701 pike street, suite 1700 seattle, wa 98101 206.623.3427 745 west fourth avenue, suite 502...
TRANSCRIPT
701 Pike Street, Suite 1700Seattle, WA 98101206.623.3427
745 West Fourth Avenue, Suite 502Anchorage, AK 99501-2136907.258.0106
Bid Protests 2012: Tips and Trends
byJonathan A. DeMella
forNCMA West Sound Chapter
November 8, 2012
Snapshot Comparison
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
Issue GAO Court of Federal Claims
Statutory Jurisdiction CICA, 31 USC 3551 Tucker Act, 28 USC 1491
Procedures GAO Regulations, 4 CFR 21 CoFC Rules
Timeliness Fixed Times, 4 CFR 21.1 Equitable “Laches”
Stay of Procurement Automatic, if filed within deadline of 31 USC 3553
Not Automatic: TRO/PI Required
Protective Order Yes Yes
Awardee Participation Yes, as intervenor Yes, as intervenor
Agency Representation Agency Counsel Department of Justice
Agency Documentation Agency Report Administrative Record
Nature of Relief Recommendation Permanent Injunction
Award Protest costs Yes No, except for EAJA
Length of Process 100 days by statute Case by case, often 3-16 months
2
Recent Trends at the GAO
FY2007 FY2008 FY2009 FY2010 FY20110
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Cases Filed
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
3
Recent Trends at the GAO
FY2007 FY2008 FY2009 FY2010 FY20110
50100150200250300350400450500
Merit Decisions / Percent Sustained
27%
21%18%
19%16%
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
4
What can be protested?Illegalities or improprieties in:
1. Solicitations by federal agencies for goods or services
2. Cancellations of solicitations by federal agencies
3. Awards or proposed awards by federal agencies
4. Terminations or cancellations of contract awards by federal agencies, if the protest alleges that the termination or cancellation was based on improprieties in contracts award
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012 5
What cannot be protested?• Challenges to size standards, NAICS codes
classifications (SBA)• PIA violations not reported within 14 days of
discovery• Awards, proposed awards of subcontracts• Suspensions, debarments
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
6
Bid Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
7
• Forums– Agency Protest– GAO Protest– Court of Federal Claims Protest– FAA / ODRA
Agency Level Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
8
• Process Defined by individual agency supplemental regulations
• FAR 33.103 Basic Requirements– Written protest directed to the appropriate Government representative– Evidence that the protester is an “interested party” (offeror whose direct
economic interest is affected by the award)– Detailed statement of the factual and legal basis of the protest– Stated of the requested relief– Evidence that the protest is timely (proof that filed not later than 10 days
after the grounds for the protest known or should have been known – 5 days after debrief)
Agency Level Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
9
• If protest is timely, Agency must suspend contract’s performance until protest is resolved, unless finding of urgent need is made
• Agency must exercise “best efforts” to resolve protests within 35 days
• Can appeal adverse protest decision to GAO or US Court of Federal Claims
Agency Level Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
10
• Pros– Fairly informal process– Relatively inexpensive– Usually a quick resolution
• Cons– Often decided by the same individual whose actions form the
basis of the protest– May adversely affect the business relationship with the customer– Process varies among the agencies
GAO Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
11
• Rules set forth in 4 CFR Part 21 (outside the FAR System)
• Process is more structured, but similar requirements– Protest must be in writing– Protest must contain detailed statement of factual and legal
basis of the protest– Protest must demonstrate that offeror is an interested party– Protest must demand a ruling by the Comptroller General– Protest must state the requested relief
GAO Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
12
• May request a protective order– Access to competitor’s offer or bid– Limited to counsel admitted under the Order
• Contract performance may be suspended if protest is filed within 10 days of award or 5 days of debriefing– Remember to give GAO 1 full day to notify Agency to be on the
safe side
GAO Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
13
• Within 30 days of notification of protest by GAO, Agency must file Agency Report responding to the protest– Must be delivered to GAO, protester, and any intervenors– Must contain a complete statement of facts, memorandum of law
explaining Agency’s position under applicable procurment law, and copies of documents relevant to the protest
• Protestors and intervenors must file response to the Agency Report within 10 days– Failure to file on time will result in dismissal of protest
GAO Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
14
• Pros– Relatively informal process– Detailed but accessible rules and regulations– Meaningful participation by counsel in the process
• Cons– Lengthier decision process– Limited opportunity for meaningful discovery
Court of Federal Claims Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
15
• Civil Lawsuits brought against the Government decided under the standards of the APA
• Under APA, Agency decision presumed to be “rational.” • Decision will not be overturned unless found to be
“arbitrary and capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law.”
• Must show Prejudice• Rules applicable to COFC bid protests are contained in
Appendix C to the Court’s Local Rules
Court of Federal Claims Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
16
• Unlike typical civil litigation, bid protests before the COFC require:– 24 hour notice to the DoJ, the Court’s Clerk, the Agency and
apparent winning offeror of the protestor’s intent to file an action
• Court will schedule an initial status conference as soon as possible after filing of the complaint to discuss:– Identity of interested persons– Whether the apparent winning offeror should be added as
intervenor in protest– Requested injunctive relief– Content and timing of filing of administrative record
Court of Federal Claims Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
17
• Bid protest cases are subject to the 6 year statute of limitations established by the Tucker Act
• Unreasonable delay in filing will prejudice protestor’s right to relief
Court of Federal Claims Protests
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
18
• Pros– Ability to conduct discovery– Benefit of established rules and procedures– More formal, rigorous process
• Cons– More formal, rigorous process– Expensive– No deadline within which protest must be resolved– Agency decision given deference; high standard of review– No automatic stay without TRO
Mandatory Stay Issues
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
19
• Critical “preliminary” relief afforded to disappointed bidders
• At Agency and GAO, triggered by timely filed protest (which is why considered “mandatory” or “automatic”)
• At COFC, must seek immediate injunctive relief (e.g., TRO, PI)
Mandatory Stay Issues
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
20
• Pre-award protest– File before bids/offers are due– Agency may not award contract until resolved, except in
exceptional circumstances
• Post award protest– File within 10 days of contract award or five days after the
debriefing date, whichever is later– Contract performance is suspended until resolved, except in
exceptional circumstances
Sustained Cases• Most sustained protests reflect procedural
errors. • GAO does not question agency’s informed
exercise of judgment• Three areas where errors most often found:
1. Evaluation inconsistent with stated solicitation criteria (failure to follow the ground rules)
2. Inadequate documentation of evaluation
3. Discussions are inadequate or misleading
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
21
When to Protest a“Ground Rules” Violation
• SSA fails to follow the stated evaluation criteria• Ground rules don’t mirror mission needs• Agency changes ground rules, without allowing offerors
a chance to respond to changes• Rating scheme is complex and unclear
– Offerors can’t understand requirements– Offerors can’t prepare offers intelligently, on equal basis
BUT, if this is obvious at the outset, protest right away
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
22
When to Protest for Lack of Adequate Documentation
• Agency must document and retain evaluation materials• There must be a supporting rationale in record to
conclude Agency had reasonable basis for source selection decision
• This will likely become apparent after protest is filed, but may be evident during debriefing
• Be inquisitive during the debriefing (this will help your attorney!)
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
23
When to Protest for Lack of Meaningful Discussions
• Discussions must sufficiently identify areas of concern– Tailored to each offeror’s proposal– Object is to maximize Agency’s ability to obtain best value
• Discussions must not be vague or misleading• Discussions may not favor one offeror over another• Clarifications (limited exchanges) are not discussions
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
24
SBA Size Protests• Nothing to do with a company’s ability to perform
the work• Entirely focused on whether a company meets
the size requirements for a particular contract
25NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
Bringing a Protest• Short time frame
– 5 days from bid opening or notice of the intended awardee
• Low evidentiary bar – Protestor only needs to show that there is some basis
for the belief that the protested concern is other than small for the procurement
– SBA will review a wide variety of materials• Newspaper articles, information from websites,
promotional information
26NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
Defending a Protest• Three days to respond
• SBA will require various types of business information • Annual reporting information, ownership records, familial
information, information related to business relationships, income statements and tax returns for the previous 3 years
• Failure to provide this information may result in an adverse finding
• If the protest is successful, the protested concern will lose its small business status and can’t bid on set-aside contracts until it is recertified by the SBA.
27NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
Danger Zones
• Ostensible subcontractor– When a subcontractor performs vital and primary
requirements of a contract or– The prime contractor is unusually reliant on the
subcontractor
• Familial relationships– There must be a clear line of fracture between the
companies.
• Totality of the circumstances
28NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
Best Practices• Keep up with the regulations• Be aware of your company’s internet presence• Be mindful of your business and subcontracting
relationships – particularly those involving family members
29NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
Hot Issues
• Recent Federal Circuit Decisions– Systems Application and Technologies, Inc., __ F.3d __, 2012
WL 3631249 (Fed. Cir. August 24, 2012)– Scott Timber Co. v. United States, __ F.3d __, 2012 WL 3834661
(Fed. Cir. Sept. 5, 2012)
• In-Sourcing Decisions
NCMA West Sound ChapterNovember 8, 2012
30