a major paper submitted in partial fulfillment of the ... · ! 3! i. introduction the salt pond...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Mapping Impervious Cover Within Charlestown, Rhode Island’s
Salt Pond Region
By
Amanda Ryan
A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ENVIRONMENTAL
SCIENCE AND MANAGEMENT
UNIVERSITY OF RHODE ISLAND
MAY 10, 2012
MAJOR PAPER ADVISORS: Dr. Arthur Gold & Dr. Peter August
MESM TRACK: Earth and Hydrologic Science
![Page 2: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Abstract
Impervious cover (IC) has become widely recognized as a reliable indicator of
urban environmental stress, particularly decreased water quality. It is key to
transporting nonpoint source pollution into rivers, streams, lakes and ponds.
Southern Rhode Island has experienced a significant increase in human
population and impervious cover associated with land development. The
consequences of the changing watershed landscape has become manifest in the
deterioration of the health of the salt ponds. Specifically, the ponds have
undergone eutrophication, fish kills, eelgrass reductions, increased levels of toxic
contaminants, and permanently closed shellfish harvest areas among other
degradations. The aim of this project is to provide the town of Charlestown, RI
with a highly accurate impervious cover Geographic Information System (GIS)
dataset within the state-designated Salt Pond region and also describe the
methods used to create this dataset so that other towns may create the same
tool. This information can be used to help enforce the Rhode Island municipal
separate storm sewer system mandate, regulate the stormwater Best
Management Practice requirement mandated by RI’s Stormwater Design and
Installation Standards Manual which is based on land parcel percentage IC, and
provide town planners with a baseline IC for future zoning regulation
amendments. In general, this dataset offers the town of Charlestown a unique
GIS dataset to assist their efforts to improve the health of their salt ponds.
![Page 3: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
I. Introduction
The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant
suburbanization beginning in the 1950’s. The growth rate has been high, with a
69% increase in population from 1981 to 1992 and the region continues to attract
new residents (Ernst et al., 1999). As a result, Rhode Island’s ecologically
important salt pond environments have become degraded. The increase in
human population and land development has ultimately resulted in the
deterioration of salt pond water quality.
A. Impervious Cover
Impervious cover, also referred to as impervious surface, is one of the most
consistent and pervasive aspects of a developed landscape. It is defined as any
material that prevents the infiltration of water into the soil and includes rooftops,
roads, sidewalks, parking lots, compacted soil and any other impenetrable
surface (Arnold & Gibbons, 1996). As development increases, so does the area
of impervious cover; it has been shown that an area’s population density is
closely correlated to the amount of impervious cover (Stankowski, 1972). The
figure below highlights the basic relationship between urbanization, impervious
cover, and the resulting environmental impacts.
![Page 4: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Figure 1. Hydrologic impact of urbanization. Gray boxes identify impacts directly related to impervious surfaces (Hurd & Civco, 2004)
The environmental impacts of impervious cover can be divided into four
categories: hydrological, physical, biological, and water quality.
Hydrological Impacts
The alteration of the hydrologic cycle, the way which water is transported and
stored, begins when runoff reaches an impervious surface. By causing the
volume and velocity of surface runoff to increase, both shallow and deep
infiltration into the ground are reduced which may cause the water table to
subside, leaving less groundwater available to streams, vegetation, and for
![Page 5: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
human use (Paul & Meyer, 2001). The figure below illustrates the impacts of
increasing percentages of impervious cover within a landscape. In a natural
environment, approximately 10% of rainwater will runoff the land surface, 50%
with infiltrate the ground, and 40% is returned to the atmosphere via
evapotranspiration. Even a small increase in impervious surface, 10-20%, will
cause the surface runoff volume to double. A 1 acre paved parking lot produces
16 times the amount of runoff as a similarly sized undeveloped meadow (Center
for Watershed Protection, 2002).
Figure 2. Changes in site hydrology with increasing impervious cover (EPA, 1994).
Impervious cover reduces baseflow, or the groundwater seepage into stream
channels, which sustains streams during dry periods. Increasing surface runoff
![Page 6: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
also exacerbates flooding severity by decreasing the time it takes to reach peak
flow and increasing the volume of peak flow, because less water is infiltrating the
ground (Paul & Meyer, 2001).
Physical Impacts
Increased runoff also leads to the physical alteration of the environment. Land
development leaves less tree and vegetative cover, so there is a decreased
capacity for soils to be held in place. A greater amount of sediment and debris
from construction sites, stream banks, and non-vegetated soils is transported
downstream due to the greater erosional forces of larger volumes of faster
flowing stormwater. The resulting sediment loads will carve out wider and
straighter stream channels, only to further increase the velocity of water flow
during the next storm. These conditions also damage the riffle and pool
structures, which are ecologically important stream habitats. Paul & Meyer (2001)
showed that stream channels begin to show observable widening in a landscape
with as little as 2% impervious cover.
In addition, the reduced tree and vegetative cover can reduce regulation of
stream temperatures throughout the year, which may result in a greater range
that is unsuitable for certain inhabitants (Arnold & Gibbons, 1996).
Biological Impacts
There have been many studies investigating the impact to biological indicators
within streams flowing through watersheds having various levels of impervious
cover (Schiff & Benoit, 2007). Generally, results show that a watershed with 10%
![Page 7: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
or greater impervious cover will have definitively degraded water bodies. The
relationship between stream health and percent impervious cover within a
watershed is shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3. General relationship of imperviousness to stream health. (Arnold & Gibbons, 1996).
Schiff and Benoit (2007) found that at multiple spatial scales (watershed, local
contributing area, and the 100-m riparian buffer for each) a total impervious area
(TIA) as low as 5% had a negative impact on stream water quality,
macroinvertebrate community assemblage, and in-stream habitat. Conditions
worsened with a TIA of up to 10% and remained constant with increasing
percentages of TIA. Spatially, both the water and habitat quality had a strong
correlation to TIA at all scales, while the macroinvertebrate showed a relatively
weaker relationship to TIA at larger spatial scales.
![Page 8: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
A literature review of impervious surface and water quality by Brabec et al.
(2002) reports a wide variation amongst the dozens of studies reviewed
regarding the percentage IC when certain aspects of stream health will begin to
degrade, from 4% - 50%. However, the studies specifically investigating a
stream’s biotic integrity, or aquatic species richness and composition, had ranges
much lower, from 4% -15% IC, suggesting this an extremely sensitive indicator.
Water quality tended to be less sensitive and its degradation threshold ranged
from 7.5% - 50% impervious cover.
Water Quality Impacts
The alteration of the hydrologic cycle also impacts the ecology of an area in
several ways. Nonpoint source pollution has been identified as one of the
greatest contributors to water quality degradation to U.S. rivers, lakes, and
estuaries. (EPA, 1994). Stormwater is known to be a major transporter of
nonpoint source (NPS) pollution, carrying pollutants such as pathogens and
excess nutrients from lawns and toxic contaminants and debris from roads and
parking lots into coastal waters (Mallin et al., 2000). When runoff infiltration is
reduced, these pollutants bypass natural degradation processes that occur as
water percolates through the soil. Surface waters receiving high levels of NPS
pollution often undergo eutrophication, a response by ecosystems to an
excessive concentration of nutrients, which can reduce biodiversity and cause
phytoplankton blooms and fish kills (Ernst et al., 1999).
![Page 9: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Total maximum daily load (TMDL) is a tool that States are required to use under
the Clean Water Act to limit the quantity of pollutants entering an impaired water
body from both point sources and nonpoint sources of pollution. The TMDL
represents the amount of pollution a water body can accept without adversely
impacting wildlife, recreation, or other public uses. States typically calculate
TMDLs by reviewing water quality monitoring data and watershed modeling.
A pilot project conducted by the Connecticut Department of Energy and the
Environment (DEEP), the University of Connecticut, and the town of Mansfield,
CT studied the use of IC to determine a watershed’s TMDL. The project was
based on research done within the state, collecting samples from 125 stream
segments to determine the composition of the benthic macroinvertebrate
populations, which was used as an indicator of stream health. These data were
compared with the watershed impervious cover estimates. None of the stream
segments having greater than 12% impervious cover within their watersheds met
Connecticut DEEP’s aquatic life standards for a healthy stream. (CT NEMO,
2012) Other studies have found similar results, showing a negative relationship
between catchment urbanization and various biotic indices such as in-stream
taxon richness, EPT richness (an index based on the total number of taxa in
three distinct insect orders) and the Invertebrate Community Index (Roy et al.,
2003). The results of the CT DEEP study provided the basis for a new IC-based
TMDL for impaired waterways in Connecticut.
An IC-based TMDL encourages the use of Low Impact Development (LID)
strategies to reduce the impact of runoff carrying NPS pollution to water bodies
![Page 10: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
and degrading their water quality. The primary strategies to mitigate excess
runoff and its associated pollution to receiving waters are to disconnect IC from
the drainage system, reduce or remove IC where possible, and treat runoff (CT
NEMO, 2012).
B. Using Impervious Cover as an Environmental Indicator
Knowing the percentage of a watershed that is developed or impervious can help
planners make informed land use decisions. Local planners require a simple tool
to determine the impacts of development on the environment and water
resources. Impervious cover can be used as a quantifiable environmental
indicator because it is a major contributor to the adverse environmental impacts
of urbanization. Many studies have identified a strong correlation between
percent IC in a landscape and negative impacts to the quality of receiving waters
(Schiff & Benoit, 2007; Arnold & Gibbons,1996; Wang et al., 2007).
An advantage of using IC as an environmental indicator is it provides an estimate
of the effective impact to water resources by humans without requiring extensive
data collection or analysis. Another benefit is that it is measureable, which makes
it a useful option for planning and regulation (Arnold & Gibbons, 1996).
Lathrop and Conway (2001) used impervious cover as an indicator of nonpoint
pollution when developing a build-out analysis for a Barnegat Bay watershed in
New Jersey. A build-out analysis maps the expected extent of maximum
development given existing zoning regulations. Using IC as a surrogate indicator
![Page 11: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
for NPS pollution, these researchers were able to make future estimates of NPS
pollution impacts that otherwise would have been difficult to predict.
C. Salt Pond Region Special Area Management Plan (SAMP)
Salt ponds are shallow, productive lagoons that are separated from the ocean by
barrier spits (Ernst et al., 1999). They provide many valuable ecosystem services
such as habitat for recreational and commercial fin and shellfish, migratory
waterfowl habitat, and productive eelgrass beds (Ernst et al., 1999). In southern
Rhode Island, efforts to improve the degraded quality of the surface and
groundwater entering the salt ponds have been ongoing since the early 1980’s.
The Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council is responsible for
developing management plans for the protection and enhancement of the state’s
coastal resources. A growing population and continued land development within
these areas began noticeably stressing the pond’s ecosystem functions in the
1970’s, which was the impetus for the initial 1984 Salt Pond SAMP. (Ernst et al.,
1999)
The Salt Pond SAMP was developed for the region extending from the barrier
spits separating the ponds from the ocean to the inland boundary of the
individual pond’s watershed. The figure below shows the extent of the Salt Pond
SAMP within the town of Charlestown, RI.
![Page 12: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Figure 4. A map of the Rhode Island Salt Pond Region SAMP within Charlestown, RI, classified by intensity of development. (Ernst et al., 1999)
Charlestown included the 1984 Salt Pond SAMP recommendation of increasing
the minimum residential lot size to 2 acres in their 1991 Town Comprehensive
Plan (VHB, 1991). The initial SAMP was effective at limiting the potential extent
of development and pollution sources, however, the cumulative impacts of
nonpoint source pollution, particularly bacteria and Nitrogen, resulted in salt pond
eutrophication and permanent shellfish closures (Ernst et al. 1999). In the 1999
Salt Pond SAMP revision, stormwater runoff mitigation has been listed among
![Page 13: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
the top priorities for salt pond restoration, because it is not only a major
transporter of both excess nutrients and bacteria, but also sediment, road salt,
heavy metals and petroleum hydrocarbons into the salt ponds and their
tributaries.
II. Purpose
The purpose of this project is to provide the town of Charlestown, RI with a more
accurate impervious cover GIS dataset within the state-designated Salt Pond
region. This dataset can be used to help enforce the Rhode Island municipal
separate storm sewer system mandate, regulate the stormwater Best
Management Practice requirement of RI’s Stormwater Design and Installation
Standards Manual which is based on land parcel percentage IC, and provide
town planners with a baseline IC for future zoning regulation amendments.
III. Methods
The dataset created for this project was completed using ArcGIS 10
(Environmental Systems Research Institute, Redlands CA). ArcGIS 10 is a
geographic information system that allows users to map and analyze geospatial
data. GIS is a commonly used tool in the field of environmental science. The
Rhode Island Geographic Information System (RIGIS) Impervious Surfaces
dataset was developed in 2006-2007 and was based on the 2003-2004
orthorectified aerial photography for Rhode Island. It is a raster dataset made up
of two classes, pervious and impervious land cover. This dataset was derived
using semi-automated methods and is available to be downloaded for free on the
![Page 14: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
RIGIS website. This is an excellent resource for documenting the extent of
Rhode Island’s impervious cover and is best suited for state or town-level
analysis. On a larger scale, such as at the neighborhood level, the inaccuracies
of the dataset become apparent.
The following procedure was used to manually update the RIGIS Impervious
Surface dataset for the Charlestown, Rhode Island Salt Pond region:
Create a geodatabase
• In ArcCatalog, right click the folder where you want the new geodatabase to
be stored.
• Select New > File Geodatabase
o Choose a meaningful name without any blank spaces or non-alpha
numeric characters other than dash or underscore.
Prepare your area of analysis
• Download the RIGIS Impervious Surfaces raster dataset from
http://www.edc.uri.edu/rigis/data/ under the Environment and Conservation
section.
• Next, right click the new geodatabase in ArcCatalog and select Import >
Raster dataset and browse to the location where the Impervious Surfaces
dataset is saved.
• Open a new map document in ArcMap and add the Impervious Surfaces
raster dataset to the map.
![Page 15: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
• Also add the feature class or shapefile of the extent of the area to be
analyzed to your map.
Clip the Rhode Island Impervious Surface raster dataset
It is a good idea to clip the Impervious Surface dataset to your study region early
in the process because it is a large dataset.
• In ArcMap, open the ArcToolbox window > Data Management Tools >
Raster > Raster Processing > Clip.
o In the Clip wizard, for Input Raster, select the Impervious Surface
dataset.
o Select the area of analysis file for Output Extent.
o Check the Use Input Features for Clipping Geometry box.
o Save the new dataset into the geodatabase.
Reclassify raster dataset
• Open the Catalog Window and find the geodatabase containing the
clipped IC raster dataset. Drag this file into the empty ArcMap screen.
• Next, open the ArcToolbox window and expand the Spatial Analyst Tools
Toolbox > Reclass > Reclassify.
o In the Reclassify wizard, select the clipped impervious cover
dataset for the Input Raster line.
o Select Value from the Reclass Field dropdown menu.
o Under the New Value column, assign NoData for the top value and
1 for the bottom value.
![Page 16: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
o Choose the geodatabase as the location for the file, select a new
name for this file and select OK.
Convert raster dataset into a vector dataset
• In ArcMap 10, open the ArcToolbox window and expand the Conversion
Tools Toolbox > From Raster > Raster to Polygon.
o In the Raster to Polygon wizard, select the final reclassified
impervious surface raster dataset for the Raster input line.
o Name the output vector file in the second line.
o Check the Simplify Polygons box to get smooth polygons rather
than shapes that follow the raster pixel borders and select OK.
o The resulting data layer will be used for editing the impervious
surfaces.
o Add this data layer to the map. Right click the layer in the Table of
Contents window and select Properties. Under the Symbols tab,
you can change the appearance of the polygons. For this project, I
choose to outline the impervious polygons with a thin red line for
maximum visibility of the underlying aerial photograph.
Other data layers
In addition to the impervious surface vector dataset created in the previous step,
there are a few other data layers used to do this analysis.
• Base Maps:
![Page 17: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Base maps are used as background images and can be directed
streamed within ArcMap from online sources rather than downloading
these large images onto your computer. The base maps used for this
project were the Rhode Island 2008 digital aerial photography and the
Rhode Island 2011 RIDEM digital true color orthophotography.
o To use online base maps in ArcMap, find the Add Data icon at the
top of the screen and select ‘Add Data from ArcGIS Online…’
o Type ‘Rhode Island’ in the search window to view available online
base maps for the state.
• Charlestown SAMP boundary
o The SAMP boundary data layer was obtained from the town of
Charlestown GIS specialist. It was used to clip the RIGIS
impervious surface dataset and serves as the boundary for this
project.
• E-911 Sites
o This dataset is available online from the RIGIS website. It is a point
dataset and provides basic information for each significant structure
in Rhode Island, such as address and owner and is up-to-date as of
March 2012. It provides helpful reference points during the editing
process.
Create a grid layer to create distinct areas (optional)
![Page 18: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
This technique may be useful as a guide while examining each impervious
surface polygon.
• Right click in an empty area within the upper portion of the screen near the
ArcMap toolbars. A list of optional toolbars will appear, select both Draw
and Editor.
• There is an icon that looks like the outline of a square, select this and
select an appropriate shape, for this project the square was used.
• Draw a large square covering the entire region to be edited and ensure it
is selected.
• Opening the Drawing dropdown menu, select Convert Graphics to
Features. Identify the coordinate system and use the geodatabase as the
location for this new feature class and click OK. Select Yes in the following
window to add this shape as a new layer on your map.
• Using the Editor toolbar, select Start Editing. Select the feature, in this
case, the rectangle and click on the Cut Polygons icon in the Editor toolbar.
This allows you to divide the polygon into various sections. These sections
can be symbolized in unique ways so that they stand out and it makes it
easy to see when a section border has been reached. For this project, the
rectangle was divided into smaller squares, each made 90% transparent
with a unique color. Alternatively, each square could be outlined with a
uniquely colored border to avoid tinting the aerial photo base maps. Within
the attribute table for this layer, a new field was created and each square
was labeled with a unique number.
![Page 19: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Editing polygons
Once all the data layers are saved in the geodatabase and available within the
ArcMap document, the process of analyzing the impervious surfaces of the study
area can begin.
• Create a new field in the attribute table and name it ‘Altered’. Assign 0 to
the entire column before editing. Every time a specific polygon is edited
change the 0 value to a 1. This will help keep track of how many edits
have been made.
• Prior to editing, determine the general path you will follow to review each
impervious polygon and how you will use the grid layer as a reference.
• The scales used for this project ranged from 1:700 and 1:1,000. Choosing
the scale is a balance between efficiency and ability to clearly distinguish
the boundaries between impervious and pervious surfaces.
• It was necessary to use both the 2011 aerial photos and 2008 aerial
photos. The 2011 photos offered the most recent images and the 2008
photos offered the highest resolution. Each polygon was examined over
each set of photography.
• Select Editor on the Editing toolbar and select Start Editing. Using the
feature selection arrow, click on the impervious surface layer. Now you
can use any of the editing tools to reshape the data layer to more closely
match the aerial photograph underneath.
• In order to edit polygons as consistently as possible, I developed a list of
rules for determining how to categorize surfaces. My guidelines were:
![Page 20: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
o Any driveway is impervious, even if not paved.
o Boats are not impervious surfaces.
o Decks and patios are impervious surfaces.
o If the impervious surface layer of a road is shifted but still
represented an accurate impervious area, it was left unedited.
Comparing completed dataset with the original RIGIS Impervious Surface
dataset
One way to analyze the new dataset is to compare it to the original dataset in
ArcMap by combining both maps. The result provides one dataset with four
distinct categories: areas where both maps were pervious, areas where only the
RIGIS dataset was impervious, areas where only the manually-edited dataset
was impervious, and areas where both datasets were impervious.
Convert vector dataset into a raster dataset
• Open ArcToolbox and expand the Conversion Tools toolbox > To Raster >
Feature to Raster.
• Enter the edited impervious surface dataset into the Input Features field.
• Select Value for the Field line. This will be the only value transferred into
the Attribute Table of the new raster dataset.
• Select your File Geodatabase for the destination and a unique name in the
Output field.
• Enter the same cell size used in the original dataset, in this case it was 2,
and select OK.
![Page 21: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Reclassify the edited impervious surface dataset
• In ArcToolbox, expand Spatial Analyst Tools > Reclass > Reclassify.
• Use the raster created in the step above as the Input Raster.
• Select Value in the Reclass Field.
• Change the Old Value of 1 to a New Value of 10 and the Old Value of
NoData to a New Value of 0.
• Select your File Geodatabase for the destination and a unique name in the
Output field and select OK.
Clip the dataset
• In ArcToolbox, expand Data Management Tools > Raster > Raster
Processing > Clip.
• Enter the reclassified raster from the step above into the Input Raster field.
• Select the feature class representing the extent of your study area in the
Output Extent field, in this case it was the Charlestown SAMP region.
• Leave the default values in the Rectangle fields.
• Select your File Geodatabase for the destination and a unique name in the
Output field.
• Check the ‘Use Input Features to Clip Geometry’ Box and select OK.
Reclassify the original dataset
• In ArcToolbox, expand Spatial Analyst Tools > Reclass > Reclassify.
• Use the original impervious surface raster dataset for the Input Raster.
![Page 22: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
• Select Value in the Reclass Field.
• Leave the Old Value of 1 as the New Value and change the Old Value of
NoData to a New Value of 0.
• Select your File Geodatabase for the destination and a unique name in the
Output field and select OK.
Clip the dataset
• Use the same procedure as outlined above for the edited-dataset.
Combine the datasets
• Go to ArcToolbox > Spatial Analyst Tools > Map Algebra > Raster
Calculator.
• Double click on the reclassified and clipped original dataset.
• Click on the ‘ + ’.
• Double click on the reclassified and clipped edited dataset.
• Select your File Geodatabase for the destination and a unique name in
the Output field and select OK.
IV. Results and Discussion
By comparing the edited version of the impervious cover dataset to the original
RIGIS impervious dataset, I calculated the area change in IC and noticed trends
that emerged between the two datasets. First, I found that my impervious dataset
had 35 more acres of impervious cover than the original dataset, which was
based on 2003-2004 imagery. This difference can be attributed to new
![Page 23: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
development that occurred from 2004 - 2011, omissions of impervious surface by
the original dataset, and overestimates of impervious cover in my dataset.
Common omissions of the original dataset were small structures like sheds and
patios, although this is not likely a great contributor to the difference in
impervious area between the datasets. By looking at the summation dataset, it
appears that new development contributes most to the increase in area of
impervious cover.
On the other hand, the original dataset often mapped foot trails, small paths, and
sometimes stonewalls as impervious surfaces while my dataset did not. It was
less likely that an isolated structure in a less developed area would be missed in
the original dataset than the manually edited version.
![Page 24: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Figure 5. Example snapshot of the summation dataset created by using the Raster Calculator
tool to combine both datasets.
Figure 5 above illustrates many of the common patterns between the two
datasets. The red areas indicate impervious cover only delineated in the
manually edited dataset. This area includes many small sheds, small additions to
![Page 25: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
established structures, and larger areas, which were typically found along Route
1. The larger red and green area near the center of the figure is an example of
the original dataset’s underestimation of impervious areas where tree cover
overhangs impervious roads, parking lots and homes. The series of short purple
diagonal lines are dirt rows between strips of vegetation. For the edited dataset,
I chose to map these as pervious along with similar features like small trails.
It took an estimated 80 hours to complete all the impervious cover polygons
within the 12.66 mi2 SAMP area, or 6.3 hours/mi2. This process was time-
consuming and may not be a reasonable project for town GIS specialists.
Factors like computer-processing speed, size of the area being mapped, and
complexity of the impervious surfaces would likely have a significant impact on
the time needed to complete the project. It may be a good task to set aside for
interns or divided into small areas to be worked on as time permits.
Considering the large time commitment to manually develop this dataset, I
calculated the percentage of IC from each dataset: 9.3% for the original dataset
and 9.7% for the manually edited dataset. With a percent difference of 0.4%, this
method is definitely not recommended for large or even moderately sized areas.
However, this still may be worth the effort on the parcel level. This analysis
resulted in an impervious surface data layer of higher accuracy for the
Charlestown Salt Pond region than provided by the original layer for the State of
Rhode Island. While not a quick process, this data layer provides valuable
impervious surface data for the town to use as a baseline inventory and for
regulating development based on changes of impervious cover per parcel.
![Page 26: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank Lorraine Joubert for informing me of this project and
connecting me with the right people to get started. I would also like to
acknowledge Steve McCandless from the Town of Charlestown, RI for providing
direction, being available for assistance, and for the initial shapefiles to get
started. Dr. Art Gold took the time to discuss many possible project options
throughout my MESM career and provided guidance on the structure for this
paper. Finally, Dr. Pete August helped me plan the project methods and
reviewed and provided guidance for this paper. I’m also very thankful for his
understanding and the extension offered when the first version of the impervious
dataset was lost. Thank you for all the support.
![Page 27: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
Literature Cited
Arnold, C.L. and C.J. Gibbons. 1996. Impervious surface coverage: the
emergence of a key environmental indicator. Journal of the American Planning
Assoc. 62:243-258.
Brabec, E., S. Schulte, and P.L. Richards. 2002. Impervious surfaces and water
quality: a review of current literature and its implications for watershed planning.
Journal of Planning Lit. 16:499-514.
Center for Watershed Protection, 2002. Is Impervious Cover Still Important?
From “Runoff Rundown,” www.cwp.org/runoff_rundown.htm, Center for
Watershed Protection, Ellicott City, MD
Connecticut Nonpoint Education for Municipal Officials (CT NEMO), Total
Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Project in Connecticut’s Eagleville Brook
Watershed http://clear.uconn.edu/projects/TMDL/index.htm. Last accessed May
5, 2012.
Environmental Protection Agency. 1994. The quality of our nation’s water. United
States Environmental Protection Agency #EPA-841-S-94-002. Washington, DC:
USEPA Office of Water.
Ernst, L.M., L.K. Miguel, and J. Willis. 1999. Rhode Island’s Salt Pond Region: A
Special Area Management Plan. Prepared for the Rhode Island Coastal
Resources Management Council.
Hurd, J.D. and D.L. Civco. 2004. Surface Water Quality and Impervious Surface
Quantity: A Preliminary Study. NOAA Grant NA16OC2673.
Lathrop, R.G. and T.M. Conway. 2001. A build-out analysis of the Barnegat Bay
watershed. CRSSA Technical Report 2001-02.
Mallin, M.A. et al. 2000. Effect of human development on bacteriological water
quality in coastal watersheds. Eco App. 10:1047-1056.
![Page 28: A MAJOR PAPER SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE ... · ! 3! I. Introduction The salt pond watersheds of southern Rhode Island have experienced significant suburbanization beginning](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022070915/5fb5ed080bb5130a43322f5b/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
Paul, M.J. and J.L. Meyer. 2001. Streams in the urban landscape. Annu. Rev.
Ecol. Syst. 32:333-65.
Roy et al. 2003. Stream macroinvertebrate response to catchment urbanization.
Freshwater Biology. 48:329-346.
Schiff, R. and G. Benoit. 2007. Effects of impervious cover at multiple spatial
scales on coastal watershed streams. Journal of Amer. Water Res. Assoc.
43:712-730.
Stankowski, S.J. 1972. Population Density as an indirect indicator of urban and
suburban land-surface modifications. U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper
800-B: B219-B224.
Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc. (VHB), 1991. Town of Charlestown, RI
Comprehensive Plan.
Zhou, Y. and Y.Q. Wang. 2006. Extraction of impervious surface area using
orthophotos in Rhode Island. ASPRS Annual Conference.