theissuance by the NHCP of a letter manifesting no objection to the same and the actions the city hastaken to set aside the cease and desist order and to further clarify procedures that seem to havecaused confusion and misunderstanding on a matter or area of supposed common interest andcooperation. (Item 6, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

5a. Committee Report Nr. EDUC-2015-007Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0047-15 introduced by Hon. Edison R. Bilog co-authored by Hon. Isabelo B.Cosalan Jr. entitled, "Requesting the National Commission for Culture and Arts and the various culturalagencies attached to said office to coordinate with the City Government of Baguio for its information andguidance before the declaration as Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites any place, location or building inthe City of Baguio."The Committee on Education, Culture and Historical Research recommends that the matter beNOTED without prejudice to any proper or appropriate action that may be taken after a finalresolution of the case relating to the suspension of the implementation of the fencing andimprovement of the City Hall ground as per "cease and desist order" from the NationalCommission on Culture and Arts (NCCA) that is being sought by the city to be reconsidered.

Item 6a, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


2/14


5b. Committee Report Nr. EDUC-2015-006Oral motion of Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda as amended during the 13 April 2015 Regular Session to refer tothe Honorable City Mayor and the Committee on Education, Culture and Historical Research all issues raisedduring the discussion of the ongoing construction project at the City Hall ground which was declared as one ofthe national heritage sites of the Philippines.The Committee on Education, Culture and Historical Research, taking into consideration developments

following the issuance by the National Commission on Culture and Arts (NCCA), particularly themanifested no objection by the National Historical Commission of the Philippines (NHCP) on theimplementation of the subject project that is seen to provide factual understanding in the resolution of thepending motion for reconsideration filed by the city with the NCCA to lift the cease and desist order,recommending that all issues arising from the deliberations of the Council be simply NOTED.

For clarification though, committee recommends to further note in advance the following observations, towit:

1. City Hall was marked as an important cultural property in 2009 as shown from the list submittedby Atty. Ludovico D. Badoy, Executive Director III of the National Historical Commission of thePhilippines, in compliance to the request made by the city for the same; from the said list, onlyMansion House will appear as a declared historical landmark or cultural property in the city;

2. Burnham Park is not a declared heritage site as stated in the letter of Dr. Ronaldo A. Paraan of 29April 2015. The letter of Atty. Badoy of 17 April 2015 to the Honorable City Mayor referred to inthe letter of Dr. Paraan was merely to inform the city that the National Historical Commission ofthe Philippines has recognized the national historical significance of the park that it will beinstalled with a historical marker, the text of which was attached to the letter received by the cityfor information;

3. It is hoped that the resolution of the motion for reconsideration filed by the city with the NCCAwill also resolved all other issues, including the scope or limitation of restrictions or protectionunder the heritage act and the need of environment impact under Presidential Decree No. 1586,that arose in the deliberations that were all aimed for the protection and conservation of national,as well as, city cultural heritage for a clearer understanding and interpretation of the provisionsand processes of Republic Act 10066, better known as the "National Cultural Heritage Act of2009".

Hon. Faustino A. Olowan, Member of the Committee signified, "for discussion en banc." (Item 6b, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

6. Committee Report Nr. EDUC-2015-003Letter dated 29 April 2015 of Dr. Ronaldo A. Paraan, Chair, Baguio Heritage Foundation, Inc., regarding thedeclaration of Burnham Park as national heritage site by the National Historical Commission of the Philippines.Attached is the letter dated April 17, 2015 of Executive Director Ludovico D. Badoy, National HistoricalCommission of the Philippines, informing among others that the Commission has recognized the nationalhistorical significance of Burnham Park.

The Committee on Education, Culture and Historical Research recommends that the letter be returned tothe Baguio Heritage Foundation, Inc. for the simple reason that the information intended to be relayed,that is the declaration of Burnham Park as a national heritage site, is not accurate as will be noted in theattached letter of Executive Director Ludovico B. Badoy of the National Historical Commission of thePhilippines (NHCP) which simply mentions of the NHCP recognizing the national historical significance ofBurnham Park through a proposed installation of a historical marker. The Committee thus furtherrecommends that the Baguio Heritage Foundation be requested to clarify the declaration of BurnhamPark as a national heritage site it manifested or to otherwise provide the Sanggunian a copy of theappropriate resolution or document showing such declaration as to merit further action on the matter. (Item 7, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

7. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2014-0041st Indorsement dated 18 November 2013 of the Office of City Mayor Hon. Mauricio G. Domogan, forwardingfor information and appropriate action the Supplemental Memorandum of Agreement between the CityGovernment of Baguio represented by Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan and R & R Management andSanitary Services represented by its General Manager, Ruperto V. Alvar, for the proposed putting up of comfortroom at Block 4, Baguio City Public Market.

The Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Supplemental Memorandum ofAgreement. (Item 8, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

8. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-010SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0038-14 authored by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. entitled, "Requiring all personsoperating or doing business within the territorial jurisdiction of the City of Baguio for the mandatory submissionof environmental sustainability action plan upon securing or renewing business and/or Mayor's permit and

providing penalties for violations thereof."(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 09 June Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr.78]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed ordinancewill be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication.")

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommends APPROVAL of the above proposedordinance on SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATION.Hon. Joel A. Alangsab, Member of the Committee, signified "clarifications on some issues".(Item 9, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

9. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2014-0403rd Indorsement dated 17 July 2014 from the Office of the Honorable City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan,forwarding to the Hon. Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog, inviting attention to the advice of the Legal Office, forinformation and appropriate action on the 2nd Indorsement dated 16 July 2014 of Atty. Melchor Carlos R.Rabanes, OIC- City Legal Office, Re: Draft Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) on the Program to Grant theSale of Rice on Credit between the National Food Authority and the City Government of Baguio.

The Committee on Laws recommends that a City Council Resolution be adopted to authorize the Hon.Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan, to enter into the above stated Memorandum of Agreement in behalf of theCity Government. (Item 10, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


3/14


10. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2014-041Oral motion of Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. during the 14 July 2014 Regular Session requesting theCommittee on Laws to look into the pending issue whether or not resolutions should be signed by theCity Mayor.

It has always been the position of the Committee on Laws that Resolutions may or may not be

signed by the City Mayor considering that these Resolutions are used as vehicles for legislativeaction and to express the sentiment of the City Council on important public policy issues.

To put the matter into rest, the Committee on Laws recommends that the word "APPROVED" bythe City Mayor, which appears in the final form of the Resolution, be changed to "NOTED" by theCity Mayor. (Item 11, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

11. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2014-044Letter dated 11 July 2014 of Ms. Pita S. Picpican, USTD, DOST USTC-Baguio to Honorable City MayorMauricio G. Domogan, furnishing a copy of the signed and notarized Memorandum of Agreement for theeffective collaboration between DOST-CAR, DILG-CAR and the City Government of Baguio in supportof the Science and Technology for the Enhancement and Advancement of Municipalities/Cities (STEAM).The Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Memorandum ofUnderstanding. (Item 12, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

12. Committee Report Nr. TOURISM-2014-019Letter dated 12 August 2014 of Ms. Cordelia C. Lacsamana, City Environment and Parks Management

Officer, City Environment and Parks Management Office to Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan,forwarding for adoption, approval and as basis for funding purposes the Master Development Plan of theBaguio Centennial and Botanical Park prepared by Saint Louis University, School of Engineering andArchitecture, Department of Architecture Engineering Urban Planning Research Laboratory withArchitect Maria Criselda Perez-Soriano as Project Coordinator and Architect Joseph M. Alabanza,Environmental Planner as the Principal Consultant.

(NOTE: Res. No. 152, s. 2014 requested the City Environment and Parks Management Office to submit thedevelopment plan of the Botanical Garden to the Sangguniang Panlungsod (City Council), among others.)

The Committee on Tourism, Special Events, Parks and Playgrounds recommends that theaforementioned Master Development Plan of the Baguio Centennial and Botanical Park beapproved and adopted. The committee further recommends that this be included among the priorityprojects of the city to be funded for the Year 2015. (Item 13, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

13. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2014-010Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0113-14 introduced by Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled, "Urging theCongress of the Philippines, through the Hon. Nicasio M. Aliping Jr. to initiate the repeal of RA 4653, or'An act to safeguard the health of the people and maintain dignity of the nation by declaring it a national

policy to prohibit the commercial importation of textile articles commonly known as used clothing andrags."The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection recommendsAPPROVAL of the above proposed resolution. (Item 14, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

14. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2014-010Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0111-14 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. entitled, "Calling on HisExcellency President Benigno S. Aquino III, President of the Republic of the Philippines, to spare the"ukay-ukay" or "wag-wag" business in the City of Baguio from the crackdown being done by the Bureauof Customs."The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce suggests that the resolution be subjected tofurther discussion to consider the following:

1. Setting the rules or guidelines on what resolutions or matters are to be forwarded to theattention of the Office of the President or to the President directly;

2. Directing the resolution instead to the Bureau of Customs to protest the action;

3. Forwarding a copy of the resolution to be finalized to the Hon. Nicasio M. Aliping Jr.,Congressman, Baguio City, to support his announced intention to call for an inquiry by theHouse of Representatives on the action taken by the Bureau of Customs;

4. Adoption of a resolution urging or asking Congress thru the Office of Congressman NicasioM. Aliping Jr. for the amendment or repeal of Republic Act No. 4653 (An Act to Safeguardthe Health of the People and Maintain the Dignity of the Nation by Declaring it a NationalPolicy to Prohibit the Commercial Importation of Textile Articles Commonly Known asUsed Clothing and Rags) as reported being proposed by the Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabandawhich should include repeal or amendment also of similar or related laws like the provisionof the Implementing Rules and Regulations of PD 856 (Sanitation Code of the Philippines)Section 8.9.1 which consider as other types of nuisance the distribution or sale of articlessuch as clothes, shoes, linens, towels, bedding materials, blankets, pillows, and anything usedfor sleeping or resting, which are second hand or made of second hand materials that areoffered for sale to the public. (Item 15, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

14a. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2014-014

Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0120-14 introduced by Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda and Fred L.Bagbagen entitled, "Supporting House Bill No. 4055, 'An act legalizing the importation of second-hand orused clothing and rags into the Philippines, repealing, for that purpose, Republic Act 4653, otherwiseknown as 'An act to safeguard the health of the people and maintain dignity of the nation by declaring it anational policy to prohibit the commercial importation of textile articles commonly known as usedclothing and rags'."

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce recommends APPROVAL of the above statedProposed Resolution.

Hon. Peter C. Fianza, Member of the Committee signified, "with certain concerns for discussions." (Item 15a, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


4/14


15. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2014-016Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0103-14 introduced by Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr. entitled, "Requesting theOffice of the Honorable Nicasio M. Aliping Jr., Representative of the Lone District of Baguio City toallocate or source out funds in the amount of Ten Million Pesos (Php10,000,000.00) for the constructionof a Baguio City Livelihood and Entrepreneurial Development Center Building for micro entrepreneursand barangay-based livelihood groups in the City of Baguio."

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities (PWD),recommends APPROVAL of the above proposed resolution. (Item 16, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

16. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2014-011Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0052-14 introduced by Hon. Peter C. Fianza entitled, "Requiring thesubmission of a feasibility study as a matter of course in the evaluation of proposed waste managementtechnologies to the city."

The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection recommendsAPPROVAL of the above proposed resolution. (Item 17, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

17. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2014-012Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0060-14 introduced by Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda entitled, "Tasking theHealth Services Office to conduct regular inspection of pay comfort rooms to ensure cleanliness and

proper maintenance."

The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection recommendsAPPROVAL of the above proposed resolution. (Item 18, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

18. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-014Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0128-13 introduced by Hon. Vice Mayor Daniel T. Fariñas entitled,"Requesting the Office of the Solicitor General to file the appropriate case/s for the declaration of thenullity of Original Certificate of Titles No. 018-0-162 and all its derivative titles issued by the Register ofDeeds of Baguio City covering portions of Busol Forest Reservation in Baguio City, including the filingof the appropriate administrative and/or criminal charges against all those responsible in the issuance ofthe said titles."

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing deems it proper to adopt the legal opinionforwarded by OIC-City Legal Officer contained in his 5th Indorsement dated 18 August 2014 thatthe proposed resolution has to be passed considering its urgency.

Attached is a copy of the 5th Indorsement of Atty. Melchor Carlos R. Rabanes, OIC-City LegalOffice, Baguio for the information, guidance and consideration of the Honorable Members of theCity Council.

In view thereof, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing reiterates its previous

recommendation for the approval of the above proposed resolution with the committee members asco-authors. (Item 19, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

19. Committee Report Nr. WAYSA-2014-044Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0055-14 introduced by Hon. Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog, Hon. Elaine D.Sembrano, Hon. Joel A. Alangsab, Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen and Hon. Peter C. Fianza entitled,"Appropriating the amount of P10,000,000.00 or so much thereof for the construction of a collapsible

parking facility in the City of Baguio."Hon. Faustino A. Olowan signified, "What is this?"(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 22 September 2014 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 56; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of an ordinanceshall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed ordinance will beapproved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication.'')

The Committee on Ways and Means and Finance, Cluster A, recommends that the above mentionedproposed ordinance be APPROVED on SECOND READING. (Item 20, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

20. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2014-014

Proposed Resolution Nr. SCOFAD 14-14 of Hon. Senior Citizen Councilor Adoracion N. Rullodaentitled, "Requesting the City Government of Baguio to encourage all residents of Baguio to plantflowering plants and flowering trees such as bougainvillas, sunflowers, fire trees etc. along both sides ofroads, streets and highways of Baguio to enhance the title of Baguio as the City of Flowers."

The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection suggests tochange the title of the above to read anew and hence shall be entitled as "Encouraging the residentsof Baguio to plant flowering plants and trees such as bougainvillas, sunflowers, fire trees, etc. alongthe sides of the streets, roads and highways within the city's jurisdiction to project Baguio as theCity of Flowers", so that the tenor of the proposed resolution be more direct to the citizenry, andthus recommends APPROVAL of the proposal. (Item 21, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

21. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2014-015Proposed Resolution Nr. SCOFAD 09-14 of Hon. Senior Citizen Councilor Jane A. Tayab entitled,"Strongly endorsing organic backyard gardening to augment the nutritional needs of the elderly and thefamily."The Committee on Health and Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection recommendsAPPROVAL of the above proposed resolution. (Item 22, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

22. Letter dated 17 October 2014 of Hon. Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog, seeking clarification pertaining toResolution No. 224, series of 2014.

(NOTE: [a] With marginal notation of Hon. Edison R. Bilog, "Sir Jun, pls. include in the agenda on10/20/2014."); and[b] Resolution Numbered 244, series of 2014 approved the application for the tr ansfer of rights to Ms. MarissaT. Ordonio over Lot 82, Block 8, Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City, per report andrecommendation of the Sangguniang Panlungsod (City Council) Committee on Urban Planning, Lands andHousing in its 4th Indorsement dated 19 November 2013.) (Item 23, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


5/14


6/14


30. Committee Report Nr. PUTTL-2014-021Resolution Numbered 333, series of 2014, of the Sangguniang Bayan of Itogon, Benguet entitled,"Resolution opposing the water permit application for surface/ground water filed by the BasesConversion Development Authority (BCDA) docketed as Water Permit Application (WPA)

No. CAR-BENG-2014-04-042 within Barangay Happy Hallow, Baguio City."

(NOTE: The above matter is related to the letter dated 28 April 2014 of Atty. Elenito M. Bagalihog, Chief,Water Rights Division, National Water Resources Board, requesting the following:a. that the Notice/s of Water Permit Application of Bases Conversion and Development Authority at Happy

Hallow, Greenwater and Hillside Barangays be posted on the bulletin board of the office concerned andshall remain posted for a period of thirty (30) days from receipt hereof; and

b. issuance of a certification that it was posted pursuant to the rules. This was referred to the Committeeon Public Utilities, Transportation and Traffic Legislation on 18 June 2014.)

The Committee on Public Utilities, Transportation and Traffic Legislation favorably endorsesand support the resolution of the Sangguniang Bayan of Itogon, Benguet, and likewise herebyinform the said Sanggunian of the actions of the Baguio City Council on said issue with theattached approved resolutions.

Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Member of the Committee signified, "Our opposition isconsistent with the 19 conditionalities which must be respected.(Item 31, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

31. Committee Report Nr. HUMAN-2014-009SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0056-13 of Hon. Edison R. Bilog entitled, "Prohibiting discriminationin the City of Baguio on the basis of religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation and gender identity,health status, disability, and age providing penalties for violation thereof and for other purposes."

(NOTE: a] FIRST READING - 02 September 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 12]; andb] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication.'')

The Committee on Human Rights, Justice, Public Protection and Safety, Peace and Order,recommends APPROVAL on SECOND READING BEFORE PUBLICATION.

Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Member of the Committee signified, "Is this not covered byexisting laws? The equal protection clause of the Philippine Constitution I believe wouldaddress the concern. May I call your attention to Sec. 2 of the proposed ordinance. Thedeclaration of policy refers to: "The City of Cebu" not Baguio. If in case this was patterned or

copied from the City of Cebu, let us check on the progress of the ordinance."(Item 32, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

32. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-019Letter dated 18 June 2014 of Ms. Georgie Galera Romero, requesting transfer of rights over Lot 32,Block No. 21, Bayan Park Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City from the late Ms. Carmen S. Galera inher favor.

After careful evaluation of the documents submitted by the applicant to support hisapplication over the above stated parcel of land at the Baguio Workingmen's Village, thecommittee finds that the applicant substantially complied with all the essential requirementsas provided for under City Ordinance Numbered 65, series of 1948, as amended.

The applicant submitted the following documents:

1. Sworn Application;

2. Barangay Certification dated September 3, 2014 issued by PB Melvin Cortez, BayanPark Village Barangay, Baguio City certifying that the lot application of Georgie G.Romero was posted at the barangay hall for three (3) months and no body opposed to therequest of Ms. Romero.

3. DENR Certification issued by Edgardo S. Flor, OIC, CENR Officer certifying that Ms.Carmen Galera is an applicant-holder of MS No. V-55197 covering a parcel of landparticularly described as Lot 32, Block 21, BCS-2032-D situated at Res. Sec. "H", BaguioWorkingmen's Village, Baguio City with an area of 250 square meters;

4. Certificate of Non-Property;5. Tax Declaration of the subject lot;6. Official receipt as proof of payment of real property tax for CY 2014;7. Waiver and Quitclaim executed by Romeo S. Galera, Percival S. Galera and Juliet

Galera-Lim, all siblings of Georgie Galera Romero waiving and quitclaiming the rightsover the said property to Georgie Galera Romero;

8. Waiver and Quitclaim executed by Letty P. Galera, Solomon P. Galera Jr., Jennifer P.Galera-Casil, Lerriza P. Galera-Abad and Jonathan P. Galera, all heirs of Carmen S.Galera, waiving and quitclaiming their rights over the said property in favor of GeorgieGalera-Romero;

9. Pictures of improvements; and10. Lot plan.

In view of all the foregoing, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housingrecommends approval of the application of Ms. Georgie Galera Romero over Lot 32, Block 21,Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City. (Item 33, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


7/14


33. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-020Letter dated 18 June 2013 of Ms. Sabina Sungduan, submitting documents for the transfer of rightsover Lot 26, Block 26, Residence Section "H", Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, BaguioCity, from Ms. Delia C. Marquez in her favor.

After careful evaluation of the documents submitted by the applicant to support herapplication for the transfer of rights over Lot 26, Block 26 Residence Section "H" over theabove stated parcel of land at the Baguio Workingmen's Village, the committee finds that theapplicant substantially complied with all the essential requirements as provided for under CityOrdinance Numbered 65, series of 1948, as amended.


1. Sworn application;2. Barangay Certification dated October 2, 2014 issued by PB Tomas A. Tolete

(Ret. Judge), East Bayan Park Aurora Hill Barangay, Baguio City certifying that the lotapplication of Sabina C. Sungduan was posted at the barangay hall for fifteen (15) daysand that the above named person introduced thereof (sic) improvements on the said lot.Further the application was posted in conspicuous place for fifteen days and there were

no other claimants;3. Certificate of non-property;4. Certificate of Non-Delinquency;5. Tax Declaration of Real Property;6. Copy of City Council Resolution Numbered 8-73 that was approved during the regular

meeting held on January 10, 1973;7. Waiver of Rights executed by and between Delia Marquez and Sabina Sungduan;8. Official Tax receipt as proof of payment of real property tax for CY 2014;9. Pictures of improvements; and10. Lot plan.

In view of all the foregoing, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housingrecommends approval of the application of Ms. Sabina Sungduan for transfer of rights overLot 26, Block 26, Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City.(Item 34, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

34. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-021Letter dated 18 June 2013 of Mr. Gerald Sungduan, submitting documents for the transfer of rightsover Lot 25, Block 26 at Residence Section "H", Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill,Baguio City, from Ms. Cleopatra C. Maddela in his favor.

After careful evaluation of the documents submitted by the applicant to support hisapplication for the transfer of rights over Lot 25, Block 26 over the above stated parcel ofland at the Baguio Workingmen's Village, the committee finds that the applicant substantiallycomplied with all the essential requirements as provided for under City Ordinance Numbered65, series of 1948, as amended.


1. Sworn application;2. Barangay Certification dated October 2, 2014 issued by PB Tomas A. Tolete (Ret.

Judge), East Bayan Park Aurora Hill Barangay, Baguio City certifying that the lotapplication of Gerald Sungduan was posted at the barangay hall for fifteen (15) daysand that the above named person introduced thereof (sic) improvements on the saidlot. Further the application was posted in conspicuous place for fifteen days and therewere no other claimants;

3. Certificate of Non-Property;4. Certificate of Non-Delinquency;5. Tax Declaration of Real Property;6. Copy of City Council Resolution Numbered 8-73 that was approved during the regular

meeting held on January 10, 1973;7. Waiver of Rights executed by and between Cleopatra C. Maddela and Gerald

Sungduan;

8. Official Tax receipt as proof of payment of real property tax for CY 2014;9. Pictures of improvements; and10. Lot plan.

In view of all the foregoing, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housingrecommends approval of the application of Mr. Gerald Sungduan for transfer of rights overLot 25, Block 26, Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City.(Item 35, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


8/14


35. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-025Letter dated 22 August 2014 of Ms. Felicidad Orante to Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., submitting herapplication for the transfer of rights over Lot 16, Block 22, Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill,Baguio City, containing an area of 250 square meters, more or less from Josie T. Andrada in her favor.

After careful evaluation of the documents submitted by the applicant to support her applicationover the above stated parcel of land at the Baguio Workingmen's Village, the committee finds thatthe applicant substantially complied with all the essential requirements as provided for under CityOrdinance Numbered 65, series of 1948, as amended.

The applicant submitted the following documents:1. Certification dated 22 May 2013 of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 7, Baguio City

certifying that its DECISION dated April 11, 2013 in Civil Case No. 6227-R entitled: JosieAndrada vs Felicidad Orante, has not been appealed from, revoked, amended or modifiedand is now final and executory;

2. DECISION dated April 11, 2013 in Civil Case No. 6227-R entitled: Josie Andrada vsFelicidad Orante;

3. CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY dated 19 July 2006 issued by Judge Edilberto T. Claravall,Presiding Judge, RTC Branch 60, Baguio City certifying that LRC ADM CASE NO. 1543-Rhas not been amended, revoked or appealed from and has attained finality;

4. ORDER dated 31 March 2006 issued by Judge Edilberto T. Claravall, Presiding Judge, RTCBranch 60, Baguio City, in re: LRC ADM CASE NO. 1543-R or Ex-Parte Petition for theissuance of Writ of Possession over a parcel of land covered by ARP No. 2006-01-04-51603and Building covered by ARP No. 2006-02-004-51604 of the City Assessor of Baguio in thename of Petitioner Felicidad Orante;

5. SHERIFF'S RETURN submitted by Delfin E. Ariaga, Sheriff IV, RTC, Baguio City,informing that the Writ of Possession was duly served and enforced and the propertiescovered by ARP No. 2006-01-04-51603 (land) and ARP No. 2006-02-004-51604 (Building)have already been turned over to the peaceful possession of the petitioner, Felicidad Orante;

6. Certificate of Non-Property;7. Certificate of Non-Delinquency as to payment of taxes and other obligations to the City;8. Baguio City Council Resolution No. 141, series of 2004 that was approved during the

Regular Session held on 02 June 2004;9. Sketch Plan;10. Sworn Application;11. Memorandum for Engr. Leo C. Bernardez Jr. dated January 3, 2007 submitted by Engr.

Gerald Sannad;

12. Tax Declaration of Real Property; and13. Motion for the Issuance of Writ of Execution/Certificate of Finality issued November 11,2014 in Civil Case No. 6227-R entitled: Josie T. Andrada vs Felicidad Orante and CityAssessor of Baguio.

In view of all the foregoing, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommendsapproval of the application of Ms. Felicidad Orante for the transfer of rights over Lot 16, Block 22,Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City. (Item 36, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

36. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-026Letter dated February 3, 2014 of Mrs. Florecita A. Sevilla, et al., of Workingmen's Village, East ModernSite, Baguio City to Hon. Leandro Yangot Jr., City Councilor, re: Sworn application for occupancy and/or

purchase of lot and/or cottage at the Workingmen's Village.

After careful evaluation of the documents submitted by the applicant to support her applicationover the above stated parcel of land at the Baguio Workingmen's Village, the committee finds thatthe applicant substantially complied with all the essential requirements as provided for under CityOrdinance Numbered 05, series of 1948, as amended.

The applicant submitted the following documents:1. Barangay Certification dated July 21, 2014 issued by PB Nenita V. Trinidad, East Modern

Site, Aurora Hill Barangay, Baguio City certifying that the lot application of Florecita A.Sevilla was posted at the barangay hall for one (1) month and that there is no opposition tothe application;

2. Certificate of Non-Property;3. Tax Declaration of the subject lot;4. Tax of the residential house that was built within the subject lot;5. DENR-CAR certification issued by Edgardo S. Flor, OIC, CENR Officer certifying that

Florecita A. Sevilla is an applicant holder of a parcel of land containing Two Hundred FiftyFour (254) square meters, Lot 9, Block 36, GSS-529 which is inside Exec. Proc. No. 358(Baguio Workingmen's Village);

6. Affidavit of Waiver and Quitclaim executed by Angelica Arcelona-Juan quitclaiming therights over the said property to Florecita A. Sevilla;

7. Agreement with undertaking executed by and between Angelica Rabena Arcelona-Juan,Florecita Rabena Arcelona-Sevilla and Agnes Arcelona-Alamares;

8. Tax Official receipt as proof payment of real property tax for CY 2014;9. Pictures of improvements; and10. Lot plan.

In view of all the foregoing, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommendsapproval of the application of Mrs. Florecita A. Sevilla over Lot 9, Block 36, Baguio Workingmen'sVillage, Aurora Hill, Baguio City. (Item 37, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


9/14


37. Committee Report Nr. HEALTH-2014-017Letter dated 14 November 2014 of Dr. Minda S. Manantan, Executive Director, National MeatInspection Service, Quezon City, seeking cooperation in ensuring the safety of meat consumersduring this holiday season and submitting copy the handbook on Meat Regulations which will helpthe Sanggunian in the adoption of local ordinances in regulating meat trade.

As contained in the letter, it requests the City Government of Baguio to:"1. Direct your personnel involved in market regulations for heightened visibility andenforcement of applicable regulations in particular AO 5 and AO 6 which provide forthe hygienic handling of meat in the markets:

. Sale of frozen meat is NOT allowed in the market when the stall is not equipped withtemperature controlled storage (freezer, chillers, refrigerators, etc.);

. Prohibit entry and sale of "hot meat" (those not coming from legitimateslaughterhouses and did not pass government inspection);

. Confiscate "botcha" or meat from double dead animals.

2. Display tarpaulins and posters calling for consumer vigilance (provide consumercomplaint hotlines or contact numbers)".

Considering that the holiday season is already underway, the Committee on Health and

Sanitation, Ecology and Environmental Protection recommends APPROVAL of the request ofthe National Meat Inspection Service (NMIS), and refer the matter to the City Mayor's Officefor appropriate action. The different instrumentalities of the City Government of Baguio whoshall be charged to oversee and implement the foregoing and apposite ordinances and nationallaws regarding food safety is thus requested to closely coordinate with the NMIS.(Item 38, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

38. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2014-029Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0093-14 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr. entitled, "Urgingthe DENR-CAR to pursue the segregation of all Baguio City barangays within the Camp John HayReservation."

The Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommends APPROVAL of theproposed resolution. (Item 39, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

39. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2015-007

SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION:Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0020-14 introduced by Hon. Fred L Bagbagen and coauthored by Hon.Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog, Hon. Roberto C. Ortega, Hon. Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda, Hon. IsabeloB. Cosalan Jr., Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Hon. Elmer O. Datuin, Hon. Richard A. Cariño, Hon.Faustino A. Olowan, Hon. Joel A. Alangsab, Hon. Elaine D. Sembrano, Hon. Peter C. Fianza andHon. Michael L. Lawana entitled, "Amending Section 3 of Ordinance Numbered 02, series of 2012'Prohibiting job mix activities on major thoroughfares and all barangay roads in the City of Baguioas well as the placing of cement batching stations therein'."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 24 March 2014 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr.90]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication;[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION AND POSTING - 27 October 2014

- The above proposed ordinance was published in the 13 November 2014 issue of Sun Star Baguio.It was also posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, City Public Market, City Library, Post Office andHealth Services Office starting 28 October 2014.)

The Committee on Laws recommends APPROVAL on SECOND READING AFTERPUBLICATION and POSTING of the above stated proposed ordinance. (Item 40, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

40. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2015-0091st Indorsement dated 04 December 2014 of the Office of Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan,forwarding for information and appropriate action the Extra Judicial Settlement of Estate withSimultaneous Deed of Donation made and executed by and between Emilio P. Perez, et al., hereinreferred to as the Heirs/Donors and the City Government of Baguio represented by City MayorMauricio G. Domogan, herein referred to as the Donee, over a parcel of land at Bakakeng Norte,Baguio City.

Considering that the City Engineer's Office recommended that the subject lot be accepted fordonation by the City Government since it has long been utilized as part of the BakakengBarangay Road, the Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Deedof Donation. (Item 41, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

41. Committee Report Nr. PWORKS-2015-002Letter dated 05 January 2015 of Honorable City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan, requestingrealignment of the projects as contained on page 7 of the 2014 Annual Investment Plan, morespecifically on Item III-A-1 - Major Development Projects (2014 Local Development Fund) toDesign and Construction of an Engineered Sanitary Landfill/site Development of Integrated SolidWaste Disposal site at Sto. Tomas Multi Land Use Area, Baguio City in the amount ofP87,802,0000.00.

The Committee on Public Works recommends for DISCUSSION EN BANC the above requestrealignment. (Item 42, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


10/14


42. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2015-010a. 1st Indorsement dated 15 January 2015 of the Office of Hon. City Mayor Mauricio G. Domogan,forwarding for information and appropriate action the amended BLISTT Memorandum of Agreemententered into by and among the BLISTT members and concerned agencies.

b. Letter dated 19 January 2015 of Ms. Milagros A. Rimando, Director, NEDA-CAR, BLISTT Secretariat

to Hon. Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog, requesting that the BLISTT MOA be reviewed and the passage of aresolution confirming the signing by the City Mayor of said MOA.

The Committee on Laws recommends confirmation of the above stated Memorandum ofAgreement.

Hon. Elmer O. Datuin, Member of the Committee signified, "the PCL of Benguet & Baguio must bemade members of the BLISTT Dev't. Council under Sec. 3.1." (Item 43, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

43. Committee Report Nr. WAYSC-2015-014Ordinance No. 01, series of 2015, of Holy Ghost Proper Barangay entitled, "An ordinance amendingSection One of Barangay Ordinance No. 1, series of 2011, otherwise known as an ordinance for one-sided parking spaces along the streets within the territorial jurisdiction of Holy Ghost Proper Barangayand prescribing regulatory fees, extending the coverage thereof to include portions of Sumulong St.,Laurel St., Laubach Road and Yangco Road."

(NOTE: Res. No. 403, s. 2011 approved the report and recommendation of the Sangguniang Panlungsod(City Council) Committee on Laws as contained in its 5th indorsement dated 29 September 2011 on

Barangay Ordinance no. 01, series of 2011 [an ordinance providing for one [side] parking spaces along thestreets within the territorial jurisdiction of Holy Ghost Proper Barangay and prescribing regulatory feesthereof.], of Holy Ghost Proper Barangay, Baguio City.)

In view of the foregoing compliance with Sections 186 and 187 of the Local Government Codemandating that ordinances levying taxes, fees or charges shall be the subject of a public hearingprior to its enactment as could be evidenced by the hereto attached minutes of meetings andattendance to the general assemblies, the Committee on Ways and Means and Finance (Cluster C)recommends FAVORABLE REVIEW of the subject barangay ordinance. (Item 44, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

44. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2015-011SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATIONProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0088-13 introduced by Hon. Edison R. Bilog, Hon. Roberto R. Ortega, Hon.Betty Lourdes F. Tabanda, Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan, Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Hon. Elmer O. Datuin,Hon. Faustino A. Olowan, Hon. Joel A. Alangsab, Hon. Peter C. Fianza, and Hon. Fred L. Bagbagen,

entitled, "Amending Ordinance Numbered 13, series of 2012 entitled, 'Furthermore amending the TradeFair Ordinance of 1994'."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 11 November 2013 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 85];[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication'; and[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION - 03 November 2014

- The above proposed ordinance was published in the Sun.Star Baguio issue of 13 November 2014and was posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, Public Market, Post Office, City Library and the HealthServices Office starting 10 November 2014.)

The Committee on Laws recommends approval on SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATIONand POSTING of the above stated proposed ordinance. (Item 45, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

45. Committee Report Nr. MARKET-2015-006Board Resolution No. 09, series of 2015 of the Liga ng mga Barangay- Baguio City Chapter entitled,"Resolution strongly urging the City Government of Baguio to allow the Liga ng mga Barangay- BaguioCity Chapter to conduct a trade fair at Juan Luna Drive on March 15, 2015 to May 15, 2015 for the

purpose of raising funds for the benefit and provisional grant of honorarium for barangay tanods and s treetsweepers of the 128 barangays of City of Baguio."

The Committee on Market, Trade and Commerce puts forward the following observations:1. The proposed trade fair activity from March 15 to May 15, 2015 is a two-month timeframe

that patently violates the 15-day timeline restriction provided under Section 2 of OrdinanceNo. 13, series of 2012 entitled, "Furthermore amending the Trade Fair Ordinance of 1994."

2. The same activity which is requested to be held at Burnham Park is also violative of thevenue-restriction provided for in the same Section under the said Ordinance, which I quote,"to totally disallow the conduct of trade fairs and other similar activities in all city-owned orcity-managed public parks..."

3. The noble intention as explained in proponent's Board Resolution No. 09, series of 2015 ---which is to raise funds for the benefit and provision grant of honorarium for barangaytanods and street sweepers of the 128 barangays in the City --- cannot justify the patentviolation of an existing City Ordinance. No goal, no matter how lofty, can ever make theactivity as legal and in conformity of the law. Other law-abiding means of fund-raisingshould instead be fostered by government frontline service deliverers, least of all barangayassociations such as the Liga proponent.

4. It is made to appear before us that the protected activity may qualify as among the activitiesunder the Summer Vacation Program annually conducted under the city government'sauspices. The implication is misguiding and has no basis in fact. Nowhere is it providedunder the Sumvac 2015 program that trade fair may be among such summer activities.Furthermore, it should be noted that through the years, the Sumvac has never had anytrade fair as part of its activity list.

In view thereof, the committee recommends DENIAL. (Item 46, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


11/14


46. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2015-014SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTINGProposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0034-14 on Integrated City PPP Code (Selection Process and ContractManagement) authored by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., coauthored by Hon. Joel A. Alangsab and Hon.Michael L. Lawana entitled, "A City Code pursuing a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) approach towardsdevelopment, providing for the procedure for selecting the private sector proponent, adopting a contract

management framework, and providing appropriations and for other purposes."(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 02 June 2014 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr.72];[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposedordinance will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed pr ior to publication";[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION AND POSTING - 22 September 2014 Regular Session

- Posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, City Public Market, City Library, Post Office and HealthServices Office starting 24 September 2014.; and

[d] The simplified version of PO 0034-2014 as attached to the letter dated 19 September 2014 of Hon.Leandro B. Yangot Jr. to Hon. Richard A. Cariño was approved on 2nd reading for publication by posting on22 September 2014 Regular Session.)

The Committee on Laws recommends to APPROVE ON SECOND READING AFTERPUBLICATION BY POSTING the substituted and rewritten version of the proposed ordinanceafter consultation with the Members of the Council. It is further proposed that said ordinance be

jointly and collectively authored by all the Members of the City Council.(Item 47, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

46a. Report on Amended Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0034-14 introduced by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr.,Hon. Joel A. Alangsab and Hon. Michael L. Lawana, entitled, "A City Code pursuing a Public-PrivatePartnership (PPP) approach towards development, providing for the procedure for selecting the privatesector proponent, adopting a contract management framework, and providing appropriations and for other

purposes." (Second Reading after posting) (Item 47a, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

47. Committee Report Nr. UPLH-2015-002Letter dated 28 November 2013 of Mr. Sunny G. Isidro to Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., resubmitting hisapplication for transfer of rights over Lot 44, Block 25, Baguio Working's Village, East Bayan Park,Baguio City.

(NOTE: The above matter is related to the letter dated 14 April 2010 of Mr. Sunny G. Isidro to Hon. IsabeloB. Cosalan Jr., withdrawing his application over Lot 44, Block 25, Baguio Workingmen’s Village, East BayanPark, Aurora Hill Barangay, Baguio City.)

After careful evaluation of the documents submitted by the applicant to support his application overthe above-stated parcel of land at the Baguio Workingmen's Village, the committee finds that theapplicant substantially complied with all the essential requirements as provided for under CityOrdinance Numbered 65, series of 1948, as amended.

The applicant submitted the following documents:1. Sworn Application;2. Barangay Certification dated December 3, 2014 issued by PB Judge Tomas A. Tolete (Ret),

East Bayan Park, Aurora Hill Barangay, Baguio City certifying that Sunny G. Isidro is thelone applicant of Lot 44, Block 25 of the Baguio Workingmen's Village, further upon ocularinspection no person claiming to have application on the lot was verified and that there wasno existing improvement of other claimants except that of Mr. Sunny Isidro on the specifiedlot;

3. DENR-CAR certification issued by Edgardo S. Flor, OIC, CENR Officer certifying that aparcel of land containing an area of one hundred twenty nine (129) square meters more orless located at Res. Sec. "H" overlaps a portion of creek (3.00-5.00 m wide). However thisplan falls within Lot 1, Executive Proclamation No. 358 dated September 17, 1938 ofWorkingmen's Village and outside Forest/Military Reservation;

4. Barangay Resolution No. 25, series of 2004 of East Bayan Park entitled "A RESOLUTIONFOR THE PROPER OFFICE PERMISSION FOR THE EAST BAYAN PARK BARANGAY

AURORA HILL, BAGUIO CITY TO WAIVE THE PARCEL OF LAND LOT NO. 44,BLOCK 25 TO MR. SUNNY G. ISIDRO;

5. Joint affidavit of Carolina G. Isidro and Sunny G. Isidro on 24th day of July 2008;6. East Bayan Park Barangay undated notice to the public that the Council of Barangay East

Bayan Park, Aurora Hill, Baguio City through the Resolution No. 25, series of 2004 hasallowed Mr. Sunny G. Isidro to build a house on a public lot between Mr. and Mrs. Noli G.Trinidad and Mr. and Mrs. Paciante Balnges residence signed by Punong Barangay FelipeGabriz;

7. Certificate of Non-Property;8. Tax Official receipt as proof payment of real property tax for CY 2014;9. Pictures of improvements; and10. Lot Plan.

In view of all the foregoing, the Committee on Urban Planning, Lands and Housing recommendsapproval of the application of Mr. Sunny G. Isidro for the transfer of rights over Lot 44, Block 25,Baguio Workingmen's Village, Aurora Hill, Baguio City. (Item 48, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

48. Committee Report Nr. TOURISM-2015-010Letter dated 24 April 2015 of Mr. Adrian Galang, President, UP Management Association, Inc. to Hon.Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr., seeking partnership with the City Government of Baguio for the conduct of aseminar on sustainable tourism entitled, "Destination Management: A Strategy Towards Sustainability" onMay 13, 2015, 1:00 pm at Jack's Grandview, #58 Montinola Subdivision, Kisad Road, Baguio City.

The Committee on Tourism, Special Events, Parks and Playgrounds recommends to regretfullyinform the UP Management Association, Inc. through its President, Mr. Adrian Galang that theirrequest could not be granted because there is no immediate available fund for their event. (Item 50, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


12/14


49. Committee Report Nr. LAWS-2015-020a. Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0033-14 authored by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Hon. Joel A. Alangsaband Hon. Elmer O. Datuin entitled, "Dividing the administrative responsibilities for the dissolvedBarangay Bagong Lipunan, Baguio City."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING - 26 May 014 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 74]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed ordinance

will be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication."[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING - 03 November 2014- Posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, City Public Market, City Library, Post Office and Health Services Office

starting 04 November 2014.[d] SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTING – 06 April 2015)

b. Letter dated 28 April 2015 of Ms. Evelyn B. Trinidad, CESO V, City Director, Department of theInterior and Local Government (DILG), Baguio City Field Office, submitting her opinion regarding theProposed Ordinance Nr. 0033-14 authored by Hon. Leandro B. Yangot Jr., Hon. Joel A. Alangsab andHon. Elmer O. Datuin.The Committee on Laws recommends that the above stated matters be discussed en banc. (Item 51, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

50. Committee Report Nr. EDUC-2015-002Proposed Resolution Nr. PR 0059-15 introduced by Hon. Vice Mayor Edison R. Bilog entitled,"Requesting the Commission on Higher Education (CHED), through Secretary Luistro for the immediaterelease of the educational benefits of the family members of the SAF 44."The Committee on Education, Culture and Historical Research recommends discussion en banc ofthe proposed resolution to consider the following observations, to wit:

1. While DepEd Secretary Armin A. Luistro was directed by the President to assist inproviding the relatives and families of the SAF 44 also with college educational benefits,the program that was identified and coordinated for the purpose is with the Commissionon Higher Education (CHED) that the request may have to be directed to CHEDChairperson Dr. Patricia B. Licuanan;

2. The financial assistance that may be extended will be in the form of a scholarship in whichdependents may be found to qualify to or a grants-in-aid or "Tulong Dunong" ofP12,000.00 each under the Student Financial Assistance Program (STUFAPS);

3. The release of the financial assistance or benefit will therefore be in accordance with thescholarship program to which the dependent may qualify to or with the "TulongDunong" program;

4. To avail of the benefits, dependents will have to file their respective applications with theRegional Offices of CHED where they reside which will collate all the applications and

transmit the same to the central office of the CHED;5. In the Cordillera Administrative Region (CAR), eight (8) of the nine (9) applications were

transmitted to the central office on May 28, 2015. The last application that wasaccordingly received recently was likewise transmitted to the CHED, also recently;

6. It will further appear that the processing of the applications will require the applicant tofirst enroll in a chosen school. His enrolment form and a certification of enrolment willthen have to be submitted to the CHED. In short, the financial assistance will be in thenature of a reimbursement;

7. The immediate release of the financial assistance to the dependents of SAF 44 will nottherefore be in accordance with the CHED system or program which the Committee findswill be destructive to the cause of SAF 44 for reasons that need not be mentioned;

8. The financial assistance being provided by the CHED is in addition to educational aids orgrants being provided the dependents of the SAF 44, including from funds beingadministered by the NAPOLCOM. (Item 52, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

51. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2015-006SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTING:Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0015-15 introduced by Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr. entitled, "Makingavailable a Livelihood and Marketing Assistance Fund for the promotion of Barangay-Based LivelihoodGroups and Micro and Small Enterprises in the City of Baguio."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING -11 May 2015 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr.54]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed ordinancewill be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication.''[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING - 25 May 2015

- Posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, City Public Market, City Library, Post Office and Health ServicesOffice starting 26 May 2015.)

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities (PWD),recommends APPROVAL on SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTING of theabove proposed ordinance. (Item 53, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

52. Committee Report Nr. EMPLOY-2015-007SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTING:

Proposed Ordinance Nr. PO 0014-15 Introduced by Hon. Isabelo B. Cosalan Jr. entitled, "An Ordinanceestablishing the One Barangay One Product Program of the City Government of Baguio."

(NOTE: [a] FIRST READING -04 April 2015 Regular Session [Agenda Item Nr. 60]; and[b] Rule IV, Sec. 2A of the Internal Rules of Procedures states "On second reading before publication of anordinance shall be open for discussion, proposals and amendments to know whether or not the proposed ordinancewill be approved before publication. Amendments may be allowed prior to publication.'[c] SECOND READING FOR PUBLICATION BY POSTING - 25 May 2015

- Posted on the bulletin boards of City Hall, City Public Market, City Library, Post Office and Health ServicesOffice starting 26 May 2015.)

The Committee on Employment, Livelihood, Cooperatives and Persons With Disabilities (PWD),recommends APPROVAL on SECOND READING AFTER PUBLICATION BY POSTING of theabove proposed ordinance. (Item 54, 13 July 2015 Agenda)

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

w

w

.

c

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o

u

n

c

i

l

.

b

a

g

u

i

o

.

g

o

v

.

p

h

w

.

c

o


13/14


14/14

20 july 2015 agenda(marked)

Documents