25301. - virginia
TRANSCRIPT
BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD
PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL
DOCKET NO: VGOB 97-0218-0564-05
RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSEMENT FROM ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) A portion of 1, A portionof 12, 5, 6, 7 (2) AND AUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECT PAYMENT OF ROYALTIES (3) AND DISMISSAL OFCOAL OWNERS PURSUANT TO CODE OF VIRGINIA SECTION 45.1-361.22:2.
HEARING DATE: November 15, 2016
DRILLING UNIT: U28
BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA
PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSEMENT OF ESCROW FUNDS
1.Petitioner and its counsel
Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, PO Box 570, Pounding Mill, VA 24637, (276)596-5075.Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Hillard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capital Street, Suite 201,Charleston, WV 25301.
2. Relief Sought
(1) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's Escrow Agent,attributable to a portion of Tracts 1, 5, 6, 7 & 12, as depicted upon the annexed table; (2)authorization to begin paying royalties directly to Emmanuel Wade, Inez Kimbrell, Wanda Griffith,Sherman Baldwin, Nancy B. Komp, Sandy Baldwin Cranmer, Donna Foote, Pamela Case, RufusBaldwin, David Baldwin, Tammy Muir, Sharon Baldwin, Eddie Baldwin, Kathy Whitt, Lisa Shaver,Patti Gilbert, Michael T. Boyd, Eleanor Hagy, Venia Newberry, Virginia Edith Smith, Scotty Bond,Judy Tiedemann, Joann Smith, Pauline Casey, Chad M. Casey, Robert B. Casey, RusselJohnson, Daniel Johnson, Phyllis Boyd, Kathy & Dickey Looney, Rita Jill Baker, Jack KirbyMullins, Jr., Kendris Harman, Henry Harman, and Sarah Jane Keen; and (3) Dismissal of coalowners: Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, Buchanan Coal Company, Sayers-Pocahontas CoalCompany, Buchanan Mining Company LLC (formerly Consolidation Coal Company), HughMcRae Land Trust, Chisos LTD, and Rockport Oil 8 Gas.
3. Legal Authority
Va. Code Ann. g 45.1-361.1et seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140., and relevant Virginia Gas and OilBoard Orders ("Board" ) heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.
4. Type of Well(s)
Coalbed Methane
5. Factual basis for relief requested
Page Number 1.
a. Kendris Harman and Henry Harman are entitled to 100% of the CBM royalties awarded underCase No. 12-292, Opinion dated January 22, 2015, Said decision allows the Applicant andDesignated Operator to pay royalties directly to the person(s) identified in Exhibit EE annexedhereto and the annexed Table, further, specifies how said royalties are to be paid.b. Emmanuel Wade, Inez Kimbrell, Wanda Griffith, Sherman Baldwin, Nancy B. Komp, SandyBaldwin Cranmer, Donna Foote, Pamela Case, Rufus Baldwin, David Baldwin, David Baldwin,Tammy Muir, Sharon Baldwin, Eddie Baldwin, Kathy Whitt, Lisa Shaver, Patti Gilbert, Michael T.Boyd, Eleanor Hagy, Venia Newberry, Virginia Edith Smith, Scotty Bond, David Smith, DonaldSmith, Judy Tiedemann, Joann Smith, Peggy Smith, Pauline Casey, Chad M. Casey, Robert B.Casey, Russel Johnson, Daniel Johnson, Phyllis Boyd, Kathy & Dickey Looney, Rita Jill Baker,Jack Kirby Mullins, Jr., and Sarah Jane Keene are the gas claimants in Tract(s) a portion of 1, 5,6, 7. As such, is entitled to 100% of the CBM royalties now in escrow and as may be hereafterpayable. See Va. Code Ann. /J 45.1-361.22:2.A.c. That CNX Gas Company LLC has given the notice(s) required by fJ 45.1-361.22:2.Ato allconflicting claimants identified in the above referenced pooling Order and any supplementalOrders pertaining thereto.d. That none of the conflicting claimants noticed have provided, within 45 days of the notice(s)given as provided in b. above, the Board, its designated agent the Director of the Division of Gasand Oil, the Operator and/or the Applicant evidence of either an agreement regarding theescrowed funds/royalties or a proceeding regarding same.
e. That a detailed accounting in accordance with the applicable provisions of fJ 45.1-361.22 issubmitted herewith and identified as Exhibit J.f. That an Exhibit identified as Table 1 is annexed hereto, and it specifies how the disbursement(s) is to be calculated and paid by the escrow agent.g. That Va. Code Ann. () 45.1-361.22:2.A.further provides that the Operator shall pay suchroyalties as may hereafter be payable directly to the gas claimant Emmanuel Wade, InezKimbrell, Wanda Griffith, Sherman Baldwin, Nancy B. Komp, Sandy Baldwin Cranmer, DonnaFoote, Pamela Case, Rufus Baldwin, David Baldwin, David Baldwin, Tammy Muir, SharonBaldwin, Eddie Baldwin, Kathy Whitt, Lisa Shaver, Patti Gilbert, Michael T. Boyd, Eleanor Hagy,Venia Newberry, Virginia Edith Smith, Scotty Bond, David Smith, Donald Smith, Judy Tiedemann,Joann Smith, Peggy Smith, Pauline Casey, Chad M. Casey, Robert B. Casey, Russel Johnson,Daniel Johnson, Phyllis Boyd, Kathy & Dickey Looney, Rita Jill Baker, Jack Kirby Mullins, Jr., andSarah Jane Keen and not escrow same. See Exhibit EE annexed hereto.
6. Attestation
The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and correct.
Page Number 2.
331
VGOB-97-0219-0564
Company CONsOL INO.
Tract No.County eucNANAN
This plat is a new plat XXX
Well Name and Nu
Elevation QuaDistrict Sca'n updated plat
Form DGO-GO-7Rev. 9/91 Licensed Professional Engineer 1 al)
Page Number 3.
COMSOI Zno.CSM 8 28
Traot Zdentif ioations
1. 4/5 Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, et al - Tr. 1101/5 C. L. Ritter Lumber Co. Tr. 51
Coal Oil and GasIsland Creek. Coal Company - Coal Below TillerPermac Coal Company - Coal above drainageBuchanan Production Comply - CBM, Oil 6 Gas LesseeYukon Poc'ahontas Coal Ccmpany, et al - Surface24.64 acres - 30.80008
Yukon Pooahontas Coal Company, et al - Tr. 40Coal Oil and Gas
Island Creek Coal Company - Coal Below TillerPermac Coal Company - Coal above drainageBuchanan Production Company - CBM, Oil 6 Gas LesseeAndrew Deskins - surface11.81acres - 14.88758
3. Yukon Pooahontas coal Company, et al - Tr. 40Coal Oil and Gas
Island creek Coal Company - Coal Below TillerPermac Coal Company - coal above drainageBuchanan production Company - CBM, Oil 6 Gas Lessee16.00 acres - 20.00008
3A. B. J. Morton - Surface
3B. Ronald Matney - Surface
3C. Cody Herman - Surface
Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, et al - Tr. 11-3Coal Oil and Gas
Island Creek Coal Company —Coal Below TillerPermac Coal company - Coal above drainageBuchanan Production Company - CBM LesseeBuchanan Production Company - CBM, Oil & Gas Lessee6 63 acres - 8.28758
4A. Thelma Addison - Surface
4B. Cody Harman - Surface
4C. Glenn Matney - Surface
4D. B. J. Horton - Surface
4E. Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company et al. - Surface
Page Number 4.
Gussie Johnson - Surface
4G,
4H.
4I.
KathY Looney - SurfaCe
Larry Stacy - Surface
Roscoe Deskins - Surface
5 ~
Cody Herman -. Surface
Virginia Department of Transportion - Surface
Hugh MacRae Land Trust - Tr. 17 - Coal- CoalCoal LesseesIsland Creek Coal Company - Pocahontas No. 3 seamUnited Coal Company - Coal above drainageconsolidation coal Company - Coal below drainageBuchanan Production CompanY - CBM, Oil & Gas LesseeGussie Johnson - Surface, Oil & Gas1.23 acres - 1.5375&
Hugh MacRae Land Trust - Tr. 17 - CoalCoal
Lessees'sland creek Coal Company - pocahontas No. 3 seamUnited Coal Company - Coal above drainageConsolidation Coal Company - Coal below drainageBuchanan Production Company —CBM, .Oil & Gas LesseeKathy Looney - Surface, Oil & Gas0.75 acres - 0.9375&
Hugh MacRae Land Trust - Tr. 17 - CoalCoal LesseesIsland Creek Coal Company - Pocahontas No. 3 seamUnited Coal Company - Coal above drainageConsolidation Coal Company - Coal below drainageBuchanan Production Company - CBM, Oil & Gas LesseeSelma J. Mullins - Surface, Oil & Gas0.49 acres - 0.6125&
Hugh MacRae Land Trust —Tr. 17 - CoalCoal LesseesIalsnd Creek Coal Company - Pocahontas No. 3 seamUnited coal Company - Coal above drainageConsolidation Coal Company - Coal below drainageBuchanan Production Company — CBM LesseeRoscoe Deskins —Oil & Gas5.18 acres - 6.4750&
Page Number 5.
9 Hugh MacRae Land Trust - Tz. 6 - CoalCoal LesseesIsland Creek Coal Company - Pocahontas No. 3 seamUnited Coal Company - Coal above drainageConsolidation Coal Company —Coal below drainageBuchanan Production Company - CBM LesseeConsolidation Coal Company - Oil & Gas3.18 acres - 3.9750\
9B.
Consolidation Coal Company - Surface
Darrell Meadows - Surface
10. Yjakon Pocahontas Coal Company, et al - Tr. 99Coal, Oil & Gas
Coal LesseesIsland Creek Coal. Company - Coal Below TillerJ'swell Smokeless Coal Corp.Pmrmac, Inc.Buchanan Production Company - CBM Lessee9,84 acres 12.30008
10A. virginia Department of Transportion - surface
10B. Darzell Meadows - Surface
10C. Roscoe Deskins - Surface
10D. Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company et al. - Surface
10E. Gus Vandyke -- Surface
Hbgh MacRae Land Trust - Tr. 17 - coalChal LesseesINland Creek Coal Company - Pocahohtas No. 3 seamUpited Coal Company - Coal above drainageCpnsolidation Coal Company —Coal below drainageBuchanan Production Company — CBM LesseeLikxry Stacy - Surface, Oil & Gas0,'.12 acres - 0.15008
12 Hhgh MacRae Land Trust - Tr. 17 - CoalChal LesseesInland Creek Coal COmpany - Pocahontas No. 3 seamUnited Coal Company — Coal above drainageCnnsolidation Coal Company - Coal below drainageBuchanan Production Company - CBM LesseeA.'. J. Herman Heirs —Surface, Oil & Gas0.03 acres - 0.03758
Page Number 6.
VGOB Disbursement
Unit U28
VGOB-97-0218-0564-05
Fractional Net Acreage
Ownershi Ownership
P
in Tract in Tract
Royalty
Split
Agreement Disbursed Disbursed
Escrowed Percent of Disbursement
Acres EscrowedFunds
Table 1
Tracts: A portion of 1, A portion of 12, 5, 6, 7
Item Tract Disbursement Table
Total acreage in escrow before disbursement 13.53200
1
1 1
2 1
3 1
4 1
5 1
6 1
7 1
8 1
9 1
10 1
11 1
12 1
13 1
14 1
15 1
16 1
17 1
18 1
19 1
20 1
21 1
22 1
Tract 1 (total acreage)Emmanuel Wade)226 Adams Street Blountville TN 37617Inez B. Kimbrell>225 Raven Circle Raven VA 24639
Wanda Griffith>PO Box 116 Doran VA 24612Sherman Baldwin>1210 Lake Witten Road North Tazewell VA 24630
Nancy Wooten Kompt2510 Arthur Road Springfield OH 45502Sandra Cranmert11651 SE 69th Terrace Lot 18 Belleview FL 34420
Donna Foote>32632 Downing Road Delmar MD 21875Pamela Case)325 Second Street Little Rock AR 72117Rufus Baldwin>208 High Street Richlands VA 24641
David Baldwin)PO Box 803 Raven VA 24639
Tammy Muirt4480 Clarks Valley Road Swords Creek VA 24649
Sharon G. Baldwintc/o Chelsi Stoneman PO Box 1328 Hillsville VA 24343Eddie Baldwint1210 Sunset Drive Richlands VA 24641
Kathy Whitt)8740 Swords Creek Road Swords Creek VA 24649
Lisa Shaver>89 Sevier Street Lebanon VA 24266-7142
Patti Gilbert)3603 Kents Ridge Road Richlands VA 24641
Michael T. Boyd)3849 Kents Ridge Road Richlands VA 24641
Eleanor Hagyt1 4475 Rainbow Road Lot 31 Bristol VA 24202
Virginia E. SmithtPO Box 335 Doran VA 24612
Scotty Bond)PO Box 82 Swords Creek VA 24649
Judy Tiedemannt530 150th Street Amery Wl 54001
Joann P. SmithtPO Box 1143 Claremont NC 28610
24.64001/60
1/360
1/360
1/360
1/720
1/720
1/720
1/720
1/1800
1/1800
1/1800
1/1800
1/1080
1/1080
1/1080
1/90
1/90
1/90
1/120
1/1440
1/720
1/720
0.41070.0684
0.0684
0.0684
0.0342
0.0342
0.0342
0.0342
0.01370.01370.01370.01370.0228
0.0228
0.0228
0.27380.27380.27380.20530.01710.0342
0.0342
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
100.00'/o
0.41070.0684
0.0684
0.0684
0.0342
0.0342
0.0342
0.0342
0.01370.01370.01370.01370.0228
0.0228
0.0228
0.27380.27380.27380.20530.01710.0342
0.0342
3.0348'/o
0.5058'/o
0.5058'/o
0.5058'/o
0.2529'/o
0.2529'/o
0.2529'/o
0.2529'/o
0.1012'/0
0.1012'/0
0.1012'/0
0.1012'/0
0.1686'/o
0.1686'/o
0.1686'/o
2.0232'/0
2.0232'/0
2.0232'/0
1.5174~/o
0.1264'/o
0.2529'/o
0.2529'/o
$790.94
$131.82
$131.82$131.82
$65.91
$65.91
$65.91
$65.91
$26.36
$26.36
$26.36
$26.36
$43.94
$43.94
$43.94
$527.29
$527.29
$527.29
$395.47
$32.96
$65.91
$65.91
Page Number 7.
1
23 1
24 1
25 1
26 1
5
1 5
2 5
3 5
6
6
7
12
1 12
2 12
3 12
Tract 1 (total acreage)Pauline Caseyt1279 Hilltop Road Jewell Ridge VA 24622
Chadwick M. Casey)520 Watson Road Pounding Mill VA 24637
Brian Casey)798 Pond Steet Pounding Mill VA 24637
Venia Wade Newberry)639 Daniel Drive Newport News VA 23601-1701
Tract 5 (total acreage)Daniel Johnson)5312 Old Kentucky Turnpike Raven VA 24639Russell Johnson)PO Box 4538 North Myrtle Beach SC 29597Phyllis Boyd)5500 Qualla Road Chesterfield VA 23832Tract 6 (total acreage)
iKathy and Dickey Looney)PO Box 276 Oakwood VA 24631
Tract 7 (total acreage)
iJack K. Mullins, JrAPO Box 492 Keen Mountain VA 24624
iRita J. BakertPO Box 94 Rosedale VA 24280
Tract 12 (total acreage)Kendris Harman>110 Carmel Drive Tazewell VA 24651
Sarah J. Keent1817 Fifth Street Richlands VA 24641
Henry F. Harmant21363 Sim Road Abingdon VA 24211-6286
24.64001/105
1/105
1/105
1/30
1.23001/3
1/3
1/3
0.7500
0.49001/2
1/2
0.030012/121
24/121
85/242
0.2347
0.23470.23470.8213
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
0.2347 1.7342 /0
0.2347 1.7342 /0
0.2347 1.7342 /0
0.8213 6.0696/o
$451.97
$451.97$451.97
$1,581.88
0.41000.41000.4100
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
0.4100 3.0299/o
0.4100 3.0299/o
0.4100 3.0299/o
$789.66
$789.66
$789.66
0.2450'00.00'/0i
0.2450'00.00'/0i
0.2450'.8105'/0i
0.2450'.8105'/0i
$471.87
$471.87
0.00300.00600.0105
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
100.00'/0
0.0030 0.0220 /o
0.0060 0.0440'/o
0.0105 0.0779/o
$5.73
$11.46
$20.29
0 75001 100 00/01 0 75001 5 5424'/oI $1 444 50
Wells contributing to the escrow account: CBM U-28A, CBM U-28B, CBM U-28C W/PL, CBM U-28D W/PL, CBM U-28E W/PL
Page Number 8.
Exhibit EUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB-974I21 84I5644I5List of Respondents that require escrow
Net Acresin Unit
Interestin Unit
Divison of Interest in2 Left 3 Left 4 Left
12 3699% 27 5653% 3 2092%
Tract ¹1.24.64 Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
Tract ¹1.24.64 Acre Tract
Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, et al. Tr. 110
(1) Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, et al.(On/y 3/5 interest confficli ng)
24.64 acres
14.78 acres3/5 of 24.64 acres
30.8000% 3.8099% 8.4901% 0.9884%
18.4800% 2.2860% 5.0941% 0.5931%
(a) Yukon Pocahontas Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651
12.32000 acres1/2 of 24.64 acres
15.4000% 1.9050% 4.2451% 0.4942%
(b) Buchanan Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651
2.73778 acres1/9 of 24.64 acres
3 4222% 0 4233% 0 9433% 0 1098%
(c) Sayers-Pocahontas Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651
1.36889 acres1/18 of 24.64 acres
1.7111% 0.21fyyr 0.4717% 0 0549%
(d) Buchanan Mining Company LLC *
3337 Contrary Creek RoadRaven, VA 24639
8.21333 acres1/3 of 24.64 acres
10.2667% 1.2700% 2.8300% 0.3295%
Note: Plum Creek Timberiands retained their CBM interest.
OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP
Yukon Pocahontas Coal Co. Tr. 110, et al
W9's /Affidavils nol received - Unresolved Heimhip
(3) INalter INade Heirs (1/5)
24.64 acres 30.8000% 3.8099% 8.4901% 0.9884%
(a) Carl INade Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a.2) Gaylene Deskins Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a.2.1) Nick Deskins720 Skyview DnveChilhowie, VA 24319-4527
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(a.2.2) Valmy Shannon103 Blanton DnveSeaford, VA 23696-2522
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(b) Eunice Wade Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(b.2) Abce Ruth Meadows5931 State Route 314Fredencktown, OH 43019-9225
0.06844 acres1/360 of 24.64 acres
0.0856% 0.0106% 0.0236% 0.0027%
(b.4) Ted Allen Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(b.4.1) Pansy Delons Baldwin135 indian Springs DriveCedar Bluff, VA 24609
0.06844 acres1/360 of 24.64 acres
0.0856% 0.0106% 0.0236% 0.0027%
(b.6) Marty BaldwinAddress Unknown
0.06844 acres1/360 of 24.64 acres
Page 1 of 5
0.0856% 0.0106% 0.0236% 0.0027%
11/7/2016
Page Number 9.
Exhibit EUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB-974I21 84I5644I5List of Respondents that require escrow
Net Acresin Unit
Interestin Unit
Divison of Interest in2 Left 3 Left 4 Left
12 3699% 27 5653% 3 2092%
(b.7) Ola G. Baldwin Arnold Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Pre-Deceased
(b.7.1) Wanda Gay BohonAddress Unknawn
(b.10) Norman Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
0.06844 acres1/360 of 24.64 acres
Pre-Deceased
0.0856% 0.0106% 0.0236% 0.0027%
(b.10.3) Michael BaldwinPO Box 1044Raven, VA 24639
0.01369 acres1/1800 of 24.64 acres
0.0171% 0.0021% 0 0047% 0 0005%
(b.12) Marty Arnold (adopted grandson)Uo Wanda Griffith
PO Box 116Doran, VA 24612
0.06844 acres1/360 of 24.64 acres
0.0856% 0.0106% 0.0236% 0.0027%
(c) Stella Wade Gillespie Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(c.1) Cecil Gillespie439 Brown AvenueRichlands, VA 24641
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(c.2) Troy Gillespie20307 Cleveland RoadAbingdon, VA 24211
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(c.3) David Gillespie3241 Clef LaneLakeland, TN 38002-9718
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(c.4) Darrell GillespieAddress Unknawn
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(f) Eady Wade Smith Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
(f.1) Lola Smith Robins Heirs, Devisees,Successors or AssignsDacumenisiian requested 6/20/2016
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(f.1.1)Timothy K Martin
331 Sugar Run RoadCedar Bluff, VA 24609
(f.1.2) Patnma Diane TaylorPO Box 2104Honaker, VA 24260-2104
(f.1.3) Louise R. Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or AssignsHeirs Unknown
Pre-Deceased
(f.2) Earl Dolphus Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(f.2.1) Marie Carter Smith905 Big Creek RoadRichlands, VA 24641
0.20533 acres1/120 of 24.64 acres
0.2567% 0.0317% 0.0708% 0.0082%
(f.4) Luther Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(f.4.1)Geraldine Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Page 2 of 5 11/7/2016
Page Number 10.
Exhibit EUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB-974121 841564415List of Respondents that require escrow
Net Acresin Unit
Interestin Unit
Divison of Interest in2 Left 3 Left 4 Left
12 3699o/o 27 5653o/o 3 2092o/o
(f.4.1.1) Lisa Wallace Heirs, Devisees, Predeceased Luther & Gers/dine Smith
(f.4.1.1.1)Anna Bond1760 Knox Creek RoadHurley, VA 24620
0.01711 acres1/1440 of 24.64 acres
0.0214'/o 0.0026'/o 0 0059'/o 0 0007'/o
Removed from 85 petition prior to hearing due to mail still in transit
(f.4.2.1) David Smith84 Poison Ivy DnveTaylorsville, NC 28681
0.03422 acres1/720 of 24.64 acres
0.0428'/o 0 0053'/o 0.0118'/o 0.0014'/o
Removed from 85 petition prior to hearing due to mail still in transit
(f.4.2.2) Donald Smith84 Poison Ivy DnveTaylorsville, NC 28681
0.03422 acres1/720 of 24.64 acres
0.0428'/o 0 0053'/o 0.0118'/o 0.0014'/o
Removed from 85 petition prior to hearing due to mail still in transit
(f.4.2.5) Peggy Smith84 Poison Ivy DnveTaylorsville, NC 28681
(4) Myrta N. Ratitff Heirs, Devisees,Successors or AssignsHeirs Unknown
0.03422 acres1/720 of 24.64 acres
4.92800 acres1/5 of 24.64 acres
0.0428'/o 0 0053'/o 0.0118'/o 0.0014'/o
6.1600'/o 0.7620'/o 1.6980'/o 0.1977'/o
(5) Mons Webb Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns (1/5)
(d) Virginia W Cole HeirsDevisees, Successors or Assigns
(d.3) Mekssa M. Turner3480 Eaglebrook Rd.Chnstiansburg, VA 24073
(d.4) Maura Nichole Turner (minor)3480 Eaglebrook Rd.Chnstiansburg, VA 24073
(d.5) Garrett Raid Turner (minor)3480 Eaglebrook Rd.Chnstiansburg, VA 24073
(d.6) Jordyn Noetic Turner (minor)3480 Eaglebrook Rd.Chnstiansburg, VA 24073
Total tract acresTotal tract percent
0.08800 acres1/280 of 24.64 acres
0.08800 acres1/280 of 24.64 acres
0.08800 acres1/280 of 24.64 acres
0.08800 acres1/280 of 24.64 acres
7.39849 2479o/o
0.1100'/o 0.0136'/o 0 0303'/o 0 0035'/o
0.1100'/o 0.0136'/o 0 0303'/o 0 0035'/o
0.1100'/o 0.0136'/o 0 0303'/o 0 0035'/o
0.1100'/o 0.0136'/o 0 0303'/o 0 0035'/o
Tract ¹11.0.12Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17do Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
0.120 acres 0.1500'/o 0.0186'/o 0.0413'/o 0.0048'/o
By Assignmeni snd Bill of Sa/e (Gas lease royallyl. HMLT devised a// of its nght, tii/e and rnteresi luther than "Excluded AssetsD to
Torch Energy Advisors Inc effective September 4 /99/ and recorded m Buchanan Couniy under DB474/PG354
Torch Oil & Gas Companydo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SlN
Darning, New Mexico 88030 Page 3 of 5 11/7/2016
Page Number 11.
Exhibit EUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB-974121 841564415List of Respondents that require escrow
Net Acresin Unit
Interestin Unit
Divison of Interest in2 Left 3 Left 4 Left
12 3699% 27 5653% 3 2092%
Effeciive 2/1/11. Torch Oil & Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI to SAC lnvsstmenis L P
Effeciive 3/31/14. Torch Oil & Gas Company ei al assigned and conveyed 10% of iis nght, title and viieiest lo Rockporl Oil &
Gas. L L C In addition Torcti Oil & Gas Company, et al assigned and conveyed lhe remavvng 90% of its nght, title andand mterest to Ctnsos. Ltd
Rockport Oil & Gas L L C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SlN
Darning, New Mexico 88030
0.01 acres1I10 of 0.12 acres
0.11 acres9I10 of 0.12 acres
0 0150'/r 0 0019'/r 0 0041'/r 0 0005'/r
0.1350% 0.0167% 0.0372% 0 0043%
OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP
(1) Larry S. & Sheila Stacy, TE
W9's /A¹idavits nol received
0.1200 acres 0.1500% 0.0186% 0.0413% 0.0048%
Conveyed ta Tony M. & Angels Deskins, TE by deed dated July 2, 1999, af record in DB 494/844
(a) Tony M. Deskins6507 Riverside DriveRaven, VA 24639
0.06 acres1I2 of 0.12 acres
0.0750'/ 0.0093'/ 0.0207'/ 0.0024'/
(b) Angels Y. Deskins9847 Riverside DriveOakwood, VA 24631
0.06 acres1I2 of 0.12 acres
0.0750'/ 0.0093'/ 0.0207'/ 0.0024'/
Tract ¹12. 0.03Acre Tract
COALOWNERSHIP
(1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17Ho Alan Siegel EsqGamp, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
0.030 acres 0 0375% 0.0046% 0.0103% 0.0012%
By Assignmeni and Bill of Sale (Gas lease royallyl. HMLT devised aff of its nght, tii(e and rnteresi (other than "Excluded Assetsg to
Torch Energy Advisors Inc effeclrve September 4 1991 and recorded m Buchanan Cooniy under DB474/PG384
Torch Oil & Gas CompanyHo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SlN
Darning, New Mexico 88030
Effeciive 2/1/11. Torch Oil & Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI to SAC lnvsstmenis L P
Effeciive 3/31/14. Torch Oil & Gas Company ei al assigned and conveyed 10% of iis nght, title and viieiest lo Rockporl Oil &
Gas. L L C In addition Torcti Oil & Gas Company, et al assigned and conveyed lhe remavvng 90% of its nght, title andand mterest to Ctnsos. Ltd
Rockport Oil & Gas L L C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SlN
Darning, New Mexico 88030
0.003 acres1I10 of 0.03 acres
0.027 acres9I10 of 0.03 acres
0.0038% 0 0005% 0.0010% 0.0001%
0.0338% 0.0042% 0 0093% 0.0011%
OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP
A.J. Herman heirs, et al(25.83 acres)
(1) A.J. Herman Heirs, Devisees, Successors or Assigns
0.03 acres
Page 4 of 5
0 0375% 0.0046% 0.0103% 0.0012%
11I7I2016
Page Number 12.
Exhibit EUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB-974121 841564415List of Respondents that require escrow
Net Acresin Unit
Interestin Unit
Divison of Interest in2 Left 3 Left 4 Left
12 3699o/o 27 5653o/o 3 2092o/o
(a) Luther Herman Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
(a.2) Virgie H. Keen
(a.3) Dike H. Shortndge
(a.4) Eva H Rat8ff
(a.5) Evelyn H Ford
(a.6) Mazy H Gnzzle
(a.7) Ruth H Baldwin
(a.8) Glen Herman
(a.7) INalter L. Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Legal issue pending
Conveyed interest July 1, 1963 to Walter Lee Keen & Henry Herman by DB 157/360
Conveyed interest July 1, 1963 to Walter Lee Keen & Henry Herman by DB 157/360
Conveyed interest July 1, 1963 to Walter Lee Keen & Henry Herman by DB 157/360
Conveyed interest July 1, 1963 to Walter Lee Keen & Henry Herman by DB 157/360
Conveyed interest July 1, 1963 to Walter Lee Keen & Henry Herman by DB 157/360
Conveyed interest June 27, 1962 to Walter Lee Keen & Sarah Jane Keen by DB 157/358
Conveyed interest June 27, 1962 to Walter Lee Keen & Sarah Jane Keen by DB 157/358
(a.7.1) Estate of Walter Lee Keenr/o Angels Bailey, ExecutrixPO Box 525Doran, VA 24612
0.0105 acres85/242 of 0.03 acres
0.0132'/r 0.0016'/r 0.0036'/r 00004'/r
Prior to his death, yyalter L. Keen wasPrevailing plantiffunder Case No. CL 12-292Awarded 100% of the CBM royalty.
Total tract acresTotal tract percent
0.01050.0132/o
Acreage in Unit 7.52889Percentage of Unit 94fff/o
Page 5 of 5 11/7/2016
Page Number 13.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653'4 3.2092'/
Percentof Escrow
Tract ¹1.24.64 Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company et al., Tr 110 24.64 acres(Only 3/5 interest con /lie ting)
(1) Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, et al. 14.78 acres(Only 3/5 interest con /lie ting) 3/5 of 24 64 acres
30.8000% 3.8099% 8 4901% 0 9884%
18.4800% 2.2860% 5 0941% 0 5931%
(a) Yukon Pocahontas Coal CompanyP.O Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651
7.39200 acresI/2 of 24.64 acres
9.2400% 1.1430% 2 5470% 0 2965% n/a
(b) Buchanan Coal CompanyP.O Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651
1.64267 acresI/9 of 24.64 acres
2.0533% 0.2540% 0 5660% 0 0659% n/a
(c) Sayers-Pocahontas Coal CompanyP.O Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651
0.82133 acresI/18 of 24.64 acres
1.0267% 0.1270% 0 2830% 0 0329% n/a
(d) Buchanan Mining Company LLC3337 Contrary Creek RoadRaven, VA 24639
4.92800 acresI/3 of 24.64 acres
Rove/ties Paid tor
Plum Creek Timberlands, L PAttn Mineral Department
Five Concourse Parkway, Suite 1650Atlanta, GA 30328
4.92800 acresI/3 of 24.64 acres
6.1600% 0.7620% 1 6980% 0 1977% n/a
Note: Plum Creek Timberlands retained their CBM interest, there is no conflict.The royalty for (d) is to be paid to Plum Creek.
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
Yukon Pocahontas Coal Co. Tr. 110, et al 24 64 acres 30.8000% 3.8099% 8 4901% 0 9884%
(3) Walter Wade Heirs (1/5)
(a) Carl Wade Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a I) Emanuel Wade226 Adam StreetBlountville, TN 37617
0.41067 acresI/60 of 24 64 acres
0.5133'/ 0.0635% 0 1415% 0 0165'/ 3.0348%H 82058
(b) Eunice Wade Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(b I) Inez B. Kimbrell
225 Raven CircleRaven, VA 24639
0.06844 acresI/360 of 24 64 acres
0.0856'/ 0.0106% 0 0236% 0 0027'/ 0.5058%H 82058
(b 3) Wanda Griffith
PO Box 116Doran, VA 24612
0.06844 acresI/360 of 24 64 acres
0.0856'/ 0.0106% 0 0236% 0 0027'/ 0.5058%H 82058
(b 5) Sherman Baldwin
1210 Lake Witten RoadNorth Tazewell, VA 24630
0.06844 acresI/360 of 24 64 acres
0.0856'/ 0.0106% 0 0236% 0 0027'/ 0.5058%H 82058
(b 8) D C. Baldwin Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
Pre-Deceased
(b 8 I) Nancy Baldwin Komp2510 Arhtur RoadSpringfield, OH 45502
0.03422 acresI/720 of 24 64 acres
0.0428'/ 0.0053% 0 0118% 0 0014'/ 0.2529%H 82058
(b 8 2) Sandy Baldwin Cranmer11651 SE 69th Terrace, Lot ¹18Belleview, FL 34420
0.03422 acresI/720 of 24 64 acres
Page I of 7
0.0428'/ 0.0053% 0 0118% 0 0014'/ 0.2529%H 82058
1 1 /7/201 6
Page Number 14.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653% 3.2092%
Percentof Escrow
(b 9) Shirley F Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Pre-Deceased
(b 9 I) Donna Foote32632 Downing RdDelmar, MD 21875
0.03422 acresI/720 of 24 64 acres
0.0428% 0.0053% 0 0118% 0 0014% 0.2529%H 82058
(b 9 2) Pamela Ginger Case325 Second StreetLittle Rock, AR 72117
0.03422 acresI/720 of 24 64 acres
0.0428% 0.0053% 0 0118% 0 0014% 0.2529%H 82058
(b 10) Norman Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Pre-Deceased
(b 10 I) Rufus Baldwin208 High StreetRichlands, VA 24641
0.01369 acresI/1800 of 24 64 acres
0.0171% 0.0021% 0 0047% 0 0005% 0.1012%H 82058
(b 10 2) David Baldwin
PO Box 803Raven, VA 24639
0.01369 acresI/1800 of 24 64 acres
0.0171% 0.0021% 0 0047% 0 0005% 0.1012%H 82058
(b 10 4) Tammy Baldwin Muir
4480 Clarke Valley RoadSwords Creek, VA 24649
0.01369 acresI/1800 of 24 64 acres
0.0171% 0.0021% 0 0047% 0 0005% 0.1012%H 82058
(b 10 5) Sharon G Baldwinc/o Chelsi StonemanDTGC Guardianship ProgramPO Box 1328Higsvige, VA 24343
0.01369 acresI/1800 of 24 64 acres
0.0171% 0.0021% 0 0047% 0 0005% 0.1012%H 82058
(b 11) Bane Baldwin Heirs, Devisees, Successors Pre-Deceasedor Assigns
(b 11 I) Eddie Baldwin1210 Sunset Drive
Richlands, VA 24641
0.02281 acresI/1080 of 24 64 acres
0.0285'4 0.0035% 0 0079% 0 0009'4 0.1686%H 82058
(b 11 2) Kathy Whih8740 Swords Creek RoadSwords Creek, VA 24649
0.02281 acresI/1080 of 24 64 acres
0.0285'4 0.0035% 0 0079% 0 0009'4 0.1686%H 82058
(b 11 3) Lisa Shaver89 Sevier StreetLebanon, VA 24266-7142
0.02281 acresI/1080 of 24 64 acres
0.0285'4 0.0035% 0 0079% 0 0009'4 0.1686%H 82058
(d) Glayds Ida Boyd Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
(d I) Petti Gilbert3603 Kents Ridge RoadRichlands, VA 24641
0.27378 acresI/90 of 24 64 acres
0.3422'4 0.0423% 0 0943% 0 0110'4 2.0232%H 82058
(d 2) Michae/T Boyd3849 Kents Ridge RoadRichlands, VA 24641
0.27378 acresI/90 of 24 64 acres
0.3422'4 0.0423% 0 0943% 0 0110'4 2.0232%H 82058
(d 3) Eleanor Hagy14475 Rainbow Road, Lot ¹31Bristol, VA 24202
0.27378 acresI/90 of 24 64 acres
0.3422'4 0.0423% 0 0943% 0 0110'4 2.0232%H 82058
(e) Venia Wade Newberry639 Daniel DriveNewport News, VA 23601-1701
0.82133 acresI/30 of 24 64 acres
1.0267'4 0.1270% 0 2830% 0 0329'4 6.0696%H 82058
(f) Eady Wade Smith Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
(f 3) Raymond S Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(f.3.1) Virginia Edith Smith
PO Box 3350.20533 acres 0.2567% 0.0317% 0 0708% 0 0082% 1.5174%
I/120 ¹fdgh6¹r¹oles 11/Ngtyg¹8
Page Number 15.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653% 3.2092%
Percentof Escrow
Doran, VA 24612
(f 4) Luther Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(f.4.1)Geraldine Smith Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(f 4.1 1) Lisa Wallace Heirs, Devisees, Predeceased Lu/her 5 Gera/drne Smrln
(f 4 1.1.2) Scotty BondPO Box 82
Swords Creek, VA 24649
0.01711 acresI/1440 of 24 64 acres
0.0214% 0.0026% 0 0059% 0 0007% 0.1264%H 82058
(f4.23) Judy Tiedemann530 150th Street
Amery, Wl 54001-2805
(f4.24) Paul Smith, Sr Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
0.03422 acresI/720 of 24 64 acres
0.0428% 0.0053% 0 0118% 0 0014% 0.2529%H 82058
(f 4 2.4.1) Jo-Ann Perkins SmithPO Box 1143Claremont, NC 28610
0.03422 acresI/720 of 24 64 acres
0.0428% 0.0053% 0 0118% 0 0014% 0.2529%H 82058
(5) Mone Webb Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a) Harold Webb Heirs, Devisees,Successors or AssignsDocumen/anon Pendmg
0.70400 acresI/35 of 24 64 acres
0.8800% 0.1089% 0 2426% 0 0282% n/a
(b) Herman Webb106 3rd AvenueRichlands, VA 24641
0.70400 acresI/35 of 24 64 acres
0.8800% 0.1089% 0 2426% 0 0282% n/a
(c) John WebbP. O.Box 577Keen Mountain, VA 24624
0.70400 acresI/35 of 24 64 acres
0.8800% 0.1089% 0 2426% 0 0282% n/a
(d) Virginia W. Cole HeirsDevisees, Successors or Assigns
(d I ) Carold Cole Ownbey2908 Valley Farm RoadWaxhaw, North Carolina 28173
0.17600 acresI/140 of 24 64 acres
0.2200% 0.0272% 0 0606% 0 0071% n/a
(d 2) Barbara Cole Maxwell5780 Chicwood DrivePulaski, VA 24301
0.17600 acresI/140 of 24 64 acres
0.2200% 0.0272% 0 0606% 0 0071% n/a
(e) Emma R Hurbert Heirs, Devisees,Successors, or Assigns
(e I) Bill Chambers8940 Mill Creek RoadMigboro, VA 24460
0.70400 acresI/35 of 2 14 acres
0.8800% 0.1089% 0 2426% 0 0282% n/a
(f) Ruby W Wells5980 Pearl RoadParma Heights, OH 44130
(g) Robert W. Casey Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
(g I) Pauline Cole Casey (2nd wife)1279 Hilltop RoadJeweg Ridge, VA 24622
0.70400 acresI/35 of 24 64 acres
0.23467 acresI/105 of 24 64 acres
0.8800% 0.1089% 0 2426% 0 0282% n/a
0.2933% 0.0363% 0 0809% 0 0094% 1.7342%H 82058
(g 2) Chadwick Michael Casey520 Watson RoadPounding Mill, VA 24637
0.23467 acresI/105 of 24 64 acres
0.2933% 0.0363% 0 0809% 0 0094% 1.7342%H 82058
(g 3) Brian Casey798 Pond StreetPounding Mill, VA 24637
0.23467 acresI/105 of 24 64 acres
Page 3 of 7
0.2933% 0.0363% 0 0809% 0 0094% 1.7342%H 82058
1 1 /7/201 6
Page Number 16.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653'A 3.2092'/
Percentof Escrow
Total tract acres 7.4199Total tract percent 9.2321%
Tract ¹5. 1.23Acre Tract
COALOWNERSHIP
(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
1.230 acres 1.5375'4 0.1902% 0 4238% 0 0493'4
By Assignmenf end Bill of Sale (Gas lease royally'. HMLT devised aff of ifs nghl sfle and inleresl (ofher /hen "Excluded Assefs ) fo
Torch Eriergy Advrsors Inc effeclive Seplemoei 4 7997 arid recorded iri Buchanan Counly under DB474/PG384
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effechve 2/7/11 Torch OS E. Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI lo SAC Invesfmenls L P
Elfechve 3/37/14 Torch OS 7 Gas Company el al assigned arid conveyed 79% of as nghl sfle arid mleiesl fo Rockpoil OS E.
Gas L L C Iri addilion. Torch Qs& Gas Company sf el essigried and conveyed ffie remammg 90% olds nghl nile endend inferesf fo Cliisos Lld
Rockport Oil & Gas L L.CPO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
0 12 acresI/10 of 1.23acres
0.1538'4 0.0190% 0 0424% 0 0049'4
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
I 11 acres9/10 of 1.23acres
1.3838'/ 0.1712% 0 3814% 0 0444'/
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
(I) Gussie Johnson Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
1.23 acres 1.5375'4 0.1902% 0 4238% 0 0493'4
(a) Daniel Johnson5312 Old Kentucky TurnpikeRaven, VA 24639
0.41 acresI/3 of 1.23acres
0.5125'/ 0.0634% 0 1413% 0 0164'/ 3.0299%H 82058
(b) Russell JohnsonPO Box 4538North Myrtle Beach, SC 29597
0.41 acresI/3 of 1.23acres
0.5125'/ 0.0634% 0 1413% 0 0164'/ 3.0299%H 82058
(c) Phyllis Boyd5500 Quaga RoadChesterfield, VA 23832
0.41 acresI/3 of 1.23acres
0.5125'/ 0.0634% 0 1413% 0 0164'/ 3.0299%H 82058
Tract ¹6. 0.75 Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
0.750 acres 0.9375'4 0.1160% 0 2584% 0 0301'4
By Assignmenf end Bill of Sale (Gas lease royally'. HMLT devised aff of ifs nghl sfle and inleresl (ofher /hen "Excluded Assefs ) fo
Torch Eriergy Advrsors Inc effeclive Seplemoei 4 7997 arid recorded iri Buchanan Counly under DB474/PG384
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effechve 2/7/11 Torch OS E. Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI lo SAC Invesfmenls L P
Elfechve 3/37/14 Torch OS 7 Gas Company el al assigned arid conveyed 79% of as nghl sfle arid mleiesl fo Rockpoil OS E.
Gas L L C Iri addilion. Torch Qs& Gas Company sf el essigried and conveyed ffie remammg 90% olds nghl nile endend inferesf fo Cliisos Lld
Page 4 of 7 11/7/2016
Page Number 17.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653'4 3.2092'/
Percentof Escrow
Rockport Oil & Gas L L.CPO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
0 08 acresI/10 of 0.75 acres
0.0938'4 0.0116% 0 0258% 0 0030'4
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
0 68 acres9/10 of 0.75 acres
0.8438'4 0.1044% 0 2326% 0 0271'4
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
(I) Kathy & Dickey Looney, TEPO Box 276Oakwood, VA 24631
0.75 acres 0.9375'4 0.1160% 0 2584% 0 0301'4 5.5424%H 82058
Tract ¹7. 0.49 Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
0.490 acres 0.6125'4 0.0758% 0 1688% 0 0197'4
By Assignmenf end Bill of Sale (Gas lease royally'. HMLT devised aff of ifs nghl elle and inleresl (ofher Ihan "Exclvded Assefs ) fo
Torch Eriergy Advrsors Inc effeclive Seplemhei 4 7997 arid recorded iri Buchanan Covnly under DB474/PG384
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effecfrve 2/7/11 Torch OS & Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI lo SAC Invesfmenls L P
Elfechve 3/37/14 Torch OS & Gas Company el al assigned arid conveyed 79% of de nghl sfle arid mleiesl fo Rockpoil OS &
Gas L L C Iri addilion. Torch Os & Gas Company ef el essigried and conveyed ffie remammg 90% of ds nghl nile endend inferesf fo Cliisos Lid
Rockport Oil & Gas L L.CPO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
005 acresI/10 of 0.49 acres
0.0613'4 0.0076% 0 0169% 0 0020'4
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
0 44 acres9/10 of 0.49 acres
0.5513'/ 0.0682% 0 1520% 0 0177'/
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
(I) Selma June Mullins Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
0.49 acres 0.6125'4 0.0758% 0 1688% 0 0197'4
(a) Jack Kirby Mullins, JrPO Box 492Keen Mountain, VA 24624
0.245 acresI/2 of 0.49 acres
0.3063'4 0.0379% 0 0844% 0 0098'4 1.8105%H 82058
(b) Rite Jill BakerPO Box 94Rosedale, VA 24280
0.245 acresI/2 of 0.49 acres
0.3063'4 0.0379% 0 0844% 0 0098'4 1.8105%H 82058
Tract ¹8. 5.18Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
5.180 acres 6.4750'4 0.8010% 1 7849% 0 2078'4 nya
By Assignmenf end Bill of Sale (Gas lease royally'. HMLT devised aff of ifs nghl elle and inleresl (ofher Ihan "Exclvded Assefs ) fo
Torch Eriergy Advrsors Inc effeclive Seplemhei 4 7997 arid recorded iri Buchanan Covnly under DB474/PG384
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Page 5 of7
708252
11/7/2016
Page Number 18.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653'4 3.2092'/
Percentof Escrow
Effechve 2/7711 Torch OS 8. Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI lo SAC Invesfmenls L P
Erfechve 3/37/14 Torch OS 8 Gas Company el al assigned arid conveyed 79% of as nghl sfle arid mleiesl to Rockpoil OS 8.
Gas L L C Irr addi/ron. Torch Qd 8. Gas Company ef el essigrred and conveyed Ilia remammg 90% of ds nghl nile endend interest fo Clrisos Lld
Rockport Oil & Gas L L.CPO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
0 52 acresI/10 of 5.18acres
0.6475'/ 0.0801% 0 1785% 0 0208'/
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
4 66 acres9/10 of 5.18acres
5.8275% 0.7209% 1 6064% 0 1870% nfa
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
(I) Roscoe Reuben Deskins Sr Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
5.18 acres 6.4750% 0.8010% 1 7849% 0 2078%
(a) Roscoe Deskins, Jr1728 Wardeg RdCedar Bluff, VA 24609
2.59 acresI/2 of 5.18acres
3.2375% 0.4005% 0 8924% 0 1039% nfa
(b) Calvin Eddie Deskins6972 RiversideRaven, VA 24639
2.59 acresI/2 of 5.18acres
3.2375% 0.4005% 0 8924% 0 1039% nfa
Tract ¹9. 3.18Acre Tract
COAL OWNERSHIP
(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr6c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
3.180 acres 3.9750% 0.4917% 1 0957% 0 1276% nfa
By Assignmenf end Bill of Sale (Gas lease royally'. HMLT devised aff of ifs nghl htle and in(eras( (ofher Ihan "Excluded Assefs ) to
Torch Errergy Advrsors Inc effeclrve Seplemhei 4 7997 arid recorded irr Buchanan Covnly under DB474 I PG384
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
708252
Effechve 2/7711 Torch OS 8. Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI lo SAC Invesfmenls L P
Erfechve 3/37/14 Torch OS 8 Gas Company el al assigned arid conveyed 79% of as nghl sfle arid mleiesl to Rockpoil OS 8.
Gas L L C Irr addi/ron. Torch Qd 8. Gas Company ef el essigrred and conveyed Ilia remammg 90% of ds nghl nile endend interest fo Clrisos Lld
Rockport Oil & Gas L L.CPO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
0 32 acresI/10 of 3.18acres
0.3975% 0.0492% 0 1096% 0 0128%
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
2 86 acres9/10 of 3.18acres
3.5775% 0.4425% 0 9861% 0 1148%
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
(I) CNX Gas Company LLCPO Box 643830Pittsburgh, PA 15264-3830
3.18 acres 3.9750% 0.4917% 1 0957% 0 1276% nfa
Tract ¹12. 0.03 Acre Tract
COALOWNERSHIP
(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tr 17c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-6715
0.030 acres 0.0375'/ 0.0046% 0 0103% 0 0012'/
By Assignmenf end Bill of Sale (Gas lease royally'. HMLT devised aff of ifs nghl htle and in(eras( (ofher Ihan "Excluded Assefs ) to
Torch Errergy Advrsors Inc effeclrve Seplemhei 4 7997 arid reqtatjec67678pchanan Covnly under DB474 I PG384 11/7/2016
Page Number 19.
Interestin Unit
Exhibit EEUnit U-28
Docket ¹VGOB 97.0218-0564.05List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
Divison of Interest in
2 Left 3 Left 4 Left12.3699% 27.5653'4 3.2092'/
Percentof Escrow
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effechve 2///11 Torch OS & Gas Coinpany assigned a 2% ORRI lo SAC Invesfmenls L P
Effecnve 3/3//14 Torch OS & Gas Company el al assigned arid conveyed 10% of us nghl sfle arid mlei eel Io Rockpoil OS &
Gas L L C Iii addi/ion. Torch Od & Gas Company ef el essigiied and conveyed Ilia iemammg 00% of ds nghl elle endend in/eras/ fo Cliisos Lid
Rockport Oil & Gas L L.CPO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
0 003 acresI/10 of 0.03 acres
0.0038'/ 0.0005% 0 0010% 0 0001'/
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
0 027 acres9/10 of 0.03 acres
0.0338% 0.0042% 0 0093% 0 0011%
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
A J Herman heirs, et el(25.83 acres)
0.03 acres 0.0375'/ 0.0046% 0 0103% 0 0012'/
(I) A.J Herman Heirs, Devisees, Successors or Assigns
(a) Luther Herman Heirs, Devisees, Successorsor Assigns
(a I) S.W. Herman Conveyed interest July 15, 1967 to Kendris Herman by DB 214/154
(a 1 I) Kendris HermanPO Box 144Tazeweg, VA 24651
0 0030 acres12/121 of 0 03 acres
0.0037'/ 0.0005% 0 0010% 0 0001'/ 0.0220%
Prevailing plantiff under Case No. CL 12-292Awarded 100%of the CB/N royalty.
(a 7) Ruth H Baldwin
(a 8) Glen Herman
Conveyed interest June 27, 1962 to Walter Lee Keen & Sarah Jane Keen by DB 157/358
Conveyed interest June 27, 1962 to Walter Lee Keen & Sarah Jane Keen by DB 157/358
(a 9) Sarah Jane Keen1817 Fifth StreetRichlands, VA 24641
0 0060 acres24/121 of 0 03 acres
0.0074% 0.0009% 0 0021% 0 0002% 0.0440%H 82058
Sarah Jane Keen notincluded in Case No. CL 12-292
(a 10) Henry F. Herman21363 Sim RoadAbingdon, VA 24211-6286
0.0105 acres85/242 of 0 03 acres
0.0132'/ 0.0016% 0 0036% 0 0004'/ 0.0779%
Prevailing plantiff under Case No. CL 12-292Awarded 100%of the CB/N royalty.
Acreage in Unit 18.2693Percentage of Unit 22.7939'4
Page 7 of 7 1 1 /7/201 6
Page Number 20.
AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF BUCHANAN
Applicant: CNX Gas Company LLCRelief Sought: Disbursement Petition for U28
VGOB: 97-0218-0564-05
I, Anita D. Duty, after being duly sworn upon oath, state as follows:
1. I am the Pooling Supervisor for CNX Land Resources, Inc. and am responsible for the notification
process required by Va. Code Ann. $45.1-361.19of the Code of Virginia and 4VAC25-160-40.
2. That on October 13. 2016 a true and correct copy of the Notice of Hearing and Exhibits were
mailed, via certified mail return receipt requested, based upon information and belief, the names and last-known
addresses, where such addresses are known, of the parties owning an interest in this cause are set forth and attached
hereto.
Notice of this cause has therefore been served by mail pursuant to the applicable statues and rules
of the Board.
a D> DutyPoo 'pervisorfor CNX Land LLC
STATE OF VIRGINIA
COUNTY OF TAZEWELL, TO-WIT:fy
TAKEN, SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this FJ day of kui/e.ri LroX
2016.
Commorssreaith of Vtrainia
Jeff -y A. Sinr.-us - NotaT Pubi't
Commission X): 7?15200My Ccities gxsres iist3ti~
Nota uMc ~~
My commission expires: Av 0 u 4'8 3/ Zf)76l '
Page Number 21.
CERTIFICATION OF NOTICECNX Gas Company LLC
Unit U28I/GOB 97-0218-0564-65DisbursementBuchanan
Last NameBaker
Baldwin
Baldwin
Baldwin
Baldwin
Baldwin
Bond
Sovd
Sovd
Case
Casev
Gases
Gases
Cook
Cranmer
PcoteGilbert
GrSlith
Hwnr
Herman
Herman
lohnson
lohnscm
Keen
KimbreB
Komo
loonavMuir
MuBinsJr
Newbenv
5haval'mith
Smith
Tradarrlsm
Wade
Whitt
First NameRite IDavid
Eddie
Rufrrr
Sharon
Sherman
ScotteMichaelT
PhvBis
Pamela Girwer
Chadwick Michael
Pauline Cole
Robert arian
T. Shee
Sandra
Donna
PateWanda
Eleanor
Henwv
Kendris
D n IA
Russell
Sarah Jane
Ines
Nenes Baldwin
KathvlkDi kev
Tammv Baldwin
I ckK
annie Wade
U
Jo-Ann Perkins
Mrginla Edith
Judv
Emanuel
Kathv
MAILED RECEIPT 910/13/2016 70160MMOMNSBID/13/2D16 701603400MONS910/13/ID16 701603400MON8910/13/2016 701603400M0898910/13/2016 TD160340MOOS989
10/13/2016 7D16034MOOM939
10/13/2016 7016207M00102S210/13/2016 7016207M001028210/13/2D16 701620700001028210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 701620700001023210/13/2016 70162D70DM10282
10/13/2016 70162070M0102IQ10/13/2016 70162D70M010282
ID/13/2016 7016207000010282ID/13/2016 70162070M010282ID/15/2016 701620700M1028210/13/2D16 701620700001028210/13/2016 701620700M1028210/13/2016 70162070M010282IO/IS/2026 TOISIOTOOOOIONI
10/13/2016 70162070M01028210/13/2016 7D16207000010282
ID/15/2016 7D16207M001028210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 7016207000D1028210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 70162070M01028210/13/2016 70162070M01028210/13/2016 70162070C00102S210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 701620700001028210/13/2016 7016207000DID282
10/13/2016 7016207000010232
1354486118781835189219M776277997M5781276297836764380937850786773747881789879047911792S79357942810979597966797379307997SODO
803180558062
N798086
Received10/19/2016
10/IS/lD1610/17/2016
10/19/201610/17/2016
10/18/2016ID/21/2016
10/15/201610/16/2016
10/21/201610/16/201610/17/2D1610/17/2D16
10/17/201610/20/2016ID/17/201610/17/2016
10/20/201610/19/2016
10/19/201610/15/201610/15/2016
10/17/201610/17/2016ID/24/2016
10/18/201610/24/201610/I 7/201610/31/201610/15/201610/18/201610/21/201610/19/2016
ID/20/2016
10/17/ID1610/17/2016
Page Number 22.
te
g O'5 —,OOE OO
ll'
gjE
0 iik jegee !.
f mi::j!i
~ ~ ~
R I
SO NUl G. IG
pEE ')g
OO 0
55
PG
I0C~ d
0.'U
E
/!Q- CI
10 Q '
CG
E
G.0
0 Ej pt:-~4l-!GOC 0
I
L
OO IC0
!6
~ ~ ~ 0
0U N
0 0.8$C
0 !I%So
000 5 ==
i
!EJ
CIliCI 5= G
m c
C—C
0
IU
IPG
: E
I!
OO 'I I
= hQ IE
IP
I': 5"- I!.
f ~ 5 ~
0 A
g~ z
N
'4c55)i;
56
6
0
I
0'QI
GI
I'IU"IQE w 0
I
!g; 6E.,IG'FQOG
'" Ul
,',='5! .aj',g fg $ EI
f
~ ~ ~
O El hi
Gl
0C—C'
000
0'
~c
Ul
IEQ, [
,5 Q !
!.!HIGCGOOO
OO
gR~
lych
=!isI ~ ~ ~
0
vs
e xcecaCG
'5 C Z
r
Ct
I EClP .E
FQ E
Er
CGC C Gc
0
I(- '-::C
Q!55 5
CC
'--'-,.j
CO 2
!5
.<2
;!!!I!0
0
',QI Q
'l-. m
QI
56
Oof
XW IG
EO
'5
$ 5
5 5 f)
f )ci
.'Hi "
OOIE . 5
i
!GGEEXI e-0
I: xW.!
P9
:EE„
I
g R!0
=606
~ 5 ~
8CC
C
0Ol00~ O
O
~ C
Q Li
IG
g$ E
iHE ..jN
I-'
~ C ~
ka:0 0ROI e)!O e
O 0. IL'
0
EQI Q'iQ
f
m i
IOCV
Gt
Q G
0 )0C
crl
U IG
0
Xl0
'Q
Page Number 23.
g RBD ik
OBI8'44]g
LD
i~a~ 3
'I-j
3 Ezf 8tl
EI
—8-B f'8
Bg;
Eg
9 Bjl
DO
E0 44 Q
CO 4! O
lb'CCBB
8~888~ c
0 «I 8IUo 8IO EOOOI'-rrfa
E
„'3 38i
DI4
DOC
e K
IB cO IQ
IL F> 4!
8„88)QPE«8
Ipd;::-,. i="-:IID
—a
9N4
OB «I NNY >
3 IL O
Dael —-
C
4'
O
ClI
fo
~ ~ ~ e ~ ~
8
i
tgi la
f EB
!g $
:I8:.I
~ ~ ~
8B
rr El
88
IOf0 la
SNXO'8 Ec
Dho-c0
=ICC0
0
0~ 0
i
l! O
JlO
IJm
'Bi~I:!I;.0CIC Q 00
8
BBI;IP-'
'BUBB ml0000 0
r
E iB. 88Er ir
80
E II8 38—R-f EfoBE
3
.I".fB 8
8 8-'
e
NIQ8
@388
~geogx iai li
IQ
IID C +
8 D Il04 IQ
eO 04- IL K
8 )ff
888Iea
C!
8r.
C
C
O
CI
00- e ao
i.
1448(8)4'84;$84.8:-=i
! .
Bf 8
0
[i
!
4ha i.~kg
4
t
00
E 8
O NB=DCY
N Ur
8C C
N I
OO
I
88 8F 8:.
Q.Ej-'m"-8'iB
0
-E
E p
Qg-.
r
N4t
8L! 80 oN
C Itrg of
8DNYE
NQ.
'coco«I
IU«I
cr
n 'OCI
I! r
N 'lC
e4,0Xl
fg R
BE Eg0
8
08o3CD>OKN
ca 2Y f C."Of
D
C 9 a.
8 888jjf'—
IU
ir
[
O
C44
NC
8 0<e 4I
Pf D
= 0O N e
Ct
Cl
C 4
Page Number 24.
0
E kftk 0 J
4djl>0 0 0
j
4i
I
X
0 t'0j=
0 a-
"'E'0
ig zEI
~ ~ ~
0
ECC
0
O
00
=80
0'U
im
8li
Wi
Ct C
E ooY
DE tL 0
'00
la 0
0CtZ I Io
O
IO0
C'L
at0
0 ~
0'Bjj ADD
0
~00 0 GG
:Itxjlz '.
iif SQDja 100
of
0 0
EENC
gf
i
'0
'E
oaooaom
X
IE
Nj jgl
0 2
iUZ
U
E'
"-I Y
g I ~ ~
QQ~ QD
0'
0 00 Itt00 0R la
0K o.
IC000N
000
0Z
i0
ftl
iE it,E n
E
otC0C
0-EftfEEEEE
5 fk j
0
EEEE
leaf Ij
i
1
,0 II 0 '
ll Jl
I ..:$'E
jmEt=;$
I ~ 0 0
0 P' .'I0
el Il 0g
'I'g> -$-'k
X
0E
Ct0 0 gCt
oYCC
0 0CI 0
00 CC
IU
oi
0
0
iOj
0
ot CG
EE~bt j,)9vh;Jj!i
0 t 0
0=
Page Number 25.
Igl
I
IO10
0
.0",k.'E..'-EES jE )i 50,'„'
0 l
Ot
0000E IO
—I0Ie
00 0.000 a 0
CCLOC ul
C
IU
IU
la
it a,l
«I
I
iPr~j(uu ~ 0
f,iS. S >I~ 8a>=n-Ecj5$ ~SI jIli) 5sj
0!je
I i-'-',-.:--=0 «
Ycf
g ii-
I flXI
'fl! E
S
j SC -"..j
IS 00 tl
g!
d\ dl03 te
E0 00
loIU 0
C
Z0
00
lu
!~'i= S.ES«'
0
I
CEjPSB'f),~$>
lu
0'I
CNc
0!0'
C
E
0
I I ', =-
003
." == S E 8~ ~ 0
S SIC 0EL'I
IC 0N0 <
Sa.
'l4jjSS00000
0
I
,'S
0
I
:!he:4
-0 '!CI
elfU0!
CIC!
0!C!Cl
jjRR.: ;-
'8 SS
jig
ES3'. I-
kg j;„S
Ekki
E )$ 5$ 1t
~ I
J 0„.[ US E S E
t«Iel
„- 01 <0 0 00 '0 0
o 0e
to
I '
100«!Oo0
—000
a3'l
S
,'l aSCI
IU
I~i Uf
..a 0
I
B.j 'I
SIR,0 0
3II
NI
Cl
ClClI«
N o0
0 0
C'
to
0
moIU
I
CI E N0!ce>
Ne NIU N
,PO o0. Cl
fu-'U
0 aCI
CIAl
o
I)
I-
Sl I '„."S'7
XI
S
SSSASSHS;.0000 0.
0
R jSSEES
r~9BB~ Sflu 1 0.::=S 0 0
0 =ue —-00
op E
,'
0 «0
I»
It lee <
'E>Y'U 00a eaE 'EES gIe e Ol
'0
—:N
03f.00'ja
-„
I, Clf
IS
I .-..*
«Ig. 03 „
Sl ~ c
SEE 0
X
ld
0
0 5e oIao 50. Y
0
I
CIle
0
N
o ge Z
o0 z
IU
a
CI
ofU
Page Number 26.
Exhibit JUnit U28 Escrow Account Rcconcilidtion
VGOB 97-0218-0564
CNX Deoosd nn Ww
08*10 I*10/24/199811/25/199812/24/1998I/25/19992/25/19993/25/19994/24/19995/25/19996/25/19997/24/19998/25/19999/25/1999
10/25/199911/25/199912/22/1999
I/25/20002/25/2000
3/24/20004/25/20005/25/2000
6/23/20007/25/20008/25/2000
9/25/200010/25/200011/24/2000
12/22/2000I/25/20012/23/2001
3/23/20014/25/20015/25/2001
6/25/20017/25/20018/24/2001
9/25/200110/25/200111/23/200112/24/2001
I/25/2002
CI IN 644324564
486550515240
5430ssag5740591560966332655567717016735175617792802982818542
87839032932496289938
10177105421084111178115441185712227
1255312956133621369614019143621482415350
Ttl55,897 59
5424 3351,395 94S1,458 4751,814 52
51,469 64St,eee ao51,572 92
S3,268 9151,906 59
5857 27
5763 30St,oga 26
5819 595541 945674 69S322 895280 535413 72S384 78
5521 34S499 835559 435890 025662 155733 78
Seto a45825 42
S1,366 82
51,621 195896 78SB49 82
5795 595689 31Ssya 92
5301 09Sass 22
5173 30S147 875140 91
10/31/199811/30/199812/31/1998I/31/19992/28/19993/31/19994/30/19995/31/19996/30/19997/31/19998/31/19999/30/1999
10/31/199911/30/199912/31/1999
I/31/20002/29/2000
3/31/20004/30/20005/31/2000
6/30/20007/31/20008/31/2000
9/30/200010/31/200011/30/200012/31/2000
I/31/20012/28/2001
3/31/20014/30/20015/31/20016/30/20017/31/20018/31/20019/30/2001
10/31/200111/30/200112/31/2001
I/31/20022/28/2002
3/31/20024/30/20025/31/2002
6/30/20027/31/2002
8/31/20029/30/2002
10/31/2002
Bse 4RoyaltyD
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
510,990 8551,469 6451,666 Bo
51,572 9253,268 9151,906 59
5857 275763 30
51,098 2651,36153
5674 695322 895280 535413 725384 785521 345499 835559 43
5890 02
So 005733 78
Seto a45825 42
52,192 24
51,621 195896 78S849 82
5795 595689 31S578 92
5301 09Sass 215173 305147 ay
5140 91So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
Iso e
523 81564 55554 82
568 06Sas ee554 88
5116 18Sag s4569 58
5278 78572 68Salle593 82Saa ge
5121 875115 855123 575125 995121 74
So 00Siss ao5135 205145 035251 015119075116 905100 21586 07591 73589 23
567 90561 51548 48552 05530 99522 92
525 35So 00
528 20S23 7252242523 57522 80519 29
I M ketl t CDARB I t
59 34520 54522 47522 93523 94526 01528 50528 34529 06529 99
Dattnutw s Co eetw s Aud t Costs 0 Wloss
SI 22
54 43514 20
56 9756 1156 09
54 55
So 89525 55
540 87
50.00
50.0050.0050.0050.00
50.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.00
Roy Ity
no os
Tot II t,d ress
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
515 59539 58518 15538 16555 61522 78
592 23562 09514 97
5207 92572 68582 16593 82Saa 96
5121 875115 855123 575125 995121 74
So 005135 805135 205145 035251 015119075 11690Slog 21586 07591 73589 23
567 90561 51S48 48552 05530 99522 92525 35
So 00528 20
523 72522 42
523 57522 80519 29
nwonsnw;
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
511,1064451,215 66
514,200 61515,81169519,13621521,065 58
522,015 08522,840 47523,953 70525,523 15526,270 52526,675 57
527,049 92527,552 60528,059 25
528,696 44529,319 84S30,005 26
531,01702531,823 03532,692 61533,448 65534,419 10535,891 90537,632 16538,645 64539,595 87540,477 53541,258 57541,926 72
542,295 71542,710 43542,932 21543,132 13543,304 03543,326 95543,352 30543,352 30543,380 50
543,404 22
543,426 64
543,450 21543,473 01543,492 30
55,897 5956,321 92
57,717 8659,176 33
510,99085
512.476 08514,182 46515,773 53519.08060521,042 80521,922 85
522,778 38523,938 73524,773 29
525,523 15526,270 52526,675 57527,049 92527,552 60Sta,osg tsSta,ege 44529,319 84530,005 26
531,01702531,679 17532,548 75
533,304 79534,275 24
535,893 07537,633 33Ssa,e47 ol539,597 04540,478 70541,259 74541,927 89542,296 88542,711 60542,933 38543,133 30543,305 20543,328 12
543,353 47543,353 47543,381 67543,405 39543,427 81543.451 38543,474 18543,493 47
R lsBN Dnf
55,897 5956,321 92
57,717 8659,176 33
510,990 85
51,369 64512,966 Bo
51,572 92
53,268 9151,906 59
5857 27
5763 30S1,098 26
5819 59
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
5143 865143 86
5143 865143 86
St wSt wSI 37St wSt wSt wSt wSI wSt wSt wSt wSt wSI wSt wSt wSt wSt wSt wSt wSt wSt w
Page I of 5
Page Number 27.
Exhibit JUnit U28 Escrow Account Reconcil(ation
VGOB 97-0218-0564
CNX Deoosd nn Ww
Ca*lot* CI IN 6 Tlf11/30/200212/31/2002
I/31/20032/28/20033/31/20034/30/20035/31/20036/30/2003
7/31/20038/31/20039/30/2003
10/31/200311/30/200312/31/2003
I/31/20042/28/2004
3/31/2004
4/30/20045/31/20046/30/2004
7/31/20048/31/20049/30/2004
10/31/200411/30/200412/31/2004
I/31/20052/28/20053/31/20054/30/20055/31/20056/30/2005
7/31/20058/31/20059/30/2005
10/31/200511/30/200512/31/2005
I/31/20062/28/20063/31/20064/30/20065/31/20066/30/2006
7/31/20068/31/2006
10/31/200611/30/200612/31/2006
ase oRoyaltyD
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
Iso e
Sll BS
S2O 12
Sg aa
59 05
54 52
5740Ss 1457 05
54 31Sl 78
Sl 56
Sl 3953 70Sl 3954 49SB 22
Sl 96
SS 23
Ss 1456 97
59 02518 54522 04526 07534 08533 75
545 20551 38Sso 04Sas aa570 40576 02
576 02Sas 61592 11594 96597 56
5105 49Sny 22
5116 365120 75
5139 545134 60514o ao5140 785153 345173 065177 555179 40
I M ketl t CDARS I t
(53 11)(524 61)
50.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.00
Fees D st lwtw s Co eetw s Aud t Costs 0 Wloss Roy Ity
no tls
Tot II t.d Fees
SB BS
51O 22
59 8859 0554 52
57 40Ss 1457 0554 31Sl 78
Sl 56
52 3953 70
52 3954 4953 22
Sl 96SS 23
Ss 1456 9759 02
518 54522 04526 07534 08533 75
545 20551 38550 04565 86570 40576 02576 02SBS 61592 11594 96597 56
5105 495117 22
5116 365120 75
5139 545134 60
S140 80S140 785153 34
5173 065174 445154 79
nwn
nsnw'43,513
65543,533 77
543,543 65543,552 70543,557 22
543,564 62543,569 76543,576 81543,581 12543,582 90543,584 46543,586 85543,590 55543,592 94543,597 43543,600 65543,602 61543,607 84543,612 98543,619 95543,628 97543,647 51543,669 55
543,695 62543,729 70543,763 45543,808 65543,860 03543,910 07543,975 93544,046 33544,122 35544,198 37544,283 98544,376 09544,471 05544,568 61544,674 10544,791 32544,907 68545,028 43545, 167 97545,302 57545,443 37545,584 15545,737 49546,071 18546,245 62546,400 41
R lsBN543,514 82543,534 94543.544 82543,553 87543,558 39543.565 79543,570 93543,577 98543.582 29
543,584 07543,585 63543,588 02543,591 72543,594 11543,598 60543,601 82543,603 78543,609 01543,614 15543,621 12
543,630 14543,648 68543,670 72
543,696 79543,730 87543,764 62
543,809 82543,861 20543,911 24
543,977 10S44,047 50S44,123 52
S44,199 54S44,285 15S44,377 26
S44,472 22
S44,569 78S44,675 27
S44,792 49S44,908 85545,029 60545,169 14545,303 74545,444 54545,585 32545,738 66545.91172546,086 16546,240 95
Dnl
Sl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl wSl w
5159 465159 465159 46
Page 2 of 5
Page Number 28.
Exhibit JUnit U28 Eecrow Account Reconcil(otion
VGOB 97-0218-0564
CNX Deoosd nn uw
Ck*IDI* CI IN 8 Ttf
Ose 4RoyaltyD
Iso~ tnketI t CDARSI t Fees D st Toto s Co ecto s Aod t Costs G Ils ssRoy Ity
no tts
Tot II t.d Fees
Oaoosnw'
I a8 n Dnf
I/31/20072/28/2007
3/31/20074/30/20075/31/2007
6/30/20077/31/20078/31/2007
9/30/200710/31/200711/30/200712/31/2007
I/31/20082/29/looa3/31/20084/30/20085/31/2008
6/30/20087/31/20088/31/2008
9/30/200810/31/200811/30/200812/31/2008
I/I/20092/28/2009
3/31/20094/30/20095/31/20096/30/20097/31/20098/31/20099/30/2009
10/31/200911/30/200912/31/2009
I/I/20102/I/20103/I/20104/I/20105/I/20106/I/20107/I/20108/I/20109/I/2010
10/I/201011/I/201012/I/2010I/31/2011
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
5169 615163 14Slso as5174 235160 145167 195327 64Sleo aa
5255 145160 735166 005153 105122 31S104 03591 15Sea 26556 06
Sss ao553 68Sea 29
561 04549 01564 57
526 08
Sl 29
(S2 38)5648
(S4 ls)(54 18)(S4 31)(S4 38)(S2 53)(Sl 79)(S2 09)(Sl 95)(S7 35)
54 aeSs 06
Ss 60Ss 79Ss 24
Ss 4255.4454.6454.3153.9953.4252.6552.69
5075Sl 83
52 5753 7054 6056 77SB 91
So 00(52 12)(S2 20)(S2 20)(S2 20)
(S2 20)(S2 20)(S2 20)
(S2 20)(S2 20)
(52 20)
(S2 20)(S2 44)
50.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.00
(S22,865 75)50.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.00
(S23 04)
(S28 47)
(S22 74)(Sl 86)
5169 615163 145150 855174 235160 145167 195327 645160 885255 145160 735166 005153 105122 315104 03591 15568 26556 06555 80553 68568 29
561 04549 01564 57
52608Sl 29
52 38
56 4854 1554 1854 3154 38Sl Ss
Sl 7952 09Sl 9557 3554 8952 9453 4053 5953 04
519 8253 9954 27
54 68522 98Ss 82
515 52
57 30
546,570 02546,733 16546,884 01547,058 24
547,218 38547,385 57547,549 39547,710 27
547,965 41548, 126 14548,292 14548,445 24
548,567 55548,671 58
548,762 73548,830 99548,887 05548,942 85548,996 53549,064 82549,125 86549,174 87549,239 44
526,399 77526,401 06526,398 68
526,405 16526,401 01526,396 83526,392 52526,388 14526,385 61526,383 82526,381 73526,379 78
526,372 43526,369 42526,372 36526,446 10526,379 35526,382 39526,362 57526,366 56526,370 83526,375 51526,352 53526,358 35526,342 83526,350 13
546,410 56546,573 70546.724 55546,898 78547,058 92
547,226 11547,553 75547,714 63547.969 7754a,lso soS48,296 5054a,449 eo54a,sw 91S48,675 9454a,767 oe54a,ass ssS48,891 4154a,947 B549,000 89549,069 18549,130 22
549,179 23
549,243 80526,404 13526,405 42
526,403 04526,409 52526,405 37526,401 19526,396 88526,392 50526,389 97526,388 18S26,386 09526,384 14526,376 79526,381 68526,384 62
526,388 02526,391 61526,394 65
526,374 83526,378 82S26,383 09526,387 77526,364 79526.370 61S26,355 09526,362 39
5159 465159 46
5159 465159 465159 46
5159 46
54 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 3654 3654 36
54 36512 26512 26
SSB 08512 26512 26
512 26512 26512 26
512 26512 26
512 26512 26512 26
Page 3 of 5
Page Number 29.
Exhibit JUnit U28 Escrow Account Roconciliation
VGOB 97-0218-0564
CNX Deoosd nn Ww
Co*Inc* CI IN 6 TII2/28/20113/31/20114/30/20115/31/20116/30/20117/31/20118/30/20119/30/2011
10/31/201111/30/201112/31/2011
I/31/20122/28/20124/30/2012
5/31/20126/30/20127/31/20128/31/20129/30/2012
10/31/201211/30/201212/31/2012
I/31/20132/28/20133/31/20134/30/20135/31/20136/30/20137/31/20138/31/20139/30/2013
10/31/201311/30/201312/31/2013
I/31/20142/28/20143/31/20144/30/2014
5/31/20146/30/20147/31/20148/31/20149/30/2014
10/31/201411/30/201412/31/2014
I/31/20152/28/20153/31/2015
asc 4RoyaltyD
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
511,42155
So 00So 00So 00So 00
51.7651.4651.06SI.OI50.9050.9250.7753.8553.91ss.el53.7453.9853.0050.8250.56SO.32
50.3750.4450.4250.4150.4350.4150.4150.3750.4050.4150.4250.4150.4250.4550.4050.4150.4050.4350.4550.3750.4150.4150.4350.4050.4350.4350.4250.4250.4550.8251.6552.0552.59
59 06510 73510 87511 42
511 11511 51Sn 29
511 01512 90512 66513 38514 14513 12516 06516 65516 07515 51513 60512 59512 58511 26
59 96Sa 8157 9755 9455 54
55 7155 5355 74
55 7655 5855 7655 43
55 5155 65
55 1855 8055 62
55 9655 7755 9755 9955 6655 8055 52547153 5852 4652 56
(S2 20)(S2 20)
(52 201
(S2 20)(S2 20)
(52 201
(S2 20)(S2 20)
(53 151
(S3 ls)(S3 ls)(S3 ls)(S3 ls)(S3 ls)(S3 ls)(S3 ls)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(S2 99)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(52 16)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(52 171
(S2 17)(S2 17)
50.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.00
(S2,021 84)
(S9,929 a4)
(S6 97)(S9 20)
(57 261
(S5 20)
So 03 (55 99)(53 891
(Sa 81)(S6 97)
(511551
(59 69)(56 84)
(512 72)(Se s4)(Se ee)(S2 70)(Sa 22)
(Sl 63)(513 38)
(S3 ss)(S4 42)
(53 54)(S4 B)(Sa B)(55 58)(53 56)
(S2 58)
I coon tnketI t CDARSI t Fees Dottnutw s Co ectw s AudtCosts 0 Wloss Roy Ity
no tts
Tot II t.d Fees
Sl 65
So 79
52 47Ss 0353 8556 34
Sl 05Ss 69
52 1153 44
Sy 13elle56 4357 07
511 36510 02510 26
52 3356 47Ss 58
Ss 1653 1753 O2
SO 23
SO 2153 79
53 97Sl 20
54 0054 0553 8254 0153 67
53 78
53 9453 3954 0553 8654 22
54 0054 23
54 25
53 9154 0553 8053 36
53 0652 34
52 98
nwo
nsnw'26,351
78526,352 57
526,355 04526,360 07526,363 92526,370 26526,371 31537,798 55
537,800 66537,804 10537,811 23
537,813 48537,819 91537,835 72
537,847 08535,835 26535,845 52
535,843 19535,849 66535,855 24
535,860 40535,863 57535,866 59535,866 36525,936 31525,940 10525,944 07525,945 27525,949 27
525,953 32525,957 14525,961 15525,964 82525,968 60525,972 54
525,975 93525,979 98525,983 84525,988 06525,992 06525,996 29
526,000 54526,004 45526,008 50
526,012 30526,015 66
526,018 72526,021 06526,024 04
R I sB n Dns
526,364 04526,364 83526.367 30526,372 33526,376 18526.382 52526,383 57537,810 81537.812 92537,816 36537,823 49
537,825 74537,832 17537,839 24
537,850 60535,838 78535,849 04535,846 71535,853 18535,858 76535,863 92S35,867 09535,870 11535,869 88525,939 83525,943 62
525,947 59525,948 79525,952 79525,956 84525,960 66525,964 67525,968 34525,972 12525,976 06525,979 45525,983 50525,987 36525,991 58525,995 58525,999 81526,004 06526,007 97526,012 02
526,015 82526,019 18526.022 24
526,024 58526,027 56
512 26512 26
512 26512 26512 26
512 26512 26512 26
512 26512 26512 26
512 26512 26
53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl53 sl
Pege4of5
Page Number 30.
Exhibit JUnit U28 Egcrow Account Reconcil(ntion
VGOB 97-0218-0564
CNX Deoosu hdbmw
Co*Inc* CI IN b Tti4/30/20155/31/20156/30/20157/31/20158/31/20159/30/2015
10/31/201511/30/201512/31/2015
I/31/20162/28/2016
3/31/20164/30/20165/31/20166/30/20167/31/20168/31/2016
Btc oRoyaltyD
50 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 00
52.7853.2353.1353.3453.5053.5453.9954.1054.2350.7454.3354.5654.3954.5953.9754.0954.15
51 585117SI 1351 osSo 45
51 73So 05
So 05
51 79So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00St 3350725073
(S2 17)(S2 17)(52 171
(S2 17)(S2 17)(52 171
(S2 17)(S2 17)(52 171
(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)(S2 17)
50.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.0050.00
So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00So 00
I coon 9n ketl t CDAR91 t Fees Dat ltutw s Co ectw s Aud t Costs 0 Ilt ssRoy Ity
Bo ttt
50 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 0050 00
Total
Tot II t.d Fees
52 1952 23
52 09St 20
Sl 78
Ss 10Sl 87Sl 9853 8551 4352 1652 3952 22
52 42
54 1352 64
St 72
59,201.67
Bmk
Bsmw'26,026
23526,028 46526,030 55526,032 75526,034 53526,037 63526,039 50526,041 48526,045 33526,043 90526,046 06526,048 45526,050 67526,053 09526,057 22
526,059 86526,062 57
R leBN526,029 75526,031 98
526.034 07526,036 27526,038 05
526.041 15526,043 02S26,045 00526.048 85526,047 42
526,049 58526,051 97526,054 19526,056 61526,060 74526,063 38S26,066 09
Dnl
53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st53 st
Total Deposited $40,260.30
Interest snd Fees $9,20L67
01 Disbursement
02 Disbursement
Error per DGO, refund
03 Disbursement
Total
-$22,865.75
-$2,02L84
tn1,42L55
-$9,929.84
$26,066.99
August 2016 First Bank and Trust balance
$26,062.57
D ffumce $3 52
Page 5 of 5
Page Number 31.
FROM :BUCHANAN COCIRCUIT CLERKS OFFC FAX NO. :2769557886 Jun. 81 2815 85/85PM Pi
m5JRNZ8 PPI 3 16
VIRG IN I A I
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR BUCHANAN COUNTY
KENDRIS HARMAN, HENRY HARMAN
AND
WALTER KEEN,
Plaintiffs,
CNX GAS COMPANY, LLC,
HUGH MACRAE LAND TRUST,
AND TORCH OIL dI GAS COMPANY,
Defendants.
))))))))
)Case No. CL 12-292
)))))))
CONSENT ORDER
Upon the representation of Defendant Torch Oil 4, Gas Company ("Torch" ), by counsel,
that:
a) it has no claim to coalbcd methane on certain tracts of land in Buchanan County
where gas operators and the Virginia, Gas and Oil Board ("VGOB") have listed Torch and the
Plaintiffs, Kendris Herman, Henry Herman and Walter Keen (as heirs to A.3. Herman), as
conflicting claimants to coalbed methane, due to the recent decision of the Supreme Court of
Virginia, Swardr Creek Land Partnership u Selcher, Case No. 131590 (Sep. 12, 2014); and
b) '1'orch has no knowledge of, and makes no representation as to, the plaintiff s chain of
title or claim of ownership of the gas interest other than as admitted or denied in response to
PlaintitFs complatnts,
I 2968/7/6849'I I 4 v I
12968/7/6933619v I
Page Number 32.
FROM 'BUCHANAN COCIRCUIT CLERKS OFFC FAK NO. :2769357886 Jun. 81 2815 83'35PM PZ
And upon evidence presented by Plaintiffs as to /heir ownership of the gas interests on
the properties described in the complaints; and with the consent of Defendant Hugh MacRae
Land Trust; and for good cause shown, it ls therefore ADJUDGED and ORDERED:
a) Torch is not in conflict with the plaintiffs as to ownership of coalbed methane on those
properties on which they had previously been listed as conflicting claimants in pooling orders
issued by VGOB; and
b) that Plaintiffs, claiming as heirs of A,J, Herman, are therefore entitled to any royalties
relating to the extraction of coalbed methane gas on those properties in which VGOB pooling
orders have listed them as conflicting claimants with Torch to coalbed methane ("the Conflict
Properties" ), in proportion Io their ownership inteiests in the gas estate on those real property
tracts; and
c) upon petition to VGOB, any funds held in escrow attributable to theplaintiffs'wnership
interests of coalbed methane in the Conflict Properties, on account of perceived
conflict with Torch, shall be released to the plaintiffs; and
d) any future royalty amounts to which they may be entitled, based on this Order, shall be
paid directly to them by any gas operator responsible for making such payments,
All other claims asserted by any party against the other(s) are demed, and this action is
dismissed with prejudice to the plaintiffs and defendants as to any such other claims and made
part of this Order, with each party to pay his/her/its own costs.
The Clerk is directed to forward a certified copy of the Foregoing to all counsel of record,
to remove this matter from the active docket of this Court and to place thc same among the ended
actions before this Court.
~8988Entered this 2, day of ~/vv8848.% , 201'.
1 8968/7/6840914 v I
12968/7/6933619v1
Page Number 33.
FRON :BUCHANAN COCIRCUIT CLERKS OFFC FAX NO. :2765357886 Jun. 81 2815 83:35PN P3
JU GE,'CIRCUIT COURT OFBUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA
REQU. T Eh
Terredce %e&ookT, Shee Cook, P.C.P.O. Box 507Richlands, Virginia 24641Counsel for Plaintiffs
Scen:
J. )(cott'Scxttdn (VSB No. 29284)Kathleen L, Wright (VSB hlo. 48945)GENTRY LOCKE RAKES dt MOORE, LLP10 Franklin Road, SE, Suite 800P.O. Box 40013Roanoke, VA 24022-0013Phone. (540) 983-9300Fax. (540) 983-9400sextongentrylocke.corn
wright@gentrl/locke,cornCounsel for Defendant 'I'orch Oil dt Gas Company
l)avidM.ShAltize209 FaP.O, BTazew
JamesBlair N
The Cr318 NBlacksCouns L/.C
3
I 2968/7/689(nl de I
IZ96S/7/69736I99I
Page Number 34.
FROM :BUCHANAN COCIRCUJT CLERKS OFFC FAX NO. :2769357886 Jun. 81 2815 83:35PM P4
Hugh MacRae Land Trust, ~William 8, Cocke, Jr.„Esq,Trustee, Hugh MacRae Land TrustP.O. Box 606Newland, NC 28647
l 9969/7/6940914 v I
1996lll'II69316I9vl
Page Number 35.
T. SHEA COOK, P.C.ATTORNEY AT LAW
2411 Second StreetPost Office Box 507
Richlands, Virginia 24641Phone (276)963-4332-Facsimile (276) 963-6271
May 29, 2015
Mark Swartz601 6th Ave //200
Saint Albans, WV 25177
David AltizerPO Box 30Tazewell, VA 24651
Anita D, DutyPooling Supervisor2481 John Nash Blvd.Bluefield, VA 24701
RE: Heirs of A.J. Barman v. Torch Oil and Gas (Henry Harman, Sarah Jane Keen, WalterKeen and Kendris Harman)
Dear Folks:
Please find enclosed a Consent Order signed by Torch waiving their interest in coal bed methanein the wells referenced in the attached bill of complaint; the consent order entered relative to thesame; affidavits of ownership by each of the four individuals, comprising total ownership of thetracts in question; as well as W9 forms for each.
I respectfully request that you initiate the process of petitioning the Virginia Gas & Oil Board fordistribution of coal bed methane escrowed royalties as soon as possible. I look forward to hearing
from you. Ifyou have any questions, dq not hesitate to contact me.
Terre ce Shea Cook
TSC/
cc; Henry Harman (w/o encl.)Sarah Jane Keen (w/o encl.)Walter Keen (w/o encl.)Kendris Herman (w/o encl.)
JUN 3 2015
Page Number 36.
Name of Conflicting Claimant: Henry Harman
Unit: (Tract): 1/~~ M+C6tvt dM (,TQr-T 5Ce~ V2.e C~~ igz
C-6~ V-~16'~ Z$8
AFFIDAVIT PURSUANT TO VA. CODE g 45.1-361.22
1. My name is Henry Harman.
2. I am over the age of eighteen and able to make the statements in this affidavit.
3. I am attaching a W-9 to this affidavit with my correct social security number and current
address.
4. As of the date set forth below, I am a lawful owner of the coalbed methane interests in
the above referenced unit and tracts, and described or referenced in the attached Order or
Agreement and affirm the Order or Agreement and the contents therein.
5. I swear and/or affirm that the information set forth above and in the attached W-9 is true
and accurate.
6. Terrence Shea Cook is my authorized attorney in fact to receive for distribution on my
b hdt llf d h Id'bth VGOB.
Dated this gA day of this month ITS&/
and year 2015
Name:Address: L]ggQ
i >)
Page Number 37.
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA )) to-wit:
CITY/CO~TY OFfXtdlllAO II
0 II Iagd Ifthm'/2dld
PP db f f/@it m lltlc A 2/ fbeing first duly sworn, stated that the foregoing is true and correct to the'best of his knowledge,
information and belief.
My Commission Expires:l~~ 3n-l(Notary Public
llllll/I ll/t/I
,;"~q8 S U E @"O
NOTARY
PUBLIC: REG MFEIT603 '..
OMY COIVIMISSION;EXPIRES
6/30/20 I 6
FRLTII OEI
I I I I I I I Ill
Page Number 38.
Name of Conflicting Claimant: Kendris Harman
gp g g g gZ C i@<) z33Unit: (Tract):
t" 6NI U24 C~I7~~gz9 CW6er 03
Ppn Q Zk (~&)AFFIDAVIT PURSUANT TO VA. CODE tI 45.1-361.22
1. My name is Kendris Harman.
2. I am over the age of eighteen and able to make the statements in this affidavit.
3. I am attaching a W-9 to this affidavit with my correct social security number and current
address.
4. As of the date set forth below, I am a lawful owner of the coalbed methane interests in
the above referenced unit and tracts, and described or referenced in the attached Order or
Agreement and affirm the Order or Agreement and the contents therein.
5. I swear and/or affirm that the information set forth above and in the attached W-9 is true
and accurate.
6. Terrence Shea Cook is my authorized attorney in fact to receive for distribution on my
behalf all funds held in escrow by the VGOB.
D t dthi /5/7v d y fthm that/YLand year 2015
Page Number 39.
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA )) to-wit:
CITY/C~OY OFM(/2% ~ I
On this /eQ day off~2015 appeared before me lmd7NS 4i A~, who
being first duly sworn, stated that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of his knowledge,information and belief.
My Commission Expires: g 3C)46Notary Public
Rill III II
illa'""pterSUE @",,o~'.,
NOTARY07
PUBLIC: REG ¹7517808:!YMY COMMISSION i
EXPIRES6i30/2016
";, E7tLTR 0~ „;"
Page Number 40.
T. SHEA COOK, P.C.ATTORNEY AT LAW
2411 Second StreetPost Office Box 507
Richlands, Vu'ginia 24641phone (2761963-4332-Facsimile (276) 963-6271
tshcacoolc(a>yahoo.corn
January 20, 2016
Cen ified no. 70/3 /090 000/ 2744 /826Anita D. DutyPooling SupervisorPO Box 570Pounding ivlill, VA 24637
Dear Anita:
Please lind enclosed W-9's and Aflidavits of ownership executed by Kathy B. Looney andDickey Looney. I request that you file the petition for disbursement of their royalties from theVGOB escrow agent for their interest in VP2SGU1 (Tracf. 21); U28 (6) and V28 (2B)
Please contact me if you have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this matter.
Most Sincerely,
TelTence Shea Cook
TSC/crb
Cc: Kathy B. LooneyDickey Looney
Page Number 41.
Natne of Conflicting Claimann
2,
APFIDAVIT PURSUANT TO VA. CODDE 6 45.1-361.22
My "a '" 0t C.ke,q LVpn (,gI am over the age of eighteen and able to kn a e to make the statements in this affidavit
3, I am attachin a W-' -9 to this affidavit with my correct social so ec socia security number and current
address.
4. As of the date set fort li below, I am a. lawi'ul owner of the coalb do e coa e methane interests in
the above referenced unit and tracts and d'" ' ' ac e r er ors, an escribed or referenced in the attached Order or
Agreement and affirm the Order or Agree ', d "h t':. 'n.r greement and the contents therein.
5. I swear and/or affirm that the information set f h b'se .ort a oveandintheattached W-9istrue
and accurate,
6 II+ $ 4L s~ Qok„PP, is my authorized attorney in fact. t '' ' ''n»yin ac to rece''ve for distribution on my
behalf all funds held in escrow by the VGOI3,
Dated th'his ~~ day of this months,
and year 201$ tiz/g
Name; 13,'y j„rs>rkyAddress. r9',~0 6e)c
fn.4 I d. ~v zh.>(
Page Number 42.
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA )
) to-wit:
CITY/COUbLTY OF MD~m~~~ )
l(On this /I day of laura.> 20/appeared before me A,'Qe~ Lcicvv.v, who
being frrst duly sworn, statec! (hat tfxe foregoing is true and correct to the best of hts knowledge,
information and belief,
Y8. (.'.I- ( ~
Notary Public
M, C: i i E pYi: ~'/ll// "/
/
Page Number 43.
Name of Conflicting Claimant
U i: iT-ai: j/p2 Qfgll, 1. ('flZO~< 3 i)tta13 Cs3
VzR CarAFFIDAVIT PURSU NT TO VA. CODE 6 45,1-361.22
l. My name is
2. I am over the age of eighteen and able to make the statements in this affidavit.
3. I am attaching a W-9 to this affidavit with my correct social security number and current
address,
4. As of the date set forth below, I am a lawful owner of the coalbed methane interests in
the above referenced unit and tracts, and described or referenced in the attached Order or
Agreement and affirm the Order or Agreement and the contents therein,
5. I swear and/or affirm that the information set forth above and in the attached W-9 is true
and accurate,
6, M 5 g s~ @ok~ pQ, is my authorized attorney in fact to receive for distribution on my
behalf all funds held in escrow by the VGQI3,
Dated this /K day of this months~,
and year 20lfd-
Inc:SIVR ~~
JAN 2 7 2016
Name'Q~4j 8 J,sidneyAddress: p+
4K)W 1'R zk(~I
Page Number 44.
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA )) to-wit;
CITY/COUNTY OF Akd~~~ )
/&On this IIg day of t>~., 20+appeared before me AI/tl,. &cnI', who
I
being first duly sworn, stated tKat the foregoing is true and correct to 4e best ofhis knowledge,
information and belief.
My Commission Expires: /I'3////// /
Notary Public
iiilllllIIw~ ~iQA C//g
qOT~g ',
-g.',>p ~BL\O$ .4'oz ' 4'pprg'5, '+
'III"llliii
Page Number 45.
SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING —COAL OWNER
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF BUCHANAN
Applicant: CNX Gas Company LLCRelief Sought: Disbursement/Dismissal for Unit U28
VGOB: 97-0218-0564-05
I, Anita D. Duty, being first duly sworn on oath, depose and say:
l. I am the Pooling Supervisor for CNX Land LLC, and I am authorized to submit this
Affidavit on behalf of the Applicant CNX Gas Company LLC.
2. I affirm that the coal owuer(s) in this Unit was properly noticed under Va. Code Ann.45.1-361-22:2on October 2. 2015 dk Mav 10.2016. See annexed Certificate of Notice and coal ownernotice form letter example.
3. Hugh MacRae (Torch Oil), Chisos LTD, Gentry Locke, Rockport Oil & Gas,Yukon/Pocahontas/Sayers-Buchanan Coal Company, Consolidation Coal Company (NowBuchanan Mining Company LLC) should be dismissed as Respondent/coal claimant for failure totimely provide evidence of a relevant proceeding or agreement.
Anna D. DutyPooBig Supervisorfor CNX Land LLC
STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF TAZEWELL, TO-WIT:
TAKEN, SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this
r 7~, ))~/,2016./2 day of
Notarygfblic~~M
My commission expires: Au wud 7/ 7//7P
Commomsutttth of Virginia
NtgtuyA Smmcns- Nota/y. istttttCommisskst ID: 72t 8200
Btsau 88O(/~
Page Number 46.
CERTIFICATION OF NOTICE
CNX Gas Company LLC
unit u27 8 u28 part of VP2SGUIVGOB 97-02184)5634)4 Ik 97-0218-0564-03Coal owner dismissal
Last NameChlso . LTD (coal owner)
oentn Locke (coal owner)
Hugh M ac gee Land Trust Icos I owner)
Yukonrocahontas/Buchanan/5 Y *(malowner)
Ro ko rtODlkeasConsolidation Coal Co Icosi o
First Name U27 u28 MAILED RECEIPT ¹1D/2/15 701515200D035333 4521LD/2/15 701515200M35333 45381D/2/15 7015152000035333 450710/2/15 7D1434900M18926 2727
3/10/16 7D0916800M1D891 0567**ha ddelv r d'*
RECEIVED10/5/2015
10/6/201510/5/2015
LDN/2025
5/18/2016
Page Number 47.
%SO Io> z
OD ~ri J I-ill
g)R
ai S„O
I„lg,.
5[II i
mCI
CIIO IOfUoI ol
0
o.
IR
$0 D:.ir-':
I )Y
~IlkIi
4
IU I
~Iru
'rI
co
ol IL
oog Do
k.O
lo OO Px:
I
dJ
/iglD ~
. rsvp,t jl]l s
fgi O
S S'8 S I
I =Parol g
0v 4
pgp'
I.
IO
mCI
D
ru~ri Io I
I
Ol
m,CI'I
CI
IO
O IOl
Irrv5
Page Number 48.
moe a lar RaraEHselsaMNlRRwaaaraj
' Compkrmltemal,2,amds.luaooomplete A
Sam all eraeemr'0000aaay Srerelmu. Oeoent
D. la Fwneenla Oats
KP,or> 5Il* (~ LLC.
'g~x. KH> (::aea<rmg~J,
O Reehoraad'--'eara aaaaaptoaMabeae s'O ewaae aaaS O C.ao.4. ~oaorarytgaareyar0 Oura
,'"'7DOS Zeaa a'DDZ ass> aSVV
PS Form 3811,February 2004 oamaaeo raaumrraouyy:"'
Page Number 49.
CONSOLRNRRGY. CONGASCNX Gas Company LLC
PO Box 570Pounding Mill, VA 24637
Phone: (724) 485-3600
Date
«FNAME» «LNAME»«Attention Line»«Street Address»«City»«State»«Zip»COAL OWNERS
RE: UnitMiscellaneous Petition for Disbursement from Escrow
Dear Property Owner,
House Bill 2058 was signed by the Governor and became law effective July 1,2015. This new law requires the Virginia Gas and Oil Board to disburse monies placedin escrow because of conflicting claims (between coal owners and oil and gas owners)to coalbed methane gas royalties to the oil and gas owners of the tracts in this Unit.
In aeneral. under this new law escrowed funds are to be caid to oil and aasowners unless the coal owner(s) orovides the ooerator CNX and the Division of Gasand Oil "with evidence of a oroceedina" Ias in a court easel "or an aareement." Thenew law aives coal owners/coal claimants 45 davs from the date vou aet this letter toorovide that evidence.
Enclosed herewith please find a copy of the 45 day Notice of Filing. Please readthe Notice carefully to be sure you understand that you have 45 days to provideevidence to the operator CNX Gas Company LLC at the address above and theDivision of Gas and Oil at PO Draw 159, Lebanon, VA 24266
In order to help us keep our records current and to make sure you receive all
correspondence and notices promptly, please notify us of any address change at theaddress above.
Sincerely,
Enclosure(s)Anita DutyPooling Supervisor
Page Number 50.