7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: laurentide ice sheet history and dynamics

57
ld seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure aurentide Ice Sheet history and dynami The Clyde River project, on northeastern Baffin Island

Upload: yvon

Post on 07-Feb-2016

27 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

The Clyde River project, on northeastern Baffin Island. 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics. 4 Questions to consider:. Why can’t blockfields be used as evidence for LGM refugia? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages:Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

The Clyde River project, on northeastern Baffin Island

Page 2: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

4 Questions to consider:

1. Why can’t blockfields be used as evidence for LGM refugia?

2. Recall that we’re presently in the “Goldilocks Paradigm.” Howis the Goldilocks model incorrect?

3. What are weathering zones really telling us?

4. What is potentially wrong with a story that is based on only a fewcosmogenic exposure ages?

Page 3: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

10 km NClyde Foreland

Page 4: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Differentially-weathered fiord landscapes

Page 5: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 6: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 7: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Extent of “fresh” zone indicates extent of LGM ice

Page 8: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Weathered uplands are covered, but not eroded, during the LGM

Page 9: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 10: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 11: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 12: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Tor: ≥67.5±7.2 ka

Boulder: 17.5±1.9 ka

Page 13: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Tor:≥64.1±2.2 (Be)≥61.4 ± 2.7 (Al)

Boulder:10.2±1.1

Cobble:11.6±0.9 (Be)14.8±1.7 (Al)

Page 14: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Page 15: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Updated from Briner et al., 2003,QSR

Page 16: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Locations of “LGM” erratics

380-430 m

410-610 m520-580 m620-690 m

? ??

?

Page 17: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Cold-based

Cold-based

warm-based

Shearzone Shear

zone

Ice Stream

Page 18: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 19: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 20: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Cold-based

Cold-based

warm-based

Shearzone Shear

zone

Ice Stream

Page 21: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

South

North

10 km N

Page 22: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

South North

Page 23: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

glacially scoured

N S

Page 24: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 25: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

no evidence of glacial erosion

glacially scoured

N S

Page 26: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 27: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

no evidence of glacial erosion

some evidence of glacial modification

glacially scoured

N S

Page 28: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 29: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

28.3+0.7 ka 32.5+1.1 ka

10.2+0.5 ka34.2+0.9 ka

9.5+0.7 ka23.3+0.7 ka

9.5+0.3 ka23.7+1.0 ka

11.4+0.5 ka11.6+0.3 ka80.0+3.4 ka

9.4+0.4 ka

22.0+0.7 ka

Cosmogenic Exposure ages: Bedrock and Erratics

Page 30: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

28.3+0.7 ka 32.5+1.1 ka

10.2+0.5 ka34.2+0.9 ka

9.5+0.7 ka23.3+0.7 ka

9.5+0.3 ka23.7+1.0 ka

11.4+0.5 ka11.6+0.3 ka80.0+3.4 ka

9.4+0.4 ka

22.0+0.7 ka

erosive ice (>2 m of erosion)

erosive ice (<2 m of erosion)some glacial modification of upland bedrock

highest areas: no observable glacial modification

Clarke et al., in prep.

Page 31: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Page 32: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Page 33: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Page 34: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Future work . . .

Page 35: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

What we’ve learned:

?? ?

1. LGM ice at shelf break2. Uplands covered by cold-based ice

3. WZs mark of basal thermal regimes

4. Ice streams occupied fiords

weatheredfresh

Page 36: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

10 km N

Page 37: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 38: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 39: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

5.5±0.3

5.1±0.34.0±0.3

3.9±0.3

50.0±1.230.1±0.755.8±1.3

Page 40: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

5.5±0.3

5.1±0.34.0±0.3

3.9±0.3

50.0±1.230.1±0.755.8±1.3

Al/Be burial age:~430 ka

Page 41: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 42: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 43: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Byrd Glacier, Antarctica

LANDSAT-1 image

Page 44: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Lambert Glacier: an Antarctic ICE STREAM

JPL - RADARSAT AMP

Page 45: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

ice-sheet scalepatterns in basal thermal regime…

Page 46: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

JPL - RADARSAT AMP

Page 47: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 48: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

4 Questions to consider:

1. Why can’t blockfields be used as evidence for LGM refugia?

2. Recall that we’re presently in the “Goldilocks Paradigm.” Howis the Goldilocks model incorrect?

3. What are weathering zones really telling us?

4. What is potentially wrong with a story that is based on only a fewcosmogenic exposure ages?

Page 49: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

2D numerical glacier model run in MatLab

Bob Anderson and Mark Kessler (University of Colorado)

Published:Kessler et al. 2006

QuickTime™ and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 50: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 51: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

QuickTime™ and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 52: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Erosion is deepest as it crosses the crest.Erosion accelerates through time

Page 53: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

X-section of a typical Baffin Island Fjord

> 2 km

100 km

Page 54: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 55: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics

Bob Anderson, Mark Kessler

QuickTime™ and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 56: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics
Page 57: 7 field seasons and 250 cosmogenic exposure ages: Laurentide Ice Sheet history and dynamics