20130121 - draft decision · decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 faxed letter from the therapeutic...

16

Upload: others

Post on 26-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation
Page 2: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation
Page 3: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation
Page 4: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation
Page 5: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation
Page 6: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

SCHEDULE OF DOCUMENTS

REQUEST UNDER FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 1982

Date of

document No. of pages

Description

Decision on release

1. 7/05/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 392 tablets of Viagra and 80 tablets of Cialis

Release in part s47F

2. 2/05/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 60 VigRX Plus tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

3. 2/05/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 262 Sildigra Prof tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

4. 9/05/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 72 Maximum Powerful tablets containing Sildenafil and Tadalafil

Release in part s47F

5. 9/05/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 240 Spier Tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

6. 13/06/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 24 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

7. 13/06/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 160 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

8. 13/06/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 160 Stree Overlord Capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

9. 26/06/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 170 Sildigra tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

10. 26/06/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 480 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

11. 28/06/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 400 unknown tablets found to be for the treatment of erectile dysfunction

Release in part s47F

12. 29/06/2012 4

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 320 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

13. 29/06/2012 4

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 80 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47G

14. 29/06/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 50 Satchets of Kamagra containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

15. 17/08/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 380 Filagra capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

16. 27/08/2012 4

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 600 Zhong Hau Niu Bian tablets containing Sildenafil, Tadalafil, Glibenclamide and Sibutramine

Release in part s47F

Page 7: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

Date of

document No. of pages

Description

Decision on release

17. 27/08/2012 4

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 400 black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil and 190 Tadalafil tablets and 5 satchets of Kamagra containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

18. 14/09/2012 4

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 2000 Chao Jimengnan Super Powerful Man tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

19. 24/09/2012 7 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 120 Tadalafil Tablets

Release in part s47F

20. 23/10/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 1 KG filagra sachets and 20 Filagra tablets containing Sildenafil and

Release in part s47F

21. 7/11/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 240 VigRX Plus tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

22. 26/11/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 700 Jimengnan Super Powerful Man tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

23. 4/12/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 380 Filagra tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F s4G

24. 19/12/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 164 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil and 12 Stree Overlord capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

25. 19/12/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 480 VigRX tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

26. 2/11/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 160 Counterfeit Viagra and 80 counterfeit Cialis tablets

Release in part s47F

27. 28/06/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 400 Counterfeit Viagra tablets

Release in part s47F

28. 17/08/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 480 counterfeit Viagra tablets

Release in part s47F

29. 18/01/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 100 Sachets of Kamagra containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

30. 7/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 12 Saturo capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

31. 10/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 24 Saturo capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

32. 13/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 16 Sachets of Maxman, 10 Tiger King Pills and 54 African Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

33. 13/02/2012 6

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 6 Superhard capsules containing Sildenafil and Tadalafil

Release in part s47F

34. 13/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 300 "Weili" Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil and Tadalafil

Release in part s47F

Page 8: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

Date of

document No. of pages

Description

Decision on release

35. 13/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 2680 Maxman capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

36. 13/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 60 Hard Ten Days Capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

37. 14/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 100 Tiger King tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

38. 8/03/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 100 Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil and Tadalafil

Release in part s47F

39. 9/03/2012 4

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 300 Maximum Powerful tablets containing Sildenafil and Tadalafil

Release in part s47F

40. 21/03/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 501 Sachets of Kamagra containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

41. 23/03/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 24 Saturo capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

42. 29/03/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 20 boxes of Kamagra sachets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

43. 29/03/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 720 VigRX tablets containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

44. 29/03/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 240 African Black Ant capsules containing Sildenafil and Tadalafil and 240 Stiff nights capsules containing Sildenafil

Release in part s47F

45. 27/04/2012 7

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 1000 Cialis tablets containing Tadalafil

Release in part s47F

46. 13/02/2012 5

Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation of therapeutic goods: 800 Counterfeit Viagra Tablets

Release in part s47F

47. 16/01/2013 1

Statistics obtained from Customs and Border Protection's 'Detained Goods Management System (DGMS) of seizures made under the direction of the Therapeutic Goods Administration for the calendar year 2012.

Release in full

Page 9: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

ATTACHMENT B

Relevant Legislation

Section 47F - Public interest conditional exemptions—personal privacy

(1) A document is conditionally exempt if its disclosure under this Act would involve the unreasonable disclosure of personal information about any person (including a deceased person).

(2) In determining whether the disclosure of the document would involve the unreasonable disclosure of personal information, an agency or Minister must have regard to the following matters: (a) the extent to which the information is well known; (b) whether the person to whom the information relates is known to be (or to have

been) associated with the matters dealt with in the document; (c) the availability of the information from publicly accessible sources; (d) any other matters that the agency or Minister considers relevant.

(3) Subject to subsection (5), subsection (1) does not have effect in relation to a request by a person for access to a document by reason only of the inclusion in the document of matter relating to that person. …

Section 47G - Public interest conditional exemptions—business

(1) A document is conditionally exempt if its disclosure under this Act would disclose information concerning a person in respect of his or her business or professional affairs or concerning the business, commercial or financial affairs of an organisation or undertaking, in a case in which the disclosure of the information: (a) would, or could reasonably be expected to, unreasonably affect that person

adversely in respect of his or her lawful business or professional affairs or that organisation or undertaking in respect of its lawful business, commercial or financial affairs; or

(b) could reasonably be expected to prejudice the future supply of information to the Commonwealth, Norfolk Island or an agency for the purpose of the administration of a law of the Commonwealth or of a Territory or the administration of matters administered by an agency.

(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to trade secrets or other information to which section 47 applies.

(3) Subsection (1) does not have effect in relation to a request by a person for access to a document: (a) by reason only of the inclusion in the document of information concerning that

person in respect of his or her business or professional affairs; or (b) by reason only of the inclusion in the document of information concerning the

business, commercial or financial affairs of an undertaking where the person making the request is the proprietor of the undertaking or a person acting on behalf of the proprietor; or

(c) by reason only of the inclusion in the document of information concerning the business, commercial or financial affairs of an organisation where the person making the request is the organisation or a person acting on behalf of the organisation.

(4) A reference in this section to an undertaking includes a reference to an undertaking that is carried on by, or by an authority of, the Commonwealth, Norfolk Island or a State or by a local government authority.

Page 10: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

(5) For the purposes of subsection (1), information is not taken to concern a person in respect of the person’s professional affairs merely because it is information concerning the person’s status as a member of a profession.

11B - Public interest exemptions—factors

(1) This section applies for the purposes of working out whether access to a conditionally exempt document would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest under subsection 11A(5).

(2) This section does not limit subsection 11A(5).

Factors favouring access

(3) Factors favouring access to the document in the public interest include whether access to the document would do any of the following: (a) promote the objects of this Act (including all the matters set out in sections 3 and

3A); (b) inform debate on a matter of public importance; (c) promote effective oversight of public expenditure; (d) allow a person to access his or her own personal information.

Irrelevant factors

(4) The following factors must not be taken into account in deciding whether access to the document would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest: (a) access to the document could result in embarrassment to the Commonwealth

Government, or cause a loss of confidence in the Commonwealth Government; (aa) access to the document could result in embarrassment to the Government of

Norfolk Island or cause a loss of confidence in the Government of Norfolk Island; (b) access to the document could result in any person misinterpreting or

misunderstanding the document; (c) the author of the document was (or is) of high seniority in the agency to which the

request for access to the document was made; (d) access to the document could result in confusion or unnecessary debate.

Guidelines

(5) In working out whether access to the document would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest, an agency or Minister must have regard to any guidelines issued by the Information Commissioner for the purposes of this subsection under section 93A.

Page 11: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

FO

 

OI Fact Sh

 

If you disagInformationreview if yoto informatyour requesare two wathe Australi

Internal re

If  an  agendisagree  wits  decisiondifferent agsenior level

You must  aof  the  decapplication you wish  tomake  a  revnot do  so, affirmed. 

Internal  revthe  chief  opersonally. 

Review by

The  Informoffice  holdagencies an

Is a review 

No. The Infocomplaints However,  idecision is wfor  a  reviecomplaint w

heet 12 –

Freed

gree with  thn Act 1982  (ou sought cetion that is ast or  if yourays you can aian Informat

eview 

ncy  makes ith,  you  cann.  The  reviegency officer. There is no

apply  withinision,  unlesstime. You  so  seek  an  eview  decisioits original d

view  is  notfficer  of  the

y the Inform

mation  Commder  who  cand ministers 

the same as

ormation Coabout agencf  you  are  cwrong, it wilew.  Your  mwhen a revie

Freedom

dom o

e decision othe FOI Act)ertain documbout you, if r application ask for revieion Commiss

an  FOI  decn  ask  the  agw  will  be  cr, usually somo charge for i

n  30  days  os  the  agencshould  contaextension.  Tn within  30 decision  is  c

t  available  ie  agency ma

mation Com

missioner  is n  review  thunder the FO

s a complain

ommissioner cy actions uncomplaining l be treated atter  will  bw would not

of informa

of info

of an Austral), you can a

ments and wethe agency hto have you

ew of a decissioner. 

cision  that gency  to  revcarried  out  bmeone at a mnternal revie

of  being  notcy  extended act  the agenhe  agency mdays.  If  it  d

considered  to

if  a  ministeade  the  deci

missioner

an  independhe  decisionOI Act. 

t? 

also investignder the FOI that  an  ageas an applicabe  treated  at be practica

ation: You

rmatio

lian Governmsk  for  the dere not givenhas informedur personal sion:  interna

you view by  a more ew. 

tified    the ncy  if must does o be 

er  or  ision 

dent s  of 

gates  Act. ency ation as  a l  

oifthwsa

Dre

NCaadqp

D

Nfr

H

Ya

o

p

fa

e

in

ur review r

on – Y

ment agencydecision  to bn full accessd you that itinformation al review by 

or would not f  you  were hat containswas releasedheet 13 – Frea complaint.

Do  I  have  toeview proce

No.  You mayCommissionegency’s  intgency  the  odecision,  andquickly  withoprocess. 

Do I have to p

No.  The  Inforee. 

How do I app

You must apppplication in

online:   ww

post:    GP

ax:    +6

email:   en

n person:  Le17Sy

FOI fa

rights

Your re

y or ministebe  reviewed., if someonet will imposeamended wthe agency,

address younot  consultyour person). For more ieedom of inf

o  go  throughss first? 

y  apply  direer.  Howeverternal  revieopportunity d  your  neeout  undergo

pay? 

ormation  Co

ply? 

ply in writingn one of the f

ww.oaic.gov

PO Box 2999

61 2 9284 96

nquiries@oa

vel 3,  75 Pitt Streetydney NSW 2

act she

eview

r under  the . You may we is to be grae a charge fowas not acce and extern

ur concerns (ted  about  anal informatinformation formation: H

h  the  agenc

ectly  to  the r,  going  thew  process to  reconsid

eds  may  beoing  an  exte

ommissioner

g and you canfollowing wa

v.au 

9, Canberra A

666 

aic.gov.au 

t  2000 

A

eet 12

1

rights

April 2011

Freedom ofwant  to  seekanted accessor processingepted. Thereal review by

for example,a  documention before itsee FOI fact

How to make

cy’s  internal

Informationhrough  thegives  the

er  its  initial  met  moreernal  review

’s  review  is

n lodge yourays: 

ACT 2601 

ATTACHME

s

f k s g e y 

, t  t t e 

n e e l e w 

ENT C

Page 12: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

FOOI Fact Sh

An applicatwww.oaic.ga  copy  of  tobjecting  tcontact detobjecting to

Can I get he

Yes.  The available  tanything is 

When do I h

If you are oto documena  documenCommissionof  the  decito grant accwithin 30 da

You  can  asextension oif  the  Inforeasonable 

Who will co

Staff of thethe review. FOI Commismake a dec

Does  the review my m

No.  The  Innot  to  revmisconceiveto cooperate

after  reasoagainst that

Alternativeldecide  that(AAT) wouldand  if  so, applying to 

heet 12 –

tion  form  is gov.au.  Yourthe  notice  oto  (if  one ails. You shoo the decisio

elp in comple

Information o  help  youunclear. 

have to appl

objecting  to nts, impose ant,  you  musner within 60sion.  If  you cess to anotays of being 

k  the  Informof time to apormation  Coin the circum

onduct the re

 InformationOnly the Infssioner or thision at the e

Informatiomatter? 

nformation view  an  aped or  lackinge with the pr

onable  attet decision. 

ly  the  Infort  the  Admid be better pwill  advise the AAT. Th

Freedom

available onr  applicationof  the  decisiwas  provid

ould also set n. 

eting the ap

Commissiou  with  you

ly? 

a decision  ta charge or st  apply  to 0 days of beare  objectinther person,notified of t

mation Commply, and thisommissioner mstances. 

eview? 

n Commissioformation Cohe Privacy Coend of the re

n  Commiss

Commissionpplication  thg  in substanrocess or can

empts.  You 

rmation  Coministrative  Aplaced to revyou  of  theis will not be

of informa

n  the websitn  should  incon  that  youded),  and out why you

plication? 

oner’s  staff r  applicatio

to  refuse acrefuse to amthe  Informaeing given nong  to  a  deciyou must ahat decision

missioner  fos may be graconsiders 

oner will conommissionerommissionereview. 

sioner  have

ner  may  dehat  is  frivolce, or  if younot be contacannot  ap

mmissioner Appeals  Tribview the mae  proceduree common. 

ation: You

te at clude u  are your  u are 

are on  if 

ccess  mend ation otice ision  apply n. 

or  an nted it  is 

duct r, the r can 

e  to 

ecide  lous, u  fail acted ppeal 

may bunal atter, e  for 

C

Ybd

W

TamcIn

oth

MsSdateh

W

Tcaso

thth

C

YCae

Wdb

Yfremhb

ur review r

Can I withdra

Yes. An applicbefore  the  Indecision. 

What happen

The review ps  possible. may  contact larify mattenformation C

or minister tohe reasons g

Most  reviewsubmissions aometimes  tdecide  to  hopplies.  Partielephone. If hearing may 

Will there be

There  may  ban  join  othepplication. Fomeone else

hat concernshe review. 

Can someone

Yes,  includingCommissionernd  cost‐effencourage leg

Will  the  Infodocuments,  ibe exempt?

Yes.  The  Inforesh decisionxamined,  incminister has dave occurred

be considered

rights

aw my applic

cation can benformation 

ns in the rev

rocess is desThe  Infor

you or  any rs  and  seek ommissioner

o provide reagiven were in

s will  be maand papers phe  Informatold  a  hearines may  partconfidentialbe held part

 other partie

be.  The  Infoer  parties wFor example,e being grant

s you, that p

e else repres

g a  lawyer. Hr prefers the ective  as  pgal representa

ormation  Coincluding on

rmation  Comn, so all the recluding documdeclined to red since  the od. 

cation? 

e withdrawnCommission

view process

signed to bermation  Coof  the othemore  infor

r may also as

asons for thenadequate. 

ade  on  the provided by tion  Commisg  if  one  of ticipate  in  al matters arely or wholly 

es to the rev

ormation  Cowho  are  affe,  if you are ted access to

person may 

sent me? 

However,  theprocess to bepossible  andation. 

ommissionernes  that are

mmissioner’selevant matements that thelease. Develoriginal decis

2

n at any timener makes  a

e as informalommissionerer parties  tomation.  Thesk the agency

eir decision if

basis  of  thethe parties.ssioner maythe  parties

a  hearing  bye raised, thein private. 

view? 

ommissionerected  by  theobjecting  too  information

be  joined  in

  Informatione as informald  does  not

r  look  at  alle  claimed  to

review  is  aerial must behe agency oropments that

ion may also

2

e a 

l r  o e y f 

e . y s y e 

r e o n n 

n l t 

l o 

a e r t o 

Page 13: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

FO

 

OI Fact Sh

What powehave? 

While  the informal, thpowers  to or  documeanswer  quaffirmation 

An  agency undertake f

What decismake? After  revieCommission

set the

affirm 

vary th

The Informathe decision

Will the dec

Yes.  The  Idecisions omaterial  thNor will  thethat personreason to p

heet 12 –

ers does the

review  prhe Informatiorequire  anyoents,  to  comuestions  anthat their an

or  ministefurther searc

ions can the

ewing  a  dner must do 

e decision asid

the decision

he decision.  

ation Commn. 

cision be ma

nformation n the websitat  is not  rele  name of  tn requests otublish it. 

Freedom

e Informatio

rocess  is  don Commissone  to prodmpel  anyonnd  to  takenswers will b

er  can  also ches for docu

e Informatio

decision,  thone of three

de and make 

n, or  

issioner will 

ade public? 

Commissionte. Exempt meased) will nthe  review  atherwise or t

of informa

n Commissio

designed  toioner has foduce  informae  to  attende  an  oathbe true. 

be  ordereduments. 

n Commissio

he  Informae things: 

a fresh decis

give reason

ner  will  pumaterial  (thanot be  incluapplicant, unthere is a sp

ation: You

oner 

o  be rmal ation d  to h  or 

d  to 

oner 

ation 

sion  

s for 

blish at  is, ded. nless ecial 

WC

YCpisecfi

F2

TaFmthp

Ytha

Tg

ur review r

What can I dCommissione

You  can  appCommissionerproceedings. Ts  $777  (at  Nxemptions foard  holders inancial hards

FOI  applicat2010 

The  Informatigency’s or mOI  request  omade your FOhe decision wprocess is diff

You must firsthe decision. Yre not satisfie

The  informatieneral nature

For fut

emwrite: GPor visit o

rights

o if I disagreer’s review d

peal  to  the r  will  not The fee for loNovember  20or health careand  the  AATship grounds

tions made

on Commissinister’s FOI don  or  after  1OI request bewas made aferent. 

t ask the agenYou may thened with the d

on provided e. It is not a s

urther ielephone: 1ail: enquiriePO Box 2999our website a

ee with the decision? 

  AAT.  The be  a  part

odging an AA010),  althouge and pensioAT  can  waives. 

e  before  1 

sioner  can ondecision if yo1 November efore 1 Novemfter  that date

ncy for internn appeal to thdecision. 

  in  this  fact substitute for

inform1300 363 [email protected], Canberra Aat www.oai

3

Information

Informationy  to  thoseT applicationgh  there  aren concessione  the  fee  on

November

nly  review anou made your2010.  If  youmber, even ife,  the  review

nal review ofhe AAT if you

sheet  is of  ar legal advice

ation 2  v.au  ACT 2601 ic.gov.au

3

n e n e n n 

n r u f w 

f u 

a . 

Page 14: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

FO

OI Fact Sh

Free

You  may about  howthe  FreedoAct.  If  yodocuments  Disagree w

If  you  disadecision onhave  the  rYou  can  asinternally. Informationor  ministerFreedom  ofor more inf

If  you  are has handledInformation

What are tCommissio

The  Informa  complainan  FOI  reqtook  undeCommissionabout a min

In  conductiCommission

make in

obtain i

take podocume

heet 13 –

edom

complain w  an  Ausom  of  Infoou  are  uns, you shou

with an FOI 

agree  with  an your  requeright  to  havsk  an  agencYou  also  han Commissior’s  decision.of  informatiformation ab

concerned  ad your matten Commissio

the powersoner? 

mation  Commnt  about  hquest,  or  oer  the  FOner  cannot nister. 

ing  the  invener has the p

nquiries of an

information 

ossession of, ents. 

How to m

of info

to  the  Astralian  Goormation  Ahappy  withld ask for th

decision? 

an  agency’sest under  thve  the  deciscy  to  reviewave  the  rigoner to revie.  See  FOI  Fon  –  Your bout the rev

about  the wer, you can cner. 

s of the Info

missioner  cahow  an  agother  actionI  Act.  Theinvestigate

estigation  thpower to: 

n agency 

from any pe

or inspect, a

ake a com

ormatio

Australian overnment Act  1982 (th  the  agehe decision 

  or  ministee FOI Act, ysion  reviewew  its  decisiht  to  ask  tew an agencyFact  Sheet review  righiew process.

way  an  agenomplain to t

ormation 

an  investigaency  handlns  the  agene  Informati  a  compla

he  Informati

rson 

any relevant 

mplaint

on – H

Informatioagency  hathe  FOI  Aency’s  decito be revie

er’s you ed.  on the y’s  12 hts  . 

ncy  the 

ate  ed  ncy  on int 

on 

If incothco

W

AnacYoun

W

YoCoreco

BeCodiIninyonoto

How to

on  Commisandled  a ct)  or  toosion  aboutwed, which

the  Informvestigate yoomplained  ahe  complainonducts inve

Who can ma

ny  person  cctions of an aou  do  not  nnder the FOI

When should

ou  can ommissionerelates  to  anomplaint at a

efore  makinommissionerrectly  to  trformation  Cvestigate yoour  concernsot  given  theo deal with yo

FOI fa

make

ssioner  if request  fok  any  othet  giving  orh is a separa

mation  Comour complainbout  will  bent.  The  Infostigations of

ke a compl

can  make  aagency in reneed  to  haveAct. 

d I make a c

complain r  at  any  tin  FOI  requeany stage of t

ng  a  complar,  you  shoury  to  resolvCommissioneour complains  first with  te  agency  a our complain

act she

a com

Octo

you  haveor  documeer  action  ur  refusing ate process.

mmissioner nt,  the agene  notified  inormation  Cof complaints 

laint? 

a  complaintelation to an e  requested

complaint?

to  the me.  If  youest  you  canthe process.

aint  to  the uld  contact ve  your  coer  may  decnt  if you havthe agency oreasonable nt. 

A

eet 13

1

mplaint

ober 2010

e  concernsents  underunder  thataccess  to

decides  tocy you haven  writing  ofommissionerin private. 

t  about  theFOI activity.  documents

 

Informationr  complaintn  make  the 

Informationthe  agencyncerns.  Thecide  not  toe not raisedor you haveopportunity

ATTACHME

t

0

s  r  t  o  

o e f  r 

e . s 

n t e 

n y e o d e y  

ENT D

Page 15: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

FOOI Fact Sh

How do I m

Your  compspecify  theYou  can  sthe  detailscomplaint  fat www.oai

If  you  neecontact  usto enquiries

What informcomplaint?

To  help  tthe  best please  proas  possiblecomplaint would like t

Is there a fe

No.  There complaint t

What will 

An  officer  ocontact  youwill  be  kepcomplaint a

Before  deccomplaint make  prelihave compl

If  the  Infoinvestigate will write  toto assist wit

heet 13 –

make a com

plaint  must   agency  yosend  your s  at  the  enform  is  alsoc.gov.au. 

ed  help  we s  on  1300 [email protected]

mation do I n? 

the  Informaconsiderati

ovide  as  mue.  Be  clear and  what to see as a re

ee for makin

are  no  coso the Inform

happen to 

of  the  Inforu  to  discusspt  informed along the wa

ciding  whetthe  Informminary  inquained about

ormation  Cyour  comp

o  the agencyth the invest

How to m

mplaint? 

be  in  writu  are  compcomplaint 

nd  of  this   available  o

can  assist 363  992 

au. 

need to put 

ation  Common  to  youuch  relevanabout  the  iaction  or esult. 

ng a complai

sts  involvedmation Comm

my compla

mation  Coms  your  compof  the  proy. 

ther  to  invation  Commuiries  of  tht. 

Commissioneplaint,  the y and requetigation. 

ake a com

ing  and  muplaining  aboto  us  usifact  sheet. n  our webs

you.  You  cor  by  em

in the 

missioner  giur  complaint  informatiissues  in  yooutcome  y

nt? 

  in  makingmissioner. 

int? 

mmissioner wplaint  and  yogress  of  yo

vestigate  yomissioner  me  agency  y

er  decides Commission

est  informati

mplaint

ust ut.  ing  A ite 

can mail 

ive  nt,  on  our you  

g  a 

will you our 

our may you 

to ner  on 

Cain

Yenoin

If inCoth

H

Inininyothsuagwin

an the Informnvestigate m

es.  The  Infoot  to  invevestigation, 

your compaction und

it  is moreto  anotheCommonw

it  is moredecision to

the  agencwith  yourdealing wi

your  comsubstance

you  do  nmatter. 

the  Informavestigate  orommissionerhe reasons fo

ow will my

  some  casevestigation   the  agenou  have  cohe  Informauggestions gency  shouldill be notifievestigation.

mation Comy complaint

rmation  Comstigate,  or if: 

plaint does nder the FOI A

e  appropriater  body  (sucwealth Ombu

e appropriateo be reviewe

cy  you  compr  complaint, ith it 

mplaint  is e or not made

not  have  su

ation  Commr  discontinuer will  notify or this in writ

complaint 

es  the  Inforand  inte

ncy  addresomplained  ation  Commor  recommd  implemened  in writing

missioner de? 

mmissioner may  disc

not concern Act 

te  for  you  tch  as  the  agudsman) 

e  for you  toed 

plained  abouor  is  in  the

frivolous, e in good fai

ufficient  inte

missioner  deces  an  investyou  and  thting. 

be resolve

rmation  Comervention  msing  the about.  In  omissioner mendations nt.  You  and g of  the outc

2

ecide not to 

may  decideontinue  an

an agency’s

to  complaingency  or  the

o ask  for  the

ut  has  dealte  process  of

lacking  inith 

erest  in  the

cides  not  totigation,  thee  agency  of

d? 

mmissioner’smay  resultissues  thatother  casesmay  makethat  the

the  agencycome of  the

2

e n 

n  e 

t f 

o e f 

s t  t  s  e e  y e 

Page 16: 20130121 - Draft Decision · Decision on release 1. 7/05/2012 5 Faxed letter from the Therapeutic Goods Administration requesting the application of the Customs Act 1901 to the importation

FOOI Fact Sh

If  an  aand  appany  recoCommissionimplementathe  agencyto  implemInformationwritten  repthe  agencyParliament.

Your  nameunless  therfirst consult

Investigati

The  Comminvestigate agencies uncomplainedinvestigatedthe  OmbudCommissioninvestigatednot  to  inrelevant  doInformation

heet 13 –

gency  failropriate  aommendationer  may ation  noticey  to  explainment  the n  Commissioport  to  the y,  and  the  

e  will  not  bre  is  a  spected. 

ion by the O

monwealth complaints

nder the FOId  about  eithd  by  the  Indsman  will ner  to  avoidd  twice.  If nvestigate, ocuments mn Commissio

How to m

s  to  takaction  to ons,  the 

issue e.  This  no  what  actiorecommen

oner  may  aminister  rereport  will 

be  included cial  reason  a

Ombudsma

Ombudsmas  about  act Act. Howevher  could  benformation  Cconsult  th

d  the  same the  Ombudthe  complust  be  tranner. 

ake a com

ke  adequaimplemeInformatia  form

otice  requiron  it  will  tadations.  Talso  provideesponsible  fbe  tabled 

in  the  repoand  you  we

an 

an  can  altion  taken ver, if the isse  or  has  beCommissione  Informatimatter  bei

dsman  decidaint  and sferred  to  t

mplaint

ate ent  on mal res  ake  The e  a for  in 

ort ere  

lso by sue een er, on ing des all  the 

ThtoapOcoabwyo

 

Thge

he  Informatio  the Ombudppropriately mbudsman. omplaint  is  obout an ageill be commour complain

he  informatioeneral nature

For futele

emaiwrite: GPO

o

on Commissdsman a com

be  inThis  could 

only  one  pancy’s actionson. You will nt is transferr

on provided e. It is not a su

rther inephone: 1il: enquiriesO Box 2999,or visit our wwww.oaic

sioner  can  amplaint  that nvestigated   occur  wheart  of  a wides.  It  is unlik be notified red. 

in  this  fact  substitute for 

nforma300 363 [email protected], Canberra Awebsite at c.gov.au

3

also  transfercould moreby  the

ere  the  FOIer  grievanceely  that  thisin writing  if

sheet  is of  alegal advice.

ation 2 v.au ACT 2601 

3

r e e I e s f