2017 call evaluation outcome - security research · panel meeting (esr) 02-20/10/17 remote ethics...

18
H2020 Societal Challenge 7 Secure Societies 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome Angelo Marino Head of Unit Research Executive Agency, B4 Brussels, 05/03/2018

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jan-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

H2020

Societal Challenge 7 Secure Societies

2017 Call Evaluation Outcome

Angelo MarinoHead of Unit

Research Executive Agency, B4

Brussels, 05/03/2018

Page 2: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Agenda

1. General information on

the calls H2020-SC7-2017

2. Evaluator statistics

3. Proposal statistics

4. Evaluation outcome

Page 3: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

General Info

Work Programme: H2020-2016-2017

Title: Secure Societies

Calls: H2020-CIP-2016-2017-2

H2020-DS-SC7-2017

H2020-SEC-2016-2017-2

Opening date: 01/03/2017

Closing date: 24/08/2017

Page 4: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Budget as per WP

23,75

50,75

39,25

16,3

20

35,6

Total Budget: M€ 185.65CIP: M€ 20.00 – DS: M€ 35.60 – SEC: M€ 130.05

SEC - DRS

SEC - FCT*

SEC - BES*

SEC - GM

CIP

DS

* M€ 16.5 shared between FCT & BES (common budget SEC-07-FCT & SEC-18-BES)

Page 5: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Publication

14/10/15

Opening

01/03/17

Deadline 24/08/17

Remote Evaluation (IER)

18-29/09/17

Evaluation in Bxl

(CR)

02-20/10/17

Panel Meeting

(ESR)

02-20/10/17

Remote

Ethics Screening

16/10-03/11/17

CMs

Ethics Screening

06-10/11/17

Security Scrutiny

≤ 04/12/17

Information to PC and to applicants

+Start Evaluation

Review ≤ 24/01/18

Grant Preparation+

Programme Committee consultation

02-04/18

Start of projects

from

01/05/18

Timeline

Page 6: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

184 Evaluators*

115 (62 %) Male

69 (38 %) Female

166 (90%) from Member States

15 (8%) from Associated Countries

3 (2%) from 3rd countries

All MS represented except SK and LU

*Not including:

- 24 Independent Rapporteurs

- 9 Ethics Experts

- 1 Observer

Evaluators: Nationality

Page 7: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Industry, 55

Academia; 69

End-users; 60

Profile+

Higher Education;

76

Research Organisati

on; 49

Non-research

public body; 42

Non-research private

body; 68

Other; 35

Sector#

# self-declared in EU-data base, multiple labels possible

Evaluators: Affiliation

+ analysis by REA based on expert's CV

Page 8: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Proposals

Proposals

- received: 316 [2016: 299]

- inadmissible: 13*[2016: 20]

- ineligible: 4 [2016: 2]

- evaluated: 299 [2016: 277]

*12 not fulfilling add. conditions

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

CIP DS SEC

Ineligible/Inadmissible Received

ReceivedIneligible

Inadmissible

CIP 25 -

DS 160 4

SEC 131 13

Total 316 17

Page 9: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Received proposals per topic:

Topic Coverage: Submission Stage

Topic # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

CIP 25

DS 78 82

SEC 1 13 20 1 9 26 1 9 13 7 6 25

Evaluated proposals per topic:

Topic # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

CIP 25

DS 77 79

SEC 1 13 17 1 7 24 1 8 10 6 6 24

Page 10: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Number of resubmissions per topic:

37 Resubmissions in 2017:

Topic # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

CIP 3

DS 4 7

SEC 0 0 7 0 0 8 0 0 0 0 0 8

Open topic last year:

Topic # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

CIP Y

DS N N

SEC N N Y N N Y N N N N N Y

Page 11: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Applications: All Calls

3,748 applications by 1,953 unique applicants

• Member States : 3,437 applications

• Assoc. Countries : 280 applications

• 3rd Countries : 31 applications

Applications per sector:

• HES: 749 (20%)

• REC: 627 (17%)

• PUB: 601 (16%)

• PRC LE: 911 (24%)

• PRC SME: 698 (19%)

• OTH: 162 (4%)

Page 12: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Requested Funding: All Calls

1,225 M€ total requested funding

• Member States: 1,122 M€

• Assoc. Countries: 99 M€

• 3rd Countries: 4 M€

Requested funding by sector:

• HES: 271 M€ (22%)

• REC: 252 M€ (21%)

• PUB: 100 M€ (8%)

• PRC LE: 312 M€ (26%)

• PRC SME: 239 M€ (19%)

• OTH: 51 M€ (4%)

Page 13: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Evaluation Outcome

Global Success Rate 14.0% [2016: 14.1%]

• CIP: 12%

• DS: 8%

• SEC: 22%

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

CIP DS SEC

Below Thresh.

No Money

BelowThresh.

NoMoney

ReserveList

Main List

CIP 12 8 2 3DS 51 85 7 13SEC 48 30 14 26Total 111 123 23 42

Page 14: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Number of mainlist proposals per topic*:

Topic Coverage: Mainlist

Topic # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

CIP 3

DS 6 7

SEC 1 3 4 1 1 5 1 1 1 1 1 6

*

CIP-01: only best proposal per CI can be funded, all 3 open CIs covered (Health, Finance, Communications)

DS-08: all 3 strands covered

SEC-07-FCT: only best proposal per subtopic can be funded, all 4 open subtopics covered

SEC-21-GM: Subtopic (a) – covered disciplines: custom authorities, explosive specialists and medical emergency teams

Subtopic (b) – covered areas: Mediterranean region, the Arctic and North Atlantic region

Subtopic (d) – covered

Page 15: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Ratio mainlist / evaluated proposals (%)*:

Success rate per topic:

Topic # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

CIP 12

DS 8 9

SEC 100 23 24 100 14 21 100 13 10 17 17 25

*

CIP-01: only best proposal per CI can be funded, all 3 open CIs covered (Health, Finance, Communications)

DS-08: all 3 strands covered

SEC-07-FCT: only best proposal per subtopic can be funded, all 4 open subtopics covered

SEC-21-GM: Subtopic (a) – covered disciplines: custom authorities, explosive specialists and medical emergency teams

Subtopic (b) – covered areas: Mediterranean region, the Arctic and North Atlantic region

Subtopic (d) – covered

Page 16: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Applications: Mainlist All Calls

603 applications by 462 unique applicants

• Member States : 544 applications

• Assoc. Countries : 52 applications

• 3rd Countries : 7 applications

Applications per sector:

• HES: 117 (20%)

• REC: 102 (17%)

• PUB: 141 (23%)

• PRC LE: 135 (22%)

• PRC SME: 83 (14%)

• OTH: 25 (4%)

Page 17: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Funding: Mainlist All Calls

194.8 M€ total requested funding

• Member States: 178.2 M€

• Assoc. Countries: 16.4 M€

• 3rd Countries: 0.2 M€

Requested funding by sector:

• HES: 34.6 M€ (18%)

• REC: 53.0 M€ (27%)

• PUB: 28.1 M€ (15%)

• PRC LE: 43.8 M€ (22%)

• PRC SME: 29.5 M€ (15%)

• OTH: 5.8 M€ (3%)

Page 18: 2017 Call Evaluation Outcome - Security Research · Panel Meeting (ESR) 02-20/10/17 Remote Ethics Screening 16/10-03/11/17 CMs Ethics Screening 06-10/11/17 Security Scrutiny ≤ 04/12/17

Thank you very much for your attention.