a#room: currier poker rm start: 3:30pm jvp ayaz, abdullah harvard high school jv 6 cambridge, ma...

Room: G & P 103 Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Allen, Ben

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Cambridge, MA February 16"t8, 2012

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POS

I l

~ -

POINTS RANKS

Arbor View OS Max= 30

r I POS

Kristina Diaz~ --~-

)~.~ 3 'j_ Adrianna Simmons Q9.j ~ 9--

The better debating was done by the A#AFf or NEG

POINTS

Sequoyah CW Max= 30

Tate Cook 3o Eva Whitley ~~./

from Ar_, 1/ltLJ 0 Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

RANKS

I L(

Signed:~ ~--~---------------------~

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

Room: Hilles P02 Start: 3:30pm

( j\1P5 ,......,___ ,~

c::__(A/L) 7

AFFIRMATIVE POS Casady-CC

"---.I (

---6~ ( ~-

Antigua, Jorman ---~ --------------- -~ ~-- .---...,___

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV .

POINTS Max• 30

Cambridge, MA February 16-18, 2012

NEGATIVE RANKS POS

Kugnus Acts CJ POINTS RANKS Max• 30

I Agnish Chakraburtty 2_)5.5" ~ 2- Andrew Choi <-9_7 ·'2--.

"L- Conner Coles 'Z.~ ' ----- I ---- -I Hye Jeon 2p;; y

I

The better debating was done by the 8 Pp from {.' /"5 ,,, ,j AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT1NAME

Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

Signed:~~-


R FD: (}(-12 CA-ri 11 ) p-e/ r~ -J-r.) S"J-Jc cp Pesotu--t) Di 5 -tl3o fJf} f f?r/" t-vl,,.,J .?1/J)c

.::;!vr /7

Room: Currier Poker Rm Start: 3:30pm JVP

Ayaz, Abdullah

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV

6


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS Loyola WW Max= 30

POS POINTS RANKS East Mountain KN Max= 30

2 Javon Williams 27.Y -z. ) Nicolas Kennedy '2.7.3 3 J Anthony Ward 21.5" I ~ Quinter Nyland .......... _...., ..... y ... ....

The better debating was done by the A(.f from low/CI'-AFF or NEG -TE.::A~M'...j.IO:..:::R...:.CO...:.N_T_ES-T-AN_T_N-AM_E __ _

~~-~


Signed C(Jhi4L ~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

---1~0 0 ~Ct> IV!-0-e-k haM >o (LAPS. ->fwc-h-~ u(JUnc.e_ orN&/ aff ~s lhJ-. n ' 7 .; ~~ o6 ntJ;f- co~ fc.tY · ··

Hv SVJt>tA).. ~ hu.J ~ -~ cvlOv'v(_ ~ -e.,y_. C- .(,.v J..L

vh' c r ~-,;..,,,. ""' ~ ...._ ( "'.J.., ,J.-~o , , "" s..er.,J,J... .fi..t... o. U.

- l-w11 ~ ;, ypvy I osrc.. ~ ~ uJ. ct ~

-1--W ~.f-{-- YIM'F S-f-1/l t-~lA-- b c:

t{ ; I'V\(?C.. c.f fflk-e C) v+-. o f'- i mp4.. cA--Ie~Htt c.!-f.t>r.

~oV'.. ta~ 5-fv{'k r--a < a))_ )ece n k

8011-f ~wt~ ca))_ ~ ~'cs/hlto~ '-) IU( VJc&.h ctJ-Jr_ ?

.fkJr 1-) 1-J,

~av k ~'r;_V\ A{'h.~~ .. s~~ )v

v-er -~~rJ.

C ~t'A~J-t~ 1. ec,.

;n'cn 1-cJ..A<-:,+-fWt ~ t-lh + f-Olr fc -e l'lfi--Vl'<>

{_1Ju)- yv~,J\,J- '_t,u\IJ..- \:>c AM-) , Pp-J c4

Room: PfoHo Moors 3 Start: 3:30pm 6 Barnum, Miriam JVP

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Cambridge, MA February 16-18, 2012


\ ~

~1POINTS RANKS

Pine Crest Preparator B ~Max=30 POS

Divya Bhansali ~t- ~ l

Mellissa Chang r;.s tr 1-

The better debating was done by the \.J£~ AFF or NEG

Atholton AS

Am an Aggarwal

Isabel Slavinsky

from A~ho\\oo TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME


Signed:


QrQ;l

POINTS RANKS Max= 30

J-1,<6 'L 2<3,3 ' -


6 Bartholomae, Mat


~.~J~ ,;,~~.<)\,1._,~ p..rls-1 saJ~ .sl"""~~ \( I '1<>!' ~ !W"~-C,.sW-.

J{\L~ NoJs ... ~,~~>JW""~ we.-1 UMiJ ~-e;ttJ ~ ;1,~ ~ w>( ~ ~~ 3 1""-'~U 'f"' jw:X -\lrwJ ~ ~ ~,J-+h- br-\, """( ~

~ J~ ~ s«~/-b,cr~o~ ~ ";;~ JoL upL:y ~~K; W::J:,.) ~c ),~iw1o -j/;..,,- ~~~ /y,IGj

~~~.~~~~~1 rH-1J. ~~~ y..l'ov ~ j,~\\ ~(tA-'<aJ ~ c~~ ) 0~ VJV~

'


6 Basler, David

AFFIRMATIVE - -- - -- ----- -----

POS Stuyvesant CG

rt,... Mindi Cao


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS Max= 30 Agape Leaders Prep LH

u-:z. .. 1,.. r Monicaa Lee

\ Daniel Goynatsky t.'t. fo I 1- Ashley Han

The better debating was done by the A~~ from ~1l)"(v~A-rll TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

n this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

~~--


21.\, J '2..1 '-1

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: !J5: ~- LA,.r~ '11\<l..t.JI!S -1.14!-t> ,. -puo..J · s·~s ""c" """ .pJ-J ,....,.-- ,,.._ ,.,~. ,....,

(it wdt.. 7. rllll1 r-JI:Rs:?) )~ tL~~'fV'l-,u.;r-.~L-r trPF. ttl<-- ~~~ll1!.- ,crt/111'1 /It< t.J~TIA.. , t.~ r J\11[71"HV"- u ~·'-'-+< ,.. ...,_,,.... .JI.ft-1:>

;.---- ~ M ,.<.e c.<> lri<;;o JO ,rr<>? 'f - o-f>vl I<-. W ->i<-9 t .-vi~ f'/<,o.-1 '1<-'f f OL'l./3 / '7_?1

~ " ('lt-'PI - I J.WU lr /.14<4' 'f7MI!' pUv-t.-< 'rtrJ"-- .lvi'I><-P'\'5 r o-.Jt:"<-'1~ 1' --- ~·""? pyt,s ; ...... ..,.,,...,_, 1-#U> ')<> ""'.__,._ .~ 'r - •• ~.,.,.,~ ~ '<•'-' (..0

{'t-c ,_..,I $• ""v1V' "3 P\SO' - ~ 1>-;:}tu 1' P"' '-~--' ~- 11?1-)!cf ~ J tt< 1. t.r.!U' i" f't->J 'I ,.d e.¥ 1 " - Ak n-t1SO"-"1' ., » ..,fJ-t, ~-=-' ----- 1\ !' \L. pl-tlv'j

I ,J,t. - r1 ~- •• • • JU g..;{ "'-' r 't•" 4<C ~"f1A. '-t•.J"-- r> _.._,. ""'' 1>-1 '!'", .::..;,.;..- I \.1-l't '-1> A-t-:S 0 >111. 'l<~.J f"""'\~.SI::!J) jv·J~c..~..J.UIY.J ~...,_,$' d·,.~ So'WJ ~~

.:.-- ;,:.;--- ) 05 ruz[.llu...,. "', J""" 't¢ ""'- "-",_,I ~,_, "? . lhf:-- )/,A--?1./L. - ~~ ~\S'/1-.J~ -~

¢- (\~ $/Lt.~<l {,W4Lvo-\ ""'' ~ •fftl>'<.'""''s.r P~ ~vT"''-'k 1r '-1•"

1>"-o ff\11'> A-...JV{.."""! u-l n-hr IL 'tt.o-' !.NI:-' T Pv-<-.

1.AA- ,...., ("''.,.!.:"' I? l - t;,.-tl;r4-r AI~ vrJ-41.. . Y<:. v :1+1 r /-1-t--<-.. ~ I<. 5' 0 F'l ..(""(" o 15' ~ .

tf1' ~ }J i:ft. 1-f.A\-S It L~ ,- C F l .-J tL o ..l 'RT~ p-L-6vJ '6v'l (\-Ff? 1+1-) /1-7 ~> ') tJ. ICl. U::. ,.J c t:n-'1.55" 17+4-r H-~:?Z 4 ~ c C) t+~~ r s1ta., , .-1 n+t .~ t-tJv.J o .

~vL--1/ {DUr--l-rrt ror """'u,-v¥-c'f ~Lv~iA/1.!" p0u· '7't:> t2-tR.Jo...ltrL He:z.e:.---,_o..Jf

pL LL/,-JI.. 4-J( (C).A<f{_ v-1-ecvv~ ('T-Htf If (4-P) - J,J'G" ~I..!L"VJ 11~ For( lWZ-f)i:!"(.L 7 VJo~c.,l~ • ' A • ..II "' - . ·- - .rJv-7.. .

Room: Cabot TVNid Rm Start: 3:30pm 6 Bleyle, Britney JVP


G.

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POINTS I RANKS Max= 30

POS POINTS RANKS

G. Holmes Braddock DT Max= 30 Pos 1Achievement F,irst SW

~I Eyana Walker ~ Randy Diaz ~~~~ 1 '

~~it (). I Elizabeth Tejeda I I . Khaliq Spruill

The better debating was done by the I\ reO\ from f.-; Ur)!m £l7 ·~. d dDc ~· ~ ~OR~EwN~E .. f\. Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

Signed:~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

S vo~J heO) b e[AA se ~ . · . ' 6l·-

the;~tli~ eo~ f ~+e.~) +o~We -.ofFD J!t~q b~e 1i06Gdr~.1h;)lt_ 0\MW d-Ni/cJ[fjeJdaJ5 ~ ~ DJp;zHAcJ-6ppeJ !YA~ CP' ~ .

A-t+: f)J~ l.j- reJ--+hen~~~cyt(Cro3~~~~l . :. Rbll'lC'frl W +o ·~ Af\SWerll,d1l~~~ M\ ~arf..d£

. ~~ n~ ':JOm-eff:,'n~ rs WMAII~ . ~ ~ 10fY!n~ I c~ ~ iht4~0 i ltl~, NJ ~&J v'lfg!Afl'el\15 1n /lit,

K£0·. ~ U\l1kin oV~>f6f\ lNtot coJl/NBI'Jf& lnJAC~IM C()S~ OfjVVvttrt5tn ~0 U{c_(o5S-e>t. t6~~ \J o(K Dfl C(~~~ -:;orne, llYl'-f )0\.St' ex:ftflJ QL( ds \a'\ d W f- J ~ eeJ· f)1or&xp ~ ncc+t on pfar ds/ ~Vtli\eft\c A l7o, remt~n tl¥' . .J...f'lfA9if' nr I "".r:- i lfHAV .l.-itmP · ... · J,


6 Cheung, William


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POS Boston Debate League (

POINTS RANKS jax= 30

POS St. Pius X BK

( Henry Chavez &1A !L. Z; -Joe Bruckner

(_ Michael John rL11L ( lJ Justin Kalan

The better debating was done by the ti4t.\-· from e o ~~ AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME


Signed:~···


u~/9 - 9

)

'Z7. ~ I


(1-1& t,J~~(1w_ej! ~f/A.v) & ~~~ }) /~~ piw111frf-C-{JM,

fU [.(__ (iv~ ~ft. I t-- rl~t\: fl!A 1'\ LJ k"' Mtcw\ 1 t f'¥\. s'., (t£ I

Zbk- - ltrc(L <>.. f /WI. CY\. </LL C (J '3 '

)~ak -fvvt. c1MfrAtf- ()lYI(fttrro

c{f(lc ~w~ y "" <~ ~·r fl/e<Fr cu> ~7 ,( ~)lnl-)lv,.tL . ~~ ~ fu_. if_ -~- vt-. i-h(&vk.- ~--~-· ~

Cfil{__ , ,____~ a~/-¥f-c<-' l'A"'~

lf\ IL ~ J t.k )'}-- J} ~,j~tfvh~,f--ovvefY1 cc.J__ t-w e.~ fie_

L ;<f.(Jc I } wr ""'?1--'

'if'/tvL OV\ ~ ~- IJL~.(--tv ~ lP

Room: Cabot Junior CR Start: 3:30pm 6 Choudhury, Maneo JVP

AFFIRMATIVE POS Centennial DL

\ Connor Driscoll

l Kevin Li


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS Max= 30

POS Bronx Science HH

2B.~ ~ 2 Sara Huang

2~~·7 ) i Yiwen Huang

The better debating was done by the A ff- from C@f( fJ.fll~ / TEAM OR CONTSTANT NAME AFForNEG


Signed: v w v v --v~ /144~_e;,e



2J:J 2 '78,£ ~


6 Cisneros, Bridge


NEGATIVE POINTS I RANKS I I POS POINTS RANKS Max= 30 Calhoun KW Max= 30

Rachel Nadboy

~~~ Hannah Ku !__9 e_

Masha Morozov 1 Z6.) 3 Alyssa Waters £8.~ t



~ ~

MLClRd -Cr~ ~f- ~-uJtn ~<t~J. Yl·,~~n ~ o~c~) ~, hcu_~~(\ ~xo ~~~

~~ J:t LtXW ~Um ~ all, tlt

'L\J·\~~ tied ~ ~iW ~at ~ ~ ~oA ~ ~~~~ 6o1 ~\a r-~cl ~v~ .~ ~ wbuJ& ~ l;,wt_ Ulil~ glrul ~ d~~ ~WJ( J l(U\Q\ W&ll (Lbfrt(;o ~1 M0*ll J ti0 I tw 1 de (i~~~~ --

~GJVV\Ovh I AiRj ~ ja____

]? ~ ~ i:LJ H()ufl ('l{M X IiliA ·th_t ~ ~OtA sh90ot had Qs~kecf ~OL(_~ weM 61lv fb ~~ U.m ~ htlAJ\L th !UtJ io bt ~(JJ_({ ( ~ ~ fu t1~ 6 b-e /wwJ he~r.e ~D Li\1~/f

.c M flM ~~~ fu '~j11

QJ,_d,. ~ S-k ,. ~<_QM c ~ l 1UJJ k.Qd ctuJ~ :t ~Mt Ukt ~ -tlamtrL~

(8() K<?r 0-fjl-Q-o.MJ.'\~ ~ ~

"'---·····


6 Clark, Karla


AFFIRMATIVE POS Boston Debate League\ rJGNTS = 30

Ted White lA 'l.8 Darien Amado t.p, 't1.9


NEGATIVE RANKS POS

Lakeland District Deb B

l Jatin Barwhani tN ~ Humza Tahir ltv


1..1 11 l..f Z1.8 ~

The better debating was done by the ~ from ~bY\ ~ I JJ n D. V(.. AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME ~



c\ 0\1 'o \L $() \ve.nwt

~ laretf -n~o~~~L

'P-· \)v . ~6\\~.


6 Huley, ~ifer

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Coe_ Cambridge, MA February 16-18, 2012

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POS POINTS RANKS

Atholton RZ Max= 30 POINTS I RANKS

Pos 1Aaaoe Leaders Preo PY 1 Max= 3o

·2 Adam Pahlavan c9:.1 ~-,· lftiJ 2 Advait Ramanan 3o I r Johann Yang ?_{o .(o ~ Lf I Simon Zhu '?.. tt f <:

--- ----· ---- --- --- --- -- -- -

The better debating was done by the A r {;I'_ from (J,Tllorrtu.J R ~ EAM OR CONTESTANT NAME


Signed: ~ ----.. ;n~;:e ;;:;;;:";;::;'~ lht ~ ~ ~. v tvi/1 vl?l4/!t ft'lf ~ !W"/JtJI>-IJ ~.iA ~A·--- _ _ _ _ _ .. _ . · _ . - --0 w ~ r;u;;(f!l"

1/JN-JJ)k~~~~c ~~-~ !lrt~r;{-t/u ~~u6 ~~-~~~~~~

~ ~-p~ ~ mfflR ~ ~ rmt/JJ ~ ~. j;u f1J/wl ~ iJJ &t lll£p lku> Qmtf ~ o.n.t on -tt'{ 1v.;ict ~ d rJ ~ lk ~~uti /4;. L~R-~#ron~ ~;~ c4iw~~kwwi.e

.IJ. o1 Al . . : lk ~IJ-R o/ceo Ov Nllitteltr~ o/ ,~ Cf 01 )JU<J11f11 '

~ ~ ~~ <TIA/;M!IW~ ~ufJ'1fo~ ~D'71S,~OMJ~d ~ fl71 Pktu!/~. 1M ~ wuJ.t> w.!Jz.A£ 6 ~ r/utu ~; ~ M/fJuf /& '#;; IE ~ ~ &dikf/4,)/ ~-


6 Cole, Donnel


AFFIRMATIVE

,f I Bradley Sheen

;ry,


NEGATIVE POS

Lexington LS

J Matt Liu

J_ Zack Steigerwald-Schn

The better debating was done by the NEG from AFF or NEG


Signed:-----------------


--r1Jt fe.q Jf/171/h )ekah c/ve P -fh (:.c,t- /hy ftt ;;,n kef a k-/fr /{';vi? ,k,-//" /7, 7h. /f f ;C Wct5 N~ fvt/iq/ /Jpf lilts Wus nul- fir c/terdtJ ~r /KIA/S (Of/nd. 7/u Iff fltl11 5 f"-'..CS/&n<?-4 P!Fic/ nfe4f~s.s c;rbev f. 1~1"/c:~;~Jy

Av/)'lttl/rly 6v-.J-c/)Nfr t1'-f/-~ a;xue_'J, $-;:;> /"1-. 1/ff j/e//"ft'c/ tu/rel1 1/v. ~c:J-, ;Jiflv/dee-1 C{~fle;;_, w-14:/~ c·~vnle/' JP){(/J JV/;,c~ Wi:t5 af1J '11drttlvv !~-f /A,r iVttS a cfsqjh,/-rl«7f pu,ftz.e-v-j

C{ 6~/;;ce,f1Ct/:,/e /11'~ kl'teh":/-, ~At /llj vt~oc{~/- //t-'/"/()P'iJ2.e..

w-ell {/f/ 4 I '&h kdlc) lo. !Ia C If:'~ ,


-;)7rl; If n91JJI. '1¥-l' t;( ,..,

Room: Hilles 107 Start: 3:30pm JVP

AFFIRMATIVE - --- --

POS River Hill DK

2- Alexis Datta

I Athena Kan

6 Cook, Bill


NEGATIVE ----------


POS

Ransom Everglades PG

'2-1.-r ~?- f Zachary Perlman -r

~ ( "2-- Andrew Geraghty


2L 'f 2f J

The better debating was done by the A-F F from I{' V C t2... I+, L-L- j) K AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: /1/'tJ

Signed ~L ff~ ~ c;M;;•;:::;R;::ar-~ / ;r-/-; ,._ ~· V-// Le_

/.tul :f ~ ~. #e{; CX-~ J,.:( ~ '/r · ~~r-,~ffF 7::r-~ . ~r /l?r C-x. ~~ ~~· . ·/':{5-~~tr~ ~...;c .:e-~~ ~r~~=, AI£~ r:~· -. "'~r~ ~~ ~. JJPF ~ ~ ;;._ .£:- .:4.--;/ -u!f"'

~4-.AIC6 ..Lf ~ ~~ ._.__L;/~ 1-~~~A:7~~~~~ ~~~ ~~ ..t ~~---rr ~~ ~r~~ ~A/~~.--~~--+·~~<1--~ +.PP

~,4?~~~~~~~ ~~-~~/~~~.

Room: Hilles 2N-A West Start: 3:30pm 6 Fiebrantz, Aly JVP

AFFIRMATIVE

· HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Cambridge, MA February 16-18, 2012

NEGATIVE POS I POINTS I RANKS

La Cueva SH Max= 30

~ I Kyle Stenseth r' ·~L~51 2J li Richard Huang Lt

/ ~ The better debating was done by the 41:£ from UQ L A For NEG EAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on this line if a low-poil)t win was intended: __ _

Signed:, ,--;c,t \I"' '<"4' :>-<=


-bth ~<V'ts (~~ oco:~k o)J ~ '\i Stv~ ~l}f ~-)-~- fajocJ<_ ~'i~ ~J

\I l r r;:)~ Jr 0 ··= Oo ~\JII::::

; a~\L . • • L v ~vv i~ meD ltll \c ~kJ)u ()~L-&1 ~

./ ~ SUft1 mu~; ~J· ex )6t l{~~~d ~

~/

La

~~ w\; u \or ~· Jf ~ ~J J~~\)J~- .m . ('

Room: G & P 216 Start:--~:30pm JVP

6 Freeman, Jim


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE -- - -- - -

POS POINTS RANKS

Baltimore Urban Debat J 1\ex=3o

~ Darius Adejo_Liely ll1.~ L{

i>_OS

Rogers Heritage ·RM

1 Roberto Rojo -

'POINTS Max= 30

z«.-z,

J Jabree Gordon - ?-6 3 ') Sean Madson JL~1

The better debating was done by the N "-"'") AFF or NEG

'· '

from _R1± TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check ori this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

Signed: rn--=--;.q==-··

COMMENTS & REAsON FOR DECISION:

~0~~-~~otJ:~}ee>l1 fl,J ·

.. ---

RANKS

'/

'L

Room: Hilles P13 Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Garnick, Jonah


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POS Lakeland District Deb AI

~POINTS RANKS Max= 30

POS

Niles North BB

I James Allen d~ d. \ Ben Barov

l Akshay Ramaswamy ~~.1. \ ~- Martin Barr .. _____ ----- -----

The better debating was done by the Arr:- from L'l\Lt-\ov.~ AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on this line if a low-point win was inte

Signed: r ~ - c 11 1 u 7 7 Tl I i



'J+.s )

'cl.i Lf

QF\) ·. -~t.j ---"~D~~ ~ ~& \'q ... -4-1~ t.\""':y~.s ~V\ f>o1~.\-.'q 1

if f1o ;V"1!1"~ C...tc_. -<;~_,.._ ~ """' ck -!..._ A# v..W'I c§ l'OVI ~"~ .;., V•t-... ,,J'p

v..,, VI~•. ~ :I: "'"' <-.'+ V•~ Nj .. 4 @ ~/( -ke_ ~"k,n._\ ~+ be...~h'-4 1..) I) .. Q.!\ C...o~ vJ~._ ~~ MtJJ

e J d.) p._tf ~.~, <. ... r \ ~r~,._k.. ~r t-c.ul vi~~~ I"'\


6 Geathers, Andrew


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POS Boston Debate LeaguEd

~POINTS RANKS ex= 30 POS

La Salle Colle_g_e PS

~ Richard·Davis· ·- . . . '2).fp .. ·--7··-·· ~ - Nicholas Petaccio

\ , Rachel Dunning ~7. 5 'f I Brenden Sosnader

The better debating was done by the U'Jtf..o..c. from t.c. 5 .. 114- CA/(r,<. For NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME


Signed:,~~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

-•••·'-•/• .·- .:. r~; -··-~---

1.~.0 :1 ~~ .. \:. fltr.~ f-h,''i> ~

0 1\C "'"~t. "'"""" ~'-:"I\( ~N\~. ~ .. , rJ ~5: ,.\6-1-~>.<,.idt .. s}.. .. k! wvrk

) OO).J.ht.. I1..C.1 Q. ......

~·1...-lo l-.vc. otynlu4 Q'.S"....,Jt.l.e ....

b) 4is .. , Q(J. _.{, 1o p"~ .... , ..... .., .. , .... ~-~-.~ ~,,..h:.~ a•s·"'J ';)

:t ~1 ... .,~.s,~ ~. ~i yw-C&r ; .. 11.•• A·~.k

c) l.Ht ,'I{,. ,.J 1-o "'>'d•ll'a. :---~.hb.J.t..J~t-e.- -· ···--· ..

[.,...J.t>pe~ , ..... ~~

/'6 r .... l~ .J..I. w" l;t'J! ;,~:'?I. .....

1111·

1" "~"&.c.~ ($....,~Jo" c.

e1.,,u.At~ li'. ( .. )\:}

La


.. !2 « ·2 I

2'·' 2

Room: Hilles 2N-B East Start: 3:30pm 6 Gerard, Bonnie JVP



/,A

}~

~ ~-

?:z\

POINTS RANKS POS POINTS

Ransom Everglades DB Max= 30 East Kentwood 08 Max= 30

Dylan Denman t8.<) \ \Vl Michael Obuchi Z..l lker Belausteguigoitia 21.< 7/ 2J\ Georgie Booker Z7.t

The better debating was done by the ~t from~,., ~ ~r-t~..) !IF orN G EAMORC TES TNA--


Signed: ~t.\A .... ~ J { -<::r A, \A r.


rud CQ\Attltt5 ~ p.LIM ~ c:~~ '(_ ~ 21\J~

p ....t~ ""'- ~ o \v--(. '>

Aft- W6r¥ D\\ 11\'K ~~(f---

ZJA~ w~ Dti vf"L_ Plow i w~ -H~

o.) M(r')'t o>J cJtA \t ).Xt f~~ \

1/V 0 - \AI Of v 0\. nv " ()r-ti ~ ~ 15"- ~ oJ::l:

RANKS

t~··

3

~ .z:~1


AFFIRMATIVE POS Johns Creek GT

l Hersh Gupta

l Derek Tang

6 Gilbert, Colt<;>n

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Cambridge, MA February 16-18, ·2012

NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS Max= 30

POS

Brooklyn Technical SN

Zl..S 'i ~ Narish Singh

Z7 3 l Zareb Noel

POINTS Max= 30

z.g

']$.5

.11 , .. --r from W ~l\l"' Ttcl. · '6lJ TEAM OR CO TESTANT NAME

RANKS

?.. (


f..rD' .. Aft iS io ~r beM/J. 6n ~.

_ . lli.J Goo~ ~+\o~~ d) \Ac ,1

~ '/ov (IJ1. ,o.. li\:1\t. INit'w.t.l '~' ~1. 0\1\9 hv.l \?.A iis u~bi'( ':\.i~ c.laA<-·t"k uJ. ~ AC.:]]· tl'U~ht bt ~ -\o ~ \oruts.l: W c!£~~~ \~. ~~~ h~t'C ~'.~ t~JU.L~ Qf(.

.A.\ ~ p~~~ ~tit- Wkf: -lu . ~~:ts~; ld 1./10-' ~ ~1\M.k. ~ ~ 1()(/'AtN. -\\M""t,./!'1 U(l {ii"A A.ll~ cY1 II'\ .fkt e.. '3:: Gt>&.l. J I t..l12- 'f'ov r ·, ""f' d ( .. lw lv\ ito)IASr ~fl.. \Sr\i- CA~·'/o'() *t ~ 4'\.1. lL ...,( l~.S ]'U"tt;cA. ~cr )b't> ('o\~-h"'-e.. ll'vl ~ clovl?'· L __ . ~ ~ ~ (~.Itt\ 0~~ 4\.. l..l{ f,O'o.I\G ~ v~ rt 1b ~·~CA. a r\)1(. tA . ~ wn ) qp ~ \-t 5o '-' rnart.~~j(...J: hoc \!"" '"' o}M~. 'IOU# 11-rt. -tJ..lb ~1\t~- .L ~f<A. o 'tka. ~ ~ ~ (Jc -h..ts .:t ~ ~ ~ -1., •• s I~~ ~ -\ull\.or\ --1'$1. Je•kv fluiP• $ "1/JJSC "'-:J I pro~'· Nl~-~_illl \h>t.c.A tlk<l-' rMro tki t . ~l))t\'t ~~'ole -hi<n. V,(Ollt1.-tlf Q\ flJ "l~ \ Gco~ ~t)N~ d'\ t Ac.\fwr ,.J.PJI ~f~.l-1-Ml\t~ov~ MO\< ~,\<.. 4.i~ \nL.luti.L~~ ~ ~ ~-~\t, ~ .f'/"' ~ ~ ~ b~~ ~~h ~e6tA. ~~C.. ~L~Vr-t. Nt)(t iiYk.! ·,~tlu~ ~ ~, 1~ptt:1S vs. ~ V\ l -1NA\I.. \k' t,Mk .... hN w~ ~ ~ olo~ ~ hvtl'-Jt~Ul4 ~e,M ~ +o -ft to fUm~~. r;;tJ)_'U{))1,0{ a.t-trr1Ld;~. ~\&.::r·~ ol~'f\~~ ~ ~ . . . ~ 1 ~ ~~ t 1\..t ld.t'~Ol\

15 ol~ ... 0 o~ ~b 'th -1\u. ~Mf2. 6\lok&\ ~cs~H' ~.r;,i 'l.)(t),{~.J: ~r\tlu

·,, / ~O'I'l ~ OJ'\ ~~Gl\ OV\. -t.u ~n.ti\ve.' fHt ' ~~~ ~ r&~~·d ~~·-11M. ''-·~· .

-Gr pc1~ out l~ 0 e.xkut CaJu_ tJJA btA.l.t


6 Jobi, Demi


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS

POS Nashua VI Max= 30 POS POINTS RANKS

East Mountain ML Max= 30

Srilekha Vangavolu 3 52~.~ L Marisa Michealson t~~ 9--

Anish Iyengar 4 ~z,·5 I Benjamin Lopez ?-9 \

The better debating was done by the N [ G from D_o=5'1 MowVJ()q~'"" M L • -- r NEG TE'ifM OR CONTESTANT NAME •


Signed: A COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

GreQ< ""'"J. 41/ conk<hlnh a:r1 V'<~ vJI~'" A Aw- irnpc:nJ ]bi~h &We Cl!l1pbJ•Ij ~ ~· ~ ,;/,_ #II' tf.t tlit ~otrsw>~ecl +k ~~~·wae J ~. (}Wee~~ ate OtK \""',

tio 'if d k~s t0.. ~rev,. uMilheG I ~ "~ II~~ ~~~~~ k lkltf !ftii\NOV I J i'1Q e4 1'/'DJf ~( e V'<V>\a~..t me D«fj'(' • I < ~ }<lO

tole lO mho ~tt 11- PJJWj f/tv~J !~~t,v- 1

N5 <)fell~ }I~ '/A~ i~ rk" <s M 5('f£f ~ c ;;\H. p_, IJ"l. COS } <>Y .)Jo.t I~~ i lA (.k. \Mo+/t' J ~e 101-v

t' I< "J ¥"~" 1 "'""'' n•ll~ "'lei, f<' k 'l'"" Dhw~ ..! '0

' f ., , 1 r' S .vk. U~ ,l)n(\1·~ f<:, OCJ;vGpVil'!1'

n I ,. ,j ·I J, '\~I IJJ 5 -;brv I J co I f\.r-e) [ACA.-0-t 19-e ·i( \;\_ [osJ l \;v Q01JvV'I.'\\ \ Q . I J

\}\ \-f1Nt4/l-\i y ~ ~ ~rtV\j - V\,:!> .. ' I I I .,

1

n n I 1 v11o~ 1 kre ~ rcx r ;t; \ . _ ~ ~""k Ices~,<.. 'J<o,.,.. Ue '"j "!'F"" D~f"'<SeG1 = 0 K ) "" · r~ c.- wre

~7. • ~ 0 ~,~1... +•''"""'"" fJ'<J \) ", =cj.S . ~~ , VIe~ -mw«J crvJI· itt< ~"" 1'7 ~{"'' 1· ~J1'1fhl)1\ ~''"'-' ~n . \ ) ,. U

i"'~'' cJ M Us ().Y< \>\o~Jil~ ,. ~llx, ~i r.WiL ilt...~e · ~ Tk \1')1~ l~ ~ G\ 3\ohJ •ltJo.>( ~ ~6 1- re hccJJwl to 'iay ,/.4

·AJ!t,


6 Johnson, Willie


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE !7- O~ l;rJ!J i-t'JJ POS POINTS

George Washin_g_ton SL Max= 30 Pos 'Lexinaton DL POINTS I RANKS Max= 30

Nathan Davidson 'd- Katharine Sigler !J7. 7 r~ I Charles Li £)~ ~ Sophie Levine {) 7\'_g

The better debating was done by the 1\f- -~ from }~4 r wz/.-;. .. AFF or NEG Tt~R'CONTii-,T NAME


Signed: WJviN-·-~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

RANKS

2 :;

Pwv~~., ~~·:r~ ~f:'~:~'·zh:~~~iZ ~'l~~~~u~jJ\ D 3 - I

7" ~ /, ,/_.·/ <:;?( -D(d·-l

CjO iP "16-r - ]'-e_ V u-&-t ifo \7-cf'S Cu.. --c ~- '- vv


6 Nyguyen, Victori



3 I

Cypress Bay PV POINTS RANKS Max= 30

POS

Zachary Pestcoe 1q.9 2_ 2 Gabriel Valladares 3D \ 4

)•.?, 1) ~

~ The better debating was done by the ..,tb:::'"

~EG

Connally KH POINTS Max= 30

lann Karamali '2 & '7

Geoffrey H u ley 2~ fJ7ir 3:t;D

from __ .W..RXf5.~-- ,_. ~~Y{ }" \1

"f( \)OV\·+ v.vq V\J.

Tlt1 ~ \,1\ \( VI 0 \A fu {

\'"Q..\?\1\.~ \.

0\ v v \ \'1 9 c v o~ <;I,

tvv t:J\}.Q.V\1\R.W o{ \-(_Q..'-1 yv\Y\h c\"'Y'n ~

We~. ~vo ?fLeA vv'\ 0\-\ o-t oV\ c Ci( ~-e .

~~~- \\iAA \J\AI(M\11 o.-\ ~ v-o ok- 0\.V\ c\ \Nl-\ c\

s~ tt C) tA 'V'- s+

~e~,

'N Q,). ~Vt>~~,e_c\ \<

RANKS

~ :s

Room: Hilles Cinema Start: 3:30pm 6 Olu-alakija, lni JVP

~ HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV , ~.rT~ Cambridge, MA

February 16-18, 2012 ~-

<?.. .• { ~


Brooklyn Technical MA Max= 30 POS

Chandler Preparatory L< l ~ Harith Morgan 27,5 f 1 Audrey Laughrey

I Temur Abdurrazakov 2J. ~ 3 ~ Chase Grindler

The better debating was done by the A f + from t 11. 1;..e~ . AFF or NEG

Signed: , '2::? ... ~. { _,.... r ::;:: :::::>


A f1 ~J -~rf'b I/ 1-J tw.d 7 tl'fVI

Aft 11/so JclvoJ fur t tt? no 7 .

POINTS ~Max=30

RANKS

:21 'I' "

;)7_?; 'J, -


'·6' :·s~~ Orchweri, Mark



I~

1J\

POINTS RANKS POS

Marriotts Ridge PZ Max= 30

Simon Park l~ 'l I

I lN

Kevin Zheng . d-~·1.. \ I :21-.J

The better debating was done by the Af} AFF or NEG

George Washington SM POINTS Max= 30

Zachary Stieneker ')_Yl.5

Mason Munro-Ehrlich l~-~

from \'{\l)..«,v\:\:-<:::> '\)..-,,),.~ TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME .


Signed: ~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

'1\~ 'i\0~ '-.lC\_.

~\:.\\,~,'.\~ (3\~

(A~\~'~'"'f'l ·, '::::.

w~~

\1\JI),.":::,

\~~-

w\~~'~) ~J;- ~

\.):1~\~, ":,\;, \... ~ ~

{'">.;:i\: ~~~ \)\

~~~ kl;, \~\),<, > '<~o- '":) '"

-\'\--._~ f\0~"'"Q. \j~~\t.._ \'.~c{

-\-""-~·

-, !'t\~~"" i 'h\)v.:> e" c(

'\)..:J.,~-4.c).,;,'::>c:..~ ~ G""'~~~\<;)(\

~ <M\

~:).;)<. \-0 ('\'"'fil--\

~Vo~\\,_(1~'"<\

~\N\.::J

'J~:>\'\I.,_<'':J

·\~~ ~\-~ ~ ::s::.~

~-~

~)..J< .. ~':::l~

\~~~ \:"'Q,..

~ ~'-.I'\:) \J0~,\~

~""'~ ~--i ~<S~~:-~

"'""""'-"'---~ ~~"". lv~~

-~.}. .

.1• . ·~·-··

fl

RANKS

~

3


6 Ortiz, Kate

AFFIRMATIVE POS Clear Lake LG

\ Michael Liou

1- Akilan Gopal


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS Max= 30 Lakeland District Deb Tl

2_&- z_ "]__ Wylie Thornquist

L..~-5" l I Temma Pelletier L--..

The better debating was done by the -'-'J>t~lt from ~~'::t=:'!'::·.·-J.-s!":~.: ... r?:':':

5int win was intended: _....:..._ __

Signed: v /.f r~..c= , I )' 4



t1 ~ ?_7, ~ 3


6 Paddock, Chris

~ 8 'I""'\ }·' ·,;

~~



POS Agape Leaders Prep HK Max= 30 POS

La Salle College FG

(A- Chulsoon Hwang 'L1 > :> 1/JC Paul Forrest

2A Leo Kim li l r> rJC 1'-'' David Grabowski ---- --- --------

La

0 () g . 0 (C) .~ -~

> ,/ t _..: ~ <

~ <:...o v- J LIJ


ZC9 d. cf

2-b '2 -

The better debating was done by the l\ t='f from Alj 'V?r{ Le t{ ~...s e~ (_.p AFF or NEG TEAM C TESTANT NAME

Ple:~gen:~ on !CiFiJZ was intended


~U~Po// xft J1J ~. fv d/lf Job . fr6 &:J #J -fL._ s/ "'- f"'-5 fiA.o ;(;, Wc,-f :J "'oc:f ~~. ~- .

TL.y 9~1A:_ .deoefe>pi'_~ tt ~fr~ll\ for Je.,z [ ';") v;+~ .Cfoba.l tJ~ 1ft f~'oa.cftve a~ f r. -1 (_ d t.J t_ /k£-dflfA.u;:5


6 Pareek, Purti


- -- - -- ----- -- - -[o oG Q

POS Lexington PK POINTS RANKS Max= 30

POS I Bronx Science ZC

2 Frankeisha Price 21- 1 1_ Jenny Zheng

j_ Mia Kobs 1io2 j_ 2_ Jin Choi

The better debating was done by the Df~ from 1zl'/IJ" .f:".A ':I ~\><-.. ..?' 1

Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: w

Signed:~

POINTS I RANKS Max= 30

210·:8' 4 20·'1 0

COMMENTS & RE ASON FOR DECISION· ~~--5\~ cXJvJtl l ~rv-Jt!E,do rmre &mt::IVXJ dWld t9JL{{1U$ !W ~ 1ffi('f'G Vl(!d ta 1'0\- d 0 iJJ 11')0.11 Y S\f'Cil!OW fXimSlOVl S: 9 fri1 r:VU Wly -\0 l \( IQ\IJOl\:l: 1Y1a l~roQ It n lc sW'kl r loS ·

~ w t fl s en~ 1-{l_r rLS ,

Room: PfoHo Moors 2 Start: 3:30pm 6 Pestcoe, Scott JVP



Bronx Science GM Max= 30 POS

Rogers Heritage HP

l Tehani Gunaratna t1.~ ~? )_ George Hill

)_ Ridwan Mia 21:1 ~t l Jaryn Phillips


I ;l.8' 1

')1.la )-

The better debating was done by the A/£~ from g 0 ~ S lHe.ri d-ec-~ AFF or NEG TEAM OR CO STANT NAME

Signed: I "' v- I ...-- I • ...._... {) ....


{jr~ rvV!t!J /1 fculi~ vu67 J

~en-- 'Ja~-

Room: G & P Tchr Lng Start: 3:30pm 6 Porter, Greg JVP



Ft. Lauderdale LA Max= 30 POS

Nashua SE

Britania Lawrence 0G,\ ~ pv Aditi Srinivasan

Matthew Alford ~~,4 ~ ta\~ Dody Eid ----------

The better debating was done by the JVfJ.t& from lYf'!.XL~. Please check on this line if a ldwcf>oint win was intended: __ _

Signed: \ / ''I - / .~r , / / , sr; ;;;;.- 1:;:r t


~G.d y c10, 2 J --- -

€ -~~

" . I vi - / (h ~ rt..-r -----~ (}- 0\7\V f '1?7 ~«v~ '6 CTc<H/nty ut r~ t ~- Wit

r he_ )£4-C qk ct0)5 . 5Pf1l tv 7-'11'- b6 ~ff~i-111t-/~ ~ J1lti 5 -tfll~ ~'Y. ft * .fVJ:W t)S 0\J ca fcls ih ~ {1, e 11/V ~ f0 dae- dro· -ecJ T v

~M; ~eg Ar <'leo IYl CVJ, 1 tfc ~ I 5frd}- J ll +oc ?J1r>LK . . ·. t I~ 0 '1Jfe:l +n~ 5"~~~ J/ii lf1i- Crt f f?~ 11 H-~ { gfn-e{l_ (PD~ ri-ff- elf T c;nd 'Z Dfr cr; J~qe11rf7i!b rn t lt1 e {dvtfld, fo ]: uok :.J 1 .


6 Reinghans, Ross



POINTS RANKS

Loyola HM Max= 30

7 Demitrius Heard ?7,~

POS

I POINTS I RANKS

Agape Leaders Prep LC M•x=3o

-? Kevin Lam -L_-+----------------rl~--'~~~r.--~1

I Travis McClendon zi,J" ... J Brandyn Chan

The better debating was done by the/- {/ - - J E

Signe~.

!A-f }'Fe fJ' . -~ re r/. .f.r, r:. "/ "" -7"" f'q/" ~ !7 ,koJf 7~ ,A? "7"'c~ ,£7 _r;, COMMENT?l RE~?~'N F?flD~ ISION· /} ~ .__--

;.f'!J•M 7 v {j/?7JM6-f.~/ ~,rr-~cford'/'l';r .. d/' a 1-· r--t,-.e ¥'":

AI- c~ -K /],'-' j/ld rf'J c!r .. ..4 r {1., ,;? ·~ . ' Tf r ~~ ,4 y L .

1,~, ;k .. ~ t~/ .. _,u~;t. 1r ;s? ~.,£. ~JXJ ,j ~"."Aft~i/-t .f ~./"N' ~//A . I / '/ L I / ./. /

/1 - I t•· ;. i}p'1 'l' ~~' jl>e tl U"".,( r r~,, ,.d.K" i'" .... "'• rt:- r- / ,/ '7 / . ,q /,1; 1f.s eo*'~ ~.,{::je 3/ .h-r flP'/"le.- p/,jbn .

/(-It/!'"/ ,Mr/fr ~ 4 ,._, ~111 JtY~ a>nf,/~,.;:(J rr<>.tr-rr,.;// ~ lkrj~;t~ f/ll~vll~ /4 ?J- t{ ~ . ,/. . ,u j /#l!(t ~ /Af '"''" ~?'' p _.. t:. f ;r,., ,;/.rA "-'

hr;'f! :/elf/ }111:) /2J.rft/U1//J:' ~ /" N/. ~ j!ft x~"r v~ 7CJff Jr~ #v/l!ff J{7 f'/! i"'P" 'If"' (./

~N-/f-· ~//~ .1:.;/ ,/rtf,,~ '"' r' ~ f /-/ H~r:/ ,j/ ' h hJ! A~· -'Y?J/Y'J'; J/K ,?f,/t-6/- t',tYjj/ ;r/-re ('Pi' t- ~-"~ ~7"~, f. r~/)~:,~ ~" i:',. 7'/e" N,fi, Y"" ,. ,;/ ,..,.,;,J' ~ ~ ""/7/£ :;r-..y .

4 -!frh/ you -Jr•/ £, 6 Jti ~----· )~,!fr/ :/~// '"~ /M' 0~ .A/< 'i,__:y % r/ ;A V_f.~ .r./;.-», 4r jf'.f" j'•• ,-e ':Y .1~~ ~r{Jr'C.

Room: Hilles 2S Coli Z Start: 3:30pm 6 Roth, Anna JVP

AFFIRMATIVE


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS POS Boston Debate League J ex=30 George Washington PG

r Chianne Arthur 21.{, ~ r· Benjamin Papadopoulo

t Alex O"Neal 21-~, ~ ~ /2_ v Stuart Gordon

POINTS Max= 30

~ Z::f, B

21.-::r

)ya$

~

~~ The better debating was done by the lite!.\ from b W <f' b z: :..:;... ~F 9EG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

~ Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

~ \I\: "> •

S. d c,-------rgne : ____________ _


RANKS

I 1-.

~~~~ ~ /J;f!; tM A-/?I'<J/(r ·- 4H" ;~ 0'-,J ~..___;;~

;hpF-vf r /i-,;1; r~ 1-J


6 Sanchez, Taylor

AFFIRMATIVE POS McDonagh SR

2-- Sahil Shah


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS Max= 30 Boston Debate League_)

'Z-l, P- 2 MunoAii

~ HariniRadhakrishnan ~?) 1 \ Amina Mohamed

POINTS Mx=30

'2-~·l

'01

The better debating was done by the _Jrff_ AFF or NEG

from , '-'-~L ~v~ __ 11~ "=J'-


Signed: ~ , • , , ., , ( 'V , , , , ...... , , '' IJ ' {\ 'C 2 V ""'" lj 1/ . ' . J


RANKS

~

6

neao.:tiVe- • Ul{.)(~ 01'\ jc.ur up\MQ-fiGV\ of fht- f;rr\piYfl, -tl'\e(D, ancl fuel

oJt. t na.Jlj h\in!L -\1-lt pum 1s SiYfNI9 nert~ I'Y\~1?-t Ll£< a ~ov~l'tle-1\1

or Mtli t'-tV\ ~ ~). ft;t fh\ s oJf .

IN ~ ttAi CU.\ ~Y\ ~ (k G o{ OVV\\S6\0A •

~all 1\a. v e g l>\ 11> Q.l'\.rw er c fNI olr-n tiflo.J i ~ ..

\ Prf(. ~r-(K\cA "tMr 1ime _ Of " fC. \ .v . . on fh e Puwt lXVtd Qm ph a Silt.. ~ t

V ~s 0 J .fMd r~ t111fiYe rurs~tr~ ... 1 of.

f\fO: Condih OhfLhi1 Y\AA "~ wvum"" QY\o\ f'tl tMb IY) ~

pow ctt'\1 LUJ q~

~--

Room: Hilles 105A Start: 3:30pm 6 Sehgal, Dhruv

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV JVP



2A-

!Cr

POINTS RANKS POS POINTS RANKS Niles North ON Max= 30 Johns Creek RB Max= 30

Irene Diblich 11/8 ( trJ Rohan Rao fl,( tj Shelby Nordstedt 1..1 ~ 1 '1. .. .- 1/J Kevin Buck 27.~ .)

The better debating was done by the Af{ from ~ { ~ .S fJvr fh ))Aj AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME


SG·ef'li'lriO f 'lf\ f1 cb o~l\ 1 \ c( (f) p pe d b 1 - N e:Jtt ii v.e . -~ -e. )('t-\V\ eM OJ!) -

~ e.M'V\S IIV\ro<ht- S i Vl tt... T \" Vv L:J aft 17 do lt6/- vva.-rv/-

.fo cile,. M so 1 5 ervci'd cd i WJ ~f {q r d { evmJ weak £ r ftu.. nej l\t-;ve ~


6 Seitz, Harrison

AFFIRMATIVE

pos Atholton HD

;)___ Salva Hasan


POINTS Max= 30


NEGATIVE RANKS POS

St. Andrew's

' (') Nikhil Arora

I Shakira Dineshkumar t_..l I I I Umer Salman

The better debating was done by the from ~lt,A. tfP AFF or Nt:\j

- ....... . TEAM OR CONTE::> IAN I NAMt:

Please check on this line if a lo~oint win was intended:

li~-Signed:~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

{)r,.; c~

RANKS

~

y


6 Semple, Aubrey



Ft. Lauderdale HM Max= 30 POS POINTS RANKS

Desert Vista L T Max= 30

I Samuel Houle :2.7.1 :> 2 Amy Lin ~3 I c._ Damon Morales e-7-t.. y r Steven Tran Z1.Kf z._

Signed: ~


c?@---- ,:.,"'-- -fv@ ft ~.~.'-c .. ( .'~/ {- (/w....._ ( §) flc_ ~.

~~~~o (~ ?(-~~ / ~~~~ <""""· ~ 8 1 CAr~ s 6-tl~

r~ rr>< _ rv--~· ~ -~ ; ~crc t-o l\.J. ~ 1r- ,~......s v.: s."'":__ o ,-

- -p;r~<f 5b\_Tl~-----d~ , -- . - rLev.... v..£-~ ,f.L-- V;,~'"'l 1 ~ J. [&> -k<>/ ;ilL 0"'- c#u:S d'ek,&<fo_

Room: Hilles Cinema Lo Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Shaner, Jake


AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS George Washington AG Max= 30

POS POINTS RANKS Brooklyn Technical MB Max= 30

\ Thomas Angus z_%:.z, ~ \ Fariya Methila z_q-. I 3 ~ Joseph Gordon z13 Lf ~ lmen Boussayoud ere: fl

The better debating was done by the 4 from _!.!' _: ____ -1._.' .. _! .....

Please check OI'Nhis line ~int win was intended: __ _

Signed:~4


~~ ~~ r~~~& ~ J (.(: z_'Z--

[_':YJ ~s ~ ccyo +--- (CIC,~ VVi cu--e_

r/]vt-', ck~~et: a-Jct-·h~~ I ~'I / c;y1 ~· ~ \---- Ct>fSf2--~ ~ eve_

vw~ ~~~·~~ur ·~ lr:>~~y ~ fo( lvlt2-l - - ? .

Room: Currier Treehous Start: 3:30pm 6 Shields, Jharick JVP


La I


RANKS POS POINTS RANKS

Achievement First HW Max= 30

I Colin Hoffman \ Mark Williams ~t},) 5 l Christian Marble 2. Lindsay Henson 9q.j t

···--

The better debating was done by the oJo from ,.g v-- - -- v-A or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NA .. ;;;

Pl:~:n::eck ?f):ii" win ~s intend~

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: I 6-ouJ tovV"'1 IAv<_; ~JA~I'Yl· ~~o4C('i

::f ~ ol/l'{io vs ·~ ~ 1->w {A),'U<.. _. M ~ a/IJ1a;{ .fh~4 Gt)i C!ZJ.rJ ~ )(,J ~ 1/if ~-;/" 1 () (/ h tiAJ'(_,y, If s (c/cl C1' tJtfo rd, G'e_ f /;, C/O zRj)/_1 ~

Jl~: 8e sure .ftt,._J t'vf.k:Jci ,'w-~rP.t'-'j cw-~ Vf IJV iMw ~Xu~~ 1/ C41)f. jr.J.e~l4_

~ ~ 1/t)~~ /.M '/b ~ Cf/[J~At.-.6 yot/(N_ ~ ~. . ;YZt/:)v.~ "'b.. rx ~~·~ v re4.4di. 'lrv"J!!fi"""J""'~~ ~ tl'/ ike :lA/Uv ~ /;1/t, J/s ;1/ft~ ~ Vi/1-fd;i-f/.u afti*14.J./w_ IP1J,:Js tie ~ 'foil dor1! tfl1trl aut-aki-Cfov~·/,'k.. ·

1\f ~ Cfl?t k u 1rv ~wJf cue~/!!!:! r1.ett1 1r> #u ~· ~wan, +tot:Jlc,Ot)ra?tf-tjoVG_ftz -l/zet rJD·v:!)~

/:fD _' fA, ft Jro 1!:' /flmJ. llt,Ot'€. ~+.f{t l'i/h 6( il.t~ (.>~J r'0 7" · f 5(Y<r PM ~trt_h~fLft~'~d,J

0 vJ Cn~vt G)ve;, ~f)

tv11s J1guJ l VJ f/-J_ z -1- 1/1/ R.. k-e?l ~~~~, &4Jf/f'h.J·. ·lf!!J IJ1Uf;1CJI;J;fMr Vtfk /Jr 11M a?theJ dv;<t0e_. Uf fJut/ Jvf sro;., ~)lx if>V· TwVrf

~e ~ Wn'k'1W( n{lhfh ~'#e w;/Jntr5 ~ 4.1 t#'lar/Jr I.J'M f J;f, W tfev, 'fNitlflctM"'J~

.- ;},. J I'J.. "u t.btM J l.. 11 dAAI n,A,.~~J~ ,shbr,At-~.~l .. J.,. L.AAA .'!!:..., .11.-.~....L.~: ltllJJM• llr:.;>~CJu;..k, 1,.. ...


6 Singh, Ravi


AFFIRMATIVE POS

POINTS

Brooklyn Technical WD Max= 30

Amanda Woo b/ .. J Dante DeBlasio .;~l


NEGATIVE RANKS POS

Bishop Kelley MF

-g Matt Marra

,? Emma Francois

POINTS Max= 30

~~ ~?.s·

The better debating was done by the I V \(C5,Z from !S lh lJ P • -- -~ TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on thi~t win was i:::ed

Signed: ~


/Vfb +€Ct:M---- Uv~ 0~~

RANKS

)

L..

~~ ~;;zz :-fh~ VlJ LA (8 hct ~ ----, r1 Yl ce_ kA_ ~ \ Y\ ~ - J-QV Q. \0 r.Q.Sl

0\.Vl ~el:)~~c:_., ~VV\V/V~MA~,> 0vnC , s1 s~~~ _,

Room: PfoHo Hastings Start: 3:30pm 6 Smaga, Sarah Sie JVP

POS

\

2.. ----

----- ... -OverlandAK

Yonatan Araia

Bennito Kelty ----- -----


. -POINTS Max= 30

'\}\·1..

~~ --


----------

RANKS POS . - -

. -Agape Leaders Prep KL

l\ ' William Kang

-; l Haofei Liu

The better debating was done by the ~jEG from ~-S . .Qf\01:=~.~·~--Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

Sign•drYb/ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: •


"' "'"' 'V

~~'Y l

f\c- S'\\O\.lld s~ ~~ d.tfud "notl'YW fNtU&f~ -tbr ~,, «\oJ.. fio.t- sotve~ rot.AN.t.s Ia ice. ~ nttnoh.4.&~ _fc.c.ltt towel ~ ftv. .c/1' .. 1'1\t\'fbc. ytM: CoW.~ teo.d -O. ~rtephot\-

1111c.· rc.f.ld l'af< tkFcn~ ba~ MvM-ItA.,.e.. k-: ~klltl Qtl~ cmp4cJs/ D1li wer trv~"cf. \4)o.:tu. "1~ fi M.c.

1\ud fo ttdtl moreon.1k.k 4\d CP · p~) r~"i tJt4;(Afi QJt f~l'l, 'IV\9Ad'"C4/~ ett.. fe_.ad G'JVII;(<.f ·tA-/c{p/ COlJAtu S'tOJ\d4rd~.DI\ 'T. 1'1\0.\(t. M~ d~ o..t"'f~ -n,._ oQsad. ard-1\o o~oha ~ ""~

roa.- wort-tOt\ c '~ t.lA.IIUf;h w'~ ~~ ~ "'l(DIA.\iill s~otc.\d.t.Wwet""~~ Nl· ~oDd cl\.olL<. 1 UJCl(A a.M"~ i\4W ~ 1-~ 1 ~f ~ .fo t«Ate. ab>~ t. ~ ltlr Sov.td$ Q.l,inf t.tw, 1\u.d 11l k~ ~tJ.ba.cr w""t it tv\41c« JJJJ~ ~ Of ldHS! . .fows ~ -r:

:goo·. ttt~ ''':l<rf ~ iha.\ a~ , YY\ctt laMA. ts oc- \,.(,{(er ~~ I ~'kr tJ..e~ s

Koom: Hllles 322 Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Sosa,Jorge



POS Stuyvesant WC Max= 30 POS POINTS RANKS

Casady KR Max= 30

If¥ Lucas Weiner a e. 1 I ~~ Deja Kirk ;), 1. 5" .? I<. A-- Alice Chu fr-l.J, q IN Fiona Rendon ~B d...

The better debating was done by the rtf .P from Jt"U ~ V t:JS lfNf \'J 0 • ~~ - ··~~ TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended:

Signed ~ =ks=e= COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

' I II I • l"l ffJO~ 11'1 ~ f /16 Ol? B 1111? po o6 rfO r N 1b f 1 c rrz_, t11 1

w n ~ t I 6/ I liJ~r t' /N rt!CffP 13 77?/'t1/S f3 1 frC- 'SJ.rs:p 11Mf

1'#-- HI/7N t-1177Jt-'Pf 'P'f2- -nTz?//i?- purN ~ r/'11lf

Ill FVU'/< IP (Z (J JV/Z-N I fV.q U IV/ 77'Tf2t fJe'fUittv"f?(.- .

f'lfP 11 N vI f'( ?80 t-<f3 -t7f1l7 '('1(?1 r/2- pt.fi1v w ff:5 ~~vtJ~LYf <{VPIC/'J1-- I/7VD -jltff'l/'2.- ptftlv ~ ~ IN fl72-f31't5 17(11'1" W tlfbff tJ W> I I)? fl/£7

1Jl> vN t>mz-. I 155 or- 17f1j- f!A'%'<> & vn 6 N . • 11t'fi' ''f11VI Tfl72'j 'f/12.-v c/742-r.J$" 5 W fH /91) Hlf VZ> 17J

-n ~ !tff 51 ru w H16 lfw!Jif 5 lf!VP (2--<f'AO s 1J/14'1 f1ffr:T' up tJVt- !!IPP-11-~~t2-lf J!. ;vrf

t7l\utu<:; J v lfi--1 M 1 /_; 1 rtrf2J1. • fVB'~; f ?Pv-r r7lffr 'fOV/2- Cf!..Ot:'5 fit!CI/n.? k-ff1<:f

ft~JR (..dl# f'fJ f}'-'qiiA?A 'f f> IJ/S"l5'S 87\1 D IJJIIC t ~ t.P {/if b17 /) }.J s.

Room: Cabot Whitman CR Start: 3:30pm 6 Tran, Jamie JVP

~ Cf\~d)

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Cambridge, MA~- t_'tu February 16-18, 2012 ~ ' l


Connally LF Max= 30 POS ~?INTS RANKS

Lakeland District Deb G ax= 30

t Bryant Le L., -c1t £.... Hassan Muhammad Lf "Z1.V

c Mikaela Fitzmaurice 1 -z... t;.1., f James Gummerson 7 7..1Ji

The better debating was done by the A~~ from --::!.:~==~~~-AFF or NEG



~ ~\) \ tJ~ ~\~ ~. Llt,t.\v (,6 \w,llf\,1 • ~~ 4~""~ v<, JQQ c-V"'' w .-0 t..iVl, ~ ;., <~..- ~~~ \))L~ ~ """~ ,_.,., t-xh-..J.-....v \ ~I \,J- '4''"'~ ~.r~~ \~ ~~ w~~ -!-1..-v-h,.,.;J ~~ ( "t'W~ ...J~ j, N rv ~~1>,-w>~ ~~ -k~~ff,>M(.; 11-~1 ro~-~~

'4- : ~\~ ~lk\ l\ltr-J~. * B) )pt pvJJ, ~~~ J:,ti:J ~~~\~-r ~~~~~ ~~~""l - "'A~@~ ~ 1-,__Xf4."'-w1ut

·~ [.,0'1,1.\v.\t \-~ ',~~~~~ \~ k """""' - }4\-rvo v.Ji.,._,_,;

\1J \ ~~ \\IG ~w'. I\J Ff\ v ~ lJ~\-~~l-V'h \~~-~~·>t--~ h h~f«-1- ..J- •.. j ~~If~

'0) \Miv ~ ~ J~~- \w.f\kt~-~:.~ "-0~ ~~W- ON!/~ "")~ J-.J1. ® ~* \1M , • ,..+- ,JtJ-/o,_, a~-.JU, ~-. ?u ~~ ~.-- \~vAAl!~ ~ l U L -· 1~ ' +- ! ,J_ p~ 1"1- ~{lwt- -tt~IU>?,

w ~~t;il s-'fl~~~ ~& kwt ~~M~ ~~~w~~ _ ~ e ~~ ~ ~~ M-Ql, ~M{~I/ 4.; ~~

Room: Hilles Conf 2 Start: 3:30pm 6 .Val,dez, Rosie ·. .

HARVARD HIGH SCHO~~"'j\(.Yd~GJ~ JVP

AFFIRMATIVE

pas I Pace Academ_y FQ

/I Reid Funston

Jacob Queller

POINTS Max= 30

:Jf1.5


NEGATIVE RANKS POS

River Hill SK

I I I Raghav Srivastava -

I llfl. C.. I, .:< I 121 Russell Krizan

The better debating was done by the f?dd from ? a.c.e. .- ~- --~G TEAM OR CONTESTANT Nl

Please check on tlil-is line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

Signed: 1 .....__...... - '--""'==I ,.............-


{kd-

RANKS

FO(

1 ~ · ~/ ~t-<Cs- r¢ .

~ 1 {I1!?V--' u ;du; w fo 41 ~ ~ II -h /1Jid~ - ~#a-lese 8 k ?<) ~ Jtuj ~~ ~~ ,:f ~ /s rUJ

;Uh ~ wtJ-~ c}fu; ~ ~· ~ ~ '!rnt~ ¥ 7) ?- )


6 Weisberger, Dave

AFFIRMATIVE ---- -

POS Lexington MW

j Manu Meel

2- Madison Wong


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS Max= 30 Boston Debate League t

'2 ;.l y I

t Kalvin Nash

7.--1, 3 ) I ~--- ---------

~ Juan Paniagua

The better debating was done by the fV<J AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME


Signed: ~~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

( IJ\( _ IN~f 1;w1l J.p(;v~'t"'

~~POINTS RANKS px=30

17, v 'l I

} 715 ' I

/IJ( - 5o1<i? p.(f. r~5e P('. tPJ (j) ~·~ 'V]trl4 -I01e+;.. T5S"Ve ;y t(: ''yJro~)t>tl:-fv] I ~t{~l5--(lti~ . .fFfd}-IJ tire tl.r/!5

)A{_ - WVt.•f l'lt1.f -fX1rt! ,( -/('f(tJf.-1111 aJJtrfl-/t'lf-e? 'lOt! fl!iJ(~I 4Uvw t'i1(J) ·Jot! 111"Cfi ~if11f ((7cicfltt?

lNC -I!} f.- -

( atd? 1olli(( /!4

0;t tftiS~'r:Jifllli)"-1 J)J"..f C1[P'tfoly.f:t') "o.ldi ok. 'l-le111uf 4? ruf>);t Ctf.f"'MI'IIIb

(}(c pe 1VT<">;5 j >p! jiiP<U;I ~qve {df•W ''"'I (brf 5~/<: sciJMCy , t?n(j)

(ar~"'~"'"'~'~l:- .J.,eH Pft!Jit!Jlll ;~ J 1-;JI ~ndifl') {l/:)'141'7 1511 '+ i5 q 'r>erctJ

tv j 4'1-'t.H -eu '4,.1rr .... i"' f 8;; (¢Sf!j

rd'JUJ./it'il~ Wq) tit ();/ c.t:j:.

I~&..- l/tlf 5M1 Ti~~'~f tYJul1tf1(1111IPJ-i-· Atmts~/Jvi~1JI'1127fi j aAA Jit~Jt'.J,.t( ""J'I cP. VN lf!J~ptt &~f.yf!l,~1o~tCf I) ~rJ~VJu~ ynr( ll~' .·-s .1.1. +v.r: ·te1 /c . .-.

i-V rL- 0CJtJtA Oil AtJr-n-1 ftfl)urv1tolll r;,p-,ol IJ(I P~ ·7--- "J~t-ul~ V!i!ltl'f 51/Jt'nt VV!t1/P !;111~ .t?l1. ci0!J. 'l'iy

r (}I"' veri /v'C'9' .?/! (p a11A ~~t~~{f'r-7A ;J ~ ,~

Room: Cabot Lansing Rm Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Clar~am

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL J \._(eJ~I \~ ·-·---------------=:

AFFIRMATIVE

Pos 'Chamblee Charter AP

Swap nil Agrawal ~

POINTS Max= 30

Cambridge, MA ruary 16-18, 2012

NEGATIVE RANKS POS

EdgemontJM r-

F!llll~ 1&11 IIR

~ POINTS RANKS Max= 30

t(uv(c 9 :17 4

c.~ &:..1

·,_ ···~u-Chae Park (tA Zachary Mohamed(~ ~l~ 3

The better debating was done by the ~ ff from ( 4.( n11fke AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _ .- 2; ;;;;;.:::::: ' Signed: ~ 3 ~ 7)


V@:?kv; ~~ "If~ 1BEJ! ~{ -~-"~ /£. L . .tr . t6e,xf.~ ctt( U · , ·· ·. U rt'l.fie" ~F1 / d.\ rer 119-Jo ~c · .

9 · . · -- -CiJrt 0\ ~..:::~ rli1'3-:-

.. =-• bet<~ wd< &1Rtu{k (&;~-rttWl} ('5;~ tbr 00

1}e IJ::; !<Jcks tA ~J @() w({). do/~r'"'y ~{ 'r{ ~ r e;.rfe.lty I( AI// "'.P,1i> -.{lte C'J'~?t5'{.. "-ttt)' eG'f- ~r Me.

- \ ~ f(t; !::= ~ :~ f>1U·'~ --f<r_, ~;, IA~-J-;/vtr-

tfe~: ~"'it~1 PiVVI \ ' , e/1'-VY~' ~1{ ~ &v?e cru'(? c;,&:;<l'l~t? .:{oc-Jf~ ~ •i ~~~£e fie &1~\y ~~~~ {...J .,f JJ¢ . , f> (~!! yo,},t-2 o~

-,(Jijfj.,_ f:-· l "'/) _ _, " {8r ~-~,. ,y,lrtl • n . . ..[ II. ~-, A 1/. "(' . .II 't ~Vtt{ ;{tt'ftt

G. olJrY. &((11.~ or ..;.(Is ·, {p •'v .... '>'.~ tl .w.... . £1·"' , ,1 ·. • . G .• ' . fr~tl({~ 'f'~

'b., " ! "!; .\ ex . eyt- [~14 I ' (_ fJvt IP \ yov #'e) 'b - /' .. • ------~ tJ.Il lie r-le,,J f4"C~ '

~ ____ ,., ........ ,..... ' ' . 7 " .. .J~,, . /P) ~ Iii ' 'f.J~r,..., -1!:tfl'(l' - ft .[ CD' .Z.n'\ f'lf'1 /J!Jt ~IJrB JN!fl•""' ,j ;

er}1J.;;r . / ~ t)J\j.ry ·f\o,e 5r~rdej . i ,/.. d . . ,/ I ~f;eA rP '1 I ..0 ' ,~~,~ ~ .... f1e.1i r~ eifte4"' v- (~t.:'fl) .. ~ .. kt'ffU/~f'tJ~rl {v""~""' ~~'~ \ i"' {J( ~ <- . -" • ·----- _o-(1

,1/Q - N-y,gJu!. f)rlbY'fow~ \ - · \ 4011-.j 'k.- (IJ'ik ~r t+ yr;J aee& lf&rC •-j1'(1'e. \4,u \ Z:,,a;'-~ \ k;'ilt'IJ "j(efA'k> ~"~11f<e~·rt ~fe~' ~(fo 1\keJi'{.. \ ~i '-Ia ~..-~/d. ' J -~ tillf(t-drfle \

~ .. lei{y &e·~ bD<>D -fat.t «t{t~C M cqQMti'~ ~ \

~,.j-< 12.,J... -r>t,.re . 4IJ 1tkt-iftJ4 ~{4"\• \.

~euV 1jt~t w~ .~ " ·- .. •. . .. a {fJtJre A/ft f(

6vj ,. , (fJ.1'~jJ0- ~rf _(tM ~ !li:k{: ~}!

~ /!t;~,:t ·~>'" ~., .wt -t'te cP~@') ·fp-Ke P.rf1.'/ c ( ~ Cll1~'l \ ({t) ~iv:."A 'fte!r- f~W<Jf.i'( '/jf><- I ~bur OlfjJ <{1t9 r""

4~ ,.....,._

Ot~ ~- t'ct?t' cft~,1'~ --11~.

# e.-'- .. ~ 7 . ~ fA.~(~ ~re f('"!';{JL; ~~ k~.~r '4rzt4_ te/1

r~k ~: -p; ~ fit/11~"~ M~ 6<<91./w

(J)~ bGtK " AJ I?> (CJ/lC~ef,~


6 Yellin, Zofia



POINTS RANKS

Brooklyn Technical DO Max= 30 POS

Great Hearts Academy C

1- Isabella Divilova Z.~~3 -j_ 1.. Jack Coburn

2 Sam Osterfield zg l 2- Sam Thomas

POINTS "fax= 30

a,.q ~7.8'

The better debating was done by the A~ AFF or NEG

from ~~'ia'(\, \..t~u.vl TEAM OR CONTES T NAME \


Signed: L.,L".,. . ,/ ,.er •


Cf ,6 fJt;S 181 ter(Yl~

RANKS

3 I

~ I

Roo,': Hilles P12 Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Sanchez, Taylor

AFFIRMATIVE POS McDonogh SR

2-- Sahil Shah


NEGATIVE POINTS RANKS POS Max= 30 Boston Debate League )

0l0f t. 2 MunoAii

~ HariniRadhakrishnan ~~ 1 \ Amina Mohamed

POINTS Mx=30

2~·1

'01

The better debating was done by the __!rtf_ AFF or NEG

from 1 , ,-L ,{'VY¥ Jl'""'- \.:: J'-


Signed: ~ I u r I II\ ( av \ o- ,{~1) ·' \ I I ' _q C: 2 V vo ·j 1/ 0 I . I


RANKS

~ Ill!.. \,.I

M8A.tiVe, • !J.l(Jy'l' 01'\ J~ . .tr U.p\MQii(/(\ cf fl'tt- E;tl\fi!Yfl, me(9, CAY'\cl .(.he;

o.,\t.

( f€a.1\j fnin!L \-tit pU!Yl iS $-h"~~ heY(; !'1\~~ U~ 0.. ~0~11'\1'1\Q,\\,1

()'( M~ ~IV\~ ~). fct -th\ s o.:ff •

f N ~ <tA-i CM.\ ~l\ ~ (k G o{ 0YY\\S6\0t\ •

jttll t\a.~~ 3!>1 it> <ll'\{l'\let' CINiohiliNioJi~ .•

I M<.- s~-tn tA J IIJJ 1i me ()'I .

Of o..(0 . o..\S o a.~ ..1 -11le puwt a.nd Qm ph a .lilt- -J1'I t pow O..t'fn.W qt.-.-J 1 " 'lA "~ -E'n1fiY e OJLt~e.rt ... 1 ol. 'IVY\

f\fO: Condih OhfLhl-1 Y\AA "~ ww.M M QJ\cl f~i LMb 1\'\ ~

....


6 Semple, Aubrey



Ft. Lauderdale HM Max= 30 POS POINTS RANKS

Desert Vista L T Max= 30

I Samuel Houle 2...7. 7 :> 2. Amy Lin ~3 I z_ Damon Morales tz-?.1. y r Steven Tran Z1-KS! z_

Signed: ~


cr 0----- ,;bu._ -tv~ ft n~,;_,_"'-( -"~/ {- flw.- ( §) flc ~.

sru~~~~ ~ ?f--~~ <"""" )6 '8. ·f CAI4- S ~~

/ ~~of-~

r~ rrx - "fv--v::t· ~ /% ; vV-~ t-o

~- d \.-;~ v.:~~- o ,._ .

- p;r---~ s-IA_Tl,_..,d~ , -- . - rLev... v-~~ ,f.~- v.,s..---<... , ~ ~ c_,... fr<>/ ;i(t:_ ""'- :;iuJ c/e4,~

Room: Hilles Cinema Lo Start: 3:30pm JVP

6 Shaner, Jake

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV Cambridge, MA February 16·18, 2012


George Washington AG Max= 30 POS POINTS RANKS

Brooklyn Technical MB Max= 30

\ Thomas Angus ·z_<£1 2- ~ \ Fariya Methila z_({. 1 3 ~ Joseph Gordon -z1.'l Lf ~ lmen Boussayoud c:rc: f(

L ------- ------- -

Signed: ~~~-.--


y~ ~~ r~~~& ~ -::> C.f2-'2--

[_':YI~s ~ ca_p +- (C/C,~vv, ~

0e~-t~· Je,~u~ a'JCc-·h~~ 1 vve:) 1

1 WI d-. ~ Y- coF:,f2-~ s, eve_

vvtrl~ ~"~-~~ur ·~ ~~t~y ~ M. lv((l__.T ---? •

Room: Currier Treehous Start: 3:30pm 6 Shields, Jharick JVP


La I


La Salle College HM Max= 30 POS POINTS RANKS

Achievement First HW Max= 30

I Colin Hoffman ~9.1 I \ Mark Williams vtt,) 5 l Christian Marble ~l1,(; (__ 2. Lindsay Henson ;)q,j t --

The better debating was done by the ~ from L()._ J tt //e {;jkj&: A or NEG 'fuM OR CONTESTANT NAI -


Signed: \ 1/ V"-~-vv u ~- "V


~~o4C('i 6-oaJ tDv-VV"~ lAv<) ~.,(,fv{Vl. J' 01-1/1. oV!'/io v.s .--4 ~few fA>/«<-, we a-u.

oltn•J ./-fluwj~ '.Jt {!I?)JJ ~ )( J ci ~ ~ <:1-1 tJ t/ /, tfA;'tr1 fl S tf.L 'ci cr tJt../0 rd. fe f /:-, vol.e/) /! ~

v~; Be svre ./t,./ t4ft:Jci ,'L4-~J2r·'-'j CCV~ '1ov.iww~h~~1(c~p;k~de

~.. 1/t)/v~ ~ .. ~ 4/:Jl"'t.-." yc)~ ~~· ntlb ~~~tln'j~a&1--v'1~~"'"1~ ~ 1~ ike WUv ~ /;!Jt', J7; f1/1t#.t ~ vYJfd;.-t.,-f.tu aft~l-lw.- /Pl,Lfi tie

O vJ Cr,~' ut 6)vv, } v;w dom tll'tri o=tkrift!v~·;,·k. ~f) ~ ~ ca.n. kU1~VWJf~!!!!!/I/Miollu~.

~wan, f{!Jt~t~ovra~ tjoeb_'/4 /t;/zef J,0 'V13t ffD.' rA, k j, 1/0 l&nr llt~~+&rvhJ6(!-M~ ~11t{

r0 ~ · fSf.Yf- PM ~~aJtf?YJIJ'{yp.){eMJW+ tr/115 J1t1)) l VJ f(e_ z--+ 1 /IJ R.. k-e1o ~lntl:vJ., f4Jf/f'"J· .. ~ f111A1rvi;J;fMr IM-~rn$M ~-~-&it" ax. klM- fl.ut1 jJ-~ tu#.j~~· TwVrf

.ftHme ~ wrt'k'1wY n/t(Yih ~ '.JI,e W1i1ttv.5 i A /J ~tlrfr ~ t biJt?J~ tJw, 'ft~tlc&Jccwretj'JI-

.... IJ / ,.;,. 1 I'J .. A u t .I» .111 J _l., ,, fJAAI /) Mu.JJ11~ ".h;vf-.h..l.k. ~A. f) lA A., 1'1.-uJ...: nll.n.N'l aoaCJvJm_t,


6 Singh, Ravi


AFFIRMATIVE POS Brooklyn Technical WD

POINTS Max= 30

Amanda Woo b/,.J Dante DeBlasio ~2-~

----- ----


NEGATIVE RANKS POS

Bishop Kelley MF

- ~ Matt Marra

--.? Emma Francois --- '

POINTS Max= 30

~'1 ~?.~·

The better debating was done by the flf d, from !S 1(·:;., () P ~ TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on thi~t win wa~ed:

Signed: ~


fVfb fec:-t 2/J----.- UV/.5'n... 0 -~.--;,

RANKS

/ L-

~~~~ :~cJ V.JLA f) hct S -, rn1Ce kA ~ t Yl ~ -. Jw Q. \ Cl r.Q.S~

C\V1 c~e't:)~~c:__, 'o/V\Q;yl~~ 0VnC. S'JS~ _,

Room: PfoHo Hastings Start: 3:30pm 6 Smaga, Sarah Sie JVP


- .... - .... ____ ,. -.... -- . .,..., -... " - ----- ...... -- • .,... v-- --, ... --

POS POINTS RANKS OverlandAK Max= 30

POS Agape Leaders Prep KL

\ Yonatan Araia ~·1, l\ ' William Kang

2.. Bennito Kelty ~~ ~ J. Haofei Liu

The better debating was done by the ~~EG from ~-&Qf\..ll&~ .. t~.-Please check on this line if a low-point win was intended: __ _

Signed ~/\ ¥£6> / COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: •


" ,,:''\,, 'V

ft,~'Y l I

f) c.- 'S'koutd S«Uf ~eM ~ "nofM&l ~r~ -b" ~,, i\of- fioJ-. ..rotve" rot~.NA$ Ia~ -n..c. nctno~ kc.t. c.owd ~ Far hi!' .. ~'f~ YM· c~ tt4d ... ~ ~ruph&/\-

ave.- rc.a.d ('a~ tbful~ bawt MvtU\.ftA.,.e.. AG: ~l-ulel catt. uvep4us/ o-t' wer tw~4f· '-"~ "'~tiM.&.

N.td ~o ~d MoteM ""tM..k 4\d CP · p~» r~"t tlt"c.cfi QJt fcAll\, '~PAcn:.4i"- ett.. te..M G1Vt•:l<t ·tA'{c(p/co""w s-mdttrrA;.cn. -r. h\0.\C.t. M~ d~ an.~ oQs C!d • CJ..rd. 1\o o~o~ · • -, art 'ntt:

ba.- WOt1:.-~M Dt34A.IfUt:hWi~ ~~ ~" l(OIA\fill s~o~tlaAS~~rt Ntt· ~Oad cl\otl.<. t l-Dutd. ONi~ i\4W w-fk- t... ~I ~f llU/.( .fo tftt~ ~j of t:o-\.

""' So~ ~ lctfk kW, 1\u.d 'fg ~~ ~4baJ.t W""t lt tl\~ tJJJop.k ~ 0( ldDfS{ • ~w.f ~ -r:

BD.f)', 1\i~ 11\t<ffl ~ iha.t a~ ~ Yv\~ hMA. n oc: ht~ ~MOl\ /t,e~ u~ s


6 Seitz, Harri.son



POINTS RANKS POS

Atholton HD Max= 30 St. Andrew's

2.- Salva Hasan ~ Nikhil Arora

I Shakira Dineshkumar ~ Umer Salman

The better debating was done by the from TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Please check on this line if a lo~oint win was intended: __ _

Signed: ----..#1~~~~rtP?6:"-----7·1.__' . .,.,...._._ .... ·-----


.. ,

RANKS


QUAR Torre, Christian


Blake SW (Zahir Shaikh & Allen Wang) vs. West Des Moines Valle SD (Rishi Shah & Brody Diehn)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

f/lcJ~R Sh We~ 1- /Jes @otn'fJ 10~ Sf) NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the #/- from /3Jai~ 5/J· TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME AFForNI::G

Signed:~ :;r-~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

/'lb ukt? or lrr7FJ- on I f'Y/MJI>~ YO(/ ~ 11- yJ T.

~ mfM'- a,y/-)CV'~ u tw: uw- fJ /"lf.M

clt.(atis ; rna:Jk f!MJ )2dkv dt.rtuk- ~~ jltctJl,~off ~~~


QUAR Hagen, Cecilia


Blake SW (Zahir Shaikh & Allen Wang) vs. West Des Moines Valle SD (Rishi Shah & Brody Diehn)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

13\ ate_ 0w . ~ [~e_rJ- Lkw rna rn e:s \{sllb ~ NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the ~ ~

from (~(R' TEAM oR coNTESTANVNAWC:J\ ne._ \J ~\.\e. 5\)

Signed: c~ l b~ J'tL ~'\ ~ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

~~C- U-)A 0 (\D~ \6~\LC\_\.


QUAR Gatsajak, Junah ~·

HARVARD HIGH SCHOOL JV ~c.eQc1r-nJ\.c-=-cambridge, MA (};4.-rr--.'"c)c... Jo~·~ February 16-18, 2012 1

West Des Moines Valle SD (Rishi Shah & Brody Diehn) vs. Blake SW (Zahir Shaikh & Allen Wang)

AFFIRMATIVE

~\-.l£-t.. s w NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the tJe-4 ~EG

NEGATIVE

\Je...sr- QvS ~,· ... ~s v .. n't. so NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

Wt--s+ o~ IJ.o~~~~ v~-.Lit:.. - ··-- _z .. -- --·-·····

Signed: ,......, cv .___ , '!..:C ;; "" 0 :> )


~fO ~ ~

_.; ...J_.., e"'"c\..vl ~~ (e,.o..~'

~ ..Jp,\..,\.() t)-... '\ "'t~ .. \t0 t..-- 4 """' ...... \+--h..k.

0 ~f.f' ~~'~ 1..\P 1'--. ~~'- (;}At.. .y r~ .... ~

(;Jp k ~1..,.,-jh

p.... V>- ~ 4.1 ~"+vPr".k.4hw -1-o ,\..~~ p

~"'v~~" ~ ~£yw...,.,.,o

~~· (,6l.S V'VV"'~ ~ ~<-- pie-GIG.{ cC-4-.-<o. '[) ..... ~ I

~. \'"1. ~

~ \oo ........... "'"' 1'\~ ~Q'a'-~ ~ ;),M.,

~) Oe.~:~~\-,<-) v~ \.( .... ).-:~.v' ~~

a#room: currier poker rm start: 3:30pm jvp ayaz, abdullah harvard high school jv 6 cambridge, ma...

Documents