2013 02 05 cmyk na 04online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/pageone0205.pdf · 2018-08-27 · in...

1
YELLOW ****** TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 5, 2013 ~ VOL. CCLXI NO. 29 WSJ.com HHHH $2.00 CONTENTS CFO Journal................. B6 Corporate News.... B2,3 Global Finance........... C3 Health & Wellness D2,3 Heard on the Street C8 In the Markets.......... C4 Leisure & Arts............ D5 Opinion.................. A13-15 Sports.............................. D6 Technology................... B5 U.S. News................. A2-6 Weather Watch........ B6 World News.......... A8-11 DJIA 13880.08 g 129.71 0.9% NASDAQ 3131.17 g 1.5% NIKKEI 11260.35 À 0.6% STOXX 600 283.90 g 1.5% 10-YR. TREAS. À 13/32 , yield 1.973% OIL $96.17 g $1.60 GOLD $1,675.30 À $5.90 EURO $1.3514 YEN 92.38 s Copyright 2013 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved Vital Signs Orders for manufactured goods rose in December, largely because of higher military spending linked to concerns about potential cutbacks. The value of new orders for the month climbed 1.8% to $484.76 bil- lion, the Commerce Depart- ment said. But excluding de- fense, orders increased just 0.3%. Demand for nonde- fense capital goods exclud- ing aircraft fell 0.3%. U.S. factory orders, in billions Source: Commerce Department '09 '10 '11 '12 ’08 ’07 0 100 200 300 $400 > T urmoil returned to Eu- rope’s markets as the con- fluence of a political scandal in Spain and a banking scan- dal in Italy sparked a flight from bonds and stocks in the Continent’s southern nations and pummeled the euro. C1 The Dow industrials posted their first triple-digit drop this year, losing 129.71 points amid weakness in tech shares. C4 n The Justice Department filed civil charges against S&P, alleging that the firm ig- nored its own standards in rating mortgage bonds that im- ploded in the financial crisis. A1 n Michael Dell is close to fin- ishing a $23 billion deal to take private the computer firm he founded, in an effort to remake Dell Inc. for a post-PC era. A1 n Conflicts of interest among the possible new SEC chairman and other top agency officials could make it harder to ap- prove enforcement cases. C1 n The SEC is gathering data on a broad number of trades by corporate executives in shares of their own firms, expanding a high-profile investigation. C3 n U.S. aviation regulators ap- peared poised to approve some Boeing 787 flight tests as part of investigations into the cause of battery fires on the planes. B1 n U.S. banks reported stronger demand for busi- ness, home and auto loans during the winter, in a posi- tive sign for the economy. A3 n The average U.S. household paid an estimated $2,912 for gasoline last year, sucking up nearly 4% of the average house- hold income before taxes. A4 n U.K. banks may have to raise billions in new capital as part of a review by regulators into how the lenders assess the risk of the assets on their books. C3 n The Super Bowl attracted an average of 108.4 million viewers, the third-largest au- dience for a television event on record, CBS said. B3 n Oracle will acquire Acme Packet in a $1.7 billion deal, its biggest move yet into the market for equipment that transports Internet data. B3 n Yum, whose KFC unit was the target of a Chinese probe into antibiotics use in poultry, said it expects earnings per share to decline in 2013. B4 n The EU will propose new cybersecurity rules that would require a range of businesses to report disruptions to gov- ernment authorities. B3 n A group of hedge-fund creditors sent J.C. Penney a notice alleging that the re- tailer violated the terms of bonds held by the group. B4 n Bridgewater will launch a new All Weather fund. The world’s largest hedge-fund firm also said it sold a stake to an outside investor. C3 n CME Group plans to close the grain-trading pits at the Kansas City Board of Trade, ending a 157-year run for the wheat-futures exchange. C4 n Afghanistan, Pakistan set a target for a Taliban accord. The two countries’ leaders, af- ter talks hosted in Britain by Cameron, agreed on a six- month timeline to reach a peace settlement with the Tal- iban, the latest effort in a push to end the Afghan war. A focus of the meetings was a plan to open a Taliban office in Qatar, which could serve as the base for peace talks with Kabul. The Afghan Taliban’s leader- ship is based in Pakistan. A10 With U.S.-led forces set to withdraw, the West wants a compromise with the Tal- iban to prevent a civil war. n France pursued Islamist militants in north Mali with fighter jets and special forces and pressed West African na- tions to send more troops. A8 n Iran’s president and speaker accused each other of blackmail, corruption and other crimes during a public parliamentary session. A9 n Bulgaria plans to release a report blaming Hezbollah and its ally Iran for a terrorist bombing last summer that killed five Israeli tourists. A11 n The U.S. military suspended its blacklisting of Kam Air af- ter Kabul promised a probe of drug allegations against the private Afghan airline. A10 n Hundreds of soccer games world-wide have been fixed by international crime rings, Europol officials said. A8 n Myanmar and ethnic rebels, following talks in China, agreed to ease military tensions after weeks of intense fighting. A10 n Efforts to develop a new TB vaccine stumbled when the most advanced experimental inoculation failed to protect infants in a clinical study. A2 n A Vietnam court sentenced 22 dissidents to prison terms ranging from 10 years to life in a continuing government crackdown on dissent. A11 n Mexico’s attorney general blamed an accumulation of gas, possibly methane, for the blast at state oil company Pe- mex that killed at least 37. A11 n The Bolshoi Ballet director is heading to Germany in a bid to save his vision after an acid attack and said he knows who was behind the assault. A10 n Gay-rights activists gath- ered at Boy Scouts headquar- ters, urging the group to drop its ban on gay members. A3 n Investigators are probing whether human error or me- chanical failure caused a deadly California bus crash. A4 n Greek police are investigat- ing a death threat after the fi- nance ministry received a bul- let and warning note. A10 n Turkey said it suspected the group that bombed the U.S. Em- bassy was planning an attack, but didn’t know where or when. n An Alabama hostage drama ended when FBI agents killed the abductor and freed the 5- year-old boy he was holding. A2 Business & Finance World-Wide Follow the news all day at WSJ.com personal Journal. Getty Images The Science Behind Stress and Sweat Return of the House Call What’s News– i i i i i i TOPEKA, Kan.—Even if he doesn’t enter the race himself, this state’s Republican governor, Sam Brownback, is determined to play a starring role in the next presidential election. How? By turning Kansas into what he calls Exhibit A for how sharp cuts in taxes and government spending can generate jobs, wean residents off pub- lic aid and spur economic growth. “My focus is to create a red-state model that allows the Republican ticket to say, ‘See, we’ve got a differ- ent way, and it works,’ ” Mr. Brown- back said in a recent interview. Coming off the largest tax cut in state history on Jan. 1, Kansas is now on the leading edge of a growing but still largely untested quest among conservative governors to create growth by dra- matically revamping state tax codes. The Brownback experiment is stirring both praise and anxiety among Kansas conservatives even as it helps spark similar overhaul proposals in the GOP-led states of Indiana, Louisiana, Ne- braska, North Carolina, Ohio and Oklahoma. The focus on fiscal innovations in the heartland comes as conservatives nationally seek ways to re- vive the GOP’s standing in the aftermath of its stinging election losses last year. Bruised by the continuing budget battles in Washington, where divided government has led to near-gridlock, top Republicans nationally are holding up Kansas and other GOP-dominated states as examples of what the party might accomplish if left to its own de- vices. Mr. Brownback recounts how Senate Minority Please turn to page A12 The Justice Department sued Standard & Poor’s Ratings Serv- ices late Monday, alleging the firm ignored its own standards to rate mortgage bonds that imploded in the financial crisis and cost inves- tors billions, according to people familiar with the matter. The civil charges by U.S. Attor- ney General Eric Holder against the New York company, one of the bond-rating industry’s three gi- ants, are the first federal enforce- ment action against a credit-rating firm over the crisis. Several state attorneys general are likely to join. S&P said in a statement earlier Monday that the government suit would be “entirely without factual or legal merit,” and denied wrong- doing. After The Wall Street Journal reported Monday afternoon that the government intended to launch the civil case, S&P con- firmed the expected lawsuit and said the rating firm was being punished unfairly by the U.S. gov- ernment for “failing to predict” the housing meltdown or financial crisis. The two sides have discussed a possible settlement for about four months, according to people close to the negotiations, but S&P balked over concerns that a deal could sink the company. The government was seeking penalties of more than $1 billion, another person close to the talks said, which would be the biggest sanction imposed on a firm re- lated for its actions in the crisis. S&P officials also were rattled that the government was pushing the company to admit wrongdoing that could leave it more vulnera- ble to pending or new lawsuits by Please turn to the next page By Jean Eaglesham, Jeannette Neumann and Evan Perez U.S. Sues S&P Over Ratings Justice Department Says Endorsements of Risky Mortgage Bonds Fueled Crisis Michael Dell is close to finish- ing a risky $23 billion deal to take private the computer com- pany he founded nearly 30 years ago, in an effort to remake Dell Inc. for a post-PC era. Late Monday, Mr. Dell was in talks with Microsoft Corp. and private-equity firm Silver Lake Partners to offer shareholders be- tween $13.50 and $13.75 a share, said people familiar with the matter, about a 25% premium to Dell’s stock price in January be- fore the possibility of a deal be- came public. The buyout, if approved by shareholders, would be the larg- est such deal since the financial crisis. It also would be an admission by Mr. Dell that he wasn’t able to pull off the changes needed to improve his company’s revenue and profit under Wall Street’s glare. The buyout would give Mr. Dell the largest stake in the com- pany, ensuring that the 47-year- old is the one who gets to over- see any changes. The Round Rock, Texas, firm once boasted a market capitaliza- tion above $100 billion as the world’s largest PC maker. But the company’s market share has since dwindled to third behind Hewl- ett-Packard Co. and Lenovo Group Ltd. as tablets and smart- phones became more popular. Mr. Dell has also had to endure critical comparisons of the finan- cial performance of his company and Apple Inc., a matter of par- ticular frustration, according to people familiar with the matter. Interviews with current and former Dell executives, plus other people who know the CEO, paint a picture of a man who appeared increasingly worried about his legacy. These people said it has been years since Mr. Dell showed Please turn to page A6 BY BEN WORTHEN AND ANUPREETA DAS Dell Nears $23 Billion Deal to Go Private BY NEIL KING JR. AND MARK PETERS Party Eyes ‘Red-State Model’ To Drive Republican Revival BARED BONES: English researchers said the skeleton found under a parking lot is Richard III, slain 500 years ago. DNA and a curved spine, Shakespeare’s ‘lump of foul deformity,’ marked it as the controversial king. A10 University of Leicester/European Pressphoto Agency, University of Leicester/Associated Press Moving an Octogenarian Is Tough, Especially One That Put Down Roots i i i A Plan to Relocate Florida’s Largest Rain Tree For Towers Has Fans Shaking Like a Leaf FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla.—De- veloper Asi Cymbal thinks his proposed residential project here is just what this city needs to liven up a derelict stretch of its riverfront downtown. The futuristic, three- tower complex would include about 1,000 rental units, three res- taurants and a marina. There’s just one problem: The tree standing right where one of the towers is supposed to sprout up. And not just any tree. It is a roughly 80-year- old, six-story-tall rain tree, the largest of its kind in Florida. Mr. Cymbal has an elaborate plan, involving con- sultants and a mover of giant fa- mous trees, to relocate it about 800 feet away at the entrance of the property and build a park around it. Even though Mr. Cymbal wants to save it and not chop it down, some of the city’s tree lovers are upset. They believe that if the tree is moved, its days might be numbered. “It will die a slow, agonizing death,” says Charles Livio, an ar- borist in nearby Oak- land Park. He and others op- posed to the relocation urged the Broward County Commission to pass a measure that would have declared the tree historic, an effort that failed in December. Now, they have turned their attention to the City Commission, which has the authority to prevent the tree’s relocation because a 1987 ordinance declares it protected. The commission is expected to take up the matter in the spring. Please turn to page A12 Asi Cymbal BY ARIAN CAMPO-FLORES ‘Bloody Thou Art, Bloody Will Be Thy End’ THE RIGHT WAY? FIRST IN A SERIES Heard on the Street.................... C8 Call 1.855.299.APPT | clevelandclinic.org /1heart U.S.News & World Report, 2012-13 The # 1 heart care in the nation. 18 years in a row. It’s why 24,498 people from around the world traveled to Cleveland last year for heart care. Same-day appointments available. C M Y K Composite Composite MAGENTA CYAN BLACK P2JW036000-6-A00100-1--------XA CL,CN,CX,DL,DM,DX,EE,EU,FL,HO,KC,MW,NC,NE,NY,PH,PN,RM,SA,SC,SL,SW,TU,WB,WE BGN,BMT,BRX,CCA,CHR,CKP,CPD,CXT,DNV,DRG,HAW,HLD,KCS,LAG,LAT,LKD,MIA,MLJ,NMX,PAL,PHI,PVN,SEA,TDM,TUS,UTA,WOK P2JW036000-6-A00100-1--------XA

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2013 02 05 cmyk NA 04online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/pageone0205.pdf · 2018-08-27 · in Spain and abanking scan- ... to report disruptions to gov-ernment authorities

YELLOW

* * * * * * TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 5, 2013 ~ VOL. CCLXI NO. 29 WSJ.com HHHH $2 .00

CONTENTSCFO Journal................. B6Corporate News.... B2,3Global Finance........... C3Health & Wellness D2,3Heard on the Street C8In the Markets.......... C4

Leisure & Arts............ D5Opinion.................. A13-15Sports.............................. D6Technology................... B5U.S. News................. A2-6Weather Watch........ B6World News.......... A8-11

DJIA 13880.08 g 129.71 0.9% NASDAQ 3131.17 g 1.5% NIKKEI 11260.35 À 0.6% STOXX600 283.90 g 1.5% 10-YR. TREAS. À 13/32 , yield 1.973% OIL $96.17 g $1.60 GOLD $1,675.30 À $5.90 EURO $1.3514 YEN 92.38

s Copyright 2013 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved

Vital Signs

Orders for manufacturedgoods rose in December,largely because of highermilitary spending linked toconcerns about potentialcutbacks. The value of neworders for the monthclimbed 1.8% to $484.76 bil-lion, the Commerce Depart-ment said. But excluding de-fense, orders increased just0.3%. Demand for nonde-fense capital goods exclud-ing aircraft fell 0.3%.

U.S. factory orders, in billions

Source: Commerce Department

'09 '10 '11 '12’08’07

0

100

200

300

$400

>

Turmoil returned to Eu-rope’s markets as the con-

fluence of a political scandalin Spain and a banking scan-dal in Italy sparked a flightfrom bonds and stocks in theContinent’s southern nationsand pummeled the euro. C1TheDow industrials postedtheir first triple-digit drop thisyear, losing 129.71 points amidweakness in tech shares. C4n The Justice Departmentfiled civil charges againstS&P, alleging that the firm ig-nored its own standards inratingmortgage bonds that im-ploded in the financial crisis.A1nMichael Dell is close to fin-ishing a $23 billion deal to takeprivate the computer firm hefounded, in an effort to remakeDell Inc. for a post-PC era. A1nConflicts of interest amongthe possible new SEC chairmanand other top agency officialscould make it harder to ap-prove enforcement cases. C1n The SEC is gathering dataon a broad number of trades bycorporate executives in sharesof their own firms, expanding ahigh-profile investigation. C3nU.S. aviation regulators ap-peared poised to approve someBoeing 787 flight tests as partof investigations into the causeof battery fires on the planes.B1n U.S. banks reportedstronger demand for busi-ness, home and auto loansduring the winter, in a posi-tive sign for the economy. A3nThe average U.S. householdpaid an estimated $2,912 forgasoline last year, sucking upnearly 4% of the average house-hold income before taxes. A4nU.K. banksmay have to raisebillions in new capital as partof a review by regulators intohow the lenders assess the riskof the assets on their books.C3n The Super Bowl attractedan average of 108.4 millionviewers, the third-largest au-dience for a television eventon record, CBS said. B3n Oracle will acquire AcmePacket in a $1.7 billion deal,its biggest move yet into themarket for equipment thattransports Internet data. B3n Yum, whose KFC unit wasthe target of a Chinese probeinto antibiotics use in poultry,said it expects earnings pershare to decline in 2013. B4n The EU will propose newcybersecurity rules that wouldrequire a range of businessesto report disruptions to gov-ernment authorities. B3n A group of hedge-fundcreditors sent J.C. Penney anotice alleging that the re-tailer violated the terms ofbonds held by the group. B4n Bridgewater will launch anew All Weather fund. Theworld’s largest hedge-fundfirm also said it sold a staketo an outside investor. C3n CME Group plans to closethe grain-trading pits at theKansas City Board of Trade,ending a 157-year run for thewheat-futures exchange. C4

nAfghanistan, Pakistan set atarget for a Taliban accord.The two countries’ leaders, af-ter talks hosted in Britain byCameron, agreed on a six-month timeline to reach apeace settlement with the Tal-iban, the latest effort in a pushto end the Afghan war. A focusof the meetings was a plan toopen a Taliban office in Qatar,which could serve as the basefor peace talks with Kabul.The Afghan Taliban’s leader-ship is based in Pakistan. A10With U.S.-led forces set towithdraw, the West wantsa compromise with the Tal-iban to prevent a civil war.n France pursued Islamistmilitants in north Mali withfighter jets and special forcesand pressedWest African na-tions to send more troops. A8n Iran’s president andspeaker accused each otherof blackmail, corruption andother crimes during a publicparliamentary session. A9n Bulgaria plans to release areport blaming Hezbollah andits ally Iran for a terroristbombing last summer thatkilled five Israeli tourists. A11nThe U.S. military suspendedits blacklisting of Kam Air af-ter Kabul promised a probe ofdrug allegations against theprivate Afghan airline. A10nHundreds of soccer gamesworld-wide have been fixedby international crime rings,Europol officials said. A8nMyanmar and ethnic rebels,following talks in China, agreedto ease military tensions afterweeks of intense fighting. A10n Efforts to develop a newTB vaccine stumbled when themost advanced experimentalinoculation failed to protectinfants in a clinical study. A2nA Vietnam court sentenced22 dissidents to prison termsranging from 10 years to life ina continuing governmentcrackdown on dissent. A11nMexico’s attorney generalblamed an accumulation ofgas, possibly methane, for theblast at state oil company Pe-mex that killed at least 37. A11n The Bolshoi Ballet directoris heading to Germany in a bidto save his vision after an acidattack and said he knows whowas behind the assault. A10nGay-rights activists gath-ered at Boy Scouts headquar-ters, urging the group to dropits ban on gay members. A3n Investigators are probingwhether human error or me-chanical failure caused adeadly California bus crash. A4nGreek police are investigat-ing a death threat after the fi-nance ministry received a bul-let and warning note. A10nTurkey said it suspected thegroup that bombed theU.S. Em-bassy was planning an attack,but didn’t knowwhere or when.nAnAlabama hostage dramaendedwhen FBI agents killedthe abductor and freed the 5-year-old boy hewas holding.A2

Business&Finance World-Wide

Follow the news all day at WSJ.com

personalJournal.

Getty

Images

The Science BehindStress and Sweat

Returnof theHouseCall

What’s News–i i i i i i

TOPEKA, Kan.—Even if he doesn’t enter therace himself, this state’s Republican governor, SamBrownback, is determined to play a starring role

in the next presidential election.How? By turning Kansas into what

he calls Exhibit A for how sharp cutsin taxes and government spending cangenerate jobs, wean residents off pub-lic aid and spur economic growth.

“My focus is to create a red-statemodel that allows the Republicanticket to say, ‘See, we’ve got a differ-ent way, and it works,’ ” Mr. Brown-back said in a recent interview.

Coming off the largest tax cut in state historyon Jan. 1, Kansas is now on the leading edge of agrowing but still largely untested quest among

conservative governors to create growth by dra-matically revamping state tax codes.

The Brownback experiment is stirring bothpraise and anxiety among Kansas conservativeseven as it helps spark similar overhaul proposalsin the GOP-led states of Indiana, Louisiana, Ne-braska, North Carolina, Ohio and Oklahoma.

The focus on fiscal innovations in the heartlandcomes as conservatives nationally seek ways to re-vive the GOP’s standing in the aftermath of itsstinging election losses last year. Bruised by thecontinuing budget battles in Washington, wheredivided government has led to near-gridlock, topRepublicans nationally are holding up Kansas andother GOP-dominated states as examples of whatthe party might accomplish if left to its own de-vices.

Mr. Brownback recounts how Senate MinorityPleaseturntopageA12

The Justice Department suedStandard & Poor’s Ratings Serv-ices late Monday, alleging the firmignored its own standards to ratemortgage bonds that imploded inthe financial crisis and cost inves-tors billions, according to peoplefamiliar with the matter.

The civil charges by U.S. Attor-ney General Eric Holder againstthe New York company, one of thebond-rating industry’s three gi-ants, are the first federal enforce-ment action against a credit-rating

firm over the crisis. Several stateattorneys general are likely to join.

S&P said in a statement earlierMonday that the government suitwould be “entirely without factualor legal merit,” and denied wrong-doing.

After The Wall Street Journalreported Monday afternoon that

the government intended tolaunch the civil case, S&P con-firmed the expected lawsuit andsaid the rating firm was beingpunished unfairly by the U.S. gov-ernment for “failing to predict”the housing meltdown or financialcrisis.

The two sides have discussed apossible settlement for about fourmonths, according to people closeto the negotiations, but S&Pbalked over concerns that a dealcould sink the company.

The government was seekingpenalties of more than $1 billion,another person close to the talkssaid, which would be the biggestsanction imposed on a firm re-lated for its actions in the crisis.

S&P officials also were rattledthat the government was pushingthe company to admit wrongdoingthat could leave it more vulnera-ble to pending or new lawsuits by

Pleaseturntothenextpage

By Jean Eaglesham,Jeannette Neumann

and Evan Perez

U.S. Sues S&P Over RatingsJustice Department Says Endorsements of Risky Mortgage Bonds Fueled Crisis

Michael Dell is close to finish-ing a risky $23 billion deal totake private the computer com-pany he founded nearly 30 yearsago, in an effort to remake DellInc. for a post-PC era.

Late Monday, Mr. Dell was intalks with Microsoft Corp. andprivate-equity firm Silver LakePartners to offer shareholders be-tween $13.50 and $13.75 a share,said people familiar with thematter, about a 25% premium toDell’s stock price in January be-fore the possibility of a deal be-came public.

The buyout, if approved byshareholders, would be the larg-est such deal since the financialcrisis.

It also would be an admissionby Mr. Dell that he wasn’t able topull off the changes needed toimprove his company’s revenueand profit under Wall Street’sglare. The buyout would give Mr.Dell the largest stake in the com-pany, ensuring that the 47-year-old is the one who gets to over-see any changes.

The Round Rock, Texas, firmonce boasted a market capitaliza-tion above $100 billion as theworld’s largest PC maker. But thecompany’s market share has sincedwindled to third behind Hewl-ett-Packard Co. and LenovoGroup Ltd. as tablets and smart-phones became more popular.

Mr. Dell has also had to endurecritical comparisons of the finan-cial performance of his companyand Apple Inc., a matter of par-ticular frustration, according topeople familiar with the matter.

Interviews with current andformer Dell executives, plus otherpeople who know the CEO, painta picture of a man who appearedincreasingly worried about hislegacy. These people said it hasbeen years since Mr. Dell showed

PleaseturntopageA6

BY BEN WORTHENAND ANUPREETA DAS

Dell Nears$23 BillionDeal to GoPrivate

BY NEIL KING JR. AND MARK PETERS

Party Eyes ‘Red-StateModel’To Drive Republican Revival

BARED BONES: English researchers said the skeleton found under a parking lot is Richard III, slain 500 yearsago. DNA and a curved spine, Shakespeare’s ‘lump of foul deformity,’ marked it as the controversial king. A10

Universityof

Leicester/Eu

ropean

Presspho

toAgency,

Universityof

Leicester/AssociatedPress

Moving an Octogenarian Is Tough,Especially One That Put Down Roots

i i i

APlan to Relocate Florida’s Largest Rain TreeFor Towers Has Fans Shaking Like a Leaf

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla.—De-veloper Asi Cymbal thinks hisproposed residential project hereis just what this city needs toliven up a derelict stretch of itsriverfront downtown.

The futuristic, three-tower complex wouldinclude about 1,000rental units, three res-taurants and a marina.

There’s just oneproblem: The treestanding right whereone of the towers issupposed to sprout up.And not just any tree. Itis a roughly 80-year-old, six-story-tall raintree, the largest of itskind in Florida. Mr. Cymbal hasan elaborate plan, involving con-sultants and a mover of giant fa-mous trees, to relocate it about800 feet away at the entrance ofthe property and build a park

around it.Even though Mr. Cymbal

wants to save it and not chop itdown, some of the city’s treelovers are upset. They believethat if the tree is moved, its daysmight be numbered. “It will die aslow, agonizing death,” says

Charles Livio, an ar-borist in nearby Oak-land Park.

He and others op-posed to the relocationurged the BrowardCounty Commission topass a measure thatwould have declared thetree historic, an effortthat failed in December.Now, they have turnedtheir attention to theCity Commission, which

has the authority to prevent thetree’s relocation because a 1987ordinance declares it protected.The commission is expected totake up the matter in the spring.

PleaseturntopageA12

Asi Cymbal

BY ARIAN CAMPO-FLORES

‘Bloody Thou Art, Bloody Will Be Thy End’

THERIGHTWAY?FIRST INA SERIES

Heard on the Street.................... C8

Call 1.855.299.APPT |clevelandclinic.org /1heartU.S.News & World Report, 2012-13

The #1 heart care in the nation.18 years in a row.It’s why 24,498 people from around the worldtraveled to Cleveland last year for heart care.

Same-day appointments available.

CM Y K CompositeCompositeMAGENTA CYAN BLACK

P2JW036000-6-A00100-1--------XA CL,CN,CX,DL,DM,DX,EE,EU,FL,HO,KC,MW,NC,NE,NY,PH,PN,RM,SA,SC,SL,SW,TU,WB,WEBGN,BMT,BRX,CCA,CHR,CKP,CPD,CXT,DNV,DRG,HAW,HLD,KCS,LAG,LAT,LKD,MIA,MLJ,NMX,PAL,PHI,PVN,SEA,TDM,TUS,UTA,WOK

P2JW036000-6-A00100-1--------XA