a) … · a) .>?@abc(def(ghij>ef(?c(ke>lhed(fbmch@eh(mchl@>c>lcf(?c ... ... 6! «...

58
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

Upload: others

Post on 04-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 1 -

!"#$"%&$'&()"(*&(+,-#./-(012*.#&((

!"##./-(.!

0$"3,-%&!("-($"*&#./-(#4-(*&(.50*"5"-%&#./-()"(*&().!04!.#./-()"(*&(#4-6"-#./-(!"*"##.4-&)&(0&$&(!"$(&-&*.7&)&("-(*&(#,&$%&($4-)&(

/$3&-4!()"(#4-%$4*(!,0"$.4$8(#4-("*(+.-()"()"!&$$4**&$((5"#&-.!54!(54)"$-4!(0&$&(0$"6"-.$8()"%"#%&$8(!&-#.4-&$(9("$$&).#&$(*&!(

0$:#%.#&!(#4$$,0%&!(;&$%'#,*4(...8(0:$$&+4(<()"(*&(#4-6"-#./-=(

A ) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C(FB(MJNF(MJHJ(MHCOC>@H8(?CLCKLJH8(FJ>K@E>JH(P(CHHJ?@KJH(DJF(MHQKL@KJF(KEHHBMLJF(P(FCRJDC(SHCOCTC>LC(CD(MHEMGF@LE(JF@I>J?E(J(KJ?J(B>E(?C(CDDEFU(

B ) !CDCKK@E>C(J(KE>L@>BJK@G>(V(G(W(?C(DEF(J>LCH@EHCF(GHIJ>EF8(LC>@C>?E(C>(KBC>LJ(FB(@TMEHLJ>K@J(@>FL@LBK@E>JD(P(ABC(DJF(XB>K@E>CF(JF@I>J?JF(J(DEF(T@FTEF(KBSHJ>(B>E(E(OJH@EF(?C(DEF(MHEMGF@LEF(?C(MHCOC>@H8(?CLCKLJH8(FJ>K@E>JH(P(CHHJ?@KJH(DJF(MHQKL@KJF(KEHHBMLJF(ABC(IC>CHC>(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(?@FK@MD@>JH@JY(J?T@>@FLHJL@OJY(MJLH@TE>@JD(E(K@O@DY(P(MC>JDU(

C ) #E>(HCFMCKLE(J(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(FCDCKK@E>J?EF(C>(DJ(HCFMBCFLJ(J(DJ(MHCIB>LJ(2=8(HCX@ZHJFC(C>(DE(MEF@SDC(J(JFMCKLEF(LJDCF(KETE(DEF(ABC(FC(@>?@KJ>(J(KE>L@>BJK@G>8(J?[B>LJ>?E(KEM@J(?C(DJF(?@FMEF@K@E>CF(E(TC?@?JF(ABC(FBFLC>LC>(FBF(HCFMBCFLJF(E(FCRJDJ>?E(DEF(C>DJKCF(KE>(DJF(MQI@>JF(C>(.>LCH>CL(C>(ABC(CDDJF(MBC?J>(FCH(KE>FBDLJ?JF\(

@U !BF(ES[CL@OEF(P(XB>K@E>CFY(DJ(JBLE>ETNJ(MJHJ(FB(KBTMD@T@C>LEY(P(KBJ>?E(KEHHCFME>?J8(CD( C[CHK@K@E( ?C( XB>K@E>CF( C>( KE>KBHHC>K@J( E( KETMJHL@?JF( KE>( ELHEF( GHIJ>EF( E(JBLEH@?J?CF(P(DEF(TCKJ>@FTEF(MJHJ(FEDBK@E>JH(COC>LBJDCF(KE>XD@KLEF(?C(KETMCLC>K@JU(

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

Page 2: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 2 -

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`&8.;%.&/8.%6!!9+!#'()&-+8!_a!*%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!6%J#+#!=-%!#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!+%!&8''%678.*%!%+!*%67#&A8!*%!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!#6-.(86Y!!

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b/?/+#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!.8'@#6!*%!&8.('8+!C!>/6&#+/D#&/0.!#6)!&8@8!#6%68'#'!C!#78C#'!#!+86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+!/.(%'.8!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!NbF! 96(#3+%&%'! +#6! 3#6%6! ?%.%'#+%6! 7#'#! +#! '%#+/D#&/0.! *%! #-*/(8')#6! %.! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!#6)!&8@8!'%#+/D#'!+#6!#-*/(8')#6!=-%!6%!'%=-/%'#.!#!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!%.!6-6(/(-&/0.!8!#78C8!*%!6-6!7'87/86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+B!bF!b/?/+#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8<!78'!7#'(%!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&# !,%*%'#+<!*%!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7+#.%#&/0.<!7'%6-7-%6(#&/0.<!/.?'%686<!>/.#.&/#@/%.(8<!/.;%'6/0.<!*%-*#<!7#('/@8./8<!>8.*86!C!;#+8'%6B!b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bN!3/6F!]/'/?/'<!8'?#./D#'!C!87%'#'!%+!$/6(%@#!*%!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0. !123+/&#!,%*%'#+!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+#!"%C!*%!+#!@#(%'/#<!*/&(#.*8!+#6!'%68+-&/8.%6!&8.*-&%.(%6!%.!+86!&#686!*%!*-*#!683'%!+#!/.(%'7'%(#&/0.!C!#+&#.&%6!*%!6-6!.8'@#6B!bNNF! U%#+/D#'<! 78'! 6)! 8! #! 68+/&/(-*! *%! +#! $%&'%(#')#! *%! H#&/%.*#! C! E'V*/(8! 123+/&8! 8! *%! +#!&88'*/.#*8'#!*%+!6%&(8'!&8''%678.*/%.(%<!#-*/(8')#6!C!%;#+-#&/8.%6!#!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!

Page 3: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 3 -

*%! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<! &8.!%+!83:%(8!*%!7'8@8;%'! +#!%>/&/%.&/#!%.!6-!?%6(/0.!C!7'87/&/#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+86!83:%(/;86!&8.(%./*86!%.!6-6!7'8?'#@#6B!b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cF!\7/.#'<!7'%;/#@%.(%!#!6-!%S7%*/&/0.<! 683'%! +86!7'8C%&(86!*%!.8'@#6!*%!&8.(#3/+/*#*!C!*%!&8.('8+! %.! @#(%'/#! *%!7'8?'#@#&/0.<!7'%6-7-%6(#&/0.<!#*@/./6('#&/0.!*%! '%&-'686!A-@#.86<!@#(%'/#+%6!C!>/.#.&/%'86<!#6)!&8@8!683'%!+86!7'8C%&(86!*%!.8'@#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&8.('#(#&/0.!*%!*%-*#!C!*%!@#.%:8!*%!>8.*86!C!;#+8'%6!=-%!>8'@-+%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8B!cF!]%6/?.#'!#!+86!#-*/(8'%6!%S(%'.86!*%!+#6!%.(/*#*%6<!#6)!&8@8!.8'@#'!C!&8.('8+#'!6-!*%6%@7%J8B!!cNF! ]%6/?.#'<! 7#'#! %+! @%:8'! *%6#''8++8!*%+! 6/6(%@#!*%!&8.('8+! C!%;#+-#&/0.!?-3%'.#@%.(#+%6<!*%+%?#*86! *%! +#! 7'87/#! $%&'%(#')#! #.(%! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C!0'?#.86!*%6&8.&%.('#*86!*%! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!&%.('#+/D#*#<!C!&8@/6#'/86!%.!+86!0'?#.86!*%!?83/%'.8!8!;/?/+#.&/#!*%!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!1#'#%6(#(#+B!c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cNNNF!E8+#38'#'!&8.!+#!E8.(#*-')#!R#C8'!*%!H#&/%.*#!7#'#!%+!%6(#3+%&/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!.%&%6#'/86! =-%! 7%'@/(#.! #! #@386! 0'?#.86! %+! @%:8'! &-@7+/@/%.(8! *%! 6-6! '%67%&(/;#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6B!!cNbF! N.>8'@#'!7%'/0*/&#@%.(%!#+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!683'%!%+!'%6-+(#*8!*%!+#!%;#+-#&/0.!'%67%&(8!*%!+#!?%6(/0.!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!#6)!&8@8!*%!#=-%++#6!=-%!A#C#.!6/*8!83:%(8!*%!>/6&#+/D#&/0.<!%!/.>8'@#'!#!+#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!&8@7%(%.(%6<!&-#.*8!7'8&%*#! *%+! '%6-+(#*8! *%! (#+%6! /.(%';%.&/8.%6! C<! %.! 6-!&#68<!*/&(#'! +#6!#&&/8.%6!=-%!*%3#.!*%6#''8++#'6%!7#'#!&8''%?/'!+#6!/''%?-+#'/*#*%6!*%(%&(#*#6B!cbF!U%&/3/'!C!'%?/6('#'!+#6!*%&+#'#&/8.%6!7#('/@8./#+%6!=-%!*%3#.!7'%6%.(#'!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!C!;%'/>/&#'!6-!&8.(%./*8!@%*/#.(%!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!=-%!>-%'%.!7%'(/.%.(%6!*%!#&-%'*8!&8.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!#7+/&#3+%6B!cbNF!T(%.*%'!+#6!=-%:#6!%!/.&8.>8'@/*#*%6!=-%!7'%6%.(%.!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!&8.!@8(/;8!*%!&8.;%./86!8!&8.('#(86!=-%!&%+%3'%.!&8.!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!6#+;8!+86!&#686!%.!=-%!8('#6!+%C%6!%6(#3+%D&#.!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!/@7-?.#&/0.!*/>%'%.(%6B!cbNNF! E8.8&%'! %! /.;%6(/?#'! +#6! &8.*-&(#6! *%! +86! 6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86<! =-%! 7-%*#.! &8.6(/(-/'!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6B!#7+/&#'!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!=-%!&8''%678.*#.!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+%C!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!7'%6%.(#'!+#6!*%.-.&/#6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!#.(%!%+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8<!7'%6(M.*86%!7#'#!(#+!%>%&(8!+#!&8+#38'#&/0.!=-%!+%!>-%'%!'%=-%'/*#B!cbNNNF! T7'83#'! C! '%?/6('#'! +#6! %6('-&(-'#6! 8'?M./&#6! C! 8&-7#&/8.#+%6! *%! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!6-6!@8*/>/&#&/8.%6B!7'%;/8!*/&(#@%.!7'%6-7-%6(#+!>#;8'#3+%!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8B!cbNNN!3/6F!96(#3+%&%'!.8'@#6!C!+/.%#@/%.(86!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7+#.%#&/0.!C!#*@/./6('#&/0.!*%!7%'68.#+B!cNcF!96(#3+%&%'!.8'@#6<!78+)(/&#6!C!+/.%#@/%.(86!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!#*=-/6/&/8.%6<!#''%.*#@/%.(86<!*%6/.&8'78'#&/0.!*%!#&(/;86<!6%';/&/86!C!83'#6!723+/&#6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!ccF!E8.*-&/'!+#!78+)(/&#!/.@83/+/#'/#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!6#+;8!78'!+8!=-%!6%!'%>/%'%!#! +#6!7+#C#6<! D8.#! >%*%'#+!@#')(/@8! (%''%6('%<! (%''%.86!?#.#*86!#+!@#'!8!&-#+=-/%'!*%706/(8!*%!

Page 4: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 4 -

#?-#6!@#')(/@#6!C!*%@M6!D8.#6!>%*%'#+%6B!!!ccNF!9S7%*/'!.8'@#6!(V&./&#6<!#-(8'/D#'!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!7'8C%&(#'<!&8.6('-/'<!'%A#3/+/(#'<!&8.6%';#'!8!#*@/./6('#'<!*/'%&(#@%.(%!8!#!('#;V6!*%!(%'&%'86<!+86!%*/>/&/86!723+/&86!C<!%.!?%.%'#+<!+86!3/%.%6!/.@-%3+%6!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.<!#!>/.!*%!83(%.%'!%+!@#C8'!7'8;%&A8!*%+!-68!C!?8&%!*%!+86!@/6@86F!1#'#! (#+! %>%&(8<! +#! $%&'%(#')#! 78*'M! &88'*/.#'6%! &8.! %6(#*86! C! @-./&/7/86<! 8! 3/%.! &8.! +86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!C!&8.!8('86!7#)6%6B!ccNNF! T*@/./6('#'! +86! /.@-%3+%6! *%! 7'87/%*#*! >%*%'#+<! &-#.*8! .8! %6(V.! #6/?.#*86! #!#+?-.#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%.(/*#*B!ccNNNF!U%?-+#'! +#!#*=-/6/&/0.<!#''%.*#@/%.(8<!%.#:%.#&/0.<!*%6(/.8!8!#>%&(#&/0.!*%! +86!3/%.%6!/.@-%3+%6! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+! C<! %.! 6-! &#68<! '%7'%6%.(#'! %+! /.(%'V6! *%! +#!,%*%'#&/0.B!#6)!&8@8!%S7%*/'!+#6!.8'@#6!C!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!7#'#!+#!>8'@-+#&/0.!*%!/.;%.(#'/86!C!7#'#! +#! '%#+/D#&/0.! C! #&(-#+/D#&/0.! *%! +86! #;#+286!683'%!*/&A86!3/%.%6!=-%! '%#+/&%! +#!7'87/#!$%&'%(#')#<!8!3/%.<!(%'&%'86!*%3/*#@%.(%!#-(8'/D#*86!7#'#!%++8B!ccNbF! "+%;#'! %+! '%?/6('8! 723+/&8! *%! +#! 7'87/%*#*! /.@83/+/#'/#! >%*%'#+! C! %+! /.;%.(#'/8! ?%.%'#+ !&8''%678.*/%.(%<!C!ccNb!3/6F!U%/;/.*/&#'!+86!3/%.%6!7'87/%*#*!*%!+#!.#&/0.<!78'!&8.*-&(8!*%+!1'8&-'#*8'!G%.%'#+!*%!+# !U%723+/&#B!C!ccbF!,8'@-+#'!C!&8.*-&/'!+#!78+)(/&#!?%.%'#+!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!7#'#!%6(#3+%&%'!#&&/8.%6!=-%!7'87/&/%.!+#!('#.67#'%.&/#!%.!+#!?%6(/0.!723+/&#<!+#!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!C!%+!#&&%68!78'!7#'(%!*%!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!#!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!#=-V++#!?%.%'%<!C!!ccbNF!1'8@8;%'!+#6!%6('#(%?/#6!.%&%6#'/#6!7#'#!%6(#3+%&%'!78+)(/&#6!*%!?83/%'.8!%+%&('0./&8<!C!ccbNNF!"#6!*%@M6!=-%!+%!%.&8@/%.*%.!%S7'%6#@%.(%!+#6!+%C%6!C!'%?+#@%.(86F!

!9+!'%?+#@%.(8!/.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!7-3+/&#*8!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!%+!_!*%!T?86(8!*%!KLdd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e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

.U $-36%&'%(#')#!*%!E8.('8+!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!123+/&#!

..U $-36%&'%(#')#!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!C!E8.('#(#&/8.%6!123+/&#6!

...U $-36%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!!

.6U \>/&/#+)#!R#C8'!!6U E88'*/.#&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!W'?#.86!*%!b/?/+#.&/#!C!E8.('8+!!6.U Q./*#*!*%!T6-.(86!f-')*/&86!!6..U Q./*#*!*%!18+)(/&#6!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!E887%'#&/0.!N.(%'.#&/8.#+!!6...U E8.('#+8')#!N.(%'.#!!

Page 5: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 5 -

.]U ]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.!!eF!N.6(/(-(8!*%!T*@/./6('#&/0.!C!T;#+286!*%!e/%.%6!^#&/8.#+%6!!EF!]%+%?#*86<!$-3*%+%?#*86!C!E8@/6#'/86!123+/&86!C!!]F!I /(-+#'%6!*%!+86!W'?#.86!N.(%'.86!*%!E8.('8+!!!1#'#!+86!%>%&(86!*%!+8!7'%;/6(8!78'!+#6!>'#&&/8.%6!cN!C!cNN!*%+!#'()&-+8!_a!*%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#<!+# !$%&'%(#')#!&8.(#'M! &8.! +86! (/(-+#'%6! *%! +86! 0'?#.86! /.(%'.86! *%! &8.('8+! %.! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6!*%! +# !T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!%.!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#!C!&8.!+86!(/(-+#'%6!*%!+#6!M'%#6!*%!#-*/(8')#<!*%!=-%:#6!C!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!*%!*/&A86!0'?#.86<!=-/%.%6!(%.*'M.!%+!&#'M&(%'!*% !#-(8'/*#*<!#6)!&8@8!&8.!+86!*%+%?#*86<!6-3*%+%?#*86!C!&8@/6#'/86!723+/&86!=-/%.%6!(%.*'M.!+#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!#!=-%!6%!'%>/%'%.!+86!#'()&-+86!ag!#!Od!*%!%6(%!U%?+#@%.(8F!!9+! '%?+#@%.(8! /.(%'/8'! *%! +#! $,1! 7-%*%! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*8! %.! +#! 6/?-/%.(%! */'%&&/0.! %+%&('0./&#Y!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/@#?%6Z*8&(86ZTE9UETZ'%?+#@%.(8`/.(%'/8'`6>7F7*>!!

@@U "D(QTS@LE(?C(FBF(XB>K@E>CF8(@>?@KJ>?E(F@(C @FLC>(C^KCMK@E>CF(JD(T@FTEU(

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d<!K!C!_!*%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!@/6@86!=-%!%.!(V'@/.86!?%.%'#+%6!7'%&/6#.!+#6!3#6%6!*%!8'?#./D#&/0.!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+F!!9.!@V'/(8!*%!+8!#.(%'/8'<!6%!@%.&/8.#!=-%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!E%.('#+/D#*#!C!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!1#'#%6(#(#+<!6%!/.(%?'#.!*%!+#!6/?-/%.(%!@#.%'#Y!!

J=!"#!1'%6/*%.&/#!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!+#6!$%&'%(#')#6!*%!96(#*8<!+86!]%7#'(#@%.(86!T*@/./6('#(/;86!C!+#!E8.6%:%')#!f-')*/&#!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!/.(%?'#.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!E%.('#+/D#*#F!S=( "86! 8'?#./6@86! *%6&%.('#+/D#*86<! +#6! %@7'%6#6! *%! 7#'(/&/7#&/0.!%6(#(#+<! +#6! /.6(/(-&/8.%6!.#&/8.#+%6! *%! &'V*/(8<! +#6! 8'?#./D#&/8.%6! #-S/+/#'%6! .#&/8.#+%6! *%! &'V*/(8<! +#6! /.6(/(-&/8.%6!.#&/8.#+%6! *%! 6%?-'86! C! *%! >/#.D#6! C! +86! >/*%/&8@/686<! &8@78.%.! +#!#*@/./6('#&/0.!723+/&#!7#'#%6(#(#+F!

!9.! '#D0.!*%! +8!#.(%'/8'<! 6%!&8+/?%!=-%! +#6! >-.&/8.%6!*%!;/?/+#.&/#<! &8.('8+!C!>/6&#+/D#&/0.!=-%!'%#+/D#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!6%!#*;/%'(%.!*%!+#!+%&(-'#!=-%!#+!%>%&(8!6%!'%#+/&%!*%!+86!#'()&-+86!_a!*%!+#!"%C! \'?M./&#! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+! C! gL! #! gO! *%! +#! "%C! ,%*%'#+! *%! +#6! 9.(/*#*%6!1#'#%6(#(#+%6<!@/6@86!=-%!6%!('#.6&'/3%.!#!&8.(/.-#&/0.Y!!

- $-7-%6(86! 7'%;/6(86! %.! +#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!A((7YZZ[[[F*/7-(#*86F?83F@SZ"%C%6e/3+/8Z*8&Zdh_F*8& Y!!

!X!T! +#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!&8''%678.*%!%+!*%67#&A8!

*%!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!#6-.(86Y!!

Page 6: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 6 -

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

!NNF! 9S7%*/'! +#6!.8'@#6!=-%! '%?-+%.! +86! /.6('-@%.(86!C!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!&8.('8+!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!7#'#!+8!&-#+!78*'M!'%=-%'/'!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!&8@7%(%.(%6<!+#!%S7%*/&/0.!*%!.8'@#6!&8@7+%@%.(#'/#6!7#'#!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%+!&8.('8+!#*@/./6('#(/;8B!

!NNNF!b/?/+#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!.8'@#6!*%!&8.('8+!C!>/6&#+/D#&/0.!#6)!&8@8!#6%68'#'!C!#78C#'!#! +86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+!/.(%'.8!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!

!NbF!96(#3+%&%'! +#6!3#6%6!?%.%'#+%6!7#'#!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!#-*/(8')#6!%.!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!#6)!&8@8!'%#+/D#'!+#6!#-*/(8')#6!=-%!6%!'%=-/%'#.!#!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!%.!6-6(/(-&/0.!8!#78C8!*%!6-6!7'87/86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+B!

!bF!b/?/+#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8<!78'!7#'(%!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+<! *%! +#6! */6786/&/8.%6! %.! @#(%'/#! *%!7+#.%#&/0.<! 7'%6-7-%6(#&/0.<! /.?'%686<! >/.#.&/#@/%.(8<! /.;%'6/0.<! *%-*#<!7#('/@8./8<!>8.*86!C!;#+8'%6B!

!b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

!bN! 3/6F! ]/'/?/'<! 8'?#./D#'! C! 87%'#'! %+! $/6(%@#! *%! $%';/&/8! 1'8>%6/8.#+! *%!E#''%'#!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+#!"%C!*%!+#!@#(%'/#<!*/&(#.*8!+#6!'%68+-&/8.%6!&8.*-&%.(%6!%.!+86!&#686!*%!*-*#!683'%!+#!/.(%'7'%(#&/0.!C!#+&#.&%6!*%!6-6!.8'@#6B!!bNNF! U%#+/D#'<! 78'! 6)! 8! #! 68+/&/(-*!*%! +#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8! 8! *%! +#! &88'*/.#*8'#! *%+! 6%&(8'! &8''%678.*/%.(%<! #-*/(8')#6! C!%;#+-#&/8.%6!#!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!&8.!%+!83:%(8!*%!7'8@8;%'!+#!%>/&/%.&/#!%.!6-!?%6(/0.!C!7'87/&/#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+86!83:%(/;86!&8.(%./*86!%.!6-6!7'8?'#@#6B!

!

Page 7: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 7 -

b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

!NcF!\7/.#'<!7'%;/#@%.(%!#!6-!%S7%*/&/0.<!683'%!+86!7'8C%&(86!*%!.8'@#6!*%!&8.(#3/+/*#*! C! *%! &8.('8+! %.! @#(%'/#!*%!7'8?'#@#&/0.<!7'%6-7-%6(#&/0.<!#*@/./6('#&/0.! *%! '%&-'686!A-@#.86<!@#(%'/#+%6!C! >/.#.&/%'86<!#6)! &8@8!683'%! +86!7'8C%&(86!*%!.8'@#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&8.('#(#&/0.!*%!*%-*#!C!*%!@#.%:8!*%!>8.*86!C!;#+8'%6!=-%!>8'@-+%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8B!

!cF!]%6/?.#'!#! +86! #-*/(8'%6!%S(%'.86!*%!+#6!%.(/*#*%6<!#6)!&8@8!.8'@#'!C!&8.('8+#'!6-!*%6%@7%J8B!

!cNF!]%6/?.#'<!7#'#!%+!@%:8'!*%6#''8++8!*%+!6/6(%@#!*%!&8.('8+!C!%;#+-#&/0.!?-3%'.#@%.(#+%6<!*%+%?#*86!*%!+#!7'87/#!$%&'%(#')#!#.(%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!0'?#.86!*%6&8.&%.('#*86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!&%.('#+/D#*#<!C!&8@/6#'/86!%.!+86!0'?#.86!*%!?83/%'.8!8!;/?/+#.&/#!*%!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!1#'#%6(#(#+B!

!cNNF!]%6/?.#'!C!'%@8;%'!#!+86!(/(-+#'%6!*%!+86!0'?#.86!/.(%'.86!*%!&8.('8+!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!*%!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#! G%.%'#+! *%! +#! U%723+/&#<! #6)! &8@8! #! +86! *%! +#6!M'%#6!*%!#-*/(8')#<!=-%:#6!C!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!*%!(#+%6!0'?#.86<!=-/%.%6!*%7%.*%'M.!:%'M'=-/&#! C! >-.&/8.#+@%.(%! *%! +#! $%&'%(#')#! *%!E8.('#+8')#!C!]%6#''8++8!T*@/./6('#(/;8<! (%.*'M.! %+! &#'M&(%'! *%! #-(8'/*#*! C! '%#+/D#'M.! +#! *%>%.6#!:-')*/&#!*%!+#6!'%68+-&/8.%6!=-%!%@/(#.!%.!+#!%6>%'#!#*@/./6('#(/;#!C!#.(%!+86!I'/3-.#+%6!,%*%'#+%6<!'%7'%6%.(#.*8!#+!I /(-+#'!*%!*/&A#!$%&'%(#')#B!

!cNNNF!E8+#38'#'!&8.!+#!E8.(#*-')#!R#C8'!*%!H#&/%.*#!7#'#!%+!%6(#3+%&/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!.%&%6#'/86!=-%!7%'@/(#.!#!#@386!0'?#.86!%+!@%:8'!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6B!

!cNbF!N.>8'@#'!7%'/0*/&#@%.(%!#+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!683'%!%+!'%6-+(#*8!*%! +#!%;#+-#&/0.! '%67%&(8!*%! +#!?%6(/0.!*%! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!#6)!&8@8!*%!#=-%++#6!=-%!A#C#.!6/*8!83:%(8!*%!>/6&#+/D#&/0.<!%!/.>8'@#'!#!+#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!&8@7%(%.(%6<!&-#.*8!7'8&%*#!*%+!'%6-+(#*8!*%!(#+%6!/.(%';%.&/8.%6!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!*/&(#'!+#6!#&&/8.%6!=-%!*%3#.!*%6#''8++#'6%!7#'#!&8''%?/'!+#6!/''%?-+#'/*#*%6!*%(%&(#*#6B!

!cbF!U%&/3/'!C!'%?/6('#'!+#6!*%&+#'#&/8.%6!7#('/@8./#+%6!=-%!*%3#.!7'%6%.(#'!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!C!;%'/>/&#'!6-!&8.(%./*8!@%*/#.(%!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!=-%!>-%'%.!7%'(/.%.(%6!*%!#&-%'*8!&8.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!#7+/&#3+%6B!

!

Page 8: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 8 -

cbNF!T(%.*%'!+#6!=-%:#6!%!/.&8.>8'@/*#*%6!=-%!7'%6%.(%.!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!&8.!@8(/;8! *%! &8.;%./86! 8! &8.('#(86! =-%! &%+%3'%.! &8.! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!6#+;8!+86!&#686!%.!=-%!8('#6!+%C%6!%6(#3+%D&#.!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!/@7-?.#&/0.!*/>%'%.(%6B!

!cbNNF! E8.8&%'! %! /.;%6(/?#'! +#6!&8.*-&(#6!*%! +86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!=-%!7-%*#.!&8.6(/(-/'! '%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6B!#7+/&#'!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!=-%! &8''%678.*#.! %.! +86! (V'@/.86! *%! +%C! C<! %.! 6-! &#68<! 7'%6%.(#'! +#6!*%.-.&/#6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!#.(%!%+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8<!7'%6(M.*86%!7#'#!(#+!%>%&(8!+#!&8+#38'#&/0.!=-%!+%!>-%'%!'%=-%'/*#B!

!cbNNNF!T7'83#'!C! '%?/6('#'! +#6!%6('-&(-'#6!8'?M./&#6!C!8&-7#&/8.#+%6!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+! C! 6-6!@8*/>/&#&/8.%6B!7'%;/8!*/&(#@%.!7'%6-7-%6(#+!>#;8'#3+%!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8B!!cbNNN! 3/6F! 96(#3+%&%'! .8'@#6! C! +/.%#@/%.(86! %.! @#(%'/#! *%! 7+#.%#&/0.!C!#*@/./6('#&/0.!*%!7%'68.#+B!

!cNcF!96(#3+%&%'!.8'@#6<!78+)(/&#6!C!+/.%#@/%.(86!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!#*=-/6/&/8.%6<!#''%.*#@/%.(86<!*%6/.&8'78'#&/0.!*%!#&(/;86<!6%';/&/86!C!83'#6!723+/&#6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!

!ccF!E8.*-&/'! +#!78+)(/&#! /.@83/+/#'/#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!6#+;8! 78'! +8! =-%! 6%! '%>/%'%! #! +#6! 7+#C#6<! D8.#! >%*%'#+!@#')(/@8! (%''%6('%<!(%''%.86!?#.#*86!#+!@#'!8!&-#+=-/%'!*%706/(8!*%!#?-#6!@#')(/@#6!C!*%@M6!D8.#6!>%*%'#+%6B!

!ccNF!9S7%*/'!.8'@#6! (V&./&#6<!#-(8'/D#'!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!7'8C%&(#'<!&8.6('-/'<!'%A#3/+/(#'<!&8.6%';#'!8!#*@/./6('#'<!*/'%&(#@%.(%!8!#!('#;V6!*%!(%'&%'86<!+86!%*/>/&/86!723+/&86!C<!%.!?%.%'#+<!+86!3/%.%6!/.@-%3+%6!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.<!#!>/.!*%!83(%.%'!%+!@#C8'!7'8;%&A8!*%+!-68!C!?8&%!*%!+86!@/6@86F!1#'#!(#+!%>%&(8<!+#!$%&'%(#')#!78*'M!&88'*/.#'6%!&8.!%6(#*86!C!@-./&/7/86<!8!3/%.!&8.!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!C!&8.!8('86!7#)6%6B!

!ccNNF! T*@/./6('#'! +86! /.@-%3+%6! *%! 7'87/%*#*! >%*%'#+<! &-#.*8! .8! %6(V.!#6/?.#*86!#!#+?-.#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%.(/*#*B!

!ccNNNF! U%?-+#'! +#! #*=-/6/&/0.<! #''%.*#@/%.(8<! %.#:%.#&/0.<! *%6(/.8! 8!#>%&(#&/0.!*%!+86!3/%.%6!/.@-%3+%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!'%7'%6%.(#'!%+!/.(%'V6!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.B!#6)!&8@8!%S7%*/'!+#6!.8'@#6!C!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!7#'#!+#!>8'@-+#&/0.!*%!/.;%.(#'/86!C!7#'#!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!C!#&(-#+/D#&/0.! *%! +86! #;#+286! 683'%! */&A86! 3/%.%6! =-%! '%#+/&%! +#! 7'87/#!$%&'%(#')#<!8!3/%.<!(%'&%'86!*%3/*#@%.(%!#-(8'/D#*86!7#'#!%++8B!

!ccNbF! "+%;#'! %+! '%?/6('8! 723+/&8! *%! +#! 7'87/%*#*! /.@83/+/#'/#! >%*%'#+! C!% +!/.;%.(#'/8!?%.%'#+!&8''%678.*/%.(%<!C!

!ccNb!3/6F!U%/;/.*/&#'! +86!3/%.%6!7'87/%*#*!*%!+#!.#&/0.<!78'!&8.*-&(8!*%+!1'8&-'#*8'!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#B!C!

Page 9: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 9 -

!ccbF!,8'@-+#'! C!&8.*-&/'! +#!78+)(/&#!?%.%'#+!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!7#'#!%6(#3+%&%'!#&&/8.%6!=-%!7'87/&/%.!+#!('#.67#'%.&/#!%.!+#!?%6(/0.!723+/&#<!+#!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!C!%+!#&&%68!78'!7#'(%!*%!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!#!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!#=-V++#!?%.%'%<!C!

!ccbNF! 1'8@8;%'! +#6! %6('#(%?/#6! .%&%6#'/#6! 7#'#! %6(#3+%&%'! 78+)(/&#6! *%!?83/%'.8!%+%&('0./&8<!C!!

!ccbNNF! "#6! *%@M6! =-%! +%! %.&8@/%.*%.! %S7'%6#@%.(%! +#6! +%C%6! C!

!!

- $-7-%6(86! 7'%;/6(86! %.! +#! "%C! ,%*%'#+! *%! +#6! 9.(/*#*%6! 1#'#%6(#(#+%6!A((7YZZ[[[F*/7-(#*86F?83F@SZ"%C%6e/3+/8Z*8&ZddLF*8&Y!!

&$%.#,*4(_`Ua(9+!W'?#.8!*%!b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bUa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

Page 10: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 10 -

&$%.#,*4(_cUa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a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dUa( "#6! %@7'%6#6! *%! 7#'(/&/7#&/0.! %6(#(#+! @#C8'/(#'/#<! 6/.!7%':-/&/8!*%!+8!%6(#3+%&/*8!%.!6-6!%6(#(-(86!C!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+#!+%?/6+#&/0.!&/;/+! 8! @%'&#.(/+! #7+/&#3+%<! 7#'#! 6-! ;/?/+#.&/#<! &8.('8+! C! %;#+-#&/0.<!/.&8'78'#'M.!+86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+!/.(%'.8!C!&8.(#'M.!&8.!+86!E8@/6#'/86!123+/&86! =-%! *%6/?.%! +#! $%&'%(#')#! *%! +#! E8.('#+8')#! G%.%'#+! *%! +#!,%*%'#&/0.!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+86!7'%&%*%.(%6!#'()&-+86!*%!%6(#!"%CF!!"86! >/*%/&8@/686!723+/&86!#!=-%!6%! '%>/%'%!%+!#'()&-+8!iL!*%!%6(#!"%C<! 6%!#:-6(#'M.!%.!+8!=-%!+%6!6%#!&8@7#(/3+%!#!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!#.(%'/8'%6F!!!&$%.#,*4( _VUa( "#! E88'*/.#*8'#! *%! $%&(8'<! #! ('#;V6! *%! 6-! (/(-+#'! 8!'%7'%6%.(#.(%<! @%*/#.(%! 6-! 7#'(/&/7#&/0.! %.! +86! 0'?#.86! *%! ?83/%'.8! 8!&8.6%:86! *%! #*@/./6('#&/0.! *%! +#6! 7#'#%6(#(#+%6<! 78*'M! '%&8@%.*#'! +#6!@%*/*#6!#*/&/8.#+%6!=-%!%6(/@%!7%'(/.%.(%6!683'%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!(8@#*#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&8.('8+F!!!&$%.#,*4(_WUa("#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!E8.('#+8')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!78*'M! '%#+/D#'! ;/6/(#6!C!#-*/(8')#6!#!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!7#'#%6(#(#+%6<!&-#+=-/%'#!=-%!6%#!6-!.#(-'#+%D#<!#!>/.!*%!6-7%';/6#'!%+!#*%&-#*8!>-.&/8.#@/%.(8!*%+!6/6(%@#!*%!&8.('8+B!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#!&#'?8!*%!&#*#!

Page 11: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 11 -

-.8!*%!+86!./;%+%6!*%!+#!#*@/./6('#&/0.!@%.&/8.#*86!%.!%+!#'()&-+8!gd<!C!%.!6-!&#68!7'8@8;%'!+8!.%&%6#'/8!7#'#!&8''%?/'!+#6!*%>/&/%.&/#6!-!8@/6/8.%6!%.!=-%!6%!A-3/%'#!/.&-''/*8F!!!&$%.#,*4( __Ua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eUa(9.!#=-%++#6!%@7'%6#6!%.!+#6!=-%!7#'(/&/7%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!&8.!+#!6-6&'/7&/0.!*%+!Khj!#+!hLj!*%+!&#7/(#+<!*/;%'6#6!#!+#6!6%J#+#*#6!%.!%+!#'()&-+8!KP!*%!%6(#!"%C<! 6%!;/?/+#'M.!+#6!/.;%'6/8.%6!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!8!%.!6-!&#68!*%+!]%7#'(#@%.(8!*%+!]/6('/(8!,%*%'#+<!#!('#;V6!*%+!E8@/6#'/8!=-%!6%!*%6/?.%!78'!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!E8.('#+8')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!C!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%!+86!*%'%&A86!'%67%&(/;86!6%!A#'M!78'!&8.*-&(8!*%!+#!*%7%.*%.&/#!&8''%678.*/%.(%!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%+!#'()&-+8!__!*%!%6(#!"%CF!!!&$%.#,*4(_fUa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

T!%>%&(8!*%!>8'(#+%&%'!+8!#.(%6!@%.&/8.#*8<!#!@#.%'#!*%!6).(%6/6!6%!>8'@-+#.!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!#'?-@%.(86Y!

"#!;/?/+#.&/#!C!&8.('8+!%.!%+!M@3/(8!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!6%!%:%'&%!78'!&8.*-&(8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%! +#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!*%7%.*%.&/#!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+!=-%!'%#+/D#!>-.&/8.%6!*%!&8.('8+!#*@/./6('#(/;8!/.(%'.8!=-%!%.!(V'@/.86!?%.%'#+%6!(/%.%!#!6-!&#'?8!8'?#./D#'!C!&88'*/.#'!%+!6/6(%@#!*%!&8.('8+!C!%;#+-#&/0.!?-3%'.#@%.(#+!%!/.67%&&/8.#'!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%+!?#6(8!723+/&8!>%*%'#+F!

9.!%>%&(8<!+#!>-.&/0.!*%!&8.('8+!/.(%'.8!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!%6(M!#!&#'?8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!&-C8!(/(-+#'!C+4'?+.*+$%*/#'8+'4%'91-./:-'@A<4/.%C<'%6!*%6/?.#*8!C!'%@8;/*8!+/3'%@%.(%!78'!%+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!9+!&8.('8+!C!;/?/+#.&/#!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!7'87/#!$%&'%(#')#!%6(M.! #! &#'?8! *%! -.#!E8.('#+8')#! N.(%'.#<!#*6&'/(#!*/'%&(#@%.(%!#+!$%&'%(#'/8<! C! &-C8! '%678.6#3+%!%6!*%6/?.#*8!78'!%+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!

"#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!(/%.%!#!6-!&#'?8! C+-'D%$+*/%'8+'.#-$*#4'E'F/3/4%-./%C<!%.('%!8('#6<!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6! #('/3-&/8.%6Y! 8'?#./D#'! C! &88'*/.#'! %+! 6/6(%@#! *%! &8.('8+! C! %;#+-#&/0.! ?-3%'.#@%.(#+B!/.67%&&/8.#'!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%+!?#6(8!723+/&8!>%*%'#+<!C!6-!&8.?'-%.&/#!&8.!+86!7'%6-7-%6(86!*%!%?'%686B!

Page 12: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 12 -

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

"86!/.6('-@%.(86!*%!&8.('8+!%.!+86!=-%!6%!#78C#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!7#'#!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!#('/3-&/8.%6!68.<!%.('%!8('86<!+#!T-*/(8')#!G-3%'.#@%.(#+B!+#!^8'@#(/;/*#*!*%!T*=-/6/&/8.%6<!\3'#6!123+/&#6<!$%';/&/86<!e/%.%6!R-%3+%6<!T+@#&%.%6!C!1#('/@8./8!N.@83/+/#'/8!,%*%'#+B!+#!T-*/(8')#!9S(%'.#B!+86!0'?#.86!N.(%'.86!*%!E8.('8+B!+86!]%+%?#*86!C!E8@/6#'/86!123+/&86B!+#!T(%.&/0.!*%!N.&8.>8'@/*#*%6<!C!%+!6/6(%@#!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86F!

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

@@@U *J( TJ>CHJ( C>( DJ(ABC(FC(J?EMLJ>(FBF(?CK@F@E>CF8( @>?@KJ>?E(F@(C @FLC>( @>FLJ>K@JF(TgDL@MDCF(KE>(KETMCLC>K@J(MJHJ(hJKCHDE(P(F@(ZFLJF(FE>(KEDCI@J?JF(E(B>@MCHFE>JDCFY(DEF(HCKBHFEF(?C(HCO@F@G>(ABC(LJ>LE(C>(FB(@>LCH@EH(KETE(J>LC(ELHEF(GHIJ>EF(E(JBLEH@?J?CF (C LCH>JF(MHEKC?C>(KE>LHJ(DJF(?CK@F@E>CF(J?EMLJ?JFY(P(DJF(JKK@E>CF(>CKCFJH@JF(MJHJ(JMD@KJH(E(hJKCH(CXCKL@OJF(?@KhJF(?CK@F@E>CFU(

"#!$,1!%6(M!7'%6/*/*#!78'!%+!$%&'%(#'/8!*%! +#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!%+!&-#+!%6!.8@3'#*8!78'!%+!I /(-+#'!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.! +8!*/67-%6(8!78'!+#!>'#&&/0.!NN!*%+!#'()&-+8!OP!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86F!!!9+!#'()&-+8!i!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!%6(#3+%&%!=-%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!&8.*-&/'M!6-6!#&(/;/*#*%6!%.!>8'@#!7'8?'#@#*#!C!&8.!3#6%!%.!+#6!78+)(/&#6!=-%!%6(#3+%D&#!%+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!7#'#!%+!+8?'8!*%!+86!83:%(/;86!C!7'/8'/*#*%6!*%!+#!7+#.%#&/0.!.#&/8.#+!*%+!*%6#''8++8!C!*%!+86!7'8?'#@#6!#!6-!&#'?8F!T6/@/6@8!6%J#+#!=-%! +#!$%&'%(#')#!&8+#38'#'M!& 8.! +#!T-*/(8')#!$-7%'/8'!*%! +#!,%*%'#&/0.!*%!+#!EM@#'#!*%!]/7-(#*86!7#'#!%+!%6(#3+%&/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!=-%!+%6!7%'@/(#.!%+!@%:8'!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!!9+!#'()&-+8!h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

Page 13: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 13 -

1#'#!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!#('/3-&/8.%6!+#!$,1!('#3#:8!&88'*/.#*#@%.(%!&8.!*/;%'6#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!%!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!(#+%6!&8@8!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8!C!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!U%+#&/8.%6!9S(%'/8'%6<!%.('%!8('#6<!#6)!&8@8!&8.!+86!W'?#.86!96(#(#+%6!*%!E8.('8+!*%!+#6!9.(/*#*%6!,%*%'#(/;#6!4E1E9X,5!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!1'%6/*%.&/#!*%!+#!E8@/6/0.!1%'@#.%.(%!*%!E8.('#+8'%6!96(#*86X,%*%'#&/0.F!!!9+!#'()&-+8!g!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'<!6%J#+#!+#6!>#&-+(#*%6!.8!*%+%?#3+%6!=-%!&8''%678.*%.!#+!$%&'%(#'/8!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#Y!!!

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bF! $8@%(%'! #! +#! &8.6/*%'#&/0.! C! #7'83#&/0.! *%+! 1'%6/*%.(%! *%! +#!U%723+/&#! +86!7'8?'#@#6!%67%&/#+%6! #! &#'?8! *%! +#! $%&'%(#')#! 7'%;/6(86! %.! %+! 1+#.! ^#&/8.#+! *%! ]%6#''8++8<!#6)! &8@8!%.&8@%.*#'!#!+#6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!&8@7%(%.(%6!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!+#!%:%&-&/0.!C!#&&/8.%6!*%! +86! @/6@86<! &8.! +#! 7#'(/&/7#&/0.! =-%! &8''%678.*#<! %.! 6-!&#68<!#! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6<! +#6!%.(/*#*%6!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#B!bF!\'*%.#'!%+!&8.('8+<!;/?/+#.&/#!C!>/6&#+/D#&/0.!*%!+#6!78+)(/&#6!=-%!%6(#3+%D&#!%+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!#6)!&8@8!'%#+/D#'!6-!%;#+-#&/0.B!bNF!1'878.%'!#+!I /(-+#'!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+!+86!7'8C%&(86!*%!/./&/#(/;#6!*%!+%C%6!8!*%&'%(86<!#6)!&8@8!+86!7'8C%&(86!*%!'%?+#@%.(86<!*%&'%(86<!#&-%'*86!C!0'*%.%6!683'%!+86!#6-.(86!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#B!bNNF!]#'!&-%.(#!#+!E8.?'%68!*%!+#!Q./0.!*%+!%6(#*8!=-%!?-#'*#.!+86!#6-.(86!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!%!/.>8'@#'!%.!+86!&#686!%.!=-%!6%!*/6&-(#!-.#!+%C!8!6%!%6(-*/%!-.!#6-.(8!&8.&%'./%.(%!#!6-6!#&(/;/*#*%6<!&-#.*8!6%#!'%=-%'/*8!7#'#!%++8!78'!&-#+=-/%'#!*%!+#6!EM@#'#6!=-%!+8!/.(%?'#.B!bNNNF!96(#3+%&%'!+86!+/.%#@/%.(86!C!78+)(/&#6!=-%!8'/%.(%.!+#!&8+#38'#&/0.!=-%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%3#!7'%6(#'! #! +#! T-*/(8')#! $-7%'/8'! *%! +#! ,%*%'#&/0.! *%! +#!EM@#'#!*%!]/7-(#*86<!7#'#!%+!@%:8'!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6B!NcF!U%>'%.*#'!7#'#!6-!;#+/*%D!C!836%';#.&/#!&8.6(/(-&/8.#+%6!+86!'%?+#@%.(86<!*%&'%(86<!#&-%'*86!C!0'*%.%6! %S7%*/*86! 78'! %+! 1'%6/*%.(%! *%! +#! U%723+/&#<! &-#.*8! 6%! '%>/%'#.! #! #6-.(86! *%! +#!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#B!!cF!U%7'%6%.(#'!#+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#!%.!+#6!&8.('8;%'6/#6!&8.6(/(-&/8.#+%6!C!#&&/8.%6!*%!/.&8.6(/(-&/8.#+/*#*!#!=-%!6%! '%>/%'%!%+!#'()&-+8!dLh!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86!C!+#!"%C!U%?+#@%.(#'/#!*%!+#6!>'#&&/8.%6!N!C! NN!*%+!T'()&-+8!dLh!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86<!%.!+86!&#686!%.!=-%!+8!*%(%'@/.%!%+!(/(-+#'!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!7-*/%.*8!6%'!6-7+/*8!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.! +8!*/67-%6(8!%.!%+!#'()&-+8!Og!*%+!7'%6%.(%!U%?+#@%.(8B!cNF! T7'83#'! +#! 8'?#./D#&/0.! C! >-.&/8.#@/%.(8! *%! +#! E8.('#+8')#! N.(%'.#! *%! +#! $%&'%(#')#<!#('/3-CV.*8+%! 8('#6! >#&-+(#*%6! =-%! .8! %6(V.! &8@7'%.*/*#6! %.! %6(%! U%?+#@%.(8! C!=-%!6%#.!.%&%6#'/#6!7#'#!6-!&8@%(/*8!+%?#+<!/.>8'@#.*8!#+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#!683'%!+#6!@%*/*#6!=-%!6%!A-3/%'#.!#*87(#*8!#+!'%67%&(8B!cNNF! T7'83#'! +#!8'?#./D#&/0.!C! >-.&/8.#@/%.(8!*%! +#!$%&'%(#')#!C!#*6&'/3/'!8'?M./&#@%.(%!6-6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6<!#6)!&8@8!%.&8@%.*#'+%6!>-.&/8.%6!#*/&/8.#+%6!C!=-%!6%#.!.%&%6#'/#6!7#'#!%+!*%67#&A8!*%!+86!#6-.(86!*%!+#!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#B!

Page 14: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 14 -

cNNNF!9S7%*/'!%+!R#.-#+!*%!\'?#./D#&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!*/678.%'!6-!7-3+/&#&/0.!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.<!#6)!&8@8!#7'83#'!C!%S7%*/'!+86!*%@M6!@#.-#+%6!*%!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!C!*%!6%';/&/86!#+!723+/&8!7#'#!%+!@%:8'!>-.&/8.#@/%.(8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#B!cNbF!T7'83#'!%+!7'8C%&(8!*%!7'%6-7-%6(8!*%!%?'%686!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!7'%6%.(#'+8!#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8<!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!#7+/&#3+%6B!cbF!$-6&'/3/'!+86!&8.;%./86!=-%! +#!$%&'%(#')#!&%+%3'%!&8.!8('#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6<!%.(/*#*%6<!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!8!+86!8'?#./6@86!&8.6(/(-&/8.#+%6!#-(0.8@86<!#6)!&8@8!+86!&8.;%./86!8!&8.('#(86!=-%!&%+%3'%!&8.!+86!78*%'%6!+%?/6+#(/;8!C!:-*/&/#+<!+86!?83/%'.86!%6(#(#+%6!C!@-./&/7#+%6<!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!C!*%@M6!7%'68.#6!>)6/&#6! 8! @8'#+%6<! 6#+;8! =-%! %+! 7'87/8! $%&'%(#'/8! #-(8'/&%<! %.! %+ ! &#68! &8.&'%(8<! =-%! #+?2.!$-36%&'%(#'/8!6-6&'/3#!*/&A86!*8&-@%.(86B!cbNF!9S7%*/'!+#6!.8'@#6!'%+#(/;#6!#!+86!/.>8'@%6<!*#(86!C!&887%'#&/0.!(V&./&#!=-%!*%3#!*#'6%!%.('%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!*%>/./'!&8.:-.(#@%.(%!&8.!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8!C!+# !&88'*/.#*8'#!*%!6%&(8'!&8''%678.*/%.(%<!+#6!.8'@#6!683'%!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!*%3#.!7'878'&/8.#'!6-6!%.(/*#*%6!7#'#%6(#(#+%6B!cbNNF!,8'@-+#'!6-?%'%.&/#6!#!+#6!E8@/6/8.%6!^#&/8.#+%6!e#.&#'/#!C!*%!b#+8'%6!C!*%!$%?-'86!C!,/#.D#6<!#! >/.!*%!=-%!%+! &8.('8+! C! +#! >/6&#+/D#&/0.!*%! +#6!%.(/*#*%6!>/.#.&/%'#6!*%!&#'M&(%'!7#'#%6(#(#+!6%!%:%'D#.!*%!@#.%'#!&88'*/.#*#<!&8.>8'@%!#!+#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!*%!&#*#!#-(8'/*#*B!cbNNNF!]%6/?.#'!C!'%@8;%'!#!+86!*%+%?#*86!C!6-3*%+%?#*86!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!%.!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#<!#!+86!&8@/6#'/86!723+/&86!%.!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!C!#!+86!(/(-+#'%6!*%!+86!0'?#.86!/.(%'.86!*%!&8.('8+!C!#!+86!*%!+#6!M'%#6!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6<!#-*/(8')#!C!=-%:#6!*%!*/&A86!0'?#.86!%.!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!+#6!%.(/*#*%6<!#6)!&8@8!%.!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#B!cNcF!N.>8'@#'!7%'/0*/&#@%.(%!#+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#!683'%!%+!'%6-+(#*8!*%!+#!%;#+-#&/0.!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6<!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#<!=-%!A#C#.!6/*8!83:%(8!*%!>/6&#+/D#&/0.<!#6)!&8@8!683'%! +#!%:%&-&/0.!C!#;#.&%6!*%! +86!1'8?'#@#6!#!&#'?8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!=-%!*%'/;%.!*%+!1+#.!^#&/8.#+!*%!]%6#''8++8B!ccF!U%68+;%'!+86!'%&-'686!#*@/./6('#(/;86!=-%!6%!/.(%'78.?#.!%.!&8.('#!*%!'%68+-&/8.%6! */&(#*#6! 78'! %+! 7'87/8! $%&'%(#'/8<! #6)! &8@8! +86! *%@M6! =-%! +%?#+@%.(%! +%!&8''%678.*#.B!!ccNF!T&8'*#'!+#6!3#6%6!7#'#!+86!.8@3'#@/%.(86!*%+!7%'68.#+!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!8'*%.#'!#+!\>/&/#+!R#C8'!6-!%S7%*/&/0.<!#6)!&8@8!'%68+;%'!+#6!7'87-%6(#6!=-%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!A#?#.!7#'#!+#!&'%#&/0.!*%!7+#D#6!C!*%6/?.#&/0.!8!'%@8&/0.!*%+!7%'68.#+!*%!?#3/.%(%!*%!#78C8!8!*%!&8.>/#.D#!=-%! .8! %6(V!6-:%(8!#! +#!"%C!*%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#!%.! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!!ccNNF!96(#3+%&%'!+#6!&8@/6/8.%6!/.(%'.#6!=-%!6%#.!.%&%6#'/#6!7#'#!%+!3-%.!>-.&/8.#@/%.(8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#<!#6)!&8@8!*%6/?.#'!#!+86!/.(%?'#.(%6!*%!+#6!@/6@#6!C!#!=-/%.!*%3#!7'%6/*/'+#6B!ccNNNF!U%68+;%'! +#6!*-*#6!=-%!6%!6-6&/(%.!&8.!@8(/;8!*%!+#!/.(%'7'%(#&/0.!8!#7+/&#&/0.!*%!%6(%!U%?+#@%.(8!C!683'%!+86!&#686!.8!7'%;/6(86!%.!%+!@/6@8<!C!!ccNbF! "#6! *%@M6!=-%!&8.! (#+! &#'M&(%'! +%!#('/3-C#.!%S7'%6#@%.(%! +#6!*/6786/&/8.%6! +%?#+%6!C!'%?+#@%.(#'/#6!8!+%!%.&8@/%.*%!%+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!

!,/.#+@%.(%<!%+!#'()&-+8!Og!*%!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'<!%6(#3+%&%!=-%!*-'#.(%!+#6!#-6%.&/#6!*%+!$%&'%(#'/8<!%+!*%67#&A8! C! '%68+-&/0.! *%! +86! #6-.(86! &8''%678.*/%.(%6! #! +#! $%&'%(#')#! %6(#'M.! #! &#'?8! *%! +86!$-36%&'%(#'/86!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!C!E8.('#(#&/8.%6!123+/&#6<!*%!E8.('8+!C!T-*/(8'/#!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!123+/&#<!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!*%+!\>/&/#+!R#C8'!8!*%+!I /(-+#'!*%!+#!Q./*#*!*%!T6-.(86!f-')*/&86<!%.!%+!8'*%.!@%.&/8.#*8F!!9+! *8&-@%.(8! &/(#*8! 7-%*%! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*8! #! ('#;V6! *%+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z&8.8&%X+#X6>7FA(@+!!

@OU *J(TJ>CHJ(C>(ABC(FE>(MHCO@FLEF(DEF(KJHIEF(?C(FBF(TQ @TJF(JBLEH@?J?CF8(@>?@KJ>?E(F@(ZFLJF( FE>( ?C( MCHNE?E( X@[E( E( ?C( D@SHC( >ETSHJT@C>LE( P( HCTEK@G>( P( DJF( @>FLJ>K@JF(KETMCLC>LCF(MJHJ(C @I@HDCF(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(MEH(FBF(JKLBJK@E>CF(P(?CK@?@H(JKCHKJ(?C(FB(MCHTJ>C>K@J(C>(CD(KJHIEU((

Page 15: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 15 -

"#!$,1!%6(M!7'%6/*/*#!78'!%+!$%&'%(#'/8!*%! +#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!%+!&-#+!%6!.8@3'#*8!78'!%+!I /(-+#'!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.! +8!*/67-%6(8!78'!+#!>'#&&/0.!NN!*%+!#'()&-+8!OP!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86F!!

!9+!#'()&-+8!i!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!%6(#3+%&%!=-%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!&8.*-&/'M!6-6!#&(/;/*#*%6!%.!>8'@#!7'8?'#@#*#!C!&8.!3#6%!%.!+#6!78+)(/&#6!=-%!%6(#3+%D&#!%+!1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!7#'#!%+!+8?'8!*%!+86!83:%(/;86!C!7'/8'/*#*%6!*%!+#!7+#.%#&/0.!.#&/8.#+!*%+!*%6#''8++8!C!*%!+86!7'8?'#@#6!#!6-!&#'?8F!T6/@/6@8!6%J#+#!=-%! +#!$%&'%(#')#!&8+#38'#'M!& 8.! +#!T-*/(8')#!$-7%'/8'!*%! +#!,%*%'#&/0.!*%!+#!EM@#'#!*%!]/7-(#*86!7#'#!%+!%6(#3+%&/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!=-%!+%6!7%'@/(#.!%+!@%:8'!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!

!9+!#'()&-+8!h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ccN!*%+!#'()&-+8!g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

OU *J( TJ>CHJ( C>( DJ( ABC( FC( ?CLCHT@>J>( DEF( HCKBHFEF( hBTJ>EF( >CKCFJH@EF( MJHJ( FB(XB>K@E>JT@C>LE(P(C>(DJ(ABC(FE>(MHEO@FLEF(DEF(T@FTEF8(@>?@KJ>?E(F@(FB(MCHFE>JD(CF(?C(D@SHC(>ETSHJT@C>LE(P(HCTEK@G>(E(F@(CF(FCDCKK@E>J?E(MEH(KE>KBHFE(?C(TZH@LEFY(F@(FC(C @IC(CD(KBTMD@T@C>LE(?C(HCAB@F@LEF(MJHJ(JKKC?CH(J(DEF(KJHIEFY(P(F@(?@KhE(MCHFE>JD(CFLQ(FB[CLE(J(B>(HZI@TC>(?C(@>hJS@D@?J?CF(C(@>KETMJL@S@D@?J?CF(P(?C(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(MEH(FBF(JKLBJK@E>CFU(

9.!RVS/&8!%S/6(%.!.8'@#6!=-%!%6(#3+%&%.!6/6(%@#6!7#'#! +#!&8.('#(#&/0.!*%! >-.&/8.#'/86!723 +/&86!%.!*/6(/.(86!./;%+%6!C!M@3/(86!*%!?83/%'.8F!

9.! %6(%! 6%.(/*8<! %.! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#!,%*%'#+!E%.('#+/D#*#<!*%7%.*/%.(%!*%+!18*%'!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!&-%.(#!&8.!+#!"%C!*%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!6-!U%?+#@%.(8<!8'*%.#@/%.(86!=-%!%6(#3+%&%.!-.#!6%'/%!*%!.8'@#6!C!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!#&&%68!#+!6%';/&/8!723+/&8!&8.!3#6%!%.!%+!@V'/(8!C!%S7%'/%.&/#F!!

9.!+#!$%&'%(#')#!6%!&-%.(#!&8.!7%'68.#+!*%!+/3'%!*%6/?.#&/0.<!?#3/.%(%6!*%!#78C8<!#6)!&8@8!%+!7%'68.#+!#6/@/+#*8!#!-.!6/6(%@#!+%?#+!*%!6%';/&/8!&/;/+!*%!&#''%'#B!C!=-/%.%6!7'%6(%.!6-6!6%';/&/86!@%*/#.(%!&8.('#(8<!6-:%(86!#+!7#?8!*%!A8.8'#'/86F!^8!836(#.(%<!7-%*%.!7#'(/&/7#'!%.!+86!&8.&-'686!7#'#!8&-7#'!+86!7-%6(86!;#&#.(%6!=-%!%.('%.!%.!%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#<!6/%@7'%!C!&-#.*8!&-@7+#.!&8.!+86!'%=-/6/(86!%6(#3+%&/*86F!

!

Page 16: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 16 -

9.!%+!&#68!*%!+#!$,1<!+#!'%?-+#&/0.!*%+!6%';/&/8!7'8>%6/8.#+!*%!&#''%'#!(/%.%!+#!/.(%.&/0.!*%!7'8>%6/8.#+/D#'!+#!(#'%#!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!7#'#!=-%!%+!6%';/*8'!723+/&8!+8?'%!+#!@MS/@ #!%>/&#&/#!C!%+!&8@7'8@/68!68&/#+!%.!6-6!#&&/8.%6<!8>'%&/%.*8!#+!@/6@8!(/%@78<!878'(-./*#*%6!*%!*%6#''8++8!C!7'8?'%68<!?'#&/#6!#!-.!7+#.!*%!&#''%'#<!8'/%.(#*8!#!+86!(#+%.(86<!&8.!-.!#>M.!*%!/..8;#&/0.<!&#+/*#*!C!&'%#(/;/*#*!#6%'(/;#F!!

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h!*%!+#!"$1E5F!!

!

O@U *J(C @FLC>K@J(?C(TJ>BJDCF(B(ELHEF(?EKBTC>LEF(C>(DEF(ABC(FC(?CFKH@SJ>(DJF(XB>K@E>CF(?CD(MCHFE>JD(J(FB(FCHO@K@E8(@>?@KJ>?E(J?CTQF(F@(FC(DC(@TMJHLC(KJMJK@LJK@G>(MCH@G?@KJ(C>(HCDJK@G>(KE>(?@KhJF(XB>K@E>CFU(

9+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!%6(#3+%&%!+#!&8@7%(%.&/#<!8'?#./D#&/0.<!>#&-+(#*%6!C!#('/3-&/8.%6!*%!+#6!Q./*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#F!!

9+! *8&-@%.(8! &/(#*8! 7-%*%! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*8! #! ('#;V6! *%+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z&8.8&%X+#X6>7FA(@+!!

"#!$%&'%(#')#!&-%.(#!&8.!-.!R#.-#+!G%.%'#+!*%!\'?#./D#&/0.!&8.!%+!>/.!*%!=-%!+#6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!C!0'?#.8!*%6&8.&%.('#*8!*%! +#!$,1<!&-%.(%.!&8.!-.! /.6('-@%.(8!*%!#78C8!7#'#!++%;#'!#!&#38!*%!-.#!@#.%'#!%>/&#D!C!%>/&/%.(%!6-!=-%A#&%'!6-6(#.(/;8!%.!&8.?'-%.&/#!&8.!+#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!=-%!+%!8(8'?#.!*/&A8!8'*%.#@/%.(8! +%?#+!%.!6-!T'()&-+8!_a<! +#! +%?/6+#&/0.!#7+/&#3+%!%.!@#(%'/#!*%! '%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!9.(/*#*%6!1#'#%6(#(#+%6<!+#!"%C!*%!T*=-/6/&/8.%6<!T''%.*#@/%.(86!C!$%';/&/86!*%+!$%&(8'!123+/&8<!+#!"%C!*%!\3'#6!123+/&#6!C!$%';/&/86!U%+#&/8.#*86!&8.!+#6!R/6@#6<!+#!"%C!G%.%'#+!*%!e/%.%6!^#&/8.#+%6<! +#!"%C!*%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!6-!U%?+#@%.(8!#6)!&8@8!8('#6!+%C%6<!'%?+#@%.(86<!*%&'%(86<!#&-%'*86!C!0'*%.%6!*%+ !1'%6/*%.(%!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!

9+! R#.-#+! G%.%'#+! *%! \'?#./D#&/0.! *%! +#! $,1! 7-%*%! 6%'!&8.6-+(#*8!#! ('#;V6!*%+! 6/?-/%.(%!;).&-+8Y!!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z&8.8&%X+#X6>7FA(@+!

U%%6('-&(-'#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!!

9+!hk!N.>8'@%!*%!"#38'%6!*%!+#!$,1!4KLdL5!6%J#+#!=-%!%.!&-@7+/@/%.(8!#!+8!%6(#3+%&/*8!%.!%+!1'8?'#@#!*%!^#&/8.#+!*%!U%*-&&/0.!*%!G#6(8!123+/&8!41^UG15<!+#!$,1!A#!++%;#*8!#!&#38!+#6!#&&/8.%6!8'/%.(#*#6!#!*/6@/.-/'! 6-! ?#6(8! 87%'#(/;8! C! #*@/./6('#(/;8<! #6)! &8@8! #! +#! &8@7#&(#&/0.! *%! 6-6! %6('-&(-'#6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6F!!I#+!6/(-#&/0.!=-%*0!'%>+%:#*#!%.!+#6!@8*/>/&#&/8.%6!=-%!6%!A/&/%'8.!#!+#!%6('-&(-'#!*%!+#!$,1<!C!=-%!(/%.%.!+# !

!=-%!6%!'%>8'@#.<!#*/&/8.#.!C!*%'8?#.!*/;%'6#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!7-3+/&#*8!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!4]\,5<!%+!_!*%!#?86(8!*%!KLddF!!!!

Page 17: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 17 -

]/&A#6!@8*/>/&#&/8.%6!*%!@#.%'#!?%.%'#+!&8.6/6(/%'8.!%.!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!#:-6(%6Y!!!

E#@3/8! *%! *%.8@/.#&/0.! *%! +#! $-36%&'%(#')#! *%! T(%.&/0.! E/-*#*#.#! C! ^8'@#(/;/*#*<! %.!$-36%&'%(#')#!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!C!E8.('#(#&/8.%6!123+/&#6<!7#'#!#:-6(#'!6-!*%.8@/.#&/0.!%.!&8.?'-%.&/#!&8.!+#6!@#(%'/#6!=-%!'%6-+(#.!*%!+#!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!+#!@/6@#F!]%'/;#*8!*%!%6(%!&#@3/8<!6%!%+/@/.#!+#!Q./*#*!*%!T(%.&/0.!E/-*#*#.#<!7#'#!&'%#'!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!]%.-.&/#6!%!N.;%6(/?#&/8.%6F!

! 9.!+#!$-36%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!6%!&#@3/0!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!*%!

U%&-'686!H-@#.86!%.! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<! C! 6-6! >-.&/8.%6!6%! ('#.6>/%'%.!#!+#!Q./*#*!*%!18+)(/&#!*%!U%&-'686!H-@#.86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!#!+#6!]/'%&&/8.%6!G%.%'#+%6! *%! ]%6#''8++8! H-@#.8! C! $%';/&/8! 1'8>%6/8.#+! *%! E#''%'#! C! *%! \'?#./D#&/0.! C!U%@-.%'#&/8.%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!!!

9.!+#!\>/&/#+)#!R#C8'!6%!%+/@/.0!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!R8*%'./D#&/0.!T*@/./6('#(/;#!C!1'8&%686!C!6-6!>-.&/8.%6!6%!('#.6>/%'%.!#!+#!\>/&/#+)#!R#C8'<!#6)!&8@8!#!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!U%&-'686!H-@#.86F!

!]%'/;#*8!*%!+8!#.(%'/8'<!#+!_d!*%!#?86(8!*%!KLdd<!+#!%6('-&(-'#!8'?M./&#!3M6/&#!*%!+#!$,1!%.!6-!M@3/(8 !&%.('#+<!=-%*0!&8.>8'@#*#!78'!_K!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6<!&8.!d<_dK!7+#D#6!*%!@#.*8!C!%.+#&%!*%!#+(8 !./;%+!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*<!#6)!&8@8!ihO!7+#D#6!*%!%.+#&%!C!87%'#(/;#6<!A#& /%.*8!-.!(8(#+!*%!d<aaL!7+#D#6F!!9+!*8&-@%.(8!&/(#*8!7-%*%!6%'!&8.6-+(#*8!#!('#;V6!*%+!6/?-/%.(%!;).&-+8Y!!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/@#?%6Z*8&(86ZIUT^$1TU9^ENTZN.>8'@%6`*%`"#38'%6`9Zh(8`/.>8'@% +#38'%6`6>7F7*>!!1'8?'#@#!T.-#+!*%!E#7#&/(#&/0.Y!!9+!1'8?'#@#!T.-#+!*%!E#7#&/(#&/0.!*%!+#!N.6(/(-&/0.!*%3%'M!&8.6/*%'#'!#+!@%.86!+86!%+%@%.(86!6/?-/%.(%6Y!(

.U( T&&/8.%6!*%!E#7#&/(#&/0.Y!(

J=!]%!/.*-&&/0.<!=-%!68.!+#6!=-%!&8''%678.*%.!#!+#!>8'@#&/0.!C!&#7#&/(#&/0.!*%+!7%'68.#+!*%!.-%;8!/.?'%68<!=-%!/.&+-C#!#+!@%.86!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!6%!/.*/&#Y!/F! 1#'#!/.*-&&/0.!#!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+Y!

\'?#./D#&/0.!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B! U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6! #*@/./6('#(/;#6! *%! +86! 6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86<! *%!

&8.>8'@/*#*! &8.! +8! 7'%;/6(8! %.! +#! E8.6(/(-&/0.! 18+)(/&#! *%! +86! 96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86!C!%.!+#!+%C!*%!+#!@#(%'/#B!

I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!#&&%68!#!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!723+/&#!?-3%'.#@%.(#+<!&8.>8'@%!#!+#!+%?/6+#&/0.!;/?%.(%B!

9=-/*#*!*%!?V.%'8B!! ]%'%&A86!H-@#.86<!C!! 1'8*-&(/;/*#*B!

!//F! 1#'#!/.*-&&/0.!#!+#!N.6(/(-&/0.Y!

^#(-'#+%D#!:-')*/&#!*%!+#!N.6(/(-&/0.B! 96('-&(-'#!8'?M./&#B! R/6/0.<!;/6/0.<!83:%(/;86<!@%(#6<!#('/3-&/8.%6<!C! ]%'%&A86!C!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%+!7%'68.#+!%.!+#!N.6(/(-&/0.<!C!

Page 18: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 18 -

!///B' 1#'#!/.*-&&/0.!#+!7-%6(8Y!

96('-&(-'#!*%+!M'%#!8'?#./D#&/8.#+!*%! ('#3#:8!C!*%! +#6!M'%#6!&8.!+#6!=-%!%S/6(%!@#C8'!/.(%'#&&/0.!%.!'#D0.!*%+!7-%6(8B!

9+!83:%(/;8!?%.%'#+!C!@%(#6!*%+!7-%6(8B! T('/3-&/8.%6! *%+! M'%#! 8! +#! Q./*#*! #*@/./6('#(/;#! %.! =-%! 6%! %.&-%.('%!

#*6&'/(8!%+!7-%6(8!C!+#6!>-.&/8.%6!=-%!#!V6(%!&8''%678.*%.B! "-?#'!8!+-?#'%6!*%!('#3#:8!%.!=-%!6%!*%6#''8++#.!+#6!>-.&/8.%6!*%+!7-%6(8<!C! 9=-/78<! @83/+/#'/8! C! *%@M6! A%''#@/%.(#6! 8! 3/%.%6! *%! #78C8! 7#'#! %+!

*%6%@7%J8!*%+!7-%6(8F!!S=( ]%!>8'(#+%&/@/%.(8!*%+!*%6%@7%J8<!68.!+#6!=-%!&8''%678.*%.!#!+#!&#7#&/(#&/0.!7#'#!

'%>8'D#'<!&8@7+%@%.(#'!C!7%'>%&&/8.#'!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!+#6!>-.&/8.%6!*%+!7-%6(8B!!K=( ]%! #&(-#+/D#&/0.<! 68.! +#6! =-%! (/%.*%.! #! @#.(%.%'! ;/?%.(%6! +86! &8.8&/@/%.(86<!

A#3/+/*#*%6! C! #7(/(-*%6! =-%! %+! *%6%@7%J8! *%! +#6! >-.&/8.%6! *%+! 7-%6(8!%S/?%.!#+!6%';/*8'!723+/&8<!C!

!?=( ]%!*%6#''8++8<!68.!+#6!=-%!&8''%678.*%.!#!/.&'%@%.(#'!+86!&8.8&/@/%.(86<!A#3/+/*#*%6!C!

#7(/(-*%6!*%+!6%';/*8'!723+/&8<!&8.!%+!>/.!*%!7'%7#'#'+%!7#'#!#6-@/'!>-.&/8.%6!*%!@#C8'!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!C!&8@7+%:/*#*<!C!

!..U( "#6!#&&/8.%6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!78*'M.!'%;%6(/'!+#6!@8*#+/*#*%6!6/?-/%.(%6Y!!

J=( 1'%6%.&/#+B!!S=( T!*/6(#.&/#<!&8.!#78C8!*%!+86!6/6(%@#6!(%&.8+0?/&86!*/678./3+%6<!C!!K=( R/S(#<!+#!=-%!'%6-+(#!*%!+#!&8@3/.#&/0.!%.('%!+#!@8*#+/*#*!7'%6%.&/#+!C!#!*/6(#.&/#F!!

"#6!N.6(/(-&/8.%6!%.;/#'M.<!#!('#;V6!*%!+86!@%*/86!C!&8.!+#!7%'/8*/&/*#*!=-%!%6(#3+%D&#!+#!Q./*#*!7#'#!6-!'%?/6('8<!%+!1'8?'#@#!T.-#+!*%!E#7#&/(#&/0.<!+86!#;#.&%6!C!+86!'%6-+(#*86!83(%./*86F!

!"#6! #&&/8.%6! *%! &#7#&/(#&/0.!6%!%;#+-#'M.!#! ('#;V6!*%! +86! /.6('-@%.(86!8!@%&#./6@86!=-%!*%(%'@/.%.!+#6!N.6(/(-&/8.%6!7#'#!&#*#!(/78!*%!%;#+-#&/0.Y!!.U( ]%! '%#&&/0.Y! 1%'@/(%! &8.8&%'! +#! 7%'&%7&/0.! *%! +86! 7#'(/&/7#.(%6!683'%! +86!*/>%'%.(%6!

%+%@%.(86!=-%!/.(%?'#.!+#6!#&&/8.%6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.<!&8.!%+!>/.!*%!@%:8'#'<!('#.6>8'@#'!C!8'/%.(#'!+#!(8@#!*%!*%&/6/8.%6B!

!..U( ]%!#7'%.*/D#:%Y!b#+8'#!+86!&8.8&/@/%.(86<!A#3/+/*#*%6<!#7(/(-*%6!C!%.!6-!&#68!#&(/(-*%6!=-%!

786%%.!+86!7#'(/&/7#.(%6!683'%!+#!(%@M(/&#!;/.&-+#*#!&8.!%+!+8?'8!*%+!83:%(/;8!7'87-%6(8!7#'#!+#!#&&/0.!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!*%!=-%!6%!('#(%F!1-%*%!6%'!/./&/#+<!/.(%'@%*/#!8!>/.#+!*%7%.*/%.*8!*%+!@8@%.(8!%.!=-%!6%!&8.6/*%'%!&8.;%./%.(%!#7+/&#'<!C!

!...U( ]%! /@7#&(8!8! '%6-+(#*86Y!]%(%'@/.#!6/!-.#!#&&/0.!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!7'8*-:8!+86!%>%&(86!

*%6%#*86!%.! +86!7#'(/&/7#.(%6!8!%.! +86!7-%6(86<!M'%#6!8! N.6(/(-&/0.!#!+#!=-%!7%'(%.%&%F!TC-*#!#!&8.8&%'!6/!+#!#&&/0.!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!/@7#&(0!%.!%+!*%6%@7%J8!8!%.!%+!'%6-+(#*8!83(%./*8F!

!

Page 19: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 19 -

"#!%;#+-#&/0.!*%!+#!&#7#&/(#&/0.!*%3%!6#(/6>#&%'!+86!7'8706/(86!6/?-/%.(%6Y!!

.U( ]%(%'@/.#'!%.!=-V!@%*/*#!6%!&-@7+%.!+86!83:%(/;86!*%!#7'%.*/D#:%!*%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!=-%!6%!'%#+/D#.!%.!+#!N.6(/(-&/0.B!

(..U( 1'8;%%'!/.>8'@#&/0.!2(/+!7#'#!+#!*%(%&&/0.!*%!.%&%6/*#*%6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.<!#!('#;V6!*%!+86!

'%6-+(#*86!83(%./*86B!(...U( e'/.*#'! /.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!#&'%*/(%!=-%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!@#.(/%.%.!#&(-#+/D#*86!6-!

7%'>/+!C! +86!&8.8&/@/%.(86<!A#3/+/*#*%6<!#7(/(-*%6!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!#&(/(-*%6!'%=-%'/*#6!7#'#!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;86!7-%6(86<!C!

(.6U( E8.('/3-/'!#!+#!@%:8'#!*%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.<!#6)!&8@8!#!+#!@%:8'#!*%!+86!3/%.%6!8!

6%';/&/86!7'%6(#*86!78'!+#!N.6(/(-&/0.F!!

E8@8!7#'(%!*%+! '%>8'D#@/%.(8!683'%!%+! (%@#!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7'%;%.&/0.!C!&8@3#(%!#! +#!&8''-7&/0.<!6%!/.&+-C%'8.!%.!%+!1'8?'#@#!T.-#+!*%!E#7#&/(#&/0.!41TE5!*-'#.(%!%+!#J8!KLdd!%6(#6!>-%'8.!+#6!#&&/8.%6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!'%#+/D#*#6!78'!+#!$,1Y!!

T*@/./6('#&/0.!*%!'/%6?86F!!

E8.*-&(#!l(/&#!%.!%+!$%';/&/8!1-3+/&8!49.!&8+#38'#&/0.!&8.!+#!E^]H5F!!

E-+(-'#!*%!+#!"%?#+/*#*F!!

E-'68!N,TN! 683'%!('#.67#'%.&/#!C!+#!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#65F!!

I'#.67#'%.&/#<!1'%;%.&/0.!C!E8@3#(%!#!+#!E8''-7&/0.!!

O@@U *J(C @FLC>K@J(?C(MHEKC?@T@C>LEF(?EKBTC>LJ?EF(MJHJ(CD(?CFJHHEDDE(?C(DJF(LJHCJF8(E(?C(TJ>BJDCF(E(IBNJF(HCDJL@OJF(J(DJF(T@FTJFY(DJF(JKK@E>CF(?C(XEHLJDCK@T@C>LE(@>FL@LBK@E>JD(E(?C(TC[EHJT@C>LE(?C(KJD@?J?(@TMDCTC>LJ?JFY(P(DJ(@TMDCTC>LJK@G>(?C(F@FLCTJF(E(?C(LCK>EDEINJF(TE?CH>JF(MJHJ(XJK@D@LJH(CD(?CFJHHEDDE(?C(DJF(DJSEHCFU(

T!7#'(/'!*%!6%7(/%@3'%!*%!KLLP!6%!/./&/0!-.#!'%>8'@#!'%?-+#(8'/#!*%+!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+!&8.!%+!>/.!*%!>#&/+/(#'!+#!;/*#!*%!+86!&/-*#*#.86<!/.&'%@%.(#'!+#!&8@7%(/(/;/*#*!C!>#;8'%&%'!%+!*%6#''8++8!%&8.0@/&8!C!68&/#+!*%+!7#)6F!

G83/%'.8F!T!7#'(/'!*%!%6(%!/.;%.(#'/8!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!6%!*/8!#!+#!(#'%#!*%!/*%.(/>/&#'!+#!*-7+/&/*#*! *%! .8'@#6<! +86! 7'8&%686! C! #&(/;/*#*%6! /.%>/&/%.(%6<! +86! &86(86! %S&%6/;86! C! +86! ('M@/(%6!3-'8&'M(/&86!=-%!?%.%'#.!&86(86!/..%&%6#'/86!#+!&/-*#*#.8F!

U%6-+(#*8!*%!%6(#!(#+#!'%?-+#(8'/#<!6%!%+#38'#'8.!C!7-3+/&#'8.!<(5J>BJDCF!?C(&MD@KJK@G>(3C>CHJD<!&8.!%+!7'8706/(8!*%!87(/@/D#'!+#!87%'#&/0.!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!!&8.>8'@%!+#!,/?-'#!dF!

!

!

Page 20: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 20 -

+@IBHJ(b\(5J>BJDCF(?C(&MD@KJK@G>(3C>CHJD(

!

9.!%+!@#'&8!*%!%6(#!%6('#(%?/#<!%+!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+!A#!+8?'#*8!'%*-&/'!+#!.8'@#(/;/*#*!/.(%'.#!#*@/./6('#(/;#!7#'#!87%'#'!#6)<!&8.!+#6!.8'@#6!@)./@#6!6->/&/%.(%6!%.!+#6!@#(%'/#6!*%!T*=-/6/&/8.%6<!T''%.*#@/%.(86!C!$%';/&/86!*%+!$%&(8'!1'/;#*8B!\3'#6!123+/&86!C!$%';/&/86!U%+#&/8.#*86!&8.!+#6!@/6@#6B!U%&-'686!H-@#.86B!U%&-'686!,/.#.&/%'86B!U%&-'686!R#(%'/#+%6B!I%&.8+8?)#6!*%! +#!N.>8'@#&/0.!C!*%!+#6!E8@-./&#&/8.%6B!I'#.67#'%.&/#B!T-*/(8'/#B!C!E8.('8+!N.(%'.8F!!

"86! P! /.6('-@%.(86! 7-3+/&#*86! %.! %+! ]/#'/8! \>/&/#+! *%! +#! ,%*%'#&/0.! 7#'#! #&(-#+/D#'! +86! R#.-#+%6!T*@/./6('#(/;86!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!68.Y!!

! 5JLCH@J( .>FLHBTC>LE(

d! T-*/(8'/#!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!@8*/>/&#!%+!]/;%'68!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%6(#3+%&%.!+#6!]/6786/&/8.%6!G%.%'#+%6!7#'#!+#!U%#+/D#&/0.!*%!T-*/(8')#6<!U%;/6/8.%6!

C!b/6/(#6!*%!/.67%&&/0.F!

K! T*=-/6/&/8.%6!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!@8*/>/&#!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!T*=-/6/&/8.%6<!T''%.*#@/%.(86!C!$%';/&/86!*%+!

$%&(8'!123+/&8F!

_! \3'#6!123+/&#6!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!@8*/>/&#!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!\3'#6!123+/&#6!C!$%';/&/86!U%+#&/8.#*86!&8.!+#6!

@/6@#6F!

i! E8.('8+!N.(%'.8!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!@8*/>/&#!%+!]/;%'68!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%@/(%.!+#6!]/6786/&/8.%6!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!E8.('8+!N.(%'.8!C!6%!%S7/*%!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!E8.('8+!N.(%'.8F!

Page 21: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 21 -

h! U%&-'686!,/.#.&/%'86! T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%@/(%!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!U%&-'686!,/.#.&/%'86F!

g! U%&-'686!R#(%'/#+%6! T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!'%>8'@#!%+!]/;%'68!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%6(#3+%&%.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!U%&-'686!R#(%'/#+%6!C!$%';/&/86!G%.%'#+%6F!

a! I'#.67#'%.&/#!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!#*/&/8.#!C!'%>8'@#!%+!]/;%'68!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%@/(/0!

%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#F!

O! U%&-'686!H-@#.86!

1'8C%&(8!*%!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!#&(-#+/D#!%+!]/;%'68!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%@/(%.!+#6!]/6786/&/8.%6!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!1+#.%#&/0.<!\'?#./D#&/0.!C!

T*@/./6('#&/0.!*%!+86!U%&-'686!H-@#.86<!#6)!&8@8!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!*/&A#!@#(%'/#B!C!6%!%S7/*%!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%+!$/6(%@#!*%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#!

%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!E%.('#+/D#*#F!

P! I%&.8+8?)#6!*%!+#!N.>8'@#&/0.!

1'8C%&(8!*%!T&-%'*8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!@8*/>/&#!%+!]/;%'68!78'!%+!=-%!6%!%S7/*%!%+!R#.-#+!T*@/./6('#(/;8!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!%.!R#(%'/#!*%!I%&.8+8?)#6!*%!+#!N.>8'@#&/0.!C!E8@-./&#&/8.%6<!C!6%!%6(#3+%&/%'8.!+#6!

*/6786/&/8.%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!%.!%6#!@#(%'/#F!

"86! P!R#.-#+%6!T*@/./6('#(/;86!*%!T7+/&#&/0.!G%.%'#+!7-%*%.!6%'!&8.6-+(#*86!#! ('#;V6!*%+! 6/?-/%.(%!;).&-+8Y!!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z7'8?'#@#6Z@#.-#+%6!

(

O@@@U *J(TJ>CHJ(C>( DJ(ABC(FC(DC(FBT@>@FLHJ(J(DEF(K@B?J?J>EF(@>XEHTJK@G>(JKCHKJ(?C(FBF(ES[CL@OEF(P(XB>K@E>CFY(FC(DCF(?J>(J(KE>EKCH(DEF(MHEKC?@T@C>LEF(CFLJSDCK@?EF(MJHJ(CD(KBTMD@T@C>LE(?C(FBF(XB>K@E>CFY(P(FC(DCF(EH@C>LJ(JKCHKJ(?C(KGTE(HCJD@iJH(ICFL@E>CF(J>LC(DEF(T@FTEFU(

9+!#'()&-+8!a!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!T&&%68!#!+#!N.>8'@#&/0.!123+/&#!G-3%'.#@%.(#+<!6%J#+#!+#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!=-%!+86!6-:%(86!83+/?#*86!49+!18*%'!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#5<!*%3%.!78.%'!#!*/6786/&/0.!*%+!723+/&8!C!#&(-#+/D#'F!"#!/.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!*/&A8!#'()&-+8!6%J#+#!&8@8!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#!%6!+#!6/?-/%.(%Y!!

.U $-!%6('-&(-'#!8'?M./&#B!!

..U "#6!XJKBDLJ?CF!*%!&#*#!-./*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#B!

...U 9+!*/'%&(8'/8!*%!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!*%6*%!%+!./;%+!*%!:%>%!*%!*%7#'(#@%.(8!8!6-6!%=-/;#+%.(%6B!

.6U "#! '%@-.%'#&/0.!@%.6-#+!78'!7-%6(8<! /.&+-68!%+! 6/6(%@#!*%!&8@7%.6#&/8.%6<!6%?2.!+8!%6(#3+%D&#.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6B!

6U 9+!*8@/&/+/8!*%!+#!Q./*#*!*%!9.+#&%<!#*%@M6!*%!+#!*/'%&&/0.!%+%&('0./&#!*8.*%!78*'M.!'%&/3/'6%!+#6!68+/&/(-*%6!7#'#!83(%.%'!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.B!

6.U "#6!TCLJF(P(ES[CL@OEF!*%!+#6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.!6-6!

Page 22: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 22 -

7'8?'#@#6!87%'#(/;86B!!6..U "86!6%';/&/86!=-%!8>'%&%.B!!6...U "86!LHQT@LCF8(HCAB@F@LEF(P(XEHTJLEF !.]U "#! /.>8'@#&/0.!683'%!%+!7'%6-7-%6(8!#6/?.#*8<!#6)!&8@8!+86!/.>8'@%6!683'%!6-!

%:%&-&/0.! %.! +86! (V'@/.86! =-%! %6(#3+%D&#! %+! 1'%6-7-%6(8! *%! 9?'%686! *%! +#!!

]U "86! '%6-+(#*86! *%! +#6! #-*/(8')#6! #+! %:%'&/&/8! 7'%6-7-%6(#+! *%! &#*#! 6-:%(8!!

].U 9+!*/6%J8<!%:%&-&/0.<!@8.(86!#6/?.#*86!C!&'/(%'/86!*%!#&&%68!#!+86!7'8?'#@#6!*%!!

]..U !]...U !].6U !]6U !]6.U 9.!6-!&#68<!+86!@%&#./6@86!*%!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!&/-*#*#.#<!C!!]6..U !

"#!/.>8'@#&/0.!483+/?#&/8.%6!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#5!*%!+#!$,1!7-%*%!6%'!&8.6-+(#*#!%.!%+!6/?-/%.(%!;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ78'(#+('#.67#'%.&/#F?83F@SZ78(Z*%7%.*%.&/#Z6A8[]%7%.*%.&/#F*8m@%(A8*n3%?/.o'%*/'%&&/8.#*8n('-%o`/*]%7%.*%.&/#nLLLKa!!

T*/&/8.#+@%.(%<! +86! ('M@/(%6! C! 6%';/&/86! *%! +#! $,1! 7-%*%.! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*86! %.! %+! 6/?- /%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z('#@/(%6XCX6%';/&/86FA(@+!!!

!

@ U *EF(TCKJ>@FTEF(?C(KE>LHED(@>LCH>E(P(?C(JLC>K@G>(?C(HCKDJTEF8(ABC[JF(E(?C>B>K@JF(HCDJK@E>J?JF(KE>(CD(KBTMD@T@C>LE(?C(FBF(ES[CL@OEF(P(KE>(CD(?CFCTMCRE(?CD(MCHFE>JD(J(FB(FCHO@K@EU((

]%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.!+8!*/67-%6(8!%.!+86!#'()&-+86!iL!C!ii!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$,1<!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!T*:-.(#!*%!p-%:#6<!]%.-.&/#6!%!N.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!4]GTp]N5!*%!+#!E8.('#+8')#!N.(%'.#!*%!+#!$,1!(/%.%!#('/3-&/8.%6!7#'#!&8.8&%'!683'%Y!!

NF p-%:#6! C! *%.-.&/#6! =-%! 6%! 7'%6%.(%.! 78'! A%&A86! 7'%6-.(#@%.(%! /''%?-+#'%6! #('/3-/3+%6! #!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!#*6&'/(86!#!%6(#!]%7%.*%.&/#!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!*%.('8!*%!+86!=-%!6%!%.&-%.('#.!+86!I /(-+#'%6!*%!+86!W'?#.86!N.(%'.86!*%!E8.('8+!C!6-6!M'%#6!! '%67%&(/;#6<!*%6/?.#*86! %.! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+! C! *%! +#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!#6)!&8@8!*%!6-!W'?#.8!]%6&8.&%.('#*8<!%+!N^]TTeN^F!

NNF N.&8.>8'@/*#*%6!=-%!6%!>8'@-+%.!78'!#&(86!-!8@/6/8.%6!*%!+86!E8@/(V6!*%!1'8>%6/8.#+/D#&/0.!C!*%!$%+%&&/0.!*%+!$/6(%@#!*%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#!%.!+#!T1,F!

NNNF 1'8@8;%'!%+!%6(#3+%&/@/%.(8!*%!#&&/8.%6!=-%!&8#*C-;%.!#+!@%:8'#@/%.(8!*%!+#!?%6(/0.!%.!+#6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!8!*%!6-!0'?#.8!*%6&8.&%.('#*8F!

9+!7'8&%*/@/%.(8!7#'#!+#!#(%.&/0.!*%!=-%:#6!C!*%.-.&/#6!%6!%+!6/?-/%.(%Y!!

dFX!$%!'%&/3%!+#!=-%:#!8!*%.-.&/#F!

KFX!$%!+%!#6/?.#!.2@%'8!*%!%S7%*/%.(%!4&8.('8+!/.(%'.85F!

Page 23: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 23 -

_FX!$%!#6/?.#!%+!%S7%*/%.(%!#+!#38?#*8!%.!(-'.8!7#'#!%+!('M@/(%!&8''%678.*/%.(%F!

iFX! $%! '%#+/D#! %+! #.M+/6/6! /./&/#+!7#'#!*%(%'@/.#'! +#!&8@7%(%.&/#!C!%.!6-!&#68!%+! /./&/8!*%! +#!/.;%6(/?#&/0.F! !

iFdF!$%!*%(%'@/.#!6/!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%.-.&/#*86!68.!*%+!M@3/(8!*%!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!%6(#!T-(8'/*#*!T*@/./6('#(/;#B!*%!.8!6%'!#6)!6%!%@/(%!-.!#&-%'*8!*%!/.&8@7%(%.&/#!C!6%!8'*%.#!6-!'%@/6/0.!#!+#!#-(8'/*#*!>#&-+(#*#!7#'#!&8.8&%'!*%+!#6-.(8F!

iFKF!$/!*%+!%6(-*/8!%>%&(-#*8!6%!#*;/%'(%!=-%!.8!6%!&-%.(#!&8.!%+%@%.(86!6->/&/%.(%6!7#'#!78*%'! %6(#3+%&%'! +).%#6! *%! /.;%6(/?#&/0.<! 6%! +%! '%=-/%'%! #+! 7'8@8;%.(%! 7'%&/6%! +#6!&/'&-.6(#.&/#6!*%!+86!A%&A86!=-%!(/+*#!*%!/''%?-+#'%6B!6/!.8!+86!7'878'&/8.#!6%!%@/(%!-.!#&-%'*8!*%!.8!/./&/8!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/0.F!

iF_F!$/!+#!=-%:#!CZ8!*%.-.&/#!!&8.(/%.%!%+%@%.(86!*%!&8.;/&&/0.!=-%!/.>/%'#.!+#!7'%6-.(#!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#!*%+!6%';/*8'!723+/&8!*%.-.&/#*8<!#6)!&8@8!%.!+86!&#686!%.!+86!=-%!6%!'%=-/'/%'8.!@#C8'%6!*#(86!*%!+86!A%&A86!*%.-.&/#*86<!6%!!%@/(%!#&-%'*8!*%!/./&/8!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/0.<!%.!%+!&-#+!6%!8'*%.#!+#!&+#6/>/&#&/0.!*%!'%6%';#!%.!(V'@/.86!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!T&&%68!#!+#!N.>8'@#&/0.!123+/&#!G-3%'.#@%.(#+B!#6)!&8@8!+#!.8(/>/&#&/0.!#+!7'8@8;%.(%F!

iFiF!$%!?/'#.! +86!8>/&/86!*%!68+/&/(-*!*%! /.>8'@#&/0.!7#'#!#++%?#'6%!*%! +86!%+%@%.(86!.%&%6#'/86!7#'#!*%(%'@/.#'!+#!%S/6(%.&/#!8!.8!*%!-.#!7'%6-.(#!&8.*-&(#!/''%?-+#'F!!

iFhF!$%!'%#+/D#!%+!#.M+/6/6!*%!+86!%+%@%.(86!=-%!/.(%?'#.!%+!%S7%*/%.(%!7#'#!*%(%'@/.#'!6/!6%!%.&-%.('#!*%3/*#@%.(%!/.(%?'#*#!+#!/.*#?#(8'/#!7#'#!%.!6-!&#68<!8'*%.#'!%+!&/%''%!*%!+#!@/6@#!C!%@/(/'!%+!#&-%'*8!&8''%678.*/%.(%<!@/6@8!=-%!6%!.8(/>/&#!#+!7'8@8;%.(%F!

iFhFdF!$/!*%+!%6(-*/8!*%!+#6!&8.6(#.&/#6!&8.(%./*#6!%.!%+!6-@#'/8!6%!#*;/%'(%!=-%!.8!A#C!%+%@%.(86!3#6(#.(%6<!/*0.%86!C!6->/&/%.(%6!=-%!6-6(%.(%.!-.#!7'%6-.(#!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#!'%7'8&A#3+%!#+!*%.-.&/#*8<!6%!&8.&+-C%!@%*/#.(%!-.!#&-%'*8!*%!#'&A/;8!78'!>#+(#!*%!%+%@%.(86F!

iFhFKF!$/!*%!+#!'%;/6/0.!6%!*%67'%.*%.!%+%@%.(86!3#6(#.(%6<!/*0.%86!C!6->/&/%.(%6!=-%!7'%6-@#.!+#!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#!*%+!6%';/*8'!723+/&8!*%.-.&/#*8<!%+!#6-.(8!6%!&8.&+-C%!&8.!#&-%'*8!*%!(-'.8!#+!q'%#!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!7#'#!=-%! %6(#! #! 6-! ;%D<! *%! &8.6/*%'#'+8! 7'8&%*%.(%<! /./&/%! %+! 7'8&%*/@/%.(8!#*@/./6('#(/;8! */6&/7+/.#'/8! 7'%;/6(8! %.! %+! #'()&-+8! Kd! *%! +#! "%C! ,%*%'#+! *%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86F!

R%&#./6@86!*%!&8.('8+!/@7+%@%.(#*86!%.!+#!]GTp]N!7#'#!%+!6%?-/@/%.(8!*%!=-%:#6!C!*%.-.&/#6Y!

9.!%+!M'%#!6%! ++%;#!7#'#!%+! &8.('8+!*%! +#!#6/?.#&/0.!C! ('M@/(%!*%! +86!#6-.(86<!-.#!3#6%!*%!*#(86! %.!%+!7'8?'#@#!9S&%+<!=-%!6%!#&(-#+/D#!*/#'/#@%.(%<!#6)!&8@8!%+!$/6(%@#!N.(%?'#+!*%!T(%.&/0.!E/-*#*#.#!4$NTE5<!%.!%+!&-#+!6%!&#7(-'#.!+86!*#(86!'%+#&/8.#*86!&8.!%+!=-%:868<!*%.-.&/#*8<!+86!A%&A86<!%+!%6(#*8!7'8&%6#+!=-%!?-#'*#!%+!%S7%*/%.(%<!6-!&8.&+-6/0.<!.8(/>/&#&/8.%6!C!6%?-/@/%.(8F!

!

!

!

Page 24: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 24 -

U *J(TJ>CHJ(C>(DJ(ABC(FC(IJHJ>L@iJ>(DEF(HCKBHFEF(MHCFBMBCFLJDCF(>CKCFJH@EF(MJHJ(FB(XB>K@E>JT@C>LEU((

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e/3+/8Z7*>Z",1UHF7*>!

(

@U #BJ>?E(KEHHCFME>?J8(DEF(TCKJ>@FTEF(?C(KEEH?@>JK@G>(MJHJ(JHTE>@iJH(FBF(XB>K@E>CF(KE>(DJF(?C(ELHEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(E(ME?CHCF(MgSD@KEF(P(MJHJ(ESLC>CH(CD(JMEPE(?C(ELHJF(JBLEH@?J?CF(P(?C(DJ(K@B?J?J>NJ(MJHJ(CD(KJSJD(KBTMD@T@C>LE(?C(FBF(XB>K@E>CFU(

$83'%! %6(%!7#'(/&-+#'<! 6%!#&+#'#!=-%! +#!%;#+-#&/0.!C!6-7%';/6/0.!*%+! &8.('8+! /.(%'.8!683'%! +86!18*%'%6!"%?/6+#(/;8!C!f-*/&/#+<!*#*#!+#!*/;/6/0.!*%!78*%'%6!=-%!%6(#3+%&%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!%.!6-!#'()&-+8!iP<!#6)!&8@8!*%!+86!8'?#./6@86!#-(0.8@86!>%*%'#+%6!X/.&+-C%.*8!+8!'%+#(/;8!#+!'%?/6('8!7#('/@8./#+X<!6%!'%#+/D#!78'!6-6!7'87/86!8'?#./6@86!/.(%'.86!6/.!/.(%';%.&/0.!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#F!!

^8!836(#.(%!+8!#.(%'/8'<!A#3')#!=-%!&8.6/*%'#'!=-%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'# +<!%.!6-!#'()&-+8!_a<!>'#&&/0.!cNNN<!+%!&8.>/%'%!#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!+#!>#&-+(#*!*%!& 8+#38'#'!&8.!+#!E8.(#*-')#!R#C8'!*%!H#&/%.*#!C2#E'G18/$#*6%'?1>+*/#*'8+'4%'9+8+*%./:-C<!7#'#!%+!%6(#3+%&/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!.%&%6#'/86!=-%!7%'@/(#.!#!#@386!0'?#.86!%+!@%:8'! &-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6<!78'!+8!=-%!%.!&-@7+/@/%.(8!#!%6(%!6-7-%6(8<!%+!7#6#*8!O!*%!@#C8!*%!KLLd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h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e/3+/8Z*8&ZKiLF*8&<!%.!6-!#'()&-+8!O<!>'#&&/0.!cbN<!%6(#3+%&%!+#!83+/?#&/0.!*%!(8*86!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!#(%.*%'!&8.!*/+/?%.&/#!+#6!/.6('-&&/8.%6<!'%=-%'/@/%.(86!8!'%68+-&/8.%6!=-%!'%&/3#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#<!*%+!&8.('#+8'!/.(%'.8!8!*%!+86!(/(-+#'%6!*%!+#6!M'%#6!*%!#-*/(8')#<!*%!=-%:#6!C!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6<!&8.>8'@%!#!+#!&8@7%(%.&/#!*%!V6(86<!%.!&8.?'-%.&/#!&8.!+#6!A/70(%6/6!7'%;/6(#6!%.!%+!#'()&-+8!KL!*%!%6%!@/6@8!8'*%.#@/%.(86F!!T6/@/6@8<! +86!#'()&-+86!__!#!id!*%!+#!"%C!*%!1+#.%#&/0.<!&8.(%@7+#.!+#!786/3/+/*#*!*%!=-%!%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+! 6-6&'/3#!&8.;%./86!*%!&88'*/.#&/0.!&8.! +86!?83/%'.86!*%! +#6!%.(/*#*%6! >%*%'#(/;#6!7#'#!=-%!7#'(/&/7%.!%.!+#!7+#.%#&/0.!.#&/8.#+!*%+!*%6#''8++8!C!=-%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!#!'%#+/D#'6%!78'!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!C!+86!96(#*86<!6%!7+#.%%.!*%!@#.%'#!&8.:-.(#!#6)!&8@8!7#'#!=-%!%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!78'!6)!8!#!('#;V6!*%!6-6!*%7%.*%.&/#6<!C!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!7#'#%6(#(#+%6<!&8.&%'(%.!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!7'%;/6(#6!%.!%+!1+#.!

Page 25: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 25 -

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e/3+/8Z*8&ZhPF*8& Y!!

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i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bF!"#!%+#38'#&/0.!*%!+86!7'8?'#@#6!'%?/8.#+%6!#!=-%!6%!'%>/%'%!+#!>'#&&/0.!NNN!*%+!T'()& -+8!di!*%!%6(%!8'*%.#@/%.(8B!C!b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hFX!9.!+#!&%+%3'#&/0.!*%!+86!&8.;%./86!#!=-%!6%!'%>/%'%!%6(%!&#7)(-+8<!%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+!*%>/./'M!+#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!*%!+86!0'?#.86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!&%.('#+/D#*#!=-%!#&(2%.!%.!+#6!%.(/*#*%6!>%*%'#(/;#6<!%.!+#6!#&(/;/*#*%6!*%!7+#.%#&/0.!=-%!'%#+/&%.!+86!'%67%&(/;86!?83/%'.86!*%!+#6!%.(/*#*%6F!!

Page 26: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 26 -

T'()&-+8! _gFX! 9+! 9:%&-(/;8! ,%*%'#+! 8'*%.#'M! +#! 7-3+/&#&/0.<! %.! %+! ]/#'/8! \>/&/#+!*%! +#!,%*%'#&/0.<! *%! +86! &8.;%./86! =-%! 6%! 6-6&'/3#.! &8.! +86! ?83/%'.86! *%! +#6!%.(/*#*%6!>%*%'#(/;#6F!!!T'()&-+8!_a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i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idFX! "#6! 78+)(/&#6! =-%! .8'@%.! %+! %:%'&/&/8! *%! +#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!=-%! +#6! +%C%6!&8.>/%'#.! #+! 9:%&-(/;8! ,%*%'#+! 7#'#! >8@%.(#'<! 7'8@8;%'<! '%?-+#'<! '%6('/.?/'<! 8'/%.(#'<!7'8A/3/'<!C<!%.!?%.%'#+<!/.*-&/'!#&&/8.%6!*%!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!%.!@#(%'/#!%&8.0@/&#<!68&/#+!C!#@3/%.(#+<!6%!#:-6(#'M.!#!+86!83:%(/ !!(

@@U *EF(TCKJ>@FTEF(?C(HC>?@K@G>(?C(KBC>LJF(FESHC(CD(KBTMD@T@C>LE(?C(FBF(XB>K@E>CFY(DJ(TJ>CHJ( C>( DJ( ABC( FC( HCKEM@DJ(P(MHEKCFJ( DJ( @>XEHTJK@G>(>CKCFJH@J(MJHJ(CFLEY(P( DJ(@>XEHTJK@G>(CT@L@?J(KE>(LJD(MHEMGF@LE(P(DJ(XEHTJ(C>(ABC(ZFLJ(FC(hJKC(MgSD@KJ(P(ABC(DEF(K@B?J?J>EF(MBC?C>(LC>CH(JKKCFE(J(DJ(T@FTJU(

9+!#'()&-+8!a!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!T&&%68!#!+#!N.>8'@#&/0.!123+/&#!G-3%'.#@%.(#+<!6%J#+#!+#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!=-%!+86!6-:%(86!83+/?#*86!49+!18*%'!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#5<!*%3%.!78.%'!#!*/6786/&/0.!*%+!723+/&8!C!#&(-#+/D#'F!"#!/.>8'@#&/0.!=-%!*/&A8!#'()&-+8!6%J#+#!&8@8!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#!%6!+#!6/?-/%.(%Y!!

Page 27: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 27 -

.U $-!%6('-&(-'#!8'?M./&#B!!

..U "#6!XJKBDLJ?CF!*%!&#*#!-./*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#B!

...U 9+!*/'%&(8'/8!*%!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!*%6*%!%+!./;%+!*%!:%>%!*%!*%7#'(#@%.(8!8!6-6!%=-/;#+%.(%6B!

.6U "#! '%@-.%'#&/0.!@%.6-#+!78'!7-%6(8<! /.&+-68!%+! 6/6(%@#!*%!&8@7%.6#&/8.%6<!6%?2.!+8!%6(#3+%D&#.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6B!

6U 9+!*8@/&/+/8!*%!+#!Q./*#*!*%!9.+#&%<!#*%@M6!*%!+#!*/'%&&/0.!%+%&('0./&#!*8.*%!78*'M.!'%&/3/'6%!+#6!68+/&/(-*%6!7#'#!83(%.%'!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.B!

6.U "#6!TCLJF(P(ES[CL@OEF!*%!+#6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.!6-6!7'8?'#@#6!87%'#(/;86B!!

6..U "86!6%';/&/86!=-%!8>'%&%.B!!6...U "86!LHQT@LCF8(HCAB@F@LEF(P(XEHTJLEF !.]U "#! /.>8'@#&/0.!683'%!%+!7'%6-7-%6(8!#6/?.#*8<!#6)!&8@8!+86!/.>8'@%6!683'%!6-!

%:%&-&/0.! %.! +86! (V'@/.86! =-%! %6(#3+%D&#! %+! 1'%6-7-%6(8! *%! 9?'%686! *%! +#!!

]U "86! '%6-+(#*86! *%! +#6! #-*/(8')#6! #+! %:%'&/&/8! 7'%6-7-%6(#+! *%! &#*#! 6-:%(8!!

].U 9+!*/6%J8<!%:%&-&/0.<!@8.(86!#6/?.#*86!C!&'/(%'/86!*%!#&&%68!#!+86!7'8?'#@#6!*%!!

]..U !]...U !].6U 9+!@#'& !]6U !]6.U 9.!6-!&#68<!+86!@%&#./6@86!*%!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!&/-*#*#.#<!C!!]6..U !

"#!/.>8'@#&/0.!483+/?#&/8.%6!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#5!*%!+#!$,1!7-%*%!6%'!&8.6-+(#*#!%.!% +!6/?-/%.(%!;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ78'(#+('#.67#'%.&/#F?83F@SZ78(Z*%7%.*%.&/#Z6A8[]%7%.*%.&/#F*8m@%(A8*n3%?/.o'%*/'%&&/8.#*8n('-%o`/*]%7%.*%.&/#nLLLKa!!

E8.! >-.*#@%.(8!%.! +8!*/67-%6(8!78'! +86!#'()&-+86!P_!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86<!K_!*%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!Ok!*%!+#!"%C!*%!1+#.%#&/0.<!+#!$,1!%+#38'#!C!7'%6%.(#!#.-#+@%.(%!6-!N.>8'@%!*%!"#38'%6F!]/&A8!/.>8'@%!%6(M!%6('-&(-'#*8!*%!#&-%'*8!&8.!+86!83:%(/;86!C!%6('#(%?/#6!*%!+86!&/.&8!%:%6!*%!78+)(/&#!723+/&#!%6(#3+%&/*86!%.!%+!1+#.!^#&/8.#+!*%!]%6#''8++8!KLLaXKLdK!C!*%!+86!83:%(/;86!%6('#(V?/&86!*%!+#!$,1F!!!"86! /.>8'@%6! *%! +#38'%6! *%! +#! $,1! 7-%*%.! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*86! #! ('#;V6! *%+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z('#.67#'%.&/#Z/.>8'@#&/8.X*/;%'6#Z/.>8'@%6X*%X+#38'%6XCX*%X%:%&-&/8.FA(@+!!T*/&/8.#+@%.(%!C!#.(%!%+!&/%''%!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!KLLgXKLdK<!%+!7#6#*8!dh!*%!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLdd<!%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+!7-3+/&0!%.!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!%+!G.1+*8#'>%*%'4%'K+-8/./:-'8+'51+-$%)'8+'4%'G8D/-/)$*%./:-' @A<4/.%' 9+8+*%4' LMMNCLMOLF! 9+! T&-%'*8! (/%.%!78'!83:%(8!%6(#3+%&%'! +#6!3#6%6!=-%! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!*%3%'M.!836%';#'!7#'#!+#!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!KLLgXKLdK!C!7#'#!+#!%.('%?#X'%&%7&/0.!*%!+86!#6-.(86!#!6-!&#'?8!#!+#!6/?-/%.(%!?%6(/0.!?-3%'.#@%.(#+<!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!=-%!+#!@/6@#!6%!'%#+/&%!*%!@#.%'#!8'*%.#*#<!('#.67#'%.(%<!&8.>/#3+%<!878'(-.#!C!A8@8?V.%#<!C!7%'@/(#!*#'!&8.(/.-/*#*!#!+86!6%';/&/86!C!>-.&/8.%6!?-3%'.#@%.(#+%6!#6)!&8@8!#!+86!7'8?'#@#6!C!7'8C%&(86!#!6-!&#'?8F!!

Page 28: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 28 -

"#6! */6786/&/8.%6! %6(#3+%&/*#6!%.!%6(%!T&-%'*8!7#'#! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!*%! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&# !,%*%'#+<! 6%'M.!#7+/&#3+%6!#!6-6!0'?#.86!#*@/./6('#(/;86!*%6&8.&%.('#*86<!#6)!&8@ 8!#!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!

!9+!T&-%'*8!6%J#+#!=-%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!%+#38'#'M.!-.!/.>8'@%!*%!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!KLLgXKLdK<!%+!&-#+!&8.(%.*'M!+#6!#&&/8.%6!'%#+/D#*#6!*-'#.(%!*/&A#!?%6(/0.<!&8.>8'@%!#!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!#7#'(#*86Y!

!.U!9+!@#'&8!:-')*/&8!*%!#&(-#&/0.!&8.>8'@%!#!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86<! +%C%6<! '%?+#@%.(86<!*%&'%(86<!#&-%'*86<!#&(86!:-')*/&86!*%!&'%#&/0.B!'%?+#6!*%!87%'#&/0.<!C!*%@M6!*/6786/&/8.%6!;/?%.(%6!=-%!'%6-+(%.!#7+/&#3+%6B!#6)!&8@8!@#.-#+%6!*%!8'?#./D#&/0.<!*%!7'8&%*/@/%.(86<!*%!('M@/(%6!C!6%';/&/86!#+!723+/&8<!8!*%!&-#+=-/%'!8('8!(/78B!..U("#6!#&&/8.%6!C!+86!'%6-+(#*86!'%+%;#.(%6!83(%./*86!*-'#.(%!%+!7%'/8*8!&8@7'%.*/*8!*%+!d!*%!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLLg!#+!_L!*%!.8;/%@3'%!*%!KLdK<! '%67%&(8!*%! +86!7'8?'#@#6<!7'8C%&(86!C!#6-.(86!*%!6-!&8@7%(%.&/#B!...U("86!'%&-'686!>/.#.&/%'86<!/.?'%686!C!%?'%686<!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!#!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLLg!C!#!+86!%:%'&/&/86!*%!KLLa<!KLLO<!KLLP<!KLdL<!KLdd!C!A#6(#!%+!_L!*%!.8;/%@3'%!*%!KLdK<!&8.!3#6%!%.!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!'%78'(#*#!%.!+#6!&-%.(#6!723+/&#6!*%!+86!#J86!KLLg!#!KLdd<!#6)!&8@8!%.!%+!N.>8'@%!*%!T;#.&%!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!,/.#.&/%'#!7#'#!%+!#J8!KLd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dKB!6..U("#6!#&&/8.%6!'%#+/D#*#6!C!+86!'%6-+(#*86!83(%./*86!%.!%+!@#'&8!*%+!1'8?'#@#!^#&/8.#+!*%!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6<!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!E8@3#(%!#!+#!E8''-7&/0.<!KLLOXKLd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

9+! *8&-@%.(8! &/(#*8! 7-%*%! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*8! #! ('#;V6! *%+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F.8'@#(%&#F?83F@SZT'&A/;86Zgh`]`KPiK`L_XLdXKLdKF7*>!

!

D) #E>(HCFMCKLE(J(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(FCDCKK@E>J?EF(C>(DJ(HCFMBCFLJ(J( DJ(MHCIB>LJ(2=8( @>XEHTC(F@>LZL@KJTC>LC(FESHC( DEF( HCFBDLJ?EF(ABC(hJ>(ESLC>@?E(C>(CD(KBTMD@T@C>LE(?C(FBF(XB>K@E>CF8(FBT@>@FLHJ>?E(DJ(@>XEHTJK@G>(MCHL@>C>LC(?C(DJ(ABC(?@FME>IJ(FB(MJNF(P(HCX@H@Z>?EFC(C>(DE(MEF@SDC(J(JFMCKLEF(LJDCF(KETE(DEF(F@IB@C>LCF\((

/F $/!%+!'%67%&(/;8!0'?#.8!(/%.%!>-.&/8.%6!*%!7'%;%.&/0.!*%!+#6!7'M&(/&#6!&8''-7(#6<!'%+#&/8.%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!=-%!%.!+86!2+(/@86!&/.&8!#J86!6%!A#C#.!*%6#''8++#*8!7#'#!7'%;%./'!*/&A#6!7'M&(/&#6<!(#+%6! &8@8! &#@7#J#6! *%! */;-+?#&/0.! *%! +#6! &8.6%&-%.&/#6! =-%! +#6!@/6@#6!#&#''%#.B!

Page 29: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 29 -

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

"D(0HEIHJTJ(-JK@E>JD(?C($C>?@K@G>(?C(#BC>LJF8(%HJ>FMJHC>K@J(P(#ETSJLC(J(DJ(#EHHBMK@G>(c``fac`bc(!

9+!P!*%!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLLO<!%.!%+!@#'&8!*%+!])#!N.(%'.#&/8.#+!&8.('#!+#!E8''-7&/0.<!%+!G83/%'.8!,%*%'#+!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!$,1!7'%6%.(0!%+!1'8?'#@#!^#&/8.#+!*%!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6<!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!E8@3#(%!#!+#!E8''-7&/0.!KLLOXKLdK!41^UEIEE5F!9+!1^UEIEE!%6!-.#!7'8?'#@#!*%!&#'M&(%'!%67%&/#+!C!*%!836%';#.&/#!83+/?#(8'/#!7#'#!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!7#'#!?%.%'#'!-.#!&-+(-'#!68&/#+!*%!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6<!&8@3#(%!#! +#!&8''-7&/0.!C!#7%?8!#! +#! +%?#+/*#*<!#!7#'(/'!*%! +#! ('#.6>8'@#&/0.!*%!7'8&%686!*%+!7'87/8!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+!C!*%!+#!'%*%>/./&/0.!*%!+#6!'%+#&/8.%6!%.('%!%+!96(#*8!C!+#!68&/%*#*F!!

!9+!1^UEIEE! (/%.%!6%/6!83:%(/;86!=-%!&8.('/3-C%.!#+! +8?'8!*%!+86!83:%(/;86!C!+).%#6!*%!#&&/0.!*%+!1+#.!^#&/8.#+!*%!]%6#''8++8F!"86!83:%(/;86!*%+!1^UEIEE!68.Y!!

!dF E8.68+/*#'!-.#!78+)(/&#!*%!96(#*8!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!/.>8'@#&/0.<!('#.67#'%.&/#!C!'%.*/&/0.!*%!

&-%.(#6F!!KF ,8'(#+%&%'! +#! >/6&#+/D#&/0.! *%! +86! '%&-'686! 723+/&86! C! @%:8'#'! %+! &8.('8+! /.(%'.8! *%! +#!

T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!7#'#!=-%!&8.('/3-C#!#!+#!%>%&(/;/*#*!C!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!+#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6F!!

_F E8.('/3-/'!#+!*%6#''8++8!*%!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!#7%?8!#!+#!+%?#+/*#*<!*%!V(/&#!C!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!723+/&#F!!

iF N.6(/(-&/8.#+/D#'!@%&#./6@86!*%!;/.&-+#&/0.!C!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!&/-*#*#.#!%.!%+!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.!C!+#!@%:8'#!*%!+#!('#.67#'%.&/#!C!*%!+#!+%?#+/*#*F!

hF 96(#3+%&%'!@%&#./6@86!*%!&88'*/.#&/0.!*%!#&&/8.%6!7#'#!%+!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+F!!

gF E8@3#(/'!+#!&8''-7&/0.!%.!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%+!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+!=-%!7#'(/&/7#.!%.!+#!7'%;%.&/0.<!/.;%6(/?#&/0.!C!7%'6%&-&/0.!*%!+86!*%+/(86<!#6)!&8@8!%.!+#!%:%&-&/0.!*%!6#.&/8.%6!7%.#+%6F!!

!96(%!7'8?'#@#<!7-3+/&#*8!%+!dd!*%!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLLO!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.<!>-%!*/6%J#*8!&8.!-.!%.>8=-%!*%!?%6(/0.!@M6!#3/%'(8!#!+#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!*%!+#!68&/%*#*!C!8'/%.(#*8!#!>8'(# +%&%'!7'M&(/&#6!C!;#+8'%6!*%.('8!*%!+#!?%6(/0.!/.6(/(-&/8.#+!=-%!7%'@/(#!%6(#3+%&%'!-.#!.-%;#!;8&#&/0.!7#'#!'%.*/'!&-%.(#6!78'!7#'(%!*%!+#6!*/6(/.(#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!723+/&#6F!

!9+!*8&-@%.(8!#6)!&8@8!+86!/.>8'@%6!#.-#+%6!6%!6%?-/@/%.(8!#+!1^UEIEE!7-%*%.!6%'!&8.6-+(#*86!#!('#;V6!*%+!6/?-/%.(%!;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z7'8?'#@#6Z7.'&(&& XKLLOXKLdKFA(@+!!9.!%+!@#'&8!*%+!1'8?'#@#!6%!A#.!'%#+/D#*8!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!#&&/8.%6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7'%;%.&/0.Y!!

!J= &KK@E>CF( ?C( ?@XBF@G>8( KETB>@KJK@G>8( KJMJK@LJK@G>(P(FC>F@S@D@iJK@G>(?C( DEF(MHEIHJTJF(P(

JKK@E>CF(?C(DJ(!CKHCLJHNJ\((!

U%*-&/'!+86!./;%+%6!*%!&8''-7&/0.!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!&8.('/3-/'!#+!*%6#''8++8!*%!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!#7%?8!#!+#!+%?#+/*#*<!V(/&#!C!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!723+/&#<!A#.!*#*8!7#68!#!+#6!&#@7#J#6!=-%!A#!

Page 30: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 30 -

*%6#''8++#*8!+#!$,1!*-'#.(%!+#!7'%6%.(%!#*@/./6('#&/0.F!$%!A#.!*/6%J#*8!*/;%'6#6!&#@7#J#6!/.6(/(-&/8.#+%6!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!6%.6/3/+/D#'!#!+#!68&/%*#*!683'%!+86!&86(86!C!+#6!&8.6%&-%.&/#6!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!96(#6!&#@7#J#6!(#@3/V.!A#.!3-6&#*8!7'8@8;%'!+#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!&/-*#*#.#!%.!+#!&8.68+/*#&/0.!*%!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#!%!/.(%?'/*#*F!!!9.('%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!*%!*/>-6/0.<!&8@-./&#&/0.<!&#7#&/(#&/0.!C!6%.6/3/+/D#&/0.!=-%!6%!A#.!'%#+/D#*8!%.!+#!7'%6%.(%!#*@/./6('#&/0.!*%6(#&#.Y!!

!#JTMJRJF(@>FL@LBK@E>JDCF(MJHJ(XETC>LJH(DJ(KBDLBHJ(?C(DCIJD@?J?(P(?C(KETSJLC(J(DJ(KEHHBMK@G>\ !&8.!%+!83:%(/;8!*%!*/>-.*/'!+#6!#&&/8.%6!=-%!+#!$,1!++%;#!#!&#38!%.!3%.%>/&/8!*%!+86!&/-*#*#.86!C!*%!+#!7'87/#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.<!&-+(-'#!*%!+#!+%?#+/*#*!C!+#!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#<!*%6*%!%+!KLLa!6%!A#.!'%#+/D#*8!#&&/8.%6!*%!/.>8'@#&/0.!C!&8@-./&#&/0.<!(#.(8!#!./;%+!.#&/8.#+!&8@8!/.(%'.#&/8.#+F!9.('%!+#6!&#@7#J#6!'%#+/D#*#6!*%6(#&#.Y!!!

rTA8'#!%6!@M6!6%.&/++8s!4KLdd5! U%67-%6(#6!%.!%+!(/%@78!4KLdL5! Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8!4KLLP5! ]%.-.&/#!E/-*#*#.#!4KLLO5! 9+!I'M@/(%!@M6!N.2(/+!4KLLO5! tp-V!A-3/%'#!7#6#*8!6/m!4KLLO5! Q.!RVS/&8!@%:8'!%6!.-%6('#!>-.&/0.!4KLLa5!!

!"#6! &#@7#J#6! 7-%*%.! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*#6! %.! %+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z6#+#X*%X7'%.6#Z&#@7#.#6X*%X+#X6>7FA(@+!

!#JTMJRJ(?C(#@>CT@>BLEFY!%.!KLLa!C!&8.!%+!>/.!*%!6%.6/3/+/D#'!#!+86!&/-*#*#.86!683'%!%+!7'83+%@#!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.<!+#!$,1!:-.(8!&8.!%+!N.6(/(-(8!R%S/&#.8!*%!E/.%@#(8?'#>)#!'%#+/D#'8.!&-#('8!&/.%@/.-(86!7#'#!?%.%'#'!&8.&/%.&/#!%.!+#!68&/%*#*!683'%!+86!&86(86!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.!%.!+#!;/*#!&8(/*/#.#!*%!+#6!7%'68.#6!C!683'%!%+!7#7%+!*%!+86!/.*/;/*-86!7#'#!%.>'%.(#'!%6(%!7'83+%@#F!"#!*/>-6/0.!*%!%6(86!&8'(8@%('#:%6!/.(/(-+#*86!

!*/&A#!&#@7#J#!6%!++%;0!#!&#38!%.!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T1,!&8@8!7#'(%!*%+!1'8?'#@#!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6!KLLO!41IUE5B!#6)!&8@8!#!('#;V6!*%!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!#&#*V@/&#6!C!*/;%'686!8'?#./6@86!7'/;#*86!C!68&/#+%6F((

( (9.!.8;/%@3'%!*%!KLLP!%.!&87'8*-&&/0.!&8.!%+!N.6(/(-(8!R%S/&#.8!*%!E/.%@#(8?'#>)#!6%!'%#+/D0!-.#!6%'/%!*%!&8'(8@%('#:%6!*%.('8!*%!

!>8'(#+%&/0!+#!*/>-6/0.!*%+!.2@%'8!*%!*%.-.&/#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!LdOLL,Q^EN\^F!!

!]/&A#!&#@7#J#!6%!('#.6@/(/0!%.!da!9.(/*#*%6!,%*%'#(/;#6<!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!(%+%;/6/0.<!/.(%'.%(!C!6#+#6!*%!&/.%F!T*/&/8.#+@%.(%<!6%!('#.6@/(/0!%.!+86!@%*/86!/.6(/(-&/8.#+%6<!&8@8!+#6!7#.(#++#6!*%!+86!#%'87-%'(86F!!

!"#! &#@7#J#! @%.&/8.#*#! 7-%*%! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*#! %.! %+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z6#+#X*%X7'%.6#Z&/.%@/.-(86FA(@+!!

!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!&8.(/.-#'!7'87/&/#.*8!+#!'%>+%S/0.!C!

#&(/(-*%6!>#;8'#3+%6!A#&/#!+#!A8.%6(/*#*<!+#!+%?#+/*#*!C!+#!('#.67#'%.&/#<!%.('%!+86!%6(-*/#.(%6<!7#*'%6!*%!>#@/+/#!C!+86!7'8>%68'%6!*%+!$/6(%@#!*%!9*-&#&/0.!eM6/&#! #&/8.#+<!6%!A#!/@7-+6#*8!%+!E8.&-'68!^#&/8.#+!

!!

Page 31: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 31 -

"86!./J86!C!#*8+%6&%.(%6!=-%!7#'(/&/7#.!%.!%+!&8.&-'68<!*/3-:#.!-.#!/@#?%.!=-%!%S7'%6#!6-6!7-.(86!*%!;/6(#!%.!(8'.8!#!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!7'%?-.(#6Y!tp-V!6/?./>/&#!'%67%(#'!+#6!.8'@#6!C!+#6!+%C%6m!t18'!=-V!.8!*%3%!A#&%'!('#@7#m!tE-M+%6!68.!+86!3%.%>/&/86!*%!(%.%'!-.!7#)6!A8.%6(8m!C!tp-V!6%!7-%*%!A#&%'!7#'#!=-%!%.!+#!&#6#<!%.!+#!%6&-%+#!C!%.!+#!&8@-./*#*!6%!'%67%(%.!+#6!.8'@#6!C!+%C%6m!!!T!+8!+#'?8!*%!+86!2+(/@86!#J86!+#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!A#!6/*8!+#!6/?-/%.(%Y!!

!").#./-( 0&$%.#.0&-%"!(

T*/06!#!+#6!I'#@7#6!KLLaXKLLO! dudKLL<LLL!T*/06!#!+#6!I'#@7#6!KLLP! KudKh<iaa!T*/06!#!+#6!I'#@7#6!KLLPXKLdL! duPLa<Lai!T*/06!#!+#6!I'#@7#6!KLdLXKLdd! duPdP<iig!

!9.!%+!KLLO! +#!$,1!7-3+/&0<! &8.!%+!#78C8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!9*-&#&/0.!123+/&#!C!%+!,8.*8!*%!E-+(-'#!

*%!9*-&#&/0.!e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

!0BSD@KJK@E>CF8( CFLB?@EF( C( @>OCFL@IJK@E>CF\( %+! 1'8?'#@#! ^#&/8.#+! *%! U%.*/&/0.! *%! E-%.(#6<!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!E8@3#(%!#!+#!E8''-7&/0.<!%6(#3+%&%!%+!&8@7'8@/68!*%!+#!$,1!7#'#!%+#38'#'!%!/.&%.(/;#'!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!%6(-*/86!*%! ('#.67#'%.&/#<! '%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!C!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.!78'!7#'(%!*%!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!#&#*V@/&#6!8!&%.('86!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/0.F!9.('%!+#6!7-3+/&#&/8.%6!%!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!'%#+/D#*#6!*%6*%!%+!KLLa<!*%6(#&#.Y!!!

5#4+../:-'P8/$#*/%4'51%8+*-#)')#<*+'K+-8/./:-'8+'51+-$%)&'!X ^8F!d5!"#!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6!%.!RVS/&8Y!1%'67%&(/;#6!C!U%(86!4KLLP5!X ^8F!K5!"#!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6!%.!RVS/&8Y!*/6%J8!/.6(/(-&/8.#+!C!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!&/-*#*#.#!

4KLLP5!X ^8F!_5!G%6(/0.!123+/&#!C!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6Y!tQ.!%.>8=-%!3#6#*8!%.!&-@7+/@/%.(8!#!-.8!

3#6#*8!%.!'%6-+(#*86m!4KLdd5!X ^8F!i5!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6!N.(%'?-3%'.#@%.(#+!%.!-.!$/6(%@#!,%*%'#+!4KLdd5!!

K+-8/./:-'8+'51+-$%);'Q*%-)>%*+-./%'E'5#D<%$+'%'4%'5#**1>./:-;'?+.*+$%*6%'8+'4%'91-./:-'@A<4/.%'+'R-)$/$1$#'"%./#-%4'8+'G8D/-/)$*%./:-'@A<4/.%'SLMMTU''

K+)>#-)%</4/8%8+)'G8D/-/)$*%$/F%)'E'P4+../#-+);'4%'4+3%4/8%8'.#D#'.%D/-#'>%*%'4%'*+)>#-)%</4/8%8'>A<4/.%;'?+.*+$%*6%'8+'4%'91-./:-'@A<4/.%'SLMMVU'

P4'.#2+.2#'+-'4%)'%801/)/./#-+)'8+4')+.$#*'>A<4/.#;'DW$#8#)'%.$#*+)'E'D+8/8%)'>%*%'.#D<%$/*4#;'?+.*+$%*6%'8+'4%'91-./:-'@A<4/.%'E'X*3%-/Y%./:-'>%*%'4%'5##>+*%./:-'E'+4'Z+)%**#44#'P.#-:D/.#)'SLMM[U'

\+D#*/%)'8+4'L]'5#4#01/#'"%./#-%4'8+'Q*%-)>%*+-./%;' %./%'4%'5#-)#4/8%./:-'8+'4%'Q*%-)>%*+-./%'.#D#'@#46$/.%'@A<4/.%;' ?+.*+$%*/%'8+' 4%'91-./:-'@A<4/.%'+' R-)$/$1$#'"%./#-%4'8+'G8D/-/)$*%./:-'@A<4/.%'SLMM[UB''

!

Page 32: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 32 -

0HEIHJTJF(?C(KJMJK@LJK@G>(P(XEHTJK@G>(C>(TJLCH@J(?C(LHJ>FMJHC>K@J(P(KBDLBHJ(?C(DCIJD@?J?\ !&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!6%.6/3/+/D#&/0.!#!+#!&/-*#*#.)#!C!#!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!683'%!+86!&86(86!C!&8.6%&-%.&/#6!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.<!6%!A#.!*%6#''8++#*8!*/;%'686!&-'686!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!C!>8'@#&/0.F!9.('%!%6(86!&-'686!*%6(#&#.!+86!6/?-/%.(%6Y(((

$%?-.*8!E8+8=-/8!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/

123+/&#!C!%6(-;8!*/'/?/*8!#!>-.&/8.#'/86!723+/&86!4KLLa5F! E-'68!E-+(-'#!*%!+#!"%?#+/*#*<!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!!E8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.B!&8.;8&#'8.!+#!$-7'%@#!

E8'(%!*%!f-6(/&/#!*%!+#! #&/0.!C!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#F!9+!6%@/.#'/8!%6(-;8!*/'/?/*8!#!>-.&/8.#'/86!723+/&86!!4KLLa5F!

$%@/.#'/8!%.!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!e-%.!G83/%'.8Y!A#&/#!-.!?83/%'.8!#3/%'(8!C!7%+!=-%! (#@3/V.!&8+#38'#.!%+! N.6(/(-(8!I%&.8+0?/&8!C!*%!96(-*/86!$-7%'/8'%6!*%!R8.(%''%C!C!%+!e#.&8!R-.*/#+F!96(%!6%@/.#'/8!%6(M!*/'/?/*8!#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+86!('%6!./;%+%6!*%!?83/%'.8!4$%@/.#'/8!%.!+).%#5F!

%! #! +#! E8''-7&/0.! %.! RVS/&8Y! T67%&(86! "%?#+%6<! R%:8'%6! 1'M&(/&#6! C!&'%(#')#!*%!+#!

,-.&/0.!123+/&#!4KLLO5F( E8.>%'%.&/#! U%?/8.#+! "#(/.8#@%'/&#.#Y! E8@7'8@/68! C! &887%'#&/0.! %.! +#! "-&A#! &8.('#! +#!

C!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!4KLLO5F!(

,-.*#@%.(86!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!%T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!C!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!4KLLO5F!

XE8+8@3/#F!]/'/?/*8!#!>-.&/8.#'/86!723+/&86!*%!#@386!7#)6%6!4KLdL5F!

9@7'%6#'/#+Y!Q.#!96('#(%?/#!E8@7#'(/*#!7#'#!R%:8'#'!+#!E8@7%(/(/;/*#*!C!+#!N.;%'6/0.!4KLdL5F!!

!0HEIHJTJ(?C(#BDLBHJ(?C(DJ(*CIJD@?J?(MJHJ(!CHO@?EHCF(0g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

$%.6/3/+/D#'!683'%!+#!/@78'(#.&/#!*%+!96(#*8!*%!*%'%&A8!C!+#!/.(%?'/*#*!%.!+#!;/*#!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!&8@8!7'8>%6/8.#+%6<!@/%@3'86!*%!>#@/+/#!C!&/-*#*#.86F(

]%6#''8++#'!A#3/+/*#*%6!*%!(8@#!*%!*%&/6/8.%6<!68+-&/0.!*%!7'83+%@#6!C!'#D8.#@/%.(8!+%?#+!C!@8'#+!7#'#!=-%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!+8?'%.!/*%.(/>/&#'!C!*#'!68+-&/0.!#!*/+%@#6!V(/&86!*%6#>/#.(%6!*%!-.#!@#.%'#!6#(/6>#&(8'/#F(

p-%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!&8@7'%.*#.!=-%!6/%@7'%!%6!786/3+%!#&(-#'!7#'#!7'8@8;%'!%+!&#@3/8!#!>#;8'!*%!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!+#!+%?#+/*#*F!(

!E8@8!7'/@%'#! >#6%!*%! +#! /@7+%@%.(#&/0.!*%!%6(%!&-'68!%.!+#!T1,<!*-'#.(%!#?86(8X*/&/%@3'%!KLdd!6%!&#7#&/(0!#!-.!?'-78!*%!hah!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!C!#&(-#+@%.(%!6%!*%6#''8++#!-.!7+#.!*%!('#3#:8!7#'#!+#!&#7#&/(#&/0.!#!M'%#6!%6('#(V?/&#6!*%!(8*#!+#!T1,F!!!

Page 33: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 33 -

T*/&/8.#+@%.(%<! 6%! A#.! ++%;#*8! #! &#38! +#6! 6/?-/%.(%6! #&(/;/*#*%6! *%! &#7#&/(#&/0.! C! >8'@#&/0. !7#'#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86Y!!

dF ]86!6%@/.#'/86!683'%!V(/&#!C!&-+(-'#!*%!+#!+%?#+/*#*!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!7'87/&/#'!+#!'%>+%S/0.!C!*/6&-6/0.!*%!(8*86!+86!7#'(/&/7#.(%6!%.!+#!@#(%'/#F!9.!-.8!*%!%++86<!7#'(/&/70!f%626!^/%;%6<!*%!+#!

!%+!8('8<!&8.!%+!#78C8!*%!,'#.&/6&8!U/;#6<!'%7'%6%.(#.(%!*%!^$NE!%.!RVS/&8<!

E%.('8!*%!N.;%6(/?#&/0.!7#'#!%+!]%6#''8++8!*%!RVS/&8!4EN]TE5F!KF $%! '%#+/D0! -.#! &#7#&/

E8.('8+<!*%+!q'%#!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!C!*%+!q'%#!*%!p-%:#6!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T1,F!

!S=("DJSEHJK@G>(?C(TJ>BJDCF(E(IBNJF(ABC(EH@C>LC>(J(DEF(FCHO@?EHCF(MgSD@KEF(P(J(DEF(MJHL@KBDJHCF(FESHC(KETMEHLJT@C>LEF(ZL@KEF(C>(FBF(HCDJK@E>CF(KE>(CD("FLJ?E\(((.>FLHBTC>LJK@G>8(JKLBJD@iJK@G>(P(JMD@KJK@G>(?CD(#G?@IE(?C(jL@KJ(?C(DJ(&?T@>@FLHJK@G>(0gSD@KJ(P(?C(DEF(#G?@IEF(?C(#E>?BKLJ(?C(DJF(?CMC>?C>K@JF(P(C>L@?J?CF(?C(DJ(&+0Y!E8.!'%67%&(8!9+!#'()&-+8!iP!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!6%J#+#!+8!6/?-/%.(%Y!!!

$#'+-'+4'%*$6.14#'_V'8+'4%'(+E'+D/$/*='1-'5:8/3#'8+'`$/.%'01+'.#-$+-8*=' *+34%)' .4%*%)' >%*%' 01+;' +-' 4%' %.$1%./:-' 8+' 4#)' )+*F/8#*+)' >A<4/.#);' /D>+*+'/-F%*/%<4+D+-$+'1-%'.#-81.$%'8/3-%'01+'*+)>#-8%'%'4%)'-+.+)/8%8+)'8+'4%')#./+8%8'E'01+'#*/+-$+')1'8+)+D>+a#'+-')/$1%./:-'+)>+.6,/.%)'01+')+'4+'>*+)+-$+-;'>*#>/./%-8#'%)6'1-%'>4+-%'F#.%./:-'8+')+*F/./#'>A<4/.#'+-'<+-+,/./#'8+'4%'.#4+.$/F/8%8B'''P4'5:8/3#'8+'`$/.%'%'01+')+'*+,/+*+'+4'>=**%,#'%-$+*/#*;'8+<+*='2%.+*)+'8+4'.#-#./D/+-$#'8+'4#)')+*F/8#*+)'>A<4/.#)'8+'4%' ''

T!%>%&(8!*%!*#'!&#3#+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!#!+86!7'%&%7(86!+%?#+%6!6%J#+#*86<!%+!_d!*%!:-+/8!*%!KLLK!6%!7-3+/&0!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!%+!8>/&/8X&/'&-+#'!@%*/#.(%!%+!&-#+!6%!*/8!#!&8.8&%'!%+!E0*/?8!*%!l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d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

Page 34: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 34 -

96('#(%?/#!_Fd!!1'8@8;%'!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!#7%?8!#!+#!+%?#+/*#*!%.('%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!!").%#6!*%!#&&/0.!

_FdFd! 96(#3+%&%'! %! /@7+%@%.(#'! 7'8?'#@#6! *%! */>-6/0.! C! &#7#&/(#&/0.! 7%'@#.%.(%! 7#'#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!=-%!>8'(#+%D&#.!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#<!/.(%?'/*#*<!#7%?8!#!+#!+%?#+/*#*!C!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6F!!!

_FdFK! ]%.('8!*%+!7'8?'#@#!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!C!>8'@#&/0.!*%!+86!W'?#.86!*%!b/?/+#.&/#!C!E8.('8+!&8.6/*%'#'!&-'686!-!8('86!'%&-'686!*/*M&(/&86!7#'#!*%6#''8++#'!&8@7%(%.&/#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&-+(-'#!*%!+%?#+/*#*!C!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6<!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!=-%!*/&A86!'%&-'686!7-%*#.!>#&/+/(#'!%6(#!7'M&(/&#!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+F!!!

_FdF_! 96(#3+%&%'!@%&#./6@86!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!7#'#!=-%!=-/%.%6!/.?'%6%.!#+!6%';/&/8!723+/&8!%.!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!#!('#;V6!*%+!$%';/&/8!1'8>%6/8.#+!*%!E#''%'#<!&8.8D&#.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!=-%!'%?-+#.!%+!#&(-#'!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86F!!!

!96('#(%?/#!_FK!E8.68+/*#'!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!V(/&#!%! /.(%?'/*#*!%.('%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+F!!").%#6!*%!#&&/0.Y!

_FKFd! 9@/(/'!+/.%#@/%.(86!?%.%'#+%6!&8.>8'@%!#!+86!&-#+%6!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#!%6(#3+%D&#.!#&&/8.%6! 7'%;%.(/;#6! 7#'#! ?#'#.(/D#'! %+! #*%&-#*8! %:%'&/&/8! *%+! 6%';/&/8!723+/&8<!*%!&8.>8'@/*#*!&8.!%6(#3+%&/*8!%.!%+!I )(-+8!E-#'(8!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86F!!

_FKFK! 9;#+-#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'/.&/7/86!C!;#+8'%6!%6(#3+%&/*86!%.!%+!E0*/?8!*%!l(/&#!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!#!('#;V6!*%!-.!6/6(%@#!*%!/.*/&#*8'%6!C!*%!%;#+-#&/0.F!!

_FKF_! T&(-#+/D#'!%!/@7+%@%.(#'!+86!&0*/?86!*%!&8.*-&(#!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!#!7#'(/'!*%! +86!7'/.&/7/86!C!;#+8'%6!%6(#3+%&/*86!%.!%+!E0*/?8!*%!l(/&#!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+F!!

_FKFi! E8.6('-/'!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!V(/&#!723+/&#!=-%!6/';#!7#'#!%6(#3+%&%'!;#+8'%6!C!7'/.&/7/86!=-%!?-)%.!C!8'/%.(%.!%+!#&(-#'!*%! +86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!&8.!%+!7'8706/(8!*%!*#'!7-.(-#+!&-@7+/@/%.(8! #! +#! +%C! C! 6%.6/3/+/D#'! #! V6(86! 683'%! %+! 7#7%+! %:%@7+#'! =-%! *%3%.!*%6%@7%J#'!#.(%!+#!68&/%*#*F!!

!!!

Page 35: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 35 -

96('#(%?/#!_F_!1'8@8;%'!%.('%!+#!&/-*#*#.)#!+#!&-+(-'#!*%!/.(%?'/*#*<!#7%?8!#!+#!+%?#+/*#*!C!*%!'%&A#D8!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!!").%#6!*%!#&&/0.!

_F_Fd! 96(#3+%&%'!%!/@7+%@%.(#'!7'8?'#@#6!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.!7#'#!-6-#'/86!C!3%.%>/&/#'/86!*%!7'8?'#@#6! >%*%'#+%6<! =-%! &8.('/3-C#.! #! &8.68+/*#'! -.#! '%+#&/0.! ('#.67#'%.(%! C!#7%?#*#!#!+#!+%?#+/*#*!%.('%!68&/%*#*!C!?83/%'.8<!#!7#'(/'!*%!-.!%.>8=-%!*%!%:%'&/&/8!*%!*%'%&A86!C!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!83+/?#&/8.%6F!!

_F_FK! 1'8@8;%'!%.!&88'*/.#&/0.!&8.!+#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!%*-&#(/;#6!*%+!7#)6<!+#!>8'@-+#&/0.!C!%:%&-&/0.!*%!7'8?'#@#6!C!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!#&&/8.%6!=-%!&8.('/3-C#.!#!>8'(#+%&%'!+#!>8'@#&/0.!*%!./J86!C!:0;%.%6!%.!(%@#6!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#<!V(/&#<!/.(%?'/*#*!C!&-+(-'#!*%!+#!+%?#+/*#*F!!

_F_F_! ]%6#''8++#'!7'8?'#@#6!C!&8@7#J#6!*%!6%.6/3/+/D#&/0.!7#'#!7'8@8;%'!C!&8.68+/*#'!-.#!&-+(-'#!*%!+%?#+/*#*!%.!%+!7#)6!C!%+!'%&A#D8!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!!

_F_Fi! ]/>-.*/'!C!7'8@8;%'!%.('%!+#!68&/%*#*<!+#!#*87&/0.!*%!@%&#./6@86!*%!#-(8''%?-+#&/0.!=-%!&8.('/3-C#.!#!A#&%'!@M6!('#.67#'%.(%!+#!'%+#&/0.!&8.!%+!?83/%'.8!C!%.('%!#?%.(%6!7'/;#*86F!

_F_Fh! ]/>-.*/'!%+!-68!%>/&/%.(%!*%+!*%'%&A8!#!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!&8@8!-.#!@%*/*#!*%!&8.('#+8')#!68&/#+!%!/.A/3/&/0.!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!

_F_Fg! ]/>-.*/'! +#6! 6#.&/8.%6! =-%! 6%! #7+/&#.! #! +86! 6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86! =-%! /.&-''%.!%.!&8@78'(#@/%.(86!/+)&/(86<!7#'#!#&(/;#'!+86!@%&#./6@86!*%!6#.&/0.!68&/#+!C!*%.-.&/#F!

!E8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!&8.8&%'!%+!?'#*8!*%!#;#.&%!%.!%+!7'8&%68!*%!%+#38'#&/0.!C!#*87&/0.!*%!+86!E0*/?86!*%!E8.*-&(#! N.6(/(-&/8.#+%6<! *-'#.(%! %+! KLLO<! +#! $,1! +%;#.(0! -.#! %.&-%6(#X*/#?.06(/&8! %.! +#6! KaL!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%! +#!T1,<!@/6@#!=-%! >-%! '%678.*/*#!78'! KdL!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%!+#!T1,F!"86!7'/.&/7#+%6!'%6-+(#*86!=-%!6%!*%'/;#'8.!*%!+#!%.&-%6(#X*/#?.06(/&8!68.!+86!6/?-/%.(%6Y!!

KL_! /.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!%+#38'#'8.!C!7-3+/&#'8.!6-6!'%67%&(/;86!E0*/?86!*%!E8.*-&(#F!

"86!(%@#6!@M6!'%&-''%.(%6!=-%!6%!/.&+-C%'8.!%.!+86!E0*/?86!*%!E8.*-&(#!>-%'8.Y!.U 1'%6%';#&/0.!C!-68!#*%&-#*8!*%!'%&-'686!723+/&86!4Phj5F!..U "/.%#@/%.(86!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&8.>+/&(8!*%!/.(%'%6%6!4Ogj5F!...U ^8!*/6&'/@/.#&/0.!4O_j5F!.6U 9=-/*#*!*%!?V.%'8!4a_j5F!6U \3+/?#&/0.!7#'#!*%.-.&/#'!*%!#&(86!*%!&8''-7&/0.!4aKj5F!

!9+!dK!*%!:-+/8!*%!KLd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l(/&#!*%!+#!T1,F!!!

Page 36: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 36 -

9+! *8&-@%.(8! &/(#*8! 7-%*%! 6%'! &8.6-+(#*8! #! ('#;V6! *%+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z7'8?'#@#6Z@#.-#+%6!!T*/&/8.#+@%.(%!C!7#'#!#6%?-'#'!%+!&#3#+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+86!7'/.&/7/86!C!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!%6(#3+%&/*86!%.!+86!#'()&-+86!iO!C!iP!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86! $%';/*8'%6! 123+/&86<! =-%! 6%J#+#.! +#!83+/?#&/0.!*%! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!7#'#!%6(#3+%&%'!#&&/8.%6!7%'@#.%.(%6!7#'#!*%+/@/(#'!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!=-%!%.!6/(-#&/8.%6!%67%&)>/&#6!*%3%'M.!836%';#'!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!#*6&'/(86!#!+#6!@/6@#6!%.!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!6-6!%@7+%86<!&#'?86!8!&8@/6/8.%6<!+#!$,1!%@/(/'M! *-'#.(%! %+!7'/@%'! ('/@%6('%!*%!KLdK! +86! (/-+%D/+-$#)'3+-+*%4+)'>%*%'01+' 4%)'8+>+-8+-./%)'E'+-$/8%8+)'8+'4%'G8D/-/)$*%./:-'@A<4/.%'9+8+*%4'+)$%<4+Y.%-'%../#-+)'>+*D%-+-$+)'>%*%'8+4/D/$%*'.#-81.$%)'01+'+-')/$1%./#-+)'+)>+.6,/.%)'8+<+*=-'#<)+*F%*'4#)')+*F/8#*+)'>A<4/.#)'+-'+4'8+)+D>+a#'8+')1)'+D>4+#)'.%*3#)'#'.#D/)/#-+)F!!!96(%!/.6('-@%.(8!6%'M!*%!&#'M&(%'!;/.&-+#(8'/8!C!%6(#3+%&%'M!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!&8@7'8@/686Y!!

(NF "#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6<!7'87/&/#'M.!=-%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!#*6&'/(86!#!+#6!

@/6@#6<!&8.8D&#.<!&8@7'%.*#.!C!#7+/=-%.!%+!E0*/?8!*%!l(/&#!%.!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!6-6!>-.&/8.%6!723+/&#6<!/.6('-@%.(#.*8!+#6!#&&/8.%6!=-%!7'87/&/%.!6-!#*%&-#*#!*/>-6/0.!C!-(/+/D#.*8!%.!6-!&#68<!+#6!(%&.8+8?)#6!*%!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!C!&8@-./&#&/8.%6!&8.!+#6!=-%!&-%.(%.F!

!NNF "86!(/(-+#'%6!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!+86!0'?#.86!*%!?83/%'.8!*%!+#6!%.(/*#*%6<!(8@#.*8!%.!

&8.6/*%'#&/0.! +#6! >-.&/8.%6! C! #&(/;/*#*%6! 7'87/#6! *%! &#*#! /.6(/(-&/0.<!%6(#3+%&%'M.!#&&/8.%6! 7%'@#.%.(%6! 7#'#! *%+/@/(#'! +#6!&8.*-&(#6!=-%<!%.! 6/(-#&/8.%6!%67%&)>/&#6!*%3%'M.!836%';#'!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!#*6&'/(86!#!+#6!@/6@#6<!%.!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!6-6!'%67%&(/;86!%@7+%86<!&#'?86!C!&8@/6/8.%6F!T6/@/6@8<!#&(-#+/D#'M.<!#7'83#'M.!C!%S7%*/'M.!6-6!'%67%&(/;86!&0*/?86!*%!&8.*-&(#F!

!NNNF "#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6<! /.(%?'#'M.!-.!E8@/(V!*%!l(/&#<!0'?#.8!&8+%?/#*8!*%!

&8.6-+(#!C!#6%68')#!%67%&/#+/D#*#!%.!(%@#6!C!#6-.(86!'%+#&/8.#*86!&8.!+#!#7+/&#&/0.!C!&-@7+/@/%.(8! *%! 6-6! '%67%&(/;86! &0*/?86! *%! &8.*-&(#<! #6)! &8@8! 7#'#! 7'87/&/#'! %+!&-@7+/@/%.(8! *%! +#6! #&&/8.%6! 7%'@#.%.(%6! %6(#3+%&/*#6! 78'! +86! (/(-+#'%6! *%! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6! C! +86! 0'?#.86! *%! ?83/%'.8! *%! +#6!%.(/*#*%6F!]/&A8!&8@/(V! (%.*'M! +#6!6/?-/%.(%6!>-.&/8.%6Y!!

(#F 9+#38'#'!*-'#.(%!%+!7'/@%'!('/@%6('%!*%!&#*#!#J8<!6-!7+#.!#.-#+!*%!('#3#:8B!3F 1'87/&/#'!+#!@%:8'#!C!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!#&&/8.%6!7%'@#.%.(%6!/@7-+6#*#6!78'!%+!

I /(-+#'!*%!+#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%+!0'?#.8!*%!?83/%'.8!*%!+#!%.(/*#*<!7#'#!*%+/@/(#'!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!=-%!%.!6/(-#&/8.%6!%67%&)>/&#6!*%3%'M.!836%';#'!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!%.!%+!*%6%@7%J8!*%!6-6!%@7+%86<!&#'?86!8!&8@/6/8.%6B!

&F 1'878.%'!%+!7'8C%&(8!*%!&0*/?8!*%!V(/&#<!7#'#!=-%!%.!6-!878'(-./*#*<!6%#!%S7%*/*8!78'!%+!(/(-+#'!*%!+#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%+!0'?#.8!*%!?83/%'.8!*%!+#!%.(/*#*B!

*F 1'878.%'!+#!'%;/6/0.!C!#&(-#+/D#&/0.!*%+!E0*/?8!*%!E8.*-&(#B!%F 1'878.%'!#!+#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%.(/*#*<!+#!/@7+%@%.(#&/0.!C!*%6#''8++8!*%!*/#?.06(/&86!

7#'#!/*%.(/>/&#'!&8.*-&(#6!6-6&%7(/3+%6!*%!@%:8'#<!&8.!%+!7'8706/(8!*%!#*%&-#'+#6!7#'#!=-%!'%678.*#.!#!+#6!.%&%6/*#*%6!*%!+#!68&/%*#*B!

>F ,-.?/'! &8@8! 0'?#.8! *%! &8.6-+(#! C! #6%68')#! %67%&/#+/D#*#! %.! (%@#6! C! #6-.(86!'%+#&/8.#*86!&8.!+#!#7+/&#&/0.!C!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%+!&0*/?8!*%!&8.*-&(#B!

?F N@7+%@%.(#'!6/6(%@#6!*%!/.>8'@#&/0.!C!&8@-./&#&/0.<!7#'#!&8.8&%'!*%!6/(-#&/8.%6!%67%&)>/&#6!'%+#&/8.#*#6!&8.!+#!#7+/&#&/0.<!836%';#.&/#!%!/.&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%+!E0*/?8!

Page 37: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 37 -

*%!E8.*-&(#!7+#.(%#*#6!78'!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%.(/*#*<!#6)!&8@8!7#'#!+#!'%&%7&/0.!*%!6-?%'%.&/#6!8!'%&8@%.*#&/8.%6!7#'#!+#!'%;/6/0.!C!@%:8'#!*%+!'%>%'/*8!&0*/?8B!

AF 1'878.%'!#!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!#&&/8.%6!%67%&)>/&#6!(%.*/%.(%6!#!68+;%.(#'!+86!786/3+%6!/.&-@7+/@/%.(86!#+!E0*/?86!*%!l(/&#!C!%.!6-!&#68<!'%&8@%.*#'!&8.*-&(#6!&8.&'%(#6!#.(%!/.&-@7+/@/%.(86!'%/(%'#*86B!C!

/F b#+8'#'!+#!&8.;%./%.&/#!*%!A#&%'!*%+!&8.8&/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!-./*#*%6!8!M'%#6!:-')*/&#6<!*%!'%&-'686!A-@#.86!8!*%+!0'?#.8!/.(%'.8!*%!&8.('8+!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!#=-%++#6!&8.*-&(#6<!#&&/8.%6!-!8@/6/8.%6!=-%!78'!6-!.#(-'#+%D#!C!%>%&(86<! 6-!#(%.&/0.!C!&8.8&/@/%.(8!&8''%678.*#!#!/.6(#.&/#6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6<!:-*/&/#+%6!8!:-'/6*/&&/8.#+%6F!

(1'8@8&/0.!*%!@%&#./6@86!*%!#-(8''%?-+#&/0.!%.!%+!6%&(8'!7'/;#*8Y!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!7'8@8;%'!+#!#*87&/0.!*%!@%&#./6@86!*%!#-(8''%?-+#&/0.!%.!+#6!%@7'%6#6<!+#!$,1!A#!7#'(/&/7#*8!%.!*/;%'686!%;%.(86!*/'/?/*86!#!+#!/./&/#(/;#!7'/;#*#<!*#.*8!#!&8.8&%'!+#!%6('#(%?/#!#.(/&8''-7&/0.!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!6%.6/3/+/D#.*8!683'%!+#!/@78'(#.&/#!*%!+#!&8''%678.6#3/+/*#*<!/@7#&(#.*8!#!&%'&#!*%!dhLL!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!%6(%!6%&(8'F!!

(]-'#.(%!%+!2+(/@8!#J8! +#!$,1!8'?#./D0!.-%;%!%;%.(86!*%!;/.&-+#&/0.!&8.!%+! 6%&(8'!7'/;#*8!7#'#!*#'!#!&8.8&%'!+#!%6('#(%?/#!#.(/&8''-7&/0.!C!*%!(#+#!'%?-+#(8'/#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!7'8@8;%'!+#!&8''%678.6#3/+/*#*!%.! %6(%! 6%&(8'F!"86!%;%.(86!&8.(#'8.!&8.! +#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!*%+! $%&'%(#'/8!*%! +#!$,1! /@7#&(#.*8!#!-.!7'8@%*/8!*%!daL!7'%6/*%.(%6!C!#+(86!*/'%&(/;86!*%!+#6!&M@#'#6<!#68&/#&/8.%6!*%!7'8>%6/8./6(#6!C!8'?#./6@86!%@7'%6#'/#+%6!@M6!'%7'%6%.(#(/;86!*%!RVS/&8F!

!9+!P!*%!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLdL<!%.!%+!@#'&8!*%+!])#!N.(%'.#&/8.#+!&8.('#!+#!E8''-7&/0.<!+#!$,1!8'?#./D0!%+!6%@/.#'/8! @7#'(/*#!7#'#!R%:8'#'!

683'%!%+!/@7#&(8!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.!%.!%+!#@3/%.(%!*%!.%?8&/86<!+#!&8''%678.6#3/+/*#*!%.!%+!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.! C! +86! '%(86! C! 7%'67%&(/;#6! %.! %6(#! @#(%'/#F! 9+! %;%.(8! &8.(0! &8.! +#! 7#'(/&/7#&/0.! *%! KLL!%@7'%6#'/86!C!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!&M@#'#6!C!8'?#./6@86!%@7'%6#'/#+%6F!

!#E>OC>@EF(?C(#EDJSEHJK@G>(KE>(CD(FCKLEH(MH@OJ?E\(]-'#.(%!+86!2+(/@86!*86!#J86<!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!>/'@0!&8.;%./86!*%!&8+#38'#&/0.!&8.!+#!T68&/#&/0.!*%!E8@7#J)#6!T>/#.D#*8'#6!*%!RVS/&8!4T,NT^vT5!C! +#!EM@#'#!*%!E8@%'&/8!N.(%'.#&/8.#+!E#7)(-+8!RVS/&8!4NEE!RVS/&85F!!

!9.!%+!@#'&8!*%+!&8.;%./8!&8.!T,NT^vT<!>/'@#*8!%.!KLLP<!%+!?83/%'.8!*%!RVS/&8!A#!++%;#*8!#!&#38!@%6#6!*%!('#3#:8!7#'#!>8'(#+%&%'!%+!7'8&%68!*%!;#+/*#&/0.!*%!>/#.D#6<!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!%;/(#'!+#!%.('%?#!*%!>/#.D#6!#70&'/>#6!%.!+#!T1,F!!

!9.!%+!@#'&8!*%+!&8.;%./8!&8.!NEE<!>/'@#*8!%.!KLdd<!6%!*/6%J0!-.!7+#.!*%!('#3#:8<!%+!&-#+!7'8@-%;%!%+!*%6#''8++8!C!+#!/@7+%@%.(#&/0.!*%!*/;%'6#6!@%*/*#6!%67%&)>/&#6!7#'#!&8@3#(/'!%+!>%.0@%.8!*%!+#!&8''-7&/0.!%.!%+!M@3/(8!723+/&8!C!7'/;#*8F!"#6!;%'(/%.(%6!*%!('#3#:8!68.!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6Y!!

]%.-.&/#!C!7'8(%&&/0.!#!*%.-.&/#.(%6F! $%.6/3/+/D#'!C!&#7#&/(#'!%.!/.(%?'/*#*!%@7'%6#'/#+F! U%&8.8&/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!%@7'%6#6!=-%!A#.!/@7+%@%.(#*8!-.!7'8?'#@#!*%!/.(%?'/*#*!%@7'%6#'/#+!48!

7'8?'#@#!#.(/&8''-7&/0.5<!78'!7#'(%!*%+!?83/%'.8F! l(/&#!723+/&#F!

!%JDDCHCF( P( COC>LEF( ?C( KJMJK@LJK@G>( KE>( CD(FCKLEH(MH@OJ?E\( "#!$%&'%(#')#!*%! +#! ,-.&/0.!123+/&#!%@7'%.*/0!#!7#'(/'!*%!KLdL!-.#!&#@7#J#!*%!6%.6/3/+/D#&/0.!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!*%!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!*/&A#!*%7%.*%.&/#!%.!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!%;%.(86!4$%!#.%S#!'%+#&/0.!*%!%;%.(865F!(

Page 38: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 38 -

(E8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!7'8@8;%'!+#!#*87&/0.!*%!@%&#./6@86!*%!#-(8''%?-+#&/0.!%.!+#6!%@7'%6#6<!*-'#.(%!%+!2+(/@8!#J8!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!Q./*#*!*%!18+)(/&#6!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!E887%'#&/0.!N.(%'.#&/8.#+<!7#'(/&/7#'8.!%.!*/%D!%;%.(86!*/'/?/*86!#!+#!/./&/#(/;#!7'/;#*#<!*#.*8!#!&8.8&%'!+#!%6('#(%?/#!#.(/&8''-7&/0.!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!6%.6/3/+/D#.*8!683'%!+#!/@78'(#.&/#!*%!+#!&8''%678.6#3/+/*#*<!/@7#&(#.*8!#!&%'&#!*%!dhLL!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!%6(%!6%&(8'F((9.!@#C8!*%!KLdd!6%!++%;0!#!&#38!%+!1'/@%'!*%!N.(%?'/*#*!9@7'%6#'/#+<!=-%!(-;8!&8@8!83:%(/;86Y!6%.6/3/+/D#'!683'%! +86! /.6('-@%.(86! /.(%'.#&/8.#+%6! =-%! (/%.%.! %>%&(8! %.! +#6! %@7'%6#6!=-%!87%'#.!%.!RVS/&8!C<!7'8@8;%'!+#!V(/&#!%@7'%6#'/#+!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!*/>-6/0.!*%!A%''#@/%.(#6!7#'#!7'%;%./'!+#!&8''-7&/0.!C!%+!>'#-*%F!96(%!(#++%'!>-%!*%6#''8++#*8!%.!&8.:-.(8!&8.!+#!e#''#!R%S/&#.#!E8+%?/8!*%!T38?#*86<!+#!T68&/#&/0.! #&/8.#+!*%!T38?#*86!*%!9@7'%6#! 4T^T]95<!%+!1#&(8!R-.*/#+!*%! +#!\^Q!%.!RVS/&8<!+#!EM@#'#!*%!E8@%'&/8!N.(%'.#&/8.#+!E#7)(-+8!RVS/&8!C!%+!E8@/(V! #&/8.#+!*%!1'8*-&(/;/*#*!%!N..8;#&/0.!I%&.8+0? /&#!4E\R1NI95F!]-'#.(%!%+!(#++%'!6%!&#7#&/(#'8.!#!aL!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!%@7'%6#6!%.!+#!/.6('-@%.(#&/0.!*%!7'8?'#@#6!*%!/.(%?'/*#*<!/@7#&(#.*8!#!6%&(8'%6!&8@8!%+!>#'@#&V-(/&8<!#+/@%.(/&/8<!*%!&8.6-+(8')#<!*%!#-(8('#.678'(%!C!%.%'?V(/&8F(

!K=(&KK@E>CF(MJHJ(MHETEOCH(DJ(MJHL@K@MJK@G>(?C(DJ(FEK@C?J?(C>(DJ(DBKhJ(KE>LHJ(DJ(KEHHBMK@G>(P(C>(KE>FED@?JK@G>(?C(B>J(KBDLBHJ(?C(LHJ>FMJHC>K@J((

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dL<! +#!%6('#(%?/#! (-;8!-.!.-%;8!%.>8=-%<!%.! +#!&-#+! +86!*/6(/.(86!#&(8'%6!*%!+#!68&/%*#*!&/;/+!68. !=-/%.%6!7'878.%.!+86!(%@#6!7#'#!+#!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!*%!+#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%+!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+F!1#'#!%++8<!+#! $,1! %@/(/0! -.#! &8.6-+(#! #! +#! 68&/%*#*! &/;/+! 7#'#! =-%!6%!7'87-6/%'#.! (%@#6!683'%! +86!&-#+%6! +#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%+!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+!7-*/%'#.!'%.*/'!&-%.(#6!#!+#!68&/%*#*<!&8.!&'/(%'/86!&+#'86!=-%!*%3)#.!&-@7+/'!+#6!7'87-%6(#6!7#'#!6%'!6%+%&&/8.#*#6F!!

!$%!'%&/3/%'8.!__!7'87-%6(#6<!dd!*%!+#6!&-#+%6!&-@7+/%'8.!+86!&'/(%'/86!*%!6%+%&&/0.!C!>-%'8.!(-'.#*#6!#!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6! &8''%678.*/%.(%6! 7#'#! =-%! >-%6%.! '%678.*/*#6!C!7#'#!=-%! +#6! '%67-%6(#6!3'/.*#*#6!6%!7-3+/&#'#.!%.!6-6!78'(#+%6!/.6(/(-&/8.#+%6F!!9.!KLdd!6%!+#.D0!.-%;#@%.(%!+#!E8.6-+(#!C!+#6!7'87-%6(#6!#-@%.(#'8.!%.!@M6!*%!-.!&/%.!78'!&/%.(8!#+!'%&/3/'6%!g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dd!6%!'%#+/D#'8.!iK!9:%'&/&/86! *%! U%.*/&/0.! *%! E-%.(#6! #! +#! $8&/%*#*! %.! +86! =-%! 7#'(/&/7#'8.! _Kd! &/-*#*#.86! =-%!'%7'%6%.(#'8.!#!KLg!8'?#./D#&/8.%6!*%!+#!68&/%*#*!&/;/+<!&#@7%6/.#6<!*%!+#!#&#*%@/#!C!*%+!6%&(8'!7'/;#*8F!

Page 39: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 39 -

1#'#! @#C8'! /.>8'@#&/0.! 6%! 7-%*%! &8.6-+(#'! %+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y!A((7YZZ[[[F7'8?'#@##.(/&8''-7&/8.F?83F@SZ7'8?'#@#`KLddFA(@+!!!%CFL@IEF(!EK@JDCF\(9.!%+!.-%;8!U%?+#@%.(8!*%!+#!"%C!*%!T*=-/6/&/8.%6<!T''%.*#@/%.(86!C!$%';/&/86!*%+!$%&(8'!123+/&8<!7-3+/&#*8!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%! +#!,%*%'#&/0.!%+!KO!*%!:-+/8!*%!KLd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

!E8.!6-!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!%.!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!&8.('#(#&/0.!6%!3-6&#!#7'8;%&A#'!6-!%S7%'/%.&/#!C!@%:8'#'!+# !/?-#+*#*!*%!&8.*/&/8.%6!%.('%! +86! +/&/(#.(%6<! +#!&#+/*#*!*%! +#6!&8.('#(#&/8.%6!C!7'8@8;%'!+#!%>/&/%.&/#<!%>/&#&/#<!/@7#'&/#+/*#*<!('#.67#'%.&/#!C!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!"86!7'/.&/7#+%6!'%6-+(#*86!83(%./*86!%.('%!6%7(/%@3'%!*%!KLdL!C!:-./8!*%!KLdd!>-%'8.!+86!6/?-/%.(%6Y!

!$%! #-(8'/D#'8.! Od! *%6/?.#&/8.%6! 7#'#! Od! 7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!&8.('#(#&/0.<!=-%!#+&#.D#'8.!-.!@8.(8!%6(/@#*8!*%!dLP<hP_!@/++8.%6!*%!7%686<!*%!+86!&-#+%6!dg!&8''%678.*/%'8.!#!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!%.!83'#!723+/&#!C!gh!#!#*=-/6/&/8.%6<!#''%.*#@/%.(86!C!6%';/&/86F!]%!#&-%'*8!#+!;#+8'!%6(/@#*8!*%!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!%.!83'#!723+/&#!6-@#'8.!K_<dPK!@/++8.%6!*%!7%686!C!%.!#*=-/6/&/8.%6<!#''%.*#@/%.(86!C!6%';/&/86!Oi<iLd!@/++8.%6!*%!7%686F!!T! :-./8! *%! KLdd<! 6%! %.&8.('#3#.! '%?/6('#*86! _P! (%6(/?86! 68&/#+%6<! &/.&8! *%! %++86! 7%'68.#6! @8'#+%6!48'?#./D#&/8.%6!+#!68&/%*#*!&/;/+5!C!_i!7%'68.#6!>)6/&#6Y!!!

dZ!N.>8'@#&/0.! */678./3+%! #!:-./8! *%!KLdd!^]Y!.8!*/678./3+%B! @*7Y!@/++8.%6! *%!7%686!,Q9^I9Y!$%&'%(#')#! *%! +#!,-.&/0.! 123+/&#!

#E>LHJDEHNJ(!EK@JD(C>(0HEIHJTJF(+C?CHJDCF(?C()CFJHHEDDE(!EK@JD \(9.!#3'/+!*%!KLLO!6%!7-3+/&0!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!%+!G5bPKZX'>#*'+4'01+')+'+)$%<4+.+-'4#)'(/-+%D/+-$#)'>%*%'4%'>*#D#./:-'E'#>+*%./:-'8+'4%'5#-$*%4#*6%'?#./%4'+-'4#)'>*#3*%D%)',+8+*%4+)'8+'8+)%**#44#')#./%4 F!T!.8;/%@3'%!*%!KLdd!-.!(8(#+!*%!g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

#E>KCMLE( c``W( c``_( c``e( c``f( c``<( c`b ( c`bbbk(

%CFL@IEF(!EK@JDCF($CI@FLHJ?EF(

W( bW( cd( c<( dV( d<( d<(

1%'68.#6! >)6/&#6! _! dK! dP! Ki! KP! _i! _i!1%'68.#6!@8'#+%6! K! _! i! h! h! h! h!

)CF@I>JK@E>CF( ?C(LCFL@IEF( h! _K! i_! dPi! dKa! dK_! id!5E>LEF(?C(HCKBHFEF( ;T?M=( ^]! ^]! ad<!iLL! _ig<!_KL! _dh<!hda! dO_<!d__! iO<!aKg!

Page 40: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 40 -

E8.! %6(#6! #&&/8.%6<! 6%! +8?'0! =-%! %.! %+! KLdL! >/.#+/D#'#! &8.! +#!&8.>8'@#&/0.!*%!_O<aKi!E8@/(V6!*%!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+!%.!hi!7'8?'#@#6!>%*%'#+%6!*%!*%6#''8++8!68&/#+!%.!+86!=-%!7#'(/&/7#.!dh_<h_P!&/-*#*#.86!=-%!68.!3%.%>/&/#'/86!*%!+86!@/6@86F!

.TMBDFE(?C(DJ(#E>LHJDEHNJ(!EK@JD(C>(0HEIHJTJF(+C?CHJDCF\($%!A#.!&8.&'%(#*8!#&&/8.%6!&8.!8('#6!/.6(#.&/#6!.8!83+/?#*#6!78'!"/.%#@/%.(86!7#'#!/@7+%@%.(#'!%6=-%@#6!*%!E8.('#+8')#!68&/#+F!9:%@7+8!*%!%++8!%6!=-%!#!.8;/%@3'%!*%!KLdd!/.6(#.&/#6!&8@8!,/.#.&/%'#!U-'#+<!$%&'%(#')#!*%!R%*/8!T@3/%.(%!C!U%&-'686!^#(-'#+%6!C!%+! N.6(/(-(8!^#&/8.#+!*%!+#6!R-:%'%6!&-%.(#.!%.!;#'/86!*%!6-6!7'8?'#@#6!&8.!%6=-%@#6!*%!&8.('#+8')#!68&/#+F!$%!A#.!'%#+/D#*8!#&%'&#@/%.(86!&8.!8('#6!]%7%.*%.&/#6!7#'#!/.&8'78'#'!7'8?'#@#6!&8@8!%+!1U\ETR1\<!%.('%!8('86F(

T&(-#+@%.(%<!-.8!*%!&#*#!*86!1'8?'#@#6!,%*%'#+%6!&-%.(#!&8.!-.!%6=-%@#!*%!&8.('#+8')#!68&/#+ F!

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e#:8!%+!@/6@8!/.6('-@%.(8<!(#@3/V.!6%!&8.&%.('#.!#&(/;/*#*%6!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#!C!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!&8@8!%+!6%?-/@/%.(8!#+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!&8.;%.&/8.%6!/.(%'.#&/8.#+%6!*%!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.<!+#!7'8@8&/0.!*%!836%';#(8'/86!&/-*#*#.86!C!*%!#&&/8.%6!*%!

7'87-%6(#6!C!3-%.#6!7'M&(/&#6!*%!&8@/(V6!*%!&8.('#+8')#!68&/#+!C!&/-*#*#.86F(

E#*#!#J8!6%!'%#+/D#!+#!U%-./0.!^#&/8.#+!*%!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+<!&8.!+#!#6/6(%.&/#!*%!'%7'%6%.(#.(%6!*%!+86!W'?#.86!96(#(#+%6!*%!E8.('8+!C!*%!+86!1'8?'#@#6!,%*%'#+%6!*%!]%6#''8++8!$8&/#+F!]/&A8!%;%.(8!(/%.%!&8@8!83:%(/;8!#.#+/D#'! C!?%.%'#'!7'87-%6(#6!*%!78+)(/&#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!('#.67#'%.&/#<!'%.*/&/0.!*%!&-%.(#6!C!&8.('#+8')#!68&/#+F!

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dd!%+!7'8?'#@#!&-%.(#!&8.!+#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!*%!dh!%.(/*#*%6!>%*%'#(/;#6!&8.!-.!(8(#+!*%!gOg!@-./&/7/86!#&(/;86F!]%!6%7(/%@3'%!*%!KLdL!#!#?86(8!*%!KLdd<! 6%! /@7#'(/%'8.!di! (#++%'%6!&8.! +#!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!*%!Kig!@-./&/7/86!C!hOa!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86F!E8.!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!'%6-+(#.(%!%.!+86!(#++%'%6!6%!%+#38'#.!/.>8'@%6!*%!'%6-+(#*86!=-%!6%!-(/+/D#. !&8@8!3#6%!7#'#!+#!7'%7#'#&/0.!*%!7+#.%6!*%!@%:8'#!/@7+%@%.(#*86!78'!+86!@/6@86!@-./&/7/86F!

&KK@E>CF( KE>[B>LJF( KE>( &KJ?CT@J( P( 4HIJ>@iJK@E>CF( ?C( DJ( !EK@C?J?( #@O@D \( $%! A#! /@7-+6#*8!>-%'(%@%.(%!+#!&#7#&/(#&/0.!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+<!7'/.&/7#+@%.(%!#!('#;V6!*%!]/7+8@#*86!*%!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+F!]-'#.(%!KLdL!6%!++%;#'8.!#!&#38!&/.&8!*/7+8@#*86!*%!&8.('#+8')#!68&/#+!'%#+/D#*86!*%!@#.%'#!&8.:-.(#!&8.!W'?#.86!96(#(#+%6!*%!E8.('8+!4E8.('#+8')#6!*%!+86!G83/%'.86!96(#(#+%65<!N.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%!9*-&#&/0.!$-7%'/8'!C!\'?#./D#&/8.%6!*%!+#!$8&/%*#*!E/;/+F!E8.!%6(#!#&&/0.!6%!>8'(#+%&%.!+#6!A#3/+/*#*%6<!&#7#&/*#*%6! C! &8.8&/@/%.(86! *%! 6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86! *%! +86! ('%6! 0'*%.%6! *%! ?83/%'.8! #6)! &8@8!*%!/.(%?'#.(%6!*%!8'?#./D#&/8.%6!C!@%*/86!*%!&8@-./&#&/0.F!96!/@78'(#.(%!6%J#+#'!=-%!#!7#'(/'!*%!KLdd!+#!Q./;%'6/*#*!T-(0.8@#!*%!E/-*#*!f-M'%D!/./&/0!+#!R#%6(')#!%.!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+<!%.!6-!;%'6/0.!#!*/6(#.&/#F (

Page 41: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 41 -

]-'#.(%!KLLO<!KLLP!C!KLdd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

E8@8!-.!/.6('-@%.(8!(%&.8+0?/&8!=-%!7%'@/(%!+#!6/6(%@#(/D#&/0.<!#.M+/6/6!C!%;#+-#&/0.!*%!+#!&8.('#+8')# !68&/#+<!C!*#'!6%?-/@/%.(8!#!+#6!&V*-+#6!*%!;/?/+#.&/#!=-%!++%.#.!+86!3%.%>/&/#'/86!*%+!7'8?'#@#<!6%!*/6%J0!C!6%!7-68!#!*/6786/&/0.!%+!$/6(%@#!N.>8'@M(/&8!*%!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+!4$NE$5<!A%''#@/%.(#!683'%!+#!&-#+!6%!&#7#&/(0!#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+86!('%6!0'*%.%6!*%!?83/%'.8F!

]%!6%7(/%@3'%!*%!KLdL!#!#?86(8!*%!KLdd<!+#!$,1!&#7#&/(0!7#'#!6-!-68!#!K<gdL!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*% !(8*86!+86!0'*%.%6!*%!?83/%'.8<!*%6(#&#.*8!h_!=-%!7#'(/&/7#'8.!%.!%+!7'8C%&(8!*%!>8'@#&/0.!*%!/.6('-&(8'%6!*%+!$NE$F!!

1#'#! @#C8'! /.>8'@#&/0.! 683'%! +#6! #&&/8.%6! '%#+/D#*#6!78'! +#6!$,1!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7'%;%.&/0.!*%! +#6!7'M&(/&#6!*%!&8''-7&/0.!6%!7-%*%.!&8.6-+(#'!+86!/.>8'@%6!*%!+#38'%6!4KLLa<!KLLO<!KLLP<!KLdL!C!KLdd5!*%!+#!$,1! %.! %+! 6/?-/%.(%! ;).&-+8Y! A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z('#.67#'%.&/#Z/.>8'@#&/8.X*/;%'6#Z/.>8'@%6X*%X+#38'%6XCX*%X%:%&-&/8.FA(@+!!

@@U !@(CD(HCFMCKL@OE(GHIJ>E(L@C>C(XB>K@E>CF(?C(?CLCKK@G>(?C(DJF(MHQKL@KJF(KEHHBMLJF(ABC(IC>CHJ>(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(?@FK@MD@>JH@JY(J?T@>@FLHJL@OJY(MJLH@TE>@JD(E(K@O@DY(E(MC>JD(MJHJ(AB@C>CF( HCFBDLJ>( @>OEDBKHJ?EF(C>( DJF(T@FTJF8( HCDJK@E>C8(KBJ>?E(KEHHCFME>?J8(CD(>gTCHE( LELJD(?C(@>OCFL@IJK@E>CF(@>@K@J?JF(C>(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(gDL@TEF(K@>KE(JREF8(@>?@KJ>?E(KBQ>LJF(FC(C>KBC>LHJ>(C>(KBHFEY(KBQ>LJF(FC(C>KBC>LHJ>(FBFMC>?@?JF(MEH(KBJDAB@CH(HJiG>Y(KBQ>LJF(hJ>(MHCFKH@LE(MEH(>E(hJSCH(F@?E(KE>KDB@?JF(C>(DEF(LZHT@>EF(CFLJSDCK@?EFY(KBQ>LJF(hJ>(F@?E(JHKh@OJ?JF(F@>(ABC(FC(hJPJ(ME?@?E(J?EMLJH(B>J(?CK@F@G>(?C(XE>?E(FESHC(CD(KJFE(@>OCFL@IJ?EY(KBQ>LJF(FC(C>KBC>LHJ>(C>(KE>?@K@E>CF(?C(MCHT@L@H(ABC( KE>(SJFC(C>( DJ(CDDJF(FC(MBC?J(J?EMLJH(B>J(?CK@F@G>(?C( XE>?E(FESHC(CD(KJFE(@>OCFL@IJ?EY(P(KBQ>LJF(hJ>(hCKhE(KBHFE(hJK@J(DJ(@>FLJ>K@J(KETMCLC>LC(MJHJ(J?EMLJH(?@KhJ(?CK@F@G>U(

@@@U !@(CD( HCFMCKL@OE(GHIJ>E(L@C>C(XB>K@E>CF(?C(FJ>K@G>(?C(DJF(MHQKL@KJF(KEHHBMLJF(ABC(IC>CHJ>(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(?@FK@MD@>JH@JY(J?T@>@FLHJL@OJY(MJLH@TE>@JD(E(K@O@DY(E(MC>JD(MJHJ(AB@C>CF( HCFBDLJ>( @>OEDBKHJ?EF( C>( DJF(T@FTJF8( HCDJK@E>C(CD(>gTCHE( LELJD(?C(KJFE(@>OCFL@IJ?EF(ABC(FC(C>KE>LHJSJ>(D@FLEF(MJHJ(FB(?CK@F@G>(C>(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(gDL@TEF(K@>KE(JREFY(CD(>gTCHE(?C(?CK@F@E>CF(J?EMLJ?JF(C>(HCDJK@G>(KE>(DEF(T@FTEFY(CD(>gTCHE(?C(CFLJF(?CK@F@E>CF(ABC(HCFBDLJHE>(C>(@TMBLJK@G>(?C(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(E(FJ>K@G>Y(CD(>gTCHE(?C(CFLJF(?CK@F@E>CF(ABC(HCFBDLJHE>(C>(>E(@TMBLJK@G>(?C(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(E(JSFEDBK@G>Y(P(CD(>gTCHE(?C(CFLJF(?CK@F@E>CF(HCDJL@OJF(J(MHCFKH@MK@G>(?C(DJ(FJ>K@G>(E(C L@>K@G>(?C(DJ(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(MEH(>E(hJSCHFC(J?EMLJ?E(DJ(?CK@F@G>(?C>LHE(?C(DEF(LZHT@>EF(CFLJSDCK@?EFU((

@OU !@(CD( HCFMCKL@OE(GHIJ>E(L@C>C(XB>K@E>CF(?C(FJ>K@G>(?C(DJF(MHQKL@KJF(KEHHBMLJF(ABC(IC>CHJ>(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?(MJLH@TE>@JD(E(K@O@D(MJHJ(AB@C>CF(HCFBDLJ>(@>OEDBKHJ?EF(C>(DJF(T@FTJF8( @>?@ABC( CD( TE>LE( ?C( DJF( FJ>K@E>CF( MCKB>@JH@JF( @TMBCFLJF8( E( ?C( DEF(HCFJHK@T@C>LEF(MJLH@TE>@JDCF(EH?C>J?EF(J(XJOEH(?CD("FLJ?E8(ABC(hJPJ>(@>IHCFJ?E(JD(CHJH@E(MgSD@KE(C>(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(gDL@TEF(K@>KE(JREFU((

Page 42: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 42 -

E8.!'%67%&(8!#!+86!7-.(86!//<!///!C!/;!6%!/.>8'@#!+8!6/?-/%.(%Y!!

"#!$%&'%(#')#!*%! +#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!%6!-.#!*%7%.*%.&/#!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+!=-%!%.!(V'@/.86!*%!+8!*/67-%6(8! 78'! %+! #'()&-+8! _a! *%! +#! "%C! \'?M./&#! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+<! &-%.(#! &8.!#('/3-&/8.%6! 7#'#! /.;%6(/?#'! C! %.! 6-! &#68<! 6#.&/8.#'! *%6*%! %+! 7-.(8!*%!;/6(#!#*@/./6('#(/;8!#=-%++#6!&8.*-&(#6!=-%!&8@%(#.!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!%.!&8.('#;%.&/0.!#!+#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!=-%!+%6!/@78.%!%+!#'()&-+8!O!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86F!!!A((7YZZ[[[F*/7-(#*86F?83F@SZ"%C%6e/3+/8Z7*>ZKiLF7*>!!T5!96! /@78'(#.(%!@%.&/8.#'!=-%!%.!@#(%'/#!*/6&/7+/.#'/#!C!#*@/./6('#(/;#<! +#!$%&'%(#')#!*%! +#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!&-%.(#!&8.!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!#('/3-&/8.%6Y!!

- ! X! T! +#! $%&'%(#')#! *%! +#! ,-.&/0.! 123+/&#! &8''%678.*%! %+!*%67#&A8! *%! +86! 6/?-/%.(%6! #6-.(86Y!A((7YZZ[[[F*/7-(#*86F?83F@SZ"%C%6e/3+/8Z*8&Zdh_F*8& !

Y!!

!!

NNNF!b/?/+#'!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!.8'@#6!*%!&8.('8+!C!>/6&#+/D#&/0.!#6)!&8@8!#6%68'#'!C!#78C#'!#!+86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+!/.(%'.8!*%!+#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+B!

!NbF!96(#3+%&%'!+#6!3#6%6!?%.%'#+%6!7#'#!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!#-*/(8')#6!%.! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#!,%*%'#+<! #6)! &8@8! '%#+/D#'! +#6!#-*/(8')#6!=-%!6%! '%=-/%'#.!#! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6!%.!6-6(/(-&/0.!8!#78C8!*%!6-6!7'87/86!0'?#.86!*%!&8.('8+B!

!bF! b/?/+#'! %+! &-@7+/@/%.(8<! 78'! 7#'(%! *%! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!*%!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!%.! @#(%'/#! *%! 7+#.%#&/0.<! 7'%6-7-%6(#&/0.<! /.?'%686<!>/.#.&/#@/%.(8<!/.;%'6/0.<!*%-*#<!7#('/@8./8<!>8.*86!C!;#+8'%6B!!

!! !

cNbF! N.>8'@#'!7%'/0*/&#@%.(%!#+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+<!683'%!%+!'%6-+(#*8!*%! +#! %;#+-#&/0.! '%67%&(8! *%! +#! ?%6(/0.! *%! +#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.(/*#*%6! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#! ,%*%'#+<! #6)! &8@8! *%!#=-%++#6!=-%!A#C#.!6/*8!83:%(8!*%! >/6&#+/D#&/0.<!%! /.>8'@#'!#!+#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!&8@7%(%.(%6<! &-#.*8!7'8&%*#!*%+!'%6-+(#*8!*%!(#+%6!/.(%';%.&/8.%6! C<! %.! 6-! &#68<! */&(#'! +#6! #&&/8.%6! =-%! *%3#.!*%6#''8++#'6%!7#'#!&8''%?/'!+#6!/''%?-+#'/*#*%6!*%(%&(#*#6B!

!cbF!U%&/3/'! C!'%?/6('#'!+#6!*%&+#'#&/8.%6!7#('/@8./#+%6!=-%!*%3#.!7'%6%.(#'! +86! 6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86! *%! +#! T*@/./6('#&/0.! 123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!C!;%'/>/&#'!6-!&8.(%./*8!@%*/#.(%!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!=-%!>-%'%.!7%'(/.%.(%6!*%!#&-%'*8!&8.!+#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!#7+/&#3+%6B!

!

Page 43: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 43 -

!cbNNF!E8.8&%'!%!/.;%6(/?#'!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!=-%!7-%*#.!&8.6(/(-/'!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6B!#7+/&#'!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!=-%!&8''%678.*#.!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+%C!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!7'%6%.(#'!+#6!*%.-.&/#6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!#.(%!%+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8<!

!!T!@#C8'!#3-.*#@/%.(8<!&#3%!@%.&/8.#'!=-%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!4",UT$15<!(/%.%!78'!83:%(8!'%?+#@%.(#'!%+!I )(-+8!E-#'(8!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%!+86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86<!%.!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!@#(%'/#6Y!!

&HLNKBDE(bUa(96(#!"%C!(/%.%!78'!83:%(8!'%?+#@%.(#'!%+!I )(-+8!E-#'(8!*%! +#! E8.6(/(-&/0.! 18+)(/&#! *%! +86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86<!%.!@#(%'/#!*%Y!!.Ua( "86! 6-:%(86! *%! '%678.6#3/+/*#*! #*@/./6('#(/;#! %.! %+! 6%';/&/8!723+/&8B!!..Ua("#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!%.!%+!6%';/&/8!723+/&8B!!...Ua("#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!C!6#.&/8.%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!%.!%+!6%';/&/8!723+/&8B!!.6Ua( "#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!&8@7%(%.(%6!C!%+!7'8&%*/@/%.(8!7#'#!#7+/&#'!*/&A#6!6#.&/8.%6<!C!!6Ua( !

!9.!&8.?'-%.&/#!&8.!+8!#.(%'/8'<!%+!#'()&-+8!KL!*%!+#!",UT$1!&8.(%@7+#!=-%!7#'#!%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!*%! +#!$%&'%(#')#!*%! +#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!%+!&8.('#+8'!/.(%'.8!8!+86!(/(-+# '%6!*%!+#6!M'%#6!*%!#-*/(8')#<!*%!=-%:#6!C!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!DDCOJHQ>(J(KJSE(@>OCFL@IJK@E>CF(?CS@?JTC>LC(TEL@OJ?JF(E(JB?@LEHNJF( HCFMCKLE( ?C( DJF( KE>?BKLJF( ?C( DEF( FCHO@?EHCF( MgSD@KEF( ABC( MBC?J>( KE>FL@LB@H(HCFME>FJS@D@?J?CF( J?T@>@FLHJL@OJF<! 7#'#! +8! &-#+! V6(86<! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! 8! %.(/*#*%6! *%3%'M.!7'878'&/8.#'!+#!/.>8'@#&/0.!C!*8&-@%.(#&/0.!=-%!+%6!6%#.!'%=-%'/*#6F!!9+!/./&/8!*%!+#6!#-*/(8')#6!8!*%!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!#+-*/*#6!%.!%+!7M''#>8!7'%&%*%.(%<!78*')#.!@8(/;#'6%!78'!+#6!=-%:#6!8!*%.-.&/#6!'%&/3/*#6!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+8!*/67-%6(8!78'!%+!#'()&-+8!dL!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86<!@/6@8!=-%!6%!('#.6&'/3%!#!&8.(/.-#&/0.Y!

!X! 9.! +#6! *%7%.*%.&/#6! C! %.(/*#*%6! 6%! %6(#3+%&%'M.!

-./*#*%6!%67%&)>/&#6<!#!+#6!=-%!%+!723+/&8!(%.?#!>M&/+!#&&%68<!7#'#!=-%!&-#+=-/%'! /.(%'%6#*8!7-%*#!7'%6%.(#'!=-%:#6!8!*%.-.&/#6!78'!/.&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86F!!"#6! =-%:#6! 8! *%.-.&/#6! *%3%'M.! &8.(%.%'! *#(86! 8! /.*/&/86! =-%!7%'@/(#.!#*;%'(/'!+#!7'%6-.(#!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!*%+!6%';/*8'!723+/&8F!!"#!$%&'%(#')#!%6(#3+%&%'M!+#6!.8'@#6!C!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!7#'#!=-%!+#6!=-%:#6! 8! *%.-.&/#6! *%+! 723+/&8! 6%#.! #(%.*/*#6! C! '%6-%+(#6! &8.!%>/&/%.&/#F!

Page 44: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 44 -

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d_!*%!+#!",UT$1<!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!6/?-/%.(%6Y!A((7YZZ[[[F*/7-(#*86F?83F@SZ"%C%6e/3+/8Z*8&ZKiLF*8& <!!

X! "#6!6#.&/8.%6!78'!>#+(#!#*@/./6('#(/;#!&8.6/6(/'M.!%.Y!!NFX! T@8.%6(#&/0.!7'/;#*#!8!723+/&#B!!NNFX! $-67%.6/0.! *%+! %@7+%8<! &#'?8!8!&8@/6/0.!78'!-.!7%')8*8!.8!@%.8'!*%!('%6!*)#6!./!@#C8'!#!-.!#J8B!!NNNFX! !]%6(/(-&/0.!*%+!7-%6(8B!!NbFX!$#.&/0.!%&8.0@/&#<!%!!b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bNNN<!c!#!cNb<!cbN<!cNc<!ccNN!C!ccNNN!*%+!#'()&-+8!O!*%!+#!"%CF!!1#'#!=-%!-.#!7%'68.#!=-%!A-3/%'%!6/*8!/.A#3/+/(#*#!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%! +#! "%C! 78'! -.! 7+#D8! @#C8'! *%! */%D! #J86<! 7-%*#! ;8+;%'! #!*%6%@7%J#'!-.!%@7+%8<!&#'?8!8!&8@/6/0.!%.!%+!6%';/&/8!723+/&8!-.#!;%D! ('#.6&-''/*8!%+!7+#D8!*%!+#!/.A#3/+/(#&/0.!/@7-%6(#<!6%!'%=-%'/'M!=-%!%+!(/(-+#'!*%!+#!*%7%.*%.&/#!8!%.(/*#*!#!+#!=-%!7'%(%.*#!/.?'%6#'<!*V! #;/68! #! +#! $%&'%(#')#<! %.! >8'@#! '#D8.#*#! C! :-6(/>/&#*#<! *%! (#+!&/'&-.6(#.&/#F!

Page 45: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 45 -

!"#!&8.('#;%.&/0.!#! +8!*/67-%6(8!78'!%+!7M''#>8!=-%!#.(%&%*%!6%'M!&#-6#!*%! '%678.6#3/+/*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+#!"%C<!=-%*#.*8!6/.!%>%&(86!%+!.8@3'#@/%.(8!8!&8.('#(8!=-%!%.!6-!&#68!6%!

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id!#!ig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`/.(%'/8'`6>7F7*>!!9.('%! +#6!7'/.&/7#+%6!-./*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!&8.! +#6! >#&-+(#*%6!#.(%6!@%.&/8.#*#6<!6%!%.-.&/#.!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6Y!!X!$-36%&'%(#'/#!*%!E8.('8+!C!T-*/(8'/#!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!123+/&#B!X!$-36%&'%(#'/#!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!C!E8.('#(#&/8.%6!123+/&#6B!X!E88'*/.#&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!W'?#.86!*%!b/?/+#.&/#!C!E8.('8+B!X!Q./*#*!*%!9;#+-#&/0.!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!C!%+!]%6%@7%J8!G-3%'.#@%.(#+B!X!Q./*#*!*%!E8.('8+!*%!+#!G%6(/0.!123+/&#B!X!Q./*#*!*%!T-*/(8'/#!G-3%'.#@%.(#+B!X!Q./*#*!*%!E8.('8+!C!T-*/(8'/#!#!\3'#!123+/&#B!X!Q./*#*!*%!\7%'#&/0.!U%?/8.#+!C!E8.('#+8')#!$8&/#+B!X!E8.('#+8')#!N.(%'.#B!X!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!E8.('8;%'6/#6!C!$#.&/8.%6!%.!E8.('#(#&/8.%6!123+/&#6B!X!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!T-*/(8')#6!9S(%'.#6B!X!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!]%.-.&/#6!%!N.;%6(/?#&/8.%6B!X!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!C!$/(-#&/0.!1#('/@8./#+B!X!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.B!X!]%+%?#*86<!$-3*%+%?#*86!C!E8@/6#'/86!123+/&86<!C!X! I /(-+#'%6! *%! W'?#.86! N.(%'.86! *%! E8.('8+! C! +86! *%! 6-6! M'%#6! *%! T-*/(8'/#<! *%! p-%:#6! C! *%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6F!!

Page 46: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 46 -

e5!9.!@#(%'/#!7%.#+!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!%.!6-!#'()&-+8!_a<!>'#&&/0.!cbNN!>#&-+(#!#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!7#'#Y!!

#E>EKCH(C(@>OCFL@IJH!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!=-%!7-%*#.!&8.6(/(-/'!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6B!#7+/&#'!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!=-%!&8''%678.*#.!%.! +86! (V'@/.86!*%!+%C!C<!%.!6-!&#68<!MHCFC>LJH(DJF(?C>B>K@JF(KEHHCFME>?@C>LCF(J>LC(CD(5@>@FLCH@E(0gSD@KE <!7'%6(M.*86%!

!!9.!%6%!6%.(/*8<!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!%6(#3+%&%!+8!6/?-/%.(%Y!!

X! $/! +#! $%&'%(#')#! 8! %+! &8.('#+8'! /.(%'.8! (-;/%'#.!&8.8&/@/%.(8!*%!A%&A86!=-%!/@7+/=-%.!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!7%.#+<!*%3%'M.!*%.-.&/#'+86! #.(%! %+! R/./6(%'/8! 123+/&8! 8<! %.! 6-! &#68<! /.6(#'!#+!M'%#!:-')*/&#! *%! +#! *%7%.*%.&/#! 8! %.(/*#*! '%67%&(/;#! #! =-%! >8'@-+%! +#6!

!!

9.! '#D0.!*%! +8!#.(%'/8'<! 6%!#&+#'#!=-%!6/!3/%.!+#!7#'(%!>/.#+!*%!+#!>'#&&/0.!cbNN!*%+!#'()&-+8!_a!*%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!>#&-+(#!#!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!7#'#!7'%6%.(#'!+#6!*%.-.&/#6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!#.(%!%+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8<!7'%6(M.*86%!7#'#!(#+%6!%>%&(86!+#!&8+#38'#&/0.!=-%!+%!>-%'%!'%=-%'/*#<!(#@3/V.!+8!%6!=-%!+#!/.;%6(/?#&/0.!C!7%'6%&-&/0.!*%!+86!*%+/(86!+%!&8''%678.*%!#!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!6%?2.!6%!#*;/%'(%!*%!+8!7'%;/6(8!%.!%+!#'()&-+8!Kd!7'/@%'!7M''#>8!*%!+#!E8.6(/(-&/0.! 18+)(/&#! *%! +86! 96(#*86! Q./*/.;%6(/?#&/0.!*%!+86!*%+/(86!&8''%678.*%!#+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8!C!#!+#6!78+/&)#6<!+#6!&-#+%6!#&(-#'M.!3#:8!+#!

#'()&-+8!i8F<! >'#&&/0.! N!*%! +#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%! +#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%! +#!U%723+/&#!#+!7'%&/6#'!=-%!

S2$$>&HHIIIB8/>1$%8#)B3#<BDJH(+E+)c/<4/#H>8,HOB>8,' E'2$$>&HHIIIB8/>1$%8#)B3#<BDJH(+E+)c/<4/#H>8,H(X@7KB>8,U!!T*/&/8.#+@%.(%<!6%!@%.&/8.#!=-%!+#!6-36(#.&/#&/0.!*%+!:-/&/8!7%.#+!C!+#!/@786/&/0.!*%!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!=-%!*%'/;%.!*%+!@/6@8<!&8''%678.*%!#!+#!#-(8'/*#*!:-*/&/#+<!%.!+86!(V'@/.86!*%!+8!7'%;/6(8!%.!%+!(%'&%'!7M''#>8!*%+!#'()&-+8!Kd!*%! +#!E8.6(/(-&/0.!18+)(/&#!*%! +86!96(#*86!Q./*86!R%S/&#.86<!%.!%+!=-%!6%!7'%&/6#!=-%!@TMEF@K@G>(?C(DJF(MC>JF8(FB(TE?@X@KJK@G>(P(?BHJK@G>(FE>(MHEM@JF(P(C^KDBF@OJF(?C(DJ(JBLEH@?J?(

<! &8.>8'@%!#! +86! (V'@/.86!C! >8'@#+/*#*%6!7'%;/6(#6!%.!%+!E0*/?8!,%*%'#+!*%!1'8&%*/@/%.(86!1%.#+%6<! 6%?2.! 6%! *%67'%.*%! *%! +#! +%&(-'#! =-%! 6%! >8'@-+%! #+! #'()&-+8! iF!4A((7YZZ[[[F*/7-(#*86F?83F@SZ"%C%6e/3+/8Z7*>Za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a!#!*/&/%@3'%!*%!KLdd!X%6!*%&/'!*-'#.(%!+86!2+(/@86!&/.&8!#J86!68+/&/(#*86XB!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!hJ(XEHTBDJ?E(V``(?C>B>K@JF(MC>JDCF(MEH(JKLEF(?C(KEHHBMK@G> <!%.!+#6!=-%!6%!#('/3-C%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!#*6&'/(86!#!*/;%'6#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!C!%.!#+?-.86!&#686!/.&+-68!#!7#'(/&-+#'%6!/.;8+-&'#*86!(#@3/V.!%.!#&(86!=-%!('#.6?'%*%.!#+?2.!3/%.!:-')*/&8!(-(%+#*8<!+#6!

Page 47: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 47 -

&-#+%6!A#.!@8(/;#*8!%+!/./&/8!*%!/?-#+!.2@%'8!*%!#;%'/?-#&/8.%6!7'%;/#6!#!&#'?8!*%!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#F!!I#+%6!*%.-.&/#6<!8'/?/.#*#6!C!6-6(%.(#*#6!%.! +#!*8&-@%.(#&/0.!'%&#3#*#!*-'#.(%!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6! ++%;#*#6!#!&#38!78'!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!A#.!6/*8!7'%6%.(#*#6!78'!%6(#!]%7%.*%.&/#!*%+!9:%&-(/;8!,%*%'#+!#.(%!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!U%723+/&#<!%.!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+8!*/67-%6(8!%.!+86!#'()&-+86!_a!>'#&&/0.!cbNN!*%!+#!"%C!\'?M./&#!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!dda!*%+!E0*/?8!,%*%'#+!*%!1'8&%*/@/%.(86!1%.#+%6B!#6)!&8@8!%.!+86!.-@%'#+%6!dK!>'#&&/0.!cNNN!C!dh!>'#&&/0.!N!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!&-C86!(%S(86!%.!+8!&8.*-&%.(%!6%!('#6&'/3%.!#!&8.(/.-#&/0.!7#'#!7'8.(#!'%>%'%.&/#F!!

*CP(4HIQ>@KJ(?C(DJ(&?T@>@FLHJK@G>(0gSD@KJ(+C?CHJD (!

X!T!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!&8''%678.*%!%+!*%67#&A8!*%!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!#6-.(86Y!

!!cbNNF! E8.8&%'! %! /.;%6(/?#'! +#6! &8.*-&(#6! *%! +86! 6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<! =-%! 7-%*#.! &8.6(/(-/'! '%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6B!#7+/&#'!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!=-%!&8''%678.*#.!%.!+86!(V'@/.86! *%! +%C! C<! %.! 6-! &#68<! 7'%6%.(#'! +#6! *%.-.&/#6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!#.(%!%+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8<!7'%6(M.*86%!7#'#!(#+!%>%&(8!+#!&8+#38'#&/0.!=-%!+%!>-%'%!'%=-%'/*#B!!

!!#G?@IE(+C?CHJD(?C(0HEKC?@T@C>LEF(0C>JDCF(!

X! I8*#! 7%'68.#! =-%! %.! %:%'&/&/8! *%! >-.&/8.%6!723+/&#6! (%.?#!&8.8&/@/%.(8!*%! +#!7'83#3+%!%S/6(%.&/#!*%!-.!*%+/(8!=-%!*%3#!7%'6%?-/'6%!*%!8>/&/8<!%6(M!83+/?#*#!#!7#'(/&/7#'+8!/.@%*/#(#@%.(%!#+!R/./6(%'/8!123+/&8<!('#6@/(/V.*8+%!(8*86!+86!*#(86!=-%!(-;/%'%<!78./%.*8!#!6-!*/6786/&/0.<!*%6*%!+-%?8<!#!+86!

!!

$CIDJTC>LE(.>LCH@EH(?C(DJ(!CKHCLJHNJ(?C(DJ(+B>K@G>(0gSD @KJ(!TUIwEQ"\!dKFX!E8''%678.*%'M!#!+#!Q./*#*!*%!T6-.(86!f-')*/&86!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!#('/3-&/8.%6Y!!

!!cNNNF! E88'*/.#'6%! &8.! +#! 1'8&-'#*-')#! C! &8.! +#! 1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!f-6(/&/#!*%+!]/6('/(8!,%*%'#+!7#'#!+#!/.;%6(/?#&/0.!*%!+86!*%+/(86!*%+!8'*%.!>%*%'#+!8!&8@2.!=-%!6%!*%(%&(%.!&8.!@8(/;8!*%! +#6! #&&/8.%6!87%'#(/;#6!*%! +#!$%&'%(#')#<! &8#*C-;#.*8!%.!'%7'%6%.(#&/0.! *%! +#! @/6@#! %.! +86! 7'8&%*/@/%.(86! 7%.#+%6<!78+)(/&86!C!#*@/./6('#(/;86!&8''%678.*/%.(%6B!

!!

Page 48: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 48 -

TUIwEQ"\!dhFX!E8''%678.*%'M!#!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!T*:-.(#!*%!T6-.(86!1%.#+%6!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!#('/3-&/8.%6Y!!NF 1'%6%.(#'! #.(%! %+! R/./6(%'/8! 123+/&8! &8@7%(%.(%! +#6!

*%.-.&/#6! C! =-%'%++#6! 78'! A%&A86! 7'83#3+%@%.(%!&8.6(/(-(/;86!*%!*%+/(8!=-%!'%6-+(%.!*%!+#!#7+/&#&/0.!*%!7'8&%*/@/%.(86<!7'8?'#@#6!C!87%'#(/;86!#!&#'?8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!C!=-%!#>%&(%.!+86!/.(%'%6%6!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!C! 8(8'?#'! %+! 7%'*0.! +%?#+! %.! +86! &#686! %.! =-%! 6%#!7'8&%*%.(%B!

!NNF !

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f-6(/&/#!,/6&#+!C!T*@/./6('#(/;#F!!T!%6(%! '%67%&(8<! &#3')#!&8@%.(#'!=-%!%.! (V'@/.86!?%.%'#+%6! &8.>8'@%!#! +86!#'()&-+86!dO!C!Ki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f-6(/&/#!,/6&#+!C!T*@/./6('#(/;#F!

E8.!'%67%&(8!#!+86!7-.(86!//<!///!C!/;!6%!#.%S#.!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!%6(#*)6(/&#6Y!!

T.%S8!d!4p-/.(8!N.>8'@%!*%!"#38'%6!*%!+#!$,15!#F ^2@%'8!*%!6#.&/8.%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!/@7-%6(#6!#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!78'!*%7%.*%.&/#!C!

78'!(/78!*%!6#.&/0.F!3F ^2@%'8!*%!6#.&/8.%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6!/@7-%6(#6!#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!78'!*%7%.*%.&/#!C!

8'/?%.F!!&F ^2@%'8!*%!6#.&/8.%6!>/'@%6!78'!*%7%.*%.&/#!C!(/78!*%!6#.&/0.F!!*F ^2@%'8!*%!*%.-.&/#6!7%.#+%6!78'!*%7%.*%.&/#!C!%.(/*#*<!6%?2.!.2@%'8!*%!7%'68.#6!C!

@8.(86!/.;8+-&'#*86F!!!

Page 49: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 49 -

T.%S8!KF!^2@%'8!*%!&#686!/.;%6(/?#*86!C!*%&/6/8.%6!#*87(#*#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!#*@/./6('#(/;#6F!!

T.%S8! _F! ^2@%'8!*%!6#.&/8.%6! /@7-%6(#6!78'! +#!$,1<! +#!E8.('#+8')#! N.(%'.#!*%! +#!$,1!C! +86!W'?#.86!N.(%'.86!*%!E8.('8+F!!

T.%S8!iF!R8.(8!*%!+#6!6#.&/8.%6!%&8.0@/&#6!/@7-%6(#6!+#!$,1<!+#!E8.('#+8')#!N.(%'.#!*%!+#!$,1!C!+86!W'?#.86!N.(%'.86!*%!E8.('8+F!!

T.%S8!hF!R8.(86!'%&-7%'#*86!#.-#+@%.(%F! T.%S8!gF!^2@%'8!*%!&#686! /.;%6(/?#*86!C!*%&/6/8.%6!#*87(#*#6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!;%'/>/&#&/0.!*%!

%;8+-&/0.!7#('/@8./#+F!(

!E ) #E>(HCFMCKLE(J(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(FCDCKK@E>J?EF(C>(DJ(HCFMBCFLJ(

J(DJ(MHCIB>LJ(2=8(@>XEHTC(SHCOCTC>LC(FESHC(?@X@KBDLJ?CF(MJHJ(CD(DEIHE(?C(DEF(MHEMGF@LEF(?C(MHCOC>@H8(?CLCKLJH(P(FJ>K@E>JH(DJF(MHQKL@KJF(KEHHBMLJF8(ABC(FCJ>(MCHL@>C>LCF(LC>@C>?E(C>(KBC>LJ(FBF(XB>K@E>CF8(P(F@(KEHHCFME>?C8(@?C>L@X@ABC(>CKCF@?J?CF(CFMCKNX@KJF(?C(KEEMCHJK@G>(LZK>@KJU!

E8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!>8'(#+%&%'!+#!+-&A#!&8.('#!+#!&8''-7&/0.!'%6-+(#!.%&%6#'/8Y!

bU +EHLJDCKCH(CD(TJHKE([BHN?@KE\((

9.!7#'(/&-+#'!6%!'%=-/%'%!+#!#7'83#&/0.!78'!7#'(%!*%!+#!EM@#'#!*%!]/7-(#*86!*%+!E8.?'%68!@%S/&#.#!*%!*86!/./&/#(/;#6! *%! +%C<! 7'%6%.(#*#6! 78'! %+! 9:%&-(/;8! ,%*%'#+! C! #7'83#*#6! 78'! @#C8')#! %.! +#! EM@#'#! *%!$%.#*8'%6F!!

96(#6!/./&/#(/;#6!*%!+%C!68.Y!!

dF N./&/#(/;#!=-%!'%>8'@#!*/;%'686!#'()&-+86!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!,-.&/8.#'/86!123+/&86!&8.!%+!>/.!*%!7'8(%?%'!#!+86!*%.-.&/#.(%6!C!*%!&-#+=-/%'!7%'68.#!=-%!#78'(#!/.>8'@#&/0.!;#+/86#!7#'#!+86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/0.<!#-*/(8'/#!8!*/6&/7+/.#'/#6F!!

!KF N./&/#(/;#!*%!"%C!T.(/&8''-7&/0.!%.!E8.('#(#&/8.%6!123+/&#6F!

!"#!7'/@%'#!/./&/#(/;#!(/%.%!78'!83:%(8!>8'(#+%&%'!%+!@#'&8!:-')*/&8!=-%!'%?-+#!+#6!'%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!*%! >8'@#!7#'(/&-+#'<!7+#.(%#!&'%#'! +#6!&8.*/&/8.%6!=-%!/.&%.(/;%.!C!>#;8'%D&#.!+#6!*%.-.&/#6!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!C!+86!7#'(/&-+#'%6!=-%!&8.8D&#.!*%!7'M&(/&#6!=-%!'%6-+(%.!/ +%?#+%6!C<!78'!(#.(8<!&8.('#;%.?#.!+86!7'/.&/7/86!=-%!'/?%.!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%!+#!>-.&/0.!723+/&#F!!!"#!/./&/#(/;#!*%!+%C!&8.(/%.%!+86!6/?-/%.(%6!%+%@%.(86Y!!

,8'(#+%&/@/%.(8!*%! +#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%! +86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!%.!#'#6!*%!7'8(%?%'!#!+86!*%.-.&/#.(%6!C!7%'68.#6!=-%!7'878'&/8.%.!/.>8'@#&/0.!'%+#&/8.#*#!&8.!7'%6-.(86!A%&A86!/''%?-+#'%6<!#6)!&8@8!/.&8'78'#&/0.!*%!6-!/.&-@7+/@/%.(8!&8@8!-.#!/.>'#&&/0.!*%!&#'M&(%'!?'#;%<!+8!&-#+!&8.++%;#')#!+#!*%6(/(-&/0.!%!/.A#3/+/(#&/0.!*%!dL!#!KL!#J86!#+!6%';/*8'!723+/ &8!=-%!'%6-+(%!'%678.6#3+%F!

$%!/.&8'78'#.!+#6!&8.*/&/8.%6!=-%!7'87/&/#.!=-%!+#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!&8@7%(%.(%6!/.6('-@%.(%.!6/6(%@#6!%>/&#&%6!=-%!>#&/+/(%.!+#!*%.-.&/#!*%!#=-%++86!#&(86!=-%!&8.('#;%.?#.!+86!7'/.&/7/86!=-%!'/?%.!%+!%:%'&/&/8!*%!+#!>-.&/0.!723+/&#F!

$%!A#&%!%S7'%6#!+#!786/3/+/*#*!*%!7'%6%.(#'!*%.-.&/#6!C!=-%:#6!#.0./@#6F!

Page 50: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 50 -

]#*8!=-%!+#!*%.-.&/#!*%!#&(86!*%!&8''-7&/0.!%6!&8.6/*%'#*#!&8@8!-.#!*%!+#6!%6('#(%?/#6!@M6!%S/(86#6!%.!%+!&8@3#(%!#!+#!@/6@#B!6%!%6(#3+%&%.!@%*/*#6!*%!7'8(%&&/0.!%67%&)>/&#6!#!>#;8'!*%!+86!*%.-.&/#.(%6!C!*%!(8*#6!+#6!7%'68.#6!=-%!#78'(%.!/.>8'@#&/0.!;#+/86#!'%+#&/8.#*#!&8.!+#!&8@/6/0.!*%!A%&A86!/''%?-+#'%6F!

$%!/.&8'78'#'!6-7-%6(86!7#'#!>8'(#+%&%'!+#!83+/?#&/0.!7'%;/6(#!%.!%+!#'()&-+8!O<!>'#&&/0.!ccN!*%!+#!"%C!,%*%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!T*@/./6('#(/;#6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86<!#!>/.!*%!=-%!+#! $%&'%(#'/#! *%! +#! ,-.&/0.! 123+/&#<! 6%!#6%?-'%.!*%!=-%! +86!7'8&%*/@/%.(86<! ('M@/(%6!C!6%';/&/86!%.! +86!=-%!7#'(/&/7%.!+86!*%.-.&/#.(%6!%!/.>8'@#.(%6<!6%!*%6#''8++%.!&8.!%6('/&(8!#7%?8! #! +#! .8'@#(/;/*#*<! 8! 3/%.<! *%! =-%! +86! 6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%.-.&/#.(%6<!.8!6%#.!+%6/8.#*86!%.!>8'@#!#+?-.#!%.!6-!%.(8'.8!+#38'#+F!

$%!/.&8'78'#!-.!6/6(%@#!*%!/.&%.(/;86!7#'#!7'8@8;%'!+#6!*%.-.&/#6!C!+#!&8+#38'#&/0.!%.!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6Y!3%.%>/&/86!%&8.0@/&86<!%6()@-+86!C!'%&8@7%.6#6<!#*%@M6!*%!+#!*/6@/.-&/0.!*%!6#.&/8.%6!7#'#!#=-%++86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!=-%!#-.!C!&-#.*8!7#'(/&/7%.!%.!+86!A%&A86!/''%?-+#'%6<!&8#*C-;%.!&8.!+#!#-(8'/*#*!(#.(8!%.!%+!&8.8&/@/%.(8!*%!+86!@/6@86<!&8@8!%.!6-!&8@7'83#&/0.!C!'%&8.8&/@/%.(86!.8!%&8.0@/&86!7#'#!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!=-%!*%.-.&/%.!#&(86!*%!&8''-7&/0.F!

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

!"#!6%?-.*#! /./&/#(/;#! (/%.%!78'!83:%(8!*/678.%'! +#! '%678.6#3/+/*#*!C! +#6!6#.&/8.%6!#! +#6!=-%!6%!A#'M.!#&'%%*8'#6!+#6!7%'68.#6!>)6/&#6!C!@8'#+%6<!.#&/8.#+%6!C!%S('#.:%'#6<!78'!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!/''%?-+#'%6!7'%;/6(#6!%.!+#!"%C!%.!=-%!/.&-''#.!&8.!@8(/;8!*%!6-!7#'(/&/7#&/0.!%.!+#6!&8.('#(#&/8.%6!723+/&#6!*%!&#'M&(%'!>%*%'#+B!#6)!&8@8!+#6!7%'68.#6!>)6/&#6!C!@8'#+%6!.#&/8.#+%6!78'!6-!&8.*-&(#!/''%?-+#'!%.!('#.6#&&/8.%6!&8@%'&/#+%6!/.(%'.#&/8.#+%6!#6)!&8@8!%6(#3+%&%'!+#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!>%*%'#+%6!&8@7%(%.(%6!4$,15!7#'#!/.(%'7'%(#'!C!#7+/&#'!*/&A#!+%CF!!!"#!/./&/#(/;#!*%!+%CY!!!

E8.(/%.%! +#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!#7+/&#3+%6!#!*/&A86!#&(86<!=-%!7%'@/(%.!6#.&/8.#'!#!6-!;%D!#!7#'(/&-+#'%6!=-%!83(/%.%.!-.!3%.%>/&/8!/.*%3/*8! (#.(8!%.!7'8&%*/@/%.(86!*%!&8.('#(#&/8.%6!723+/&#6!*%!&#'M&(%'!.#&/8.#+<!&8@8!%.!('#.6#&&/8.%6!&8@%'&/#+%6!/.(%'.#&/8.#+%6<!*/&A#!/.&+-6/0.<!6-36#.#!+#!8@/6/0.!=-%!#&(-#+@%.(%!6%!%.&-%.('#!%.!+#6!+%C%6!#7+/&#3+%6!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!&8.('#(#&/8.%6!723+/&#6F!

N.&8'78'#!&8.!-.!@#C8'!#+&#.&%!%.!+#!/@786/&/0.!*%!@-+(#6!%!/.A#3/+/(#&/0.<!7'%;/%.*8!#*%@M6!+#!%S&+-6/0.!*%!&/%'(86!3%.%>/&/86!723+/&86F!

N.&8'78'#!-.#!*%6&'/7&/0.!*%!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!/''%?-+#'%6!=-%!6%'M.!6#.&/8.#*#6F!! 96(#3+%&%!%+!7'8&%*/@/%.(8!#*@/./6('#(/;8!6#.&/8.#*8'F!! 96(#3+%&%!-.!.-%;8!6/6(%@#!*%!6#.&/8.%6!C!*%!'%*-&&/0.!*%!6#.&/8.%6!!

!cU +EHLJDCK@T@C>LE(?C(DEF(TCKJ>@FTEF(KEEH?@>JK@G>(@>LCH@>FL@LBK@E>JD (!E8.! +#! >/.#+/*#*!*%! >8'(#+%&%'! +#6!#&&/8.%6<!7'8?'#@#6!C!78+)(/&#6!*%6(/.#*86!#!7'%;%./'! C! &8@3#(/'! +#!&8''-7&/0.<!'%6-+(#!.%&%6#'/8!>8'(#+%&%'!+86!@%&#./6@86!/.(%'/.6(/(-&/8.#+%6!*%!&88'*/.#&/0.F!9.!7#'(/&-+#'<!6%!*%3%'M!>#&/+/(#'!%+!/.(%'&#@3/8!*%!/.>8'@#&/0.!C!@%:8'#'!+#!#'(/&-+#&/0.!*%!%6>-%'D86!%.('%!+#6!/.6(#.&/#6!'%678.6#3+%6! *%! +#!7'%;%.&/0.<!*%(%&&/0.!C!6#.&/0.!*%!7'M&(/&#6!C!&8.*-&(#6!&8''-7(#6!=-%!?%.%'#.!'%678.6#3/+/*#*!#*@/./6('#(/;#!C!7%.#+<!#6)!&8@8!&8.!+#6!/.6(#.&/#6!>/6&#+%6!C!*%!/.(%+/?%.&/#!*%+!96(#*8F!!

Page 51: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 51 -

!dU #EHHCFME>FJS@D@?J?(?C(DEF(ELHEF(ME?CHCF(P(GH?C>CF(?C(IES@CH>E(JFN(KETE(?C(DJ(FEK@C?J?(C>(

IC>CHJDU((!

,/.#+@%.(%<!C!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!&8.68+/*#'!-.#!;%'*#*%'#!78+)(/&#!*%!96(#*8!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!7'%;%.&/0.!C!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.<!'%6-+(#!.%&%6#'/#!+#!&8''%678.6#3/+/*#*!*%!+86!78*%'%6!"%?/6+#(/;8!C!f-*/&/#+!#6)!&8@8!*%!+86!?83/%'.86!+8&#+%6!496(#(#+%6!C!@-./&/7#+%65!C!*%!+#!68&/%*#*!%.!6-!&8.:-.(8F!!!VU -CKCF@?J?CF(?C(KEEMCHJK@G>(LZK>@KJ(

!U%67%&(8!#!786/3+%6!#&(/;/*#*%6!*%!#6/6(%.&/#!(V&./&#!6%!A#!/*%.(/>/&#*8!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!M'%#6Y!!

'NF N.(%'&#@3/8!*%!3-%.#6!7'M&(/&#6Y!+#!#6/6(%.&/#!(V&./&#!6%!&%.('#!%.!+#!8'/%.(#&/0.!:-')*/&#!C!+#!

*/6('/3-&/0.!*%!-.#! '%&87/+#&/0.!*%!3-%.#6!7'M&(/&#6!C!%.6%J#.D#6!%S('#)*#6<!#6)!&8@8!+#!#6/6(%.&/#!*%!%S7%'(86!/.!6/(-!C!%.!+#!%+#38'#&/0.!*%!-.!7+#.!*%!#&&/0.F!

!NNF T6/6(%.&/#!:-*/&/#+!'%&)7'8&#Y!6%!*%3%!*#'!7'/8'/*#*!#!+#!8'/%.(#&/0.!:-')*/&#<!+#!*/;-+?#&/0.!*%!

3-%.#6!7'M&(/&#6!C!%.6%J#.D#6!%S('#)*#6<!C!+#!%+#38'#&/0.!*%!-.#!?-)#!7'M&(/&#!C!@#(%'/#+!*%!&#7#&/(#&/0.F!

!NNNF N.;%6(/?#&/8.%6! &8.:-.(#6Y! '%#+/D#&/0.! *%! /.;%6(/?#&/8.%6! &8.:-.(#6<! /.(%'&#@3/8! *%!

/.>8'@#&/0.!C!&8+#38'#&/0.!%.('%!#-(8'/*#*%6!.#&/8.#+%6F!!!

NbF IV&./&#6!%67%&/#+%6!*%! /.;%6(/?#&/0.Y!#6%68'#@/%.(8! :-')*/&8!C! +#!*/;-+?#&/0.!*%!3-%.#6!7'M&(/&#6!C!(V&./&#6!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/0.!%!/.(%+/?%.&/#!7#'#!%+!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!!

F) !@(DE(?CFCJ8(@>XEHTC(KETE(TQ @TE(FESHC(B>J(SBC>J(MHQKL@KJ(?CFJHHEDDJ?J(C>(HCDJK@G>(KE>(FBF(XB>K@E>CF(MEH(KJ?J(B>E(?C(DEF(GHIJ>EF(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(FCDCKK@E>J?EF(C>(DJ(HCFMBCFLJ(J(DJ(MHCIB>LJ(2=(ABC(FC(AB@CHJ(KETMJHL@H(KE>(DEF(?CTQF(MJNFCF(@>LCIHJ>LCF(?CD(5"!.#.#8(BL@D@iJ>?E(MJHJ(CFLE8(C>(DE(ABC(KE>F@?CHC(JMHEM@J?E8(CD(XEHTJLE(CFLQ>?JH(FBICH@?E(KETE(IBNJ(MJHJ(MHCFC>LJH(CFLJ(@>XEHTJK@G>(ABC(FC(J>C^J(JD(MHCFC>LC(KBCFL@E>JH@E(;J>C^E(..=U((

Page 52: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 52 -

!"##./-(...(!

.-+4$5&#./-(!42$"(*&(&,%4$.)&)($"!04-!&2*"()"*().*.3"-#.&5."-%4()"*(0$"!"-%"(#,"!%.4-&$.4(!

18'!>#;8'<! &8@7+%(%!+#!6/?-/%.(%!/.>8'@#&/0.Y!!

4#5!96(#*8!1#'(%Y!RVS/&8!435!9+!>-.&/8.#'/8!#!=-/V.!7-%*%!&8.6-+(#'6%!683'%!+#6!'%67-%6(#6!*#*#6!#!%6(%!&-%6(/8.#'/8!%6Y!!$'FZ$'#FY!$'F!T+>'%*8!967#'D#!f#/@%!I)(-+8Z&#'?8Y!]/'%&(8'!G%.%'#+!T*:-.(8!*%!96(-*/86!C!18+)(/&#6!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!U%.*/&/0.!*%!E-%.(#6!\'?#./6@8Z8>/&/.#Y!Q./*#*!*%!18+)(/&#6!*%!I'#.67#'%.&/#!C!E887%'#&/0.!N.(%'.#&/8.#+!X!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!!]8@/&/+/8Y!R/?-%+!"#-'%.(! 2@F!K_h<!d%'!7/68<!E8+F!]%+!b#++%<!L_KLL!RVS/&8<!]F, !E8''%8!%+%&('0./&8Y!#%67#'D#x>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@S!^2@%'8!*%!(%+V>8.8Y!hK!hh!KLLLXdLaL!!^2@%'8!*%!>#SY!!

!

Page 53: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 53 -

+4$5&%4("!%:-)&$(!,3"$.)4(#454(3,'&(0&$&(0$"!"-%&$(.-+4$5&#./-(!42$"(2,"-&!(0$:#%.#&!(bk((

.>FL@LBK@G>\($%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#! !]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.!4]GNN5F!

!cUa( %NLBDE\(

1'8?'#@#!Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8F!!dUa( )CFKH@MK@G>(?C(DJ(SBC>J(MHQKL@KJU(! "#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!6%!%.&-%.('#!/.@%'6#!%.!-.!7'8&%68!*%!/..8;#&/0.!%6('#(V?/&#!

=-%! /.;8+-&'#! %.('%! 8('#6<! +#! #(%.&/0.! /.@%*/#(#! #! +#! *%.-.&/#! &/-*#*#.#<! %+! *%6#''8++8! *%!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!%6('-&(-'#+%6!%.!M'%#6!>8&#+/D#*#6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!#@3#6!%.!&88'*/.#&/0.!&8.!8('#6!*%7%.*%.&/#6!*%!?83/%'.8<!&8.!%+!7'8706/(8!*%!?%.%'#'!%6('#(%?/#6!C!78+)(/&#6!723+/&#6! *%! &8'(8<! @%*/#.8! C! +#'?8! #+&#.&%<! =-%!&8#*C-;%.!#!*/6-#*/'<! &8.(%.%'!C!%''#*/&#'! +#!&8''-7&/0.!%.!+#6!*/;%'6#6!/.6(#.&/#6!C!./;%+%6!*%+!?83/%'.8!>%*%'#+!@%S/&#.8F!

!! ]%! (#+!@#.%'#!=-%!*%.('8!*%!6-6!&#@3/86!%6('-&(-'#+%6!*M!&#3/*#!#!+#!&'%#&/0.!*%!+#!]/'%&&/0.!

G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!/.(%?'#&/0.!4]GNN5<!&-C#6!>-.&/8.%6!6%!%.>8&#.!#!/.;%6(/?#'!@#6!#++M!*%!+8!=-%!#!6/@7+%!;/6(#!6%!7-%*%!*%(%&(#'<!('#6!6-!&'%#&/0.!6%!+%!&8.>/'/%'8.!;#'/#6!#('/3-&/8.%6<!-.#!*%!%++#6<!%+!*%.8@/.#*8!1'8?'#@#!Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8<!=-%!&8.6/6(%!%.!+#!;%'/>/&#&/0.!*%+!&-@7+/@/%.(8!*%!+#6!83+/?#&/8.%6!*%!+86!>-.&/8.#'/86!723+/&86<!%+!&-#+!#!+#!>%&A#!A#!*#*8!?'#.*%6!6#(/6>#&&/8.%6!#!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!%.!(8'.8!#+!&8@3#(%!>'8.(#+!%@7'%.*/*8!&8.('#!+#!&8''-7&/0.F!

!VUa( $JiE>CF(C(.TMEHLJ>K@JU(

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

WUa( ">XEABCU("86! 87%'#(/;86! *%! Q6-#'/8! $/@-+#*8! 68.! -.#! %6('#(%?/#! 87%'#(/;#! 7#'#! *%(%.%'!%.! >+#?'#.&/#!C!6#.&/8.#'<! 7%.#+! C! #*@/./6('#(/;#@%.(%<! #! 6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86! *%! (8*86! +86! ./;%+%6! *%! +#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+<!=-%!-(/+/D#.!6-!&#'?8!7#'#!83(%.%'!#+?2.!3%.%>/&/8!%&8.0@/&8!8!7%'68.#+<!&8''8@7/%.*8!6-6!#('/3-&/8.%6<!#*%@M6!*%!+%6/8.#'!&8.!6-!#&(-#&/0.!#!+#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%+!96(#*8!R%S/&#.8!C!%+!/.(%'V6!&/-*#*#.8F!

!

1. Las preguntas contenidas en el presente formato tienen como propósito guiar a los Estados acerca de la información que podrían suministrar sobre buenas prácticas, en caso de que así lo deseen, y serían respondidas en lo que consideren apropiado.

Page 54: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 54 -

(_Ua( .TMDCTC>LJK@G>U(! $%!/@7+%@%.(0!C!6%!@#.(/%.%!+#!*/>-6/0.!723+/&#!%.!+86!*/>%'%.(%6!@%*/86!%+%&('0./&86!C!#-*/8;/6-# +%6!

*%!+#!%S/6(%.&/#!C!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!%6(#!%6('#(%?/#<!&8.!+#!>/.#+/*#*!*%!#+%.(#'!#!+#!&/-*#*#.)#!7#'#!=-%!7'%6%.(%! +#6!*%.-.&/#6!&8''%678.*/%.(%6!%.!&8.('#!*%!@#+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86<!C!*%!/.A/3/'!+#6!&8.*-&(#6!&8''-7(#6!%.!%6(86!2+(/@86F!

!E8.! %+! 83:%(/;8! *%!#@7+/#'! +#6!#&&/8.%6!C! '%6-+(#*86!*%+!1'8?'#@#!Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8<! 6%!%6(M.!/.&8'78'#.*8!Q./*#*%6!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%.!+86!W'?#.86!N.(%'.86!*%!E8.('8+!%.!+#!]%7%.*%.&/#6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!=-%<!78'!6-!.#(-'#+%D#!C!.%&%6/*#*!*%!#(%.&/0.! #!+#!&/-*#*#.)#<!'%=-/%'%.! '%>8'D#'! +#6!#&&/8.%6!=-%!%.!%6(%! (%@#! '%#+/D#! +#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.F!

!eUa( )CFJXNEFU(! 9.!%+!7#)6!%.!?%.%'#+<!%S/6(%!78&#!&-+(-'#!683'%! +#!*%.-.&/#!%.!&8.('#!*%!*%+/(86!&8@%(/*86!78'!

6%';/*8'%6! 723+/&86<! %6(8! 6%! *%3%! %.! 7#'(%! #! =-%! %S/6(%! +#!7%'&%7&/0.!*%!=-%!6/!%+! &/-*#*#.8!*%.-.&/#<!.8!78*'M! '%#+/D#'!+86!('M@/(%6!8!'%&/3/'!+86!6%';/&/86!'%=-%'/*86<!#-.#*8!#+!(%@8'!*%!6%'!83:%(8!*%!'%7'%6#+/#6!78'!7#'(%!*%!+86!>-.&/8.#'/86!*%.-.&/#*86F!

!! 18'!%++8<! +#!]GNN!#6%68'#!#+!&/-*#*#.8<!+8!#&8@7#J#!%.!+#!@%*/*#!*%!+8!786/3+%<!6/.!('#6?'%*/'!+#!

.8'@#(/;/*#*!#7+/&#3+%<!*-'#.(%!+#!7'%6%.(#&/0.!*%!+#!*%.-.&/#<!C!-.#!;%D!/./&/#*8!%+!7'8&%68!7%.#+!6/!+8!A-3/%'%<!@#.(/%.%!&8.(#&(8!&8.!%+!*%.-.&/#.(%!A#6(#!+#!&8.&+-6/0.!*%+!7'8&%*/@/%.(8!C!#!6-!;%D!+#!]/'%&&/0.!6%!'%('8#+/@%.(#!*%!+86!#;#.&%6!+8?'#*86!%.!%+!*%6#''8++8!*%+!&#68F!

!fUa( $CFBDLJ?EFU(! ]%!6%7(/%@3'%!*%!KLLO!#!.8;/%@3'%!*%!KLdd<!6%!A#.!'%#+/D#*8!g_!87%'#(/;86<!*%!+86!&-#+%6!%+!dLLj!

A#!*%'/;#*8!%.!7'8&%*/@/%.(8!7%.#+!C!#*@/./6('#(/;8<!+8?'#.*8!*%(%&(#'!C!*%(%.%'!%.!>+#?'#.&/#!#!ah!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!78'!+86!*%+/(86!*%Y!&8A%&A8<!%S(8'6/0.<!A86(/?#@/%.(8!6%S-#+<!#3-68!*%!#-(8'/*#*<!'838!C!>'#-*%!460+8!-.8!*%!+86!ah!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!/.;8+-&'#*86!%6(M!7'0>-?85B!#6/@ /6@8<!*-'#.(%!+86!87%'#(/;86! >-%'8.!*%(%./*86!78'!6-!7#'(/&/7#&/0.<!*86! /.(%?'#.(%6!*%! +#!18+/&)#!R/./6(%'/#+!*%+!96(#*8!*%!E#@7%&A%<!*86! >#+686!%+%@%.(86!*%! +#!T?%.&/#!,%*%'#+!*%!N.;%6(/?#&/0.!41GU5!%.!%+!96(#*8! *%! b%'#&'-D<! -.#! 76%-*8! 6%&'%(#'/#! C! *86! %@7'%6#'/86! *%! 8'/?%.! &A/.8! 4-.8! *%! %++86!.#(-'#+/D#*8!%6(#*8-./*%.6%5F!

!! "86!*%+/(86!=-%!6%!A#.!(/7/>/&#*8!%.!%6(86!87%'#(/;86!68.Y!>'#-*%<!&8A%&A8<!'838<!%S(8'6/0.<!#&868!

6%S-#+<!%S(8'6/0.!%.!?'#*8!*%!(%.(#(/;#<!>'#-*%!%=-/7#'#*8<!#3-68!*%!#-(8'/*#*<!%:%'& /&/8!/.*%3/*8!*%!>-.&/8.%6!C!78'(#&/0.!*%!#'@#!*%!>-%?8!*%!-68!%S&+-6/;8!*%+!%:V'&/(8F!

!! $%!A#!+8?'#*8!#!6-!;%D<! >8'(#+%&%'!+#!&88'*/.#&/0.!/.(%'/.6(/(-&/8.#+!&8.!+#!1'8&-'#*-')#!G%.%'#+!*%!+#!

U%723+/&#<!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!$%?-'/*#*!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!C!+#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!*%!+#!T*@/./6('#&/0.!123+/&#!,%*%'#+!&8.!+#6!=-%!6%!A#.!*%6#''8++#*8!+86!87%'#(/;86F!

!<Ua( !CIB@T@C>LEU(! T2.! &-#.*8! +#! #('/3-&/0.! &8.&+-C%! -.#!;%D!=-%!6%!*%(/%.%!#+! /.>'#&(8'<! +#!]GNN! &8.(/.2#!*#.*8!

6%?-/@/%.(8!#+!7'8&%68!*%+!&#68!@%*/#.(%!&8.(#&(8!&8.!+86!*%.-.&/#.(%6<!&88'*/.#&/0.!&8.!+#6!M'%#6!:-')*/&#6! C! *%! '%678.6#3/+/*#*%6! (#.(8! *%! +86! W'?#.86! N.(%'.86! *%! E8.('8+! &8@8! *%! +#! 7'87/#!$%&'%(#')#<!7#'#!;%'/>/&#'!%+!#;#.&%!83(%./*8!*%!&#*#!7'8&%68!/.6(#-'#*8F!

!! $%!%+#38'#.!+86!/.>8'@%6!*%!#;#.&%6!'%=-%'/*86!78'!+#6!*/6(/.(#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!683'%!&#*#!-.8!*%!+86!

87%'#(/;86!'%#+/D#*86F!

Page 55: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 55 -

!b`Ua( *CKK@E>CF(JMHC>?@?JFU(! ,8@%.(#'!C! '%7+/&#'!%+!1'8?'#@#!Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8!C#!=-%!6%!A#!786/&/8.#*8!&8@8!-.8!*%!+86!

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

!!!!!!!!!E8.(/.-#'! &8.! +#! &#@7#J#! %@7'%.*/*#! %.! +86! @%*/86! *%! &8@-./&#&/0.! (#.(8! /@7'%686! &8@8!

%+%&('0./&86<!C#!=-%!6%!A#!?%.%'#*8!-.!/@7#&(8!786/(/;8!78'!+#!*/>-6/0.!*%!+#!%S/6(%.&/#!C!%>/&#&/#!*%+!1'8?'#@#!Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8<!#6)!&8@8!+86!'%6-+(#*86!*%+!@/6@8<!#*%@M6!*%!=-%!%+!%>%&(8!/.A/3/(8'/8!#+&#.D#*8!%.('%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86!*%!+#!T1,<!A#!&8#*C-;#*8!#!'%&-7%'#'!+#!&8.>/#.D#!&/-*#*#.#!%.!+#6!/.6(/(-&/8.%6!C!6-!&#7#&/*#*!*%!'%#&&/0.!%.!*%>%.6#!*%!6-6!/.(%'%6%6F!

!!bbUa( )EKBTC>LEFU(

9.!+#6!6/?-/%.(%6!+/?#6!6%!%.&-%.('#.!-.#!3'%;%!'%6%J#!*%+!1'8?'#@#!Q6-#'/8!$/@-+#*8<!#6)!&8@8!;/*%86!83(%./*86!*-'#.(%!%+!*%6#''8++8!*%!+86!87%'#(/;86!'%#+/D#*86!*%!KLLP!#!+#!>%&A#F!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z7'8?'#@#6Z-6-#'/8X6/@-+#*8FA(@+!A((7YZZ[[[F>-.&/8.7-3+/&#F?83F@SZ/.*%SF7A7Z6#+#X*%X7'%.6#Z;/*%86X*%X87%'#(/;86FA(@+!!

!bcUa( #E>LJKLEU(

"/&F!R#')#!TD-&%.#!R-''/%(#!E%';#.(%6!]/'%&(8'#!*%!E8.('8+!C!1+#.%#&/0.!96('#(V?/&#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.!R/?-%+!"#-'%.(!^8F!K_h<!E8+F!]%+!b#++%<!]%+%?#&/0.!e%./(8!f-M'%D<!EF1F!L_dLL!I%+V>8.8!KLLL!_LLL<!%S(%.6/0.!hLgK!C!hKOPF!

Page 56: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 56 -

+4$5&%4("!%:-)&$(!,3"$.)4(#454(3,'&(0&$&(0$"!"-%&$(.-+4$5&#./-(!42$"(2,"-&!(0$:#%.#&!(ck((

((bUa( .>FL@LBK@G>\(

$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#! !]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.F!!cUa( %NLBDE\(

N.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!*%!9;8+-&/0.!1#('/@8./#+F!!!dUa( )CFKH@MK@G>(?C(DJ(SBC>J(MHQKL@KJU((! "#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#!6%!%.&-%.('#!/.@%'6#!%.!-.!7'8&%68!*%!/..8;#&/0.!%6('#(V?/&#!

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

VUa( $JiE>CF(C(.TMEHLJ>K@JU("#!%6('#(%?/#!*%!N.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!*%!9;8+-&/0.!1#('/@8./#+!7%'@/(%!*%6#''8++#'!#&&/8.%6!*%!/.(%+/?%.&/#!%!/.;%6(/?#&/0.!7#'#!%+!&8@3#(%!#!+#!&8''-7&/0.<!7'/.&/7#+@%.(%!%.!#=-%++86!&#'?86!C!*%7%.*%.&/#6!*%!+#!T1,!7'8&+/;%6!#!+#!&8@/6/0.!*%!%6%!(/78!*%!>+#?%+86F!!

WUa( ">XEABCU("#!#7+/&#&/0.!*%!+#!%6('#(%?/#!7%'@/(%!+#!&88'*/.#&/0.!&8.!%.(/*#*%6!*%!+86!('%6!./;%+%6!*%!?83/%'.8!(#+%6!&8@8!+#!Q./*#*!*%!N.(%+/?%.&/#!,/.#.&/%'#!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!H#&/%.*#!C!E'V*/(8!123+/&8<!+#!E8@/6/0.!^#&/8.#+!e#.&#'/#!C!*%!b#+8'%6<!+86!G83/%'.86!96(#(#+%6!C!R-./&/7#+%6<!%.('%!8('86F!!E8.!%+!-68!*%!%6(#!(M&(/&#!6%!7-%*%!&8.(#'!&8.!/.>8'@#&/0.!;%'#D!=-%!7%'@/(#!+#!(8@#!*%!*%&/6/8.%6!%.!(/%@78!C!>8'@#<!'%*-&&/0.!*%!(/%@786!%.!%+!#.M+/6/6!*%!+#6!9;8+-&/8.%6!1#('/@8./#+%6<!'%*-&&/0.!*%!(/%@786!%.!+#!#(%.&/0.!*%!+86!#6-.(86!%.!('M@/(%<!#-@%.(8!%.!+#!&8.&+-6/0.!*%!&#686!%S/(8686!C!%;/(#'!+#!7'%6&'/7&/0.!*%!+86!@/6@86F!!

_Ua( .TMDCTC>LJK@G>U(1#'#!A#&%'!786/3+%! +#!%6('#(%?/#!6%!A#.!'%#+/D#*8!%6>-%'D86!%.!%+!*%6#''8++8!%!/@7+%@%.(#&/0.!*%!#+?-.#6!A%''#@/%.(#6!(#+%6!&8@8!%+!$/6(%@#!*%!T+%'(#6!$83'%!]%&+#'#&/8.%6!1#('/@8./#+%6!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!*%! +#!T1,<!%+! '%*/6%J8!*%+!,8'@#(8!7#'#! +#!1'%6%.(#&/0.!*%! +#!]%&+#'#&/0.!1#('/@8./#+! C<! =-/DM! #2.! @M6! /@78'(#.(%<! %+! >8'(#+%&/@/%.(8! *%! +#! ;%'/>/&#&/0.! *%! +#6! @/6@#6!*%&+#'#&/8.%6F!!

2. Las preguntas contenidas en el presente formato tienen como propósito guiar a los Estados acerca de la

información que podrían suministrar sobre buenas prácticas, en caso de que así lo deseen, y serían respondidas en lo que consideren apropiado.

Page 57: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 57 -

9+!*%6#''8++8!*%!+#6!A%''#@/%.(#6!%.!+#6!=-%!6%!#78C#!+#!%6('#(%?/#!.8!6%')#.!*%!@-&A#!-(/+/*#*!6/.!-.!6878'(%!*%!&#'M&(%'!:-')*/&8<!78'!+8!=-%!>-%!.%&%6#'/8!@8*/>/&#'!%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!7#'#!*8(#'!#!+#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.!*%!+#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!.%&%6#'/#6!7#'#!*%6#''8++#'!*/&A#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6! C! 6%! %.&-%.('#.! 6-6(%.(#*#6! %.! +86! #'()&-+86! ah<! ah! 3/6! C! ah! 3/6! d! *%+! &/(#*8!'%?+#@%.(8F!!]%!%6(#!>8'@#!6%!A#!+8?'#*8!*#'!-.!.-%;8!%.>8=-%!#!+#6!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!*%!%;8+-&/0.!7#('/@8./#+!*%!+86!$%';/*8'%6!123+/&86!/.;8+-&'#*86!%.!#+?2.!*%+/(8!8!78'!6%?-/@/%.(8!*%!8>/&/8!*%!6-6!%;8+-&/8.%6F!!

eUa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

fUa( $CFBDLJ?EFU(]%67-V6!*%!-.!+#'?8!7%')8*8!*%!('#3#:8!&8.!*/;%'6#6!#-(8'/*#*%6<!6%!+8?'0!=-%!%+!*)#!_!*%!#?86(8!*%!KLdd!6%!7-3+/&#'#!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.<!%+!]%&'%(8!78'!%+!=-%!6%!'%>8'@#.<!#*/&/8.#.!C!*%'8?#.!*/;%'6#6!*/6786/&/8.%6!*%+!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'!*%!+#!$,1<!%.!%6(#!@8*/>/&#&/0.!#+!'%?+#@%.(8!6%!#@7+/#'8.! +#6! >#&-+(#*%6!*%! +#!]GNN!@%*/#.(%! +#! /.&8'78'#&/0.!%.!%+!T'()&-+8!ah<!,'#&&/0.!c<!'%>%'%.(%!#!+#!/.;%6(/?#&/0.!%.!@#(%'/#!*%!%;8+-&/0.!7#('/@8./#+!C!+86!T'()&-+86!ah!3/6!C!ah!3/6!dF!!]%!+8!=-%!6%!*%67'%.*%!=-%<!+#6!>#&-+(#*%6!*%!&88'*/.#'!C!8'*%.#'!+#!'%#+/D#&/0.!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!8!#-*/(8')#6!%.!'%+#&/0.!&8.!+#!6/(-#&/0.!7#('/@8./#+!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6<!&8@7%(%!#!V6(#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%! N.>8'@#&/0.!%! N.(%?'#&/0.!C!6%!'%#+/D#.!#!('#;V6!*%!6-!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!T*:-.(#!*%!9;8+-&/0.!1#('/@8./#+F!96(8<!#!7#'(/'!*%!+#!%.('#*#!%.!;/?8'!*%+!&/(#*8!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'/8'F!!T!7#'(/'!*%!%6#!>%&A#<!+#!]GNN!#!('#;V6!*%!+#!]GT91!A#!/./&/#*8!&8.!%+!7'8&%68!*%!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!*%!%;8+-&/0.!7#('/@8./#+!&8.!-.#!.-%;#!07(/&#!C!%.!3'%;%!6%!%6(#'M.!.8(#.*8!+86!&#@3/86!C!3%.%>/&/86!*%!%6(#!#('/3-&/0.F!!

<Ua( !CIB@T@C>LEU(! T2.!&-#.*8!+#!#('/3-&/0.!&8.&+-C%!-.#!;%D!=-%!6%!(-'.#!%+!*/&(#@%.!*%!+#!%;8+-&/0.!7#('/@8./#+!#!+#!

]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!U%678.6#3/+/*#*%6!C!$/(-#&/0.!1#('/@8./#+!*%!+#!$,1<!+#!]GNN<!&8.(/.2#!*#.*8!6%?-/@/%.(8!C!6%!%+#38'#.!+86!/.>8'@%6!*%!#;#.&%6<!'%=-%'/*86!78'!+#6!*/6(/.(#6!#-(8'/*#*%6!683'%!&#*#!-.#!*%!+#!9;8+-&/8.%6F!!

b`Ua( *CKK@E>CF(JMHC>?@?JFU(!!!!!!!!9.!#?86(8!*%!KLdd!6%!7-3+/&#'8.!%.!%+!]/#'/8!\>/&/#+!*%!+#!,%*%'#&/0.!4]\,5!+#6!@8*/>/&#&/8.%6!#+!

.-%;8!U%?+#@%.(8!N.(%'.8!*%!+#!$%&'%(#')#!*%!+#!,-.&/0.!123+/&#<!#!('#;V6!*%!+#6!&-#+%6!6%!*8(0!#!+#!]/'%&&/0.! G%.%'#+!*%! N.>8'@#&/0.!%! N.(%?'#&/0.!*%! +#6!#('/3-&/8.%6!.%&%6#'/#6!7#'#!*%6#''8++#'!/.;%6(/?#&/8.%6!7#('/@8./#+%6!@%*/#.(%!+#!/.6('-@%.(#&/0.!*%!.-%;86!7#'#*/?@#6!C!A%''#@/%.(#6!=-%!A#.!786/3/+/(#*8!+#!#(%.&/0.!%.!(/%@78!C!>8'@#!*%!+#6!*%.-.&/#6!&#7(#*#6!C!+86!/.*/&/86!83(%./*86!'%67%&(8!#!786/3+%6!/''%?-+#'/*#*%6!%.!%+!/.&'%@%.(8!7#('/@8./#+!*%!+86!6%';/*8'%6!723+/&86F!!!

!!!!!!!!!

Page 58: A) … · A) .>?@ABC(DEF(GHIJ>EF(?C(KE>LHED(FBMCH@EH(MCHL@>C>LCF(?C ... ... 6! « !!!!!

- 58 -

T6/@/6@8<!#!('#;V6!*%+!'%*/6%J8!*%+!>8'@#(8!*%!*%&+#'#&/0.!7#('/@8./#+!6%!A#!+8?'#*8!%>/&/%.(#'!%+!$/6(%@#!]9E"TUT^9I<!'%*-&/%.*8!#6)!+#!8@/6/0.!78'!%''8'!8!*8+86#!*%!*#(86!(#+%6!&8@8!&-%.(#6!3#.&#'/#6!C!e/%.%6!/.@-%3+%6F!!!!H%@86! #7'%.*/*8! =-%! %6! @-C! /@78'(#.(%! %+! 6%?-/@/%.(8!C! +#! >8'@#+/D#&/0.!*%! +#!&88'*/.#&/0.!/.(%'/.6(/(-&/8.#+!#!('#;V6!*%!&8.;%./86!C!#&-%'*86!*%!&8+#38'#&/0.<!78'!@%*/8!*%!+86!&-#+%6!6%!>#&/+/(%!C!#?/+/&%!%+!/.(%'&#@3/8!*%!/.>8'@#&/0.!'%>%'%.(%!#+!(%@#F!!

bbUa( )EKBTC>LEFU("#!6/?-/%.(%!+/?#!&8''%678.*%!#+!$/6(%@#!]9E"TUT^9I<!%.!%++#!6%!7-%*%!%.&8.('#'!%+!@#.-#+!*%!]%&+#'#.%(7+-6<!-.#!?-)#! 'M7/*#!7#'#!&#7(-'#!C!%.;)8!*%!/.>8'@#&/0.<!/.>8'@#&/0.!'%>%'%.(%!#!+86!@0*-+86!*%!#(%.&/0.<!+#!.8'@#(/;/*#*!&8''%678.*/%.(%!C!#+?-.86!8('86!*#(86!7#'#!%+!&8''%&(8!-68!*%+!6/6(%@#!C!*%!/.(%'V6!?%.%'#+F!A((7YZZ*%&+#'#.%(F?83F@SZ!!

bcUa( #E>LJKLEU("/&F!R#')#!TD-&%.#!R-''/%(#!E%';#.(%6!]/'%&(8'#!*%!E8.('8+!C!1+#.%#&/0.!96('#(V?/&#!]/'%&&/0.!G%.%'#+!*%!N.>8'@#&/0.!%!N.(%?'#&/0.!R/?-%+!"#-'%.(!^8F!K_h<!E8+F!]%+!b#++%<!]%+%?#&/0.!e%./(8!f-M'%D<!EF1F!L_dLL!I%+V>8.8!KLLL!_LLL<!%S(%.6/0.!hLgKF!

!