2013 cambridge mena’s emerging healthcare industry rani zahr
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
MENA’s Emerging Healthcare
Industry
Outline• Global Medical Tourism• Demand for Medical Tourism in MENA
o MENA Capacity for the Health Care Industry
• Lebanon’s Distinguished Healthcareo Infrastructure
• Proposed Plan of Actiono Legal Infrastructureo Medical Service Tourist Sectoro Projected Tourism Revenue
Global Medical Tourism
Quality Cost AnonymityTechnolog
y/Expertise
Availability
2004 2010 2012 2013
4060
80100
Global Revenues
$ B
illi
on
s
Statistics
• 50+ Destination Countries• Over 8 million patients• 2013 Expected Growth 20%
TOP 5 Destinations (~6.5 Million MT )
THAILAND
HUNGARY
INDIA
SINGAPORE
MALAYSIA
Global Medical Tourism Hotspots
Demand for Medical Tourism in MENA
150 JCI Accredited Hospitals and Clinics
Medical Tourism Mena
KSA
12 JCI$1 B 240K MT
$2 Billion IMF Loan
Jordan
10 % Growth
40 JCI$1.6 B 50K MT
44 JCI42K MT20%
Growth$16.8 B HC Costs ~ 2015
100K Medical tourists ~ 2016
Middle East Healthcare Market
Trends
Growing HC Demand
(9%)
Growing & Aging Population w/
Chronic Disease Burden
Health Consumption Drivers: Rising
Income Levels and Increased Insurance
Penetration (mandatory)
Human Capital
Shortages
Shortage in physicians. High dependence on
expatriates
Limited medical education options
Increased Regulation
eClaims, DRG-based licensing
Price Revisions
MENA HealthcareD
isease
D
rive
rs
Unhealthy Dietary Habits
Inter-marriages within families
Smoking
Low Exercise Level
Poor Road Safety
38.00%
17.00%
16.00%
3.00%
3.00%
2.00%
21.00%
Leading Causes of Death
MENA Healthcare
KSA Kuwait Bahrain UAE Oman Qatar
400 488 497
885
264
688608
1579
771
1704
520
1612GCC Per Capita Healthcare Costs (USD)
2000
2009
525252
52%
224% 134
%
54%
93%
97%
• Preventative Care• Disease Management• Population 3.2% CAGR
MENA Region Population (millions) 1950 2007 2050Arabian Peninsula 8 61 125North Africa 44 156 235Western Asia 52 215 332
MENA Medical Tourist Projects
OmanInternational Medical City
$1.0 B project 530-bed hospital Transplant Center Rehabilitation Center Diagnostic Prevention Health Resort
BahrainDilmunia Health Island
$1.6 B project 358-bed hospital 216-bed hospital Specialist clinics Sports medicine 3 five-star hotels, Leisure & Recreation Shopping centers 15,000 pp
community
GCC Outpatient Medical Travel
ME 32%
EU 13%
EU 40%NA 95%
ME 2%ME 58%
ME 8%
MENA Medical Travel Destinations
Lebanon’s Distinguished
Healthcare
“Lebanon will be the regional resource serving the advancement of health and medical tourism to the people of the MENA”
Quality & Affordable Health Care
Availability of Hospital Beds Highly Qualified Medical Staff Physician & Nurse Patient
Ratios High Nurse to Patient Ratios Geographic Location World Class Services &
Culture, Skilled and Multi-lingual Staff
Medical Tourism Lebanon
JCI Accredited & University Affiliated Medical Centers
St. GeorgeBalamand University
Rafik HaririLebanese University
Rizk Hospital
Lebanese American Uni
Hotel DieuSt. Joseph's University
Center Hospital
Kaslik University
University Affiliated Medical Centers (Non-Accredited)
Hospitals, Accreditation & Affiliation
Columbia University
U. George Washington
John Hopkins University
Saint Jude Children Research Hospital
University of Poitiers Neurosciences
Laval University in Quebec
Cardiovascular Sciences
Diabetes and Metabolic Disorders
Stem Cell Biology and Therapeutics
Cancer Neuroscience Immunology
Centers of Excellence
Infrastructure
Capacity … 100 000 Medical Tourists
Today … 10,000 foreign MT
10,000 Nurses12,000 Doctors
117
19
28
Private Short& Medium
Private Long Stay
Public Hospitals
(1570)
(9224 beds)
(3496)
Brain Drain… Wasted Talent
19
New Hospital Tower
Cancer and Children’s Hospital
Academic and Clinical Center
Current Medical Center
$500 M Project600 Bed Hospital342 physicians129 (38%) US Board Certified
AUBMC’s Regional Dominance
Active Regional Health Related
Activities• Al Manaa General Hospital
(AMGH) • Damascus Cardiovascular
Center (DCVC)• Jordan Ministry of Health• Iraq Ministry of Health• UNRWA• Palestinian Red Crescent
Society (PRCS• Al Quds University • Medical City Teaching Hospital
(MCTH) in Baghdad• World Health Organization
(WHO): Training for 100 Iraqi physicians and nurses in:o Advanced Trauma Life
Support (ATLS)o Cardiac Life Support (CLS)o Pre-Hospital Trauma Life
Support (PHTLS)o Advanced Trauma Care for
Nurses (ATCN)o Pediatric Trauma
• Al Quds University - Palestine
• King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research Center - KSA
• King Hussein Cancer Center - Jordan
• Medical City Teaching Hospital (MCTH) - Iraq
• Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI) - Bahrain
• Dr. Haifa Mahmoud Eye Center/Hospital – Bahrain
• Mouwasat – KSA• Harley Street Medical
Clinics – Abu Dhabi
Surgery ('000) USA
India
Jordan
Singapore
Thailand
Lebanon (AUBMC)
Heart Bypass 144 9 10 14 24 15
Angioplasty 57 9 5 8 7 4Heart Valve Rep.
170 1.5 12 14 22 15
Hip Rep. 50 8 8 11 14 14
Knee Rep. 50 7 7 11 12 13
Spinal Fusion 100 12 10 18 11 20Dental Implant
2 - 10 0.5 3 3 0.8
Lap Band 30 8 5 12 12 12Breast Implants 10 5 3 5.4 4 4
Rhinoplasty 8 4 2.5 2.7 3.5 4
Face Lift 15 7 3 4 7 4.7
Hysterectomy 15 5.5 2.5 4 5 4.5
Price Analysis
Infrastructure
Patient Flow
Lebanon’s Proposed Plan of Action
Public Private Partnerships
Quality Assurance Board
Medical Research
Regional Marketing
Expedited Visas
Tax Incentives
Tax Write-Offs
Reinvestment into Healthcare
Low Import Duties on new equipment
Depreciation on old equipment
Initiatives
Moving Forward
Accreditation of Medical Tourist Stakeholders
International Accreditation of Health-Care Facilities
Informed Patient Choice
Continuity of Care
Non-Waiver of Liability
• Create a National Regulatory & Accreditation Boardo Maintain the Registrar of Medical Practitioners o Administer continuing medical education o Encourage synergies among the various medical centers
(medical, health, lab, wellness…etc.)o Stimulate collaboration between the health sector and the
emerging entrepreneurial ecosystem in Lebanon. o Regulate the ethical conduct of registered medical
practitioners. Privacy and Confidentiality of Patient Information
Professional Standard of Care and Health Services
Training and Certification of MT Agents
Medical Travel and Complication Insurance
Contributions to Compensation Fund
Potential Revenues
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020$0
$200,000,000
$400,000,000
$600,000,000
$800,000,000
$1,000,000,000
$1,200,000,000
Medical Tourist Revenue (million USD)
Tourist Revenues
Medical Revenues
RevenueMedical Expense $8,560 Tourists Per Patient 4Avg. Length of Travel 5Expense/Person $300 Total Other Costs $6,000
Year Medical Tourists Healthcare Staff Service Staff Total New Jobs
2015 16,695 83 334 4172016 26,085 130 522 6522017 40,693 203 814 10172018 51,127 256 1023 12782019 62,604 313 1252 15652020 75,125 376 1503 1878
Total 6808