2012 progress report final

88
THE UNITED NATIONS 2012 PROGRESS REPORT DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE FRAMEWORK 2012-2016 BANGLADESH

Upload: undp-bangladesh

Post on 18-Mar-2016

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2012 progress report final

THE UNITED NATIONS

2012 PROGRESS REPORTDEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE FRAMEWORK 2012-2016

BANGLADESH

Page 2: 2012 progress report final

Copyright © United Nations in Bangladesh 2013All rights reservedThe United Nations Development AssistanceFramework, 2012 Annual Progress Report,Bangladesh

Published by United Nations BangladeshIDB Bhaban, Agargaon, DhakaBangladesh

Photographers and UN Agenciesthat contributed photographs

Agencies:UNICEFWFPUNFPAIOMUNDP

Photographers:A. S. M. Maruf KabirAhsan KhanCornelia PaetzGMB AkashHaqueKauser HaiderM. A. HassanMawaMartinRein SkulleradSalman Saeed

Designwww.viscombd.com

Page 3: 2012 progress report final

2012 PROGRESS REPORTDEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE FRAMEWORK 2012-2016

3

Page 4: 2012 progress report final

4

The ‘UNDAF 2012-2016 in Bangladesh Year-1 Progress Report’ is the first progress report that summarizes the joint Government of Bangladesh and UN System’s substantive development results achieved in 2012 in each of seven UNDAF Pillars.

Thepreparation of the progress report was initiated jointly by the UN Wing, Economic Relations Division (ERD) and United Nations Office of UN Resident Coordinator (UN RCO). The process of preparation of the progress report was guided by the UNDAF Action Plan 2012-2016. It was a consultative and collaborative process, and the final product benefits from inputs of different Government ministries, divisions, and agencies as well as UN organizations that are working together to implement development interventions of the UNDAF 2012-2016 framework.

The progress report identifies remarkable joint achievements of the Government and the UN System across all UNDAF Pillars in 2012, for example: introducing e-innovation in public service delivery is one step forward to Government’s Sixth Five Year Plan commitment on Digital Bangladesh (Pillar One); various labour market reform initiatives undertaken in 2012, including approval of National Skills Development Policy (Pillar 6) will ultimately contribute to prioritizing women food security and assets as a key to growth (Pillar 2 and Pillar 7); decentralization of health planning (Pillar 3) and mainstreaming of National Nutritional Services into the health system will positively impact health services in coming years (Pillar 4); adoption of the Disaster Management Act 2012 will ensure better lives for millions of disaster vulnerable people (Pillar 5). These results also assure the country is on the right track to realize Vision 2021.

Apart from working jointly to achieve substantive development results, the first year of UNDAF implementation also meant establishing the foundations for UNDAF implementation through to 2016, including instituting of the UNDAF governance structure, setting up implementation and monitoring and evaluation mechanisms, etc.

The 2012 results of UNDAF implementation were reviewed in May 2013 by the UNDAF Steering Committee. The Committee meeting praised the achievements and discussed the areas where UNDAF implementation will be strengthened in the future. These areas included, inter alia, joint results monitoring and evaluation, information exchange on UNDAF implementation among all UNDAF stakeholders, optimization of inter-Pillar synergies, etc. The recommendations in these areas will be followed up by respective partners of the UNDAF implementation process and reported upon during the 2013 UNDAF Review Process.

I am thankful to all, including concerned implementing ministries, divisions, and agencies, UN organization, ERD officials, and the UN Resident Coordinator Officefor providing timely assistance and information and data used in this progress report. I am also looking forward to participate in UNDAF implementation and reviews in the future.

(Abul Kalam Azad)Secretary, Economic Relations DivisionMinistry of Finance

FOREWORD

Page 5: 2012 progress report final

5

Bangladesh has made enormous development progress over the past 20 years. This is clearly evident in Bangladesh’s performance against the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) – many of which the country is set to achieve. The strides Bangladesh has made are testament to development through partnerships, hard work and commitment over time.Credit goes to successive government administrations and to the tireless work of the many actors, local, national and international.

The United Nations has been a trusted partner in the country for over 40 years. The current focus of UN work is defined in the United Nations Development Assistance Framework 2012-2016 (UNDAF). Jointly formulated with Government, aligned with the nationaldevelopment agenda as defined in key documents, the UNDAF maps the priorities of UN work over the next years. The UNDAF is accompanied by an ambitious Action Plan in which the UN agencies operating in the country voluntarily outlined how to work in ways that would strengthen UN coordination, coherence and impact.

In 2012, the first year of UNDAF implementation, we built the foundation of what we need to ensure sustainable impact and results. This includes the UNDAF substantive andgovernance structures, monitoring and evaluation systems, a platform for advocacy, and alignment with Government efforts through the seven UNDAF pillars. We are confident that 2012 laid solid ground that will ensure the UNDAF iseffectively implementedin the coming years.

Despite the necessary internal focus on “how we work”, 2012 and has brought substantive successes and a promise of more to come. Some of the initial gains are detailed in the

accompanying UNDAF Joint Results Stories 2012, and I encourage you to take the time to read it. It can often be difficult to measure the impact of development assistance, and numbers and graphs rarely reflect the human development aspect of this work. The Joint Results Stories attempt to put a face to the figures.

The stories highlighted are a mix of results that include grassroots capacity-development initiatives such as with Community Nutrition Worker Halima Begum (Pillar 4), building community resilience through coordination to adequately prepare and respond to disaster (Pillar 6), high level advocacy to build the architecture for the delivery of social services (Pillars 2 and 3), and preventing child marriage through community education and advo-cacy (Pillar 7).

I am very proud of UN work in Bangladesh, of our long history of collaboration in Bangla-desh, and of the first-year results we have documented from our ambitious UNDAF. I am delighted to be a part of the UN team here that is working hard to support the Government’s efforts to achieve the results we have set for our joint efforts.

Neal WalkerUN Resident Coordinator andUNDP Resident Representative

FOREWORD

Page 6: 2012 progress report final

6

Page 7: 2012 progress report final

I. Introduction

II. Key Development Trends

III. Progress Toward UNDAF Outcomes and the United Nations’ Contribution

Pillar One: Democratic Governance and Human Rights

Pillar Two: Pro-Poor Growth with Equity

Pillar Three: Social Services for Human Development

Pillar Four: Food Security and Nutrition

Pillar Six: Pro-Poor Urban Development

Pillar Seven: Gender Equality and Women’s Advancement

IV. Progress on United Nations Reform

V. Lessons Learned and Way Forward

ANNEXES

Pillar Five: Climate Change, Environment, and Disaster Risk Reduction and Response

Annex 1: Acronyms

Annex 2: UNDAF Annual Review Process Calendar

Annex 4: Revised UNDAF Indicators

Annex 3: UNDAF Results Framework Report

PAGE 09PAGE 13

PAGE 18PAGE 17

PAGE 24PAGE 28

PAGE 36

PAGE 40PAGE 45

PAGE 48PAGE 52

PAGE 55

PAGE 59PAGE 61

PAGE 79PAGE 63

TABLE OF CONTENTS

7

Page 8: 2012 progress report final

8

Page 9: 2012 progress report final

9

I. INTRODUCTIONThe United Nations Development Assistance Framework (UNDAF) in Bangladesh is the result of an ongoing consultative process intended to analyze how the UN can mosteffectively respond to national priorities and needs. It is guided by the goals and targets of the Millennium Declaration, as endorsed by the Government, as well as the national Vision 2021, Sixth Five Year National Development Plan, Joint Cooperation Strategy and other relevant documents.

The unifying theme of the UNDAF is to accelerate human development with equity by 2015, specifically through achievement of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in the worst performing and most vulnerable geographic areas and among the most vulnerable segments of the population. The UNDAF translates all this into a common operational framework for development activities upon which individual UN organizations formulate their actions for the period 2012-2016. In turn, the seven UNDAF Pillars are:

Democratic Governance and Human Rights Pro-Poor Growth with Equity Social Services for Human Development Food Security and Nutrition Climate Change, Environment, and Disaster Risk Reduction and

Response Pro-Poor Urban Development Gender Equality and Women’s Advancement

Page 10: 2012 progress report final

10

Pillar 1, on democratic governance and human rights, consists of two outcomes. The first is on building the capacity of public and Government institutions to more effectively carry out their mandates and deliver improved services in an accountable, transparent and inclusive manner. The second concerns increased access to, and more efficiency of, justice systems and strengthened human rights institutions better able to promote and protect human rights, particularly for women and vulnerable groups.

Under Pillar 1, the UN System continues to ensure representations and participation through democratic processes, complementing this with efforts to deepen democracy through strengthened partnerships with civil society to create democratic space for larger civic engagement. A focus on institutional reform, decentralization and local governance are also key areas for effective service delivery, thereby contributing to local development based on community needs.

Pillar 2, focuses on economic growth and its impact on poverty and other welfareconditions, notably, nutrition and labour market participation. The Pillar’s single Outcome objective targets pro-poor growth, defined by both its level and its distribution between

These seven interrelated and mutually reinforcing focus areas offer a robust development approach that links human rights with 12 measurable and time-bound Outcome results targeted for achievement by 2016. They are framed by the overarching imperative of creating, for all the people of Bangladesh, more equitable access to knowledge, skills, livelihoods, employment, justice, social services, food security, nutrition, financial services and social protection.

1. High-level advocacy;2. Capacity development of individuals;3. Systems strengthening;

4. Partnership building, participation and raising the voice of civil society; and

5. Targeting interventions in geographic regions, based on districts lagging on MDG achievements and on vulnerability mapping determined by key social indicators. A total of 20 districts and 30 cities or towns have been targeted. Toward this overall end, the UN System is working with greater collaboration and coherence, including through the mechanism of seven Pillar Working Groups.

Five core strategies underpin the full range of UNDAF results,including

Page 11: 2012 progress report final

11

groups and localities. Given this, the management and reduction of inequality is an implicit policy target, alongside broad growth acceleration. The Pillar defines poverty widely, including both income and human development dimensions. Outputs are backed by a suite of indicators tracking policy changes and direct project interventions in areas as diverse as trade promotion and social protection policies. Special attention is given to the geographical pattern of growth and the impact on key vulnerable groups, including women. Parallel interventions with a poverty impact are undertaken in other Pillars as well.

In addressing social services for human development, three Outcomes of Pillar 3 aim to contribute to poverty reduction by strategically creating or facilitating linkages andsynergies between key sectors so that deprived populations, particularly women, children and youth, benefit from increased and more equitable use of quality health and population, education, water, sanitation, social protection and HIV services. UN System interventions contribute to enhanced practices by deprived community members of key life-saving, care and protective behaviours, and raise their demand for quality social services. Intense policy advocacy efforts have led to the development or updating of legal instruments and policies to harmonize these with international human rights standards (see also Pillar 1).

Capacity development, communication and mobilization efforts at different levels of Government and society also are contributing to facilitate effective and efficientimplementation of policies and national strategies that will translate into improved provision and demand for social services. Further UN System support for evidence-based policymaking is contributing to strengthening of institutional learning and accountability by systematically embedding results-based planning, monitoring and evaluation into all programmatic areas.

Interventions under Pillar 4, food security and nutrition, are in line with key crosscutting gaps identified in analysis of several of the MDGs in Bangladesh, including the nutrition aspects of MDG1 (halve the proportion of people who suffer from hunger); MDG3 (promote gender equality and empower women); MDG4 (reduce child mortality), MDG5 (improve maternal health); and MDG7 (ensure environmental sustainability).

Although significant efforts and important decisions have been made by the Government to mainstream food security and nutrition into the national development agenda, a need exists to strengthen institutional linkages across core sectors directly engaged in nutrition interventions, including food, agriculture and health. Ongoing capacity strengthening will need to be fostered within a multi-sectoral framework in order to leverage theseinvestments for significant and sustainable improvements. Improvement of food safety especially requires the establishment of cross-sectoral cooperation mechanisms andimplementation of core capacity development activities; recent Government initiatives

have recognized this pressing need and the necessary policy actions will be taken forward. Particularly considering the needs of the most vulnerable, including women and under-5 children, this multi-sectoral Pillar requires complementary results from other Pillars, including improved access to social services and increased income opportunities for the poor. It also is intended to contribute to national priorities on reducing poverty, boosting economic production, and securing human resource development.

Pillar 5, on environment, climate change and Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) and response, represents a major strength of this UNDAF, conceiving that these areas are fundamentally synchronized and interwoven. A holistic approach is pursued that contributes to poverty reduction and sustainable development, reduces vulnerability to hazards, and recognizes that food insecurity, social inequality and ecological degradation are important elements of overall vulnerability.

With Bangladesh’s sheer number of vulnerable people and a highly degraded natural resource base, the impacts of adverse change in any ecological or climatic sub-system have particular potential to multiply and destabilize entire system. This challenges theattainment of the MDGs by widening existing gaps in resource allocations, creating further inequality in access to basic services, and increasing levels of vulnerability by exposing individuals and communities to various forms of hazards. It also causes systems andinstitutions to break down and become inefficient. Thus, the Pillar is focused on two thematic Outcome areas that aim to help create a State in which all relevant systems (social, institutional, policy and governance) can more efficiently respond to the needs of people and ensure their protection and well-being.

Page 12: 2012 progress report final

12

UNDAF Pillar 6 focuses on secure and equitable pro-poor urban development and mitigation of the worst effects of rapid urbanization. It contributes to the national priorities on securing human resource development and promoting environmental sustainability in low-income urban settlements. At policy level, the Pillar supports development of national and municipal plans and budget allocations that promote the rights of the urban poor and vulnerable populations, particularly with regard to land tenure security and access to affordable housing. Secondly, the Pillar focuses on promotion of democratic and pro-poor urban governance, along with developing stakeholder capacities to plan and manage sustainable urbandevelopment. Critically, it emphasizes empowerment and capacity development of the urban poor to improve their socioeconomic conditions, along with increasing their access to basic services and social protection programmes.

Lastly, Pillar 7 focuses on gender equality and women’s empowerment and its impact on women’s socioeconomic empowerment in particular, creating an enabling environment to increase women’s participation in the labour market and their accessibility to information,

skills development and training opportunities in which they can generate income. Its two Outcomes are interrelated: marginalized and disadvantaged women increase their participation in wage employment and other income-generating activities, while their social and institutional vulnerabilities simultaneously are intended to be reduced. This two-track, complementary approach promotes overall gender equality and equity by focusing on critical gender-related issues that affect the economic and social status of women and girls and their right to productive participation in the labour market. Moreover, the strategies employed by these twin tracks utilize gender as both a crosscutting and a stand-alone approach.

In terms of monitoring and evaluation, progress data for indicators have been collected year-round by the UNDAF M&E Group. The Group not only monitors the validity ofassumptions and risks made at the design stage of the UNDAF, but also is monitoringprogress under an agreed M&E Plan. The Group also further provided feedback to Pillars on drafts of the Pillar Annual Reports to sharpen the annual review process.

Page 13: 2012 progress report final

13

Bangladesh’s general election, scheduled in late 2013, presents both key challenges and opportunities to the UN System, both of which began manifesting in 2012. The 15th Amendment to the Constitution, in 2011, that removed the provision for a Caretaker Government, introduced major course of change in national affair. Election-related issues notwithstanding, change in public institutions has been steady, and independent institutions such as the National Human Rights Commission and the Election Commission display visible signs of building capacity with important policy contributions. There remains a Government commitment at legislative level to build greater capacities and improve service delivery overall. The poor in particular have benefited from these initiatives, and in fact may benefit further if the forthcoming elections accelerate such delivery as the Government looks to showcase its achievements.

Efforts to deepen reform of the civil service have been slow to translate into real change. For example, the overall setting for urban governance remains fragmented at national and municipal levels, both in terms of institutions and service delivery; although the Municipal Act 2010 requires master plans for urban areas, few towns have yet prepared them, and even those that exist are rarely implemented.

In terms of the economy, Bangladesh continued to record robust growth, reaching 6.3 percent in fiscal 2012, alongside per-capita growth of 4.61 percent. While this performance represents an improvement over the base, the headline figure is below the target given in the Sixth Five Year Plan, and as a result, so too is the per-capita figure below the UNDAF target.

II. Key Development Trends

...................................................................................................................................................................1 Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) Report, December 2012.

Page 14: 2012 progress report final

14

...................................................................................................................................................................

2 LabourForce Survey (LFS) 2013. 3 World Bank World Development Indicators (WDI) series, 2012. 4 EIU, op.cit.; Central Bank Bulletin, various dates.5 UNRC Economic Briefing, Quarter 4 2012.6 Ibid.

Employment and labour market trends reported in 2012, which are central to securing pro-poor growth, were somewhat better over those reported a year earlier; the overall participation rate showed improvement (59.3 vs. 58.5 percent), especially for women (36.0 vs. 29.2 percent)2. These Outcome indicators show on-track performances. However, with regard to the budgetary position, where the share of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) allocated to health and education is used as a proxy for pro-poor budgeting, the trends are somewhat disappointing. The overall percentage expended in these sectors declined to 3.4 percent of GDP3.

Provisional data show the Ready Made Garments (RMG) sector remained the engine of growth, with this likely to continue to have a positive impact on the level and pace of poverty reduction, given the sector’s labour intensity and linkages with the wider, but generally informal, service sector4. It is notable, however, that the economic “footprint” of RMG is almost entirely urban, and particularly focused on the core cities. It is also critical to recognize the importance of agriculture, fisheries and livestock to the livelihoods of the poor, and hence, the poverty impact of growth. A majority of the workforce continues to be engaged in these activities, regardless of their falling share of GDP. Bangladesh continues to experience one of the most rapid urbanization processes in Asia, at an annual rate of 4 to 6 percent. Coupled with population growth and land tenure issues, this has led to an increasing number of people – estimated at more than 7 million – living in poverty and in informal urban settlements with poor access to basic services.

In line with national trends, however,employment opportunities in urban areas increased, especially for urban women, whose labour force participation rose from 27.4 percent in 2005 to 34.5 percent in 2010. This, along with other economic data, underlines the ongoing economic vibrancy of cities.

The continuing resilience of international remittances and the flow of workers overseas also are positive features in development trends. These act both as a support to national incomes and are crucial to the balance of payments position, which alongside the fiscal deficit emerged as a key policy issue during the year5. Indeed, severe budgetary and balance of payment difficulties were only avoided through swift policy actions by the Government and central bank. These pressures will remain present in 2013 and may have some direct impact on UN System programming as the Government continues to rein in spending levels6. Price inflation weakened during 2012, due especially to moderating prices for food and other staples, and this will benefit the living standards of the poor.

Page 15: 2012 progress report final

15

Nevertheless, the Consumer Price Index is likely to remain above 7 percent in 2013, and reversals are possible, especially if a major climatic event occurs.

Two further less positive economic features also must be noted: First, the geographical pattern of growth is becoming more uneven and is likely to drive spatial inequalities. Second, the economy and the livelihoods of the poor themselves remain vulnerable to climatic events and ongoing environmental degradation. Bangladesh remains among the countries most vulnerable to climate change as well as a disaster risk hot spot, with a host of profound, multi-layered challenges that result in increased vulnerability. Large-scale climatic events in the country were absent in 2012, although 1.3 million people were affected in the southwest region by small-scale flooding and landslides.

National disaster management capacity, including the prioritization and integration of Disaster Risk Reduction and climate change adaptation across sectors, continued to strengthen. Central to this was enactment of the Disaster Management Act 2012, which was a catalyst for institutional reform that formalized the comprehensive disaster management system and provided legal empowerment to disaster-vulnerable people. A new humanitarian architecture, aligned with global best-practice principles and linked to the nationaldevelopment framework, is expected to strengthen humanitarian coordination under Government leadership.

Meanwhile, agricultural output performed well for the year, while steady progress was recorded in policy enhancement and market penetration of energy-efficient appliances and cleaner energy generation. No significant progress in food production diversification was recorded, highlighting that macroeconomic growth and higher agricultural productivity, although essential are inadequate on their own to address food security and nutrition. Food access, however, has been substantially strengthened, and a steady decline in food inflation in the early part of 2012 continued till the later part of the year. Food adulteration,contamination and poor oversightof the production-to-consumption chain are growing concerns that threaten the safety of the quality of food supply, public health and economic productivity. At the same time, overall growth in rural areas, although lower than that in urban areas, continues to provide a bulwark to domestic demand and incomes.

Critically, gender equality remains highly challenged in Bangladesh; although the country has ratified the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) and is a signatory to the Beijing Platform for Action, there has been little progress in withdrawing remaining national reservations to the Convention. Continuing large differentials between women and men’s labour force participation rates, for both urban and rural areas, underscores the strength of gender-based disparities. Violence Against Women (VAW) remains a particularly prevalent and socially sensitive issue.

Page 16: 2012 progress report final

16

Despite impressive progress in improving maternal mortality and reproductive health services in Bangladesh, there remain serious shortfalls in maternal health outcomes and access to services, particularly for poor women and in hard-to-reach areas. These shortfalls are due in part to the comparative absence of a skilled health workforce with the full spectrum of basic midwifery skills and competencies at facility and community levels; this is now being addressed. To meet MDG5 at national level, for example, Bangladesh must increase the proportion of births attended by skilled health personnel to 50 percent by 2015.

A positive trend in the social services relates to a continuing reduction in the open defecation rate, now standing at 4 percent7. This remarkable achievement has been possible through intensive social mobilization, including efforts supported by the UN System, which has contributed to shifts in social norms.

Significantly, 2012 also marked an important strategic shift for the Government through the mainstreaming of nutrition within the health sector and significant attention given tonutrition as a crosscutting development issue. This is particularly crucial given that under weight among under-5 children, although declining, remains high, at 36 percent,

.....................................................................................................................................7 JMP, 2012.8 BDHS 2011; United Nations global estimates, 2012.

with stunting among young children even higher, at 41 percent. The prevalence of anaemia among children, adolescent girls and pregnant women also remains high, at 40 percent, while the proportion of malnourished people overall stands at 16.8 percent8. Appropriate complementary feeding represents a major concern, with only 1 in 5 infants benefiting from a minimally acceptable diet.

All this underscores the need for an integrated and multi-sectoral set of targetedinterventions by the Government with technical support from the UN Agencies and in line with the National Food Policy Plan of Action 2008-2015 and Country Investment Plan (CIP) for Agriculture, Food Security and Nutritionthat are being monitored by the Food Planning and Monitoring Unit, Ministry of Food in collaboration with 17 partner ministries andgovernment departments and agencies. The CIP, developed with UN assistance and sustained by an inclusive multi-stakeholder coordination mechanism, has been effective in scaling up total financing for investments in food and nutrition which have risen by about US$3.3 billion, to a total of $6.2 billion, even as the gap to be financed until June 2015 stands at US$3.6 billion. The CIP has been incorporated in 6th FY Plan and GOB is looking to the UN and development partners to extend cooperation to fill this gap of resources.

Page 17: 2012 progress report final

17

III. PROGRESS TOWARD UNDAF OUTCOMES AND THE UNITED NATIONS’ CONTRIBUTION

Page 18: 2012 progress report final

18

Key Government organizations at both national and sub-national levels have demonstrated clear and consistent building of capacity with UN System support. The Bangladesh Election Commission conducted a number of elections in 2012 that were assessed as welladministered by international observers, and public confidence levels have been

PILLAR ONE

DEMOCRATICGOVERNANCEANDHUMAN RIGHTS

Outcome 1.1: Government institutions at national and sub-national levels are able to more effectively carry out their mandates, including delivery of public services, in a more accountable, transparent, and inclusive manner.

maintained. A total of 80 percent of respondents in a 2012 national survey by Democracy International strongly or somewhat agree that the Election Commission is a neutral entity and will conduct elections in a free and fair manner. The voter register has been updated with support of UN Agencies, and 7.01 million names have been added,

Page 19: 2012 progress report final

19

resulting in a register of 92 million voters. As part of the Election Commission’s decentralization plan, 80 percent of 478 server stations have been completed and are capable of delivering localized electoral services to voters.

Following wide consultations with representatives of different cadres of the Bangladesh Civil Service as well as discussions with leaders of several government employees associations, with assistance from the UN System, a draft of the Public Service Act covering all Government employees and underscoring efficient and merit-based human resource management system, was finalized. The bill’s submission to the Parliament is imminent. Gender mainstreaming issues in human resource management policies also have paid dividends, and an increase of 2.4 percentage points was recorded among women in senior civil servant posts. Presently, a total of 10.5 percent of senior civil servants are women, according to the Public Administration Computer Center, Ministry of Public Administration (see also Pillar 7).

UN System support to Parliament has resulted in enhanced strategic direction of theParliamentary Secretariat, through the drafting of a strategic plan and action plan identifying priorities to improve secretariat services. The UN System has supported strengthened policy interventions by committees on climate change and on women and children, including presentation of preliminary findings of a study on gender responsiveness in the Parliament to the latter committee. This is expected to assist in better accommodating women inParliament as both elected officials and secretariat employees (see also Pillar 7). In addition, UN Agencies also worked to help establish a parliamentary caucus on issues of indigenous peoples, and have supported the inclusion of inputs from indigenous women in the draft Bangladesh Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act. The UN system also took the formal initiative to form women parliamentarians caucus. They also have facilitated workshops to makeparliamentarians more aware of both general issues related to CEDAW and of specific rights of women living with HIV and sex workers, including the prevention of violence, stigma and discrimination, and attention to emerging social, medical and legal issues. This represents a significant step toward positive policy and legal reform for these populations.

The establishment of a Government Innovation Unit in the Prime Minister’s Office has facilitated the identification and dissemination of e-innovation in public service delivery, introduced by civil servants. A total of 56 service providers from 14 Ministries, in 16 districts, have adopted the second-generation citizen charters with UN System support. They have also initiated the development of performance indicators for Public Service Providers (PSP) in order to improve quality and efficiency in service delivery. In addition, to improve demand-side pressures and public accountability in service delivery, 105 committees in 65 upazilas (sub-districts) have been supported to become functional, with 2,210 meetings

held to address communities’ demands and needs. In terms of gender-sensitive budgeting, a Government gender budget report covering 15 Ministries has been prepared with UN System-supported technical and financial assistance, which has highlighted gender-ensitive budgeting in the Medium Term Budgetary Framework and formulation of a sex-disaggregated recurrent, capital, gender and poverty budget database.

South-South cooperation toward achievement of this Outcome has been very rich.Members of the Election Commission gained understanding of the role of electoraladministration in the regional context through observation of elections in Myanmar. Police and other officials visited South Africa and Thailand to learn about modern human resource development, criminal investigation procedures, and management of criminal intelligence. Parliamentarians and officials from the Parliamentary Secretariat studied innovativeparliamentary strategic planning and gender-sensitive budgeting in these two countries. To assist effective implementation of the second-generation of citizen charters, India’s lessons and experiencesinimplementing and monitoring citizen charters was shared andsubsequently applied to piloting districts. India provided a model for learning about tools and implementation strategies for pilot citizen charters, and Indonesia shared knowledge on effective data capture, processing and analysis. In turn, Bangladesh supported 13 countries from Asia and the Pacific, Africa and Latin America by hosting a high-level conference on climate change for members of parliament from Least Developed Countries and most vulnerable nations, out of which a network of concerned parliamentarians was formed (see also Pillar 5).

Page 20: 2012 progress report final

20

Outcome 1.2: Justice and human rights institutions are strengthened to better serve and protect the rights of all citizens,including women and vulnerable groups.

Supported by the UN System, the Government took initiatives in 2012 to improve policy and legislative frameworks that strengthen justice institutions and human rights protection for women, children and people with disabilities in particular (see also Pillar 7). Publicconfidence in the police service has increased, with 50 percent of the public surveyed by Democracy International responding that they had such confidence, up from 45 percent in

a 2010 baseline survey. Moreover, greater perceptions of capacity and professionalism are resulting in improved levels of confidence in law and order institutions as a whole. According to a 2013 survey by the Daily Star and CSR, 50 percent of the public believes law and order has improved, although obstacles remain to efficient access to justice, particularly for the poor and vulnerable.

Page 21: 2012 progress report final

21

In a pilot initiative supported by UN system across 5 districts working to activate the Upazilla and Union level referral committees and District Legal Aid Committees as well as increasing national awareness of the State legal aid services provision, the average number of monthly legal aid service recipients increased by 154% over 18 months where approximately 50% of recipients were women [in 2010 average 79 service recipients per month; in 2012 average 201 service recipients per month]. Further to this, improved service provision was reflected in the decrease of number of days required to process legal aid applications from 30 days in 2010 to on an average 2 days at the pilot districts. During the period, figures for application of legal aid fund nationally also showed a 40% increase. A national case management committee has been established under the auspices of the Supreme Court to specifically review case management and put in place a more streamlined system to address the huge backlog of cases in lower courts. Amendments to the Powers of Attorney Act and Civil Procedure Code, support by the UN System, also should speed up case times, with clear deadlines for conclusion of cases in place.

UN Agencies are assisting local-level justice structures to rapidly start to reach out to communities. In an independent evaluation survey of the performance of village courts in 2012, 69 percent of petitioners and respondents were satisfied or very satisfied with the manner in which their case was handled. Of these, 64 percent believed that social problems and petty crimes were occurring less in their locality due to the presence of village courts.

As a result of increased capacity of village court officials, along with rising demand-side pressures from the public, 10,553 cases were resolved in line with the Village Court Act in 2012, a 30 percent increase over 2011. Tailored workshops and public awareness campaigns were supported by UN Agencies to promote awareness of village courts, especially among women. As a result, 32 percent of cases in 2012 (5,161 out of 16,588) included women petitioners, a sharp rise from 2 percent the year before (see also Pillar 7).

A total of 46 percent of legal aid recipients were women, further ensuring equality in access to justice.

Page 22: 2012 progress report final

22

The NHRC played an important role in directing changes to key national legislation in 2012, by using its increased capacities to provide expert opinions and evidence-based reports that have assisted in aligning legislation on children, persons with disabilities, and migrant workers with international standards.

A 2012 Results Oriented Monitoring (ROM) report by the European Commission concluded that, following training, the knowledge of Union Parishad chairpersons of village court procedures is now excellent and that these localized courts are providing justice tocommunities in a timely and affordable manner. On a policymaking level, national ownership increased with revisions to the Village Court Act 2006 and further policy buy-in, with Government orders providing greater clarity on jurisdiction of the village courts. Dispute resolution capacity in refugee camps also has strengthened, with 70 percent of 1,112 cases during the year resolved through mediation. Government officials were supported to brief participants at a regional conference in India on alternative dispute resolutions, including village courts, and related reforms for increased access to justice.

Turning to broader issues of human rights, Bangladesh’s most recent Universal Periodic Review (UPR) submission, supported by the UN System, has helped develop particular insight within the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) on the implementation and national obligations under international treaties. The UPR consultation process included coordination among UN Agencies to ensure the inclusion of issues of vulnerable groups, including indigenous peoples. In its UPR report, the NHRC concluded that important steps had been taken to implement 25 of the 34 accepted recommendations from the 2009 UPR process for the country. However, there remain areas that require continued engagement, particularly the persistent of alleged rights abuses involving paramilitary units of the police9.

Overall, the NHRC capacity to report on and defend human rights has been strengthened through UN System support, including through a study visit to learn from successful commission models in Malaysia and Philippines.

The NHRC played an important role in directing changes to key national legislation in 2012, by using its increased capacities to provide expert opinions and evidence-based reports that have assisted in aligning legislation on children, persons with disabilities, and migrant workers with international standards. The Government also submitted its Fifth Periodic Report on implementation of the Convention of the Rights of the Child (CRC) in 2012 and has set targets for the elimination of the worst forms of child labour by 2016. In collaboration with the Association for Land Reform and Development, the NHRC strengthenedSouth-South cooperation with countries such as India and Philippines through its organization of a regional workshop that resulted in adoption of a declaration to assure effectiveimplementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and to encourage governments to take action to protect public and private property......................................................................................................................................

9 Odikar submission to the UPR for Bangladesh, 2012

Page 23: 2012 progress report final

23

Supported by the UN System, the NHRC launched a campaign on domestic violence against women along with a series of policy dialogues on access to services by people living with HIV and by sexual minorities. Victim support centres are increasingly becoming a model for the country as provisions are included in the mid-term budget providing a sustainable support service for victims of VAW (see also Pillar 7). These centres provided support to 411 women and children in 2012. The UN System provided training and support to staffmembers of the centres and Government officials, including judges and law enforcement personnel, on CEDAW, the Domestic Violence Act 2010, and the Sexual Harassment Act, to further understanding of these key human rights provisions. Drafting of an action plan for implementation of the national Women’s Development Policy 2011 is under way.

Meanwhile, the police service, with support from UN Agencies, has continued to promote gender equality within its ranks as well. A gender and anti-discrimination policy for the Bangladesh Police has been drafted, setting out clearly the rights of women police. The ratio of women on the force has increased significantly. During 2012 alone, 1,524 women were recruited, representing nearly 12 percent of recruits and totalling 525 more than in 2011. Recruitment is being supported with workplace reform to ensure a woman-friendlyenvironment on the job. Six new model sub-districts for police have specific accommodation wings for women to encourage greater diversity on the force, and a children’s nursery facility has been opened in Dhaka to provide daycare facilities for children of police. In the field of human trafficking (see also Pillar 3), 149 police officers received training resulting from cooperation among UN Agencies. A total of 148 investigations were begun. In 2012, 320 victims, including 184 women and children, were recovered out of 405 reported victims.

UN System advocacy has resulted in more than 10,500 news stories related to children and child rights being published in national newspaper, according to media monitoring in 2012. In addition, 350 child rights-related programmes aired on national television and radio, reaching an estimated audience of 120 million. As part of local capacity development, technical support provided to the National Institute for Local Government has resulted in the development of a comprehensive training package for local administrators at district, upazila and union levels to strengthen coordination, participatory planning and monitoring and reporting on issues of children and women.

Page 24: 2012 progress report final

24

Major progress was achieved in the context of the UN System’s work on labour market reform and policies. Foremost, 2012 saw the adoption of the National Technical and Vocational Qualifications Framework (NTVQF), secured through UN leadership and brokerage. This provides a national frame for accrediting various qualifications and for moving the training and skills agenda forward to secure higher-value-added work,

increased productivity and better working conditions. The UN System also has been actively engaged in delivery of apprenticeship training; trainee hiring rates have been strong, at 65 percent in the leather sector, for example; 80 percent of the youth programme; and 100 percent in shipbuilding. These efforts have played a catalytic role in spurring the growth in labour market participation and employment levels.

PILLAR TWO

PRO-POORGROWTHWITH EQUITY

Outcome 2.1: Economic growth is achieved in an inclusive manner, extending opportunities to the rural and urban poor and protecting the vulnerable from shocks.

Page 25: 2012 progress report final

25

A total of 30,000 extreme poor women and their households were assisted to achieve impressive growth in incomes, assets and food security, with income, for example, sharply rising by more than 200 percent (see also Pillar 7)10.

The UN System has specifically addressed the economic empowerment of women migrant workers, protecting rights in overseas employment and strengthening skills training programmes (see also Pillar 7). To address the concerns of target groups, this has included preparation of standard worker contracts and a Memorandum of Understanding with the Bureau of Manpower, Employment and Training; inclusion of an article related to protection of migrant rights in the Overseas Employment and Migrant Workers Rights Bills; development of training manuals for the caregiving trade, for overseas workers; and establishment and consolidation of a network of women migrant workers to build capacity to seek relevant policy change. Focus also has been given to supporting measures for social protection of returnee migrant workers and their families.

The year also saw considerable developments with UN System support with regard to social protection policy, drawing on the Government’s commitment in 2011 to develop a National Social Protection Strategy (NSPS) (see also Pillar 3). UN Agencies’ technical, advocacy and capacity development support thus has enabled development a major policy intervention to spur wholesale reform of the social protection system in Bangladesh and of individual Ministry welfare programmes, based on an innovative life cycle approach. This is being taken forward by an inter-ministerial sub-committee coordinated by the General Economics Division (GED), Planning Commission which reports to the larger Central Monitoring Committee on Social Safety Net Programmes chaired by the Cabinet Secretary. Specific UN-sponsored initiativesincluded: (1) support to several high-level policy events and a weeklong residential training course on social protection policy for mid-level policymakers and technical staff; (2) carrying out of a joint mission to support the Planning Commission to deliver the NSPS, including a draft Action Plan, followed by longer-term substantive interventions; and (3) sponsorship of a substantive research programme by the International Food Policy Research Institute.

In terms of social protection delivery, the UN System maintained a strong field presence, supporting food security for the ultra-poor, among others (see also Pillar 4). At the same time, the UN System has maintained capacity development activities with the Government’s Vulnerable Group Development Programme. A total of 30,000 extreme poor women and their households were assisted to achieve impressive growth in incomes, assets and food security, with income, for example, sharply rising by more than 200 percent (see also Pillar 7)10. Most of the households covered are considered to be on the path to a sustainable exit from poverty. A stronger focus also is being given to prevention of undernutrition,particularly among vulnerable pregnant and lactating women and under-5 children (see also Pillars 3 and 4).

.....................................................................................................................................10 World Food Programme project data..

Page 26: 2012 progress report final

26

Some success also has been recorded within social protection and national budgeting processes as part of the UN System’s advocacy work on human rights and equity, specifically relating to sexual minorities and marginalized groups (see also Pillar 1). Notably, budget allocations have been ensured for the transgender population and work to include people living with HIV in national social protection schemes is well-advanced. The UN System also has been working with the Government on revising the National Strategic Plan and Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) Framework Plan on HIV/AIDS.

National policy support activities have focused on building Government capacity to shape the use of resources and channel growth into pro-poor areas and achieve key development targets. This has been enabled through both an MDG M&E project, which ended in 2012, and a new aid effectiveness project. These are situated within the Planning Commission and

the Ministry of Finance respectively. The former has not only assisted the Government in planning and allocating resources to meet MDG objectives, but also has been instrumental in providing a platform for the dialogue on post-2015 development goals. Additionally, the-post 2015 process has been taken on by General Economics Division (GED), which with UN support will be organizing a series of further activities and events. The aid effectiveness project, meanwhile, has begun the process of building capacity in development assistance management, an intervention that will prove crucial in ensuring resource planning decisions remain pro-poor. A specific area of activity has been to support the strengthening of the Local Consultative Group (LCG) machinery; as a result, the number of related Joint Cooperation Strategy milestones that have been completed has more than doubled, from 5 to 11.

Page 27: 2012 progress report final

27

The cornerstone of the UN System’s approach to vulnerable groups engaged in farming remains the creation of Farmer Field Schools, an interactive and community-based method that involves the creation of a local organization and strengthening of collective capacity to build social and economic capital.

The cornerstone of the UN System’s approach to vulnerable groups engaged in farming remains the creation of Farmer Field Schools, an interactive and community-based method that involves the creation of a local organization and strengthening of collective capacity to build social and economic capital. With a stronger voice, farmers can better engage in bargaining, leading to inclusion and protection in markets. Greater opportunities for farmers have been provided by UN Agencies through input delivery and technology transfer, accompanied by access to new productive assets.

Area-based inputs, currently carried out under the major Chittagong Hill Tracts Development Facility (CHTDF), supported 3,257 communities within Para Development Committees (PDCs) for livelihoods work, and covered around 63,000 poor and vulnerable households (350,000 people)11. The Facility has overhauled its local economic development work, which is now making a major difference in economic and labour market activity within thisdisadvantaged sub-region of the country; micro-studies and qualitative evidence continue to show greater levels of employment and declining rates of poverty. This may be attributable in large part to the positive changes brought about through the formation of more than 1,650 effective women’s groups through income-generating activities, targeted capacity development, advocacy and leadership initiatives; engagement of women in project planning, formulation and management; greater women’s access to Government and non-Government information and services related to the project; increased leadership in financial control and management; enhanced skills development; and opportunities for regular savings (see also Pillar 7)

In addition, area-based activities, supported by the UN System have focused on a series of activities in the shrimp-processing sector around quality and inspection. These have included: (1) training of 217 staff from 50 factories to implement social compliancerequirements; (2) technical assistance to training of trainers programmes for fisheries inspection quality control, as well as provision of testing kits to the Ministry of Fisheries for quality control of fisheries products ; (3) follow-on training of industry personnel in the Chittagong and Khulna regions; and (4) the successful lifting of the mandatory 20 percent

testing requirement of seafood industry products by the European Union12. The latterrepresents a particularly major impact and is expected to deliver real improvements in competitiveness, and in turn, new employment opportunities in this crucial sector.

A number of other coordinated programmatic activities are in the planning stages, including a Joint Programme on pro-poor trade and Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), additionalarea-based development, and support to master plans for agricultural development in southern Bangladesh and the Chittagong Hill Tracts (see also Pillar 4).

.....................................................................................................................................11 United Nations Development Programme project data.12United Nations Industrial Development Programme project reports.

Page 28: 2012 progress report final

28

Highlights under Outcome 3.1 include UN System support in planning, financing,implementation and M&E, including partnerships and coordination. In health, UN Agencies are working with the Government to implement operational plans improving services and strengthening systems, under the Health, Population and Nutrition Sector Development Plan (HPNSDP) and the National Health Policy 2011. Health policy dialogues and strategic

forums are providing key opportunities for inclusive development, promotion of research and organization of workshops on evidence generation and utilization. In particular, UN Agencies have supported women-friendly hospitals, including in the area of addressing VAW, to strengthen their institutional service provision and capacity development (see also Pillar 7).

PILLAR THREE

SOCIAL SERVICESFOR HUMANDEVELOPMENT

Outcome 3.1: Deprived populations in selected areas, particularly women, children and youth, benefit from increased and more equitable utilization of quality health and population, education, water, sanitation and HIV services.

Page 29: 2012 progress report final

29

During the year, 14 of the 20 UNDAF districts implementing local-level capacity development interventions utilized more than 75 percent of funds disbursed against local-level plans. Local-level planning was completed in selected UNDAF districts under joint initiatives with the Government to address maternal and neonatal health issues in particular. These focus on strengthening facility-based maternal, neonatal and child health (MNCH) services by addressing implementation bottlenecks through plans at district and sub-district levels.

Facility-based interventions included support to delivery of integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) and emergency obstetric care (EmOC), along with establishment of special-care newborn units at secondary- and tertiary-level hospitals. Remarkable progress made in the area of midwifery, including the launching of the nation’s first midwifery diploma programme, which is expected to result in long-term improvements in the country’s maternal health situation. The development of midwives in Bangladesh is moving forward rapidly following the Government’s commitment to educate and deploy 3,000 midwives by 2015.

Community-based MNCH interventions were implemented in nine UNDAF districts covering more than 17 million people, addressing demand-side bottlenecks. A pay-for-performance initiative with health personnel has led to increased coverage of institutional deliveries at district- and upazila-level health facilities and, in turn, to quality improvements. A positive developmentis the institutionalization of a maternal and perinatal death review, which allows the generation and analysis of data on mothers, neonates and stillborn infants, as well as translation of this analysis into more targeted and strategic programmatic action (see also Pillar 7).

To reach the unreached children aged 0-5 years with immunization, UN System support contributed to development and implementation of micro-plans in all 35 upazilas of five UNDAF districts. Field workers and supervisors were trained on the introduction of new vaccines, thereby facilitating the smooth introduction of measles-rubella and measles second-dose vaccines. Uninterrupted supplies and a functional cold chain were maintained at all levels in the five districts.

In education, strong UN System advocacy has resulted in the Government’s announcement that all registered non-Government primary schools will be turned into Government primary schools, marking a significant positive change that is expected to have great impact in the coming years. This change, which will benefit about 3 million children in 20,000 schools per year, will eliminate the discrepancy in Government support provided to these

two types of schools and should improve the delivery of quality primary education. A further system-level improvement is the introduction of a teacher training programme leading to a Diploma in Education, which is being piloted with technical support from UN Agencies. Meanwhile, the Government has included the school feeding programme in its Annual Development Programme to improve the micronutrient status, learning ability and school attendance among poor primary school-age children.

Remarkable progress made in the area of midwifery, including the launching of the nation’s first midwifery diploma programme, which is expected to result in long-term improvements in the country’s maternal health situation.

Page 30: 2012 progress report final

30

Also with UN technical support, the Ministry of Primary and Mass Education (MoPME) has developed a pre-primary education expansion plan. The plan defines minimum standards and proposes gradual improvement of quality and access to pre-primary education through the coordinated action of Government and non-Government actors. The support from UN Agencies is unlocking the effective utilization of US$319 million allocated to pre-primary education. MoPME also has initiated a process of developing curriculum materials for the

.....................................................................................................................................13 International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh (ICDDR,B) Health Impact Study, preliminary data,2012. estimates, 2012.

provisionof education in six ethnic-minority languages, with UN Agencies bringing their technical expertise and experience to bear. In collaboration with other development partners, the UN System also provided technical support to MoPME to pilot a practical model to address the persistent issue of low learning achievement. Lastly, with the support of UN System, MoPME has developed a strategy for raising awareness on other key education issues such as education of children with disabilities and creation of child-friendly learning environments.

Technical assistance of the UN Agencies has been instrumental in helping MoPME to successfully launch and scale up the school feeding programme, which is benefiting 2.5 million children in poor areas with the distribution of micronutrient-fortified biscuits. De-worming treatments also have been undertaken for these children, including 70,000 ethnic-minority children from the Chittagong Hill Tracts. In addition, the Ministry has setup a coordination unit for activities in 34 upazilas under 16 districts.

The UN System supported interventions to increase access to improved water and sanitation facilities and key hygiene promotion messages for more than 7.8 million people in 23 districts in 2012, including in six UNDAF districts. Through these interventions, significant progress was achieved at household, school, community and Government levels to improve access to, use of and demand for safe water and improved food hygiene and sanitation, which in turn can positively affect health by addressing issues of stunting or delayed mental development of children. Wide-ranging interventions supported by UN Agencies have contributed to a demonstrated reduction in diarrhoeal rates13, particularly in rural areas, through improved access to safe water, a reduction in open defecation, and an improvement in the very low rates of hygienic behaviours. This achievement has been possible through technical and strategic support by UN Agencies at national, sub-national and community levels.

At policy level, UN System support has resulted in the formulation and adoption of the National Hygiene Strategy and WASH (Water, Sanitation and Hygiene) in Schools standards, along with dissemination of a sector development plan (2011-2025) and a strategy for hard-to-reach areas and people. UN advocacy efforts and technical assistance also have resulted in the integration of WASH priorities into the National Urban Policy and the Water Act. Government institutions were supported to improve the accuracy of water quality testing related to arsenic contamination through the procurement of arsenic testing kits, training and real-time data collection and analysis, critical given that an estimated 22 million people

Page 31: 2012 progress report final

31

UN-supported awareness raising campaigns to prevent HIV reached about 126,000 returnee migrants and people in migration-prone areas.

consume water containing excessive levels of arsenic. Local Government bodies also received innovative technical, managerial and financial assistance to design, plan andmaintain WASH facilities. Communities, meanwhile, were supported to demand improved WASH facilities and services and to mitigate the impact of natural disasters.

Steady gains also are being made in the fight against HIV and AIDS and other communicable diseases. Eleven Agencies collaborated with the Government to finalize a four-year UN Joint Support Programme on HIV/AIDS that aligns collective UN key results with the National HIV and AIDS Strategic Plan and its M&E framework. UN-supported awareness raising campaigns to prevent HIV reached about 126,000 returnee migrants and people in migration-prone areas.

Meanwhile, capacities of Bangladesh’s health service providers are being developed on treatment, support, combating stigma and discrimination, and human rights of people living with HIV, through collaboration between the UN System and the National AIDS/STD Programme. Key results in 2012 included the revision of national anti-retroviral therapy (ART) guidelines and Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission (PMTCT) guidelines to align with updated international standards; mainstreaming of PMTCT services into the curricula of three medical universities; mainstreaming of HIV education into pre-departure briefings to outgoing migrant workers; and conducting of a situation analysis in six prisons on needs for HIV services. UN System support has resulted in sensitization and orientation of policymakers as well as formation of a steering committee on linkages between HIV and sexual and reproductive health, which is providing technical guidance to mainstream this linkage of issues. Capacities of planners and implementers of national NGOs and networking organizations likewise are being developed to implement and monitor integrated HIV- and sexual and reproductive health-related services.

Extension of the Global Fund grant for HIV has assured that interventions among key affected populations will be continued, including technical support to the Government for inclusion and expansion of opioid substitution therapy, drafting of the National Strategic Plan of Action on Migration and Health (HIV and tuberculosis), and drafting of the National HIV Risk Reduction Strategy for most-at-risk adolescents. The Government monitoring, evaluation and strategic information system for HIV and AIDS also is being revitalized with UN System support, and relevant evaluations, integrated surveillance and practical application of tools are under way to strengthen evidence-based action.

Other key interventions under Pillar 3 in 2012 included working with city corporations and other major stakeholders to ensure provision of a package of basic services in selected urban communities (see also Pillar 6).

Page 32: 2012 progress report final

32

Although several social protection schemes are in place, a need has existed for acomprehensive child-sensitive and equitable National Social Protection Strategy (see also Pillar 2). UN System support to develop a profile on existing social protection measures in Bangladesh, including safety nets, and its facilitation of overseas training for officials is contributing to development of this strategy. Meanwhile, adoption of the National Labour Policy 2012 – which emphasizes social protection for workers, most of whom are outside any social security scheme - likewise is a positive development.

On goingUN-supported initiatives aim to address gaps not only at policy level, but also at

institutional and operational levels. In partnership with key stakeholders, UN support under Pillar 3 is particularly focusing on designing a comprehensive social protection model that brings together social services and protective systems, with particular attention to the social norms that restrain the realization of child rights. The imminent enactment of the new Children Act will provide required policy underpinnings for more decisive action in this area (see also Pillar 2); the law makes provisions for access to revenue for scaling up social protection services. To support operationalization of the Act, UN Agencies are collaborating with nine relevant Government Ministries and other partners to develop a budgeting framework that is child-sensitive.

Outcome 3.2: Children, women and youth demand and benefit from effective social protection policies and improved services aimed at eliminating abuse, neglect, exploitation and trafficking.

Page 33: 2012 progress report final

33

The amended Birth and Death Registration Act approved by the Cabinet, which includes the establishment of a Register General Office, also will strengthen the policy framework for child-sensitive budget allocations. The UN System is supporting increased efficiency in birth registration, with more than 55 million of 150 million manually registered birth records now computerized. A draft alternative care policy was developed and submitted to the Ministry of Social welfare with the support of UN Agencies. The policy introduces alternative care options for children without parental care and vulnerable children, and facilitates the reduction of unnecessary institutionalization. In all, child rights monitoring is ongoing in all districts, with more than 670 Government officials trained in use of the framework developed to monitor compliance with the CRC.

In 2012, the continuum-of-care approach was operationalized for child protection,encompassing prevention, identification of children at risk or victims of abuse or exploitation, assessment, referral and services provision. Based on equity-focused situation analysis, it was replicated in selected areas at sub-national level, providing child-sensitive social protection services among vulnerable communities such as urban slums, tea gardens, and Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) affected by natural disasters. Software for the case management database has been developed, and once rolled out, the database will become a hub allowing tracking of children benefiting from all child protection services, thereby facilitating adequate Government budget allocations to this area. Building knowledge and strengthening capacities for community empowerment and resilience also are greatly contributing to establishment of a solid basis to operationalize social protection policies and strategies.

UN efforts under Pillar 3 to halt human trafficking have led to concrete actions (see also Pillar 1). Shelter and legal assistance services were provided to 55 trafficked men, women and children through partnership with a national non-Government organization (NGO). Training also was provided to a select number of lawyers and public prosecutors on the application of the new Human Trafficking Deterrence and Suppression Act 2012. In addition, aweb-based Crime Database Management System was established at police headquarters and operationalized in all 64 district police stations.

Other UN-supported activities related to the prevention of violence, abuse and exploitation include partnerships with national institutions that led to provision of child protection services to vulnerable and/or affected populations. A total of 3,000 adolescents, including 2,004 girls, were provided with support in the form of conditional stipends for income generation, civic action or personal development (see also Pillar 7).

Lastly, 31,487 adolescent girls and boys began civic engagement in their communities through adolescent clubs on issues of child marriage and child labour to stimulate debate

31,487 adolescent girls and boys began civic engagement in their communities through adolescent clubs on issues of child marriage and child labour to stimulate debate on these harmful social norms and practices.

on these harmful social norms and practices. Based on the results of research on adolescent suicide ideation, a theory of change was formulated on the empowerment of adolescents to prevent child marriage, a first step toward communities publicly declaring themselves free of such practices through adoption of community-based social compacts (see also Outcome 3.3). A related monitoring framework is under development.

Page 34: 2012 progress report final

34

A vital ingredient in achieving Pillar 3 results involves communication for social change and development. The UN System has clearly defined communication for development (C4D) as a social process based on dialogue that seeks change at different levels, including building trust, sharing knowledge and skills, and building policy for meaningful change, using an array of channels, tools and methods. Initiatives supported by UN Agencies followed a multi-pronged strategy to promote the practice of child- and gender-sensitive behaviours and social norms that included awareness raising, brokering and convening, evidence generation, and national capacity development. This was carried out in collaboration with Government agencies, civil society and community efforts.

In this area, strategy advocacy resulted in a National Social Change Forum being formed to address issues of child marriage, child labour and corporal punishment. This is particularly crucial because, for example, Bangladesh has had an act against child marriage since 1929, yet non-enforcement has encouraged the practices continued prevalence, with almost one-third of women aged 20-24 (32.3 percent) married by age 1514. In all, the Forum is expected to strengthen the partnership among Government, civil society and development partners around these critical child rights issues to create a more protective environment for children. In addition, the media were engaged in a pioneering dialogue on how to collaborate with children as change agents to reach their peers for concerted action on these issues.

Meanwhile, in 2012 awareness and access to information increased for 55.1 million people – more than one-third of the population – on maternal health, childcare and feeding, water, sanitation, hygiene and handwashing, as well as on protective “facts for life” practices. This was achieved through the broadcast of TV and radio spots, as well as docudramas with episodes on maternal and child health, aired on national television to address widespread knowledge gaps. Key messages on food safety and hygiene at household level also were disseminated through print and audiovisual media by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW), while consumer group Information on food handling practices was gathered and outreach materials on safe practices was prepared and distributed.

Outcome 3.3: Deprived community members in selected areas practice key life-saving, care and protective behaviours and raise their demands for quality social services.

.....................................................................................................................................14Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) 2007.

Page 35: 2012 progress report final

35

General awareness on disability also increased as a result of a multiple-media strategy that included radio and TV spots and print materials to generate discourse and promote actions toward social inclusiveness. These efforts likewise reached an estimated one-third of the population and contributed to the advancement of human rights for all in Bangladesh through a group targeting approach.

To increase impact, an intensive safe motherhood campaign was launched to coincide with two key national events celebrated annually, Midwifery Day and Safe Motherhood Day. Implementation of a package of interventions included a roundtable discussion in the media, newspaper supplements and an opinion piece on safe motherhood published in national newspapers with wide circulation. It is estimated that these efforts reached more than 128 million people throughout the intensified campaign months. Outcomes of these interactions with society are being assessed, and analysis of findings will help draw lessons on the impact of interventions that can be scaled up to include other key behaviours being promoted by the UN System.

AUN-supported national assessment to identify barriers to full realization of the rights of children and women to benefit from social sector interventions revealed significant

knowledge gaps for caregivers and immediate family members alike. The analysis ofbottlenecks revealed that access to adequately staffed services and information is particularly constrained by the lack of adequate health education at facility level. In turn, this assessment has provided the required insight to develop strategies to target and remove these barriers to improved practices of protective behaviours.

Lastly, operational standards, tools and resources on C4D were developed and used to support quality training. In addition, guidelines to support community radio listening groups and operational guidelines on Social and Behavioural Change Communication cells to coordinate C4D activities among partners were developed and rolled out to partner NGOs and Government counterparts in seven UNDAF districts. In addition, support was provided for quality training on interpersonal communication and on engaging communities to address bottlenecks in knowledge, attitudes, practices and social norms. As a follow-up, 230 frontline workers, including ward promoters, para workers and union coordinators, gained new skills for effective interpersonal communication, counselling and socialmobilization, with an emphasis on effective handwashing, where rates remain at less than 5 percent.These UN System-supported efforts set a solid basis for national capacity development of social actors at different levels.

Page 36: 2012 progress report final

36

PILLAR FOUR

FOOD SECURITYAND NUTRITION

Outcome 4.1: The urban and rural poor have adequate food security and nutrition throughout the life cycle.

Progress toward achieving the Pillar 4 Outcome has been substantial both in terms of nutrition and food security outputs, especially among vulnerable groups, including under-5 children and poor pregnant and lactating women. The UN System continues to support the Government’s efforts to enhance its comprehensive approach to food and nutrition security and poverty reduction, through a combination of policy support and capacity development at both institutional and individual levels. Strengthening Government mechanisms at

national and local levels and support to instituting of policies thus forms a unifying theme for the work of Pillar 4 members. Within this framework, the UN Agencies are providing technical assistance to the Food Planning and Monitoring Unit (FPMU), Ministry of Food, to strengthen a composite inter-Ministerial governance mechanism for coordinating the formulation and monitoring of food security and Nutrition Plan of Action and the Country Investment Plan across 17 Ministries, departments and agencies.

Page 37: 2012 progress report final

37

To inform this process, a set of 16 research initiatives on key food security and nutrition issues has been initiated with the involvement of CSOs and academia. UN Agencies are also providing technical and financial assistance to the Institute of Public Health and Nutrition (IPHN), under the supervision of MoHFW, to strengthen a mainstream response to different forms of malnutrition and to promote healthy dietary practices. As a result, IPHN is undertaking formulation of the National Nutrition Policy 2013, to which aUN-supported NationalMicronutrient Survey also will contribute.

The UN System also is supporting the printing and dissemination of guidelines, training modules and checklists for supervision and monitoring of the implementation of the National Nutritional Services (NNS). Simultaneously, tools are being developed tounderstand demand-side barriers that prevent visits to district health facilities for treatment of children with Severe Acute Malnutrition. Guidelines for a desirable dietary pattern, a complementary feeding manual based on trial of improved practices, national food composition tables and a study to assess food safety risks have been completed. Community-based maternal and child nutrition activities have been implemented with technical and financial contributions of UN Agencies (see also Pillar 3).

In 2012 partnerships were developed with key NGOs, supported by urban municipalities in Dhaka, to mainstream essential nutrition services into urban public health service provision, with a particular focus on poor communities. Through these new partnerships, support is being provided to local urban bodies, partners and stakeholders in building and strengthening essential systems for information, monitoring, coordination and human resource development in nutrition. Innovative platforms to reach the most vulnerable have been piloted in settings such as garment factories, thereby reaching key groups including young women and mothers.

Establishing and strengthening essential systems for coordination and information on food and nutrition security has been another important area of focus. The UN System issupporting the establishment of a Food Security and Nutrition Information System within the Ministry of Food in coordination with other partners, particularly the Department of Agricultural Marketing, Management Information System-Health, and Food SecurityNutritional Surveillance Project. To enhance coordination, the MDG-F Joint Programme has undertaken a mapping of all food security and nutrition programmes in the country. The UN System also has supported identification of appropriate nutrition indicators for integration into the national Health Management Information System, which will improve planning, monitoring, quality and coverage of evidence-based direct nutrition interventions. UN Agencies also targeted the unethical marketing of breastmilk substitutes through design and piloting of a national Breast Milk Substitutes (BMS) monitoring system.

UN Agencies undertook special efforts to enhance national capacities on food safety, which represents a major food security and nutrition issue in Bangladesh. These includedstrengthening capacity within MoHFW and partner Ministries for food analysis, food standards and consumer food safety awareness; development of policies; establishment of food-borne surveillance systems; and strengthening of food inspection and legislation and development of a Food Safety Act and its enactment as well as food safety management systems

The Bangladesh Food Safety Act 2013 under the coordination of the Ministry of Food and a single authority titled ‘Bangladesh Food Safety Authority’ has been proposed forimplementation. The technical support of the UN agencies to assist in the implementation of this Act has been emphasized.

Page 38: 2012 progress report final

38

A state-of-the-art National Food Safety Laboratory was inaugurated in October 2012 and is expected to address a key gap in the national food control system. Specific support was given to the drafting of a National Food Safety and Quality Policy 2012, expected to fill a key legislative gap, as well as to the Food Safety Emergency Response Plan. Other major achievements have included training and capacity building on healthy and safe street food vending, and provision to vendors of the tools, materials and equipment to institutionalize and implement safe street foods and better meet the food security and nutrition needs of the urban and peri-urban poor.

Product value chains in specific sub-sectors are being supported to showcase the efforts of the private sector in upgrading its food safety regimes. In addition, a three-month food safety awareness and Behaviour Change Communication campaign on simple food safety measures at home was developed and implemented, targeting women and schoolchildren. These comprehensive capacity building efforts have been mainstreamed into the Health Population Nutrition Sector Development Plan (2011-16) and have been highlighted to the Governance Innovation Unit of the Prime Minister’s Office.

Meanwhile, to improve effective coverage of essential nutrition services, the UN System is giving focus to redefining indicators used to monitor nutrition activities, standards used to assess such activities, and reporting systems. A bottleneck analysis approach is being employed. By the end of 2012, 20 upazilas in eight UNDAF districts were implementing a standardized package of essential nutrition services for mothers and children.Through supplementary feeding, a total of 90 unions under six priority districts were being covered for treatment of between 70 and 90 percent of moderately acutely malnourished children and pregnant and lactating women, leading to a recovery rate of more than 60 percent.

Direct technical input from UN Agencies contributed to acceptance of multiple micronutrient powders for prevention and management of anaemia and other deficiencies in young children, thereby increasing the overall availability of fortified foods. The UN System, in collaboration with national and international research institutions, is supporting development of local recipes for children with different degrees of undernutrition. It has supported 13 national oil refineries in producing fortified edible oil with Vitamin A, and assisted the

A state-of-the-art National Food Safety Laboratory was inaugurated in October 2012 and is expected to address a key gap in the national food control system.

Government to draft a national law that will make oil fortification mandatory. UN Agencies also have taken the initiative to produce complementary food supplements, using locally available/preferred ingredients and manufacturers; this could be scaled up to support Government and other stakeholders in efforts to prevent and treat undernutrition, especially among food-insecure vulnerable groups. Support is also being provided to the Bangladesh Breast Feeding Foundation in developing guidelines and recipes forcomplementary feeding in line with international indicators and for use in the community. Integrated agriculture and health based interventions are being implemented through the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock and the National Nutrition Services with technical support from the UN agencies to improve food security and nutrition among mothers and children in selected districts of the South. In a successful pilot initiative, the UN System has introduced cash transfers to enhance the food security of vulnerable women and their families in particular. Regular cash transfers are being offered along with life skills training and networking (see also Pillar 7).

Page 39: 2012 progress report final

39

Non-health sectors, notably fisheries and livestock sectors contribution to improving food and nutrition security and their role needs to be leveraged. These sectors also contribute to employment generation. There is a wide gap between total demand and supply of fisheries and livestock. Large scale production of fish, livestock and poultry has been emphasized in 6th FYP and perspective plan (Vision 2021) of the government with specific targets and strategies. There is a need to include fisheries and livestock issues, programmes and targets in the UNDAF and support the development of those sectors for a sustainable food based approach to improve nutrition.

Emergency assistance during the year contributed to the stabilization of food security and nutritional status among food-insecure households in Chittagong Hill Tracts andflood-affected households in the southwest of the country (see also Pillar 5). More than 20,000 disaster-stricken households were provided with support through a focus onimmediate resumption of farming activities and recovery of agriculture-based livelihoods. Support also has been provided in developing food composition tables for ethnic foods and in documenting the nutrient profile of selected foods grown and consumed in the Chittagong Hill Tracts region.

Resilience capacities were built among extreme-poor food-insecure households in the disaster-prone communities of 120 unions. Participants received support in terms of food

and cash for assets and food and cash for training. As a result, consumption of all food items in these unions has increased, including a sharp rise of 167 percent in consumption ofanimal-protein food. In addition, a total of 30,000 extreme-poor households in flood-prone areas of three districts received asset grants.

UN agencies are particularly involved in policy and advocacy activities to ensure effective frameworks are available to bring about long-term change. In addition to ongoing policy-level consultations noted above, Agencies are organizing workshops, joint visits and other means to promote food security and nutrition in the country based on evidence-based research and knowledge generation. For example, a national workshop on raising the exclusive breastfeeding rate provided the scope to analyze factors affecting Infant and Young Child Feeding (IYCF) practices and the strategy for promoting exclusive breastfeeding in the NNS. A case study on the role of food security and women’s empowerment also has been carried out with UN System support. Support was provided to high-level officials from various Ministries to observe multi-sectorial coordination mechanisms for food safety in the region and to participate in meetings of the Codex Alimentarius Commission on standardsformulation for safe food.

Overall, community-level functionaries of the Government and NGO partners are being trained in nutrition concepts and communication skills. A combination of methods is used, including courtyard sessions, individual counselling, cooking demonstrations and establishment of community gardens and school gardens/fields, all of which have improved the level of knowledge on diet and nutrition. A 25 percent increase in children 0-5 months who are exclusively breastfed and a 27 percent increase in children 6-23 months receiving a minimally acceptable diet was observed in project areas compared to 2011 results. However, there still exists a need for more standardized and harmonized nutrition promotion tools and materials.

In terms of South-South cooperation, two regional workshops were organized to share experiences with partners across South and Southeast Asia. Ministry of Food officials were supported for study tours to selected Asian countries on public food distribution systems and food management issues.

Resilience capacities were built among extreme-poor food-insecure households in the disaster-prone communities of 120 unions.

Page 40: 2012 progress report final

40

PILLAR FIVE

CLIMATE CHANGE,ENVIRONMENT,ANDDISASTER RISKREDUCTIONAND RESPONSE

Outcome 5.1: Populations vulnerable to climate change and natural disaster have become more resilient to adapt to risks.

In terms of improved national planning for disaster risk reduction (DRR) and climate change adaptation (CCA), adoption of the Disaster Management Act 2012 represented the culmination of many years of concerted advocacy and effort by the UN System, development partners and civil society. The Act provides a basis for managing all elements of disasters as well as provides legal standing for a comprehensive and multi-stakeholder approach to disaster management, a crucial point given that more than 15,000 volunteers in urban areas alone stand ready to alert communities, direct people to shelters, and administer life-saving support. This will have the effect of making disaster management amore transparent process that is underpinned by clear lines of responsibility and accountability.

Also through the advocacy impacts of the UN System, CCA and DRR safeguards wereintroduced into the national planning process for the first time in 2012 through adoption of a new set of relevant guidelines for the Annual Development Programme. This offerspromise to guide future development on pathways toward a disaster- and climate-resilient nation. Gender equality and women’s empowerment forms an important element of UN System efforts on DRR, with more than 70 percent of participants in a key programme to enhance resilience being women (see also Pillar 7). Institutional capacity building efforts have particularly strengthened the awareness of Union Disaster Management Committees (DMCs) of their roles and responsibilities and enhanced DMCs’ abilities to manage local risk reduction schemes.

Page 41: 2012 progress report final

41

The adoption of the Disaster Management Act 2012 represented the culmination of many years of concerted advocacy and effort by the UN System, development partners and civil society.

In 2012, professionalizing of disaster management in Bangladesh has significantly enhanced with increasing number of professionals and graduate students have completed their post graduate diplomas/trainings. With technical support from CDMP, a total of 283 much students have completed post-graduate diplomas and Masters from 24 universities. Access to knowledge resources have been improved through establishing 10 e-learning centers and 3 knowledge management decentralized system in universities and training centers. The culture of safety at primary education centers has been strengthened and institutionalized in 2012. Disaster management and climate change as a topic has been incorporated into 23 textbooks with CDMP’s continued effort. With regard to preparedness, 6,540 Cyclone Preparedness Volunteer were recruited and thereby bringing 1.6 million people under cyclone preparedness network. Interactive Voice Response Service, text SMS service for disseminating disaster early warning messages through mobile phones has also been acknowledged by wide variety of stakeholders. Incorporation of Disaster risk information into city planning has been promoted to make cities resilient to disasters in 2012.

Creating knowledge products to inform future reforms and interventions has been an additional area of focus. The Climate Public Expenditure and Institutional Review (CPEIR), for example, was the first study on climate financing undertaken by the General Economic Division of the Planning Commission, with UN System support. The study was guided by aninter-departmental team that involved experts from finance, agriculture, disaster management, water management and local Government and revealed that, of the approximately 7 percent of combined annual budget spent on climate change, the overarching focus has been on adaptation (97 percent). Following the study recommendations, the Government isdeveloping national- and local-level climate fiscal frameworks to help mainstream climate change finance into the budget process. UN System support also saw the realization of two new information and knowledge exchange initiatives for CCA and DRR. The Knowledge Network on Climate Change was established with 80 members, mainly Government officials, from across 40 institutions to further mainstream the integration of CCA and DRR into the development process as well as support evidence-based policy advocacy and decision-making. In addition, the UN’ Solution Exchange virtual platform has built a Community of Practice for stakeholders, further fostering the exchange of best practices.

To strengthen field presence and pre-positioning of emergency supplies, the UN System prepared a DRR Strategy that has made a notable contribution in the integration of disaster

risks in sectoral programme planning. In April 2012, this capacity was evident when 2,000 cyclone-affected families of Monpura Upazila, in Bhola District, saved their lives and valuable belongings by constructing temporary shelters with the 4,000 plastic sheets they were given from prepositioned stock. Meanwhile, strengthening disaster management in education will help to build generations of schoolchildren who can become the frontline of defence in reducing Bangladesh’s vulnerability to disasters, both today and in the future.

Page 42: 2012 progress report final

42

Reducing the physical vulnerability of communities to disaster risks is an essential part of disaster management, and preparedness plays a key role. Given this, improvements in early warning, access to cyclone shelters and overall disaster response in 2012 have significantly e ccthe Flood Forecasting and Warning Centre has increased its lead-time flood forecast for

the Brahmaputra basin from 3 to 5 days, improving the centre’s capacity to give early and accurate warnings and providing greater opportunity for people to protect life and assets.Expansion of the cyclone preparedness network in 2012 gave an additional 1.6 million people in cyclone-prone zones immediate access to early warning, improved mechanisms to reach shelters, and strengthened access to first aid and relief goods and services, as well as increased awareness among union officials, village heads and communities on DRR and CCA15. This is supported by 50,000 volunteers covering the entire coastal belt, including five affected coastal sub-districts that are exposed to new trends in cyclone tracks.

National capacity for emergency response and early recovery was significantly enhanced through stronger partnerships across sectors and actors in 2012. A key achievement in this area is the reinvigorated humanitarian coordination architecture under the auspices of the LCG on Disaster and Emergency Response (DER), as also noted in Section II. In addition, sector-specific humanitarian clusters, led by relevant UN Agencies, are engaging to provide a more strategic, transparent, efficient, effective and coordinated humanitarian response in times of crisis. A post-flooding Joint Needs Assessment carried out in Satkhira in 2012 marked the first cooperative study by the clusters and initiated a new era in joint response.Also in 2012, the UN System has been focused on institutionalizing the regular assessment of climate change-induced vulnerability and health impacts, including building the capacity of health facilities to accommodate major disasters. Emergency preparedness and response plans have been developed for all Civil Surgeon Offices and Upazila Health Complexes. Disaster-related services including for burns and psycho-social health, along with making emergency drugs and equipment available, also has been readied for crisis situation.

With climate change impacts likely to affect agriculture and aquaculture significantly, the UN System is working in vulnerable districts to develop resilient approaches to sustainable food security, poverty reduction and livelihood development, including master plans for integrated agricultural development (see also Pillar 3). A national Aquaculture Development Strategy and Plan was developed with UN support to provide guidance through such methods as promoting the conservation of aquatic biodiversity, enhancing genetic resources, and strengthening measures to harness livelihood opportunities for rural people through employment in aquatic sectors. A sustainable process for knowledge transfer also is being implemented through Farmer Field Schools that allows for farmers to mutually exchange experiences and knowledge and experiment on further improvements in technologies (see also Pillar 4). Meanwhile, the UN System has continued to support the strengthening of diagnostic and surveillance capabilities of national bodies to combat the potential increase of infectious and other transboundary diseases as a result of climate change.

.....................................................................................................................................15 Comprehensive Disaster Management Programme II Mid-Term Review 2012.

Page 43: 2012 progress report final

43

Participatory risk reduction for communities represented a common theme for UN Agencies. For example, participatory community risk assessments were used to identify risks and inform planning around DRR and the construction of new community assets such as embankments/tertiary road facilities, canal systems, and cluster homesteads. Communities were engaged in each stage of planning and implementation, and construction activities provided short-term employment to 82,000 ultra-poor households, around 70 percent of whom were women and often the sole income earner (see also Pillars 3 and 7). Community resilience was further enhanced by protecting or restoring productivity to more than 50,000 hectares of agricultural land to maintain livelihoods, and by providing more than 787,000 people with tertiary road facilities. As a result, the status of rural infrastructure in 117 targeted unions has improved significantly and now addresses an average of 69 percent of total infrastructure requirements, compared to the previous 26 percent16.

Significantly, a UN-supported project on community-based adaptation to climate change through coastal afforestation extended the belt of afforested mangroves by 3,000 ha to provide a “green shield” for an increasing number of vulnerable communities in the high-risk coastal zone. The project also restored productivity to 72 ha of barren coastal land that can now be used for livelihood generation by poor, landless households and utilized community cash-for-work schemes to provide additional income to more than 12,300 people. This project received a prestigious international award in 2012 for its demonstration of abest-practice model that aims to achieve the “triple-win” objectives of povertyreduction, climate change adaptation and mitigation.

.....................................................................................................................................16 Community Asset Score.

A key policy outcome in 2012, supported by the UN System, was the adoption of the National Sustainable Development Strategy 2011-2021 to upscale social equity and environmental integrity as strong policy drivers in the national development planning process. In this context, UN Agencies’ advocacy and partnerships resulted in integration of the poverty-environment-climate change nexus into this process. Annual National Development Programme Guidelines for 2012-2013 now promote climate-resilient public sector

Outcome 5.2: Vulnerable populations benefit from betternatural resource management and access to low-carbonenergy.

investment and offer the opportunity for greater compliance with environment-friendly, pro-poor and climate change-sensitive development. The guidelines will be supported by an appropriate indicator framework produced by the Planning Commission with UN support to guide systematic results monitoring as the country moves towardclimate-resilient development.

Progressive national buy-in and increased commitment for low-emission practices in 2012 is reflected by the Parliament’s passage of the Sustainable and Renewable Energy Development Authority Act 2012. With UN support, this Act has removed, among others, the institutional barriers for promotion and dissemination of renewable energy technologies in the country. Bangladesh’s commitment to low-emission development has been further reflected in a number of high-level policy documents, including the country report submitted in June 2012 to the UN Commission for Sustainable Development (UNCSD).

Page 44: 2012 progress report final

44

Access to renewable energy for rural households in targeted communities has increased from 4.6 to 7 percent in 2012.

In 2012, the UN provided crucial support to the Government in the lead-up to the Rio+20 Conference, with the national Rapid Assessment of the UN Secretary-General’s Sustainable Energy for All (SE4ALL) initiative reflecting Bangladesh’s strong performance in 2012. When a high-level mission from SE4ALL visited the country early in the year, Agencies facilitatedhigh-level policy discussions and consultations with top officials from various Ministries, donor partners, UN Agencies, the private sector and civil society. With technical support from UN Agencies, the REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) Readiness Roadmap was finalized and approved by the Government to set the groundwork or combating carbon emissions through the forestry sector.

In part through these collaborations on REDD+, the UN System’s well-established relationship with the Ministry of Environment and Forests has been further built; as part of buildingGovernment capacity to manage new environmental challenges, UN Agencies undertook a needs assessment of MoEF in 2012 that has resulted in development of an institutional strengthening programme. The UN also has provided support for a team of Bangladesh Forest Department staff to receive training on remote sensing by the National Institute for Space Research in Brazil, and on greenhouse gas inventory for land use, land use change and forestry. To capitalize on further South-South training opportunities, the UN System is looking to join forces with the US Forest Service and USAID and follow examples set by Philippines, Indonesia and Cambodia.

Lastly, a growing green energy marked in Bangladesh is reflected by the fact that solar home systems across the country have continued to multiply at a rate higher than any otherdeveloping nation through collaborative efforts of the UN System, the Government and key development partners. Through this effort, access to renewable energy for rural households in targeted communities has increased from 4.6 to 7 percent in 2012. To support this growth, 1,500 solar technicians were trained, with most finding wage employment in the field.

UN-supported initiatives for mandatory standard labelling for energy-efficient products also have now been introduced nationally, and plans are in place to expand this system to enhance efficiency. UN Agencies also remained engaged in building public-private capacity for sustainable management of industrial waste and provided a range of technical support to the industrial sector, including tanneries, in the practice of sustainable cleaner production. The result of such efforts has been significant, including reduced water consumption in the sector for an overall water savings of 21 percent.

Page 45: 2012 progress report final

45

Living conditions and livelihoods of 3 million urban poor, particularly women, continued to strengthen in 2012 as a result of UN-supported social mobilization and improved access to socioeconomic benefits and enhanced living conditions and infrastructure such as water supply, improved sanitation, elevated footpaths and storm drainage (see also Pillar 7). The Household Income and Expenditure Survey (HIES) 2010 showed that urban poverty

incidence had fallen to 21.3 percent, compared to 28.4 percent in 2005. Moreover, the Labour Force Survey 2010, published in 2012, demonstrated that urban women’sparticipation in the labour market had increased to 34.5 percent from 27.4 percent in 2005 (see also Pillar 2).

Outcome 6.1: At least 3 million urban poor have improved living conditions and livelihoods to realize their basic rights.

PILLAR SIX

PRO-POORURBANDEVELOPMENT

Page 46: 2012 progress report final

46

In a major empowerment initiative, UN Agencies assisted urban poor women and girls in particular to improve their livelihoods and living conditions through support toestablishment of Community Development Committees (CDCs) and town-level Federations to address specific community needs. Many CDCs have reached a sustainable level ofmaturity, with urban poor community leaders being included in municipal decision-making processes.

As a result, more than 8,000 women have gained leadership experience in a community governance entity; 28 women have run for the key office of ward councillor in municipal elections, and eight were elected. A total of 90 percent of elected community leaders are women. More than 160,000 poor and extreme-poor women CDC members activelyparticipated and received daily wage employment in implementing, managing andmonitoring the construction of slum infrastructure. More than 55,000 women, meanwhile, received conditional cash transfers of 5,000 Taka (about US$62) as a block grant to start their own businesses and some 36,000 women received 1,500 Taka per month as income during six-month apprenticeships. Over 44,000 girls from extreme-poor and poor households received educational grants to continue their education, significant in that few poor girls have traditionally been educated. In addition, more than 48,000 women improved urban and peri-urban food production, income and nutrition, while more than 49,500 women received training on savings and credit management.

Access to savings and credit schemes among urban poor households likewise increased, by 18 percent against a 2011 baseline, and reached more than 3,75,000 new households. Access to loan facilities for promoting small-scale enterprises soared by 42 percent among urban poor households and reached more than 67,800 households in 2012. As a result of greater transparency and increased confidence in savings and credit systems, savings increased by 39 percent in 2012, reaching US$5.1 million, and loans by 50 percent, totalling US$3.7 million.

With UN high-level technical assistance, endorsement of the National Skills Development Policy by the Government followed a wide consultative process. This set the ground to increase the access of disadvantaged groups, including the urban poor, to skills as well as to facilitate their inclusion as informal apprentices in the formal system, through recognition of prior learning. Overall, political will to address pro-poor urbanization has gained momentum, resulting in the finalization of an urban sector policy document with substantive inputs from the UN System, as well as formation of a high-level inter-Ministerial steering committee to institutionalize the Bangladesh Urban Forum (BUF). This UN-supported Forum has laid the foundation to bring all key relevant stakeholders together, including the urban poorthemselves, for the first time to discuss, advocate and address emerging urban challenges that directly impede on increased economic opportunities for the urban poor andvulnerable groups.

Similar advocacy and assistance through the UN System has fostered a process of concrete steps by Government authorities to address land tenure security status of low-income settlement dwellers. In 2012, the Government pledged that poor people will not be evicted in three towns, while the High Court delivered verdicts in favour of slum dwellers against the backdrop of a series of forced evictions in the largest slum settlement of Dhaka. A further positive development resulting from UN advocacy is the significant focus on the urban agenda in the Sixth Five Year Plan, which for the first time recognizes that “slums are adevelopment issue which needs to be faced.” Municipal authorities have allocated more resources for service delivery and other poverty reduction activities in poor communities.

While longer-term improvement is visible, results specific to 2012 remain limited as a result of the unavailability of updated data. A clearer picture of Outcome-level progress is likely only in 2014, when the next HIES takes place. In urban poor settlements targeted by the UN System, water-borne diseases also have fallen from 36 to 18 percent, and the proportion of people not washing their hands at appropriate times decreased from 56 to 11 percent. Poor urban households with rain-caused waterlogging fell from 87 to 11 percent as a result of drainage and footpath construction. Similarly, access to improved primary health care services increased for more than 850,000 urban poor through a network of 12 satellite clinics, 205 health clinics and 660 trained health volunteers supplied by partners of the UN System.

Meanwhile, around 2.5 million children in poverty-prone areas are directly benefiting from the distribution of micronutrient-fortified biscuits in 72 upazilas in 20 districts. Of which 88,000 primary school children are assisted in urban slum areas. The urban poor children live somewhat a different life than those in rural areas. Many of the slum children are indeed working children that affect their enrolment and attendance in the schools.

In a major empowerment initiative, UN Agencies assisted urban poor women and girls in particular to improve their livelihoods and living conditions through support to establishment of Community Development Committees (CDCs) and town-level Federations to address specific community needs.

Page 47: 2012 progress report final

47

The school feeding assistance has been contributing to reducing the dropout rate and increasing school attendance; the attendance rate in targeted urban primary schools has increased by 16 percentage points since 2009, and in 2012 reached an average of 73 percent. The school feeding programme contributes to the Government’s goal of achieving universal primary education by 2015 through improving access to basic education for school aged children. Many households in urban areas were forced to take their children out of school to domestic labour in order to supplement the family income. To assist in easing the pressure on ultra-poor urban families, the school feeding programme in Dhaka city has been much useful. Each student receives a 75 gm High Energy Biscuits (HEB) for every day of attendance that provides 338 kilocalories per day and 70% of the daily micronutrient requirement of vitamin A, zinc, folate, iron and others.

Anecdotal feedback from the parents, teachers and students has revealed that students are less frequently absent as a result of illness and are more attentive in class. Evidently, urban school feeding has had an extremely positive impact on the health and well-being ofultra-poor school children, providing them with an opportunity to receive a meaningful education and break away from the cycle of poverty.

On a study tour to Brazil, a high-level Government delegation learned about that country’s successful school feeding model, with a view to further integrate suitable elements and approaches in poor urban communities in Bangladesh. Support also was provided tohigh-level policy officials to participate in the work of the Committee on World FoodSecurity in Rome, thereby contributing to a common understanding and harmonized approach to addressing food and nutrition security.

Page 48: 2012 progress report final

PILLAR SEVEN

GENDER EQUALITYAND WOMEN’SADVANCEMENT

Outcome 7.1: Marginalized and disadvantaged women in selected districts and urban slums increase their participation in wage employment and other income-generating activities.

Gender is mainstreamed in the UNDAF 2012-2016, so that nearly all of the contributions to the Pillar 7 Outcomes are also contributing to other Pillars and are already mentioned there. Critically, UN joint programming and other interventions at the planning stage have not yet directly contributed to the Outcome. UN agencies have joined forces with the Ministry of Women and Children’s Affairs and Ministry of Home to develop a major project on women’s

economic empowerment focused on policy support, skills development, access toinformation, establishment of women’s help desks at police station/thanas and capacity building, including police forces in selected districts. The projects are scheduled for launch by mid-2013.

48

Page 49: 2012 progress report final

Union Information and Service Centres (UISC) and Town Information and Service Centre (TISC) across the country supported 40,421 women to register for jobs in Hong Kong, Singapore, Middle East and other countries – Pillar 1 Effective area-based support in the traditionally disadvantaged Chittagong Hill Tracts to livelihoods opportunities of poor women (Pillar 2) Strengthening of skills training programmes and enhancement of opportunities in overseas employment (Pillar 2) Specifically focusing on the extreme poor to achieve growth in incomes, assets and food security (30,000 women) (Pillar 2) Piloting cash transfers to enhance the food security of vulnerable women and their families (Pillar 4) Supporting short-term employment for extreme poor households to construct key community assets as part of participatory DRR (Pillar 5) Offering business start-up grants and short-term apprenticeships to build livelihoods for poor urban women (Pillar 6)

Key interventions already noted as contributing to economic-related, gender-specific Outcomes include:

49

Page 50: 2012 progress report final

50

Particular attention has been given to situation and needs analyses of women workers in selected informal sectors and development of training modules for women in non-traditional trades, including skills training on solar home systems. In addition, the Bangladesh Skill Development Policy and Plan and National Strategy for promoting Gender Equality in Technical and Vocational Education (TVET) in Bangladesh contributedsignificantly to women’s empowerment in Bangladesh. In other interventions, a UN-supported access to information project already has contributed to an increase in women’s economic activities through ensuring that female operators constitute half of the operators in each of more than 4,500 Union Information and Service Centres. In addition, marginalized groups such as HIV-infected and -affected women members of the Network of People Living with HIV have been empowered with entrepreneurial skills through training and small grants support. Finally, a field survey on economic and social barriers to women and girls’ access to educational facilities, led to development of an advocacy strategy aimed at increasing retention of girls and women in education.

A UN-supported Joint Programme to address VAW works toward reducing women’s social and institutional vulnerabilities, among others, through focusing on the policies and legal frameworks aimed at preventing VAW while protecting and supporting survivors. Some 23,000 participants from 388 unions in six districts received information on how to access security and legal, medical and rehabilitation support services through service providers. For example, women-friendly hospitals have provided legal aid assistance to more than 580 victims of violence, and more than 4,250 female survivors of violence received treatment and counseling through linkages with 12 legal aid agencies. Union Parishad standing committees on family conflict resolution and women’s and children’s welfare meet regularly, with most elected leaders capable of conducting local arbitration according to established guidelines.

In 2012, Bangladesh observed the UN Secretary-General’s UNiTE campaign to end VAW, which was for the first time coordinated among 11 UN Agencies, 11 Ministries and a large number of civil society organizations. This high-level joint advocacy effort had a wide geographical scope and reached diverse population groups, including from remote areas.

Government spearheaded the campaign, with 30 parliamentarians pledging “no” to all types of VAW.Awards were given for 9 well-documented good practices on ending VAW. The campaign received wide media coverage, and was involved not only a multitude of diversified actions and synergistic effects, but also distribution of information, education and communication materials backed by establishment of a Media Forum at divisional level to review the status of VAW and support the role of the media in combating VAW.

As a result, anecdotal evidence suggests that more Hindu women are becoming aware of the importance of marriage registration to minimize discrimination and that more dowry cases are being solved, while more family conflicts are being resolved through local arbitration and counseling (see also Pillar 1). The country also is beginning to witness community dialogues on understanding masculinity and how it relates to gender discrimination and VAW, which is expected to lead to changes that encourage the engagement of men and youth.

The secondary school curricula, teacher training curricula and textbooks have been fully reviewed, revised and upgraded using the gender lens by NCTB with support from UNESCO. The final curricula and 7 textbooks have subsequently been published and distributed among 7,138,688 boy students and 7,504,291 girl students throughout the country in early 2012. This is linked to the National Education Policy 2010, which focuses on gender violence addressed through curricula and textbooks.

Outcome 7.2: Social and institutional vulnerabilities ofwomen, including the marginalized and disadvantaged, are reduced.

Page 51: 2012 progress report final

51

Other key interventions contributing to this Outcome but already mentioned under other UNDAF Pillars include:

The review of the ILO code of practice, legal and policy framework in Bangladesh has been completed. Recommendations from review served as a guiding document for policy; plan formulation and revision of the Labor Act 2006. Sensitization and trainings were also conducted for various stakeholders, including MoLE, trade unions, private sector employer federation (Bangladesh Employer Federation – BEF, etc.). As a result, the Labor Act 2006 is currently being revised (not yet finalized/approved) to highlight the issue of violence at the work place (including VAW); the BEF drafted a gender equality policy (including addressing VAW) and trade union placed VAW prevention as its own agenda. HR policy was reviewed as well.

In terms of South-South cooperation, a study visit to several locations in India was arranged for Government officials and others to enhance the exchange of knowledge andexperiences on brothel- and street-based interventions and programmes for sex workers. In other such cooperation, Bangladesh shared national actions to address empowerment of the girl child, with a special focus on actions against child marriage, with participants from all other South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) countries at a regional meeting in Kathmandu, Nepal, to mark the first International Day of the Girl Child.

Enhancing policy and legislative frameworks that strengthen justice institutions and human rights protection for women, as well as gender-sensitive budgeting (Pillar 1) Building sustainable support services for victims of VAW to address rights violations (Pillar 1) Improving attention to gender issues in civil service recruitment policies (Pillar 1) Strengthening political interventions by parliamentary committees on women and children (Pillar 1) Significantly strengthening the empowerment of poor women in the Chittagong Hill Tracts through support to form and lead sustainable

community-level structures and to manage community assets, as well as introduction of women-friendly social arbitration guidelines for traditional leaders, and support to issuance of customary marriage certificates and enforcement of equal inheritance rights (Pillar 2) Ensuring women in deprived populations benefit from more equitable quality social services (Pillar 3) Supporting women to demand and benefit from effective social protection policies and improved services aimed at eliminating abuse, exploitation and

trafficking (Pillar 3) Focusing on women’s participation in strengthening of DRR resilience (Pillar 5) Significantly strengthening the empowerment of poor urban women through support to form and lead sustainable community-level governance

structures that provide a key forum for interacting with municipalities and managing community assets (Pillar 6)

Page 52: 2012 progress report final

52

Iv. PROGRESS ON UNITED NATIONS REFORMUnder the UNDAF, the UN System has volunteered to work with a joint Action Plan that replaced Country Programme Action Plans (CPAPs) of four Executive Committee Agencies and integrated programmes of specialized and non-resident Agencies. This effort intends to reduce transaction costsfor the Government arising from coordinating with Agencies on four different frameworks. In addition, through the Action Plan the UN System hascommitted to support the Government in simplifying the project approval process, which had been delaying fund disbursement and, ultimately, impacts of project outcomes.

Through the Action Plan, the UN System has strategized in maximizing results impact by

adopting the geographic targeting mechanism. This strategy defined the 20 poorest and most vulnerable districts (out of 64), where Agencies primarily focus.

As noted above, the UN System plays a collective and substantive role in the national forum for development dialogue, the Local Consultative Group (LCG). Out of 18 Working Groups under the LCG, the UN Agencies co-lead seven programmatically significant and strategic Working Groups (Agriculture, Food Security and Rural Development, Governance, Disaster and Emergency Response, Urban, Poverty, Gender and Chittagong Hill Tracts). These groups are the nodal fora for policy discussions among Government and other development actors.

Page 53: 2012 progress report final

53

A further key development in Bangladesh with regard to UN Reform is the implementation of the humanitarian architecture reform (see also Pillar 5), with full endorsement of the Government. A second key reform that credits UN System coherence is development of humanitarian needs assessment tools and a coordinated approach to needs assessment, as also noted above.

In several of the Pillar areas, meanwhile, thematic area meetings are evolving from an opportunity to update on progress among Agencies to a greater emphasis on policy and discussion of major issues that affect the entire scope of the work of the UN System in Bangladesh.

For example, under the leadership of the Resident Coordinator due to the crosscutting nature of governance and human rights, Pillar 1 has encouraged greater contributions and synergies between Agencies. In addition, greater emphasis has been given to monitoring of progress toward Outcomes and targets for the Pillar. Following a series of consultations, a set of clear indicators and annual targets has been developed; in each quarter, these have been monitored by the Pillar secretariat, which has encouraged member Agencies toestablish improved and realistic results and indicator tools. The stakeholder submission for the UPR in 2012 also benefited from members’ inputs, which demonstrated increased coordination. Similar coordinated work was developed in the areas of parliamentary affairs, human rights, and law and justice, driven by the nature of information shared in the Pillar meetings.

Like Pillar 1, the Pillar 2 Working Group is transitioning toward a genuine thematic forum for programme development and policy dialogue. This will be a feature of its 2013 activities, alongside harmonizing M&E reporting with the LCG Poverty Working Group. A series of meetings have been dedicated to the facilitation of joint programming activities, specifically on social protection policymaking, employment and skills training, and pro-poor trade and FDI. The Pillar is active within the UNDAF M&E network and has successfully finalized its reporting framework and all required data. As noted, this will be further developed with the Government’s Development Results Framework (DRF), which is the primary nationalreporting mechanism, through the Poverty LCT.

Given the multisectoral nature of the Outcomes pursued under Pillar 3, on social services for human development, inter-Agency coordination and cooperation still needs to be further strengthened among all Agencies and Ministries contributing to Pillar results. Meanwhile, the UN System is helping to take appropriate food security and nutrition actions to scale in the same population through its Joint Programme specifically targeting families withundernourished children in 11 unions in three upazilas, under Pillar 4. On the basis of the

success demonstrated by the Joint Programme, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) in late 2012 approved funding for another joint initiative on integrated agriculture- and health-based interventions for improved food and nutrition security in selected districts of the south, thereby setting the stage for scaling up effective and sustainable interventions.

Page 54: 2012 progress report final

54

As part of the Renewed Efforts Against Child Hunger and Undernutrition Initiative (REACH), the UN Agencies have jointly committed to work together to support the Government to strengthen nutrition coordination mechanisms at national and district levels and to scale up nutrition actions in the priority district of Satkhira. UN partners both individually and through UN REACH are supporting the SUN initiative in Bangladesh to promote nutrition advocacy and to support the scale up of nutrition interventions focusing on the first 1000 days of life. Likewise, as a result of the increasing recognition of the need for adequateemergency preparedness and coordination across the country, two related humanitarian clusters were formed, the Food Security Cluster and the Nutrition Cluster to strengthen the collective capacity of humanitarian actors whilst providing support to the Government and the Local Consultative Group Working Group on Disaster and Emergency Response (LCG

DER) on response efforts during times of both slow and sudden onset emergencies. The FSC and Nutrition Clusters work closely with the Nutrition Cluster among others, theGovernment, the Local Consultative Group Working Group on Disaster and Emergency Response (LCG DER) and participate in meetings of the Humanitarian Coordination Task Team (HCTT) on all emergency coordination related activities/issues as well as maintain constant liaison and exchange of information with its government counterparts (including the Local Consultative Group on Agriculture, Food Security and Rural Development and the Local Consultative Group on Health, respectively).

In 2012, the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) project housed within the FPMU, MoF and communicated through the FSC, is support from the UN to map and carry out food security and nutrition analysis in the acute phase of food insecurity. The firstanalysis covers the eight districts of the coastal zone of Bangladesh considering on agro ecological, socioeconomic and disaster vulnerabilities relating to food security. The areas facing natural disasters were found to depict the highest levels of acute food insecurity due to a combination of poor food availability, access and / or utilization that were persistent in these districts.

Overall, increased coordination across sectors, particularly under Pillar 5, has been enhanced through the new humanitarian coordination architecture under the LCG for Disaster and Emergency Response. This new architecture represents an important platform for engaging with sector-specific Clusters to coordinate joint needs assessments and deliver relief in times of crisis. Other programmes and projects such as the Integrated Water Management Programme 2012-2013 and the Urban Disaster Risk Reduction project have strengthened coordination between or within Agencies. The Pillar has finalized its M&E framework for use in tracking and reporting results.

Participating Agencies in Pillar 6, which have met regularly, also have used this Pillar as a forum for policy dialogue, coordinated programme management, and new programme development on urban poverty reduction. In 2012, the Pillar Agencies targeted the urban extreme poor in a coordinated approach through their development support to community empowerment, access to education, water and sanitation, school feeding, safe housing and income generation. Pillar members also have conceptualized a joint Integrated Urban Poverty Reduction Programme. The Pillar will emphasize implementation of results-based M&E in 2013, as well as facilitation of the Urban Development LCG, and contributions to the Government’s DRF monitoring and reporting.

Page 55: 2012 progress report final

55

Overall, UNDAF targets and indicators across Pillars remain relevant and consistent. However, some still may need to be revised, for example, to accommodate new base assumptions or external conditions. In the event of a serious deterioration of the national political climate, a mid-term review of all targets for 2013 may be beneficial. In terms of overall M&E reporting, a comprehensive M&E framework for the UNDAF was developed using DevInfo technology. Annual tracking of Outcome-level indicators is not possible because, in most cases, such data are not available, nor are district-level data by age, sex and economic status.

Major lessons learned also have arisen from those areas adopting a joint programming approach, including, for example, with regard to the social protection arena. Continuing challenges in this area include needs for design of effective delivery modalities; more flexibility among participating Agencies to enhance coordination; stronger and moretransparent donor liaising; and more effective management of both expectations and

relationships. However, many further opportunities for joint programming also remain for all Pillars. Meanwhile, a constraint common to all Pillars is found in the lengthy Government project approval procedure, which often delays project implementation. This requires further special attention and support.

Under Pillar 1, it has been recommended that there be a review of the target set for children in the media to reflect an appropriate level of monitoring resources and realistic indicators. Outcome 1.1 will need to include an output to better address progress in HIV-related interventions at public policy and public institution levels to ensure inclusiveness of approaches. Increased efforts to coordinate results reporting in the few cases whereprogress toward targets has not already been reported will be encouraged. An opportunity particularly exists to develop greater coordination, including with external partners ifnecessary, in the generation of baselines and midterm surveys to collect information and data that are not presently exploited.

V. LESSONS LEARNED AND WAY FORWARD

Page 56: 2012 progress report final

56

With regard to Pillar 2, measurement of output indicators has been problematic andincomplete, a result of both project timing and intermittent data sources. Further major changes may be merited following the anticipated full publication of the latest HIES 2010 and poverty maps. It may be necessary to revisit some output-level activities, notably with respect to common pool resources, which may not be jointly delivered with Pillar 4.

Key challenges for realizing the rights of children, particularly vulnerable children, remain and are related to conceptual underpinnings, legal and institutional settings, andequity-based resource allocations. Sustained impact depends on a strong rights-based child protection system, bolstered by an effective legal and policy framework, capacitydevelopment, a minimum package of services, a protective environment, transformation of institutions, and enhanced M&E for results.

Inadequate staffing of health facilities and frequent transfers of Government and staff have made coordination and communication difficult, reducing effectiveness under both Pillars 3 and 4. In addition to human resource constraints, limited decentralized financial management authority, coupled with lengthy approval processes for local-level plans at national level, continue to hinder the efficient application of local-level plans for health services in particular and will need to be addressed. Strengthening of coordination mechanisms also remains urgent to ensure a unified response to needs. A gradual increase in allocation of pool funds for local-level planning will facilitate expansion and sustainability of this effective strategy for addressing the MDGs.

An important lesson learned under Pillar 3 has been to leverage additional support fromdevelopment partners to cover four unreached UNDAF districts with comprehensive MNCH interventions from these partners, given that comprehensive efforts by UN Agencies there are not yet under way. Dialogue has been initiated to this effect. Pillar 3 also plans toparticularly scale up efforts to increase awareness of the serious issue of arsenic contamination affecting the water quality of some 22 million people, including through clear labelling of affected sources and messaging on water safety plans.

With regard to education, continuing challenges that constrain the effectiveness of UN support in Bangladesh include a need for strengthened overall investments in the sector in general and in adult literacy in particular. Large numbers of vacancies exist in the education system, particularly at the decentralized levels, and will need to be addressed. Moreover, the effectiveness of education stipend programmes remains to be established. Coordination mechanisms for education in emergencies require development, and Disaster RiskReduction strategies continue to be inadequately integrated into education programmes.

Page 57: 2012 progress report final

57

Under Pillar 4, it is recommended to monitor and report on effective coverage of key nutrition interventions that are proven to contribute to reduction of undernutrition, with prevalence data (stunting, anaemia status) used for baseline and end-line comparisons since comparable surveys are not conducted annually. Efforts of the FSC and Nutrition Clusters will require stronger coordination to avoid duplication. Efforts are on going in developing a common narrative on nutrition and to further support the strengthening of multi-sectoral platforms and mechanisms within the Government’s institutional arrangements.

The significant attention by the Government to the SE4ALL initiative of the UN Secretary-General affords an opportunity for Pillar 5 Agencies to join together and support preparation and implementation of a national action plan to promote access to energy by the poor. Similarly, an opportunity exists for Pillar Agencies to support the development of a disaster vulnerability index that could assist the UN System to effective measure vulnerability in Bangladesh; in turn, the Pillar M&E framework could be revisited based on the newvulnerability index as well as other emerging assumptions and external conditions. Joint programming under this Pillar will remain a priority, particularly in the areas of humanitarian coordination, implementation of the REDD+ Readiness Roadmap, industrial pollution management, green jobs and sustainable energy, and DRR. Significant efforts will be made to turn the Pillar into an advocacy forum and engage members to address key policypriorities in climate change, environment and disaster management.

An integrated approach toward urban poverty reduction, along with a strong partnership

between relevant Government counterparts and the UN System, has been found effective to achieve the expected Outcome target of 3 million urban poor people experiencing better lives. The Pillar’s effort to translate the well-defined concept of an Integrated Urban Poverty Programme into action presents a significant opportunity to demonstrate real impact from such a partnership.

The Pillar 6 M&E framework requires some adjustment to make Pillar-level results monitoring more efficient and credible. The adjustment will need to be made not only on the basis of changes in assumptions and challenges, but also Agencies’ feedback and UNDAF geographical targeting. Further the consumption-based measure of the official urban poverty rate does not reflect the multidimensional aspects of deprivation that are more appropriate in the urban context. Thus, the Pillar requires a more accurate measurement of poverty to underpin its Outcome-level process. Specifically, revision of two indicators, Outcome 6.1 and Output 6.1.2, is proposed.

Pillar 7 found that the Joint Programme and joint campaign against VAW has made efficient use of available resources, thereby increasing its impact. Concurrently, for efficient programme management, the Pillar noted that joint programmes should preferably, not include more than 3-5 partners. The need for enhanced synergies within the Pillar and with other Pillar interventions was another important lesson learned. Finally, some Pillar 7 indicators need to revised and adjusted in the results framework, based on programme needs.

Page 58: 2012 progress report final

58

Page 59: 2012 progress report final

59

ARH - Adolescent Reproductive Health

ART- Anti-retroviral therapy

BEF - Bangladesh Employers' Federation

BGMEA - Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association

BMET - Bureau of Manpower Employment and Training

BMS- Breast Milk Substitutes

BNFE - Bureau of Non-Formal Education

BRAC - Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee

BTEB - Bangladesh Technical Education Board

CCA – Climate Change Adaptation

CDMP - Comprehensive Disaster management Programme

CEDAW - Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women

CHT - Chittagong Hill Tracts

CHTDF- Chittagong Hill Tracts Development Facility

CHTDB - Chittagong Hill Tracts Development Board

CIP - Country Investment Plan

CMES - Centre for Mass Education in Science

CPAP- Country Programme Action Plan

CRC - Convention on the Rights of the Child

C4D- Communication for Development

DPP - Development Project Proposal

DRR - Disaster Risk Reduction

EFA - Education For All

EMIS –Education Management Information System

EmONC - Emergency Obstetric and New born Care

EPI - Expanded Programme of Immunization

FAO - Food and Agriculture Organization

FDI – Foreign Direct Investment

FFS - Farmer Field Schools

FP – Family Planning

FPMC – Food Planning and Monitoring Committee

FPMU- Food Planning and Monitoring Unit

GASP - Global Agriculture and Food Security Programme

GoB - Government of Bangladesh

HCTT- Humanitarian coordination task team

HDCs - Hill District Councils

HIES - Household Income and Expenditure Survey

HIV/AIDS - Human Immunodeficiency Virus/ Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome

HMIS - Health Management Information System

HPNSDP- Heath, Population and Nutrition Sector Development Plan

IAEA - International Atomic Energy Agency

IAF - International Accreditation forum

IASC – Inter Agency Steering Committee

ICDDR, B - International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh

IMCI- Integrated Management of Childhood Illness

IPC- Integrated Food Security Phase Classification

IPHN - Institute of Public Health and Nutrition

IYCF- Infant and Young Child Feeding

JCS – Joint Cooperation Strategy

LCG - Local Consultative Group

LFS- Labour Force Survey

LTSH – Landside Transport, Storage and Handling

LSD – Local Storage Depot (PFDS)

M&E - Monitoring and Evaluation

MDG - Millennium Development Goal(s)

MICS - Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey

MJT – Ministry of Jute and Textile

MNCH - Maternal, Neonatal and Child Health

MoA - Ministry of Agriculture

MoCA - Ministry of Cultural Affairs

MoCHTA - Ministry of Chittagong Hills Tracts Affairs

MoE - Ministry of Education

Annex 1: Acronyms

Page 60: 2012 progress report final

60

MoEF - Ministry of Environment and Forests

MoEWOE - Ministry of Expatriates Welfare and Overseas Employment

MoF- Ministry of Finance

MoFA- Ministry of Foreign Affairs

MoFDM - Ministry of Food and Disaster Management

MoFL - Ministry of Fisheries & Livestock

MoHPW - Ministry of Housing and Public Works

MoHA – Ministry of Home Affairs

MoHFW - Ministry of Health and Family Welfare

MoI- Ministry of Information

MoJT - Ministry of Textiles and Jute

MoL - Ministry of Land

MoLE - Ministry of Labour and Employment

MoLGRD&C - Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Cooperatives

MoLJPA - Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs

MoPME - Ministry of Primary and Mass Education

MoRA - Ministry of Religious Affairs

MoSW - Ministry of Social Welfare

MoWCA - Ministry of Women and Children Affairs

MoYS - Ministry of Youth and Sports

MP – Member of Parliament

NASP - National AIDS and STD Programme

NCTB- National Curriculum and Textbook Board

NDSC - National Disease Surveillance Centre

NFPCSP - National Food Policy Capacity Strengthening Programme

NFPPOA - National Food Policy Plan of Action

NGO - Non-Governmental Organisation

NHRC- National Human Rights Commission

NILG - National Institute of Local Government

NTVQF- National Technical and Vocational Qualifications Framework

NSAPR-II - The National Strategy for Accelerated Poverty Reduction-2

NSP III - Nutrition Surveillance Project 3

NSPS- National Social Protection Strategy

OHCHR - Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights

PDCS- Para Development Committees

PFDS – Public Food Distribution System

PKSF - Palli Karma-Sahayak Foundation

PLHIVs – People Living with HIV

PMT – Programme Management Team

PMTCT- Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission

PSP- Public Service Providers

RCO – Resident Coordinators Office

REACH- Renewed Efforts Against Child Hunger and Undernutrition Initiative

REDD - Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation

REOPA - Rural Employment Opportunities for Public Assets

RMG- Ready Made Garments

RR – Regular Resources

SAARC- South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation

SDPs – Service Delivery Points

SE4ALL- Sustainable Energy for All

SF – School Feeding

SGBV - Sexual and Gender-Based Violence

SMART - Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant and Time-bound

SME - Small Micro and Medium Enterprise

SWAPs - Sector-Wide Approach

TPP – Technical Project Performa

TVET - Technical and Vocational Education and Training

UN - United Nations

UNCT - UN Country Team

UNCSD- UN Commission for Sustainable Development

UNDAF - United Nations Development Assistance Framework

UPHC - Urban Primary Health Care

UPR- Universal Periodic Review

UPPR - Urban Partnerships for Poverty Reduction Project

UZP – UpazilaParishad

VAW - Violence Against Women

VGD – Vulnerable Group Development

WASH - Water and Sanitation Hygiene

Page 61: 2012 progress report final

61

Annex 2: UNDAF Annual Review Process Calendar

WHAT WHO RESPONSIBLE WHENNOVEMBER 2012

Pillar leads requested to initiate 2012 UNDAF Annual Progress reporting process. (RCO shared Pillar progress report format)

Pillar leads 12 November

Pillar M&E focal points requested to start indicator progress data collection andentry into UNDAF Info Results Framework

Pillar M&E Focal Points 27 November

DECEMBER 2012

Pillars requested to initiate review meetings in the last weeks of January 2013.

Pillar leads 17 December

JANUARY 2013

1st dra of Pillar Annual Reports submi ed to RCO that facilitated feedback from M&E Group

Pillars 15 January

Feedback to the Pillars from M&E group on the1st dra of Pillar Annual Reports

M&E Group/RCO Till the last week of January

UNCT Annual Planning Meeting: Pillar leads presented key achievements and 2013 priorities

UNCT and Pillars 30 January

FEBRUARY 2013

Final dra s of Pillar Annual Reports submi ed to RCO

Pillars 15-25 February

Consolidation of Pillar reports into 1st dra UNDAF Annual Progress Report (UNDAF APR)

RCO (with support from Consultant) 25 Feb – 2 March

MARCH 2013

1st dra of UNDAF Annual Progress Report (UNDAF APR) circulated to Pillar Leads for comments

RCO 3 March

Pillars provided comments on 1st dra of UNDAF APR to RCO

Pillar 10-14 March

Revision of 1st dra of UNDAF APR integrating comments from Pillars

RCO (with support from Consultant) 14-15 March

Page 62: 2012 progress report final

62

2nd draft of UNDAF APR (revised with comments from Pillars) shared with ERD for comments.

RCO 18 March

UN agencies requested for UNDAF financial informa on to be sent to RCO by 31 March (ongoing)

RCO 19 March

2nd draft of UNDAF APR shared with UNCT for comments at the subsequent UNCT mee ng

RCO 20 March

with GoB Implemen ng Partners 2nddraft of UNDAF APR circulated among par cipants of UNDAF Steering

Committee

mee ng

RCO& ERD 30 April

MAY 2013

Final review of proposed and revised UNDAF indicators by the UNDAF M&E group

UNDAF M&E Group 7 May

UNDAF Steering Committee Mee ng held

RCO 14 May

ERD &GoB IP comments on 2nd draft of “UNDAF Annual Progress Report (UNDAF APR)” received

ERD 24 May

JUNE 2013

3rd draft of UNDAF APR circulated among Pillar leads and UNCT for final comments (comments received from Pillar/UNCT members prior to the UNDAF SC mee ng incorporated)

RCO 03 June

UNDAF Steering Commi ee mee ng proceedings finalized ERD and RCO 30 June

UNDAF Annual Progress Report finalized

ERD and RCO 30 June

Final UNDAF Annual Progress Report disseminated ERD and RCO July 2013

APRIL 2013

Shared UNDAF Results Framework progress report (quan ta ve) and UNDAF Info access with ERD

RCO 15 April

2nd draft of “UNDAF APR” (with draft annexes UNDAF Results framework)shared with Pillar leads for further dissemina on

RCO 22 April

WHAT WHO RESPONSIBLE WHENMARCH 2013

Page 63: 2012 progress report final

63

Annex 3: UNDAF Results Framework ReportGenerated on: 6/17/2013 5:05:51 PMGenerated by: siteadmin

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 82 84 86 88 90 90Actual 80

waLdennalP PassedActual No legal

framesPlanned 10.4 12.8 15.2 17.6 20 20Actual 8 10.4

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 2.8Actual 2.09 2.82

Planned 4.1Actual 2.66 4.19

7.419.6dennalPActual 4.7 7.01

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No No

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

6dennalPActual 3

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

5dennalPActual 0 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

0001dennalPActual 639 636

di Monitoring - Standard Report

Pillar 1 - Democra c Governance and Human Rights

Outcome 1.1 - Government ins tu ons at the na onal and sub-na onal levels are able to more effec vely carry out their mandates, including delivery of public services, in a more accountable, transparent, and inclusive manner

1.1 a Public trust in the credibility of elec ons (Percent)

Bangladesh Elec on Commi_Elec on Commission

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNCD

BEC,CSO UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.1 b Progress of approval of Civil Service Act Enactment and revised rules

BGD_Government Gaze e_2013, UNDP_Annual Project Report_2011

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNCDF,UNDP,UNESC

Cabinet Division

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.1 c Percentage of women in civil service in senior management posi ons

BGD_Ministry of Establishment

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNCD

MoPA UNDP Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.1.1 - The Elec on Commission has increased capacity to conduct credible elec ons

1.1.1 a Number of ci zens registered at server sta ons (Number, Female)

Bangladesh Elec on Commi_Elec on Commission

UNDP BEC UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.1.1 a Number of ci zens registered at server sta ons (Number, Male)

Bangladesh Elec on Commi_Elec on Commission

UNDP BEC UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.1.1 a Number of ci zens registered at server sta ons (Number)

Bangladesh Elec on Commi_Elec on Commission

UNDP BEC UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.1.2 - The Bangladesh Parliament has improved capacity to exercise oversight and representa on func ons

1.1.2 a Progress of Standing Commi ees rules of procedure revision to

UNDP_Annual analysis of Parliament Rules of

ILO,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

Parliament,Parliamentary

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.1.3 - Civil society and media are be er able to promote par cipa on of people in democra c processes and public dialouges

1.1.3 a Number of ar cles and news stories in the media covering targeted

UNDP_UNDP es mate_2012 UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BBS,Cabinet Division,CSO,L

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.1.4 - The civil service has greater ins tu onal capacity and be er business processes

1.1.4 a Number of ministries (including related field offices) responsible for

MoPA_Ministry of Public Administra on Report_2010,

UNDP MoPA UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.1.5 - Selected local government mechanisms have improved capacity to deliver public services

1.1.5 a Number of Unions and Upazillas (sub-districts) in selected areas that have

UNDP_Upazila Governance Project Report_2012

UN WOMEN,UNCD

BBS,Cabinet Division,CSO,L

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Page 64: 2012 progress report final

64

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

02dennalPActual 0.5

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 47 49 51 53 55 55Actual 45 50

51dennalPActual 0

PlannedActual 1.6

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No Yes

05dennalPActual 25 96

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

005dennalPActual 224 350

Planned 66.2 68.4 70.6 72.8 75 75Actual 64 70

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 1500 2000 3500 4500 6000 7000Actual 500 498

PlannedActual 5

PlannedActual 35

Planned 500 600 700 800 900 1000Actual 440 40

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

0004dennalPActual 70 36

Output 1.1.6 - Authorities from the government and private sector make be er use of technology to benefit under-served communities

1.1.6 a Number of citizens with access to government e-solution services

Agency project report_Annual project

UNDP PMO UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Outcome 1.2 - Justice and human rights institutions are strengthened to be er serve and protect the rights of all citizens, including women and vulnerable groups

1.2 a Percentage of citizens who are satisfied with law and order service

Democracy International_National Public

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Bangladesh Police,CSO,Jud

UNDP Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2 b Number of recommendations made by 2008 Universal Periodic Review

BRAC IGS_State of Governance Report_2010,

ILO,UN WOMEN,UNAI

CSO,Judicial Academy

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2 c Number of case backlog reduced (Number)

UNDP_Project Inception Report_2009

ILO,UN WOMEN,UNAI

CSO,Judicial Academy

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.2.1 - Members of key justice sector institutions have increased capacity for sectoral planning, coordination and legal aid

1.2.1 a Coordination body for the National Strategy for the Justice Sector

UNDP_Sectoral Reform Coordination Body meeting

UNDP UNDP UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2.1 b Percentage of utilization of legal aid budget per year (Percent)

UNDP_Annual Report_2010, UNDP_Justice Sector Annual

UNDP UNDP UNDP Bangladesh No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.2.2 - The rural poor and refugees benefit from strengthened local justice mechanisms

1.2.2 a Number of village courts providing justice (Number)

MoLGRDC_Activating Village Court Annual Report_2012,

UNDP LGD

1.2.2 b Percentage of cases resolved by refugees to camp management

UNDP, LGRD and EU_Project evaluation_2015,

UNHCR

No

No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Bangladesh No

MoDMR,NGOs UNDP Bangladesh No

UNDP Bangladesh

Output 1.2.3 - Authorities from key law enforcement agencies are more service oriented and more sensitive to gender and human rights, and equity issues

1.2.3 a Number of female victims of crime supported with improved victim

Bangladesh Police_Victim Support Center Report

IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNHCR,UNI

Bangladesh Police,BGB,M

UNDP

Bangladesh Police,BGB,M

UNDP

No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2.3 b Number of law enforcement officials trained on human trafficking

GoB_Police Training Academy Record_2012

IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNHCR,UNI

Bangladesh Police,BGB,M

Number of law enforcement officials trained on human trafficking

GoB_Police Training Academy Record_2012,

No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2.3 b Number of law enforcement officials trained on human trafficking

GoB_Police Training Academy Record_2012

IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNHCR,UNI

UNDP Bangladesh

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 1.2.4 - Members of key oversight institutions and civil society organizations have strengthened capacity to be er promote equity and protect human rights

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2.3 b UNDP Bangladesh No NoIOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNHCR,UNI

Bangladesh Police,BGB,M

No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2.4 Number of human rights investigations referred to

NHRC_National Human Rights Commission Annual

ILO,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

MoWCA,NASP,NHRC,PLHIV

Page 65: 2012 progress report final

65

Output 1.2.5 - Children who come into contact with the law as victims, witnesses and offenders benefit from improved justice and security systems that serve to end impunity for crimes against children

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

seYdennalPActual No No

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 4.84 5.13 5.42 5.71 6 6Actual 4.55 4.80

Planned 31.96 34.72 37.48 40.24 43 43Actual 36 36

Planned 86.84 86.88 86.92 86.96 87 87Actual 86.8 85.8

Planned 59.8 61.1 62.4 63.7 65 65Actual 58.5 59.5

Planned 4.52 4.34 4.16 3.98 3.8 3.8Actual 3.7 3.4

Planned 9.2 9.56 9.91 10.27 10.62 10.62Actual 8.85

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No

Planned 409344 4E+05 4E+05 456576 5E+05 472320Actual 393600 590,000

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No No

Planned 30.08 30.06 30.04 30.02 30 30Actual 30.1

Planned 24.93 25.26 25.59 25.92 26.25 26.25Actual 24.6

Planned 12.45 15.49 18.54 21.58 24.63 24.63Actual 9.4

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No No

1.2.5 a Percentage of perpetrators of crime against children sentenced by courts

UNICEF CSO,LGD,MoHA,MoLJPA,Mo

UNICEF Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

1.2.5 b Three child friendly children acts in the country dra ed (Text)

GoB_Official Gaze e_2016, UN_UNDAF Action Plan 2012-

UNHCR MoDMR,NGOs,NHRC

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Pillar 2 - Pro-Poor Economic Growth with Equity

Outcome 2.1 - Economic Growth is achieved in an inclusive manner, extending opportunities to the rural and urban poor and protecting the vulnerable from shocks

2.1 a Per Capita GDP growth at constant prices (Percent)

BBS_System of National Accounts_2009, BBS_System

FAO,ILO,IOM,UN

MoA,MoCA,MoCHTA,MoEF,

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1 b Labour force participation rate, disaggregated by gender (Percent,

BBS_Labour Force Survey_2008, BBS_Labour

FAO,ILO,IOM,UN

MoA,MoCA,MoCHTA,MoDM

UNDP Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1 b Labour force participation rate, disaggregated by gender (Percent,

BBS_Labour Force Survey_2008, BBS_Labour

FAO,ILO,IOM,UN

MoA,MoCA,MoCHTA,MoDM

UNDP Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1 b Labour force participation rate, disaggregated by gender (Percent)

BBS_Labour Force Survey_2008, BBS_Labour

FAO,ILO,IOM,UN

MoA,MoCA,MoCHTA,MoDM

UNDP Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1 d Percentage of GDP accounted for by public health and education

World Bank_WB World Development

FAO,ILO,IOM,UN

MoCA,MoCHTA,MoDMR,Mo

UNDP Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1 c Percentage of poorest quintile in national consumption (Percent)

BBS_HIES_2010, BBS_HIES_2015

FAO,ILO,IOM,UN

MoCA,MoCHTA,MoDMR,Mo

UNDP Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 2.1.1 - The vulnerable and poor are provided with decent and productive employment opportunities in domestic and overseas markets

2.1.1 a The National Vocational Qualifications Framework (NVQF) is

GoB_Official Gaze e_2011, GoB_Official Gaze e_2016

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

MoA,MoCA,MoCHTA,MoE,M

ILO Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.1 b Number of workers going overseas through official channels (Number)

BMET MIS_Annual Report of BMET_2012, ILO_Overseas Migration Survey_2010,

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,UNESCO

MoA,MoCA,MoE,MoEWOE,MoLE,MoPME

ILO Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 2.1.2 - Poor families are less vulnerable to external shocks through greater access to financial and insurance services, social safety nets with clear graduation strategies

2.1.2 a National Social Protection strategy prepared

GoB_Official Gaze e_2011, GoB_Official Gaze e_2016,

FAO,UNDP,UNICEF,WFP

MoA,MoDMR,MoEF,MoFL,M

UNDP,WFP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.2 b Percentage of households (HHs) benefiting from social safety nets

BBS_HIES_2010, BBS_HIES_2015

FAO,UNDP,UNICEF,WFP

MoA,MoDMR,MoEF,MoFL,M

UNDP,WFP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.2 b Percentage of households (HHs) benefiting from social safety nets

BBS_HIES_2010, BBS_HIES_2015

FAO,UNDP,UNICEF,WFP

MoA,MoDMR,MoEF,MoFL,M

UNDP,WFP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.2 b Percentage of households (HHs) benefiting from social safety nets (Percent, Urban)

BBS_HIES_2010, BBS_HIES_2015

FAO,UNDP,UNICEF,WFP

MoA,MoDMR,MoEF,MoFL,MoLGRD and

UNDP,WFP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 2.1.3 - Vulnerable and disadvantaged populations gain be er access to productive resources

2.1.3 a National policy dra ed that promotes community based

GoB_Official Gaze e_2011, GoB_Official Gaze e_2016,

FAO,UNDP MoA,MoCHTA,MoFL,UPs,UP

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Page 66: 2012 progress report final

66

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 8.4 11.8 15.2 18.6 22 22Actual 5 11

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 2 4 6 8 10 10Actual 0

Planned 1 2 3 4 5 5Actual 0

Planned 3 6 9 12 15 15Actual 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 104 108 112 116 120 120Actual 100

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 33.2 31.73 30.25 28.78 27.31 27.31Actual 34.67

Planned 26.91 25.71 24.52 23.32 22.13 22.13Actual 28.10

Planned 33.84 32.34 30.83 29.33 27.83 27.83Actual 35.34

Planned 32.65 31.2 29.75 28.3 26.85 26.85Actual 34.10

Planned 87 174 261 348 435 435Actual 0 50

Planned 21.8 43.6 65.4 87.2 109 109Actual 0

Planned 91.2 182.4 273.6 364.8 456 456Actual 0

Planned 200 400 600 800 1000 1000Actual 0 50

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual 63.8 63.8

PlannedActual 11.5 11.5

Planned

Output 2.1.4 - Government and non-government stakeholders have the capacity to improve aid effectiveness with a special focus on achieving the MDGs with equity and pro-poor growth

2.1.4 a GoB Joint Cooperation Strategy fully implemented

UN RCO_Report to LCG Plenary_2012, UNDP

UN WOMEN,UNDP,

MoF,MoP,MoSW,MoWCA

UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 2.1.5 - Government, civil society and the private sector are be er able to plan for and augment geographically and sectorally balanced Foreign Direct investment and trade

2.1.5 a Number of Aid for Trade (AFT) initiatives directly facilitated by the

UNDP_Trade Project Reports_2010, UNDP_Trade

UNDP,UNIDO MoC (commerce),

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.5 a Number of Aid for Trade (AFT) initiatives directly facilitated by the

UNDP_Trade Project Reports_2010, UNDP_Trade

UNDP,UNIDO MoC (commerce),

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.5 a Number of Aid for Trade (AFT) initiatives directly facilitated by the

UNDP_Trade Project Reports_2010, UNDP_Trade

UNDP,UNIDO MoC (commerce),

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 2.1.6 - Vulnerable groups engaged in farming, especially small producers in targeted Upazilas benefit from innovative services and community training to increase agricultural incomes and food security

2.1.6 a Increase in the annual incomes of participating households (Number)

FAO_Baseline survey_2012, FAO_Endline survey_2016

FAO MoA,MoFL FAO No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 2.1.7 - Vulnerable groups benefit from area-based interventions that support local economic development and improve livelihoods

2.1.7 a Change in poverty headcounts rates in the targeted areas at district level

WFP_WFP LA Poverty Mapping_2010, WFP_WFP

UNDP MoC (commerce),

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2.1.7 a Change in poverty headcounts rates in the targeted areas at district level

WFP_WFP LA Poverty Mapping_2010, WFP_WFP

UNDP MoC (commerce),

2.1.7 a Change in poverty headcounts rates in the targeted areas at district level

WFP_WFP LA Poverty Mapping_2010, WFP_WFP

UNDP 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoC (commerce),

MoC (commerce),

UNDP No No

2.1.7 b Number of MSMEs in targeted lagging regions assisted to access

UNDP/UNIDO_Area Based Development Project Reports

UNDP

2.1.7 a Change in poverty headcounts rates in the targeted areas at district level

WFP_WFP LA Poverty Mapping_2010, WFP_WFP

UNDP

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoC (commerce),

MoC (commerce),

UNDP No No

2.1.7 b Number of MSMEs in targeted lagging regions assisted to access

UNDP/UNIDO_Area Based Development Project Reports

UNDP

2.1.7 b Number of MSMEs in targeted lagging regions assisted to access

UNDP/UNIDO_Area Based Development Project Reports

UNDP

No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoC (commerce),

UNDP No

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Pillar 3 - Social Services for Human Development

2.1.7 b Number of MSMEs in targeted lagging regions assisted to access

UNDP/UNIDO_Area Based Development Project Reports

UNDP MoC (commerce),

Outcome 3.1 - Deprived populations in selected areas, particularly women, children and youth benefit from increased and more equitable utilization of quality health and population, education, water, sanitation and HIV services

3.1 a Proportion of births a ended by skilled health personnel (Percent,

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 ILO,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNESCO,UN

BMET,MoCHTA,MoDMR,Mo

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1 a Proportion of births a ended by skilled health personnel (Percent,

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 ILO,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNESCO,UN

BMET,MoCHTA,MoDMR,Mo

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1 a Proportion of births a ended by BDHS_BDHS_2011, ILO,UNAIDS,UN BMET,MoCHT UNICEF Yes Yes 2012,2013,201Bangladesh

Page 67: 2012 progress report final

67

Actual 25.2 25.2Planned 35.36 39.02 42.68 46.34 50 50Actual 31.7 31.7

PlannedActual 53.7 53.7

PlannedActual 51.1

PlannedActual 52.9

PlannedActual 51.4

Planned 53.88 55.66 57.44 59.22 61 61Actual 52.1 51.2

PlannedActual 54.0

Planned 73.76 80.32 86.88 93.44 100 100Actual 67.2 79.5

Planned 80.2 82.4 84.6 86.8 89 89Actual 78 80.0

Planned 81.8 83.6 85.4 87.2 89 89Actual 80 81.0

Planned 86 87 88 89 90 90Actual 85 85.0 85.0

Planned 53.4 54.8 56.2 57.6 59 59Actual 52 55.0

Planned 54.2 55.4 56.6 57.8 59 59Actual 53 56.0

Planned 56.8 57.6 58.4 59.2 60 60Actual 56 57.0

Planned 22.6 23.7 24.8 25.9 27 27Actual 21.5 23.4

Planned 28.28 29.46 30.64 31.82 33 33Actual 27.1 29.6

Planned 46.96 47.72 48.48 49.24 50 50Actual 46.2 50.3

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

Planned 530 560 590 620 650 650Actual 500

Planned 38 41 44 47 50 50Actual 35 35

Planned 7 9 11 13 15 15Actual 5 5

Planned 3 6 9 12 15 15Actual 0 1

Planned 885.6 1414 1943 2471.4 3000 3000Actual 357 537

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 22 39 56 73 90 90

skilled health personnel (Percent, 6102,5102,4oM,RMDoM,ANU,OCSENU,PD1102_SHDB_TROPIN3.1 a Proportion of births a ended by

skilled health personnel (Percent)BDHS_BDHS_2011, NIPORT/MEASURE

ILO,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNESCO,UN

BMET,MoCHTA,MoDMR,Mo

3.1 a Proportion of births a ended by skilled health personnel (Percent,

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 ILO,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNESCO,UN

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoCHTA,MoHA,MoHFW

BMET,MoCHTA,MoDMR,Mo

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 b Contraceptive prevalence rate (any modern method) (Percent, Lowest

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 UNAIDS,UNDP,UNODC

3.1 b Contraceptive prevalence rate (any modern method) (Percent, Highest

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 UNAIDS,UNDP,UNODC

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoCHTA,MoHA,MoHFW

MoCHTA,MoHA,MoHFW

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 b Contraceptive prevalence rate (any modern method) (Percent)

BBS/UNICEF_MICS_2014, BDHS_BDHS_2011,

UNAIDS,UNDP,UNODC

3.1 b Contraceptive prevalence rate (any modern method) (Percent, Rural)

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 UNAIDS,UNDP,UNODC

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoCHTA,MoHA,MoHFW

MoCHTA,MoHA,MoHFW

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 c Proportion of boys and girls who enrolled in grade 1 reaching the last

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

UNESCO,UNFPA,UNICEF

3.1 b Contraceptive prevalence rate (any modern method) (Percent, Urban)

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 UNAIDS,UNDP,UNODC

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

LGED,LGRD,MoDMR,MoHF

MoCHTA,MoE,MoHA,MoHF

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 d Proportion of population using an improved drinking water source

WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2012, WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2016

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

3.1 d Proportion of population using an improved drinking water source

WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2010, WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2012,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

LGED,LGRD,MoDMR,MoHF

LGED,LGRD,MoDMR,MoHF

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 e Proportion of population using an improved sanitation facility (Percent,

WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2010, WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2012,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

3.1 d Proportion of population using an improved drinking water source

WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2010, WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2012

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

MoDMR,MoHFW,MoPME

MoDMR,MoHFW,MoPME

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 e Proportion of population using an improved sanitation facility (Percent,

WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2010, WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2012,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

3.1 e Proportion of population using an improved sanitation facility (Percent)

WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2010, WHO/UNICEF_JMP_2012,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

BMET,MoEWOE,MoHFW

MoDMR,MoHFW,MoPME

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes

3.1 f Proportion of women aged 15-49 who gave birth in the 2 years

BDHS_BDHS_2011, NIPORT_BDHS_2011,

IOM,UNFPA,UNICEF,WHO

3.1 f Proportion of women aged 15-49 who gave birth in the 2 years

BDHS_BDHS_2011, NIPORT_BDHS_2011,

IOM,UNFPA,UNICEF,WHO

Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

BMET,MoEWOE,MoHFW

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.1 - Communities, including the most vulnerable groups, benefit from increased availability and accessibility of quality Health MDG- related services in selected areas

3.1 f Proportion of women aged 15-49 who gave birth in the 2 years

BDHS_BDHS_2011, NIPORT_BDHS_2011,

IOM,UNFPA,UNICEF,WHO

BMET,MoEWOE,MoHFW

3.1.1 a Percentage of certified SDPs providing 24/7 midwifery services by

UNFPA,UNHCR,UNICEF,WHO

MoCHTA,MoDMR,MoE,MoH

UNFPA Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.1 b Number of beds in radiotherapy centres (Number)

IAEA_Agency Reports_2011, IAEA_Report_2016

IAEA MoHFW IAEA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.1 a Percentage of district hospitals, MCWCs and UHCs providing

MoHFW_BHFS_2012, MoHFW_MoHFW APR_2012,

MoCHTA,MoDMR,MoE,MoH

UNFPA No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.1 a Percentage of district hospitals, MCWCs and UHCs providing

MoHFW_BHFS_2012, MoHFW_MoHFW APR_2012,

MoCHTA,MoDMR,MoE,MoH

UNFPA No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.1 a Percentage of district hospitals, MCWCs and UHCs providing

MoHFW_Annual Programme Progress Report

MoCHTA,MoDMR,MoE,MoH

UNFPA No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.1 a Number of midwives trained and certified to international standards

Agency project report_Annual project

MoCHTA,MoHFW,MoWCA

UNFPA No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.2 - District and Sub-district authorities have capacity to plan, allocate and utilize resources for MDGs related health services delivery, especially for the poorest and most vulnerable

3.1.2 a Proportion of districts and upazilas Agency project UNDP,UNFPA,U MoCHTA,MoD UNICEF District No Yes 2012,2013,201

Page 68: 2012 progress report final

68

Actual 5 70

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 1 2 3 4 5 5Actual 0 1

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

Planned 93.76 95.32 96.88 98.44 100 100Actual 92.2 92.7

Planned 98.08 98.56 99.04 99.52 100 100Actual 97.6 97.3

Planned 95.84 96.88 97.92 98.96 100 100Actual 94.8 94.9

Planned 42.56 44.42 46.28 48.14 50 50Actual 40.7 36.3

Planned 46 48 50 52 54 54Actual 44.0 39.1

Planned 44.24 46.18 48.12 50.06 52 52Actual 42.3 37.7

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 0 0 0 0 0 0Actual 0

PlannedProgres

seYsActual No Progres

s

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 0 0 0 0 0 0Actual 0

Planned 42.8 48.6 54.4 60.2 66 66Actual 37 54

Planned 29.2 38.4 47.6 56.8 66 66Actual 20 40

Planned 38 45 52 59 66 66Actual 31 48

Planned 19 33 47 61 75 75Actual 5 44.5

that have utilized 75 percent of the report_Annual report_2016, 6102,5102,4WFHoM,RM,FECINU,RCHN

Output 3.1.3 - Health authorities have updated, developed and approved equity-focused policies, strategies and guidelines using evidence and/or best practices

3.1.3 a Number of evidence-based strategies and guidelines developed

Agency project report_Annual project

UNFPA,UNICEF,WHO

MoHFW WHO National No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.4 - Boys and girls, especially from marginalized and vulnerable communities and areas are enrolled in Pre-primary, Primary schools or equivalent life skills based basic education programmes

3.1.4 a Percentage of girls and boys aged 5-14 from selected marginalized and

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.4 a Net primary enrolment (NER) for boys and girls (Percent, Boys)

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

ILO,UNDP,UNESCO,UNHCR,UN

MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME,MoW

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.4 a Net primary enrolment (NER) for boys and girls (Percent, Girls)

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

ILO,UNDP,UNESCO,UNHCR,UN

MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME,MoW

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.4 a Net primary enrolment (NER) for boys and girls (Percent)

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

ILO,UNDP,UNESCO,UNHCR,UN

MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME,MoW

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.4 a Percentage of Grade 1 students in primary schools who have a ended

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

UNDP,UNESCO,UNHCR,UNICEF

DPE,MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME,

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.4 a Percentage of Grade 1 students in primary schools who have a ended

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

UNDP,UNESCO,UNHCR,UNICEF

DPE,MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME,

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.4 a Percentage of Grade 1 students in primary schools who have a ended

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

UNDP,UNESCO,UNHCR,UNICEF

DPE,MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME,

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.5 - Marginalized children benefit from national education policies and strategies that have been approved and being implemented by government

3.1.5 a Percentage of girls and boys from ethnic minorities receiving formal

BANBEIS_Report_2016, no data_review of reports_2012

UNESCO,UNICEF

MoCHTA,MoE,MoPME

UNESCO Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.5 a Government approved curriculum for education in mother language in pre-primary and lower primary grades (Available)

Agency project report_Annual project report_2011, Agency project report_Annual report_2016,

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.6 - Deprived population in communities, schools and health facilities in hard-to-reach areas (haor, char, flood, cyclone, and drought prone areas, arsenic and salinity-affected areas, CHT) have increased availability of community-based integrated WASH package

3.1.6 a ############################## UNICEF_Project Document_2011,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WHO

MoDMR,MoE,MoHFW,MoP

UNICEF District No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.6 a Percentage of primary schools with separate functional toilets for girls

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.6 a Percentage of primary schools with separate functional toilets for girls

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.6 a Percentage of primary schools with separate functional toilets for girls

Dept of Primary Education_Annual Education

2012,2013,2014,2015,20162012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.1.6 a Percentage of health facilities (excluding community clinics) having

MoHFW_BHFS_2012, MoHFW_BHFS_2016

Page 69: 2012 progress report final

69

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 4 8 12 16 20 20Actual 0 8

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 6 12 18 24 30 30Actual 0 6

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 17.76 28.32 38.88 49.44 60 60Actual 7.2 7.2

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 1.84 1.38 0.92 0.46 0 0Actual 2.3 2.3

Planned 57.6 68.2 78.8 89.4 100 100Actual 47 47

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 20 40 60 80 100 100Actual 0 31

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 13 14 15 16 17 17Actual 12 5

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedProgres

seysActual no Progres

s

UNICEF District No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.8 - Authorities in sector institutions at all levels apply sector policies/guidelines on decentralized planning and financial management, including PME systems, in order to ensure sustainable, efficient and effective WASH service delivery

3.1.7 a Percentage of LGIs in project areas taking measures to ensure safety

no data_review of reports_2012,

UNICEF,WHO MoHFW

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.1.9 - Vulnerable people (MARPs, other Vulnerable groups as identified for NSP III (and PLHIVs) benefit from increased availability of and access to HIV prevention, treatment, care & support

3.1.8 a Percentage of LGI initiatives complying with guidelines on

UNICEF_Project Document_2011,

UNICEF BMET,MoDMR,MoEWOE,M

UNICEF District No Yes

UNAIDS National No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Outcome 3.2 - Children, women and youth demand and benefit from effective social protection policies and improved services aimed at eliminating abuse, neglect, exploitation, and trafficking

3.1.9 a Percentage of MARPs, including Most at Risk Adolescents (MARA),

UNAIDS_Global AIDS RESPONSE Progress Report

IOM,UNAIDS,UNESCO,UNFPA,

BMET,MoEWOE,MoHFW

3.2 a Percentage of 5-14 year out of school children who are involved in

BBS/UNICEF_MICS_2006, BBS/UNICEF_MICS_2015,

ILO,IOM,UNHCR,UNICEF

MoDMR,MoEWOE,MoHA,M

UNICEF National Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.2 b Percentage of cases of all forms of trafficking prosecuted (Percent)

MOHA_Anti Trafficking Project_2012, MOHA_Anti

ILO,IOM,UNICEF

MoEWOE,MoHA,MoLE,MoL

UNICEF National No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.2.1 - Deprived and vulnerable families have improved access to social protection services to reduce their vulnerability to abuse, violence and exploitation especially children, youth and women

3.2.1 a Percentage of children/adolescents/women who

MOWCA/MOSW/UNICEF_CP-MIS_2016, no data_review of

ILO,IOM,UNICEF

MoDMR,MoEWOE,MoHA,M

UNICEF National No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.2.2 - All social protection policies and legal frameworks harmonized with international human rights conventions and protocols

3.2.2 a Number of key social protection laws and policies and

MOWCA/MOSW/UNICEF_CP-MIS_2016, no data_review of

ILO,IOM,UNHCR,UNICEF

MoDMR,MoEWOE,MoHA,M

102,3102,2102oNlanoitaN4,2015,2016

Output 3.2.3 - Communities practice positive social norms favourable to the prevention of violence, abuse and exploitation

3.2.3 a Existence of surveillance system for identification, reporting, referral, investigation, treatment and follow-up of instances of child

MOWCA/MOSW/UNICEF_CP-MIS_2016, no data_review of reports_2012, UNICEF_Annual Project

ILO,IOM,UNHCR,UNICEF

MoDMR,MoLE,MoLJPA,MoSW

102,3102,2102oNlanoitaNFECINU4,2015,2016

Output 3.1.7 - Authorities in LGIs have the technical and managerial capacity to implement WASH package to ensure safety and sustainability of drinking water, especially for the poor

Page 70: 2012 progress report final

70

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 13 26 39 52 65 65Actual 0 24.9

Planned 70 67.5 65 62.5 60 60Actual 72.5 70.4

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 20.76 25.92 31.08 36.24 41.4 41.4Actual 15.6 15.6

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

373706dennalPActual 60

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

33336.53dennalPActual 38.5 38.5

33333.43dennalPActual 34.3 34.3

33336.53dennalPActual 36.4 36.4

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

654.26dennalPActual 62.4

Planned 74 72 70 68 66 66Actual 74

Planned 68 66 64 62 60 60Actual 70

Planned

3.3 a Percentage of households with water and soap at specific place for

Agency project report_Annual project

UNICEF MoDMR,MoE,MoEF,MoFL,M

UNICEF National No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

3.3 b Adolescent fertility rate per 1,000 women (Ratio)

World Bank_WB World Development

UNFPA,UNHCR,UNICEF

MoDMR,MoE,MoEF,MoHFW

UNICEF National Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 3.3.1 - Deprived communities in selected areas have increased knowledge on key life-saving, care and protective behaviours

3.3.1 a Percentage of adolescents who have comprehensive knowledge on

UNICEF_Project Document_2012,

UNFPA,UNHCR,UNICEF

MoDMR,MoE,MoEF,MoFL,M

UNICEF National No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Pillar 4 - Food Security and Nutri on

Outcome 4.1 - The urban and rural poor have adequate food security and nutrition throughout the life cycle

4.1 a Percentage of population able to meet minimum daily energy

FAO,WFP DAE,MoA,MoDMR,MoF,Mo

102,3102,2102seYhsedalgnaBPFW4,2015,2016

4.1 a Percentage of population able to meet minimum daily energy

FAO,WFP DAE,MoA,MoDMR,MoF,Mo

102,3102,2102seYhsedalgnaBPFW4,2015,2016

4.1 a Percentage of population able to meet minimum daily energy

BBS_HIES_2010, BBS_HIES_2015

FAO,WFP DAE,MoA,MoDMR,MoF,Mo

102,3102,2102seYhsedalgnaBPFW4,2015,2016

4.1 a Percentage of poor households with acceptable level of food

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 a Percentage of poor households with acceptable level of food

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 a Percentage of poor households with acceptable level of food

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of underweight children under five years of age (Percent,

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 FAO,IAEA,IOM,UNICEF,WFP,W

BAEC,MoA,MoDMR,MoHF

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of underweight children under five years of age (Percent,

NIPORT_BDHS_2011 FAO,IAEA,IOM,UNICEF,WFP,W

BAEC,MoA,MoDMR,MoHF

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of underweight children under five years of age (Percent)

NIPORT_BDHS_2011, NIPORT_BDHS_2015

FAO,IAEA,IOM,UNICEF,WFP,W

BAEC,MoA,MoDMR,MoHF

UNICEF Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of wasted children under five years of age (Percent, Female)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of wasted children under five years of age (Percent, Male)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of wasted children under five years of age (Percent)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of stunted children under five years of age (Percent,

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of stunted children under five years of age (Percent,

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 b Percentage of stunted children under five years of age (Percent)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1 c Percentage of populations with poor or borderline diet diversity score

BBS_HIES_2010 FAO,IAEA,IOM,UNHCR,WFP

DAE,DLS,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL

102,3102,2102oNhsedalgnaBOAF4,2015,2016

4.1 c Percentage of populations with poor or borderline diet diversity score

BBS_HIES_2010 FAO,IAEA,IOM,UNHCR,WFP

DAE,DLS,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL

102,3102,2102oNhsedalgnaBOAF4,2015,2016

4.1 c Percentage of populations with poor or borderline diet diversity score

BBS_HIES_2010 FAO,IAEA,IOM,UNHCR,WFP

DAE,DLS,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL

102,3102,2102oNhsedalgnaBOAF4,2015,2016

4.1 d Anaemia prevalence of pregnant 102,3102,2102oN,hsedalgnaBFECINUWFHoMW,FECINU,AEAI

Outcome 3.3 - Deprived community members in selected areas practice key life-saving, care and protective behaviours and raise their demand for quality social services

Page 71: 2012 progress report final

71

ActualPlanned 41.8 37.6 33.4 29.2 25 25Actual 46Planned

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 20 20 24 26 30 30Actual 0 20

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

Planned 40 50 60 75 95 95Actual 0

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

Planned 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.5Actual 6

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 60 70 80 90 100 100Actual 50

Planned 60 70 80 90 100 100Actual 50

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 26 30 34 38 42 42

women (Percent, 6102,5102,4noisiviDOHW,PF)laruR4.1 d Anaemia prevalence of pregnant

women (Percent)UNICEF_CRM_2010, UNICEF_CRM_2016

IAEA,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

MoHFW UNICEF Bangladesh,Division

102,3102,2102oN4,2015,2016

4 1 d Anaemia prevalence of pregnant IAEA UNICEF W MoHFW UNICEF Bangladesh No 2012 2013 201

Output 4.1.1 - Poor communities benefit from strengthened institutional mechanisms for coordinating and monitoring the implementation of food security, safety and nutrition policies and programs, effective at national and in targeted sub-national levels

4.1.1 a National policies, guidelines and tools on food security, food safety

FAO/UNICEF/WFP_Project Report_2011,

FAO,UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

MoA,MoDMR,MoHFW

FAO National No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 4.1.2 - Communities, including the most vulnerable, benefit from services for the prevention and treatment of maternal and child malnutrition at Upazila and union levels

4.1.2 a Number of targeted Upazilas trainined on basic package of

UN Agency_Annual report_2011,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

IPHN,MoHFW,NGOs

102,3102,2102oNFECINU4,2015,2016

4.1.2 b Recovery rates of severely and moderately malnourished children

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

IPHN,MoHFW,NGOs

4.1.2 b Recovery rates of severely and moderately malnourished children

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

Targeted Upazila

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF Targeted Upazila

No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

IPHN,MoHFW,NGOs

IPHN,MoHFW,NGOs

UNICEF Targeted Upazila

No Yes

4.1.2 c Proportion of target children 6-59 months supplemented with Vitamin

4.1.2 c Proportion of target children 6-59 months consuming MNP as per

UNICEF_Annual Project Report_2012,

UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNICEF District,Targeted Upazila

102,3102,2102oN4,2015,2016

4.1.2 c Proportion of pregnant women who are supplemented with adequate

4.1.2 c Proportion of target children 2-5 years dewormed twice yearly

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Bangladesh

FAO Bangladesh

Output 4.1.3 - Poor communities benefit from improved access to agricultural inputs, food technologies and fortified foods

4.1.3 a Ratio of non-food grain crop to food grain production (Ratio)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1.3 b Increase in major crop yields (ton per hector, Rice)

FAO_Baseline survey_2012, FAO_Endline survey_2016

FAO,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

MoA,MoDMR,MoFL,MoHA,

UNDAF_Disaster response report by UN agencies_2011

FAO,IOM,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

102,3102,2102oN4,2015,2016

4.1.3 b Share of rice value added in total food value added in current price

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 4.1.4 - Disaster- stricken, food insecure household's benefit from adequate and diversified food and agricultural rehabilitation support provided in a timely manner

4.1.4 a Percentage of disaster affected vulnerable households including

CSO,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL,M

WFP Bangladesh

102,3102,2102hsedalgnaBPFW4,2015,2016

Output 4.1.5 - The rural and urban poor have improved knowledge and practices on nutrition, e.g. gender, hygiene, IYCF and food safety

4.1.4 a Percentage of disaster affected vulnerable households including

UNDAF_Disaster response report by UN agencies_2011

FAO,IOM,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

CSO,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL,M

4.1.5 a Proportion of targeted households WFP_Programme baseline 102,3102,2102hsedalgnaBPFWoM,AoM,OSCNU,RCHNU,OAF

Page 72: 2012 progress report final

72

Actual 26 26Planned 23 27 31 35 39 39Actual 23 23

Planned 24 28 32 36 40 40Actual 24 24

Planned 23 42 42Actual 23 23

Planned 33 46 46Actual 33 33

Planned 30 45 45Actual 25.2 24.2

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 13.44 12.88 12.32 11.76 11.2 11.2Actual 14 11

PlannedActual

Planned 132 174 216 258 300 300Actual 90 117

06dennalPActual 26

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 180 260 340 420 500 500Actual 100 150

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 800 1100 1300 1300 1300 1300Actual 500 685

Planned 3 6 9 12 15 15Actual 0 1

Planned 3 6 9 12 15 15Actual 0 1

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 2400 4800 7200 9600 12000 12000Actual 0 4181

Planned 18000 26000 34000 42000 50000 50000

following appropriate basic nutri on, and outcome 6102,5102,4M,LFoM,RMDOHW,PFW,FECI2102_troper4.1.5 a Propor on of targeted households

following appropriate basic nutri on, WFP_Programme baseline and outcome report_2012

FAO,UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

CSO,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL,M

102,3102,2102hsedalgnaBPFW4,2015,2016

4.1.5 a Propor on of targeted households following appropriate basic nutri on,

WFP_Annual report _2012, WFP_Programme baseline

FAO,UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

CSO,MoA,MoDMR,MoFL,M

102,3102,2102hsedalgnaBPFW4,2015,2016

4.1.5 b Percentage of children aged 6-23 months in the targeted areas

WFP_Programme baseline and outcome report_2012

FAO,UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

MoDMR,MoHFW,NGOs

5102,2102hsedalgnaBPFW

4.1.5 b Percentage of children aged 6-23 months in the targeted areas

WFP_Programme baseline and outcome report_2012

FAO,UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

MoDMR,MoHFW,NGOs

5102,2102hsedalgnaBPFW

4.1.5 b Percentage of children aged 6-23 months in the targeted areas

NIPORT_BDHS_2011, WFP_Programme baseline

FAO,UNHCR,UNICEF,WFP,WHO

MoDMR,MoHFW,NGOs

5102,2102hsedalgnaBPFW

4.1.5 b Percentage of of newborns breastfed within the first hour after birth in the

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

4.1.5 b Percentage of children 0-5 months exclusively breastfed in the targeted

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Pillar 5 - Climate Change, Environment, Disaster Risk Reduc on and Response

Outcome 5.1 - By 2016, popula ons vulnerable to climate change and natural disaster have become more resilient to adapt with the risk

5.1 a Environment, climate and disaster vulnerability index (Number)

UNDP_E mate_2012, UNDP_UNDP Es mate_2011,

FAO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BWDB,Community,DoE,LGD

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1 a Climate and disaster vulnerability index (Number)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1 b Community Asset Score for disaster risk reduc on (Number)

Agency project report_Annual project

FAO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

LGD,LGED WFP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1 b Average Community Asset Score (CAS) to measure the disaster

Agency project report_Annual project

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.1.1 - Climate change adapta on and disaster risk reduc on integrated into sectoral policies and plans

5.1.1 a Amount of resources budgeted by the Government for disaster risk

Finance Division_Mid -term budgetary framework

FAO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

Academic Ins tu ons,B

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.1.2 - Community and Local Ins tu ons have greater capacity on Disaster Risk Reduc on and climate change adapta on

5.1.2 a Number of Unions in disaster prone areas with developed community

DMRD_Annual Report_2009, DMRD_Annual Report_2016,

FAO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

MoDMR UNDP No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1.2 b Number of rural communi es with disaster/climate resilient habitats

DMRD_Annual Report_2016, UNDP_Annual Project

FAO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

MoDMR

5.1.2 b Number of UDMCs implemen ng local DRR schemes (Number)

DMRD_Annual Report_2011, DMRD_Annual Report_2012,

Bangladesh

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.1.3 - Communi es, local and na onal governments have greater capacity to respond and to provide basic services in emergencies and early recovery

5.1.2 c Number of unions assisted to improve the disaster resilience

5.1.3 a Number of disaster rescue and evacua on volunteers (Number,

CDMP_Project Report_2011, Fire Service and Civil

FAO,IOM,UNDP,UNESCO,UNFP

MoDMR UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1.3 a Number of disaster rescue and CDMP_Project Report_2011, FAO,IOM,UNDP MoDMR UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,201

Page 73: 2012 progress report final

73

Actual 10000 10803Planned 20400 30800 41200 51600 62000 62000Actual 10000 14984

Planned 22 26 31 35 40 40Actual 17 17

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 28 33 39 44 50 50Actual 22 14

Planned 784 924 1064 1204 1344 1344Actual 644

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

222202dennalPActual 18 20

Planned 217.6 363.2 508.8 654.4 800 800Actual 72 78

Planned 71.14 69.68 68.22 66.76 65.3 65.3Actual 72.6 80

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

06064584dennalPActual 44 44

Planned 0 0 400 800 1000 1000Actual 0 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 10 20 30 30Actual 5 8

01015dennalPActual 0 0

02dennalPActual 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

554dennalPActual 2 2

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

evacua on volunteers (Number, Fire Service and Civil ,UNESCO,UNFP 4,2015,20165.1.3 a Number of disaster rescue and

evacua on volunteers (Number)CDMP_Project Report_2011, UNDP_CCED top results

FAO,IOM,UNDP,UNESCO,UNFP

MoDMR UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1.3 b Number of district DMCs with a resourced disaster response plan

CCED cluster UNDP_PM_2012,

FAO,IOM,UNDP,UNESCO,UNFP

MoDMR UNDP Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.1.4 - Communi es, local and na onal authori es have be er access to knowledge on climate change impact for be er decision making

5.1.4 a Percentage of targeted communi es, local and na onal authori es who

CCED cluster UNDP_PM_2012,

FAO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

MoDMR UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.1.4 a Number of UDMCs using Union Climate factsheets to plan local DRR

DMRD_Annual Report_2011, DMRD_Annual Report_2016

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Outcome 5.2 - By 2016, vulnerable popula ons benefit from natural resource management (NRM); environmental governance and low- emission green development

5.2 a Number of Government policies, strategies or plans approved in

Bangladesh Government_Rio+ 20:

FAO,ILO,UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,

MoFL,Planning Commission

5.2 b Energy generated from renewable sources (MW)

IDCOL_Personal Interview_2011, Ministry of

FAO,ILO,UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,

Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

UNDP Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Power Division

UNDP Bangladesh No

UNDP Bangladesh Yes Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.2.1 - Communi es and local and na onal authori es are be er able to conserve biodiversity and manage natural resources in a pro-poor and sustainable manner

5.2 c Percentage reduc on in ozone-deple ng (ODP tons)

DoE_HCFC Phase-out Management Plan (HPMP)

FAO,ILO,UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,

DoE

5.2.1 a Number of communi es implemen ng a sustainable natural

BGDP, UNDP_Annual Report_2014, BGDP,

FAO,UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,UNH

DoE UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.2.1 b Area covered under effec ve pollu on abatement prac ces

DOE_Annual Report_2010, DOE_Annual Report_2016,

FAO,UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,UNH

DoE UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.2.2 - Relevant ins tu ons have greater capacity to implement exis ng environment policies, plans and budgets for be er environmental governance integra ng considera ons of poverty-environment- climate change interfaces

5.2.2 a Number of Government investment projects incorpora ng Poverty

PECM, GED Planning Commission_ADP Screening

UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,UNIDO

Planning Commission

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.2.2 b Number of Upazila administra ons that have a proper monitoring and

DOE_Annual Report_2010, DOE_Annual Report_2016,

UNDP,UNEP,UNESCO,UNIDO

DoE UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.2.2 b Number of districts having environmental monitoring and

DOE_Annual Report_2010, DOE_Annual Report_2016

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.2.3 - Pro-poor Plans, strategies and partnership mechanism are in place to implement low emission green growth with be er access to climate financing mechanisms

5.2.3 a Number of plans, strategies and policies dra ed in favor of low

BGDP, UNDP_Annual Report_2014, BGDP,

FAO,ILO,UNDP MoI,MoT,Power Division

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 5.2.4 - On-grid and pro-poor off-grid clean energy technologies promoted

Page 74: 2012 progress report final

74

Planned 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.5Actual 0 0

Planned 5.28 5.96 6.64 7.32 8 8Actual 4.6 7

Planned 2 4 6 8 10 10Actual 0 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 15.07 13.94 12.8 11.67 10.54 10.54Actual 16.2

Planned 13.49 12.47 11.46 10.44 9.43 9.43Actual 14.5

Planned 13.58 12.56 11.54 10.52 9.5 9.5Actual 14.6

Planned 14 28 42 56 70 70Actual 0

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 4 8 12 16 20 20Actual 0 3

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 36 42 48 54 60 60Actual 30

PlannedActual 25000 27407

PlannedActual 19000 20124

PlannedActual 8000 10031

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 22000 28578

PlannedActual 11000 11758

PlannedActual 8000 21767

PlannedActual 14000 14377

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 0

5.2.4 a Percentage of rural households with access to renewable energy sources

BGDP, UNDP_Annual report_2015,

UNDP,UNEP,UNHCR,UNIDO

Power Division

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.2.4 a Percentage of rural households with access to renewable energy sources

IDCOL_Personal Interview_2011, UNDP

UNDP,UNEP,UNHCR,UNIDO

Power Division

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

5.2.4 b Amount in National budget Allocated to Energy Efficiant Constructions and

GED, Planning Commission_SFYP 2010-

UNDP,UNEP,UNHCR,UNIDO

Power Division

UNDP Bangladesh No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Pillar 6 - Pro-Poor Urban Development

Outcome 6.1 - By 2016, at least three million urban poor have improved living conditions and livelihoods to realize their basic rights

6.1 a Urban extreme poverty rate in 28 urban areas as measured by direct

BBS_HIES_2005, BBS_HIES_2015

ILO,IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,

BMET,CBOs,CSO,DWASA,M

UNDP Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1 a Urban extreme poverty rate in 28 urban areas as measured by direct

BBS_HIES_2005, BBS_HIES_2015

ILO,IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,

BMET,CBOs,CSO,DWASA,M

UNDP Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1 a Urban extreme poverty rate in 28 urban areas as measured by direct

BBS_HIES_2005, BBS_HIES_2015

ILO,IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,

BMET,CBOs,CSO,DWASA,M

UNDP Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1 b Percent of targeted urban poor households who report that their

UPPR_Se lement Living Condition Score Card_2011,

ILO,IOM,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,

BMET,CSO,DWASA,MoDM

UNDP Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1 a Urban poverty rate as as measured by Cost of Basic Needs (Percent)

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1 b Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) in targeted urban areas

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 6.1.1 - Key stakeholders are be er able to provide the urban poor with secure tenure and affordable housing

6.1.1 a Number of programme towns where government authorities clarify the

UNDP_UPPR, Annual Results Report_2012, UPPR,

UNDP CSO,MoLGRD and

UNDP Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 6.1.2 - Urban poor have improved access to financial services and decent employment

6.1.2 a Percent of targeted urban poor who have regular, decent employment

UPPR, UNDP_UPPR Household Census_2009,

ILO,IOM,UNDP Financial Institutions,M

UNDP No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Page 75: 2012 progress report final

75

PlannedActual 9000 9258

PlannedActual 5000 5704

PlannedActual 4000 4389

PlannedActual 11000 12753

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 36000 45344

PlannedActual 6000 5954

Planned 36400 39800 43200 46600 50000 50000Actual 47619 67821

PlannedActual 14000 14798

PlannedActual 9000 9104

PlannedActual 10000 10472

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 33000 33841

PlannedActual 20000 20740

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 4000 5297

PlannedActual 14000 14402

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 7000 16266

PlannedActual 9000 9625

PlannedActual 2000 24788

Planned 334400 4E+05 4E+05 383600 4E+05 400,000Actual 318,000 376777

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 72000 1E+05 1E+05 183000 2E+05 220,000Actual 35,000 90220

Planned 67000 94000 1E+05 148000 2E+05 175,000Actual 40,000 59535

Planned 232200 4E+05 5E+05 601800 7E+05 725000Actual 109000

Planned 93200 2E+05 2E+05 270800 3E+05 330,000Actual 34,000 64585

PlannedActual

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.2 b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access

UNDP, UPPR_Participatory Identification of the Poor

ILO,IOM,UNDP BMET,Financial

UNDP No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 6.1.3 - Urban poor have be er access to improved basic services and social assistance programs

6.1.3 a Number of beneficiary households in supported low income se lements

UNDP, UNICEF_Data on Water and Sanitation_2012,

ILO,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,WF

CSO,DWASA,MoDMR,MoH

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.3 a Number of beneficiary households in supported low income se lements

UNDP, UNICEF_Data on Water and Sanitation_2012,

ILO,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,WF

CSO,DWASA,MoDMR,MoH

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.3 a Number of beneficiary households in supported low income se lements

UNICEF/UNDP_UNICEF-UNDP WASH Data_2009,

ILO,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,WF

CSO,DWASA,MoDMR,MoH

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.3 a Number of beneficiary households in supported low income se lements

UNDP, UNICEF_Data on Water and Sanitation_2012,

ILO,UNDP,UNFPA,UNICEF,WF

CSO,DWASA,MoDMR,MoH

UNICEF No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.3 b Number of boys and girls receiving a school snack of 75 gm of biscuits by

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Page 76: 2012 progress report final

76

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

Planned 600 1200 1800 2400 3000 3,000Actual 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual 36.4

53dennalPActual 36

PlannedActual 34.5

PlannedActual 40.7

PlannedActual 47.3

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

PlannedActual

PlannedActual 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

02dennalPActual 45.5

02dennalPActual 21.2

02dennalP

6.1.3 b Number of boys and girls receiving a school snack of 75 gm of biscuits by

2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

6.1.3 b Number of boys and girls receiving a school snack of 75 gm of biscuits by

2012,2013,2014,2015,20162012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 6.1.4 - Municipalities and urban poor have a greater capacity for participatory and pro-poor urban governance

6.1.3 c MT of biscuits distributed (MT)

UNDP No Yes 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Pillar 7 - Gender Equality and Women's Advancement

6.1.4 a Number of targeted urban poor communities that have presented

UNDP, UPPR_CDC Data Reconciliation

UNDP,UNICEF CSO,DWASA,MoLE,MoPME

Outcome 7.1 - Marginalized and disadvantaged women in selected districts and urban slums increase their participation in wage employment and other income-generating activities

7.1 a Labor force participation among the women in the lowest two quintiles

BBS_Labour Force Survey_2010

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,B

UN WOMEN,

Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1 a Labor force participation among the women in the lowest two quintiles

BBS_Labour Force Survey_2010

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,B

UN WOMEN,

Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1 a Labor force participation among the women in the lowest two quintiles

BBS_Labour Force Survey_2010

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,B

UN WOMEN,

Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1 a Labor force participation among the women (Formal labor sector, 2nd

BDHS_BDHS 2007_2007 ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,B

UN WOMEN,

Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1 a Labor force participation among the women (Formal labor sector, Lowest

BDHS_BDHS 2007_2007 ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,B

UN WOMEN,

Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.1.1 - Marginalized and disadvantaged women in selected districts and urban slums have increased skills and knowledge leading to improved employability and entrepreneurship

7.1.1 a Percentage of women & girls received vocational and

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

BEF,BMET,BTEB,CBOs,CSO,D

ILO,IOM,UN

Chittagong,Rajshahi,Targ

No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.1.2 - Girls in selected districts benefit from an enabling environment that facilitates their access to secondary and tertiary education

7.1.2 a Percentage of secondary and tertiary institutions in the selected areas

UN WOMEN,UNES

BANBEIS,BNFE,BSA,BTEB,CB

UNICEF No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1.2 a Percentage of secondary and tertiary institutions in the selected areas

UN WOMEN,UNES

BANBEIS,BNFE,BSA,BTEB,CB

UNICEF No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1.2 a Percentage of secondary and tertiary institutions in the selected areas

UNDAF Pillar 7_Baseline and Endline_2012

UN WOMEN,UNES

BANBEIS,BNFE,BSA,BTEB,CB

UNICEF No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.1.3 - Policy makers and implementers both in the public and private sectors apply increased knowledge to better support gender sensitive work environments.

7.1.3 a Percentage of women working in the selected organizations who perceive

ILO_Baseline Survey in 5 selected districts_2011

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BEF,BGMEA,BMET,BTEB,DT

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1.3 a Percentage of women working in the selected organizations who perceive

ILO_Baseline Survey in 5 selected districts_2011

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BEF,BGMEA,BMET,BTEB,DT

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1.3 a Percentage of women working in the ILO_Baseline Survey in 5 ILO,IOM,UN BEF,BGMEA,B UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,201

Page 77: 2012 progress report final

77

Actual 23.602dennalP

Actual 31.102dennalP

Actual 76.602dennalP

Actual 83

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual 15.6

PlannedActual 15

PlannedActual 16.4

PlannedActual 67.23

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual

PlannedActual 0

PlannedActual 0

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

seYdennalPActual No

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implementing Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to National Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Reporting Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual

selected organizations who perceive selected 6102,5102,4TD,BETB,TEM,PDNU,NEMOW1102_stcirtsid7.1.3 a Percentage of women working in the

selected organizations who perceive ILO_Baseline Survey in 5 selected districts_2011

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BEF,BGMEA,BMET,BTEB,DT

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.1.3 a Percentage of women working in the selected organizations who perceive

ILO_Baseline Survey in 5 selected districts_2011

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BEF,BGMEA,BMET,BTEB,DT

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,20162012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.1.4 - Marginalized and disadvantaged women in the poorest districts and urban slums have increased access to accurate. relevant information and credit.

7.1.3 a Percentage of women working in the selected organizations who perceive

ILO_Baseline Survey in 5 selected districts_2011

ILO,IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP,

BEF,BGMEA,BMET,BTEB,DT

UNFPA Bangladesh No No

UN WOMEN,

No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Outcome 7.2 - Social and institutional vulnerabilities of women including the marginalized and disadvantaged are reduced

7.1.4 a Percentage of women applied for institutional credit who received

UNDAF Pillar 7_Baseline and Endline_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNDP

MoDMR,MoEF,MoEWOE,Mo

7.2 a Median age at first marriage for girls of the last two wealth quintiles in

NIPORT_BDHS_2007 IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,BB

UNFPA Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2 a Median age at first marriage for girls of the last two wealth quintiles in

NIPORT_BDHS_2007 IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,BB

UNFPA Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2 a Median age at first marriage for girls of the last two wealth quintiles in

NIPORT_BDHS_2007 IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,BB

UNFPA Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2 b Percentage of women and girls aged 15-49 in the selected areas who have

BBS_Violence Against Women Survey_2011

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAI

Academic Institutions,BB

UNFPA Bangladesh Yes No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.2.1 - Boys, men, girls, and women have increased awareness and display positive a tudes towards reducing/eliminating GBV

7.2.1 a Percentage of boys aged 10-19, men aged 20-60, girls aged 10-19 and

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNFP

Academic Institutions,CB

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.1 a Percentage of boys aged 10-19, men aged 20-60, girls aged 10-19 and

UNDAF Pillar 7_Baseline and Endline_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNFP

Academic Institutions,CB

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.1 a Percentage of boys aged 10-19, men aged 20-60, girls aged 10-19 and

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNFP

Academic Institutions,CB

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.1 a Percentage of boys aged 10-19, men aged 20-60, girls aged 10-19 and

UNDAF Pillar 7_Baseline and Endline_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNFP

Academic Institutions,CB

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.1 a Percentage of boys aged 10-19, men aged 20-60, girls aged 10-19 and

UNDAF Pillar 7_Baseline and Endline_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNFP

Academic Institutions,CB

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.2.2 - Decision-makers benefit from strengthened government systems to generate and validate new and existing data on GBV from different sources for planning, implementation and monitoring

7.2.2 a National database on VAW established and functional

BBS_Violence Against Women Survey_2011,

UNDP,UNFPA,WHO

BBS,BRAC,DWA,HEU,MoHF

UNFPA Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.2.3 - Policy makers and CSOs have increased capacity to align and implement the existing laws and policies with international frameworks on women's rights (e.g CEDAW, CRC and BPfA)

7.2.3 a Number of revised policies approved to align and comply with

UN WOMEN,UNFP

CSO,MoWCA,Parliament,Pla

UN WOMEN

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Output 7.2.4 - Survivors of VAW have increased access to shelter, medical, psychological, legal support and vocational training

Page 78: 2012 progress report final

78

Sr. NUecruoSrotacidnIoN System Agencies

Implemen ng Partners

Lead Agency

Geographic Area

UNDAF 25 priority

indicators with MDGs links

Link to Na onal Development Plan /

SWAP indicators

Repor ng Time Status Baseline(2011)

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Programme Target (2017)

PlannedActual No

BaselinePlannedActual No

BaselinePlannedActual No

BaselinePlannedActual No

BaselinePlannedActual No

baseline

7.2.4 a Number of vic ms of violence received quality service (Number, Health Service)

MoHFW_MoHFW APR_2012 IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNFP

BRAC,CBOs,DWA,Legal Aid Organiza ons,

UN WOMEN,UNDP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.4 a Number of vic ms of violence received quality service (Number, Legal Service)

MoWCA and MoSW_MoWCA and MoSW APR for Legal service_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNFP

BRAC,CBOs,DWA,Legal Aid Organiza ons,

UN WOMEN,UNDP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.4 a Number of vic ms of violence received quality service (Number, Referral Service)

MoWCA and MoSW_MoWCA and MoSW Referral service_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNFP

BRAC,CBOs,DWA,Legal Aid Organiza ons,

UN WOMEN,UNDP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.4 a Number of vic ms of violence received quality service (Number, Shelter)

MoWCA and MoSW_MoWCA and MoSW APR_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNFP

BRAC,CBOs,DWA,Legal Aid Organiza ons,

UN WOMEN,UNDP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

7.2.4 a Number of vic ms of violence received quality service (Number)

MoWCA, MoSW and MoHFW_MoWCA, MoSW and MoHFW APR_2012

IOM,UN WOMEN,UNAIDS,UNDP,UNFP

BRAC,CBOs,DWA,Legal Aid Organiza ons,

UN WOMEN,UNDP

Bangladesh No No 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016

Page 79: 2012 progress report final

79

In the first year of UNDAF 2012-2016 implementation, the UNDAF Pillars and the UNDAF M&E Group checked viability of all indicators, including data source, data source reliability, disaggregation and frequency. As a result, several indicators were revised by UNDAF Pillars together with the UNDAF M&E Group during the Annual Review process (red colored revised/replaced).

The reasons for the 2012 revision of indicators are described under each of the revised indicators in the table below. The reasons for indicator revisions vary. For example, four composite indicators were not feasible to monitor and thereforewere split to ensure adequate monitoring of the respective output/outcome; some indicators required simple rephrasing to align with existing national framework and thereby allow for use of the same data sources; six indicators with missing baselines (some at aggregated and some atdisaggregated level) were reviewed and alternate indicators were suggested.

With the revision, the total number of UNDAF indicators is now 117.

Annex 4: Revised UNDAF Indicators

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list) (Pillar One)

New List of UNDAF Indicators

1.1a Public trust in the credibility of elections

1.1a Public trust in the credibility of elections

1.1b Progress of approval of Civil Service Act Enactment and revised rules

1.1b Progress of approval of Civil Service Act Enactment and revised rules

1.1c Percentage of women in civil service in senior management positions (Joint/Secretary and above)

1.1c Percentage of women in civil service in senior management positions (Joint/Secretary and above)

1.1.1a Number of citizens registered at server stations

1.1.1a Number of citizens registered at server stations

1.1.2a Progress of Standing Committees rules of procedure revised to facilitate the oversight and public engagement responsibilities

1.1.2a Progress of Standing Committees rules of procedure revised to facilitate the oversight and public engagement responsibilities

1.1.3a Number of articles and news stories in the media covering targeted issues

1.1.3a Number of articles and news stories in the media covering targeted issues

1.1.4a Number of ministries (including related field offices) responsible for basic service delivery with performance indicators and a monitoring system

1.1.4a Number of ministries (including related field offices) responsible for basic service delivery with performance indicators and a monitoring system

1.1.5a Number of Unions and Upazilas (sub-districts) in selected areas that have functional coordination forums, addressing communities’ demands for quality services and promoting dialogue between service providers and community members

1.1.5a Number of Unions and Upazilas (sub-districts) in selected areas that have functional coordination forums, addressing communities’ demands for quality services and promoting dialogue between service providers and community members

1.1.6a Number of citizens with access to government e-solution services

1.1.6a Number of citizens with access to government e-solution services

1.2a Percent of citizens who are satisfied with law and order service providers

1.2a Percent of citizens who are satisfied with law and order service providers

1.2b Number of recommendations made by 2008 Universal Periodic Review implemented

1.2b Number of recommendations made by 2008 Universal Periodic Review implemented

1.2c Number of case backlog reduced 1.2c Number of case backlog reduced

1.2.1a Coordination body for the National Strategy for the Justice Sector established

1.2.1a Coordination body for the National Strategy for the Justice Sector established

1.2.1b Percent of utilization of legal aid budget per year

1.2.1b Percent of utilization of legal aid budget per year

1.2.2a Number of village courts providing justice

1.2.2a Number of village courts providing justice

1.2.2b Percent of cases resolved by refugees to camp management committee

1.2.2b Percent of cases resolved by refugees to camp management committee

1.2.3a Number of female victims of crime supported with improved victim support services

1.2.3a Number of female victims of crime supported with improved victim support services

Page 80: 2012 progress report final

80

2.1.2a National Social Protection Strategy prepared

2.1.2a National Social Protection Strategy prepared

2.1.2b Percentage of poor households benefiting from social safety nets

2.1.2b Percentage of poor households benefiting from social safety nets

2.1.3a National policy drafted that promotes community based management of productive common pool resources

2.1.3a National policy drafted that promotes community based management of productive common pool resources

2.1.4a GOB Joint Cooperative Strategy fully implemented

2.1.4a GOB Joint Cooperative Strategy fully implemented

2.1.5a Number of new Aid for Trade (AFT) initiatives directly facilitated by the project in targeted districts or pro-poor sectors

2.1.5a Number of new Aid for Trade (AFT) initiatives directly facilitated by the project in targeted districts or pro-poor sectors

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list) (Pillar One) New List of UNDAF Indicators

3.1a Proportion of births attended by skilled health personnel

3.1a Proportion of births attended by skilled health personnel

3.1b Contraceptive prevalence rate (modern method)

3.1b Contraceptive prevalence rate modern method)

2.1.6a Increase in the annual income of participating households

2.1.6a Increase in the annual income of participating households

2.1.7a Change in poverty headcounts rates in the targeted areas at district level

2.1.7a Change in poverty headcounts rates in the targeted areas at district level

2.1.7b Number of MSMEs in targeted lagging regions assisted to access markets, and financial and technological services

2.1.7b Number of MSMEs in targeted lagging regions assisted to access markets, and financial and technological services

1.2.3b Number of law enforcement officials trained on human trafficking

1.2.3b Number of law enforcement officials trained on human trafficking

1.2.4a Number of human rights investigations referred to government agencies from the National Human Rights Commission that were resolved

1.2.4a Number of human rights investigations referred to government agencies from the National Human Rights Commission that were resolved

1.2.5a Percent of perpetrators of crimes against children sentenced by courts of law

1.2.5a Percent of perpetrators of crimes against children sentenced by courts of law

1.2.5b Three child-friendly children acts in the country drafted

1.2.5b Three child-friendly children acts in the country drafted

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list) (Pillar One) New List of UNDAF Indicators

2.1a Per Capita GDP growth at constant prices

2.1a Per Capita GDP growth at constant prices

2.1b Labour force participation rate disaggregated by gender

2.1b Labour force participation rate disaggregated by gender

2.1c Percentage of poorest quintile in national consumption

2.1c Percentage of poorest quintile in national consumption

2.1d Percent of GDP accounted for by public health and education spending

2.1d Percent of GDP accounted for by public health and education spending

2.1.1a The National Vocational Qualifications Framework (NVQF) is approved by the Government

2.1.1a The National Vocational Qualifications Framework (NVQF) is approved by the Government

2.1.1b Number of workers going overseas through official channels

2.1.1b Number of workers going overseas through official channels

Page 81: 2012 progress report final

81

3.1.2a Proportion of districts and upazilas that have utilized 75 percent of the funds allocated as per the MNCH, AH-FP plans developed according to the local level planning (LLP) guidelines

3.1.2a Proportion of districts and upazilas that have utilized 75 percent of the funds allocated as per the MNCH, AH-FP plans developed according to the local level planning (LLP) guidelines

3.1.3a Number of evidence-based strategies and guidelines developed and approved

3.1.3a Number of evidence-based strategies and guidelines developed and approved

3.1c Proportion of boys and girls who enrolled in grade 1 reaching the last grade of primary education

3.1c Proportion of boys and girls who enrolled in grade 1 reaching the last grade of primary education

3.1d Proportion of population using an improved drinking water source

3.1d Proportion of population using an improved drinking water source

31.e Proportion of population using improved sanitation facility

31.e Proportion of population using improved sanitation facility

3.1f Proportion of women aged 15-49 who gave birth in the 2 years preceding the survey receiving post natal care within 2 days of delivery from medically trained provider

3.1f Proportion of women aged 15-49 who gave birth in the 2 years preceding the survey receiving post natal care within 2 days of delivery from medically trained provider

3.1.1a Percent of certified SDPs providing 24/7 midwifery services by certified professionals, EMONC services, IMCI, and at least three modern planning methods at any given time.

(Revised: Indicator split into two to ensure measurability through existing sources)

3.1.1a Percentage of district hospitals, MCWCs and UHCs providing comprehensive EmOC services 24/7 (Percent, District Hospitals)

3.1.1b Number of midwives trained and certified to international standards deployed to district hospitals and UHCs. (Number)

3.1.1b Number of beds in radiotherapy centers

3.1.1c Number of beds in radiotherapy centers

3.1.6a Percentage of hard-to reach population, schools and health facilities in programme areas with access to integrated package of WASH interventions

(Revised: Indicator split into two to ensure measurability through existing sources)

3.1.6a Percentage of primary schools with separate functional toilets for girls

3.1.6b Percentage of health facilities (excluding community clinics) having separate, improved toilets for female clients

3.1.7a Percentage of LGIs in project areas taking measures to ensure safety and sustainability of drinking water supply

3.1.7a Percentage of LGIs in project areas taking measures to ensure safety and sustainability of drinking water supply

3.1.8a Percentage of LGI initiatives complying with guidelines on decentralized management of WASH service delivery, including use of planning, monitoring and evaluation

3.1.8a Percentage of LGI initiatives complying with guidelines on decentralized management of WASH service delivery, including use of planning, monitoring and evaluation

3.1.9a Percentage of MARPs, including Most at Risk Adolescents (MARA), young people 15-24 accessing prevention services

3.1.9a Percentage of MARPs, including Most at Risk Adolescents (MARA), young people 15-24 accessing prevention services

3.1.4a Percentage of girls and boys aged 5-14 from selected marginalized and vulnerable communities who are enrolled in formal and informal education

(Revised: Indicator split into two to ensure measurability through existing sources)

3.1.4a Net primary enrolment (NER) for boys and girls

3.1.4b Percentage of Grade 1 students in primary schools who have attended pre-primary education

3.1.5a Percentage of girls and boys from ethnic minorities receiving formal pre-primary and lower primary education in their mother languages as per national education policy

(Revised: Indicator is difficult to measure and there is lack of reliable data at the district level.)

3.1.5a Government approved curriculum for education in mother language in pre-primary and lower primary grades

Page 82: 2012 progress report final

82

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list) (Pillar One)

New List of UNDAF Indicators

4.1.a Percentage of population able to meet minimum daily energy requirements of 2122kcal

(Revised: Data unavailable for current indicator. Alternate suggested.)

4.1a Percentage of poor households with acceptable level of food consumption in the poverty prone regions

4.1.b Percentage of underweight children under five years of age

Two new indicators proposed to adequately measure outcome

4.1b Percentage of wasted children under five years of age

4.1c Percentage of stunted children under five years of age

4.1.c Percentage of populations with poor or borderline diet diversity score

4.1.d Percentage of populations with poor or borderline diet diversity score

4.1.d Anaemia prevalence of pregnant women

4.1.e Anaemia prevalence of pregnant women

4.1.1.a National policies, guidelines and tools on food security, food safety and nutrition are updated, disseminated and implemented in expected time frame

4.1.a National policies, guidelines and tools on food security, food safety and nutrition are updated, disseminated and implemented in expected time frame

4..1.2a Twenty percent of targeted upazilas provide facility and community based quality nutrition services

(Revised: Project based data available for current indicator. Alternate suggested.)

4.1.2a Number of targeted upazilas trained on basic package of nutrition by IPHN/NNS

4.1.2b Recovery rates of severely and moderately malnourished children and pregnant and lactating women in respective treatment programs

4.1.2b Recovery rates of severely and moderately malnourished children and pregnant and lactating women in respective treatment programs

3.3a Percentage of households with water and soap at specific place for hand washing

3.3a Percentage of households with water and soap at specific place for hand washing

3.2a Percentage of 5-14 year out of school children who are involved in child labor activities

3.2a Percentage of 5-14 year out of school children who are involved in child labor activities

3.2b Percentage of cases of all forms of trafficking prosecuted

3.2b Percentage of cases of all forms of trafficking prosecuted

3.2.1a Percentage of children/adolescents/women who received social services through case management

3.2.1a Percentage of children/adolescents/women who received social services through case management

3.2.2a Number of key social protection laws and policies and strategies/operational plan reviewed and harmonized with international standards

3.2.2a Number of key social protection laws and policies and strategies/operational plan reviewed and harmonized with international standards

3.2.3a Existence of surveillance system for identification, reporting, referral, investigation, treatment and follow-up of instances of child maltreatment

3.2.3a Existence of surveillance system for identification, reporting, referral, investigation, treatment and follow-up of instances of child maltreatment

3.3b Adolescent birth rate per 1,000 women

3.3b Adolescent birth rate per 1,000 women

3.3.1a Percentage of adolescents who have comprehensive knowledge on marriage (i.e. can state 2 harms of early marriage and 3 benefits of delayed marriage)

3.3.1a Percentage of adolescents who have comprehensive knowledge on marriage (i.e. can state 2 harms of early marriage and 3 benefits of delayed marriage)

Page 83: 2012 progress report final

83

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list)

(Pillar Five) New List of UNDAF Indicators

5.1a Environment, climate and disaster vulnerability index

(Revised: To adequately measure the outcome. Alternate suggested)

5.1a Climate and disaster vulnerability index

5.1b Community Asset Score for disaster risk reduction.

(Revised: To adequately measure the outcome. Alternate suggested)

5.1b Average Community Asset Score (CAS) to measure the disaster resilience of the targeted Unions

5.1.1a Amount of resources budgeted by the Government for disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation against sectoral policies and plans

5.1.1a Amount of resources budgeted by the Government for disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation against sectoral policies and plans

5.1.2b Number of rural communities with disaster/climate resilient habitats and community assets

(Revised: To adequately measure the output. Alternate suggested)

5.1.2b Number of UDMCs implementing local DRR schemes

5.1.2c Number of unions assisted to improve the disaster resilience

5.1.3a Number of disaster rescue and evacuation volunteers

5.1.3a Number of disaster rescue and evacuation volunteers

5.1.3b Number of district DMCs with a resourced disaster response plan

5.1.3b Number of district DMCs with a resourced disaster response plan

5.1.4a Percentage of targeted communities, local and national authorities who are aware of the impact of climate change on their respective communities and/or sectors

(Revised: To adequately measure the output. Alternate suggested)

5.1.4a Number of UDMCs using Union climate factsheets to plan local DRR schemes

5.1.2a Number of Unions in disaster prone areas with developed community based risk reduction & CC adaptation action plans

5.1.2a Number of Unions in disaster prone areas with developed community based risk reduction & CC adaptation action plans

4.1.4a Percentage of disaster affected vulnerable households, including displaced households, receiving an adequate & appropriate food, nutrition and agriculture inputs assistance as part of emergency response

4.1.4a Percentage of disaster affected vulnerable households, including displaced households, receiving an adequate & appropriate food, nutrition and agriculture inputs assistance as part of emergency response

4.1.2c Proportion of target children and women taking micro nutrient supplements as recommended

(Revised: Project based data available for current indicator. Split into four indicators.)

4.1.2c Proportion of target children 6-59 months consuming MNP as per guidelines

4.1.2d Proportion of target children 6-59 months supplemented with Vitamin A twice daily

4.1.2e Proportion of target children 2-5 years dewormed twice yearly

4.1.2f Proportion of pregnant women who are supplemented with adequate dose of Iron Folate Acid (IFA)

4.1.3a Ratio of non-food grain crop (MT)** to food grain production (MT)

(Revised: Data unavailable for current indicator. Alternate suggested.)

4.1.3a Share of rice value added in total food value added in current price

4.1.3b Increase in major crops yields 4.1.3b Increase in major crops yields

4.1.5a Proportion of targeted households following appropriate basic nutrition, hygiene and sanitation practices

4.1.5a Proportion of targeted households following appropriate basic nutrition, hygiene and sanitation practices

4.1.5b Percent of children aged 6-23 months receiving complementary food with at least the minimum (4+ food groups) dietary diversity

(Two additional indicators proposed to adequately monitor the output)

Two additional indicators proposed to adequately monitor the output:

4.1.5c Percentage of newborns breastfed within the first hour after birth in the targeted communities

4.1.5d Percentage of children exclusively breastfed up to 6 months in the targeted communities

Page 84: 2012 progress report final

84

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list)

(Pillar Six) New List of UNDAF Indicators

6.1a Urban extreme poverty rate in 28 urban areas as measured by Direct Calorie Intake

(Revised: To adequately measure the outcome. Alternate suggested)

6.1.a Urban poverty rate as measured by the Cost of Basic Needs

6.1b Percentage of households in low income urban areas who report that their living conditions have improved in the past 5 years

((Revised: To adequately measure the outcome. Alternate suggested)

6.1.b Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) in targeted urban areas

6.1.1a Number of programme towns where government authorities clarify the tenure security status of low-income settlement dwellers

6.1.1a Number of programme towns where government authorities clarify the tenure security status of low-income settlement dwellers

6.1.2a Percentage of urban poor who have regular, decent employment

6.1.2a Percentage of urban poor who have regular, decent employment

6.1.2b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access to credit through savings and credit groups

6.1.2b Number of targeted urban poor households saving and having access to credit through savings and credit groups

6.1.3a Number of beneficiary households in supported low income settlements provided with improved access to: water (tubewell and water reservoir) and sanitation facilities (latrines)

(Two additional indicators proposed to adequately monitor the output)

Two additional indicators proposed to adequately monitor the output:

6.1.3b Number of boys and girls receiving a school snack of 75 gm of biscuits by age group and gender

6.1.3c MT of biscuits distributed

6.1.4a Number of targeted urban poor communities that have presented their concerns to local authorities

6.1.4a Number of targeted urban poor communities that have presented their concerns to local authorities

5.2.2a Number of Government investment projects incorporating Poverty Environment and Climate Change Indicators in the project design and implementation

5.2.2a Number of Government investment projects incorporating Poverty Environment and Climate Change Indicators in the project design and implementation

5.2.2b Number of Upazila administrations that have a proper monitoring and regulatory mechanism

(Revised: To adequately measure the output. Alternate suggested)

5.2.2b Number of districts having environmental monitoring and regulatory mechanism

5.2.3a Number of plans, strategies and policies drafted in favor of low emission green growth

5.2.3a Number of plans, strategies and policies drafted in favor of low emission green growth

5.2.4a Percentage of rural households in targeted communities with access to renewable energy sources and technologies

5.2.4a Percentage of rural households in targeted communities with access to renewable energy sources and technologies

5.2.4b Amount in national budget allocated to energy efficient construction and appliances

5.2.4b Amount in national budget allocated to energy efficient construction and appliances

5.2a Number of Government policies, strategies or plans approved in support of sustainable management of natural resources

5.2a Number of Government policies, strategies or plans approved in support of sustainable management of natural resources

5.2b Energy generated from renewable sources

5.2b Energy generated from renewable sources

5.2c Percentage reduction in ozone-depleting substances/greenhouse gases

5.2c Percentage reduction in ozone-depleting substances/greenhouse gases

5.2.1a Number of communities implementing a sustainable natural resource management plan

5.2.1a Number of communities implementing a sustainable natural resource management plan

5.2.1b Area covered under effective pollution abatement practices

5.2.1b Area covered under effective pollution abatement practices

Page 85: 2012 progress report final

85

UNDAF Action Plan indicators (old list) (Pillar One) New List of UNDAF Indicators

7.1a Labor force participation among the women in the lowest quintiles

(Revised: Data unavailable for current indicator. Alternate suggested.)

7.1a Labor force participation among women in formal labour sector

7.1.1a Percent of women & girls received vocational and entrepreneurial skills training in the selected areas who secured employment within six months of completion of the training

(Revised: Data unavailable for current indicator. Alternate suggested.)

7.1.1a Percentage of women and girls admitted for vocational and entrepreneurial skills training in the selected areas/institutions have successfully completed the training

7.1.2a Percentage of secondary and tertiary institutions in the selected areas which meet the gender-friendly environment criteria (including physical facilities separate washroom, crèche etc.)

(Revised: Data unavailable for current indicator. Alternate suggested.)

7.1.2a Percentage of secondary institutions in selected areas which have separate functional washroom facilities for girls.

7.1.3a Percentage of women working in the selected organizations who perceive that they are working in safe and gender sensitive environment

7.1.3a Percentage of women working in the selected organizations who perceive that they are working in safe and gender sensitive environment

7.1.4a Percentage of women applied for institutional credit who received it without collateral from the selected institutions

(Indicator taken out)

(Indicator taken out)

7.2a Median age at first marriage for girls of the last two wealth quintiles in the selected areas

(Revised: To align with existing sources of indicators)

7.2a Median age at first marriage for girls (age 20-24) of the last two wealth quintiles in Bangladesh (Age group, 2nd& lowest quintile, National)

7.2.1a Percentage of boys aged 10-19, men aged 20-60, girls aged 10-19 and women aged 20-49 in the selected areas who are aware of the negative effects of GBV.

(Revised to align with existing sources of indicators)

7.2.1a Percentage of currently married women/men age 15-49 who agree that a husband is justified in hitting or beating his wife for at least one of the reasons.

7.2.2b National database on VAW established and functional

7.2.2b National database on VAW established and functional

7.2.3a Number of revised policies approved to align and comply with international frameworks on women’s rights

7.2.3a Number of revised policies approved to align and comply with international frameworks on women’s rights

7.2.4a Number of women support centers or shelters which provide services for survivors of VAW established and functional in the selected districts

(Revised to align with existing sources of indicators)

7.2.4a Number of victims of violence received quality service (Number, Health Service/ Legal Service/Referral service /Shelter/Total) in the project areas.

7.2b Percent of women/girls aged 15-49 who have experienced any forms of violence in the past 12 months

(Revised: To align with existing sources of indicators)

7.2b Percentage of women and girls aged 15-49 who have experienced any forms of violence in the past twelve months

Page 86: 2012 progress report final

86

Page 87: 2012 progress report final

ADDRESS:UNDP IDB BHABAN, E/8-A, BEGUM ROKEYA SHARANI, SHER-E-BANGLA NAGAR

DHAKA-1207, BANGLADESH. TEL.: 880-2-811-8600, 880-2-811-8601

Page 88: 2012 progress report final