3/6/2006fy07/08 doe budget briefing1 fy07/08 budget briefing jonathan dorfan director persis drell...
TRANSCRIPT
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 1
FY07/08 Budget Briefing
Jonathan DorfanDirector
Persis DrellDeputy Director
SLAC
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 2
Outline
Status of FY06 Opportunities for FY07 FY07 Budget Discussion Scenarios for FY07 FY08 Budget Discussion Scenarios for FY08
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 3
Status of FY06 FY06
Funding--HEP $145.8M Funding—BES 29.4M TOTAL $175.2M
Impact/Opportunities of FY06 budget Full funding to B-factory operations
B-factory AIP reduced $0.5M Strong ILC Program funded at $12.3M Some investment in future opportunities
EXO 200 Accelerator R&D LSST R&D
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 4
Status of FY06 (cont.) Program Elements
B-factory Technical problem currently limiting luminosity
Subject of weekly discussions with program office Impact at ~5% level on long-term luminosity goals
40 running weeks Integrated luminosity projected for FY06: 91/fb
IFR upgrade starts summer 06 Machine upgrades summer 06
GLAST DOE project complete Build-up of ISOC
Instrument operations support capped at $5M/yr Getting ready for science
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 5
Status of FY06 (cont.) ILC R&D
SLAC R&D focus—GDE supported e+e- sources Beam Delivery system Rf power sources Availability and operation Instrumentation
Operations support for L-band klystron development Leadership positions in many subsystems Small increase in detector R&D
Continued test beam experiments E166 e+ polarization run completed
ATLAS: SLAC has applied to join ATLAS and will submit proposal to become a Tier 2 site for ATLAS
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 6
Status of FY06 (cont.) Advanced Accelerator R&D
Plasma wake field acceleration E164/E164X/E167 Optimize program for final FFTB runs Spectacular results, very successful
Laser acceleration experiment progressing in ESB Some slow down due to funding shortfall
SABER white paper developed Workshop March 15/16 Working on operating costs and schedule Possibility of SABER commissioning in FY08
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 7
Status of FY06 (cont.) New Initiatives
EXO EXO200 under construction
All resources focused on getting to WIPP 12/06 Barium tagging R&D on hold
LSST Redirected some of resources from GLAST roll off Build up of collaboration Resources focused on upcoming competition/ P5
process Director’s review of cost and schedule this week
SNAP Growing into major role in electronics Natural evolution of expertise developed on GLAST Small investment from base, growth to come through
LBNL
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 8
FY07 Budget Discussion Changes from FY06 to FY07 (Summary)
FY06 Funding: $175.2M Program Changes 06->07 11.1M (see slide 9)
FY07 Funding Needed: $186.3M
FY07 President’s Budget $186.3M
2007 is a year of opportunity! With careful management and close coordination
with the national priority setting process, SLAC can help grow programs central to the future of the field.
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 9
Program Changes FY06 to FY07Program Changes in FY07 from FY06 M$
Staff Retention 5.0
Power (40 weeks) 4.2
AIP @ $4M, klystron production and detector upgrade complete
(3.2)
ILC 2.5
Infrastructure 2.0
Additional offset from LCLS and other programs (3.0)
Unallocated resources for other new opportunities 3.6
Total Program Changes 11.1
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 10
Additional Resources Available in FY07 We will continue to manage the staff size
down through attrition and targeted programmatic layoffs In all scenarios anticipate an addition ~$1M will
be liberated in this fashion We will continue to manage the transfer of
staff from GLAST and B-factory programs to LCLS, ILC and new initiatives Klystron department manpower Electronics engineering Mechanical engineering
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 11
Additional FY07 Priority Program Opportunities
LSST We will compete for additional funds to
develop ground based dark energy telescope
ILC We will compete for additional funds to
develop the RF sources for the ILC LCD
We will compete for additional funds to grow the Linear Collider Detector effort
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 12
FY07 Scenario A $195.3M B-Factory
40 weeks $4M AIP Int L (Run 6)= 180/fb
ILC $21M ILC program focused on GDE priorities
Assumes successfully compete for additional $6M Increase LCD by $1M after successful competition for additional resources
GLAST Instrument operations preparation, support for I&T, preparation for science
EXO 200 operating Invest in Barium tagging R&D for big EXO
Accelerator R&D Start construction of SABER Support HG program from base resources
LSST Increase by $2.1M assuming successful competition for dark energy
resources and encouragement from P5 ATLAS
Development of Tier 2 assuming successful proposal
FY07 President’s Budget + 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 13
FY07 Scenario A $ 195.3M Opportunities
B-factory program focused on maximum luminosity before end of FY08
ILC—focused on RF source development taking advantage of unique SLAC resources (klystron dept)
EXO—R&D for ultimate double beta decay expt. Go forward with LSST Go forward with SABER
Healthy running program and growth of new opportunities for field Well aligned with HEP roadmap from P5
FY07 President’s Budget + 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 14
FY07 Scenario B $186M B-Factory
40 weeks $4M AIP Int L (Run 6)= 180/fb
ILC $14.8M program focused on GDE priorities
Assumes unsuccessfully compete for additional resources May lose opportunity to contribute to ILC power source
GLAST Instrument operations preparation, support for I&T, preparation for science
EXO 200 operating Invest in Barium tagging R&D for big EXO
Accelerator R&D Start construction of SABER Support HG program from base resources
LSST Assume unsuccessful competition for dark energy resources Investment from base program depends on P5 recommendation Would be balanced with investment in EXO R&D
ATLAS Development of Tier 2 assuming successful proposal
FY07 President’s Budget
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 15
FY07 Scenario B $186M Opportunities
B-factory program focused on maximum luminosity before end of FY08
ILC—target modulator development. Cannot engage in klystron development
No increase in LCD R&D above small FY06 base level, risking US leadership on detector development
Will be guided by P5 recommendations in determining investments in EXO—R&D vs LSST
Go forward with SABER Healthy running program and limited growth of new
opportunities for field Will bring headcount down by additional ~15 to allow
for new opportunities
FY07 President’s Budget
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 16
FY07 Scenario C $176.7M B-Factory
40 weeks $4M AIP Int L (Run 6)= 153/fb
ILC $12.8M program flat from FY06
Lose opportunities to contribute to power source, Cannot grow modulator program Minimal investment in LCD
GLAST Instrument operations preparation, support for I&T, preparation for science. Lay off all
staff coming off instrument integration support EXO 200 operating
R&D unfunded Accelerator R&D
SABER unfunded HG program unfunded
LSST Flat or down depending on P5
Staff measures RIF approximately 60 people, impact B-factory performance
FY07 President’s Budget – 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 17
FY07 Scenario C $176.7M IMPACTS(Relative to Scenario B)
B-factory integrated luminosity hurt by loss of people due to layoffs
Compromise SLAC role in ILC Reduction in staff cripples ability to
foster new program initiatives for the field. No new initiatives supported What HEP physics will we be doing in 2012?
FY07 President’s Budget – 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 18
FY08 Budget Discussion
Scenarios for FY08 depend on budget in FY07
Talent lost in FY07 cannot be recaptured in FY08
Will assume Scenario A(+5%) in FY07 for Scenario D(+10%) in FY08
Will assume Scenario B(PB) in FY07 for Scenario E(PB)&F(-5%) in FY08
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 19
Changes FY07 to FY08
Changes from FY07 from FY08 M$Staff Retention 5.0
Power (+4 weeks operations) 3.3
Total Changes 8.3
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 20
FY08 Scenario D $204.6M B-Factory
44 weeks $3.5M AIP Int L (Run 7)= 366/fb
ILC $24M ILC program focused on GDE priorities (Increase $2M over FY07) LCD held flat at FY07 level
GLAST On orbit operations and beginning of science
EXO 200 operating Continued investment in Barium tagging R&D
Accelerator R&D Complete SABER Phase I (no bypass) Support HG program from base resources
LSST Flat assuming encouragement from P5
SNAP Flat or increase with LBNL support
ATLAS Continued development of Tier 2
Scenario A + 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 21
FY08 Scenario D $204.6M Opportunities
Final year of B-factory program focused on maximum luminosity before end of run
ILC—continued growth in focused areas EXO—R&D for ultimate double beta decay expt. Continued LSST pre-engineering Completion of SABER Phase I (no bypass) and
possible operations of plasma program Healthy running program and growth of
new opportunities for field Well aligned with HEP roadmap from P5
Scenario A + 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 22
FY08 Scenario E $186M B-Factory
44 weeks $3.5M AIP Int L (Run 7)=366/fb
ILC $14.8M program flat from FY07. No LCD growth (continued flat from FY06)
GLAST On orbit operations and beginning of science
EXO 200 operating Accelerator R&D
Unable to complete SABER Phase I (no bypass) No support for HG program
LSST & Big EXO R&D FY06 levels or down depending on P5 recommendations
Staff Measures Approximately 35 layoffs
FY08 = FY07 President’s Budget
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 23
FY08 Scenario E $186M Opportunities (Relative to scenario B)
Final year of B-factory program focused on maximum luminosity before end of run
ILC—no growth, SLAC not in leadership role Operations for EXO 200 Very limited resources for LSST camera
construction and/or Big EXO R&D Completion of SABER Phase I (no bypass) not
possible Limited possibilities to future program
development or ILC contributions Would narrow program (SABER, EXO, LSST,
SNAP, ILC) to focus and make one or two successful
FY08 = FY07 President’s Budget
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 24
FY08 Scenario F $176.7M B-Factory
44 weeks $3.5M AIP Int L (Run 7)=311/fb
ILC $8.8M program (reduction of $6M vs FY07) No LCD growth (continued flat from FY06)
GLAST On orbit operations and beginning of science
EXO 200 operating Accelerator R&D
Unable to complete SABER Phase I (no bypass) No support for HG program
LSST & Big EXO R&D, Research Programs Would need to eliminate several efforts to recover $3.5M in resources
Staff Measures Approximately 120 layoffs – or limit B-factory running in FY08
Impact on B-factory performance Impact on research productivity of lab
FY08 = FY07 President’s Budget – 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 25
FY08 Scenario F $176.7M IMPACTS (relative to scenario B)
B-factory program reduced Diminished efficiency due to layoffs of technical staff
ILC SLAC minor role in ILC development, jeopardizing
international ILC program GLAST
Cut in operations threatens science productivity of the mission
EXO and new initiatives not supported No support to Advanced Accelerator Program
No FFTB replacement Approximately 120 additional staff layoffs needed;
Impacts efficiency of B-factory operations
FY08 = FY07 President’s Budget – 5%
3/6/2006 FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing 26
Conclusions SLAC program offers tremendous physics
opportunities to national HEP community Program is tight and aggressively managed
FY07 budget and future Office of Science growth offers significant opportunities for SLAC to serve the national program Investments will be aligned with national
roadmap for the field