2004-tectonic and stratigraphy evolution of the sarulla graben geothermal area, north...

Upload: subekti94

Post on 02-Mar-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    1/14

    Tectonic and stratigraphic evolution of the Sarulla graben geothermalarea, North Sumatra, Indonesia

    R.G. Hickmana,*, P.F. Dobsonb, M. van Gervenc, B.D. Sagalad, R.P. Gundersone

    aStructural Solutions, 1330 Sugar Creek Blvd., Sugar Land, TX 77478, USAbEarth Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA

    c

    Autodesk Inc., GIS Solutions Division, San Rafael, CA, USAdUnocal Geothermal Indonesia, Sentral Senayan-I Office Tower, Jln. Asia Afrika No. 8, Jakarta 10012, IndonesiaeUnocal Geothermal Technology and Services, 1160 N. Dutton Ave., Santa Rosa, CA 95401, USA

    Received 18 February 2003; revised 11 June 2003; accepted 16 June 2003

    Abstract

    The Sarulla graben is a composite Plio-Pleistocene basin developed along the northwest striking, dextral-slip Sumatra fault in a region

    where the fault coincides with the Sumatra volcanic arc. Offset of the 0.27 ^ 0.03 Ma Tor Sibohi rhyodacite dome by an active strand of the

    Sumatra fault, the Tor Sibohi fault (TSF), indicates a slip rate of about 9 mm/y. This value is lower than previous regional estimates of,25

    30 mm/y for Holocene slip on the Sumatra fault determined from stream offsets in the Taratung region. This discrepancy may be due to (1) a

    difference between Holocene and late Quaternary rates of slip and (2) additional slip on other faults in the Sarulla area. Since the magnitude

    of undated stream offsets along the TSF in the Sarulla area is similar to those in the Taratung area, the discrepancy is likely to be due largely

    to a change in slip rate over time.Within the Sarulla area, major volcanic centers include the Sibualbuali stratavolcano (,0.70.3 Ma), the Hopong caldera (,1.5 Ma), and

    the Namora-I-Langit dacitic dome field (0.80.1 Ma). These centers generated the majority of the ash-flow tuffs and tuffaceous sediments

    filling the Sarulla graben, and appear to have been localized by structural features related to the Sumatra fault zone.

    Four geothermal systems within the Sarulla area are closely linked to major faults and volcanic centers. In three of the systems, reservoir

    permeability is clearly dominated by specific structures within the Sumatra fault system. In the fourth geothermal system, Namora-I-Langit

    geothermal field, permeability may be locally influenced by faults, but highly permeable fractures are widely distributed.

    q 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

    Keywords: Strike-slip faulting; Slip rate; Volcanism; Geothermal systems; Sumatra

    1. Introduction

    From mid-1993 through early 1998, Unocal Corporation,

    under a Joint Operation Contract with Pertamina (the

    Indonesian state-owned oil company) carried out an

    exploration program for geothermal resources within the

    15 by 63 km Sarulla contract area located in North Sumatra

    (Fig. 1). This program included mapping of lithologic units,

    hydrothermal alteration and structures, radiometric dating

    of volcanic units, and locating, sampling, and analyzing

    fluids from surface geothermal features within the contract

    area (Gunderson et al., 1995). Structural mapping was

    carried out by traverses, mainly along streams and roads

    where the likelihood of outcrops was the highest. This was

    supplemented by interpretation of 1:20,000 aerial photos.These photos were acquired in 1974 at a time when the

    forest cover was less extensive, thus facilitating aerial

    mapping. The photos were especially useful in (1)

    projecting faults identified in traverses, (2) identifying

    other lineaments that may reflect fault or fracture trends, and

    (3) in mapping the extent of alluvium, intensely cultivated

    areas, and large areas affected by hydrothermal or supergene

    alteration. An additional part of the program consisted of

    conducting gravity, time-domain electromagnetic (TDEM)

    and magnetotelluric (MT) surveys. Following these surveys,

    13 exploration wells were drilled within the contract area

    (Gunderson et al., 2000).

    As a result of the geothermal prospects being

    located within or near the Sarulla graben and adjacent to

    1367-9120/03/$ - see front matter q 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

    doi:10.1016/S1367-9120(03)00155-X

    Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448www.elsevier.com/locate/jseaes

    * Corresponding author. Tel.:1-218-240-1057; fax:1-281-240-8457.

    E-mail address:[email protected] (R.G. Hickman).

    http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jseaeshttp://www.elsevier.com/locate/jseaes
  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    2/14

    the Sumatra fault zone, these exploration efforts provide

    new data regarding the geometry and displacement history

    of the Sumatra fault zone and the interaction between the

    fault system and the Quaternary-Recent volcanic arc, which

    coincides with the fault zone in this region. Additionally,

    this paper advances the understanding of the Quaternary

    volcanic history of the region and the general development

    of geothermal systems in the proximity of major strike-slip

    fault zones.

    2. Tectonic setting

    Sumatra lies along the southern margin of the Eurasian

    plate (Fig. 1). Late Paleozoic meta-sedimentary rocks

    including limestones, argillites, and graywackes comprisethe oldest widely distributed rock unit in Sumatra. These are

    part of the Sundaland craton, believed to have been accreted

    to the Eurasian margin during Triassic time (Stauffer, 1983;

    Cooper et al., 1989). These strata are overlain by Jurassic

    and Cretaceous sediments, meta-sediments and mafic

    volcanics, and are intruded by Late Cretaceous granitic

    rocks (Page et al., 1979; Mitchell, 1993).

    The backarc basins of southern, central, and northern

    Sumatra developed as a result of initial extensional faulting

    during the Eocene followed by subsequent sag-phase

    deposition. This was followed by uplift and inversion of

    both backarc and forearc basins beginning during the middle

    Miocene (McCarthy, 1997). The Cretaceous through

    Quaternary history of Sumatra has been interpreted as one

    of continual convergence, during which periods of subduc-

    tion were interrupted by obduction of arcs onto the western

    margin of Sumatra during the late early Cretaceous and

    during the middle Eocene (Mitchell, 1993,Fig. 2).

    Currently, the Indo-Australian plate is moving northward

    (azimuth of 0030258) relative to Eurasia at about 60

    75 mm/y (Minster and Jordan, 1978; DeMets et al., 1990;McCaffrey, 1992) and is being subducted beneath the Java-

    Sunda trench. South of Java, the trend of the Java trench is

    about 1008and plate convergence is nearly orthogonal to the

    trench (Bellier and Sebrier, 1994). In contrast, the Sunda

    trench west of Sumatra has an average trend of about 140 8

    and plate convergence across that zone is oblique.

    This oblique convergence is believed to result in strain

    partitioning in which a sizeable portion of the margin-

    parallel component of convergence is taken up by dextral

    strike-slip motion on the Sumatra fault system (SFS, Fitch,

    1972; Beck, 1983; Jarrard, 1986) and the Mentawai fault of

    the Sumatran fore-arc basin (Diament et al., 1992,Fig. 1).

    The SFS extends about 1650 km from the Sunda Straitextensional fault zone to the Andaman Sea spreading center

    where it acts as a transform fault (Page et al., 1979).

    Displacement on the Mentawai fault appears to be

    transferred to the northern SFS via the Batee fault (Bellier

    and Sebrier, 1995).

    Because the SFS is linked to the Andaman Sea

    spreading center, the SFS likely has been active as a

    dextral slip fault since at least the mid-Miocene, when

    seafloor spreading started in the Andaman Sea (Curray

    et al., 1979). The proposed range of total displacement of

    the fault zone is large (McCarthy and Elders, 1997).Curray

    et al. (1979)estimate of 460 km displacement based on the

    amount of opening of the Andaman Sea since the mid-Miocene represents an upper limit of possible displacement

    Fig. 1. Map showing the general tectonic setting of Sumatra and thelocation of the Sarulla area. SFS, Sumatra fault system; MF, Mentawai

    fault; BF, Batee fault.

    Fig. 2. Schematic diagram showing the successive closing of ocean basins

    along the Asian continental margin during the cretaceous to present.

    Modified afterMitchell (1993).

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448436

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    3/14

    on the fault. The largest proposed displacements based on

    offset volcanic centers and rock units range from 90 to

    150 km (Posevec et al., 1973; McCarthy and Elders, 1997).

    Seih and Natawidjaja (2000) suggest that distension of

    forearc structures and the trench near the Sunda Strait

    implies about 100 km of arc-parallel stretching of the

    forearc region since the early Pliocene. However, based on

    offsets of major drainages, they argue that the total offset of

    the Sumatra fault may be only about 20 km.

    Recent slip rates based on stream offsets show an

    increase from less than 10 mm/y where the SFS enters the

    Sunda Strait to 23^ 2 mm/y adjacent to Lake Toba in

    northern Sumatra (Bellier and Sebrier, 1995). Geodetic

    measurements suggest that between 0.88 S and 2.78 N the

    current slip rate is nearly uniform at about 25 mm/y

    (Genrich et al., 2000).From the Lake Toba area to the Sunda Strait, Quaternary

    and Recent volcanoes of the Sumatra volcanic arc are in

    very close proximity to the Sumatra fault zone (Fig. 1,Page

    et al., 1979; McCarthy and Elders, 1997), and it seems

    possible that the fault zone and the volcanic arc influence

    each other.

    3. Stratigraphy of the Sarulla area

    The oldest rocks exposed within the study area are meta-

    quartzites, phyllites, argillites, and limestones interpreted to

    be of late Paleozoic age (Tapanuli Group and KuantanFormation of Aspden et al., 1982, Figs. 3 and 4). These

    strata are exposed on both sides of the SFS in the Barisan

    Mountains, along the margins of the Sarulla graben, and in

    uplifted fault slivers. Mesozoic or early Tertiary granitic

    intrusives are not exposed within the Sarulla area, but occur

    within 15 km of the western margin of the map area

    (Aspden et al., 1982). Five to ten kilometers to the east,

    marine sandstones and limestones of Miocene age crop out

    along the margin of the central Sumatra (backarc) basin

    (Aspden et al., 1982).

    Within the southern part of the study area, west of the

    active Tor Sibohi strand of the SFS, lithic arenites, arkoses,

    pebble conglomerates, and carbonaceous siltstone beds offluvial and lacustrine origin crop out in a small graben.

    These beds are most likely of late Pliocene age, but could be

    as old as late Miocene or as young as early Pleistocene

    based on arboreal pollen (V.E. Williams, pers. com.). These

    fluvio-lacustrine strata contain abundant detritus derived

    from the Paleozoic quartzites, but are free of volcanic

    material (Fig. 4). The strata are inferred to unconformably

    overlie the Paleozoic rocks. Well-sorted quartz sandstones

    that are silicified were encountered at a depth of about

    1465 m in a well drilled east of the Tor Sibohi fault (TSF)

    near the town of Sipirok; these rocks closely resemble

    Tertiary (?) strata that are exposed along the eastern margin

    of the Sipirok graben still further to the east. Other undatedpebble and cobble conglomerates, and sedimentary breccias

    Fig. 3. Simplified geologic map of the Sarulla area. ASN Flt, Aek

    Sitandiang Nemenek fault.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448 437

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    4/14

    with clasts derived from the underlying Paleozoic strata

    crop out in the northeastern part of the map area. All of these

    units, which contain sediment derived from the Paleozoic

    strata and lack significant volcanic material, may be the

    same age.

    Outcropping Pliocene (?) strata are overlain by similar,

    but less indurated sandstones, siltstones, and conglomer-

    ates that contain abundant volcanic detritus. The Silang-

    kitang 1-1 well (Fig. 3) drilled within the Sarulla graben

    encountered conglomerates with abundant volcanic clasts

    that are overlain by more than 2 km of tuffs and

    interbedded lacustrine siltstones. These are possiblycorrelative with the outcropping volcanic-rich sediments

    (Fig. 4). The possible Pliocene conglomerates of the

    northern area that lie east of the TSF grade upward into

    the conglomerates, pebbly mudstones, and tuffs containing

    clasts derived from both the Paleozoic strata and

    volcanics. These isolated units are thought to be

    approximately the same age based on their general

    stratigraphic and lithologic character, and are significant

    in that they mark the start of recent volcanic activity

    within the region. Radiometric dating of volcanic rocks

    within the greater Sarulla area indicates that volcanic

    activity in the area started about 1.8 million y ago

    and suggests the approximate age of these strata(Gunderson et al., 1995).

    The greater Sarulla stratigraphic section younger than the

    latter unit consists nearly entirely of volcanic and

    volcaniclastic strata that complexly interfinger (Fig. 4).

    These rocks consist of flows, lahars, and tuffs from volcanic

    centers within the Sarulla area as well as tuffs derived from

    more distant volcanic centers such as the Toba Caldera.

    Exploration wells and gravity data demonstrate that the

    thickness of this sequence exceeds 2000 m in the northern

    Sarulla graben and is about 2500 m thick immediately east

    of the Sibualbuali volcano. Near the volcanic centers, the

    stratigraphic relationships of major flow and tuff units have

    been partly determined by integration of mapping, radio-metric dating and petrology. Wells drilled in the basinal

    areas and margins of the volcanic centers have encountered

    unwelded, but silicified tuffs and interbedded lacustrine

    sediments that are probably partly age-equivalent to the

    exposed section, but are difficult to correlate with it. The

    geology and stratigraphy of the main volcanic centers are

    described below from south to north.

    3.1. Sibualbuali volcano

    Sibualbuali volcano is a deeply dissected stratovolcano at

    the southern end of the Sarulla contract area that is

    predominately andesitic in composition. It consists of aseries of andesitic to dacitic lavas and breccias with some

    Fig. 4. Diagram showing stratigraphic relationships across the Sarulla area.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448438

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    5/14

    interbedded tuffs that range in age from ,0.7 to 0.3 Ma

    (Gunderson et al., 1995). Following construction of the

    stratovolcano, more silicic dacite to rhyodacite lavas and

    domes (0.120.30 Ma) were erupted along the western and

    eastern flanks along the two major strands of the SFS. North

    and east of the volcano, two distinctive sanidine-bearing

    ash-flow-tuff units have been mapped. These are informally

    referred to as the Old Sibualbuali tuff and the Young

    Sibualbuali tuff and have 40Ar/39Ar sanidine ages of

    0.57 ^ 0.003 and 0.38 ^ 0.002 Ma, respectively (all age

    errors are 1s;Gunderson et al., 1995). The distribution and

    elevation of the base of the Old Sibualbuali tuff suggests

    that it may have traveled northward from Sibualbuali

    volcano. The source of the Young Sibualbuali tuff is not

    known, but pumice blocks up to 30 cm in length near the

    town of Sipirok suggest a nearby source. The youngesteruptive center in the area is the Lubukraya volcano, located

    about 6 km southwest of Sibualbuali. Lubukraya consists

    mainly of basaltic andesites; one flow yields a KAr age of

    0.12 Ma (Gunderson et al., 1995).

    3.2. Hopong caldera

    Hopong caldera is a 9 km-diameter circular volcanic

    collapse feature located on the eastern margin of the

    Sarulla graben. Along the western margin of the caldera, a

    sequence of interbedded andesitic flows and dacitic tuffs

    are exposed that grade to the north and south into a more

    tuff-rich sequence. The andesite and tuff sequence isbelieved to be part of the volcanic center that preceded

    development of Hopong caldera. Poorly welded rhyodacitic

    to rhyolitic intracaldera tuffs are found within the most

    deeply eroded parts of the caldera. A plagioclase separate

    from a welded rhyodacite ash-flow tuff yielded a 40Ar/39Ar

    plateau age of 1.46^ 0.12 Ma. Within the caldera,

    laminated tuffaceous lacustrine sediments overlie these

    tuffs. There are many deeply weathered and reworked

    ash-flow tuffs found in the surrounding areas that are

    thought to have been erupted from the caldera. A number

    of dacitic to rhyolitic domes have been extruded along the

    western margin of Hopong caldera. 40Ar/39Ar incremental

    heating of a plagioclase separate from the largest of thesedomes yielded a plateau age of 1.3 ^ 0.1 Ma. All of these

    deposits are locally capped by the regional 73 Ka Young

    Toba Tuff (Chesner et al., 1991).

    3.3. Namora-I-Langit dome field

    The Namora-I-Langit (NIL) volcanic center, in the

    northwestern part of the study area and west of the SFS,

    consists of a number of dacite and rhyolite domes and

    andesitic flows (Fig. 3). K Ar ages for this volcanic

    center range from 0.75^ 0.06 Ma for a plagioclase

    separate from an andesite lava to 0.16 ^ 0.08 Ma for a

    biotite separate from an undissected andesite flow. Thecenter is located south of the Martimbang volcano, an

    undated but geomorphologically even younger basaltic

    andesite cone. Southeast of the NIL complex and just

    west of the Tor Sibohi fault, a rhyolite dome near the

    town of Sarulla yielded a K Ar date on biotite of

    0.12 ^ 0.08 Ma (Gunderson et al., 1995). The domes and

    flows interfinger with the upper part of the sequence of

    reworked tuffs and lacustrine deposits of the Sarulla

    graben. Over much of the area, the Young Toba Tuff

    overlies these deposits.

    4. Structural geology

    The Sarulla area is bisected by the SFS (Fig. 3), which

    here consists of one through-going, active strand, the Tor

    Sibohi fault (TSF), and several parallel, less active andinactive faults. In the northern part of the area, the TSF is

    closely paralleled to the southwest by the active Hutujulu

    fault that merges with the TFS near the village of

    Silangkitang. In the central part of the area, the TSF bounds

    the eastern flank of a structural low, the Sarulla graben. Inthe southern part of the area, the TFS is paralleled to the

    southwest by the Aek Sitandiang Namenek (ASN) and Toru

    Nabara faults. These latter faults and the TFS appear to form

    a complex releasing step.

    4.1. Small-scale structures of paleozoic rocks

    Meta-quartzites, phyllites, argillites and limestones,inferred to be of late Paleozoic age, are poorly exposed

    as fault slivers along major faults and along the

    northeastern margin of the study area. Because of the

    poor quality of exposures, little can be said about

    the regional structure of these strata. However, in

    addition to having been subjected to low-grade meta-morphism, all of these rocks have undergone strong pre-

    Pliocene deformation. Bedding is generally steeply

    dipping. Tight meter-scale upright folds are developed

    in the argillites and phyllites. All of these rocks have

    been subjected to a later brittle deformation that has

    strongly fractured and locally brecciated them. Minor

    hydrothermal veins composed of quartz or calcite andpyrite typically fill these fractures. The proximity of

    exposures to strands of the SFS and the occurrence of

    hydrothermal mineralization likely related to the current

    geothermal systems, suggest that this brittle deformation

    is related to strain associated with the SFS.

    4.2. Sumatra fault systemTor Sibohi fault

    The Sumatra fault system (SFS) forms a zone up to

    10 km wide along the length of the study area. One active

    strand of the fault, the Tor Sibohi fault (TSF), extends along

    that entire distance (Fig. 3). Along much of this distance, the

    fault zone occupies a linear valley or is bounded on one sideby steep slopes. Much of the valley is intensively cultivated,

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448 439

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    6/14

    and fault scarps have been removed or strongly modified by

    extensive artificial terracing. However, the trace of the fault

    is marked by springs, gas seeps, and narrow zones of steep

    dips in tuffs and mudstones, and is locally identifiable on

    aerial photos.

    The fault has an overall strike of about N 358W, but the

    strike of individual segments of the fault ranges from about

    N 558W to N 208W. Given the dextral strike-slip motion onthe fault, these strike changes create a slight constraining

    bend near the village of Silangkitang, a releasing bend south

    of Donatasik near the south end of the Sarulla graben, a

    prominent constraining bend north of Sibualbuali volcano

    and a releasing bend along the southeastern flank of

    Sibualbuali (Fig. 3). At the point of this latter releasing

    bend, a series of faults that are subparallel to the Tor Sibohi

    fault are present. These have straight traces, are steeplydipping, and are interpreted to be dextral strike-slip faults

    that transfer some displacement from the Tor Sibohi via a

    complex releasing step.

    The fault is not well exposed, but near the northern limit

    of the contract area (UTM Coordinates 500,340 m E;

    217,590 m N), the fault is exposed in an excavated hillside.

    There the fault strikes N 458 W and dips 678 to the

    southwest. In the Silangkitang area, wells and surface

    mapping indicate that the fault dips about 878 to the

    southwest. Along the northeast flank of Sibualbuali (UTM

    Coordinates 527,520 m E; 177,350 m N), the fault strikes N

    468 W and dips about 858 to the southwest.

    4.3. Tor Sibohi fault displacements

    Numerous streams exhibit dextral jogs where they flow

    across the Tor Sibohi fault. These bends are interpreted to

    reflect dextral offset of the stream valleys by displacement

    of the fault. In this situation, the greatest and oldest offsets

    are typically shown by the largest, most deeply incised

    streams (Wallace, 1968). In the study area, stream offsets

    were estimated from aerial photos or topographic maps. The

    recognized offsets range from about 1301400 m (Table 1).

    The maximum offsets here are similar to, but slightly

    smaller than the maximum small stream offsets determined

    in the Toba area from SPOT satellite images of 1660 ^ 100 m (Detourbet et al., 1993) and 17002100 m

    offsets determined from aerial photographs and topographic

    maps in the same area (Sieh and Natawidjaja, 2000).

    Detourbet et al. (1993) and Sieh and Natawidjaja

    (2000) assumed that these offsets are on drainages

    developed after blanketing of the area by the Young

    Toba Tuff. Based on an age of the Young Toba Tuff of

    73,000^ 4000 y, the 1660 ^ 100 m offsets indicate an

    offset rate of 23^ 3 mm/y (Detourbet et al., 1993); the

    slightly larger offsets reported by Sieh and Rais (1991)

    indicate an offset rate of about 28 mm/y. Unlike the Toba

    area, in the Sarulla area the stream channels are incised

    into rocks older than the Young Toba Tuff and are not asuseful for determining recent fault-slip rates as the stream

    offsets to the north. However, the similar magnitude of

    offsets suggests late Quaternary displacement rates similar

    to the north assuming that the stream valleys were incised

    at the same time. This may have occurred because the

    Young Toba Tuff disrupted the existing drainages and

    produced a new cycle of valley incision even though the

    initially thinner blanket of tuff is now largely eroded from

    the Sarulla area.

    The Aek Welirang fault, one of the faults that make up

    the releasing bend at the southern end of the map area,

    shows abundant topographic evidence of recent movement

    (Fig. 5). Three stream valleys along this fault each show

    offsets of about 300 m (Table 1).Southwest of the town of Sipirok, the late Quaternary Tor

    Sibohi rhyodacite dome is dextrally offset by the Tor Sibohi

    fault (Fig. 5). The dome is composed of biotite-hornblende

    rhyodacite lava with flow banding defined by alternating

    pink and gray layering. The distinctive lithology of the

    rhyodacite and its original limited areal extent make it an

    ideal marker of fault displacement.

    The lateral separation of the northern contacts of the

    rhyodacite across the fault is about 2.1 km; the lateral

    separation between its southern contacts is about 2.9 km.

    The mean of these two measurements is 2.5 km. The

    maximum possible offset of the eroded southern contact is

    3.3 km. 40Ar/39Ar incremental heating analysis yieldedisochron ages of 0.27 ^ 0.03 Ma for biotite and 0.26 ^ 0.1

    Table 1

    Offsets along faults within the Sarulla area

    Offset feature UTM coordinates Offset (m)

    Tor Sibohi

    Fault

    Aek Pargarutan 508,500 m E; 204,

    650 m N

    140

    Stream 2 509,250; 203,350 230

    Stream 3 509,400; 202,900 620

    Stream 4 509,800; 202,200 130

    Aek Sibarabara 510,700; 201,150 390

    Stream 5 511,800; 199,900 630

    Stream 6 511,950; 199,400 390

    Stream 7 512,600; 198,700 700

    Sarulla r iver 513,000; 198,100 540

    Near Aek Sah 519,300; 187,100 300

    Aek Simarjambu 520,300; 185,100 6001200

    Aek Sihoruhoru 523,950; 180,600 5001400

    Aek Sibue 528,500; 176,250 1000Tor Sibohi Dome 528,700; 175,900 2500

    Aek Mandurana 530,900; 172,600 1000

    Aek Horsik 531,200; 172,100 400

    Aek Situmba 532,100; 171,150 1000

    Aek Weliran

    fault

    Aek Mandurana 529,800; 173,100 300

    Aek Horsik 530,350; 172,250 300

    Aek Weliran 531,050; 171,150 300

    Hutujulu fault Stream A 501,800; 213,600 325

    Aek Sitandiang

    Namenek fault

    Aek Nabara 523,400; 172,200 400

    Aek Sinanap north 525,100; 169,400 300

    Aek Sinanap south 524,800; 169,250 800

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448440

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    7/14

    for plagioclase from the rhyodacite (Gunderson et al.,

    1995). Combining an age of 0.27 Ma with the 2.5 km offset

    gives a dextral slip rate of about 9 mm/y. The possible age

    and offset extremes yield a range of possible offset rates

    between 7 and 14 mm/y. This range of rates reflects

    uncertainties due to (1) the effects of erosion, (2)

    inaccuracies in locating the poorly exposed contacts of the

    smaller western portion of the faulted dome, and (3) the

    error in the age date. The facies change from largely

    andesitic lavas to largely tuffs around the flanks of the

    Sibualbuali volcano shows a similar amount of offset(Fig. 3), but because of the transitional nature of this facies

    change, it is not a good marker.

    Assuming the stream offsets in the Taratung area and the

    Tor Sibohi rhyodacite dome are accurately dated, the

    discrepancy between the slip rate of 23 ^ 3 mm/y deter-

    mined from stream offsets in the Taratung region (Detourbet

    et al., 1993) and the 9 mm/y slip rate determined from the

    offset dome may be due to (1) a difference between

    Holocene and late Quaternary rates of slip and (2) additional

    slip on other faults in the Sarulla area. However, because the

    magnitude of undated stream offsets along the TSF in the

    Sarulla area is similar to those in the Taratung area, the rate

    difference is thought largely to be due a change in slip rateover time.

    4.4. Sipirok graben

    The Sipirok graben intersects the Tor Sibohi fault in

    the southern part of the study area near the town of Sipirok

    (Fig. 3). Here, reconnaissance mapping indicates that the

    basin is bounded on the east by a major steeply west-dipping

    normal fault that strikes about N 58E and gives the basin a

    half-graben geometry. Satellite imagery suggests that the

    extensional basin continues a considerable distance to the

    northeast beyond the extent of field mapping. The exposure

    of uplifted, hydrothermally altered Pliocene sandstones on

    the footwall block of the Sipirok graben fault, as well as

    topographic relief, indicate that the fault system is young

    and perhaps currently active, and developed at least in part

    contemporaneously with the Sumatra fault system.

    Study of borehole breakouts in the Central Sumatra basin75 km to the southeast of the Sarulla area indicate that the

    orientation of the maximum horizontal stress, SHmax;varies

    between northnorthwest to northeast and that stresses at

    borehole depth are compatible with a strike-slip regime

    SHmax .SVertical .SHmin (Heidrick et al., 2000). North-

    west southeast extension across the Sipirok graben is

    compatible with a northwestsoutheast orientation ofSHmin:

    4.5. Aek Sitandiang Namenek/Toru Nabara fault system

    Additional faults of the Sumatra fault system lie to the

    west of the Tor Sibohi fault. Two major faults, the Aek

    Sitandiang Namenek (ASN) and Toru Nabara faults form azone that cuts the southwestern flank of Sibualbuali

    volcano. Within the ASN fault array, faults with horizontal

    striations offset young terrace deposits and other faults may

    offset stream channels up to a few hundred meters (Table 1).

    These two faults appear to merge immediately south of

    Sibualbuali. A remote-sensing interpretation shows that the

    resultant fault zone extends many kilometers to the south-

    east, paralleling the Tor Sibohi fault zone (Fig. 10).

    The northern extent of these western faults is less clear.

    This partly reflects poor exposures and incomplete mapping,

    but also may reflect discontinuous faults. The Toru Nabara

    fault does not appear to extend north of Sibualbuali and may

    merge with the ASN fault along the northwestern flank ofthe volcano. The ASN fault definitely extends a few

    kilometers north of Sibualbuali volcano, where it exposes

    Paleozoic rocks in the Batang Toru gorge (Aspden et al.,

    1982) (Fig. 3). Photo lineaments suggest that it may extend

    further northward to join faults that bound the southwesternflank of the Sarulla graben.

    However, part of the slip of the ASN fault system appears

    to be transferred to the Tor Sibohi fault via a small pull-apart

    basin on the north flank of Sibualbuali and a second

    extensional zone further to the north comprised of easterly-

    striking faults (Fig. 6). These latter faults all show oblique,

    probably left-lateral, normal displacements. It is proposed

    that this zone transfers dextral slip from the ASN andBulumario faults to the Tor Sibohi fault. Left lateral slip on

    Fig. 5. Map showing the offset of the Tor Sibohi rhyodacite by the Tor

    Sibohi strand of the Sumatra fault system. SeeFig. 3for location.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448 441

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    8/14

    these faults would produce clockwise rotation of the

    structural blocks between these faults and the major dextral

    strike-slip faults. Such deformation would also produce

    rotation of the east northeast striking faults that originally

    may have had a southwesterly strike. This style ofdeformation is well known from other zones of wrench

    tectonics (e.g. Dibble, 1977; Nicholson et al., 1986). The

    Sibualbuali volcano is situated within the overall step

    between the ASN and Tor Sibohi faults, suggesting that the

    local extension produced by the releasing step served to

    localize the volcano. If correct, earlier extension may behidden by the volcanic edifice.

    Fig. 6. Sketch map showing the structural setting of the Hopong caldera, southern Sarulla graben, and Tor Sibohi and ASN faults. See Fig. 3for location.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448442

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    9/14

    4.6. The Sarulla graben

    The Plio-Pleistocene Sarulla graben lies west of the Tor

    Sibohi fault and extends from the Limestone Mountain area

    north to the Namora-I-Langit area (Fig. 3). The graben is

    bounded on the northeast by the Tor Sibohi fault and partly

    bounded on the southwest by the Rebean and parallel faults

    (Figs. 3 and 6). The northern extent of the Rebean fault is

    not known because of incomplete mapping, but the fault

    may join the Aek Parihanan fault further to the northwest.

    The Aek Parihannan fault has a nearly vertical dip inoutcrops, but no indicators of the sense of displacement on

    the fault are known.

    Gravity data, wells, and limited seismic data show that

    the Quaternary-Pliocene Sarulla graben is substantially

    larger than the Recent alluvial depocenter in the Donatasikarea. Gravity models across the length of the basin and

    seismic data in the Silangkitang area show that the basin

    generally has an asymmetric graben to half-graben profile

    that deepens toward the Tor Sibohi fault (Figs. 7 and 8). The

    basin fill is cut by faults paralleling the TSF that show

    normal separation.

    The overall Sarulla graben is not a typical pull-apart

    basin since it (1) is bounded along one entire margin by a

    major strike-slip fault rather than occupying a releasing

    step between two strike-slip faults, (2) generally has a half-

    graben profile, and (3) is characterized by normal faults

    that parallel the major strike-slip fault rather than oblique-

    striking normal faults that form the sidewalls of a pull-apart basin (Fig. 3). This basin geometry more closely

    resembles the asymmetrical basins produced by fault-

    normal extension along some strike-slip zones. The

    formation of these asymmetrical basins has been ascribed

    to situations where strike-slip fault zones are weaker than

    the adjacent crust and the angle between the far-field

    maximum principal stress (horizontal) and the strike of the

    fault is less than 458 (Ben-Avraham and Zoback, 1992).

    Under these conditions, stresses are reoriented near the

    fault so that maximum horizontal stress, SHmax; is more

    nearly parallel to the strike of the fault and the minimum

    horizontal stress, SHmin is nearly perpendicular to the strike

    of the fault. This situation promotes extension perpendicu-

    lar to the strike of the wrench fault.

    On a sub-basin scale, releasing and constraining bends

    along the TSF do influence the geometry of the Sarulla

    graben. In particular, the gentle releasing bend in the

    Donatasik area increased subsidence of the southern part of

    the basin (Figs. 3 and 6). The constraining bend further

    south results in the termination of the graben, the uplift of

    Paleozoic strata at Limestone Mountain, and relatively high

    elevations east of Limestone Mountain.

    4.7. Hopong caldera

    The Hopong caldera lies east of the southern Sarulla

    graben east of the Tor Sibohi fault. Satellite imagery and

    topography indicate that the caldera margin has a slightlyelliptical shape. The caldera is about 9.6 km across in a

    northeastsouthwest direction and about 8.2 km across in a

    northwestsoutheast direction (Fig. 9). Gravity data show

    that the thickest part of the caldera fill is in the northeast.

    The southern margin of the caldera is formed by multiple

    inwardly dipping normal faults. The elliptical map pattern

    suggests that similar faults probably bound the eastern and

    northern parts. In contrast, the southwestern part is bounded

    by faults of the SFS and north-striking, right-lateral faults.

    The association of rhyolite domes with these latter faults

    (Fig. 3) suggests that the faults were active during caldera

    formation and may have played a role in its formation.

    4.8. Hutajulu fault

    In the northern part of the map area, a second active

    strike-slip fault, the Hutajulu fault, parallels and lies about

    8001600 m southwest of the Tor Sibohi fault (Fig. 3). To

    the north, the strike of this fault becomes more westerly, and

    the fault forms the southwestern margin of the Taratung

    graben (Bellier and Sebrier, 1994). The southern extent of

    the Hutajulu fault is not clear, but scattered exposures and

    seismic lines suggest that it joins the Tor Sibohi fault near

    the village of Silangkitang (Fig. 3). Thus, a very narrow

    finger of the Taratung graben extends into the study area.

    Fig. 7. Cross section across the southern Sarulla graben and Hopong caldera based on surface geology and gravity data. SeeFig. 3for location of cross section.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448 443

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    10/14

    This narrow graben resembles the in-line grabens developed

    near the ends of analog models of pull-apart basins formed

    above releasing steps (Dooley and McClay, 1997).

    A tributary of the Batang Toru shows a dextral offset of

    about 325 m where it crosses the Hutujulu fault (Table 1).

    The fault also juxtaposes distinctive types of young volcanic

    rocks. Basaltic andesite flows and breccias, informally

    referred to as the Sitonde basaltic andesite, are exposed west

    of the fault from the northern limit of this map (Fig. 3)

    northward to the flanks of the Martimbang volcano. Similar

    basaltic lava flows, breccias and lahars on the east side of

    the fault along the Batang Toru extend about 4.5 km south

    of the southern contact of the western lavas, where they are

    juxtaposed against dacitic lavas and tuffs on the west. This

    pattern may reflect dextral offset of the lavas, but may also

    result from flow of lavas and lahars southward along an

    ancestral Batang Toru. The age of the lavas is not known.

    They are overlain by the 73,000-year-old Young Toba Tuff

    and overlie older tuffs, and are inferred to be of late

    Quaternary age (Fig. 4).

    5. Tectonic model for the Sarulla region

    The Sumatra fault zone in northern Sumatra is charac-

    terized by multiple fault strands that created a series of

    elongate basins along the zone in the late Neogene (Fig. 10).

    South of the Sarulla area, the elongate Purwodadi graben is

    formed by an overstepping, releasing step between the Aek

    Sitandiang Namenek/Toru Nabara fault zone and an

    unnamed fault to the southwest (Fig. 10). The currently

    active Tor Sibohi fault and Aek Sitandiang Namenek/Toru

    Nabara fault zone define a present-day valley that parallels

    the Purwodadi graben and may also be underlain by late

    Neogene sediments. The northern end of this basin is a

    complex releasing step that transfers displacement from

    the ASN fault to the Tor Sibohi strand of the Sumatra faultthrough a series of normal and sinistral oblique-slip faults in

    the area north of Sibualbuali volcano. Thus, the Purwodadi

    graben and the area between the Tor Sibohi and Aek

    Sitandiang Namenek/Toru Nabara fault zone are a series of

    pull-apart basins.

    In contrast, the Sarulla graben is not a simple pull-apart

    basin. The Tor Sibohi fault bounds the entire northeastern

    side of the Sarulla graben and the northern part of the

    graben has a half-graben profile and is internally cut by

    normal-dextral slip faults that parallel the nearly linear trace

    of the Tor Sibohi fault. Similar linear basins are described

    along the Sumatra fault zone in central and southern

    Sumatra (McCarthy and Elders, 1997). The Sarulla grabenappears to have been formed by extension nearly perpen-

    dicular to the TSF. Within the Sarulla graben this overall

    pattern of extension is locally modified by sub-basin scale

    releasing and restraining bends along the TSF.

    Further to the north, the Taratung graben is typical of a

    pull-apart basin formed between two understepping strike-

    slip faults (Bellier and Sebrier, 1994; Dooley and McClay,

    1997). At the northern end of the Sarulla graben, the

    Hutajulu fault branches off from the Tor Sibohi fault and

    parallels the latter fault for several kilometers, forming a

    narrow in-line graben before the two faults diverge at the

    southern end of the main Taratung graben (Figs. 3 and 10).

    The map pattern implies that at the latitude of TaratungCity, the bulk of strike-slip displacement occurs on

    Fig. 9. Sketch structural map of Hopong caldera area. Contours are residual

    Bouguer values in milligals.

    Fig. 8. Gravity models across the northern Sarulla graben. Numbers refer to

    densities used in the models. SeeFig. 3for location of transects.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448444

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    11/14

    the Hutujulu fault, and that the nearly north-striking

    continuation of the Tor Sibohi fault has largely normal

    displacement.

    6. Relationship between the Sumatra fault zone

    and volcanic centers

    On a regional scale, the position of the Sumatra fault

    zone and the volcanic arc are similar, although it has been

    pointed out that the two features are not coincident, but

    rather intertwine (Sieh and Natawidjaja, 2000). Because of

    the similar orientation of the two features, it is possible that

    the location and geometry of the Sumatra fault system are

    controlled by the position of the volcanic arc (Hamilton,

    1979; Bellier and Sebrier, 1994). The reason for thispresumably would be that higher heat flow and local magma

    accumulations along the arc produce a linear zone that is

    weaker than the surrounding crust. Within the Sarulla area,

    volcanic centers lie along or within a few kilometers of the

    Sumatra fault system, and on a local scale, the fault system

    may control the position of some of these volcanic features.

    Sibualbuali volcano appears to have developed in a

    releasing step between the Tor Sibohi and ANS faults. The

    igneous center is probably localized because of the

    extension produced by the releasing step. Lubukraya

    volcano lies near the northern termination of the fault

    that bounds the southwestern side of the Purwodad graben

    (Fig. 10). Stress concentrations around the terminations offaults are known to produce increased fracture permeability

    (Curewitz and Karson, 1997), which may be responsible for

    localization of the volcano.

    At the Hopong caldera, minor right-lateral strike-slip

    faults related to the Sumatra fault system appear to have

    played a role in the collapse of the western margin of the

    caldera, but it is not clear that the Sumatra fault played any

    role in localizing the volcanic center. The Namora-I-Langit

    volcanic center is bounded by the Hutajulu fault and is cut

    by smaller, parallel faults. The volcanic center lies near, but

    not at the inferred intersection of the Hutajulu and Tor

    Sibohi faults. The Martimbang volcano, about 3 km north of

    Namora-I-Langit, appears to lie on the projection of one ofthese northwest-striking minor faults.

    Thus, while there is not a one-to-one relationship in the

    Sarulla area between volcanic features and faults, there is a

    strong suggestion that volcanic features are localized at

    steps between faults, fault intersections and near the tips of

    faults. This supports previous studies that related stepovers

    along the Sumatra fault system to volcanic centers (Bellier

    and Sebrier, 1994).

    7. Geothermal systems

    Geothermal exploration in the Sarulla area was instigatedby the presence of numerous high-temperature surface

    Fig. 10. Regional tectonic map showing the relationship of the Taratung,

    Sarulla, and Purwodadi grabens.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448 445

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    12/14

    features localized along structural features and near

    volcanic centers. Exploration drilling in the Sarulla area

    has resulted in the discovery and appraisal of three

    geothermal systems and the recognition of a fourth,

    unappraised system.

    7.1. Sibualbuali geothermal system

    At Sibualbuali volcano 19 areas of fumaroles, mud

    pots, and other acid-sulfate thermal features are

    distributed over an area of about 45 km2, mainly along

    faults of the Sumatra fault system. A regional gravity

    survey found a large area of low gravity surrounding

    the volcano, suggesting an underlying thick sediment or

    tuff-filled basin. Drilling has shown this fill to be a

    sequence of silicic tuffs more than 1 km thick. Resistivitysurveys found a central zone of high resistivity beneath

    the central core of the volcano ringed by local, distinct

    areas of low resistivity. These areas of low resistivity are

    closely linked in most cases with acid-sulfate thermal

    features and their associated alteration. They also correlate

    with the faults of the Tor Sibohi, and ANS faults and

    north-striking normal faults on the northwestern flank of

    Sibualbuali (Gunderson et al., 2000).

    Four wells (with measured depths of 1266 2439 m)

    were drilled on the eastern flank of Sibualbuali. Three of the

    wells were directionally drilled through faults of the Tor

    Sibohi fault system into the thick sequence of rhyolitic

    tuffs underlying the predominately andesitic rocks ofthe Sibualbuali volcano. One well encountered a sub-

    volcanic granitic intrusive. The wells were all productive,

    finding a geothermal system whose temperature and

    permeability structure is strongly controlled by the fault

    system. Production temperatures for the wells are in the

    range of 218 248 8C. Mineralogical and fluid inclusion

    evidence for an earlier, hotter, and shallower phase of

    hydrothermal activity was found above and within the

    reservoir. The current system has strong vertical and lateral

    temperature gradients, which are attributed to the channel-

    ing of fluids along fault strands. Volumetric and reservoir

    modeling evaluation of the drilled portion of the Eastern

    Sibualbuali geothermal system suggests reserves of suffi-cient energy to generate 40 MW of electricity for 30 y. It is

    expected that further drilling on the northern, western and

    southern flanks of Sibualbuali will lead to discovery of

    significantly more reserves (Gunderson et al., 2000).

    7.2. Donatasik geothermal system

    In the Donatasik area, boiling chloride springs occur

    along the SFS and Rebean fault on the east and west flanks

    of the southern Sarulla graben (Fig. 6). Gas seeps and

    fumaroles occur east of the valley and within the Hopong

    caldera. The spring waters are generally similar to spring

    waters in the Silangkitang area, but have higher magnesiumcontent and have equilibrated at lower temperatures. Based

    on cation geothermometry, most of the Donatasik waters

    equilibrated at 200230 8C, but have since partially re-

    equilibrated at lower temperatures (Gunderson et al., 1995).

    7.3. Silangkitang geothermal system

    A series of hot springs and fumaroles is located along the

    margin of the Sarulla graben, near the village of Silangki-

    tang in the central part of the Sarulla contract area. The

    thermal features are concentrated in a 1 3 km2 strip on and

    west of the Tor Sibohi fault and about 1 km north of a

    rhyolite dome with a KAr age of 0.12^ 0.08 Ma

    (Gunderson et al., 1995). Seismic lines and gravity data

    indicate that the thermal area lies above a local sub-graben

    formed between the Tor Sibohi fault and the intersecting

    Hutujulu fault.Fault intersections are recognized areas of higher fracture

    permeability (Curewitz and Karson, 1997), and it is likely

    that the intersection of the Hutujulu fault with the Tor

    Sibohi fault increases permeability in this region. Addition-

    ally, it likely that the active Tor Sibohi fault is critically

    stressed, and as a consequence, the fault zone has increased

    permeability (Townend and Zoback, 2000).

    Five wells (2031 2330 m) drilled at Silangkitang

    encountered a geothermal system whose permeability is

    strongly controlled by the Tor Sibohi fault. The wells all

    drilled through a thin section of sediments beneath the

    Sarulla graben valley floor, followed by more than 1500 m

    of silicic tuffs from which the wells produce hot brines.Two of the wells, located approximately 700 m and 1 km

    from the Tor Sibohi fault, were drilled vertically. Per-meability in each of these wells is relatively low, and the

    dominant fracture type consists of microfaults with oblique

    to horizontal slip, as indicated by slickensides. One of these

    wells drilled the entire tuff sequence and penetrated

    underlying conglomerates and sedimentary breccias con-

    taining volcanic clasts. These strata resemble the late

    Pliocene (?) strata exposed around the margins of the basin.

    The conglomerates and breccias had low permeability and

    were non-productive.

    Three wells were deviated to the northeast toward the

    main fault zone. One of these wells crossed the Tor Sibohifault into Paleozoic argillites, quartzites, and marbles. These

    rocks contained thin, tight veinlets filled with quartz and

    pyrite, and have very low matrix permeabilities. Two of

    the Silangkitang wells that were targeted directionally into

    the Sumatra fault zone found a very strong upflow in the

    vicinity of the fault that is significantly overpressured with

    respect to a normal hydrostatic gradient. Core recovered

    from one of these wells was highly fractured and brecciated.

    These fractures have been interpreted in terms of conjugate

    Riedel shears and tension fractures associated with the

    Sumatra fault zone (Moore et al., 2001). Fractures were

    enlarged by dissolution. In this upflow zone, fluid

    temperatures exceed 3108C at a depth of around 2 km.Following extensive testing of the wells, volumetric

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448446

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    13/14

    evaluation and reservoir modeling of the geothermal system

    have confirmed reserves that could generate 80 MW for

    30 y at Silangkitang.

    7.4. Namora-I-Langit geothermal system

    The Namora-I-Langit volcanic complex consists of two

    broad coalescent volcanoes made up of andesitic to rhyolitic

    lavas and tuffs dated at 0.750.16 Ma. Associated with this

    complex is an extensive array of surface thermal features

    comprised primarily of fumaroles and acid sulfate springs,

    but also including neutral chloridesulfatebicarbonate hot

    springs, gas seeps, and numerous warm bicarbonate springs

    covering an area of about 30 km2.

    The geothermal features largely lie west of the Hutajulu

    fault, which may form the eastern boundary of thegeothermal system. Several smaller faults lie west of and

    are aligned parallel to the Hutujulu fault. These faults are

    discontinuous, and it is not clear whether they are minor

    faults or more regional faults with only small displacements

    in the young rocks exposed at the surface.

    Four wells (13331722 m) have been drilled at Namora-

    I-Langit. All of these wells drilled through the lavas into a

    thick tuff section similar to that encountered at Silangkitang.

    These wells found a large geothermal system whose

    temperature and permeability distribution appear not to be

    strongly controlled by faults. Instead, fracture permeability

    is widely distributed, and vertical and lateral temperature

    gradients within the reservoir are very low. The wells allfound high permeability and produced brines with tempera-

    tures in excess of 260 8C. Based on the results of the wells

    and their extensive flow testing, geothermal reserves

    sufficient for generation of 210 MW have been reported to

    Pertamina. Additional drilling throughout the remainder of

    the geophysical target has the potential of increasing this

    capacity significantly.

    8. Conclusions

    The Sarulla graben is a composite Plio-Pleistocene basin

    developed along the currently active Tor Sibohi strand ofthe Sumatra fault system. The geometry of the graben is

    more complex than a simple pull-apart basin, but is clearly

    controlled by overall dextral strike-slip deformation. The

    Sumatra fault system in this area is up to 10 km wide and

    consists of both active and inactive faults. For the last

    0.27 Ma, slip on the Tor Sibohi fault has averaged about

    9 mm/y.

    Volcanic centers lie along the fault system, and several

    appear to have been localized at fault steps, fault

    intersections, and near fault tips. Significant geothermal

    resources are developed in thick tuffs that fill the Sarulla

    graben and underlie Sibualbuali volcano. At the Silangki-

    tang, Donatasik, and Sibualbuali geothermal fields, fractur-ing and faulting within the Tor Sibohi fault zone control

    reservoir permeability. The Namora-I-Langit geothermal

    field lies adjacent to the active Hutajulu fault, but

    fracturing extends several kilometers from the fault and

    may not be directly related to the faulting. Geothermal

    activity in the four identified fields appears to be controlled

    by the presence of volcanism and tectonism, resulting in

    the development of high heat flow and enhanced

    permeability.

    Acknowledgements

    We would like to thank the managements of Unocal and

    Pertamina for permission to publish this paper, and the

    people of North Sumatra for their hospitality and assistance

    during our field surveys. We would also like to acknowledgethe contributions of our colleagues at Unocal, Unocal

    Geothermal Indonesia and the assistance of Pertamina

    geoscientists in this project. Warren Sharp carried out the40Ar/39Ar analyses and offered suggestions to improve the

    manuscript. We thank Ardyth Simmons and Dan Hawkes

    for their careful reviews of the manuscript. Chris Elders and

    Andrew Mitchells constructive reviews contributed greatly

    to preparation of the final version of this paper.

    References

    Aspden, J.A., Kartawa, W., Aldiss, D.T., Djunuddin, A., Whandoyo, R.,Diatma, D., Clarke, M.C.G., Harahap, H., 1982. The Geology of

    the Padangsidempuan and Sibolga Quadrangle, Directorate General of

    Mines, Geological Research and Development Centre, Bandung,

    Indonesia, 34 p.

    Beck, M.E. Jr., 1983. On the mechanism of tectonic transport in zones of

    oblique subduction. Tectonophysics 93, 111.

    Bellier, O., Sebrier, M., 1994. Relationship between tectonism and

    volcanism along the Great Sumatran fault zone deduced by SPOT

    image analysis. Tectonophysics 233, 215231.

    Bellier, O., Sebrier, M., 1995. Is the slip rate variation on the Great Sumatra

    Fault accommodated by fore-arc stretching? Geophysical Research

    Letters 22, 1969 1972.

    Ben-Avraham, Z., Zoback, M.D., 1992. Transform-normal extension and

    asymmetric basins: an alternative to pull-apart models. Geology 20,

    423426.Chesner, C.A., Rose, W.I., Deino, A., Drake, R., 1991. Eruptive history of

    earths largest quaternary caldera (Toba, Indonesia). Geology 19,

    200203.

    Cooper, M.A., Herbert, R., Hill, G.S., 30 January2 February 1989. The

    structural evolution of Triassic intermontane basins in northeastern

    Thailand, International Symposium on Intermontane Basins: Geology

    and Resources, Chiang Mai, Thailand, p. 231242.

    Curray, J.R., Moore, D.G., Lawver, L.A., Emmel, F.J., Raitt, R.W., Henry,

    M., Kieckhefer, R.M., 1979. Tectonics of the Andaman Sea and Burma.

    In: Watkins, J., Montadert, L., Dickenson, P.W. (Eds.), Geological and

    Geophysical Investigations of Continental Margins, CCOPSEATAR

    Meeting, Bandung, American Association of Petroleum Geology

    Memoir, 29., pp. 189198.

    Curewitz, D., Karson, J.A., 1997. Structural settings of hydrothermal

    outflow: Fracture permeability maintained by fault propagation andinteraction. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 79,

    149168.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448 447

  • 7/26/2019 2004-Tectonic and Stratigraphy Evolution of the Sarulla Graben Geothermal Area, North Sumatra_Hickman Et Al

    14/14

    DeMets, C., Gordon, R.G., Argus, D.F., Stein, S., 1990. Current plate

    motions. Geophysical Journal International 101, 425478.

    Detourbet, C., Bellier, O., Sebrier, M., 1993. La caldera volcanique de

    Toba et le systeme de faille de Sumatra (Indonesia) vue par SPOT.Comptes Rendus de lAcademie des Sciences. Serie II 316,

    14391445.

    Dibble, T.W., 1977. Strike-slip tectonics of the San Andreas fault and its

    role in Cenozoic basin evolution, San Joaquin Geological Society Short

    Course,.

    Diament, M., Harjono, H., Karta, K., Deplus, C., Dahrin, D., Zen, M.T. Jr,

    Gerard, M., et al., 1992. Mentawai fault zone off Sumatra, a new key to

    the geodynamics of Indonesia. Geology 20, 259262.

    Dooley, T., McClay, K., 1997. Analog modeling of pull-apart basins.

    American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin 81,

    18041826.

    Fitch, T.J., 1972. Plate convergence, transcurrent faults, and internal

    deformation adjacent to Southeast Asia and western Pacific. Journal of

    Geophysical Research 77, 44324460.

    Genrich, J.F., Bock, Y., McCaffrey, R., Prawirodirdjo, L., Stevens, C.W.,

    Puntodewo, S.S.O., Subarya, C., Wdowinski, S., 2000. Distribution of

    slip at the northern Sumatra fault system. Journal of Geophysical

    Research 105 (28), 327328.see also 342.

    Gunderson, R.P., Dobson, P.F., Sharp, W.D., Pudjianto, R., Hasibuan, A.,

    1995. Geology and thermal features of the Sarulla contract block, north

    Sumatra, Indonesia. Proceedings of the World Geothermal Congress 2,

    687692.

    Gunderson, R., Ganefianto, N., Riedel, K., Sirad-Azwar, L., Suleiman, S.,

    2000. Exploration results in the Sarulla Block, north Sumatra,

    Indonesia. Proceedings of the World Geothermal Congress,

    11831188.

    Hamilton, W., 1979. Tectonics of the Indonesian Region. U.S. Geological

    Survey Professional Paper 1078, 345 p.

    Heidrick, T.L., Kelsch, K.D., Ibrahim, A., Castillo, D.A., 2000. Utilization

    of High-Resolution Geologic, Geophysical and Borehole Data to

    Quantify Fault Seal Attributes in Major Oil Fields, AmericanAssociation of Petroleum Geologists International Conference Bali,

    Indonesia Abstracts.

    Jarrard, R.D., 1986. Terrane motion by strike-slip faulting of fore-arc

    slivers. Geology 14, 780783.

    McCaffrey, R., 1992. Oblique plate convergence, slip vectors, and fore-arc

    deformation. Journal of Geophysical Research 97, 89058915.

    McCarthy, A.J., 1997. The evolution of the transcurrent Sumatran fault

    system, Indonesia. Unpublished. University of London. PhD Thesis.

    231 p.

    McCarthy, A.J., Elders, C.F., 1997. Caenozoic deformation in Sumatra-oblique subduction and the development of the Sumatran fault system.

    In: Fraser, A.J., Matthews, S.J. (Eds.), Petroleum Geology of SE Asia,

    126. Geological Society of London Special Publication, pp. 355363.

    Minster, J.B., Jordan, T.H., 1978. Present-day plate motions. Journal of

    Geophysical Research 83, 53315334.

    Mitchell, A.H.G., 1993. Cretaceous-cenozoic tectonic events in the western

    Myanmar (Burma)-Assam region. Journal of the Geological Society

    150, 1089 1102.

    Moore, D.E., Hickman, S., Lockner, D.A., Dobson, P., 2001. Geothermal

    mineralogy and microstructures in the Silangkitang geothermal field

    along the Great Sumatran fault zone, Sumatra, Indonesia. Geological

    Society of America Bulletin 113, 11791192.

    Nicholson, C., Seeber, L., Williams, P., Sykes, L.R., 1986. Seismic

    evidence for conjugate slip and block rotation within the San Andreas

    fault system, southern California. Tectonics 5, 629648.

    Page, B.G.N., Bennet, J.D., Cameron, N.R., Bridge, D., McC Jeffery, D.H.,

    Keats, W., Thaib, J., 1979. A review of the main structural and

    magmatic features of northern Sumatra. Journal of the Geological

    Society 136, 569579.

    Posevec, M., Taylor, D., van Leeuwen, T., Spector, A., 1973. Tectonic

    controls of volcanism and complex movements along the Sumatran

    fault system. Geological Society of Malaysia Bulletin 6, 4360.

    Sieh, K., Natawidjaja, D., 2000. Neotectonics of the Sumatran fault,

    Indonesia. Journal of Geophysical Research 105 (28), 295 328.see also

    326.

    Sieh, K., Rais, J., 1991. Neotectonic and paleoseismic studies in West and

    north Sumatra. American Geophysical Union 1991 Fall Meeting

    Program and Abstracts 72, 460.

    Stauffer, P.H., 1983. Unraveling the mosaic of Palaeozoic crustal blocks in

    Southeast Asia. Geologische Rundschau 72, 10611080.

    Townend, J., Zoback, M.D., 2000. How faulting keeps the crust strong.Geology 28, 399402.

    Wallace, R.E., 1968. Notes on stream channels offset by the San Andreas

    fault, southern coast ranges, California. In: Dickinson, W.R., Grantz, A.

    (Eds.), Proceedings on Conference on Geologic Problems of San

    Andreas Fault System, 11. Stanford University Publications in the

    Geological Sciences, pp. 621.

    R.G. Hickman et al. / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 23 (2004) 435448448