69 1 8 7 view your saved researchkay/ni.hpsg.2020.pdf · null instantiation in sign-based...

16
Conference Paper Full-text available Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference on Head Driven Phrase Struct Grammar · At: Berlin, Buxtehude, wherever Project: Construction Grammar Lab: Laura Adrienne Michaelis's Lab Rui Chaves · Paul Kay · Laura Adrienne Michaelis Research Interest Citations 0 Recommendations 0 new 0 Reads · 19 new 19 See details Abstract In null instantiation (NI) an optionally unexpressed argument receives either anaphoric or existential interpretation (Fillmore, 1986; Mauner & Koenig, 2000; Kay, 2002; Ruppenhofer & Michaelis, 2010, 2014). Examples include Lexically licensed NI (Nixon resigned ), Contextual acessibility NI (Can I see ?), Labelese () contains alcohol), Diary NI (got up, got out of bed, dragged a comb across my head), Generic-habitual NI (The police only arrest (people) when there's probable cause). We think of a predicator as having NI potential when one or more of its frame elements may remain unexpressed under certain conditions. One cannot accurately predicate a predicator's NI potential based either on semantic factors (e.g., Aktionsart class of the verb, as in Hovav & Levin (1998)) or pragmatic factors (e.g., relative discourse prominence of arguments, as in Goldberg (2006)), but NI potential, while highly constrained, is not simply lexical idiosyncrasy. It is instead the product of both lexical and constructional licensing. In the latter case, a construction can endow a verb with NI potential that it would not otherwise have. Using representational tools of Sign Based Construction Grammar (Sag 2012, a.o), we offer a lexical treatment of null instantiation that covers both distinct patterns of construal of null instantiated Home 7 More 69 1 8 View your saved research You can access your Saved List at any time in your procle's new Saved List tab. OK (7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat... 1 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Upload: others

Post on 16-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Conference Paper Full-text available

Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar

December 2020Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference on Head Driven Phrase StructureGrammar · At: Berlin, Buxtehude, wherever

Project: Construction Grammar

Lab: Laura Adrienne Michaelis's Lab

Rui Chaves · Paul Kay · Laura Adrienne Michaelis

Research Interest 0.8Citations 0Recommendations 0 new 0Reads · 19 new 19See details

Abstract

In null instantiation (NI) an optionally unexpressed argument receives either anaphoric orexistential interpretation (Fillmore, 1986; Mauner & Koenig, 2000; Kay, 2002; Ruppenhofer &Michaelis, 2010, 2014). Examples include Lexically licensed NI (Nixon resigned ∅), Contextualacessibility NI (Can I see ∅?), Labelese (∅) contains alcohol), Diary NI (∅ got up, ∅ got out of bed,∅ dragged a comb across my head), Generic-habitual NI (The police only arrest (people) whenthere's probable cause). We think of a predicator as having NI potential when one or more of itsframe elements may remain unexpressed under certain conditions. One cannot accuratelypredicate a predicator's NI potential based either on semantic factors (e.g., Aktionsart class ofthe verb, as in Hovav & Levin (1998)) or pragmatic factors (e.g., relative discourse prominence ofarguments, as in Goldberg (2006)), but NI potential, while highly constrained, is not simply lexicalidiosyncrasy. It is instead the product of both lexical and constructional licensing. In the lattercase, a construction can endow a verb with NI potential that it would not otherwise have. Usingrepresentational tools of Sign Based Construction Grammar (Sag 2012, a.o), we offer a lexicaltreatment of null instantiation that covers both distinct patterns of construal of null instantiated

Home 7 More 69 1 8

ViewyoursavedresearchYou canaccessyourSavedList atany timein yourprocle'snewSavedList tab.OK

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

1 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 2: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

 Chaves, Kay &...G 2020.pdfContent uploaded by Laura

Adrienne MichaelisAuthor content

Content may be subject to copyright.

arguments and the difference between listeme-based and contextually licensed, thusconstruction-based, null complementation.

Public Full-text 1 Private Full-text 1

Page 1

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

2 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 3: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

3 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 4: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Page 2

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

4 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 5: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

5 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 6: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Page 3

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

6 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 7: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

7 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 8: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Page 4

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

8 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 9: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

9 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 10: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Page 5

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

10 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 11: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Similar research

An Informal Sketch of a Formal Architecture for Construction Grammar

Literature Review Full-text available

August 1998 · Grammars

Paul Kay

173 Reads · 90 CitationsConstructional Meaning and Compositionality

A formal architecture for Construction Grammar (CG) is sketched. Modeling domain objects(constructs) are constituent structures with feature structures at the nodes, aka FeatureStructure Trees (FTs). Constructions are partial descriptions of FTs, expressed as sets of... …

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

11 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 12: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Chapter

April 2012Paul Kay · Laura Adrienne Michaelis

438 Reads · 35 CitationsToward a Construction-Based Theory of Language Function: The Case of Nominal Extraposition

Article Full-text available

June 1996 · Language

Laura Adrienne Michaelis · Knud Lambrecht

324 Reads · 200 Citations

The ambiguity of the English present perfect

Article Full-text available

March 1994 · Journal of Linguistics

Laura Adrienne Michaelis

175 Reads · 64 Citations

A constructional account of genre-based argument omissions

Article Full-text available

December 2010 · Constructions and Frames

Josef Ruppenhofer · Laura Adrienne Michaelis

148 Reads · 38 Citations

Page 6

One of the major motivations for constructional approaches to grammar is that a given rule ofsyntactic formation can sometimes, in fact often, be associated with more than one semantic

Through a detailed examination of a particular sentence type, we outline a formal model inwhich grammatical description includes the description of use conditions on form-meaningpairs. The sentence type at issue is an exclamative construction we refer to as Nominal... …

Download Recommend Follow Share

This study examines grammatical and discourse-pragmatic rehexes of the existential andresultative readings of the English present perfect. I present both negative and positivearguments in favor of the claim that the present perfect is ambiguous (rather than vague) wit... …

Download Recommend Follow Share

Authors like Fillmore 1986 and Goldberg 2006 have made a strong case for regarding argumentomission in English as a lexical and construction-based affordance rather than one based ongeneral semantico-pragmatic constraints. They do not, however, address the question of how... …

Download Recommend Follow Share

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

12 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 13: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

About us · News · Careers · Help Center · Advertising · Recruiting  |  Terms · Privacy · Copyright · Imprint  |  © 2008-2020 ResearchGate GmbH. All rigreserved.

View more related researchOverview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

13 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 14: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

14 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 15: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

15 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM

Page 16: 69 1 8 7 View your saved researchkay/NI.HPSG.2020.pdf · Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar December 2020 Conference: HPSG 20: Twenty-seventh International Conference

Overview Stats Comments Citations References Related research (10+)

(7) (PDF) Null Instantiation in Sign-based Construction Grammar https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347291008_Null_Instantiat...

16 of 16 12/18/20, 8:39 AM