33 rd annual ashe conference november 8, 2008 jacksonville, florida don thompson cindy miller-perrin...
TRANSCRIPT
33rd Annual ASHE ConferenceNovember 8, 2008
Jacksonville, Florida
Don ThompsonCindy Miller-Perrin
Pepperdine University
Literature ReviewUndergraduates are far more spiritual than was once
recognized and desire guidance in their search for spiritual truth and meaning from their colleges and universities (Astin & Astin, 1999).
One particularly important aspect of faith and spiritual development in the context of higher education is its connection to the process of developing a sense of meaning and purpose in life, a process commonly referred to as vocational development.
Questions about life meaning and purpose often surface during the college years as students consider issues associated with personal identity, faith beliefs, and career options.
An academic mentoring community helps students develop vocational calling (Parks, 2000; Fowler, 2000).
Literature ReviewProfessors want to speak about matters of spirituality, but
lack institutional support and encouragement (Astin & Astin, 1999).
Faculty with spiritual character are more likely to help students develop social connectedness, responsiveness and accountability (Bennett, 2003).
Despite the potentially important role of faculty in student vocational development, most research on spirituality in higher education has focused on students rather than faculty.
Very little research has examined either how faculty view their roles as vocational mentors or how faculty conceptualize and experience vocation in their own lives.
Extending Our Own WorkThe current presentation describes our
findings on gender differences in discerning and acting on life-purpose in the academy, extending the results of our most recent publication:Thompson, D. & Miller-Perrin, C. (2008).
Vocational discernment and action: An exploratory study of male and female university professors. Review of Religious Research, 50(1), 97-119.
Definition of Vocation
One’s “sacred lifework”, including any human activity that gives meaning, purpose, and direction to life.
One’s calling – which transcends job/career, including friendship, parenting, marriage, church membership, and community involvement.
Research HypothesesThere are potential gender differences with regard
to the nature and development of vocational calling.
Traditional views of vocation define the concept narrowly which can be limiting, particularly to females.
Gender differences will be evident in faculty members’ discernment of life purposeperceptions of vocational barriers.
Sample CharacteristicsSurvey144 faculty - 75
respondentsAge range: 23-64; mean:
47.728% Female, 72% MalePredominantly
Caucasian, Married, Protestant
Essay120 faculty – 83
respondents Age range: 29-69; mean:
40.443% Female, 57% MalePredominantly
Caucasian, Married, Protestant
Faculty Survey
75-item survey that assessed faculty members’ Definitions of vocationPersonal experiences of vocationBarriers to vocational discernment and action.
Respondents indicated the degree to which they agreed with each statement using a 5-point Likert scale.
Survey Results: Men and Women Perceive Vocational Barriers Differently
Demographic Factors Age, Gender, Ethnicity, Education, Income
Personal Attitudes and Negative Emotions Fear, Self-doubt, Personal Control, Apathy,
SecurityInterpersonal Relationships
Family, Boy/Girlfriend, Friend, Spouse, Mentor, Teacher, Colleague, Boss
Sociocultural Pressures Finances, Discrimination, Family Duties, Church
Tradition
Barrier Differences
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Female Male
*
**
Faculty EssayFaculty completed an autobiographical assignment as part of a seminar
designed to integrate faith, learning, and vocation. Focus on some or all of the following issues:
The major “turning points” along one’s vocational journeyParticular moments of crisis or confusion as well as moments of joy and
clarity along the journeyParticular individuals who have contributed either positively or
negatively to vocational developmentExperiences that have either affirmed one’s sense of calling or that have
shaken the sense of callingDistractions, tensions, or barriers along the way that have hindered the
pursuit of vocational calling
Essay Results
70%
57%
30%
78%
39%
61%
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
Turning Point Mentor Barriers
% Present in Essays
Males
Females
Turning PointsWomen most frequently mentioned turning point
experiences that occurred in the form of a personal loss:
When I was fifteen, my parents separated. This meant the end of economic stability for my family, as my father took all of our savings with him, but a new sense of peace came over us all. I began to work full-time while in high school in order to help support my family at home and my sister away at college. While it may seem strange to some, I saw this period as a gift. I learned at a very early age that I could support myself. This opened up a whole world to me, as I realized that I could take risks in life. Suddenly, the world beyond my hometown seemed to open its doors to me.
MentoringMen are more likely to report a mentoring experience and
mentors typically include family members and professors:
In college, I came to know an incredible professor, who was the theatre department. As I worked with him in classes, on stage, and as a work-study student, I came to understand more clearly the meaning of vocation. He exuded passion for his field, and he gave of himself unselfishly. When he wasn’t directing a play, he was pulling costumes for someone else’s production, running the box office, or designing sets. And when he wasn’t doing any of those things, he was telling me how his life in academic theatre had given him the opportunity to take his family all over the world, the skills to work on dramatic productions at his church, and the drive to produce and direct children’s theatre productions at Christmas and during the summers. In short, he provided me a vocational model.
BarriersBarrier Type Men Women
Demographic 32% 56%
SES Sex
Personal 66% 69%
Fear Need for Security
Interpersonal 21% 44%
Parents Professors
Sociocultural 38% 69%
Lack of Financial Resources
Religious Tradition
Demographic Barrier Today, I can turn to my neighbors in Hollywood and say that I understand being without. I can say that I’ve been on the streets, that I’ve had to go without food, that I have lived in a garage like many of them are doing today, that I too grew up without a father, that I’ve tasted poverty, that I have dreamt dreams that were deferred like a raisin in the sun. And even though I have never told my story to any of my neighbors, they feel and acknowledge my solidarity with them. Upon reflection, I have come to understand that God rescued us from our poverty so that we can go back into it to help lighten the load of those still in it. This is my life-purpose, both metaphorically and literally.
Interpersonal BarrierMy father was the most logical candidate to mentor me, but he was simply unavailable. Even when we were together, my interests and inclinations puzzled, irritated, or confused him. I did not doubt his love, but I did doubt his ability to know me or understand me. The distance from my father greatly confused me, so I invented a theory to explain my anomalous life: I had been adopted, I decided. Anyone today who looks at a picture of my father and me would laugh at my hypothesis. But to the child’s mind—being a changeling or an adoptee made perfect sense: I was left-handed, and everyone else in my family was right-handed. I had blue eyes and everyone else had brown. Everyone else cared about the football scene of “Friday night lights,” and I didn’t. It was as simple and obvious as that: I was an orphan.
Sociocultural BarrierI have found my vocation in the resonance between my own struggles to reconcile the complexities of spirituality and life and the struggles of those I study. As a woman, about whom my church background has definite theological baggage, I also find a cultural explanation and, perhaps ironically, an escape from the ingrained gender traditions wrought so subtly as to become almost imperceptible to those who labor under their influences. To be expected to occupy a space that is uninhabitable dooms women to failure—thus the Victorian obsession with the fallen woman who becomes the scapegoat for all ills opposes the redeeming ideal who represents a panacea for the world. Neither one is real, but they make a congenial vision of good and evil. Victorian literary studies have allowed me to identify the gender issues, to see them in an historical light and to understand and name the varieties of oppression that haunt the daily lives of women even still. To work intimately with Victorian literature is to confront the history of my religious heritage. It has aided in my working out where my religious tradition has been and why it has evolved in the way it has. It has provided—often in language so beautiful it will make you weep—a framework of Christian faith that has survived both the human tragedy and the human comedy, that can stand up to critical examination and re-evaluation.
ConclusionsWomen reported experiencing a significantly
greater number of barriers than men in their understanding and pursuit of life purpose, especially as related to their sex, interpersonal relationships, and sociocultural pressures.
The traditional doctrine of vocation can sometimes be limiting to certain groups; institutions should acknowledge the possibility of multiple callings including career, parenthood, marriage, etc.
The doctrine of vocation should not only transcend job and career, but also gender, race, and class boundaries, and affirm equality among all men and women and their mutuality.
ConclusionsMale faculty tend to rely on mentoring
experiences for discernment of their vocation more than women.
Although women perceive more barriers than men, both sexes experience barriers to their vocational calling and the subthemes differ for men and women.
The academy should provide opportunities for faculty to reflect on their calling and life purpose and potential barriers, to help them mentor students who are searching for their callings.
