*2009 4 29

*

/

14:0014:10

14:1014:40

14:4015:30

15:3015:45

Coffee Break

15:4516:45

16:4517:00

*

*

*92269541198 1998 Cardiff ProcessStrategic Environmental Assessment, SEA Cardiff Process

**()

(92.01.08)(95.04.07)95.04.110950022968 (96.01.15)

*95.04.110950022968 *()

1.972.3.4.(10)5.6.7.8.9.

*()*

()

()

()

()

()

*()

*()

/1.2.3.()

*(Steel Up Policy)(Plan)

*STWT

SOSOSOSTWOWO

SOWOSO

STWO(Steel Up Policy)

*

*

199019952000200520062007() 809,650 847,590 1,382,315 1,383,945 1,482,949 1,489,755 () 578,718 887,449 783,187 621,194 738,908 565,206 () 15 59,936 129,370 155,599 187,870 173,705 () 5,343,125 7,508,480 11,732,525 13,030,868 13,830,046 14,230,650 () 3,811,427 5,108,581 8,449,171 9,893,128 10,797,823 10,995,570 () 1,531,698 2,399,899 3,283,354 3,137,740 3,032,223 3,235,080

1990CO2110,5022006265,2732006CO2139,36852.5%2006CO227,38710.3% 19.6%2006CO253.5%23.0%14.9%

CO2 *2007

Chart1

62403777487541357613826814550

59543659088381440647825134762

55363073692251408656126154736

598533078101661450684128165028

655834274112561479704430174805

669535538117461392692130154578

701542195127551806829630925531

670144455141062088872733846008

6425529101624527371069935826562

6543565771817035781225235847354

6837570701963438871205336987448

6624625442092647421373735808180

6518674272404554521462635188009

7087716652610264561628736638484

8058748292752871711732937389770

8471788032880378821878738849802

86578276629851834220340402111208

87779106330587931021368378011699

941996333320311146323384331312758

1010099843334461210725857344412838

10876111795336461302527127385814159

9899114871354381351327660394415113

10037119310349131422928998402815830

10717123044353361515930263445718313

11812133896367561544929909464216661

12904136131377171663132121429017465

12661141884380211757933589337118171

Sheet1

198025,15925,5688,5983442,4672,3043,056

198125,25824,3908,6623402,6232,1643,140

198223,65519,7149,0583802,7192,2623,027

198324,66621,69110,0103932,8982,4573,248

198426,27521,84911,1084083,1672,6003,026

198524,34224,56811,6194103,3862,6222,939

198631,30527,02212,5954653,5872,5013,216

198732,56628,61413,9515183,6842,6363,500

198839,62333,14216,0684583,9192,6953,255

198946,59232,73617,9655204,2622,6433,340

199046,45333,72419,4225694,0852,9163,457

199153,36435,35520,7046074,3222,6723,309

199257,45037,75023,8166574,5362,6452,742

199364,64439,18625,8527044,4462,6472,265

199469,97140,40827,2747314,5562,6932,791

199575,91741,54628,5448384,7022,7482,136

199681,67642,62529,5638654,8842,7752,798

199790,69745,19030,2408895,0082,4492,111

199899,87646,66331,5359505,1042,0202,552

1999107,13946,21532,8981,2115,5192,1032,550

2000121,29048,47732,9641,2975,4702,4392,547

2001125,87747,76633,0331,5255,3412,5362,876

2002130,59450,49234,1511,5055,2272,5412,835

2003141,17347,19034,5421,7815,1532,9074,543

2004148,78251,68235,9391,9385,2423,0782,464

2005157,38550,34436,8732,1775,3802,7162,384

2006164,08652,67837,1262,2455,2201,7022,220

Sheet1

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

Sheet2

19806,24037,7748,7541,3576,1382,6814,550

19815,95436,5908,8381,4406,4782,5134,762

19825,53630,7369,2251,4086,5612,6154,736

19835,98533,07810,1661,4506,8412,8165,028

19846,55834,27411,2561,4797,0443,0174,805

19856,69535,53811,7461,3926,9213,0154,578

19867,01542,19512,7551,8068,2963,0925,531

19876,70144,45514,1062,0888,7273,3846,008

19886,42552,91016,2452,73710,6993,5826,562

19896,54356,57718,1703,57812,2523,5847,354

19906,83757,07019,6343,88712,0533,6987,448

19916,62462,54420,9264,74213,7373,5808,180

19926,51867,42724,0455,45214,6263,5188,009

19937,08771,66526,1026,45616,2873,6638,484

19948,05874,82927,5287,17117,3293,7389,770

19958,47178,80328,8037,88218,7873,8849,802

19968,65782,76629,8518,34220,3404,02111,208

19978,77791,06330,5879,31021,3683,78011,699

19989,41996,33332,03111,46323,3843,31312,758

199910,10099,84333,44612,10725,8573,44412,838

200010,876111,79533,64613,02527,1273,85814,159

20019,899114,87135,43813,51327,6603,94415,113

200210,037119,31034,91314,22928,9984,02815,830

200310,717123,04435,33615,15930,2634,45718,313

200411,812133,89636,75615,44929,9094,64216,661

200512,904136,13137,71716,63132,1214,29017,465

200612,661141,88438,02117,57933,5893,37118,171

Sheet2

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

0000000

Sheet3

(2006)* 2008

TSP12,2331.82 %PM108,5353.17%PM2.55,1354.04%SOx21,30813.45%NOx18,6873.48%NMHC6,6880.90%CO52,7544.11%

2002179 g-TEQ200656g-TEQ()()2008(Toxic Equivalencies, TEQ) *

Chart3

28.50198.1321.2071.182

29.21108.071.2071.182

29.367147.931.2071.182

39.316104.991.1471.163

30.29967.9621.1471.179

26.67735.5731.1470.567

20.0734.9530.5531.147

Sheet1

889091929394

28.50111.19%29.2113.14%29.36710.17%39.31617.54%30.29914.67%26.67720.43%

1.1820.46%1.1820.53%1.1820.41%1.1630.52%1.1790.57%0.5670.43%

98.13238.53%108.06748.63%147.93251.24%104.99146.83%67.96232.91%35.57327.24%

1.2070.47%1.2070.54%1.2070.42%1.1470.51%1.1470.56%1.1470.88%

129.02250.65%139.66662.84%179.68862.24%146.61765.39%100.58748.71%63.96448.98%

254.71222.241288.718224.21206.501130.582

2000200120022003200420052006

28.50129.2129.36739.31630.29926.67720.07

98.132108.07147.93104.9967.96235.57334.953

1.2071.2071.2071.1471.1471.1470.553

1.1821.1821.1821.1631.1790.5671.147

gI-TEQ/

Sheet1

Sheet2

889091929394

129.0250.65%139.66662.84%179.68862.24%146.61765.39%100.58748.71%63.96448.98%

254.71222.241288.718224.21206.501130.582

Sheet3

*

15-1 16 12 113 14~18 ()

*

*(LCA)LCA(Input-Output analysis)

*(%)(%) () ()WSA(Life cycle assessment, LCA)1.2.3. (9430.35%)

83.96

3.76

9.59

6.39

3.53

-19.48

12.13

0

CO2

4

3.22

3.90

0.41

2.92

11.00

5.95

68.58

NOx

5.89

13.65

5.92

1.67

42.33

-25.59

9.00

47.12

SOx

7.69

9.86

9.84

4.32

21.41

-35.26

24.57

57.64

4.12

58.64

8.39

0.25

2.46

-24.61

3.1

47.62

1.94

91.19

2.97

0

0

-0.92

0.96

3.85

0

28.74

4.72

0.62

0.06

-8.15

11.27

62.73

1.46

16.71

6.87

2.69

0.04

72.22

0

CO2

0.13

17.91

0.71

4.12

-0.11

56.58

20.64

NOx

0.10

13.34

0.58

24.69

-0.23

41.03

20.44

SOx

0.07

18.13

1.32

2.84

-1.07

69.52

9.19

0.13

25.03

0.05

5.37

-2.47

26.54

45.32

0.38

56.39

0.03

0.006

2.08

12.93

25.71

0

1.41

0.54

0.02

-0.11

24.48

73.59

**2007

*

*()(WSA)2008--- *

* Dimensions()*

*()WSAHertin(2003)()

()

*

/kg-eq NOx(air) /NOx/VOC kg-eq PM2.5air PM10/ SOx, (SS)/( kg-2-4-Dsoil) VOCsPAHH+()SOxNOxNH3HClHF (kg-eq Bezeneair )(kg-eq Tolueneair ) VOCsPAH lost-time injury frequency rate

*()

/ / CO2, CH4 PAHs, Dioxins

*()

*

*

*

GDP95%90%C to C (Cradle to Cradle)

*

*()

**Steiner(1969)

*()

*()

*()SWOT

****************************************