3

LIST OF CASES Civil law Review 1Philippine Christian University 2014-2015Prof. Viviana Martin-Paguirigan

CASE TITLECITATIONTanada vs. Tuvera 136 SCRA 27Tanada vs. Tuvera146 SCRA 446Philsa vs. CA356 SCRA 174Unciano Paramedical vs. CA221 SCRA 285Cui vs. Arellano University2 SCRA 205People vs. Jabinal 55 SCRA 607Van Dorn vs. Romillo139 SCRA 139Quita vs. CA300 SCRA 406 Catalan v. BraganzaFeb. 6, 2007San Luis v. San LuisFeb. 6, 2007Bayot v. BayotNov. 7, 2008Aznar vs. Garcia 7 SCRA 95Testate Estate of Bohanan vs. Bohanan106 Phil. 997Bellis vs. Bellis 20 SCRA 358Llorente vs. CA345 SCRA 592 HUMAN RELATIONS

Velayo vs. Shell Co. Phils.100 SCRA 186Albenson vs. CA217 SCRA 16Globe Mackay vs. CA176 SCRA 778Barons Mktg. vs. CA286 SCRA 96MWSS v. Act Theater June 17, 2004Carpio v. ValmonteSept. 9, 2004RCPI vs. CA143 SCRA 657Garcia v. SalvadorMarch 20, 2007Meralco vs. CA157 SCA 243Custodio vs. CA253 SCRA 483Gashem vs. CA219 SCRA 115Rellosa vs. PellosisAugust 9, 2001NPC vs. Philipp BrothersNovember 20, 2001Frenzel vs. CatitoJuly 11, 2003Reyes vs. LimAugust 11, 2003NDC vs. Madrigal Wan HaiSeptember 30, 2003Padilla vs. CA 129 SCRA 558

(See Sections 1,2, & 3 of Rule 111, Rules on Criminal Procedure as amended, effective December 1, 2000)

PREJUDICIAL QUESTION

Donato vs. Luna 160 SCRA 441Quiambao vs. Osorio158 SCRA 674Apa vs. Fernandez242 SCRA 509Beltran vs. PeopleJune 20, 2000Spouses Pahang v. MetrobankJuly 12, 2004

(See Sections 5 & 6 of Rule 111, Rules on Criminal Procedure, as amended effective December 1, 2000)

CIVIL PERSONALITY

Geluz vs. CA2 SCRA 801

CITIZENSHIP

Mercado vs. Comelec307 SCRA 630Republic v. Chule Lim Jan. 13, 2004

(See Article IV, Sections 1 to 5, 1987 Constitution)

MARRIAGE

Balogbog v. CA269 SCRA 259Vda. De Jacob vs. CA312 SCRA 772Republic vs. CA 236 SCRA 257Silverio vs. RepublicOct. 19, 2007Sy vs. CA330 SCRA 550Sevilla v. CardenasJuly 31, 2006Mallion v. AlcantaraOctober 31, 2006Navarro vs. Domagtoy259 SCRA 129Beso vs. Daguman323 SCRA 566Republic v. IyoySept. 21, 2005Republic v. Orbecido October 5, 2005Corpuz v. Sto. TomasAugust 11, 2010Atienza vs. Brillantes 243 SCRA 32Borja-Manzano vs. Sanchez(Art. 34) Mar. 8, 2001

VOID MARRIAGES

Suntay vs. Cojuangco-Suntay 300 SCRA 760Ninal vs. Bayadog 328 SCRA 122Ty vs. CA 346 SCRA 86Terre vs. Terre 211 SCRA 6

See: Rules on Declaration of Absolute Nullity of Void Marriages and Annulment of Voidable Marriages effective March 15, 2003

PSYCHOLOGICAL INCAPACITY

Santos vs. CA240 SCRA 23Ching Ming Tsoi vs. CA 266 SCRA 324Republic vs. Molina268 SCRA 198Barcelona v. BengzonSept. 24, 2003Marcos vs. Marcos343 SCRA 755Republic v. HamanoMay 20, 2004Dedel v. DedelJan. 29, 2004Siayngco v. SiayngcoOct. 27, 2004Villalon v. VillalonNov. 18, 2005Ferraris v. FerrarisJuly 17, 2006Antonio v. ReyesMarch 10, 2006Paz v. PazFeb 18, 2010Suazo v. SuazoMarch 10, 2010Domingo vs. CA226 SCRA 573Beltran vs. People(Art. 40)334 SCRA 106Bobis vs. Bobis(Art. 40) 336 SCRA 747Mercado vs. Tan 337 SCRA 122Morigo v. PeopleFeb. 6, 2004Calisterio vs. Calisterio(Art. 41)330 SCRA 201Republic vs. Nolasco220 SCRA 21Republic v. AlegroDec. 9, 2005Republic vs. LorinoJan. 19, 2005Manuel v. PeopleNov. 9, 2005Ty v. CA346 SCRA 87Carino vs. Carino351 SCRA 131

VOIDABLE MARRIAGES

Anaya vs. Paraloan 36 SCRA 97Aquino vs. Delizo 109 Phil. 21Jimenez vs. Republic109 Phil. 273

LEGAL SEPARATION

Ocampo vs. Florenciano 107 Phil. 35Brown vs. Yambao 102 Phil. 168Lerma vs. CA 61 SCRA 440Bugayong vs. Gines 100 SCRA 616Laperal vs. Republic 6 SCRA 357Ong v. Ong Oct. 23, 2006

See: Rule on Legal Separation effective March 15, 2003

RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS BETWEEN HUSBAND & WIFE:

Arroyo vs. Arroyo42 Phil. 54Pelayo vs. Lauron 12 Phil. 453Ilusorio vs. Ilusorio 332 SCRA 169Goitia vs. Campos-Rueda35 Phil. 252

PROPERTY RELATIONS

Jocson vs. CA170 SCRA 333Toda vs. CA153 SCRA 713Wong vs. CA200 SCRA 792Belcodero vs. CA227 SCRA 303Valdez vs. RTC 260 SCRA 221Estonina vs. CA266 SCRA 627Ayala Investment vs. CA286 SCRA 272Guiang vs. CA291 SCRA 372Ferrer v. FerrerNovember 9, 2006Alinas v. AlinasApril 14, 2008Docena vs. LapesuraMarch 28, 2001Manalo vs. CamaisaJanuary 21, 2002Carlos vs. AbelardoApril 9, 2002Relucio vs. LopezJanuary 16, 2002Homeowners Savings Bank v. DailoMarch 11, 2005In Re Separation of Prop. Of MullerAugust 29, 2006Agapay vs. Palang (Art. 148)276 SCRA 341Tumlos vs. Fernandez( Art. 148)330 SCRA 718Mallilin vs. Castillo(Art. 148)333 SCRA 628Fehr v. FehrOctober 23, 2003Saguid v. ReyJune 10, 2003Atienza v. De CastroNov. 29, 2006

THE FAMILY AS AN INSTITUTION

Hontiveros vs. RTC Br. 25, Iloilo309 SCRA 340 Guerrero vs. RTC of Ilocos229 SCRA 274Hiyas Savings Bank v. MorenoAugust 31, 2006

(See Section 22 & 25, Rule 130, Rules on Evidence)

Modequillo vs. Breva185 SCRA 766Manacop vs. CA215 SCRA 773Versola v. OngJuly 31, 2006Patricio v. Dario IIINov. 20, 2006

PATERNITY AND FILIATION

Andal vs. Macaraig89 Phil. 165Babiera vs. Catotal 333 SCRA 487Benitez-Badua vs. CA229 SCRA 468Jao vs. CA152 SCRA 359Ilano vs. CA230 SCRA 242Tayag vs. CA209 SCRA 665Fernandez vs. CA230 SCRA 130Cabatania v. RegodosOct. 21, 2004Sayson vs. CA205 SCRA 321Liyao vs. Liyao378 SCRA 563De Jesus vs. Estate of Dizon366 SCRA 499Concepcion v. AlmonteAugust 31, 2005Tijingvs. CA (DNA)G.R. 125901354 SCRA 17Agustin v. ProllamanteJune 15, 2005In Re Change of Name of Julian LinMar. 30, 2005Briones v. MiguelOct. 18, 2004De Santos vs. Angeles251 SCRA 200Republic v. CapoteFeb. 2, 2007

ADOPTION

Republic vs. CA205 SCRA 356Cang vs. CA296 SCRA 128Cervantes vs. Fajardo169 SCRA 575Tamargo vs. CA209 SCRA 519Lahom vs. SibuloJuly 14, 2003In re Petition for Adoption of StephanieAstorgaMar. 31, 2005

SUPPORT

Lacson v. LacsonAugust 28, 2006

PARENTAL AUTHORITY

David vs. CA250 SCRA 82Libi vs. IAC214 SCRA 16Espiritu vs. CA242 SCRA 362Santos vs. CA242 SCRA 407Perez vs. CA (Custody)255 SCRA 661Vancil vs. Belmes(G.R. 132223)358 SCRA 707St. Marys Academy vs. Carpitanos376 SCRA 473

CASES IN PROPERTYLeung vs. Strong Machinery37 Phil. 644DBP vs. CA253 SCRA 414Republic vs. Guzman326 SCRA 574Mendoza v. AlinasFeb. 6, 2007Isaguirre vs. De Lara332 SCRA 803Geminiano vs. CA259 SCRA 344Tecnogas vs. CA2-10-97Pleasantville vs. CA253 SCRA 10Benitez vs. CA266 SCRA 242Evadel Realty vs. Soriano 4-20-01 Nazareno vs. CA257 SCRA 589Navarro vs. IAC2-12-97Robles vs. CA328 SCRA 97De Aviles vs. CA(quieting)264 SCRA 473Del Campo vs. CA351 SCRA 1Rodil Enterprises vs. CA(ownership) November 29, 2001Seraspi vs. CA331 SCRA 293Catapusan vs. CA264 SCRA 534Verdad vs. CA256SCRA593Tabuso vs. CA6-21-01Cequena vs. Bolante330 SCRA 216Quimen vs. CA257 SCRA 163Valley Land vs. Valley Golf November 15, 2001Spouses Sta. Maria vs. CA285 SCRA 351Cristobal vs. CA291 SCRA 122Camarines Norte Elec. vs. CA345 SCRA 85Villanueva vs. Velasco346 SCRA 99Costabella vs. CA193 SCRA 332Encarnacion vs. CA195 SCRA 74Dionisio vs. Ortiz204 SCRA 745Cabatingan vs. CabatinganJune 5, 2002Gonzales vs. CA (donation)June 18, 2001Republic vs. Silim (Acceptance) April 2, 2001Quilala vs. Alcantara (inter vivos) December 3, 2001Roman Catholic vs. CA198 SCRA 300Republic vs. Guzman326 SCRA 90Gestopa vs. CA342 SCRA 105Noceda vs. CA313 SCRA 504Imperial vs. CA316 SCRA 393Eduarte v. CA253 SCRA 391City of Angeles vs. CA261 SCRA 90

CASES IN SUCCESSIONUson vs. Del Rosario 92 Phil. 531Coronel vs. Court of Appeals263 SCRA 15Litonjua vs. Montilla 90 Phil. 757Ledesma vs. McLachlin66 Phil. 547DKC Holdings vs. CA329 SCRA 66Aruego vs. CA254 SCRA 711Lorenzo vs. Posadas 64 Phil. 353Castaneda vs. Alemany 3 Phil. 426In Re Will of Riosa 39 Phil 23Enriquez vs. Abadia 95 SCRA 627Miciano vs. Brimo 50 Phil. 867Bellis vs. Bellis 20 SCRA 358Bugnao vs. Ubag 14 Phil 163Bagtas vs. Paguio 22 Phil. 227Neyra vs. Neyra 76 Phil. 333Acop vs. Piraso 52 Phil. 660Jaboneta vs. Gustilo 5 Phil. 541Avera vs. Garcia 42 Phil. 145Icasiano vs. Icasiano 11 SCRA 423Cagro vs. Cagro 92 Phil. 1033Nera vs. Rimandi 18 Phil. 450Caneda vs. CA 222 SCRA 781Cruz vs. Villasor 54 SCRA 31Labrador vs. CA 184 SCRA 170Ajero vs. CA 236 SCRA 488Kalaw vs. Relova 132 SCRA 237Perez vs. Tolete 232 SCRA 722Testate Estate of Bohanan 106 Phil 997Aznar vs. Garcia 7 SCRA 95Unson vs. Abella 43 Phil. 494Testate Estate of Maloto 158 SCRA 451Molo vs. Molo 90 Phil. 37Tolentino vs. Francisco 57 Phil. 749Mercado vs. Santos 66 Phil. 215Testate Estate of Biascan vs. Biascan 347 SCRA 621Nuguid vs. Nuguid 17 SCRA 449Caniza vs. CA 268 SCRA 641Pecson vs. Coronel 45 Phil. 216Acain vs. IAC 155 SCRA 101Neri vs. Akutin 74 Phil. 185Viado Non vs. Court of Appeals 325 SCRA 652Perez vs. Garchitorena 54 Phil 431Rabadilla vs. CA 334 SCRA 522Morente vs. dela Santa 9 Phil. 387Rosales vs. Rosales 148 SCRA 69Francisco vs. Alfonso G.R. No. 138774 March 8, 2001 Nieva vs. Alcala 41 Phil. 915Florentino vs. Florentino 40 Phil. 480Solivio vs. CA 182 SCRA 119Sumaya vs. IAC 201 SCRA 178De Papa vs. Camacho 144 SCRA 281Llorente vs. Rodriguez 10 Phil. 585Pecson vs. Mediavillo 28 Phil. 81Dorotheo vs. CA 320 SCRA 12Heirs of Uriarte vs. CA 284 SCRA 511Sayson vs. CA 205 SCRA 321Bagunu vs. Piedad 347 SCRA 571Diaz vs. IAC 182 SCRA 427Dela Puerta vs. CA 181 SCRA 861Pascual vs. Bautista 207 SCRA 561Manuel vs. Ferrer 247 SCRA 476Verdad vs. CA 256 SCRA 593Cacho vs. Udan 13 SCRA 693Sarita vs. Candia 23 Phil. 443Abellana de Bacayo vs. Borromeo 14 SCRA 986Bicomong vs. Almanza 80 SCRA 421City of Manila vs. Archbishop 36 Phil. 815Torres vs. Lopez 49 Phil. 504Nepomuceno vs. IAC 139 SCRA 206Pastor vs. CA 122 SCRA 885Sanchez vs. CA 279 SCRA 647Nazareno vs. CA 343 SCRA 637Zaragosa vs. CA 341 SCRA 309Mendoza vs. CA 199 SCRA 778Aznar Brothers Realty vs. CA 327 SCRA 359Ralla vs. Untalan 172 SCRA 858Balanay vs. Martinez 64 SCRA 452Plan vs. IAC 135 SCRA 270Bicarme vs. CA 186 SCRA 294

Civ1-list of cases 1st 2014