a simple approach to contingency drawdown, presented by ben fry, 10th oct 2016, apm north west...
TRANSCRIPT
making the difference
A simple approach to contingency drawdownBen Fry
10 October 2016
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 2
The presenter
Ben Fry MEng MAPM■ Worked in Project Controls for the past 13
years (specialising in risk).
■ Primarily operating in defence, having worked in;■ Submarines ■ Maritime■ Air■ Land■ Logistics domains
■ Currently working as a Risk Manager on the Hinkley Point C Project (£18bn).
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 3
Turner & Townsend
97offices
130countries
Client Chester ZooProject Islands projectServices Cost managementValue GBP 40m
Client Heathrow Airport LimitedProject VariousServices Programme managementValue GBP 1bn per yearClient TranscendProject CrossrailServices Cost estimatingValue GBP 15bn
Client EDFProject Hinckley
Point CServices Project controlsValue GBP 16bn
“Turner & Townsend is an independent professional services company
specialising in programme management, project management, cost management
and consulting across the property, infrastructure and natural resources
sectors.”
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 4
What is contingency?
“Resource set aside for responding to identified risks.” APM: Contingency
“A sum of money held as an overall contingency to cover the cost impact of some unexpected event.” APM: Management Reserve
“A provision for a possible event or circumstance.” Google: Contingency
For the most of this presentation are using the Google definition above;
■ We are not distinguishing between Contingency and Management Reserve.■ The principles underpinning the drawdown of MR and Contingency are broadly the
same although the authority for the drawdown may be different.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 5
Forecast vs. Drawdown
Forecast
Updated regularly to determine current risk exposure.
Reflects changes in circumstance and mitigation actions being completed.
Changes to assessments.
Doesn’t update the project baselines.
Drawdown
Happens when a risk has occurred and the baseline needs to be changed.
Based on actual (rather than potential) events.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 6
What is contingency drawdown?
“The removal of funds from an agreed source resulting in a reduction of available funds.” APM: Drawdown
“The transfer of provision from a contingency budget into the Baseline or, the realisation of a benefit to the sponsor”
Baseline
Contingency
Benefit
Provision allocated to activities.
Contingency Provision.
Profit, reduced costs, early delivery or improved output performance. Transfer – Budget Release
Transfer –Budget Transfer
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 7
Features of a good contingency drawdown approach
■ Allows the controlled and visible drawdown of contingency into the baseline (or into benefit).
■ Ensures accountability/authority for the drawdown of contingency.
■ Provides and audit trail for the drawdown of contingency.
■ Should be fully integrated into other project controls processes.
■ Should fully consider all impacts associated with the drawdown engaging all stakeholders as applicable.
■ Should be simple, clear and easy to follow, requiring minimal resources to implement.
“Truth is ever to be found in simplicity, and not in the multiplicity and confusion of things.Isaac Newton
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 8
Types of contingency
Cost
Time Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 9
Types of contingency
Cost
Time Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 10
When would we drawdown cost contingency?
Sources of drawdown■ When a known risk has been realised;■ When a reasonable, unforeseen event occurs;■ When an additional funded mitigation has been approved;■ When there is sufficient confidence that risk exposure has reduced.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 11
A cost contingency approach (process)
Control Account Budgets
Contingency Budget
Profit
Risk Event Occurs
Management Plan
(Issue)
Execute Change Process
Update Budgets
Control Account Budgets
Contingency Budget
Profit
Should:• Prioritise the issue. • Seek to establish and agree the
approach to be taken.• Might involve further
development of fallback plan.
Should:• Use the project’s standard change
management process. • Consider all budgets that have been
impacted by the risk. • Have clearly defined accountability for
approving the change.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 12
Pitfalls of cost contingency drawdown
• Management may try to reduce the contingency budget to meet targets.
• As contingency isn’t allocated to a specific task is can seem tempting to reduce.
• Removing the budget doesn’t change the risk exposure.
“I want a 10% reduction in project costs”
• Often new/changed scope is required by the sponsor.
• This is not a risk and was not considered when the contingency was agreed.
• Scope changes should be provided with an associated budget.
“The vehicle needs to go 10mph faster”
Early profit realisation / cost saving New scope
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 13
Pitfalls of cost contingency drawdown
• Control Accounts may be forecasting over-budget due to under performance.
• A reasonable amount of uncertainty should be included in the CA budgets.
• Underperformance doesn’t change the risk exposure.
“Things have costed more than planned”
UnderperformanceMost of these pitfalls are consistent with a normal Earned Value (EV) methodology.
Establish early what constitutes an acceptable drawdown of the contingency budget.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 14
Giving up contingency
Linear Profile
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5£1m £1m £1m £1m £1m
• Very simple to calculate.
• Sets the expectation for the contingency release on an annual basis.
• Doesn’t relate to when the risk events will occur.
• Can result in a lack of contingency (or holding onto contingency for too long).
£3m Risk OccursBudget has been released
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 15
Giving up contingency
Impact Points Profile (Waterfall)
Time
Risk A End of Exposure
EMV = £1M
Risk B End of Exposure
EMV = £1M
Risk C End of Exposure
EMV = £1M
Risk D End of Exposure
EMV = £1MExposure (£M)
Time
4
3
2
1
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 16
Giving up contingency
Impact Points Profile (Waterfall)
• Fairly simple to calculate.
• Relates to when in time a risk can occur.
• Setting out a waterfall up front, doesn’t represent risks that are identified throughout the project.
• Approach relies on being able to attribute an exposure value to a single risk event e.g. Expected Monetary Value (EMV).
Exposure (£M)
Time
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 17
Giving up contingency
Cost Risk Analysis Review (Recommended)
Cost
Confidence
• More complex to calculate.
• Requires commitment from the business to re-run cost risk analysis regularly and use this to determine release of contingency;• Key Milestones• Annually
• Reflects any changes in the risks that occur between updates.
Original Approval @ 50% - £1M
1 year later @ 50% - £800k
1 year later: Spent £50k on
risks arisingRelease £150k to
the business
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 18
Types of contingency
Cost
Time Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 19
What is schedule contingency?
Activity A
Activity BActivity C
Milestone(Deterministic)
Schedule ContingencyMilestone
(Contract/Reported)
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 20
A schedule contingency approach
Control Account
Schedules
Schedule Contingency
Early Delivery
Risk Event Occurs
Management Plan
(Issue)
Execute Change Process
Update Schedule
Control Account
Schedules
Schedule Contingency
Early Delivery
Should:• Prioritise the issue. • Seek to establish and agree the
approach to be taken.• Might involve further
development of fallback plan.
Should:• Use the project’s standard change
management process. • Consider impact of schedule on costs. • Have clearly defined accountability for
approving the change.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 21
Pitfalls of schedule contingency
Schedule Contingency Pitfalls
Underperformance Scope Changes
Pressures for Early Delivery
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 22
Types of contingency
Cost
Time Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 23
What could performance contingency look like?
Product
Speed Noise
Acceleration Comfort
70 mphMinimum
250 mphDesirable
100 mphTarget
10.6sMinimum
4sDesirable
8.9sTarget
2HzDesirable
10HzTarget
15HzMinimum
70DbMinimum
65DbTarget
60DbDesirable
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 24
Key Requirement Features
■ Limit the number of critical requirements for your project. ■ Key requirements should be specific & measureable. ■ Often this information will be managed by engineering anyway (as engineering
tolerances), but linking it to risk or contingency budgets is not always common practice.
■ The establishment of the key requirements (and therefore performance contingency) will depend on your contracting arrangement;■ May be possible to agree these with the client.■ You could take an internal view on what a client would be willing to agree as a
concession.■ You could specify requirements higher than your contract to establish a contingency in
design or the supply chain.
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 25
Performance Contingency
Minimum Key Requirement
Performance Contingency
Planned Performancee.g. 100 mph
Minimum Performancee.g. 70 mph
Minimum Key Requirement
Performance Contingency
Risk Occurs
Reduced Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 26
Proposed approach to performance contingency
Minimum Key Requirement
Performance Contingency
Risk Event Occurs
Management Plan
(Issue)
Execute Change Process
Update MarginMinimum Key Requirement
Performance Contingency
Should:• Prioritise the issue. • Seek to establish and agree the
approach to be taken.• Might involve further
development of fallback plan.
Should:• Use the project’s standard change
management process. • Consider impact of performance on
schedule and costs. • Have clearly defined accountability for
approving the change.
Reduced Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 27
Pitfalls of performance contingency
Schedule Contingency Pitfalls
Underperformance Scope Change
Better Performance
Turner & Townsend A simple approach to contingency drawdown 28
Summary
■ Contingency budgets can be defined to cover schedule delay and performance margins as well as cost.
■ Consideration should be given monitoring/controlling all 3 “types” of contingency budget.
■ Make use of existing processes (specifically the change process);■ This defines levels of authority for approving contingency drawdown.■ Considers all aspects of the change integrating time, cost and performance. ■ Provides a joined up approach to contingency drawdown with minimal extra effort.
■ The pitfalls associated with contingency drawdown are the same irrespective of the type of contingency;■ Scope change.■ Under-performance.■ Better performance.
29
Turner & Townsend Cost Management LimitedOne CastleparkTower HillBristolBS2 0JA
t: +44 (0) 117 922 7300e: [email protected]
© Turner & Townsend Cost Management Limited. This content is for general information purposes only and does not purport to constitute professional advice. We do not make any representation or give any warranty, express or implied, and shall not be liable for any losses or damages whatsoever, arising from reliance on information contained in this document.
It must not be made available or copied or otherwise quoted or referred to in whole or in part in any way, including orally, to any other party without our express written permission and we accept no liability of whatsoever nature for any use by any other party.
This presentation was delivered at an APM event
To find out more about upcoming events please visit
our website www.apm.org.uk/events