©2004 prentice hall publishing ayers/collinge, 1/e 1 chapter 11 “fiscal policy in action”
TRANSCRIPT
1 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Chapter 11“Fiscal Policy in Action”
Chapter 11“Fiscal Policy in Action”
ECONOMICS: ECONOMICS: EXPLORE & APPLYEXPLORE & APPLYby Ayers and Collingeby Ayers and Collinge
ECONOMICS: ECONOMICS: EXPLORE & APPLYEXPLORE & APPLYby Ayers and Collingeby Ayers and Collinge
2 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Learning ObjectivesLearning ObjectivesLearning ObjectivesLearning Objectives
1.1. List the major revenue sources in the United List the major revenue sources in the United States.States.
2.2. Distinguish two principles of tax equity, and Distinguish two principles of tax equity, and explain why they conflict.explain why they conflict.
3.3. Interpret why the U.S. income tax is Interpret why the U.S. income tax is structured as it is, and why critics suggest structured as it is, and why critics suggest changing it. changing it.
4.4. Show why workers pay more Social Security Show why workers pay more Social Security tax than they see withdrawn on their pay tax than they see withdrawn on their pay stubs.stubs.
1.1. List the major revenue sources in the United List the major revenue sources in the United States.States.
2.2. Distinguish two principles of tax equity, and Distinguish two principles of tax equity, and explain why they conflict.explain why they conflict.
3.3. Interpret why the U.S. income tax is Interpret why the U.S. income tax is structured as it is, and why critics suggest structured as it is, and why critics suggest changing it. changing it.
4.4. Show why workers pay more Social Security Show why workers pay more Social Security tax than they see withdrawn on their pay tax than they see withdrawn on their pay stubs.stubs.
3 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Learning ObjectivesLearning ObjectivesLearning ObjectivesLearning Objectives
5.5. Justify the use of consumption taxes, Justify the use of consumption taxes, including the value added taxes of Canada including the value added taxes of Canada and Europe.and Europe.
6.6. (E&A) Discuss issues of market efficiency and (E&A) Discuss issues of market efficiency and tax equity as they relate to security cost.tax equity as they relate to security cost.
5.5. Justify the use of consumption taxes, Justify the use of consumption taxes, including the value added taxes of Canada including the value added taxes of Canada and Europe.and Europe.
6.6. (E&A) Discuss issues of market efficiency and (E&A) Discuss issues of market efficiency and tax equity as they relate to security cost.tax equity as they relate to security cost.
4 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
11.111.1POLICY IN PRACTICEPOLICY IN PRACTICE11.111.1POLICY IN PRACTICEPOLICY IN PRACTICE
o ““In this world, nothing can be said to be In this world, nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.”certain, except death and taxes.”
– Benjamin FranklinBenjamin Franklin
o Few thing are less popular than Few thing are less popular than taxestaxes, , since taxes represent money that is taken since taxes represent money that is taken from us involuntarily by the government.from us involuntarily by the government.
o On the other hand, we all like to be the On the other hand, we all like to be the recipients of government spending.recipients of government spending.
o ““In this world, nothing can be said to be In this world, nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.”certain, except death and taxes.”
– Benjamin FranklinBenjamin Franklin
o Few thing are less popular than Few thing are less popular than taxestaxes, , since taxes represent money that is taken since taxes represent money that is taken from us involuntarily by the government.from us involuntarily by the government.
o On the other hand, we all like to be the On the other hand, we all like to be the recipients of government spending.recipients of government spending.
5 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
The purchase of The purchase of goods and services goods and services such as highways or such as highways or national defense.national defense.
Regulatory Regulatory programs like programs like OSHA, Health OSHA, Health Administration, or Administration, or the EPA.the EPA.
The purchase of The purchase of goods and services goods and services such as highways or such as highways or national defense.national defense.
Regulatory Regulatory programs like programs like OSHA, Health OSHA, Health Administration, or Administration, or the EPA.the EPA.
Transfer paymentsTransfer payments and other and other safety-net safety-net programsprograms that that redistribute income redistribute income to the needy like to the needy like welfare, or welfare, or unemployment unemployment payments.payments.
Transfer paymentsTransfer payments and other and other safety-net safety-net programsprograms that that redistribute income redistribute income to the needy like to the needy like welfare, or welfare, or unemployment unemployment payments.payments.
Policy in PracticePolicy in PracticePolicy in PracticePolicy in Practice
Government spending encompasses a variety of programs.
6 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Federal Spending (in billions)Federal Spending (in billions)Federal Spending (in billions)Federal Spending (in billions)
YearYear TotalTotal
ExpendituresExpenditures
PurchasesPurchases Transfer Transfer PaymentsPayments
NetNet
InterestInterest
Grants in AidGrants in Aid
to State and to State and Local Govt.Local Govt.
19791979 701.1701.1 415415 230.2230.2 44.844.8 66.366.3
19801980 812812 469.4469.4 275275 53.253.2 72.372.3
19811981 923.7923.7 524.5524.5 311.8311.8 71.671.6 72.572.5
19821982 1025.11025.1 572.1572.1 348.5348.5 86.686.6 69.569.5
19831983 1113.51113.5 613.1613.1 376.4376.4 99.499.4 71.671.6
19841984 1192.11192.1 661.5661.5 387.4387.4 120.7120.7 76.776.7
19851985 1290.71290.7 719.5719.5 414.2414.2 136.5136.5 80.980.9
19861986 1378.11378.1 769.1769.1 440.4440.4 145.1145.1 87.687.6
7 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Federal Spending (continued)Federal Spending (continued)Federal Spending (continued)Federal Spending (continued)
YearYear TotalTotal
ExpendituresExpenditures
PurchasesPurchases Transfer Transfer PaymentsPayments
NetNet
InterestInterest
Grants in AidGrants in Aid
to State and to State and Local Govt.Local Govt.
19871987 1458.21458.2 813.6813.6 458458 156.7156.7 83.983.9
19881988 1532.71532.7 850.7850.7 486.5486.5 168.3168.3 91.691.6
19891989 1641.61641.6 902.6902.6 529.6529.6 187.0187.0 98.398.3
19901990 1778.01778.0 965.7965.7 583.1583.1 204.3204.3 111.4111.4
19911991 1879.71879.7 1015.21015.2 620.1620.1 223.1223.1 131.6131.6
19921992 2046.92046.9 1047.41047.4 745.4745.4 232.0232.0 149.1149.1
19931993 2130.52130.5 1072.11072.1 793.2793.2 235.8235.8 162.6162.6
19941994 2196.72196.7 1102.31102.3 825.4825.4 244.0244.0 174.5174.5
8 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Federal Spending (continued)Federal Spending (continued)Federal Spending (continued)Federal Spending (continued)
YearYear TotalTotal
ExpendituresExpenditures
PurchasesPurchases Transfer Transfer PaymentsPayments
NetNet
InterestInterest
Grants in AidGrants in Aid
to State and to State and Local Govt.Local Govt.
19951995 2293.72293.7 1133.91133.9 869.9869.9 268.0268.0 184.5184.5
19961996 2384.52384.5 1171.81171.8 916.0916.0 274.4274.4 190.4190.4
19971997 2462.42462.4 1223.31223.3 945945 275.3275.3 196.8196.8
19981998 2592.32592.3 1261.41261.4 965.9965.9 278.8278.8 210.3210.3
19991999 2624.82624.8 1328.01328.0 1000.11000.1 263.8263.8 230.5230.5
20002000 2772.52772.5 1261.41261.4 965.9965.9 278.8278.8 210.3210.3
Federal spending has grown rapidly over the last century, especially spending on transfer payments,
interest on public debt, and grant-in aid.
9 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Marginal Personal Tax Rates for Singles, 2002Marginal Personal Tax Rates for Singles, 2002Marginal Personal Tax Rates for Singles, 2002Marginal Personal Tax Rates for Singles, 2002
•An incremental tax rate on incremental An incremental tax rate on incremental income is know as a income is know as a marginal tax ratemarginal tax rate..•Marginal Tax rate= additional taxes Marginal Tax rate= additional taxes owed as a percentage of additional incomeowed as a percentage of additional income
•An incremental tax rate on incremental An incremental tax rate on incremental income is know as a income is know as a marginal tax ratemarginal tax rate..•Marginal Tax rate= additional taxes Marginal Tax rate= additional taxes owed as a percentage of additional incomeowed as a percentage of additional income
Tax RateTax Rate Taxable IncomeTaxable Income
10%10% Up to $6,000Up to $6,000
15%15% $6,001 - $27,000$6,001 - $27,000
27%27% $27,951 - $67,700$27,951 - $67,700
30%30% $67,701 - $141,250$67,701 - $141,250
35%35% $141,251 - $307,050$141,251 - $307,050
38.6%38.6% $307,051 or more$307,051 or more
10 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Federal Revenue SourcesFederal Revenue SourcesFederal Revenue SourcesFederal Revenue SourcesOther
8% Individual Income taxes
49%
Corporate Income taxes
8%
Social Security
taxes35%
Other8% Individual
Income taxes49%
Corporate Income taxes
8%
Social Security
taxes35%
11 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Federal Revenue ExpendituresFederal Revenue ExpendituresFederal Revenue ExpendituresFederal Revenue Expenditures
Other3%
Grants14% Purchases
27%
Transfer Payments
44%
Net Intererest
12%
Other3%
Grants14% Purchases
27%
Transfer Payments
44%
Net Intererest
12%
12 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
State and Local Government State and Local Government Revenue SourcesRevenue Sources
State and Local Government State and Local Government Revenue SourcesRevenue Sources
Corporation net income
taxes3%
Individual Income taxes
23%
Property Taxes19%
Revenue from the Federal
Government22%
Other Taxes and Charges
33%
Corporation net income
taxes3%
Individual Income taxes
23%
Property Taxes19%
Revenue from the Federal
Government22%
Other Taxes and Charges
33%
13 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
State and Local Government State and Local Government ExpendituresExpenditures
State and Local Government State and Local Government ExpendituresExpenditures
Public Welfare16%
Highways7%
Education34%Other
43%
Public Welfare16%
Highways7%
Education34%Other
43%
14 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
When all revenue received by all units of When all revenue received by all units of government are added together, the result is government are added together, the result is that government revenues are over 30% of the that government revenues are over 30% of the value of production.value of production.
The average American must work until The average American must work until “tax “tax freedom day”freedom day” each year - declared to be April each year - declared to be April 2727thth as of 2002, in order to have enough money as of 2002, in order to have enough money to pay the federal government.to pay the federal government.
When all revenue received by all units of When all revenue received by all units of government are added together, the result is government are added together, the result is that government revenues are over 30% of the that government revenues are over 30% of the value of production.value of production.
The average American must work until The average American must work until “tax “tax freedom day”freedom day” each year - declared to be April each year - declared to be April 2727thth as of 2002, in order to have enough money as of 2002, in order to have enough money to pay the federal government.to pay the federal government.
Policy in PracticePolicy in PracticePolicy in PracticePolicy in Practice
15 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Evaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax Equity
The two fundamental principles of tax The two fundamental principles of tax equity are…equity are…The The benefits principlebenefits principle states that a fair tax is states that a fair tax is
one that taxes people in proportion to the one that taxes people in proportion to the benefits they receive when government benefits they receive when government spends the tax revenue.spends the tax revenue.
The The ability-to-payability-to-pay principle states that those principle states that those who can afford to pay more taxes than who can afford to pay more taxes than others should be required to do so.others should be required to do so.
The two fundamental principles of tax The two fundamental principles of tax equity are…equity are…The The benefits principlebenefits principle states that a fair tax is states that a fair tax is
one that taxes people in proportion to the one that taxes people in proportion to the benefits they receive when government benefits they receive when government spends the tax revenue.spends the tax revenue.
The The ability-to-payability-to-pay principle states that those principle states that those who can afford to pay more taxes than who can afford to pay more taxes than others should be required to do so.others should be required to do so.
16 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
The gasoline tax would appear to satisfy the The gasoline tax would appear to satisfy the benefit principle of tax equity, because gasoline benefit principle of tax equity, because gasoline tax revenues are earmarked for highway tax revenues are earmarked for highway construction and repair.construction and repair.
The ability-to-pay principle is interpreted to The ability-to-pay principle is interpreted to mean that taxes designed for redistributing mean that taxes designed for redistributing income should be income should be progressive.progressive.
A progressive tax A progressive tax collects a higher percentage of collects a higher percentage of high than of low incomes. high than of low incomes.
The gasoline tax would appear to satisfy the The gasoline tax would appear to satisfy the benefit principle of tax equity, because gasoline benefit principle of tax equity, because gasoline tax revenues are earmarked for highway tax revenues are earmarked for highway construction and repair.construction and repair.
The ability-to-pay principle is interpreted to The ability-to-pay principle is interpreted to mean that taxes designed for redistributing mean that taxes designed for redistributing income should be income should be progressive.progressive.
A progressive tax A progressive tax collects a higher percentage of collects a higher percentage of high than of low incomes. high than of low incomes.
Evaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax Equity
17 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
A A regressive taxregressive tax collects a higher collects a higher percentage of low incomes than of high percentage of low incomes than of high incomesincomes
A A proportional taxproportional tax collects the same collects the same percentage of income, no matter what the percentage of income, no matter what the income is.income is.
A A flat taxflat tax that taxes all income at the that taxes all income at the same tax rate . same tax rate .
A A regressive taxregressive tax collects a higher collects a higher percentage of low incomes than of high percentage of low incomes than of high incomesincomes
A A proportional taxproportional tax collects the same collects the same percentage of income, no matter what the percentage of income, no matter what the income is.income is.
A A flat taxflat tax that taxes all income at the that taxes all income at the same tax rate . same tax rate .
Evaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax EquityEvaluating Tax Equity
18 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Trading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and Equity Trading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and Equity
Economic efficiency involves getting the most Economic efficiency involves getting the most valuable output from the inputs available.valuable output from the inputs available.
In general an In general an efficient taxefficient tax would be one that would be one that does not change our behavior, nor can it be does not change our behavior, nor can it be influenced, or escaped.influenced, or escaped.
Taxes cause inefficiency.Taxes cause inefficiency. Tax increases cause some workers to cut back their Tax increases cause some workers to cut back their
efforts, and some corporations to cut back on efforts, and some corporations to cut back on investments.investments.
Economic efficiency involves getting the most Economic efficiency involves getting the most valuable output from the inputs available.valuable output from the inputs available.
In general an In general an efficient taxefficient tax would be one that would be one that does not change our behavior, nor can it be does not change our behavior, nor can it be influenced, or escaped.influenced, or escaped.
Taxes cause inefficiency.Taxes cause inefficiency. Tax increases cause some workers to cut back their Tax increases cause some workers to cut back their
efforts, and some corporations to cut back on efforts, and some corporations to cut back on investments.investments.
19 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Trading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and Equity Trading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and Equity
For an efficient tax, we can turn to the For an efficient tax, we can turn to the head tax.head tax.In short, if you have a head, you pay the tax.In short, if you have a head, you pay the tax.Head taxes would not be equitable.Head taxes would not be equitable.
Government tax laws and spending Government tax laws and spending promote equity through provision of a promote equity through provision of a social safety net.social safety net.The safety net targets the needy with both The safety net targets the needy with both
cash transfers and cash transfers and in-kind benefits.in-kind benefits.
For an efficient tax, we can turn to the For an efficient tax, we can turn to the head tax.head tax.In short, if you have a head, you pay the tax.In short, if you have a head, you pay the tax.Head taxes would not be equitable.Head taxes would not be equitable.
Government tax laws and spending Government tax laws and spending promote equity through provision of a promote equity through provision of a social safety net.social safety net.The safety net targets the needy with both The safety net targets the needy with both
cash transfers and cash transfers and in-kind benefits.in-kind benefits.
20 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
A trade-off between efficiency and equity A trade-off between efficiency and equity pervades our system of tax and spending pervades our system of tax and spending programs.programs.
A safety net requires guarantees, but the better A safety net requires guarantees, but the better the guarantees, the more programs will cost, the guarantees, the more programs will cost, and the less will be the incentive to work and and the less will be the incentive to work and invest.invest.
There is no ready answer to the dilemma of There is no ready answer to the dilemma of choosing between a generous safety net and choosing between a generous safety net and incentives for economic productivity. incentives for economic productivity.
A trade-off between efficiency and equity A trade-off between efficiency and equity pervades our system of tax and spending pervades our system of tax and spending programs.programs.
A safety net requires guarantees, but the better A safety net requires guarantees, but the better the guarantees, the more programs will cost, the guarantees, the more programs will cost, and the less will be the incentive to work and and the less will be the incentive to work and invest.invest.
There is no ready answer to the dilemma of There is no ready answer to the dilemma of choosing between a generous safety net and choosing between a generous safety net and incentives for economic productivity. incentives for economic productivity.
Trading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and EquityTrading off Efficiency and Equity
21 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
11.2 11.2 SOCIAL SECURITYSOCIAL SECURITY11.2 11.2 SOCIAL SECURITYSOCIAL SECURITY
• Social SecuritySocial Security is the largest government is the largest government program, both in terms of taxes collected program, both in terms of taxes collected and spending.and spending.
• Social Security collects taxes on all Social Security collects taxes on all payroll income, and allots the proceeds payroll income, and allots the proceeds for old age, survivors, and disability for old age, survivors, and disability insurance (OASDI), and hospitalization insurance (OASDI), and hospitalization insurance (HI).insurance (HI).
• Social SecuritySocial Security is the largest government is the largest government program, both in terms of taxes collected program, both in terms of taxes collected and spending.and spending.
• Social Security collects taxes on all Social Security collects taxes on all payroll income, and allots the proceeds payroll income, and allots the proceeds for old age, survivors, and disability for old age, survivors, and disability insurance (OASDI), and hospitalization insurance (OASDI), and hospitalization insurance (HI).insurance (HI).
22 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Social Tax Rates over TimeSocial Tax Rates over TimeSocial Tax Rates over TimeSocial Tax Rates over Time
Calendar YearCalendar Year OASDIOASDI HIHI TotalTotal
1937-491937-49 1.0001.000 1.0001.000
19501950 1.5001.500 1.5001.500
1951-531951-53 1.5001.500 1.5001.500
1954-561954-56 2.0002.000 2.0002.000
1957-581957-58 2.2502.250 2.2502.250
19591959 2.5002.500 2.5002.500
1960-611960-61 3.0003.000 3.0003.000
19621962 3.1253.125 3.1253.125
1963-651963-65 3.6253.625 3.6253.625
Figure 11-4Figure 11-4
23 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)
Calendar YearCalendar Year OASDIOASDI HIHI TotalTotal
19661966 3.8503.850 .350.350 4.2004.200
19671967 3.9003.900 0.5000.500 4.4004.400
19681968 3.8003.800 0.6000.600 4.4004.400
1969-701969-70 4.2004.200 0.6000.600 4.8004.800
1971-721971-72 4.6004.600 0.6000.600 5.2005.200
19731973 4.8504.850 1.0001.000 5.8505.850
1974-771974-77 4.9504.950 0.9000.900 5.8505.850
19781978 5.0505.050 1.0001.000 6.0506.050
1979-801979-80 5.0805.080 1.0501.050 6.1306.130
Figure 11-4Figure 11-4
24 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)Social Tax Rates over Time (cont’d.)
Calendar YearCalendar Year OASDIOASDI HIHI TotalTotal
19811981 5.3505.350 1.3001.300 6.6506.650
1982-831982-83 5.4005.400 1.3001.300 6.7006.700
19841984 5.7005.700 1.3001.300 7.0007.000
19851985 5.7005.700 1.3501.350 7.0507.050
1986-871986-87 5.7005.700 1.4501.450 7.1507.150
1988-891988-89 6.0606.060 1.4501.450 7.5107.510
1990 and later1990 and later 6.2006.200 1.4501.450 7.6507.650
Figure 11-4Figure 11-4
25 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Social SecuritySocial SecuritySocial SecuritySocial Security
o The combined employer and employee Social The combined employer and employee Social security tax rate is 15.3% of the first $84,900 of security tax rate is 15.3% of the first $84,900 of that income in 2002.that income in 2002.o The threshold has been adjusted upward over time The threshold has been adjusted upward over time
in response to wage inflation.in response to wage inflation.
o The portion of the social security tax paid by The portion of the social security tax paid by employers reduces their after-tax demand for employers reduces their after-tax demand for the labor by the same percentage as the tax.the labor by the same percentage as the tax.
o In effect the tax burden has been shifted from In effect the tax burden has been shifted from employers to employees.employers to employees.
o The combined employer and employee Social The combined employer and employee Social security tax rate is 15.3% of the first $84,900 of security tax rate is 15.3% of the first $84,900 of that income in 2002.that income in 2002.o The threshold has been adjusted upward over time The threshold has been adjusted upward over time
in response to wage inflation.in response to wage inflation.
o The portion of the social security tax paid by The portion of the social security tax paid by employers reduces their after-tax demand for employers reduces their after-tax demand for the labor by the same percentage as the tax.the labor by the same percentage as the tax.
o In effect the tax burden has been shifted from In effect the tax burden has been shifted from employers to employees.employers to employees.
26 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Economy’ ssupply of labor
Economy’s demandEconomy’s demandfor laborfor labor
LaborFull-employment
#1 The more payroll taxes firms#1 The more payroll taxes firmsmust pay to government, themust pay to government, theless wages they are willing toless wages they are willing topay to workers.pay to workers.
#2 The #2 The resultresultis a loweris a lowermarket market wagewageRate.Rate.
The Effect of Social Security Tax on The Effect of Social Security Tax on WagesWages
27 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Social Security is pay-as you-go, meaning that Social Security is pay-as you-go, meaning that current workers pay for people who are current workers pay for people who are currently retired.currently retired.
In this way, Social Security redistributes In this way, Social Security redistributes income from one generation to another.income from one generation to another.
It is predicted that the number of workers to It is predicted that the number of workers to retirees will drop to only about 2 to 1 by 2030.retirees will drop to only about 2 to 1 by 2030.
To keep benefits constant the Social Security To keep benefits constant the Social Security administration estimates that the tax rate administration estimates that the tax rate would need to rise by almost 21% by 2034.would need to rise by almost 21% by 2034.
Social Security is pay-as you-go, meaning that Social Security is pay-as you-go, meaning that current workers pay for people who are current workers pay for people who are currently retired.currently retired.
In this way, Social Security redistributes In this way, Social Security redistributes income from one generation to another.income from one generation to another.
It is predicted that the number of workers to It is predicted that the number of workers to retirees will drop to only about 2 to 1 by 2030.retirees will drop to only about 2 to 1 by 2030.
To keep benefits constant the Social Security To keep benefits constant the Social Security administration estimates that the tax rate administration estimates that the tax rate would need to rise by almost 21% by 2034.would need to rise by almost 21% by 2034.
Social SecuritySocial SecuritySocial SecuritySocial Security
28 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Social Security also redistributes income within Social Security also redistributes income within generations. The ratio of payments to retirees to the generations. The ratio of payments to retirees to the amount they contributed in their working years is amount they contributed in their working years is much higher for the low income than for the high much higher for the low income than for the high income.income.
Payments are also adjusted on the basis of need, Payments are also adjusted on the basis of need, which is determined in part by the number of which is determined in part by the number of dependents a person has.dependents a person has.
Even though the tax took out the same portion of Even though the tax took out the same portion of each person’s income when they were working, the each person’s income when they were working, the percentage given back is much higher for the poor.percentage given back is much higher for the poor.
Social Security also redistributes income within Social Security also redistributes income within generations. The ratio of payments to retirees to the generations. The ratio of payments to retirees to the amount they contributed in their working years is amount they contributed in their working years is much higher for the low income than for the high much higher for the low income than for the high income.income.
Payments are also adjusted on the basis of need, Payments are also adjusted on the basis of need, which is determined in part by the number of which is determined in part by the number of dependents a person has.dependents a person has.
Even though the tax took out the same portion of Even though the tax took out the same portion of each person’s income when they were working, the each person’s income when they were working, the percentage given back is much higher for the poor.percentage given back is much higher for the poor.
Social SecuritySocial SecuritySocial SecuritySocial Security
29 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
On an after tax basis, the tax may even pay the On an after tax basis, the tax may even pay the retired low-income worker more than he or she retired low-income worker more than he or she earned while working.earned while working.
The redistribution from higher-income to lower-The redistribution from higher-income to lower-income workers is one reason participation in income workers is one reason participation in Social Security is required by law.Social Security is required by law.
New investors (workers) are forced into the Social New investors (workers) are forced into the Social Security system by government and its power to Security system by government and its power to tax.tax.
On an after tax basis, the tax may even pay the On an after tax basis, the tax may even pay the retired low-income worker more than he or she retired low-income worker more than he or she earned while working.earned while working.
The redistribution from higher-income to lower-The redistribution from higher-income to lower-income workers is one reason participation in income workers is one reason participation in Social Security is required by law.Social Security is required by law.
New investors (workers) are forced into the Social New investors (workers) are forced into the Social Security system by government and its power to Security system by government and its power to tax.tax.
Social SecuritySocial SecuritySocial SecuritySocial Security
30 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
A Trust Fund of IOU’sA Trust Fund of IOU’sA Trust Fund of IOU’sA Trust Fund of IOU’s
The The Social Security Trust FundSocial Security Trust Fund is the is the depository for Social Security tax revenues.depository for Social Security tax revenues.
All savings in the fund are held in the form of All savings in the fund are held in the form of special government bonds.special government bonds.The savings in the fund are nothing more than The savings in the fund are nothing more than
government IOU’s.government IOU’s.
In order for the fund to be fully-funded, it In order for the fund to be fully-funded, it would need to well over a year’s worth of GDP.would need to well over a year’s worth of GDP.
The The Social Security Trust FundSocial Security Trust Fund is the is the depository for Social Security tax revenues.depository for Social Security tax revenues.
All savings in the fund are held in the form of All savings in the fund are held in the form of special government bonds.special government bonds.The savings in the fund are nothing more than The savings in the fund are nothing more than
government IOU’s.government IOU’s.
In order for the fund to be fully-funded, it In order for the fund to be fully-funded, it would need to well over a year’s worth of GDP.would need to well over a year’s worth of GDP.
31 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
11.311.3TAX REFORMTAX REFORM11.311.3TAX REFORMTAX REFORMTax reformTax reform is a compromise between is a compromise between
those who want to pay less, and those those who want to pay less, and those who want to receive more.who want to receive more.
Broad-based taxesBroad-based taxes are efficient because are efficient because they do not distort relative prices.they do not distort relative prices.
The personal income tax system is a The personal income tax system is a progressive tax system.progressive tax system.It is based on the ability to pay, and is a It is based on the ability to pay, and is a
compromise between efficiency and equity.compromise between efficiency and equity.
Tax reformTax reform is a compromise between is a compromise between those who want to pay less, and those those who want to pay less, and those who want to receive more.who want to receive more.
Broad-based taxesBroad-based taxes are efficient because are efficient because they do not distort relative prices.they do not distort relative prices.
The personal income tax system is a The personal income tax system is a progressive tax system.progressive tax system.It is based on the ability to pay, and is a It is based on the ability to pay, and is a
compromise between efficiency and equity.compromise between efficiency and equity.
32 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Tax ReformTax ReformTax ReformTax Reform
Measuring income is another issue in Measuring income is another issue in evaluating income taxes.evaluating income taxes.The U.S. income tax code focuses on liquid income.The U.S. income tax code focuses on liquid income.
If a person sells illiquid assets, they are taxed If a person sells illiquid assets, they are taxed on on realized capital gains.realized capital gains.
There are There are loopholesloopholes in the tax code. in the tax code.Two concepts are used to evaluate tax Two concepts are used to evaluate tax
expenditures.expenditures.Vertical equityVertical equity – based on differing ability to pay. – based on differing ability to pay.Horizontal equityHorizontal equity – says that people with equal – says that people with equal
means should pay equal tax.means should pay equal tax.
Measuring income is another issue in Measuring income is another issue in evaluating income taxes.evaluating income taxes.The U.S. income tax code focuses on liquid income.The U.S. income tax code focuses on liquid income.
If a person sells illiquid assets, they are taxed If a person sells illiquid assets, they are taxed on on realized capital gains.realized capital gains.
There are There are loopholesloopholes in the tax code. in the tax code.Two concepts are used to evaluate tax Two concepts are used to evaluate tax
expenditures.expenditures.Vertical equityVertical equity – based on differing ability to pay. – based on differing ability to pay.Horizontal equityHorizontal equity – says that people with equal – says that people with equal
means should pay equal tax.means should pay equal tax.
33 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
11.4 EXPLORE & APPLY11.4 EXPLORE & APPLYPaying for Homeland SecurityPaying for Homeland Security11.4 EXPLORE & APPLY11.4 EXPLORE & APPLYPaying for Homeland SecurityPaying for Homeland Security
It is expensive to protect the nation It is expensive to protect the nation against terrorist threats. against terrorist threats.
There are a number of ways to finance There are a number of ways to finance the new security measures.the new security measures.Use general tax revenues.Use general tax revenues.Levy taxes on specific industries for which Levy taxes on specific industries for which
the government provides security.the government provides security.Let industries facing the threats absorb the Let industries facing the threats absorb the
cost.cost.
It is expensive to protect the nation It is expensive to protect the nation against terrorist threats. against terrorist threats.
There are a number of ways to finance There are a number of ways to finance the new security measures.the new security measures.Use general tax revenues.Use general tax revenues.Levy taxes on specific industries for which Levy taxes on specific industries for which
the government provides security.the government provides security.Let industries facing the threats absorb the Let industries facing the threats absorb the
cost.cost.
34 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Terms Along the WayTerms Along the WayTerms Along the WayTerms Along the Way
• transfer paymentstransfer payments• marginal tax ratemarginal tax rate• tax incidencetax incidence• benefit principlebenefit principle• ability-to-pay ability-to-pay
principleprinciple• progressive taxprogressive tax
• transfer paymentstransfer payments• marginal tax ratemarginal tax rate• tax incidencetax incidence• benefit principlebenefit principle• ability-to-pay ability-to-pay
principleprinciple• progressive taxprogressive tax
• regressive taxregressive tax• proportional taxproportional tax• in-kind benefitsin-kind benefits• pay-as-you-gopay-as-you-go• Social Security trust Social Security trust
fundfund• fully fundedfully funded
• regressive taxregressive tax• proportional taxproportional tax• in-kind benefitsin-kind benefits• pay-as-you-gopay-as-you-go• Social Security trust Social Security trust
fundfund• fully fundedfully funded
35 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Terms Along the WayTerms Along the WayTerms Along the WayTerms Along the Way
• Individual Individual Retirement Accounts Retirement Accounts (IRAs)(IRAs)
• Personal Security Personal Security AccountsAccounts
• tax basetax base• comprehensive comprehensive
measures of incomemeasures of income
• Individual Individual Retirement Accounts Retirement Accounts (IRAs)(IRAs)
• Personal Security Personal Security AccountsAccounts
• tax basetax base• comprehensive comprehensive
measures of incomemeasures of income
• tax expenditures tax expenditures • vertical equityvertical equity• horizontal equityhorizontal equity• consumed-income consumed-income
taxtax• consumption taxconsumption tax• value-added taxvalue-added tax
• tax expenditures tax expenditures • vertical equityvertical equity• horizontal equityhorizontal equity• consumed-income consumed-income
taxtax• consumption taxconsumption tax• value-added taxvalue-added tax
36 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Test YourselfTest YourselfTest YourselfTest Yourself
1.1. An average tax rate isAn average tax rate isa.a. additional taxes owed as a percentage of additional taxes owed as a percentage of
additional income.additional income.b.b. total taxes owed.total taxes owed.c.c. total taxes owed as a percentage of total taxes owed as a percentage of
income.income.d.d. the percentage of income not collected in the percentage of income not collected in
taxes.taxes.
1.1. An average tax rate isAn average tax rate isa.a. additional taxes owed as a percentage of additional taxes owed as a percentage of
additional income.additional income.b.b. total taxes owed.total taxes owed.c.c. total taxes owed as a percentage of total taxes owed as a percentage of
income.income.d.d. the percentage of income not collected in the percentage of income not collected in
taxes.taxes.
37 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Test YourselfTest YourselfTest YourselfTest Yourself
2.2. A value-added tax is an example of a A value-added tax is an example of a
a.a. property tax.property tax.
b.b. Social security tax.Social security tax.
c.c. income tax.income tax.
d.d. consumption tax.consumption tax.
2.2. A value-added tax is an example of a A value-added tax is an example of a
a.a. property tax.property tax.
b.b. Social security tax.Social security tax.
c.c. income tax.income tax.
d.d. consumption tax.consumption tax.
38 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Test YourselfTest YourselfTest YourselfTest Yourself
3.3. The benefits principles and the ability-The benefits principles and the ability-to-pay principle refer toto-pay principle refer to
a.a. whether a tax is progressive or whether a tax is progressive or regressive.regressive.
b.b. principles of tax efficiency.principles of tax efficiency.c.c. principles of tax equity.principles of tax equity.d.d. legal principles that question the legal principles that question the
constitutionality of Social Security.constitutionality of Social Security.
3.3. The benefits principles and the ability-The benefits principles and the ability-to-pay principle refer toto-pay principle refer to
a.a. whether a tax is progressive or whether a tax is progressive or regressive.regressive.
b.b. principles of tax efficiency.principles of tax efficiency.c.c. principles of tax equity.principles of tax equity.d.d. legal principles that question the legal principles that question the
constitutionality of Social Security.constitutionality of Social Security.
39 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Test YourselfTest YourselfTest YourselfTest Yourself
4.4. The gasoline tax is The gasoline tax is a.a. used to fund various government used to fund various government
programs.programs.b.b. the best example of a progressive tax.the best example of a progressive tax.c.c. seems to satisfy the ability-to-pay seems to satisfy the ability-to-pay
principle.principle.d.d. reflects the benefit principle, since those reflects the benefit principle, since those
who pay the tax tend to receive benefits.who pay the tax tend to receive benefits.
4.4. The gasoline tax is The gasoline tax is a.a. used to fund various government used to fund various government
programs.programs.b.b. the best example of a progressive tax.the best example of a progressive tax.c.c. seems to satisfy the ability-to-pay seems to satisfy the ability-to-pay
principle.principle.d.d. reflects the benefit principle, since those reflects the benefit principle, since those
who pay the tax tend to receive benefits.who pay the tax tend to receive benefits.
40 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Test YourselfTest YourselfTest YourselfTest Yourself
5.5. If a tax collects 5 percent of the income If a tax collects 5 percent of the income of those making less than $100,000 and of those making less than $100,000 and 10 percent of the income of those 10 percent of the income of those making $100,000 or more, the the tax ismaking $100,000 or more, the the tax is
a.a. progressive.progressive.b.b. regressive.regressive.c.c. proportional.proportional.d.d. flat.flat.
5.5. If a tax collects 5 percent of the income If a tax collects 5 percent of the income of those making less than $100,000 and of those making less than $100,000 and 10 percent of the income of those 10 percent of the income of those making $100,000 or more, the the tax ismaking $100,000 or more, the the tax is
a.a. progressive.progressive.b.b. regressive.regressive.c.c. proportional.proportional.d.d. flat.flat.
41 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
Test YourselfTest YourselfTest YourselfTest Yourself
6.6. If a tax collects 10 percent of the income of If a tax collects 10 percent of the income of those making less than $100,000 and 5 those making less than $100,000 and 5 percent of the income of those making percent of the income of those making $100,000 or more, the the tax is$100,000 or more, the the tax is
a.a. a head tax.a head tax.
b.b. progressive.progressive.
c.c. regressive.regressive.
d.d. proportional.proportional.
6.6. If a tax collects 10 percent of the income of If a tax collects 10 percent of the income of those making less than $100,000 and 5 those making less than $100,000 and 5 percent of the income of those making percent of the income of those making $100,000 or more, the the tax is$100,000 or more, the the tax is
a.a. a head tax.a head tax.
b.b. progressive.progressive.
c.c. regressive.regressive.
d.d. proportional.proportional.
42 ©2004 Prentice Hall Publishing Ayers/Collinge, 1/e
The End!The End!Next Chapter 12Next Chapter 12
““Economic Growth"Economic Growth"