a review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the global nutrition targets 2025...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
A review of studies examining the link
between food insecurity and malnutrition
![Page 2: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Cover photographs
Left image: ©FAO/Alessandra BenedettiCentre image: ©FAO/James HillRight image: ©FAO/Vasily Maximov
![Page 3: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
FOOD AND AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION OF THE UNITED NATIONSRome, 2018
A review of studies examining the link
between food insecurity and malnutrition
byChandana Maitra
University of Sydney
![Page 4: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Suggested Citation
Maitra, C. 2018. A review of studies examining the link between food insecurity and malnutrition. Technical Paper. FAO, Rome. 70 pp. Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO. (Available at http://www.fao.org/3/CA1447EN/ca1447en.pdf)
This paper was commissioned by FAO through the project Voices of the Hungry (VoH). VoH collects information on food insecurity (restricted food access) as experienced by individuals in over 140 countries using the Food Insecurity Experience Scale (FIES). The project also aims to assist countries interested in adopting the FIES as part of national food security monitoring efforts.Comments received on previous versions of this paper from Cristina Alvarez, Anne Kepple and Meghan Miller are gratefully acknowledged.For further information please see: http://www.fao.org/economic/ess/ess-fs/voices/en/
The designations employed and the presentation of material in this information product do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) concerning the legal or development status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The mention of specific companies or products of manufacturers, whether or not these have been patented, does not imply that these have been endorsed or recommended by FAO in preference to others of a similar nature that are not mentioned.
The views expressed in this information product are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of FAO.
ISBN 978-92-5-130942-1© FAO, 2018
Some rights reserved. This work is made available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Share-Alike 3.0 IGO licence (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO; https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/igo).
Under the terms of this licence, this work may be copied, redistributed and adapted for non-commercial purposes, provided that the work is appropriately cited. In any use of this work, there should be no suggestion that FAO endorses any specific organization, products or services. The use of the FAO logo is not permitted. If the work is adapted, then it must be licensed under the same or equivalent Creative Commons license. If a translation of this work is created, it must include the following disclaimer along with the required citation: “This translation was not created by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). FAO is not responsible for the content or accuracy of this translation. The original [Language] edition shall be the authoritative edition.
Any mediation relating to disputes arising under the licence shall be conducted in accordance with the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) as at present in force.
Third-party materials. Users wishing to reuse material from this work that is attributed to a third party, such as tables, figures or images, are responsible for determining whether permission is needed for that reuse and for obtaining permission from the copyright holder. The risk of claims resulting from infringement of any third-par-ty-owned component in the work rests solely with the user.
Sales, rights and licensing. FAO information products are available on the FAO website (www.fao.org/publications) and can be purchased through [email protected]. Requests for commercial use should be submitted via: www.fao.org/contact-us/licence-request. Queries regarding rights and licensing should be submitted to: [email protected].
![Page 5: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
iii
Abstract Areviewof120studiespublishedsince2006wasundertakentoexaminetherelationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityatthehouseholdorindividuallevelandthefollowingnutritionindicators:childstunting,childwasting,lowbirthweight,exclusivebreastfeedingofinfants<6monthsofage,anaemiainwomenofreproductiveage,childoverweightandadultobesity.Whilethereissomeevidenceofadirectassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstuntingforchildreninlower-middleandupper-middleincomecountries,evidenceoflinksbetweenfoodinsecurityandeitherchildwastingoroverweightisalmostabsent,withtheexceptionofanassociationwithoverweightamonggirlsinmiddle-andhigh-incomecountries.Theobesity–foodinsecuritylinkismostpredominantamongwomeninhigh-incomecountries,whileitisalmostabsentinmen.Inaddition,foodinsecurityincreasestheriskforlowbirthweightininfantsandanaemiainwomen.Methodologicalconcernsthatposechallengesforvalidcomparisonofresultsrelatetostudydesign,dataanalysistechniques,useofdifferentindicatorsofhousehold/individualfoodsecurityandmalnutrition,andthelimitedavailabilityofhigh-qualitymicro-leveldatafromlarge-scalesurveys.Moststudiesreportcorrelationratherthancausalassociationsbetweenfoodinsecurityandnutritionindicators;longitudinalmicro-leveldatafromlarge-scalesurveyscanhelpestablishcausalassociationandcapturethedynamicnatureoffoodinsecurity.Foodinsecurityemergesasapredictorofundernutritionaswellasoverweightandobesity,highlightingtheneedformultisectoralstrategiesandpoliciestocombatfoodinsecurityandmultipleformsofmalnutrition.
![Page 6: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
![Page 7: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
v
Contents Abstract..................................................................................................iv
ListofAbbreviationsandAcronyms........................................................vii
Introduction.............................................................................................1
Methods...................................................................................................4SEARCHSTRATEGY............................................................................................................4
CRITERIAFORINCLUSIONOFPAPERS...............................................................................4
Findings....................................................................................................5FOODINSECURITYANDUNDERNUTRITION......................................................................5
Childstunting...............................................................................................................5Childwasting................................................................................................................6Lowbirthweight..........................................................................................................6Anaemiainwomenofreproductiveage......................................................................6Exclusivebreastfeeding................................................................................................6
FOODINSECURITYANDOVERWEIGHT/OBESITY..............................................................6Childoverweight..........................................................................................................6Adultobesity................................................................................................................7
Discussion................................................................................................8PATHWAYSFROMFOODINSECURITYTOMALNUTRITIONINADULTSANDCHILDREN.................................................................................................................8
Foodinsecuritytostuntingandwastinginchildren....................................................9Foodinsecuritytoanaemia........................................................................................10Foodinsecuritytoexclusivebreastfeeding................................................................10Foodinsecuritytolowbirthweight...........................................................................11FoodFoodinsecuritytooverweightinchildrenandobesityinadults......................11
EXPLAININGTHELACKOFASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDMALNUTRITION......................................................................................................13HOWTORECONCILETHECONTRADICTORYEVIDENCEFROMVARIOUSSTUDIESEXAMININGTHEFOODINSECURITY–MALNUTRITIONLINK...........................................14GAPSINTHELITERATURE...............................................................................................17
Conclusion..............................................................................................19
![Page 8: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
vi
Tables
TABLE1.STUDIESONTHEASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDCHILDHOODSTUNDING..........................................................................................20TABLE2.STUDIESONTHEASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDCHILDHOODSTUNTING..........................................................................................27TABLE3.STUDIESONTHEASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDLOWBIRTHWEIGHT...............................................................................................30TABLE4.STUDIESONTHEASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDANAEMIAINWOMEN.............................................................................................31TABLE5.STUDIESONTHEASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDEXCLUSIVEBREASTFEEDING...................................................................................33TABLE6.STUDIESONTHEASSOCIATIONBETWEENFOODINSECURITYANDOVERWEIGHTANDOBESITY...................................................................................35
References.............................................................................................45
![Page 9: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
vii
Abbreviations and acronyms AOR AdjustedOddsRatioBMI BodyMassIndexDHS DemographicandHealthSurveyEBF ExclusiveBreastfeedingEBFSS Experience-BasedFoodSecurityScalesEBIA EscalaBrasileiradeInsegurançaAlimentar
(BrazilianFoodInsecurityScale)ELCSA EscalaLatinoamericanayCaribeñadeSeguridadAlimentaria
(LatinAmericanandCaribbeanFoodSecurityScale)ENSANUT EncuestaNacionaldeSaludyNutrición(NationalHealthand
NutritionSurvey)ENSMI EncuestaNacionaldeSaludMaternoInfantil
(NationalMaternal-InfantHealthSurvey)FI FoodInsecurityFIES FoodInsecurityExperienceScaleHAZ Height-for-AgeZ-scoreHFI HouseholdFoodInsecurityHFIAS HouseholdFoodInsecurityAccessScaleHHs HouseholdsHICs High-IncomeCountriesHIV HumanImmunodeficiencyVirusID IronDeficiencyLBW LowBirthWeightLICs LowIncomeCountriesLMICs Lower-MiddleIncomeCountriesMANA ProgramadeMejoramientoAlimentarioyNutricionaldeAntioquia
(FoodandNutritionImprovementPlanforAntioquia)MINIM MaternalandInfantNutritionInterventioninMatlabUMICs Upper-MiddleIncomeCountriesUSHFSSM UnitedStatesHouseholdFoodSecuritySurveyModuleWIC SpecialSupplementalFoodProgramforWomen,Infants,and
Childreny year
![Page 10: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
1
Introduction Foodsecurityisacomplexandmultidimensionalphenomenondefinedasastatewhen“allpeople,atalltimes,havephysical,socialandeconomicaccesstosufficient,safeandnutritiousfoodthatmeetstheirdietaryneedsandfoodpreferencesforanactiveandhealthylife”(1).Akeycomponentoffoodinsecurityislackofaccesstoasufficientquantityofnutritiousfood,whichisapotentialriskfactorformalnutritioninchildrenandadults(2-4).However,evidenceontheassociationbetweenhouseholdorindividualfoodinsecurityandmalnutritionisnotconclusiveintheexistingliterature.Establishingacausaleffectoffoodinsecurityonnutritionalconsequencesisachallengingtask,duetoseveralmethodologicalconcernsrelatedtostudydesign,analyticaltechniques,thediversityoffoodinsecurityandmalnutritionindicatorsused,andaboveall,thelimitedavailabilityofhighqualitymicro-leveldatafromlargescalesurveys(5-7).Yet,itisimportanttoexplorethisrelationshipbecausemalnutritionhasenormouseconomicandsocialcosts(8-9).Poornutritioninearlychildhoodhaslong-termcostsintermsofadversehealth,schooling,andconsequenteffectsonthelabourmarketinlaterlife(10-11).Inthecontextoflow-orlower-middleincomecountries,nutritionaldeprivationinearlylifeposesoneofthegreatestobstaclestopovertyreductionbyperpetuatingthecycleofpoverty,poornutrition,lowhumancapital,andlowproductivity(10).Insubpopulationsinhigh-incomecountries,foodinsecuritymaybeariskfactorforobesitywhichmaycauseadverseintergenerationalhealthconsequences(12).Giventheaboveconsiderations,theaimofthepresentstudywastogatherevidenceonthenatureandextentoftheassociationbetweenfoodinsecurity(specificallytheexperienceofnothavingaccesstosafe,nutritiousandsufficientfoodduetolackofmoneyorotherresources)andselectedindicatorsofmalnutritioninadultsandchildrenacrosstheglobe.Establishingtheserelationshipsisimportantinthecontextofbothresource-poorandresource-richsettingsandwiththeemergenceofnewconcernssuchasthe‘doubleburdenofmalnutrition’(13-14),definedasthecoexistenceofundernutritionandoverweight/obesity.Multipletypesofmalnutritionmayoccursimultaneouslywithinpopulations,households,orevenindividuals.TheissueistimelyandrelevanttotheGlobalNutritionTargets2025(15)aswellastheSustainableDevelopmentGoals(SDGs)thataimtoeliminatepovertyandachievezerohunger,goodhealthandwell-beingforall.Adetailedreviewoftheliteraturewasundertakentoextractthekeyfindingsontherelationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityandselectednutritionindicators.Thefoodsecurityindicatorsusedinthestudiesthatwerereviewedwerebasedontheclassofexperience-basedfoodsecurityscales(EBFSS),whichquantitativelycapturefood-relatedbehavioursandexperiencesassociatedwithdifficultiesinaccessingfoodduetoresourceconstraints(16).Severalreliableandvalidatedexperientialscalesexist,includingtheUnitedStatesHouseholdFoodSecurity
![Page 11: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
2
SurveyModule(USHFSSM),theFoodInsecurityExperienceScale(FIES)(16),theHouseholdFoodInsecurityAccessScale(HFIAS)(17),theHouseholdHungerScale(HHS)(18),andtheLatinAmericanandCaribbeanFoodSecurityScale(ELCSA)(19).Thekeynutritionindicatorsconsideredinthestudiesare:stunting,wastingandoverweightinchildren,adultobesity,lowbirthweight(LBW),exclusivebreastfeedingofinfants<6months(EBF)andanaemiainwomenofreproductiveage.Conceptually,thepathwaysfromfoodinsecuritytomalnutritioncanbeincorporatedintothetheoreticalparadigmoftheSocio-EcologicalModel(20),whichoffersabioecologicalframeworkofhumandevelopment.Thisapproachplacesanemphasisonboththeimmediateandbroaderenvironmentasimportantforhumandevelopment,incorporatingtimeasanimportantinfluencefrominfancythroughtoadulthood.Withinthiscontext,foodinsecuritycanbeviewedasafactorthathaslong-termimpactonanindividual’snutritionalstatusthroughoutthevariousstagesofthelifecycle.Theframework,whichhasapplicationsinseveralfields,includingnutritionandpublichealth,comprisesindividual/intrapersonal,interpersonal,communityandenablingenvironments.Theinfluenceswithinandbetweeneachenvironmentarebi-directional,withtherelationshipshavingimpactbothawayfromandtowardstheindividual.Individual(intrapersonal)factorscompriseage,sex,socio-economicstatus,race/ethnicity,physicalhealth,knowledgeandskills,andpersonalpreferences.Thesecondlevel(interpersonal)relatestorelationshipswithpeers,partners,andfamilythatmayinfluencetheoutcome.Forexample,amother’seducationlevelcaninfluenceherchild’sgrowthanddevelopment.Thethirdlevel(community)considersthesettingsinwhichindividualslive,learnandwork,includingearlycareandeducationprograms,schools,worksites,communitycentresandfoodserviceestablishments.Thesettingsthusdefinealargersocialcontextinwhichtheindividualdoesnotdirectlyfunction,butwhichinfluencedevelopmentfromchildhoodtoadulthoodbyinteractingwithsomeelementinhis/herintra-andinterpersonalenvironment.Forexample,ahigh-qualitycommunitychildcareprogramthatbenefitstheentirefamilymightreducethenegativeimpactoffoodinsecurityonchildgrowth,thusmoderatingthestrengthoftheassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandchildnutritionalstatus.Settingsalsohavethepotentialforbroaderpopulation-levelimpactiftheyareintegratedwithstrategiescomingfrommultiplesectors,whichbroadlycomprisetheenablingenvironment–theoutermostlayerintheindividual’sdevelopment.Thesesectorsincludegovernments,education,healthcare,transportation,publichealth,communityorganizations,businessesandindustries,allofwhichplayanimportantrolebyinfluencingpeople’saccesstohealthyfoodandopportunitiestobephysicallyactive,ortheyinfluencesocialnormsandvalues.Thislevelthereforelooksatbroadsocietalfactorsthathelpcreateaclimateinwhichtheindividualcangrowasahealthyandproductiveeconomicagent.Thus,health,economic,educationalandsocialpoliciesareimportantspheresofinfluenceatthislevel.
![Page 12: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
3
Theeffectoftheseelementsoftheenablingenvironmenthaveacascadinginfluencethroughouttheinteractionsofallotherlayers.Forexample,arevisedhealthcaresystematthemacrolevelmightreduceout-of-pockethealthcareexpenditureandimprovehealthservicesforthevulnerablepopulation(e.g.householdsfromlow-incomeorminoritycommunities),consequentlylesseningtheimpactoffoodinsecurityonindividualnutritionaloutcomesatthemicrolevel.Theorganizationofthepaperisasfollows:thenextsectionpresentsthemethodsusedinthereview.Sectionthreereportskeyfindings,whilesectionfourdiscussesthem.Thefinalsectiondiscussesgapsintheexistingliteratureandsectionsixconcludeswithpotentialpolicyimplicationsoftheresults.
![Page 13: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
4
Methods Thissectiondiscussesthesearchstrategyandcriteriaforinclusionofpapers.Thescopeoftheliteraturereviewislimitedtopapersthatreportempiricalassociationsbetweenhouseholdorindividualfoodinsecurity(FI)andtheselectedindicatorsofmalnutrition.
SEARCH STRATEGY Databases‘Pubmed’and‘Scopus’weresearchedusingkeywordssuchashouseholdfoodsecurity,foodinsecurity,foodaccess,andvariouscombinationsofthefollowingtermsinthetitleandabstract:undernutrition,overnutrition,anthropometry,malnutrition,nutritionalstatus,stunting,wasting,overweight,obesity,BodyMassIndex(BMI),anaemia,haemoglobin,lowbirthweight,exclusivebreastfeeding.Theabovesearcheswerealsocombinedwiththewordschildand/orwomenand/oradultsand/ormaternal.Theabstractsofpaperswerereadtoidentifythoselikelytomeettheinclusioncriteria(statedbelow).TheabovesearchstrategyproducedaMasterListwhichwasfurtherenrichedbyaddingadditionalpapersavailablefromthereviewsontherelevanttopics(forexample,(21-24).Theabstractsofthepapersthatcitedthosereviewswerealsoread.Finally,additionalpaperswereextractedfromthebibliographyofthepapersincludedintheMasterListunlesstheywerealreadycountedin.Thefinallistcomprised180studiesconductedinvarioussettings.
CRITERIA FOR INCLUSION OF PAPERS Thecriteriaforinclusionofpapersinthefinalsamplewereasfollows:first,studieswereincludedifhouseholdfoodinsecurity(HFI)wasmeasuredusingsomevariationofanEBFSSandusingavalidatedquestionnaire(locallyadapted,abbreviatedortranslated).Second,studiesusingcontinuousmeasuresofweightandheight(height-for-agez-score,weight-for-heightz-score,BMIz-score)wereincluded,inadditiontostudiesusingcategoricalmeasuressuchasstunting,wasting,obesity/overweight.Foradults,anyBMImeasure(continuousorcategorical)wasconsideredacceptable,whileforchildren,weightpercentilesforageandothercategorizationswereaccepted.Third,onlypaperspublishedbetween2006andFebruary2018wereincludedinthereview;however,ahandfulofstudiesthatwerepublishedbefore2006wereincludedduetotheirseminalimportanceinthisliterature.Fourth,onlypublishedjournalarticleswereincludedinthereview,withtheexceptionofonereportonGuatemala(25).Theabovecriteriaresultedin120studiesbeingincludedinthefinalsample.
![Page 14: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
5
Findings Findingsarereportedaccordingtotheassociationfoundbetweenfoodinsecurityandthevariousformsofmalnutrition:positive,negative,noassociation,ormixedresults.Apositiveassociationgenerallyimpliesadirectandstatisticallysignificantassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandmalnutritionindicator(i.e.foodinsecurityincreasestheriskofmalnutrition),whileanegativeassociationimpliesastatisticallysignificantinverseassociation(i.e.,foodinsecuritydecreasestheriskofmalnutrition).Mixedresultsindicatethosestudiesthatreportamixofpositive,negativeornoassociationfordifferentage,genderorgeographicalgroupswithinthesamestudy.Forchildren,findingsarereportedaccordingtotwobroadagegroups:under-fiveandabovefive.1Malnutritioninthefirstfiveyearsoflifehaslong-termconsequencesforhealthandcognitivedevelopmentinlaterlifeandthereforechildrenunderfiveshouldbestudiedseparately.Asfarasobesityisconcerned,itishardertodetectthesignificanceofanyparticularchangeinBMIinyoungerchildrenasitchangesacrossdifferentagegroups.Therefore,studiesoftentypicallyreportoverweight/obesitystatisticsseparatelyforolderchildrenandadults(27).
FOOD INSECURITY AND UNDERNUTRITION Inthissection,thefindingsontheassociationbetweenFIandindicatorsofundernutritionarereported.Theindicatorsusedarestunting,wasting,LBW,EBFandanaemiainwomen.Thestudiesareconcentratedinlow(LICs),lower-middle(LMICs)orupper-middleincomecountries(UMICs).Thereislimitedevidencefromhigh-incomecountries(HICs).
Child stunting Ofthe30studiesthatexaminedtherelationshipbetweenFIandstunting(TABLE1)16studiesidentifiedasignificantpositiveassociationbetweenFIandstuntingforchildrenunderfive,i.e.childreninfoodinsecurehouseholdsweremorelikelytobestuntedthanchildreninfood-securehouseholds(2,28-42).Fourstudiesfoundasignificantpositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstuntingforchildrenabovefiveyears(43-46).Onestudyreportedmixedresults(25)forchildrenunderfive,whiletworevealedmixedfindingsforchildrenolderthanfiveyears(47-48).SeveralstudiesfromAfrica,Asia,LatinAmericaandNorthAmericareportednoassociationforeitherunder-fivechildren(49-52)orforchildrenabovefiveyears(44,53-55).
1 However, often there is considerable overlap because some studies cover broad age-ranges such as 2–11 years, e.g. Kaur et al. (26).
![Page 15: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
6
Child wasting Ofthefifteenstudiesreviewed(TABLE2)(2,28,30,33,35,38,40-42,45,50-52,56-57),onlythreereportedapositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandchildwasting,mostlyinLICsorLMICs(28,51,56);thethreewereconductedwithchildrenunder-fiveyearsofage.
Low birth weight AlthoughthenumberofstudiesontheassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandLBWislimited(TABLE3),twostudiesfromHICs(58-59)andonefromlow-incomesettings(60)reportedthatFIissignificantlyassociatedwithLBW.
Anaemia in women of reproductive age Sevenoutofeightstudies(TABLE4)foundasignificantormixedassociationbetweenHFIandanaemiainwomen,fromcountriesasdiverseasEcuador(61),Bangladesh(62),Cambodia(50),Guatemala(25),Mexico(63-64)andtheUnitedStatesofAmerica(65).
Exclusive breastfeeding AlimitednumberofstudiesareavailableontheassociationbetweenFIandEBFpractices(TABLE5).Outoftheeightstudiesreviewed,threereportedasignificantnegativeassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandexclusivebreastfeedinginCanada(66)andKenya(67).Fourstudiesreportednoassociation(68-71).Lastly,onestudy(72)onHIVaffectedmothersinUgandareportedmixedevidence:whilemoderateorsevereHFIwasnotassociatedwithEBFat6months,amongthosewomenstillexclusivelybreastfeedingat4months,thoseexperiencingfoodinsecurityweresignificantlymorelikelytoceaseEBF.Twostudiesestimatedinfantfeedingpracticesastheoutcomevariable,onecomponentofwhichwasEBF(68,70).
FOOD INSECURITY AND OVERWEIGHT/OBESITY EvidenceontheassociationbetweentheexperienceofFIandobesity/overweightisgrowing,andalargebodyofevidence(55studiesinthisreview)isavailablefromresource-richandresource-poorsettingsalike(TABLE6).
Child overweight OutofthirteenstudiesonthelinkbetweenFIandoverweight(TABLE6)inchildrenunderfiveyearsofage,fourreportedapositiveassociationormixedresults(73-76),whiletheothersfoundnoassociation(30,41,77-83).Metallinos-Katsarasetal.(75)reportedanegativeassociationbetweenHFI(withandwithouthunger)andoverweightforgirlsagedlessthantwoyearsbutpositiveassociationforgirlsagedtwotofiveyearsexperiencingfoodinsecuritywithhunger.Noassociationwasreportedforboys.
![Page 16: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
7
Outofthetwenty-twostudiesreviewedforchildrenoverfiveyearsofage,twelvestudiesreportedsomekindofassociation–positive,negativeormixed.Fourstudies(83-85,215)reportedasignificantpositiveassociation,onereportedaninverserelationship(86)andsevenstudiesreportedmixedresults(3-4,26,48,87-89).Forexample,Jyotietal.(3)foundapositiveassociationforgirlsalone.Kauretal.(26)foundapositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityoftheadultsinterviewedandobesityamong6-11-year-oldchildren,whilenoassociationwasfoundbetweenchildhoodobesityandchildfoodsecurity,asmeasuredbyquestionsposedtotheadultrespondentsbutrelatingtoexperiencesofchildreninthehousehold.Ingeneral,theevidencethatfoodinsecurityincreasestheriskofoverweightismorepronouncedforgirls(3-4,76,90,215).
Adult obesity Twelvestudiesoutofthetwenty-threereviewedfoundthatfoodinsecuritywassignificantlyassociatedwithoverweight/obesityinadults.FiveofthesewereinLMIC/UMICsettings(31,37,83,91-92)andseveninHICs(93-99)(TABLE6).Fifteenofthestudiesfocussedonwomen(orwomenandchildren)only(31,38,45,52,61,83,91-92,94-95,99-103).Ofthesefifteenstudies,seven(31,83,91-92,94-95,99)reportedsignificantassociationsbetweenFIandobesityinwomen.Laraiaetal.(2013;2015)investigatedtherelationshipinthecontextofpregnantwomen.Eightstudiesfocusedonmenandwomen/childrenasthestudypopulation(37,93,96-98,104-106),fiveofwhichreportedapositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandobesityinwomenonly.TheseresultscorroboratethosereportedinotherliteraturereviewswhichsuggestedHFIisariskfactorforobesityamongwomenbutnotmen(6,21-24,94).
![Page 17: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
8
Discussion ThisliteraturereviewrevealsthattheevidenceontheassociationbetweenFIandmalnutritioninchildrenandadultsislargelyinconclusive.Duetomethodologicaldifferencesacrossstudies,thecomparabilityofresultsischallenging.However,afewkeypointsemerge:
¾ SomeevidenceexistsofanassociationbetweenFIandchildstunting.ThepositiveFI–stuntinglinkispredominantlyinUMICsandLMICsasopposedtoLICs.
¾ LimitedevidenceisavailableontheassociationbetweenFIandchildwasting,andthisassociationispredominantlyinLIC/LMICsettings.
¾ Despitethelimitednumberofstudies,thereisevidenceofanassociationbetweenFIandbirthweightofinfants,withfoodinsecurityincreasingtheriskofLBW.
¾ Whilesomestudiesontheassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandanaemiainwomenreportmixedresults,overallresultsindicatethatFIisariskfactorforanaemia.
¾ TheevidenceofanassociationbetweenFIandoverweightinchildrenislimitedthoughsomeevidenceofapositiveassociationexistsforschool-agedgirls.
¾ TheevidenceontheassociationbetweenFIandobesityisabsentformen.However,thereisevidenceofapositiveassociationforadultwomenfromHICs.Ingeneral,evidenceisabsentinLICs/LMICs.
¾ LimitedevidenceisavailableontheassociationbetweenEBFandFIsincethenumberofstudiesthatusedexperience-basedfoodsecuritymeasuresisverylimited.
Giventheabove,thefollowingquestionsarise:
1. TotheextentthatstudiesfindevidenceofpositiveornegativeassociationbetweenFIandnutritionalstatus,whatcouldbethemediatingfactorsintheserelationships?Inotherwords,whatarethepathwaysfromFItomalnutritioninadultsandchildren?
2. WhatfactorscouldexplainthelackofassociationbetweenFIandsomeformsofmalnutrition?
3. HowcanthecontradictoryevidenceintheliteratureontheFI–malnutritionlinkbereconciled?
PATHWAYS FROM FOOD INSECURITY TO MALNUTRITION IN ADULTS AND CHILDREN MultiplepathwayscanlinkFIandmalnutritioninchildrenandadults.Itisimportanttoidentifysuchmediatorstofacilitateeffectivepolicyformulation.
![Page 18: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
9
Food insecurity to stunting and wasting in children FIisassumedtoaffectthenutritionalstatusofchildrenbycompromisingquantityandqualityofdietaryintake(107-109).Food-insecurehouseholdsaremorelikelytohavechildrenwhosufferfromlowernutrientintakes(110).Theevidencefromstudiesthatexaminedthemediatingroleofdietarydiversityintherelationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityandnutritionalstatusismixed,however.Alietal.(42)didnotfinddietarydiversitytobeamediatorintheassociationbetweenFIandchildundernutritionforBangladesh,EthiopiaandVietNam.However,usinglongitudinaldata,Humphriesetal.(48)reporteddietarydiversitytobeamediatorintheassociationbetweenFIandanthropometricindicatorsforschool-agedchildreninVietNam,India,PeruandEthiopia.Theuseofcross-sectionalversuslongitudinaldata(48)andthedifferentagegroupsofchildren(42,48)couldprovidesomeexplanationforthedifferencesinresults.Furthermore,inthecontextofhigh-incomecountries,childreninseverelyfood-insecurehouseholdswerelesslikelytomeettheguidelinessetoutintheUSFoodPyramid(54).AnotherpathwayfromFItopoorchildnutritionalstatusistheperinatalnutritionofmotherandthechild,includingtheinternatalperiodforthemother(110).Thereisoverwhelmingevidencethatperinatalnutritionaffectshealthandwell-beingofallagegroups(111).Maternalfoodinsecurityduringpregnancyhasbeenfoundtobeassociatedwithpoorerfoetalhealthoutcomes(58).Almondetal.(112)foundthattheavailabilityoffoodstamps(aformofsocialprotectionaimedataddressingfoodinsecurity)reducedtheincidenceofLBWbirthsthroughimprovementsinnutrition.HFImayalsocompromisechildhealthbycompromisingmaternaldietandhealth(113).Forpregnantwomen,FImaycauselower-than-recommendedweightgainduringpregnancyandisassociatedwithintrauterinegrowthrestriction(12),ariskfactorforstunting.Additionally,short-termmanagementstrategiesoftenincludelimitingportionsizesandskippingmealsforthecaregiver,especiallythemother(114),andcompromisedmaternalnutritionmayeventuallyinfluencechildgrowthnegatively(10).AnotherkeypathwayfromFItochildgrowthisviafeedingpractices.Foodinsecurityhasbeenshowntobenegativelyassociatedwithbothinitiationanddurationofbreastfeeding(115-116),withsomestudiesreportingastrongnegativeassociationbetweenFIandEBF(66,70).Theconsequencesforchildnutritionalstatusstemfromthefactthatthe1000daysbetweenconceptionandachild’ssecondbirthdayisawindowofsupremeopportunityforchildhealthpromotion.Indeed,EBFuptosixmonthsandadequatecomplementaryfeedinguptotwoyearsofageensuresnormalchildgrowth(117-118).Furthermore,FImaybelinkedtochildundernutritionthroughcaretakermentalhealth(29,119).Asastressor,FImaycontributetounfavourableparentingpractices(81,120),onemanifestationofwhichisanegativeeffectonbreast-feeding(121).Casey,Goolsby,Berkowitzetal.(122)havereportedmaternal
![Page 19: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
10
depressiontohavenegativeeffectsonearlychildhoodgrowth,particularlyheight-for-age,viaunresponsiveparenting.FIisalsoassociatedwithanaemiainwomen(61-62),andsomestudiessuggestedthatirondeficiency(ID)maybeariskfactorformaternaldepressivesymptoms(123),whichinturnmayaffectchildhealthstatus(122).Aless-studiedpathwaybywhichFIcanaffectmaternalstresslevel,andconsequentlychildhealth,isthroughsubstanceuse(124).FIcouldalsoleadtocompromisedimmunesystemfunctions,puttingachildintowhatisreferredtoasaninfection–malnutritioncycle(110).Foodinsecurityisassociatedwithinadequatefoodintake,whichcanleadtoimmunodeficiencyincreasingsusceptibilitytoinfectionandthusresultinginpoornutritionaloutcomes(109,125).Theseadverseconsequencesareexacerbatedbypoorsanitaryconditions.Additionally,whennutritionissuboptimal,ittakesachildlongertorecoverfromanillness,andtherepetitionofthiscyclecanworsenoverallhealth.Forexample,Pérez-Escamillaetal.(126)foundHFItobeassociatedwithmalariainruralHaiti.Malaria,inturn,hasbeenreportedasariskfactorforstuntingandwastingamongyoungchildreninarecentcohortstudyinEthiopia(127).
Food insecurity to anaemia FIcanleadtoanaemiathroughinadequateintakeofmicronutrients(128-129).Poormicronutrientintakeinfood-insecurehouseholdscanbearesultofunderconsumptionoffood,oroverconsumptionofenergy-densebutnutrient-poordietsthatmaybelesscostly(130-131),ashealthyfoodisoftenmoreexpensive(132).Fischeretal.(63)hypothesizethatHFImayleadtoanaemiaamongadultwomenfromMexicothroughthreediet-relatedpathways:first,alackofadequateconsumptionofiron;second,throughadietlackingsufficientconsumptionofmicronutrientsthatfacilitateironabsorptionandutilization(suchasvitaminC);andthird,byconsumingfoodsrichinphyticacidthatmaydecreasetheabsorptionofiron,henceincreasingtheriskofanaemia.
Food insecurity to exclusive breastfeeding TheliteraturealsoidentifiespathwaysbywhichFImayundermineamother’sabilitytoadoptEBFpractices.Foodinsecuritycanmotivatematernalemploymentoutsideofthehome,andthereisstrongevidenceofanegativeimpactofmaternalworkonbreastfeedingpracticesinbothHICsandLIC/LMICs(133-134).Foodinsecuritymayalsoimpactmaternalself-efficacy,whichinturnmayadverselyaffectinitiationanddurationofEBF(135).HFIhasbeenassociatedwithhigherratesofmaternaldepressionandstressinlowincomesettingssuchasEthiopia(136)aswellasinhighincomesettingssuchastheUnitedStatesofAmerica(137),whichinturnisasignificantpredictorofreducedbreastfeedingself-efficacy,exclusivityanddurationofbreastfeeding(138-139).Additionally,womeninfood-insecurehouseholdsaremorelikelytoexperiencediabetesmellitus,aconditionthathasbeenfoundtoaffectbreastfeedinginitiationand
![Page 20: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
11
durationnegatively(140-141).Psychologicalandphysiologicalstressassociatedwithseverefoodinsecuritymayaffectsubsequentmilkoutput(142-143).ResearchersarguethatinsituationswhereFIcausesseverematernalmalnutrition,physiologicalmechanismsmayalterbreastmilkoutputortheconcentrationofcertainfatsandmicronutrients(144-145).Ontheotherhand,foodinsecuritymayalsoincreasethepracticeofEBFbylimitingeconomicaccesstoalternativeinfantfoods,aslongasattitudestoEBFarepositive(146).
Food insecurity to low birth weight Nutritionalqualityofthediet,intermsofmicronutrients,mightbethekeynutritionalpathwayfromFItobirthoutcome.Asystematicreviewof45articlesshowedthatpreconceptionandpericonceptionintakeofvitaminandmineralsupplementsbythemotherwasassociatedwithareducedriskofpretermdeliveriesandhavingaLBWbaby(147).Thekeynon-nutritionalpathwaylinkingFIandbirthweightofchildrenismaternalmentalhealth,includingdepressivesymptomsandanxiety(59).Asstatedbefore,FIhasbeenassociatedwithdepressionandanxietyamongmothers(122,141),andpregnantwomenexperiencingdepressivesymptomsareatriskfordysfunctionalplacentationandintrauterinegrowthrestriction,whichaffectbirthoutcomessuchaspretermbirth(148-149).
Food insecurity to overweight in children and obesity in adults ThemechanismslinkingFIandobesity/overweightarerelativelywellunderstood,andafewtheoreticalframeworkshavebeenofferedintheliteraturetoexplainthisassociation.Nettleetal.(6)proposetheinsurancehypothesis,whichclaimsthatindividualsstoremorefatwhentheyreceivecuesthataccesstofoodisuncertain.Oneextensionofthishypothesisistodevelopmentalinfluencesonobesity:experiencesinearlylife,suchaspoornutritionin-utero(150),childhoodexposuretofoodscarcity(151),orpsychosocialstressingeneral(152-153)canpredisposeindividualstomaintaininghigherlevelsofbodyfat,notjustaschildren,butsubsequentlyasadults.Dhurandhar(154)proposestheResourceScarcityHypothesiswhicharguesthatrandomlyprimingindividualstocuesthatimplyresource-scarcitycausesthemtobemorelikelytochooseandconsumehigh-caloriefooditems(155),specificallyinlowsocio-economicstatusindividuals.Thehypothesisisthatpositiveenergybalancearisesaslowsocial-economicstatusisassociatedwithchronicallyhigherenergyintake(vialowincomeandsocialstress),lowrestingmetabolicrateandlowactivityenergyexpenditure.Lowsocio-economicstatusindividualsmaybemoresusceptibletotheperceptionoflowfoodsecurity(156).
FoodassistanceprogramsmaymoderatetheassociationbetweenHFIandchildoverweightstatus(157)tosomeextent.However,binge-eatinghabitswhenfoodisplentiful,arisefromtheepisodicnatureofFIandcanleadtoobesity(158-159),
![Page 21: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
12
andsuchcyclicalfoodrestrictionsleadtoquickerweightgainwhenrefeeding(160).Monthlyfoodassistancebenefits,forexample,canbeassociatedwitha‘feast–famine’cycle(158)iftheyarenotadequatetoguaranteesufficientfooduntiltheendofthemonth.Thiscouldpotentiallycontributetoobesityinchildren.Inleanperiods,parentsmayrestricttreats,therebyincreasingchilddemandandintakeofthesefoodswhenhouseholdslaterhavemoremoneytospend(54).Motbainoretal.(51)offersuchanexplanationofcyclicalfoodrestrictionfortheFI–BMIlinkinthelow-incomesettingofEthiopiawithrespecttolean/plentyseasonsinagriculture.
Food-insecureindividualsmayalsobecomeoverweightbyconsumingalow-qualitydiet.Foodinsecurityisassociatedwithconsumptionofcheapandenergy-densefood(foodshighinaddedsugarandfat),overconsumptionofwhichmaycauseweightgain(132,161–162).Womenfromfood-insecurehouseholdsinparticularmayrelyonlow-cost,highlyprocessed,high-caloriefoodstocopewithalimitedhouseholdbudget(132).HFImayresultinreducedmicronutrientintakeamongwomenofchild-bearingage(163-164),decreasedfruitandvegetableconsumption,andasignificantincreaseindisorderedeatingpatterns(164).Additionally,duetotheoccurrenceoffeast–faminetypesofepisodicfoodinsecurity,HFImaycausefluctuationsineatinghabits.Suchfluctuationsmaycausemetabolicalterations,sothatevenwithouteatingmorecalories,itispossibletoincreaseweight(165).Finally,childhoodstunting,whichisapotentialoutcomeoffoodinsecurity,canbeariskfactorforweightgaininlaterlife(166).EarlylifeexposuretoHFImayalsoresultinfoodhordingandthussetlong-termtrajectoriesofweightgain(132,167).Acculturation,aprocessofsocio-culturalandbehaviouralchangethatstemsfromtheblendingofcultures,maymodifytherelationshipbetweenFIandBMI(168).Someofthemostnoticeablegroup-leveleffectsofacculturationincludechangesinfood,clothing,andlanguage.ArecentanalysisofLatinochildrenintheUnitedStatesofAmericademonstratedthat,amongchildrenoffamilieswithloweracculturation,FIwasassociatedwithlowerBMI(86).WhileamongurbanLatinowomenwithhigheracculturationFIwaspositivelyassociatedwithobesity,amongwomenwithloweracculturationtherewasnoassociationbetweenFIandobesity(169).Loweracculturationinthiscontextmaybeassociatedwithconsumptionofahealthierdietclosertothatofthecountryoforigin,meaningonecontainingmorebeansandfruit(170).FIandoverweightinchildrenmaybelinkedthroughparentingandinfantfeedingpractices(81).Adultsinfood-insecurehouseholdsaresignificantlymorelikelytoexhibitlesspositiveparentingthanotheradults(3,124).2Inappropriatefeedingpracticessuchasnon-exclusivebreast-feedinganduntimelyintroductionof
2UnfavourableparentingpracticesasmediatorsoftheFI–malnutritionlinkcaninfluencebothundernutritionindicatorsandobesity.
![Page 22: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
13
complementaryfeedingmayeventuallyleadtochildhoodobesity(171).Furthermore,FIisrelatedtomorerestrictiveandpressuringmaternalfeedingstylescomparedwithfood-securemothers(69),ariskfactorforcurrentandfutureweightgain.Bydecreasingtheabilityofchildrentoself-regulateeatingbehaviours,controllingfeedingpracticescanposeariskforchildhoodobesity(172).HFImayalsoleadtochildoverweightbyaffectingthedietoffood-insecuremothers.Poordietqualityinpregnancyposesariskforgestationalweightgain(173),whichinturnmayresultinfutureweightgaininthechild(174).Themother–childobesitycyclecouldthuspersist(175).Thekeynon-nutritionalpathwayfromFItooverweightandobesityispoormentalhealth.FIhasbeenfoundtobeassociatedwithpoormentalhealthstatusindependentofotherindicatorsoflowsocio-economicstatus,inbothresource-rich(176)andresource-poor(177)settings.Specifically,ithasbeenassociatedwithanxiety(136),depression(176),andstress(178).Stressbroughtonbyfoodinsecuritymaycausenon-homeostaticeatingandmayleadtotheselectionof“comfort”foods,orhighlypalatablefoodsthatarerichinfat,sugar,andsodium(179-180)andhavebeenfoundtophysiologicallyreducestress(181).Furthermore,inthepresenceofmarginalfoodinsecurity,womenwhostrugglewithweightanddietingissuesmaybeatriskforexcessiveweightgain.Marginalfoodinsecurityanddietaryrestraintmightaffectweightthroughthecyclicalfoodrestrictionpatterns,the“yo–yo”typediet(182)ordietingfollowedbyovereating,thatcouldleadtoweightgain(173).Finally,anadditionalpathwaythatrequiresfurtherattentioninvolvestheroleofphysicalinactivity(24).
EXPLAINING THE LACK OF ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND MALNUTRITION SeveralstudiesfoundnoevidenceofanassociationbetweenFIandmalnutritioninchildrenoradults,indicatingthatwhilefoodsecuritymaybeanecessaryconditionforgoodnutritionoutcomes,itisinsufficientonitsown.Onekeyexplanationforthislackofassociationmightberelatedtoconceptualconcerns.EBFSScaptureshort-termfoodinsecurity,whilemalnutritionindicatorssuchasstuntingrepresentlong-termdeprivation.Moreover,EBFSSmeasureaccesstofoodasopposedtofoodutilization,whichdirectlyinfluencesnutritionalstatus.Availabilityandaccesstofooddonotensurefoodsecurity,asproperabsorptionoffoodbythebodyisalsonecessarytobefoodsecure(183).Factorssuchasnutritionknowledgeandpractices,andaccesstoqualityhealthcare,cleanwaterandsanitationarecrucialtoensuregoodnutritioninthiscontext(184-186).Second,aconglomerationofsocial,economicandculturalfactorsotherthanFIinfluencethenutritionofindividuals.Forexample,household-levelpoverty(187),maternalnutritionalstatus(10,188),intrahouseholdallocationofresources(189-
![Page 23: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
14
190),women’sstatus(191-192),dietqualityandfoodchoice(193-194),foodenvironment(195)andimprovedaccesstofullservicedsupermarkets(196)aresomeofthefactorsinfluencingnutritionaloutcomesofchildrenandadults.Theassociationbetweensupermarketaccessandobesityisagrowingareaofresearch(197-198).Homehealthcare,foodpreparation,andtheprovisionofaresponsiveandstimulatingenvironmenttoachildareotherfactorsconfoundingtheinfluenceoffoodaccessonthenutritionalstatusofchildren.Eveninpoorcommunitieswithlimitedfoodaccess,childrenmightgrownormallybecauseofpositivefamilyandcaregiverbehaviours(199-200).Mothers’knowledgeofappropriateinfantandyoungchildfeedingpracticesisalsoimportant(201).Finally,afactorexplainingthelackofassociationbetweenFIandmalnutritionindicatorscouldbemethodological(discussedindetailinthenextsection).Duetomethodologicalissues,evenstudieswhichcontrolappropriatelyforthekeypredictorsofmalnutritionmayfindnoassociation.Itisimportanttokeepinmindthatthesamesetofunobservedfactorscaninfluencebothfoodinsecurityandmalnutrition(5).Giventhatresearchersmostlyuseobserveddataratherthanexperimentaldatatoconducttheseanalyses,suchunobservablefactorsareoftennotcontrolledfor,resultinginomittedvariablebias.Consequently,establishingacausalassociationbetweenFIandmalnutritionremainsachallenge.
HOW TO RECONCILE THE CONTRADICTORY EVIDENCE FROM VARIOUS STUDIES EXAMINING THE FOOD INSECURITY–MALNUTRITION LINK TheliteraturereviewrevealsthatthenatureandextentoftheassociationbetweenFIandindicatorsofmalnutritiondependsconsiderablyonthecontextandmethodology.First,resultsvarybyincomelevelofthecountry.Forchildren,anyassociationbetweenFIandstuntingisnotedmostlyinLMIC/UMICsettings,whilethelimitedassociationbetweenFIandoverweight(mostlyforgirls)ismorepredominantinHICs.ItispossiblethatLMICsorUMICssuchasIndiaorBrazil,respectively,areinastageofnutritiontransitionwhereratesofchildundernutritionhavenotyetbeenovertakenbyoverweightorobesityinyoungchildren.“Occurrenceofashiftfromunder-nutritiontoobesitytendstofollowapatternthatusuallyoccursfirstinadults,followedbyadolescents,andonlylaterintimebychildren”(77)(p.6).Arecentmeta-analysis(6)showedthatfoodinsecuritypredictshighbodyweightonlyinHICs;inLMICstheaverageassociationiszero.Inalow-incomesetting,FIislesslikelytoresultinoverweightchildrenbecauseeventhecheapestenergy-densefoodmaynotprovidesufficientenergytocauseexcessweightgain(53)ortoallowthebuild-upoffatreservesbeforethenextperiodofscarcitystrikes(6).
![Page 24: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
15
AgemayinteractwithFItoproducevariedoutcomesintermsofnutritionalindicators.RegardingtheFI–stuntinglink,theproportionofstudiesreportingpositiveassociationsismuchlargerforunder-fivechildrencomparedtoschool-agedchildren.Incontrast,FIisfoundtohavenoassociationwithwastingforunder-fivechildreninmostofthestudies.AsfortheFI–obesity/overweightlinkinchildren,alargerfractionofzeroassociationisreportedforunder-fivechildrenasopposedtoschool-agechildren.Theweight–heightrelationshipmayberelevantintermsofsheddinglightonthedifferentialoutcomesonstunting–wastinginunder-fivechildrenwithrespecttoFI(202).Studieshavedemonstratedthatlineargrowthfaltersthroughoutthefirst2–3yearsoflifeinmanydevelopingcountries,whereasweightfor-heighttendstofalterduringamorelimitedagewindowinthefirstyearoflife,afterwhichiteitherstabilizesorincreases(203).Asfortheobesity–FIlink,oneexplanationfortheage-wisevariationsfollowfromsacrificetheory(21),wherebyyoungerchildrenaremoreprotectedbyparentsintimesofscarcefoodaccess.Additionally,studiesonchildrengenerallymeasurefoodinsecuritythroughparentalreports(204),potentiallyweakeningtheabilitytodiscoverarelationship.Finally,simpleBMI-typemeasuresmaybeparticularlyproblematicforassessingadiposityingrowingchildren(205).Resultsalsovarybygender:aconsensusofthereviewsonfoodinsecurityandbodyweightmeasures(21-24)isthatthelimitedavailableevidenceonthepresenceofanyassociationbetweenFIandhighbodyweightinchildrenisnotedforoldergirls(>5years)only.Additionally,thisrelationshipismostpronouncedamongwomeninHICsandalmostabsentinmen.ForadultwomeninHICs,theoddsofhighbodyweightareaboutfiftypercenthigherforfood-insecureindividualscomparedtofood-secureones(6).Thisoutcomemaywellrelatetothewiderfindingthatlowsocio-economicstatusisamoreconsistentpredictorofobesityinwomenthaninmen(206).Resultsmayalsovarybystudydesign–cross-sectionalversuslongitudinal.Forexample,inthisreview,themajorityofstudiesontheFI–obesityassociationarecrosssectional,eightypercentofwhichdonotreportanyassociationbetweenFIandobesityamongchildren/adults.RegardingtheFI–undernutritionlink,themajorityofstudiesarecrosssectional.Giventhelimitednumberoflongitudinalstudies,itwouldbeworthexploringwhatlongitudinaldatarevealsbyconductingmoresuchstudies.Inthecurrentreview,theonlythreelongitudinalstudiesontheFI–stuntinglinkprovidedmixedevidence:negativeassociation(47);positiveassociation(29);andmixedresults(48).StudiesuseavarietyofEBFSStomeasureFI–fromasinglefoodadequacyquestiontofullsurveymodulessuchasUSHFSSM,HFIAS,ELCSA,oradaptedlocalversionsofUSHFSSM/HFIASandshorterscalessuchastheHHS.Whilemostofthesemeasureshavebeenvalidatedandarewidelyused,locallyadaptedversionsaresometimesnotsubjectedtofullpsychometrictesting.Hence,theirsuitabilityinestimatingtheimpactofFIonnutritionalstatusmaybequestionable.Useof
![Page 25: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
16
differentindicatorsmightalsomakecomparabilityofestimatesacrossdifferentstudiesachallengingtask.Anotherinconsistencyisnotedwithrespecttothelevelatwhichfoodinsecurityismeasured–individualorhousehold.Alimitednumberofstudiesusefoodsecuritymeasuresatindividualorchildlevel(122,207-208).Acrucialaspectregardingfoodsecuritymeasurementisthecategorizationschemeusedfortheexperience-basedfoodsecurityindicator,whetherexperientialfoodinsecurityismeasuredasacontinuous,dichotomous,ormultinomialvariable.Thiscategorizationislikelytoaffectresults.Forexample,severalstudies(122,158,160)reportthatitwasthemilderbutnotthemostseverelevelsoffoodinsecuritywhereincreasedoddsofobesitywerefound.Gubertetal.(30)reportedchildstuntingtobeassociatedwithseverefoodinsecuritybutnotwithmild/moderatefoodinsecurity.Suchoutcomesindicatethatdichotomizationoftheexperientialfoodinsecuritytojusttwocategoriesmightconcealmeaningfulvariationsinresults.Hownutritionalstatusismeasured–self-reportedvsmeasured,continuousvsdichotomous–mayalsoberelevanttoexplainingvariationsinoutcomesonFI–malnutritionlink.Forexample,Nettleetal.(6)foundsignificantlystrongerassociationsbetweenFIandweightstatuswhentheoutcomevariablewasobesity(BMI≥30)thanwhentheoutcomewasoverweight(BMI≥25).However,theyfoundnosignificantdifferencesinthestrengthoftheassociationaccordingtowhichpredictor(FImeasure)wasused.AccordingtoLyons,ParkandNelson(209),associationsbetweenobesityandFIaremorepronouncedwhenself-reporteddataonheightandweightareusedthanwhenmeasuredheightandweightdataareused.Finally,howtherelationshipbetweenFIandmalnutritionisempiricallymodelledalsoservestoreconcilethecontradictoryevidencetoaconsiderableextent.Empiricalconcernsthatneedtobeaddressedrelatetoproblemssuchasomittedvariablebias,selectionbiasorsimultaneitybias.Thesamesetofunobservedfactorsmayaffectboththedependentvariable(malnutrition)andtheexplanatoryvariable(foodinsecurity).Forexample,‘ability’(atypicalexampleofunobservedfactorinlaboureconomics)(210)ofanindividualcansimultaneouslyaffecthis/herfoodsecuritystatusandnutritionalstatusbyaffectingproductivity.Unlesstheresearcherisabletocontrolfortheseunobservedfactors,acorrelationbetweenobservedandunobservedfactorscanbiastheestimatedeffectofFIonmalnutrition.Additionally,sample“selection”problemsarisewhenfactorsunobservedtotheresearchersdriveselectionofhouseholdstofood-secureorfood-insecurestatus(5).Furthermore,thereisclassificationerrorinviewofthefactthattruefoodinsecuritystatusisnotobserved.Theremayalsobesimultaneitybiasintherelationship,aspotentiallytheFI–malnutritionlinkisbi-directional.JustasFIcanpredictmalnutrition,thelattercanalsobeariskfactorforFIbyaffectinglong-termproductivityofindividualsandfurtherimpoverishingthem(10).Theseconcernscreateidentificationproblemsandconsequently,
![Page 26: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
17
estimatingcausalimpactofFIonnutritionaloutcomesbecomeschallenging.Addressingtheseconcernsismoreproblematicincross-sectionaldata,whilelongitudinaldatamitigatethemtoaconsiderableextentbytakingcareofunobservedfactorswhicharetime-invariant.
GAPS IN THE LITERATURE Considerablegapsinknowledgeexistintheliteratureexaminingtheassociationoffoodinsecurityandthenutritionalstatusofchildrenandadults.TheliteraturehasfocusedonexaminingthecorrelationbetweenFIandarangeofnutritionaloutcomesratherthanattemptingtoestablishcausalityintherelationship(5).Improvedanalyticalmethodssuchasempiricalmodels,whichcanaddressseveralbiasesintherelationship,arewarranted.Significantgapsalsoexistinexploringthetemporaldimensionoffoodinsecurity(173).Thehealthconsequencesoftemporaryandpersistentfoodinsecuritymightnotbethesame(211).Forexample,itispossiblethatthosewhoexperiencepersistentfoodinsecurityhavedevelopedcopingstrategiestoaddressthesituation.Asfaraschildrenareconcerned,howthemovementinandoutoffoodinsecuritycaninfluencechildren’snutritionalanddevelopmentaloutcomesremainsanimportantquestion.Pérez-EscamillaandPinheirodeToledoVianna(212)observedthatakeygapintheliteratureisthatstudieshavenotbeendesignedtofindoutifthereisacriticalperiodofinitialexposuretoHFIintermsofchilddevelopmentoutcomes.ItisthereforeimportanttobetterunderstandthepathwaysfromFItopoornutritionaloutcomes.Fewstudieshaveinvestigatedthesemediatingfactors.Forexample,howdietarydiversitymediatestherelationshipbetweenHFIandnutritionaloutcomesisanimportantquestionandthelimitedavailableevidenceisinconclusive(42).Theory-baseddesignsandimprovedanalyticalframeworksarerequiredtoinvestigatehowthemediatorswork(175).AccordingtoJacknowitzandMorrissey(213),pathwayscanvaryaccordingtowhoisexperiencingtheinsecurityinthehousehold(adultorchild),andwithregardstochildfoodinsecurity,whetherthechildisdirectlyaffectedbyfoodinsecurityorindirectlyaffectedthroughtheexperienceofadultsorotherchildrenintheirhousehold.Pathwayswillalsovaryaccordingtotheoutcomeofinterestsuchasundernutritionoroverweightandobesity.Hugedatagapsexistintheliteratureonthistopic.Itisimpossibletoanswertheaboveconcernswithoutaccesstolongitudinaldata.DatasetsthatfollowchildrenfrombirtharenecessaryinordertoobservetheeffectofFIwithinalifecourseframework.Longitudinalstudiescanalsoimproveourunderstandingofthetemporalityinfoodinsecurity,suchastheeffectsofchronicandtransientfoodinsecurity.
![Page 27: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
18
Itisalsoimportanttohavelarge-scalemicrodatasetstoavoidproblemsoflowstatisticalpowerforquantitativeanalysis(214).Moreover,dataqualityandsurveydesignareoftenpoor.Datacollectionprocessesmustadheretomeasurementprotocolsandtheexperience-basedfoodsecuritymeasureandtheanalyticprotocolsmustbestandardized(suchastheFIES)toallowcross-culturalcomparabilityofstudyresults.Finally,itisrecommendedthatinordertounderstandthefoodinsecurity–malnutritionlinkamongchildren,furtherresearchbeundertakenregardinghowtomeasurefoodinsecurityatthechildlevel.TheAmericanDieteticAssociation,inanotepublishedin2003,concludedthat‘householdfoodinsecuritydoesnotappeartobeassociatedwithoverweightamongchildren,afindingthatmaybedue,inpart,tothefactthatacomprehensivemeasureofchildfoodinsecuritywasnotusedinmoststudies’(citedinEisenmannetal.(24).ArecentreviewonFI–obesitylinkintheUnitedStatesofAmerica(22)findsonlysevenstudies(outoftwenty-five)reviewingHFIandweightstatusamongchildrenandadolescents,usechild-specificmeasuresoffoodinsecurity.
![Page 28: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
19
Conclusion Thisliteraturereviewrevealsmixedevidenceontheassociationbetweentheexperienceoffoodinsecurity(constrainedaccesstoadequatefood)andmalnutritionindicators.Resultsvarybyincome,settings,age,genderandstudydesign,choiceofindicatorsandempiricalmodellingtechniques.Duetomethodologicaldifferences,validcomparisonofresultsisachallengingtask,thereforeaddressingmethodologicaldiscrepanciesisessentialtobetterunderstandthisrelationship.Highqualitylongitudinaldataisrequiredtobetterunderstandthetruenatureoftherelationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityandmalnutrition.Furtherresearchisalsonecessarytodeterminethemediatorsofexperientialfoodinsecurityandnutritionalindicatorswithaviewtoinformingpolicy.Ingeneral,foodinsecurityisidentifiedasapredictorofundernutritionaswellasoverweightandobesity.Thepolicyimplicationofthisresultisthattacklingfoodinsecurityshouldsimultaneouslyallowforaddressingdifferentnutritionalchallenges,especiallythemultipleburdenofnutrition.However,malnutritionisnotmerelyafoodprobleminthathealthisshapedbythebroadersocietalandeconomiccontextinwhichtheindividualresides(12).Therefore,effortstopromotefoodsecurityalonemaynotbeadequateincombatingmalnutrition.Revertingtotheconceptualbioecologicalframeworkdescribedattheoutset,malnutritionislikelytobedrivenbyacomplexarrayofriskfactorsinterplayingattheindividual,communityandsocietallevel.Therefore,cost-effectivemultisectoralinterventionsareneeded.Forexample,subsidizinghealthyfood,taxingsugaryfood,providingincentivestoproductionoftraditionalnutrition-richstaples,influencingfoodchoicethroughnutritionlabellingandnutritioneducation,andprovidinghealthymealsatschoolmightbesomepotentialsolutions.Overall,thesesuggestionsalsounderscoretheimportanceofanutrition-sensitivesupplychain.Itisimportanttoidentifythebottleneckateachpointofthesupplychainsothattailoredactionscanbeimplementedtotargeteachdistinctproblem.Encouragingprogramstopromotephysicalactivityisalsoakeypotentialintervention.Lastbutnottheleast,sustainableandinclusiveeconomicgrowth,whichaimstoreduceincome,educational,andgenderinequalityshouldbethekeypolicygoalinasuccessfulfightagainstfoodinsecurity,hungerandmalnutrition.
![Page 29: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
20
Tables TABLE 1. STUDIES ON THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND CHILDHOOD STUNTING*
Country Author(year) Studypopulation
andsamplesize
Methods Resultsontheassociationbetween
foodinsecurityandchildhoodstunting
orlowerhaz
BANGLADESH
(28-29)Hasanetal.(2013)
Children<5yofage(N=5904).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBangladeshDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheHFIAS.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theoddsofbeingstuntedweresignificantlyhigherforchildreninfood-insecureHHs.
Sahaetal.(2009)
Children0to24monthsofage(N=1343).Matlabdistrict.
Longitudinalstudy:childrenwerefollowedfrombirthto24monthsofage;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonthefoodsecuritycomponentquestionnaireoftheMINIMatstudy(scaledevelopedspecificallyforBangladesh).
Positiveassociation.Theproportionofstuntedchildrenwassignificantlyhigheramongfood-insecureHHscomparedtofood-secureHHs.HouseholdfoodsecuritywaspositivelyassociatedwithhighergaininHAZ.
BRAZIL
(2,30,32,55)Gubertetal.(2016)
Children<5yofage(N=4064).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheBrazilianFoodInsecuritySecurityScale(EBIA).
Positiveassociationbetweenseverefoodinsecurityandstunting.
Lopesetal.(2013)
12–18yoldadolescents(N=523).Low-incomeareaofthemunicipalityofDuquedeCaxias,RiodeJaneiro.
Cross-sectionalstudy;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
Noassociation.
![Page 30: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
21
Reis(2012) Children<5yofage(N=4860).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
PositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowerHAZ.
Santosetal.(2013)
Children<5yofage(N=4817).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
PositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowerHAZ.
CAMBODIA
(50)McDonaldetal.(2015)
Children<5yofage(N=900HHs).FourruraldistrictsofPreyVengprovince.
Cross-sectionalstudy;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS.
Noassociation.
COLOMBIA
(34,53)Hackettetal.(2009)
PreschoolchildrenreceivingMANAfoodsupplements(N=2784low-incomeHHs).Randomsamplerepresentativeofthe200000MANAparticipants.DepartmentofAntioquia.
Cross-sectionalstudy;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonthe12-itemColombianHouseholdFoodSecurityScale.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theriskforchildstuntingincreasedinadose-responsewayasfoodinsecuritybecamemoresevere.
Isanakaetal.(2007)
Children5to12yofage(N=2526).PrimarypublicschoolsinBogotá.
Cross-sectionalstudyofschool-agechildren’shealthandnutritionalstatus;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonamodifiedversionoftheSpanish-languageUSHFSSM(16version)plus5child-specificquestionsusedtomeasurechildfoodsecurity.
Noassociation.
![Page 31: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
22
ETHIOPIA
(33,35,47,51)Belachewetal.(2013)
Adolescents13to17yofage(N=1431).Jimmazone,SouthwestEthiopia.
LongitudinalJimmaLongitudinalFamilySurveyofYouth(JLFSY)study;participantswereinterviewedinthreesurveyroundsoneyearapart;foodinsecurityestimatebasedon4ofthe18questionsinUSHFSSMandthecopingstrategiesindex.
Mixed.Negativeassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlineargrowthinfemaleadolescentsbutnotinmaleadolescents.Food-insecuregirlswereshorterbynearly1cm(0.87cm)comparedwithsecuregirlsatbaselineandcatchupduringfollowupperiodwasinadequate.Themeanheightoffood-insecuremaleswasnotsignificantlydifferentfromfood-securemalesbothatbaselineandoverthefollowupperiod.
Beteboetal.(2017)
Children6monthsto<5yofage(N=508).EastBadawachodistrict,SouthEthiopia.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theoddsofbeingstuntedforchildreninfood-insecureHHswere6.7timesthatofchildreninfood-secureHHs.
Jemaletal.(2016)
Children6monthsto<5yofage(N=284)Gambellatown.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedsurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theoddsofbeingstuntedweresignificantlyhigherforchildreninsevereandmoderatelyfood-insecureHHs.
Motbainoretal.(2015)
Children<5yofage(N=4110HHs).EastandWestGojjamZonesofAmharaRegion.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Noassociation.
GHANA(52) Saakaetal.(2013)
Children6to36monthsold(N=337).TamaleMetropolisofNorthernGhana.
Cross-sectionalstudy,primarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonthe30-dayHFIAS.
Noassociation.
![Page 32: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
23
GUATEMALA
(25)Chaparro(2012)
Children<5yofage(N=10100nationallyand2477intheWesternHighlandsregion).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingdatafromtheNationalmaternal–infanthealthsurvey(ENSMI);foodinsecurityestimatebasedonfivequestionsadaptedfromtheUSHFSSM.
Mixed.Positiveassociationbetweenseverefoodinsecurityandstuntingatnationallevel,butnosignificantassociationintheWesternHighlandsregion.
HONDURAS
(44)Grayetal.(2006)
School-agechildren(N=75).FivevillageslocatedontheEastbankofLagodeYojoaintheDepartmentofCortesinruralCentralHonduras.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonanadaptationoftheUSHSSM(8items).
Positive(weak)associationbetweenseverefoodinsecurityandstunting.
IRAN(ISLAMIC
REPUBLICOF)
(43)
Shahrakietal.(2016)
Childrenaged7–11y(N=610).SistanandBaluchestanProvincesinSouthEasternIran(IslamicRepublicof).
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonthe18-itemUSHFSSM.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theoddsofbeingstuntedforchildreninseverelyfood-insecureHHswere10.1timesthatofchildreninfood-secureHHs.
MALAYSIA
(45)AliNaseretal.(2014)
Children2–12yofage(N=223).BachokdistrictinKelantan,ruralareaofNorthEastPeninsularMalaysia.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheRadimer/Cornellhungerandfoodsecurityscale.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Childreninfood-insecureHHswerethreetimesmorelikelytobestuntedthanchildreninthefood-secureHHs.
![Page 33: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
24
MEXICO
(36-37)Shamah-Levyetal.(2014)
Children<5yofage(Nnotprovided).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingMexicanNationalHealthandNutritionSurvey(ENSANUT)2012;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheELCSA.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theoddsofbeingstuntedforchildreninmoderatelyandseverelyfood-insecureHHswere1.37and1.79,respectively,timesthatofchildrenlivinginfood-secureHHs.
Shamah-Levyetal.(2017)
Preschoolchildren(N=5087)andschoolchildren(N=7181).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingMexicanNationalHealthandNutritionSurvey(ENSANUT)2012;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheELCSA.
Theproportionofstuntedchildrenwassignificantlyhigheramongseverelyandmoderatelyfood-insecureHHs(16.2%and16.8%,respectively)comparedtomildlyfood-insecureandfood-secureHHs(13.2%and10.7%,respectively).TheinteractionbetweenHFIandmaternalobesityhadasignificantimpactonstunting.
NEPAL
(38,41,49)Oseietal.(2010)
Children6to23monthsofage(N=368).KailaliDistrict.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingacommunity-basedprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonashort-adaptedversionoftheHFIAS(5questions).
Noassociation.
Singhetal.(2014)
Children<5yofage(N=2335).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingNepalDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS(7items).
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Theoddsofbeingstuntedforchildreninfood-insecureHHswere1.50timesthatofchildreninfood-secureHHs.
Sreeramareddyetal.(2015)
Children<5yofage(N=2591).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingNepalDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS(7items).
PositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowerHAZ.
NICARAGUA
(46)Schmeeretal.(2017)
Children3–11yofage(N=431HHs).León,Nicaragua.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatedbasedonELCSA.
PositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowerHAZ.
![Page 34: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
25
PAKISTAN(39) Baig-Ansarietal.(2006)
Children6to18months(N=399).SquattersettlementsofKarachi.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatedbasedonthe18-itemUSHFSSM.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstunting.Food-insecureHHswithhungerwerethreetimesmorelikelythanotherHHstohaveastuntedchild.
UNITEDSTATES
OFAMERICA
(54)
Kaiseretal.(2002)
Mexican–Americanchildren3to6yofage(N=211).California.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonRadimer/Cornellscale.
Noassociation.
BANGLADESH,
ETHIOPIA,VIET
NAM(42)
Alietal.(2013)
Children6monthsto<5yofage.Bangladesh(N=2356),Ethiopia(N=3422),VietNam(N=3075).
Cross-sectionalsurvey;foodinsecurityestimatedbasedontheHFIAS.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandstuntingacrossthethreecountries.Theoddsofbeingstuntedweresignificantlyhigherforchildreninseverelyfood-insecureHHsinBangladeshandEthiopia,andinmoderatelyfood-insecureHHsinVietNam.
BANGLADESH,
BRAZIL,INDIA,
NEPAL,
PAKISTAN,
PERU,SOUTH
AFRICA,AND
THEUNITED
REPUBLICOF
TANZANIA(40)
Psakietal.(2012)
Childrenaged2to5y(N=800total,100ineachofthe8countries).Urban,ruralandperi-urbanareas.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonHFIAS.
PositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowerHAZacrosscountries.
![Page 35: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
26
INDIA,PERU,
ETHIOPIA,VIET
NAM(48)
Humphriesetal.(2015)
Childrenaged1,5,and8y(threeroundsofdatacollection)invariouscountries.Ethiopia(N=1757),India(N=1825),Peru(N=1844),andVietNam(N=1828).
Longitudinalstudyfollowingthesamechildrenatages1,5and8y,usingaprimarysurvey;atage5y.foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonamodifiedversionoftheUSHFSSM,atage8y,theestimatewasbasedontheHFIAS.
Mixed.PositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowerHAZatage5y.However,theassociationattenuatedafteradjustingforotherhouseholdfactorsandanthropometryatage5yandremainedsignificantonlyforVietNam.FoodinsecuritywasnotsignificantlyassociatedwithHAZatage8y.
Notes.*Stuntingreferstoaheight-for-agezscore(HAZ)<-2
![Page 36: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
27
TABLE 2. STUDIES ON THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND CHILDHOOD WASTING*
Country Author(Year) Studypopulationandsamplesize Methods
Resultsontheassociation
betweenfoodinsecurityand
childhoodwasting
BANGLADESH(28) Hasanetal.(2013) Children<5yofage(N=5904).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBangladeshDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheHFIAS.
Positivesignificantassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandwasting.
BRAZIL(2,30) Gubertetal.(2016)
Children<5yofage(N=4064).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheBrazilianFoodInsecuritySecurityScale(EBIA).
Noassociation.
Reis(2012) Children<5yofage(N=4860).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonEBIA
Noassociation.
CAMBODIA(50) McDonaldetal.(2015)
Children<5yofage(N=900HHs).FourruraldistrictsofPreyVengprovince.
Cross-sectionalstudy;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS.
Noassociation.
ETHIOPIA(33,35,51,57)
Abdurahmanetal.(2015)
Children2to<5y.ofage(N=453children).HaromayaDistrict.
Crosssectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatedbasedonHFIAS.
Noassociation.
Beteboetal.(2017)
Children6monthsto<5yofage(N=508).EastBadawachodistrict,SouthEthiopia.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedsurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Noassociation.
![Page 37: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
28
Jemaletal.(2016) Children6monthsto<5yofage(N=284).Gambellatown.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedsurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Noassociation.
Motbainoretal.(2015)
Children<5yofage(N=4110HHs).EastandWestGojjamZonesofAmharaRegion.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingacommunity-basedprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Positivesignificantassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandwasting.
GHANA(52) Saakaetal.(2013) Children6to36monthsold(N=337).TamaleMetropolisofNorthernGhana.
Cross-sectionalstudy,primarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonthe30-dayHFIAS.
Noassociation.
MALAYSIA(45) AliNaseretal.(2014)
Children2–12yofage(N=223).BachokdistrictinKelantan,ruralareaofNorthEastPeninsularMalaysia.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheRadimer/Cornellhungerandfoodsecurityscale.
Noassociation.
NEPAL(38,41) Sreeramareddyetal.(2015)
Children<5y.ofage(N=2591).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingNepalDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatedbasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS(7items).
Noassociation.
Singhetal.(2014) Children<5y.ofage(N=2335).Nationallyrepresentativesurvey.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingNepalDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatedbasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS(7items).
Noassociation.
NIGERIA(56) Ajaoetal.(2010) Children<5y.ofage(N=423).lle-lleregioninSouthWesternNigeria.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonthe18-itemUSHFSSM.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandwasting.Theoddsofwastingforchildrenlivinginfood-insecureHHswere5.7timesthatofchildrenlivinginfood-secureHHs.
![Page 38: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
29
BANGLADESH,
ETHIOPIA,VIETNAM
(42)
Alietal.(2013) Children6monthsto<5yofage.Bangladesh(N=2356),Ethiopia(N=3422),VietNam(N=3075).
Cross-sectionalsurvey(baselinedata);foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheHFIAS.
Mixed.SignificantpositiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandwastinginBangladesh.NoassociationinEthiopiaandVietNam.
BANGLADESH,
BRAZIL,INDIA,NEPAL,
PAKISTAN,
PERU,SOUTHAFRICA
ANDUNITED
REPUBLICOF
TANZANIA(40)
Psakietal.(2012) Childrenaged2to5y(N=800total,100ineachofthe8countries).Urban,ruralandperi-urbanareas.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonHFIAS.
Noassociation.
Notes.*Wastingreferstoaweight-for-heightzscore(WHZ)<-2.
![Page 39: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
30
TABLE 3. STUDIES ON THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND LOW BIRTH WEIGHT
Country Author(Yer) Studypopulationandsamplesize MethodsResultsontheassociationbetweenfood
insecurityandlowbirthweight
BANGLADESH
(60)Chowdhuryetal.(2018)
Householdswithalivebirthbetween2006and2011(N=8753).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Crosssectionalsurvey:2011BangladeshDemographicandHealthSurvey(DHS);foodsecuritymeasuredbyfivequestionsaimedatcapturing“theavailabilityoffoodandaperson'saccesstoit.”
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandsmallsizeinfants.
UNITED
STATESOF
AMERICA
(58-59)
Bordersetal.(2007)
WomenreceivingwelfareinnineIllinoiscounties(N=1363).
IllinoisFamilyStudy,alongitudinalcohortstudy;foodsecuritymeasuredusingUSHFSSM.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowbirthweight.
Griloetal.(2015)
Womenandadolescents(aged14–21)whoattendedprenatalcareatoneofthe14participatingclinicalsitesinNewYorkCity(N=881).
Longitudinalstudy,primarysurvey;foodsecuritymeasuredusingasinglequestion:“Doyoueverrunoutofmoneyorfoodstampstobuyfood?”
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandlowbirthweight.
![Page 40: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
31
TABLE 4. STUDIES ON THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND ANAEMIA IN WOMEN
Country Author(Year) Studypopulationandsamplesize MethodsResultsontheassociationbetweenfoodinsecurity
andanaemiainwomenBANGLADESH(62) Ghoseetal.
(2016)Marriedwomenagedbetween13and40y(N=5666).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBangladeshDemographicandHealthSurvey(BDHS2011)data;foodsecuritymeasuredusingHFIAS.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandanaemia.Theoddsofbeinganaemicweresignificantlyhigherforwomeninfood-insecureHHs.
CAMBODIA(50) McDonaldetal.(2015)
Motherswithachildunderfiveyold(N=900HHswithsuchmothers).PreyVengprovince.
Crosssectionalstudyusingdatafromabaselinesurveyconductedbeforetheimplementationofaninterventionstudy;foodsecuritymeasuredusinganadaptedversionofHFIAS.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandanaemia.HFIincreasedtheoddsofmaternalanaemiainadose-responsemanner.
ECUADOR(61) Weigeletal.(2016)
AdultwomenlivinginHHswithchildreninlow-incomeneighbourhoodsinQuito,Ecuador(N=794).
Crosssectionalstudyusingprimarysurveydata;foodsecuritymeasuredusingtheSpanishversionofUSHFSSM.
Positiveassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandanaemia.Theoddsofbeinganaemicweresignificantlyhigherforwomeninfood-insecureHHs.
GUATEMALA(25) Chaparro(2012)
Females15–49ysofage(N=16819nationallyand3762intheWesternHighlandsregion).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingdatafromtheNational
maternal–infanthealthsurvey(ENSMI);foodinsecurityestimatebasedonfivequestionsadaptedfromtheUSHFSSM.
Usingnational-leveldata,HFIwasassociatedwithhaemoglobinconcentrationofwomenofreproductiveage.However,asignificantassociationwasnotreportedforWesternHighlands.
![Page 41: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
32
MEXICO(63-64) Fischeretal.(2014)
Womenofreproductiveage(12–49y)(N=16944).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingdatafromENSANUT2012;foodsecuritymeasuredusingELCSA.
TheassociationbetweenHFIandanaemiawasnotsignificantforadolescentwomen(12–20y),whereasinadultwomen(21–49y),theadjustedoddsofhavinganaemiawerehigheramongthoselivinginmildtoseverelyfood-insecureHHs,comparedtoadultwomenresidinginfood-secureHHs.
Jonesetal.(2017)
Non-pregnantfemaleadolescents(15–19ys)andnon-pregnantadultwomenofreproductiveage(20–49ys)(N=4,039non-pregnantfemaleadolescentsand10,760non-pregnantadultwomenofreproductiveage).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Crosssectionalstudyusingdatafromthe2012NationalHealthandNutritionSurveyofMexico;foodsecuritymeasuredusingELCSA.
Womenfrommildtomoderatelyfood-insecureHHshadgreateroddsofanaemia.SevereHFIwasnotassociatedwithanaemiaamonggirlsorwomen.NoassociationbetweenHFIandanaemia,obesity,ortheirco-occurrenceamongfemaleadolescents
UNITEDSTATESOF
AMERICA(65,173)Laraiaetal.(2010)
PregnantwomeninNorthCarolinawithincomes≤400%oftheincome/povertyratio(N=810).
LongitudinalstudyusingdatafromthePregnancy,InfectionandNutritionprospectivecohortstudy;foodsecuritymeasuredusingUSHFSSM
NosignificantassociationsbetweenHFIandanaemia.
Parketal.(2014)
Pregnantfemalesaged13to54y.Nationallyrepresentativesample.
PooledanalysisusingdatafromNationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey;foodsecuritymeasuredusingUSHFSSM
Mixedresults.TheoddsofID,classifiedbyferritinstatus,were2.90timeshigherforfood-insecurepregnantfemalescomparedwithfood-securepregnantfemales.OtherindicatorsofIDwerenotassociatedwithfoodsecuritystatus.
![Page 42: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
33
TABLE 5. STUDIES ON THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND EXCLUSIVE BREASTFEEDING
Country Author(Year) Studypopulationandsamplesize MethodsResultsontheassociationbetweenfood
insecurityandexclusivebreastfeeding
BANGLADESH
(70)Sahaetal.(2008) InfantswhowerebornbetweenMay
2002andDecember2003werefolloweduntilDecember2004andbeyond(N=1343).Matlabdistrict.
LongitudinalstudyusingdatafromtheMaternalandInfantNutritionInterventioninMatlab(MINIMat)study.Foodsecuritymeasuredusingscalebasedonelevenitems(scaledevelopedspecificallyforBangladesh).
NosignificantassociationbetweenHFIandEBFatanyage.
BRAZIL(68) GomesandGubert(2012)
Children<2yofage(N=1635).
CrosssectionalstudyusingdatafromBrazilianDHS.FoodsecuritymeasuredusingtheBrazilianFoodInsecurityScale(EBIA).
Noassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandbreastfeedinginthefirstyearoflifeorearlyintroductionoffoodsotherthanbreastmilk.
CANADA(66) Orretal.(2018) WomenwhohadcompletedtheMaternalExperiencesBreastfeedingModuleandtheHouseholdFoodSecuritySurveyModuleoftheCanadianCommunityHealthSurvey(2005–2014)andwhohadgivenbirthintheyearoforyearbeforetheirinterview(N=10450).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingpooleddatafromthe2005–2014CanadianCommunityHealthSurvey(CCHS).FoodsecuritymeasuredusingtheHouseholdFoodSecuritySurveyModuleoftheCCHS.
Negativeassociation.Motherscaringforinfantsinfood-insecureHHswerelessablethanfood-securewomentosustainexclusivebreastfeeding.Relativetowomenwithfoodsecurity,thosewithmarginal,moderateandseverefoodinsecurityhadsignificantlyloweroddsofexclusivebreastfeedingto4months,butonlywomenwithmoderatefoodinsecurityhadloweroddsofEBFto6months.
ETHIOPIA
(71)Yeneabat,BelachewandHaile(2014)
Mothersofinfants(N=592).NorthwestregionofEthiopia.
Community-basedcross-sectionalstudyusingbothquantitativeandqualitativemethods.Foodsecuritystatusassessedusingadaptedversionofquestionnairefrom2005EthiopianDemographicandHealthSurvey.
Noassociation.Inadjustedmultivariatemodels,cessationofEBFwasnotsignificantlyassociatedwithfoodinsecurity.
![Page 43: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
34
KENYA(67,135)
Machariaetal.(2018)
Childrenlessthan12monthsofageandtheirmothersagedbetween12and49y(N=1110).KorogochoandViwandani,Nairobi.
LongitudinalstudyusingprimarysurveydatacollectedonhouseholdfoodsecurityatbaselineandIYCFpracticespostpartum.FoodsecuritymeasuredusingHFIAS.
Negativeassociation.Infantslivinginfood-insecureHHsweresignificantlylesslikelytobeexclusivelybreastfedupto6monthsofagecomparedwithinfantsfromHHsthatwerefoodsecure.
Webb-Girardetal.(2012)
75HIV-affectedand75HIV-statusunknown,low-incomewomenwhowereeitherpregnantorwithachild≤24monthsandresidinginNakuru,Kenya(N=150).
Crosssectionalstudyusingmixedmethod–quantitativeandqualitativedatafromfocusgroupdiscussionsand9-itemHFIAS.
FoodinsecuritynegativelyaffectsattitudeandbelieftowardsEBF.TheexperienceoffoodinsecurityreducestheircapacitytoimplementEBFfor6months.
UGANDA(72) Youngetal.(2014)
180HIV-infectedpregnantandbreastfeeding(BF)womenreceivingcombinationantiretroviraltherapy.Tororo,Uganda.
LongitudinalcohortstudyusingdatafromthePregnantWomenandInfantStudy,aNationalInstituteofChildHealthandHumanDevelopment(PROMOTE)trial.FoodsecuritymeasuredusingtheHouseholdHungerScale
Mixedresults.NoassociationbetweenmoderateorsevereHHhungerandEBFat6months.However,amongthosewomenstillpracticingEBFat4months,thoseexperiencingmoderateorseverehouseholdhungerweresignificantlymorelikelytoceaseEBFbetween4and6months.
UNITED
STATESOF
AMERICA
(69)
Grossetal.(2012) English-orSpanishspeakingmothersatleast18-yoldwithasingletonfull-term(≥37weeksgestationalage)infantparticipatingintheSpecialSupplementalFoodProgramforWomen,Infants,andChildrenwithinfantsagedbetween2weeksand6months(N=201mother–infantpairs).Largeurbanmedicalcenter.
CrosssectionalstudyofWICparticipantsatalargeurbanmedicalcenter.2-itemfoodsecuritymoduleadaptedfromtheUSHFSSMcoremodule:‘worriedfoodwouldrunout’and‘lowcostfood.”Responseoptionsincludedoften,sometimes,ornevertrueinthelast12months.Motherswhorespondedsometimesoroftentruetobothofthequestions,wereclassifiedasfood-insecure.
Noassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandexclusivebreastfeeding.
![Page 44: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
35
TABLE 6. STUDIES ON THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN FOOD INSECURITY AND OVERWEIGHT AND OBESITY
Country Author(Year) Studypopulationandsamplesize Methods
Resultsontheassociationbetween
foodinsecurityandoverweightand
obesity
BRAZIL(30-31,55,77,83,91,215-216)
Gubertetal.(2017) Mothersaged15–49andtheirchildrenunder5yofage.(N=4299mother–childpairs.)Nationallyrepresentativesample
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheBrazilianFoodInsecuritySecurityScale(EBIA).
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinwomen.
Gubertetal.(2016) Children<5yofage(N=4064)Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheBrazilianFoodInsecuritySecurityScale(EBIA).
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren<5y
Kac,Schlüsseletal.(2012)
Children<5yofage(N=3433)Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren<5y
Kac,Velásquez-Melendezetal.(2012)
Adolescentfemales15-19yofage(N=1529).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandexcessiveweightinadolescentfemales.Therewasahigherprevalenceofexcessiveweightforadolescentfemaleslivinginseverelyfood-insecurehouseholdscomparedtofood-securehouseholds.
Lopesetal.(2013) 12–18yoldadolescents(N=523).Low-incomeareaofthemunicipalityofDuquedeCaxias,RiodeJaneiro.
Cross-sectionalstudy;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinadolescents.
Oliveira,Lira,Verasetal.(2009)
Adolescents(N=1528)andadults(N=1163)fromtwotownsinthestateofPernambuco,innorth-easternBrazil.
Cross-sectional,primarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightorobesityamongadolescents.
![Page 45: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
36
Schlüsseletal.(2013)
Adolescentfemales(N=1502),adultwomen(N=10226)andchildren<5yofage(N=3433).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandobesityamongadultwomen;PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandexcessweightamongfemaleadolescents.NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesityamongchildren(eitherboysorgirls).
Velásquez-Melendezetal.(2011)
Womenaged18to45y(N=10226).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingBrazilianDHS2006;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheEBIA.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightamongadultwomen.
CANADA(73,87) Duboisetal.(2006) Childrenaged1.5–4.5y(N=2103children,49%girls)inQuebec.
LongitudinalStudyofChildDevelopmentinQuebecFoodsecuritymeasuredusingasinglefoodinsufficiencyquestionaskedtomothers
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandchildoverweightandobesityat4.5yofage.
Marketal.(2012) Boysandgirlsaged9–18y(N=8938).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingtheCanadianCommunityHealthSurvey(CCHS)Cycle2.2;foodinsecurityestimatewasbased10adult-referencedquestionsand8child-referencedquestions.
Mixedresults.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinboys9–18yofage.TherewasahigherprevalenceofBMI≥85thpercentileinboysinlow-incomefood-insecureHHsthanamongboysinfood-securelow-incomeHHs.
COLOMBIA(53) Isanakaetal.(2007)
Children5–12yofageandtheirmothers(N=2526).ChildrenattendingpublicschoolsinBogota.
Cross-sectionalstudyofschool-agechildren’shealthandnutritionalstatus;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonamodifiedversionoftheSpanish-languageUSHFSSM(16version)plus5child-specificquestionsusedtomeasurechildfoodsecurity.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandchildormaternaloverweight.
![Page 46: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
37
JAMAICA(88)
Duboisetal.(2008) Children10–11yofage(N=1674inJamaica;1190inQuebec).Nationallyrepresentativesamples.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingtheQuébecLongitudinalStudyofChildDevelopment(QLSCD)2008&JamaicaYouthRiskandResiliencyBehaviourSurveyof2007.Foodinsecuritywasmeasuredbasedontwoquestionsaskedtochildrenaboutexperiencesoffoodinsecurity.
Mixedresults.NegativeassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightamongchildrenaged10–11yinJamaica.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightorobesityonlyingirlsInQuébec.
ECUADOR(61,100) Weigeletal.(2016) AdultwomenlivinginHHswithchildren(N=794)inlow-incomeneighbourhoodsinQuito,Ecuador.
Crosssectional,primarysurvey.foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheSpanishversionoftheUSHFSSM
NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinadultwomen.
WeigelandArmijos(2015)
Womenofreproductiveage(N=10748).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingtheEncuestaDemograficadeSaludMaternaeInfantil2004survey.Foodinsecuritywasmeasuredbasedontwoquestionsonfoodinsufficiency.
Noassociationbetweenfoodinsecurityandadultoradolescentfemaleoverweight/obesity.
FRANCE(97) Martin-Fernandezetal.(2014)
Adultmenandwomen(N=2967).RepresentativesampleofParismetropolitanarea.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingthethirdwaveofalongitudinal,cohortstudy,theHealth,InequalitiesandSocialRuptures(SIRS)survey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheUSHFSSM.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweight(higherBMI)amongwomen.Noassociationformen.
GHANA(52) SaakaandOsman(2013)
Womenofreproductiveage(15to45y)(N=337).TamaleMetropolisofNorthernGhana.
Cross-sectionalstudy,primarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonthe30-dayHFIAS.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandwomen’sBMI.
IRAN(Islamic
Republicof)(78)
Jafarietal.(2017) Childrenaged9.30±1.49y(N=587:439girlsand148boys)inIsfahan.
Cross-sectionalstudy,primarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheRadimer/CornellScale.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinchildrenaged7–12y.HFIwasassociatedwithabdominalbutnotgeneralobesity.
LEBANON(92,104) Jomaaetal.(2017) Motherswhohavechildren<18yofage(N=378)inBeirut.
Cross-sectionalstudy,primarysurvey;foodinsecuritywasmeasuredbasedalocally-validated,ArabicversionoftheHFIAS.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinwomen.
![Page 47: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
38
Ghattasetal.(2017)
Childrenandadults(N=474)from84HHsintwosettlementsintheBekaavalley.Children<5yofage(N=66)Children5–17yofage(N=146)Adults>18yofage(including65andabove)(N=302)
Cross-sectionalstudy,primarysurvey;foodinsecuritywasmeasuredusinganArabicversionoftheUSHFSSMadaptedtotheLebanesecontext.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightandobesityamongadults.
MALAYSIA(45,101-102)
AliNaseretal.(2014)
Mothersaged18–55ywhowerenon-lactating,non-pregnant,andhadatleastonechildaged2–12y(N=223).BachokdistrictinKelantan,ruralareaofNorthEastPeninsularMalaysia.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheRadimer/Cornellfoodsecurityscale.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesity/overweightinadultwomen.
Mohamadpouretal.(2012)
Indianwomen(19–49yofage,non-pregnant,andnon-lactating)(N=169)inpalm-plantationHHsinNegeriSembilan.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheRadimer/Cornellfoodsecurityscale.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinadultwomen.However,significantassociationobservedbetweenHFIandriskwaist-circumference.
Shariffetal.(2014) Womenofreproductiveage(N=625)inthreestatesofPeninsularMalaysia.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheRadimer/Cornellfoodsecurityscale.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesity/overweightinadultwomen.
MEXICO(37) Shamah-Levyetal.(2014)
Children<5yofageandadults.(Nnotprovided).Nationallyrepresentativesamples.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingMexicanNationalHealthandNutritionSurvey(ENSANUT)2012;foodinsecurityestimatebasedontheELCSA.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweight(higherBMI)amongadults.HFIsignificantpredictorofoverweight/obesityinadults,especiallywomen.
NEPAL(38,41) SinghandRam(186)
Marriedwomenaged15to49y(N=4581).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingNepalDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS(7items).
NoassociationbetweenHFIoverweightinwomen.
Sreeramareddyetal.(2015)
Children<5yofage(N=2591).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingNepalDHS2011;foodinsecurityestimatebasedonanadaptedversionofHFIAS(7items).
NoassociationofHFIwithchildoverweight(BMI-for-agezscore).
![Page 48: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
39
UGANDA(105) Chaputetal.(2007) 60food-secure(30maleand30female)and60food-insecure(30maleand30female)individualsinurbanKampala.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecurityestimatewasbasedontheRadimer/Cornellfoodsecurityscale.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinwomen.
UNITEDSTATESOF
AMERICA(3-4,26,74-76,79-82,84-86,93-96,98-99,103,207-208,217-221)
Asfouretal.(2015) Children2to5yofage(N=1211)intwenty-eightsubsidizedchildcarecentresinMiami-DadeCounty,Florida.
CrossSectionalstudyusingbaselinedatafromapreschoolinterventiontrial.FoodinsecuritymeasuredusingfivesurveyquestionsfromtheUSHFSSM.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandBMIpercentileamongchildren2to5yofage.
Bhargavaetal.(2008)
Children>5yofage(kindergartentofifthgrade)(N=5797boysand5682girls).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudybasedontheEarlyChildhoodKindergartenCohortStudy;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren>5yofage.
Bronte-Tinkewetal.(2007)
Children2yofage(N=8693children).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudybasedontheEarlyChildhoodLongitudinalSurvey-BirthCohort;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
Nodirectassociation.HFIinfluencesoverweightviaparentingpracticesandinfantfeedingpractices.
Buscemietal.(2011)
Latinochildren2–17yofage(N=63,30girlsand33boys)fromimmigrantandnon-immigrantfamiliesattendingaprimaryhealthcareclinicservinglowincomefamiliesinMemphis.
Cross-sectionalstudy,usingaprimarysurvey;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
NegativeassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren2–17yofage.Acculturationisasignificantmoderatingvariable.
Caseyetal.(2006) Children3–17yofage(N=3553boysand3442girls).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingNHANESdata;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM(8child-referenceditems).
Mixedresults.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightforthefollowingdemographicgroups:children12to17yofage;whitegirls;childrenlivinginHHswithincome<1and>4timesthefederalpovertylevel.Childfoodinsecurityassociatedwithriskforoverweightfor:abovegroups,andages3–5,MexicanAmerican,andwhite.
![Page 49: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
40
Gundersenetal.(2009)
Children8–17yofage(N=2516).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingpooledNHANESdata;foodinsecuritywasmeasureusingtheUSHFSSM.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren8–17yofage.
Gundersenetal.(2008a)
Children10–15yofage(N=1031).Boston,Chicago,andSanAntonio.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingdatafromtheWelfare,Children,andFamiliesThree-CityStudy;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthreequestionsfromtheUSHFSSM.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren10–15yofage.
Gundersenetal.(2008b)
Children3–17yofage(N=841)andtheirmothers.Nationallyrepresentativesample.
Pooledtimeseries-crosssectiondatafromtheNHANES;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM(8-itemchildscale).
NodirectassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightamongchildren3–17yofage.
Kauretal.(2015) Children2to11yofage(N=9701).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudyusingNHANESdata.Child-levelfoodinsecuritywasassessedwithUSHFSSMbasedoneightchild-specificquestions.Personalfoodinsecuritywasassessedwithfiveadditionalquestions.
Mixedresults.Obesitysignificantlyassociatedwithpersonalfoodinsecurityforchildren6–11yofagebutnotinchildren2–5yofage.
Kukuetal.(2012) Children(N=959).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudyusingtheSecondChildDevelopmentSupplement(CDS-II)ofthePanelStudyofIncomeDynamics(PSID);foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
HFIpositivelyassociatedwithobesityinchildren.Moreover,thisrelationshipdiffersacrossrelevantsubgroupsincludingthosedefinedbygender,race/ethnicityandincome.
Hansonetal.(2007)
Adultmenandwomen≥20yofage(N=4338menand4172women).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingtheNHANES;foodinsecuritymeasuredusing18itemUSHFSSM.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinwomenbutnotinmen.Greaterlikelihoodofobesityinfoodinsecure:married,widowed,andpartneredwomen(asopposedtofoodsecure,nevermarried).Menwithlowfoodsecuritylesslikelytobeoverweight.Womenwithmarginalfoodsecuritymorelikelytobeoverweight.Womenwithlowfoodsecuritymorelikelytobeobese.
![Page 50: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
41
Hernandezetal.(2017)
Adults18–59yofage(N=1990).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
CrosssectionalstudyusingNationalHealthInterviewSurveydata;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe10-itemUSHFSSM.
Foodinsecuritywasassociatedwith41%and29%higheroddsofbeingoverweight/obeseamongwhiteandHispanicwomen,respectively.Foodinsecuritywasnotrelatedtooverweight/obesityamongblackwomennoramongwhite,black,andHispanicmen.
Jyotietal.(2005) ECLS_Kcohort(N=5682boysand5498girls)kindergartenthrough8thgrade.
EarlyChildhoodLongitudinalStudy-KindergartenCohort;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
Mixedresults.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightonlyamonggirls.
Laraiaetal.(2015) Women>16yofage(N=526)inNorthCarolina.
LongitudinalstudyusingdatafromthePregnancy,InfectionandNutrition(PIN)PostpartumStudy;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandhigherBMIamongpost-partumwomen.Amongoverweight/obesewomen,foodinsecuritywasassociatedwithahigherBMIat12monthspostpartumcomparedtooverweight/obesewomenfromfood-secureHHs.Foodsecuritystatuswasassociatedwithhigherlevelsofperceivedstress,disorderedeatingbehaviouranddietaryfatintakeabovetherecommendedamountat3and12monthspostpartum
Laraiaetal.(2013) Pregnantwomen(N=1041)inNorthCarolina.
LongitudinalstudybasedonthePregnancy,InfectionandNutrition(PIN)PostpartumStudy;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
Positiveassociationbetweenmildfoodinsecurityandriskofexcessiveweightgainamongpregnantwomen.
Lohmanetal.(2009)
Children10–15yofage(N=1011)inBoston,Chicago,andSanAntonio.
CrosssectionalstudyusingWelfare,Children,andFamiliesThree-CityStudy(1999Wave1);foodinsecuritymeasuredusinga3-itemsubscaleoftheUSHFSSSM(child)
NodirectassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren10–15yofage;positiveinteractionoffoodinsecurityandmaternalstressindex
![Page 51: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
42
MartinandLippert(2012)
Adultmenandwomenofchildbearingage(N=7931).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudyusingthePSID;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweight/obesityinwomen.Amongwomen,food-insecuremothersweremorelikelythanchild-freewomentobeoverweightorobese.Therisksaregreaterforsinglemothersrelativetomothersinmarriedorcohabitingrelationships.
MartinandFerris(2007)
Children2–12yofage.(N=212;108girls,104boys)inHartford,Connecticut.
Crosssectionalstudyusingacommunitysurvey;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe18itemUSHFSSM.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildren2–12yofage.
Metallinos-Katsarasetal.(2012)
Children2–5yofage(N=2353)fromlow-incomefamiliesparticipatingintheMassachusettsSpecialSupplementalNutritionProgramforWomen,Infants,andChildren.
Longitudinalstudybasedonaprimarysurvey;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe18-itemUSHFSSM.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinchildren2–5yofage.
Metallinos-Katsarasetal.(2009)
Children≤5yofage(N=8493)fromlow-incomefamiliesparticipatingintheMassachusettsSpecialSupplementalNutritionProgramforWomen,Infants,andChildren.
Crosssectionalstudyonaprimarysurvey;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe4-itemsubscaleofUSHFSSM.
Mixedresults.NegativeassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightingirls<2yofage.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightingirls2–5yofage.
MillimetandRoy(2015)
Children(kindergartenthrougheighthgrade)(ECLS-KcohortN=6470);Childrenfrombirththroughkindergartenentry(ECLS-BcohortN=4100).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudyusingdatafromtheECLS-KandECLS-B;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM.
Nolong-runcausalrelationshipbetweenfoodsecurityandchildobesityinthepresenceofmeasurementerror.Onlyintheabsenceofmeasurementerrorthereexistsanysuggestiveevidencethatfoodinsecurityhasalong-run(negative)causaleffectonchildobesityandoverweightstatusofchildren.
![Page 52: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
43
OlsonandStrawderman(2008)
Adultchildbearingwomen(N=662)livingina10-countyruralareaofupstateNewYork.
LongitudinalstudyusingdatafromtheBassettMothersHealthProject,anobservationalcohortstudyofhealthyadultwomenfollowedfromearlypregnancyuntil2ypostpartum;HFImeasuredpostpartumusinga3-itemsubscaleoftheUSHFSSM.
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinwomenattwoyearspostpartum;associationlostsignificanceaftercontrollingforcovariates.
RoseandBodor(2006)
Childrenintheirkindergartenyear(N=16889).Nationallyrepresentativesample.
LongitudinalstudyusingtheEarlyChildhoodLongitudinalStudy-KindergartenCohort(ECLS-K);foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe18-itemUSHFSSM
NoassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinchildrenofkindergartenage.
Speirsetal.(2016) Children2–5yofage(N=438)recruitedfrom30licensedchildcarecentresinfivecountiesincentralIllinois
CrosssectionalbasedontheSynergisticTheoryandResearchonObesityandNutritionGroupKids(STRONGKids)program;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe18itemUSHFSSM.BothHHfoodinsecurityandchildfoodinsecurityestimated
Mixedresults.NoassociationbetweeneitherHFIorchildfoodinsecurityandBMIforthefullsample.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandBMIz-scoresforgirlsonly.
Trappetal.(2015) Low-incomechildrenaged2–4y(N=222)
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurveyrelatedtoanobesityprevention/reversalstudy(StepstoGrowingUpHealthy);foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSM
NoassociationbetweenHFIandchildBMIpercentile.
WhitakerandSarin(2007)
Motherswithpreschoolchildren(N=1707)from20largecities.
LongitudinalstudybasedontheFragileFamiliesandChildWellbeingStudy(Baseline2001–2003;follow-up2003–2005);foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheUSHFSSMadultitems.
NoassociationbetweenHFIandobesityinwomen.Significanceofassociation(atbothperiods)waslostaftercontrollingforcovariates.
Widomeetal.(2009)
Multiethnicmiddleandhighschoolstudents(N=4746)from31primarilyurbanschoolsinMinneapolis–St.Paul,Minnesotaarea.
Cross-sectionalstudyusingaprimarysurvey,partofProjectEAT(EatingAmongTeens);foodinsecuritymeasuredusingthe2itemsfromUSHFSSM
PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightinadolescents.Food-insecureyouthsweremorelikelytohaveabodymassindexabovethe95thpercentile.
![Page 53: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
44
VIETNAM(106) Vuongetal.(2015) 250adults(N=250)inDistricteightinHoChiMinhCity
Crosssectionalstudyusingprimarysurvey;foodinsecuritymeasuredusingtheELCSA.
NosignificantassociationbetweenHFIandoverweight/obesityinadults.
INDIA,PERU,ETHIOPIA,
VIETNAM(48)Humphriesetal.(2015)
Childrenaged1,5,and8y(threeroundsofdatacollection)infourcountries.Ethiopia(N=1757),India(N=1825),Peru(N=1844),andVietNam(N=1828).
Longitudinalstudyfollowingthesamechildrenatages1,5and8y,usingaprimarysurvey;at5yofagefoodinsecurityestimatewasbasedonamodifiedversionoftheUSHFSSM,at8yofage,theestimatewasbasedontheHFIAS.
Mixedresults.NoassociationbetweenHFIandBMI-Zinanyofthe4countriesincross-sectionalanalysisat5yofage,andonlyinPeruandVietNamat8yofage.
UNITEDSTATESOF
AMERICAANDMEXICO
(89)
Rosasetal.(2011) 5-year-oldchildrenandtheirmothers.InCalifornia,mother–childpairsofwhomallchildrenwerebornintheUSandallmothersborninMexico,participantsintheCenterfortheHealthAssessmentofMothersandChildrenofSalinas(CHAMACOS)study(N=287mother–childpairs).InMexico,mothersandtheir5-year-oldchildrenwhowerebeneficiariesofthesocialwelfareprogramOportunidades(N=316mother–childpairs)
Abinationalstudyusingtwocross-sectionalsamplesof5-year-oldchildrenandtheirmothersinCaliforniaandMexico;foodinsecuritywasmeasuredbasedontheUSHFSSM-SpanishVersion(ShortForm)
Mixedresults.PositiveassociationbetweenHFIandoverweightorobesityamongchildreninMexico.NoassociationofHFIwithchildweightstatusinCalifornia.
![Page 54: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
45
References 1. FAO1996.RomeDeclarationonFoodSecurity.WorldFoodSummit.Rome.(alsoavailable
at:http://www.fao.org/docrep/003/w3613e/w3613e00.HTM).
2. Reis,M.2012.Foodinsecurityandtherelationshipbetweenhouseholdincomeand
children'shealthandnutritioninBrazil.HealthEconomics,Vol.21No.(4):pp.405–27.10.1002/hec.1722.
3. Jyoti,D.F.,Frongillo,E.A.&Jones,S.J.2005.Foodinsecurityaffectsschoolchildren's
academicperformance,weightgain,andsocialskills.JournalofNutrition,Vol.135No.(12):pp.2831–9.10.1093/jn/135.12.2831.
4. Casey,P.H.,Simpson,P.M.,Gossett,J.M.,Bogle,M.L.,Champagne,C.M.,Connell,C.,
Harsha,D.,Mccabe-Sellers,B.,Robbins,J.M.,Stuff,J.E.&Weber,J.2006.Theassociationof
childandhouseholdfoodinsecuritywithchildhoodoverweightstatus.Pediatrics,Vol.118No.(5):pp.e1406–13.10.1542/peds.2006-0097.
5. Gundersen,C.,Kreider,B.&Pepper,J.2011.TheEconomicsofFoodInsecurityintheUnited
States.AppliedEconomicPerspectivesandPolicy,Vol.33No.(3):pp.281–303.http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/aepp/ppr022].
6. Nettle,D.,Andrews,C.&Bateson,M.2017.Foodinsecurityasadriverofobesityinhumans:
Theinsurancehypothesis.BehavioralandBrainSciences,Vol.40p.e105.10.1017/s0140525x16000947.
7. NationalResearchCouncil&InstituteofMedicine2013.ResearchOpportunitiesConcerning
theCausesandConsequencesofChildFoodInsecurityandHunger:AWorkshopSummary.
Washington,DC,Press,T.N.A.(alsoavailableat:
https://www.nap.edu/catalog/18504/research-opportunities-concerning-the-causes-and-
consequences-of-child-food-insecurity-and-hunger).
8. Hoddinott,J.2013.Theeconomiccostofmalnutrition.In:Eggersdorfer,M.,Kraemer,K.,
Ruel,M.,Van,Meringen,M.,Biesalski,H.K.,Bloem,M.,Chen,J.,Lateef,A.&V,M.(eds.)
TheRoadtoGoodNutrition:AGlobalPerspective.Basel,Switzerland:Karger.(alsoavailableat:https://www.karger.com/Article/Pdf/355994).
9. Victora,C.G.,Adair,L.,Fall,C.,Hallal,P.C.,Martorell,R.,Richter,L.,Sachdev,H.S.,Group,
M.&Study,C.U.2008.Maternalandchildundernutrition:consequencesforadulthealth
andhumancapital.Lancet,Vol.371No.(9609):pp.340–57.10.1016/s0140-6736(07)61692-4.
10. Black,R.E.,Allen,L.H.,Bhutta,Z.A.,Caulfield,L.E.,DeOnis,M.,Ezzati,M.,Mathers,C.,
Rivera,J.,Group,M.&Study,C.U.2008.Maternalandchildundernutrition:globaland
regionalexposuresandhealthconsequences.Lancet,Vol.371No.(9608):pp.243–60.10.1016/s0140-6736(07)61690-0.
11. Grantham-Mcgregor,S.,Cheung,Y.B.,Cueto,S.,Glewwe,P.,Richter,L.,Strupp,B.&Group,
I.C.D.S.2007.Developmentalpotentialinthefirst5yearsforchildrenindeveloping
countries.Lancet,Vol.369No.(9555):pp.60–70.10.1016/s0140-6736(07)60032-4.
![Page 55: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
46
12. Perez-Escamilla,R.,Bermudez,O.,Buccini,G.S.,Kumanyika,S.,Lutter,C.K.,Monsivais,P.&
Victora,C.2018.Nutritiondisparitiesandtheglobalburdenofmalnutrition.BMJ,Vol.361p.k2252.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29899012].
13. Popkin,B.,Monteiro,C.&Swinburn,B.2013.Overview:BellagioConferenceonProgram
andPolicyOptionsforPreventingObesityintheLow-andMiddle-IncomeCountries.ObesityReviews,Vol.14Suppl2pp.1–8.10.1111/obr.12108.
14. WHO.2017.Thedoubleburdenofmalnutrition.Policybrief.WHO/NMH/NHD/17.3.
http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/doubleburdenmalnutrition-policybrief/en/].
15. WHO.2018.GlobalTargets2025toimprovematernal,infantandyoungchildnutrition[Online].WHO.Available:http://www.who.int/nutrition/global-target-2025/en/[Accessed
August16,20182018].
16. Ballard,T.,Kepple,A.&Cafiero,C.2013.Thefoodinsecurityexperiencescale:developmentofaglobalstandardformonitoringhungerworldwide.http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/ess/voh/FIES_Technical_Paper_v1.1.pdf].
17. Coates,J.,Swindale,A.&Bilinsky,P.2007.HouseholdFoodInsecurityAccessScale(HFIAS)formeasurementofhouseholdfoodaccess:indicatorguide(v.3).Washington,D.C.(also
availableat:http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/eufao-fsi4dm/doc-
training/hfias.pdf).
18. Ballard,T.,Coates,J.,Swindale,A.&Deitchle,M.2011.HouseholdHungerScale:IndicatorDefinitionandMeasurementGuide.Washington,DC.(alsoavailableat:
https://www.fantaproject.org/monitoring-and-evaluation/household-hunger-scale-hhs).
19. Perez-Escamilla,R.,Melgar-Quiñonez,H.,Nord,M.,AlvarezUribe,M.C.&Segall-Correa,A.
M.2007.EscalaLatinoamericanayCaribeñadeSeguridadAlimentaria(ELCSA)
[LatinamericanandCaribbeanFoodSecurityScale].PerspectivasenNutriciónHumanaColombiaNo.(18):pp.117–134.].
20. Bronfenbrenner1979.TheEcologyofHumanDevelopment:ExperimentsbyNatureandDesign.Cambridge,Massachusetts,HarvardUniversityPress).
21. Dinour,L.M.,Bergen,D.&Yeh,M.C.2007.TheFoodInsecurity–ObesityParadox:AReview
oftheLiteratureandtheRoleFoodStampsMayPlay.JournaloftheAmericanDieteticAssociation,Vol.107No.(11):pp.1952–1961.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jada.2007.08.006.
22. Franklin,B.,Jones,A.,Love,D.,Puckett,S.,Macklin,J.&White-Means,S.2012.Exploring
mediatorsoffoodinsecurityandobesity:areviewofrecentliterature.JournalofCommunityHealth,Vol.37No.(1):pp.253–64.10.1007/s10900-011-9420-4.
23. Larson,N.I.&Story,M.T.2011.FoodinsecurityandweightstatusamongU.S.childrenand
families:areviewoftheliterature.AmericanJournalofPreventiveMedicine,Vol.40No.(2):pp.166–73.10.1016/j.amepre.2010.10.028.
24. Eisenmann,J.C.,Gundersen,C.,Lohman,B.J.,Garasky,S.&Stewart,S.D.2011.Isfood
insecurityrelatedtooverweightandobesityinchildrenandadolescents?Asummaryof
studies,1995–2009.ObesityReviews,Vol.12No.(5):pp.e73–83.10.1111/j.1467-789X.2010.00820.x.
![Page 56: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
47
25. Chaparro,C.2012.HouseholdFoodInsecurityandNutritionalStatusofWomenof
ReproductiveAgeandChildrenunder5YearsofAgeinFiveDepartmentsoftheWestern
HighlandsofGuatemala:AnAnalysisofDatafromtheNationalMaternal–InfantHealth
Survey2008–09ofGuatemala.Washington,DC.(alsoavailableat:
https://www.fantaproject.org/sites/default/files/resources/FANTA-Guatemala-ENSMI-
Report_March%202012.pdf).
26. Kaur,J.,Lamb,M.M.&Ogden,C.L.2015.TheAssociationbetweenFoodInsecurityand
ObesityinChildren-TheNationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey.JournaloftheAcademyofNutritionandDietetics,Vol.115No.(5):pp.751–8.10.1016/j.jand.2015.01.003.
27. Sweeting,H.N.2007.MeasurementandDefinitionsofObesityInChildhoodand
Adolescence:Afieldguidefortheuninitiated.NutritionJournal,Vol.6No.(1):p.32.10.1186/1475-2891-6-32.
28. Hasan,M.M.,Ahmed,S.&Chowdhury,M.a.H.2013.FoodInsecurityandChild
Undernutrition:EvidencefromBDHS2011.JournalofFoodSecurity,Vol.1No.(2):pp.52–57.10.12691/jfs-1-2-7.
29. Saha,K.K.,Frongillo,E.A.,Alam,D.S.,Arifeen,S.E.,Persson,L.Å.&Rasmussen,K.M.2009.
Householdfoodsecurityisassociatedwithgrowthofinfantsandyoungchildreninrural
Bangladesh.PublicHealthNutrition,Vol.12No.(9):pp.1556–1562.10.1017/S1368980009004765.
30. Gubert,M.B.,Spaniol,A.M.,Bortolini,G.A.&Pérez-Escamilla,R.2016.Householdfood
insecurity,nutritionalstatusandmorbidityinBrazilianchildren.PublicHealthNutrition,Vol.19No.(12):pp.2240–2245.10.1017/S1368980016000239.
31. Gubert,M.B.,Spaniol,A.M.,Segall-Corrêa,A.M.&Pérez-Escamilla,R.2017.Understanding
thedoubleburdenofmalnutritioninfoodinsecurehouseholdsinBrazil.MaternalandChildNutrition,Vol.13No.(3).10.1111/mcn.12347.
32. Santos,L.P.&Gigante,D.P.2013.Relationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityandnutritional
statusofBrazilianchildrenundertheageoffive.RevistaBrasileiradeEpidemiologia,Vol.16No.(4):pp.984–94.].
33. Betebo,B.,Ejajo,T.,Alemseged,F.&Massa,D.2017.HouseholdFoodInsecurityandIts
AssociationwithNutritionalStatusofChildren6–59MonthsofAgeinEastBadawacho
District,SouthEthiopia.JournalofEnvironmentalandPublicHealth,Vol.2017p.6373595.10.1155/2017/6373595.
34. Hackett,M.,Melgar-Quiñonez,H.&Alvarez,M.C.2009.Householdfoodinsecurity
associatedwithstuntingandunderweightamongpreschoolchildreninAntioquia,Colombia.
RevistaPanamericanadeSaludPublica,Vol.25No.(6):pp.506–10.].
35. Jemal,Z.,Hassen,K.&Wakayo,T.2016.HouseholdFoodInsecurityanditsAssociationwith
NutritionalStatusamongPreschoolChildreninGambellaTown,WesternEthiopia.JournalofNutritionandFoodScience,Vol.6No.(6).10.4172/2155-9600.1000566.
36. Shamah-Levy,T.,Mundo-Rosas,V.,Morales-Ruan,C.,Cuevas-Nasu,L.,Méndez-Gómez-
Humarán,I.&Pérez-Escamilla,R.2017.Foodinsecurityandmaternal–childnutritional
![Page 57: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
48
statusinMexico:cross-sectionalanalysisoftheNationalHealthandNutritionSurvey2012.
BMJOpen,Vol.7No.(7):p.e014371.10.1136/bmjopen-2016-014371.
37. Shamah-Levy,T.,Mundo-Rosas,V.&Rivera-Dommarco,J.A.2014.[Magnitudeoffood
insecurityinMexico:itsrelationshipwithnutritionalstatusandsocioeconomicfactors].
SaludPublicaMexicana,Vol.56Suppl1pp.s79–85.].
38. Singh,A.&Ram,F.2014.Householdfoodinsecurityandnutritionalstatusofchildrenand
womeninNepal.FoodandNutritionBulletin,Vol.35No.(1):pp.3–11.10.1177/156482651403500101.
39. Baig-Ansari,N.,Rahbar,M.H.,Bhutta,Z.A.&Badruddin,S.H.2006.Child'sgenderand
householdfoodinsecurityareassociatedwithstuntingamongyoungPakistanichildren
residinginurbansquattersettlements.FoodandNutritionBulletin,Vol.27No.(2):pp.114–27.10.1177/156482650602700203.
40. Psaki,S.,Bhutta,Z.A.,Ahmed,T.,Ahmed,S.,Bessong,P.,Islam,M.,John,S.,Kosek,M.,
Lima,A.,Nesamvuni,C.,Shrestha,P.,Svensen,E.,Mcgrath,M.,Richard,S.,Seidman,J.,
Caulfield,L.,Miller,M.,Checkley,W.&Investigators,F.M.N.2012.Householdfoodaccess
andchildmalnutrition:resultsfromtheeight-countryMAL-EDstudy.PopulationHealthMetrics,Vol.10No.(1):p.24.10.1186/1478-7954-10-24.
41. Sreeramareddy,C.T.,Ramakrishnareddy,N.&Subramaniam,M.2015.Associationbetween
householdfoodaccessinsecurityandnutritionalstatusindicatorsamongchildrenaged<5
yearsinNepal:resultsfromanational,cross-sectionalhouseholdsurvey.PublicHealthNutrition,Vol.18No.(16):pp.2906–14.10.1017/s1368980014002729.
42. Ali,D.,Saha,K.K.,Nguyen,P.H.,Diressie,M.T.,Ruel,M.T.,Menon,P.&Rawat,R.2013.
HouseholdfoodinsecurityisassociatedwithhigherchildundernutritioninBangladesh,
Ethiopia,andVietNam,buttheeffectisnotmediatedbychilddietarydiversity.JournalofNutrition,Vol.143No.(12):pp.2015–21.10.3945/jn.113.175182.
43. Shahraki,S.H.,Amirkhizi,F.,Amirkhizi,B.&Hamedi,S.2016.HouseholdFoodInsecurityIs
AssociatedwithNutritionalStatusamongIranianChildren.EcologyofFoodandNutrition,Vol.55No.(5):pp.473–90.10.1080/03670244.2016.1212710.
44. Gray,V.B.,Cossman,J.S.&Powers,E.L.2006.Stuntedgrowthisassociatedwithphysical
indicatorsofmalnutritionbutnotfoodinsecurityamongruralschoolchildreninHonduras.
NutritionResearch,Vol.26No.(11).10.1016/j.nutres.2006.09.009.
45. AliNaser,I.,Jalil,R.,WanMuda,W.M.,WanNik,W.S.,MohdShariff,Z.&Abdullah,M.R.
2014.Associationbetweenhouseholdfoodinsecurityandnutritionaloutcomesamong
childreninNortheasternofPeninsularMalaysia.NutritionResearchPractices,Vol.8No.(3):pp.304–11.10.4162/nrp.2014.8.3.304.
46. Schmeer,K.K.&Piperata,B.A.2017.Householdfoodinsecurityandchildhealth.MaternalandChildNutritionVol.13No.(2).10.1111/mcn.12301.
47. Belachew,T.,Lindstrom,D.,Hadley,C.,Gebremariam,A.,Kasahun,W.&Kolsteren,P.2013.
FoodinsecurityandlineargrowthofadolescentsinJimmaZone,SouthwestEthiopia.
NutritionJournal,Vol.12p.55.10.1186/1475-2891-12-55.
![Page 58: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
49
48. Humphries,D.L.,Dearden,K.A.,Crookston,B.T.,Fernald,L.C.,Stein,A.D.,Woldehanna,T.,
Penny,M.E.,Behrman,J.R.,Team,Y.L.D.&Project,C.O.C.G.2015.Cross-Sectionaland
LongitudinalAssociationsbetweenHouseholdFoodSecurityandChildAnthropometryat
Ages5and8YearsinEthiopia,India,Peru,andVietNam.JournalofNutrition,Vol.145No.(8):pp.1924–33.10.3945/jn.115.210229.
49. Osei,A.,Pandey,P.,Spiro,D.,Nielson,J.,Shrestha,R.,Talukder,Z.,Quinn,V.&Haselow,N.
2010.HouseholdFoodInsecurityandNutritionalStatusofChildrenAged6to23Monthsin
KailaliDistrictofNepal.FoodandNutritionBulletin,Vol.31No.(4):pp.483–494.10.1177/156482651003100402.
50. Mcdonald,C.M.,Mclean,J.,Kroeun,H.,Talukder,A.,Lynd,L.D.&Green,T.J.2015.
Householdfoodinsecurityanddietarydiversityascorrelatesofmaternalandchild
undernutritioninruralCambodia.EuropeanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.69No.(2):pp.242–6.10.1038/ejcn.2014.161.
51. Motbainor,A.,Worku,A.&Kumie,A.2015.StuntingIsAssociatedwithFoodDiversitywhile
WastingwithFoodInsecurityamongUnderfiveChildreninEastandWestGojjamZonesof
AmharaRegion,Ethiopia.PLoSOne,Vol.10No.(8):p.e0133542.10.1371/journal.pone.0133542.
52. Saaka,M.&Osman,S.M.2013.DoesHouseholdFoodInsecurityAffecttheNutritional
StatusofPreschoolChildrenAged6–36Months?InternationalJournalofPopulationResearch,Vol.ArticleID304169.].
53. Isanaka,S.,Mora-Plazas,M.,Lopez-Arana,S.,Baylin,A.&Villamor,E.2007.Foodinsecurity
ishighlyprevalentandpredictsunderweightbutnotoverweightinadultsandschool
childrenfromBogotá,Colombia.JournalofNutrition,Vol.137No.(12):pp.2747–55.10.1093/jn/137.12.2747.
54. Kaiser,L.L.,Melgar-Quiñonez,H.R.,Lamp,C.L.,Johns,M.C.,Sutherlin,J.M.&Harwood,J.
O.2002.Foodsecurityandnutritionaloutcomesofpreschool-ageMexican-American
children.JournaloftheAmericanDieteticAssociation,Vol.102No.(7):pp.924–9.].
55. Lopes,T.S.,Sichieri,R.,Salles-Costa,R.,Veiga,G.V.&Pereira,R.A.2013.Familyfood
insecurityandnutritionalriskinadolescentsfromalow-incomeareaofRiodeJaneiro,
Brazil.JournalofBiosocialScience,Vol.45No.(5):pp.661–74.10.1017/s0021932012000685.
56. Ajao,K.O.,Ojofeitimi,E.O.,Adebayo,A.A.,Fatusi,A.O.&Afolabi,O.T.2010.Influenceof
familysize,householdfoodsecuritystatus,andchildcarepracticesonthenutritionalstatus
ofunder-fivechildreninIle-Ife,Nigeria.AfricanJournalofReproductiveHealth,Vol.14No.(4Specno.):pp.117–26.].
57. Abdurahman,A.A.,Mirzaei,K.,Dorosty,A.R.,Rahimiforoushani,A.&Kedir,H.2016.
HouseholdFoodInsecurityMayPredictUnderweightandWastingamongChildrenAged24–
59Months.EcologyofFoodandNutrition,Vol.55No.(5):pp.456–472.10.1080/03670244.2016.1207069.
![Page 59: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
50
58. Borders,A.E.,Grobman,W.A.,Amsden,L.B.&Holl,J.L.2007.Chronicstressandlowbirth
weightneonatesinalow-incomepopulationofwomen.Obstetrics&Gynecology,Vol.109No.(2Pt1):pp.331–8.10.1097/01.AOG.0000250535.97920.b5.
59. Grilo,S.A.,Earnshaw,V.A.,Lewis,J.B.,Stasko,E.C.,Magriples,U.,Tobin,J.&Ickovics,J.R.
2015.FoodMatters:FoodInsecurityamongPregnantAdolescentsandInfantBirth
Outcomes.JournalofAppliedResearchonChildren:InformingPolicyforChildrenatRisk,Vol.6No.(2).
60. Chowdhury,M.,Dibley,M.J.,Alam,A.,Huda,T.M.&Raynes-Greenow,C.2018.Household
FoodSecurityandBirthSizeofInfants:AnalysisoftheBangladeshDemographicandHealth
Survey2011.CurrentDevelopmentsinNutrition,Vol.2No.(3):p.nzy003.10.1093/cdn/nzy003.
61. Weigel,M.M.,Armijos,R.X.,Racines,M.&Cevallos,W.2016.FoodInsecurityIsAssociated
withUndernutritionbutNotOvernutritioninEcuadorianWomenfromLow-IncomeUrban
Neighborhoods.JournalofEnvironmentalandPublicHealth,Vol.2016p.8149459.10.1155/2016/8149459.
62. Ghose,B.,Tang,S.,Yaya,S.&Feng,Z.2016.Associationbetweenfoodinsecurityand
anemiaamongwomenofreproductiveage.PeerJ,Vol.4p.e1945.10.7717/peerj.1945.
63. Fischer,N.C.,Shamah-Levy,T.,Mundo-Rosas,V.,Méndez-Gómez-Humarán,I.&Pérez-
Escamilla,R.2014.HouseholdfoodinsecurityisassociatedwithanemiainadultMexican
womenofreproductiveage.JournalofNutrition,Vol.144No.(12):pp.2066–72.10.3945/jn.114.197095.
64. Jones,A.D.,Mundo-Rosas,V.,Cantoral,A.&Levy,T.S.2017.Householdfoodinsecurityin
Mexicoisassociatedwiththeco-occurrenceofoverweightandanemiaamongwomenof
reproductiveage,butnotfemaleadolescents.MaternalandChildNutritionVol.13No.(4).10.1111/mcn.12396.
65. Park,C.Y.&Eicher-Miller,H.A.2014.IronDeficiencyIsAssociatedwithFoodInsecurity
inPregnantFemalesintheUnitedStates:NationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey
1999–2010.JournaloftheAcademyofNutritionandDietetics,Vol.114No.(12):pp.1967–1973.].
66. Orr,S.K.,Dachner,N.,Frank,L.&Tarasuk,V.2018.Relationbetweenhouseholdfood
insecurityandbreastfeedinginCanada.CanadianMedicalAssociationJournal,Vol.190No.(11):pp.E312–E319.10.1503/cmaj.170880.
67. Macharia,T.N.,Ochola,S.,Mutua,M.K.&Kimani-Murage,E.W.2018.Associationbetween
householdfoodsecurityandinfantfeedingpracticesinurbaninformalsettlementsin
Nairobi,Kenya.JournalofDevelopmentalOriginsofHealthandDisease,Vol.9No.(1):pp.20–29.10.1017/s2040174417001064.
68. Gomes,G.P.&Gubert,M.B.2012.Breastfeedinginchildrenunder2yearsoldand
householdfoodandnutritionsecuritystatus.JornaldePediatria(RioJ),Vol.88No.(3):pp.279–82.doi:10.2223/JPED.2173.
![Page 60: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
51
69. Gross,R.S.,Mendelsohn,A.L.,Fierman,A.H.,Racine,A.D.&Messito,M.J.2012.Food
insecurityandobesogenicmaternalinfantfeedingstylesandpracticesinlow-income
families.Pediatrics,Vol.130No.(2):pp.254–61.10.1542/peds.2011-3588.
70. Saha,K.K.,Frongillo,E.A.,Alam,D.S.,Arifeen,S.E.,Persson,L.Å.&Rasmussen,K.M.2008.
HouseholdFoodSecurityIsAssociatedwithInfantFeedingPracticesinRuralBangladesh.
TheJournalofnutrition,Vol.138No.(7):pp.1383–1390.http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2518644/].
71. Yeneabat,T.,Belachew,T.&Haile,M.2014.Determinantsofcessationofexclusive
breastfeedinginAnkeshaGuagusaWoreda,AwiZone,NorthwestEthiopia:across-sectional
study.BMCPregnancyChildbirth,Vol.14p.262.10.1186/1471-2393-14-262.
72. Young,S.L.,Plenty,A.H.,Luwedde,F.A.,Natamba,B.K.,Natureeba,P.,Achan,J.,
Mwesigwa,J.,Ruel,T.D.,Ades,V.,Osterbauer,B.,Clark,T.D.,Dorsey,G.,Charlebois,E.D.,
Kamya,M.,Havlir,D.V.&Cohan,D.L.2014.Householdfoodinsecurity,maternalnutritional
status,andinfantfeedingpracticesamongHIV-infectedUgandanwomenreceiving
combinationantiretroviraltherapy.MaternalandChildHealthJournal,Vol.18No.(9):pp.2044–53.10.1007/s10995-014-1450-y.
73. Dubois,L.,Farmer,A.,Girard,M.&Porcherie,M.2006.Familyfoodinsufficiencyisrelated
tooverweightamongpreschoolers.SocialScienceandMedicine,Vol.63No.(6):pp.1503–16.10.1016/j.socscimed.2006.04.002.
74. Metallinos-Katsaras,E.,Must,A.&Gorman,K.2012.Alongitudinalstudyoffoodinsecurity
onobesityinpreschoolchildren.JAcadNutrDiet,Vol.112No.(12):pp.1949–58.10.1016/j.jand.2012.08.031.
75. Metallinos-Katsaras,E.,Sherry,B.&Kallio,J.2009.Foodinsecurityisassociatedwith
overweightinchildrenyoungerthan5yearsofage.JAmDietAssoc,Vol.109No.(10):pp.1790–4.10.1016/j.jada.2009.07.007.
76. Speirs,K.E.,Fiese,B.H.&Team,S.K.R.2016.TheRelationshipBetweenFoodInsecurity
andBMIforPreschoolChildren.MaternalandChildHealthJournal,Vol.20No.(4):pp.925–33.10.1007/s10995-015-1881-0.
77. Kac,G.,Schlüssel,M.M.,Pérez-Escamilla,R.,Velásquez-Melendez,G.&DaSilva,A.a.M.
2012.HouseholdFoodInsecurityIsNotAssociatedwithBMIforAgeorWeightforHeight
amongBrazilianChildrenAged0–60Months.PLOSONE,Vol.7No.(9):p.e45747.10.1371/journal.pone.0045747.
78. Jafari,F.,Ehsani,S.,Nadjarzadeh,A.,Esmaillzadeh,A.,Noori-Shadkam,M.&Salehi-
Abargouei,A.2017.Householdfoodinsecurityisassociatedwithabdominalbutnotgeneral
obesityamongIranianchildren.BMCPublicHealth,Vol.17No.(1):p.350.10.1186/s12889-017-4262-3.
79. Asfour,L.,Natale,R.,Uhlhorn,S.,Arheart,K.L.,Haney,K.&Messiah,S.E.2015.Ethnicity,
HouseholdFoodSecurity,andNutritionandActivityPatternsinFamiliesWithPreschool
Children.JournalofNutrition,EducationandBehavior,Vol.47No.(6):pp.498–505.e1.10.1016/j.jneb.2015.07.003.
![Page 61: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
52
80. Bhargava,A.,Jolliffe,D.&Howard,L.L.2008.Socio-economic,behaviouraland
environmentalfactorspredictedbodyweightsandhouseholdfoodinsecurityscoresinthe
EarlyChildhoodLongitudinalStudy-Kindergarten.BritishJournalofNutrition,Vol.100No.(2):pp.438–44.10.1017/s0007114508894366.
81. Bronte-Tinkew,J.,Zaslow,M.,Capps,R.,Horowitz,A.&Mcnamara,M.2007.Foodinsecurity
worksthroughdepression,parenting,andinfantfeedingtoinfluenceoverweightandhealth
intoddlers.JournalofNutrition,Vol.137No.(9):pp.2160–5.10.1093/jn/137.9.2160.
82. Trapp,C.M.,Burke,G.,Gorin,A.A.,Wiley,J.F.,Hernandez,D.,Crowell,R.E.,Grant,A.,
Beaulieu,A.&Cloutier,M.M.2015.Therelationshipbetweendietarypatterns,bodymass
indexpercentile,andhouseholdfoodsecurityinyoungurbanchildren.ChildObes,Vol.11No.(2):pp.148–55.10.1089/chi.2014.0105.
83. Schlüssel,M.M.,Silva,A.a.M.,Pérez-Escamilla,R.&Kac,G.2013.Householdfood
insecurityandexcessweight/obesityamongBrazilianwomenandchildren:alife-course
approach.CadernosdeSaúdePública,Vol.29pp.219–226.http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0102–
311X2013000200003&nrm=iso].
84. Kuku,O.,Garasky,S.&Gundersen,C.2012.Therelationshipbetweenchildhoodobesityand
foodinsecurity:anonparametricanalysis.AppliedEconomics,Vol.44No.(21):pp.2667–2677.10.1080/00036846.2011.566192.
85. Widome,R.,Neumark-Sztainer,D.,Hannan,P.J.,Haines,J.&Story,M.2009.Eatingwhen
thereisnotenoughtoeat:eatingbehaviorsandperceptionsoffoodamongfood-insecure
youths.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.99No.(5):pp.822–8.10.2105/ajph.2008.139758.
86. Buscemi,J.,Beech,B.M.&Relyea,G.2011.PredictorsofobesityinLatinochildren:
acculturationasamoderatoroftherelationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityandbodymass
indexpercentile.JournalofImmigrantandMinorityHealth,Vol.13No.(1):pp.149–54.10.1007/s10903-009-9263-6.
87. Mark,S.,Lambert,M.,O'loughlin,J.&Gray-Donald,K.2012.Householdincome,food
insecurityandnutritioninCanadianyouth.CanadianJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.103No.(2):pp.94–9.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22530529].
88. Dubois,L.,Francis,D.,Burnier,D.,Tatone-Tokuda,F.,Girard,M.,Gordon-Strachan,G.,Fox,
K.&Wilks,R.2011.HouseholdfoodinsecurityandchildhoodoverweightinJamaicaand
Québec:agender-basedanalysis.BMCPublicHealth,Vol.11p.199.10.1186/1471-2458-11-199.
89. Rosas,L.G.,Guendelman,S.,Harley,K.,Fernald,L.C.,Neufeld,L.,Mejia,F.&Eskenazi,B.
2011.FactorsassociatedwithoverweightandobesityamongchildrenofMexicandescent:
resultsofabinationalstudy.JournalofImmigrantandMinorityHealth,Vol.13No.(1):pp.169–80.10.1007/s10903-010-9332-x.
90. Smith,C.&Richards,R.2008.Dietaryintake,overweightstatus,andperceptionsoffood
insecurityamonghomelessMinnesotanyouth.AmericanJournalofHumanBiology,Vol.20No.(5):pp.550–63.10.1002/ajhb.20780.
![Page 62: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
53
91. Velásquez-Melendez,G.,Schlüssel,M.M.,Brito,A.S.,Silva,A.A.,Lopes-Filho,J.D.&Kac,G.
2011.MildbutnotlightorseverefoodinsecurityisassociatedwithobesityamongBrazilian
women.JournalofNutrition,Vol.141No.(5):pp.898–902.10.3945/jn.110.135046.
92. Jomaa,L.,Naja,F.,Cheaib,R.&Hwalla,N.2017.Householdfoodinsecurityisassociated
withahigherburdenofobesityandriskofdietaryinadequaciesamongmothersinBeirut,
Lebanon.BMCPublicHealth,Vol.17No.(1):p.567.10.1186/s12889-017-4317-5.
93. Martin,M.A.&Lippert,A.M.2012.Feedingherchildren,butriskingherhealth:the
intersectionofgender,householdfoodinsecurityandobesity.SocialScience&Medicine,Vol.74No.(11):pp.1754–64.10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.11.013.
94. Laraia,B.,Epel,E.&Siega-Riz,A.M.2013.Foodinsecuritywithpastexperienceofrestrained
eatingisarecipeforincreasedgestationalweightgain.Appetite,Vol.65pp.178–84.10.1016/j.appet.2013.01.018.
95. Laraia,B.,Vinikoor-Imler,L.C.&Siega-Riz,A.M.2015.Foodinsecurityduringpregnancy
leadstostress,disorderedeating,andgreaterpostpartumweightamongoverweight
women.Obesity(SilverSpring),Vol.23No.(6):pp.1303–11.10.1002/oby.21075.
96. Hernandez,D.C.,Reesor,L.M.&Murillo,R.2017.Foodinsecurityandadult
overweight/obesity:Genderandrace/ethnicdisparities.Appetite,Vol.117pp.373–378.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2017.07.010.
97. Martin-Fernandez,J.,Caillavet,F.,Lhuissier,A.&Chauvin,P.2014.Foodinsecurity,a
determinantofobesity?-ananalysisfromapopulation-basedsurveyintheParis
metropolitanarea,2010.ObesityFacts,Vol.7No.(2):pp.120–9.10.1159/000362343.
98. Hanson,K.L.,Sobal,J.&Frongillo,E.A.2007.Genderandmaritalstatusclarifyassociations
betweenfoodinsecurityandbodyweight.JournalofNutrition,Vol.137No.(6):pp.1460–5.10.1093/jn/137.6.1460.
99. Olson,C.M.&Strawderman,M.S.2008.Therelationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityand
obesityinruralchildbearingwomen.JournalofRuralHealth,Vol.24No.(1):pp.60-6.10.1111/j.1748-0361.2008.00138.x.
100. Weigel,M.M.&Armijos,M.M.2015.Foodinsufficiencyinthehouseholdsofreproductive-
ageEcuadorianwomen:associationwithfoodandnutritionalstatusindicators.
EcologyofFoodandNutrition,Vol.54No.(1):pp.20–42.10.1080/03670244.2014.953249.
101. Mohamadpour,M.,Sharif,Z.M.&Keysami,M.A.2012.Foodinsecurity,healthand
nutritionalstatusamongsampleofpalm-plantationhouseholdsinMalaysia.
JournalofHealth,PopulationandNutrition,Vol.30No.(3):pp.291–302.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23082631.
102. Shariff,Z.M.,Sulaiman,N.,Jalil,R.A.,Yen,W.C.,Yaw,Y.H.,Taib,M.N.,Kandiah,M.&Lin,
K.G.2014.Foodinsecurityandthemetabolicsyndromeamongwomenfromlowincome
communitiesinMalaysia.AsiaPacificJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.23No.(1):pp.138–47.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24561982.
![Page 63: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
54
103. Whitaker,R.C.&Sarin,A.2007.Changeinfoodsecuritystatusandchangeinweightarenot
associatedinurbanwomenwithpreschoolchildren.JournalofNutrition,Vol.137No.(9):pp.2134–9.10.1093/jn/137.9.2134.
104. Ghattas,H.,Barbour,J.M.,Nord,M.,Zurayk,R.&Sahyoun,N.R.2013.Householdfood
securityisassociatedwithagriculturallivelihoodsanddietqualityinamarginalized
communityofruralBedouinsinLebanon.JournalofNutrition,Vol.143No.(10):pp.1666–71.10.3945/jn.113.176388.
105. Chaput,J.P.,Gilbert,J.A.&Tremblay,A.2007.Relationshipbetweenfoodinsecurityand
bodycompositioninUgandanslivinginurbanKampala.JournaloftheAmericanDieteticAssociation,Vol.107No.(11):pp.1978–82.10.1016/j.jada.2007.08.005.
106. Vuong,T.N.,Gallegos,D.&Ramsey,R.2015.Householdfoodinsecurity,diet,andweight
statusinadisadvantageddistrictofHoChiMinhCity,VietNam:across-sectionalstudy.
BMCPublicHealth,Vol.15p.232.10.1186/s12889-015-1566-z.
107. Oh,S.Y.&Hong,M.J.2003.Foodinsecurityisassociatedwithdietaryintakeandbodysize
ofKoreanchildrenfromlow-incomefamiliesinurbanareas.EuropeanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.57No.(12):pp.1598–604.10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601877.
108. Kaiser,L.L.&Townsend,M.S.2005.FoodInsecurityAmongUSChildren:Implicationsfor
NutritionandHealth.TopicsinClinicalNutrition,Vol.20No.(4).].
109. Schaible,U.E.&Kaufmann,S.H.2007.Malnutritionandinfection:complexmechanisms
andglobalimpacts.PLoSMed,Vol.4No.(5):p.e115.10.1371/journal.pmed.0040115.
110. Cook,J.T.,Frank,D.A.,Berkowitz,C.,Black,M.M.,Casey,P.H.,Cutts,D.B.,Meyers,A.F.,
Zaldivar,N.,Skalicky,A.,Levenson,S.,Heeren,T.&Nord,M.2004.Foodinsecurityis
associatedwithadversehealthoutcomesamonghumaninfantsandtoddlers.JournalofNutrition,Vol.134No.(6):pp.1432–8.10.1093/jn/134.6.##.
111. Smedley,B.D.,Syme,S.L.,Health,C.O.C.O.S.S.&Public's,B.R.T.I.T.2001.Promoting
health:interventionstrategiesfromsocialandbehavioralresearch.AmericanJournalofHealthPromotion,Vol.15No.(3):pp.149–66.10.4278/0890-1171-15.3.149.
112. Almond,D.,Hoynes,H.W.&Schanzenbach,D.W.2011.Insidethewaronpoverty:The
impactoffoodstampsonbirthoutcomes.TheReviewofEconomicsandStatistics,Vol.93No.(2):pp.387-403.doi:10.1162/REST_a_00089.
113. Tarasuk,V.S.2001.Householdfoodinsecuritywithhungerisassociatedwithwomen'sfood
intakes,healthandhouseholdcircumstances.JournalofNutrition,Vol.131No.(10):pp.2670–6.10.1093/jn/131.10.2670.
114. Mcintyre,L.,Glanville,N.T.,Raine,K.D.,Dayle,J.B.,Anderson,B.&Battaglia,N.2003.Do
low-incomelonemotherscompromisetheirnutritiontofeedtheirchildren?CanadianMedicalAssociationJournal,Vol.168No.(6):pp.686–91.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12642423].
115. Mcisaac,K.E.,Stock,D.C.&Lou,W.2017.Householdfoodsecurityandbreast-feeding
durationamongCanadianInuit.PublicHealthNutrition,Vol.20No.(1):pp.64–71.10.1017/s136898001600166x.
![Page 64: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
55
116. Zubieta,A.C.,Melgar-Quinonez,H.&Taylor,C.2006.BreastfeedingpracticesinUShouseholdsbyfoodsecuritystatus.PaperpresentedattheExperimentalBiology2006.San
Francisco,Available:https://www.fasebj.org/doi/abs/10.1096/fasebj.20.5.A1004-d2006].
117. Arimond,M.&Ruel,M.T.2004.Dietarydiversityisassociatedwithchildnutritionalstatus:
evidencefrom11demographicandhealthsurveys.JournalofNutrition,Vol.134No.(10):pp.2579–85.10.1093/jn/134.10.2579.
118. Stewart,C.P.,Iannotti,L.,Dewey,K.G.,Michaelsen,K.F.&Onyango,A.W.2013.
Contextualisingcomplementaryfeedinginabroaderframeworkforstuntingprevention.
MaternalandChildNutritionVol.9Suppl2pp.27–45.10.1111/mcn.12088.
119. Black,M.M.,Baqui,A.H.,Zaman,K.,ElArifeen,S.&Black,R.E.2009.Maternaldepressive
symptomsandinfantgrowthinruralBangladesh.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.89No.(3):pp.951S–957S.10.3945/ajcn.2008.26692E.
120. Ke,J.&Ford-Jones,E.L.2015.Foodinsecurityandhunger:Areviewoftheeffectsonchildren'shealthandbehaviour.PaediatricsandChildHealth,Vol.20No.(2):pp.89–91.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25838782].
121. Zaslow,M.J.&Eldred,C.A.1998.ParentingBehaviorinaSampleofYoungMothersinPoverty:ResultsoftheNewChanceObservationalStudy.(alsoavailableat:https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED424982.pdf).
122. Casey,P.,Goolsby,S.,Berkowitz,C.,Frank,D.,Cook,J.,Cutts,D.,Black,M.M.,Zaldivar,N.,
Levenson,S.,Heeren,T.,Meyers,A.&Group,C.S.S.N.a.P.S.2004.Maternaldepression,
changingpublicassistance,foodsecurity,andchildhealthstatus.Pediatrics,Vol.113No.(2):pp.298–304.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14754941].
123. Corwin,E.J.,Murray-Kolb,L.E.&Beard,J.L.2003.Lowhemoglobinlevelisariskfactorfor
postpartumdepression.JournalofNutrition,Vol.133No.(12):pp.4139–42.10.1093/jn/133.12.4139.
124. Weinreb,L.,Wehler,C.,Perloff,J.,Scott,R.,Hosmer,D.,Sagor,L.&Gundersen,C.2002.
Hunger:itsimpactonchildren'shealthandmentalhealth.Pediatrics,Vol.110No.(4):p.e41.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12359814].
125. Katona,P.&Katona-Apte,J.2008.TheInteractionbetweenNutritionandInfection.ClinicalInfectiousDiseases,Vol.46No.(10):pp.1582–1588.10.1086/587658.
126. Pérez-Escamilla,R.,Dessalines,M.,Finnigan,M.,Pachón,H.,Hromi-Fiedler,A.&Gupta,N.
2009.HouseholdfoodinsecurityisassociatedwithchildhoodmalariainruralHaiti.JournalofNutrition,Vol.139No.(11):pp.2132–8.10.3945/jn.109.108852.
127. Gari,T.,Loha,E.,Deressa,W.,Solomon,T.&Lindtjørn,B.2018.Malariaincreasedtheriskof
stuntingandwastingamongyoungchildreninEthiopia:Resultsofacohortstudy.PLoSOne,Vol.13No.(1):p.e0190983.10.1371/journal.pone.0190983.
128. Skalicky,A.,Meyers,A.F.,Adams,W.G.,Yang,Z.,Cook,J.T.&Frank,D.A.2006.Childfood
insecurityandirondeficiencyanemiainlow-incomeinfantsandtoddlersintheUnited
States.MaternalandChildHealthJournal,Vol.10No.(2):pp.177–85.10.1007/s10995-005-0036-0.
![Page 65: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
56
129. Dixon,L.B.,Winkleby,M.A.&Radimer,K.L.2001.Dietaryintakesandserumnutrients
differbetweenadultsfromfood-insufficientandfood-sufficientfamilies:ThirdNational
HealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey,1988–1994.JournalofNutritionVol.131No.(4):pp.1232–46.10.1093/jn/131.4.1232.
130. Drewnowski,A.&Eichelsdoerfer,P.2010.CanLow-IncomeAmericansAffordaHealthy
Diet?NutritionToday,Vol.44No.(6):pp.246–249.10.1097/NT.0b013e3181c29f79.
131. Drewnowski,A.2004.Obesityandthefoodenvironment:dietaryenergydensityanddiet
costs.AmericanJournalofPreventativeMedicine,Vol.27No.(3Suppl):pp.154–62.10.1016/j.amepre.2004.06.011.
132. Drewnowski,A.&Darmon,N.2005.Theeconomicsofobesity:dietaryenergydensityand
energycost.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.82No.(1Suppl):pp.265S–273S.10.1093/ajcn/82.1.265S.
133. Moffat,T.2002.Breastfeeding,wagelabor,andinsufficientmilkinperi-urbanKathmandu,
Nepal.MedicalAnthropology,Vol.21No.(2):pp.207–30.10.1080/01459740212902.
134. Otoo,G.E.,Lartey,A.A.&Pérez-Escamilla,R.2009.Perceivedincentivesandbarriersto
exclusivebreastfeedingamongperiurbanGhanaianwomen.JournalofHumanLactation,Vol.25No.(1):pp.34–41.10.1177/0890334408325072.
135. Webb-Girard,A.,Cherobon,A.,Mbugua,S.,Kamau-Mbuthia,E.,Amin,A.&Sellen,D.W.
2012.Foodinsecurityisassociatedwithattitudestowardsexclusivebreastfeedingamong
womeninurbanKenya.MaternalandChildNutritionVol.8No.(2):pp.199–214.10.1111/j.1740-8709.2010.00272.x.
136. Hadley,C.,Tegegn,A.,Tessema,F.,Cowan,J.A.,Asefa,M.&Galea,S.2008.Foodinsecurity,
stressfullifeeventsandsymptomsofanxietyanddepressionineastAfrica:evidencefrom
theGilgelGibegrowthanddevelopmentstudy.JournalofEpidemiologyandCommunityHealth,Vol.62No.(11):pp.980–6.10.1136/jech.2007.068460.
137. Huddleston–Casas,C.,Charnigo,R.&Simmons,L.A.2009.Foodinsecurityandmaternal
depressioninrural,low-incomefamilies:alongitudinalinvestigation.PublicHealthNutrition,Vol.12No.(8):pp.1133–40.10.1017/s1368980008003650.
138. Galler,J.R.,Harrison,R.H.,Ramsey,F.,Chawla,S.&Taylor,J.2006.Postpartumfeeding
attitudes,maternaldepression,andbreastfeedinginBarbados.InfantBehaviorandDevelopment,Vol.29No.(2):pp.189–203.10.1016/j.infbeh.2005.10.005.
139. Dennis,C.L.&Mcqueen,K.2009.TheRelationshipBetweenInfant-FeedingOutcomesand
PostpartumDepression:AQualitativeSystematicReview.Pediatrics,Vol.123No.(4):p.e736.http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/123/4/e736.abstract].
140. Loopstra,R.&Tarasuk,V.2013.WhatDoesIncreasingSeverityofFoodInsecurityIndicate
forFoodInsecureFamilies?RelationshipsBetweenSeverityofFoodInsecurityandIndicators
ofMaterialHardshipandConstrainedFoodPurchasing.JournalofHunger&EnvironmentalNutrition,Vol.8No.(3):pp.337–349.10.1080/19320248.2013.817960.
![Page 66: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
57
141. Whitaker,R.C.,Phillips,S.M.&Orzol,S.M.2006.Foodinsecurityandtherisksof
depressionandanxietyinmothersandbehaviorproblemsintheirpreschool-agedchildren.
Pediatrics,Vol.118No.(3):pp.e859–68.10.1542/peds.2006-0239.
142. Jelliffe,D.B.&Jelliffe,E.F.1978.Thevolumeandcompositionofhumanmilkinpoorly
nourishedcommunities.Areview.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.31No.(3):pp.492–515.10.1093/ajcn/31.3.492.
143. Dewey,K.G.2001.Maternalandfetalstressareassociatedwithimpairedlactogenesisin
humans.JournalofNutrition,Vol.131No.(11):pp.3012S–5S.10.1093/jn/131.11.3012S.
144. Nommsen,L.A.,Lovelady,C.A.,Heinig,M.J.,Lönnerdal,B.&Dewey,K.G.1991.
Determinantsofenergy,protein,lipid,andlactoseconcentrationsinhumanmilkduringthe
first12mooflactation:theDARLINGStudy.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.53No.(2):pp.457–65.10.1093/ajcn/53.2.457.
145. Haskell,M.J.&Brown,K.H.1999.MaternalvitaminAnutritureandthevitaminAcontent
ofhumanmilk.JournalofMammaryGlandBiologyandNeoplasia,Vol.4No.(3):pp.243–57.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10527467].
146. Lesorogol,C.,Bond,C.,Dulience,S.J.L.&Iannotti,L.2018.Economicdeterminantsof
breastfeedinginHaiti:Theeffectsofpoverty,foodinsecurity,andemploymentonexclusive
breastfeedinginanurbanpopulation.MaternalandChildNutritionVol.14No.(2):p.e12524.10.1111/mcn.12524.
147. Ramakrishnan,U.,Grant,F.,Goldenberg,T.,Zongrone,A.&Martorell,R.2012.Effectof
women'snutritionbeforeandduringearlypregnancyonmaternalandinfantoutcomes:a
systematicreview.PaediatricandPerinatalEpidemiology,Vol.26Suppl1pp.285–301.10.1111/j.1365-3016.2012.01281.x.
148. Mcelrath,T.F.,Hecht,J.L.,Dammann,O.,Boggess,K.,Onderdonk,A.,Markenson,G.,
Harper,M.,Delpapa,E.,Allred,E.N.,Leviton,A.&Investigators,E.S.2008.Pregnancy
disordersthatleadtodeliverybeforethe28thweekofgestation:anepidemiologic
approachtoclassification.AmericalJournalofEpidemiology,Vol.168No.(9):pp.980–9.10.1093/aje/kwn202.
149. Kramer,M.S.1987.Determinantsoflowbirthweight:methodologicalassessmentand
meta-analysis.BulletinoftheWorldHealthOrganization,Vol.65No.(5):pp.663–737.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3322602].
150. Law,C.M.,Barker,D.J.,Osmond,C.,Fall,C.H.&Simmonds,S.J.1992.Earlygrowthand
abdominalfatnessinadultlife.JournalofEpidemiologyandCommunityHealth,Vol.46No.(3):pp.184–6.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1645067].
151. Olson,C.M.,Bove,C.F.&Miller,E.O.2007.Growinguppoor:long-termimplicationsfor
eatingpatternsandbodyweight.Appetite,Vol.49No.(1):pp.198–207.10.1016/j.appet.2007.01.012.
152. D'argenio,A.,Mazzi,C.,Pecchioli,L.,DiLorenzo,G.,Siracusano,A.&Troisi,A.2009.Early
traumaandadultobesity:ispsychologicaldysfunctionthemediatingmechanism?
PhysiologyandBehavior,Vol.98No.(5):pp.543–6.10.1016/j.physbeh.2009.08.010.
![Page 67: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
58
153. Greenfield,E.A.&Marks,N.F.2009.Violencefromparentsinchildhoodandobesityin
adulthood:usingfoodinresponsetostressasamediatorofrisk.SocialScienceandMedicine,Vol.68No.(5):pp.791–8.10.1016/j.socscimed.2008.12.004.
154. Dhurandhar,E.J.2016.Thefood-insecurityobesityparadox:Aresourcescarcityhypothesis.Physiology&Behavior,Vol.162pp.88–92.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2016.04.025.
155. Laran,J.&Salerno,A.2013.Life-historystrategy,foodchoice,andcaloricconsumption.
PsychologicalScience,Vol.24No.(2):pp.167–73.10.1177/0956797612450033.
156. Briers,B.,Pandelaere,M.,Dewitte,S.&Warlop,L.2006.HungryforMoney:TheDesirefor
CaloricResourcesIncreasestheDesireforFinancialResourcesandViceVersa.PsychologicalScience,Vol.17No.(11):pp.939–943.10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01808.x.
157. Jones,S.J.,Jahns,L.,Laraia,B.&Haughton,B.2003.Lowerriskofoverweightinschool-agedfoodinsecuregirlswhoparticipateinfoodassistance:resultsfromthepanelstudyof
incomedynamicschilddevelopmentsupplement.ArchivesofPediatricsandAdolescentMedecine,Vol.157No.(8):pp.780–4.10.1001/archpedi.157.8.780.
158. Townsend,M.S.,Peerson,J.,Love,B.,Achterberg,C.&Murphy,S.P.2001.Foodinsecurity
ispositivelyrelatedtooverweightinwomen.JournalofNutrition,Vol.131No.(6):pp.1738–45.10.1093/jn/131.6.1738.
159. Wilde,P.E.&Ranney,C.K.2000.TheMonthlyFoodStampCycle:ShoppingFrequencyand
FoodIntakeDecisionsinanEndogenousSwitchingRegressionFramework.AmericanJournalofAgriculturalEconomics,Vol.82No.(1):pp.200–213.http://www.jstor.org/stable/1244489].
160. Dietz,W.H.1995.Doeshungercauseobesity?Pediatrics,Vol.95No.(5):pp.766–7.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7724321].
161. Drewnowski,A.&Specter,S.E.2004.Povertyandobesity:theroleofenergydensityandenergycosts.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.79No.(1):pp.6–16.10.1093/ajcn/79.1.6.
162. Rao,M.,Afshin,A.,Singh,G.&Mozaffarian,D.2013.Dohealthierfoodsanddietpatterns
costmorethanlesshealthyoptions?Asystematicreviewandmeta-analysis.BMJOpen,Vol.3No.(12):p.e004277.10.1136/bmjopen-2013-004277.
163. Rose,D.&Oliveira,V.1997.Nutrientintakesofindividualsfromfood-insufficient
householdsintheUnitedStates.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.87No.(12):pp.1956–61.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9431283].
164. Kendall,A.,Olson,C.M.&Frongillo,E.A.1996.Relationshipofhungerandfoodinsecurity
tofoodavailabilityandconsumption.JournaloftheAmericanDieteticAssociation,Vol.96No.(10):pp.1019–24;quiz1025-6.10.1016/s0002-8223(96)00271-4.
165. Alaimo,K.,Olson,C.M.,Frongillo,E.A.&Briefel,R.R.2001.Foodinsufficiency,family
income,andhealthinUSpreschoolandschool-agedchildren.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.91No.(5):pp.781–786.http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1446676/].
![Page 68: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
59
166. Hoffman,D.J.,Sawaya,A.L.,Verreschi,I.,Tucker,K.L.&Roberts,S.B.2000.Whyare
nutritionallystuntedchildrenatincreasedriskofobesity?Studiesofmetabolicrateandfat
oxidationinshantytownchildrenfromSãoPaulo,Brazil.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.72No.(3):pp.702–7.10.1093/ajcn/72.3.702.
167. Viswanathan,M.,Siega-Riz,A.M.,Moos,M.K.,Deierlein,A.,Mumford,S.,Knaack,J.,
Thieda,P.,Lux,L.J.&Lohr,K.N.2008.OutcomesofMaternalWeightGain.EvidenceReport/TechnologyAssessmentNo.168.Rockville,MD.(alsoavailableat:
https://www.ahrq.gov/downloads/pub/evidence/pdf/admaternal/admaternal.pdf).
168. Ward,R.K.,Jilcott,S.B.&Bethel,J.W.2011.Acculturation,FoodInsecurity,DietQuality,
andBodyMassIndexAmongPre-Conception-AgedLatinoWomeninEasternNorthCarolina.
JournalofHunger&EnvironmentalNutrition,Vol.6No.(4):pp.490–496.10.1080/19320248.2011.627300.
169. Wolin,K.Y.,Colangelo,L.A.,Chiu,B.C.&Gapstur,S.M.2009.Obesityandimmigration
amongLatinawomen.JournalofImmigrantandMinorityHealth,Vol.11No.(5):pp.428–31.10.1007/s10903-007-9115-1.
170. Ayala,G.X.,Baquero,B.&Klinger,S.2008.Asystematicreviewoftherelationshipbetween
acculturationanddietamongLatinosintheUnitedStates:implicationsforfutureresearch.
JournaloftheAmericanDieteticAssociation,Vol.108No.(8):pp.1330–44.10.1016/j.jada.2008.05.009.
171. Butte,N.F.2009.Impactofinfantfeedingpracticesonchildhoodobesity.JournalofNutrition,Vol.139No.(2):pp.412S–6S.10.3945/jn.108.097014.
172. Matheson,D.M.,Varady,J.,Varady,A.&Killen,J.D.2002.Householdfoodsecurityand
nutritionalstatusofHispanicchildreninthefifthgrade.AmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.76No.(1):pp.210–7.10.1093/ajcn/76.1.210.
173. Laraia,B.,Siega-Riz,A.M.&Gundersen,C.2010.Householdfoodinsecurityisassociated
withself-reportedpregravidweightstatus,gestationalweightgain,andpregnancy
complications.JournaloftheAmericanDieteticAssociation,Vol.110No.(5):pp.692–701.10.1016/j.jada.2010.02.014.
174. Sridhar,S.B.,Darbinian,J.,Ehrlich,S.F.,Markman,M.A.,Gunderson,E.P.,Ferrara,A.&
Hedderson,M.M.2014.Maternalgestationalweightgainandoffspringriskforchildhood
overweightorobesity.AmericanJournalofObstetricsandGynecology,Vol.211No.(3):pp.259.e1–8.10.1016/j.ajog.2014.02.030.
175. Pérez-Escamilla,R.&Bermúdez,O.2012.Earlylifenutritiondisparities:wheretheproblem
begins?AdvancesinNutrition,Vol.3No.(1):pp.71–2.10.3945/an.111.001453.
176. Alaimo,K.,Olson,C.M.&Frongillo,E.A.2002.Familyfoodinsufficiency,butnotlowfamily
income,ispositivelyassociatedwithdysthymiaandsuicidesymptomsinadolescents.JournalofNutrition,Vol.132No.(4):pp.719–25.10.1093/jn/132.4.719.
177. Cole,S.M.&Tembo,G.2011.Theeffectoffoodinsecurityonmentalhealth:panelevidence
fromruralZambia.SocialScienceandMedicine,Vol.73No.(7):pp.1071–9.10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.07.012.
![Page 69: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
60
178. Belle,D.&Doucet,J.2003.Poverty,inequality,anddiscriminationassourcesofdepression
amongU.S.women.PsychologyofWomenQuarterly,Vol.27No.(2):pp.101–113.doi:10.1111/1471-6402.00090.
179. Dallman,M.F.,Pecoraro,N.,Akana,S.F.,LaFleur,S.E.,Gomez,F.,Houshyar,H.,Bell,M.E.,
Bhatnagar,S.,Laugero,K.D.&Manalo,S.2003.Chronicstressandobesity:Anewviewof
“comfortfood”.ProceedingsoftheNationalAcademyofSciencesoftheUnitedStatesofAmerica,Vol.100No.(20):pp.11696–11701.10.1073/pnas.1934666100.
180. Epel,E.,Lapidus,R.,Mcewen,B.&Brownell,K.2001.Stressmayaddbitetoappetitein
women:alaboratorystudyofstress-inducedcortisolandeatingbehavior.
Psychoneuroendocrinology,Vol.26No.(1):pp.37–49.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11070333].
181. Pecoraro,N.,Reyes,F.,Gomez,F.,Bhargava,A.&Dallman,M.F.2004.Chronicstress
promotespalatablefeeding,whichreducessignsofstress:feedforwardandfeedbackeffects
ofchronicstress.Endocrinology,Vol.145No.(8):pp.3754–62.10.1210/en.2004-0305.
182. Atkinson,R.L.,Dietz,W.H.,Foreyt,J.P.&Etal.1994.Weightcycling.JAMA,Vol.272No.(15):pp.1196–1202.10.1001/jama.1994.03520150064038.
183. Fao.2008.AnIntroductiontotheBasicConceptsofFoodSecurity.http://www.fao.org/docrep/013/al936e/al936e00.pdf].
184. Wolfe,W.S.&Frongillo,E.A.2001.BuildingHouseholdFood-SecurityMeasurementTools
fromtheGroundUp.FoodandNutritionBulletin,Vol.22No.(1):pp.5–12.10.1177/156482650102200102.
185. WorldHealthOrganization.2015.Improvingnutritionoutcomeswithbetterwater,sanitationandhygienePracticalsolutionsforpolicyandprogrammes.Geneva.(alsoavailableat:
http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/publications/washandnutrition/en/).
186. Charmarbagwala,R.,Ranger,M.,Waddington,H.&White,H.2004.Thedeterminantsofchildhealthandnutrition:ameta-analysis.Washington,DC.(alsoavailableat:
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/505081468327413982/The-determinants-of-
child-health-and-nutrition-a-meta-analysis).
187. Bhattacharya,J.,Currie,J.&Haider,S.2004.Poverty,foodinsecurity,andnutritionaloutcomesinchildrenandadults.JournalofHealthEconomics,Vol.23No.(4):pp.839–862.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhealeco.2003.12.008.
188. Ramakrishnan,U.,Martorell,R.,Schroeder,D.G.&Flores,R.1999.Roleofintergenerational
effectsonlineargrowth.JournalofNutrition,Vol.129No.(2SSuppl):pp.544S–549S.10.1093/jn/129.2.544S.
189. Thomas,D.1997.Expenditures,andHealthOutcomes:EvidenceonIntrahouseholdResourceAllocation.Baltimore,MD,JohnHopkinsUniversityPress.(alsoavailableat:
http://ebrary.ifpri.org/cdm/ref/collection/p15738coll2/id/127320).
190. Haddad,L.&Kanbur,R.1990.HowSeriousistheNeglectofIntra-HouseholdInequality?TheEconomicJournal,Vol.100No.(402):pp.866–881.10.2307/2233663.
![Page 70: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
61
191. Quisumbing,A.R.&Smith,L.C.2007.CaseStudy4–5,IntrahouseholdAllocation,Gender
Relations,andFoodSecurityinDevelopingCountries.In:Pinstrup-Andersen,P.&Cheng,F.(eds.)FoodPolicyforDevelopingCountries:CaseStudies.(alsoavailableat:http://cip.cornell.edu/dns.gfs/1200428166).
192. Smith,L.C.,Ramakrishnan,U.,Ndiaye,A.,Haddad,L.&Martorell,R.2003.TheImportanceofWomen'sStatusforChildNutritioninDevelopingCountries.Washington,DC:
InternationalFoodPolicyResearchInstitute,2.US.(alsoavailableat:
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/6289649.pdf).
193. Darmon,N.&Drewnowski,A.2008.Doessocialclasspredictdietquality?TheAmericanJournalofClinicalNutrition,Vol.87No.(5):pp.1107–1117.10.1093/ajcn/87.5.1107.
194. Beydoun,M.A.&Wang,Y.2008.Donutritionknowledgeandbeliefsmodifytheassociation
ofsocio-economicfactorsanddietqualityamongUSadults?PreventativeMedicine,Vol.46No.(2):pp.145–53.10.1016/j.ypmed.2007.06.016.
195. Michimi,A.&Wimberly,M.C.2010.Associationsofsupermarketaccessibilitywithobesity
andfruitandvegetableconsumptionintheconterminousUnitedStates.InternationalJournalofHealthGeography,Vol.9p.49.10.1186/1476-072x-9-49.
196. Treuhaft,S.&Karpyn,A.2010.Thegrocerygap:whohasaccesstohealthyfoodsandwhyitmatters.Philadelphia,PA.(alsoavailableat:
http://thefoodtrust.org/uploads/media_items/grocerygap.original.pdf).
197. WhiteHouseTaskForceonChildhoodObesity,2010.SolvingtheProblemofChildhoodObesityWithinaGeneration:AccesstoHealthy,AffordableFood.(alsoavailableat:https://letsmove.obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/letsmove.gov/files/TaskForce_on_Ch
ildhood_Obesity_May2010_FullReport.pdf).
198. Drewnowski,A.,Aggarwal,A.,Hurvitz,P.M.,Monsivais,P.&Moudon,A.V.2012.Obesity
andsupermarketaccess:proximityorprice?AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.102No.(8):pp.e74–80.10.2105/ajph.2012.300660.
199. Galler,J.R.,Ramsey,F.C.,Harrison,R.H.,Brooks,R.&Weiskopf-Bock,S.1998.Infant
feedingpracticesinBarbadospredictlatergrowth.JournalofNutrition,Vol.128No.(8):pp.1328–35.10.1093/jn/128.8.1328.
200. Pelto,G.H.2000.Improvingcomplementaryfeedingpracticesandresponsiveparentingasa
primarycomponentofinterventionstopreventmalnutritionininfancyandearlychildhood.
Pediatrics,Vol.106No.(5):p.1300.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11061843].
201. Unicef.2001.Povertyandchildren:lessonsofthe90sforleastdevelopedcountries.NewYork.(alsoavailableat:
https://www.unicef.org/publications/files/pub_poverty_children_ldcs_en.pdf).
202. Richard,S.A.,Black,R.E.&Checkley,W.2012.Revisitingtherelationshipofweightand
heightinearlychildhood.AdvancesinNutrition,Vol.3No.(2):pp.250–4.10.3945/an.111.001099.
203. Victora,C.G.1992.Theassociationbetweenwastingandstunting:aninternationalperspective.JournalofNutrition,Vol.122No.(5):pp.1105–10.10.1093/jn/122.5.1105.
![Page 71: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
62
204. BenjaminNeelon,S.E.,Burgoine,T.,Gallis,J.A.&Monsivais,P.2017.Spatialanalysisof
foodinsecurityandobesitybyarea-leveldeprivationinchildreninearlyyearssettingsin
England.SpatialandSpatio-temporalEpidemiology,Vol.23pp.1–9.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sste.2017.07.001.
205. Freedman,D.S.,Wang,J.,Maynard,L.M.,Thornton,J.C.,Mei,Z.,Pierson,R.N.,Dietz,W.
H.&Horlick,M.2005.RelationofBMItofatandfat-freemassamongchildrenand
adolescents.InternationalJournalofObesity,Vol.29No.(1):pp.1–8.10.1038/sj.ijo.0802735.
206. Sobal,J.&Stunkard,A.J.1989.Socioeconomicstatusandobesity:areviewoftheliterature.
PsychologicalBulletin,Vol.105No.(2):pp.260–75.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2648443].
207. Lohman,B.J.,Stewart,S.,Gundersen,C.,Garasky,S.&Eisenmann,J.C.2009.Adolescent
overweightandobesity:linkstofoodinsecurityandindividual,maternal,andfamily
stressors.JournalofAdolescentHealth,Vol.45No.(3):pp.230–7.10.1016/j.jadohealth.2009.01.003.
208. Gundersen,C.,Lohman,B.J.,Garasky,S.,Stewart,S.&Eisenmann,J.2008.Foodsecurity,
maternalstressors,andoverweightamonglow-incomeUSchildren:resultsfromthe
NationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey(1999–2002).Pediatrics,Vol.122No.(3):pp.e529–40.10.1542/peds.2008-0556.
209. Lyons,A.A.,Park,J.&Nelson,C.H.2008.Foodinsecurityandobesity:acomparisonofself-
reportedandmeasuredheightandweight.AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.98No.(4):pp.751–7.10.2105/ajph.2006.093211.
210. Angrist,J.D.&Krueger,A.B.1999.Empiricalstrategiesinlaboreconomics.InAshenfelter&
Card,eds.HandbookofLaborEconomics,pp.1277–1366.Elsevier.1999].
211. Hernandez,D.C.&Jacknowitz,A.2009.Transient,butnotpersistent,adultfoodinsecurityinfluencestoddlerdevelopment.JournalofNutrition,Vol.139No.(8):pp.1517–24.10.3945/jn.109.105593.
212. Pérez-Escamilla,R.&PinheiroDeToledoVianna,R.2012.Foodinsecurityandthe
behaviouralandintellectualdevelopmentofchildren:Areviewoftheevidence.JournalofAppliedResearchonChildren:InformingPolicyforChildrenatRisk,Vol.3No.(1).].
213. Jacknowitz,A.&Morrissey,T.2012.FoodInsecurityAcrosstheFirstFiveYears:Triggersof
OnsetandExit.DiscussionPaperSeries2012-08[Online].https://uknowledge.uky.edu/ukcpr_papers/34/].
214. Ribar,D.C.&Edelhoch,M.2008.EarningsVolatilityandtheReasonsforLeavingtheFood
StampProgram.InJolliffe,D.&Ziliak,J.P.,eds.In:IncomevolatilityandfoodassistanceintheUnitedStates,pp.63–102.Kalamazoo,MI,W.E.UpjohnInstitute.Available:
http://research.upjohn.org/up_bookchapters/9/2008].
215. Kac,G.,Velásquez-Melendez,G.,Schlüssel,M.M.,Segall-Côrrea,A.M.,Silva,A.A.&Pérez-
Escamilla,R.2012.SeverefoodinsecurityisassociatedwithobesityamongBrazilian
adolescentfemales.PublicHealthNutrition,Vol.15No.(10):pp.1854–60.10.1017/s1368980011003582.
![Page 72: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
63
216. Oliveira,J.S.,Lira,P.I.C.D.,Veras,I.C.L.,Maia,S.R.,Lemos,M.D.C.C.D.,Andrade,S.L.L.
S.D.,VianaJunior,M.J.,Pinto,F.C.D.L.,Leal,V.S.&BatistaFilho,M.2009.Estado
nutricionaleinsegurançaalimentardeadolescenteseadultosemduaslocalidadesdebaixo
índicededesenvolvimentohumano.RevistadeNutrição,Vol.22pp.453–465.].
217. Gundersen,C.,Lohman,B.J.,Eisenmann,J.C.,Garasky,S.&Stewart,S.D.2008.Child-
specificfoodinsecurityandoverweightarenotassociatedinasampleof10-to15-year-old
low-incomeyouth.JournalofNutrition,Vol.138No.(2):pp.371–8.10.1093/jn/138.2.371.
218. Gundersen,C.,Garasky,S.&Lohman,B.J.2009.Foodinsecurityisnotassociatedwith
childhoodobesityasassessedusingmultiplemeasuresofobesity.JournalofNutrition,Vol.139No.(6):pp.1173–8.10.3945/jn.109.105361.
219. Martin,K.S.&Ferris,A.M.2007.Foodinsecurityandgenderareriskfactorsforobesity.JournalofNutrition,EducationandBehavior,Vol.39No.(1):pp.31–6.10.1016/j.jneb.2006.08.021.
220. Millimet,D.L.&Roy,M.2015.Partialidentificationofthelong-runcausaleffectoffood
securityonchildhealth.EmpiricalEconomics,Vol.48No.(1):pp.83–141.10.1007/s00181-014-0867-x.
221. Rose,D.&Bodor,J.N.2006.Householdfoodinsecurityandoverweightstatusinyoungschoolchildren:resultsfromtheEarlyChildhoodLongitudinalStudy.Pediatrics,Vol.117No.(2):pp.464–73.10.1542/peds.2005-0582.
![Page 73: A review of studies examining the link between food ...relevant to the Global Nutrition Targets 2025 (15) as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eliminate](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042911/5f41e23bbb0d8d292c50bdd1/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
CA1447EN/1/09.18
ISBN 978-92-5-130942-1
9 7 8 9 2 5 1 3 0 9 4 2 1