a sasanian hoard from hilla / by a.d.h. bivar

Upload: digital-library-numis-dln

Post on 01-Jun-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    1/26

    THE NUMISMATIC

    CHRONICLE

    AND

    JOURNAL

    OF THE

    ROYAL

    NUMISMATIC SOCIETY

    Edited

    by

    JOHN

    WALKER

    C.B.E.

    .A.

    .HTT. .B.A.

    .S.A.

    Keeperf

    CoinsBritish useum

    E. S. G. ROBINSON

    C.B.E.

    .A. .LITT.

    .B.A.

    .S.A.

    and

    C. H. V. SUTHERLAND

    M.A.

    .LITT.

    .S.A.

    Keeper

    f

    CoinsAshmoleanuseum

    SEVENTH

    ERIES

    Volume

    II

    LONDON

    THE

    ROYAL NUMISMATIC

    SOCIETY

    1963

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:05:09 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    2/26

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    3/26

    A

    SASANIAN

    HOARD

    FROM

    HILLA

    By

    A.

    D.

    H.

    BIVAR

    [SEE

    PLATES

    VI,

    XVll]

    THE FIND

    The hoard of Sasanian coins

    described

    n

    the

    present

    ote has been

    preserved

    or

    ecordinghrough

    heefforts

    f

    Mr.

    John

    Hansman of

    theKhuzistan

    evelopment

    ervice,

    nsouthernran.The coinswere

    Fig.1.

    purchased

    by

    him

    their ondition

    eing

    then

    extremely ragile1

    from n

    Iraqi

    dealer

    who

    stated hat

    they

    had

    been

    found t

    Hilla,

    which s the

    modern own

    lose

    to the

    ite

    f ncient

    abylon,

    n

    raq.

    It

    goes

    without

    aying

    hat heunverified

    tatements

    fvendors re to

    be received

    with

    aution.

    n

    the

    present

    ase, however,

    he

    contents

    of

    the

    find

    n

    no

    way

    contradicthis tatement.

    oreover here eems

    to be

    no

    possible

    motive

    or

    prevarication,

    nd the

    vendor's

    ccount

    need

    not be

    regarded

    s

    untrustworthy.

    1

    Few f he oins ereegiblehenirsteen. leaningf large artf he oardwas ndertakent he

    nstitute^of

    rchaeologynderheupervisionfMr.H. W.M.

    Hodges;

    nother

    ortion

    as

    leaned

    y

    Mr.K. A.

    Howes,

    t

    the

    epartment

    f

    Coins

    nd

    Medals,

    ritish useum.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    4/26

    158 A. D. H. BIVAR

    It enhances he nterest f the find hat he date of

    deposit

    an be

    very

    losely

    fixed,

    nd also

    that

    the coins

    were

    recovered

    omplete

    with heir

    riginal

    ontainer,

    he

    mall

    glazed

    ar,

    unbroken nd com-

    plete

    with

    id,

    illustratedn

    figs.

    1 and 2.1

    Closely

    dated Sasanian

    Fig.2.

    pottery

    s

    decidedly

    are,

    nd

    so

    it is

    hoped

    that

    publication

    f

    this

    example

    may

    be

    helpful

    o

    excavators

    oncerned

    with uch

    material.

    I

    am

    grateful

    o

    the

    owner,

    Mr.

    Hansman,

    for

    ntrusting

    e

    with he

    publication

    f

    the

    find;

    nd

    to

    Dr. John

    Walker,

    f

    the

    Department

    of

    Coins

    and

    Medals

    at the

    British

    Museum,

    not

    only

    for

    effecting

    our

    introduction,

    ut also

    for

    his

    advice on

    many

    points

    of

    method

    and

    reading uring

    my

    examination f

    the

    coins.

    All

    of

    the coins

    are

    silver

    rachmae,

    nd

    with ne

    exception

    hey

    are issues oftheSasaniandynasty f ran.The exception elongs o

    1

    For

    he

    rawing

    am

    bliged

    o

    Dr.

    F.

    R.

    Allchin.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    5/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 159

    one of the

    Hephthalite

    rinces

    f

    eastern

    ran,

    a ruler etter nown

    forhis coin

    series

    f

    east ranian

    fabric,

    f

    which

    pecimens

    re

    very

    common.1

    His characteristicrown s

    surmounted

    y

    the

    effigy

    f

    a water-buffalo's

    ead,

    and his

    name,

    egible

    on

    the

    eastern

    eries

    but

    wanting

    n

    the

    present xample,

    s

    given

    n

    Pahlavi

    script

    s

    Npky

    MLK'

    The

    correspondence

    f

    his

    name

    with hose f

    Hephtha-

    lite rulers

    knownfrom

    historical ources2 nd its

    owner's

    historical

    role are still arfrom

    lear. The

    present

    ind

    helps,

    none

    the

    ess,

    to

    reinforcehe belief hatNpkyMLK

    '

    was one of theHephthalite

    princes;

    hat s to

    say,

    a

    rulerof that

    group

    of

    Huns

    dominant n

    eastern

    ran

    during

    he

    period

    of

    theSasanian

    kings

    eroz

    a.D.

    457-

    84),

    Balash

    a.D.

    484-8),

    and Kavadh I

    (a.D.

    488-531).

    Now

    coins

    of

    Npky

    MLK

    '

    in

    the Sasanian fabric

    as

    opposed

    to the

    entirely

    if-

    ferent abric characteristic

    f

    Afghanistan)

    re

    decidedly

    carce.

    Therefore,

    lthough

    he

    present

    pecimen

    earsno

    legible

    esignation

    of

    mint,

    t

    s a

    welcome ddition o

    the

    canty

    material

    n

    this

    ruler.

    Apart

    from his solated

    non-Sasanian

    oin,

    the

    hoard

    represents

    the

    Sasanian

    rulers

    eroz,

    Kavadh

    I,

    Khosrau

    I,

    and

    Hormizd

    V

    (a.D. 579-90).There s onlya single ertain ieceofthis astruler,

    no.

    60,

    and it bears the

    regnal

    date HDY

    '(Year)

    one'.

    Being

    with

    one

    possibleexception

    he

    atest

    oin

    in

    the

    hoard,

    t

    demonstrates

    neatly nough

    hatthe

    deposit

    was

    put

    away

    very hortly

    fter

    he

    first

    ear

    of Hormizd

    V,

    i.e. A.D.

    579. No. 61 is

    possibly,

    f

    not

    quite

    certainly, piece

    of

    the

    same ruler's

    fourth

    ear,

    A.D.

    583.

    If

    this

    attribution

    s

    accepted,

    t

    provides

    he

    earliest

    ossible

    date for

    the

    deposit.

    One

    of

    the hief

    roblems

    f the

    ater

    asanian

    coinage,

    nd

    one

    to

    which he

    present

    ote

    mustdevote ome

    space,

    s the

    dentification

    ofthemint-monogramshich he coins bear on the

    right-hand

    ide

    of the

    reverse. hese

    monograms

    epresent

    he

    names of

    mint-cities

    in

    abbreviated

    orm,

    ut their

    nterpretation

    s

    not

    always

    traight-

    forward,

    espite

    he

    contributionso

    their

    understanding

    ade

    by

    a number

    f writers.3

    t

    is a

    criterion f

    correct

    nterpretation

    f

    1

    Cf.

    A.

    Cunningham,

    Coins

    f heater

    ndo-Scythians',

    C

    1894,

    67:

    l.XII,

    .

    2

    It s

    possible

    o onstructhe

    ollowing

    rovisionalynastic

    able

    Toramana

    Mihirakula

    Rajatarangini

    ,

    293)

    Khingila

    arendradityaRajatarangini,

    ,

    346)

    Lakhanadayadityabutalled arendradityanRajataranginiii, 83)Purvaditya

    3

    A. D.

    Mordtmann,

    Erklärung

    er

    Münzen

    it

    ehlevi-Legenden

    ZDMG

    viii,

    1854, -209; ii, 858, -57; ix,

    865,

    73-496nd

    Nachtrag

    679,

    was

    he

    ioneer

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    6/26

    160 A. D. H. BIVAR

    the

    monograms

    hattheir

    ecipherment

    hould result n

    the actual

    Sasanian

    names

    of cities

    existing

    n

    the

    period

    citiesof

    sufficient

    consequence

    dministratively

    o

    possess

    mints,

    uch s

    headquarters

    towns of

    province

    nd kūra

    Many

    of

    the fanciful

    nterpretations

    which nce

    held the field re thus

    uled

    out. The careful

    ublication

    of

    a

    range

    of hoards

    of

    established

    rigin

    will

    help

    to

    extend he

    number

    f

    confirmed

    nterpretations,

    ince n

    anypart

    f

    he

    asanian

    empire

    he

    issues of

    important

    ocal

    mints hould

    naturally

    endto

    predominate. omparativelyewSasanianhoards have infactbeen

    recorded

    p

    to

    the

    present

    ime.1

    or

    thisreason

    he

    present

    ontri-

    bution

    s to some

    extent

    xploratory.

    s

    material

    s

    accumulated,

    and the

    igsaw

    begins

    to take

    shape,

    the

    location

    of

    the

    obscurer

    mints

    will tend

    to be

    clarified,

    nd more

    extensive

    onclusions

    an

    be

    expected

    o

    emerge.

    One

    of

    the

    problems

    n

    cataloguing

    find f

    Sasanian coins

    s

    to

    devise

    systematic

    equence

    of

    the mints. ince

    neither he

    reading

    of

    the

    mint-monograms

    or

    their

    dentifications

    generally

    greed,

    t

    is not

    possible

    o

    lay

    down

    a

    definitive

    lphabetical

    r

    geographical

    arrangement.he onlyescape from hisdifficultys to follow he

    procedure

    sed

    in

    the

    study

    f

    Book-Pahlavi;

    to

    arrange

    he

    mono-

    grams

    n the

    order

    f

    theSemitic

    lphabet,

    ut

    so

    that,

    where wo or

    more

    of the

    original

    emitic

    haracters

    re

    represented

    y

    the

    same

    Pahlavi

    etter-form,

    his

    mbiguous

    orm

    s

    placed

    under

    he

    first f

    its

    possible

    values.

    The

    resulting

    lphabetical

    order,

    used in

    the

    catalogue

    below,

    approximates

    o

    that

    of

    H. S.

    Nyberg

    n

    the

    Glossary

    o

    his

    Hilfsbuch

    es Pehìevi.

    However,

    ince

    the

    numismatic

    attempt.

    .

    D.

    J.

    Paruck,

    asanian oins

    Bombay

    924,

    ave

    complete

    ut

    not

    always

    ritical

    urvey

    f

    eadingsp

    ohis ime.

    .

    Herzfeld,

    Notes n

    he

    chaemenid

    coinagend omeasanian int-names',INC 936413-26,irsttilizedhevidence

    of he

    asanian

    ullae.everalewdentificationsade

    y

    J.

    Walker,

    Catalogue

    f

    the

    Muhammadan

    oins

    n he ritish

    useum

    Arab-Sassanian

    oins

    apply

    qually

    to he

    asanian

    eries.

    lfred

    .

    Bellinger,

    A

    Note n he asanian

    int

    onograms',

    Numismatic

    eview

    946,8,

    ontributed

    n

    mportant

    dentification,

    urther

    iscussed

    on

    p.

    165 elow.

    .

    Gobi,

    Aufbauer

    Münzprägungen'

    n

    Franz

    ltheimnd

    Ruth

    Stiehl,

    in

    siatischer

    taat

    Wiesbaden,954,

    1-128,

    ontributed

    handy

    urvey

    f

    the

    ubject,

    ut is reatment

    f he

    mint-monograms

    snot

    lways

    p

    odate. ee

    lso

    the

    ame

    riter's

    ie

    Münzener asanidenm

    Königlichenünzkabinett

    aag

    The

    Hague

    962.

    1

    One f

    he est

    nown,

    hatf

    epe

    Marinjan,

    oes

    ot aisehe

    uestion

    fmint-

    monograms

    R.

    Curiel,

    Le

    Trésore

    TepeMaranjan',

    nR.

    Curielnd

    D.

    Schlum-

    berger,

    résors

    onétaires

    Afghanistan,

    953,

    03-30).

    hoard f

    very

    imilar

    composition

    othat

    onsideredere

    as

    isted

    y

    Mrs.Malikzādeh

    ayânî,

    Tafoqïq

    dar âreh-yiado

    bist nuh

    ikkeh-yi

    āsānī'

    Majalleh-yiāstānshināsī

    ii

    and v,Tehrān,338,7-32. oundn he icinityf ârï,Mazandaränrovince,t s nterest-

    ing

    ince

    t

    ontains

    oins

    fmint-marks

    M

    for

    mul)

    ndGW

    Gurgān),

    ot

    resent

    in

    our

    wn

    more

    esterly

    ind.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    7/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 161

    Pahlavi

    of our

    period

    generally

    istinguishes

    u

    (alep)

    from

    v

    (het),

    the atter

    s here allowed to retain ts normal

    place

    in the orderof

    the Semitic

    lphabet.

    t now seems

    customary

    o transliterate

    int-

    monograms

    n

    capitals, practice

    therwise

    eserved or

    he

    Aramaic

    ideograms

    n

    the ransliteration

    f

    Pahlavi.

    Although nly

    ne

    of

    the

    monograms

    s

    actually

    n Aramaic

    deogram,

    he

    monograms ar-

    take

    of

    the nature

    f

    ideograms,

    nd I

    have

    therefore ollowed

    he

    practice

    f

    representing

    hem

    by capitals.

    MINT NOTES1

    I

    Proposed

    reading:

    B

    Proposed

    dentification: barshahr

    Catalogue

    no.

    7.

    Abarshahr

    n

    Khorasan,

    the

    city

    now

    known s

    Nishapur,

    s the

    traditional

    nterpretation

    f

    this

    monogram,

    nd

    seems

    unobjection-

    able.2 t would

    be

    possible

    to

    read

    Y,

    but

    Erān-Khurra-Shāpūr

    s

    already

    accounted

    for at IV below. It

    might

    be

    possible

    to

    bring

    Erān-āsān-kard-Kavādhnto thereckoning,3nd therewere ndeed

    other

    Sasanian names

    beginning

    imilarly.4

    ut

    stronger

    vidence

    would

    be needed

    to

    displace

    a

    recognized

    mint,

    ven

    though

    ts

    situation

    s rather emote.

    II

    U

    Proposed

    reading:

    W

    Proposed

    dentification:Hormizd-Ardashir

    Ahvaz)

    Catalogue

    nos.

    8, 9,

    and 10.

    This

    monogram

    s

    sometimes aken

    as a

    variant

    f

    Uli

    ('RT),

    confidentlyttributableo Ardashir-Khurranow Firuzabad) in

    Fars. At the

    ame

    time,

    pparently ointless

    ariations

    n

    the

    mono-

    gram

    f a

    single

    mint

    re not

    very cceptable,

    nd other

    ossibilities

    are worth

    onsidering.

    he

    letters ould

    be

    read

    W,

    which orm he

    initial

    etters

    f the

    word

    whlmzdy

    Ohrmizd),

    nd could thus

    repre-

    sent

    place-name

    eginning

    ith

    his lement.

    n the

    context

    f

    the

    present

    hoard

    representation

    y

    as

    many

    as three

    oins would be

    feasible

    or

    Hormizd-Ardashir

    nearby

    usa

    has

    four),

    ut there

    re

    variousother

    possibilities.

    1

    Definitely

    oubtfulttributions

    re

    marked

    ithn

    sterisk

    *).*Paruck,asanianoins130.Gobi,Aufbau',5.

    8

    Herzfeld,

    Achaemenid

    oinage

    nd

    asanian

    int-names',

    20.

    4

    Sevenre isted

    y

    J.

    Marquart,

    rānšahr

    330,

    withome

    ossibleuplication.

    C

    1987

    M

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    8/26

    162 A. D. H. BIVAR

    III

    bX'

    Proposed

    reading:

    RT

    Proposed

    dentification

    Ardashir-Khurra

    Catalogue

    no. 11.

    The

    monogram

    s

    traditionally,

    nd

    no doubt

    rightly,

    ttributedo

    the well-known

    istrict

    n

    Fars,

    the

    headquarters

    ity

    of whichwas

    known s

    Gūr and

    subsequently

    iruzabad.

    IV

    "

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    9/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 163

    Anotherdifficult

    onogram,

    n

    respect

    of

    which t is hard to

    support

    Gobi's identificationith

    Banjihir

    Panjshlr

    n

    Afghanistan).

    This

    place

    was

    not

    certainly

    nderSasanian

    control

    n

    the

    period

    of

    Khosrau

    I;

    and is

    excessively

    emote

    from

    our

    find-spot.

    f the

    characters

    re

    correctly

    ead

    BN,

    this

    tends

    o

    suggest

    place-name

    occurring

    n

    theKarnamak1

    s

    KXo

    1

    j

    which llows

    of

    the

    reading

    Brťt

    rthšyr

    and

    coincides

    atisfactorily

    ith ur mono-

    gram.Unfortunately

    he evidence

    or

    this

    place2

    s

    still

    nadequate.

    Apparently

    t

    lay

    in the PersianGulf area, and was

    perhaps

    the

    headquarters

    f

    the

    Sasanian

    province

    n

    Qatîf,

    n

    the

    Arabian hore.

    An

    identification

    s not

    justified

    n

    the

    absence of

    confirmatory

    evidence.

    VIII

    Reading:

    *GB

    Identification:

    ncertain

    Catalogue

    nos.

    22,

    23, 24,

    25.

    This

    mint-monogram

    s

    traditionally

    ead as

    ZR,

    and

    attributed

    toZaranj nSegistan.3hepresentwriter eels he trongestoubtof

    the

    existence

    f

    any

    basis

    for

    either he

    reading

    r

    the

    attribution.

    The first

    haracter eems

    ndisputably

    ,

    and

    could

    only

    be takenfor

    Z if a

    corruption

    s assumed.

    A

    mint

    known

    from

    he reformed

    Umayyad

    urrency,

    f which he Sasanian

    equivalent

    as

    not

    so far

    been

    recognized,

    s

    Jay,

    he

    twin

    ity

    of

    Isfahan.4

    One

    possibility

    s

    that

    the

    presentmonogram

    might

    upply

    his

    name.

    However,

    he

    number

    f

    coins seems o

    be too

    large

    o

    represent

    mint

    o

    remote

    from

    ur

    alleged

    find-spot

    t

    Hilla,

    an

    argument

    hich

    pplies

    ll

    the

    more,of course,to Zaranj. The questionshouldthereforee left

    open

    pending

    urther

    vidence.

    IX

    -Jtf

    Reading:

    D'

    Identification

    Dārābgird

    in Fars)

    Catalogue

    nos.

    26

    and

    27.

    Anotherwell-establisheddentification.

    1

    Kârnâmak-î

    rtakhshîr-î

    âpakân

    ed.

    Nosherwân,

    ombay,896),

    4,

    ection6.

    2

    Assembled

    y

    .

    Marquart,

    rānšahr

    42,

    who esolveshe

    orrupt

    orms

    iven

    y

    Tabari

    ndHamza s

    i

    ^

    Ļr*.8e.g. aruck,asanianoins190;Gobi,Aufbau',3.

    4

    There

    s,

    however,

    nother

    ombinationf ettershich

    ould

    qually

    epresent

    Jay,

    ee

    elow,

    .

    167.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    10/26

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    11/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 165

    XII

    c

    Reading:

    WH,

    WYH

    Identification:

    eh-Ardashir

    Catalogue

    nos.

    30, 31,

    32,

    33/34,

    5,

    36,

    37.

    The statistical

    redominance

    f

    this

    monogram

    if

    ndeed

    he two

    forms

    epresent

    singlemint)

    s a common

    feature

    n

    finds

    rom

    Mesopotamia.

    t

    provides strong

    onfirmation

    f

    the dentification

    made

    by

    A. R.

    Bellinger

    n

    1946.1

    hat

    s

    to

    say,

    hemint

    epresented

    is oneof those onnectedwith heSasaniancapitalofCtesiphon.As

    in

    Parthian

    imes,

    he

    ity's

    hief

    mint ould have stood

    n

    theformer

    city

    f

    Seleucia

    on

    thewest

    bank

    of

    the

    river,

    district

    nown

    o the

    Sasanians

    as

    Veh-Ardashir. lso

    in

    favour of

    this

    theory

    s

    the

    prominence

    f this

    monogram

    n

    Sasanian

    gold,

    whichwould ssue

    largely

    rom he

    capital.

    Yet it is

    worthy

    f

    remark

    f

    two

    distinct

    outlines hould

    represent

    single

    mint;

    and this

    calls for

    further

    study.

    Note must e

    taken

    n

    the

    one

    hand

    of

    Gobi's

    suggestion

    hat

    the horter

    orm f

    the

    monogram

    epresents

    he Sasanian

    capital

    of

    Khuzistan,Belabad/Jundai-Shapur,pelt n Middle PersianWhy-'

    ndywk-Šhypwhry

    2 On the other

    hand,

    alternative

    pellings

    f

    the

    name

    of

    Veh-Ardashirwere

    certainly

    urrent,

    .g.

    the variants

    Wyh-lthštr

    nd

    Wh-lthštr

    n

    bullae

    reproduced y Maricq.3

    Each

    form

    f

    the

    monogram

    ould

    represent

    ne

    of

    these

    pellings.

    urther

    hoard evidence

    will

    be

    required

    before

    he identificationf these

    monograms

    an be

    finalized.

    XIII

    Reading:

    WLC

    Proposed dentificationGeorgia

    Catalogue

    no.

    38.

    This abbreviation

    ppears

    to

    represent

    he Sasanian

    name

    for

    he

    province

    f

    Georgia

    n

    the Caucasus

    region,

    f

    which he Pahlavi

    inscriptions

    ow attest the full

    spelling

    Wlwc'n,

    nd the

    Greek

    equivalent

    Ißrjpi

    .4

    The name and

    situation f the

    provincial

    apital

    seem

    o be unattested

    or

    he asanian

    period,

    utunder he

    Umayyad

    1

    Alfred

    .

    Bellinger,

    A

    Note n

    Sasanian

    int-monograms',

    umismatic

    eview

    1946,

    8.

    2

    4

    Aufbau',

    5.

    For he

    MP

    pelling

    ee

    M.

    Sprengling,hirdentury

    ran

    12, ndpl.21.

    3

    'Vologesias,

    'emporium

    e

    Ctésiphon',yria

    xxvi,

    959,

    67-8.

    4

    Cf.

    M.

    Sprengling,

    hird

    entury

    ran

    12, .30;

    7,

    .12.

    bid.

    ,

    1.2 nd

    ,

    1.25

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    12/26

    166 A. D. H. BIVAR

    caliphate

    he

    mint-city

    as Tiflīs.1 he remote

    ituation

    f

    this

    mint

    from

    ur

    find-spot

    t Hilla

    agrees

    well

    with he

    circumstance

    f

    its

    beingrepresented

    nlyby

    a

    single

    oin.

    XIV

    iuiá

    Reading:

    L'M

    Identification: am-Hormizd

    Catalogue

    no. 39.

    AlthoughRam-Ardashir, r any othercityname commencing

    with he same

    element,

    would

    present

    heoretical

    lternatives,

    here

    is

    little

    doubt that

    Ram-Hormizd n

    southern huzistan

    s

    the

    best

    choicefor his

    monogram.

    his

    town

    has

    retained

    ts Sasanian name

    downto

    the

    present ay

    as

    Rām Hormuz. t was the

    headquarters

    f

    a kūra administrative

    istrict',

    nder he

    Arabs,

    nd

    no

    doubtalso

    previously

    nder he Sasanians.

    XV

    **£ Proposedreading:*LG

    Interpretation

    Uncertain

    Catalogue

    no. 53.

    This

    may

    be no morethan a blundered ersion

    f

    the

    succeeding

    monogram,

    ut the die is so

    sharply ngraved

    hat t seems

    best to

    list t as

    a

    separate

    tem,

    n

    case other

    xamples ventually

    ome

    to

    light.

    XVI

    v

    A 3^ Reading:

    LD

    Interpretation

    Ray (in

    eastern

    Media)

    Catalogue

    nos.

    40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45,

    possibly

    3.

    The attribution

    f

    these

    monograms

    s due to

    Herzfeld.2

    y

    some

    writers

    he two

    forms re

    regarded

    s

    graphic

    variants.The full

    Sasanian

    spelling

    or

    his

    ity

    s

    Ldy?

    Some

    notemustbe taken

    f

    the

    possibility

    hat

    he second

    form

    may

    represent

    distinct

    mint,

    ince

    give

    he arthian

    rthography,

    yršrt.

    heGreek

    ccurs

    t

    p.

    73,

    .3.

    obi,

    Aufbau',

    93,

    id

    not ocalize

    his

    mint,

    ut

    ays

    unsicher,

    ermutlich

    mN

    oder des

    Reichs'.

    1

    Cf.BMCM

    i

    Arab-yzantine

    nd

    ost-reform

    maiyad

    oins),

    xxvi.

    2

    C. G.

    Miles,

    Numismatic

    istoryfRayyAmerican

    umismatic

    ociety:

    Numismatictudieso. ) 1-4, iveshe ull istoryf he ecipherment.8

    Attestedn

    coins,

    .g.

    aruck,

    asanian

    oins

    pl.

    v,

    no.

    129;

    lso

    drachma

    f

    Hormizd

    I

    in

    my ersonal

    ollection.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    13/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 167

    it could

    stand

    equally

    for

    Gdy

    a

    Sasanian

    spelling

    f

    the

    city-name

    Jay

    ttested

    n the Pahlavi

    nscriptions.1

    f two

    mintswere nvolved

    this

    might elp

    to

    explain

    he

    unusually arge

    number

    f coins n this

    group.

    On the other

    hand

    the

    heavy preponderance

    f

    coins

    of

    Madīnat al-Salām

    Bagdad)

    and

    al-Muhammadīya

    Ray)

    in finds

    f

    the Abbāsid

    period

    ould

    well

    represent

    n

    economic

    attern

    arried

    down

    from

    asanian

    times,

    when he

    dominantmints

    may

    have

    been

    Veh-Ardashirnd

    Ray.

    It seems

    best,

    therefore,

    or

    the

    present

    o

    place the two forms ogether,husfollowingheexampleofMiles;

    and at the ame time o bear n mind

    he

    possibility

    hat wo distinct

    mints

    may

    be here nvolved.

    XVII

    Hi

    Proposed

    reading:

    *LYN

    Proposed

    dentification: ncertain

    Catalogue

    no. 46.

    This s a

    monogram

    which,

    hough

    oorly

    truck n

    this

    pecimen,

    seems o

    coincide withone

    well

    represented

    n

    finds rom

    northern

    Iraq that s tosay, nthevicinityfKirkuk ndArbil.Bothreading

    and

    interpretation

    re,

    however,

    till

    extremely

    ncertain,

    nd evi-

    dence for he Sasanian

    city-names

    f

    this rea

    is

    rather

    canty.

    he

    elucidation

    f this

    monogram

    must

    herefore

    wait

    a

    further

    ind.

    XVIII

    Reading:

    ML

    Identification: arv

    Catalogue

    no.

    47.

    Though

    MY for

    Mys'n

    Mēshān)

    has

    been

    suggested

    s a

    possible

    alternative,hemost atisfactorydentificationor hismonograms

    thatwith

    Marv,

    n

    Khurasan.2

    nce

    more,

    he

    remote

    ituation

    f

    the

    proposed

    mint

    s

    in

    keeping

    with ts

    representation

    y

    only

    single

    coin.

    XIX

    1a>

    Reading:

    SK

    Identification:

    rovince f

    Segistān/Sīstān,

    o

    doubt

    often

    representing

    he

    provincial

    apital

    of

    Zaranj.

    Catalogue

    no.

    48.

    1

    M.

    Sprengling,p.

    it.

    .

    12,

    .33.

    2A fullerorm fthis ahlavimonogramppearsnUmayyadirhamsf

    Marv f

    the eformed

    eries,

    f.

    MCM i Arab-

    yzantine

    nd

    ost-reform

    maiyad

    coins),

    79.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    14/26

    168 A. D. H. BIVAR

    The

    attribution

    s

    due to Walker.1t

    is

    confirmed

    y

    a drachma

    f

    Bahram I in

    the

    Paruck

    Collection

    at

    Delhi,2

    which

    expands

    the

    abbreviationo

    Skstn,

    s also do

    drachmae

    f

    Shapur

    I

    published

    y

    the ate J.

    M. Unvala.3 As

    often,

    he

    only

    outstanding

    ssue s the

    precise

    ituation f

    the

    mint-city

    ithin

    he

    province.

    XX

    pfcàJ

    Reading:

    ST

    IdentificationIstakhrin Fars)

    Catalogue

    nos.

    49,

    50.

    The correct

    dentification

    as

    proposed

    many years

    ago by

    Olshausen,4

    nd

    has met

    with

    general cceptance.

    XXI

    Proposed

    reading:

    PL

    Proposed

    dentification

    Furāt-Maisān

    -Mēshān)

    Cataloguenos. 51,52.

    The

    attribution

    s that

    of

    Herzfeld,5

    o

    correspond

    with

    l-Furāt,

    which

    ppears

    on

    coins

    of

    the

    reformed

    mayyad

    eries. t

    is

    perhaps

    not

    quite

    ertain hat

    heSasanian

    monogram

    eferso

    the ame

    mint

    but the

    suggestion

    s not

    acking

    n

    probability.

    TABLE SHOWING DISTRIBUTION

    BY

    PROVINCES

    Note

    Conjectural

    ttributionsre marked

    ith

    n asterisk

    *)

    Province Mint Catalogueos.

    Asuristan

    Veh-Ardashir

    *30,

    31,

    32,

    3,

    4,

    5,

    36,

    7.

    Khuzistan

    HWC,

    erhapselabad/

    28,

    9.

    Jundai-Shapur

    *Hormizd-Ardashir

    8,9,

    10

    Susa/Eran-Khurra-Shapur

    2,

    3,

    4,

    5

    RamHormizd

    39

    Mēshān

    *Furāt-Mēshān

    51,

    2

    1

    BMC

    M (Arab-Sassanian

    oins),

    xxix.

    a

    F.

    D.

    J.

    Paruck,

    Observationsur

    inq

    monnaies

    assanides',

    N

    1936,

    1-86.

    8 Some are asanianndArab-Sasanianoins', C1957,47-50.4

    'Auszüge

    usBriefenes

    Dr.

    Mordtmann',

    DMG

    i,1848,

    15.

    6

    4

    Achaemenid

    oinage

    nd

    asanian

    int-names',

    INC 936425.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    15/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 169

    Province

    Mint

    Catalogue

    os.

    Media

    Ray

    40,

    1

    42,

    3,

    4, 5,

    *53

    Hamadan

    16,

    7

    ♦Dinavar 3

    (see

    lso

    *GB

    below)

    Fars

    Bishapur

    18, 9, 0,

    0

    Istakhr

    5,

    49,

    50

    Darabgird

    26,

    7

    Ardashir-Khurra

    1

    Khurasan Marv

    47

    *Abarshahr 7

    Sistan

    SK(stn)

    resumably

    epresent-

    8

    ing rovincialapital,aranj

    Georgia

    WLC,

    presumably

    epresent-

    8

    ing

    he

    rovincialapital

    Uncertainrovinces

    BN

    21,

    perhaps

    5

    *GB

    22,

    3,

    4,

    5

    *LG

    53

    ♦LYN

    46

    STATISTICALAND GENERALCONCLUSIONS

    It

    will

    be seenthat hemintwhich

    ccounts

    for

    he

    argest

    umber

    of

    pieces

    n

    the

    hoard

    s the

    metropolitan

    int

    f

    Veh-Ardashir,

    ith

    eight pecimens.

    f

    thehoard came

    n

    fact

    from

    Hilla,

    as

    stated,

    his

    is

    entirely

    s

    we

    should

    xpect.

    he

    next

    argest

    roup

    s

    that

    f

    Ray.

    There s some

    doubt

    here,

    ince

    variant

    orm f the

    monogram

    o

    attributed

    may

    actually

    elong

    to

    Jay

    Isfahan). Ray

    was,however,

    an

    important

    conomic

    entre

    n

    the Abbāsid

    period,

    nd its

    pro-

    minence lso in

    the ime

    f

    Khosrau is understandable

    nough.

    The

    uncertainminthereread as *GB is representedyno less thanfour

    coins.

    n view

    of the

    distance,

    t

    is

    scarcely

    redible hatthe tradi-

    tional' identificationf

    this

    monogram

    with

    Zaranj

    in

    Slstān an be

    correct.

    his viewwas

    already

    uspect

    n

    epigraphic rounds,

    ut

    t

    is

    not

    easy

    to

    replace

    t with

    he

    correct

    dentification.usa is also

    represented

    y

    four

    coins,

    a

    number

    mphasizing

    he commercial

    importance

    f

    that

    ity

    ven t

    so

    late a date.

    t

    was

    never,ndeed,

    he

    Sasanian administrative

    apital

    of

    Khuzistan,

    perhaps

    owing

    to

    a

    tradition

    f

    separatism

    hich

    ong prevailed mongst

    ts

    population,

    but t seems o have been

    a

    prolific

    mint.

    Bishapur

    s

    likewise

    epre-sented yfour oins, nd thepossible*Hormizd-Ardashirythree,

    as is

    also Istakhr.

    ince

    thefirst

    as

    a

    provincial

    eadquarters

    n

    this

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    16/26

    170 A. D. H. BIVAR

    period,

    nd also

    the closest

    own n

    Fars,

    its

    prominence

    s

    under-

    standable.

    Uncertainties

    urrounding

    he econd

    place

    exclude

    t

    from

    discussion. stakhr

    was

    of

    course one of the

    greatest

    ities

    of

    Fars,

    a

    province

    which an be

    seento have

    played

    prominent

    art

    n

    the

    supply

    f

    coinage

    to

    the Sasanian

    empire.

    The more

    weaklyrepresented

    mints

    ndicate,

    or the

    most

    part,

    either

    emote

    ities,

    r

    some

    of

    theminor

    ommercial

    entres.

    n each

    case

    the

    distribution

    ppears

    o confirm

    he orrectness

    f

    the

    lleged

    find-spot,

    ince

    a strong mpression

    s

    conveyedthat

    the

    coins

    were

    put away

    at a

    point

    close to the intersectionf two

    great

    routes,

    he one

    leading

    from

    Ctesiphon

    via Hamadan and

    Ray

    to

    Khurasan,

    while the second

    ran once more from

    Ctesiphon

    via

    the

    cities

    of Khuzistan o

    Fars and Sīstān. The

    appearance

    of the

    monogram

    f

    Georgia,

    pparently

    omewhat

    are,

    s

    an

    interesting

    feature.

    More

    elaborate

    tatistical onclusions

    an

    hardly

    e

    drawn

    from

    the

    distributionf

    monograms

    n

    a

    single

    hoard of

    modest

    ize. t

    is,

    however,

    hen

    substantial umber f

    such

    hoards re recorded

    nd

    published hat heobscurermonograms an be expected o fall nto

    place.

    A

    difficulty

    hich

    has inhibited

    he

    recording

    f Sasanian

    hoards,

    part

    from

    heir

    ery

    volume,

    s the

    problem

    f

    devising

    meaningfulequence

    for

    isting

    hese

    oins,

    when

    both

    the

    readings

    and the

    nterpretations

    f

    heir

    monograms

    reso

    often

    roblematical.

    The

    purpose

    f

    the

    present

    ote s to

    emphasize

    hat

    t s

    possible

    o

    devise

    n

    interim

    olution o this

    problem.

    This,

    though

    dmittedly

    to

    some

    extent

    mperfect,

    ince

    any

    method

    of

    classifying

    oin-

    legends

    when these

    are blundered r of

    doubtful

    nterpretation

    s

    bound to have

    deficiencies,

    ay

    provide

    some

    encouragement

    o

    those facedwith he task of isting inds fSasaniansilver oins. t

    is

    probable

    that the

    study

    of

    the Sasanian

    mint-monograms

    as

    reached he

    imit

    f

    progress

    n

    purely

    heoreticalines

    of

    inquiry.

    The theoretical

    onclusions an

    now be

    veryusefully upplemented

    by

    deductions rom

    he

    omposition

    fhoards.

    These

    can

    often

    ssist

    in

    determining

    uch

    questions

    s whether

    mintwas situated n

    the

    far ast or

    the xtreme est f

    theSasanian

    empire,

    nd the

    vidence

    of

    hoards

    is

    naturally

    much

    strengthened

    hen

    t can be

    applied

    cumulatively.

    one

    the

    ess,

    the

    evidence f

    the

    present

    oard

    alone

    seems

    sufficiento

    invalidate he traditional

    dentificationf

    the

    monogram owread as *GB withZaranj in Sīstān, nd with hat

    read

    BN

    with

    Panjshlr,

    lso in

    Afghanistan.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    17/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 171

    There

    s a

    point

    of numismaticnterest hich

    rises

    n connexion

    with wo

    of

    thecoins isted

    n

    the

    present

    ind,

    os. 8 and 46. This s

    the

    ppearance

    t 6 o'clock

    n

    thereverse

    margin

    f

    groups

    f

    pellets.

    In

    the first

    xample

    there

    re

    two,

    and

    in the second

    four,

    pellets.

    The

    occurence

    of these

    pellets,

    n

    varying

    numbers,

    as been re-

    corded

    by

    other

    writers.1

    hey

    are not confined

    o the ssues

    of

    any

    one

    mint,

    or

    to those

    of

    any

    one

    year,

    nd their

    omparative

    arity

    makes t

    unlikely

    hat

    they

    onstituted routine

    ystem

    f officina

    marks, inceparallel officinae ould tend to issue approximately

    equal

    volumes

    of

    coinage.

    More evidence

    will

    therefore

    ave to be

    collected efore he

    ignificance

    f these

    die-markings

    ecomes lear.

    Besides he

    coins,

    herewere wo other

    bjects

    n

    the

    hoard

    which

    call for brief

    otice.One

    is

    thefolded

    trip

    f

    silver,

    tem

    2

    in

    the

    catalogue,

    which

    weighs

    53*14

    gm.

    and measures

    -1

    inches

    by

    2-1

    inches verall.

    Unhappily

    t bears

    no

    inscription

    r

    other

    istinguish-

    ing

    mark

    Pl.

    XVII.

    62].

    The second tem

    s

    the

    shallow

    ar

    in

    which

    the hoard is

    reported

    o have been

    found,

    nd

    which,

    s

    already

    mentioned,

    as

    purchased

    with t

    by

    Mr. Hansman

    [figs.

    and

    2].

    It measures5f by 2f inches, nd bears extensive racesof a blue-

    green

    glaze

    upon

    the nside.The outside

    may

    also once have

    been

    similarly lazed.

    f

    so,

    the

    glaze

    has there

    isintegratedhrough

    he

    effectsf

    corrosion,

    xposing

    hebuff abric f

    the

    pottery.

    ndenta-

    tions

    nside

    the

    ar,

    and also on the inside of

    the

    id,

    indicate he

    points

    of

    attachment

    f

    the

    three-armed arthenware

    pacers by

    means

    of

    which

    he

    ars

    were tacked ne

    upon

    another n the kiln.

    These

    spacers

    re

    extremely

    ommonfinds

    n

    the

    vicinity

    f ancient

    kilns n

    Iraq,

    sincewhen

    firing

    as

    complete hey

    ervedno

    purpose

    and

    had

    to be

    thrown

    way.

    We haveseenthat hehoardmusthave beenput away nor soon

    after

    he

    fourth

    ear

    of

    Hormizd V

    (a.D. 583).

    It is of

    quite

    small

    size,

    and

    there s no

    need

    to

    postulateany

    far-reaching

    olitical

    reason,

    of

    war or

    public

    disorder,

    or

    example,

    o

    account for

    ts

    abandonment. t

    may

    be

    taken as the

    savings

    of

    some

    relatively

    humble

    erson,

    peasant

    or small

    trader, idden,

    robably

    nough,

    for

    easons f

    a

    personal

    nature,

    nd never

    eclaimed. he soil

    of the

    Middle

    East must

    conceal

    thousands,

    f not

    millions,

    f

    such

    de-

    posits,

    each

    evidence of

    some

    unrecorded

    ndividual

    hazard or

    tragedy.

    1

    J.

    de

    Morgan

    n

    Bab.Traitéii

    Monnaies

    rientales

    ,

    3;

    Dynastie

    assanide),

    pl.

    xvii,3;

    xviii,

    7

    nd 8.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    18/26

    172 A. D. H. BIVAR

    CATALOGUE

    OF COINS

    Size

    No. Wt. Obverse

    Reverse

    Hephthalites

    Npky

    LK

    (?

    contemporary

    fKhosrau

    )

    1 1-2 Head

    f

    king,

    .

    wearing

    inged

    ire-altaretween

    wo

    uardians.

    3-67 crown

    urmounted

    y

    uffalo's ncertain

    nscriptions:

    o

    r.,

    head,

    and withdiadem-ties

    lundered;

    oi.,

    streaming

    rom

    ehind

    houl-

    ders. eforeace V GDH*

    glory'.

    utside

    ingle

    order,

    crescents

    t

    3,

    6,

    nd

    o'clock.

    PI.

    XVI.

    Sasanians

    Peroz

    a.D.

    59-84)

    2

    108 Head

    of

    king,

    .,

    wearing

    irst,

    ire-altaretweenwo

    uardians,

    3-44

    wingless

    rown

    as

    Paruck

    42).

    their odies

    nnaturally

    lon-

    Star ehind

    ead.

    rescent

    n

    gated

    nd

    reducedo double

    each

    shoulder. efore

    ace,

    line f

    dots,

    reading

    rom utside own-To

    r.,

    mint)

    JL)

    wards,ähl,nscr.yriyvc). To1.,date)bscure.

    Symbols.

    PI.

    XVI.

    Kavadh

    (a.D.

    88-531)

    With

    ingle

    everseorder

    '

    Aufbau'

    /a).

    3

    M Head of

    king,

    .

    Before

    ace,

    Fire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians,

    3-59

    Kw't

    pzwn(y).

    in

    ingle

    order.

    Symbols:

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    ^

    w

    I

    w

    To

    1.,

    date)

    j>)dh.

    17)

    Margins:

    *

    v

    v

    *

    v

    With

    oubleeverse

    order

    4

    Aufbau'

    /ß).

    4 11 Head

    of

    king,

    .

    Before

    ace,

    Fire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians,

    3-0

    legend

    bscured.

    in

    double order.

    Broken

    Symbols:

    To

    r.,

    mint)DYN'W,

    ee

    Mint-

    w

    |(?)

    note

    .

    Margins:

    s no.

    3.

    To

    1-,

    date)

    csy.33)

    Pl. XVI.

    5

    11

    Portionf

    king's

    ead.

    Before

    ire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians,

    1

    II

    face,

    ähl,

    egend,

    w't

    pzwny

    in

    double

    order.

    Fragment

    ymbols:

    nly pļC

    een.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    only reserved.

    )To

    £preserved.

    1.,

    date) ncsy.

    35)

    £preserved.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    19/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 173

    Size

    No.

    Wt. Obverse

    Reverse

    6

    1-15 Head of

    king,

    .

    Before

    ace,

    Fire-altaretween

    wo

    uardians,

    3-19 Pähl,

    egend,

    w't

    pz[

    in

    ouble

    order

    partly

    ouble-

    Symbols:

    KI3ÍC

    struck).

    w

    I

    ?)

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    T,

    see

    Mint-note

    Margins:

    s no.

    3.

    XX.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    šsy.

    36)

    Khosrau

    (a.d.

    531-79)

    (All

    he oins f his uleralln

    he

    ategory

    Aufbau'

    /y).

    7

    1-2

    Bust f

    king

    o r.

    Legends

    ot

    Fire-altar

    etween

    wo

    uardians.

    3-92 clearndetail. Tor.,mint)B, eeMint-note,

    Broken

    Margins:

    %

    To

    1.,

    date)

    robably

    ncdh.

    15)

    u

    , %

    Similar

    argins

    ccur

    n ll

    ub-

    Pl. XVI.

    sequent

    oins

    f

    his

    uler.

    8 1

    25

    As above. efore

    ace,

    racesf As

    bove.

    3-35

    Pähl,

    egend

    wslw[.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    W,

    eeMint-noteI.

    To

    1.,

    date) ptcķl.

    47)

    Margin:

    wo

    ellets

    t

    6

    o'clock.

    Pl. XVI.

    9 Fragmentetailsost. Right-handortionf oin nly

    1-58

    preserved,

    ith

    mint)

    W,

    for

    which

    ee

    Mint-note

    I.

    Margin

    one

    pellet

    isible

    t

    6

    o'clock;

    secondost.

    10

    Fragment

    etailsost.

    Right-hand

    pper

    ortion

    f oin

    0-93

    onlypreserved,

    ith

    mint),

    'W,

    or hichee

    Mint-note

    I.

    11

    1-3

    Heavily

    orroded nd

    indis-

    Fire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians.

    3-76

    tinguishable.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    RT,

    ee

    Mint-note

    Corroded

    III.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    Wcdh.

    12)

    12 1*1 Bust fkingor.;beforeace,Aspreceding.

    3*72

    Pähl,

    egend:

    wslwy.

    ehind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)ŅM,

    eeMint-note

    *pzwn'

    IV.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    pdh.17)

    L XVI.

    13

    1-2

    Area

    heavily

    orroded,

    nd r.

    As

    preceding.

    3- 0

    margin

    ierced

    y

    orrosion.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    říM.

    To

    1.,

    date) šsy.36)

    14 1-2

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As

    preceding.

    3-64

    Pähl,

    egend

    Hws[lw]y;

    ehind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    YL'N,

    see Mint-

    *pzw[.

    note

    .

    To

    1.,

    date)

    wysty.

    20)

    PL XVI.

    15 1-4 Aspreceding;eforeace, ähl. Aspreceding.

    3*98

    legend:

    wsl[.; ehind,

    pzw['

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    YL'N.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    wcwyst.

    29)

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    20/26

    174 A. D. H. BIVAR

    Size

    No. Wt.

    Obverse Reverse

    16 1-2

    Legends

    nd

    etailsbscure.

    As ast.

    3-80

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    YL'N.

    To

    1.,

    ate ncertain.

    17 1-2

    Lower

    ortion

    f

    oyal

    ust,

    ith

    As

    ast.

    1-65

    part

    fPähl,

    egend,

    Ņw]slwy.

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    YL'N.

    Fragment

    To

    1.,

    ate

    wanting.

    18

    M

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As

    ast.

    2-95

    tracesf

    king's

    ame.

    ehind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    YS,

    ee

    Mint-note

    'pzwn. VI.To1.,date)hly.40)

    Pl.

    XVI.

    19 1*1

    As

    ast;

    efore

    ace,

    wslwy

    be- As ast.

    3-67

    hind,

    pzwn

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    YŠ.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    w'chl.

    42)

    20 1-1

    Lower

    ortion

    f

    oyal

    ust. e-

    Base

    f

    ire-altar,

    nd

    ight-hand

    2*53

    fore

    ace,

    wsl[. guardian

    nly.v

    Fragment

    To

    r., mint)

    YŠ.

    To

    1.,

    ate

    wanting.

    21

    M

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    Fire-altar

    etween

    wo

    uardians.

    3-23

    Pähl,

    egend,

    wslwy

    behind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    BN,

    eeMint-note

    *pzw[- VII.

    To

    1.,

    date) csy.33)

    Pl. XVI.

    22

    M

    Area

    heavily

    ncrusted.

    ehind

    As ast.

    3-56

    head,

    ähl,

    egendpzw[.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    JZJ~

    perhaps

    identicalith

    ollowing

    umber.

    To

    1.,

    date) stdh.

    18)

    l.

    XVI.

    23

    1-1

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As

    ast.

    3-57 Pähl,

    egend,wslwy

    ;

    behind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    GB,

    eeMint-note

    'pzw[.

    '

    VIII.

    To

    1.,

    date) nc

    wyst(?

    25).

    PI.

    XVI.

    24

    M Area

    much

    ncrusted,

    ut

    o

    r.,

    As ast.

    3-19 H]wslw[yandto 1., p[ are Tor.,mint)GB.

    Broken

    legible.

    To

    1.,

    date) nchl.

    45)

    25 1-1 Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As ast.

    1-85

    Ņwsl[

    nd

    ehind

    ead,

    pzwn.

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    GB.

    Corroded Coin

    orroded

    hrough

    bove To

    1.,

    date) nly

    c-

    isible,

    shoulder

    f

    ing. Perhaps

    imilar

    o

    ast.

    26

    1-1 As

    last,

    ut bverse uch or-

    As

    ast.

    3-81 rodednd bscure. To

    r.,

    mint)

    '

    see

    Mint-note

    IX.

    To

    1.,

    date) cdh.11)

    l. XVI.

    27

    1-1

    Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.,

    n

    neat mall As

    ast,

    ith

    omencrustation.

    3-71

    style,

    ndwell

    reserved.

    e-

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    '

    fore ace, ähl,egendntact, o1.,date) pdh.17)

    j

    Hwslwy.

    ehind

    he

    head,

    'pzwn,

    lso

    ntact.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    21/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 175

    Size

    No. Wt.

    Obverse Reverse

    28 1-1 Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    legends

    ot Fire-altaretween

    wo

    uardians.

    3-53

    wholly

    lear,

    utbefore

    ace,

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    WC,

    ee

    Mint-note

    Hw[

    s

    visible,

    nd

    ehind

    ead XI.

    ypzw[.

    his oin rokecrossTo

    1.,

    date) cwysty.

    23)

    duringleaning,

    nd he

    ieces

    PI. XVI.

    have een

    oinedogether.

    29

    1

    2 As

    ast,

    ut

    rea

    inelyreserved,

    s

    ast,

    ncluding

    int

    nd

    ate.

    2-79

    though arginseeply

    otched.

    Broken

    Before

    ace,

    wslwy

    and

    be-

    hind

    ead,

    pzwrt

    withll

    etters

    clear.

    30

    1-2

    Bust f

    king

    o

    .,

    ut

    egends

    b- Fire-altaretweenwo

    uardians.

    3-76 scure

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    řl,

    ee

    Mint-note

    XII.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    štdh.

    18)

    Pl.

    XVI.

    31

    1-2 Bust f

    king

    o

    .,

    ut

    egends

    b-

    As ast.

    2-33

    scure. he

    margin

    roken

    nd To

    r.,

    mint)

    I1.

    Broken

    notched.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    st

    wyst

    .

    ? 28)

    32

    1-2 Bust f

    king

    o

    r.,

    with etails

    As ast.

    3-98

    well

    preserved.

    efore

    ace,

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    IJ.

    Pähl,

    egend

    wslwy.

    ehind,

    o

    1.,

    date) esy(31)

    'pzwy. arginlightly

    otched.

    PI. XVI.

    33 1-2 Bust fkingor.,with etailsAs ast.3-49 mostlyreserved.eforeace,To r., mint)WYI1, eeMint-

    Pahl.

    egend:

    wslw[

    behind,

    note

    II.

    'pzwn.

    argin

    roken,

    pper

    To

    1., date)y. 30)

    PI.

    XVI.

    right.

    34

    1*2

    Obverse

    eavily

    orroded.

    As ast.

    2-23

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    YH.

    Corroded

    To

    1.,

    date)

    hly.40)

    35

    1-2 Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    egends

    ome-

    As ast.

    3-31

    what

    bscure,

    ut

    efore

    ace

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    YH.

    Broken

    ]s/h>[

    anbe

    made ut.

    Upper

    To

    1.,

    date) nchl.45)

    and eft

    argin

    roken.

    36 M 5 Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As ast.

    3-02 usual egend: wslw[.o 1., Tor.,mint) YH.Broken obscure.

    Upper

    right-hand

    o

    1.,

    date)

    ot

    ullyegible,er-

    margin

    roken.

    haps newyst.25)

    37 0-7 Lower

    ortion

    f

    oyal

    ust.

    Right-handuardian,

    ith

    dja-

    1-12

    cent

    mint)nscription

    nly,

    Fragment

    WYI1.

    38

    1 2

    Area

    adly

    ncrusted,

    ut

    ttribu-

    ire-altaretweenwo

    uardians.

    3-13 tion oKhosrau

    not

    n

    doubt.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    LC,

    eeMint-note

    XIII.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    hichi.

    44)

    Pl. XVI.

    39

    1 2

    Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.

    before

    ace,

    Fire ltar

    etween

    wo

    uardians.

    3-72 Pähl,

    egend

    ws[

    ;

    behind

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    'M,

    eeMint-note

    'pzw[.

    '

    XIV.To

    1.,

    date)llegible.

    Pl. XVII.

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    22/26

    176 A. D. H. BI VAR

    Size

    No.

    Wt. Obverse

    Reverse

    40

    M

    Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    Fire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians.

    3-53 Pähl,

    egend

    efinitely

    wslwdy.

    o

    r.,

    (mint)

    OJ

    perhaps

    Behind,

    pzw[.

    similaro

    hose

    ollowing.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    T.

    (6)

    Pl.

    XVII.

    41

    115

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As ast.

    311 usual

    egend:

    wslwy.

    ehind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)D,

    see

    Mint-note

    Broken

    *pzw[. Right-hand

    argin

    XVI.

    broken

    way.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    w*cwyst.

    22)

    42 1-1

    As

    ast,

    ut

    nscr.o

    r.

    obscured.

    s ast.

    3-36 To1.,pzwn Tor.,mint)-seeiscussionf his

    monogram

    n

    Mint-note

    VI.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    wcwyst.

    29)

    Pl.

    XVII.

    43

    1-15

    Usual bverse

    ype,

    ut

    egends

    s ast.

    3*62

    badly

    bscured.

    To

    r.

    mint) onogram

    sno.

    2.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    ķlsy.34)

    44

    1-1 Obverse

    eavily

    orroded,

    nd As ast.

    1-62

    margins

    roken.

    To

    r.

    mint)

    onogram

    s no.

    2.

    Broken

    To

    1.,

    date)

    hlsy.34)

    45

    1-2

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    legends

    b-

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    D,

    seeMint-note

    3-60

    scured

    xcept

    ehind

    ead

    /?[.

    XVI.

    To1.,date) ptsy.37)Pl. XVII.

    46

    1-2 Usual bverse

    ype. egends

    b-

    As

    ast.

    3-61

    scure,xcept

    ehindead

    zw[.

    To

    r.,

    mint) onogram

    iscussed

    Broken

    Upper

    eft-hand

    argin

    otched.

    in

    Mint-note

    VII.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    ķlsy.

    34)

    In

    margin

    t

    6

    o'clock,

    pel-

    lets.

    Pl. XVII.

    47

    1-17 Obverse

    ncrusted

    nd

    details

    ire-altaretweenwo

    uardians.

    3-79 obscure.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    L,

    ee

    Mint-note

    XVIII.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    ķīsy.

    34)

    l.

    XVII.

    48

    11 Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    As ast.

    2-86 Pähl,egend: wslwy.ehind, o r., mint)K,see Mint-note

    Broken

    *pzw[

    Lower

    argin

    roken.

    XIX.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    šsy.36)

    l. XVII.

    49

    1-15 Obverse

    omewhat

    braded,

    ut

    As

    ast.

    2-57

    before

    ace

    f

    king

    Hws [

    To

    r.,

    mint),

    T,

    eeMint-note

    behind

    ead

    pzwn.

    XX.

    To

    1.,

    date) ptcķl.47)

    50

    1-2

    Lower

    ortion

    f

    oyal

    ust,

    ell Fire-altar

    with

    right-hand

    2-33

    preserved.

    ing's

    ame

    want-

    guardian.

    Fragment

    ng,

    ave

    for inal

    y;

    behind

    or.,

    mint)

    T.

    head

    pzwn

    reserved.

    To

    1.,

    ate

    wanting.

    51

    M

    Bust f

    king

    o

    r.,

    withlldetails

    ire-altaretween

    wo

    uardians.

    3-77 wellpreserved.eforeace,Tor.,mint),L, eeMint-notePähl,

    egend:

    w[s]lwy;

    e- XXI.

    hind,

    pzwn.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    tpdh.17)

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    23/26

    A SASANIAN HOARD FROM HILLA 177

    Size

    No.

    Wt.

    Obverse

    Reverse

    52 1 2 Bust f

    ing

    o

    .,

    with

    etails

    ell

    As ast.

    3-26

    preserved.

    efore

    ace,

    ähl.

    To

    r.,

    mint)

    L.

    Broken

    legend: wslwy.

    egend

    o

    1.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    c.sy.

    33)

    PI.

    XVII.

    wanting.

    eft-hand

    argin

    nd

    part

    f rea roken.

    Fragmentary

    nd

    oubtful

    oins

    f

    Khosrau

    53

    1*1

    Bust

    f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    Fire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians.

    3-48

    Pahlavi

    egend:Hwslwy.

    e- To

    r.

    mint)

    LG,

    ee

    Mint-note

    hind,bscure. XV.

    To

    1.,

    date)

    lundered,

    erhaps

    hptwyst.27)

    Pl. XVII.

    54 1*15 Obverse

    eavily

    orroded;

    ar-

    Heavily

    orroded,

    nd

    legends

    1-51

    gin

    and

    area

    broken nd

    wholly

    bscure.

    Fragment

    notched.

    55

    1-2

    Obverse

    orroded,

    ut

    oinde-

    Fire-altar

    etweenwo

    uardians.

    2-17

    finitely

    fKhosrau.

    Tor.

    mint)

    ncertain

    onogram,

    Corroded

    'B

    or

    Y.

    To

    1.,

    date) ķly.40)

    56

    1-15 Bust f

    king

    o

    r.

    before

    ace,

    As ast.

    2-43 Pähl,

    egend:

    w[sl.

    behind,

    o

    r.,

    mint)

    uncertain.

    Fragmentspzw[ To1.,date)ncomplete.

    57

    1-05

    Upper art

    f

    crown,

    ith

    .,

    Left-hand

    uardian

    nd

    date,

    2-20

    Hw[s

    and

    .,

    p[

    hpdh

    17) nly.

    Fragment

    58

    M

    Upperpart

    of

    crownmuch

    Left-hand

    uardian

    nd

    date,

    1-39 corroded.

    races

    f

    p[ y'cchl

    41)

    only.

    Fragment

    59

    1-05

    Upper art

    f

    rown,

    ith

    egend

    eft-hand

    uardian,

    nd

    date,

    1-55 to

    r.,

    Ņws[

    cķlchl

    44) nly.

    Fragment

    HormizdV a.d.579-590)

    60

    1-2 Bust f

    king

    o

    r.;

    before

    ace,

    Fire-altaretweenwo

    uardians.

    3-84

    Pähl,

    egend:

    whl[mzdy.

    ar- To

    r.,

    mint)

    YŠ,

    ee

    Mint-note

    gins:

    VI.

    V

    V**

    To

    (date>

    HE>Y.

    1)

    Pl. XVII.

    61

    1-15 Obverse

    eavily

    orroded.

    rea

    Fire-altar

    etween

    wo

    uardians.

    2-54

    twice

    ierced,

    nd

    ower

    argin

    o

    r.

    mint)

    -''U

    uncertain.

    Corroded

    notched.

    he

    characteristic

    p

    o

    / ,

    »■»•

    LB

    »>,

    a'

    di

    l"

    yvit

    VIL

    marginal

    ecorationsf this

    rp

    o

    l>

    date)

    ,

    »■»•

    LB

    »>,

    (4)

    a'

    di

    l"

    yvit

    VIL

    rulerannot edistinguished.The alligraphyf he everse

    none

    he ess

    eemsonecessi-

    tate

    his ttribution.

    C

    1987

    N

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    24/26

    178 A. D. H. BIVAR

    Size

    No. Wt.

    Other

    bjects

    62 2-1

    q.

    Folded heet

    f

    ilver,

    pened

    n the

    aboratory.

    t s of

    rregular

    53-14

    shape,

    nd ears o

    nscription

    r

    design.

    Pl. XVII.

    63

    5

    1

    X

    |

    Earthenware

    ar

    with

    id,

    earing

    races

    f

    blue-green

    laze

    n nside.

    (See igs.

    and

    .)

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    25/26

    SASANIAN

    OARD

    FROM

    HILLA

    i)

    NUM. CHRON.

    1963,

    PL. XVI

    This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Sun, 17 May 2015 17:04:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

  • 8/9/2019 A Sasanian hoard from Hilla / by A.D.H. Bivar

    26/26

    SASANIAN OARD

    FROM HILLA

    2)

    NUM.

    CHRON.

    1963,

    PL.

    XVII