3. claims

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

1/11

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

2/11

leund ly bis arjud, js sbk `eucd net dkoenstrjtk tbjt it wjs eutsidk tbk s`epk ea bis jmkn`y.

Henstjntines Jmjpites jnd Jnetbkrv. Ijn @bjrcks Jmnkw jnd EtbkrsX

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

3/11

te jveid cijlicity in rkspk`t ea tbksk rishs jnd wkrk net cijlck te Pvknshj Hrkdit aer tbksk rishs.

Pin`k tbk rkinsurkr is ajr rkoevkd areo tbk eriminjc insurkd it dkpknds bkjvicy en tbk insurkr te ojhk dktjickd invkstimjtiens ea tbkeriminjc `cjio te knsurk tbjt it is ckmitiojtk jnd `evkrkd undkr tbk tkros ea tbk eriminjc insurjn`k peci`y. Tbk @eurt ea Jppkjc in tbkrk`knt `jsk eaLretbkrten jnd Etbkrs v. Jskmurjderj @ecskmures PJ jnd Jnetbkr(

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

4/11

Lcj`h Pkj Pbippinm @erperjtienv. Ojssik (Tbk Citsien Vridk)X:92;_ : Cceyds \kp. 40=

Tbk pcjintiaas wkrk ewnkrs ea tbk sbip wbi`b wjs insurkd jmjinst wjr rishs witb tbk dkakndjnt undkrwritkrs. Tbk peci`y èntjinkd j ènditien tbjt ia

tbk sbip sjickd inte bjzjrdeus wjtkrs, jn jdditienjc prkoiuo sbeucd lk pjid te tbk undkrwritkrs. Durinm tbk Irjn/Irjq wjr tbk sbip kntkrkd tbk djnmkr

zenk jnd wjs dkstreykd ly oissick airk. Tbk èurt bkcd tbjt tbk sbipewnkrs jnd tbk lrehkrs j`tkd arjuduckntcy jnd tbjt tbk duty iopeskd upen tbk

insurkd te dis`cesk ìrùostjn`ks wbi`b wicc jaak`t tbk prkoiuo `bjrmkd deks èntinuk jatkr tbk rish bjs lkkn j``kptkd en èvkr.

@entinkntjc Iccineis Ljnh Trust @eopjny ea @bi`jmev. Jccijn`k Jssurjn`k @eopjny Cioitkd (Tbk @jptjin

Vjnjmes)X:921_ < Cceyds \kp. 4=6

In @entinkntjc Iccineis Ljnh Trust @eopjny ea @bi`jmev. Jccijn`k Jssurjn`k @eopjny Cioitkd (Tbk @jptjin Vjnjmes) X:921_ < Cceyds \kp. 4=6

tbk insurkd ojdk j arjuducknt `cjio. Tbk insurkd wbe ewnkd tbk sbip mreundkd tbk sbip jnd skt it jcimbt jnd tbkn seumbt te rkèvkr tbk èst ea j

ènstru`tivk tetjc cess undkr tbk tkros ea tbk insurjn`k peci`y. Tbk èurt bkcd tbjt tbk insurkd bjd lkkn arjuducknt jnd ly virtuk ea sk`tien := ea tbk

Ojrink Insurjn`k J`t :961 tbk insurkrs wkrk jlck te tkroinjtk tbk èntrj`t jl initie.

Erjhpev. Ljr`cjys Insurjn`k Pkrvi`ks jnd JnetbkrX:99;_ C.\.C.\. 440

Tbk pcjintiaa ojdk oisrkprkskntjtiens te @eookrìjc [nien rkmjrdinm tbk ènditien ea bis prepkrty in Cenden. Bk wjs jwjrk tbjt tbkrk bjd lkkn dry

ret prelckos witb tbk prepkrty aer seok tiok jnd bk kxjmmkrjtkd tbk `cjios aer cess ea rknt areo tbk lkdsittinm reeos in tbk prepkrty. Tbk @eookrìjc

[nien insurjn`k peci`y bjd rk`kntcy lkkn rkviskd te ojhk it ènaero te pcjin Knmcisb, jnd js j rksuct tbk sk`tien (rkcjtinm te tbk aj`t tbjt tbk

suloissien ea j arjuducknt `cjio weucd rkoevk jcc lknkaits undkr tbk insurjn`k peci`y) bjd lkkn rkoevkd. Nkvkrtbkckss, tbk @eurt ea Jppkjc bkcd tbjt

tbis ojdk ne diaakrkn`k. Tbk aj`t ea tbk ojttkr wjs tbjt js pjrt ea tbk duty ea utoest meed ajitb tbk insurkd is elcimkd te put aerwjrd benkst `cjios, jnd

ia j arjuducknt `cjio is ojdk tbkn tbis wicc okjn tbjt tbk insurkr `jn lk dis`bjrmkd areo cijlicity.

Insurjn`k @erperjtien ea tbk @bjnnkc Iscjnds jnd \eyjc Insurjn`k @eopjny Cioitkdv. O`Bumb jnd \eyjc Betkc

CioitkdX:99=_ C.\.C.\. 94In Insurjn`k @erperjtien ea tbk @bjnnkc Iscjnds jnd \eyjc Insurjn`k @eopjny Cioitkdv. O`Bumb jnd \eyjc Betkc CioitkdX:99=_ C.\.C.\. 94 tbk

insurkd inacjtkd tbk `cjio ly kxjmmkrjtinm tbk reeo e`ùpjn`y jt tbk betkc. Tbis `jsk wjs unusujc in tbjt tbk èntrj`t èntjinkd spkìjc ènditiens

rkmjrdinm tbk eptiens jvjicjlck te tbk insurkr in tbk kvknt tbjt tbk insurkd prkskntkd j arjuducknt `cjio, jnd tbk `jsk vkry ou`b aeùskd upen tbk

intkrprktjtien ea tbk tkros. Bewkvkr, tbk èurt sticc okntienkd tbk èntinuinm duty ea utoest meed ajitb.

In Dirk`t Cink Insurjn`k pc` v. Hbjn jnd Etbkrs X

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

5/11

suo lk`jok pjyjlck upen rkckmjtien ea tbk `cul wbktbkr er net it èucd sbew tbjt it bjd j`tujccy suaakrkd okjsurjlck ainjnìjc cess.

In tbk rk`knt `jsk ea]iskv. Mrupe Njìenjc Vrevinìjc PJX

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

6/11

Ojbciv. Jllky Ciak Jssurjn`k @eopjny CioitkdX:991_ C.\.C.\.

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

7/11

jcwjys ckjr.

\EJ\ Ojrink Cioitkdv. Liokb Irjn Insurjn`k @eopjny X:992_ : Cceyds \kp. 4

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

8/11

@eooutjtienJ èooutjtien jmrkkoknt is jn undkrstjndinm lktwkkn tbk rkinsurkr jnd tbk rkinsurkd wbkrkly in ènsidkrjtien ea j pjyoknt ly tbkrkinsurkr te tbk rkinsurkd tbk rkinsurkd rkckjsks tbk rkinsurkr areo auturk cijlicitiks undkr tbk rkinsurjn`k èntrj`t.

It is diaaiùct te dktkroink tbk èrrk`t pri`k aer j èooutjtien lut in ènsidkrinm tbk vjcuk tbk rkinsurkr wicc ceeh jt tbk `cjiosbistery ea tbk èntrj`t er èntrj`ts jnd pregk`t inte tbk auturk wbjt `cjios jrk cihkcy te lk ojdk jnd tbk cihkcy èst ea tbesk `cjios,jnd wbjt pjyoknts jrk cihkcy te lk ojdk in tbk auturk in rkspk`t ea kxistinm `cjios. Tbk rkinsurkr wicc nerojccy `jrry eut j

witbeut-prkgudi`k inspk`tien ea tbk rkinsurkds rkèrds prier te j èooutjtien te mivk it j lkttkr undkrstjndinm ea tbk rkinsurkds`cjios stjtisti`s jnd te jssist witb `jcùcjtinm tbk inùrrkd lut net rkpertkd (ILN\) aimurks. Tbk rkinsurkr wicc pregk`t tbk `cjiosaimurks inte tbk auturk jnd tbkn ojhk j dkdu`tien te tjhk j`èunt ea tbk aj`t tbjt tbk rkinsurkd is in rk`kipt ea tbk pjyoknt kjrcikr tbjnbk weucd bjvk lkkn ia tbk `cjios bjd lkkn pjid wbkn tbky wkrk prkskntkd in tbk auturk jnd wicc tbus lk jlck te invkst tbis oenky.\kinsurkrs sbeucd cijisk `ceskcy witb tbkir rktre`kssienjirks wbkn tbky jrk ènsidkrinm èooutinm lusinkss in erdkr te jveid jnydiaaiùctiks wbi`b ojy jrisk wbkn tbk rkinsurkr triks te rkèvkr tbk èooutjtien dkjc pjyoknt areo its ewn rkinsurkrs.

]bkn tbk èooutjtien tkros bjvk lkkn jmrkkd lktwkkn tbk pjrtiks tbky wicc lk ènairokd in j rkckjsk jmrkkoknt. Tbk rkckjskjmrkkoknt wicc `ckjrcy idkntiay tbk èntrj`ts wbi`b bjvk lkkn èooutkd, spkìay tbk pjyoknt dktjics jnd eutcink wbkrk jnd wbkn tbkpjyoknt sbeucd lk ojdk. It wicc èntjin j ènaidkntijcity `cjusk prkvkntinm tbk pjrtiks areo dis`cesinm tbk dktjics ea tbkir jmrkkokntte etbkr pjrtiks, j `cjusk stjtinm wbi`b cjw wicc mevkrn tbk jmrkkoknt jnd tbk gurisdi`tien witbin wbi`b jny disputks rkmjrdinm tbkjmrkkoknt wicc lk dktkroinkd. It is jcse èooen aer tbk jmrkkoknt te èntjin jn jrlitrjtien `cjusk te knsurk tbjt jny disputksrkmjrdinm tbk pjrtiks jmrkkoknt jrk dktkroinkd ly tbk jrlitrjtien pre`kss rjtbkr tbjn ly citimjtien.

J typi`jc èooutjtien jmrkkoknt weucd ceeh cihk tbis7

@EOO[TJTIEN JND \KCKJPK JM\KKOKNT(bkrkinjatkr rkakrrkd te js tbk Jmrkkoknt)

TBIP Jmrkkoknt is kntkrkd inte ly jnd lktwkkn Xinskrt njok ea \kinsurkr_, deoiìckd in (bkrkinjatkr rkakrrkd te js tbk\KINP[\K\) jnd Xinskrt njok ea tbk @eopjny_, deoiìckd in (bkrkinjatkr rkakrrkd te js tbk @EOVJNY), jnd ojdkkaak`tivk Xinskrt kaak`tivk djtk_.

]BK\KJP, tbk \KINP[\K\ jnd tbk @EOVJNY kntkrkd inte j rkinsurjn`k èntrj`t, Nuolkr Xinskrt peci`y nuolkr_, kaak`tivkXinskrt djtk_, jnd kxkùtkd ly tbk \KINP[\K\ en Xinskrt djtk_, jnd ly tbk @EOVJNY en Xinskrt djtk_ (tbk @entrj`t). Tbk tkro@entrj`t sbjcc in`cudk jcc etbkr jrrjnmkoknts, rkprkskntjtiens jnd jmrkkoknts (wbktbkr writtkn er net), wbi`b tbk \KINP[\K\ jndtbk @EOVJNY ojy bjvk ojdk witb rkspk`t te tbk rkinsurjn`k elcimjtiens wbi`b jrk tbk sulgk`t ea tbk @entrj`t8

]BK\KJP, tbk \KINP[\K\ jnd tbk @EOVJNY dksirk auccy jnd ainjccy te skttck jnd èooutk jcc pjst, prksknt jnd auturkelcimjtiens jnd cijlicitiks hnewn jnd unhnewn ea tbk \KINP[\K\ jnd tbk @EOVJNY jrisinm undkr er in jny wjy ènnk`tkd witbtbk @entrj`t8

NE], TBK\KAE\K, aer meed jnd vjcujlck ènsidkrjtien tbk rk`kipt ea wbi`b is bkrkly j`hnewckdmkd, IT IP JM\KKD LY JNDLKT]KKN TBK \KINP[\K\ JND TBK @EOVJNY TBJT7

:. Tbk \KINP[\K\ sbjcc pjy te tbk @EOVJNY tbk suo ea , dktjickd in P`bkduck J, jttj`bkd bkrkte/ witbin djys jatkrtbk simninm tbk Jmrkkoknt ly letb pjrtiks.

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

9/11

prkdk`kssers, su``kssers, jaaicijtks, eaai`krs, dirk`ters, kopceykks, pjrknts, sulsidijriks, ste`hbecdkrs, ciquidjters,rk`kivkrs jnd jssimns ea tbk pjrtiks bkrkte.

;. Tbk pjrtiks bkrkte kxprksscy wjrrjnt jnd rkprksknt tbjt tbky jrk kntitiks in meed stjndinm in tbkir rkspk`tivk pcj`ks eadeoiìck8 tbjt tbk èn`cusien jnd tbk kxkùtien ea tbis Jmrkkoknt is auccy jutberizkd ly kj`b ea tbko8 tbjt tbk pkrsen er

pkrsens èn`cudinm jnd kxkùtinm tbis Jmrkkoknt bjvk tbk nk`kssjry jnd jppreprijtk jutberity te de se8 tbjt tbkrk jrk nepkndinm jmrkkoknts, trjnsj`tiens, er nkmetijtiens te wbi`b jny ea tbko jrk j pjrty tbjt weucd rkndkr tbis Jmrkkoknt erjny pjrt tbkrkea veid, veidjlck, er unknaer`kjlck8 jnd tbjt ne jutberizjtien, ènsknt er jpprevjc ea jny mevkrnoknt kntity

is rkquirkd te ojhk tbis Jmrkkoknt vjcid jnd lindinm upen tbko.1. Tbis Jmrkkoknt èntjins tbk kntirk jmrkkoknt lktwkkn tbk pjrtiks js rkspk`ts its sulgk`t ojttkr. Jcc disùssiens jnd

jmrkkoknts prkvieuscy kntkrtjinkd lktwkkn tbk pjrtiks èn`krninm tbk sulgk`t ojttkr ea tbk èooutjtien jrk okrmkd intetbis Jmrkkoknt. Tbis Jmrkkoknt ojy net lk oediaikd er jokndkd, ner jny ea its previsiens wjivkd, kx`kpt ly jninstruoknt in writinm, simnkd ly tbk pjrtiks bkrkundkr.

=. Tbk pjrtiks bkrkte jnd kj`b ea tbko de bkrkly èvknjnt jnd jmrkk te de su`b tbinms jnd kxkùtk su`b aurtbkr deùoknts,jmrkkoknts jnd jssurjn`ks js ojy lk nk`kssjry er jdvisjlck areo tiok te tiok in erdkr te `jrry eut tbk tkros jndènditiens ea tbis Jmrkkoknt in j`èrdjn`k witb tbkir truk intknt.

2. Tbis Jmrkkoknt sbjcc lk mevkrnkd ly jnd ènstrukd in j`èrdjn`k witb tbk cjws ea jnd tbk pjrtiks bkrkte bkrklyirrkve`jlcy suloit te tbk nenkx`cusivk gurisdi`tien ea tbk @eurts in , jnd te tbk kxtknt pkroittkd ly cjw kxprksscywjivk jcc rimbts te `bjccknmk er etbkrwisk cioit su`b gurisdi`tien.

9. Tbis Jmrkkoknt sbjcc lk rkjd jnd lk ènsidkrkd js jn intkmrjc pjrt ea tbk @entrj`t jnd in tbk `jsk ea jny ènaci`t witbjny pjrt ea sjid @entrj`t tbk previsiens ea tbis Jmrkkoknt sbjcc prkvjic.

:6. Tbis Jmrkkoknt ojy lk kxkùtkd jnd dkcivkrkd in enk er oerk èuntkrpjrts, kj`b ea wbi`b sbjcc temktbkr ènstitutk enkjnd tbk sjok instruoknt.

::. Nkitbkr pjrty sbjcc dis`cesk tbk dktjics ea tbis Jmrkkoknt te jny tbird pjrty etbkr tbjn witb tbk prier ènsknt ea tbk etbkrpjrty kx`kpt wbkrk etbkrwisk rkquirkd ly cjw er jutberity ea j èurt er jrlitrjtien pjnkcs in wbi`b kvknt dis`cesurk sbjcc,inseajr js is prj`ti`jlck, lk ojdk ency jatkr ènsuctjtien witb tbk pjrty tjhinm inte j`èunt tbk rkjsenjlck rkquirkoknts eatbk etbkr pjrty.

IN ]ITNKPP ]BK\KEA, tbis Jmrkkoknt bjs lkkn kxkùtkd tbisUUUUUUUUdjy eaUUUUUUUUly

Aer jnd en Lkbjca ea UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUXinskrt njok ea @eopjny_

Njok7 Titck7 Djtk7

Aer jnd en Lkbjca ea UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUXinskrt njok ea \kinsurkr_

Njok7 Titck7 Djtk7

P`bkduck J

@entrj`t dks riptien @entrj`t nuolkr \kinsurkrs rkakrkn`k @kdjnts rkakrkn`k [ndkrwritinm ykjr

Tbk tkndkn`y is aer tbk industry te tbinh ea èooutjtien js j wjy te dispesk ea dkjd lusinkss lut èooutjtiens `jn jcse lkjttrj`tivk te tbk rkinsurkr te mkt tbko eaa rish en j cink ea lusinkss, wbi`b is ne cenmkr preaitjlck witb jn kxistinm `ciknt se tbjt tbky`jn aeùs en oerk preaitjlck lusinkss cinks meinm aerwjrd.

Tbk èooutjtien preteècEn

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

10/11

DIPV[TK \KPEC[TIENJrlitrjtien jnd disputk rksecutien jrk dkjct witb in mrkjtkr dktjic in @bjptkr :6. Bewkvkr, disputk rksecutien is vkry rkckvjnt te `cjiossin`k eatkn jny diaaiùct issuks jnd tknsiens lktwkkn tbk rkinsurkr jnd `kdjnt wicc jrisk in rkcjtien te nen-dis`cesurks,oisrkprkskntjtiens er tbk nen-pjyoknt ea `cjios.

Tbk pjrtiks wicc nerojccy inèrperjtk jn beneurjlck knmjmkoknt `cjusk er jn jrlitrjtien `cjusk inte tbkir rkinsurjn`k èntrj`t teknsurk tbjt disputks lktwkkn tbk pjrtiks in rkcjtien te tbk èntrj`t wicc lk dktkroinkd ly jrlitrjtien rjtbkr tbjn citimjtien.

Jn beneurjlck knmjmkoknt `cjusk indi`jtks tbk pjrtiks wisb net te akttkr tbk dkìsien-ojhinm pre`kss ea tbk jrlitrjters witb tbkjppci`jtien ea stri`t ckmjc prinìpcks ia tbky ènsidkr tbjt tbk disputk sbeucd lk rksecvkd en jn kquitjlck ljsis.

J stjndjrdBeneurjlck Knmjmkoknt @cjusk weucd rkjd cihk tbis7

sbjcc intkrprkt tbis trkjty js jn beneurjlck knmjmkoknt, jnd sbjcc dktkroink jny rkakrkn`k in j`èrdjn`k witb ùrrknt rkinsurjn`k ojrhkt prj`ti`k

pkrtjininm durinm tbk ùrrkn`y ea tbis Jmrkkoknt, witb j vikw te kaak`tinm tbk mknkrjc purpesk ea tbis rkinsurjn`k in j rkjsenjlck ojnnkr rjtbkr tbjn in

j`èrdjn`k witb tbk stri`t rucks ea cjw jnd citkrjc intkrprktjtien ea tbk cjnmujmk.

Tbk pjrtiks eatkn prkakr te bjvk tbkir disputk dkìdkd ly jrlitrjtien lk`jusk it is pkr`kivkd te lk qui`hkr, `bkjpkr jnd ckss pulci`tbjn èurt pre`kkdinms. Tbky jcse jrk hkkn te bjvk tbkir disputk rksecvkd ly seokenk wbe is ajoicijr witb insurjn`k jnd rkinsurjn`kojrhkt prj`ti`k jnd wbe wicc lk ajoicijr witb tbkir prelckos. Jrlitrjtien is skkn te lk oerk inaerojc tbjn èurt pre`kkdinms,`krtjincy jrlitrjters jrk ckss rkstri`tkd ly tbk de`trinks ea prk`kdknt jnd tbk cjw lut tbk styck ea tbk jrlitrjtien is vkry ou`b dkpkndkntupen tbk vikw ea tbk jrlitrjters jppeintkd ly tbk pjrtiks jnd in seok situjtiens tbk jrlitrjtien `jn oirrer èurt pre`kkdinms in rkcjtiente kvidkn`k, dis`cesurk jnd kx`bjnmk ea deùoknts. In rkcjtien te spkkd, jrlitrjtiens `jn lk qui`hkr lut tbk spkkd dkpknds upen tbk

jttitudks ea tbk pjrtiks jnd tbk issuks in disputk. In ojny rkspk`ts, jrlitrjtien ojy net lk j `bkjpkr jctkrnjtivk te citimjtien lk`jusktbk èst ea kxpkrt jrlitrjters `jn lk sulstjntijc jnd tbk pjrtiks wicc jcse lk rkquirkd te pjy tbk èst ea tbk vknuk wbkrk tbk jrlitrjtienis bkcd.

Tbk J\IJP (Tbk \kinsurjn`k jnd Insurjn`k Jrlitrjtien Peìkty ea tbk Intkrnjtienjc Jsseìjtien Aer Insurjn`k Cjw (JIDJ))jrlitrjtien `cjusk jnd rucks jrk arkqukntcy uskd in rkinsurjn`k èntrj`ts jnd tbk rucks `jn lk jddkd te j èntrj`t ly siopcy in`cudinmtbk werds J\IJP Jrlitrjtien @cjusk. Tbk rucks cjy dewn muidkcinks rkmjrdinm tbk jppeintoknt ea jrlitrjters, tbk èopesitien eatbk Trilunjc, tbk èoouni`jtien ea tbk dkìsien, tbk pesitien in rkcjtien te akks jnd se en. Tbk mknkrjc ruck is tbjt tbkrk wicc lk tbrkkjrlitrjters, enk jppeintkd ly kj`b ea tbk pjrtiks jnd tbk tbird te lk jppeintkd ly tbk twe jrlitrjters. ]itb rkmjrd te tbk qujciai`jtienea tbk jrlitrjters, j`èrdinm te J\IJP tbky sbeucd lk pkepck witb jt ckjst :6 ykjrs kxpkrikn`k in tbk insurjn`k er rkinsurjn`kindustriks er bjvk :6 ykjrs kxpkrikn`k js j cjwykr er etbkr preakssienjc jdviskr ea skrvinm tbk industry. (Tbk J\IJP \ucks jrkdkjct witb oerk spkìai`jccy in @bjptkr :6.)

Tbk `jsk eaErien @eopjmnij Kspjnecj dk Pkmuresv. Lkcaert Ojjts`bjppig veer Jcmkoknk QkrzkhmrinmkknX:91

8/10/2019 3. CLAIMS

11/11

3. claims

Documents