a human/robotic exploration design reference …...spudiset al., 2014; cassanelli and head, 2016)...

29
James Head, Carle Pieters, David Scott, Brandon Johnson, Ross Potter: Brown Univ., Providence, RI USA Jeffrey Hoffman: MIT, Cambridge, MA USA Bernard Foing: ESA ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands Lev Zelenyi, Igor Mitrofanov: Institute for Space Research, RAS, Moscow, Russia Mikhail Marov, Alexander Basilevsky, Mikhail Ivanov: Vernadsky Institute, RAS, Moscow, Russia Ralf Jaumann, DLR Institute of Planetary Research, Berlin, Germany Long Xiao: China University of Geosciences, Wuhan, Hubei, China Junichi Haruyama, Makiko Ohtake: ISAS, JAXA, Sagamihara, Japan P. Senthil Kumar: CSIR-NGRI, Hyderabad, India Oded Aharonson:Weizmann Institute, Rehovot, Israel A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference Campaign Architecture: Opportunities for Commercial Missions

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

JamesHead,CarlePieters,DavidScott,BrandonJohnson,RossPotter:BrownUniv.,Providence,RIUSA

JeffreyHoffman:MIT,Cambridge,MAUSABernardFoing:ESAESTEC,Noordwijk,TheNetherlands

LevZelenyi,IgorMitrofanov:InstituteforSpaceResearch,RAS,Moscow,RussiaMikhailMarov,AlexanderBasilevsky,MikhailIvanov:Vernadsky Institute,RAS,

Moscow,RussiaRalfJaumann,DLRInstituteofPlanetaryResearch,Berlin,GermanyLongXiao:ChinaUniversityofGeosciences,Wuhan,Hubei,ChinaJunichiHaruyama,MakikoOhtake:ISAS,JAXA,Sagamihara,Japan

P.Senthil Kumar:CSIR-NGRI,Hyderabad,IndiaOded Aharonson:Weizmann Institute,Rehovot,Israel

AHuman/RoboticExplorationDesignReferenceCampaignArchitecture:OpportunitiesforCommercialMissions

Page 2: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

ApolloLunarExplorationProgram:SixScientificExpeditionstotheMoon

EstablishedtheMoonasaCornerstoneforSolarSystemScience

Page 3: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

TheMoonasa CornerstoneforSolarSystemScience

-Oneormorespacecraftcurrently/recentlyorbitingeachofthe terrestrialplanets.

-Wehavefundamentalquestionsabouttheformationandevolutionofeachoftheseplanetarybodies,andtogethertheterrestrialplanetarybodiesasawhole.

-Manyofthesequestionscanonlybeansweredinthecontextoflunarexploration

Page 4: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

1.Theimportanceofcoordinatedhuman/roboticexploration.2.WhytheOrientalemulti-ringbasin?3.Human/RoboticScientificDestinationsatOrientale.4. TheHuman/RoboticArchitecture:ABasisforDesignReference

Missions.

ExplorationofPlanetaryCrusts:AHuman/RoboticExplorationDesignReferenceCampaign

totheLunarOrientaleBasin

Page 5: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

1.Theimportanceofcoordinatedhuman/roboticexploration.2.WhytheOrientalemulti-ringbasin?3.Human/RoboticScientificDestinationsatOrientale.4. TheHuman/RoboticArchitecture:ABasisforDesignReference

Missions.

ExplorationofPlanetaryCrusts:AHuman/RoboticExplorationDesignReferenceCampaign

totheLunarOrientaleBasin

Page 6: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Human/RoboticExplorationOptimizationCentersonSixThemes

• I)Precursor (Whatdoweneedtoknowbeforewesendhumans?).

• II)Context (Whataretheroboticmissionrequirementsforfinallandingsiteselectionandregionalcontextforlandingsiteresults?).

• III)Infrastructure/Operations (Whatspecificroboticcapabilitiesarerequiredtooptimizehumanscientificexplorationperformance?).

• IV)Interpolation (Howdoweuseroboticmissionstointerpolatebetweenhumantraverses?).

• V)Extrapolation (Howdoweuseroboticmissionstoextrapolatebeyondthehumanexplorationradius?).

• VI)Progeny (Whattargetedroboticsuccessormissionsmightbesenttotheregiontofollowupondiscoveriesduringexplorationandfrompost-campaignanalysis?).

Page 7: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

What is the Relationship of Human and Robotic Exploration?

Page 8: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Apollo19-21Dual-ModeRovingVehicle

Page 9: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

1.Theimportanceofcoordinatedhuman/roboticexploration.2.WhytheOrientalemulti-ringbasin?3.Human/RoboticScientificDestinationsatOrientale.4. TheHuman/RoboticArchitecture:ABasisforDesignReference

Missions.

ExplorationofPlanetaryCrusts:AHuman/RoboticExplorationDesignReferenceCampaign

totheLunarOrientaleBasin

Page 10: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

FormationandEvolutionofPlanetaryCrusts

TheMoonisaLaboratoryfortheStudyofPrimaryandSecondaryCrustsinEarlyPlanetaryHistory.

S.R.Taylor

Page 11: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

• 1. Crustalgeometry/physicalstructure• 2. Crustalchemistry/mineralogy/petrology;• 3. Exogenic crustal modificationbyimpacts;• 4. Chronologyofcrustalformation/evolution.

Page 12: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

1

2

34

10010

Bowl shapedCircular rim

SwirlFlat floor

Polygonaloutline

Central peakTerraces

Cra

ter D

epth

(km

)

Crater Diameter (km)

FreshCraterCharacteristics

MajorLunarFeatures:Multi-ringbasins:

What about thetransition to

Peak-Ring Basins?

(R. Pike)

Page 13: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Lunar Orientale Impact Basin: The Type Area for Lunar Basin Formation and Evolution.

Page 14: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Orientale Basin: Rings & Geologic Units

Hevelius Formation(Basin Ejecta Deposit)

Montes Rook Fm.(Knobby, Domical Deposit)

Maunder Formation(Basin Impact Melt Deposit)

(J.McCauley,D.Wilhelms,D.Scott,K.Howard,C.Hodges)

Page 15: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Ejecta Thickness (Isopach) Map of the Hevelius Formation

(Fassett andHead, 2011,GRL)

CompositionoftheEjecta fromtheOrientaleBasin:CrustandMantle

Page 16: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

StructureandCompositionoftheLunarCrust:TheMagmaOceanModel

• Crustaverages~50±16kmthick.• Upperandlowercrustaboutequal.• Uppercrustheavilymodifiedinthe

upper~10kmbyimpactprocesses.

Megaregolith(~10kmthick)

------------------------------UpperAnorthositic Crust

(~15kmthick)------------------------------

LowerNoritic Crust(~25kmthick) “NewViewsoftheMoon”(2006)

Page 17: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Hevelius Formation(Basin Ejecta Deposit)

Feldspathicbreccias;homogeneous,well-mixed.

Montes Rook Fm.(Knobby, Domical Deposit)

Feldspathicbreccias;someanorthositeblocks.

Maunder Formation(Basin Impact Melt Deposit)

MoonMineralogyMapper(M3)

Orientale Basin: Rings & Geologic Units

--------

Cordillera Mountains: Feldspathicbreccias;

unweathered.

Outer Rook Mountains: Norites,noriticanorthosite

andanorthosite;morecrystallineblocks.

Inner Rook Mountains: Massifsarecrystallineanorthosite;discretepeaksandclustersofpeaks.

RedDots (InnerRookMountains):Materials>~98%plagioclase(Cheeketal.,2012)

(Pietersetal.,2009,2011;Headetal.,2010,2012;Cheeketal.,2012)

Page 18: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Maunder Formation(Basin Impact Melt Deposit)

Orientale Impact Melt Sea

(WilsonandHead,2010;Vaughanetal,2011,2012;

Spudis etal.,2014;Cassanelli andHead,2016)

Page 19: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results

16

Page 20: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

16

Page 21: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

(Whittenetal.,2010)

FillingoftheOrientaleBasinwithMareDeposits.

Page 22: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

1.Theimportanceofcoordinatedhuman/roboticexploration.2.WhytheOrientalemulti-ringbasin?3.Human/RoboticScientificDestinationsatOrientale.4. TheHuman/RoboticArchitecture:ABasisforDesignReference

Missions.

ExplorationofPlanetaryCrusts:AHuman/RoboticExplorationDesignReferenceCampaign

totheLunarOrientaleBasin

Page 23: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

-IftheOuterRookringrepresents thetransientcavityrimcrest, whatistheoriginofthe CordilleramountainringandtheMontesRookFormation?

RegionofInterest(ROI)1:OriginofBasinRings/CrustalStructure

Page 24: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

ROI2:WhatistheOriginoftheInnerRookMountains?

Page 25: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

Maunder Formation(Basin Impact Melt Deposit)

ROI 3-Orientale Impact Melt Sea

(WilsonandHead,2010;Vaughanetal,2011,2012;

Spudis etal.,2014;Cassanelli andHead,2016)

Page 26: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

ROI4-ExplosiveVolcanicIonianRing

Page 27: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

1.Theimportanceofcoordinatedhuman/roboticexploration.2.WhytheOrientalemulti-ringbasin?3.Human/RoboticScientificDestinationsatOrientale.4. TheHuman/RoboticArchitecture:ABasisforDesignReference

Missions.

ExplorationofPlanetaryCrusts:AHuman/RoboticExplorationDesignReferenceCampaign

totheLunarOrientaleBasin

Page 28: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten

• I)Precursor (Whatdoweneedtoknowbeforewesendhumans?).

• II)Context (Whataretheroboticmissionrequirementsforfinallandingsiteselectionandregionalcontextforlandingsiteresults?).

• III)Infrastructure/Operations (Whatspecificroboticcapabilitiesarerequiredtooptimizehumanscientificexplorationperformance?).

• IV)Interpolation (Howdoweuseroboticmissionstointerpolatebetweenhumantraverses?).

• V)Extrapolation (Howdoweuseroboticmissionstoextrapolatebeyondthehumanexplorationradius?).

• VI)Progeny (Whattargetedroboticsuccessormissionsmightbesenttotheregiontofollowupondiscoveriesduringexplorationandfrompost-campaignanalysis?).

LunarScienceforLandedMissionsWorkshop

Page 29: A Human/Robotic Exploration Design Reference …...Spudiset al., 2014; Cassanelli and Head, 2016) Lunar Orientale Basin: Link to Apollo Missions Environments/Results 16 16 (Whitten