2010 michigan bridge conference site & situation...

38
2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation Bridges in Context Burton Collection

Upload: others

Post on 17-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE

Site & Situation – Bridges in Context

Burton Collection

Page 2: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Site & Situation – Bridges in Context

• The bridge

• The setting

• The environment

• The stakeholders

Page 3: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Stoney Creek Village:• Founded in 1824• Home to Rochester

Hills Museum at Van Hoosen Farm

Tienken Road & Bridge:• Bridge into village

structurally deficient, functionally obsolete.

• Bridge NOT historic, • Bridge NOT a

candidate for rehab.

Page 4: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

• 40’ long

• 24’ wide

• No sidewalk

• Non-original railing

Page 5: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

RCOC

Page 6: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Photo from RCOC

Page 7: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek

The same area, January 20, 2010.

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Page 8: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Page 9: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Page 10: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Page 11: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge

Page 12: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

MDOT – Tim Burke

Page 13: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 14: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 15: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 16: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 17: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 18: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 19: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 20: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Page 21: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

MDOT Alpena TSC

Page 22: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

MDOT Alpena TSC

Page 23: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Hillman – M-32 BS Bridge

Replacement Bridge:

• Recalls historic camelback design and opens views of river

• Design favored by community

Page 24: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

M-6 over the Thornapple River

• Obscures river views for motorists

• Some aesthetic quality on outboard side of barrier

Page 25: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Congress Ave. Bridge, Austin, TX

Photo: Lori Kay Stone

Page 26: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Congress Ave. Bridge, Austin, TX

• Built in 1910,

• Deck replaced in 1980,

• Renamed the Ann W. Richards Congress Avenue Bridge in 2006.

Photo: TripAdvisor.com

Page 27: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates:

East Delhi Road Bridge

www.historicbridges.org

Page 28: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

• Initial funding through old Critical Bridge program – required replacement

• Bridge was considered ineligible for NRHP in 1995 survey – due to “lack of pedigree.”

• Community opposed to replacement

– Sense of place

– Historic

– Traffic management

– Reduce development pressure

Historic Bridge Updates: East Delhi Road Bridge

Page 29: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates: East Delhi Road Bridge

Page 30: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates: East Delhi Road Bridge

www.historicbridges.org

Page 31: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates:

East Delhi Road Bridge

• Cost $1.2 Million

• Residents agreed to special assessment

• Award winning collaboration www.historicbridges.org

Page 32: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates:Wm Milliken State Park

Page 33: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates:

State St Bridge - Bridgeport

Page 34: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates: State St Bridge - Bridgeport

Page 35: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates: State St Bridge - Bridgeport

Page 36: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates: State St Bridge - Bridgeport

mlive.com

Page 37: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Historic Bridge Updates:Historic Bridge Inventory

Courtesy of Vern Mesler

Page 38: 2010 MICHIGAN BRIDGE CONFERENCE Site & Situation ...michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/workshops/materials/...Stoney Creek & Tienken Road Bridge Stoney Creek Village: •Founded in

Thank You !

Lloyd BaldwinStaff HistorianProject Planning Division

Environmental Section

517.241.2702

[email protected]

Fort Street Bascule Bridge Concept –Hardesty & Hanover