206 court street, portsmouth, nhfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry...

12
206 COURT STREET PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE COVER SHEET 1 RD/JJ AS NOTED G ARCHITECTURE McHENRY Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street McHA: Scale: 206 COURT STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NH SEPTEMBER 2019 - Historic District Commission - Public Hearing PROJECT DESIGN INTENT 1. Purpose - The project is to renovate the existing building at 206 Court Street and to build an addition off the south elevation and southeast corner of the property. The purpose is to return the building to its original residential use. There will be 2 units, 1 on the first floor and the other on the second and third floors. This will require extensive renovations and repairs to the existing building and the construction of the new addition. The design intent is to bring the existing building to current standards on the interior while maintaining its historic exterior. The new addition is in contrast to the existing building. The placement of the addition, its smaller massing, visual separation and its use of contemporary materials and details are utilized to both respect the historic structure and be separate from it. 2. History - The existing brick masonry building was likely constructed during the period 1815-1820, in the aftermath of the fire of 1813 and is in the Federal Style, similar to many buildings being built in Portsmouth at that time. We have not determined its actual builder to date, but note that the masonry details and window types are typical of that era. It appears that the front entry door and some interiors details are from the mid-nineteenth century. Further research would be required of the building's architectural and ownership history. A photo of the building on the adjoining lot that was at one time Portsmouth's fire station, shows a two story wood frame addition at the rear of the house. 3. Context- 206 Court Street is surrounded by a variety of building types in its location near the urban center of Portsmouth. Its immediate abutters include a two story wood frame structure (the former fire station) to the west, the granite monumental Greek Revival South Church to the north across Court Street, to the east a wood and masonry mixed use building and to the south, the historic Lord House barn and garden adjoining the 20th century brick masonry Citizen's Bank building. The wide variety of mass, scale and height are obvious in this context. SEPTEMBER 2019

Upload: others

Post on 20-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

COVER SHEET 1 RD/JJ

AS NOTED

G

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

206 COURT STREET

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NH

SEPTEMBER 2019 - Historic District Commission - Public Hearing

PROJECT DESIGN INTENT

1. Purpose - The project is to renovate the existing building at 206 Court Street and to build an addition off the south elevation and southeastcorner of the property. The purpose is to return the building to its original residential use. There will be 2 units, 1 on the first floor and theother on the second and third floors. This will require extensive renovations and repairs to the existing building and the construction of thenew addition. The design intent is to bring the existing building to current standards on the interior while maintaining its historic exterior.The new addition is in contrast to the existing building. The placement of the addition, its smaller massing, visual separation and its use ofcontemporary materials and details are utilized to both respect the historic structure and be separate from it.

2. History - The existing brick masonry building was likely constructed during the period 1815-1820, in the aftermath of the fire of 1813 andis in the Federal Style, similar to many buildings being built in Portsmouth at that time. We have not determined its actual builder to date,but note that the masonry details and window types are typical of that era. It appears that the front entry door and some interiors details arefrom the mid-nineteenth century. Further research would be required of the building's architectural and ownership history. A photo of thebuilding on the adjoining lot that was at one time Portsmouth's fire station, shows a two story wood frame addition at the rear of the house.

3. Context- 206 Court Street is surrounded by a variety of building types in its location near the urban center of Portsmouth. Its immediateabutters include a two story wood frame structure (the former fire station) to the west, the granite monumental Greek Revival South Church tothe north across Court Street, to the east a wood and masonry mixed use building and to the south, the historic Lord House barn and gardenadjoining the 20th century brick masonry Citizen's Bank building. The wide variety of mass, scale and height are obvious in this context.

SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 2: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

EXISTING PHOTOS 2 RD/JJ

NTS

E

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

PLEASANT STREET VIEW

SOUTH CHURCH VIEW

FLEET STREET VIEW

COURT STREET VIEW

VIEW TO ADJACENTREAR PROPERTY

VIEW FROM SIDE PROPERTY LINE VIEW FROM REAR PROPERTY LINE

SEPTEMBER 2019

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 3: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

EXISTING PHOTOS FROM BEHIND BUILDING 3 RD/JJ

NTS

E

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

VIEW FROM ADJACENT REAR PROPERTY VIEW TO REAR PROPERTY LINE

VIEW FROM ADJACENT REAR PROPERTY VIEW FROM ADJACENT REAR PROPERTY

SEPTEMBER 2019

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 4: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED MODEL CHANGES 4SEPTEMBER 2019

RD/JJ

NTS

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED MODEL

DESIGN CHANGES

1. Scope of Work - The previous design proposed three apartments with one on each floor. Thecurrent design proposes a two story wing off the rear of the building placed such that it isconnected with a hip roof to the existing building and set in eight feet from the southwest cornerand approximately five feet from the southeast corner. The result is that the massing of theaddition is minimized in relation to the existing building. In the updated design, this footprint hasbeen further decreased to approximately ten and a half feet from the southwest corner andeleven feet from the southeast corner

2. Rooftop Deck - The previous design had a rooftop deck for the exclusive use of the third floorunit, along with an area at the northeast corner of the deck for mechanical equipmentsurrounded by a slightly raised parapet wall. This has been removed in the new design.

3. Exterior Cladding - The addition's exterior cladding remains the same as previouslyapproved.

Previously approved: The addition will have horizontal cladding similar to the productshown in the attached photos of a project that is also in the historic district.  The photos showa shiplapped siding similar in scale to traditional clapboards. Note that the corner trim andwindow and door trim are all flush and monochromatic, save for the window sills. These details contribute to a simple and contemporary appearance, critical to the design intent of theaddition.

4. Windows and doors - Window and door styles will remain as previously approved but witha new pattern due to the decreased size of the addition. 

Previously approved:  The window openings on the new addition are similar in scale tothe masonry openings of the existing building, but instead of imitating the double hung window layout, simple awning style configurations are used. Windows in the new additionare proposed to be the Marvin Integrity line, with its slim head and jamb profile. The entrydoor and rear exit door in the proposed design is simple and modern, consistent with the overall intent of the addition. 

5. Existing Building Exterior - While the new addition will use modern materials and finishes,the existing building will be carefully repaired to maintain its historic features. The front door andits surround will be repaired and replicated where required. The windows will be replaced usingall wood, historically accurate replacements throughout from Green Mountain WindowCompany. New window shutters will be added to all exposed windows on the existing building. The existing brick exterior will be repaired as needed and the existing painted surfaces will bemaintained. A new architectural grade 30 year reinforced asphalt shingle roof will replace theexisting pitched roof and will also be used for the new addition.

6. Approvals Process - The project is still consistent with its original Design Intent, which is torespectfully maintain and renovate the existing building and enhance its use by an addition tothe rear of the building that compliments it without imitating it, as described above.

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 5: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PERSPECTIVE VIEWS 5 RD/JJ

NTS

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

SEPTEMBER 2019

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 6: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

25

'-0

"

20'-8 1/2"

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

BUILDING FOOTPRINT 6 RD/JJ

1/8"=1'-0"

E

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

EXISTING BUILDING FOOTPRINT

SEPTEMBER 2019

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 7: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

36'-5 1/2" 8'-0"

9'-6"

11'-2 1/2"

24'-0"

20'-0"

5'-0"

31' - 5

1

2

" 10'-8

1

2

"

7'-3"

13'-5

1

2

"

14

'-9

"

14

'-0

"

11

'-0

"

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

BUILDING FOOTPRINT 7 RD/JJ

1/8"=1'-0"

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED BUILDING FOOTPRINT PROPOSED BUILDING FOOTPRINT

SEPTEMBER 2019

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

AutoCAD SHX Text
NEW FENCE
AutoCAD SHX Text
NEW FENCE
Page 8: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

EXISTING ELEVATIONS 8 RD/JJ

1/8"=1'-0"

E

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

FRONT ELEVATION BACK ELEVATION

RIGHT ELEVATION LEFT ELEVATIONSEPTEMBER 2019

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 9: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED AND PROPOSED ELEVATIONS 9 RD/JJ

1/8"=1'-0"

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

PREVIOUSLY APPROVEDFRONT ELEVATION

PREVIOUSLY APPROVEDRIGHT ELEVATION

SEPTEMBER 2019

PROPOSEDFRONT ELEVATION

PROPOSEDRIGHT ELEVATION

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

AutoCAD SHX Text
MARVIN INTEGRITY WOOD ULTREX CASEMENT WINDOW (OR EQUAL)
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE SIDING AND TRIM
AutoCAD SHX Text
AWNING ENTRY ROOF
AutoCAD SHX Text
MARVIN INTEGRITY WOOD ULTREX DOOR (OR EQUAL)
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE DECK
AutoCAD SHX Text
MARVIN INTEGRITY WOOD ULTREX CASEMENT WINDOW (OR EQUAL)
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE SIDING AND TRIM
AutoCAD SHX Text
AWNING ENTRY ROOF
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE FENCE TO MATCH ADDITION
AutoCAD SHX Text
MASONRY INFILL TO MATCH ADJACENT EXISTING WALL AT EXISTING WINDOW OPENINGS
AutoCAD SHX Text
FIRE RATED CERAMIC WINDOW
AutoCAD SHX Text
RUBBER ROOF
Page 10: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED AND PROPOSED ELEVATIONS 10 RD/JJ

1/8"=1'-0"

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

PREVIOUSLY APPROVEDBACK ELEVATION

PREVIOUSLY APPROVEDLEFT ELEVATION

SEPTEMBER 2019

PROPOSEDBACK ELEVATION

PROPOSEDLEFT ELEVATION

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

AutoCAD SHX Text
MARVIN INTEGRITY WOOD ULTREX CASEMENT WINDOW (OR EQUAL)
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE SIDING AND TRIM
AutoCAD SHX Text
AWNING ENTRY ROOF
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE FENCE TO MATCH ADDITION
AutoCAD SHX Text
MASONRY INFILL TO MATCH ADJACENT EXISTING WALL AT EXISTING DOOR OPENING
AutoCAD SHX Text
RUBBER ROOF
AutoCAD SHX Text
MARVIN INTEGRITY WOOD ULTREX DOOR (OR EQUAL)
AutoCAD SHX Text
MARVIN INTEGRITY WOOD ULTREX CASEMENT WINDOW (OR EQUAL)
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE SIDING AND TRIM
AutoCAD SHX Text
AWNING ENTRY ROOF
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE DECK
AutoCAD SHX Text
COMPOSITE FENCE TO MATCH ADDITION
Page 11: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

PREVIOUSLY APPROVED DETAILS 11 RD/JJ

NTS

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

CASEMENT/AWNING WINDOWS AT ADDITION REPLACEMENT WINDOWS

NEW SHUTTERS ON EXISTING BUILDING

CUSTOM SHUTTER COMPANY

SEPTEMBER 2019

FIRE RATED CERAMIC WINDOW

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

Page 12: 206 COURT STREET, PORTSMOUTH, NHfiles.cityofportsmouth.com/files/planning/apps/... · awning entry roof. composite fence to match addition. masonry infill to match adjacent existing

SECOND FL

9' - 0"

RUBBER MEMBRANE

ROOF

APA RATED PLYWD

SHEATHING

2X WD FRAMING

COMPOSITE PANELING,

PAINTED

COMPOSITE TRIM,

PAINTED

MTL FLASHING

2' - 4"

TYPICAL EXTERIOR

WALL AT ADDITION

MEMBRANE TO

EXTEND UP WALL

MIN. 8"

MTL FLASHING WITH

DRIP EDGE

1/4"/12" PITCH

THIRD FL

17' - 5"

2

" / 1

'-0

"

RUBBER MEMBRANE ROOF

APA RATED PLYWD

SHEATHING

MIN. R-38 CLOSED CELL

SPRAY FOAM INSULATION

2X WD FRAMING- REFER TO

STRUCTURAL DWGS

GYP BD STRAPPED TO

UNDERSIDE OF STRUCTURE

TYPICAL EXTERIOR WALL-

REFER TO WALL TYPES

WINDOW HEADER- REFER TO

STRUCTURAL DWGS

MTL DRIP EDGE

1X TRIM

2X WD FRAMING

SIDING

206 COURT STREET

PORTSMOUTH, NEW HAMPSHIRE

PROPOSED DETAILS AND PREVIOUSLY APPROVED SIDING 12 RD/JJ

1 12" = 1'-0"

P

ARCHITECTUREMcHENRY

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 4 Market Street

McHA:

Scale:

HIP ROOF EDGE DETAILSEPTEMBER 2019

ENTRY CANOPY DETAIL

UNION STREET SIDING EXAMPLE

FENCE STYLE

BORAL SHIPLAP SIDING

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, WORK SESSION / PUBLIC HEARING - SEPTEMBER 2019

AutoCAD SHX Text
5X5 POSTS
AutoCAD SHX Text
NOTE: FINISH TO MATCH SIDING ON BUILDING