2016-01-04 plaintiff's 56.1 answer (flores v doj) (foia) (stamped)

7/21/2019 2016-01-04 Plaintiff's 56.1 Answer (Flores v DOJ) (FOIA) (Stamped)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2016-01-04-plaintiffs-561-answer-flores-v-doj-foia-stamped 1/33

!"#$%& ($)$%( &#($*#+$ +,!*$

%)($%*" &#($*#+$ ,- "%. /,*0

#$%&' (#$)*'+

!"#$%&$'' +

,-

%.&/*0 '/1/*' 0*21)/3*./ $(

4%'/&5*+

()')%*#%& -

678598:;:< =4>?=)#3?

12)#"$#--3( &#(1!$% ,- )"& )"(.%* $,

&%-%"&)"$3( 2,+)2 +#4#2 *!2% 5678 ($)$%9%"$

2@AB@CDE EF )@GH 7;-6 FI EJH #FKCG 5L,LG )@GHB FI EJH %-'- 0LBEALKE 5F@AE IFA .HM

NFAOPB BF@EJHAD CDQ HCBEHAD QLBEALKEB+ 2GCLDELII #F@LB (GFAHB =R2GCLDELIIS FA R(GFAHBS?

QLBT@EHB BECEHUHDEB UCQH VW 0HIHDQCDE %-'- 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH =EJH R0$4S FA EJH

R>F,HADUHDES? EJCE EJHAH CAH RDF XHD@LDHS LBB@HB EF VH EALHQ CDQ+ LDBEHCQ+ UCOHB EJFBH

QLBT@EHB ODFMD JHAHLD CDQ BHEB IFAEJ CQQLELFDCG BECEHUHDEB FI UCEHALCG ICKEB+ D@UVHAHQ

EF CDBMHA 0HIHDQCDEPB 'ECEHUHDE+ MLEJ CQQLELFDCG BECEHUHDEB+ CB IFGGFMBY

)7 1:;<=><??3@ *ABCA@> ?DE #=?DEF;><D= ;=G -,#) *ABCA@>

6- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ FEJHA EJCD EF BTHKLIW EJCE EJH

1BBLBECDE %-'- 1EEFADHW LD Z@HBELFD LB 1DXHGC >HFAXH =R>HFAXHS?- ='LDXJ 0HKG-+ *[- . CE 6?-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- (?- /JH AHGCEHQ H8UCLG H[KJCDXH JCB VHHD ILGHQ LD EJH QFKOHE FI EJLB KCBH-

=0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?-

:- 2GCLDELII QLBT@EHB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VW TFLDELDX F@E EJCE Y

Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 23 Filed 01/04/16 of 33 PageID #: 392



8 : 8

C- &D EJH 3CAKJ :<+ :\6] H8UCLG =EJH R(LABE *8UCLG )HZ@HBES?+

2GCLDELII AHZ@HBEHQ LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E Y

=L?- ^JW EJH 0$4 MCB UCOLDX EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB C

TALFALEW+ CDQ MJCE MCB EJH 0$4 EAWLDX EF CKJLH,H VW EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI

CKEL,LBEB+ LDKG@QLDX #E- 5JFL _

=LL?- ^JW EJH 0$4 MF@GQ DFE AHIHA EF #E- 0CDLHG 5JFL =R#E-

5JFLS? VW JLB %-'- ULGLECAW BHA,LKH ACDO _ CDQ

=LLL?- 1BOLDX IFA EJH QLBKGFB@AH FI EJH K@U@GCEL,H KFBE FI EJH

>F,HADUHDEPB TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ MJLKJ+ KFGGHKEL,HGW VHKCUH C

IACUHMFAO FI Z@HBELFDB EJCE GCEHA VHKCUH EJH IF@DQCELFD FI EJH ($&1

AHZ@HBE QCEHQ ]\ 1TALG :\6] =EJH R(LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBES?- =0OE- .F- 6:+

*[- 1 EF *[- & FI *[- 5?-

V- /JH 0$4 DH,HA CDBMHAHQ EJH EJAHH AHZ@HBEB LD EJH (LABE *83CLG

)HZ@HBE- =0OE- .F- 67 ]6?-

]- 2GCLDELII QLBT@EHB EJLB BECEHUHDE _ EJH %-'- 1EEFADHWPB $IILKH LD EJH

0LBEALKE FI 5FG@UVLC MCB DFE BFGHGW LD KJCAXH FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ BLDKH GCM

HDIFAKHUHDE CAAHBEHQ #E- 5JFL CDQ >HFAXH CDQaFA FEJHA TAFBHK@EFAB TAFBHK@EHQ #E- 5JFL

VCBHQ FD ^JLEH bF@BH LDIFAUCELFD BHDE VW cALCD cFDQ CDQ FEJHA LDIFAUCELFD CDQ GHXCG

CDCGWBLB TAF,LQHQ VW FEJHA *[HK@EL,H cACDKJ CXHDKLHB+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ EF+ EJH

.CELFDCG 2CAO 'HA,LKH CDQ EJH %-'- 0HTCAEUHDE FI EJH &DEHALFA- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- bb =EJH

R^JLEH bF@BH HUCLGS?+ *[- > CE /CV c =EJH R5CTE- >@QQHULPB .F,HUVHA :: HUCLGS?+ CDQ *[-

> CE /CV 1 =EJH R3WHAB UHUF =HUCLG?S??-

d- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF CQQ Y

C- /JH 0$4 DH,HA CDBMHAHQ EJH 1TALG 6\+ :\6] H8UCLG =EJH

R'HKFDQ *8UCLG )HZ@HBES?- =0OE- .F- 67 ]:?-

V- /JH AHGCEHQ H8UCLG H[KJCDXH JCB VHHD ILGHQ LD EJH QFKOHE FI EJLB

KCBH- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?-

7- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE- / JH AHGCEHQ H8UCLG H[KJCDXH

JCB VHHD ILGHQ LD EJH QFKOHE FI EJLB KCBH- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?-




8 ] 8

;- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

<- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ DFELDX EJCE EJH CQQAHBB @BHQ VW

2GCLDELII EF CQQAHBB EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MCB TAF,LQHQ EF 2GCLDELII VW EJH 0$4+ EJCE

^LGGLCU 3LGGHA MCB EJH 2@VGLK &DIFAUCELFD $IILKHA =R3LGGHAS?+ CDQ EJCE 3LGGHA MAFEH EF

2GCLDELII EJCE EJH *[HK@EL,H $IILKH IFA %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWB =EJH R*$%'1S? R+$"" -)./0%*

&0 102- -)32).& *$-)4&"1 S =HUTJCBLB CQQHQ?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- 0 EF *[- & FI *[- 5?-

C- 2ALFA EF EJH ILGLDX FI EJLB CKELFD+ EJH *$%'1 DH,HA AHBTFDQHQ EF

EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE QLAHKEGW EF (GFAHB- =0OE- .F- 67 7\?-

e 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ BLDKH 2GCLDELII UCQH BH,HACG AHZ@HBEB

IFA LDIFAUCELFD+ CB IFGGFMB Y

C- 1GG AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG VCBLB FI

TAFBHK@ELDX CKEL,LBEB+ MJF HDXCXH LD TAFEHBEB+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ+ EF

AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD AHXCAQLDX Y

=L? MJCE OLDQ FI CKEL,LBEB UCW VH ECAXHEHQ IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+

JFM UCDW CKEL,LBEB JC,H VHHD ECAXHEHQ IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+ MJCE CAH EJH

DCUHB FI B@KJ CKEL,LBEB+ CDQ MJLKJ 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FIILKLCGB

CTTAF,HQ FI B@KJ TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB _

=LL? MJHEJHA EJH DCE@AH CDQ T@ATFBH FI TAFBHK@ELFD FI

CKEL,LBEB UCW VH CXXAHBBL,H+ BHGHKEL,H+ FA LD,FG,H F,HAAHCKJ+ CDQ MJLKJ

0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FIILKLCGB CTTAF,H FI B@KJ DCE@AH CDQ T@ATFBH FI

TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB _

=LLL? GLULEB+ A@GHB+ TAFKHQ@AHB+ FA FEJHA X@LQHGLDHB EJCE U@BE

FA BJF@GQ VH ECOHD LDEF KFDBLQHACELFD VHIFAH+ Q@ALDX+ CDQ CIEHA EJH

TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB EF ULULULBH EJH LDEHAIHAHDKH MLEJ (LABE

1UHDQUHDE ALXJEB+ FEJHA 5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG GLVHAELHB+ CDQ FEJHA

KL,LG ALXJEB FI CKEL,LBEB _

=L,? KFDBLQHACELFD FI FEJHA KLAK@UBECDKHB + KFDQLELFDB+ CDQ

AHBEALKELFDB EJCE IFAU CDW TCAE FI EJH QHKLBLFD EF ECAXHE CKEL,LBEB IFA

TAFBHK@ELFD _ CDQ+ LI B@KJ KFDBLQHACELFDB H[LBE+ @DQHA MJCE




8 d 8

KLAK@UBECDKHB+ @DQHA MJCE KFDQLELFDB+ CDQ B@VfHKE EF MJCE

AHBEALKELFDB _

=,? CDW CDQ CGG CXHDKW+ H[HK@EL,H+ f@QLKLCG+ FA

KFDXAHBBLFDCG AHTFAEB+ UHUFACDQC+ AHKFAQB+ CDQ LDIFAUCELFD+ MJLKJ

TAF,LQH CDW QHBKALTELFD FI EJH TAFKHBB IFA EJH QHEHAULDCELFD CB EF

MJHEJHA CKEL,LBEB KCD VH ECAXHEHQ IFA TAFBHK@ELFD _ CDQ

=,L? MJHEJHA CXHDKLHB FEJHA EJCD EJH 0HTCAEUHDE FI

4@BELKH UCW ECAXHE CKEL,LBEB IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+ CDQ+ LI BF+ @DQHA MJCE


AHBEALKELFDB _ CDQ MJLKJ CXHDKW FIILKLCGB CTTAF,H FI B@KJ TAFBHK@ELFD FI

C K E L , L B E B -

V- 1GG AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+

THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG VCBLB IFA EJH CAAHBE CDQaFA TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+

LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ EF+ AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD AHXCAQLDX Y

=L? MJHEJHA EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL MCB TCAE FI CDW

0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKHPB TAFKHBB EF ECAXHE CKEL,LBEB _ CDQ

=LL? EJH GLULEB FI EJH 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKHPB TAFBHK@ELFD

EF ULULULBH EJH LDEHAIHAHDKH MLEJ (LABE 1UHDQUHDE+ FEJHA

5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG GLVHAELHB+ CDQ FEJHA KL,LG ALXJEB FI #E- 5JFL-

K- 1GG AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+

THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG VCBLB IFA EJH 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FA %-'- 1EEFADHWPB

$IILKH EF ICLG EF AHIHA EF #E- 5JFL VW JLB ULGLECAW ACDO+ LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ 1AUW

)HX@GCELFD ;<\86-

Q- /JH EFECG KFBE FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE

GLULEHQ EF Y

=L? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA

CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH KFBE FI CAAHBELDX CDQaFA

TAFBHK@ELDX #E- 5JFL+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ EF+ AHKFAQB CDQ

LDIFAUCELFD AHXCAQLDX Y




8 7 8

=1? CDW CDQ CGG CXHDKW+ H[HK@EL,H+ f@QLKLCG+ FA

KFDXAHBBLFDCG AHTFAEB+ UHUFACDQC+ AHKFAQB+ CDQ LDIFAUCELFD+

MJLKJ LDQLKCEH+ KCGK@GCEH+ FA CDCGWgH EJH V@QXHQ CDQ CKE@CG KFBE

FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL _

=c? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI EJH KFBE FI BECII KFBEB+

BECII VHDHILEB+ EAC,HG+ EACDBKALTEB+ CKKFUUFQCELFDB+ UHCGB+ DFD8

CEEFADHW LD,HBELXCELFD KFBEB+ AHBHCAKJ KFBEB+ FEJHA LD,HBELXCELFD

KFBEB+ CDQ CGG FEJHA KFBEB FD EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL _

=5? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI EJH KFBEB FI ICKE CDQ

H[THAE MLEDHBBHB LD KFDDHKELFD MLEJ EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E-

5JFL _

=0? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI CBBLBECDKH TAF,LQHQ VW

FEJHA GCM HDIFAKHUHDE CXHDKLHB LD KFDDHKELFD MLEJ EJH

TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL _ CDQ

=*? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI JF@AB MFAOHQ+ TCLQ FA

@DTCLQ F,HAELUH JF@AB+ CDQ FEJHA LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E THABFDDHG

JF@AB MFAOHQ LD KFDDHKELFD MLEJ EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL-

=0OE- .F- 67 ]d?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?-

e-6 0HIHDQCDE JCB HLEJHA MLGI@GGW LXDFAHQ BFUH FI AHZ@HBEB LD EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE+ TAF,LQHQ TCAELCG AHBTFDBHB EF BFUH+ CDQ MLGI@GGW MLEJJHGQ AHKFAQB MLEJF@E

HLEJHA CD H[TGCDCELFD FA C 5#267% &DQH[+ QHBTLEH AHZ@HBEB IFA KGCALILKCELFD CDQ C 5#267

&DQH[ UCQH VW 2GCLDELII+ IFA BFUH AHZ@HBEB+ CB BHE IFAEJ VHGFM Y

C- /JH 0$4 JCB DFE I@GGW CDBMHAHQ EJLB EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ CB

IFGGFMB Y

=L? &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-6-1-+ EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ

CD CKKF@DELDX+ CB BHE IFAEJ VHGFM Y

=1? DFE LQHDELILHQ MJCE OLDQ FI CKEL,LBEB UCW VH

ECAXHEHQ IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+

=c? DFE LQHDELILHQ JFM UCDW CKEL,LBEB JC,H VHHD

ECAXHEHQ IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+

=5? DFE LQHDELILHQ MJCE CAH EJH DCUHB FI B@KJ

CKEL,LBEB+ CDQ

=0? DFE LQHDELILHQ MJLKJ 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH

FIILKLCGB CTTAF,HQ FI B@KJ TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB _




8 ; 8

=LL? &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-6-c-+ EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ

CD CKKF@DELDX FA CDW LDIFAUCELFD CB EF Y

=1? MJHEJHA EJH DCE@AH CDQ T@ATFBH FI

TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB UCW VH CXXAHBBL,H+ BHGHKEL,H+ FA LD,FG,H

F,HAAHCKJ+ CDQ

=c? MJLKJ 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FIILKLCGB CTTAF,H

FI B@KJ DCE@AH CDQ T@ATFBH FI TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB _

=LLL? &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-6-5-+ EJH 0$4 JCB KGCLUHQ LE QLQ C

BHCAKJ+ V@E EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ EJH LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJH GLULEB+

A@GHB+ TAFKHQ@AHB+ FA FEJHA X@LQHGLDHB EJCE U@BE FA BJF@GQ VH ECOHD LDEF

KFDBLQHACELFD VHIFAH+ Q@ALDX+ CDQ CIEHA EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB EF

ULULULBH EJH LDEHAIHAHDKH MLEJ (LABE 1UHDQUHDE ALXJEB+ FEJHA

5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG GLVHAELHB+ CDQ FEJHA KL,LG ALXJEB FI CKEL,LBEB _

=L,? &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-6-0-+ EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ

CD CKKF@DELDX FA CDW LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E Y

=1? EJH KFDBLQHACELFD FI FEJHA KLAK@UBECDKHB +

KFDQLELFDB+ CDQ AHBEALKELFDB EJCE IFAU CDW TCAE FI EJH QHKLBLFD

EF ECAXHE CKEL,LBEB IFA TAFBHK@ELFD _ CDQ

=c? LI B@KJ KFDBLQHACELFDB H[LBE+ @DQHA MJCE


AHBEALKELFDB hKF@GQ CKEL,LBEB VH TAFBHK@EHQi _

=,? &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-6-*-+ EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ

CD CKKF@DELDX FA CDW CXHDKW+ H[HK@EL,H+ f@QLKLCG+ FA KFDXAHBBLFDCG

AHTFAEB+ UHUFACDQC+ AHKFAQB+ CDQ LDIFAUCELFD+ MJLKJ TAF,LQH CDW

QHBKALTELFD FI EJH TAFKHBB IFA EJH QHEHAULDCELFD CB EF MJHEJHA CKEL,LBEB

KCD VH ECAXHEHQ IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+ CDQ EJH 0$4PB MLGI@G QHKLBLFD EF DFE

KFjTHACEH UCOHB LE QLIILK@GE IFA 2GCLDELII CDQ EJLB 5F@AE EF ODFM MJHEJHA

EJH 0$4 JCB TAF,LQHQ CGG FI EJHBH AHKFAQB _ CDQ

=,L? &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-6-(-+ EJH 0$4 JCB DFE LQHDELILHQ

MJHEJHA CXHDKLHB FEJHA EJCD EJH 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH UCW ECAXHE

CKEL,LBEB IFA TAFBHK@ELFD+ CDQ+ LI BF+ @DQHA MJCE KLAK@UBECDKHB+ @DQHA




8 < 8

MJCE KFDQLELFDB+ CDQ B@VfHKE EF MJCE AHBEALKELFDB _ CDQ MJLKJ CXHDKW

FIILKLCGB CTTAF,H FI B@KJ TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB+ CDQ EJH 0$4PB MLGI@G

QHKLBLFD EF DFE KFjTHACEH UCOHB LE QLIILK@GE IFA 2GCLDELII CDQ EJLB 5F@AE EF

ODFM JFM U@KJ LDIFAUCELFD EJH 0$4 LB QHGLVHACEHGW MLEJJFGQLDX-

V- &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-:-+ EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ CGG FI EJH

AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH

GHXCG VCBLB IFA EJH CAAHBE CDQaFA TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE

GLULEHQ EF+ AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD AHXCAQLDX Y

=L? /JH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ AHKFAQB EJCE LQHDELIW

MJHEJHA EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL MCB TCAE FI CDW 0HTCAEUHDE FI

4@BELKHPB TAFKHBB EF ECAXHE CKEL,LBEB+ LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-:-1- _

CDQ

=LL? /JH 0$4 JCB KGCLUHQ LE QLQ C BHCAKJ+ V@E EJH 0$4 DFE

TAF,LQHQ AHKFAQB EJCE LQHDELIW EJH GLULEB FI EJH 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKHPB

TAFBHK@ELFD EF ULULULBH EJH LDEHAIHAHDKH MLEJ (LABE 1UHDQUHDE+ FEJHA

5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG GLVHAELHB+ CDQ FEJHA KL,LG ALXJEB FI #E- 5JFL+ LD

CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-:-c-+ )84)/& &7#& Y

=LLL? /JH 0$4 JCB Y

=1? KAHCEHQ C AHQ JHAALDX MJHD LE AHGHCBHQ C

TCAELCG KFTW FI EJH TGHCQLDX ILGH LD EJH >F,HADUHDEPB

TAFBHK@ELFD KCBH CXCLDBE #E- 5JFL =EJH R(LABE ($&1 )HGHCBHS FA

EJH R)HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBHS? EJCE AHIHAHDKHQ UCDW QFK@UHDEB

V@E EJCE MJLKJ MHAH ULBBLDX IAFU EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- (?_

=c? /JH )HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBH KFDECLDHQ

AHIHAHDKHB EF EJH OLDQB FI QFK@UHDEB EJCE 2GCLDELII JCQ VHHD

BHHOLDX+ V@E EJH 0$4 QHGLVHACEHGW MLEJJHGQ B@KJ QFK@UHDEBEJCE MHAH CDBMHACVGH EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE =R2GCLDELIIPB

&DQH[ EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HBTFDBHS? =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- c? _

=5? /JH KF,HA GHEEHA IAFU EJH 0$4+ QCEHQ 6k

1@X@BE :\67+ CKODFMGHQXHQ EJH H[LBEHDKH FI R.FDT@VGLK

AHKFAQB THAECLDLDX EF C EJLAQ TCAEWS EJCE EJH 0$4 MCB

QHGLVHACEHGW MLEJJFGQLDX =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ( CE 6? =EJH

R*[HUTEHQ )HKFAQBS?_ CDQ




8 e 8

=0? /JH 0$4 QHKGLDHQ EF TAFQ@KH EJH .FDT@VGLK

)HKFAQB LD CKKFAQCDKH EF EJH 2AL,CKW 1KE+ 7 %-'-5- l 77:C-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ( CE 6?- /JH H[HUTELFD+ @DQHA EJH 2AL,CKW 1KE+

7 %-'-5- l 77:C+ LB EJH FDGW ELUH LD EJH CKELFD VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE

EJCE EJH 0$4 JCB KLEHQ CD H[HUTELFD @DQHA ($&1 EF H[TGCLD C

MLEJJFGQLDX FI AHKFAQB-

=*? /JH 0$4+ LD EJH KF,HA GHEEHA EACDBULEELDX EJH

)HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH+ QLQ DFE UCOH C GLDH8LEHU CKKF@DELDX FI

HCKJ LEHU AHZ@HBEHQ LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+

*[- ( CE 68:?-

K- &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-]-+ EJH 0$4 JCB KGCLUHQ LE QLQ C BHCAKJ+

V@E EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,-

6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG VCBLB IFA EJH 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FA %-'-

1EEFADHWPB $IILKH EF ICLG EF AHIHA EF #E- 5JFL VW JLB ULGLECAW ACDO+ LD CKKFAQCDKH

MLEJ 1AUW )HX@GCELFD ;<\86-

Q- &D AHBTHKE FI AHZ@HBE &-d-+ EJH 0$4 JCB KGCLUHQ LE QLQ C BHCAKJ+

V@E EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJH EFECG KFBE FI EJH

TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ EF Y

=L? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD+ LD CKKFAQCDKH

MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-d-1-+ KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH

KFBE FI CAAHBELDX CDQaFA TAFBHK@ELDX #E- 5JFL+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ

EF+ AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD AHXCAQLDX Y

=1? CDW CDQ CGG CXHDKW+ H[HK@EL,H+ f@QLKLCG+ FA

KFDXAHBBLFDCG AHTFAEB+ UHUFACDQC+ AHKFAQB+ CDQ LDIFAUCELFD+

MJLKJ LDQLKCEH+ KCGK@GCEH+ FA CDCGWgH EJH V@QXHQ CDQ CKE@CG KFBE

FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE

&-d-1-C- _

=c? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI EJH KFBE FI BECII KFBEB+

BECII VHDHILEB+ EAC,HG+ EACDBKALTEB+ CKKFUUFQCELFDB+ UHCGB+ DFD8CEEFADHW LD,HBELXCELFD KFBEB+ AHBHCAKJ KFBEB+ FEJHA LD,HBELXCELFD

KFBEB+ CDQ CGG FEJHA KFBEB FD EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LD

CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-d-1-V- _

=5? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI EJH KFBEB FI ICKE CDQ

H[THAE MLEDHBBHB LD KFDDHKELFD MLEJ EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E-

5JFL+ LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-d-1-K- _




8 k 8

=0? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI CBBLBECDKH TAF,LQHQ VW

FEJHA GCM HDIFAKHUHDE CXHDKLHB LD KFDDHKELFD MLEJ EJH

TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-d-1-Q- _

CDQ

=*? CDW CDQ CGG AHKFAQB FI JF@AB MFAOHQ+ TCLQ FA

@DTCLQ F,HAELUH JF@AB+ CDQ FEJHA LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E THABFDDHG

JF@AB MFAOHQ LD KFDDHKELFD MLEJ EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ LD

CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ AHZ@HBE &-d-1-H-+ )84)/& &7#& Y

=(? /JH 0$4 JCB LDIFAUHQ 2GCLDELII EJCE EJH 0$4

KCDDFE BHXAHXCEH KFBEB IFA EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL IAFU EJH

TAFBHK@ELFD FI FEJHA CKEL,LBEB- =mHGGW 0HKG-+ ` :68:d?+ CDQ

=>? 0HBTLEH 2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE EJCE 2GCLDELII MLGG

CKKHTE CGG FI EJH KFBEB FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB EJCE

LDKG@QH EJH KFBE FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFL+ 0HIHDQCDE JCB

DFE QLBKGFBHQ B@KJ KFBEB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6J?

H- /JH 0$4 JCB DFE TAF,LQHQ CD LDQH[ AHZ@HBEHQ VW 2GCLDELII FI EJH

TAL,CKW8HDK@U VHAHQ AHKFAQB MLEJJHGQ VW EJH 0$4- =0OE- 6:+ *[- 1+ c CE d;?-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE ` df=L?8=LL??-

k- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE- 2GCLDELII UCQH HLXJEHHD =6e? AHZ@HBEB

LD IF@A KCEHXFALHB FI QFK@UHDEB CDQ AHKFAQB LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- /JH IF@A

KCEHXFALHB KCD VH B@UUCALBHQ CB Y =L? R1GG EJH AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD THAECLDLDX EF EJH

GHXCG VCBLB FI TAFBHK@ELDX CKEL,LBEB+ MJF CAH HDXCXHQ LD TAFEHBEBS =0OE- .F- 67 ]dC? _ =LL?

R1GG EJH AHKFAQB CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG

VCBLB IFA EJH CAAHBE CDQaFA TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFLS =0OE- .F- 67 ]dV? _ =LLL? R1GG AHKFAQB

CDQ LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG VCBLB IFA EJH

0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FA %-'- 1EEFADHWPB $IILKH EF ICLG EF AHIHA EF #E- 5JFL VW JLB ULGLECAW

ACDOS =0OE- .F- 67 ]dK? _ CDQ =L,? R/JH EFECG KFBE FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI #E- 5JFLS =0OE-

.F- 67 ]dQ?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2# 7;-6 1DBMHA ` eC=L?8=,L?+ eV=L?8=LL? + eK+

CDQ eQ=L?=1?8=*?-

6\- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH 0HIHDQCDEPB BECEHUHDE CE 6\

KFDEACQLKEB 0HIHDQCDEPB BECEHUHDE CE k-

C- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBEHQ LDKG@QHQ BL[ B@V8KCEHXFALHB+ CDQ EJHBH KCEHXFALHB CAH B@VULEEHQ LD EJH




8 6\ 8

AHKFAQ FI EJH TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2# 7;-6

1DBMHA eC=L?8=,L??-

V- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBEHQ LDKG@QHQ EMF B@V8KCEHXFALHB+ CDQ EJHBH KCEHXFALHB CAH B@VULEEHQ LD

EJH AHKFAQ FI EJH TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2#

7;-6 1DBMHA eV=L?8=LL??-

K- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF DFEH EJCE

2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE LB B@VULEEHQ LD EJH AHKFAQ FI EJH TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB

5F@AE- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2# 7;-6 1DBMHA eK?-

Q- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBEHQ LDKG@QHQ IL,H B@V8KCEHXFALHB+ CDQ EJHBH KCEHXFALHB CAH B@VULEEHQ LD

EJH AHKFAQ FI EJH TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2#

7;-6 1DBMHA eQ=L?=1?8=*??-

66- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF CQQ Y

C- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE 2GCLDELII MCB EFGQ FD 7 4@DH :\6] VW

0$4 TCACGHXCG 'CDfCW 'FGC =R'FGCS? EJCE 'FDWC ^JLECOHA =R^JLECOHAS? MF@GQ

QHEHAULDH MJHEJHA 2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE IFA H[THQLEHQ TAFKHBBLDX MF@GQ VH

CTTAF,HQ- 2GCLDELII DH,HA AHKHL,HQ CDW AHBTFDBH IAFU ^JLECOHA CVF@E JLB

AHZ@HBE IFA H[THQLEHQ TAFKHBBLDX- =0OE- 67 dd8d7?-

V- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE QHBTLEH 'FGCPB TAFULBHB EF 2GCLDELII+

2GCLDELII DH,HA AHKHL,HQ CDW QHEHAULDCELFD CVF@E JLB IHH MCL,HA AHZ@HBE VHLDX

QHDLHQ VW EJH 0$4- =0OE- 67 d;8d<?-

6:- 2GCLDELII DFEHB I@AEJHA EF 0HIHDQCDEPB BECEHUHDE EJCE CUFDXBE EJH

LDQL,LQ@CGB+ MJF AHKHL,HQ EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ MCB >HFAXH- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 44?- =0OE-

k :k?- /JLB ICKE MCB UHDELFDHQ VW 2GCLDELII CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH-

C- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE 0HIHDQCDE KJCDXHQ LEB AHTAHBHDECELFD EF EJH

5F@AE EJCE >HFAXH AHKHL,HQ EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MJHD LE ILGHQ LEB 1UHDQHQ

1DBMHA- =0OE- 6< :k?-




8 66 8

V- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE 2GCLDELIIPB KJCDXH LD LEB AHTAHBHDECELFD

VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE KFDEAC,HDHB LDIFAUCELFD EJCE 0HIHDQCDE XC,H EF 2GCLDELII

Q@ALDX C /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH EJCE EFFO TGCKH FD 6; $KEFVHA :\67+ DCUHGW+ EJCE

>HFAXH JCQ C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE CGG CGFDX-

6]- 2GCLDELII CDQ EJLB 5F@AE QF DFE JC,H CDW LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJH GFX CE EJH

*$%'1+ VHKC@BH EJH 0$4 JCB DFE TAFQ@KHQ CDW AHKFAQB CVF@E EJH GFX FA CVF@E EJH FALXLDCG

AHZ@HBE =)HZ@HBE .F- 6]867\;? FA EJH CTTHCG =1TTHCG .F- 128:\6d8\\ek\?- 'LDKH

AHKFAQB CVF@E EJH GFX CAH DFE LD H,LQHDKH+ ICKEB CVF@E EJH GFX CAH DFE C,CLGCVGH EF EJH

5F@AE CDQ EF 2GCLDELII- 2GCLDELII KCD FDGW CEEHBE EF VHLDX TAF,LQHQ VW 'FGC EJH AHZ@HBE

D@UVHA Y 6]867\; EJCE 'FGC LDIFAUHQ 2GCLDELII EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE JCQ VHHD CBBLXDHQ-

=0OE- 67 dd?-

6d- 2GCLDELII QLBT@EHB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH 0$4 JCB DFE CKKF@DEHQ IFA

JFM CDW FI EJH 0$4PB CKEL,LELHB QHBKALVHQ VW 2GCLDELII LD EJH 5FUTGCLDE CAH KFDBLBEHDE MLEJ

EJH 0$4PB LDCVLGLEW EF GFKCEH C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =0OE- 6 ]k8;6?-

C- 1GG EJCE LB ODFMD LB MJHD EJH 0$4 ILABE ILGHQ LEPB 1DBMHA LD EJH

TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE+ EJH 0$4 CQULEEHQ EJCE+ R0HIHDQCDE JCB DFE WHE

AHGHCBHQ CDW AHKFAQB EJCE CAH AHBTFDBL,H EF 2GCLDELIIPB ($&1 AHZ@HBE CE LBB@H LD

EJLB CKELFD CDQ JCB DFE WHE TAF,LQHQ CD H[TGCDCELFD EF 2GCLDELII-S =0OE- k :<?-

V- &D LEB 1DBMHA ILGHQ MLEJ EJH 5F@AE+ 0HIHDQCDE DH,HA LD,FOHQ CD

*[HUTELFD @DQHA ($&1 CB C AHCBFD MJW LE DH,HA TAF,LQHQ CD RH[TGCDCELFDS EF

2GCLDELII IFA MJW LE JCQ DFE WHE RAHGHCBHQ CDW AHKFAQB EJCE CAH AHBTFDBL,H EF

2GCLDELIIPB ($&1 AHZ@HBE-S =0OE- k :<?-

K- &D LEB 1UHDQHQ 1DBMHA ILGHQ MLEJ EJH 5F@AE+ 0HIHDQCDE MCB

IFAKHQ EF KJCDXH LEB H[K@BH EJCE EJH *$%'1 KF@GQ DFE ILDQ EJH AHZ@HBE ILGH EF EJH

*$%'1 QLQ DFE JC,H C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =0OE- .F- 6< 7:?-

67- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

6;- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ CB EJH 0$4 LB LUTGWLDX EJCE EJH

BJFAEJCDQ QHBKALTELFD FI ^LGGOLH (CAA n >CGGCXJHA ##2 =R2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHGS? LD EJH ]\

1TALG :\6] GHEEHA EF EJH $IILKH FI &DIFAUCELFD 2FGLKW =R$&2S? =EJH R($&1 1TTHCGS? IFA EJH




8 6: 8

DLDH8TCXH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE BJF@GQ BFUHJFM GLULE FA AHBEALKE EJH 6e AHZ@HBEB LD IF@A

KCEHXFALHB FI QFK@UHDEB CDQ AHKFAQB LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =0OE- 67 ]d?- =0OE- .F-

6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2# 7;-6 1DBMHA eC=L?8=,L?+ eV=L?8=LL?+ eK+ CDQ eQ=L?=1?8=*?- =(GFAHB

0HKG-+ *[- 1?-

C- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE LD 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHGPB ($&1 1TTHCG

LDQLKCEHQ EJCE C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MCB HDKGFBHQ Y R=EJH R)HZ@HBES?

=*DKGFBHQ?-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 1 CE :?-6

V- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE 2GCLDELII CTTAFCKJHQ EJH FIILKH FI JLB

HGHKEHQ 5FDXAHBBLFDCG AHTAHBHDECEL,H+ %-'- )HTAHBHDECEL,H 4FBHTJ 5AFMGHW+ MJF

MAFEH C GHEEHA QCEHQ 6\ (HVA@CAW :\6d FD 2GCLDELIIPB VHJCGI =EJH R5FDXAHBBLFDCG

)HZ@HBES?+ CQQAHBBHQ EF EJH *$%'1+ CBOLDX EJH *$%'1 EF TAFKHBB EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE- =0OE- .F- 6: *[- & EF *[- 0?- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- c?-

K- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE EJH >F,HADUHDE DH,HA CDBMHAHQ EJH

5FDXAHBBLFDCG )HZ@HBE- =0OE- .F- 67 dk?-

Q- 2GCLDELII B@VULEB 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHGPB 6k 3CAKJ :\6d H8UCLG

AHTFAE8VCKO EF 2GCLDELII LD MJLKJ 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG MAFEH EJCE EJH 0$4 MCB

REACDBLELFDLDX EJHLA BWBEHU IAFU C TCTHA IFAUCE EF CD HGHKEAFDLK IFAUCE+ MJLKJ

JCB VHHD KC@BLDX BFUH QHGCW LD TAFKHBBLDX+ V@E EJCE WF@A AHZ@HBE LB VHLDX

TAFKHBBHQ+S I@AEJHA DFELDX EJCE EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE RBJF@GQ VH TAFKHBBHQ LD

:8] MHHOB+S VHIFAH KFDKG@QLDX EJCE+ CKKFAQLDX EF 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG+ EJLB UHCDE

EJCE RBFUHFDH UCW CKE@CGGW VH GFFOLDXS CE EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+

*[- 5?-

6<- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH KFUU@DLKCELFD EJCE EJH

$&2 BHDE EF 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG QLQ DFE BECEH EJCE EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MCB GFBE- /JH

GHEEHA+ QCEHQ :\ 3CW :\6d IAFU EJH $&2 EF 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG =EJH R$&2 )HBTFDBHS? DFEHQ

EJH AHUCDQ FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE EF EJH *$%'1- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 0 CE 6?-

6 1GEJF@XJ+ LD 2GCLDELIIPB KFTW FI EJH H8UCLG+ LE QFHB DFE CTTHCA EJCE EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MCB

CEECKJHQ+ 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE FDH FI EJH GCMWHAB CE 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG MCB DH,HA CBOHQ EF

TAF,LQH C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ..?-




8 6] 8

C- 1EECKJHQ EF EJH $&2 )HBTFDBH MCB CD LDEHADCG 0$4

UHUFACDQ@U+ @DQCEHQ+ EF '@BCD >HABFD+ CD CBBLBECDE QLAHKEFA CE EJH *$%'1+

IAFU 3HGCDLH 1DD 2@BECW+ C QLAHKEFA FI EJH 0$4 =R2@BECWS?+ CDQ 'HCD )- $P.HLGG+

EJH KJLHI FI 1QULDLBEACEL,H 1TTHCGB 'ECII =R$P.HLGGS? =EJH R0$4 )HUCDQ 3HUFS?-

&E MCB LD EJH 0$4 )HUCDQ 3HUF+ CDQ DFE LD EJH $&2 )HBTFDBH+ MJHAH 2@BECW CDQ

$P.HLGG MAFEH EJCE EJH *$%'1 ICLGHQ EF GFKCEH EJH AHZ@HBE ILGH- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE

EJH 0$4 )HUCDQ 3HUF QFHB DFE BCW EJCE EJH *$%'1 KF@GQ DFE ILDQ EJH (LABE

($&1 )HZ@HBE- /JH H[CKE MFAQLDX LB Y R*$%'1PB ICLG@AH EF GFKCEH EJH AHZ@HBE

ILGH-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 0 CE :?-

V- /JH 0$4 )HUCDQ 3HUF LDBEA@KEHQ *$%'1 EF RTGHCBH AHFTHD

EJLB AHZ@HBE CDQ KFDQ@KE C BHCAKJ IFA AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB+ CDQ BHDQ CDW

AHGHCBCVGH AHKFAQB QLAHKEGW EF EJH AHZ@HBEHA+ B@VfHKE EF CDW CTTGLKCVGH IHHB+S

CQQLDX EJCE EJH $&2 CEEFADHW AH,LHMLDX EJH ($&1 1TTHCG MCB ^JLECOHA+ EJH BCUH

THABFD 'FGC LDIFAUHQ 2GCLDELII MF@GQ QHEHAULDH MJHEJHA 2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE IFA

H[THQLEHQ TAFKHBBLDX MF@GQ VH CTTAF,HQ- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 0 CE :?- =0OE- 67 `

dd8d7?-

K- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG LDIFAUHQ 2GCLDELII

,LC H8UCLG QCEHQ \k 4@DH :\6d =EJH R>FFQ .HMB H8UCLGS? EJCE EJH $&2 JCQ RBHDE

EJLB VCKO QFMDS EF EJH *$%'1 REF KFDQ@KE C BHCAKJ IFA+ CDQ TAFQ@KH+ AHBTFDBL,H

AHKFAQB-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- *?-

Q- &D EJH $&2 )HBTFDBH+ 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG MCB CQ,LBHQ Y R&I WF@A

KGLHDE LB QLBBCELBILHQ MLEJ UW CKELFD FD WF@A CTTHCG+ EJH (AHHQFU FI &DIFAUCELFD

1KE THAULEB JLU EF ILGH C GCMB@LE LD IHQHACG QLBEALKE KF@AE LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ 7

%-'-5- l 77:=C?d?=c?- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 0 CE 6?-

H- 1E DF ELUH TALFA EF 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHGPB AHTAHBHDECELFD FI

2GCLDELII QLQ EJH 0$4 H,HA KFUU@DLKCEH EF 2GCLDELII EJCE EJH 0$4 FA EJH $&2 JCQ DF

KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE FA C RAHZ@HBE ILGHS IFA EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ CDQ

CE DF ELUH Q@ALDX 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHGPB AHTAHBHDECELFD FI 2GCLDELII QLQ 2GCLDELIIPB




8 6d 8

5F@DBHG LDIFAU 2GCLDELII EJCE EJH 0$4 FA EJH $&2 JCQ DF KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE FA C RAHZ@HBE ILGHS IFA EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ..?-

I- /JH $&2 DH,HA AHGHCBHQ AHKFAQB LD AHBTFDBH EF EJH ($&1

1TTHCG- =0OE- .F- 6 7]?-

X- 2GCLDELIIPB 5F@DBHG DH,HA H[TGCLDHQ EF 2GCLDELII EJH $&2PB ICLG@AH

EF H,HA AHGHCBH AHKFAQB LD AHBTFDBH EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE-

J- /JH 5F@AE JCB DH,HA CBOHQ EJH 0$4 EF CKKF@DE IFA JFM EJH (LABE

($&1 )HZ@HBE FA EJH RAHZ@HBE ILGHS IFA EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MCB GFBE-

H7 1:;<=><?? #=<><;>A@ $I<@ 2;J@C<>

6e- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

6k- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

+7 $IA (A;EKIA@ ?DE #=?DEF;><D= *A@LD=@<MA >D 1:;<=><??3@ -,#) *ABCA@>

:\- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH 0$4 QFHB DFE LDQLKCEH JFM

EJH 0$4 FVECLDHQ C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ CDQ EJH 0$4 QFHB DFE CKKF@DE IFA CGG

EJH ELUH EJCE EJH 0$4 ICLGHQ EF AHGHCBH RCDW AHKFAQB EJCE CAH AHBTFDBL,H EF 2GCLDELIIPB ($&1

AHZ@HBE CE LBB@H LD EJLB CKELFDS CDQ JCQ RDFE WHE TAF,LQHQ CD H[TGCDCELFD EF 2GCLDELII+S CB

FI EJH ILGLDX FI EJH 0$4PB 1DBMHA LD EJLB CKELFD- =0OE- k :<?-

:6- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD EF ,HALIW EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EJCE 2GCLDELII

JCB FVfHKEHQ EF HCKJ FI EJH IFAU FI EJH BHCAKJ KFDQ@KEHQ+ GLULECELFDB LUTFBHQ VW EJH 0$4

LD EJH KFDQ@KE FI EJH BHCAKJHB+ CDQ EJH Z@CGLILKCELFD FI mCALD mHGGW+ MJF KFDQ@KEHQ EJH

BHCAKJHB+ LD 2GCLDELIIPB GHEEHA EF 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG+ QCEHQ :; $KEFVHA :\67 =EJH R2GCLDELIIPB

0@H 0LGLXHDKH #HEEHAS?- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6?-

::- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD EF ,HALIW EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EJCE 2GCLDELII

JCB FVfHKEHQ EF EJH 0HKGCACELFD FI mCALD mHGGW FD EJH VCBLB EJCE Q@ALDX C /HGHTJFDH

5FDIHAHDKH VHEMHHD 2GCLDELII CDQ 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG FD 6; $KEFVHA :\67 EJH R0@H

0LGLXHDKH /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKHS?+ 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG JCQ TAFULBHQ 2GCLDELII EJCE EJH

BHCAKJ MF@GQ VH KFDQ@KEHQ IFA RX@LQHGLDHB+ TAFEFKFGB+ TAFKHQ@AHB+S V@E EJH 0HKGCACELFD FI

mCALD mHGGW MCB BLGHDE CVF@E EJHBH QHBKALTELFDB FI AHKFAQB- 1UFDXBE FEJHA KFUTGCLDEB




8 67 8

UCQH VW 2GCLDELII MCB EJCE EJH 0HKGCACELFD FI mCALD mHGGW UHDELFDHQ EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE LEHUB &-6-5-+ &-:-c+ LEHU &-]+ CDQ LEHU &-d- bFMH,HA+ DFDH FI EJH FEJHA LEHUB MHAH

LDQL,LQ@CGGW CQQAHBBHQ- 2GCLDELII AHZ@HBEHQ C I@GG KGCALILKCELFD FD CD LEHU8VW8LEHU VCBLB FI

EJH BHCAKJ AHB@GEB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6V+ 6L?-

:]- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE FD EJH VCBLB EJCE EJH BHCAKJ MCB

QHIHKEL,H+ LDKFUTGHEH+ CDQ GLULEHQ+ CB DFEHQ LD 2GCLDELIIPB 0@H 0LGLXHDKH #HEEHA+ MJHAH

2GCLDELII MAFEH EJCE EJH BHCAKJ BEALDXB QHGLVHACEHGW F,HA8GFFOHQ MFAQLDX LD EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE+ TCAELK@GCAGW EF AHIHAHDKHB EF R(LABE 1UHDQUHDE+ FEJHA 5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG

GLVHAELHQ+ CDQ FEJHA KL,LG ALXJEB FI CKEL,LBEB-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6X?- 1UFDXBE EJH

QFK@UHDEB LDKG@QHQ LD EJH 'HKFDQ ($&1 )HBTFDBH MHAH KFTLHB FI BHKELFDB IAFU EJH

%DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG CTTGLKCVGH EF RQHUFDBEACELFDB-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >

CE /CV 0?- 9)) :;9; ()/<& 0' =2.&$4)+ %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG l k8;7-ee\+ -ee6+

-ee:- /JHBH AHKFAQB LDQLKCEHQ EJCE EJH 0$4 KCD TAFBHK@EH CKEL,LBEB- /JH 0$4 CGBF

TAFQ@KHQ FEJHA AHKFAQB IAFU EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >

CE /CVB * CDQ >?- /JCE EJH 0$4 GCEHA TAFQ@KHQ AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB @BLDX CGEHADCEL,H

KFUUFD BHDBH BHCAKJ BEALDXB BJFMB EJCE EJH 0$4PB BHCAKJ IFA AHKFAQB EJCE TAFQ@KHQ EJH

)HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH MCB QHIHKEL,H+ LDKFUTGHEH+ CDQ @DGCMI@G-

:d- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE FD EJH VCBLB EJCE 2GCLDELII JCB

Z@HBELFDHQ EJH HUTGFWUHDE BECE@B FI mCALD mHGGW- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6C?- /JH FEJHA

0$4 HUTGFWHH TAF,LQLDX C 0HKGCACELFD LD EJLB UCEEHA JCB FDGW VHHD HUTGFWHQ VW EJH 0$4

BLDKH 1TALG :\67+ CDQ 2GCLDELII JCB ACLBHQ FVfHKELFDB CVF@E MJW EHUT+ f@DLFA+ FA DHM BECII

MHAH KCGGHQ EF TAF,LQH 0HKGCACELFDB LD EJLB UCEEHA- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE :C8:K?-

:7- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB BECEHUHDE FEJHA EJCD EF TFLDE

F@E EJCE THAJCTB 3B- mHGGW LB BHHULDXGW CQULEELDX FKK@TCELFDCG LXDFACDKH-

!" $%&'() *+' ,%(+'-. ,%./+0.12% 3+ 43%5. ! &0- 6 +* 78&1031**9. :;4< ,%=>%.3

:;- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ BLDKH+ LD EJH 0HKGCACELFD FI mCALD

mHGGW+ FDGW LEHUB &-6-5 CDQ &-:-c- CAH LDQL,LQ@CGGW GLBEHQ IFA LEHUB 6 CDQ : FI EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE- /JHAH LB DF CKKF@DELDX IFA CDW FI EJH FEJHA LEHUB- =mHGGW 0HKG-+ 6\86k?-

=0OE- 67 ]d?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- =2# 7;-6 1DBMHA eC=L?8=,L?+ eV=L?8=LL??-




8 6; 8

:<- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ H[KHTE EJCE 2GCLDELII JCB FVfHKEHQ

EF EJH IFAU FI EJH BHCAKJ- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6?-

:e- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ H[KHTE EJCE 2GCLDELII JCB FVfHKEHQ


:k- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ BLDKH 2GCLDELII JCB FVfHKEHQ EF EJH

BHCAKJ BEALDX @BHQ VW mCALD mHGGW- 2GCLDELII JCB I@AEJHA FVfHKEHQ EF EJH 0$4 BHCAKJLDX IFA

EHAUB+ GLOH RECAXHEHQS =VHKC@BH LE MCB QHBKALTEL,H FI EJH HIIHKE FI EJH 0$4PB KFDQ@KE CDQ LB

C GFCQHQ MFAQ+ XL,HD EJCE EJH 0$4 MF@GQ DFE VH GLOHGW EF RUCOH B@KJ ,FG@DECAW

KGCBBLILKCELFD LD LEB LDEHADCG AHKFAQB EJCE MF@GQ AHIGHKE FD LEB FMD ULBKFDQ@KES?+ V@E DFE

IFA CDW FI EJH GCMB EJCE MF@GQ XF,HAD EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB+ B@KJ CB R(LABE

1UHDQUHDE+ FEJHA 5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG GLVHAELHB+ FA FEJHA KL,LG ALXJEB-S

(@AEJHAUFAH+ EJH 0$4 GFKCEHQ X@LQHGLDHB IAFU EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG

CTTGLKCVGH EF RQHUFDBEACELFDB-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- > CE /CV 0?- 9)) :;9; ()/<& 0' =2.&$4)+

%DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG l k8;7-ee\+ -ee6+ -ee:- /JH 0$4 CGBF TAFQ@KHQ FEJHA

AHKFAQB IAFU EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- > CE /CVB * CDQ >?-

NHE+ AHCBFDCVGH CDQ CTTGLKCVGH BHCAKJ EHAUB+ GLOH RQHUFDBEACELFDB+S MHAH QHGLVHACEHGW

FULEEHQ MJHD EJH 0$4 KFDQ@KEHQ LB BHCAKJ FI AHKFAQB EJCE GCEHA VHXCE EJH )HQ bHAALDX

)HBTFDBH+ VHKC@BH EJH BHCAKJ EHAUB MHAH GLULEHQ EF RCKEL,LBEBS CDQ RECAXHEHQ-S =mHGGW

0HKG- 66+ 6<?- 3FAHF,HA+ 2GCLDELII FVfHKEHQ EJCE EJH BHCAKJ MCB GLULEHQ EF KHAECLD+ GFCQHQ

MFAQB _ FDGW KHAECLD LEHUB LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE MHAH BTHKLILKCGGW LQHDELILHQ _ LD CGG FI

EJH 0HKGCACELFD FI mCALD 0HGGW+ EJH 0$4 ICLGHQ EF CQQAHBB C BHCAKJ IFA HCKJ GLDH LEHU LD EJH

(LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE _ CDQ 2GCLDEII FVfHKEHQ EF CEEHUTEB VW EJH 0$4 EF RQHGLVHACEHGW KAHCEH

FVI@BKCELFD-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6X+ 6L?-

]\- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE- /JH 0$4 LB KLELDX CD H8UCLG EJCE JCB

DFE VHHD LDEAFQ@KHQ LDEF H,LQHDKH+ CDQ 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE mCALD mHGGW Z@FEHQ EJH

RAHGH,CDE TFAELFDS FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ V@E EJHAH LB DF QFK@UHDECELFD MJCE EJCE

TFAELFD LB FA MCB+ EALXXHALDX CD FVfHKELFD VW 2GCLDELII- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6H?-

C- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE EJH 0$4 LB AHIHAALDX EF CD LDKFAAHKE

)HIHAHDKH .@UVHA IFA EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- /JH mCALD mHGGW 0HKGCACELFD




8 6< 8

AHIHAB EF ($&1 )HZ@HBE .F- :\678\:d::+ V@E EJH $&2 )HBTFDBH AHIHAAHQ EF ($&1

)HZ@HBE .F- :\6]867\; CDQ 1TTHCG .F- 128:\6d8\\ek\- =mHGGW 0HKG-+ 7?-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 0 CE 6?

]6- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ AHTHCEB JLB FVfHKELFD EF EJH IFAU FI

EJH BHCAKJ+ CDQ AHTHCEB JLB FVfHKELFD EF EJH AHQ@KELFD FI EJH DLDH8TCXHB FI EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE EF EJH EMF MFAQB+ FDH FI MJLKJ+ RCKEL,LBE+S LB @BHQ MLEJF@E BHCAKJ BEALDXB IFA

BWDFDWUB FA AHGCEHQ GCMB EJCE MF@GQ XF,HAD EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB+ B@KJ CB

RQHUFDBEACELFDBS FA R(LABE 1UHDQUHDE+ FEJHA 5FDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB+ KL,LG GLVHAELHB+ FA

FEJHA KL,LG ALXJEB+S AHBTHKEL,HGW _ CDQ EJH FEJHA+ RECAXHEHQ+S MJLKJ MCB QHBKALTEL,H FI EJH

HIIHKE FI EJH 0$4PB KFDQ@KE CDQ LB C GFCQHQ MFAQ+ XL,HD EJCE EJH 0$4 MF@GQ DFE VH GLOHGW EF

RUCOH B@KJ ,FG@DECAW KGCBBLILKCELFD LD LEB LDEHADCG AHKFAQB EJCE MF@GQ AHIGHKE FD LEB FMD

ULBKFDQ@KE-S =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6X?-

]:- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ H[KHTE EJCE 2GCLDELII JCB FVfHKEHQ


]]- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ H[KHTE EJCE 2GCLDELII JCB FVfHKEHQ

F,HA CDQ F,HA CXCLD EF EJH MCW EJCE EJH 0$4 JCB KFDQ@KEHQ EJH BHCAKJ- &D EJLB BECEHUHDE+

mCALD mHGGW RH[TGCLDHQS EJH REWTH FI LDIFAUCELFDS VHLDX BF@XJE LDBEHCQ FI f@BE TAF,LQLDX

EJH H[CKE MFAQLDX LD EJH 6e AHZ@HBEB LD IF@A KCEHXFALHB FI QFK@UHDEB CDQ AHKFAQB LD EJH

(LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6?- /JH 0$4 ALXXHQ EJH BHCAKJ BF CB EF KFDQ@KE

DF BHCAKJ CE CGG-

]d- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB-

]7- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB-

];- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ H[KHTE EF CXCLD CBBHAE EJCE EJH

0$4 JCB VHHD QHGLVHACEHGW @BLDX FVI@BKCELFD LD FAQHA EF TAH,HDE EJH AHGHCBH FI AHKFAQB

I@GGW AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6X?- 2GCLDELII TAF,LQHQ

KFTLF@B H[CUTGHB FI CKEL,LBEB VHLDX TAFBHK@EHQ IFA EJHLA CKEL,LBU LD EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE- NHE+ EJH 0$4 QHGLVHACEHGW KJFBH DFE EF BHCAKJ EJH AHKFAQB FI EJFBH KCBHB IFA

CTTGLKCVGH GCMB FA X@LQHGLDHB+ AH,HCGLDX+ CXCLD EJH 0$4PB HIIFAE EF VCBLKCGGW KFDQ@KE DF

BHCAKJ CE CGG-




8 6e 8

]<- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB-

]e- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ H[KHTE EJCE EJH 1BBLBECDE %-'-

1EEFADHW LD Z@HBELFD LB >HFAXH CDQ EJCE+ XL,HD EJCE >HFAXH MCB EJH TAFBHK@EFA+ MJF EALHQ

#E- 5JFL+ EJHD BJH BJF@GQ JC,H VHHD CVGH EF TAF,LQHQ X@LQCDKH EF mCALD mHGGW CVF@E MJCE

MFAQB MF@GQ JC,H TAFQ@KHQ BHCAKJ AHB@GEB+ IFA H[CUTGH+ EJH @BH FI EJH MFAQ

RQHUFDBEACELFDBS FA BFUH FI EJH GCMB @DQHA MJLKJ CKEL,LBEB MF@GQ JC,H VHHD TAFBHK@EHQ

FA MJLKJ KF@GQ JC,H KAHCEHQ AHKFAQB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6X?-

]k- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH LE LB DFE C ICKE- /JH

>F,HADUHDE JCB C GFDX+ HBECVGLBJHQ JLBEFAW FI ECAXHELDX CKEL,LBEB- /JCE LB MJCE EJLB ($&1

CKELFD JCB VHHD EAWLDX EF HBECVGLBJ+ CDQ EJHAH CAH TAHBB AHTFAEB CVF@E EJH >F,HADUHDEPB

CKEL,LELHB EF ECAXHE CKEL,LBEB- =0OE- 67 ` 6<8:d?- (@AEJHAUFAH+ BLDKH EJH 0$4 JCB CBOHQ

>HFAXH EF TAF,LQH EHBELUFDW LD EJLB CKELFD+ XL,LDX 2GCLDELII CD FTTFAE@DLEW EF KAFBB8

H[CULDH JHA CB C MLEDHBB LB FDGW ICLA+ CDQ EJH 5F@AE DHHQB EF FAQHA GLULEHQ QLBKF,HAW EF

CGGFM IFA C QHTFBLELFD FI >HFAXH-

]k-6 0HBTLEH CBB@ACDKHB IAFU EJH $VCUC CQULDLBEACELFD EF EJH KFDEACAW+

CKEL,LBEB JC,H BELGG VHHD CAAHBEHQ IFA EJHLA CKEL,LBU-

C- &D AHUCAOB UCQH FD :d .F,HUVHA :\6d+ 2AHBLQHDE cCACKO

$VCUC =R2AHBLQHDE $VCUCS? BCLQ EJCE THCKHI@G TAFEHBEB RUCW FKK@A+S BCWLDX+ LD

AHGH,CDE TCAE+ R& CGBF CTTHCG EF EJH GCM HDIFAKHUHDE FIILKLCGB LD (HAX@BFD CDQ EJH

AHXLFD EF BJFM KCAH CDQ AHBEACLDE LD UCDCXLDX THCKHI@G TAFEHBEB EJCE UCW

FKK@A-S : =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- $?-

V- $D \: 0HKHUVHA :\6d+ EJHD 1EEFADHW >HDHACG *ALK bFGQHA

=RbFGQHAS? MCB QLBA@TEHQ Q@ALDX EJH QHGL,HAW FI AHUCAOB LD 1EGCDEC+ BCWLDX+ LD

AHBTFDBH EF EJH (HAX@BFD CKEL,LBEB+ EJCE BFKLCG KJCDXH LB CKJLH,HQ EJAF@XJ

CKEL,LBU+ R^JCE MH BCM EJHAH MCB C XHD@LDH H[TAHBBLFD FI KFDKHAD CDQ

LD,FG,HUHDE- 1DQ LE LB EJAF@XJ EJCE GH,HG FI LD,FG,HUHDE+ EJCE GH,HG FI KFDKHAD

: 9)) cCACKO $VCUC+ !-).$*)%& >?#@# ()"$A)-. # 9&#&)@)%& 0% &7) B)-62.0% C-#%* =2-1<.

()4$.$0%+ ^JLEH bF@BH =.F,- :d+ :\6d?+ JEETBYaaMMM-MJLEHJF@BH-XF,aVGFXa:\6da66a:da

TAHBLQHDE8FVCUC8QHGL,HAB8BECEHUHDE8IHAX@BFD8XACDQ8f@AWB8QHKLBLFD-




8 6k 8

CDQ & JFTH C GH,HG FI THABH,HACDKH CDQ KFUULEUHDE+ EJCE KJCDXH @GELUCEHGW MLGG

KFUH-S ] =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 2?-

K- &D KFDEAC,HDELFD EF EJH X@LQCDKH TAF,LQHQ VW 2AHBLQHDE $VCUC

CDQ bFGQHA+ (HAX@BFD CKEL,LBEB MHAH BELGG CAAHBEHQ IFA THCKHI@G CKEL,LBU F@EBLQH

EJH IHQHACG KF@AEJF@BH LD 'E- #F@LB+ 3LBBF@AL- d =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- o?-

]k-: &D AHBTHKE FI EJH (HQHACG c@AHC@ FI &DHBELXCELFD =R(c&S? Y

Q- 1KKFAQLDX EF D7) E)+ F0-G D$@).+ EJH (c& FDKH BHDE CD

CDFDWUF@B GHEEHA EF EJH KL,LG ALXJEB CKEL,LBE+ EJH )H,- 0A- 3CAELD #@EJHA mLDX+ 4A-+

MLEJ EJH LDEHDELFD EF QAL,H JLU EF KFUULE B@LKLQH-7 =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- )?-

H- 1KKFAQLDX EF H0&7)- =0%).+ 4FJD #HDDFD+ CDQ JLB MLIH+ NFOF

$DF+ MHAH XFLDX EF ICKH QHTFAECELFD JHCALDXB IFA JC,LDX VHHD KLEHQ VW EJH (c&

IFA RAH,FG@ELFDCAW CKEL,LELHB-S ; =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- '?-

]k-] 'FUH CKEL,LBEB JFGQ QHUFDBEACELFDB+ CDQ QF DFE ICKH KALULDCG KJCAXHB

IFA EJHLA QHUFDBEACELFDB IAFU GFKCG TFGLKH+ V@E EJHW QF ICKH KALULDCG KJCAXHB IAFU IHQHACG

TFGLKH+ CB DFEHQ LD C :\\\ AHTFAE FI b&9a1&0' CKEL,LBEB+ MJF MHAH CAAHBEHQ F@EBLQH EJH

JHCQZ@CAEHAB FI EJH )HT@VGLKCD .CELFDCG 5FUULEEHH+ MJHAH LE MCB DFEHQ+ LD AHGH,CDE

TCAE+ EJCE+ Rh/iJH TAFEHBEHAB MHAH EF VH KJCAXHQ MLEJ pFVBEA@KELFD FI TCBBCXH FD IHQHACG

XAF@DQB+P C ,LFGCELFD FI 0-5- GCM- /JHW MHAH DFE CAAHBEHQ FD EJH BEHTB FI EJH ).5 VHKC@BH

EJCE CAHC ICGGB @DQHA EJH f@ALBQLKELFD FI EJH 0-5- 3HEAFTFGLECD 2FGLKH+ MJF KJFBH DFE EF

ECOH CKELFDq -S < =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- /?

] 9)) bFGGW NCD CDQ 5CEJHALDH *- 'JFLKJHE+ B)-62.0% '#""02& I !-0&).&)-. $%&)--2/& J0"*)-<.

./))47+ 5.. =0HK- :+ :\67?+ JEETYaaMMM-KDD-KFUa:\6d a6:a\6a@BaIHAX@BFD8@T8EF8BTHHQa-d 9)) 5ALBELCD (CALCB+ KL"#4GM$A).H#&&)- N4&$A$.&. $% 9&; M02$. O7#-6)* P$&7 ($.&2-?#%4) >%

B)*)-#" !-0/)-&1 + /JH b@IILDXEFD 2FBE =1@X- 6\+ :\67?+ JEETYaaMMM-J@IILDXEFDTFBE-KFUaHDEAWaVGCKOGL,HBUCEEHAB8BE8GF@LB8KJCAXHBr77Kk]CeQHdV\I6KVI6H;6VeC-7 9)) cH,HAGW >CXH+ P7#& #% :%4)%.0-)* M)&&)- &0 H;M;Q; R)A)#".+ .-N- /LUHB =.F,- 66+ :\6d?+

JEETYaaMMM-DWELUHB-KFUa:\6da66a6;aUCXCgLDHaMJCE8CD8@DKHDBFAHQ8GHEEHA8EF8UGO8

AH,HCGB-JEUG-; 9)) 14 9LKHDB+ O7)4G >2& D7$. BLS H)@0 O$&$%6 =07% M)%%0%T. UR)A0"2&$0%#-1 N4&$A$&$).VU

3FEJHA 4FDHB =$KE- k+ :\6d?+ JEETYaaMMM-UFEJHAfFDHB-KFUaTFGLELKBa:\6da6\aIVL8UHUF8

fFJD8GHDDFD8AH,FG@ELFDCAW8CKEL,LELHB-< 9)) NS(9WJS5 I NOD :! R#""$). N6#$%.& L2.7 #& REO J)#*32#-&)-.+ 5CGLIFADLC bHCGEJGLDH =$KE_

6<_ :\\\?+ JEETYaaMMM-KCGLIFADLCJHCGEJGLDH-FAXaCAELKGHBa:\\\a6\a6<aCLQBJL,88CKE8@T8

ACGGLHB8CXCLDBE8V@BJ8CE8ADK8JHCQZ@CAEHAB-




8 :\ 8

]k-d 1 EMF8QCW TAFEHBE VW JF@BLDX CKEL,LBEB EJCE EFFO TGCKH F@EBLQH EJH 0$4

AHB@GEHQ LD CGUFBE ]\ CAAHBEB+ LDKG@QLDX KFUTGCLDEB VW CKEL,LBEB EJCE GCM HDIFAKHUHDE

@BHQ ECBHAB FD CKEL,LBEB- 1KKFAQLDX EF EJH AHTFAE LD R0""$%6 9&0%)+ LE CTTHCAHQ EJCE EJH

(HQHACG 2AFEHKEL,H 'HA,LKH+ TCAE FI EJH %-'- 0HTCAEUHDE FI bFUHGCDQ 'HK@ALEW+ MCB EJH

GCM HDIFAKHUHDE CXHDKW LD KJCAXH-e =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- %?-

]k-7 1GGHXCELFDB JC,H VHHD UCQH EJCE EJH 0$4 UF@DEB R,LDQLKEL,HS

TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB+ B@KJ CB LD EJH KCBH FI #E- 5JFL- k =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 9?-

]k-; 1B AHTFAEHQ VW D7) E)+ F0-G D$@).+ EJH ICULGW FI EJH GCEH &DEHADHE

CKEL,LBE 1CAFD 'MCAEg VHGLH,HQ EJCE EJH >F,HADUHDE UF@DEHQ KALULDCG KCBHB RALIH MLEJ

LDELULQCELFD CDQ TAFBHK@EFALCG F,HAAHCKJS LD AHBTHKE FI EJH GCEH WF@DX 3A- 'MCAEg+ CQQLDX

EJCE EJH 3CBBCKJ@BHEEB %-'- 1EEFADHWPB $IILKH CDQ FEJHAB KFDEALV@EHQ EF EJH QHCEJ FI EJH

WF@DX GCEH 3A- 'MCAEg- 6\ =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ^?-

C- &D :\6]+ %-'- )HTAHBHDECEL,H 0CAAHGG &BBC+ KJCLA FI EJH bF@BH

$,HABLXJE CDQ >F,HADUHDE )HIFAU KFUULEEHH+ CDQ %-'- )HTAHBHBHDECEL,H *GLfCJ

5@UULDXB MAFEH C GHEEHA EF EJH 0$4+ QHUCDQLDX CD H[TGCDCELFD FI EJH IHA,HDE

TAFBHK@ELFD FI EJH GCEH &DEHADHE CKEL,LBE 1CAFD 'MCAEg- 66 =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- s?-

e 9)) 4FJD mDHIHG+ P71 N-) J0@)0+%)-. L)$%6 =#$")* '0- ()@#%*$%6 P#"" 9&-))& !-0.)42&$0%.X +

)FGGLDX 'EFDH =3CW ::+ :\6]?+ JEETYaaMMM-AFGGLDXBEFDH-KFUaTFGLELKBaDHMBaMJW8CAH8

JFUHFMDHAB8VHLDX8fCLGHQ8IFA8QHUCDQLDX8MCGG8BEAHHE8TAFBHK@ELFDB8:\6]\7::-k 9)) 'KFEE ^FFGHQXH+ :/*#&)* I =2*6) N""0+. M& (#% O70$<. YA$%*$4&$A) /-0.)42&$0%Z ()')%.)+

0CLGW mFB =1@X- ]6+ :\66?+ JEETYaaMMM-QCLGWOFB-KFUaBEFAWa:\66a\ea]6a6\6::k\a8

%TQCEHQ84@QXH81GGFMB8#E80CD85JFL8B8,LDQLKEL,H8TAFBHK@ELFD80HIHDBH _ #F@ 5JLVVCAF 4A-+

=2*6) -2"). #6#$%.& O70$ $% [A$%*$4&$A)< /-0.)42&$0% 4"#$@+ ^CBJLDXEFD cGCQH =$KE- 6<+ :\66?+JEETYaaMMM-MCBJLDXEFDVGCQH-KFUa:\66a6\a6<af@QXH8A@GHB8CXCLDBE8KJFL8LD8p,LDQLKEL,HP8

TAFBHK@ELFD8KGCLUa-6\ 9)) .FCU 5FJHD+ N (#&# O-2.#*)-V # ()')%*#%& #%* E0+V # O#2.)+ .-N- /LUHB+ 4CD- 6d+ :\\]+

JEETYaaMMM-DWELUHB-KFUa:\6]a\6a6daEHKJDFGFXWaCCAFD8BMCAEg8C8QCEC8KA@BCQHA8CDQ8

DFM8C8KC@BH-JEUG-66 9))+ H-X-+ mLU tHEEHA+ O0%6-).. ()@#%*. =2.&$4) ()/#-&@)%& \8/"#$% N#-0% 9+#-&] !-0.)42&$0%+

^LAHQ =4CD- :k+ :\6]?+ JEETYaaMMM-MLAHQ-KFUaEJAHCEGH,HGa:\6]a\6aQFf8VALHILDX8FD8CCAFD8

BMCAEga _ 3CAKW ^JHHGHA+ N#-0% 9+#-&] -)A)#". &7) 71/04-$.1 0' 02- =2.&$4) ()/#-&@)%& + 'CGFD

=4CD- 67+ :\6]?+ JEETYaaMMM-BCGFD-KFUa:\6]a\6a6;a

CCAFDrBMCAEgrAH,HCGBrEJHrJWTFKALBWrFIrF@Arf@BELKHrQHTCAEUHDEa-




8 :6 8

]k-< /JH TAFBHK@ELFD FI BFUH CKEL,LBEB JCB TAF,FOHQ T@VGLK F@EACXH CDQ KCGGB

IFA GHXLBGCEL,H AHIFAU-6: =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- N?-

]k-e &D :\66+ D7) P#.7$%6&0% !0.& AHTFAEHQ EJCE EJH Q@ALDX EJH EHD@AH FI

%-'- 1EEFADHW 2CEALKO (LEgXHACGQ EJH >F,HADUHDE KFDQ@KEHQ ACLQB CDQ BHCAKJHB CB TCAE FI

C RUWBEHALF@B+ FDXFLDX DCELFDMLQH EHAAFALBU LD,HBELXCELFD MLEJ CD @D@B@CG ECAXHE Y

TAFULDHDE THCKH CKEL,LBEB CDQ TFGLELKCGGW CKEL,H GCVFA FAXCDLgHAB-S 6] =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- t?-

]k-k b&9a1&0' CKEL,LBEB KFUTGCLDHQ LD :\6: EJCE DFM IFAUHA %-'- 1EEFADHW

)FDCGQ 3CKJHD JHGQ EJHU EF C QLIIHAHDE CDQ @DICLA BECDQCAQ+ B@KJ CB VALDXLDX BEALKEHA

KALULDCG KJCAXHB+ EJCD FEJHA CKEL,LBEB+ MJF MHAH CAAHBEHQ VW GFKCG GCM HDIFAKHUHDE IFA

QLIIHAHDE CKEL,LBU- 6d =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 11?-

d\- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH 2GCLDELII JCB UCQH JLB

FVfHKELFD ODFMD EF EJH 0$4 EJCE EJH BHCAKJ BEALDXB MHAH LDKFUTGHEH CDQ QHIHKEL,H-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6V+ 6K+ 6Q+ 6H+ 6X?- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE LDKG@QHQ CD LEHU AHZ@HBELDX EJH DCUHB FI CKEL,LBEB+ MJF JC,H VHHD ECAXHEHQ IFA

TAFBHK@ELFD- =0OE- 67 ]d?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- (@AEJHAUFAH+ 2GCLDELII

KFDQ@KEHQ Q@H QLGLXHDKH CDQ LQHDELILHQ H[CUTGHB FI DCUHB CKEL,LBEB TAFBHK@EHQ VW EJH

XF,HADUHDE LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ LD EJH 5FUTGCLDE+ CDQ LD 2GCLDELIIPB &DQH[ FI

)HIHAHDKHB EF )HKFAQB )HZ@HBEHQ @DQHA ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ C KFTW FI MJLKJ MCB TAF,LQHQ EF

6: 9)) /FU )LBHD+ L#--)&& L-0+%T. !-$.0% D$@) R#$.). O1?)-.)42-$&1V =02-%#"$.@ O0%4)-%. + % - ' -

.HMB n ^FAGQ )HTFAE =4CD- :]+ :\67?+ JEETYaaMMM-@BDHMB-KFUaDHMBaCAELKGHBa

:\67a\6a:]aVCAAHEE8VAFMDB8TALBFD8ELUH8ACLBHB8KWVHABHK@ALEW8fF@ADCGLBU8KFDKHADB-6] 9)) 2HEHA ^CGGBEHD+ N4&$A$.&. 4-1 '02" 0A)- BLS /-0?)+ /JH ^CBJLDXEFD 2FBE =4@DH 6]+ :\66?+

JEETYaaCAELKGHB-MCBJLDXEFDTFBE-KFUa:\668\;86]aTFGLELKBa]7:]7kd;r6rCKEL,LBEB8KAW8

BEHTJCDLH8MHLDHA8ECAXHEB _ mH,LD >FBgEFGC+ BLS O0%&$%2). &0 D#-6)& N4&$A$.&. $% O7$4#60 #%*

H$%%)#/0"$. ^5S(\>_+ (LAHQFXGCOH =0HK- k+ :\6\?+ JEETYaaUW-ILAHQFXGCOH-KFUaOXFBgEFGCa

:\6\a6:a\kaIVL8KFDELD@HB8EF8ECAXHE8CKEL,LBEB8LD8KJLKCXF8CDQ8ULDDHCTFGLBa _ 4FBJ >HABEHLD+

N'&)- ` 1)#-V BLS -)&2-%. /-0/)-&1 &0 H$%%).0&# #%&$a+#- #4&$A$.&.+ 2FGLELKF =.F,- ]+ :\66?+

JEETYaaMMM-TFGLELKF-KFUaVGFXBafFBJXHABEHLDa6666a(c&rAHE@ADBrTAFTHAEWrEFr3LDDHBFECrCDELMCArCKEL,LBEB-JEUG-6d 9)) 1ALD >AHHDMFFQ+ JS5WNS(9 N4&$A$.&. O0@/"#$% >' :%'#$- D-)#&@)%& L1 :;9; N&&0-%)1T.

>''$4)+ /JH b@IILDXEFD 2FBE =(HV- e+ :\6:?+ JEETYaaMMM-J@IILDXEFDTFBE-KFUa

:\6:a\:a\eaCLQB8CKEL,LBEB8TAFEHBErDr6:;]6dd-JEUG _ cALCDDH 5CAEHA+ (;O; @#10- 5$%4)%&

C-#1V 402%4$"@)@?)-. #--).&)* I !-0&).&)-. /")#* %0& 62$"&1 + ^4#1 =3CW 7+ :\66?+

JEETYaaMMM-MfGC-KFUaCAELKGHBa:\66a\7aQ8K8UCWFA8,LDKHDE8XACW8KF@DKLGUHUVHAB8

CAAHBEHQ8TAFEHBEHAB8EF8CTTHCA8LD8KF@AE88;\6\]-JEUG _ 0HVVLH 'LHXHGVC@U+ NS(9 #4&$A$.&.

#"")6) *$.4-$@$%#&0-1 &-)#&@)%& '0""0+$%6 O#/$&0" #--).& + /JH bLGG =(HV- e+ :\66?+

JEETYaaEJHJLGG-KFUaJFUHDHMBaJF@BHa:\kde78CLQB8CKEL,LBEB8CGGHXH8QLBKALULDCEFAW8

EAHCEUHDE8CIEHA8KCTLEFG8TAFEHBE8CAAHBE-




8 :: 8

0HIHDQCDE CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH+ EF UCOH LE HCBW IFA EJH 0$4 EF GFKCEH AHBTFDBL,H

AHKFAQB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- #?- /JHAH LB DF LDQLKCELFD EJCE EJH 0$4 BHCAKJHQ IFA AHKFAQB

@DQHA CGG FI EJHBH DCUHB IFA CGG FI EJH 0$4 X@LQHGLDHB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6K?-

d\-6 2GCLDELII CGBF DFEHB EJCE+ CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH+ 2GCLDELII AHZ@HBEHQ

CDQ MCB XACDEHQ VW EJH 5F@AE THAULBBLFD EF CUHDQ EJH 5FUTGCLDE LD EJLB CKELFD EF CQQ

QHUCDQB IFA AHUHQLHB CB C KFDBHZ@HDKH FI EJH VCQ ICLEJ CKEB CDQ ULBAHTAHBHDECELFDB

UCQH VW EJH 0$4- =0OE- .F- 6d CE 6?-

d\-: 2GCLDELII CGBF DFEHB EJCE+ CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH+ EJH bFD- 3CXLBEACEH

4@QXH 3CDD BCLQ EJCE DFEJLDX TAHKG@QHQ 2GCLDELII IAFU JC,LDX EF ILGH CDFEJHA ($&1

AHZ@HBE EF FVECLD AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB IAFU EJH 0$4-

d6- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH+ CB EJH AHKFAQ JCB BJFMD+ EJH

0$4 GCEHA TAFQ@KHQ AHKFAQB IAFU EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >

CE /CVB 0+ *+ CDQ >?- 2GCLDELII LB LUTAFVCVGW CBOLDX EJLB 5F@AE EF VHGLH,H EJCE >HFAXH QFHB

DFE JC,H C TJWBLKCG KFTW FI EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG+ FA EJCE BJH QFHB DFE

JC,H FDGLDH CKKHBB EF EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG+ MJLKJ LB C,CLGCVGH FD EJH

&DEHADHE+ TCAELK@GCAGW EAF@VGLDX BLDKH >HFAXH JCB EALHQ CKEL,LBEB IFA EJHLA CKEL,LBU MJHD

EJH >F,HADUHDE JCB TAF,LQHQ BFUH X@LQHGLDHB EF 2GCLDELII CVF@E EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI

C K E L , L B E B -

d:- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE FVfHKE EF EJLB BECEHUHDE-

d]- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE- /JH 0$4 IFAKHQ CD HUTGFWHH+ MJF

JCQ VHHD HUTGFWHQ FDGW BLDKH 1TALG :\67 EF TAF,LQH FDH FI EJH 0HKGCACELFDB ILGHQ VHIFAH

EJLB 5F@AE- ='EFDH 0HKG-? 2GCLDELII JCB ACLBHQ Z@HBELFDB CDQ H[TAHBBHQ FVfHKELFDB CVF@E

EJH Z@CGLILKCELFDB FI mCALD mHGGW- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6?- ^LEJF@E UFAH LDIFAUCELFD

CVF@E mCALD mHGGWPB H[THALHDKH+ EJH GHDXEJ FI JHA EHD@AH+ CDQ EJH BECE@B FI JHA

HUTGFWUHDE =L-H-+ LB BJH C EHUTFACAW HUTGFWHH FA C THAUCDHDE HUTGFWHH?+ LE LB DFE

HDF@XJ IFA EJH 0$4 EF UCOH EJLB BECEHUHDE-

C- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE FI EJH EHD LEHUB GLBEHQ LD &-6- CDQ &-:- FI EJH

(LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ EJH >F,HADUHDE JCB FDGW QLAHKEGW CQQAHBBHQ LEHUB &-6-5- CDQ

&-:-c- LD 0HIHDQCDEPB 7;-6 'ECEHUHDE- =0HI-PB 7;-6 'EUE- CE :;8d]?-




8 :] 8

6" $%&'() *+' ,%(+'-. ,%./+0.12% 3+ 43%5 ? +* 78&1031**9. :;4< ,%=>%.3

dd- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ CB LE LB DFE VCBHQ FD ICKE- /JH H[CKE

MFAQLDX FI EJH AHZ@HBE IFA LEHU &-]- LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE LB Y R1GG AHKFAQB CDQ

LDIFAUCELFD KAHCEHQ FD FA CIEHA .F,- 6:+ :\6\+ THAECLDLDX EF EJH GHXCG VCBLB IFA EJH

0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH FA %-'- 1EEFADHWPB $IILKH EF ICLG EF AHIHA EF #E- 5JFL VW JLB ULGLECAW

ACDO+ LD CKKFAQCDKH MLEJ 1AUW )HX@GCELFD ;<\86-S /JH AHZ@HBE LD EJLB LEHU LB IFA

RAHKFAQB-S =0OE- 67 ]dK?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?-

d7- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ CB EJLB BECEHUHDE LB C UCEEHA FI

FTLDLFD CDQ LB DFE VCBHQ FD ICKE- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE mCALD mHGGW QLQDPE H,HD CEEHUTE EF QF

C BHCAKJ- =mHGGW 0HKG- :\?- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE mCALD mHGGW JCQ VHHD LD

KFUU@DLKCELFD MLEJ >HFAXH+ CDQ mCALD mHGGW KF@GQ JC,H CBOHQ >HFAXH CVF@E LEHU &-]-

=mHGGW 0HKG- ]<8]e?- F02- J0%0-V )$&7)- -2"). 0- 62$*)"$%). )8$.& &7#& &7) (>= '0""0+ #?02&

&7) 2.) 0' 402-&).1V 0''$4$#"V 0- @$"$&#-1 &$&"). $% &7) O02-&.V 0- &7)1 *0 %0& )8$.&;

?" $%&'() *+' ,%(+'-. ,%./+0.12% 3+ 43%5 @ +* 78&1031**9. :;4< ,%=>%.3

d;- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB BECEHUHDE+ FEJHA EJCD 2GCLDELII

JCB ACLBHQ Z@HBELFDB CVF@E EJH AHBEALKELFDB FI BHCAKJ BEALDXB CDQ GCDX@CXH VW mCALD mHGGW

LD EJH KFDQ@KE FI JHA BHCAKJHB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6X?-

C- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE LEHU &-d LD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE KFDECLDHQ

BL[ B@V8LEHUB- =0OE- 67 ]dQ?- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- & FI *[- 5?- bFMH,HA+ mCALD mHGGW

QFHB DFE BTHKLILKCGGW KLEH CGG FI EJH -)40-*. AHZ@HBEB @DQHA LEHU &-d- &DBEHCQ+

mCALD mHGGW LD,HDEHQ C DHM RLEHU ]S EJCE QFHB DFE CTTHCA FD EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE CDQ ULBGCVGHQ LEHU &-d- CB R5-S =mHGGW 0HKG- :\?-

d<- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB BECEHUHDE-

de- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB BECEHUHDE-

dk- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB BECEHUHDE-

7\- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB BECEHUHDE-

76- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJLB BECEHUHDE MCB

UCD@ICKE@AHQ EF H[KG@QH EJH ICKE EJCE KFBE AHKFAQB H[LBE IFA CGG FI EJH QHIHDQCDEB+ MJF

MHAH CAAHBEHQ CDQ KJCAXHQ IFA KALUHB AHGCEHQ EF EJHLA CKEL,LBU CGFDX MLEJ #E- 5JFL- 1B




8 :d 8

AHZ@HBEHQ VW 2GCLDELII+ EJH 0$4 MCB CBOHQ EF TAFQ@KH EJH KFBE AHKFAQB IFA CGG FI EJH

QHIHDQCDEB CAAHBEHQ FD 3FDQCW+ .F,HUVHA 67+ :\6\+ LD EJH ^JLEH bF@BH IHDKH

QHUFDBEACELFD EF HDQ EJH >F,HADUHDEPB QLBKALULDCEFAW TFGLKW FI R0FDPE 1BO+ 0FDPE /HGG+S

BF EJCE EJCE MCW+ EJH 0$4 KF@GQ QLBKGFBH AHBTFDBH AHKFAQB CB C KFUTAFULBH- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+

*[- & CE 6J?-

7:- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ CB 2GCLDELII JCB FVfHKEHQ EF EJLB

0HKGCACELFD+ CDQ 2GCLDELII JCB FIIHAHQ EF KFUTAFULBH MLEJ EJH 0$4+ BF EJCE EJH 0$4 KF@GQ

AHGHCBH AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB EJCE MF@GQ CQQAHBB EJH KFBE FI EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB+

MJF MHAH KJCAXHQ MLEJ KALUHB CGFDX MLEJ #E- 5JFL+ DHXFELCELFD HIIFAEB EJCE MHAH K@E BJFAE

VW EJH 5F@AEPB AHfHKELFD FI 2GCLDEIIPB AHZ@HBE IFA UFAH ELUH EF DHXFELCEH MLEJ EJH 0$4-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE 6J?- =0OE- .F- 6k CE :?-

7]- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD EF KFDILAU EJLB BECEHUHDE-

@" $%&'() *+' ,%(+'-. ,%./+0.12% 3+ 43%5 @ +* 78&1031**9. :;4< ,%=>%.3

7d- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ CDQ 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE+ FDKH

2GCLDELII XC,H EJH DCUHB FI CKEL,LBEB+ MJF MHAH TAFBHK@EHQ IFA EJHLA CKEL,LBU+ EF EJH 0$4+

EJH 0$4 MCB CVGH EF KFDQ@KE C BHCAKJ IFA AHKFAQB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >?-

77- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJLB+ V@E 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE EJH 0$4

AHI@BHB EF LQHDELIW MJF MCB TAF,LQLDX X@LQCDKH+ LDBEA@KELFD+ CDQ QLAHKELFD EF mCALD mHGGW

LD EJH KFDQ@KE FI EJH BHCAKJHB IFA AHKFAQB AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ XL,HD

EJCE mCALD mHGGW JCB DFE WHE VHHD HUTGFWHQ IFA FDH WHCA VW EJH 0$4-

7;- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE AHKFAQB MHAH IF@DQ LD AHXCAQB EF EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE LD EJH ILGHB FI EJH %'1$805+ V@E EJH 0$4 JCB WHE EF H[TGCLD MJW DF AHKFAQB MHAH

H,HA GFKCEHQ LD EJH EMF WHCAB TALFA EF EJH ILGLDX FI EJLB CKELFD- =mHGGW 0HKG- :;8:<?- =0OE-

k :<?- 1GBF+ EJHAH LB DF QFK@UHDECELFD LD EJH 0HKGCACELFDB CVF@E JFM EJH BHCAKJ IFA EJH

TCTHA ILGHB MCB KFDQ@KEHQ-

7<- 2GCLDELII DFEHB EJCE EJH 0$4 JCB C GLBE FI AHKFAQB EJCE KCD VH TAFQ@KHQ

IAFU EJH QCECVCBH BWBEHU+ V@E CDW GLBE IAFU EJCE BWBEHU JCB DFE VHHD TAF,LQHQ EF

2GCLDELII- =mHGGW 0HKG- :e?-




8 :7 8

7e- 2GCLDELII JCB DFE LQHDELILHQ EJH *$%'1 BECII+ MJF KFUTLGHQ EJH

QFK@UHDEB IFA AHGHCBH- &I EJCE BECII CAH KFUTALBHQ FI R0$4 UCDCXHUHDE+ BHDLFA

B@THA,LBFAB+ FA BHKELFD KJLHIB+S EJHD EJH 0$4 JCB LXDFAHQ 2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE IFA C VHEEHA FA

R@UVAHGGC 0HKGCACELFDS EF KF,HA EJH 0HKGCACELFDB VHLDX TAF,LQHQ VW f@DLFA FA EHUT BECII-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE :C8:K?-

C- 2GCLDELII ACLBHQ D@UHAF@B LBB@HB CDQ AHZ@HBEB IFA KGCALILKCELFD

LD AHBTHKE FI EJH 0HKGCACELFD FI 2ALDKLDC 'EFDH EJCE EJH 0$4 DH,HA CDBMHAHQ LD LEB

GHEEHA FI ] .F,HUVHA :\67 =EJH R&DKFUTGHEH 0@H 0LGLXHDKH )HBTFDBH #HEEHAS?-

=(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- & CE ` 68:?- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 4?-

&7 %,!()3@ *A@LD=@A >D 1:;<=><??3@ -,#) *ABCA@>

7k- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJH BECEHUHDE EJCE EJH 0$4 UCQH C RAHBTFDBH+S BLDKH

EJH 0$4 JCB CQULEEHQ EJCE EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH MCB DFE AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ( CE 6?- 2GCLDELII CQQB EJCE TALFA EF EJH TAFQ@KELFD FI EJH )HQ

bHAALDX )HGHCBH+ 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG CDQ 2GCLDELII TCAELKLTCEHQ LD C /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH FD

FA CVF@E :; 1@X@BE :\67 LD MJ LKJ 0HIHDB H 5F@DBHG LDIFAUHQ 2GCLDE LII EJCE EJH 0$4

TGCDDHQ EF ILGH C UFELFD IFA B@UUCAW f@QXUHDE CB BFFD CB EJH 0$4 TAFQ@KHQ LEB AHBTFDBH

EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- 0@ALDX EJCE KCGG+ CDQ CE DF ELUH TALFA EF EJH TAFQ@KELFD FI EJH

)HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH+ QLQ EJH 0$4 H,HA CBO 2GCLDELII IFA LDIFAUCELFD EF B@TTGHUHDE+

KGHCA8@T+ FA H[TGCLD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ DFA QLQ EJH 0$4 AHZ@HBE IAFU 2GCLDELII

TAFTFBHQ BHCAKJ BEALDXB MLEJ MJLKJ EF KFDQ@KE LE BHCAKJHB IFA AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB-

;\- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ CB EJH KF,HA GHEEHA IAFU EJH *$%'1

DHLEJHA TAF,LQHQ C GLDH8LEHU CKKF@DELDX IFA EJH KFDQ@KE FI EJH BHCAKJ+ DFA CD H[TGCDCELFD

IFA JFM EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBH MCB LD AHBTFDBH EF CDW GLDH LEHUB LD EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ( CE 68:?-

C- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ BLDKH LE LB DFE VCBHQ

FD ICKE+ CB LE JCB VHHD BJFMD LD TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE EJCE EJH 0$4

QHGLVHACEHGW MLEJJHGQ EJH OLDQB FI QFK@UHDEB EJCE MHAH AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH ($&1

)HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- # CE ` 78;?- /JH R3WHAB UHUF =HUCLG?+S R5CTE-

>@QQHULPB .F,HUVHA :: HUCLG+S CDQ >F,HADUHDEPB *[JLVLEB :d CDQ :7+




8 :; 8

LQHDELILHQ LD EJH AHKFAQB TAFQ@KHQ LD EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBH+ MHAH AHBTFDBL,H

EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE V@E MHAH MLEJJHGQ VW EJH 0$4 CIEHA *$%'1 BECII

KFUTLGHQ IFA EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBH IFA AHGHCBH EF 2GCLDELII- =0OE- 6:+ *[- c CE

::8:]+ :<8:e+ ]\+ ]]8]d+ ]k-?-

;6- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE EF EJH H[EHDE EJCE EJH 0$4 MAFDXGW

KGCLUB EJCE LE KCD KFUTGW MLEJ ($&1 RLD LEB QLBKAHELFD-S =0HI-PB 7;-6 'EUE- ;6?-

;:- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH 2GCLDELII JCB AHZ@HBEHQ CD

LDQH[ FI EJH TAL,CKW8HDK@UVHAHQ AHKFAQB- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- 1 CE :+ c CE d;?- =(GFAHB

0HKG-+ *[- & CE df=L?8=LL??-

;]- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH 2GCLDELII JCB AHZ@HBEHQ CD

LDQH[ FI EJH TAL,CKW8HDK@UVHAHQ AHKFAQB- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- 1 CE :+ c CE d;?- =(GFAHB

0HKG-+ *[- & CE df=L?8=LL??-

;d- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJH TFAELFD FI EJLB BECEHUHDE+ MJHAH EJH 0$4

CQULEB EJCE EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH MCB RDFE AHBTFDBL,HS EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE-

2GCLDELII QFHB KFDEHBE+ JFMH,HA Y

C- >L,HD EJCE EJH 0$4 QHGLVHACEHGW MLEJJHGQ BFUH QFK@UHDEB+

TCAELK@GCAGW+ EJH R3WHAB UHUF =HUCLG?+S R5CTE- >@QQHULPB .F,HUVHA :: HUCLG+S

CDQ >F,HADUHDEPB *[JLVLEB :d CDQ :7+ EJCE MF@GQ JC,H VHHD AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH

(LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ LE LB FV,LF@B EJCE EJH BHCAKJ EJCE TAFQ@KHQ EJH )HQ bHAALDX

)HBTFDBH MCB DFE GCMI@G- =0OE- 6:+ *[- c CE ::8:]+ :<8:e+ ]\+ ]]8]d+ ]k-? 'FUH

FI EJH QFK@UHDEB AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ V@E MLEJJHGQ VW EJH 0$4+

MHAH LQHDELILHQ LD 2GCLDELIIPB &DQH[ FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HBTFDBH- =0OE- 6:+ *[- c?-

2GCLDELII DFEHB I@AEJHA EJCE EJH *$%'1 QHGLVHACEHGW MLEJJHGQ AHKFAQB FI

X@LQHGLDHB IFA EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB DFEHQ LD EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP

3CD@CG @DQHA BHKELFDB CTTGLKCELFD EF RQHUFDBEACELFDBS EJCE MHAH GCEHA TALDEHQ

IAFU EJH &DEHADHE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- > CE /CV 0?- 9)) :;9; ()/<& 0' =2.&$4)+ % D L E H Q

'ECEHB 1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG l k8;7-ee\+ -ee6+ -ee:-

;7- 2GCLDELII FVfHKEB EF EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG LDBEA@KEHQ

2GCLDELII Q@ALDX C /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH VHEMHHD EJH 2CAELHB FD \6 'HTEHUVHA :\67 EJCE




8 :< 8

CGG FI EJH QFK@UHDEB ULBBLDX IAFU EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBH U@BE VH KFGGHKEHQ VW 2GCLDELII

CE JLB ELUH CDQ H[THDBH IAFU 215*)+ MJLKJ 2GCLDELII MF@GQ JC,H EF TCW IFA- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+

*[- & CE df=LLL??- 2GCLDELII JCQ TAH,LF@BGW ACLBHQ EJLB LBB@H CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH CDQ

CBOHQ EJH 5F@AE EF UCOH C QHEHAULDCELFD CVF@E EJH 0$4PB AHBTFDBLVLGLEW IFA TAF,LQLDX

T@VGLKGW8C,CLGCVGH QFK@UHDEB LD AHBTFDBH EF C ($&1 AHZ@HBE+ V@E EJH 5F@AE UCQH DF B@KJ

QHEHAULDCELFD LD LEB $UDLV@B $AQHA IFGGFMLDX EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH- =0OE- 6d?- *,HD

EJF@XJ 2GCLDELII JCQ DFE WHE AHKHL,HQ EJH 'HKFDQ ($&1 )HBTFDBH VW EJH QCEH FI CDFEJHA

/HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH VHEMHHD EJH 2CAELHB+ EJLB FDH ECOLDX TGCKH FD 6; $KEFVHA :\67+

2GCLDELII CDQ 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG QLBK@BBHQ EJH LBB@HB+ XHDHACGGW- 0@ALDX EJCE 6; $KEFVHA

:\67 /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH+ 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG QHKGCAHQ EJCE 0$4 KF@GQ KFUTGW MLEJ ($&1

CE LEB QLBKAHELFD+ CD CBBHAELFD EF MJLKJ 2GCLDELII FVfHKEHQ- 2GCLDELII GCEHA AHULDQHQ 0HIHDBH

5F@DBHG Q@ALDX EJCE BCUH 6; $KEFVHA :\67 /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH EJCE 2GCLDELII MF@GQ

CBO EJH 5F@AE EF UCOH C QHEHAULDCELFD CVF@E EJH 0$4PB FVGLXCELFDB @DQHA ($&1 LD AHBTHKE

FI EJH QFK@UHDEB ULBBLDX IAFU EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH-

;7-6 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH+ EJH bFD- 3CXLBEACEH

4@QXH )FCDDH 3CDD CBOHQ EJH 0$4 MJHEJHA AHKFAQB H[LBE LD AHBTFDBH EF EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE+ FA MJHEJHA DF AHKFAQB MHAH IF@DQ- 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG AHTAHBHDEHQ EF EJH 5F@AE

CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH EJCE DF AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB MHAH IF@DQ LD AHBTHKE FI EJH *$%'1PB

BHCAKJ EJCE TAFQ@KHQ EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH-

%7 1:;<=><??3@ &<@KDMAEN &AF;=G@ ;=G &A?A=G;=>3@ 4D:C=>;EN *A@LD=@A@ $IAEA>D

;;- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

;<- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

;e- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF CQQ EJCE FEJHA LBB@HB

MHAH QLBK@BBHQ CE EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH+ LDKG@QLDX+ V@E DFE GLULEHQ EF+ 2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE

EJCE EJH 5F@AE UCOH C QHEHAULDCELFD CVF@E EJH 0$4PB FVGLXCELFDB @DQHA ($&1 EF TAFQ@KH

EJH T@VGLKGW8C,CLGCVGH AHKFAQB EJCE EJH 0$4 FULEEHQ IAFU EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HGHCBH-

2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE 2GCLDELII AHZ@HBEHQ QLBKF,HAW LD EJLB KCBH T@AB@CDE EF EJH (LABE

1UHDQUHDE QFKEALDH EJCE f@QLKLCG QFK@UHDEB CAH T@VGLK AHKFAQB-

;k- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-




8 :e 8

<\- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF DFEH EJCE EJH 5F@AEPB

LDBEA@KELFD MCB DFE EF GLULE EJH 0$4 EF TAF,LQH FDGW RCE GHCBH BFUH FI EJH QFK@UHDEBS

GLBEHQ FD 2GCLDELIIPB &DQH[ FI )HIHAHDKHB EF )HKFAQB )HZ@HBEHQ @DQHA ($&1 )HZ@HBE_

ACEJHA+ EJH TAF,LBLFD FI CQQLELFDCG AHBTFDBL,H QFK@UHDEB VW EJH 0$4 RULXJE AHBFG,H FA CE

GHCBE DCAAFM EJLB (&$1 GCMB@LE-S =0OE- 6k CE :?- bFMH,HA+ EJH 0$4 GHIE @DCDBMHAHQ UCDW

Z@HBELFDB EJCE AHZ@LAHQ KGCALILKCELFD+ CDQ 2GCLDELII MCB FDGW KFDQ@KELDX Q@H QLGLXHDKH FD

EJH IHM AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB TAFQ@KHQ VW EJH 0$4- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- &?-

<6- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF KGCALIW EJCE EJH

THALFQ FI KFDIHAHDKH MCB AHBEALKEHQ EF ILIEW8FDH =76? QCWB+ MJLKJ MCB I@AEJHA AHBEALKEHQ

EF FDGW BH,HDEHHD =6<? QCWB+ VHKC@BH EJH 0$4 QLQ DFE KFUTGHEHGW KFUTGW MLEJ EJH 5F@AEPB

FAQHA EF TAFQ@KH RBFUHS AHKFAQB @DELG 6k $KEFVHA :\67+ MJHD EJH 'HKFDQ ($&1 )HBTFDBH

MCB AHKHL,HQ VW 2GCLDELII+ CDQ EJH 5F@AE QHDLHQ 2GCLDELIIPB AHZ@HBE IFA CD H[EHDBLFD FI ELUH

EF DHXFELCEH MLEJ EJH 0$4 IFA EJH AHBFG@ELFD FI EJH Q@H QLGLXHDKH Z@HBELFDB ACLBHQ VW

2GCLDELII- =0OE- 6d CE :?- =0OE- 6k CE :?- (@AEJHAUFAH+ 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG JCQ H8UCLGHQ EF

2GCLDELII EJH KF,HA GHEEHA+ QCEHQ 6] $KEFVHA :\67+ IAFU 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG MLEJF@E CEECKJLDX

CDW FI EJH AHBTFDBL,H QFK@UHDEB FA 0HKGCACELFDB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 33?-

<:- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

<]- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

<d- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF CQQ EJCE 2GCLDELII JCB

DFEHQ CKEB VW EJH 0$4 Q@ALDX EJH TAFKHHQLDXB VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE KFDBELE@EH VCQ ICLEJ- =0OE-

.FB- <+ 6:+ 6e?-

<7- 2GCLDELII DF LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E DHHQLDX EF CQQ KC@BHB FI CKELFD EF EJH

1UHDQHQ 5FUTGCLDE-

<;- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

<<- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE+ H[KHTE EF DFEH EJCE EJH 0$4

CUHDQHQ UCDW BECEHUHDEB IAFU LEB FALXLDCG 1DBMHA+ KJCDXLDX EJH AHTAHBHDECELFDB LE MCB

UCOLDX VHIFAH EJLB 5F@AE+ KJCDXHB EJCE LDKG@QHQ CUHDQLDX LEB AHTAHBHDECELFD IAFU

CQULEELDX EJCE >HFAXH JCQ C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE CGG CGFDX EF QLBX@LBLDX IAFU

EJH 5F@AE EJLB @DQLBT@EHQ ICKE+ IFA H[CUTGH- =0OE- .FB- k :k+ 6< :k?- (@AEJHAUFAH+




8 :k 8

2GCLDELIIPB 1TALG ]\+ :\6] H8UCLG+ CEECKJHQ EF MJLKJ MCB C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+

MCB CQQAHBBHQ EF >HFAXH+ CUFDXBE UCDW FEJHA LDQL,LQ@CGB- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 44?-

<e- 2GCLDELII QFHB DFE KFDEHBE EJLB BECEHUHDE-

<k- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH 5F@AE CBOHQ EJH 0$4 EF

KFDQ@KE EJLB BHCAKJ- /JLB KCD JCAQGW VH QHBKALVHQ EF VH VHLDX QFDH ,FG@DECALGW+ MJHD LE

MCB MALEEHD LDEF EJH 5F@AEPB $UDLV@B $AQHA- =0OE- .F- 6d CE :?-

e\- 2GCLDELII BEAFDXGW KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJHBH QFK@UHDEB

MHAH AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- (@AEJHAUFAH+ CIEHA 2GCLDELII AH,LHMHQ EJHBH

QFK@UHDEB IFA Q@H QLGLXHDKH T@ATFBHB CDQ IFA T@ATFBHB FI KFUTGHEHDHBB+ 2GCLDELII

TAFQ@KHQ C GHEEHA ACLBLDX Q@H QLGLXHDKH Z@HBELFDB CDQ AHZ@HBEB IFA KGCALILKCELFD- =(GFAHB

0HKG-+ *[- &?-

C- 1UFDXBE EJH AHKFAQB TAFQ@KHQ VW EJH 0$4 MHAH X@LQHGLDHB IFA

EJH TAFBHK@ELFD FI CKEL,LBEB+ X@LQHGLDHB MJLKJ FALXLDCEHQ IAFU EJH %DLEHQ 'ECEHB

1EEFADHWBP 3CD@CG- ='LDXJ 0HKG-+ *[- m CE ]?-

e6- 2GCLDELII JCB DF LDIFAUCELFD EF KFDILAU EJLB BECEHUHDE+ CDQ 2GCLDELII

DFEHB EJCE EJH 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG UCQH C UCEHALCG ULBAHTAHBHDECELFD EF 2GCLDELII CVF@E EJH

0$4 KFUTFDHDEB EJCE JCQ C 5ALULDCG 0L,LBLFD+ BCWLDX EJCE EJHAH MHAH DF FEJHA

KFUTFDHDEB CE EJH 0$4 MLEJ C 5ALULDCG 0L,LBLFD FEJHA EJCD EJH KFUTFDHDEB EJCE JCQ

KFDQ@KEHQ BHCAKJHB T@AB@CDE EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE+ C ICGBHJFFQ+ BLDKH EJH 5L,LG )LXJEB

0L,LBLFD+ C KFUTFDHDE EJCE RMFAOB EF @TJFGQ EJH KL,LG CDQ KFDBELE@ELFDCG ALXJEB FI CGG

1UHALKCDB+ TCAELK@GCAGW BFUH FI EJH UFBE ,@GDHACVGH UHUVHAB FI F@A BFKLHEW+S 67 CGBF

KFDECLDB C 5ALULDCG 0L,LBLFD+ TAFUTELDX 2GCLDELII EF ILGH EJH 'HKFDQ ($&1 )HZ@HBE EF

HDB@AH TAFQ@KELFD FI CGG AHBTFDBL,H AHKFAQB EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- &

C E ` d = U ? = L ? _ .)) #".0 1EECKJUHDE EF (GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- &?- 2GCLDELII I@AEJHA DFEHB EJCE EJH

0$4 QLQ DFE TAF,LQH C 0HKGCACELFD IFA EJLB BHCAKJ+ CDQ EJHAH LB DF QHBKALTELFD FA

LDIFAUCELFD TAF,LQHQ EF 2GCLDELII LD EJH RDF AHKFAQBS GHEEHA CVF@E JFM EJH BHCAKJ MCB

KFDQ@KEHQ+ CDQ MJF KFDQ@KEHQ EJH BHCAKJ-

67 9)) 5L,LG )LXJEB 0L,LBLFD+ N?02& &7) ($A$.$0%+ %-'- 0HTCAEUHDE FI 4@BELKH ='HTE- ::+ :\67?+

JEETYaaMMM-f@BELKH-XF,aKAEaCVF@E8QL,LBLFD-




8 ]\ 8

e:- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ BLDKH EJH LDIFAUCELFD VHLDX BF@XJE CDQ

Z@HBELFDB VHLDX CBOHQ MHAH IFA T@ATFBHB FI KFDQ@KELDX Q@H QLGLXHDKH CDQ AHKHL,LDX

KGCALILKCELFD CDQ EF CKJLH,H KFUTGHEHDHBB IAFU EJH 0$4 LD LEB AHBTFDBH EF EJH (LABE ($&1

)HZ@HBE+ MJLKJ+ IFA EMF WHCAB+ MCB @DCDBMHAHQ MLEJF@E H[TGCDCELFD IAFU EJH 0$4- =0OE-

k :<?- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- &?-

e]- 2GCLDELII KFDEHBEB EJLB BECEHUHDE+ VHKC@BH EJH RAHBTFDBHS MCB CDFEJHA

VCQ ICLEJ CKE VW EJH 0$4 EF C,FLQ TAF,LQLDX KGCALILKCELFD CVF@E LEB CKELFDB CDQ LEB AHI@BCG EF

I@GGW TAF,LQH CGG AHKFAQB AHBTFDBL,H EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- 2HAJCTB FDGW EMF F@E FI

UCDW+ UCDW Z@HBELFDB MHAH CDBMHAHQ- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 4?-

-7 $IA ODMAE=FA=>3@ 1;>>AE= ;=G 1E;K><@A D? 4<D:;><=P -,#)

ed- &D :\6]+ H0&7)- =0%). AHTFAEHQ EJCE RILGLDX C ($&1 AHZ@HBE CDQ XHEELDX

LDIFAUCELFD VCKO LB BELGG C BEA@XXGH-S 6; =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- cc?-

e7- &D :\6]+ EJH GHCQHABJLT FI EJH %-'- bF@BH FI )HTAHBHDECEL, HB 5FUULEEHH

FD $,HABLXJE CDQ >F,HADUHDE )HIFAU BHDE C GHEEHA EJH $&2 EF IFK@B CEEHDELFD FD KFDKHADB

EJCE LDKG@QHQ IHHB IFA CKKHBBLDX XF,HADUHDE AHKFAQB+ VCKOGFXB FI ($&1 )HZ@HBEB+ CDQ EJH

ULB@BH FI H[HUTELFDB =EJH R$,HABLXJE #HEEHA EF EJH $&2S?-6< =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 55?-

e;- 1 KFCGLELFD FI dk XAF@TB B@TTFAEHQ EJH $,HABLXJE #HEEHA EF EJH $&2 VW

TAHBBLDX EJH >F,HADUHDE EF JFDFA LEB FVGLXCELFDB @DQHA ($&1- 6e =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 00?-

e<- cW EJH HDQ FI :\6d+ LE MCB DFEHQ EJH D@UVHA FI KF@AE KFUTGCLDEB

BHHOLDX EF IFAKH EJH XF,HADUHDE EF KFUTGW MLEJ ($&1 JCB LDKAHCBHQ+ DFELDX EJCE EJH EFT

QHIHDQCDE MCB EJH 0$4-6k =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- **?-

6; 9)) *ALOC *LKJHGVHAXHA+ YH0.& D-#%./#-)%& N*@$%$.&-#&$0% \A)-Z S. 9&$"" E0& + 3FEJHA 4FDHB

=(HV- <+ :\6]?+ JEETYaaMMM-UFEJHAfFDHB-KFUaUFfFa:\6]a\:aQCAAHGG8LBBC8HGLfCJ8K@UULDXB8IFLC8EACDBTCAHDKW8QHTCAEUHDE8FI8f@BELKH-6< 9)) 0CAAHGG &BBC n *GLfCJ 5@UULDXB+ M)&&)- &0 >''$4) 0' S%'0-@#&$0% !0"$41 + %-'- bF@BH FI

)HTAHBHDECEL,HB =(HV- d+ :\6]?+ JEETYaaF,HABLXJE-JF@BH-XF,aMT8

KFDEHDEa@TGFCQBa:\6]a\:a:\6]8\:8\d80*&8**58EF82@BECW8AH8($&1-TQI-6e 9)) 4HII 2G@DXLB+ E#&$0%#" !-).. O"2? #.G. !-).$*)%& >?#@# &0 '2"'$"" B>SN /-0@$.). + .CELFDCG

2AHBB 5G@V =(HV- :7+ :\6]?+ JEETYaaMMM-TAHBB-FAXaDHMB8U@GELUHQLCaDHMBaDCELFDCG8TAHBB8

KG@V8CBOB8TAHBLQHDE8FVCUC8I@GILGG8IFLC8TAFULBHB-6k 9)) bCQCB >FGQ+ EFDV 5$4)V H0&7)- =0%). &0/ B>SN .2$&.+ 2FGLELKF =0HK- :]+ :\6d?+

JEETYaaMMM-TFGLELKF-KFUaVGFXBaUHQLCa:\6da6:aDWE8,LKH8UFEJHA8fFDHB8EFT8IFLC8B@LEB8

:\\]:7-JEUG-




8 ]6 8

ee- &D :\67+ /JH 1BBFKLCEHQ 2AHBB AHTFAEHQ EJCE+ LD AHBTHKE FI ($&1

AHZ@HBEB+ R/JH XF,HADUHDE EFFO GFDXHA EF E@AD F,HA ILGHB MJHD LE TAF,LQHQ CDW+ BCLQ UFAH

AHX@GCAGW EJCE LE KF@GQDuE ILDQ QFK@UHDEB CDQ AHI@BHQ C AHKFAQ D@UVHA FI ELUHB EF E@AD

F,HA ILGHB Z@LKOGW &7#& @$67& ?) )./)4$#""1 %)+.+0-&71 +S =HUTJCBLB CQQHQ?+ CQQLDX EJCE RLD

DHCAGW 6 LD ] KCBHB+S EJH >F,HADUHDEPB RLDLELCG QHKLBLFDB EF MLEJJFGQ FA KHDBFA AHKFAQB

MHAH LUTAFTHA @DQHA EJH GCMvV@E FDGW MJHD LE MCB KJCGGHDXHQ-S :\ =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- ((?-

ek- &D :\67+ EJH HBEHHUHQ AHTFAEHA 5JCAGLH 'C,CXH+ MJF LB HUTGFWHQ VW D7)

E)+ F0-G D$@).+ DFEHQ FD BFKLCG UHQLC EJCE BFUH GCM HDIFAKHUHDE CXHDKLHB+ TCAELK@GCAGW

EJH (HQHACG c@AHC@ FI &D,HBELXCELFD+ QHGLVHACEHGW FULEEHQ HUVCAACBBLDX QFK@UHDEB IAFU

($&1 AHBTFDBHB+ CDQ+ MJHD KC@XJE+ CKEHQ EF I@AEJHA QHGCW EJH QLBKGFB@AH FI QFK@UHDEB VW

UCDW UFDEJB- :6 =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >>?-

k\- 1E EJH &DLELCG 5FDIHAHDKH VHEMHHD EJH 2CAELHB FD 6; 'HTEHUVHA :\67+

2GCLDELII TFLDEHQ F@E EF EJH 5F@AE EJCE 0HIHDQCDE CQULEEHQ LD EJH 1DBMHA EJCE EJH 0$4 JCQ

AHKHL,HQ C KFTW FI 2GCLDELIIPB H8UCLG+ QCEHQ ]\ 1TALG :\6]+ CEECKJHQ EF MJLKJ MCB C KFTW FI

EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 44?- =0OE- .F- k d+ :k CDQ 0OE- .F- 6: CE :8]?-

k6- 0HIHDBH 5F@DBHG CQULEEHQ Q@ALDX C /HGHTJFDH 5FDIHAHDKH FD

6; $KEFVHA :\67 EJCE >HFAXH JCQ C KFTW FI EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE CGG CGFDX+ CDQ MH ODFM

IAFU EJH )HQ bHAALDX )HBTFDBH EJCE >HFAXH MCB EJH 1BBLBECDE %-'- 1EEFADHW =R1%'1S?

CBBLXDHQ EF TAFBHK@EH #E- 5JFL- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- (?

k:- /JH 0$4 CQ,LBHQ EJH HDELAH *[HK@EL,H cACDKJ FI EJH IHQHACG XF,HADUHDE

CXCLDBE ,LHMLDX EJH %-'- 'HDCEHPB EFAE@AH AHTFAE+ H,HD EJF@XJ EJH EFAE@AH AHTFAE MCB C

T@VGLK QFK@UHDE-::

:\ 9)) /HQ cALQLB+ N*@$%$.&-#&$0% .)&. -)40-* '0- +$&770"*$%6 60A)-%@)%& '$").+ /JH 1BBFKLCEHQ

2AHBB =3CA- 6e+ :\67?+ JEETYaaVLXBEFAW-CT-FAXaCAELKGHaCV\:kQ<K;:76dk]de6d]

C76II;66<7K;a@B8BHEB8DHM8AHKFAQ8QHDWLDX8KHDBFALDX8XF,HADUHDE8ILGHB-:6 9)) 5JCAGLH 'C,CXH+ /MLEEHA =1@X- ::+ :\67?+ JEETBYaaEMLEEHA-KFUaKJCAGLHrBC,CXHa

BECE@Ba;]7\;<6:k:\7<<::k:-:: 9)) 3LOH 3CBDLKO+ 0$4 bCB cGFKOHQ *,HAWFDH &D /JH *[HK@EL,H cACDKJ (AFU )HCQLDX /JH

'HDCEHPB /FAE@AH )HTFAE+ /HKJ 0LAE =.F,- 66+ :\67?+

JEETBYaaMMM-EHKJQLAE-KFUaCAELKGHBa:\67666\a\6]7]7]:<<6aQFf8JCB8VGFKOHQ8H,HAWFDH8

H[HK@EL,H8VACDKJ8AHCQLDX8BHDCEHB8EFAE@AH8AHTFAE-BJEUG-




8 ]: 8

k]- $IILKLCGB MLEJ EJH 0$4 CDQ UHUVHAB FI EJH .CELFDCG 1BBFKLCELFD FI

1BBLBECDE %DLEHQ 'ECEHB 1EEFADHWB JC,H GFVVLHQ IHQHACG GHXLBGCEFAB EF FTTFBH LUTAF,HQ

($&1 AHIFAU GHXLBGCELFD-:]

O7 $IA ODMAE=FA=> Q;@ "D> +:;<FAG %RAFL><D=@

kd- /JH >F,HADUHDE JCB DFE BTHKLILKCGGW KGCLUHQ *[HUTELFDB @DQHA ($&1

IFA CDW TCAELK@GCA $&)@ FA.2?a$&)@ GLBEHQ FD EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- (+ >+

b+ 4+ .?- =mHGGW 0HKG-?- ='EFDH 0HKG-?-

k7- /JH >F,HADUHDE JCB DFE BTHKLILKCGGW KGCLUHQ *[HUTELFDB @DQHA ($&1

IFA CDW TCAELK@GCA $&)@ FA.2?a$&)@ GLBEHQ FD EJH 'HKFDQ ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- 4?-

k;- ^JHD EJH >F,HADUHDE TAFQ@KHQ EJH 'HKFDQ ($&1 )HBTFDBH+ EJH

>F,HADUHDE QL Q DFE BTHKLIL KCGGW KGCLU CDW *[HUTELFDB @D QHA ($&1 IFA 68d7 FD

2GCLDELIIPB &DQH[ EF EJH (LABE ($&1 )HBTFDBH- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >?-

k<- /JH >F,HADUHDE JCB FDGW BTHKLILKCGGW KGCLUHQ CD *[HUTELFD @DQHA

($&1 IFA d; =EJH TAL,CKW8HDK @UVHAHQ AHKFAQB FI #E- 5J FL+ IFA MJLKJ 2GCLD ELII JCB

AHZ@HBEHQ C 5#267% &DQH[+ WHE EF VH TAFQ@KHQ VW EJH 0$4? FD 2GCLDELIIPB &DQH[ EF EJH (LABE

($&1 )HBTFDBH- =0OE- .F- 6:+ *[- c?-

ke- /JH >F,HADUHDE JCB DFE BTHKLILKCGGW KGCLUHQ *[HUTELFDB @DQHA ($&1

IFA CDW TCAELK@GCA HDEAW GLBEHQ FD 2GCLDELIIPB &DQH[ FI )HIHAHDKHB EF )HKFAQB )HZ@HBEHQ

@DQHA ($&1 )HZ@HBE- =(GFAHB 0HKG-+ *[- >?-

Q7 1:;<=><??3@ )K><M<@F +;FL;<P=

kk- 2ALFA EF EJH KFUUHDKHUHDE FI EJLB CKELFD+ 2GCLDELII JCQ GC@DKJHQ C

BFKLCG UHQLC KCUTCLXD EF KJCGGHDXH EJH 0$4PB TCEEHAD CDQ TACKELKH EJCE BWBEHUCELKCGGW

AHI@BHQ EF CDBMHA EJH (LABE ($&1 )HZ@HBE- 9))V );6;+ #F@LB (GFAHB+ /MLEEHA =$KE- 67+ :\6]+

dYd: 23 *'/?+ JEETBYaaEMLEEHA-KFUa UCBGFMBDHHQBaBECE@Ba]k\:6;:\k;];k:7dd\

=CEECKJLDX C GLDO EF C NF@/@VH ,LQHF+ MJLKJ JCQ VHHD @TGFCQHQ FD $KE- 67+ :\6]+ EJCE

H[TGFAHQ MJHEJHA LDQL,LQ@CGB F@EBLQH EJH 0$4 JCQ C AFGH LD FAQHALDX EJH CAAHBE FI #E- 5JFL

:] 9)) .LKJFGCB &F,LDF+ =2.&$4) ()/&; N442.)* 0' 9#?0&#6$%6 B>SN + 5F@AEJF@BH .HMB 'HA,LKH =0HK-

67+ :\67?+ JEETYaaMMM-KF@AEJF@BHDHMB-KFUa:\67a6:a67af@BELKH8QHTE8CKK@BHQ8FI8

BCVFECXLDX8IFLC-JEU-




IFA JLB CKEL,LBU CDQ Z@HBELFDHQ MJHEJHA EJH 0$4 MCB ECAXHELDX IFA ,LDQLKEL,H TAFBHK@ELFD

CKEL,LBEB+ MJF UCW JC,H VHHD HDXCXHQ LD TAHBB@AH TFGLELKB CXCLDBE EJH 2AHBLQHDE LD FAQHA

EF VALDX CVF@E B FKLCG KJCDXH? _ #F@LB (GFAHB+ /MLEEHA =(HV- :7+ :\6d+ dY:d 23 *'/?+

JEETBYaaEMLEEHA-KFUa UCBGFMBDHHQBaBECE@Bad]ed:d]k:k<<]<7:]: =CEECKJLDX C GLDO EF

CDFEJHA NF@/@VH ,LQHF+ MJLKJ JCQ VHHD @TGFCQHQ FD 0HK- d+ :\6]+ DFELDX EJCE BTHHKJ

KALELKCG FI XF,HADUHDE+ IFA H[CUTGH+ TFGLELKCG BTHHKJ+ LB C IAHHQFU X@CACDEHHQ CB C

TAFEHKELFD LD EJH (LABE 1UHDQUHDE EF EJH %-'- 5FDBELE@ELFD+ CQQLDX EJCE MJHD EJH 0$4

QFHB DFE JFDFA ($&1 AHZ@HBEB+ EJLB ICLG@AH CKEB EF K@AECLG IAHH BTHHKJ+ VHKC@BH EJH ICLG@AH

QHDLHB KLELgHDB LDIFAUCELFD CVF@E EJH XF,HADUHDEPB KFDQ@KE+ KFDBHZ@HDEGW TAH,HDELDX

KLELgHDB IAFU UHCDLDXI@GGW IFAULDX LDIFAUHQ BTHHKJ+ IAFU UHCDLDXI@GGW CBBHUVGLDX EF

QLBK@BB EJH XF,HADUHDEPB KFDQ@KE+ CDQ EF THELELFD EJHLA XF,HADUHDE IFA C AHQAHBB FI

XALH,CDKHB? _ CDQ #F@LB (GFAHB+ /MLEEHA ='HTE- :7+ :\6d+ 66Y67 1 3 * '/?+

JEETBYaaEMLEEHA-KFUa UCBGFMBDHHQBaBECE@Ba76767<<];e:6]7e7k: =DFELDX EJH 'HTE- 6<+

:\6d+ TAFEHBE CXCLDBE bFGQHA?-

)HBTHKEI@GGW B@VULEEHQ+

rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

0CEHQ Y 4CKOBFD bHLXJEB+ .HM NFAO

4CD@CAW d+ :\6;

#F@LB (GFAHB

]d8:6 <<EJ 'EAHHE+ 1TE- d\;

4CKOBFD bHLXJEB+ .N 66]<:

2JFDH Y =;d;? d\\866;e

GF@LBIGFAHBwGF@LBIGFAHB-KFU

!-0 9) !"#$%&$''

/$ Y hcW *5( CDQ H8UCLG EF Y A@OJBCDCJ-BLDXJw@BQFf -XF,i

)@OJBCDCJ #- 'LDXJ+ 1BBLBECDE %-'- 1EEFADHW%-'- 1EEFADHWPB $IILKH 8 *CBEHAD 0LBEALKE FI .HM NFAO

:<6 5CQUCD 2GCgC *CBE+ <EJ (GFFA

cAFFOGWD+ .N 66:\6

N&&0-%)1 '0- ()')%*#%&


2016-01-04 plaintiff's 56.1 answer (flores v doj) (foia) (stamped)

Documents