2.4 3.5 5.3 odds ratios † predictors suicide attempts boys 13.5 years † adjusted for family...
TRANSCRIPT
2.4
3.5
5.3
Odds Ratios† Predictors Suicide AttemptsBOYS 13.5 years
† adjusted for family dysfunction, significance p<.001, except ** p<.01; * p<.05
SEXUALABUSE
ANTISOCIAL
SUICIDE RISK
DRUG ABUSE
HOPELESSNESS
DEPRESSION
20.6SUICIDE
ATTEMPT
5.4**
9.4
6.4
The changing face of mental health services
In the 80s
We dealt more withAnxiety DisordersDepressionDevelopmental problemsMinor behavioural problems
Drug induced psychosis and ADHD were rareBipolar Disorder & Asperger’s almost
unknown
In the new Millennium
Serious conduct disorder and delinquency (for which we have a limited skill set)
Self-harming behaviours (60% of our CYMHS referrals in a recent survey)
Drug induced psychosis (where we are fighting a losing battle)
A wide range of disorders which may have their origins in Poor Attachment and Social Exclusion (where social change is necessary, which may be outside our ambit)
In the new Millennium
Family Crises (more families seem unable to cope with normal developmental transitions)
Depression (which may itself have origins in Poor Attachment and Social Exclusion) seems to be at epidemic proportions, and is overwhelming our skill set, but….
Anxiety Disorders (for which we have a rich skill set) are now the hidden calamity (particularly Social Phobia)
Antidepressant Use 1995 (Number)
MALE FEMALE
0-14 15-24 0-14 15-24
Amitryptiline 1727
Dothiepin 2198 724
Doxepin 199 41 178
Fluoxetine 852 63 2134
Other 27,292 4083 4940 2845
Total 27,491 7,134 5044 7417
ABS, 1999
Medication Use (18-34 yrs)NHS Survey 2005
704,200 used psychotropics 41,548 (5.9%) Citalopram 25,351 (3.6%) Paroxetine 51,407 (7.3%) Sertraline 11,972 (1.7%) Other SSRI 20,422 (2.9%) Venlafaxine 12,676 (1.8%) Tricyclics 12,676 (1.8%) Other Antidepressant 10.1% Anxiolytics 83.5% other including 69.2% Vitamins and
MineralsTable 15, page 36 Ausstats 2005
= 18.5% Total SSRIs= 18.5% Total SSRIs
Western Australian Child Health Survey:
Children with Mental Health* Problems Number (‘000) Per
centMales 30.0 20.0Females 23.5 15.4
4 to 11 year olds 30.8 16.012 to 16 year olds 22.7 20.6
All children 53.5 17.7* as determined by caregiver and teacher using the Child Behavioural Checklist
Zubrick et al 1995
Mental & Behavioural Problems, 2005
0-14 Rate % 15-24 Rate %
Alcohol/Drug np 19,000 0.71
Mood DisordersMood Disorders 30,300 0.77 144,600 5.4
AnxietyAnxiety 89,700 2.3 123,600 4.6
Psychol Devel 100,600 2.57 60,800 2.26
Behavioural 116,300 2.97 34,700 1.29
Other 19,400 0.49 21,000 0.78
Symptoms/Signs 8,300 0.21 7,600 0.28
Total 263,000 6.71 267,800 9.94
Population Total 3,920,600 2,693,000
My own experience
A PERSONAL CONTEXTLondon 1968-9
Analytic psychotherapy (Irving Kreeger, Gordon Stuart Prince)
Hypnosis (Marcuse) Behaviour Therapy (Marks and Gelder)
Canterbury 1970-74 Child Psychotherapy (Ken Munro Fraser) Structural Family Therapy (Minuchin) 25 bed inpatient Unit
A PERSONAL CONTEXT
Adelaide 1974-82 (Children’s Hospital) Infant Observation Child and Adolescent Psychotherapy Transactional Analysis (Berne) Gestalt therapy Group therapy Strategic Family Therapy (Gerard, Epstein,
Haley) Systemic Family Therapy (Palazzoli et al) Narrative Therapy (White, Epston)
A PERSONAL CONTEXT
Private Practice 1982-86 Expert Family Therapy group 2 years
Flinders Medical Centre 1986-2001 Cognitive Behavioural Therapy Individual Therapy Family Therapy (Screens and Teams) Solution Focussed Therapy (de Shazer
and Insoo Kim Berg 1990)
A Note about Private Practice
Solid Clinical Work10-12 hours per day, on the hour every
hour600 new cases in 4 years - ie about 3
new cases per weekSome school visitsSome supervision and Teaching of
registrarsArt classes one afternoon a week to
preserve sanity
If you want effectiveness and efficiency in a service, there is no substitute for highly skilled, well supervised, experienced
clinicians.
Clinical Work
Central to what we doYet we can never be quite certain what
goes on in the consulting roomNo measures, no online reporting, no
audio can really tell you what goes onCurrent administrative attempts to find
out are self serving and overwhelm the clinical process
The best Risk Management is to have good clinicians
On Entry to Clinical Service
2 week full time Orientation Program16 week twice a week therapy training
program in houseOption for lengthy training and
supervision with expert therapists (eg Malcolm Robinson or Michael White for CAMHS in South Australia) with service sharing the cost and the time cost.
Clear Clinical Expectations
1-2 new cases a week ie 70-75 per annum on average
(range 50-100) For 30 therapists in a service you
could manage about 2200 new cases10± clinical follow-ups a week
ie about 500 follow-up per annum For 30 therapists about 15,000 slots
per annum
Therapist Burnout
Too little trainingToo little supervisionToo little varietyToo many casesToo much paperwork
Important to provide enrichment - special project development, teaching, evaluation, research, publication
Issues
You must have staff who have energy to reach out
You must avoid the ‘Exclusive Service’ mentality: “we exclude everyone who does not
meet DSM4 criteria”
Every minute you take away from a clinician doing best quality clinical work wrecks
any attempt to provide efficiency.
Sustainable Service Development South
Australia Southern CAMHS (Flinders Medical Centre - 15 years) 2 teams to 6 teams No rural service, to 3 rural teams 12 therapists to 40 therapists No teaching, to Masters level programs No research, to 22 programs including two
longitudinal programs CHASP Accreditation 1994 (the first CAMHS
ever) Gold Award THEMHS 1994
Clinical Work 1985
Systematised interviewing (Eisen & Irwin)
4 sessions of assessment with an initial interview with the family, then two interviews with the child, then a family feedback session.
The problem was that the mean number of sessions attended was only 3, with a mode of 1.
Clinical Work 1995
We reviewed 200 clients to see what had happened to them.
50% had ‘got what they wanted’20% felt the service had little to
offer their problem
Clinical Work 2008Initial Consult System
Single sessionAsked the patients what they wanted to
achieve by the end of the sessionListed their problems and ranked themDiscussed alternatives for change in the
most pressing problemsPsychoeducational approachChecked at the end of the session to
see whether they had got what they wanted
Window Shopping is OK!
Registration as a Case
Genuine issue hereDo you register at the first session
- even if they are never going to come back?
Or do you wait until they commit to some specific course of therapy
Sustainable Service Development Queensland
(2001- ) RCH & District CYMHS Since 2001, Service to BYDC CYFOS Development MHATODS Team Therapy supervision ++ Reworking of CL Team and after hours service EI Strategy - KOPING strategy Recent ACHS Accreditation, exceeding most
standards Publications (35 per annum - only 7-10 mine) Silver THEMHS award 2006
RCH & Brisbane North CYMHS
We monitor clinical and other activity, and provide feedback to staff on a regular basis through team leaders
We are meeting ALL of the criteria in the National Workforce Standards documents