I~ PLAINTIFF’S|l _..~._ ~,.5_..~... |EXHIBITWindows 3.1 Program Review

February 27, 1992

A. Executive Summary

B. Internal Tut Plan and Results

C. Application Compatibility

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

XSTO23]T3

III

EXHIBIT5707

MS-PCA 1113867CONFIDENTIAL

A. Executive Summary"[’his ~ cover~ 9 rne~k:s we are using to determine i£W’mdow~ 3.1 is ready m shipor not. The ~u’rent ~hedule tnd the drip check fist tre ~ve~ in this section ~ well

1. Core product, drive~ ~d h~dwsre support sxe s~li,4 I~emal te~t~ a~e comprehensivesnd are passing overa!l. The most active beta te~t~ are al~o malting very positives~azcme~ts =bout how solid the produc~ L~.

2. Internal bug o-a/fie continues a~ a s~ady par.~ Were made 75 chang~ to RC 3 since2/17. Of those., ~o,,md 26 were required ch~nge~, the rest we could l~ve easily sEippedwith. Of the 26, only ¯ hsr, dful, ~ouod 9, were £~olu~e~y requital to ~hip the produc~.

3. Appilcatlo~ ~mpattbili~y is good. Only 10 apps of any h~ponanr~ were broken, ofthe~ 6 ~av~ already up.zeal. Update, for dae remaiai~ 4 a~ v¢~, dose. Over~ ,ppswork well with Win 3i

4. Betaprvgram. The~e i~ s ~ ¯ hish ~olum~ ofrepor~ omin8 in fi~m the beta te~ ~which i~ now about 15,000 site~ world wide. We $~ 400-.500 ~o~1 r~orts ¯ week. 936lmSs ~ n~xn~ ia F~b ~m B.C I ~.h i~ the l~est build ~w,, be~ si~s I~v~.

5. Int~rnai flopl~ sen~p test i~ Iooi~m$ prew/ $oo4. 1"r~$ te~ h~ uncov~d ¯ pate~s~ly

memioned shove. -

hit=h. Ofr~m 10~A (6) ~ 2 had DRDOS, 1 l~l a bad Imrd dis~ I £ot b~l flopl~ydisks, ~ ~ an ia~nx~lu BIOS, s~l I fmmd s tmSv~ Imv~ ~,od with dm mou~d~v~. Tlmbad n~slmmisthat tlm1~mdu~m~k~o~l~ mlvu I oftlm 6 probl~n~.

- N~w~tha~$otR~l. Sofar, wu~vucmll~ddoW~34~- A~nonlyg0~s~witha~ ahitch. Wcdo~y~ha~utlmd~milsont~f~t~u~m. WcMsoqu~d~dth~s~

w~m d~ by ~aaxketi~, ~ ~ur, h team is in tlm ~ of $~in$ tim d~mils.

T~i~ m ~ I00 n~w data ~oiats on RC~.

7. P&~ b¢ta te.~ ~s in prosmss.

9. Rollout ~o MS Corp will har4~n n~xt wink.

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1115868CONFIDENTIAL

Current scheduleF~ Compile ................................ Oct 9 (done)Ped’o~ complete ......................... Nov 4 (done)Do~ rdea.~e to [ntl ............................... De~ 1 ! (done)Fiml Bet= to PRS ................................De~ 20 (done)SDK/DDK F’m~ bet= to Pl~ ...............Dec 23 (done)

Enter F’m~l System test ........................Feb I’/(doa¢)Ke~e~s~ to Mfg .................................... ~ 9

SDK~ ofbook$ to pdate~ ..................... Feb 28RTM for softwtr¢ .............................

Iv~ 23

Boo~ =.rive =t Mfg .......................... M~r 30

DDK scheduleDoc:s tO syr, tem prod/pdat~ ............... Mtr 4RTM For foR’ware .............................M~ 23~, An-~. -, Mf~ .........................M~30

SoRwtre to Mr& ................................M~r 16

Dmd=, Sw=lE~, it=amSo~-~r~ to MrS .............................

~ 3.1 Ship Rnal Ctte~ List

- The "~ da~’

- No ~ c~ ~ or ~ o~ ~m ~ t~

No ~

. ~, up ~ so ~ isv, ~NFIDE~IAL- ~= up ~om

~ ~ ~ si~ (~y Hov~ ~ ~ r~)

MS-PCA 1113869CONFIDENTIAL

Windows 3.1February 27, 1992

B. Internal Test Plan and Result~

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113870CONFIDENTIAL

Windows 3.1 Test

~Y ~l ~ ~ ~ ~i4. ~A, E0~W, EO~ONO, ~,P~MA, SVO~ ~O~ ~ VOA, VG~ONO, ~ XOA. ~ ~ ~1~ ~ ~

13~ ~VGA: ~ BR~ ~n8 m ~

HIGHLYOONFIDE~AL

H~7023377

MS-PCA 1113871CONFIDENTIAL

Cun~tl~, tm~a| ill priat~ driv¢~ ~ ~ ~.I: ~ONIOE. ~ONI~.~4US, ~U$, ~OH. DICO~. D~, ~ 7~, ~O~4. ~Ng, ~

~PH. ~M~. ~PIN, O~4, O~ 393~ 0~, O~M, P~,p~SON9, ~3~. PROP~. PROP~, PSi, PSi. O~. ~. ~0,

115~ U~ble ~ p~t ~fic W~ ~ ~ ~y ~ f~ m IBM ~Ig~1~i~ ~o~ ~ ~ ~m~ ~ ~ IBM QW ~

15419 SONIC: dd~a~ ~ ~ ~ m~ 1 ~

Tin) ~ ~ ~m, ~’m ~t ~ ~ ~ No~, ~:~,

71o N~ I ~I ~ ~ N~M (I ~I~)

I~ ~0~ T~ ION~ - lOW~ ~ ~fi ~ ~ ~I

HIGHLYCONFIDE AL

MS-PCA 1113872CONFIDENTIAL

~LL/CONTROL PANEL

1,4313 K~I~Z8 COBOL:

~ oYd~ ~J~~ ~ f~l~,

~ ~ life of

MS-PCA 1113873CONFIDENTIAL

at I00~ rmt~ u wdl.

C)0~"r

MS-PCA 1113874CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113875CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA III_~S76 ~ICONFIDENIIAL I

MS-PCA 1113877CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111387BC~FIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113879CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113880CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113881CONFIDENTIAL

MS-POA 1113882CONFIDENTIAL

Internal Bug traffic

At~eED~A T~~ o~ ~lm~o~/~ens hosd~s

~Z~.~ - ~ ~.0 01~tvs~ cs~, ~15437

SO~.~ - 8~ 15344,

~.~Z - ~I~ ~m~a~

~I.~ - ~GP 10343 -tont

~y’s D~

¯ P~PU24.D~ ~ ~24.D~

MS-PCA 1113883CONFIDENTIAL

~C3c

OL~ - Chafiqo LfltO’~’~l ve~o£or~

~B~USH.~ - 8uqP 14764 Paqo S~p.E~ro~ ~al~ ~ a~m

RC3b

S~A.D~ - ~g~ 14776, 8OOx~O 8u~S ~Lca ~e~ ~DP ~g

I~.~ - ~ W~

~PI.~P - NW l~t Off 0~ 84

,~ - Ch~ ~r~ht

SYS~.D~ - Setup ~1~ ~ ~e 3.1- lug~14863~.~ - ¢h~ ~lu~L~ ~o 72*96, font ~ p~b~ ~o~ ~e~Lnal fon~~,~N - c~ ~o~lu~/on ~o 96"9G, font ~ln~ ~ for ~o~l fon~

S~’.~ " ~ as 3.0 ~DRZ~.~L - ~ug~ 6149, p~s ~o RI~ ~f ~Lve~ 10 I~oady p~son~

~86 ~ 384 - lug~ 1497S, D~Ln crash v/~t to ~1 a~ a~14978~ Ix~t ~L~o af~e~ A~ ~t, D~Ln

¯ - denotom bug fou~ ~e~ally (12 ou~ Of 75 o=

~7023390CO~¢~l nENTIAL

MS-PCA III3BB4CONFIDENTIAL

1690 1~92 341~ 3219 2269 24609

3.1 ~o ~v~ce ~a ~ch c~e a~ R~n 3.0

MS-PCA 1113885CONFIDENTIAL

Windows 3.1February 27, 1992

C. Application Compatibility

HIGHL~CONFIDENTIAL

Categories of problems found in ApplicationsThi~ secfio~ i~ ¯ boll up of the d~-t~led spreadsheet ~hed. It covers the c~egorics ofapplicatio~ problems we fotmd in tesdn~ Win 3,I, the numbe~ ofapps, and the number ofknow~ Excs ev~lable. (Mo~y A or B apps ~© sho~n hcr~, but some Iow~ priority apps¯ re included h~e as well i~ ~h~y Et the problem c~egory.)

To re~h the level ofapp compa~’bil~ we needed, we in~’od~r.~d "app backs" into thesy~,m. Apps ~re id~nti~ed by modu~ name ~d the ~x b applied to only the one~ thatneed it. A mclion in WI~N:2qI is U~d to descn’b~ to the sy~cm wldch app ~ shoedbe applied to which apps.

Cate~zorv # aDDS

Linear Primed/DisplayThese

~onU (~ for ~ng f~) ............. ~ (2 ~)~ ~ for ~ ~t ~ ~ ~ ~m 3.0, m ~ ~~ ~ ~,

Fonu (fore m~pia~ ........................ 6 (2 ~)~s ~ do~ ~ ~ ~ ~ to ~p fo~, ~y ~8 p~b[~s got

Fon~ (~~s

rome ~ fore ~ it o~y ~o~ how to ~#te fonts u~8 ~e A~ ~I. ~,

Fonu (~ns fonU ~ u~e) .....2

foat

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

HS-/:’CA 111J887CONF DENTI/ L l

P.en~me of vg~ax.fo~ ........................ 3 (2 Exed)Only ~ zI~ps depended on ~ ~e "~" to ~of~e ~ ~ ~ fore to ~ ~ it ~ ~Eide ~ ~e pm~nio~~ fore. We ~ ~ ~blem ~r 2 ~ps ~ ~ ~t~ sub~fion table,~ for the 3rd. Hot s ~fio~

~ps not a~e of~C ~8. ~e ~1~ ~ ~ ~mWo~. One p~blem

No ~ ~ ~don ................... 11 (10 ~)~ d~ ~e ~ for ~ fo~ ~ ~ ~ ~Y ~g ~e

bi8 ~ p~bl~.

~s ~ ¯ ~ ~ 4 ~ for ~ ~ f~ I fo~ ~h ~ We ~ ~ ~ forW~ B~¢, ~t ~d not for ~ ~, We ~ ~

~o~~~ ...................

~ fo~ .................................... 10 (6 ~)

~o ~ ul w ~e ~ o~ f~ ~ for ~mpa~b~

~B~d~ ................ ~ (~

I ~w~~W~le. We~2~~p~.

~ p~n8 ...............................S~ 1 ~ ~z ~ ~d ~ p~ to ~ p~. WornYr~ d~ ~ ~ Po~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~me d~nd~on ~e o~ ~m 3.0 PS ~. U~e b ~ ~ ~ ~om ~.

HIGHLYCONFIDE AL CONPzD~Z~

MS-PCA III~88BCDNFIDENTIAL :

d~ ~u~ p~ flow ~ c~g~. We ~ ~ ~s ~ lh~ ~ ~hout going~zck to us~g oI~ d~v~ ~ ~ ofn~ ~d ~. ~ 2 of~ez w~g at p~t ~ ~at ~e p~m~ ~ ~8~. ~ [ zpp, ~et~plat~ ~ ~e t~ltt~ ~ ~ up~t~. ~S N~Wo~ Wo~on~pdtt~ ~e’z ~ ~ A~ ~o~ problem b~se the U~v~ r~t~oio~ ~ L~RV i~ of PCL.

Addition ofD~ c~ 129 ................~ zppz ~1 o~le ~ ~ O~ ~ ~ ~e not ~ppo~ to~nv~ ~ to 0~. S~ we zdd~ ~ ~ to ~ ~g~ ~nvm w~chdi~ ~o~. ~ is ~ ~ ~e u~ ~ not ~ ~le to o~ a ~e ~th~t

H~p ~e ~ ..............................2V~ ~ pmbl~ o~.

U~ ~~ ~ ................. s (~ fl~)

~e~ ............................................. 24 (4 ~)~y ~ ~ p~i~ ~ ~ ~m t~ ~ ~ u~ to ~ t lot of

~ ~ ~ C ~ D ~z. Note ~ o~y 10 of~ 24 tppt ~ ~d~ ~ app~ I of

Un-i~ d~ ................. 18 (2 ~)O~ n~ ~e is ~ ~ ~ of~ pr~i~ ~ ~ C ~d D

Wo~ F~ ~ ~d ~, ~t ~ ~n~ ~ch ~ ~ do ~uz the~.

~ A~ ~ W~e to H~e.... 2~ ~p ~t d~ ~ge ~d~e don’t ~ ~ ~e osNo~n8 we ~

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

cONFIDENTIAL i

Ovez’w~iting our Modults ................. 16Thia is a pretty u~ly ~ ~ r~ ~me ~ e~ u~ pr~l~ ~o~yth~ im~ ~g ~ ~ do ~ R o~ ~ g~ ~e ~s m up~e. ~~mon ~ ~ PC T~ls ~ No.on ~op r~g ~.386 ~ ~ older~o~ ~o~ ~ple is wh~e F~ ~ ~t ~ disp~y ~v~ ~th a ~eDISPLAY.DEV.

Sh~e.~e (~e ~ ~che) .............5

~bl~ ~ ~ pr~l~ w~ ~ u~ ~ r~ ~ ~ S~ is ~ ~pbug ~ ~ ~ ~ ~m 3.0.

~ Bug ~ ............................ 9 (1 ~~ ~e pmb]~ du~to ~es to ~m 3.0 ~, We ~p ~ a ~~1~ ~ ~ o£~ ~ ~ ~r. ~ ~m ~8 ~ ~ P~ ~g a

~ ~~~ ~ Wm 3.1 f~ ~e~r~ ~ ~ ~

~rd ~t~ ~ ~- ~ ~ ~ ~ow ~ ~ ~pr~l~

M~ ~, ~ PmR ~ u~e t~p.~6 ~eC~f~ ! ~le~w.13 ~Dap~

AB land B-) atom that must be uvdated: fl0)Ans&1.~tera 3.1 ..............~ ..........Shipped 3.! 1 (not ol~cialJy an AB app, but imponam)HoUywood ..................................Shipped 2.0Powerbuild~ 1.0 .........................plaamed the day we let them ship toolhlp.dl]Ontime 1.0 ..................................Shipped I.I. (not oBEcially an AB app. but impo~.nt)hDC MemView !.0 .....................available whm W’m 3.1 shipsA~eEIe 1.0 ..................̄ .................Shipped 2.0 (not ol~cially ~ A.B app, but imt~rtam)FzxJt !.53 and 2.0d ......................Already shipped 2.1Forest & Tre¢~ 2.0a .....................Already shipl~d 2.0bM~crosoft Productivity Pak 1.0 ,...available when Wm 3.1 shipsBook.she.l£ for W’mdows ............... updaxe plzmmd for next M/’g rim, mid-March

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113890CONFIDENTIAL

CONFIDENTIAL)

MS-PCA 111~92CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111~89~CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113894CONFIDENI’IALI

©z..~.

CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113895CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111~B96 ~

coNFIDENTIAL1

MS-PCA 1113897CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111589BCONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113899CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111~900CONFIDENTIAL

H5"702,3 ~ O’/

MS-PEA II13901CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113902CONFIDENTIAL

VVi~:Jow’~ 3.1 Ai~i~m~on C, ompmJD41~y

MS-PCA 1113903CONFIDENTIAL

M~’~02’34 ZOCONFZDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111~904CONFIDENTIAL

WlNIN|XJ.$

HIGHLYG’ONI=tlZ)ENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113905CONFIDENTIAL

Windows 3.1February 27, 1992

D. Beta program

HIGHLY’OONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113906CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 111~907CONFIDENTIAL

Windows 3.’tFebruary 27, 1992

New user tests and results

HIGHLYC.,~N~IDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1115908CONFIDENTIAL

~opp¥

over ~e pl~ ~e~ Bel~ em ~e ~5u~ of these ~:

To~ ~em~s 7B

~ 3.1 or I minor problem du~

Filled Setups Bmakdo~

1 ~e~mem~P~5 S~ hung ~ After Ds~ M~OS ~n ~ver TSR ~. ~l~D)~ ~eo In~tl~ Flil~ ~tn ~l~ to mn enh~ m~e. Std ok (I~STiGATING)

7 T~ fs~

~m ~e~ Once

11 T~

HIGHLYCONFIDENTIAL

~IS-PC~ 1113909COnfIDEnTIaL

New ~eta tester data

5a~p

1. Had DR ~ S.O Xno~a11~, ~rko £~ when ~-~8 u~2. 5~ DK ~s ~.0 :no~a~led, ~:~ ~A~ whon ~-~8 As

4. Bad dAs~:~Ao~ dLoks5. H~ Awed ~l~ ~t ~d ~ p~s w/ 3.0. ~ ~a~ ~ZOS,

~aAlure As ve~ ~roubleo~ ~:~ ~ eup~=~ ~ o~

*No~@l o~ 8A~es ~o ~~ thl~ ~h~ w~ a~ways ~n w~

.~: ,~. ~o, HIGHLY~.... ~, ...~o~.~ OONFIDE~ALlO0~/~ o~ ~ho ~ 6Or

H~ often do ~ Mvo ~o ~P~ WL~s o= ~ho

MS-PCA 1115910CONFIDENI’IAL

Windows 3.1February 27, 1992

F. Device Support Status

cobrle ZD ~p’L,Z.,~Z,

MS-PCA 1113911CONFIDENTIAL

Device Driver Support Summary

Net~ork~12 n~vork~ ~ supported i~ S~mp, ~ s~p ~ ~ 4. ~ ~ ~ is

on out t~ ~ts w~ch ~ ~ ~o~ now.

O~p~ys~ d~lay ~, ~ ~ ~d ~ ~ in g~d s~. 3rd p~ ~l~y ddv~

w~g ~ ~ ~ oft~ (A~ ~ ~IS, ~p~ $3) to ~e t~s ~p~ bythe ~ w~ ~p.

~ ~. ~ ~ S ~ ~ o~n~ ~ ~m~ Tu~T~ ~ Fr~ but

Audio

Sou~l~, ~. ~ ~.

~L. ~e ~ Pa~ is ~ t~ ~r~e ~ ~L ~ is MSCD~ 2.21.

HIGHLY~’~NmDENTIAL

CO.IDEnTICaL

MS-PCA 1113912CONFIDENTIAL

Network Driver S~atus

~Ink

Drivers Ln o~r ~

DRC

not sarLouo.

CONFIDENTIAL3~ 3+~aare ~ 3~ima ~

T~II ~O orrectly handl~ ~

C~¢FIDENTTA~

MS-PCA 1113913CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PC~ 1113914CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113915CONFIDENTIAL

p~o~ty on~L~re ~%nd~o. ~Ls p~uc~ ham ~en ~eo~ b~ no~ ~o

Th£s Lo not recoqnLzed by Windows Setup.

ThLS ~o~-@hd pee=-~o-pe@: network does not Include WLndows-speci~£ccode s~- ~hLs tLme. we ha~ not teated this

H~023422C~FIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113916CONFIDENTIAL

w~th w~n~O, ~u~ no~ ent£~ol~. ~ho~i ~ro ~ ¢t~ea~n, ~nclud~n~

Then ~hey ~e ~ wlt~ t~elr PC-NFS T~I~ 2.0 which la~g

whLch to 8u~e~ ~o ~ ~ulLy Wtn3x ~4~1e. T~Oo ~es a~e no~

R~7023"33

MS-PCA III~917CONFIDENTIAL

MS-PCA 1113918C~FIDERTIAL

Vendor.Provided Drivers Status:

Adob~ PnsIScr/pl LL.ve! 2 d~ve~ (shipped wi~h ~ 2

2. ~e~gned~m ~und Up Ye~e~: To ~ ~l~ at ~me ~ 3.1 ~p. ~U ~

H~vlc~t Packa~ ~et SOOC (shipped with printer):So~ pr~le~ ~th T~eT~. A~ut I ~o~n ~ 3 ~ ~md 2 ~ crashing bu~~p~rd~re. ~ dn~r ml~ slat~ to ~ ~o~ p~l~ ~ ~ article at 3,1 s~p ~e.

H~vc~ Pac~ Sc~ Cotor-~stthlng Paia~ct D~r (ship~d ~ih p~uter):

lnterrnational Product Group Drivers Status:

Pleas~ sc~ the a’o~¢b~l li~ "Additlomsl motets for "&~ ~n ~d all t~sti~d ~loas". ~ "A"vernon is ~ ~n-U.S. E~sh~n~gc ~ion of W~ ~s ~ ~ 1~ of~tO Wi~ 3. I U.S, Ve~ion xv~n th~ ~ ~ "A" vc~ ~ ~II ~ ~ in~g~t~ inl~li~ ~io~: the ti~ oEm~ w~n t~ u~ ~U t~ ~D ~mn ~n the pnnter coaUoi ~n~ ~I1~ the US m~s plus ~e~ m~ In a ~upl¢ ~, ~ ~ ~m~ ~ing US m~cts(~non la~ and Ok~Oki~m) and ~pla~ ~m ~ imp~ed ~ve~ for the ~uro~

~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ F~ ~ ~ is ~ing a ~ ~ ~ t~g now on~. ~ ~ for ~ "A" ~ is ~; ~ne ~ ~ ~

MS7023425CONI~IDENTZAL

MS-PCA 1113919CONFIDENTIAL